2023 Industry Report
2023 Industry Report
2023 Industry Report
− Property Improvements 34
Introduction | TOC 1
SECTION 1
Introduction
In recent years, property managers have faced constant
reminders of the conflict that can arise between their
overlapping roles—their responsibility to balance their
clients’ financial interests with their empathy for the renters
whose homes they manage, as well as their concern for
the health of their own business.
Rental affordability: Strong demand for 2017—and more than half anticipate significant
a limited supply of low- and mid-priced growth. Companies are actively recruiting new
rentals continues to push prices up, clients; scaling up to accommodate their current
overloading renters already dealing clients’ growth; expanding their portfolios with
with inflation and pandemic-induced new property types and in new metro areas; and
financial struggles, and resulting in searching for innovative services to prove their
fewer qualified applicants.
value to owners and renters in a time of intense
Staffing: Owners’ compressed margins competition and strained affordability.
put pressure on property managers to
How do they plan to accomplish all of this, in spite
keep overhead low. This challenges
of the headwinds that respondents identified
companies to optimize their processes
in our survey? We discovered one consistent
to maintain a level of service that proves
the value of professional management, theme across a majority of property management
while operating with smaller teams. professionals’ responses, and it can be summed
up in just 10 words: Personalized customer
Competition: High rent growth and service and streamlined processes, made
RENT rental demand have drawn more
possible with technology.
companies into property management,
increasing the competition for clients Based on the experiences of thousands of
and properties just as property property management professionals—as well as
managers are looking to expand. rental owners and renters—this report will share:
SECTION 2
*Note: Throughout the report, we use the term ‘third-party property managers’ to refer to companies
that manage other investors’ rental properties, rather than or in addition to properties they own.
Growth 1 0
Efficiency 2 +2
Profitability 3 +2
Owners 4 –1
Residents 5 –3
Staff 6 +2
Vendors 7 0
Marketing 8 +3
Communication 9 +3
Organization 10 0
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Balance 11 –5
Technology 12 –3
Property improvements 13 0
How Property Management Companies Plan to Grow 4
Stayed the same size 11% 12% 19% 17% 16% 11%
2%
6%
*Excludes property managers who exclusively manage their own investment properties
TABLE OF CONTENTS
How Property Management Companies Plan to Grow 5
HOW PROPERTY MANAGERS PLAN TO GROW THEIR PORTFOLIOS IN THE NEXT 2 YEARS*
Recruiting new
clients 77 %
Encouraging current
clients to grow 51%
Acquiring other
companies/portfolios 39%
Purchasing/building
new properties 31%
Managing new
property types 30%
Expanding to new
metro areas 30%
TABLE OF CONTENTS
How Property Management Companies Plan to Grow 6
More property management companies have reported revenue growth over the
2
last two years than we’ve seen since 2017 as some pandemic-related financial
difficulties have stabilized. Half of the respondents who are bringing in more than
they were two years ago report that their revenue has grown by a significant
amount—a term that most agree represents growth of more than 25%.
Virtually all property management companies expect their revenue to rise over
3
the next two years, representing the highest revenue expectations we’ve seen
since 2018, and another significant increase since the pandemic first hit. Half of
our respondents said they expect significant growth in their company’s revenue
throughout 2023 and 2024—an outlook that’s more positive than we’ve seen in our
survey for the last five years.
2%
5% PROPERTY MANAGERS' EXPECTED REVENUE
GROWTH OVER THE NEXT 2 YEARS*
*Excludes property managers who exclusively manage their own investment properties
How Property Management Companies Plan to Grow 7
Increasing rents/
resident fees 73%
Leveraging technology
to drive efficiency 48%
Expanding service
offerings 45%
Making value-add
updates to properties 44%
Increasing
rates/client fees 44%
73% of our survey respondents planned to raise rents, and 44% planned to increase the
fees that they charge to clients, between mid-2022 and mid-2024. Many small and mid-
sized property management businesses forewent significant price increases during the
worst of the COVID-19 crisis. However, with their own costs rising astronomically—and with
strong demand for both rentals and property management services expected to continue—
many companies feel that raising their rates is an inevitable next step.
To generate additional revenue, property management companies are searching for add-on
services that appeal to residents with disposable income, and that can set their properties
apart by making them a more enjoyable place to live. Similarly, in response to demand
from investors and competition from larger real estate firms, many property management
companies are offering more services to their clients than in the past. 45% of our
respondents said their company planned to increase the services it provides to renters and
owners over the next two years; though each will have to strike a balance between offering
the services that their customers want, those that set them apart from the competition, and
those that generate consistent revenue.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction | TOC 8
Leasing properties/
92% 70% 60%
marketing vacancies
Purchasing/selling/
SALE
64% 14% 43%
brokering property sales
Accounting/
bookkeeping
72% 44% 14%
Financial reporting/
50% 25% 8%
benchmarking
Financial/investment
26% 6% 4%
advice
*Excludes property managers who exclusively manage their own investment properties,
as well as rental owners who don't currently have a property manager
How Property Management Companies Plan to Grow 9
The ongoing labor shortage—along with the pressure to keep costs low—can make it hard
for companies to attract and retain high-quality staff members at the same pace at which
they’re adding new doors. As a result, respondents told us, they’re turning to technology to
help them provide consistent, attentive service to their customers without adding to their
teams or overburdening current staff members.
One of the main ways that technology is able to help in this area is through its ability to
centralize key information and communications, allowing anyone to respond to requests
from customers or team members, whether they’re in the office, in the field, or working from
home. In addition, technology helps property management teams to automate repetitive
tasks. This has the benefit of creating more fulfilling work for employees, freeing up their
time so they can focus on higher-order functions like devising strategies to generate
additional revenue, and delivering the quality of service that differentiates small and mid-
sized companies from larger competitors.
We stopped taking rent payments and Having systems that [are] more streamlined
applications in our office and do it all allows us to take on more properties. Online
electronically, and this has saved us so much payments save time because we do not have
time. We now can focus on relationships and to manually enter them. Texting residents saves
have found that we are attracting better long- time because it’s not a 5-minute phone call.
term clients and tenants. Storing all files electronically saves time as we
(REAL ESTATE BROKER IN GRAND JUNCTION, CO) can access [them] from anywhere, at any time.
(COMPANY OWNER IN SPRINGFIELD, MO)
SECTION 3
This increase illustrates the degree to which the pandemic-era rental market has
complicated the business of owning rental property, from increased regulations to inflated
costs, supply chain delays, and labor shortages. As a result, rental owners of all experience
levels are turning to property management companies for assistance with regulatory
compliance, resident management, maintenance and repairs, and more—which makes
particular sense when you consider that nearly two-thirds of owners don’t live near their
rental properties.
But even as property management teams devote significant energy to client acquisition
and portfolio growth, many have learned that it’s worthwhile to take the time to ensure
that they’re signing the right clients. After the difficulties of the last three years, property
managers told us, they want to work with owners who are willing to invest in their
properties; who understand the delicate balance between profitability and affordability in
the current market; and who will work collaboratively and empathetically with their property
management team and their residents to resolve any issues that arise.
However, with rising mortgage rates slowing down the pace of home sales, a new
generation of Accidental Landlords may decide to rent out their homes as they wait for a
more lucrative time to sell.
Today, 76% of rental owners consider themselves investors, while just 24% identify as
Accidental Landlords. However, Accidental Landlords may appear to be more prevalent
within property managers’ client base because they’re still the most likely to seek out their
services: 71% of Accidental Landlords currently have a property manager, in comparison
with 62% of Intentional Investors and 59% of Unintentional Investors.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 13
The exodus of “mom-and-pop” landlords from the market is likely not over yet. Our survey
of rental owners was conducted in the first half of 2022. As of that time, 37% of owners
who remained in the rental market were considering selling at least one of their properties
between mid-2022 and mid-2024, of whom 20% rated themselves as likely to sell (a slight
increase since 2021). 55% of owners who planned to sell any of their properties had no
plans to acquire new ones in their place.
RENTAL OWNERS' PLANS TO SELL ANY OF THEIR PROPERTIES IN THE NEXT 2 YEARS
Owners Who Plan to Stay the Same Size ACQUISITION PLANS AMONG RENTAL OWNERS
CONSIDERING SELLING PROPERTIES IN 2022–2024
At the time of our survey, half of rental owners planned
to keep their portfolios the same size between mid-
2022 and mid-2024. This group included both rental Don’t plan to acquire any
owners who didn’t plan to make any changes to their 56 % new properties in place
of the ones they sell
holdings; as well as those who planned to sell off their
more cumbersome or less profitable properties and Plan to acquire new residential
rentals to replace those they
acquire new ones in their place. 28%
sell—as many or more than
they had before
Nearly half of the rental owners who indicated that
they plan to sell some or all of their properties over Plan to acquire new residential
the next two years also intend to acquire new ones rentals to replace those they
11%
sell, though not as many as
during the same period. In fact, a majority plan to
they had before
purchase as many or more residential rentals than
they had before, with some hoping to diversify their Plan to acquire new
commercial properties in
holdings with different property types than they’ve 5%
place of the ones they sell,
had in the past. but not residential rentals
RENTAL OWNERS' PLANS FOR THEIR PORTFOLIOS OVER THE NEXT 2 YEARS
Prices are sky-high and HAVE to come down [The] current student market is decreasing, so
one of these days. I'm just a small-time landlord, [we’re] turning some of those properties to a
so [I] have to be very careful about cash flow. different market.
(UNINTENTIONAL INVESTOR IN SAN DIEGO, CA) (SELF-MANAGING INVESTOR IN WATERLOO, IA)
This marks the most sizable increase in rental owners’ growth plans that we’ve seen
in eight years of surveys, with the number of respondents who are in an active growth
phase increasing by 11 percentage points since the early months of the pandemic. Though
investors are the most likely to have plans to invest in more properties (as we’d expect), a
surprising 1 in 5 Accidental Landlords hopes to acquire new properties as well, and may
identify as Unintentional Investors in future surveys.
2022 2021
Smart area to invest in right now 52% 32%
Somewhat smart area to invest in 27% 40%
Somewhat risky area to invest in 13% 17%
Too risky to invest in right now 8% 10%
Even with soaring prices, I'm trying to add Prices are inflated, but if the deals pencil
more doors, as rents are outpacing mortgage out, [investing in rental properties] is
costs and [we’re] seeing a greater need for still a good way to enjoy equity gains,
nice [single-family homes]. cash flow, and depreciation, and [to]
(INTENTIONAL INVESTOR IN DENVER, CO) supplement retirement income.
(INTENTIONAL INVESTOR IN RIVERSIDE, CA)
Third-party property management companies, given the extent to which their business
growth depends on their clients, should definitely feel encouraged by these figures.
However, the pace at which owners acquire new rentals will, of course, depend on the
trajectory that property prices and interest rates take from here. As many rental owners and
property management professionals identified in this year’s surveys, acquiring properties at
the top of the market makes it harder to balance rent prices that sufficiently cover owners’
mortgage payments and property costs with prices that the average renter can afford.
Most rental owners now own their properties primarily as a source of income, including
57% of owners who are actively reliant on their rental income to pay their bills or fund their
retirement. (This stands in contrast with the Accidental Landlords of the previous decade,
who had more personal reasons for owning their rental properties—often homes that they’d
inherited or used to live in.) With only 1 in 3 small-portfolio rental owners reporting that their
properties are consistently profitable, increasing their income while lowering their costs is
top of mind, though the current environment presents considerable challenges.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 18
✓ Changing up their leasing practices to avoid and shorten vacancies – e.g. keeping
rent increases low for their best residents, having their PM initiate the renewal
process earlier
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 19
More often than in the past, property managers told us, they need to set accurate
expectations for their owners when it comes to the potential profitability of any property
they acquire. With margins shrinking and new apps popping up every year, property
managers worry that the temptation is very real for owners to run their properties without
the assistance of an expert.
Together, what all of this means is that property management companies are working
harder than ever to demonstrate the value of their services—and based on our most recent
survey of small-portfolio rental owners, their efforts are paying off. By our measure, owners
who work with a property manager to run their rentals are less stressed than owners who
attempt to do so on their own by a full 16 percentage points. 1 in 4 owners with a property
manager report that they didn’t experience any stress related to their property in the last
year, in comparison with just 1 in 10 owners who run their properties on their own.
Renovations 4 +4
Legal issues 5 +1
Filling vacancies 6 –4
Residents 7 (tie) –4
Vendors 7 (tie) 0
Rent collection 9 0
Finances 10 +1
Communication 11 +2
Growth 12 –2
Balance 13 –1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Efficiency 14 0
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 20
Helping owners to navigate shifting legal conditions, fill vacancies with high-quality renters,
respond to maintenance emergencies, collect rents, and fulfill other time-consuming and
complex duties remains a strong value proposition for professional property management
services, no matter the market—and that’s why the number of rental owners who work with
property managers continues to rise.
In this section, we’ll talk about the services and technologies that rental owners expect their
property management company to provide; where rental owners are feeling the most pain;
and the opportunity that property managers have to prove their value and increase their
revenue by meeting their clients’ evolving needs.
✓ Financial reporting
& benchmarking
Highly communicative with both tenants and Expertise [and] superior knowledge of her
me. Be available to respond as needed for job. Understands my goals for my property.
emergencies. Professional, considers all risks Timely response to both mine and my
as well as upside, seeks counsel or advice tenants’ reasonable needs and requests [with]
when unsure, detail-oriented, understands trustworthy, two-way communication. Assertive,
and is aligned with my needs as an investor, decisive, and lawful responses to difficult
takes a long view (20-30 years or more) on situations. Helps me make informed decisions
our relationship and portfolio. Really think on improvements and problems. Has discovered
about the significance of the portfolio I am the best group of vendors to call on when
entrusting to you and manage it in a fiduciary necessary. [I want to] feel like I am a participating
manner. Actively provide me with ideas for member of my team [and] my opinions are
forced equity, tax strategies, risk mitigation, and valued and respected.
scaling my portfolio. In return, I will introduce (ACCIDENTAL LANDLORD IN OGDEN, UT)
Property management companies are increasingly providing their clients with access
to owner portals, which give them self-service access to the information they need
to feel reassured that their properties are in good hands, from inspection reports
to monthly statements. Survey respondents told us that this has resulted in fewer
incoming requests from owners, and requires significantly less manual work from
property management teams.
The Tools with the Largest Gains in Interest from Owners in 2022
〉 Online document sharing: +17 percentage points
〉 Property accounting software: +12 points
〉 Digital communications: +8 points
〉 Digital financial reports: +6 points
〉 Property inspection tools: +5 points
IN OWNERS' WORDS The Info They Want to Receive (and How Often)
Rent opportunities, when [the property] is Market analysis specific to my portfolio—is the
rented, increases in rent charges, need for neighborhood trending up/down, major local
maintenance, any issues going on, end-of-year news that may impact returns.
paperwork for taxes, monthly communications (INTENTIONAL INVESTOR IN JACKSONVILLE, FL)
Owner portals
Property accounting
Financial reporting
Thanks to macroeconomic forces like supply chain delays, inflation, and labor shortages,
property management companies are having greater difficulty finding supplies, appliances,
and maintenance workers on the timeline that renters would like, and at the price point
that owners would like. When emergency repairs are needed, property management
companies find themselves in competition with larger firms and developers for a small pool
of skilled workers. In addition, our respondents said, it’s harder to get owners to spring for
preventative maintenance when high costs have severely strained their rental income.
With residents spending more time at home, property management companies noticed a
significant uptick in both the amount of wear and tear that residents’ units receive, as well
as the number of maintenance requests that their teams receive. They also told us that the
switch to online processes (as well as the steady influx of a new generation of tech-native
renters) has increased residents’ expectation that property management teams provide
instantaneous responses and solutions.
A majority of both renters and owners expect property management companies to provide
online maintenance ticketing, where residents can submit and track repair requests.
Additional tools that help property managers meet their customers’ needs in this area
include a maintenance contact center and mobile property inspection tools.
[The] Buildium app is helpful for operating on We have a maintenance system that has improved
the run while in the field. [It] helps with task our labor efficiency ratio and [helps us] track open
alerts and creating [work orders] for vendors. maintenance requests.
(PROPERTY MANAGER IN OKLAHOMA CITY, OK) (COMPANY OWNER IN KENNEWICK, WA)
[Maintenance ticketing makes it] easy to Electronic property inspection templates are time-
assign repairs and keep up with updates saving, photos can be uploaded directly to the
for both owners and tenants. It is [a] great report and sent to owners/tenants. [We also use a]
accountability tool. maintenance customer service line for after-hours
(MAINTENANCE MANAGER IN CAPE CORAL, FL) calls so issues are being addressed 24/7.
(LEASING MANAGER IN BRUNSWICK, GA)
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 27
Recent levels of rent growth have made renter quality a significant pain point for property
FOR RENT
management companies and landlords. Our survey respondents told us that applicants with
incomes at least three times the monthly rent are increasingly rare; and low credit scores,
inconsistent payments, evictions, foreclosures, and employment instability have become
increasingly commonplace in renters’ histories.
Rental owners with a property manager are less stressed about filling vacancies by a
difference of six percentage points, making this another area where working with an expert
has a significant impact. In this year’s survey, owners named three key areas of leasing
where their property manager has helped them in the last year: finding high-quality renters,
positioning their properties against local market trends, and handling reams of leasing-
related communications.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 28
Both renters and rental owners now expect that listings, applications, and leases
will be shared, signed, and stored online. We’ve also seen a large uptick in renters’
interest in virtual showings and 3D tours over the last two years, with the pandemic
increasing their appetite for technologies that help them sense what it’s like to live in
a property without physically visiting it.
Online services really help with automation and Self-showings [have] allowed us to almost
a smooth process, [and they] make processing double our doors without increasing the number
[applications] and finding the most qualified of leasing agents.
applicant a breeze! When [an applicant is] trying (COMPANY OWNER IN VIRGINIA BEACH, VA)
1650
$ Challenges Property Managers Are Facing
RENT
With rental prices and property costs reaching previously unseen levels, property managers
are struggling to set prices that their residents can afford; that allow their owners to
cover their own rising bills; and that show enough of a profit to prove the continued value
of their services.
Rent collection is a service that virtually all rental owners want, and that virtually all property
managers provide. Rental owners who work with a property manager to run their properties
are less stressed about resident-related issues—of which rent collection has been a big one
in recent years—by a difference of five percentage points. During the pandemic, property
managers’ efforts to track down late payments, help residents access financial aid, set rents
at appropriate levels, and keep owners informed of their progress have made a significant
difference in rental owners’ stress levels, particularly for Accidental Landlords.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 30
A significant majority of rental owners and renters now expect their property management
company to offer the option of making payments online—including older adults who may
have been wary of electronic payments prior to the pandemic. In each of our surveys over
the last few years, renters have continually emphasized how much they appreciate being
able to pay in the way that’s most convenient for them, from any location and at any time;
whether that’s a card payment made through their resident portal, or a cash payment made
at a nearby store.
[Giving] our residents an online payment The option for e-payment of owner
option has hands-down been the best decision disbursements has really saved me time and
we have made for both our efficiency and [the] hassle of hand-writing checks.
their convenience. (PROPERTY MANAGER)
The uptick in tenant protections during the pandemic—and the frequency with which
these laws have shifted—has caused immense confusion and concern for rental owners,
particularly when it comes to collections and evictions. Respondents told us that these
legal shifts have contributed to rental owners’ exodus from the market, particularly in
states like California, Colorado, and Oregon. But among the many owners who remain
in the market, there’s been a noticeable increase in demand for property managers’
expertise in ensuring that their properties are operating in compliance with both new and
long-standing regulations.
Rental owners who work with a property manager reported lower levels of stress regarding
legal issues and regulatory compliance by a significant difference of 12 percentage points,
making this the area where property managers have the most measurable impact on rental
owners’ pain points.
In addition, financial reporting is an area where many rental owners feel that their property
management company could do more to communicate the full picture of their rentals’
performance, from cash flow statements and rent ledgers to detailed lists of expenses
and repairs made within their properties. 40% of rental owners say that finding a property
manager who regularly shares financial reports, profit/loss statements, and other property
insights is a priority in their search, particularly for investors; and there’s an appetite among
Accidental Landlords for more prescriptive financial and investment advice.
Rental owners without a property manager are more stressed about accounting and
bookkeeping than those with one by a difference of six percentage points, making this yet
another area where having a property manager has a measurable impact.
Accounting and financial reporting are two areas where we’ve seen a noticeable increase
in owners’ desire for digital delivery of information. 58% of rental owners now expect their
property management company to use dedicated property accounting tools rather than
tracking income and expenses by hand or in a spreadsheet—an increase of 12 points over
the last year alone.
In addition, 57% of rental owners want their property management company to provide
them with financial reports in a digital format—for example, through their owner portal—
representing an increase of six percentage points in the last year alone. Providing owners
with on-demand access to property insights can not only help owners feel more at ease
about the health of their properties at any given time (without the need to reach out to
TABLE OF CONTENTS
your team for help), but also presents an excellent opportunity for property managers to
demonstrate the value of their expertise.
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with
Introduction
Rental Owners
| TOC 33
IN
IN PMs'
PMs' WORDS
WORDS Where Technology Has Made a Difference
PROPERTY IMPROVEMENTS
Many small rental properties are getting on in their years, are seeing increased wear and
tear, or need updates in order to justify higher rent prices. However, in an environment
where two-thirds of rental owners aren’t consistently earning a profit from their properties,
setting aside a portion of their rental income for property enhancements is a hard sell. In
addition, the same macroeconomic forces that we discussed in the section on maintenance
services have strained the availability of construction materials and labor, causing prices to
rise higher than ever.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Rental Owners 35
Learn more about how property managers can prove the value of their
services to Accidental Landlords and Small-Portfolio Investors in our
2022 Rental Owners' Reports.
SECTION 4
Property managers told us that for the most part, they’ve tried to keep increases low
on lease renewals to avoid pricing out reliable residents. But they’ve also discovered
the ceiling on rent increases for new leases: Though vacant units are receiving an
overwhelming amount of applications, there’s a finite number of applicants whose income
fully covers the rent at current rates.
At the same time, however, property management companies are under pressure to raise
prices to market rate in the next year, with property costs rising just as quickly as rents; and
with some owners feeling tempted to switch to a property management company with lower
rates, manage their properties on their own, or sell off their properties altogether.
Within this section, we’ll review where rent growth, payment rates, and evictions currently
stand; take a look at renters’ overall financial health; examine the causes of the housing
shortage that’s driving current trends; and discuss why rent control policies worsen the
affordability issues they aim to solve.
At the high end of the rent growth continuum, popular Sun Belt markets experienced price
increases of between 22 and 42% year over year, according to an analysis of RealPage data
by Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies. This has been a shock for renters inhabiting
TABLE OF CONTENTS
once-affordable cities in states like Florida, Arizona, Texas, North Carolina, and Nevada.
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 37
Though primary markets in states like California, New York, and Massachusetts all took a
hit during the first year of the pandemic, they, too, saw double-digit growth in asking rents
between Q1-2021 and Q1-2022.(2)
By the end of Q2-2022, though rent growth remained well above historic levels, it showed
signs of moderating. This was not a surprise given the unsustainable pace of growth we’ve
seen over the previous year, but was somewhat surprising given the timing during leasing
season. Metro areas with especially high rates of rent growth—and significant decreases in
affordability for local residents—seemed to be the first to show signs of deceleration. These
areas (primarily Sun Belt cities that have seen an influx of new residents) include Phoenix,
AZ; Las Vegas, NV; Tampa, FL; and Palm Beach, FL, according to CoStar.(3)
Also as of early 2022, evictions had returned to 2012–2016 levels in half of the cities
tracked in Princeton University’s Eviction Lab database as pandemic-era tenant protections
have gradually expired.(2)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 38
TRENDS IN RENTERS’ FINANCIAL HEALTH To evaluate renters’ overall financial health, we’ll
take a look at five different indicators measured by
Rental affordability has gradually worsened over
this year’s Renters’ Survey.
the last twenty years, but has become a particularly
pressing issue for low- and middle-income renters RENTERS' HOUSEHOLD INCOME
during the pandemic. Between 2001 and 2019, Within our sample, renters’ incomes appear to
the median price of rent in the U.S. grew by 16%, have increased over the last year. We saw the
while the median income among renters rose by number of households earning annual salaries
just 5%, according to a Joint Center for Housing of less than $50,000 decrease by 10 percentage
Studies analysis of American Community Survey points between Q1-2021 and Q1-2022 as those
data.(2) This effect is particularly pronounced within renters moved into higher income brackets. This
smaller rental properties that have traditionally is primarily a result of increasing wages; but it may
been more affordable for renters, whereas also reflect the presence of higher-income renters
RealPage has found that renters’ incomes within who ordinarily would have left our sample to
market-rate apartment buildings are generally transition to homeownership if market conditions
keeping pace with recent rent increases.(4) hadn’t been so impenetrable for first-time buyers
over the last two years. (53% of young and middle-
Though this imbalance already threatened the
aged adults—and rising—say that their inability to
state of rental affordability over the previous
afford a home is the primary reason why they rent.)
decade, pandemic-driven market conditions
have pushed this trend further in the wrong Unfortunately, inflation has severely watered
direction. In 2020 alone, the number of renters down the positive effects of rising wages. In
who were considered “cost-burdened” rose by June 2022, we saw inflation increase by 9%
several percentage points, leaving 46% of renters year over year, resulting in a 4% decrease in real
spending more than a third of their income on average hourly earnings when the high price of
housing, and 24% spending more than half— housing, food, energy, gas, and other expenses
figures that have almost certainly worsened is taken into account, according to the Bureau
throughout 2021 and 2022.(2) of Labor Statistics.(5)
2022 11% 9% 6% 7%
2021
50 60% % 33 % 25
%
64% of respondents to our Renters’ Survey in the spring of 2022 were employed—a
significant improvement of 10 percentage points over the previous 12 months as the labor
market adjusted to pandemic conditions.
2022 2021
Full-time (salaried) 25% 22%
Full-time (hourly) 23% 16%
Retired* 21% 23%
Part-time/temp/freelance* 11% 11%
Out of work 7% 15%
Student 5% 3%
Business owner* 4% 6%
Stay-at-home parent 3% 5%
*Note: Between 2021 and 2022, we moved 'freelancer' from the 'business owner' category to the 'part time/
temporary' category, which may account for any change between these two employment statuses over the
last year. In addition, the number of retirees in our sample is higher than in the population overall because
we intentionally recruit equal numbers of renters in every age group.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 40
RENTERS’ ABILITY TO PAY BILLS RENTERS' ABILITY TO PAY THEIR BILLS OVER
THE LAST YEAR
64% of renters have paid all of their bills on time
and in full over the last year, and an additional 26%
Able to pay all bills
have been able to pay most bills on time and in
on time & in full 64%
full. However, 11% reported that they’re struggling
to keep up with their household expenses.
41 % TODAY'S RENTERS
31%
27% 24%
18% 14% 11% 10%
TABLE OF CONTENTS
More likely to have debt than other renters—particularly credit card debt—and
significantly less likely to have savings to fall back on.
More likely to live in households with 3+ occupants: Middle-aged adults who are
struggling to pay the bills tend to support larger households, including a significant
other, children, or other relatives. Young adults under financial strain often move in
with their parents or other family members. Older adults are the exception: those
who live on their own are more likely to be struggling to get by.
Knowing how competitive the current rental market is, property management professionals
told us that they worry about the small group of residents who have been making an effort
to pay each month, but who simply can’t keep up with payments as aid programs come
to an end. Even renters who have been able to keep up with their rent on paper may be
relying on credit cards, savings, and loans from friends and family to make ends meet—
resources that are all diminishing after nearly three years of the COVID-19 crisis.
There is not enough affordable housing. Every owner/ Just raising rents will not cover rising expenses,
investor wants top dollar rent for their property, but [and] it will put more tenants in the street. We
there are fewer and fewer renters that are able to all need to find ways to be profitable without
afford that. More housing needs to be built. making life unbearable for those in the lowest
(PROPERTY MANAGER IN SACRAMENTO, CA) level of the economy.
(PROPERTY ACCOUNTANT IN PHOENIX, AZ)
In this section, we’ll take a look at the conditions that are driving the current rate of growth
in rents and occupancy rates, and talk about why rent control is an ineffective solution to
the affordability crisis.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 43
As the economy emerged from the initial wave of the pandemic, we saw new households
being formed at a heightened pace. Recent household formation has been driven primarily
by Millennials, who have reached the age at which adults tend to transition from living with
family or roommates to living on their own or with a partner. And when they do so, at least
initially, they tend to rent—particularly as many young and middle-aged renters have found
themselves shut out of the ultra-competitive housing market for the time being.
This swell in the total number of renter households has added up to 1.1 million additional
households living in rental properties since 2020(2)—one of the main reasons why rental
occupancy rates have remained so high. Particularly in the markets that have attracted an
influx of new residents in the last few years, prospective renters have found fewer available
properties on the market than ever before, resulting in greater competition and higher
prices for the units that are available.
All of this is on top of the existing shortage of affordable housing, whose origins are
complex and generally predate the current crisis. They include the suppressed rate of
residential construction due to labor shortages following the Great Recession; local zoning
laws that prevent the construction of multifamily housing; and land and material prices
that make it hard to build profitable housing at affordable price points. But at its heart, the
housing shortage comes down to simple economics: Demand is outpacing supply, and with
the pandemic exacerbating these conditions, rents have risen to previously unseen levels in
markets across the U.S.
The construction of both single-family and multifamily rentals has been occurring at a
record-setting clip throughout 2021 and 2022. However, the addition of new, affordable
rental housing simply can’t keep up with the demand—and construction continues to be
focused on maximally profitable, high-end rentals.(2)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 44
Rent control policies have been under discussion in many areas that have seen affordability
stretched to a breaking point. However, as many real estate professionals intuitively
understand, these policies target the effect of the affordable housing crisis rather
than the cause.
Rent control tends to have a cooling effect on markets where it’s implemented. When new
residents move to the area, or when current residents’ housing needs change, they have
greater difficulty finding a place to live because existing residents tend to stay put to lock
in lower rates. When they’re unable to adjust rent prices to keep pace with property costs,
many small-portfolio rental owners don’t have enough rental income left over to reinvest
in the property through maintenance and improvements. This not only impacts living
conditions within the property—it also motivates some owners to sell, potentially handing
their properties to larger investors with every incentive to raise rents to market rate.
But most problematic of all is the cooling effect that rent control has on efforts to build
new housing—the keystone of any effective strategy to improve rental affordability. The
Wall Street Journal estimates that a rent control measure passed in St. Paul, Minnesota
in November 2021 has led to an 82% decline in multifamily building permits in the city in
comparison with the previous year, as developers have abandoned existing projects and
chosen to initiate new projects elsewhere.(6)
Why does rent control have such a chilling effect on real estate development? With prices
for land, materials, and labor rising with every passing year, developers and their lenders
need rents to be set at higher rates for projects to pencil out. When annual rent growth is
capped in an attempt to keep rents affordable, significantly less housing is built—pushing up
prices for existing properties, and exacerbating the housing shortage.
As of this spring, the Wall Street Journal reported that rent control measures were up for
discussion in a dozen different states, from Massachusetts, New Jersey, and Florida on the
East Coast to Colorado out west.(6) However, awareness of the policy’s ineffectiveness as a
means to address housing affordability—and the critical need to remove barriers that limit
the country’s rate of housing production—is also spreading. TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 45
2022
27 % 2022
28%
2021
27 % 2021
31%
Couples One-Person
Without Kids Households
2022
23% 2022
15%
2021
19% 2021
9%
Multigenerational Couples with Kids
Households
2022
12% 2022
3%
2021
12% 2021
4%
Roommate Single-Parent
Households Households
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 46
Overall, a Joint Center for Housing Studies analysis of Census data shows that 1.2 million
Americans left core neighborhoods within large metro areas in 2021, continuing a trend that
began in 2020. They moved to small and mid-sized cities, which gained 539,000 residents
in 2021; suburban neighborhoods outside of large cities, which gained 428,000 residents;
and rural areas, which gained 235,000 residents.(2)
This decrease in mobility has occurred even among the two groups who tend to move
most often: young adults and renters. Just 17% of renters moved in 2021—a decrease
of six percentage points in comparison with the previous decade, according to a Joint
Center for Housing Studies analysis of data from the Census Bureau’s Current Population
Survey. In addition, moving rates among 18- to 24-year-olds fell by four percentage points;
and they declined nearly as much among 25- to 34-year-olds in comparison with the
previous 10 years.(2)
To blame for this trend are affordability concerns—the high rate of rent growth on new
leases, plus the expenses associated with moving and putting down a deposit on a new
home—in addition to the limited supply of available rentals and starter homes.
A quick summary of how we got here: Within our sample, we saw retention rates drop
precipitously in 2020 as pandemic-driven shifts in residents’ lifestyles changed their rental
preferences. Retention then rose dramatically in 2021 as occupancy rates soared. In 2022,
retention has leveled out at slightly below the long-term average.
Note: Renters' responses describe their plans to move between the time of our survey (June 2022) and June 2023.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 49
Who are the residents who plan to renew their leases for another year?
Within our survey, renters with the following characteristics were the least likely to
be considering moving:
Here’s who our survey revealed are the most likely demographics to be set on moving
out by the midpoint of next year:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 50
Location: 25% of renters who are considering moving may change locations for
personal reasons, while 17% (primarily young adults) may do so for work or school
Amenities: 22% of renters thinking of moving out are looking for a rental with
features that are more desirable or that better suit their needs, particularly young
adults, followed by middle-aged renters with kids
Space: 18% of renters may move in the next year because their household’s needs
have changed, whether they need more space, less space, or a different layout
Experience: 14% of renters are considering moving because they haven’t been
satisfied with their experience in their current rental
Property managers have a sense that their customers’ expectations have dramatically
ramped up over the last few years—particularly their insistence on instantaneous responses.
In addition, multiple Industry Survey respondents told us that as rent prices rise, so do
renters’ expectations for the caliber of their rental experience.
owners with the kind of human connection that creates memorable experiences.
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 51
NEIGHBORHOOD
ORGANIZED
AGAINST CRIME
Safe
1 neighborhood
2 Air
conditioning
3 &In-unit
dryer
washer
4 High-speed
internet
5 Quiet
neighborhood
6 Option to
have a pet
7 Parking 8 Dishwasher
Close to stores
9 & resturants
10 Private
space
outdoor
to features like a pool, fitness center, or lounge—they’re simply willing to forego these
luxuries in exchange for lower rents.
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 52
✓ The indoor and outdoor space they need to be comfortable as they welcome kids,
relatives, and pets to their family
✓ A child-friendly home that provides air conditioning, a washer and dryer,
and a dishwasher
✓ Offerings that could be potential differentiators: High-speed internet; lawn care;
pest control; garbage/recycling/compost pick-up; access to community
amenities like a garden, pool, and space to host events; regular preventative
maintenance visits
The Tools with the Largest Gains in Interest from Renters in 2022
〉 Electronic leasing: +16 〉 Utility setup & billing: +5 points
percentage points 〉 Maintenance ticketing: +4 points
〉 Electronic payments: +11 points 〉 Self-showings: +4 points
〉 Virtual showings: +7 points 〉 Rental listings: +4 points
Invest in an online portal for both electronic Be open-minded about using technology for
payments and maintenance requests. I always processes if you haven’t already started using
worry my bank won’t get the check through the it. It makes things easier for your tenants and
mail on time, and it can feel like you’re bothering yourself once you figure it out.
somebody to text maintenance requests. (SINGLE-FAMILY RENTER IN SALT LAKE CITY, UT)
In addition, for the first time in 2022, a majority of renters reported that they already pay
their rent electronically. This is a sign of not only the increasing appeal of online payment
methods to renters, but also their increased adoption among property managers and
landlords since the pandemic began.
Electronic payments are a must. It is vastly I would like to be able to pay rent electronically
better than handling paper checks for all from my bank account [and] report my on-time
parties involved. payments to credit bureaus.
(MULTIFAMILY RENTER IN BOSTON, MA) (MULTIFAMILY RENTER IN ROANOKE, VA)
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 55
Set Up Renters
Insurance
1 2 3
$1,500.00
POLICY ABOUT YOU PAYMENT
Payment Amount
$13.75 start date
/mo 8/20/22
PURCHASE POLICY
Accounts Receivable $570.00
Balance $570.00
Learn how Buildium’s simple, unified platform can help you to take control of your portfolio,
your business, and your life: buildium.com/features
Learn how Propertyware’s open and customizable platform can enable you to reach and
exceed your business goals: propertyware.com/rental-property-management-software
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships
Introduction
with Residents
| TOC 56
[Please provide] email communication so I'm not Always have multiple ways for residents to get in
constrained by office hours for phone calls. contact with you.
(MULTIFAMILY RENTER IN NEW YORK, NY) (MULTIFAMILY RENTER IN LOUISVILLE, KY)
2022 2021
Email 49% 54%
Text message 46% 38%
Phone call 39% 43%
Online resident portal 15% 16%
In-person visit 15% 9%
Paper notice/mailed letter 12% 12%
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Social media 3% 3%
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 57
Have a nice, working site. Care about the Provide a complete selection of images of
reviews the property has in places like Google. the specific property on offer in the rental
Before I move anywhere, I always read the listing, a breakdown of costs (including rough
bad reviews and pay special attention to the estimates for any utilities), and a detailed
property’s response. and accurate description of the place and all
(MULTIFAMILY RENTER IN SEATTLE, WA) available amenities.
(MOBILE HOME RESIDENT IN SYRACUSE, NY)
We asked renters to tell us the most impactful changes their property management
company could make to improve their rental experience. Here’s what they told us:
Set clear and consistent expectations from the get-go. Many of the residents we
2 surveyed told us that they expend considerable effort to respect the guidelines that
their property manager has set, and they try to find answers on their own to avoid
bothering them. However, guidelines that are unclear, incomplete, or inconsistently
enforced across the property can lead to frustration.
Provide options for taking care of standard rental processes. The vast majority
3
of renters now prefer to complete transactions online, but preferences vary when
it comes to the method they find most convenient and intuitive. We recommend
providing multiple options for paying rent (e.g. EBT, PayPal, and credit card) and
communicating with your team (e.g. resident portal, email, and text), and also having
an agent available by phone if they run into any trouble.
Let them know you’ve received their message and when to expect a response.
5 Renters told us that they find it far easier to be patient in waiting for a solution if
they know that you’ve received their message, you’ve taken action on it, and you’ll
keep them updated on any next steps.
Proactively care for the property without being asked. From renters’ perspective,
6 the energy you devote to property upkeep demonstrates the degree to which you
and the owner care about the rental, both as an investment and as their home.
Consider conducting periodic inspections where you can address any minor issues
around the property, benefiting both residents and rental owners.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 59
Don’t skip inspections and cleanings between tenants. A unit that doesn’t make a
7
great first impression, or that immediately has issues needing to be addressed, can
leave renters worried that they won’t have a good experience in the property; and
it also sets poor expectations about the level of care you expect them to take while
they live there.
They want to feel like renting is a little more rewarding. Programs like rent
9
reporting to credit bureaus, or rewards for long-term residents who always pay on
time, can help incentivize consistent payments. They may also motivate residents to
continue renting from you over a competing property.
Your empathy matters more than you might realize. Unlike customers of any other
10 kind of business, renters’ daily lives take place inside the properties you manage;
and it matters to them that you keep this in mind when communicating with them.
They want to know that you see them as more than the rent payments they
make each month.
It’s been a hard few years for renters, rental owners, and property managers alike.
Negative headlines about real estate investors have proliferated during the pandemic,
fueling feelings of opposition between renters and the companies that own and manage the
rentals they call home. Perhaps, the current moment presents an opportunity for customer-
service-focused property management companies to foster feelings of trust, empathy,
and kindness—traveling in both directions—within these relationships once again. As one
renter put it: “To stand out, prove you care about your residents, and people will spread
your good reputation.”
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Property Managers’ Evolving Relationships with Residents 60
FOOTNOTES:
1 "Single-Family Annual Rent Growth Off to a Fast Start in 2022," CoreLogic, https://www.corelogic.com/
intelligence/single-family-annual-rent-growth-off-to-a-fast-start-in-2022, (March 15, 2022)
2 "The State of the Nation's Housing 2022," Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, https://
www.jchs.harvard.edu/state-nations-housing-2022, (June 22, 2022)
3 "Renters Finally See Market Starting to Cool After Record Growth," The Wall Street Journal, https://www.wsj.
com/articles/apartment-rents-begin-tapering-off-after-record-growth-11659301974, (August 1, 2022)
SECTION 5
Takeaways
Third-party property management companies are ready to double down on
1
expansion, primarily by attracting new clients and supporting current clients’
growth. After nearly three years of directing their energy toward shorter-term,
pandemic-induced challenges, companies are ready to shift their gaze back
to their long-term health. Their outlook remains bright despite headwinds like
increased property sales and slower property acquisitions among their clients
due to the hot housing market.
Companies are searching for new revenue streams that add value for
2
customers. In a high-inflation, low-margin environment, property management
companies are focused on increasing the revenue that their businesses and
portfolios generate. But in addition to raising prices—which many companies plan
to do in the next year—they’re on the hunt for revenue-generating offerings that
will add tangible value to renters’ and owners’ experiences with their business.
Rental affordability is being recognized as the most critical issue facing our
5
industry. Though the shortage of affordable housing isn’t new, the impact on
renters has vastly increased during the pandemic, with double-digit rent growth
and inflation neutralizing short-term increases in renters’ wages. Property
managers are feeling the strain of trying to balance rent prices that residents can
TABLE OF CONTENTS
afford with prices that cover owners’ rising costs; and industry organizations are
increasingly focused on the dire need for more housing to be built at affordable
price points.
About Our Respondents 62
APPENDIX:
19% 12%
76 % 65 % 46 % 37 %
THE NUMBER OF UNITS THEIR COMPANY MANAGES WHOSE PROPERTIES THEIR COMPANY MANAGES
22% 28%
31%
41%
10%
7%
10% 32%
7%
7%
2 4%
%
THE PRIMARY METRO AREA WHERE THE NUMBER OF METRO AREAS WHERE
THEIR COMPANY OPERATES THEIR COMPANY OPERATES
1 2%
Atlanta, GA
6%
2 Los Angeles, CA
3 Chicago, IL
1
2-5
4 New York, NY
39%
54% 6-10
>10
5 Houston, TX
6 Miami, FL
7 Dallas, TX
8 Phoenix, AZ
THE RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY TYPES THEIR
9 San Antonio, TX COMPANY MANAGES
THE SIZE OF THEIR TEAM (ALL FULL-TIME TOP 10 JOB TITLES AMONG
EMPLOYEES, INCLUDING THEMSELVES) OUR RESPONDENTS
19% 1
Property
manager 33%
2
3-5
Company
owner/CEO 21%
15% 6-10
29% 11-20
Accountant/
bookkeeper 9%
5% 21-30
31-40
Real estate
broker 7%
2%
41-50
2%
3% >50
Office
manager 7%
11%
15% Operations
manager 7%
Leasing
manager 4%
HOW MANY OFFICE LOCATIONS THEIR
COMPANY HAS
Real estate
investor 3%
Maintenance
manager 2%
Real estate
agent 2%
2%
58% Buildium
Propertyware
17%
TABLE OF CONTENTS
24 % or local NARPM
member
The communication, education, news, and
announcements are essential for us. We also
76 % enjoy the case studies and questions posed by
Not currently members that create good discussions.
a NARPM
(COMPANY OWNER IN AUGUSTA, GA)
member
Managers: NARPM.ORG/JOIN
About Our Respondents 66
3 Phoenix, AZ
THE NUMBER OF RENTAL UNITS THEY OWN
4 Denver, CO
4% 3
%
4% 5 Chicago, IL
1 6 San Francisco, CA
12 2-4
40%
%
36% 9 Riverside, CA
10 Albuquerque, NM
TABLE OF CONTENTS
About Our Respondents 67
26% 8%
$50–$99k 23 %
21%
$100–149k
19%
15% 17% >$200k 28%
$150–199k
<$50k
18%
8%
17%
1–2 11–15
3–5 16–20
6–10 >20
5%
4%
8%
42%
RENTERS' TENURE IN THEIR
CURRENT PROPERTY
16%
<2 years 11–15 years
3–5 years 16–20 years
TABLE OF CONTENTS
26%
About Our Respondents 69
TOP 10 METRO AREAS WHERE OUR WHY TODAY'S RESIDENTS RENT THEIR HOMES
RESPONDENTS LIVE
1 Finances prevent
New York, NY
them from buying
a home for now
47%
2 Los Angeles, CA
Current rental meets
3 Chicago, IL
their needs/Don't feel
like moving
28%
Don't want the
4 Boston, MA responsibility of
owning a home
21%
5 San Francisco, CA
Like the flexibility
that renting gives them 18%
6 Phoenix, AZ
Allows them to live
7 Miami, FL in a central
neighborhood
14%
8 Houston, TX Like the amenities/
community they
have access to
12%
9 Dallas, TX
27%
5%
TABLE OF CONTENTS
For more information, visit buildium.com. | Connect with us: FACEBOOK-SQUARE LINKEDIN TWITTER-SQUARE INSTAGRAM-SQUARE
VISIT REQUEST
BUILDIUM.COM A DEMO
READ CONTACT US
OUR BLOG SALES@BUILDIUM.COM
PROPERTYWARE®
Propertyware, a RealPage company, is a powerful, customizable, and open
software solution designed to help single-family property management companies
run their business their way. Propertyware provides unmatched customization, an
open API for two-way data exchange, portfolio-level accounting and reporting,
and the industry’s ideal solution for multi-regional expansion and growth, allowing
managers to easily monitor local operations and view holistic reporting.
For more information, visit propertyware.com | Connect with us: LINKEDIN TWITTER-SQUARE