(PDF) Development of Testing Facility To Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment
(PDF) Development of Testing Facility To Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment
(PDF) Development of Testing Facility To Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment
September 2015
Conference: 10th International Conference on Composite Science and Technology - ICCST/10 · At: Lisbon - Portugal
Authors:
Oil and gas transmission pipes are made from metal or plastic tubes with inner diameters
range from 4 to 48 inches (100 to 1,200 mm). Although carbon steel pipelines have been Discover the world's
research
traditionally used in Oman, advanced composites are also introduced on limited scales. In
Oman, the analysis of oil and gas pipelines failure that has been performed since 2007 has 20+ million
shown a relatively high incident of failure rate with carbon steel pipelines. A large members
percentage of the incidents involved were classified as pipe corrosion failure due to the
harsh and corrosive environments (including high percentage of Hydrogen sulfide, H2S). In 135+ million
this work, an in-house testing facility under controlled conditions has been developed in publications
order to perform design verifications for the GRE pipes that will be used in oil and gas 700k+ research
Join for free
transmission lines in Oman according to the ASTM and ISO Standards. Two pipes are projects
placed in an oven at a temperature of 65oC and internal pressure of 130 Bars. One pipe
contains water and the other crude oil with different. The pipe has been left for a period of
1000 hours and will be taken for mechanical and material testing to assure performance
and the relevant pipes design specifications.
+4
Helical filamnet A GRE pipe used 2D drawing of the Heater and GRE pipe with
winding used in… in this study wit… GRE pipes with… blower with… end-flanges
Public Full-text 1
© IDMEC 2015
*
Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
College of Engineering
Sultan Qaboos Unveristy
123 Al-Khoud, Muscat
Oman
edris@squ.edu.om
jdabdo@squ.edu.om
Key words: Glass Reinforced Epoxy, High Pressure, High Temperature, Harsh Environment,
Mechanical Behaviour
ABSTRACT
Oil and gas transmission pipes are made from metal or plastic tubes with inner
diameters range from 4 to 48 inches (100 to 1,200 mm). Although carbon steel pipelines have
been traditionally used in Oman, advanced composites are also introduced on limited scales.
In Oman, the analysis of oil and gas pipelines failure that has been performed since 2007 has
shown a relatively high incident of failure rate with carbon steel pipelines. A large percentage
of the incidents involved were classified as pipe corrosion failure due to the harsh and
corrosive environments (including high percentage of Hydrogen sulfide, H2S). In this work,
an in-house testing facility under controlled conditions has been developed in order to
perform design verifications for the GRE pipes that will be used in oil and gas transmission
lines in Oman according to the ASTM and ISO Standards. Two pipes are placed in an oven at
a temperature of 65oC and internal pressure of 130 Bars. One pipe contains water and the
other crude oil with different H2S concentrations (100 ppm, 300 ppm and 1000 ppm). The
pipe has been left for a period of 1000 hours and will be taken for mechanical and material
testing to assure performance and the relevant pipes design specifications.
1. INTRODUCTION
In comparing composites to steel pipes, there are a number of areas where composites
are superior. It must be noted that currently, cost of composite pipe is higher on all fronts.
Composites are produced, however, on life cycle cost assessment and maintenance
advantages. Comparing relative flexural strengths, composites are significantly more flexible
and lighter than steel. In fact, when strength-to-weight ratios are examined, composites can
be much “stronger” than steel [1]. Other properties include easy installation, high durability
and low maintenance and life cycle costs make them more desirable than conventional pipes.
Composite are highly resistant to many corrosive chemicals and compounds, including H 2S.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 2/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
A wide variety of applications has arisen that demand the use of chemical-resistant resins. By
selecting from a range of resin chemistries, the specifying one can achieve the most cost-
effective composites [2, 3]. Due to their attractive physical and mechanical properties GRE
pipes have been successfully used in oil and gas this industry. A chemical composition
analysis and properties of composite materials was outlined in [4]. The experimental work in
this study has proposed that composite material is a sustrainable choice in oilfield
applications. These are all highly dependent on the types of resin used, volume fraction of the
reinforcement and its orientations [5].
The current procedure of qualifying GRE pipes in oil and gas applications is based on
linear extrapolation method. It provides very good predictions of the long term behaviour of
the pipes. This can be done by extrapolating the lower confidence limit from the regression
line to rate for a design life time of 20 years [6].The in-house experimental setup proposed in
this research study adopts a 1000 hrs. Short-term Survival Test based on ASTM D-2992 [7].
The test would predict the long term bahaviour of these pipes under such complex loading
and, in particular, adverse environmental conditions. Particularly under multiaxial loadings
involve combinations of hoop and axial loads as a result of high internal pressure and harsh
chemicals (Hydrogen Sulphide, H2S and Carbon Dioxide, CO2). Sulphur mixed with water
deep underground in the presence of heat and over thousands of years produces Hydrogen
Sulphide (H2S). It is a highly corrosive, and of course, deadly poisonous gas. Oil with H 2S
content more than 500 ppm (part/million) in the gaseous state at atmospheric pressure is
classified as ‘sour’. In Oman, sour oil and gas is mostly concentrated in the southern oil
fields. Also, chemicals such as CO2 are continuously injected into the oil reservoir in enhance
oil recovery process for about 20 years. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate the chemical
compatibility of these non-metallic materials in different environments. That is whether GRE
pipes will survive the exposure to the given chemicals or not. One can collect extensive data
from current experimental work, collate it, interpret it, and, eventually, manipulate it into a
form with design curves.
Failure in oil and gas transmission lines during service is extremely serious. A large
percentage of failure incidents in steel pipelines have been classified as pipe mechanical
construction damage, corrosion failure and mechanical valve/fitting failures. Most of these
steel pipelines have reached their limit life cycle of 20 years and the replacement of these
pipes become very essential. The present work would offer GRE pipe as an alternative to the
carbon steel pipes. Depending on their particular structural make-up, other important
properties of composite materials include high corrosion and wear resistance, low thermal
conductivity and thermal expansion. These distinctive characteristics provide design
opportunities not possible with conventional monolithic metals. Consequently, unprecedented
mechanical and physical properties can be tailored to meet the requirements of a particular
application. However, difficulties are present when it comes to using composite pipelines.
Such difficulties are primarily related to the lack of test data to support the materials' long-
term behaviour and durability. The performance of the non-metallic materials (GRE) will be
evaluated by investigating the mechanical properties, micro and macro cracks formation on
the specimens after they are immerse in a mixture with the right concentration at a
temperature of ~650C and a pressure of 130 Bar for a period of 1000 hours. A dedicated in-
house test rig for GRE pipes has been developed with enhanced capacity of handling
corrosive environment, i.e., the presence of H2S and CO2.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 3/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
Figure 1: Helical filamnet winding used in Composite Pipes Industries (CPI) Oman
The orintation in helical filament winding comes with winding angle of ±55° as
shown in Figure 2. This is the best orientation since the maximum allowable stress is aligned
along the direction of the reinforements. Helical filament winding is process that produces
high reinforcement content and thus leads to GRE pipes with excellent mechanical
properties. After the desired architecture of the reinforcement has been achieved, the part is
cured and removed from the mandrel.
Figure 2: A GRE pipe used in this study with a winding angle of ±55°.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 4/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
The advantages of helical filament winding are, on one hand, the capability to
automate the process and, on the other hand, the fact that the structural properties of the final
product can be significantly tailored since the filament can be laid down in a complex pattern
to match the strength-performance requirements [10]. In addition, this fabrication process can
be used with both thermosetting and thermoplastic resins to provide excellent dimensional
control and a high degree of uniformity and repeatability of the filament. The wall structures
for the GRE pipes used in this worok are shown in Figure 3. Generally; the higher the
pressure class, the greater the wall thickness of the pipe will be [11]. The wall structural used
to manufacturing the three GRE pipes is given in Figure 3. It is considered during design and
fabrication of the pipes to guarantee optimum working conditions under internal pressurized
loading, high temperature and resistance of aggressive mixture of chemicals. The structural
bulidup of the pipes wall is given in Table 1.
Resin Glass
0.3 mm Exterior Layer 100% 0% Epoxy
Structural Wall ~ 25% ~ 75% Epoxy + E-glass
0.5 mm Internal Layer ~ 90% ~ 10% Epoxy + C-glass
Table 1: Structural Wall Build-up
The wall structural thickness of the pipe contributes to the overall stiffness of pipes.
In this experimental work, the pipes were subjected to internal pressure of 130 Bars,
temperature effect of 65oC and adverse and corrosive H2S. However, during installation the
pipes are buried and subjected to transverse loadings. Hence, the wall is built up to resist such
type of loadings. A ring deflection (Split-desk) test of a specimen of the GRE pipes is
considered to determine stiffness and resistance to structural damage to ensure that the pipes
meet specified design constraints. This test will be illustrated and discussed in subsequent
sections.
3. END-FITTING DESIGN
To conduct proper testing, which involves static pressurization of the GRE pipe, it is
imperative to design an end-fitting suitable for the task. With such a “closed-end” test setup,
the internal pressure caused by the pump is transferred to the pipe. Hence, a strong joint
between the pipe end and the fittings is essential. End-fittings have been designed and
customized for the test setup. The design of mechanical end-fitting flanges is shown in
Figures 4 and 5 respectively The end-fitting contains loose-flange that can be split into two
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 5/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
halves and blind flanges. Threaded holes on the blind flanges are used to attach pressure and
temperutre gauges and valves. Carbon steel flanges are reliable for such type of closed-end
test rig.
Oven
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 6/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
The unit was designed so that the heater and the blower were separated from the oven
space and placed at the back of the oven to achieve much better and more uniform control of
test temperature, as well as to avoid any possible damage to the side of the wall during testing
which would halt the operation of the oven. The closure was constructed with three holes to
provide access for pressure tubing, temperature gage and instrumentation wiring. A
photograph of the heater and the blower is given Figure 7.
Temperature
Controller
Heater &
Blower
5. PRESSURIZATION SYSTEM
The pressure system was designed so that it could facilitate a maximum working
pressure up to 130 Bars. The second GRE pipe ready to be placed into the thermal enclosure
is shown in Figure 8. The end-fittings were fixed at each end of the test specimen with bolted
joints for tests at 65°C. GRE pipes used for high pressure and high temperature are wound
with reinforcemnts angled helically at ±θ° to the axial load of the mandrel. The strength and
stiffness of a composite buildup depends on the orientation sequence of the reinforcements.
In this experimental study the pipes were produced at ±55° angles.
The pipe was then pressurized to create pressure class that tends to generate a state of
complex hoop-to-axial loading conditions. This was achieved by using a differential pump
driven by an air compressor via a ball valve, see Figure 9. The pump flow rate is managed by
using a pressure regulator installed in the compressed air inlet to the pump. The pressure
loading was controlled manually by the opening and closing of the unloading valve. During
pressurizing, the valve was kept closed. Once the pressure required was reached and held for
the required amount of time (1000 hrs.), the pressure was released by opening the unloading
valve. It was noted that a drop in pressure in the pipe occurred almost immediately when the
valve was opened. The short-term survival test procedure is based on ASTM D-2992 and
ASME 1598 [12].
(a) (b)
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 8/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
Download full-textFigure
PDF 10: Benchmark
Downloadpipe speciemns prepared
citation Copy link for tensile testing of with (a) Axial, (b)
Transverse starin gages
Results produced from tensile test and split-disk test appear to provide an efficient
means to assess performance of second and third pipes in such harsh environment. The
second GRE pipe has been subjected to high pressure 130 Bars and high temperature 65 0C
conditions since April 20, 2015. The proposed test is taking 1000 hrs. The effect of elevated
temperature and high pressure on the integrity and the long term durability of the pipes has
been undertaken. The procedure for determining the strength of the GRE pipes under such
conditions is based on ASTM Standard D-2992. Whereas, the influence of harsh chemicals
such as H2S and CO2 on the reinforcements will be investigated thoroughly using the third
GRE pipe. The controlled chemical condition is very close to realistic situations. The third
pipe contains crude oil with different concentrations of H2S (100 ppm, 300 ppm and 1000
ppm).
(a) (b)
Figure 11: Specimen for Split-disk test (a) with starin gages attached axially and
circumferentially, (b) Split-disk speciemn with fixtures
Failed tensile test and split-disk speciemns illustrated in Figures 12 and 13 indicate
failure mechanism which is often characterized by complex combinations of reinforcement
and resin failures.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 9/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
The tensile test specimen and the split-disk specimen were loaded beyond the onset of
the original failure. This prompted large deformation and damage into the original failure.
Observations taken during testing as well as the characteristics of the failed specimens have
shown that cracks started along the ring axis; in particular, in split-disk specimen followed by
a rupture in the GRE ring wall where the reinforcements started to tear and creates an
opening in the structural wall of the specimen as shown in Figure 13. A subsequent
experimental work is undertaken to understand the onset of failure and the failure mechanism
as a result of the interaction of high pressure, high temperature in the presence of chemicals
compounds.
7. CONCLUSIONS
This work concerned with developing an in-house testing facility that is capable to
simulate the conditions required to perform design verification for GRE pipes according to
ASTM and ISO standards. In addition, this facility has the capability to investigate the effects
of other harsh conditions, mainly, the effects of H 2S and CO2 on the GRE pipes. Two similar
pipes are placed in a thermal enclosure unit at a temperature of 65 oC and internal pressure of
130 Bars. One pipe contains water and the other crude oil with different H2S concentrations
(100 ppm, 300 ppm and 1000 ppm). The pipe has been left for a period of 1000 hours and
will be taken for mechanical and material testing to assure performance and the relevant
pipes design specifications. A third similar pipe was selected to be a reference to collect some
useful benchmarking information on the pipes mechanical properties such as maximum
applied force, maximum stresses in longitudinal and circumferential direction. Preliminary
set of tensile testing and split disk testing have been performed on specimens taking from the
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 10/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
REFERENCES
[1] I.M. Daniel, O. Ishai, Engineering Mechanics of Composite Materials, Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 2006.
[2] A.G. Gibson, Composite materials in the offshore industry. Metals and Materials,
5(10), 590–594, 1989.
[3] A.G. Gibson, The cost effective use of fiber reinforced composites offshore. Report
submitted to the Health and Safety Executive, Centre for Composite Materials Engineering,
University of Newcastle Upon Tyne, UK, 1–140, 2003.
[4] M.E. Hossain, The current and future trends of composite materials: an experimental
study. Journal of Composite Materials, 45(20), 2133–2144, 2011.
[5] S. Mazumdar, Composites Manufacturing: Materials, Product, and Process Engineering,
CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group, 2002.
[6] Future Pipes Industires, Engineering Guide for Wavistrong Filament Wound Epoxy
Pipes, 2001.
[7] ASTM D-2992, Standard practice for obtaining hydrostatic or pressure design basis
for fiberglass (glass-fiber-reinforced thermosetting resin) pipe and fittings, American Society
of Testing and Materials, 1996.
[8] P.K. Mallick, Fiber-Reinforced Composites: Materials, Manufacturing and Design,
CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group, 2007.
[9] ISO 14692 Standard, Parts 1-4, International Standards Organization, 2002.
[10] F.C. Shen, A filament-wound structure technology overview, Materials Chemistry and
Physics, 42 (2), 96–100, 1995.
[11] P.D. Soden, R. Kitching, P.C. Tse, Experimental failure stresses for ±55 filament
wound glass fibre reinforced plastic tubes under biaxial loads. Composites, 20(2), 125–35,
1989.
[12] ASTM D-1598, Standard Test Method for Time-to-Failure of Plastic Pipe Under
Constant Internal Pressure, American Society of Testing and Materials, 2009.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 11/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
10
Oct 1989
A.G. Gibson
Experimental failure stresses for ±55° filament wound glass fibre reinforced plastic tubes under biaxial loads
Article
Mar 1989 · Composites
P.D. Soden · R KITCHING · P.C. Tse
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 12/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
Project
View project
Project
View project
Project
View project
January 2019
Analysis of failure in oil and gas transmission pipes has been carried out in Oman oil and gas industry for the last 10 years. It has been
noticed carbon steel pipelines have shown a quite high event of failure rate. A great fraction of failure incidents were classified as pipe
corrosion failure caused by adverse and corrosive environments (e.g., presence of Hydrogen Sulfide). Obstacles of ... [Show full
abstract]
View full-text
Conference Paper
November 2019
GRE composite pipes are a great substitute for Carbon steel, however, obstacles of introducing GRE composite pipes into oil and gas
transmission lines have been primarily related to inadequate testing data to maintain materials’ extended performance and pipes
fatigue failure characterization. Customized testing facility has been designed and fabricated to substantiate design of GRE pipes
under ... [Show full abstract]
Read more
Conference Paper
September 2015
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 13/14
2/9/23, 3:26 PM (PDF) Development of Testing Facility to Investigate GRE Pipes Behavior in Harsh Environment.
Edris M. Hassan · Jamil Abdo
Download full-text PDF Download citation Copy link
Read more
Drilling is one of the costliest activities in oil and gas industry due to the complexity of interactions with downhole rock formation. Under
such conditions, the uncertainty of drillstring behaviour increase and hence it becomes difficult to predict the causes, occurrences, and
types of failures. Lateral and torsional vibrations often cause failure of Bottom Hole Assembly (BHA), drillstring ... [Show full abstract]
© 2008-2023 ResearchGate GmbH. All rights reserved. Terms · Privacy · Copyright · Imprint
View full-text
Drillstring and down-hole tool failure usually results from failing to control one or more of the vibration mechanisms. The solution starts
with the ability to measure different modes of vibration, hence identifying different vibration mechanisms. Lateral, torsion and axial are
vibration modes that take place when drill pipes run into problems downhole. Due to the three modes of vibration ... [Show full
abstract]
View full-text
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/303805582_Development_of_Testing_Facility_to_Investigate_GRE_Pipes_Behavior_in_Harsh_Environment 14/14