Merchant of Venice - Annual Exam - Notes1676463835
Merchant of Venice - Annual Exam - Notes1676463835
Merchant of Venice - Annual Exam - Notes1676463835
Summary
Portia enters and is introduced to the court as "the learned doctor Balthazar."
Portia asks whether Antonio can just pay off the debt, and Bassanio immediately offers to pay twice
what's owed. In fact, he's willing to pay ten times the debt, and he offers his own life as the guarantee.
Then he begs the Duke to step in, bend the rules, and save Antonio. But Portia (as Balthazar) says
bending the rules simply isn't an option; it would set a bad precedent.She looks over Shylock's bond and
declares that he has every legal right to what's owed to him because of Antonio's forfeit. Still, she again
asks Shylock to be merciful, and suggests he might forget the whole bond by accepting three times what
he's owed.
Shylock compliments Portia for her knowledge of the law, but again states that no man will move him.
He wants the flesh. Antonio is tired of all this talk and would rather just get the whole darned thing over
with, so Portia tells Antonio to bare his chest and be prepared to go under the knife for Shylock.She asks
Shylock if he has scales to weigh the flesh, and he does. Shylock is thrilled that Portia/Balthazar is
sticking to the wording of the bond and making sure the flesh comes from near Antonio's heart.
Portia asks Shylock if he has a surgeon ready nearby to stop the wounds so Antonio doesn't bleed to
death, but Shylock notes that this wasn't part of the agreement.Antonio and Bassanio then hold hands
and share tearful goodbyes. Antonio tells Bassanio not to be sad that he's dying on his behalf. He tells
Bassanio instead to be stoked that Fortune, usually a cruel wench, has allowed Antonio to die rather
Antonio loved Bassanio. Antonio then instructs Bassanio only to be sad that he's losing a friend. Antonio
himself does not regret paying Bassanio's debt to Shylock with his life, so Bassanio shouldn't either.
Nerissa, disguised as Balthazar's attendant, mutters that if Gratiano's wife were around to hear this,
there'd be no peace in his household. Shylock says that's the way Christian husbands are (i.e., no good),
and laments that his poor daughter is marrying a Christian. Portia gets back to the legal proceedings,
laying out again the stipulations of the bond: the law gives up a pound of Antonio's flesh, and the law
allows Shylock to cut it from Antonio's breast.Shylock is excited to lop off Antonio's flesh, but before he
can start, Portia suddenly halts the process. She says the bond allows for a pound of flesh, but no blood.
If Shylock sheds a drop of Christian blood from Antonio, then the law of Venice states that Venice can
Shylock is stunned. Can this be true? Portia assures him it is, and since he's been so intent on following
the letter of the bond precisely, that's what they're going to do. Hearing this, Shylock quickly backpedals;
he'd rather just take three times the bond money and be on his merry way withoutmaking Antonio into
fish-bait. But Portia insists this is no longer an option—Shylock turned down the compromise when it
was on the table. Shylock, caught, asks only for the principal of the debt, the 3,000 ducats, hoping for
the whole affair to just be over with. Though Bassanio offers it up, Portia cuts him off again. Nope. Sorry.
All he's entitled to at this point is the flesh, which he can must take at his own peril.
Shylock is beat, and he knows it. He tries to leave, but Portia stops him again. There's another law that
says that if a foreign national seeks the life of a Venetian, either directly or indirectly, then the would-be
victim gets half of his stuff, and the other half goes to the state, while the fate of the would-be murderer
is in the hands of the Duke. Portia encourages Shylock to ask the Duke for mercy.
Gratiano, always helpful, says it would be nice if Shylock could beg for permission to hang himself, but
with his estate gone, he can't afford a rope. The Duke, who has apparently gone through more
sensitivity training than Gratiano, cuts in and pardons Shylock's life before Shylock even asks him to.
The Duke declares that half of Shylock's wealth now belongs to Antonio, and the state will be merciful
and only charge Shylock a fine instead of taking the other half of his wealth.Shylock says if they take
away his means of living, they may as well take his life. Portia asks Antonio what mercy he can offer
Shylock.Antonio says that he'd like his half of the money to go to Lorenzo and Jessica, as long as Shylock
does two things: (1) convert to Christianity; and (2) draw up a will leaving the rest of his wealth to
Lorenzo and Jessica upon his death. The Duke likes all of Antonio's conditions and says that if Shylock
doesn't accept them, he'll take back his pardon. Shylock, who is clearly getting the shaft left and right,
has no choice .
7. What does Antonio suggest about the fine which was to be charged by the state from the Jew?
Antonio requests the Duke to remit that part of Shylock’s fine which is to go to the state. Shylock may be
allowed to retain half of his property by paying a fine only.