Railway Food Safety
Railway Food Safety
Railway Food Safety
INNOVATIONS
ON
FOOD SAFETY & QUALITY
Prem Narayan, GGM (P&Q)
IRCTC Corporate Office
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Outline
• Introduction
• Business Activities
• Challenges
• Food Safety & Quality Innovations
• Control Systems
• Complaint Management System
• Materials Management
• Conclusions
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Introduction
¾ Incorporated on 27 September 1999.
¾ Profit making and Dividend paying company, since
first year of operation.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Financial Performance
(Rs in Crores)
Year 2004-
2004-05 2005-
2005-06 2006-
2006-07 2007-
2007-08 2008-
2008-09
Audited Audited Audited Audited Provisional
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Business Activities
Hospitality Services
• Onboard Catering,
• At Railway Stations,
• Packaged Drinking Water
• Outdoor Catering
Travel and Tourism
• Internet Rail Ticketing
• Tourism Products & Services
• Budget Hotels
• Hotel Booking/ Car Rental etc.
• Call Centre – 139 Rail Sampark
ggmpnq@irctc.com
MISSION
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Challenges
• Serving food to 10 millions passengers daily.
• Upgradation of pantry cars
• Upgradation of base kitchen infrastructure
• Trained Man Power
– Food Production
– Service
• Catering Services during late running of trains
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Catering Services at a Glance
Mobile Catering
Trains without Pantry
Car (TSV) ‐ 118
• Supplies of food through 113 Base Kitchen
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Catering Services at a Glance…
Static Catering
• Food Plazas/Fast Food Units – 53
• Automated Vending Machine – 750
• Stalls – 2950
• Trolleys & Khomchas – 3291
• Book Stalls – 698
• Milk Stall – 249
• 7918 Static units spread over 1008 no.
of Special A, A, B & C Category of
Stations over Indian Railways network.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Quality Control System
• Five Zonal Offices headed by RD/GGMs and 10
Regional Offices headed by CRMs/RMs.
• Five Zonal Control Offices & Central Control are fully
equipped with Phone, Fax, PC with broadband
connectivity with 24 x 7 working
• Induction of Quality Control Professionals conducting
onboard quality inspections.
• Complaints Management System
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Quality Control Manuals
• Manuals have been
distributed to all
Zones/Regions regarding
standards to be followed in
catering services:
– Base Kitchen
– House Keeping
– Kitchen Stewarding
– Food Safety Assurance
Programme
• Licensees have also been
instructed accordingly.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Monitoring through QCPs
• Quality Control Professionals available
over IRCTC network for monitoring
quality of catering services.
• Inspections in trains, base kitchens &
food plazas.
• Provide training to Pantry Car Staff on
cooking and service.
• To report shortcomings to the
Zonal/Central Control.
• Interact with the licensee in case of
repeated deficiency in catering services.
• Interact with passengers, specially
complainants.
• To project a positive image of IRCTC.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Food Audit of Catering units
M/s TUV SUD South Asia, empanelled to conduct the food audits.
Food Premises Audited for Performance of Concerned Facility Provider i.e.
Audit Scope
1.Personal Hygiene
2.Cleaning and Sanitation Audit Scope
3.Storage
4.Food Safety For
5.Regulatory, Statutory and Safety Regulations Service Provider
6.Presentation
7.Personnel/ Practices
Audit Scope
1.Pest Control Audit Scope for IR
2.Infrastructure Facility
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Catering units Audited
Base Kitchens 18 82 100
Food Plazas 11 9 20
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Comparison of Avg. Score – 86 Mobile Units
15.9 %
12.6 %
Service Provider
related aspects related aspects
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Comparison of Avg. Score – 10 Base Kitchens
24.2 %
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Potential areas identified for improvement
• Upgradation of infrastructure facility
• Implementation of Good Hygiene practices while
serving/ handling food items.
• Storage of water in Covered Stainless Steel tanks.
• Separate storage of Veg. and Non Veg. raw food
items.
• Effective Pest Control.
• Training of Food handlers on Good Catering
Practices.
• Usage of branded items.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Testing of Food Samples
• Food Samples are also taken through
following sources on random basis for
testing.
Railway Health Department
Food Audit Agency
Short listed agencies during ISO certification
Outside agencies
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Customer Satisfaction Survey
• On‐board customer satisfaction survey is being conducted
through M/s IMRB International.
• Broad aspects covered in the survey for on‐board experience:
Overall
On-board
Experience
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Customer Satisfaction Survey…
• Satisfaction ratings collected on five point scale.
– Excellent = 5
– Very Good = 4
– Good = 3
– Fair = 2
– Poor = 1
• Top 3 Box score: Summation of counts of passengers
who rated their satisfaction levels as either
“Excellent” or “Very Good” or “Good”
• Onboard satisfaction rating is available for 402
mobile units already covered.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Comparison of Mean Satisfaction Scores
Compartment
2.81 2.71 2.6 2.8 2.8
Related aspects
Food & Refreshment
2.71 2.6 2.47 2.74 2.77
related aspects
Staff Behavior
2.9 2.81 2.83 3.11 3.18
Related aspects
Bedroll & Linen
2.88 2.85 2.69 2.89 2.96
related aspects
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Comparison of Mean Scores over 5 Rounds
3.4
3.18
3.2 3.11
Mean Scores
ggmpnq@irctc.com
ISO Certification
• M/s RITES engaged as a consultant
• Aims at achieving quality standards in catering
services.
• Trains, Base Kitchens & Food Plazas targeted
Catering Units Base Kitchen Food Plaza Train Total
Upto 2007-08 23 8 2 33
During 2008-09 20 11 4 35
Total 43 19 6 68
• Departmental Rajdhani – 2951/52, 2953/54 & 2301‐02
recommended for ISO 22000 certification
Redressal of Complaints
• Spreading awareness on rate & quantity of standard meal
through colored Menu Stickers.
• Pasting of menu stickers in Mail/Express trains.
• Complaints through Toll Free no. 1800‐111‐139
• Web enabled Complaints Management System (CMS)
• Telephonic complaints redressal through our Control
Offices 24 x 7
• Now, details on Rate and Quantity of standard menu also
available on e‐ticket.
• Complaints through SMS under implementation
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Pasting of Standard Menu Sticker
ggmpnq@irctc.com
SMS/Toll Free Service on Complaints
• Toll Free Calls to land in Zonal
Controls.
• Each Zonal Control has two
dedicated landline nos. &
staff for complaint redressal.
• Direct entry of complaint on Or
Log on www.irctc.com
CMS.
• System of complaints through
SMS on 9971111139 under
trial.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Analysis of Complaints
Year 2008‐09
Nature of Complaints
18% Quality (36%)
36%
Quantity (11%)
18%
Bedroll (3%)
Hygiene (2%)
12% 11%
2% 3% Over Charging
(12%)
Staff Behaviour
(18%)
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Analysis of Complaints…
Year 2008‐09
Action Taken on Complaints
Fine (12%)
26% 12%
Warning (40%)
Terminate (0.28%)
9%
40% Counselling (13%)
13%
Sugesstion Noted (9%)
Not Substantiated (26%)
0.28%
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Shortlisting/Supplier Registration
• Expression of Interest published for PAD and
non PAD items.
• Applications received from manufacturers
scrutinized by screening committee.
• Successful applicants fulfilling eligibility
criteria are empanelled.
• Govt. of India guidelines followed for SSI Units
registered with NSIC for their empanelment.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Supply of Branded items
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Supply of Branded items
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Rate Contracts & MOUs
• Rates Contract awarded for Aerated Drinks,
Biscuits, Fruit Drink, Fruit Juice, Cakes, Chips
& PDW.
• Agreement with M/s Amul for flavored milk
products and butter in blister pack.
• MOU Signed with M/s IOC for supply of LPG
Commercial Gas Cylinders.
• MOU under finalization for milk & milk
products with M/s NCDFI.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Introduction of Hamper System
• Vendor Managed Inventory concept on
the lines of JIT.
• Hamper is a basket containing various
branded grocery items in the required
quantities enough for food productions
of no. of portions for a particular menu
A, B & C for a day.
• Food production is in the slabs named
as A1500, B 3500, C 2000 etc.
• ‘A’ stands for Menu A & 1500 stands
for no. of portions.
• Hamper is delivered by Retail Chain
Supplier a day in advance of food
production in base kitchen.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Various types of hampers
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Retail Chain Suppliers
• M/s Vishal Retails Ltd. (V‐Needs)
• M/s Aditya Birla Retail Ltd (More)
• M/s Lal Mahal Retail Ltd. (365 Retail)
• M/s Express Retail Services (Big Apple)
• M/s Reliance Fresh Ltd. (R Select)
• M/s Home Store India Ltd. (Sabka Bazar)
• M/s Esvaran Foods Mills (P) Ltd (Sunwinners)
• M/s Madhav Super Mart
• M/s Vah Magna Retail Ltd. (Vahmagna)
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Advantages to IRCTC
• Less stock in inventory.
• Less pilferage
• Timely supply
• Quality product (branded)
• No blockage of revenue
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Advantages to Supplier
• Entire requirement of grocery taken from one
supplier
• Payment made within 7 days of delivery on
production of certified bills.
• Entire supplies made in one lot.
• Purchase order is issued to supplier two days in
advance (Hamper‐wise i.e. A 1500, B 2000 etc)
• Advance planning of procurement of grocery
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Implementation
• Rajdhani Base Kitchen at New Delhi & Patna
already implemented
• Rajdhani Base Kitchen at Mumbai and Howrah
– under implementation.
• Departmental Cell Kitchens would also be
covered under this system.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Food Safety & Quality Aspects
Personal hygiene of staff
Protective clothing
Safe drinking water
Safe serving, hand wash before & after handling food
Purchasing certified products like BIS, Agmark
certification etc.
Microbiological safety of serviced foods.
Food testing & analysis.
Hygienic maintenance of base kitchens.
Pest control in static/mobile catering units.
Use of dustbins with proper garbage bag & lid.
Safe & hygienic packaging of food items.
Following safe & hygienic transportation of food items.
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Conclusions
ggmpnq@irctc.com
Thank you