Xiang Changshui
Xiang Changshui
Xiang Changshui
__________________
Presented to
University of Wisconsin-Platteville
__________________
Master of Science
in
Education
__________________
by
2010
ABSTRACT
STUDENTS IN CHINA
language?” The population for the study was made of college students in China
second review of literature related to studies of imitation and recitation and their
the literature, it became clear that using imitation and recitation are effective
i
Statement of the Problem
made.
Summary of Results
find that spoken language is very important to the learning of English for ESL
college students. The ESL college students’ learning strategies are also
significant. In most studies, the imitation and recitation strategies are the two
most effective approaches to improve oral English for ESL college students.
ii
evidence that these two approaches play an important role in language learning.
Through the results of the study and personal experience, it seems that
ESL College learners’ brains are mature and have built up rich schemata for
learning a new language. Their strong logical reasoning and judgment enable
most important thing for Chinese ESL college students is to find effective
learning strategies that will assist them in the new or second language learning.
The imitation and recitation methods are the main effective ways. However, in
the future, researchers might explore more specific training forms to enhance
their oral English competences further besides just imitation and recitation
strategies.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
APPROVAL PAGE ......................................................................... i
TITLE PAGE .................................................................................. ii
ABSTRACT……………………………………………………….iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS…………………………………………..v
CHAPTER
I. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................1
Statement of the Problem
Definition of Terms
IV. REFERENCES………………………...……..……….……..25
iv
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
common. English has become an important tool and a universal language for
Chinese people to communicate with the world. Improving oral English for
communication is a chief way to study a second language well. The uses of oral
English learning approaches are significant for helping ESL students learnto
1
The problem addressed as a question is as follows:
English ability?
Definition of Terms
teaching.
carefully selected, meaning they are pure, authentic and beautiful texts, which
2
Delimitations of the Research
conducted via the Internet through EBSCO with Academic Search Elite and
Wilson Index as the primary sources. Key search topics included “imitation,”
Method
recommendations made.
3
CHAPTER 2
College learners. The main groups of College English learners in China are
mainly cover how to learn, how to grasp learning strategies, and so forth. The
learning persistence, learning habit, etc (Zhao, 2003). ESL college students in
China already have a lot of self discipline, so they can arouse learning interest,
learning habits.
the known concepts, past experiences, and background knowledge, which exist
emotions, and capacity, etc. all belong to this structure (Hu, 1996). In brains of
ESL students; abundant schemas about everything they’ve ever touched have
4
taken shape. Because the learners’ first language is Chinese, so the schemas are
ability. So a great deal of English input is necessary. ESL learners need to not
only know Chinese culture or some similarities of Chinese and English, but also
schemas. Having various kinds of English schemas in mind can simplify one’s
confronting different cultures. While reciting, ESL learners can make full use of
the schemata in their brain to channel their out put the right way.
understanding ability; they can understand the rules without too many
explanations. After they understand the rules, they can imitate them creatively
in the identical time, the speed for a child to study another language is lower
than that for an ESL college learner, who is stronger in vocabulary and grammar
study.
5
Broughter (1978) writes, “Motivation is a basic principle of all kinds of
the language is truly communicative, that it is appropriate to its context, that his
teacher’s skills are moving him forward to a fuller competence in the foreign
language.” ESL learners should be allowed to put what they have learnt into
practice and look for the training forms through which they can make oral
production activity. Thereby, they’ll find there’s still more for them to learn in
communication, and they will always be curious and highly motivation. The
originator of “Crazy English,” Li Yang, says, “In order to say a perfect and pure,
natural and exquisite English sentence, I resolved to listen to recorded tapes 100
times, have perseverance to repeat 100 times and have infatuation to shout 100
times.” To learn a foreign language is long-term, hard work, and it asks for
been established in ESL college learners and they display a strong self-control
in all aspects. They can focus more attention on study, and they are good at
6
The Introduction of Oral English
They speak for a purpose. They use the language to do things. They perform
special effects on the listeners. Whatever people’s purpose for speaking may be,
they have to go through two processes before they can communicate clearly to
listeners (Ls). First they have to plan what they want to say. Then they have to
make sure that they actually utter it in such a way that Ls understand their
tool that is spoken by two or more people. So understanding oral English is very
common problem for many Chinese students studying oral English that they
can’t understand oral English clearly and accurate. These word and
7
This level of understanding also can be used in the oral English. This level of
processing is called the Construction Process by Clark and Clark (1977) and the
structural level by Foss and Hakes (1978). Both suggest that at this level, what
and accurately follow the standard rules of pronunciation, stress, and intonation.
identifies two kinds of learning strategies are effective methods for improving
oral English for ESL college students. These are direct learning and indirect
8
inferencing, deductive reasoning, practice), and the indirect learning was
divided into two types (creating opportunities for practice, production tricks). It
practice. Therefore, it is obvious that recitation and imitation are very useful to
students must grasp English words first, then can help ESL college students
improving oral English,” which means that students should learn English words
by speaking, not by first learning words then speaking. Thus, ESL college
students have a good environment for learning language, they can imitate each
other.
learners’ oral English. Wang Yan (2008) said that “English film is an
9
is the most comprehensive encyclopedia of spoken English. Watching a large
English ‘Listen’ and ‘say.’ English movies take you to a new world. You can
learn the phrases, sentence structure, and the expression of a variety of content
in the film. What you need to do is to consider yourself as a role in the film,
you experience your lives and so do others. In short, watching a movie is better
than living in the United States a day, and also you can learn authentic spoken
approach to improve oral English when watching the films. So we can find out
imitation strategies are very important to improve oral English by ESL college
learners.
In the early periods, Lin Yutang, believed that imitation and recitation
were the right paths of learning English (Wu, 1994); in modern times, scholars
recalled the experiences of learning English: “I spent five hours reading aloud
10
the last part of the book, thirty pages with twelve thousand words. Then read
again, spending at least three hours. After several times, I could almost recite
the whole story. When I answered the questions about this part in the
final-examination paper, I felt that sentences came into being naturally without
intention.” (Xu, 1995)”His words prove the proverb, “Practice makes perfect.”
is an initial stage in this course and learners can imitate specific linguistic
higher stage. There is input in the process on the one hand, and it can provide
sense, imitation contains reciting, and reciting are higher forms of imitation.
application, writing skills, and original English thinking, etc. while reciting. It’s
even safe to say that the knowledge learners have acquired comes from
11
and learners, receive this knowledge passively. Imitation is the initial stage of
creation. But recitation can be used to practice greater English speaking ability,
English logic. In addition, reciting can make learners use the recited knowledge
actively. The target of learning English is to make learners turn their passive
knowledge into active knowledge and use this language flexibly in practice.
Therefore, we can see that only these two forms are integrated and carried out
Characteristics of Imitation
science but an art, which asks for myriads of imitation and practice to obtain
12
considered to be reasonable by scholars that SLA can follow first language
acquisition process as a model and derive good experiences from it. Thus,
strong imitating ability and can apply their logic and inference to complete
some tasks. Therefore, the learning strategy of imitation is suitable for them.
13
Learners can make speech production and acquire perception of target
what they are learning; therefore, adult learners can better their mentation,
which leads to their increased interest in imitation and more initiative to imitate;
which leaves more time for learners to notice other things in communication
Characteristics of Recitation
When we say the sentence “Do you mind opening the window?” instead
of “Do you mind to open the window?” we don’t know the reason why we say
so. In this case, English beginners must turn to their teacher to ask for
explanations, but their teacher may tell them that there is no reason and they
must memorize it. Similar sentences or other linguistic points exist in large
number in English. Even if sometime we know the reason we cannot let these
linguistic forms escape our lips. Then, only by means of internalizing and
14
internalize and stylize these patterns or models? Reciting can be employed
effectively.
expression under natural conditions after they own enough language input.
Therefore, the study should focus on providing students with the best language
input, In order to promote language acquisition. The best language input must
second, the input must be in sufficient quantity; third, the input should be
interesting and relevant (Zhang, 2000). Only the full input in order to have
materials are carefully selected which is pure, authentic and beautiful text, it is
15
ability (saying& writing) is produced on the basic of understanding input”
(Wan, 1997).
regulate students’ language output, and enhance students’ speaking and writing
competence.
Linguist Peter Skehan (1998) has ever probed into the inherent
out that there are two types of language knowledge stored in long-term
memory: one is the knowledge forming rule-based analytic system; the other is
for little space in memory, but its strength is its flexibility. In instantaneous
communication, learners need more time and attention to exercise these rules
and regulations so that they can hardly perform accurately, fluently, and
that learners can draw them out from memory rapidly under the time-limited
16
pressure and assure accuracy and fluency at the same time. The advantages and
long run, whether one can achieve effective learning that makes cognitive
structure is permanently changed. But how can make cognitive structure change
permanently? Learners can internalize what they have input and make this
subconscious layer, and perhaps they can’t realize this knowledge clearly, but
they can use the knowledge in context without thinking. This brings us to the
realization that the more recessive language one can grasp, the higher the
proficiency of using the target language. Reciting can bring input about target
only a way of inputting and the outputting function will be omitted. Thereby,
17
1) Reducing Anxiety
leaning English. Alpert and Haber (1960) thought facilitating anxiety can help
learners to improve the study result. However, (Horwitz & Young, 1991)
thought anxiety is an effective filter that hinders learners in obtaining the great
(Zhang, 2002). Actually, asking students to speak English always bring anxiety
English Ability in the ESL Classroom. These activities are among the most
example, students can recite famous masters’ speech, or try to work out some
expression of the exchange terms in specific scene. This will allow students to
18
language teaching method; using familiar methods to provide students’
knowledge can effectively reduce the anxiety level. (Shu & Zhuang, 1996).
2) Others
senses and inputs language through these channels, then delivers the language
content into learners’ short-term memory and asks them to repeat what has been
input by spoken output. It makes up for the deficiencies of input and output.
That is to say, it creates language environment for ESL learner to practice oral
English.
imitate directly in speech through reciting so that their speech is varies and
fluent. Recitation helps learners to form English thinking. It has been mentioned
above that what learners recite is surface structure of a sentence and then what is
comes into being, and finally English thinking is formed little by little.
19
Recitation plays an important role in spoken English. Recitation
fixed idioms, phrases, and patterns, which can lighten learners’ burden to
process language, make their language more accuracy and influent, and leave
Recitation can help learners saving time to think and make speeches do
successfully in real communication, so that they can reduce their anxiety and a
sense of urgency, which has positive effects on accurate and prompt oral
English expression.
so that they can boost their English perception through apperceiving author’s
can make vocal organs and oral cavity muscles meet the needs of English
20
comprehension improvement. Through reciting, students will not feel strange
about the sentence patterns they have recited, so they make it easy to understand
21
CHAPTER 3
As more and more ESL college students learn English for the purpose of
communication, the urgent study of how to improve ESL college learners’ oral
clear that ESL college learners are a common learning group which has its own
psychology. Their brain has matured and has built up rich schemata; their strong
alien to them; they are self-conscious and hesitant to open their mouth. This
transfer from mother tongue makes their English learning arduous. Thus, for
them, effective learning strategies are urgently called for. Comprehensible input
22
itself can’t be the only way to develop learners’ oral competence. Output
exercises are necessary. A learning strategy that can offer learners opportunities
that is to say, if ESL learners can imitate and internalize grammar rules in mind,
there will be the possibility for them to produce infinite sentences in ‘English
learners’ production, it is found that two gaps exist between learners’ linguistic
knowledge and the meaning they want to express, and between learners’ present
the “two gaps hypothesis.” To help ESL learners find a means by which the two
and reciting are good learning strategies to develop English speaking ability for
ESL college learners. At the same time, it is found that these two strategies can
help ESL college learners make the best use of their advantages and bypass the
and judgment help them imitate and recite effectively, imitation works well in
producing sterling English pronunciation and reciting can provide learners with
opportunities to practice English bravely, reciting can also help smooth away
college learners’ oral competence in primary stage. The training forms for ESL
23
college learners are excluded in this paper. Under the guidance of this paper,
ESL college learners can explore more specific training forms to enhance their
24
REFERENCES
Clark, H & Clark, E. (1977) Psychology and Language. New York : Harcourt
Brace Jovanovich.
Journal, 4, 63-64.
Elaine K. H & Dolly J. (1991). Young Language Anxiety: From Theory and
Prentice-hall.
Prentice-Hall.
25
Griffiths, C. (2004, Feb). Language learning strategies: Theory and research
http://www.crie.org.nz/research_paper/c_griffiths_op1.pdf
University Press.
4, 31-32.
Administration College,4,43.
26
Young , D, J . (1991). Creating a low – Anxiety classroom environment: what
75, 426.
Press.
9, 17-19.
27