Currency Trader 0105
Currency Trader 0105
Currency Trader 0105
SUPPORT
THE DOLLAR? FX TRADING SYSTEM ANALYSIS:
The latest outlook on Tweaking a trend system
9
the greenback
NEW FX SENTIMENT
7
8
INDICATOR
INTRADAY CANDLESTICK 12 6
PATTERNS: 13
5
4
Trading the morning star 11
9
formation 8
6 10
3 1
98 2
7
FOREX BASICS: 7
1
Understanding 5 2
6
rollover fees 34
4 5
5
12 3 3
6
13 1 2 4
12
9
11 7
8
10
9
88 9
7
7
6 6 1
55 3
4
3
4
32 2
1
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8
Letters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Industry News
by Carlise Peterson
What’s the future of OTC
currency derivatives?
The Bank for International Settlements
released the second part of its
tri-annual survey, this time summing
up the OTC market for currencies.
How did it fare?. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
Forex Resources
Web sites, seminars and other products
and services for FX traders. . . . . . . . . . .17
continued on p. 4
Trading Strategies
Countertrend forex trading with TD
Sequential
How to determine when a trend really isn’t
your friend –– i.e., when it’s about to
disappear.
By Tom DeMark and Rocke DeMark. . . .28
Indicator Basics
Intraday candlestick patterns for FX Weighted and exponential moving
How to combine intraday candlestick averages
patterns with conservative money A primer for new traders on weighted and
management. exponential moving averages.
By Jared Martinez. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34 By Currency Trader Staff. . . . . . . . . . . . . .42
Index of Advertisers
FXCM Investor Flix
Gain Capital
The trends
they are a-changing?
Editorial and Web assistant: Kesha Green Michael Schneider has been involved in trading since
kgreen@currencytradermag.com 1982 when he was head of the special interest group invest-
ments of the German Apple user group and operated one of the
Art director: Laura Coyle
first low-cost quote vendors in Germany. He later incorporated
lcoyle@currencytradermag.com
a small trading company that served clients in Europe (prima-
President: Phil Dorman rily Monaco). Currently he is head of the supervisory board of
pdorman@currencytradermag.com a German stock firm and director of a second company that
manages international projects. In addition, he manages the
Publisher, office of the German Vereinigung Technischer Analysten e.v.,
Ad sales East Coast and Midwest:
which is the German member of the International Federation of
Bob Dorman
bdorman@currencytradermag.com Technical Analysts.
Ad sales
West Coast and Southwest only:
Peter Theodores (spottradinggroupfx@yahoo.com) is a
Allison Ellis New York based forex-trader/money manager for
aellis@currencytradermag.com Access Currency and president of Spot Trading
Group fx, a trading company he founded with his
Classified ad sales: Mark Seger brother. He began his career 10 years ago in equi-
mseger@currencytradermag.com
ties at Generic Trading before expanding into the
currency market.
call
Bob Dorman
at
(312) 775-5421
or send an e-mail to
bdorman@activetradermag.com
with “Ad inquiry” in the subject line.
INDUSTRY NEWS BY CARLISE PETERSON
FIGURE 1 — HERFINDAHL INDICES FOR GLOBAL OTC DERIVATIVES MARKETS (ALL REPORTED CONTRACTS)
For foreign exchange derivatives markets, concentration remained stable over the period, with a continued higher level of
concentration for options than forwards and swaps.
Interest rate contracts Foreign exchange contracts Equity-linked contracts
Source: BIS
standing estimated amounts) were of derivatives contracts has a level of unchanged in the markets for EUR
lower and more stable than concentra- concentration similar to, or slightly and Swedish kronor (SEK) swaps. For
tion levels in the smaller markets. A higher than, the overall market. interest rate options, USD, EUR and
third indication, based on the concen- For USD, JPY, GBP, CHF and CAD- GBP concentration levels remained
tration levels for contracts between denominated interest rate swaps, there largely the same but were less stable,
reporting financial institutions, is that was a slight increase in concentration, while concentration increased for
the inter-dealer market for most types while concentration levels remained other major currencies.
F
FIGURE 1 — EXAMPLE OF DAILY USD/JPY NET POSITIONING SHIFT orex Capital Markets
On July 21, net positioning in USD/JPY shifted from long to short into extreme (FXCM) introduced a
positioning. At the same time, a brief sell-off ended, and USD/JPY went on to new product called
rally more than 300 pips while net positioning remained short. the Speculative Senti-
ment Index (SSI) that tracks the
U.S. dollar/Japanese yen (USD/JPY), daily collective positions of speculative
5.00 113.00
112.00 (“non-commercial”) traders based
3.00 on FXCM’s proprietary customer
111.00
110.00 flow information.
1.00
109.00 FXCM calculates the index for the
-1.00 108.00 four most popularly-traded currency
107.00 pairs: EUR/USD, USD/JPY,
-3.00 106.00 GBP/USD and USD/CHF. The con-
105.00 cept is similar to the Commodity
-5.00 Futures Trading Commission’s
104.00
(CFTC) widely-used COT report.
-7.00 103.00
However, while the CFTC releases its
6/18 5:00
6/29 13:00
7/8 13:00
7/20 5:00
7/29 13:00
8/9 13:00
8/18 13:00
8/27 13:00
9/7 13:00
9/17 5:00
9/2813:00
10/8 13:00
10/19 13:00
7/20 13:00
7/22 5:00
7/26 5:00
7/27 13:00
7/29 5:00
7/30 13:00
8/3 5:00
8/14 13:00
8/26 5:00
6/29 13:00
7/8 13:00
7/20 5:00
7/29 13:00
8/9 13:00
8/18 13:00
8/27 13:00
9/7 13:00
9/17 5:00
9/2813:00
10/8 13:00
10/19 13:00
F u t u re s - a n d - O p t i o n s - C o m b i n e d
Commitments of Traders are released
every Friday at 3:30 p.m. ET.
Source: FXCM
According to FXCM, any SSI num-
ber above or below +/-3 generally rep-
resents extreme positioning. As a con- FIGURE 4 — NET POSITIONING IN GBP
trarian indicator, FXCM says the SSI is On Oct. 25, the ratio of longs to shorts in the GBP/USD is currently 1.36, which
most effective when the customer base is within range and below the extreme +/- 3 level. The index has been volatile,
is positioned “incorrectly.” The firm flipping into net long territory after spending slightly less than 48 hours in net
says traditional technical indicators short territory. Open interest decreased by 16% as the amount of short position-
actually confirm the effectiveness of ing fell 43%, indicative of short covering.
the indicator itself. When conventional British pound/U.S. dollar (GBP/USD), daily
technicals are performing well, most 6.00 1.880
traders will be positioned on the cor- 5.00 1.860
rect side of the market, which means a 4.00
1.840
tool designed to fade the consensus, 3.00
such as the SSI, will be a losing propo- 1.820
2.00
sition.
1.00 1.800
FXCM says the SSI will perform best
in relatively uncertain conditions –– 0.00 1.780
choppy markets or periods of informa- -1.00
1.760
tion updating and forecast corrections -2.00
that lead to potentially severe and 1.740
-3.00
abrupt price reversals. In these 1.720
-4.00
instances, the technical-based specula-
6/18 5:00
6/29 13:00
7/8 13:00
7/20 5:00
7/29 13:00
8/9 13:00
8/18 13:00
8/27 13:00
9/7 13:00
9/17 5:00
9/2813:00
10/8 13:00
10/19 13:00
Dollar worries:
Overdone
or on the money?
How long can the U.S. equity and bond markets sustain
a weak dollar? Some say don’t worry about it,
while others contend the buck is running out of luck.
sumers are buying foreign products. could impede economic growth in become the global reserve currency,”
“They complain that we import too Japan and the euro zone. A weaker Goldstein says.
much,” Goldstein adds. “But where do dollar results in more expensive However, this is not a question that
we import it from? They need us as a European and Japanese goods vs. U.S. will likely be answered in terms of
market. This is not just a story about us products, and it ultimately increases months; it may take years or even
consuming too much and investing the competitiveness of U.S. companies decades to resolve the answer, some
too little. It is a story about everybody overseas. analysts say. One possibility is the
else –– they don’t consume enough.” The Bush Administration has world could move toward a multiple-
offered no signs that it will intervene reserve system, in which perhaps the
Stock and bond market to support the U.S. dollar. reserve “currency” could be a combina-
implications “Even though the government pro- tion of currencies –– say, the euro and
What could this mean for equities and fesses that its strong dollar policy yen.
stocks? Callow speculates that an “out hasn’t changed, the market regards Looking at the weaker dollar, and
of control dollar rout with the euro in
the high $1.40s heading to $1.50” could
send the yield on the U.S. 10-year “These dollar doomsday scenarios make no sense,”
above 6.00 percent and spark a 15-per-
cent pullback in the U.S. stock market. says JP Morgan Chase economist Jim Glassman.
After all, equities would be faced with
rising interest rates and inflation, “It’s like we’re in a pre-Copernican age in which
which are both historically negative
factors for stocks.
Jim Glassman, senior economist at
everyone thinks the world revolves around the trade
JP Morgan Chase in New York, offers
another view.
deficit.”
“These doomsday scenarios make
no sense,” he says. “It’s like we are in a that as completely hollow,” Callow the huge U.S. trade deficit and current
pre-Copernican age in which everyone says. “The Administration keeps say- account deficit, Goldstein concludes,
thinks the world revolves around the ing the currency values should be set “It’s a problem and it isn’t going to go
trade deficit. The U.S. is not doing any- in the market.” away. But it isn’t going to be a dooms-
thing wrong. The trade deficit is where day scenario. We could have this con-
it is because China has linked to the What’s the magic number? versation again in December 2005 and
dollar and Japan is trying to get out of Few analysts have a definitive answer very little could have changed.”
their deflation scenario. when it comes to the question: How
“The problem is that a very large part low does the dollar have to fall to trig- What’s a trader to do?
of the world has linked to the dollar to ger a negative spiral throughout the “When everyone is on one side of the
stay competitive,” he continues. “[Asian U.S. capital markets? boat, you want to be nimble,”
countries] want stable currencies so There is speculation, however, that Glassman says. “Be aware the mood
they will look like attractive places for a move to $1.45-$1.50 in the euro could change. Don’t be shocked if the
companies to come and build factories. could spark intervention from the dollar rebounds.”
We are buying their goods, but they ECB. Looking at the yen, analysts He sees potential for a rebound in
aren’t buying ours. We aren’t the cause speculated it would take a retreat to the U.S. dollar back toward the $1.15
of the problem. The problem is the the Y97.00/96.00 area to spark BOJ area vs. the euro in 2005.
underperforming world economy.” intervention. A key factor traders will want to
watch in early 2005 is the potential for
Intervention around The reserve currency a Chinese revaluation.
the corner? Another concern discussed in recent “If the Chinese currency was higher,
In recent weeks, rumblings about pos- months is whether or not the U.S. dol- no one would be complaining about
sible central bank intervention have lar will remain the world’s reserve cur- the weak dollar,” says Tom Rogers,
ricocheted around the currency mar- rency, given its long-term bear market. senior currency analyst at Thomson
ket. Some pointed to the Bank of Japan However, Goldstein questions Financial. He speculates a Chinese
(BOJ) and the European Central Bank whether other countries even want to revaluation could relieve the upward
(ECB) as likely candidates to attempt fill the void. pressure on the euro.
to stem the dollar’s slide. Both have “It’s not clear that the BOJ or the “We could see a huge sell-Europe,
voiced concerns the weaker dollar ECB even wants their currency to buy-Asia trade,” he says.
www.forex-training.com
M
ost forex brokerages have a “training” sec- By far the best tool is the free demo account. Signing up
tion, where potential (or existing) cus- takes just a few minutes, and the demo allows you to buy
tomers can go to learn more about trading and sell a host of currency pairs, plus gold and crude oil,
currencies. However, few sites are as dis- using market, limit or stop orders. All orders are executed
creet about hiding the name of the brokerage as www.forex- as they would be in a real account, and the platform
training.com. includes profit/loss totals for each individual trade as well
The site is a product of brokerage GCI Financial, although as the entire portfolio (Figure 1). Traders who delve deeper
you’d have a hard time figuring that out from the training and become more educated will find the demo program a great
home page. The only mention of GCI is a small banner ad in helper before they start using real money.
the upper right corner –– the name of the brokerage isn’t Three beneficial links outside the “Getting Started” section
even mentioned when you click on the link that allows you discuss margin requirements, overnight interest, calculating
to sign up for a live account. pip values and hedging. These links are not posted in any log-
That’s a refreshing
change-of-pace from the www.forex-training.com
way most brokerages ––
Forex-training’s free demo account has real-time data and profit-loss totals.
forex or otherwise ––
operate. Plus, the site
itself has some good in-
formation for those
unfamiliar with forex.
The “Getting Started”
link on the right side of
the page presents eight
steps –– Market Back-
ground, Open a Demo
Account, Market
Trading Decisions,
Entering Trades, Con-
trolling Risk, Exiting
Trades, Open a Live
Account and Trading
Resources –– toward
trading forex.
Each of the steps is
linked to another page
that provides greater
details. For example,
Market Background
discusses currency pairs
and spot forex vs. cur-
rency futures, while Entering Trades provides a brief ical order –– the first three are listed consecutively, while the
overview of market, limit and stop orders. hedging link is stuck between Placing Orders and Open a Live
The information for new traders is not sufficient to “go Account (both of which were covered in Getting Started).
into battle” with, but it’s a good start. While experienced traders aren’t likely to gain much
Making Trading Decisions includes links to a dozen basic from Forex-Training.com (although the demo trading
indicators –– Bollinger Bands, MACD, RSI, etc. –– and pro- account could be helpful), those looking to get into the forex
vides simple explanations of each. The Trading Resources business will find the site a good place to begin. However,
section is also helpful, as it links to a glossary, charts, news, they’ll definitely need more reading and research before
quotes and a few other sites that may be of use. plunking down real money on a trade.
BY BARBARA ROCKEFELLER twisting the meaning of the news to one, they consult charts on all.
match the price action they expected to A trader at a bank or brokerage firm
I
n December, the foreign see on the chart. Traders wanted a is usually in and out of the same cur-
exchange market behaved in a retracement of the upmove, so they rency at least five, and as many as 50,
peculiar way. The euro/dollar manufactured it out of the smallest times a day, with a one- to two-hour
was trending strongly upward evidence. A manufactured retracement holding period. The goal is to make a
on dollar-negative news, but the trend is very common in foreign exchange. few bucks on the spread between buy-
then wobbled and gave back some of To recognize a manufactured retrace- ing and selling with customers and
its gains on news that traders chose to ment, you need to understand how counterparts. To do that consistently a
interpret as not dollar-negative, even professional traders view FX market trader must get the price direction
though it really was just as dollar-neg- trendedness. right, not necessarily focusing on
ative as the earlier news. Why did that Most professionals trade in all time- heavy-duty economics. Ask a trader
happen? The answer lies in traders frames, but even if they trade in only whether a particular factor is impor-
After the Federal Reserve raised a warning flag contains at least two moves in the
countertrend direction.
Nobody has ever published empiri-
about foreigners potentially losing their appetite for cal evidence proving that FX moves
follow an Elliott Wave sequence, and
U.S. securities because of the huge current account there is plenty of evidence that other
patterns are more common. But that
deficit, the monthly capital flow report became the hasn’t stopped traders from expecting
and sometimes getting them –– the
most important piece of data in the world. self-fulfilling prophecy.
In fact, one of the most fascinating
aspects of the forex market is how
Every trader picks his own time- sionals do. That’s why we have indica- commentators twist and bend news
frame and therefore his own definition tors that show a currency is over- and data to fit what they think the
of a trend. The trend concept is useful bought or oversold. A simple observa- price should do, based on an unproven
chiefly to maintain perspective and tion of a loss of momentum works theory.
sanity. It doesn’t necessarily dictate the pretty well, too. But in FX, a new
next trade. You may be able to see the appreciation of how retracements Technicals and fundamentals
euro or yen is in a long-term uptrend, develop (or should develop) is becom- The persistence of trendedness is
but also perceive the trend is momen- ing widespread. On the whole, it is because of traders grabbing hold of
tarily tired and the next best trade is to based on the Elliott Wave theory one or two key ideas and hanging on
bet on a minor correction; i.e., go short. which states that a trend proceeds by like a terrier with a bone until a bigger
You can use technicals to make a impulse waves punctuated by correc- idea comes along. The big themes
countertrend trade, and most profes- tive waves, and the corrective wave don’t change much over the years,
either, so the longer you trade
the FX market, the easier it is to
FIGURE 2 — TREND IN THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDER understand why traders
respond the way they do to cer-
Unlike the euro example in Figure 1, the "retracements" in the yen could be defined as
tain types of news and econom-
trends in their own right, and they are identified as such by the crossovers of multiple
ic developments. If you can
moving averages.
forecast the news and economic
115.5 data, you can get a head start on
Japanese yen (JPY), monthly
115.0 what the majority of traders are
114.5 going to do. Anticipating trader
114.0
113.5 reaction to news allows you to
113.0 forecast the direction of a trend
112.5
112.0 and bet on it early –– when the
111.5 juiciest profits are to be made.
111.0
110.5 It might sound silly to say
110.0 “forecast the news” when obvi-
109.5
109.0 ously no one has a crystal ball,
108.5 but in practice we usually know
108.0 the probable range of any par-
107.5
107.0 ticular piece of news and can
106.5 guess how traders will act along
106.0
105.0 the spectrum of possible out-
105.0 comes. For example, after the
104.5
104.0 Federal Reserve raised a warn-
103.5 ing flag about foreigners poten-
103.0
102.5 tially losing their appetite for
102.0 U.S. securities because of the
101.5 huge current account deficit, the
March April May Judy July August Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. monthly capital flow report
Source: eSignal
became the most important
fully priced in. If the Fed had raised punctuated by a couple of minor this willful misreading of the news,
rates by 50 basis points instead of 25 retracements (defined here as a series but technical traders just try to figure
basis points, the hike might have offset of lower lows and lower closes that out where the retracement will end so
the bad trade and capital flow data. persists for longer than three periods they can re-enter. There are two possi-
But it was obvious the Fed wasn’t in an uptrend). bilities on the chart. We can wait for
going to raise rates by more than 25, In the first week of December, the the price to break upside resistance, or
because it told us so –– rate increases euro retraced quite a lot. In fact, daily we can watch the indicator in the
would be by “measured” amounts. lows twice penetrated the lower upper window, a momentum oscilla-
Of all the news items FX traders boundary of the linear regression tor, to signal the euro is oversold. Once
may use to rationalize their short dol- trend channel. Nobody actually the indicator pops up from the over-
lar positions, the price of oil is high on thought a trend reversal could be in sold line, the trader has a bigger profit
the list. Say oil prices rise again.
Traders will interpret the news as
worse for the dollar than for other cur- When bias toward a currency is strong, all bad news
rencies, even though European
economies tend to see a bigger second- sticks to the out-of-favor currency like Velcro, while
round inflationary effect from higher
energy prices than the U.S. (or Japan, undeniably good news slides off the currency like it
which is the most energy-efficient of
all the major countries). But you can is Teflon.
“spin” the oil news as worse for the
dollar on the grounds that higher
expected inflation in Europe will pres- the works, but when prices fall by a potential than if he or she was waiting
sure the European Central Bank to large amount like this, traders who for resistance to break.
raise its own interest rates. went long near the highs are suffering Traders will line up the true weight
Funny, the market doesn’t care much and don’t want to see their losses get of the news with the corresponding
about rates when a rate hike would bigger. A wave of stop-loss selling price change. If news continues to be
seemingly support the dollar, but now takes place, complicated in this badly dollar-negative in any objective
it’s using a short-term interest rate to instance by pre-holiday and year-end evaluation but the euro fails to rise, the
justify supporting a different currency. profit-taking by position traders who price is still in the grip of the technical
It is wildly inconsistent and even hyp- had gotten in much earlier. traders who think their retracement
ocritical, but this is the kind of slant Most analysts believe the euro will hasn’t ended. If the news is only mild-
that develops when bias toward a cur- break the upside resistance line (red), ly dollar-negative but the euro rises
rency is strong. All bad news sticks to as it has done twice before. anyway, it may be time to consider a
the out-of-favor currency like Velcro, Meanwhile, the euro is in the grip of new position even if neither of the two
while undeniably good news slides off the technicals, which dictate the technical indicators on the chart give
the currency like it is Teflon. retracement should take a particular the signal –– some other technical indi-
That’s why we can’t make a list of form — the Elliott Wave sequence. cator can always be found to justify the
FX factors once and for all and give Traders twisted the meaning of fresh position the news suggests.
each one a weight. A factor has one data during the retracement week to
weight when the price is in an impulse match that expectation. Specifically, the The market makes the news
wave –– i.e., trending strongly –– but a current account deficit was not as bad It might seem odd the news doesn’t
different weight when the price is in a as expected, so the euro fell. In any dominate the price action in foreign
corrective mode. objective analysis, this is a perverse exchange. You’d think hard data
move based on a faulty interpretation. would always have the same effect on
Anatomy of a retracement In fact, it depends on looking at the price moves –– but it doesn’t. The
The euro has been trending upward data in seasonally adjusted terms; in same data is powerful during a trend
powerfully since the first week of unadjusted terms, the current deficit and feeble when a trend is either not
September 2004 (see Figure 3, p. 21), was worse. The deficit is still 6.1 percent present or in the process of retracing. It
when the current account problem of GDP, the critical number that under- pays to know what the professionals
pushed itself to the forefront of the lies the dollar downtrend in the first are thinking, and you can be sure that
news (see “The Great Global place, and the most recent data indi- a good part of what they are thinking
Imbalance Hoax,” Currency Trader, cates a third consecutive quarter of is informed by the chart itself.
December 2004). The trend picked up worsening deficits.
steam in October and November, Economists scratch their heads at For information on the author see p. 8.
T
he Chicago Mercantile month. The Japanese yen increased to 1 2004 volume was 2.7 million compared
Exchange posted total 2004 million contracts in December com- to 1.6 million in 2003.
annual volume of more than pared to 650,503 in November. While the euro didn’t see dramatic
787 million contracts, with growing Contracts for the yen increased to 7.4 month-over-month volume –– 2.6 mil-
strength in currency futures. million in 2004 compared to 6 million in lion December contracts compared to
Overall, fourth quarter trading activi- 2003. Australian dollar futures had vol- 2.1 in November –– its yearly volume
ty was strong, with an average daily ume of 377,473 contracts in December, increase was nearly double at 20.4 mil-
volume of almost 3.1 million contracts, compared to 212,576 in November. The lion in 2004 compared to 11.2 in 2003.
up 33 percent from the same period in
2003. Leading the increase was a 79 per-
cent rise in currency trading, averaging CME to hold first Global FX Summit
252,000 contracts per day. It was the first Chicago Mercantile Exchange will host its first-ever Global FX Summit on Jan. 19,
quarter CME currency volume aver- mainly due to increased interest in the FX markets. The half-day summit, held at
aged more than 200,000 contracts per CME, will feature foreign exchange industry leaders including a roundtable dis-
day. cussion with Robert Savage, managing director of FX sales at Goldman Sachs;
The CME December volume of cur- Bill Brown, managing director at Morgan Stanley; Cornelius Luca, author of
rency products was 6.8 million, com- Trading in the Global Currency Markets; Barbara Rockefeller of Rockefeller
pared to 4.7 million in November. For Treasury Group; and Yra Harris, independent currency trader.
the year, currency product volume “We believe this summit will provide anyone –– from the novice FX investor to
reached 51.2 million, compared to 34 an experienced trader –– with valuable insight into the FX market and a deeper
million in 2003. understanding of the benefits of CME’s exchange model,” says Rick Sears, man-
Currency option volume reached aging director and head of the foreign exchange product group at the CME.
363,053 contracts in December 2004, The summit will begin at 1:30 p.m. with a one-hour educational seminar geared
compared to 250,693 in December 2003. to those who are new to FX trading. Two concurrent sessions will follow, one
Year-over-year, volume increased to 2.4 designed for the proprietary firms, trading arcades and individuals, which will
cover trading platforms, cash markets, futures and options. The other session, for
million from 2.1 million.
hedge funds, CTAs and investment managers, will look at electronic platforms,
Volume in several currency futures
trading strategies and risk management issues.
increased dramatically over the past
The information does NOT constitute trade signals. It is intended only to provide a brief synopsis of each market’s
CURRENCY FUTURES SNAPSHOT liquidity, direction and levels of momentum and volatility. See the legend for explanations of the different fields.
LEGEND: The “% Rank” fields for each time window (10-day current reading is larger than all the past readings, while
Sym: Ticker symbol. moves, 20-day moves, etc.) show the percentile rank of a reading of 0% means the current reading is lower
Vol: 30-day average daily volume, in thousands. the most recent move to a certain number of the previ- than the previous readings. These figures provide per-
ous moves of the same size and in the same direction. spective for determining how relatively large or small the
OI: Open interest, in thousands.
For example, the “% Rank” for 10-day move shows how most recent price move is compared to past price
10-day move: The percentage price move from the the most recent 10-day move compares to the past moves.
close 10 days ago to today’s close. twenty 10-day moves; for the 20-day move, the “% Volatility ratio/rank: The ratio is the short-term volatility
20-day move: The percentage price move from the Rank” field shows how the most recent 20-day move (10-day standard deviation of prices) divided by the
close 20 days ago to today’s close. compares to the past sixty 20-day moves; for the 60- long-term volatility (100-day standard deviation of
60-day move: The percentage price move from the day move, the “% Rank” field shows how the most prices). The rank is the percentile rank of the volatility
close 60 days ago to today’s close. recent 60-day move compares to the past one-hundred- ratio over the past 60 days.
twenty 60-day moves. A reading of 100% means the
This information is for educational purposes only. Currency Trader provides this data in good faith, but cannot guarantee its accuracy or timeliness. Currency Trader assumes
no responsibility for the use of this information. Currency Trader does not recommend buying or selling any market, nor does it solicit orders to buy or sell any market. There is
a high level of risk in trading, especially for traders who use leverage. The reader assumes all responsibility for his or her actions in the market.
CURRENCY TRADER • January 2005 23
CURRENCY SYSTEM ANALYSIS
Rules:
1. Enter long and cover shorts on the next bar’s FIGURE 2 — EQUITY CURVE: ORIGINAL SYSTEM
open when price closes above the 20-day high.
2. Enter short and exit longs on the next bar’s The basic system performed fairly well over the long run.
open when price closes below the 20-day low.
2,500,000
2,400,000
Risk control and money management: Size 2,300,000
each position so the maximum loss when stopped 2,200,000
out never exceeds 2 percent of account equity. 2,100,000
2,000,000
1,900,000
Test data: In this test we ran the coded systems over 1,800,000
a period of 10 years of a portfolio of daily FX Data in 1,700,000
Account balance ($)
1,600,000
the following currency pairs: Australian dollar/U.S. 1,500,000
dollar (AUD/USD), Euro/U.S. dollar (EUR/USD), 1,400,000
British pound/U.S. dollar (GBP/USD), U.S. 1,300,000
1,200,000
dollar/Swiss Franc (USD/CHF), U.S. dollar/Japanese 1,000,000
yen (USD/JPY) and U.S. dollar/Brazilian real 900,000
(USD/BRL). Note: Currency pairs for which the U.S. 800,000
700,000
dollar is the base currency (e.g., USD/JPY) were 600,000
inverted (e.g., JPY/USD) to enable portfolio testing in 500,000
terms of dollars. Data source: Comstock Data/FXtrek 400,000
300,000
(www.fxtrek.com). 200,000
Interest rate (rollover) fees were not calculated. 100,000
We also did not include commissions and slippage 0
1/5/95 10/4/95 7/26/96 5/21/97 3/16/98 1/7/99 10/29/99 8/22/00 6/15/01 4/10/02 1/3/03 11/25/03 9/17/04
because these costs are typically reflected in the bid-
Equity Cash Linear Reg Long Short
ask spread. However, if you wish to estimate these
costs you can multiply the number of trades by 10
(which is the value of one pip for 100,000 units of the base pips you wish to assess for commissions and slippage.
currency), and then multiply this figure by the number of We chose an initial account size of $1,000,000 for the port-
Drawdown
itability. One conclusion you can draw from -10.00%
-12.00%
this data: Wait until the year is done –– do -14.00%
not abandon the system during unprofitable -16.00%
-18.00%
weeks, months or quarters if you want to -20.00%
reap its long-term rewards. -22.00%
-24.00%
The maximum drawdown of 25 percent is 1/5/95 10/2/95 7/22/96 5/13/97 3/4/98 12/23/9810/14/99 8/3/00 5/25/01 3/18/02 1/6/03 10/27/03 8/17/04
not too bad for this type of system, but
chances are the longer the time window FIGURE 5 — DRAWDOWN: MODIFIED SYSTEM
examined, the larger the maximum draw- For the most part, the modifications reduced the size of the system’s drawdowns,
down will be. When you trade this system, although the most recent approached 20 percent.
you should always expect to lose 25 to 30 0.00%
percent of your total funds, even when risk- -2.00%
ing only 2 percent of your capital with every -4.00%
-6.00%
Drawdown
Modifying the system: One criticism of the system might Bottom line: This study shows how it does not always pay
be that the basic stop-and-reverse approach will frequently to tinker with a simple, robust system. By making it more
give back lots of open profits. Another weak point seems to complex, you add to its unpredictability.
be the low number of “correct” signals (which is, admittedly, ––Michael Schneider of Wealth-Lab
a hallmark of all long-term trend-following systems). The fol-
lowing system attempts to address these issues with the pre-
viously discussed modifications. PERIODIC RETURNS
Original system
Rules: % Max. Max.
1. Enter long on the next bar’s open when price closes Avg. Sharpe Best Worst profitable consec. consec.
above the 20-day high IF the bar preceding the breakout return ratio return return periods profitable unprofitable
bar closed in the lower 50-percent of its range. Weekly 0.20% 0.62 10.19% -8.24% 52.21 12 8
2. Exit long on the next bar’s open when price closes below Monthly 0.87% 0.61 16.92% -8.79% 50.00 4 7
the 10-day low. Quarterly 2.66% 0.56 40.12% -10.96% 57.50 6 4
3. Enter short on the next bar’s open when price closes Yearly 9.64% 1.26 19.59% -4.84% 90.00 9 1
below the 20-day low IF the bar preceding the breakout Modified system
bar closed in the upper 50 percent of its range. Weekly 0.09% 0.39 5.13% 6.92% 48.56 10 8
4. Cover short on the next bar’s open when price closes Monthly 0.38% 0.38 11.60% -6.29% 49.17 4 5
above the 10-day high. Quarterly 1.10% 0.41 15.57% -8.30% 55.00 4 4
Yearly 4.43% 0.4 28.77% -13.62% 70.00 3 1
Modified system results: The first impression from the
modified results is the system has slightly less exposure at LEGEND: Avg. return — The average percentage for the period • Sharpe ratio —
the expense of less profits. The portfolio profit decreased to Average return divided by standard deviation of returns (annualized) • Best
46.73 percent and the number of trades shrank from 294 to return — Best return for the period • Worst return — Worst return for the peri-
od • Percentage profitable periods — The percentage of periods that were prof-
195. But this did not pay off in terms of a substantially small- itable • Max. consec. profitable — The largest number of consecutive profitable
er drawdown or fewer losing trades. periods • Max. consec. unprofitable — The largest number of consecutive
Also, statistics such as profit factor, recovery factor, etc., unprofitable periods
been more appropriate for the forex market than in recent times.
Markets will trend, but research proves this is the exception rather than the 8 9
8
rule. Overall, markets trend 25 to 30 percent of the time, which means 70 to 75 7
percent of the time they move within defined trading ranges. 10
Historically, currency markets were more likely to trend than traditional
commodities, financial, or stock markets because policy decisions made by 7
central banks were coordinated, and these collective actions influenced cur- 6 6
rency relationships for extended periods of time. In recent years, however, 5
5
that interdependency has diminished and currency price behavior has mim- 4
icked that of other conventional markets. 4
Psychologically, it is simple to buy an advancing market and sell a declin- 3
ing market. Most traders attempt to operate in harmony with the trend, and
the news associated with such price movement serves to reinforce that ten- 3
dency and provide an excuse for its perpetuation. This is simply human 2
nature –– all of us want to be on the side of a winner, and the news accompa- 1
nying a trend is written to justify its existence. Eventually, however, the trend
exhausts itself and, almost by default, it is reversed or, at least, interrupted.
Typically, stock specialists, market makers and brokerage trading desks
supply needed liquidity by positioning themselves against the prevailing
trend. Their collective countertrend activities are responsible for price exhaus-
tion periods.
continued on p. 30
8
7
12
6
5
13
4
11
9
9
6 10 1
8 3 2
7 1
8
5 2
7
4 5
6 3
2 3 6
4
9
7
8
1
3
13 1.88
12
11
10 7
89 6 8 9
45 1.86
7
3 1
78 3 56
2 1.84
9 1 12
4
3
2
45
6 1
3 1.82
5 6 2
7 9 4
6 78
8 5
5
3
3 12 4 1.80
4 ++
12
67
+ ++ 1.78
89 1112 13
10
1.76
1.74
10 17 24 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 2 9 16 23 1 8 15 22 1 8 15
May 2004 June 2004 July 2004 August 2004 September 2004 October 2004
Source: Bloomberg, Inc.
The first occurs if, subsequent to the Because of additional selling from a close greater than or equal to the close
completion of a buy Setup, a price new group entering the market, a four price bars earlier — the
bar’s low and the prior price bar’s downtrend will unexpectedly intensi- Countdown process will “Recycle”.
close are both above the highest price fy from time to time. If the selling Sell Countdown inverts the rules for
of the entire buy Setup series. In these becomes sufficiently intense for an a buy Countdown: It begins once the
instances, the buy Setup is cancelled extended period of time to produce a minimum sell Setup requirement of
and you must begin to look for a new new buy Setup that extends past the nine consecutive closes greater than
Setup series. The second cancellation minimum nine to at least 18 consecu- the close four bars earlier is fulfilled
occurs when a contradictory sell Setup tive closes less than the close four bars for a sell setup. Beginning on bar 9 of
appears before the completion of the earlier — prior to the completion of the the Setup, a series of closes (which do
Countdown. Countdown or prior to a subsequent not have to be consecutive) greater
than or equal to the high two price
bars earlier must occur. The rules for
Historically, currencies have tended to trend because cancelling a sell Countdown are
inverted as well.
coordinated policy decisions by central banks On the daily time frame, completed
Countdown “13s” coincide with a mar-
influenced currency relationships for extended ket’s top or bottom approximately four
or five times a year. On shorter time-
periods of time. In recent years, however, that frame charts, the number of Countdown
13s will increase commensurately.
interdependency has diminished and currency price
Trading forex with TD
behavior has mimicked that of other markets. Sequential
The following daily charts illustrate
continued on p. 32
FIGURE 2 — EURO
Although both the sell Countdown in early January and the buy Countdown in mid May marked trend reversals, price tested
the 13 price level in each case and then made secondary Setup 9 series.
8
9 12
10
11 13 1.1800
24 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 2 9 16 23 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 3 10 17 24 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 2 9 16 23 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 1
Dec. 2004 Jan. 2004 Feb. 2004 March 2004 April 2004 May 2004 June 2004 July 2004 August 2004 Sept. 2004 Oct. 2004
Source: Bloomberg, Inc.
the application of TD Sequential to numbers). This sell Setup was not per- however, downside pressure subsided
cash currency trading. fected until the high close (day 12 of and the market rallied.
Figure 1 (see p. 31) of the cash the Countdown) because days 8 and 9 Figure 2 of the euro/U.S. dollar
British pound (GBP/USD) shows a sell of the sell Setup were below Setup day (EUR/USD) illustrates a sell
Setup series (green numbers) that com- 7, and the high of Setup day 7 was not Countdown in early January and a buy
pleted in late May 2004; the red arrow exceeded until two days after the sell Countdown in mid-May. Although
above the “9” indicates the sell Setup Setup day 9, which happened to be the both Countdown 13s marked trend
was “perfected.” Notice the upside Countdown “12” day, and the highest reversals, price tested the 13 price level
progress was interrupted for 11 trad- close of the rally. in each instance and then recorded sec-
ing days after this bar, as price moved In late July a buy Setup was perfect- ondary Setup 9 series. Both Setup 9
sideways and then declined. ed on day 8; a short-term rally ensued, series were perfected, which served to
The Countdown process then followed by a buy Countdown. Note reinforce the original 13’s.
began, with the qualifying bars labeled the Countdown 12 bar appeared in Also, the Setup 9/Countdown
13/Setup 9 series that completed at the
late-July bottom was particularly inter-
Operating against the trend is often difficult because esting because it defied conventional
technical wisdom, which at that point
it contradicts human nature. interpreted the trend as bearish on the
daily, weekly and monthly time frames.
with red numbers. The peak of the mid September, followed by five aster- In October, another perfected Setup 9
rally was marked by a Countdown isks before the Countdown 13 bar appeared that stalled the uptrend for a
“13” and exhausted the upside for this occurred. Each asterisk day would few days, after which the market
market. have been a “13,” but that designation entered the Countdown process.
Notice another sell Setup devel- was deferred because the lows of these In Figure 3 of the Australian dol-
oped simultaneously with this bars were not as low or lower than the lar/New Zealand dollar cross rate
Countdown (the second series of green close of Countdown bar 8. Once a (AUD/NZD), four of the five Setup
numbers, below the red Countdown valid Countdown 13 bar occurred, series have arrows that coincide with
12
3
1.160
4
5 78
6
9
1.140
1
12 3
234
45 5 78
6 9 1.120
6 45 34
6 9 3 5
7 1 1
78 12 2 2
8 1
9
34 5678 1.100
910 5
11 13 6
12 78 9 4
1
1.080
23 3
45 9 10 12
11
6
12
13 1.0600
78
15 22 3 10 17 24 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 2 9 16 23 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 1 8 15 22 1
April 2004 May 2004 June 2004 July 2004 August 2004 September 2004 October 2004 November 2004
Source: Bloomberg, Inc.
For information on the author see p. 8. You can purchase past articles online at www.activetradermag.com/pur-
chase_articles.htm and download them to your computer.
TD Sequential, TD Setup, TD Countdown
and TD Price Flip are registered trade-
marks.
Intraday candlestick
patterns for FX
This analysis of two candlestick patterns illustrates the process
of defining trade risk, profit and money management.
BY JARED MARTINEZ
these rules on two basic kinds of pat- Buy in the direction of the trend at the opening of the next candle after the can-
terns: the bullish morning star and the dle that completes the pattern.
bearish tweezer top.
Opening
The morning star pattern price of
Buy at the opening
A morning star is a bullish candlestick the bearish
of the next candle
pattern that appears at the end of a candle
downward price swing. An ideal
morning star is a three-candlestick Close of the
pattern (see Figure 2). The first candle bullish candle
must be in the
is a long bearish candle; the second is upper 40% of
a small-bodied “spinning top”-like the bearish can-
candle (white or black) that can gap dle’s range.
below the body of the previous bear-
ish candle; and the third is a long,
bullish candle that closes well into the
first bearish candle’s body.
The first long bearish candle con-
firms the strength of the downswing.
Protective stop-loss order 10 pips below the low
The subsequent small real body can-
Source: MTI Trend Trader
dle suggests the bears have, at
least temporarily, lost their
power to push prices lower. FIGURE 3 — MORNING STAR LONG TRADE
Finally, the long, bullish candle The profit-taking approach of placing a limit order 10 pips below the most recent high
shows the bulls have gained liquidated this long trade just before the market turned to the downside. The logic of
control of the market, indicating taking profits in this fashion is based on the idea that a market is likely to correct after a
a high probability of a reversal test or a previous high or low.
and rally. Euro/U.S. dollar (EUR/USD), 30-minute
1.233 was a previous high
Trading rules
When a morning star formation 1.232
Exit 10 pips below
appears in an uptrend: the previous high at
1.232 for a 55-pip profit
1. Go long on the open of the 1.228
Buy after the close of the candle
candle following the long, bull-
that completes the formation of
ish candle that completes the the morning star
formation. Note: some morning 1.224
star patterns can have several Place the protective
small-bodied candles between stop-loss order to
the first (long bearish) and final risk 33 pips
1.220
(long bullish) candles.
2. Place a protective stop-loss
order 10 pips below the pat-
tern’s low. 1.216
3. Identify the three most
recent past highs that are pre-
ceded and succeeded by two 1.212
lower highs and place a limit 9/21/2004 9/22/2004 9/23
continued on p. 36 Source: MTI Trend Trader
order 10 pips below the high offering a limit order 10 pips above the previous ket without a valid pattern having
minimum return of 1.5 times the low (identified in the same manner formed.
trade’s risk (i.e., the entry price minus described in Step 3) that offers a mini- The stop-loss is placed 10 pips below
the stop-loss price). mum return of 1.5 times the trade’s the formation’s low because the market
In a downtrend, the inverted morn- risk. Figure 3 (p. 35) shows a long trade has a tendency to test these extremes,
ing star pattern is called an evening example in the euro/U.S. dollar rate. and you must be out of the way to
star. Simply reverse the rules for the Always wait until a pattern’s last avoid getting stopped out unnecessari-
morning star long trade: Enter short candle closes before entering a trade. If ly. From experience, when price pene-
after the formation completes, place a you try to get an early jump on a trade trates the low or high of a pattern on
protective stop-loss order 15 pips by anticipating where the candle will this time frame by more than 10 pips, it
above the pattern’s high when watch- close (thus assuming the pattern will provides the bulls or bears with
ing a bid chart, and a profit-taking complete), you risk entering the mar- enough energy to keep moving in that
direction.
The profit-taking order is
placed 10 pips below a past high
(or above a past low) because
Candlestick basics bulls are trying to take out previ-
ous highs and bears are trying to
I
take out previous lows. After new
n Figure A, the trading period’s high and low are represented by
highs and/or lows are made, a
the highest and lowest points of the candlestick, while the ses-
pullback or retracement usually
sion’s open and close are represented by the top and bottom of
follows. This approach gets you
the wider part of the candlestick.
out before a new high (or low) is
The thin lines at the tops and bottoms are called shadows, and the
made and a sharp pullback
wider parts are called real bodies. The candle is white (or hollow) if the
occurs, taking away all your prof-
close was above the open and black (or filled) if the close was below the
it.
open.
Candle A closed higher than the open and candle B closed below the
The tweezer top pattern
open. Candle C closed above the open — the open was the low price of
A tweezer top is a bearish pattern
the day, and the close was the high price of the day. Candle D illustrates
that often appears at the end of a
the opposite condition. Finally, candle E opened and closed at the same
rally, signifying a dip or reversal.
price; it is identical to its bar-chart equivalent.
It is easy to spot because it looks
like a pair of tweezers –– two
FIGURE A — CANDLESTICKS
candles with small bodies and
Different candlesticks appear alongside their bar-chart equivalents. Candles use long shadows above them (see
the same price information as standard price bars, but display it to highlight bull- Figure 4). Notice that none or
ish and bearish activity. several candles can occur
between the two candles with the
Upper
shadow long “tweezer” shadows. The
High High High rules are the same for trading the
C D inverted morning star pattern, or
Close Open
High
evening star:
High
Close Open
1. Go short on the close of the
Open Close pattern.
Real
body 2. Place a protective stop-loss
order 15 pips above the pattern’s
Open Low Close
high.
Low
Open
3. Identify the three most
Close
recent past lows that are preced-
Low Low Low ed and succeeded by two higher
E
A B lows and place a limit order 10
Lower shadow pips above the low that offers a
minimum return of 1.5 times the
Source: MTI Trend Trader
trade’s risk (i.e., the entry price
Money management
Even with the best trading methodolo- Or
gy, you will go out of business if you
Ideal Realistic
don’t have a sound money-manage-
ment plan.
Many great traders are cor-
rect only 50 to 60 percent of the FIGURE 5 — TWEEZER TOP TRADE
time. With these odds, it is This tweezer top on Dec. 16, 2004 occurred at the top of a bounce in a prevailing
imperative that for every dollar downtrend. Entry occurs on the close of the bar that completes the pattern (the second
of risk, you gain a minimum of tweezer bar, in this case), and the stop is placed above the high of the pattern.
$1.50. The question is how 105.0
U.S. dollar/Japanese yen (USD/JPY), 15-minute
much of your capital do you
104.9
commit to a position?
Generally, a prudent guide- Tweezer Top 104.8
line is to risk no more than 5 104.7
percent of your equity on any
104.6
given trade, with 2 to 3 percent
as your average. (Professional 104.5
money managers will usually 104.4
risk no more than .25 to 2 per-
104.3
cent of account equity on any
given trade. However, they are 104.2
accountable to investors, most 104.1
of whom cannot handle big
risks and drawdowns. 104.0
Volume
Individual traders will general- 0.11
ly take greater risks than fund 0.00
managers.) -0.11
For example, if you have a
trading account of $10,000 and 12/16/2004 12/17/2004
risk 2 percent of equity per Source: MTI Trend Trader
trade, you need to use a protec-
tive stop of no more than $200, with a have confidence you will live to trade abilities on your side from trade to
limit order of perhaps $400 in profit (a another day even if your current posi- trade, reducing the stress and emotion
reward of two times risk). In most tion turns out to be a loser. from trading.
cases $200 represents only a 20-pip Emotions can sabotage the best trad-
stop (at $10 a pip). Most trades Patterns plus money ing plan. By using consistent trade-
described here require a 30- to 50-pip management execution rules and following conser-
stop, which is $300 to $500 in risk, or 3 This approach allows you to set well- vative money-management parame-
to 5 percent of a $10,000 account. defined stop and profit-taking levels ters, you increase your odds of long-
The goal of such guidelines is to based on a specific candlestick pattern. term survival and success.
avoid trading emotionally. If you limit This makes it possible to use money
your exposure on each trade, you can management rules that keep the prob- For information on the author see p. 8.
1.26
TRADE
1.24
TRADE SUMMARY
Date Rate Entry Initial Initial IRR Exit Date P/L LOP LOL Trade
stop target length
11/16/04 USD/CAD 1.1941 1.2186 1.1696 1.00 1.1800 12/2/04 +.0141 .0226 -.0145 12 days
(1.18%)
Legend: IRR — initial reward/risk ratio (initial target amount/initial stop amount); LOP — largest open profit (maximum available profit
during lifetime of trade); LOL — largest open loss (maximum potential loss during life of trade).
Monday
Monday Tuesday
Tuesday Wednesday
Wednesday Thursday
Thursday Friday
Friday Saturday
Saturday
Legend 1
CPI: ISM: Institute
Consumer for Supply
Price Index Management
GDP: Gross PPI: Producer
Domestic Price Index
Product
3 4 5 6 7 8
U.S.: ISM Australia: Index Japan: Monetary Germany: Retail U.S.: Employment
of commodity base balance
prices Germany:
Japan: Account Orders received
balances and manufacturing
Germany: turnover
Employment
10 11 12 13 14 15
U.S.: Wholesale Germany: U.S.: Trade U.S.: Retail sales U.S.: PPI
inventories Production index balance ECB: Governing Council
Great Britain: PPI meeting Germany: CPI
Australia: Official Great Britain: Germany: Bankruptcies;
reserve assets Monetary Policy National account Italy: Balance
Germany: Foreign Committee Japan: Balance of payments; of payments
trade meeting Corporate goods price index
17 18 19 20 21 22
Great Britain: CPI U.S.: CPI Canada: Canada: U.S.: Leading
Manufacturing Wholesale trade indicators
Canada: Leading Great Britain: survey
indicators Employment Great Britain:
Germany: PPI Capital issues
Japan: Monetary Canada: CPI
survey
24 25 26 27 28
Canada: Retail Great Britain: U.S.: Durable U.S.: GDP
trade GDP goods
Japan: Canada:
Corporate Employment
service price
index
30 31
Canada: GDP
Australia: International
reserves and foreign
currency liquidity
Italy: International reserves
and foreign currency
liquidity
The information on this page is subject to change. CurrencyTrader is not responsible for the accuracy of calendar dates beyond press time.
FX
rollover
fees
Did you know you can make ––
or be charged –– extra money
when you hold forex
positions overnight?
BY CARLISE PETERSON
FIGURE 2 — TRENDS AND WHIPSAWS In Figures 1 (p. 42) and 2, for the
most part, the WMA tracks the price
All types of moving averages generally perform well in trending periods, but
series most closely and responds most
they also tend to share the same negative fate in sideways markets.
quickly to price changes, followed by
U.S. dollar/Canadian dollar (USD/CAD), 10-minute the EMA and the SMA. However,
1.204
increased responsiveness has draw-
1.203 backs as well as advantages.
WMA
1.202 WMAs and EMAs, like SMAs, are
SMA
subject to frequent whipsaws (when
1.201
price crosses repeatedly above and
1.200 below the average) in non-trending
1.199 markets, or in any kind of market
when the moving average is too short
1.198
(and overly sensitive) to price fluctua-
1.197 tions.
EMA 1.196 Notice in Figure 1 that in late June
1.195
price closed above the WMA and EMA
–– a crossover that could be interpret-
1.194
ed as a buy signal –– while remaining
1.193 below the SMA. Price immediately
1.192 turned back down. A similar pattern
occurred near the end of the 10-minute
9:50 11:30 13:10 14:50 16:30 18:10 19:50 21:30 11/16 2:30 4:10 5:50 chart in Figure 2.
Source: TradeStation One method to avoid excessive
moving-average penetrations is to
FIGURE 3 — WEEKLY CHART
increase the length of the moving aver-
As in the other charts, the WMA and EMA tend to hug price more closely, which age. However, this also decreases the
is an advantage in some cases and a disadvantage in others. average’s responsiveness, regardless
1.42
of whether it is an SMA, WMA or
U.S. dollar/Canadian dollar (USD/CAD), weekly
EMA. Over time, though, the differ-
SMA 1.40 ence between using an SMA or an
1.38 EMA becomes less significant. For
example, every early response to a
EMA 1.36
trend change by an EMA is likely to be
1.34 balanced by a whipsaw that would not
1.32 have occurred using an SMA.
Figure 3 shows a weekly chart with
1.30 26-week simple, weighted and expo-
1.28 nential moving averages. As in the
WMA
other figures, sometimes the respon-
1.26
siveness of the WMA and EMA is ben-
1.24 eficial and sometimes it is a drawback.
1.22 Ultimately, the choice to use a particu-
lar kind of EMA must be based on test-
1.20
ing and a trader’s experience with a
1.18 particular trading strategy.
Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. 2004 Feb. Mar. Apr. May June July Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Table 3 shows some basic perform-
Source: TradeStation ance statistics for two tests of compa-
rable simple, weighted and exponen-
tial moving averages. The first test
Key points compared the performance of 100-day
Because they average price over time, all moving averages simple, weighted and exponential moving averages as the
lag price action relative to the number of days used to cal- basis of a moving average crossover system: The system
culate them. The goal of using a WMA or EMA is to reduce went long when price crossed above the 100-day average
lag by emphasizing more recent price action. and reversed position when price crossed below the aver-
Software Summary
F Xtrek’s IntelliChart is a
customizable, real-time
analysis program suitable
for beginning to ad-
vanced forex traders. Newer traders
will appreciate its user-friendly envi-
ronment, while more experienced
Product: FXtrek’s IntelliChart Desktop
What it is: Real-time forex charting software with quote
windows, customizable indicators, alerts and
multiple data feeds.
Who it is for: Currency traders
traders can take advantage of Skill level: Beginner to intermediate users
“IntelliScript,” which allows you to cre-
Company: FXtrek.com.
ate alerts and indicators as well as back-
test trading strategies on historical data. Web site: www.fxtrek.com
Address: 1234 Summer St., fifth floor
Data
Stamford, CT 06905 USA
Because the forex spot (cash) market is
not centralized, prices for any currency Contact information: General — info@fxtrek.com; technical support —
pair will vary at any given time support@fxtrek.com; sales — sales@fxtrek.com
depending on the data source.
Price: Desktop version — $100/month;
IntelliChart Desktop provides access to
Online version –– $50/month.
two of the largest data forex feeds avail-
able: Forex Capital Markets (FXCM) Upside: Versatile charting package offering everything
and S&P Comstock. The FXCM option needed for technical analysis at a great price.
provides the latest bid and ask prices User-friendly for all experience levels. IntelliScript
from its forex brokerage, while S&P feature builds custom indicators and alerts ––
Comstock shows prices averaged from excellent for applying proprietary formulas.
multiple sources. Both real-time data
Downside: Technical support should be a bit more accessible
feeds track dozens of currency pairs
(i.e., an online chat with a live representative or at
and update constantly in IntelliChart’s
least a 24-hour phone number); however, the
quote and chart windows.
e-mail service is prompt. Retrieving historical data
Historical intraday data based on
could be faster. Intelliscript requires a
any multiple of minutes or hours (i.e.,
programming background.
one minute, three minute, hourly, four
hour etc.) goes back at least 24 hours, Minimum system Online version –– No special operating
but intraday data in five-minute incre- requirements: system requirement for java charts; Desktop
ments begins on Jan. 2, 2003. Ten years version –– Windows 95 or higher.
of daily data is also available. The pro-
Recommended: Pentium 500 MHZ or higher, at least 128 MB
gram also supports Dynamic Data
RAM; MS Java (latest version).
Exchange (DDE), which enables real-
time data linkage to an Excel spread-
sheet. and alerts from scratch via its Charting. IntelliChart can plot line,
IntelliScript feature, and it exports his- bar, candlestick and point-and-figure
Features torical data to a clipboard or a text file. chart styles in more than 60 time
IntelliChart Desktop has more extensive (For a complete list of differences frames, including tick, minute, hourly,
tools than the scaled-back online version between desktop and online versions, daily, weekly and monthly intervals. Its
of the program. For example, the desk- visit www.fxtrek.com/manual/Prod zoom feature allows you to expand and
top version allows you create indicators Comparison.asp.) condense price data on a chart in set
Source: Fxtrek
which uses indicators and nearly 70 Performance line’s color and thickness right.
variables, isn’t very difficult to learn, IntelliChart is easy to install and config- We didn’t have trouble running
but it does require some basic pro- ure. Both online and desktop versions IntelliCharts on a 3.2 GHz PC with 512
gramming skills. are very user-friendly, and you can MB RAM, but we also tested it on a
IntelliScript’s programming lan- launch chart or quote windows and set slower machine that didn’t even meet
guage can also generate buy and sell up page layouts fairly intuitively. Using FXtrek’s minimum requirements with-
signals based on real-time or historical the program with more than one moni- out performance problems. The pro-
data, which lets you back-test trading tor isn’t difficult –– just “slide” each gram didn’t slow down or crash even
rules. The program displays buy and window to another monitor and when other programs ran simultane-
sell arrows on charts and calculates a change its size with your mouse. ously, and there was no disruption to
strategy’s historical performance. To open a new chart, just select a cur- the data feed. However, loading charts
Schaff TC. IntelliChart offers a unique rency pair and its timeframe from the with lots of historical data could be
feature titled “The Schaff Trend Cycle,” pull-down menu. Navigation within faster, and exporting data to a text file
or Schaff TC, which is a proprietary indi- each chart’s menu is straightforward, took longer than it should.
cator developed by Doug Schaff to iden- and you can change currency pairs,
tify trend cycles within the moving aver- timeframe and chart type add drawing Help manual and tech support
age convergence-divergence (MACD) tools and indicators, as well as modify IntelliChart includes a thorough
indicator. It shows trend/cycle direction, the window’s appearance. Default col- instruction manual in its help menu.
tops and bottoms within a trend and ors and fonts are clear, but the chart The manual is easy to understand and
potential trade entry and exit points (see may become difficult to read if you add includes everything you need to know
Figure 2, bottom right). too many indicators and lines. It can about its features.
require some handiwork to get each Our only complaint was the inability
Bottom line
FXtrek’s IntelliChart con-
tains features for both
newer and more experi-
enced forex traders. It
includes a wide range of
tools at a competitive
price. Its screen resolution
is crisp, and most of its fea-
tures are easy to learn.
IntelliScript is the pro-
gram’s best feature:
Simply set its rules and
parameters, and the pro-
gram does the rest.
In-depth analysis of how the consumer price index (CPI) report affects the stock market each
month, and whether the number will have more impact in an inflation-conscious environment.
Strategy articles on swing trading with Fibonacci percentages, a new volume-price indicator
designed to validate trends and a T-note spread-trading approach based on yield-curve analysis.
Technology for traders: How to protect your home trading network from outside attacks.
The business of Trading: Tax law changes and what they mean for traders.
Coming in the March 2005 issue of Active Trader (on newsstands in February):
Trading strategies using volume channel lines that define price support and resistance, diagonal option spreads, and the second article on the new
VPCI volume-price indicator. Also, we analyze the stock market’s historical reaction to the producer price index (PPI) report.
Market news: The SEC ruling on the trade-through rule and a look at the new “climate” futures.
Technology for traders: a review of the ErlangerQuote analysis software and how to save time, money and frustration by guarding against
spam, spyware and viruses.
Go to www.activetradermag.com to subscribe, or visit your local Barnes & Noble, Borders or Books-A-Million store to buy a copy of Active Trader.
ACCOUNT BALANCE
Rank Country 2004 Ratio* 2003 2005+ Rank Country 2004 Ratio* 2003 2005+
1 Hong Kong 16.404 10 16.697 16.598 9 United Kingdom -43.338 -2 -33.39 -43.098
2 Taiwan 21.3 6.9 29.202 19.378 10 Spain -33.066 -3.4 -23.549 -36.462
3 Germany 118.525 4.4 52.933 129.726 11 New Zealand -4.102 -4.4 -3.267 -4.151
4 Japan 159.402 3.4 136.238 148.931 12 Australia -32.036 -5.3 -30.212 -30.248
5 Canada 28.195 2.9 17 25.243 13 United States -631.268 -5.4 -530.669 -641.678
6 Denmark 4.289 1.8 6.327 4.543
Totals in billions of U.S. dollars
7 France -12.761 -0.6 5.474 -13.246 +
*Ratio: Account balance in percent of GDP; Estimate
8 Italy -18.074 -1.1 -21.942 -13.315
Source: International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook
Database, October 2004
AMERICAS
The United Kingdom’s unemployment rate for the third
Argentina’s third-quarter 2004 GDP grew by 10.9 per- quarter decreased by 0.1 percent compared to the previous
cent. The country’s jobless rate (not seasonally-adjusted) fell quarter and dropped 0.3 percent compared to the same
1.6 percent in November to 13.20 percent. quarter in 2003, according to preliminary data from the
United Kingdom Office of National Statistics.
Brazil’s economy grew at a 6.1-percent annual rate in the
third quarter of 2004, its biggest gain since 1996.
Unemployment in Brazil decreased by 0.4 percent to 10.5
ASIA & THE SOUTH PACIFIC
percent in October.
Australia’s third quarter economy grew by 0.3 percent
Canada’s growth rate increased by 0.8 percent in the third compared to Q2 but increased by 3.0 percent compared to
quarter compared to the previous quarter and rose by 3.3 the same quarter in 2003. Unemployment in November
percent year-to-year. A boom in manufacturing, wholesale dropped 0.1 percent to 5.2 percent compared to the previous
and retail sectors drove growth, but “the economy ended the month and fell 0.5 percent compared to November 2003.
quarter on a weak note, with no growth in September, fol-
lowing 0.4 percent growth in August and 0.3 percent in July,” Hong Kong’s preliminary GDP in the third quarter increased
according to a Statistics Canada press release. Canada’s 1.9 percent from the previous quarter and 4.4 percent com-
unemployment rate rose slightly to 7.3 percent in November. pared to Q3 2003. The November unemployment figure
came in at 6.7 percent, unchanged from October 2004. “The
Mexico had a record high $61.496 billion in foreign reserves upturn of the Hong Kong economy extended well into the
at the end of 2004, as the No. 5 crude oil producer in the world third quarter of 2004,” said K.C. Kwok, the government
benefitted from high oil prices even as the central bank economist, in a press release. “The Hong Kong economy
attempted to control growth. The total is up from $57.4 billion should be on track for the 7.5-percent growth forecasted in
at the end of 2003. Mexico has deposited most of the money in August.”
a special savings fund or spent it on infrastructure projects.
Japan’s October jobless rate grew 0.1 percent compared
Year-end inflation in Venezuela dropped nearly eight to the previous month, but fell 0.4 percent compared to the
percent from 2003, finishing at 19.2 percent. The country is same month in 2003.
one of many that benefitted greatly from the oil-price boom,
as increased revenue allowed the government to increase Toshiro Muto, deputy governor of the Bank of Japan
spending. Unemployment also improved, as the December (BOJ), said in late December he was unsure if the country
rate of 10.9 percent was down from 12.8 percent the month would be able to escape deflation in 2005. Although the fis-
before and 14.6 percent from a year ago. cal year does not begin until April, Muto told a Japanese
newspaper it was not clear whether deflation would be
eliminated in 2005-06, or if the country would have to wait
EUROPE until 2006-07. The BOJ will continue its fiscal policy of
"quantitative easing" until it determines the economy is
France’s October jobless rate stayed stable at 9.9 percent, ready for a shift — most likely, when it sees year-to-year
showing no change from either the previous quarter or the increases in the Consumer Price Index.
same month in 2003, according to preliminary figures.
“Bolstered by a rise in industrial output and healthier con-
sumption, France’s GDP could increase by 0.6 percent in Q4,
AFRICA
bringing growth for 2004 as a whole to 2.1 percent –– the
best performance since 2000,” said the INSEE, France’s
National Institute of Statistics and Economic Studies in its South Africa’s economy grew 5.6 percent in the third
December 2004 economic analysis report. quarter compared to Q2, as growth accelerated for the fifth
straight quarter. “All the main sectors –– agricultural pro-
Germany’s jobless rate for November increased to 10.3 duction, mining, manufacturing, services — recorded strong
percent, which was a 0.2 percent gain on October 2004 and growth in the third quarter of 2004,” said the South African
a 0.3 percent gain on November 2003. Reserve Bank in its December 2004 Quarterly Bulletin.
E
lliott Wave is a descriptive form of technical Many devotes of Elliott Wave consider price action to be
analysis based on the concept that price action a natural phenomena driven by human emotion, which
unfolds in identifiable, structured waves that makes the fractal aspect of wave patterns an effective way
define both trend and countertrend moves. to understand and describe the price movement.
Ralph Nelson Elliott (1871-1948) introduced his ideas
through a series of letters to Charles J. Collins, who help Types of waves: Impulses and corrections
Elliott published The Wave Principle in 1938. Also with Because Elliott Wave is a descriptive, rather than quantita-
Collins’ aid, Elliott published a series of articles in Financial tive, analytical approach, it is really a type of visual pattern
World magazine in 1939. recognition. Figure 1 shows the basic Elliott Wave count,
Today, Elliott Wave theory is probably best known which consists of two phases: the first consists of numbered
through the work of Robert R. Prechter Jr., who in 1978 coau- price moves, or waves, while the second contains lettered
thored with A.J. Frost the book, Elliott Wave Principle: Key to price waves. Numbered phases are “impulse” or trending
Stock Market Profits (John Wiley & Sons, 10th edition, 2001). waves; the lettered phases are called “corrective” or coun-
tertrend waves.
Waves and fractals Impulse moves are composed of five waves (1 to 5), with
Elliott Wave theory contains elements of a mathematical waves 1, 3 and 5 in the direction the dominant trend, and
concept known as a fractal, which is an object or shape that waves 2 and 4 against the trend. A basic rule of wave iden-
has self-similarity on different scales. tification is the bottom of wave 4 cannot overlap the top of
Fractals are found in a variety of phenomena. For exam- wave 1.
ple, if you look at a mountain from a distance you see a Corrective moves consist of three waves, labeled a, b, c. A
peak with relatively smooth sides leading up to it. As you five-wave impulse move followed by a three-wave correc-
move closer, you begin to see how the sides of the mountain tive move completes one wave cycle.
are actually made up of smaller sub-peaks and sides, which Figure 2 , which shows how wave patterns are subdivid-
consist of even smaller peaks and sides, all sharing a simi- ed into smaller-degree patterns or expanded into patterns of
lar basic structure or pattern. a higher degree, illustrates the fractal aspect of Elliott Wave.
Similarly, part of wave theory is the idea that any wave continued on p. 54
cycle is part of a larger wave cycle that adheres to the same
rules, and is also composed of smaller wave cycles with the FIGURE 2 — SUBWAVES:
same structure. THE “FRACTAL” NATURE OF ELLIOT WAVE
This chart shows how any wave consists of subwaves with
FIGURE 1 — THE BASIC WAVE COUNT the same structure. For example, wave 1, which is the first
The impulse (trend) move consists of waves 1 to 5. The upwave in an impulse wave, is made up of five smaller
corrective (countertrend) move consists of waves a, b and c. impulse waves.
5 (1)
5
v
iii
b
3 i b
3 iv
a v
iii a
1 ii
1 4 v
c i c
iv 4
iii (2)
ii
i
2 iv 2
ii
T
he Fibonacci series is a number progression in
which each successive number is the sum of
the two immediately preceding it: 1, 2, 3, 5, 8,
The following examples are described in terms of an 13, 21, 34, 55, and so on.
uptrend, but the same patterns are used if the trend is As the series progresses, the ratio of a number in the
down. series divided by the immediately preceding number
approaches 1.618, a number that is attributed signifi-
Interpreting waves cance by many traders because of it appearance in nat-
There are psychological and practical interpretations associ- ural phenomena (the progression a shell’s spiral, for
ated with the wave patterns shown in Figures 1 and 2. For example), as well as in art and architecture (including
example, Wave 1 is the first advance in a trend move and the dimensions of the Parthenon and the Great
usually will be driven by short covering and professional Pyramid). The inverse, .618 (.62), has a similar signifi-
buying, indicating a turn from bearishness to bullishness. cance.
Wave 2, which corrects wave 1, is often accompanied by Some traders use fairly complex variations of
a high degree of pessimism. For example, if this wave count Fibonacci number to generate price forecasts, but a
was occurring on a weekly chart of the stock market, a basic approach is to use ratios derived from the series to
wave-2 bottom might coincide with dire forecasts about calculate likely price targets.
both the economy and the stock market. For example, if a stock broke out of a trading range
Following the wave-2 low (which must be above the and rallied from 25 to 55, potential retracement levels
wave 1 low), a rally above the peak of wave 1 (signaling a could be calculated by multiplying the distance of the
wave-3 advance) will be considered a very bullish event, move (30 points) by Fibonacci ratios –– say, .382, .50
most likely occurring in tandem with news that has sud- and .618 –– and then subtracting the results from the
denly turned favorable. At this point, investor sentiment high of the price move. In this case, retracement levels
will be optimistic. of 43.60 [55 - (30*.38)], 40 [55 - (30*.50)] and 36.40 [55
Wave 4 corrects wave 3. Now, the mood of the market - (30*.62)] would result.
will likely remain stable. Wave 5 can be considered the last Similarly, after a trading range breakout and an up
hurrah, a peak in optimism immediately before a decline move of 10 points, a Fibonacci follower might project the
that corrects the entire five-wave impulse advance. The typ- size of the next leg up in terms of a Fibonacci ratio ––
ical target for the subsequent a-b-c corrective phase is the e.g., 1.382 times the first move, or 13.82 points in this
wave-4 low. Sometimes wave 5 will take the form of an case.
upward diagonal triangle. The most commonly used ratios are .382, .50, .618,
Regarding impulse waves: Wave 3 can never be the short- .786, 1.00, 1.382 and 1.618. Depending on circum-
est impulse wave in a valid wave pattern, but either wave 1 stances, other ratios, such as .236 and 2.618, are used.
or 5 can be longer than the other.
Regarding the relationship between corrective waves 2
and 4 within an impulse move: According to Elliott Wave
theory, if corrective wave 2 was long and complex, correc- Additional reading
tive wave 4 should be simple and swift, and vice-versa –– a The following articles have more information about
concept referred to as “alternation.” Fibonacci numbers:
The Fibonacci connection “Technical Tool Insight: Fibonacci ratios” (Active Trader,
Fibonacci ratios (i.e., 38.2 percent, 61.8 percent, 138 percent, April 2002).
and so on) play an import role in Elliott Wave analysis. (See This is a detailed primer on the properties of Fibonacci
“The Fibonacci series,” for an explanation of Fibonacci numbers.
numbers.)
In Elliott analysis, one price wave should typically be “Absolute price projections,” by Tom DeMark and
able to be described in terms of a Fibonacci relationship to Rocke DeMark (Active Trader, July 2004).
another wave –– for example, the length of wave 3 might be This article explores the authors’ unique application of
138.2 percent of the length of wave 1, or wave 2 could bot- Fibonacci ratios to determine potential price targets.
tom at the 61.8-percent retracement level of wave 1.
You can purchase and download past Active Trader arti-
This material was excerpted from the article, “The Elliott Wave cles at www.activetradermag.com/purchase_articles.htm .
challenge,” from the March 2004 issue of Active Trader magazine.