Calcanectomy For Osteomyelitis
Calcanectomy For Osteomyelitis
Calcanectomy For Osteomyelitis
00/0
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL
Copyright © 1998 by the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society, Inc.
Judith F. Baumhauer, M.D.,. Carlos J. Fraga, MD.,t John S. Gould, MD.,:j: and Jeffrey E. Johnson, M.D.§
Rochester, New York, Bayamon, Puerto Rico, Charlottesville, Virginia, Birmingham, Alabama, and St. Louis, Missouri
taken, with a second look procedure in three patients. status (Table 1). Modified criteria according to Woll
A rectus free flap was used for soft tissue coverage in and Beals2 5 were used to classify the results of the
one patient. Postoperative antibiotics were used for a procedure (Table 2). This classification evaluated am-
variable period of time (range, 1-8 weeks), based on bulatory status, pain, limp, and resolution of sepsis.
consultation with the infectious disease consult ser- DF and PF strength and range of motion of the ankle
vice at the Medical College of Wisconsin. The antibi- were assessed by a physical therapist postcalcanec-
otic duration was determined by the culture results tomy for six patients. Range of motion comparison
and the clinical impression of the wound and soft between limbs was not assessed on one patient with
tissues. a contralateral below-knee amputation and one pa-
The follow-up period ranged from 6 to 57 months tient with an ipsilateral below-knee amputation.
(average, 27.3 months). Early and late complications
related to the surgical procedure were identified. All
patients were functionally assessed using a modified RESULTS
Volpicelli scale"? to compare pre- and postambulatory
Demographic information and a summary of prior
procedures, type of wound healing, complications,
Tibial
artery
Achilles tendon and functional results are listed in Table 3. In all eight
(reflected for
illustration) cases, the wound was closed primarily. A rectus free
Tibial_-fJ!t-c-'----"
flap was used for soft tissue coverage in case 1. This
nerve patient presented with a traumatic avulsion of the heel
Talus pad and osteomyelitis of the os calcis. Case 3 had
Calcaneus persistent wound drainage and developed signs and
(dorsal view) symptoms suggestive of infection 2 weeks postcalca-
nectomy. Although the patient had no fever and the
wound appeared benign despite serous drainage, she
had an elevated white blood cell count and blood
Navicular Cuboid
glucose. The decision was made to return to the op-
erating room for a repeat irrigation and debridement. A
Flexor
hallucis
second look procedure was performed after 3 days.
longus tendon Cultures obtained from the operating room demon-
strated no growth. The wound was managed with
adjunctive hyperbaric oxygen treatments and dressing
Fig. 3. Posterior, lateral, dorsal, and plantar soft tissues have been
changes. During the next 8 months, this patient was
released extraperiosteally. The calcaneus has been rotated to ex-
pose the sustentaculum tali and medial neurovascular bundle for its
managed with total contact casting to promote wound
protection during release of the medial soft tissue attachments to healing. The patient developed an ulcer and eventual
the calcaneus. osteomyelitis of the distal one-third of the tibial crest.
852 BAUMHAUER ET AL. Foot & Ankle InternationallVol. 19, No. 12/December 1998
TABLE 2 ambulation which was believed to be secondary to
Classification of Results* prolonged nonweightbearing with delayed healing, re-
Rating Definition quiring a split thickness skin graft postoperatively.
Excellent Resolution of sepsis This patient also had a complete detachment of the
Return to previous ambulatory status tibialis anterior tendon upon initial presentation. Case
No pain 2 decreased one functional ambulation level. With an
No limp
ipsilateral trans metatarsal amputation and a contralat-
Good Resolution of sepsis plus ONE of the following:
NO return to previous ambulatory status eral below-knee amputation, the functional loss attrib-
Pain uted to the calcanectomy procedure alone in this pa-
Limp tient is difficult to ascertain. Case 7 decreased two
Fair Resolution of sepsis plus TWO of the following: levels of ambulation because of generalized weakness
NO return to previous ambulatory status
and balance difficulties after calcanectomy.
Pain
Limp
The results were graded according to a modified
Poor Recurrence of infection and/or THREE of the Woll and Beals classification scale 2 5 (Table 2). Scores
following: included three excellent, one good, two fair, and two
NO return to previous ambulatory status poor. At last follow-up, there was no evidence of re-
Pain current infection in the operative feet. In this primarily
Limp
diabetic population, pain is rarely a complaint. Only
* Modified from Woll and Beals,24 1991.
case 2 complained of pain, attributed to the nonunion
of the talonavicular arthrodesis. In the remainder of the
She underwent below-knee amputation at 1 year post- cases, the grading of good, fair, and poor results were
calcanectomy. caused by limitations in ambulatory status and/or a
Early complications from the calcanectomy proce- limp.
dure included two areas of superficial wound necrosis. Ankle range of motion and strength were deter-
Each was <4 cm in size. Case 5 was successfully mined bilaterally for five patients. Two patients were
treated with dressing changes. Case 6 required a lim- excluded because of contralateral (case 2) and ipsilat-
ited debridement and split thickness skin graft. Resid- eral (case 3) below-knee amputations. Strength and
ual Achilles tendon in the wound prevented granula- range of motion were compared to the uninvolved
tion tissue from forming. With debridement, release of limb. There was a wide range of findings, from in-
the tendon, and skin coverage, the wound healed and creased to decreased for both parameters. The raw
the patient progressed with physical therapy within 4 data scores are presented in Table 3. The active OF
weeks. and PF range of motion was expressed as a difference
Talonavicular subluxation was a late complication between the operative and contralateral ankles (range,
from total calcanectomy in one case (case 2) (Fig. 4). A OF 0 -10° difference; PF -15-5° difference). The OF
talonavicular arthrodesis was performed 3 months af- and PF strength was determined using manual muscle
ter the calcanectomy procedure and the patient de- testing. OF strength was found to be decreased in the
veloped a nonunion treated with bracing (Fig. 5). operative limb by an average of 1.75 grades, and PF
Using a modified ambulatory grading scale accord- strength decreased an average of 2.0 grades.
ing to Volpicelli et al.2 0 (Table 1), four of eight patients
maintained the same level of ambulation assessed DISCUSSION
before the development of osteomyelitis and postcal-
canectomy. Three patients used a heel containment Surgical management of chronic osteomyelitis of a
orthosis incorporated into an ankle-foot orthosis portion of the calcaneus has included local curet-
(AFO), four patients required only a heel containment tage 2 ,18 or partial calcaneal resection. 6, 10,16,17,23-25
orthosis and extra-depth shoe (Fig. 6). The decision With extensive involvement of the os calcis, below-
for the need of an AFO was determined on a case-by- knee amputation has been recommended.F" In the
case basis. Case 2 needed an AFO because of the diabetic and dysvascular patient population in whom
concurrent transmetatarsal amputation. Cases 6 and the majority of these problems occur, a limb salvage
7 reported a lack of stability with the heel containment procedure is particularly attractive. Long-term fol-
orthoses alone, and a brace was fabricated for sup- low-up studies report that approximately 50% of dia-
port. These cases also demonstrated muscular weak- betics with foot infections develop a contralateral limb
ness. Case 3 underwent below-knee amputation sec- infection within 18 months."? One-third of these cases
ondary to a total contact casting complication will require an amputation of the contralateral limb at
discussed previously. Case 6 decreased one level of some level. 13 As many as 50% of unilateral amputees
dJ
0
.....
Qo
):.
TABLE 3 ::J
2S::
Demographic Information and Patient Summary CD
Duration of
:J
Case Age symptoms (prior
Follow-up
Abiiity to walk" CD
number (at presentation) Sex Diagnosis
to calcanectomy) Prior procedures postcalcanectomy
(months)
Wound healing Complications
preop/postop Result" ROM; strength :3
III
(months)
g.
1 (G.M.) 43 M Right grade III open calcaneus 18 I and 0 x four; partial 6; lost to flu Rectus free flap None VINI Excellent R L ::J
III
fracture calcanectomy OF 15 15 ::::::
PF 30 30 ~
:-
DF 5/5 5/5
......
PF 5/5 5/5 ,CO
2 (K.Z.) 33 F Right purpuric heel lesion 10 I and 0 x 1; associated 57 Deiayed primary Talonavicularsubluxationwith VlIV Poor Left: BKA;
secondary to pneumococcal
sepsis and OIC
right transmet amp closure attempted fusion and
nonunion
right: trans-
metatarsal
~
amputation ......
I\)
3 (S.B.) 37 F 100M. ieft mal perforans heel 22 I and D and partial 13 Secondary intention Persistent wound drainage; VI/below-knee Poor R L
ulcer calcanectomy x 2 before below- I and D x 2; hyperbaric amputation DF 15 BKA Q
knee amputation oxygen tx; below-knee PF 30 CD
o
amputation DF 5/5 CD
PF 5/5 :3
0-
4 (D.P.) 63 M IDOM, PVD right mal perforans
heel ulcer
3 Extremity arterial bypass 47 Primary closure None III/III Excellent R L ..,
CD
......
DF 5 5 CO
25
CO
PF 10 Q)
OF 5/5 5/5
PF 3/5 5/5
5 (L.S.) 71 M IDDM, PVO right mal perforans 2 Extremity arterial bypass 20.5 Primary closure Superficial wound necrosis; tx VN Excellent R L
heel ulcer with dressing changes OF -5 5
PF 20 25
DF 2/5 5/5
PF 3/5 5/5
6 (I.S.) 67 F 100M, PVO right mal perforans 1.5 I and 0; STSG x2 15; died of Primary closure Superficial wound necrosis VlIV Fair R L
o
I
heel ulcer unrelated cause posterior heel; STSG DF -5 5 JJ
applied PF 40 40 0
DF 1/5 5/5 Z
PF 1/5 4/5 0
7 (K.P.) 55 F 100M, left mal perforans heel 1.5 None 23; died of Delayed primary None VI/IV Fair R L o
ulcer unrelated cause closure OF 10 5 ~
r
PF 40 30 o
DF 5/5 4/5 ~
Z
PF 5/5 3/5 m
8 (S.P.) 47 M 100M, right mal perforans heel 1.5 None 37 Primary closure None VINI Good R L ~
ulcer DF 5 5
r
PF 30 40 0
(J)
DF 5/5 5/5 --I
PF 5/5 5/5 m
0
ROM, range of motion; I and 0, irrigation and debridement; OF, dorsiflexion; PF, plantarflexion; OIG, disseminated intravascular coagulation; BKA, below-knee amputation; 100M, s:
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus; PVO, peripheral vascular disease; STSG, split thickness skin grafting.
-<
m
a see Table 1.
r
=l
b see Table 2. en
Q)
CJ1
c.v
854 BAUMHAUER ET AL. Foot & Ankle Internat/onallVol. 19, No. 12/December 1998
Fig. 4. Lateral foot radiograph demonstrating the late complication Fig. 5. Lateral foot radiograph demonstrating the treatment of a
of a talonavicular subluxation (case 4). talonavicular subluxation with an attempted talonavicular arthrode-
sis and the development of a nonunion.
will undergo a contralateral amputation within 2 ambulatory in a modified AFO. The patients lost an
years." Successful rehabilitation rates range from 30% average of 10° of OF, and a variable range of PF was
to 66% for unilateral amputees and 11% to 30% for noted postoperatively. The patients decreased an av-
bilateral involvement." Preservation of function with erage of 1 to 2 manual muscle grades in OF and PF in
lower energy costs through decreased oxygen de- the operative limb as compared to the contralateral
mands has been demonstrated with foot salvage sur- limb.
gery.22 A limitation of the current study is in its retrospective
Few case series have been reported in the literature analysis without the advantage of a preoperative as-
evaluating total calcanectomy for chronic osteomyeli- sessment of strength and range of motion of the op-
tis of the calcaneus." .6.8,16 The data from these series erative limb. A comparison is made, therefore, to the
are difficult to interpret. Results were combined for the contralateral limb. The contralateral limb in the neuro-
partial and total calcanectomy procedures.Y'" length pathic patient is not normal. Because of this factor, the
of follow-up was not stated," no objective criteria were assessment of baseline for the operative limb is diffi-
used to establish the results,6,16 and complications cult to determine. In an attempt to address this prob-
related to the procedure were not reported.!" These lem, a functional assessment was performed evaluat-
studies were performed before the use of current re- ing ambulatory status. This was believed to be a more
vascularization techniques and standards known to important predictor of outcome than manual strength
improve the rates of limb salvage surgery.9,12,14,1S and range of motion testing.
This article presents the results of total calcanec- In the current study, the average length of follow-up
to my for the treatment of extensive chronic osteomy- was 27.3 months. Crandall and Wagner 6 found that
elitis of the calcaneus. Adjunctive revascularization midtarsal subluxation occurred 5 years postcalcanec-
procedures and soft tissue coverage were used to
improve the outcome of this procedure in three pa-
tients. Soft tissue coverage procedures with calcane-
ctomy have been shown to provide good function with
an adequate weightbearing surface.' Of eight patients
in this series, seven healed their surgical wounds and
are currently ambulatory. At most recent follow-up,
there is no recurrence of infection in the plantar heel in
any patient. One patient underwent below-knee am-
putation secondary to a total-contact casting compli-
cation and the development of osteomyelitis of the
anterior tibial crest. One late complication of talona-
vicular subluxation underwent a talonavicular arthro-
desis and developed a nonunion. The ipsilateral trans-
metatarsal amputation may have increased the Fig. 6. Picture of a heel containment orthosis used postcalcan-
likelihood of this complication. This patient is currently ectomy.
Foot & Ankle Internationai/Vol. 19, No. 12/December 1998 CHRONIC CALCANEAL OSTEOMYELITIS 855
to my in one patient. Continued follow-up in this pa- sure of resistant large ulcers of the heel, with or without osteo-
myelitis of the os calcis. Clin. Orthop., 84:149-153, 1972.
tient population is needed to monitor for this and other
11. Johnson, J.E., Janisse, D.J., Valdez, R.R., Hanel, D.P., and
potential late complications. The length of time for Gould, J.S.: Pedorthic management of bone and soft tissue
wound healing postcalcanectomy was not specifically defects of the heel. AOFAS Annual Summer Meeting, Napa,
addressed in the clinic records for each patient. Al- California, July 17, 1992.
though it was the largest reported series, the number 12. Karmody, A.M., Leather, A.P., Shah, D.M., Corson, J.D., and
of patients included in this review was too small for Naraynsingh, V.: Peroneal artery bypass: a reappraisal of its
value in limb surgery. J. Vase. Surg., 1:809-816, 1984.
statistical analysis. Previously published reports
13. Kucan, J.O., and Robson, M.C.: Diabetic foot infections: fate
lacked objective criteria for analysis and therefore, a of the contralateral foot. Plast. Reconstr. Surg., 77:439-441,
meta-analysis combining these series can not be per- 1986.
formed. 16. Martini, M., Martini-Benkeddache, Y., Bekhechi, T., and
Total calcanectomy is a successful alternative to Daoud, A.: Treatment of chronic osteomyelitis of the calcaneus
below-knee amputation in patients with extensive by resection of the calcaneus. J. Bone Joint Surg., 56A:542-
548,1974.
chronic osteomyelitis of the calcaneus. The infection
14. Leather, R.P., Shah, D.M, and Karmody, A.M.: Infrapopliteal
can be eradicated with preservation of function. Pre- artery bypass for limb salvage: increased patency and utiliza-
operative ambulatory patients may be functional am- tion of the saphenous vein used in situ. Surgery, 90:1000-1008,
bulators at an equal or slightly decreased level post- 1981.
calcanectomy. The procedure is safe with few 15. Logerlo, F.W., and Cuttman, J.D.: Vascular and microvascular
complications. Preoperative assessment of the vascu- disease of the foot in diabetics. N. Engl. J. Med., 311:1615-
1619,1984.
lar status of the limb and the surrounding soft tissue
17. Smith, D.G., Stuck, R.M., Ketner, L., Sage, R.M., and Pinzur,
envelope is important to evaluate the potential for M.S.: Partial calcanectomy for the treatment of large ulcerations
wound healing. Adjunctive vascular procedures to im- of the heel and calcaneal osteomyelitis. J. Bone Joint Surg.,
prove blood flow and to promote healing may be 74A:571-576, 1992.
needed. 18. Smith, J.W., Jacobs, R.L., and Fuchs, M.D.: Salvage of the
diabetic foot with exposed os calcis. Clin. Orthop., 296:71-77,
1993.
REFERENCES 19. Snow, S.W., Bohne, W.H., DiCarlo, E., and Chang, V.K.:
Anatomy of the Achilles tendon and plantar fascia in relation to
1. Anderson, R.B., Foster, M.D., Gould, J.S., and Hanel, D.P.: the calcaneus in various age groups. Foot Ankle Int., 16:418-
Free tissue transfer and calcanectomy as treatment of chronic 21,1995.
osteomyelitis of the os calcis: a case report. Foot Ankle, 11: 20. Volpicelli, L.J., Chambers, R.B., and Wagner, W.F., Jr.: Am-
168-171,1990. putation levels of bilateral lower extremity amputees: analysis of
2. Antoniou, D., and Conner, A.N.: Osteomyelitis of the calca- one hundred and three cases. J. Bone Joint Surg., 65A:599-
neus and talus. J. Bone Joint Surg., 56A:338-345, 1974. 605,1983.
3. Apelqvist, J., Castenfors, J., Larsson, J., Stenstrom, A., and
21. Wagner, F.W.: A Classification and treatment program for dia-
Agardh, C.D.: Prognostic value of systolic ankle and toe blood
betic, neuropathic and dysvascular foot problems. AAOS Instr.
pressure levels in outcome of diabetic foot ulcer. Diabetes Care,
Course Lect., 28:143-165, 1979.
12:373-378, 1989.
22. Waters, R.L., Perry, J., Antonelli, D., and Hislop, H.: Energy
4. Bodily, K.C, and Burgess, E.M.: Contralateral limb and patient
cost of walking or amputees: the influence of level of amputa-
survival after leg amputation. Am. J. Surg., 146:280-282, 1983.
tion. J. Bone Joint Surg., 58A:42-46, 1976.
5. Couch, N.B., David, J.K., Tilney, N.L., and Crane, C.: Natural
history of leg amputee. Am. J. Surg., 133:469-473, 1977. 23. Weisenfeld, L.S., Flannery, D., Luzzi, A., and Picciotti, J.:
6. Crandall, R.C., and Wagner, F.W.: Partial and total calcanec- Partial calcanectomy for the treatment of osteomyelitis of the os
tomy. J. Bone Joint Surg., 63A:152-155, 1981. calcls. J. Foot Surg., 29:226-230, 1990.
7. Gaenslen, F.J.: Split heel approach in osteomyelitis of the os 24. Wiltse, L.L., Bateman, G., and Kase, S.: Resection of major
calcis. J. Bone Joint Surg., 13:759-772, 1931. portion of the calcaneus. Clin. Orthop., 13:271-278, 1959.
8. Giacalone, V.F., Gregory, J.L., and Krych, S.M.: Calcanec- 25. WolI, T.S., and Beals, A.K.: Partial calcanectomy for the treat-
tomy for the treatment of calcaneal osteomyelitis. J. Am. Podi- ment of osteomyelitis of the calcaneus. Foot Ankle, 12:31-34,
atr. Med. Assoc., 81:88-92, 1991. 1991.
9. Hobson, R.W., Lynch, T.G., Jami, Z., Karvantelian, R.G., 26. Yuh, W.T.C., Corson, J.D., Baraniewski, H.M., Rezai, K.,
Bing, L.C., Padberg, F.T., Jr., and Long, J.B.: Results of Shamma, A.R., Kathol, M.H., Sato, Y., EI-Khoury, G.Y.,
revascularization and amputation in severe lower extremity Hawes, D.R., Platz, C.E., Cooper, A.A., and Corry, R.J.:
ischemia: a five year clinical experience. J. Vase. Surg., 2:174- Osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients: evaluation with
185, 1985. plain film, 99mTc-MDP bone scintigraphy and MR imaging.
10. Horwitz, T.: Partial resection of the os calcis and primary clo- Am. J. Roentgenol., 152:795-800, 1989.