Flora and Fauna Literature 1
Flora and Fauna Literature 1
Flora and Fauna Literature 1
None of the vegetation communities within the mining lease are threatened. The
native vegetation communities recorded within the specific infrastructure areas
identified are:
Threatened Flora
Five threatened and one migratory fauna species are considered to have suitable
habitat within the study area;
• Tasmanian devil (Sarcophilus harrisii) - Endangered TSPA, Endangered
EPBCA
• Spotted-tailed quoll (Dasyurus maculatus maculatus) - Rare TSPA,
Vulnerable EPBCA
• Wedge-tailed eagle (Aquila audax subsp. fleayi) - Endangered TSPA,
Endangered EPBCA
• White-bellied sea-eagle (Haliaeetus leucogaster) - Vulnerable TSPA
• Azure kingfisher (Alcedo azurea subsp.diemenensis) - Endangered TSPA,
Endangered EPBCA
• Satin fly catcher (Myiagra cyanoleuca) – Migratory EPBC
Tasmanian devil and spotted-tailed quoll
Populations found in the study area are considered to be important populations for
the recovery of both of these species.
The potential presence of maternal dens and impact on the carrying capacity through
the removal of 194ha of habitat triggers a number of the criteria listed (see Section
6.1), including criteria 2 and 4. Other possible impacts include increased roadkill
which could have a significant impact on population viability.
Pathogens
Phytophthora cinnamomi
No symptomatic evidence of Phytophthora was observed anywhere within the
mineral lease area. Management of Phytophthora should be specifically addressed to
ensure its introduction and spread is minimised to limit impacts to heathland species
notably Epacris curtisiae (northwest heath).
Legislative implications
Obligations under the RFA require the loss of a reserve that is listed for conservation
in a commitment binding on the Government (RFA CAR reserve), to be offset by
formal reservation elsewhere. An offset strategy will need to be developed for the loss
of a portion of the Arthur Pieman Conservation Area if the mine is approved.
No known impacts of the mine and associated infrastructure impact directly on any
species protected under this Act.
A weed control strategy and works plan, including a monitoring program and good
hygiene protocols, is required to maintain the current weed free status for both
declared and environmental weeds.
Recommendations
CONTEN TS
S U M M AR Y AN D R E C O M ME ND AT IO NS I
1 . INT R O D UC T IO N 1
1.1 BACKGROUND AND AIMS 1
1.2 THE STUDY AREA AND TENURE 2
Figure 1 – The location of the survey area. 2
2 . B OT AN IC AL S UR V E Y AN D F AU N A H AB IT AT AS S E S S ME NT 3
2.1 BACKGROUND RESEARCH 3
2.2 FLORA AND FAUNA HABITAT SURVEY METHODS 3
2.3 LIMITATIONS 4
2.4 ASSESSMENT OF CONSERVATION SIGNIFICANCE 4
3 . T HE B IO L O G IC AL V AL UE S 5
3.1 VEGETATION COMMUNITIES 5
3.1.1 Vegetation of the deep pit/ open cut mine 5
3.1.2 Vegetation of the direct shipping pit 6
3.1.3 Vegetation of the processing plant 7
3.1.4 Vegetation of the tailings dam 7
3.1.5 Vegetation of the waste dump 7
3.1.5 Vegetation within the mining lease but outside the proposed impact zone 8
Figure 2 Distribution of vegetation communities 13
3.2 THREATENED FLORA SPECIES 14
3.3 TERRESTRIAL FAUNA HABITAT 18
Figure 3 Distribution of threatened flora and threatened fauna habitat 19
3.4 FAUNA OF CONSERVATION SIGNIFICANCE 20
3.5 INTRODUCED PLANT SPECIES 25
3.6 PLANT PATHOGENS 26
Phytophthora cinnamomi 26
4 . AS S E S S ME NT O F IMP AC T 27
4.1 DOWN STREAM IMPACTS OF TAILINGS 27
4.2 NATIVE VEGETATION AND FAUNA HABITAT 27
4.3 FLORA 27
4.4 THREATENED FAUNA HABITAT 27
4.5 PATHOGENS 31
5 . MIT IG AT IO N 32
6. L E G IS L AT IV E IMP L IC AT IO NS 33
6.1 COMMONWEALTH ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AND BIODIVERSITY
CONSERVATION ACT 1999 33
6.2 TASMANIAN THREATENED SPECIES PROTECTION ACT 1995 34
6.3 FOREST PRACTISES ACT 1985 34
6.4 REGIONAL FOREST AGREEMENT 34
6.5 TASMANIAN LAND USE PLANNING AND APPROVALS ACT 1993 35
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Client: Shree Minerals
Project Management: Philip Barker
Mapping: Sue Jungalwalla
Survey: Karen Ziegler and Kat Hopkins
Report: Philip Barker and Karen Ziegler
1. INTRODUCTION
1 IBRA 5, 1998
2 Bureau of Meteorology Map of Climate Zones of Australia, 18/05/2001
3 GIS Unit, RMC, DPIPWE, NVA report 40737, 10th Nov. 2010
4 EPBC Act Protected Matters report, 15th Nov. 2010
5 Bryant & Jackson, 1999
9 FCF 2007
The distribution of vegetation and the impact upon it varies from region to region
around Tasmania. The conservation status has been determined and presented at the
State level and on a bioregional basis. A bioregion is an area that is similar in biological
and physical characteristics throughout and hence the vegetation that occurs in it is
generally characteristic of the region. Vegetation that is characteristic of a neighbouring
or remote region but also occurs in the bioregion may be considered rare or threatened
in one region but not in another. Consequently, the conservation status of any
vegetation type may vary from bioregion to bioregion.
3.1 V E GE T AT I ON C OM M UNI T I ES
General Description
All elements of the mine and associated infrastructure and the areas within the
exploration lease outside the proposed impact area were surveyed during the recent
visit. The vegetation surrounding the spur road off Wuthering Heights Road which is
the access to the area has been logged and regenerated predominantly to native forest
with small areas of eucalypt plantation of Eucalyptus nitens. Along the Nelson Bay
River which forms much of the northern boundary of the exploration lease there is fire
damaged Eucalyptus obliqua forest that is at the drier end of wet sclerophyll forest. For
much of the water course the river is quite deeply incised creating a moister
microhabitat. There is then a finger of predominantly wet heathy scrub that is dissected
by the rough access track, from which mineral exploration tracks have been cut. The
majority of the area that is designated to become the waste dump supports moderately
tall Eucalyptus obliqua with extremely dense teatree understorey. The most westerly
section is predominantly low wet heathland with variable proportions of graminoids
and woody species depending on time since the last fire. Amongst and on the verges of
the low wet heathland are areas of low Eucalyptus nitida woodland with shrubby or
heathy understoreys depending on localised soil conditions.
Table 1 indicates the extent and reservation status for vegetation communities in the
study area.
Figure 2 illustrates the extent of each vegetation community, modified from Tasveg
version 2 (September 2009). The surveyed vegetation communities are significantly
different from the current mapped by Tasveg.
In this section vegetation within separate parts of the study area is described under its
relevant Tasveg mapping unit. Full community lists are given in Appendix 4.
There are three distinct communities in this relatively small area. They are described
below:
Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over Leptospermum (WOL)
On these soils in this area of the northwest of Tasmania where the vegetation would
generally be expected to be forest dominated by Eucalyptus nitida, Eucalyptus obliqua
are dominant. The trees are in general relatively short with a dense tall understorey. In
this area the understorey is a mix of Leptospermum species and other shrubs, the
dominants being L. glaucescens, L. scoparium, Philotheca virgata, Monotoca glauca
and Nematolepis squamea. Due to the dense nature there are only occasional low
shrubs, herbs and ferns, although these are relatively diverse.
The direct shipping pit contains the same three vegetation mapping communities as
the deep pit/ open cut mine. It is comprised of WOL at the northern end and a mosaic
of DNI and SWW throughout the remainder of this area.
Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over Leptospermum (WOL)
This community is as described for the deep pit/ open cut mine. It occurs immediately
adjacent to the deep pit/ open cut mine on the eastern side.
Dry Eucalyptus nitida forest and woodland (DNI)
This community is as described for the deep pit/ open cut mine.
OB1110 - Eucalyptus obliqua Wet Eucalyptus 427 969* ha intact 63 134* ha intact
– Anopterus glandulosus- obliqua forest
Acacia verticillata mixed over broad leaf 138 590* ha 9 945* ha reserved
forest shrubs. reserved
Not threatened
OB010 -Eucalyptus obliqua WOB Not threatened
– Olearia lirata- Pultenaea Not adequately reserved
juniperina wet sclerophyll 196.8 ha in study Well reserved
forest area *analysis undertaken on
*analysis WOU
undertaken on
WOU
10 Kirkpatrick et al 1995.
11 TasVeg 2003
12 TasVeg 2003
75.2 ha in study
area
Wet heathland
Sprengelia incarnata – Wet heathland Not assessed for Not assessed for
Bauera rubioides – conservation and conservation and
Lepidosperma filiforme SHW reservation status reservation status
heath
242.4 ha in study
area
Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over broad- Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over broad-
leaf shrubs (WOB). leaf shrubs (WOB) in the riparian zone of the
Nelson Bay River.
Dry Eucalyptus nitida woodland over wet Regenerating dry Eucalyptus nitida
heathland (DNI). woodland (DNI) in foreground with wet
Eucalyptus obliqua forest over
Leptospermum (WOL) in background.
Western wet scrub in the vicinity of the Wet heathland typical of western portion of
proposed processing plant (SWW). study area (SHW).
Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over broad- Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over
leaf shrubs (WOB) regenerating after logging. Leptospermum (WOL) regenerating after
logging.
Dry Eucalyptus obliqua of mallee form in Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over
small localised patches in the study area. Leptospermum (WOL) in the vicinity of the
waste dump.
311000mE
313000mE
308000mE
309000mE
312000mE
WOB
WOB
Access Road
5443000mN
50 Access Road
WOB
WOB ad
40
Ro
s
es
cc
A
WOL
WOL
50
70
80
2W
DR
WOL
WOL
oad
110
10
0
Deep
Deep Pit
Pit WOB
WOB WOB
WOB
90
70 WOR
WOR
5442000mN
80
0
10
10
0
90
WOB
WOB
DDii
rree
cctt
SShh
Waste
Waste Dump
Dump
iipp
ppii
nngg
PPii
tt
Processing
Processing Plant
Plant
WOL
WOL
5441000mN
WOL
WOL
Tailings
Tailings
WOL
WOL
Base data from theLIST, © State of Tasmania Datum: GDA94, AHD Grid: MGA Zone 55
Vegetation Communities
(Using Tasveg 2.0 mapping units)
Survey Area & Proposed Infrastructure Figure 2:
9/11/2010
DNI Eucalyptus nitida dry forest and woodland
DOB Eucalyptus obliqua dry forest and woodland
FPL Plantations for silviculture
Infrastructure - as labelled
Survey Area
Vegetation Communities
Conservation Status17
Previous records, preferred habitat and
Species Name TSPA/ Potential other observations.18
EPBCA to occur
previously. Peak flowering all of October and early
November. Potential flowering is all of October and all
of November. Perhaps the study area is too far inland
to be good habitat. Not recorded during survey.
Listed on EPBCA website. This species is known
presently from Rocky Cape National Park and near
Stanley from heathland and heathy eucalypt woodland
Corunastylis brachystachya Endangered/ LOW on well drained rocky sites and found most recently in
Shortspike midge orchid ENDANGERED March 2010 within 5km of the study area from two
populations. The few records of this species suggest a
peak flowering period in March, though there is
potential to flower throughout February to April.
This species is known from well-drained rocky areas
Cullen microcephalum Rare/ NONE in the salt spray zone. There is no suitable habitat
Dusky scurfpea -
within the study area.
Listed on EPBCA website. This species is known in
coastal scrub and wind swept coastal grassland and
heaths amongst stunted shrubs and sedges on moist
to well-drained sandy and clay loam, and occasionally
Diuris lanceolata Endangered/ NONE on rock outcrops. Peak flowering is November but
Large golden moths ENDANGERED potentially may extend through December and
January. Targeted surveys in the summer of
2008/2009 located extant populations near Sundown
Point and near Rebecca Lagoon. This species is
unlikely to extend as far inland as the study area.
This species is endemic to Tasmania with its’
stronghold in the NW, and it occurs in peaty soils or
undulating terrain in association with heathlands,
Epacris curtisiae graminoid heaths and buttongrass scrub in the
Rare/- PRESENT northwest. It occurs in altitudes below 300 m.
Northwest heath
There are many records in the vicinity of the study
area, though it is significant that the records from the
current survey extend across the northerly extent of
the distribution.
In Tasmania Lotus australis has been described as
being “local on sandy coasts” and has been recorded
around the coast north from Macquarie Harbour to
Bicheno with few records from offshore islands.
Lotus australis Rare/ NONE Habitat is described as Poa tussock grassland, low
Australian trefoil - coastal shrubbery and on dunes. The author has seen
species on sandy loams derived from basalt on Trefoil
Island. This species has colourful pink flowers and
characteristic ‘birdsfoot’ clusters of seed capsules. The
study area does not contain suitable habitat.
This is a small annual herb which inhabits open
coastal, periodically inundated areas often on sand or
clay overlying rock. It is predominantly known from
Phyllangium divergens Vulnerable NONE eastern Tasmania though recent surveys in 2008 &
Wiry mitrewort - 2009 have identified this plant as widespread and
locally abundant in the Arthur-Pieman CA. It flowers
in October to November. The study area does not have
suitable habitat.
Listed on EPBCA website. A species of windswept wet
heaths that likes fire. It potentially flowers from the
start of October to early December, with a peak in
Endangered/ early November. There are records from recent
Prasophyllum favonium
CRITICALLY MODERATE surveys in late 2008 near Couta Rocks and the
Western leek orchid
ENDANGERED Heemskirk Road. The wet heathland on the western
boundary has the greatest potential to contain this
species although it was not recorded during this
survey.
Conservation Status17
Previous records, preferred habitat and
Species Name TSPA/ Potential other observations.18
EPBCA to occur
Listed on EPBCA website and there are 6 records from
nearby at the same location over 4 years.
Endangered/
Prasophyllum pulchellum PRESENT The population that was found in the study area is in
CRITICALLY
Pretty leek orchid wet heathland at the edge of a slashed track. The time
ENDANGERED
since last fire is about four years. There are 20 plants
flowering in an area of 3 square metres.
Listed on EPBCA website. Known to occur in grassy
dune swales. Rosette and flower production is
Prasophyllum secutum Endangered/ dependent on a fire in the preceding season. There is
NONE potential for this species to flower between October to
Northern leek orchid ENDANGERED
December, with a peak in November.
There are no grassy dune swales within the study area.
Listed on EPBCA website. This species is only known
from the Arthur River area from dry sandy slopes of
sparsely vegetated stabilised sand dunes and in the
vastly different environment of permanently
Pterostylis rubenachii Endangered/ NONE wet/moist scrubby and sedgy coastal heath converted
Arthur River greenhood ENDANGERED
to semi improved pasture by slashing and cattle
grazing. Potentially flowers from October to
November, with the peak flowering period in early
November. No similar habitat in the study area.
Locally frequent in the Couta Rocks area – this
population is considered to be one of the key
Spyridium vexilliferum var. populations in Tasmania. The species is found in
Rare/ LOW
vexilliferum sandy heaths and rocky outcrops.
-
Helicopter bush
It is unlikely that this species would occur in the
predominantly wet heaths of the study area.
Known from vastly different habitats of heathlands
near the coast or in alpine situations. In coastal
Xerochrysum bicolor Rare/ LOW situations it is known more commonly from the east.
Eastcoast everlasting - There are some west coast records however it is
unlikely to be in the denser wet heaths away from the
coast as found in the study area.
19
North Barker Ecosystem Services (13 May 2010) Tarkine Drive North West Tasmania
Epacris curtisiae Survey Addendum to VEGETATION SURVEY AND FAUNA HABITAT ASSESSMENT
20Threatened Species section (2010) Listing Statement for Prasophyllum pulchellum (pretty leek orchid). Department of
Primary Industries, Parks, water and Environment, Tasmania.
309000mE
310000mE
311000mE
313000mE
312000mE
Access Road
5443000mN Nelson
Nelson
Nelson
Nelson Bay
Nelson Bay
Bay
Bay River
River
Bay River
River
River
River
50 Access Road
(
( ad
40
Ro
s
es
cc
A
50
70
80
2W
DR
g
g Ec
Ec (1250
(1250 plants,
plants, 2,500sqm)
2,500sqm)
oad
110
(
(
10
0
Deep
Deep Pit
Pit
90
70
5442000mN (
((
(
80
(
(
(
( 0
10
Ec
Ec
(800
(800 plants,
plants, (
(
10
30,000sqm)
30,000sqm)
0
90
DDii
rree
cctt
SShh
Waste
Waste Dump
Dump
iipp
ppii
nngg
(
(
PPii
(
(
tt
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
( Processing
Processing Plant
Plant
(
(
5441000mN (
(
Ec
Ec
(1-2
(1-2 million
million plants,
plants,
970,000sqm)
970,000sqm)
Tailings
Tailings
(
(
f
f Pp
Pp (20
(20 plants,
plants, 3sqm)
3sqm)
Base data from theLIST, © State of Tasmania Datum: GDA94, AHD Grid: MGA Zone 55
Threatened Flora (Status: TSPA/EPBCA) Survey Area & Proposed Infrastructure
Threatened Fauna Habitat
9/11/2010 Figure 3:
See map for number of plants
Sarcophilus harrisii (tasmanian devil) (e/En)
(
(
g
g Ec Epacris curtisiae (r/-)
f
f Pp Prasophyllum pulchellum (e/EN)
- scats present Deep Pit
BIRDS
Orange-bellied
Parrot Endangered/ The wet heaths may provide foraging habitat while the
Critically VERY LOW birds are migrating between Tasmania and the
Neophema Endangered Australian mainland.
chrysogaster
Satin Flycatcher EPBCA listed migratory species. This species was seen
migratory PRESENT foraging at several locations in the riparian areas along
Myiagra the Nelson Bay River. It may be more widespread.
25 Higgins (1999)
Status Likelihood of 23 24
Species Preferred Habitat and Observations
TSPA/EPBCA occurrence
This species nests and forages mainly near the coast but
will also live near large rivers and inland lakes, often
White-bellied moving on a seasonal basis. The nearby coast is
Sea-eagle considered habitat for this species. No records of this
Vulnerable/- LOW species have been recorded within 5km of the study area.
Haliaeetus
leucogaster The helicopter search was extended to more exposed
sites supporting suitable nest trees for this species but
failed to locate any nests.
Tasmanian
Masked Owl
Preferred habitat is lowland dry forest and woodlands.
Endangered / Nests in large hollow bearing trees. The wet forest that
Tyto LOW
Vulnerable has been burnt has some evidence of large hollows which
novaehollandiae
may provide nesting habitat.
subsp.
castanops
MAMMALS
Status Likelihood of 23 24
Species Preferred Habitat and Observations
TSPA/EPBCA occurrence
FISH
INVERTEBRATES
Marrawah
Skipper
This species is dependent on the duel presence of
Endangered/- NONE Melaleuca ericifolia swamp forest and Carex sp. These
Oreisplanus
do not occur in the study area.
munionga tax.
larana
30 Mallick 2003
32 Meander Dam Mitigation Strategy for spotted-tailed quoll (North Barker 2003).
Nelson Bay River at a bend in the river with A 2m plus water fall near the Temma Road
deep and relatively slow water. on the Nelson Bay River that would stop
the movement of Australian grayling
upstream to spawn within the study area.
3.6 P L ANT P AT HO GE NS
Phytophthora cinnamomi
Commonly known as root rot or dieback, Phytophthora is a soil borne fungal pathogen
that invades the roots of plants and starves them of nutrients and water. Heath
communities are the most susceptible to infection with a consequent serious loss of
species diversity. It is generally spread by the transportation of soil on vehicles,
construction machinery and walking boots. The establishment and spread of
Phytophthora is favoured in areas that receive above 600 mm of rainfall per annum
and are below about 800 m altitude. Within this suitable climatic envelope some soil
types are more conducive to the establishment and spread of Phytophthora than
others. Conducive soils are generally the low nutrient types that support heathy
communities. The combination of these biophysical factors results in patches of
susceptible communities on conducive sites across the landscape.
No symptomatic evidence of Phytophthora was observed anywhere within the mining
lease area.
The vegetation of the infrastructure areas is variable in terms of the potential
establishment of Phytophthora cinnamomi both in terms of favourable conditions and
vegetation susceptibility. The wet heathland, the western wet scrub and the dry
eucalypt communities with heathy understorey contain vegetation susceptible to
Phytophthora cinnamomi and have favourable conditions for its spread. The wet
shrubby eucalypt communities contain less susceptible species and are less conducive
to the spread of the soil borne pathogen.
The rare species located in great abundance in the western portion of the study area,
Epacris curtisiae is thought to be sensitive to Phytophthora cinnamomi as seen from
symptomatic evidence observed during the survey of the Tarkine Road in 2009.
4. ASSESSMENT OF IMPACT
The majority of the study area is included in the Tarkine emergency heritage listing of
4/11/2009.
4.3 FLORA
Threatened Flora
As the two threatened flora species Epacris curtisiae - northwest heath and
Prasophyllum pulchellum - pretty leek-orchid are both outside the proposed impact
zones associated with the infrastructure of the mine there should be no impact to
threatened vascular flora species. If the layout to the proposed mine and access is
revised the location of threatened flora will need to be considered.
Tasmanian devil
The entire mine area is potential foraging habitat and all forested environments offer
some denning opportunities in the large dry hollows of large eucalypt trees. The devil
may range over 15 km in search of food. Although not territorial they do have a home
range.
The numbers of dens present, if any, within the mine impact area and hence the scale
of impact is not known.
Because they are not territorial it is possible that a female devil that is displaced by the
mine and associated infrastructure of its den site could occupy an alternative den site
and survive and breed.
A significant amount of native vegetation (194ha) is proposed for clearance under the
current mining proposal. This quantity of vegetation removal will affect the carrying
capacity of the vegetation in the area to support devils. Therefore there will be an
impact on devils, however at this stage of the project and without further surveys and
monitoring this is very difficult to quantify.
The clearance of vegetation will be staged throughout the life of the mine which is likely
to be measured in decades. Devils may therefore recolonise the area during the life of
the mine.
Devil Facial Tumour Disease (DFTD) has had a significant impact on the tasmanian
devil population in Tasmania, and is the single most significant cause of mortality for
the species. The retention of naturally occurring disease free populations is a key factor
in ensuring the long term survival of the species in the wild. Any activity that may
increase the risk of accelerating the spread of DFTD into areas currently disease free
may be considered as having a significant impact to the species. The study area has
long been an area of forestry and mineral prospecting and tracks have existed for at
least the last two decades. Because the area already has been “opened up” and
subjected to levels of human activity, the mine proposal is unlikely to accelerate the
spread of DFTD into the area.
Healthy populations of Tasmanian devil are able to withstand what may appear to be
devastating mortality rates from roadkill. Roadkill rates peak in summer, impacting on
young animals just out of the den and migrating males which may have been driven out
by dominant adults. Roadkill however has been shown to have a significant impact on
small isolated populations (e.g. Cradle Valley) and also on depleted populations such as
those affected by DFTD 34. Traffic volumes and possibly speed levels will increase in the
event of the mine development going ahead. Significant increases in traffic volumes
and/or speed levels are likely to increase the incidences of roadkill.
34 Jones 2000
Spotted-tailed quoll
An area of up to 194ha of habitat will be lost to clearance and inundation. The quality of
the foraging habitat is likely to be similar throughout the proposed impact areas
although denning opportunities are likely to be greater in the mature forest in the large
dry hollows of eucalypts or under fallen logs. The habitat surrounding the mine area is
suitable for the spotted-tailed quoll and so movement of the quoll across the region will
not be hindered.
A significant amount of native vegetation (194ha) is proposed for clearance under the
current mining proposal. This quantity of vegetation removal will affect the carrying
capacity of the vegetation in the area to support spotted-tailed quolls. Therefore there
will be an impact on spotted-tailed quolls, however at this stage of the project and
without further surveys and monitoring this is very difficult to quantify.
As for the tasmanian devil, increases in vehicle traffic volume and speed levels are also
likely to increase the incidences of roadkill on the spotted-tailed quoll. There are no
specific studies detailing the impacts of roadkill on spotted-tailed quoll populations,
however given the low density of animals (one individual per 4 km²) it is likely to be
highly significant.
Azure kingfisher
As the Nelson Bay River is the only waterway within the mining lease - but outside the
impact zone of the proposed mine - that contains potential habitat for the azure
kingfisher, there is expected to be no impact on this species. Surveys failed to locate
any birds.
Satin fly catcher (Myiagra cyanoleuca)
Within the study area they were only recorded outside the proposed impact zone.
However, the SPRAT (Species Profile and Threats Database) indicates a very wide
range for habitat preference though generally focused on riparian vegetation. Riparian
habitat does occur within the waste dump footprint but no birds were recorded there
although there were limitations to access. If occupied by birds it is unclear whether
such habitat is suited to breeding.
4.5 P AT HO GE NS
Phytophthora cinnamomi
There was no symptomatic evidence of Phytophthora cinnamomi seen in the study
area. However as the western wet scrub, wet heathland and dry eucalypt forest with a
heathy understorey are susceptible to the soil borne pathogen it will be important to
ensure soil hygiene measures mitigate against the inadvertent introduction of
Phytophthora cinnamomi. The threatened flora species Epacris curtisiae - northwest
heath would be particularly susceptible to Phytophthora cinnamomi.
The movement of machinery and vehicles in general presents an increased risk of
moving Phytophthora to communities at risk. However, the implementation of simple
strategies such as machinery wash down prior to bringing machinery on-site will
reduce this risk.
5. MITIGATION
6. LEGISLATIVE IMPLICATIONS
Independent legal advice should be sought if there is any intention to disturb the
relevant values. The final implications of the following legislation will depend upon the
nature of any proposed development and attempts to mitigate or offset impacts.
The proposal will require approval if the action has, will have, or is likely to have a
significant impact on an endangered threatened species or an important population of
a vulnerable threatened species.
36 section 51(2) (b) – Part 4 Enforcement of Planning Control – Division 2 Development Control LUPA 1993
37 pp56 LUPA 1993
Vegetation Communities
None of the vegetation communities within the mining lease are threatened. The native
vegetation communities recorded within the specific infrastructure areas identified are:
Threatened Flora
Five threatened fauna and one migratory species are considered to have suitable
habitat within the study area;
• Tasmanian devil (Sarcophilus harrisii) - Endangered TSPA, Endangered
EPBCA
• Spotted-tailed quoll (Dasyurus maculatus maculatus) - Rare TSPA, Vulnerable
EPBCA
• Wedge-tailed eagle (Aquila audax subsp. fleayi) - Endangered TSPA,
Endangered EPBCA
• White-bellied sea-eagle (Haliaeetus leucogaster) - Vulnerable TSPA
• Azure kingfisher (Alcedo azurea subsp. diemenensis) - Endangered TSPA,
Endangered EPBCA
• Satin fly catcher (Myiagra cyanoleuca) – Migratory EPBC
Populations found in the study area are considered to be important populations for the
recovery of both of these species.
The potential presence of maternal dens and impact on the carrying capacity through
the removal of 194ha of habitat triggers a number of the criteria listed above (see
Section 6.1), including criteria 2 and 4. Other possible impacts include increased
roadkill which could have a significant impact on population viability.
Phytophthora cinnamomi
No symptomatic evidence of Phytophthora was observed anywhere within the mineral
lease area. Management of Phytophthora should be specifically addressed to ensure its
introduction and spread is minimised to limit impacts to heathland species notably
Epacris curtisiae (northwest heath).
Obligations under the RFA requires the loss of a reserve that is listed for conservation
in a commitment binding on the Government (RFA CAR reserve), to be offset by formal
reservation elsewhere. An offset strategy will need to be developed for the loss of a
portion of the Arthur Pieman Conservation Area if the mine is approved.
No known impacts of the mine and associated infrastructure impact directly on any
species protected under this Act.
A weed control strategy and works plan, including a monitoring program and good
hygiene protocols, is required to maintain the current weed free status for both
declared and environmental weeds.
Recommendations
References
Bell, P. J. & Mooney, N. J. (1998). Wedge-tailed Eagle Recovery Plan 1998-2003. Department
of Primary Industries, Water and Environment.
Buchanan, A.M. (1999). A Census of the Vascular Plants of Tasmania & Index to The
Student's Flora of Tasmania. Third Edition. Tasmanian Herbarium Occasional
Publication No. 6, Hobart.
Curtis, W.M. (1963). The Student’s Flora of Tasmania, Part 2. University of Tasmania.
DPIPWE 15th November 2010 Natural Values Atlas Report – 40798. Tasmania.
Flora Advisory Committee (1994). Native Higher Plant Taxa Which Are Rare Or
Threatened In Tasmania. Parks & Wildlife Service, Hobart.
Kirkpatrick, J.B., Barker, P., Brown, M.J., Harris, S., and Mackie, R. (1995). The
Reservation Status of Tasmanian Vascular Plant Communities. Wildlife
Scientific Report 95/4. Parks and Wildlife Service, Hobart.
Kirkpatrick, J.B., Peacock, R.J., Cullen, P.J. and Neyland, M.G. (1988). The Wet
Eucalypt Forests of Tasmania. Tasmanian Conservation Trust, Hobart.
Mallick, S (2003). Meander Dam Mitigation Strategy for the Spotted-tailed Quoll
(Dasyurus maculatus). North Barker Ecosystem Services, for the Rivers and Water
Supply Commission, Tasmania.
North Barker Ecosystem Services (13 May 2010) Tarkine Drive North West Tasmania.
North, A.J., Johnson, K., Ziegler, K., Duncan, F. K Hopkins, D, Ziegeler, D., Watts, S.
(1998). Flora of Recommended Areas for Protection and Forest Reserves in
Tasmania. Forestry Tasmania / Forest Practices Board / Parks & Wildlife
Service, Hobart.
PLUC (1996). Environment and Heritage Report. Background Report Part C Vol I-V.
For Tasmanian - Commonwealth Regional Forest Agreement. Tasmanian Public
Land Use Commission, Hobart.
Tasmanian State Government (1995). Threatened Species Protection Act 1995. No.83
of 1995. Government Printer, Hobart, Tasmania.
Threatened flora and fauna species in Tasmania are listed in Schedules 3 (endangered) and 4
(vulnerable) of the Threatened Species Protection Act, 1995. Rare species that are considered to
be ‘at risk’ are listed in Schedule 5 of the Act. These three categories are defined in Section 15 of
the Act.
1. “An extant taxon of native flora or fauna may be listed as endangered if it is in danger of
extinction because long-term survival is unlikely while the factors causing it to be
endangered continue operating.
2. A taxon of native flora or fauna may be listed as vulnerable if it is likely to become an
endangered taxon while the factors causing it to be vulnerable continue operating.
3. A taxon of native flora or fauna may be listed as rare if it has a small population in
Tasmania that is not endangered or vulnerable but is at risk.”
The Act provides mechanisms for protecting these species from threatening processes,
the implementation of ‘recovery plans’, ‘threat abatement plans’, ‘land management
plans’, public authority agreements’, and ‘interim protection orders’.
Section 51 (a) of the TSPA states that: “A person must not knowingly, without a permit - take,
trade in, keep or process any listed flora or fauna”. The Act defines ‘take’ as including: “kill,
injure, catch, damage, destroy and collect. A land manager is therefore required to obtain a
permit from the Tasmanian Department of Primary Industries, Parks, Water and Environment
(DPIPWE) to carry out management that may adversely affect any of the species listed in the
Act.
The EPBC Act establishes a process for assessing actions that are likely to have impacts of
national environmental significance. Such impacts include World Heritage Areas, RAMSAR
Wetland sites of international importance, migratory species protected under international
agreements, nuclear actions, the Commonwealth marine environment and nationally
threatened species and communities.
An action that is likely to affect species that are listed in any of the above categories may require
ministerial approval unless the Commonwealth Environment Minister has granted an
exemption. The Act establishes a referral process to Environment Australia to determine
whether an action requires a formal approval and thus would be required to proceed through
the assessment and approval process.
A referral must provide sufficient information to allow the Minister to make a decision. The
Minister is then required to make a decision within 20 business days of the referral. The
Minister may decide an approval is not necessary if the action is taken in a specified manner.
The action may not require approval but may require a permit if undertaken on
Commonwealth land. If an approval is required then an environmental assessment must be
carried out. In such instances the environmental assessment approach will be determined by the
Minister and may vary from preliminary documentation to a full public inquiry depending on
the scale and complexity of the impact.
A P P E NDI X 3 - F L O R A S P E C I E S L I S T
PAS062
Status codes:
ORIGIN NATIONAL SCHEDULE STATE SCHEDULE
i - introduced EPBC Act 1999 TSP Act 1995
d - declared weed WM Act CR - critically endangered e - endangered
en - endemic to Tasmania EN - endangered v - vulnerable
t - within Australia, occurs only in Tas. VU - vulnerable r - rare
Sites:
1 WOB - E310681, N5442009 17/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
2 DOB heathy - E310598, N5441971 17/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
3 SHW Sprengelia incarnata wet heathland - E308598, N5441943 18/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
4 DOB heathy - E308585, N5442105 18/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
5 SHW Wet heath - additonal species - E308598, N5441943 18/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
6 DNI - E309160, N5442777 18/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
7 DNI additional spp - E309160, N5442777 18/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
8 WOB - E311812, N5441410 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
9 WOB additional spp - E311812, N5441410 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
10 WOB additional spp riparian zone - E311675, N5441288 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
11 SWW - E311485, N5441183 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
12 WOL - E311300, N5440830 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
13 DNI additional spp - E311407, N5440885 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
14 DNI - E311590, N5440699 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
15 SWW - E311762, N5440816 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
16 WOL - E311381, N5440650 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
17 WOL additional spp riparian zone - E311409, N5440664 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
18 WOL - E311521, N5440801 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
19 SWW - E311655, N5440974 19/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
20 WOL - E311271, N5440915 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
21 DNI additional spp - E311271, N5440915 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
22 SWW - E311494, N5441021 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
23 WOL - E311163, N5440980 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
24 DNI additional spp - E311163, N5440980 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
25 SWW additional spp - E311327, N5441058 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
26 DOB additional species - E310681, N5442009 18/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
27 SWW - E310473, N5442076 19/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
28 WOL - E310528, N5441682 20/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
29 SHW Wet Heath - E310727, N5441840 20/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
30 WOB - E310929, N5441917 20/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
31 SHW - E310176, N5440520 22/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
32 WOL - E311147, N5441035 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
33 SWW additional spp - E311263, N5441135 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
34 WOL additional spp - E310946, N5441280 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
35 DOB - E310859, N5441463 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
36 DOB - E310741, N5441493 20/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
37 DNI heathy understorey - E310046, N5441035 22/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
38 WOL - E310056, N5441103 22/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
39 DNI additional species - E310046, N5441035 22/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
40 SHW additional species - E310176, N5440520 22/11/2010 Karen Ziegler
41 SHW - E310302, N5440468 22/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
42 DNI - E310610, N5440976 22/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
43 DNI additional spp riparian area - E310637, N5440987 22/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
44 DOB - E310798, N5440376 22/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
45 FPL (E nitens) - E312557, N5442147 21/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
46 WOR (regenerating forest after fire) - E312691, N5442209 21/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
47 WOL post-logging regen - E312431, N5440851 21/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
48 WOB - E312457, N5442040 21/11/2010 Katriona Hopkins
CASUARINACEAE
1 2 3 4 6 13 Allocasuarina monilifera necklace sheoak en
25 29 35 36
37 41 44
CUNONIACEAE
46 Anodopetalum biglandulosum horizontal en
1 2 3 4 6 8 Bauera rubioides wiry bauera
12 14 15 16
20 23 25 27
28 29 31 32
35 36 37 38
41 42 46
DILLENIACEAE
1 8 12 14 16Hibbertia empetrifolia subsp. empetrifolia scrambling guineaflower
20 23 26 28
30 32 35 38
45 48
EPACRIDACEAE
2 26 37 Astroloma humifusum native cranberry
3 31 Epacris curtisiae northwest heath en r
1 5 6 9 16 Epacris impressa common heath
26 30 32 37
41 42 47
ESCALLONIACEAE
1 Anopterus glandulosus tasmanian laurel en
EUCRYPHIACEAE
1 46 Eucryphia lucida leatherwood en
EUPHORBIACEAE
1 5 9 11 13 Amperea xiphoclada var. xiphoclada broom spurge
19 20 24
FABACEAE
2 3 4 6 11 Aotus ericoides golden pea
15 18 19 21
24 25 29 35
36 37 41 42
FAGACEAE
LAMIACEAE
1 Prostanthera lasianthos var. lasianthos christmas mintbush
LAURACEAE
3 6 31 42 Cassytha glabella slender dodderlaurel
1 2 4 5 11 Cassytha pubescens downy dodderlaurel
12 16 18 19
20 23 25 27
29 32 36 38
LENTIBULARIACEAE
19 25 27 36 Utricularia dichotoma fairies aprons
MIMOSACEAE
25 35 48 Acacia genistifolia spreading wattle
4 Acacia longifolia subsp. sophorae coast wattle
1 46 Acacia melanoxylon blackwood
1 4 9 11 12 Acacia mucronata variable sallow wattle
14 16 25 27
29 32 43 45
47 48
POLYGALACEAE
5 40 41 42 Comesperma calymega bluespike milkwort
5 31 41 Comesperma retusum mountain milkwort
1 26 35 Comesperma volubile blue lovecreeper
PROTEACEAE
1 2 3 4 6 11 Banksia marginata silver banksia
13 14 15 16
18 19 20 22
23 27 29 31
32 35 36 37
38 42 44
RHAMNACEAE
1 8 30 45 46Pomaderris apetala common dogwood
47 48
1 26 Pomaderris pilifera hairy dogwood
RUBIACEAE
1 26 Galium australe tangled bedstraw
RUTACEAE
8 26 28 47 Nematolepis squamea satinwood
48
1 3 6 9 27 Philotheca virgata twiggy waxflower
31 37 41 47
SANTALACEAE
4 7 25 Leptomeria drupacea erect currantbush
STACKHOUSIACEAE
5 19 31 39 Stackhousia viminea yellow candles
41 42
STYLIDIACEAE
3 37 Stylidium graminifolium narrowleaf triggerplant
THYMELAEACEAE
1 4 7 8 11 Pimelea linifolia subsp. linifolia slender riceflower
12 16 23 28
32 38 47
TREMANDRACEAE
18 35 36 Tetratheca labillardierei glandular pinkbells
1 26 31 Tetratheca pilosa hairy pinkbells
VIOLACEAE
4 8 23 33 44Viola hederacea ivyleaf violet
45
MONOCOTYLEDONAE
CENTROLEPIDACEAE
45 Centrolepis strigosa hairy centrolepis, bristlewort
CYPERACEAE
7 25 41 Baumea sp. twig rush
2 11 Baumea tetragona square twigsedge
1 2 4 8 11 Gahnia grandis cutting grass
12 14 16 18
20 22 23 27
28 29 32 35
36 38 42 44
45 47
IRIDACEAE
4 Diplarrena moraea white flag-iris
1 2 6 11 13 Patersonia fragilis short purpleflag
15 19 21 22
27 31 35 36
37 41 42 44
JUNCACEAE
10 12 17 25 Luzula sp. luzula
45
LILIACEAE
31 37 Blandfordia punicea christmas bells en
26 Dianella revoluta spreading flaxlily
1 16 18 23 Dianella tasmanica forest flaxlily
32
9 12 16 20 Drymophila cyanocarpa turquoise berry
24 30 32
ORCHIDACEAE
9 26 48 Acianthus caudatus mayfly orchid
1 14 16 18 Acianthus sp. mosquito orchid
23 30 32 35
38 43 45 48
POACEAE
40 Austrodanthonia sp. wallabygrass
1 2 3 4 6 9 Ehrharta sp. ricegrass
10 13 21 23
27 30 31 32
35 36 37 41
43 44
RESTIONACEAE
1 10 11 12 Baloskion tetraphyllum subsp. tetraphyllum tassel cordrush
17 43
1 Calorophus elongatus long roperush
3 6 31 Chordifex hookeri woolly buttonrush en
3 4 11 19 22Empodisma minus spreading roperush
23 27 31 37
41
2 3 11 27 29Eurychorda complanata flat cordrush
37
5 6 15 19 21Hypolaena fastigiata tassel roperush
41
3 11 15 19 Leptocarpus tenax slender twinerush
22 31 41
XYRIDACEAE
31 Xyris gracilis yelloweye
3 27 Xyris operculata tall yelloweye
1 2 10 11 15Xyris sp. yelloweye
19 22 41
PTERIDOPHYTA
ASPIDIACEAE
17 Rumohra adiantiformis leathery shieldfern
BLECHNACEAE
1 17 Blechnum nudum fishbone waterfern
1 8 10 12 17Blechnum wattsii hard waterfern
23 28 38 39
47
DENNSTAEDTIACEAE
9 17 45 46 Histiopteris incisa batswing fern
45 Hypolepis rugosula ruddy groundfern
1 4 6 8 11 Pteridium esculentum bracken
12 14 16 18
20 23 30 32
36 38 44 45
46 47
GLEICHENIACEAE
4 11 12 37 Gleichenia dicarpa pouched coralfern
38 41
1 10 17 23 Gleichenia microphylla scrambling coralfern
45
1 9 45 Sticherus tener silky fanfern
LINDSAEACEAE
3 4 6 16 21 Lindsaea linearis screw fern
24 27 29 36
37 44
LYCOPODIACEAE
2 5 11 Lycopodiella lateralis slender clubmoss
1 2 3 34 37 Lycopodium deuterodensum conifer clubmoss
43
OSMUNDACEAE
1 39 Todea barbara southern kingfern
SCHIZAEACEAE
3 27 Schizaea bifida forked combfern
SELAGINELLACEAE
2 3 6 11 15 Selaginella uliginosa swamp spikemoss
19 21 22 27
29 31 37 41
42 44
Sites: DNI – Dry Eucalyptus nitida forest, DNI heathy, DNI additional spp riparian area
Low Shrubs: Aotus ericoides, Astroloma humifusum, Hibbertia empetrifolia subsp. empetrifolia
Herbs: Acianthus sp., Blandfordia punicea, Caladenia alata, Caladenia carnea, Calochilus
paludosus, Chiloglottis sp., Comesperma calymega, Cryptostylis subulata, Drosera
peltata, Drosera pygmaea, Drymophila cyanocarpa, Gompholobium huegelii,
Gonocarpus micranthus subsp. micranthus, Gonocarpus tetragynus, Rhytidosporum
procumbens, Sphaerolobium minus, Stackhousia viminea, Stylidium graminifolium,
Thelymitra juncifolia, Thelymitra sp.
Low Shrubs: Acacia myrtifolia, Aotus ericoides, Astroloma humifusum, Hibbertia empetrifolia subsp.
empetrifolia, Tetratheca labillardierei, Tetratheca pilosa
Herbs: Acianthus caudatus, Acianthus sp., Caladenia alata, Caladenia carnea, Coronidium
scorpioides, Dianella revoluta, Drosera peltata, Drosera pygmaea, Euchiton sp.,
Galium australe, Gonocarpus teucrioides, Hydrocotyle hirta, Pelargonium australe,
Pterostylis nutans, Rhytidosporum procumbens, Sphaerolobium minus, Utricularia
dichotoma, Viola hederacea
Sites: WOL - Wet Eucalyptus obliqua forest over Leptospermum, WOL post-logging regen
Shrubs: Amperea xiphoclada var. xiphoclada, Bauera rubioides, Bossiaea cinerea, Epacris
impressa, Leucopogon australis, Leucopogon collinus, Lomatia tinctoria, Persoonia
juniperina, Philotheca virgata, Pimelea linifolia subsp. linifolia, Pultenaea juniperina
Low Shrubs: Aotus ericoides, Hibbertia empetrifolia subsp. empetrifolia, Tetratheca labillardierei
Herbs: Acianthus sp., Caladenia alata, Caladenia fuscata, Chiloglottis sp., Dianella
tasmanica, Drosera peltata, Drymophila cyanocarpa, Gonocarpus teucrioides, Viola
hederacea
Shrubs: Acacia genistifolia, Amperea xiphoclada var. xiphoclada, Bauera rubioides, Bossiaea
cinerea, Epacris impressa, Leucopogon australis, Leucopogon collinus, Lomatia
tinctoria, Melaleuca squamea, Olearia lirata, Philotheca virgata, Pimelea linifolia
subsp. linifolia, Pomaderris pilifera, Pultenaea juniperina
Low Shrubs: Acacia myrtifolia, Hibbertia empetrifolia subsp. empetrifolia, Tetratheca pilosa
Herbs: Acianthus caudatus, Acianthus sp., Caladenia alata, Caladenia fuscata, Chiloglottis
cornuta, Dianella tasmanica, Drosera binata, Drosera peltata, Drymophila cyanocarpa,
Euchiton sp., Galium australe, Gonocarpus teucrioides, Isolepis sp., Pterostylis
nutans, Pterostylis sp., Senecio glomeratus, Thelymitra sp., Viola hederacea,
Xanthosia pilosa