Strategic Customer Relationship Management
Strategic Customer Relationship Management
Strategic Customer Relationship Management
4
Chapter
Strategic Customer
Relationship
Management
Building effective customer relationships is widely recognized by executives as a high
priority business initiative.1 A study of 960 international executives rated customer rela-
tionship management (CRM) and strategic planning highest among ten priority strategic
initiatives for improving organizational performance.2 CRM is a cross-functional core
business process concerned with achieving improved shareholder value through the devel-
opment of effective relationships with key customers and customer segments.3
Forming and sustaining valuable customer relationships is the most prized strategic
outcome of correctly visualized and implemented CRM programs.4 A Mercer consultant
survey of top executives found developing and sustaining customer relationships to be
the most important source of competitive advantage in the twenty-first century. One of
the primary conclusions of research concerning CRM failures is that achieving desired
customer outcomes requires the alignment of the entire organization, while avoiding the
narrow and incomplete perspective of viewing CRM as a technology initiative. Moreover,
a fragmented or functional focus is not sufficient.
Successful CRM initiatives are guided by a carefully formulated and implemented
organizational strategy. CRM offers sellers the opportunity to gather customer information
rapidly, identify the most valuable customers over the relevant time horizon, and increase
customer loyalty by providing customized products and services. This is described as
“tying in an asset” when the asset is the customer. CRM supports a customer-responsive
strategy, which gains competitive advantage when it:
• Delivers superior customer value by personalizing the interaction between the customer
and the company.
• Demonstrates the company’s trustworthiness and reliability to the customer.
• Tightens connections with the customer.
• Achieves the coordination of complex organizational capabilities around the
customer.5
CRM encourages a focus on customer loyalty and retention, with the goal of winning a
larger share of the total lifetime value of each profitable customer.
113
We begin by taking a more detailed look at CRM and its pivotal role in contributing
to bottom-line enterprise performance. Next, developing a CRM strategy and building
customer lifetime value are examined. Finally, we discuss the value creation process and
consider the relationship between CRM and market segmentation, targeting, and strategic
positioning.
CRM in Perspective
CRM may refer to little more than building relationships with customers to match a
company’s product and service offer better with customer needs. Others see CRM as devel-
oping a unified and cohesive view of the customer, without regard to how the customer
chooses to communicate with the organization (in person, by mail, Internet, or telephone).
Emphasis is placed on enhanced customer service and the use of call centers to provide
consistency in how the company interacts with customers. Alternatively, CRM may focus
only on the creation and use of a customer database to support decision makers.
It is important to shift attention from the technology and hardware of CRM to the con-
tinuing process of “making managerial decisions with the end goal of increasing the value
of the customer base through better relationships with customers, usually on an individual
basis.”6 The emphasis on strategy built around profitable customers as the primary concern
of CRM is emphasized by Bain & Co. Bain’s view is that CRM must combine business
processes with customer strategies to develop customer loyalty and enhance financial per-
formance.7 Another useful viewpoint suggests that CRM consists of three main elements:
• Identifying, satisfying, retaining, and maximizing the value of a firm’s best customers.
• Wrapping the firm around the customer to ensure that each contact with the customer
is appropriate and based upon extensive knowledge of both the customer’s needs and
profitability.
• Creating a full picture of the customer.8
Advances in technology are highly supportive to the implementation of CRM at all
levels of the business. One interesting development is described in the INNOVATION
FEATURE.
Pay by Touch is a rapidly growing company operating a biometric network. To pay, custom-
ers press a finger on a scanner and enter a personal number to have the goods charged to
a credit card or bank account. From a pilot scheme at Piggly Wiggly supermarkets in South
Carolina, Pay By Touch has expanded to more than 3,000 locations in the U.S. Supervalu,
the second largest traditional U.S. grocer, is the largest user. Aside from payment efficiency,
purchases can be tied to the biometric identity of the customer.
Beyond simplifying payments, Pay By Touch can use its SmartShop technology to direct
weekly incentives and special price cuts to an individual customer based on shopping
habits and preferences. For retailers, this system offers a way to direct offers effectively to
their most loyal customers, rather than supporting the “cherry picking” on bargains by
customers who only buy the offers.
Source: Adapted from Jonathan Birchall, “Pay By Touch Puts Its Finger on Loyalty,” Financial Times, Friday,
June 22, 2007, 19.
A database created through CRM technology should contain information about the
following:
• Transactions—should include a complete purchase history for each customer with
accompanying details (date, price paid, products purchased).
• Customer Contacts—with multiple channels of distribution and communication the
database should record all customer contacts with the company and its distributors,
including sales calls, service requests, complaints, inquiries, and loyalty program
participation.
• Descriptive Information—for each individual customer, relevant descriptive data that
provide the basis for market segmentation and targeted marketing communications.
• Response to Marketing Stimuli—whether the customer responded to specific advertising,
a price offer, a direct marketing initiative, or a sales call, or any other direct contact.10
Increasingly sophisticated software is available to undertake data mining and model data
from the CRM database.
suggests that 20 percent of customers yield 80 percent of the profits, so it is very impor-
tant to find the high value customers, which are typically a small part of the total cus-
tomer base.
Nonetheless, the power of CRM to enhance a company’s depth of customer knowledge and
to allow access to individuals and small groups of customers is having profound effects on
strategic thinking. The STRATEGY FEATURE discusses the “Long Tail” issue as an exam-
ple of new strategies being driven by the combination of CRM and Internet technology.
CRM Levels
CRM can be viewed from companywide, customer-facing, and functional levels.12 Each
level has important but different implications for strategic marketing. All three perspec-
tives are important, although the companywide or strategic level provides the most complete
view of CRM. The functional perspective considers the processes that are needed to fulfill
required marketing functions. The customer-facing level offers a single view of the cus-
tomer across all of the organization’s access channels to the customer. This level of CRM is
concerned with coordinating information across all contact channels on a continuing basis.
The RELATIONSHIP FEATURE describes hotel group Accor’s customer-facing activities.
116
The France-based hotel group Accor links CRM data to guest survey information in its U.S.
Sofitel and Novatel hotels, to anticipate the preferences of frequent users. The VP for sales
and marketing for Accor North America notes “It takes us back to the time when there
were small inns and the owner knew every customer and treated them as an individual. It
should help streamline check-in and accommodate preferences for guests who, for exam-
ple, request the same room every time. The group will be able to market with a microscope
instead of a telescope.”
Source: Marian Edmunds, “Your Wish Is on My Database,” Financial Times, February 28, 2000, 16.
The company-wide level provides a strategic focus for CRM.13 It considers the implica-
tions of knowledge about customers and their preferences across the entire company. The
intent is to guide the interactions between the organization and its customers in seeking to
maximize the lifetime value of customers for the firm. Importantly, the strategic perspec-
tive acknowledges that: (1) customers vary in their economic value to the company; and
(2) customers differ in their expectations toward the firm.
The strategic use of CRM resources reflects the shift in focus by marketing executives
to the customer who delivers long-term profits, that is, an emphasis on customer retention
rather than acquisition. Well-known metrics suggest that as little as a 5 percent increase
117
in customer retention can have an impact as high as 95 percent on the net present value
delivered by the customer.14 Other studies by McKinsey consultants find that repeat cus-
tomers generate over twice as much gross income as new customers.15 CRM emphasizes
that executives should focus the organization’s strategy on customer profitability and the
gains from reducing customer “churn.”
Interestingly, as CRM evolves and offers executives deeper insights into their customer
base, the new information may challenge strategic assumptions in important ways. For
example, the points made above suggest a powerful linkage between enhanced customer
loyalty and higher customer profitability. However, companies are discovering through
CRM database analysis that this is not always true. Some groups of customers may not
justify the costs required to retain them, because the real fit between their needs and the
company’s products is weak. Just because a group of customers was profitable in the past, it
may be dangerous to assume this will always be true. For example, many non-loyal custom-
ers are initially profitable, causing the company to chase them for further profits—but once
these customers have ceased buying they become increasingly unprofitable if the company
continues to invest in them. CRM data provides executives with a unique basis to address
such issues as loyalty and profitability on the basis of fact instead of assumption, and to
focus on individual customers, rather than groups containing many dissimilar buyers.16
CRM Implementation
Gartner Inc. estimated worldwide CRM expenditures at $76 billion in 2005 and expanding at
rapid growth rates.18 Other estimates place expenditures at much higher levels. However, the
evidence of the performance of CRM systems has been disappointing for many companies.
The Gartner Group concluded that 55 percent of all CRM projects do not produce results. A
Bain & Co. 2001 survey of management tools ranked CRM at the bottom for satisfaction—
indeed, one in five users in the Bain survey reported their CRM initiatives had not only failed
to deliver profitable growth, but had also damaged long-term customer relationships.19
Successful Implementation
One recommendation proposes that the major components of the successful implementa-
tion of CRM are:
• A front office that integrates sales, marketing, and service functions across all media
(call centers, people, retail outlets, value chain members, Internet).
4 3
Enterprise Customer
Transformation Strategy
Plan
• A data warehouse that stores customer information and the appropriate analytical tools
with which to analyze that data and learn about customer behavior.
• Business rules developed from the data analysis to ensure the front office benefits from
the firm’s learning about its customers.
• Measures of performance that enable customer relationships to continually improve.
• Integration into the firm’s operational support (or “back office”) systems, ensuring the
front office’s promises are delivered.20
Causes of Failure
There have been several suggestions that high failure rates associated with CRM are caused
by managers underestimating the necessary organizational changes required for effective
implementation that obtains the benefits of CRM. While the front end of CRM systems is
concerned with building databases, integrating customer data, providing better customer
service, and establishing systems like automated call centers for enhanced responsiveness,
achieving the full potential of CRM requires change in company-wide processes, organiza-
tion structure, and corporate culture.
Some of the early lessons learned about CRM implementation relate to the call centers
and surrounding technology. The call center may be the most important point of contact
with the customer. The GLOBAL FEATURE examines the situation with international call
centers, which have caused some controversy.
120
Bain & Co. research suggests that there are four significant pitfalls to avoid in CRM
initiatives:
1. Implementing CRM before creating a customer strategy—success relies on making
strategic customer and positioning choices, and this outweighs the importance of the
computer systems, software, call centers, and other technologies.
2. Putting CRM in place before changing the organization to match—CRM affects more
than customer-facing processes: it impacts internal structures and systems that may
have to change.
3. Assuming that more CRM technology is necessarily better, rather than matching the
technology to the customer strategy.
4. Investing in building relationships with disinterested customers, instead of those cus-
tomers who value them.21
Websites giving additional information on various aspects of CRM are shown in
Exhibit 4.3. There is also extensive literature on the topic and several recent books have
been published.
Customer Value
The benefits the customer receives are expressed by the value proposition. The objective
of the organization is to provide a superior customer experience. The value proposition
“explains the relationship among the performance of the product, the fulfillment of the cus-
tomer’s needs, and the total cost to the customer over the customer relationship life cycle.”23
As discussed earlier a key concept associated with the value received by the organiza-
tion via CRM is customer lifetime value (CLV). CLV is the expected profitability of a cus-
tomer over the time-span of the relationship with the customer. The sum of CLV for all of
a firm’s customers is termed customer equity. CLV provides useful information in selecting
valuable customers for targeting.
Value received by the customer is also relevant. It is important to recognize the potential
negative impact of issues regarding consumer trust on CRM activities.25 If buyers believe
that the information collected by their suppliers may be used to exploit them, their trust in
the relationship may be jeopardized. Accordingly, executives need to recognize trust and
privacy implications of CRM initiatives.
CRM approaches may also be valuable in identifying less attractive customers and
developing effective ways to handle this issue—what Larry Selden calls separating the
“angel customers” and the “demon customers.” 25 For example, the INTERNET FEATURE
describes an approach adopted by retailers to manage the problem of excessive product
returns by some customers.
122
Some consumers cost retailers a lot of money because of such practices as: “wardrobing”—
buying expensive clothes, wearing them once, and then returning them; “pack attacks”—
damaging a package on display to buy it later at a discount; and excessive returning.
Excessive or fraudulent returning is estimated to cost U.S. retailers $16 billion annually.
Some consumers buy hundreds of items and return them all (or all but one).
The Return Exchange is a California-based data warehouse which can analyze custom-
ers return behavior from retail companies. When products are returned to stores, customer
ID and product details are sent to The Return Exchange. If analysis suggests the individual
is an excessive returner, the customer’s pattern of returns—the number, frequency, and
value—are displayed at the store when returns are made. The retailer can decide whether
the customer should be given a warning or refused a return.
Source: Adapted from Paul Rubens, “How to Get Rid of ‘Devil Customers,’ ” ft.com, June 13, 2007.
Implementation
It is critical that the adoption and implementation of CRM be seen as more than techno-
logy focused on efficiency. There are significant implications for the strategic position-
ing of a company and its customer relationships, where the voice of marketing should be
heard. Our earlier discussion of CRM implementation highlights several relevant issues.
EXHIBIT 4.4 “The perfect customer experience,” which must be affordable for the company in the
The Perfect context of the segments in which it operates and its competition, is a relatively new
Customer Experience concept. This concept is now being embraced in industry by companies such as TNT,
Source: Adrian Payne and Toyota’s Lexus, Oce, and Guinness Breweries. Therefore, multi-channel integration is a
Pennie Frow, “A Strategic critical process in CRM because it represents the point of cocreation of customer value.
Framework for Customer
Relationship Management,” However, a company’s ability to execute multi-channel integration successfully is heav-
Journal of Marketing (October ily dependent on the organization’s ability to gather and deploy customer information
2005), 173. from all channels and to integrate it with other relevant information.
123
Operationally it is important not to assume that the drivers of value for all customers
are the same, or that CRM is the key to all important customer relationships. For example,
there are signs that many customers are weary of call centers and automated responses.
Performance Metrics
The availability of CRM data provides the opportunity to update the measures used by
managers to assess the success of their brands in the marketplace. Traditional financial
and market-based indicators like sales, profitability, and market share will continue to be
important. However, CRM allows the development of measures that are customer-centric
and more insightful concerning marketing strategy effectiveness. CRM-based measures of
performance (both online and offline) may include: customer acquisition cost, conversion
rates (from lookers to buyers), retention/churn rates, same customer sales rates, loyalty
measures, and customer “share of wallet.”27
The client-satisfaction measure discussed in the earlier METRICS FEATURE is used
in all of GE’s business units from homeowners to hospitals. The CEO highlights the net-
prompter score as a key part of GE’s growth formula.28 Respondents are categorized as
promoters, passives, and detractors relative to how likely they are to recommend GE to a
friend. Perhaps most important, the metric indicates the firm’s commitment to CRM.
Competitive Differentiation
If certain customers are unprofitable, then rather than “firing” the customer, the com-
petitive issue may be how to change the route to market to make them profitable to the
company. For example, when British Airways made the decision to focus only on its
profitable business-class passengers at the expense of economy travelers, Virgin Air-
ways gained the economy-class passengers by offering a better value proposition than
BA. CRM data may provide one of the most powerful tools for identifying different
customers on the basis of their behavior and other characteristics, to locate those whose
needs have good fit with a company’s capabilities. As one-to-one marketing expert Don
Peppers has noted: “For every credit card company that wants to concentrate on higher
income customers, there’s another credit card company that wants to concentrate on
lower income customers, and they do it by streamlining their service and making it more
cost-efficient.”29 It is important that decisions about customer choices reflect strategic
priorities.
The logic of CRM as a source of customer knowledge suggests that some customers will be
more attractive than others—they are more profitable, they buy more, or they are better
prospects. In retailing, the “devil customers” who cost retailers money may be as much
as 20 percent of the customer base. The dilemma is the stance to take with less profitable
customers.
However, there may be a moral dilemma regarding the fairness of treating some custom-
ers differently than others. When Express clothing stores stopped accepting returns from
“serial returners” and Filene’s Basement banned a few customers from its stores because of
excessive returns and complaints, both received much adverse publicity. European banks
which have tried to restrict access of poorer customers to bank branches and services have
been similarly criticized. The logic of favoring some customers over others may be weak-
ened by potential damage to the brand.
Sources: Ariana Eunjung Cha, “In Retail, Profiling for Profit,” Washington Post, August 17, 2005, A01; Paul
Rubens, How to Get Rid of ‘Devil Customers,’ ” ft.com, June 13, 2007.
Nonetheless, there are issues of social responsibility and ethics which surround the ways
in which CRM technology can be used to differentiate between attractive and less attractive
customers. If handled insensitively this differentiation may be damaging to corporate and
brand reputation. The ETHICS FEATURE highlights some of these dilemmas.
125
Summary To some, CRM means little more than building relationships with customers to match the
product offer better with customer needs. Others see CRM as concerned with developing a
unified and cohesive view of the customer, no matter how the customer chooses to commu-
nicate with the organization (in person, by mail, Internet, or telephone), and emphasizing
enhanced customer service and the use of call centers to provide consistency in how the
company interacts with customers. To others, CRM focuses on the creation and use of a
customer database to support decision makers.
Understanding customer relationship management begins with recognizing that CRM
seeks to increase the value of an organization’s customer base by developing and retaining
better relationships with customers. CRM may involve the use of databases but includes
much more than technology. CRM makes it possible to examine individual customers or
narrowly defined groups (micro segments) and calculate what each offers the company in
potential profits. The resulting customer lifetime value (CLV) can be used to focus market-
ing and promotional efforts.
CRM strategy can be viewed from companywide, customer-facing, and functional per-
spectives. The companywide or strategic perspective provides the most complete view
of CRM. Designing the CRM strategy follows a sequence of initiatives: gaining organi-
zational commitment to CRM, forming the project team, analyzing business needs, and
determining the CRM strategy to be pursued by the organization.
CRM strategy includes the value proposition to be offered, the business case, the cus-
tomer strategy, the enterprise transformation plan, and responsibilities to other stakehold-
ers. CRM strategy implementation involves integration of sales, marketing, and service
functions across all media and value chain members, creation of a data warehouse, deci-
sion guidelines for use of CRM analyses, determination of performance benchmarks, and
integration of cross-functional operations.
Several hurdles to successful CRM implementation include implementing before
creating a customer strategy, launching CRM before making essential organizational
changes, assuming that more CRM technology is necessarily better, and investing time and
resources with disinterested customers. CRM is a major undertaking that is complex and
demanding.
CRM is a value creation process consisting of the value the customer receives and the
value the organization receives. The benefits the customer receives are expressed in the
value proposition. The value the organization receives is determined by a penetrating anal-
ysis of the profitability of the customer base. Customer lifetime value is the basis of the
assessment.
CRM is an important aspect of strategic marketing, recognizing that CRM is an enter-
prise spanning initiative. It is essential that CRM be carefully integrated with marketing
strategy. CRM has a vital role to play in market targeting and marketing program position-
ing strategies.
Questions for 1. How should CRM be defined to provide a complete strategy perspective?
2. Discuss the value of considering CRM at different organizational levels.
Review and
3. What is involved in estimating customer lifetime value (CLV)?
Discussion 4. Discuss the process of developing a CRM strategy.
5. What are the important issues in CRM implementation?
6. Discuss how CRM creates value for the firm’s stakeholders.
7. What is the relationship between CRM and market segmentation?
8. Discuss the role of the cross-functional CRM team.
Internet A. Visit the website of SalesForce.com. Based on the information provided discuss how
SalesForce.com can contribute to a company’s CRM.
Applications B. Visit one of the websites discussed in Exhibit 4.3. Discuss how the website may be useful to a
company in its CRM activities.
Feature A. Critically evaluate the “Net Promoter” concept of customer satisfaction used by the General
Electric Co. What role does customer experience information play in GE’s CRM?
Applications
Notes 1. Sridhar N. Ramaswami, Mukesh Bhargava, and Rajendra Srivastava, “Market-based Assets
and Capabilities, Business Process, and Financial Performance,” MSI Working Paper Series,
No. 04–001, 2004.
2. “The Cart Pulling the Horse,” The Economist, April 9, 2005.
3. Adrian Payne and Pennie Frow, “A Strategic Framework for Customer Relationship Manage-
ment,” Journal of Marketing, 69, October 2005, 167–176.
4. Sudhir Kale, “CRM Failure and the Seven Deadly Sins,” Marketing Management 13, April 2004,
42–46.
5. George Day, “Tying on an Asset,” in Understanding CRM (London: Financial Times, 2000).
6. Don Peppers and Martha Rogers, Managing Customer Relationships (Hobroken, NJ: Wiley,
2004), 33.
7. Darrell K. Rigby, Frederick F. Reichheld, and Phil Schafter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM,”
Harvard Business Review, February 2002, 101–109.
8. Lynette Ryals, Simon D. Knox, and Stan Maklan, Customer Relationship Management: The
Business Case for CRM, Financial Times Report (London: Prentice Hall, 2000).
9. V. Kumar and Werner J. Reinartz, Customer Relationship Management (Hobroken, NJ: John
Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2006), 4.
10. Russell S. Winer, “A Framework for Customer Relationship Management,” California Manage-
ment Review 43, No. 4, Summer 2001, 89–105, 92.
11. Kale, “CRM Failure and the Seven Deadly Sins.”
12. The following discussion is based on Kumar and Reinartz, Customer Relationship Management,
33–47.
13. Ibid.
14. Frederick F. Reichheld, The Loyalty Effect (Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press,
1996).
15. Winer, “A Framework for Customer Relationship Management.”
16. Werner Reinartz and V. Kumar, “The Mismanagement of Customer Loyalty,” Harvard Business
Review, July 2002, 86–94.
17. Kumar and Reinartz, Customer Relationship Management, 42–44.
18. Wendy S. Close, “The Need for a Multi-vendor Strategy in Achieving Outstanding CRM,”
Gartner Inc. CRM Project Volume 2 (June 2001).
19. Rigby, Reichheld, and Schafter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM.”
20. Simon Knox, Stan Maklan, Adrian Payne, Joe Peppard, and Lynette Ryals, Customer Rela-
tionship Management: Perspectives from the Marketplace (Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann,
2003).
21. Rigby, Reichheld, and Schafter, “Avoid the Four Perils of CRM.”
22. Payne and Frow, “A Strategic Framework for Customer Relationship Management,” 170–172.
23. Ibid., 172.
24. Ibid., 172.
25. Selden, Larry and G. Colvin, Angel Customers and Demon Customers: Discover Which Is Which
and Turbo-Charge Your Stock (Knoxville, TN: Portfolio Hardcover, 2003).
26. Payne and Frow, “A Strategic Framework for Customer Relationship Management,” 172.
27. Winer, “A Framework for Customer Relationship Management.”
28. Kathryn Kranhold, “Client-Satisfaction Tool Takes Root,” The Wall Street Journal, July 10,
2006, B3.
29. Richard Tomkins, “Goodbye to Small Spenders,“ Financial Times, February 4, 2000, 13.