Microstructural and Corrosion Resistance
Microstructural and Corrosion Resistance
Microstructural and Corrosion Resistance
Ferdinando Marco Rodrigues Borges 1#, Rafaela Luiz Pereira Santos1#, Valdemar Silva
Leal 2, José Ribeiro dos Santos Júnior 1, Anderson Oliveira Lobo 1*, Romulo Ribeiro
Magalhães de Sousa 1*
1
Materials and Science and Engineering graduate program, UFPI-Federal University of
romulorms@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
Superduplex stainless steel (SDSS) has ferrite and austenite phases in its microstructure
especially when it comes to applied welding energies. In the extraction of petroleum, wear
occurs between the friction of tools and rocky materials with interior of pipes of the
SDSS. SDSS has poor tribological properties so that they are subject to the above-
mentioned wear. Low temperature plasma nitriding falls within this context in order to
provide a surface layer with excellent wear resistance and without significant loss in
corrosion resistance. Here two nitriding techniques named conventional nitriding (CN)
and cathodic cage nitriding (CCN) were compared to modify SDSS surface. In addition,
the microstructure and the corrosion resistance of welded joint with and without nitriding
were evaluated. Optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction and
potentiodynamic polarization characterized the welded joint after nitriding. The SDSS
nitrided by CN provided a higher corrosion resistance than the CCN corrosion potential
(EC= equal to -0,06V to CN and -0.22V to CCN). The differences were attributed to the
which gave passive film more resistant to the corrosive attack of chloride ions.
1. INTRODUCTION
Super-duplex stainless steels (SDSS) are a category of stainless steels that exhibit
austenitic and ferritic microstructural phases in proportions of approximately (50:50)
50% each, due to their chemical composition and heat treatment. It has high Cr content
(24% - 27%) are also characterized by low carbon content (less than 0.03% by weight).
2.5%), copper (0.2% - 2.5%) and nitrogen (0.10 % - 0.35%). These steels are used in
locations with aggressive atmospheres that require high corrosion resistance and
excellent mechanical properties (Neto et al., 2016). These metals have wide application
systems, evaporators, distillers, storage tanks, among others, where the properties
reported above are necessary (Hsieh, et al, 2001). Even with all these qualities
mentioned, these steels are not immune to localized corrosion attacks originating from
tribocorrosion. One example is the extraction of oil in deep water. The rocky material
causes friction in the ducts, removing the passive film, favoring the penetration of
aggressive ions, such as Cl- (chlorides), the main cause of pitting corrosion (César, et
al., 2011).
In soldering the SDSS, the main difficulty is to keep the percentages of the phases close
to 50% and avoid the formation of deleterious phases (precipitates that decrease the
resistance to corrosion) during the cooling. The welding thermal input must conform to
the standard (0.5 to 2.0 kJ / mm) to keep the austenite and ferrite fractions as close as
possible. When the heat generated in the welding is so high, there is time in the cooling
process of formation of deleterious precipitates; and when there are volumetric austenite
fractions of less than 25%, this becomes unacceptable for most industrial applications
because they considerably reduce corrosion resistance (Norsok Standard, 2004). What
happens is that besides chromium, the chemical elements that give greater resistance to
the corrosion are the nickel, the manganese and the nitrogen. These are mainly
concentrated in austenite (γ). Therefore the phase “γ” has greater resistance to corrosion
when compared to ferrite (α). However, the “α”phase has higher mechanical resistance
due to the greater presence of chromium, molybdenum and silicon elements in its
maintain stability of mechanical strength and corrosion (Hsieh et al., 2001). The
corrosion. Usually the solder addition metals have a nickel content between 2-4%
higher than the base metal content, because nickel is a gamogenic element, stabilizer of
In the case of tribological properties of SDSS, the behavior is not reasonable, that is,
less than desirable hardness and low wear resistance (Neto et al., 2016). This behavior
can be observed in the petroleum industry in the wear caused by the friction of metallic
cables and rocky materials with the inner wall of the tubes. An interesting alternative to
improve the surface hardness of these materials is the use of conventional plasma (CN)
and cathodic cathode (CCN) nitriding. CN promotes the dissociation of nitrogen atoms,
which are ionized and transported at high speeds up to the metal surface. A
characteristic layer is produced by the diffusion of nitrogen on the surface of the metal
and the properties of this surface layer can be modified by varying the parameters of the
process, such as temperature, treatment time and pressure. It has been observed that
plasma nitriding increases surface hardness and wear resistance, but depending on the
temperature used (above 450 ° C), corrosion resistance can be decreased. This fact
occurs due to the precipitation of chromium nitride to the detriment of its migration
from the substrate. The chromium binds to the nitrogen present in the atmosphere of the
reactor forming CrN (Reis & Ii, 2008). Thus, it is necessary to create a hard layer on the
steel surface without compromising corrosion resistance. Generally, the CN of stainless
steel at a temperature of about 380 to 450 ° C has no adverse effects on the corrosion
resistance, due to the formation of a zone of high hardness, resulting from the diffusion
of the nitrogen in the crystalline cross-linked of the austenite, known as the γNphase
(expanded austenite) with a cubic face centered structure (FCC) (Sousa et al., 2012).
As we are dealing with welded joints of superduplex steels, the behavior of the nitriding
differs from the nitriding in the metal as received, that is, laminated. The grain structure
of the region of the weld is more refined, there are more grain contours, which favors
the diffusion of the nitrogen in the crystalline lattice. This will result in higher hardness
values in the weld region. In the literature, very rare work on nitriding in welded joints
is observed, especially Alphonsa, et al. (2013), in which the treatment was carried out
on an austenitic steel. However, the study did not address the behavior of nitrided welds
In this paper, in addition to the conventional plasma nitriding technique, the use of the
cathodic cage (CCN) nitriding technique will also be used. This is a device used to
provide uniformity and greater hardness of deposited layers. There have been many
studies with this artifice in the last decade (period that was created), however, in the
literature, there were no studies that use the cathodic cage in welded joints. At CCN, the
samples are electrically insulated because they are on top of a ceramic disk (alumina). A
voltage source applies a potential difference between the reactor wall (anode) and the
cathodic cage (cathode). Atoms are plucked from the surface of the cage and combined
with the reactive gas in the plasma atmosphere, forming compounds that attach to the
surface of the sample. The main advantage of CCN is the formation of a uniform layer,
regardless of the size and geometry of the sample used (Sousa, 2007). Based on the
above information, mainly in what CN and CCN can provide to the weld in terms of
tribological properties and resistance to corrosion, and the shortage of nitrided welded
joints, this work has the objective of evaluating the microstructure and the corrosion
2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
The base material used in this work was the superduplex stainless steel (UNS S32750)
with filler wire (ER 2594). Details of the chemical compositions of the base metal and
The welding was accomplished by the MIG-MAG proceeding (Metal inert gas/ Metal
active gas) by surface tension transfer (STT), as filler wire was used the ER 2594 and
protective gas (Ar + 2% O2), the pure Argon as purge gas at the root. The weld bead
was made using a PW-455m/STT source linked to a robotic arm HP-20 for automatic
automatized system that has advanced speed control. The welding was performed in two
Standards were also followed Norsok Standard (2004), to avoid phase imbalance and
the appearance of intermetallic precipitates, because in both cases, they could weaken
the welded joint. For the accomplishment of the work, test joints were welded to obtain
full filling of the chamfer with two passes, using the planned welding energies. After
finding the welding parameters, it was transferred to the work plate. This was machined
to the pair, with each part having the following dimensions: 150 x 150 x 6 mm, with V-
wedge (α = 60⁰), root aperture (d) 2 mm and sheet thickness (t) of 6 mm.
Subsequently, the joints were arranged on a copper-joint to enable the integrity of the
root of the weld. After welding, the specimens were drawn in the transversal direction to
reinforcement and plan the plate. Posteriorly, the samples were sanded with water sands
(granulometry of 200, 320, 400, 600 and 1200 MESH) and polished on felt disc with
Diamond paste (3m) and lubricating fluid for cleaning and finishing. Lastly, prior to
each nitriding treatment, the samples were cleaned in Acetone P. A. for 10 minutes on
an ultrasound device.
Table 1. Chemical composition of the superduplex stainless steel (UNS S32750) and
Material Cr Mo Ni C N Mn Si P S Fe
UNS S32750 24.92 3.77 7.05 0.014 0.261 0.76 0.39 0.022 0.001 Bal.
ER 2594 24.92 3.9 9.19 0.011 0.28 0.6 0.46 0.019 0.005 Bal.
Welding
speed
Type of Medium Medium Welding Energy
Filling
122 15.3 1.33 1.4
pass
2.2 Plasma nitriding process
In the conventional ionic nitriding and cathodic cage, the same equipment was
used, which contains a voltage source with a maximum current of 1500V and 2A,
made of stainless steel. The device called cathodic cage was made with austenitic
stainless steel sheet (AISI 304), 0.8mm thickness, 112mm in diameter, 25mm high and
holes with 8mm in diameter distributed uniformly with distance of 9.2mm between
formed in the cage, which functions as a cathode (the chamber wall is the anode) and
not directly on the surface of the samples (conventional nitriding), which remain in
floating potential. In both techniques used, firstly occur the previous treatment (called
atmosphere of composition balanced with 50% H2 + 50% Ar, also have the function of
cleaning the assembly, activating the surface for interaction with the plasma and make
the removing impurities remaining. The nitriding parameters are showed in Table 3.
Table 3. Nitriding parameters.
Conventional N2:H2
WJ – Welded Joint.
*
To certify the phases composition present in the welded joint of AISD UNS
S32750, was used the X-ray diffraction analysis on the diffractometer model
collected under the following conditions: voltage = 40kV, current = 30mA, in the
angular range 35-85° (2) with a step of 0.02626 ° (2θ) and count time of 80.15s. The
HighScore Plus version 3.0 software and ICSD database were used to identify the
crystalline phases. The cristalograpfic charts used were 108132, 625865 and 020389.
For microstructural characterization of the base metal (BM), of welding zones, of the
nitrided layers and to calculate the volumetric fractions of ferrrite was used optical
microscopy. The images were captured at the top and weld profile by the Bel Photonics
metabisulphite) to reveal the microstructure. The ferrite presented a low relief when
compared austenite in contact with Behara attack, because their reactivity that
facilitating the differentiation of these phases. The measurements of layer thickness and
volumetric fractions calculations of ferrite were performed with the support of Image J
software.
In the layer thickness measurements, ten measurements were made along the nitrided
layer from which the arithmetic mean arose. In the volumetric fraction calculation of
ferrite was adopted the increase of 200X. The image was binarized and ten (10) fields
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Quanta 250 FEG, FEI) was used to
qualitatively evaluate the microstructure of the welded joint in the upper part, in order to
electrochemical tests were carried out using a three-electrode cell, with a graphite
reference electrode and the working electrode being the same sample of the welded
plate delimited by a oring with 1 cm2 of area. Samples were kept in open circuit for 1
hour for system stabilization. A solution of 3.5% NaCl was used as electrolyte. The
polarization test was performed with initial scan potential of 0.15V and a scanning
speed of 1 mV/ s. The data was obtained using an open circuit potential and the final
Fig. 1(a) shows the microstructural analysis of the material as received. It was
lamellae (α - dark phase) and austenite lamellae (γ - lighter phase). Both phases are
the results found by Pessoa (2015), when conducting research involving the UNS
S32750 steel.
The ferrite volumetric fractions quantification was performed on the base metal,
obtaining an average value of 47.66%. The values found are within the expected range.
This result is consistent because in SDSS the proportion between the phases should be
approximately 50% -50% to ensure that the properties are suitable, as already studied in
(Gunn, 1997). The same samples used in optical microscopy were submitted to the SEM
the presence of elongated austenitic islands (γ) in the direction of lamination, the
characteristic microstructure appears in first plane regarding the ferritic matrix, similar
Figure 2 shows the X-ray diffraction pattern collected from welded joint using a
superduplex steel (WJ UNS S32750). The diffractogram shows the presence of two
distint phases: ferrite- cofirmed by reflexion plans (110), (200) e (211) and austenite
(110)
600
−Fe
−Fe
Intensity (a.u.)
400
(200)
(220)
200
(200)
(211)
0
40 50 60 70 80
2(Degree)
A series of tests were performed before the welding procedure to find the
parameters that: (i) propitiated the chamfer filled, (ii) good penetration in the root, (iii)
suitable reinforcement of the weld bead and (iv) welding energies within established
limits. As a starting point for the welding values, were used standard of superduplex
steels (Norsok Standard, 2004). It was verified that besides the chamfer fully filled
(Figure 3 (a)) and optimal penetration at the root (Figure 3 (b)), the visual aspect in both
Figure 3. (a) Visual aspect of the chamfer filled (b) Visual apspect of the weld root.
After the welding procedure, a sample was removed from the joint for
metallography procedure. With the chemical attack, the heat affected zone (HAZ) can
be easily identified. It was observed on the sides of the fusion zone (FZ), adjacent to the
melting lines, as a region of high ferrite content and coarse granulometry (Figure 4).
The HAZ constituent phases presented are in accordance with Schaeffler's Diagram
(Lippold & Kotecki, 2005). The adjustment of the chemical composition to obtain a
biphasic microstructure can be made from the chromium and nickel equivalent concept.
stainless-steel. Thus, the present structures were obtained by applying the chromium
and nickel equivalent criteria at room temperature. Chromium equivalent is the set of
elements that stabilize the ferrite phase and the nickel equivalent is the set of elements
that stabilize the austenitic phase (Lima, 2011). From the composition of the material as
received, were calculated the corresponding chromium and nickel equivalent by the
Mn], the values obtained were Creq = 29.275% and Nieq = 15.68%.With these results
was verified a duplex structure in the Schaeffler diagram , corroborating with the phases
In the SDSS welding, the fusion zone temperature can reach 1500°C. Above
1300°C the austenite is not stable, wich facilitates the ferritic grains formation
(Modenesi, et al,, 2005). The pronounced growth of the ferritic grains observed in the
HAZ (Figure 4), occurs due to high temperature and cooling rate in the specified region
that has been affected. High temperatures promoted the ferritic grains growth and the
BM
rapid cooling reduced ferrite to austenite transformations. Similar results were observed
by Videira (2016).
(Atarmet & King, 1992). It is important to emphasize that both the base metal and the
addition metal have gamagenic (austenite stabilizers) and alhpagenic (ferrite stabilizers)
chemical elements (Pinto, 2009). The consequence is that in the cooling of the metal
Three different austenite morphologies were observed for the HAZ and fusion
zone with the welding parameters applied. Figure 6(a) shows the structures intragranular
(inside the grain), alotriomorphic (in the grain boundary) and Widmanstätten (getting
out of the grain boundary into the grain). Such morphologies were also observed in
Fonseca (2016).
austenite and grows within delta ferrite grain. This behavior can be explained due the
presence of larger ferritic grains and slow cooling rates, propitiating the emergence of
the three austenite morphologies. When the grain boundary region is already saturated
with allotriomic austenite and the cooling temperature still favors the austenitic
transformation, the Widmanstätten austenite expands into the grain. The observed in the
literature (Ameyama, et al., 1992) also occurred in this work as can be proven by Figure
6 (a). There is benefit in the appearance of this microstructure, because it promotes a
beneficial because the presence of toughness microstructure with a low carbon content,
temperature. The volumetric fraction of ferrite in the HAZ was calculated based on its
full extent. In the case of the fusion zone, top images were used, Figure 6 (b). The
volumetric fraction of ferrite was calculated with the same methodology used for the
base metal, from the average values. Were obtained 53.79% for HAZ and 35.88% for
FZ. These results corroborate with the literature, Norsok Standard (2004), because in
the MIG/MAG processes the volumetric fractions of ferrite tend to be larger in the
HAZ, while in the fusion zone these values tend to be smaller, by the use of filler wire
with a higher percentage of Nickel. It is evident, then, that welding energy has diferente
effects on the microstructural changes undergone in the HAZ when compared to those
occuring in the fusion zone. This behavior can be attributed to high temperature and
consequently lower cooling rates that occur in the FZ, which results in a longer time for
Intragranular); 1000X magnification; (c) CN at 400 ⁰C. (d) CCN at 400 ⁰C; (e) x-Ray
welded joint of UNS S32750 superduplex stainless steel (WJ UNS S32750) and
The Figure 6 (c) shown the diffusion layer obtained after 5 hours of conventional
treatment (CN 400°C) in a gas atmosphere containing 20% N2 and 80% H2 at 400°C. In
microscopy it is possible to observe the presence of a thin and continuous layer, with a
lighter shade. X-ray diffractogram (Figure 6 (e)) identified planes (111), (110), (200) e
(ferrite) and − Fe (expanded ferrite) phases respectivelly confirming the results of
optical microscopy (Figure 6(c)). It can be inferred that the nitrided layer consists
largely of expanded austenite and expanded ferrite, and the formation of chromium
nitrides (CrN and/or Cr2N) does not occur. The expanded austenite (γN) originates from
the volumetric expansion of the Face Centered Cubic (FCC) crosslinked of the austenite
phase (γ), due to its in nitrogen (N) supersaturation. The intersticial N introduces large
promotes hardening and can increase the hardness of 4GPa to values close to 14GPa,
without a significant loss of corrosion resistance. The same diffusive process occurs
with the ferrite in its BCC crosslinked (Body Centred Cubic), forming the expanded
(CCN 400°C) in a gas atmosphere containing 80% N2 and 20% H2 at 400°C are shown
in Figure 6 (d). Unlike conventional treatment, a coumponds zones was observed when
CCN was used. When CCN is used, the sputtering system is more concentred, due to
the presence of holes in cage, called hollow cathode, propitiating a large ejection of iron
atoms from the holes and more intense interaction with the nitrogen atoms of the
consequence it can be observed the more intense formation of the Fe3N phase (Sousa et
al., 2012), this behavior can be seen in Figure 6 (e), at angles 2θ = 40,88°, 44,30° and
46,18°, respectivelly.
Thickness measurement of the nitrided layers are shown in Table 4. It should be noted
that failure to record thickness measurements for the compounds zone in the
conventionally treated sample does not imply that they do not exist. Irregular formation
and very thin thickness of the Fe3N phase may be occured in the CN treatment,
however, this fact may not have been verified by the technique used.
Nitreted layer
Standard deviation
superduplex stainless steel weld joint without nitriding, conventional plasma and
cathodic cathodic alloys. The sample curves show well defined active, passive and
The slope of the curve with respect to the axis of the current density in the
passivation region of the sample without nitriding is smaller than that of the nitrided
samples. This behavior is related to the presence of the chromium oxide film that
naturally appears in the stainless steels in contact with the atmosphere. Taking into
account that the weld region presented a high percentage of austenite, this contributed to
the high corrosion resistance. It is then considered that the intentional solder energy
used corroborated to these large formations of the austenite phase and consequent
greater resistance to degradation. Among the nitrided samples, the corrosion behavior
obtained by the CN 400°C was higher than the CCN 400°C. The presence of the
expanded austenite and expanded ferrite phases detected in the X-ray diffraction of
Figure 6 (e) played a crucial role, as these phases confer excellent tribological properties
without considerable losses in corrosion resistance (Reis & Ii, 2008). In the literature
(Sousa et al., 2012), the CCN 400°C samples presented higher and more uniform
that the corrosion results fell short of the conventionally treated sample. It can be
inferred that the sputtering mechanism of each treatment contributed to this result.
While expanded austenite and expanded ferrite were used in the conventional
treatment because of the prevalence of the nitrogen diffusion mechanism in the steel
melting pot, using cathodic cage the mechanism was sputtering in the cage, consequent
pulling out of Fe atoms, binding of Fe the nitrogen of the nitriding atmosphere and
formation of the iron nitride and condensation of this in the substrate of the steel under
study. This finding of the presence of this Fe3N phase can be seen in the XRD of Figure
6 (e). The iron nitride has a lower corrosion resistance than the phases obtained in the
penetration of chloride ions of the solution in the layer and triggering the pites
formation (Sousa, 2007). Pite is the type of localized corrosion processed in points or
small areas on the metallic surface producing cavities that present the bottom in an
angular shape and depth generally larger than its diameter (Gentil, 1987)
(transpassivation) is observed. It is in the anodic part, in the transition between the end
of the passivation region and the beginning of the abrupt increase of the current density,
indicating that there was rupture of the passive film. Table 5 presents the following
values: Corrosion Potential (ECorrosion), Corrosion Current Density (jCorrosion) and Pite
means of this electrochemical technique, is not punctual. It uses the values shown in
Table 5, added to the slope of the curve in the passive region, indicating that the greater
the angle between this and the x-axis (corrosion current density) the more passive the
material will be. Considering these assumptions, it is observed that the behavior of
welded joints without nitriding is the most resistant against the attack of aggressive
4. CONCLUSIONS
The parameters used in the welding allowed power in the 1.4 kJ / m range. This
yielded ferrite volumetric fractions of 53, 79% in HAZ and 35.88% in FZ. These values
are in cossonance with Norsok Standard.Due to the high percentage of austenite in the
passivation materials; that is, the weld presented films resistant to the chloride ion
Of the nitrided samples, the one treated conventionally at 400 ° C showed better results
against corrosion. These were higher due mainly to the presence of the expanded
austenite phase detected in x-ray diffraction. Expanded austenite is a phase that provides
high hardness by expanding the CFC structure of the austenite resulting from the
insertion of the nitrogen into the interstices without significant loss in corrosion
resistance. Finally, the cathodic cathodic samples exhibited corrosion resistance lower
than those conventionally treated mainly by the presence of the Fe3N ( - Iron Nitride)
5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
the Federal University of Uberlândia) and the Plasma Laboratory and Electrochemistry
6. REFERENCES
Alphonsa, J., Padsala, B. A., Chauhan, B. J., Jhala, G., Rayjada, P. A., Chauhan, N.,
Raole, P. M. 2013. Plasma nitriding on welded joints of AISI 304 stainless steel.
Ameyama, K., Weatherly, G. C., & Aust, K. T. 1992. A study of grain boundary
Atarmet, S.,King. J.E.1992. Super duplex stainless steels - part 1 heat affected zone
César, R., Silva, C., Nogueira, R. P., & Bastos, I. N. 2011. Electrochimica Acta
Tribocorrosion of UNS S32750 in chloride medium : Effect of the load level. 56,
8839–8845. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electacta.2011.07.077
De Sousa, R. R. M., De Araújo, F. O., Gontijo, L. C. C., Da Costa, J. a P., Alves, C.,
Sousa, R. R. . de, … Alves Jr., C. 2012. Cathodic cage plasma nitriding (CCPN) of
austenitic stainless steel (AISI 316): In fl uence of the different ratios of the (N 2
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vacuum.2012.05.008
Woodhead Publishing.
Hsieh, R.-I., Liou, H.-Y., & Pan, Y.-T. 2001. Effects of cooling time and alloying
10(5), 526–536.
Lippold, J. C., & Kotecki, D. J. 2005. Welding Metallurgy and Weldability of Stainless
Neto, J. O. P., Da Silva, R. O., Da Silva, E. H., Moreto, J. A., Bandeira, R. M.,
Manfrinato, M. D., & Rossino, L. S. 2016. Wear and corrosion study of plasma
nitriding F53 super duplex stainless steel. Materials Research. 19(6), 1241–1252.
https://doi.org/10.1590/1980-5373-MR-2015-0656
Norsok, V., & Reference, S. (2004). Welding and Inspection of Piping.
s32750 utilizando o processo arame tubular. Phd Thesis. Pos Graduate Program in
superduplex soldadas por gmaw pulsado com diferentes misturas gasosas, 115. Pos
Sul.
Reis, D. O. S., & Ii, A. M. 2008. Nitretação à plasma do aço inoxidável austenítico ISO
Senatore, M., Finzetto, L., & Perea, E. 2007. Estudo comparativo entre os aços
Tavares, S. S. M., Pardal, J. M., Lima, L. D., Bastos, I. N., Nascimento, A. M., & de
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2006.07.006
(110)
600
−Fe
−Fe
Intensity (a.u.)
400
(200)
(220)
200
(200)
(211)
0
40 50 60 70 80
2(Degree)
Intragranular); 1000X magnification; (c) CN at 400 ⁰C. (d) CCN at 400 ⁰C; (e) x-Ray
Table 1. Chemical composition of the superduplex stainless steel (UNS S32750) and
Material Cr Mo Ni C N Mn Si P S Fe
UNS S32750 24.92 3.77 7.05 0.014 0.261 0.76 0.39 0.022 0.001 Bal.
ER 2594 24.92 3.9 9.19 0.011 0.28 0.6 0.46 0.019 0.005 Bal.
speed
Type of Medium Medium Welding Energy
Filling
122 15.3 1.33 1.4
pass
Conventional N2:H2
Nitreted layer
Standard deviation