Untitled
Untitled
Untitled
Smart Health
Technologies for the
COVID-19 Pandemic
IET Book Series on e–Health Technologies
Book Series Editor: Professor Joel J.P.C. Rodrigues, College of Computer Science and
Technology, China University of Petroleum (East China), Qingdao, China; Senac Faculty of
Ceará, Fortaleza-CE, Brazil and Instituto de Telecomunicações, Portugal
Book Series Advisor: Professor Pranjal Chandra, School of Biochemical Engineering, Indian
Institute of Technology (BHU), Varanasi, India
While the demographic shifts in populations display significant socio-economic challenges, they
trigger opportunities for innovations in e-Health, m-Health, precision and personalized
medicine, robotics, sensing, the Internet of things, cloud computing, big data, software defined
networks, and network function virtualization. Their integration is however associated with
many technological, ethical, legal, social, and security issues. This book series aims to
disseminate recent advances for e-health technologies to improve healthcare and people’s
wellbeing.
Topics considered include intelligent e-Health systems, electronic health records, ICT-enabled
personal health systems, mobile and cloud computing for e-Health, health monitoring,
precision and personalized health, robotics for e-Health, security and privacy in e-Health,
ambient assisted living, telemedicine, big data and IoT for e-Health, and more.
To download our proposal form or find out more information about publishing with us, please
visit https://www.theiet.org/publishing/publishing-with-iet-books/.
Please email your completed book proposal for the IET Book Series on e-Health Technologies
to: Amber Thomas at athomas@theiet.org or author_support@theiet.org.
Smart Health
Technologies for the
COVID-19 Pandemic
Internet of medical things perspectives
Edited by
Chinmay Chakraborty and Joel J.P.C. Rodrigues
This publication is copyright under the Berne Convention and the Universal Copyright
Convention. All rights reserved. Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research
or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and
Patents Act 1988, this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any
form or by any means, only with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in
the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued
by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those
terms should be sent to the publisher at the undermentioned address:
While the authors and publisher believe that the information and guidance given in this
work are correct, all parties must rely upon their own skill and judgement when making
use of them. Neither the authors nor publisher assumes any liability to anyone for any
loss or damage caused by any error or omission in the work, whether such an error or
omission is the result of negligence or any other cause. Any and all such liability is
disclaimed.
The moral rights of the authors to be identified as authors of this work have been
asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
Index 443
This page intentionally left blank
About the editors
Joel J.P.C. Rodrigues is an Highly Cited Researcher has published over 1,000
papers in refereed international journals and conferences, 3 books, 2 patents, and 1
ITU-T Recommendation. He is the editor-in-chief of the International Journal of
E-Health and Medical Communications and an editorial board member of several
high-reputed journals. He has chaired many international conferences, including
IEEE ICC, IEEE GLOBECOM, IEEE HEALTHCOM, and IEEE LatinCom. He
has received several Outstanding Leadership and Outstanding Service Awards by
IEEE Communications Society. He is a member of the Internet Society, a senior
member ACM, and a Fellow of AAIA and IEEE.
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
Intelligent health technologies are in the revolution phase due to recent develop-
ments in sensor technology, wearables, edge computing, the Internet of Things, and
enabling wireless communication protocols, creating value-based care delivery in
terms of outcome monitoring, therapeutic and preventive interventions. This book
focuses the COVID-19 monitoring and analysis using intelligent e-healthcare sys-
tems. The innovative solutions might include (but are not limited to) detection and
treatment methods for COVID-19, strategies to find suspected patients, contact
tracing of infected patients, intelligent strategies to predict future pandemic or
epidemic outbreaks, informatics-based policies to contain such mass infectious
outbreaks, ensuring the safety of patients, careers, and the public, information
exchange, and knowledge sharing.
This book will include reviews and original works on the COVID-19 in terms
of e-healthcare, telemedicine, other medical technology, life support systems, fast
detection, and diagnoses, developed technologies and innovative solutions, bioin-
formatics, datasets, apps for diagnosis, solutions for monitoring, and control of the
spread of COVID-19, among various other topics. The book focuses on recent
advances in the Internet of Medical Things in smart advanced healthcare technol-
ogies. Intelligent advanced healthcare informatics plays a vital role in this crucial
time. The objective of the book is to present innovative technological solutions
utilizing informatics to deal with various COVID-19 outbreak issues. This book
covers comprehensive studies from healthcare informatics, biomedical engineering,
artificial intelligence, big data, blockchain, and data mining with a prime focus on
the COVID-19 pandemic.
At last, we would like to extend our sincere thanks to authors from industry,
academia, and policy expertise to complete this work for aspiring researchers in
this domain. We are confident that this book would play a key role in providing
readers a comprehensive view of COVID-19 health informatics and developments
around it and can be used as a learning resource for various examinations, which
deal with cutting-edge technologies.
Book organisation
The book consists of 16 chapters in the field of COVID-19 healthcare systems. A
summary of each chapter is presented in the following.
xviii Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
New Normal in use as a substitute for older systems. This chapter offers a template
analysis of stakeholder interviews conducted with the aid of technology to
accomplish social distancing, which is divided into three categories: educational,
public health, and social distancing, as well as manufacturing employees. A soft-
ware usage pattern has been developed due to data analysis utilizing content ana-
lysis to help create social distancing for job planning and everyday use. It can also
be used to plan future smart cities.
are many effective and proven image recognition techniques in deep learning like
Convolutional Neural networks and Transfer learning that can be used to design
very promising applications for COVID-19 detection. They enhance these models
using advanced image segmentation and edge detection techniques. The authors
have been reviewed the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the global com-
munity, the need for reliable, quick, and economical ways to detect it.
UVC light”. The objective of the current work is to discuss various inventions made
during the pandemic scenario and to contribute to the battle against COVID-19
propagation. Authors have developed a UV-based sterilization method that uses
single-wavelength far-UVC light produced by filtered exclaims to selectively
inactivate microorganisms while causing no biological damage to exposed cells and
tissues. The robot can also be used as a vacuum cleaner, eliminating the need for
and expense of cleaning by humans.
Chinmay Chakraborty
Joel J.P.C. Rodrigues
Chapter 1
Internet of Things (IoT) and blockchain-based
solutions to confront COVID-19 pandemic
Abu Hasnat Md Rhydwan1, Md Mashrur Sakib Choyon1,
A.S.M. Mehedi Hasan Sad1, Kazi Ahmed Asif Fuad1,
Kawshik Shikder1, Chowdhury Akram Hossain1 and
M. Shamim Kaiser2
Abstract
1
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, American International University-Bangladesh,
Dhaka, Bangladesh
2
Institute of Information Technology, Jahangirnagar University, Savar, Dhaka, Bangladesh
2 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
1.1 Introduction
On the other hand, due to the increasing pressure because of the ongoing pan-
demic, healthcare system of many countries faced catastrophe. The number of
diagnoses of other diseases was significantly reduced [4]. Data management in hos-
pitals and federal repositories has faced unforeseen situations and tremendous risks of
data breaching. As a result, a new challenge has arrived to ensure the privacy of the
database in the healthcare sector. Blockchain technology can provide significant
advantages in this aspect and can maintain privacy in the healthcare sector, especially
when combined with IoT [5]. This technology is being used to increase medical
system security and ensure feasible data sharing [6]. It has also seen its application in
electronic medical records (EMRs), pharmaceutical supply chain, and health insur-
ance claim [7]. In addition to that, blockchain-based solutions are also effective
against other recent issues by maintaining the efficacy of contact tracing, data shar-
ing, Internet of Medical Things (IoMT), and preventing data breaching [8].
In this chapter, different aspects of IoT and blockchain technologies that are being
used throughout the world to confront COVID-19 were discussed briefly. The chapter
gives an overall idea of how these technologies are making significant contributions in
this pandemic by facilitating in different sectors like healthcare, telemedicine, logistics
delivery, surveillance, data management, data privacy, supply chain, securing data-
base, etc. Multiple recent works have also reviewed the application of these technol-
ogies in different aspects of COVID-19 [9–13]. However, these works have focused
on a single technology and excluded some latest applications that simultaneously use
both technologies. Hence, it is necessary to survey applications of both IoT and
blockchain technology, and through this chapter, we tried to cover the existing
research gap. Key contributions of this chapter are as follows:
Analytics
Things
Central
or
control
device
Major IoT
components
User
Security
interface
Cloud Network
User interface: The user interface or UI is the visible entity of an IoT appli-
cation that the users see and provide actions or commands to the application. In
recent times, most IoT applications consist of well-designed UIs that are attractive
and user-friendly. Any IoT-based UI design must have proper hardware constraints
along with the software design. In their work, Toyama and Hirayama presented
some rules and methods in designing such UI for IoT systems [25].
Cloud: The IoT cloud entity is a high-performing sophisticated network of ser-
vers that receives and sends data between the device end and the user end. The cloud
entity is also responsible for preserving data and conducting accurate data analysis.
The cloud also processes the machine learning algorithms and other user commands
or programs. The advanced and highly distributed cloud network architecture of IoT
applications facilitates promising aspects to design, host, manage, and optimize more
futuristic IoT applications with less power consumption and more security [26].
Analytics: In IoT applications, analytics play a crucial role in managing and
improving the entire system architecture. Upon receiving analog data from the
device end, the analytics entity carries out a thorough interpretation, analysis and
provides possible solutions based on the analysis to improve the system. Real-time
intelligent analytics allow system designers or engineers to find any irregularities
and prevent them [27].
Network: Any IoT application must be connected to a good network or
Internet. The device end is controlled by the Internet and maintains the overall
communications between all entities of the system architecture. To develop a smart
city with different IoT applications, it is vital to establish a secure and robust net-
work platform for these applications to rely on [28].
6 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Security: Advancement in the field of IoT is also raising some severe security
concerns regarding the applications of this technology. To develop any efficient
IoT system, it needs to have strong security and should have the feature to maintain
privacy. The initial stage of any IoT application may contain vulnerabilities to fall
prone to cyber threats. However, with standardizations and secured development of
these applications, the IoT world is getting more secured in recent times [29–31].
Central control: The central control entity of IoT systems maintains two-way
data traffic within several different entities or networks. It plays as the central con-
trolling unit in the IoT architecture. With services like the Azure IoT Central, any
developer can establish an efficient infrastructure of the desired IoT application [32].
1.2.2 Blockchain
Blockchain is a distributed ledger that records user data in an encrypted manner [33].
Peers of the blockchain network verify the authenticity of every new block within the
blockchain network. Satoshi Nakamoto, an anonymous person or group of people,
invented this technology in 2008 to create a public transaction system for the cryp-
tocurrency known as bitcoin [34]. Since then, blockchain has become a
trustable solution for digital transactions due to its decentralized structure and
immutability [35]. Apart from cryptocurrency transactions, blockchain has been
widely used in other applications, including energy trading, healthcare, supply chain,
and video games, as shown in Figure 1.2. The continuous growth of blockchain use
cases can be observed from a recent report that shows that the worldwide blockchain
market is likely to reach USD 39.7 billion by 2025 from USD 3.0 billion in 2020 [36].
Banking Healthcare
Faster and Reduction of risk
secure of data fabrication
payment method and better transpar-
ency of data
between patients
and doctors
cryptocurrency, version 2.0 for smart contracts, version 3.0 for DAPPS, and version
4.0 for the industry.
Merkle root: Merkle root checks corruption and manipulation within the
block using mathematical formulas. The unique hash value is created by following
the concept of binary tree and combining the transaction data.
Difficulty target: Every blockchain network has a fixed difficulty level that
miners need to achieve through their computational power. The difficulty target
changes based on the number of blocks that have been added to a network in a
specific amount of time.
Nonce: Nonce, the abbreviation of “Number only used once,” is a 32-bit
number that contains in every encrypted block. Blockchain miners try to solve this
number to receive a reward in the form of cryptocurrency. It has a total of 232
possible values, which makes it computationally expensive for the miners.
Previous hash: In a blockchain network, every block relates to the previous
block of the chain. Every block stores the previous block’s hash value except the
genesis block, which contains no previous hash value.
In recent times, applications developed with IoT and IoMT technologies have
become significantly popular among many sectors, and security measures like
the blockchain, edge computing, and fog computing, available for these appli-
cations make them more efficient [39]. The rapid developments made in the
IoMT have made healthcare professionals realize the sector’s vast potential
[47]. Figure 1.4 shows the summary of IoT-based solutions in different sectors
against the COVID-19 pandemic. As shown in Figure 1.4, IoT technologies
have given great advantages in several sectors to confront the COVID-19
pandemic.
10 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Detection of
Telemedicine
IoT in healthcare possible cases or Disinfecting area Logistics delivery
service
patients
Secured data
Surveillance preserving
Real-time health
camera to detect IoT-based supply
monitoring
physical Drones with chain redefined Wider coverage of
distancing disinfecting model healthcare service
Emergency spray
response Smart Maintaining
thermometer to Contactless physical distance
detect delivery with
temperatures of drones
Smart predictions Provide healthcare
human
at the remote area
Drones for Robots with UV
Smart guidance human technologies Autonomous Remote monitoring
and temperature and delivery vehicles through sensors and
recommendations crowd detection
devices
Other wearable devices like Fitbit or Apple Watch used for regular health
fitness tracking have also shown some promising features that could be used to
sense early signs of COVID-19 symptoms [52]. Similarly, another successful
gadget that made an essential contribution against COVID-19 is the WHOOP
strap. A study was conducted with the WHOOP strap on 271 people between the
age of 25–50 years. All these people experienced symptoms like that of SARS-
CoV-2, but 81 individuals were tested positive for the virus in later days. The study
consisted of building a dataset collected by the WHOOP strap and training a novel
algorithm using those data. Later, the developed model monitored the raspatory
rate of the individuals and successfully detected 20% of the people 2 days before
the symptom commencement and 80% of the people on the third day [53].
In another work in [54], an IoMT system was developed that utilizes deep
learning for identifying different types of health-related issues caused by COVID-
19. The system generates reports based on the analysis that can be used for medical
care. Bai et al. researched the IoT-based nCapp technology to diagnose COVID-19
at an earlier stage [55]. Based on the collected data, the diagnosis automatically
labels the patient’s case as confirmed, suspected, or suspicious of the coronavirus
infection. The nCapp intelligent assisted management can play a crucial role in
treating the infected patients through various instructions based on data analysis
collected from the patient’s body. A health monitoring model was developed based
on the Business Process Management paradigm, where the main focus was to
increase the empowerment of the patients and healthcare professionals [56]. The
architecture of the model was developed with the help of health monitoring devices
and environmental sensors. Together with the connection of the web system, an
efficient IoT technology was developed for the model that could fulfill the purpose.
The patients could monitor their state of health and contribute to their health rou-
tine by deciding what to do and when to do it. Lomotey et al. developed a “Petri
Nets” service model that focuses on wearable IoT-based device data management
[57]. The proposed model by the authors has resulted in high scalability of the IoT
architecture, transparency of medical IoT data, and distributed health information
system threats. In [58], an IoT-based smart system was developed for monitoring
the health of patients. The patients can use the system through a mobile application,
and it gives the patients the freedom to monitor their health from home by them-
selves and also enables them to send necessary health reports to the doctors through
the system. Furthermore, the doctors can provide necessary health guidance to the
patients through the system as well. The system was proven to be quite helpful for
elderly people or people living independently at home. In [59], an IoT-based health
monitoring system was developed utilizing three core parts: IoT node, mobile app,
and machine learning tools. The developed system also utilizes a radio frequency
method to alert the user to maintain physical distance in both indoor and outdoor
environments. In another work, Li et al. designed a health monitoring system that
could analyze the breathing sound in real-time and detect any wheeze in the
breathing [60]. As the lungs are one of the most commonly affected parts of the
human body due to the coronavirus, such a system could prove highly useful for
healthcare professionals in detecting any blockage created in the lungs by the virus.
12 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
notification to the paired mobile, any other device, or database with the captured
face image and GPS location. Based on the received information, the healthcare
professionals or any other concerned party can take necessary actions. Similarly,
IoT-based smart glasses were developed to fulfill the same purpose [68]. In [69],
the researchers aimed to design an IoT-based global platform to confront COVID-
19 through monitoring and tracking the suspected cases. The system utilizes a
virtual IoT node to determine the suspected cases. The system was also designed
to ensure the privacy and authenticity of information providers. The information
providers are given with individual secret keys to ensure the authenticity and
privacy of data. Garg et al. reviewed different contact tracing models, and later on,
they presented a novel contact tracing model that proved to be scalable and can
also maintain the patient’s privacy [70]. The developed model utilizes IoT and
blockchain technologies that can maintain a greater efficiency in contact tracing of
COVID-19 cases while also considering moving objects with the help of RFID
transceivers. In [71], a privacy-preserving IoT model was presented that can
efficiently identify a large number of infection contacts while preserving the
individual’s privacy with the help of blockchain. In another work, Tedeschi et al.
developed IoT-based contact tracing architecture that could preserve privacy while
being configured to support several models ranging from centralized to decen-
tralized [72]. Furthermore, to impose strict lockdown on any COVID-19 hotspot
area, an IoT-based three-layered decentralized biometric face detection framework
was designed in [73], where the authors built a deep learning framework. The
framework showed significantly better results when compared with other existing
state-of-the-art architecture.
1.3.4 Telemedicine
The telemedicine service has seen a significant surge in usage throughout the world,
especially in this COVID-19 pandemic. The demand for medical counseling has
been higher than before while maintaining social distance was an essential condition
to abide by. In such a circumstance, telemedicine service proves to be a great help in
delivering medical services to the patients to a certain extent. The doctors or
healthcare professionals provide their expert guidance to the patients through tele-
medicine service through telecommunications equipment with the minimum facility
of audio and video [78]. In some cases, necessary sensors or biomedical devices that
can collect patients’ biological data are also installed [79]. As a result, the demand
for telemedicine services has gone up significantly in the COVID-19 pandemic [80].
The healthcare professionals could examine the patients’ data from their mobiles or
desktops and provide necessary instructions to the patients or medical staff taking
care of the patient [81]. With the help of telemedicine service, the massive pressure
of providing medical service by the hospital staff got lifted, along with the risk of
coronavirus emanation was reduced. In the United States, the George Washington
University hospital and Rush University Medical Center utilized telemedicine ser-
vices to provide medical consultation to their patients during the pandemic [82,83].
These hospitals arranged one-to-one video calls and webinars to provide medical
consultations. The German-made WAS vehicles are equipped with advanced IoT
technologies that can enable medical staff to monitor a patient’s health remotely
[84]. Therefore, the emergency vehicle can provide healthcare support even on the
move to the hospital. The 5G technologies combined with IoT and other related
technologies can also influence carrying out swift telemedicine service [85,86].
Such a highly advanced technology could perform critical actions like surgeries on
patients through robotic devices while being controlled by the doctors remotely.
Contact
tracing
Internet of
medical
Things
(IoMT)
Database
Blockchain security
solutions
for
COVID-19
Prevention
of data
fabrication Data
sharing
peer-to-peer networking facility [70,100]. Many recent platforms are also using this
technology to record patient information with high-security symptoms, location,
and medical records. The WHO has also launched a blockchain-based platform
called MiPasa that allows private information sharing between its users, health
organizations, and authorities. The platform also has a self-reporting feature using
which the users can report their infection with public health organizations with
precise locations [101]. In another work, a blockchain-based framework was
developed for exchanging health information [102]. The framework also allows the
patients to control their medical information and to preserve personal autonomy.
Also, in [103], a decentralized healthcare system was developed using blockchain
technology to encourage patients to safely share their medical information with
health organizations while retaining complete control of their data privacy. The
framework has the potential to solve many existing challenges of the conventional
healthcare system by offering data protection, less operating cost, and easier access
to data. A blockchain-based method was built to ameliorate data transmission and
improve the reliability of physiological information [104]. The method protects
recorded data from node manipulation threats and enables secure information
sharing between multiple parties.
In this section, different challenges that obstruct the development of IoT and
blockchain applications are mentioned. Furthermore, some practical solutions and
recommendations to mitigate these issues are also briefly discussed.
leakage of their personal data through IoT devices, and to mitigate those issues, and
various frameworks were developed [132,133]. On the contrary, recent attacks on
blockchain have raised the question of the immutable nature of the blockchain
network. To prevent future cyberattacks, numerous recent works have focused on
mitigating those attacks, including mitigating pool hopping attacks, false data
injection attacks, and 51% attacks [37,134,135]. A parallel PoW network was
proposed in [104] instead of solo mining to increase the processing speed of
transactions in the blockchain network. The proposed method can also improve the
scalability issue of blockchain. In another work, various versions of blockchain
were reviewed to find the optimal versions that require less computational power
[136].
Without resolving the crucial issues of IoT applications, the public acceptance
of these services will not increase significantly. First, the data of these applications
must be adequately encrypted. Without proper encryptions, the systems might fall
under cyberattacks, and they might also get beyond recovery. Also, the privacy of
personal data of any patient, subject, or human must be ensured in these applica-
tions. Since some of the attacks might occur through phishing, the people asso-
ciated with the system should be trained appropriately and raise their technical
knowledge or awareness. Also, the staff in charge of maintaining these applications
should be specialized to have sufficient knowledge in maintaining, safeguarding,
securing, and developing the systems. Increasing the trust and awareness of users or
patients about IoT applications is another aspect that needs to be ensured. In the
end, standardizations of these IoT applications should be ensured to have efficient
implementations of these applications.
To effectively use the blockchain-based solutions against COVID-19, specific
steps are required to be taken. Network latency of the blockchain network needs to
be improved to handle extensive data, and a suitable blockchain platform is
required to use based on the application to handle large transactions. Besides,
security issues need to be prioritized to increase user trust in such applications. To
do that, available latest technologies should be implemented against various
cyberattacks. Finally, energy consumption issues need to be handled to ensure the
large-scale use of blockchain-based platforms.
Table 1.3 Key findings from reviewed IoT and blockchain-based solutions
References
[11] Ndiaye, M., Oyewobi, S.S., Abu-Mahfouz, A.M., Hancke, G.P., Kurien, A.M.
and Djouani, K.: ‘IoT in the Wake of COVID-19: A Survey on Contributions,
Challenges and Evolution’ IEEE Access, 2020, 8, pp. 186821–186839.
[12] Nguyen, D.C., Ding M., Pathirana P.N., and Seneviratne A. ‘Blockchain and
AI-based solutions to combat coronavirus (COVID-19)-like epidemics: A
survey’ IEEE Access. 2021, 9, pp. 95730–95753.
[13] Sharma, A., Bahl, S., Bagha, A.K., Javaid, M., Shukla, D.K. and Haleem, A.:
‘Blockchain Technology and Its Applications to Combat COVID-19
Pandemic’ Research on Biomedical Engineering, 2020, pp. 1–8.
[14] Oracle. What is the Internet of Things (IoT)? [online]. 2021. Available from:
https://www.oracle.com/internet-ofthings/what-is-iot/ [Accessed May 2021].
[15] Reshetchenko, D. Top Five Sectors of IoT: Use Cases and Security [online].
2018. Available from: https://dzone.com/articles/5-sectors-which-use-the-
iot-efficiently- but-what-a [Accessed May 2021].
[16] Naeem, M.R.H., Gawhar, S., Adib, M.B.H., Sakib, S.A., Ahmed, A. and
Chisty, N.A.: ‘An IoT Based Smart Irrigation System’, in ‘2021 2nd
International Conference on Robotics, Electrical and Signal Processing
Techniques (ICREST)’, (2021), pp. 243–247.
[17] Cisco. Internet of Things (IoT) – The Future of IoT Miniguide: The
Burgeoning IoT Market Continues [online]. 2021. Available from:
https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/solutions/internet-of-things/future-of-iot.
html [Accessed May 2021].
[18] Satu, M.S., Rahman, M.K., Rony, M.A., et al.: ‘COVID-19: Update,
Forecast and Assistant – An Interactive Web Portal to Provide Real-Time
Information and Forecast COVID-19 Cases in Bangladesh’, in ‘2021
International Conference on Information and Communication Technology
for Sustainable Development (ICICT4SD)’, (2021), pp. 456–460.
[19] Asif-Ur-Rahman, M., Afsana, F., Mahmud, M., et al.: ‘Toward a Heterogeneous
Mist, Fog, and Cloud-Based Framework for the Internet of Healthcare Things’
IEEE Internet of Things Journal, 2019, 6(3), pp. 4049–4062.
[20] Farhin, F., Kaiser, M.S., and Mahmud, M. ‘Towards secured service provi-
sioning for the internet of healthcare things’, in 2020 IEEE 14th
International Conference on Application of Information and Communication
Technologies (AICT) 2020 Oct 7 (pp. 1–6). IEEE.
[21] Farhin, F., Kaiser, M.S. and Mahmud, M.: ‘Secured Smart Healthcare
System: Blockchain and Bayesian Inference Based Approach’, in Kaiser, M.
S., Bandyopadhyay, A., Mahmud, M., and Ray, K. (Eds.): ‘Proceedings of
International Conference on Trends in Computational and Cognitive
Engineering’, (Springer, Berlin, 2021), pp. 455–465.
[22] Kaiser, M.S., Zenia, N., Tabassum, F., et al.: ‘6G Access Network for
Intelligent Internet of Healthcare Things: Opportunity, Challenges, and
Research Directions’, in Kaiser, M.S., Bandyopadhyay, A., Mahmud, M.,
and Ray, K. (Eds.): ‘Proceedings of International Conference on Trends in
Computational and Cognitive Engineering’, (Springer, Berlin, 2021),
pp. 317–328.
24 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[23] Kaiser, M.S., Al Mamun, S., Mahmud, M. and Tania, M.H.: ‘Healthcare
Robots to Combat COVID-19’, in Santosh, K.C., and Joshi, A. (Eds.):
‘COVID-19: Prediction, Decision-Making, and Its Impacts’, (Springer,
Berlin, 2021), pp. 83–97.
[24] Mahmud, M. and Kaiser, M.S.: ‘Machine Learning in Fighting Pandemics:
A COVID-19 Case Study’, in Santosh, K.C., and Joshi, A. (Eds.): ‘COVID-
19: Prediction, Decision-Making, and Its Impacts’, (Springer, Berlin, 2021),
pp. 77–81.
[25] Toyama, S. and Hirayama, M.: ‘User Interface Design Method Considering
UI Device in Internet of Things System’, in ‘2018 6th International
Conference on Future Internet of Things and Cloud Workshops
(FiCloudW)’, (2018), pp. 1–6.
[26] Barcelo, M., Correa, A., Llorca, J., Tulino, A.M., Vicario, J.L. and Morell,
A.: ‘IoT-Cloud Service Optimization in Next Generation Smart
Environments’ IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, 2016,
34(12), pp. 4077–4090.
[27] Levy, E. IoT Analytics: Challenges, Applications, and Innovations [online].
2019. Available from: http://www.upsolver.com/blog/iot-analytics-chal-
lenges- applications-innovations [Accessed May 2021].
[28] Valerio, P.: ‘Is the IoT a Tech Bubble for Cities?: With More Cities Joining
the Smart City Revolution and Investing in Sensors and Other IoT Devices,
the Risk of a New Tech Bubble Is Rising’ IEEE Consumer Electronics
Magazine, 2016, 5(1), pp. 61–62.
[29] Bhuyan, H.K., Chakraborty, C., Pani, S.K. and Ravi, V.: ‘Feature and
Subfeature Selection for Classification Using Correlation Coefficient and Fuzzy
Model’ IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2021, pp. 1–15.
[30] Dhawan, S., Chakraborty, C., Frnda, J., Gupta, R., Rana, A.K. and Pani, S.K.:
‘SSII: Secured and High-Quality Steganography Using Intelligent Hybrid
Optimization Algorithms for IoT’ IEEE Access, 2021, 9, pp. 87563–87578.
[31] Frustaci, M., Pace, P., Aloi, G. and Fortino, G.: ‘Evaluating Critical Security
Issues of the IoT World: Present and Future Challenges’ IEEE Internet of
Things Journal, 2018, 5(4), pp. 2483–2495.
[32] Dominicbetts. What is Azure IoT Central [online]. 2021. Available from:
https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/iot- central/core/overview-iot-central
[Accessed May 2021].
[33] Nofer, M., Gomber, P., Hinz, O. and Schiereck, D.: ‘Blockchain’ Business &
Information Systems Engineering, 2017, 59(3), pp. 183–187.
[34] Zheng, Z., Xie, S., Dai, H., Chen, X. and Wang, H.: ‘An Overview of
Blockchain Technology: Architecture, Consensus, and Future Trends’, in
‘2017 IEEE International Congress on Big Data (BigData Congress)’,
(2017), pp. 557–564.
[35] Chowdhury, S.M.H.M., Jahan, F., Sara, S.M. and Nandi, D.: ‘Secured
Blockchain Based Decentralised Internet: A Proposed New Internet’, in
‘Proceedings of the International Conference on Computing Advancements’,
(Association for Computing Machinery, New York, 2020), pp. 1–7.
IoT and blockchain-based solutions to confront COVID-19 pandemic 25
[78] Hossain, C., Mohamed, M.A., Zishan, M., Ahasan, R. and Sharun, S.:
‘Awareness on e-Health Among Undergraduate Students in Bangladesh’
Indian Journal of Public Health Research & Development, 2019, 10, p. 636.
[79] Medicaaid. Telemedicine [online]. 2020. Available from: https://www.med-
icaid.gov/medicaid/benefits/ telemedicine/index.html [Accessed April
2021].
[80] Matsos, S. In Fight Against Coronavirus, Telemedicine Ramps Up at Johns
Hopkins [online]. 2020. Available from: https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/
coronavirus/articles/telemedicine.html [Accessed April 2021].
[81] Athena, P., Rumsfeld, J.S. and Wessler, J.D.: ‘Telehealth Is Having a
Moment’ Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 2020, 75(23),
pp. 2989–2991.
[82] Gilgore, S. GWU Hospital tackles COVID-19 with new testing site, tele-
medicine and outreach on D.C.’s east side [online]. 2020. Available from:
https://www.bizjournals.com/washington/news/2020/04/08/gwu- hospital-
tackles-covid-19-with-new-testing.html [Accessed April 2021].
[83] Shah, M. Industry Voices—How Rush University Medical Center’s Virtual
Investments Became Central to Its COVID-19 Response [online]. Available
from: https://www. fiercehealthcare.com/hospitals-health-systems/industry-
voices- how-rushuniversity-system-for-health-s-virtual [Accessed April
2021].
[84] WAS. WAS ambulance and special vehicles of the WAS brand [online].
2021. Available from: https://www.was- vehicles.com/en/home.html
[Accessed April 2021].
[85] Hossain, C., Zishan, M. and Ahasan, R.: ‘A Review on the Security Issues of
Telemedicine Network’ IJIREEICE, 2014, pp. 2183–218.
[86] Siriwardhana, Y., De Alwis, C., Gür, G., Ylianttila, M. and Liyanage, M.:
‘The Fight Against the COVID-19 Pandemic with 5G Technologies’ IEEE
Engineering Management Review, 2020, 48(3), pp. 72–84.
[87] Dawkins, T. How COVID-19 Could Open the Door for Driverless [online].
2020. Available from: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/04/how-
covid-19-could-open-the-door-for-driverless-deliveries/ [Accessed April
2021].
[88] Končar, J., Grubor, A., Marić, R., Vučenović, S. and Vukmirović, G.: ‘Setbacks
to IoT Implementation in the Function of FMCG Supply Chain Sustainability
During COVID-19 Pandemic’ Sustainability, 2020, 12(18), p. 7391.
[89] Rivest, R.L., Weitzner, D.J., Ivers, L.C., Soibelman, I. and Zissman, M.A.:
‘PACT: Private Automated Contact Tracing’ 2020, p. 3.
[90] Song, J., Gu, T., Feng, X., Ge, Y. and Mohapatra, P.: ‘Blockchain Meets
COVID-19: A Framework for Contact Information Sharing and Risk
Notification System’ arXiv preprint arXiv:2007.10529, 2020.
[91] Xu, H., Zhang, L., Onireti, O., Fang, Y., Buchanan, W.J. and Imran, M.A.:
‘BeepTrace: Blockchain-Enabled Privacy-Preserving Contact Tracing for
COVID-19 Pandemic and Beyond’ IEEE Internet of Things Journal, 2020,
8, pp. 3915–3929.
IoT and blockchain-based solutions to confront COVID-19 pandemic 29
[92] Klaine, P.V., Zhang, L., Zhou, B., Sun, Y., Xu, H. and Imran, M.: ‘Privacy-
Preserving Contact Tracing and Public Risk Assessment Using Blockchain for
COVID-19 Pandemic’ IEEE Internet of Things Magazine, 2020, 3(3), pp. 58–63.
[93] Torky, M. and Hassanien, A.E.: ‘COVID-19 Blockchain Framework:
Innovative Approach’ arXiv preprint arXiv:2004.06081, 2020.
[94] Gupta, A, Chinmay, C. and Gupta, B: ‘Secure Transmission of EEG Data Using
Watermarking Algorithm for the Detection of Epileptical Seizures’ Traitement
du Signal, 2021, 38(2), pp. 473–479, https://doi.org/10.18280/ts.380227.
[95] Azim, A., Islam, M.N. and Spranger, P.E.: ‘Blockchain and Novel
Coronavirus: Towards Preventing COVID-19 and Future Pandemics’
Iberoamerican Journal of Medicine, 2020, 2(3), pp. 215–218.
[96] Manoj, M., Srivastava, G., Somayaji, S.R.K., Gadekallu, T.R., Maddikunta,
P.K.R. and Bhattacharya, S.: ‘An Incentive Based Approach for COVID-19
Planning Using Blockchain Technology’, in ‘2020 IEEE Globecom
Workshops (GC Wkshps)’, (2020), pp. 1–6.
[97] Choudhury, H., Goswami, B. and Gurung, S.K.: ‘CovidChain: An
Anonymity Preserving Blockchain Based Framework for Protection
Against Covid-19’ ArXiv, 2020.
[98] Hasan, H.R., Salah, K., Jayaraman, R., et al.: ‘Blockchain-Based Solution
for COVID-19 Digital Medical Passports and Immunity Certificates’ IEEE
Access, 2020, 8, pp. 222093–222108.
[99] Resiere, D., Resiere, D. and Kallel, H.: ‘Implementation of Medical and
Scientific Cooperation in the Caribbean Using Blockchain Technology in
Coronavirus (Covid-19) Pandemics’ Journal of Medical Systems, 2020, 44(7).
[100] Rab, S., Javaid, M., Haleem, A. and Vaishya, R.: ‘Face Masks Are New
Normal After COVID-19 Pandemic’ Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome:
Clinical Research & Reviews, 2020, 14(6), pp. 1617–1619.
[101] Ahir, S., Telavane, D. and Thomas, R.: ‘The Impact of Artificial
Intelligence, Blockchain, Big Data and Evolving Technologies in
Coronavirus Disease – 2019 (COVID-19) Curtailment’, in ‘2020
International Conference on Smart Electronics and Communication
(ICOSEC)’, (2020), pp. 113–120.
[102] Christodoulou, K., Christodoulou, P., Zinonos, Z., Carayannis, E.G. and
Chatzichristofis, S.A.: ‘Health Information Exchange With Blockchain
amid Covid-19-like Pandemics’, in ‘2020 16th International Conference on
Distributed Computing in Sensor Systems (DCOSS)’, (2020), pp. 412–417.
[103] Khatoon, A. Use of Blockchain Technology to Curb Novel Coronavirus
Disease (COVID-19) Transmission. Preprints 2020, 2020050117 (doi:
10.20944/preprints202005.0117.v1).
[104] Alam T. ‘Internet of things and blockchain-based framework for
Coronavirus (COVID-19) disease’. Available at SSRN: http://dx.doi.org/
10.2139/ssrn.3660503.
[105] Herland, M., Khoshgoftaar, T.M. and Bauder, R.A.: ‘Big Data Fraud
Detection Using Multiple Medicare Data Sources’ Journal of Big Data,
2018, 5(1), p. 29.
30 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[106] Batool, A., Toyama, K., Veinot, T., Fatima, B. and Naseem, M.: ‘Detecting
Data Falsification by Front-line Development Workers: A Case Study of
Vaccination in Pakistan’, in ‘Proceedings of the 2021 CHI Conference on
Human Factors in Computing Systems’, (Association for Computing
Machinery, New York, 2021), pp. 1–14.
[107] Marbouh, D., Abbasi, T., Maasmi, F., et al.: ‘Blockchain for COVID-19:
Review, Opportunities, and a Trusted Tracking System’ Arabian Journal
for Science and Engineering, 2020, 45(12), pp. 9895–9911.
[108] Ahmad, R.W., Salah, K., Jayaraman, R., Yaqoob, I., Ellahham, S., and
Omar, M. ‘Blockchain and COVID-19 pandemic: Applications and chal-
lenges’, IEEE TechRxiv. 2020 Sep 17.
[109] Ramachandran, A. and Kantarcioglu, M.: ‘SmartProvenance: A Distributed,
Blockchain Based DataProvenance System’, in ‘Proceedings of the Eighth
ACM Conference on Data and Application Security and Privacy’,
(Association for Computing Machinery, New York, 2018), pp. 35–42.
[110] Siva Rama Krishnan, S., Manoj, M.K., Gadekallu, T.R., et al.: ‘A Blockchain-
Based Credibility Scoring Framework for Electronic Medical Records’, in
‘2020 IEEE Globecom Workshops (GC Wkshps)’, (2020), pp. 1–6.
[111] Sharma, B., Sekharan, C.N. and Zuo, F.: ‘Merkle-Tree Based Approach for
Ensuring Integrity of Electronic Medical Records’, in ‘2018 9th IEEE
Annual Ubiquitous Computing, Electronics Mobile Communication
Conference (UEMCON)’, (2018), pp. 983–987.
[112] Boudagdigue, C., Benslimane, A., Kobbane, A. and Liu, J.: ‘Trust
Management in Industrial Internet of Things’ IEEE Transactions on
Information Forensics and Security, 2020, 15, pp. 3667–3682.
[113] Dai, H.-N., Imran, M. and Haider, N.: ‘Blockchain-Enabled Internet of
Medical Things to Combat COVID-19’ IEEE Internet of Things Magazine,
2020, 3(3), pp. 52–57.
[114] Aileni, R.M. and Suciu, G., 2020. ‘IoMT: A blockchain perspective’, in
Decentralised Internet of Things (pp. 199–215). Springer, Cham.
[115] Srivastava, G., Crichigno, J. and Dhar, S.: ‘A Light and Secure Healthcare
Blockchain for IoT Medical Devices’, in ‘2019 IEEE Canadian Conference
of Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE)’, (2019), pp. 1–5.
[116] Celesti, A., Ruggeri, A., Fazio, M., Galletta, A., Villari, M. and Romano,
A.: ‘Blockchain-Based Healthcare Workflow for Tele-Medical Laboratory
in Federated Hospital IoT Clouds’ Sensors, 2020, 20(9), p. 2590.
[117] Košt’ál, K., Helebrandt, P., Belluš, M., Ries, M. and Kotuliak, I.:
‘Management and Monitoring of IoT Devices Using Blockchain’ Sensors,
2019, 19(4), p. 856.
[118] Ahmad, R.W., Salah, K., Jayaraman, R., Yaqoob, I., Ellahham, S. and Omar,
M.: ‘The Role of Blockchain Technology in Telehealth and Telemedicine’
International Journal of Medical Informatics, 2021, 148, p. 104399.
[119] Kim, D., Choi, J. and Han, K.: ‘Risk Management-Based Security
Evaluation Model for Telemedicine Systems’ BMC Medical Informatics
and Decision Making, 2020, 20(1), p. 106.
IoT and blockchain-based solutions to confront COVID-19 pandemic 31
[133] Sharma, M., Samriti and Singh, G.: ‘Need and Design of Smart and Secure
Energy-Efficient IoT-Based Healthcare Framework’, in Mittal, M.,
Tanwar, S., Agarwal, B., and Goyal, L.M. (Eds.): ‘Energy Conservation for
IoT Devices: Concepts, Paradigms and Solutions’, (Springer, Berlin, 2019),
pp. 259–281.
[134] Ghiasi, M., Dehghani, M., Niknam, T., Kavousi-Fard, A., Siano, P. and
Alhelou, H.H.: ‘Cyber-Attack Detection and Cyber-Security
Enhancement in Smart DC-Microgrid Based on Blockchain
Technology and Hilbert Huang Transform’ IEEE Access, 2021, 9,
pp. 29429–29440.
[135] Singh, S.K., Salim, M.M., Cho, M., Cha, J., Pan, Y. and Park, J.H.: ‘Smart
Contract-Based Pool Hopping Attack Prevention for Blockchain Networks’
Symmetry, 2019, 11(7), p. 941.
[136] Salimitari, M., Chatterjee, M. and Fallah, Y.P.: ‘A Survey on Consensus
Methods in Blockchain for Resource-Constrained IoT Networks’ Internet
of Things, 2020, 11, p. 100212.
Chapter 2
Application of big data and computational
intelligence in fighting COVID-19 epidemic
Joseph Bamidele Awotunde1, Chinmay Chakraborty2 and
Gbemisola Janet Ajamu3
Abstract
The current epidemic called coronavirus (COVID-19) is wreaking havoc on
society, humanity, and causing economic difficulties around the world. Many
techniques have been attempted to manage and contain the COVID-19 outbreak;
however, many governments remain powerless to combat and contain the virus.
Big data is driving the digital revolution in an increasingly knowledge-driven,
healthcare-innovation-driven, and connected society. The combination of com-
putational intelligence (CI) and big data analytics (BDAs) has developed methods
that make accessing and processing vast amounts of data easier and less
demanding on human expert. Hence, in combating the outbreak, big data and CI
can be applied since the use of both technologies empowered BDA and yielded
imaginable results in combating infectious diseases globally. Therefore, this
chapter reviews the applicability and importance of big data and CI methods to
data produced from the countless of ubiquitously connected healthcare devices
that produced entrenched and distributed information handling capabilities in
fighting COVID-19 outbreak. The use of CI in BDAs has resulted in knowledge-
based system that transformed big data into big knowledge with new approaches
and visions in order to provide people with better understanding and information-
driven results. There have been tremendous positive results using IoT-based
capture data with BDA and CI models for monitoring, diagnosis, and prediction
of COVID-19 outbreak. The huge amount of data can be managed using CI and
BDA by developing models that will reduce the spread of any infectious diseases
to monitoring, tracking and in the production of drugs and vaccines for the
treatment of the any outbreak globally.
1
Department of Computer Science, University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria
2
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Birla Institute of Technology, Ranchi,
India
3
Department Agricultural Extension and Rural Development, Landmark University, Omu-Aran, Nigeria
34 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
2.1 Introduction
according to Bezdek’s description. In the real sense, both AI and CI target the rea-
lization of general intelligence in real-world models. The authors in [27] explained
the distinction in both AI and CI by suggesting that hard computing technologies are
made of the former, whereas soft computing technologies are made of the latter.
We may therefore assume that there are two forms of machine intelligence: (1)
CI, defined by the hard-computing principle, and (2) AI developed by the soft-
computing theory. Compared to hard-computing-based CI, the advantages of the
soft-computing concept allow AI to adapt to several different conditions. The hard
computing models are built using Boolean logic that is based on true or false
values. The main challenge of this method is that it cannot be interpreted easily in
natural language problems. The ambiguous cases are fully taken care of with soft
computing models using fuzzy logic. One patented feature of CI is this form of
logic that approximated the human brain through the aggregation of data into
partial facts [27].
CI focuses on problems that, in theory, only individuals and animals can solve
and require intellect. It is a branch of computer science without operational com-
putational algorithms, which involve only intelligence to study and solve any
challenges. It studies problems for which no operational computational algorithms
exist. The CI allows the addition of new ideas through time and serves as patronage
of other existing algorithms like AI [27–29]. The use of CI methods has resulted in
a higher level of focus in the research community. Machine learning algorithms, as
stated in a number of recent studies, provide superior detection accuracy when
compared to various data classification techniques [30]. Due to its suitability in
precaution programming, the model achieved and resulted in great prediction
models. The accuracy of forecasting can vary depending on the approaches used by
various research systems. As a result, identifying equipment capable of providing
extremely accurate diagnosis and tracking for the outbreaks and outbursts are cri-
tical. CI approaches are the most effective policymaking strategies for dealing with
real-world and systemic issues. The goal is to see how different CI techniques
perform when it comes to categorizing COVID-19 samples. The performance of CI
techniques has been evaluated using a variety of categorization performance abil-
ities. The following are five regularly used CI models: artificial neural network
(ANN) for classification, K-nearest neighbor, support vector machine (SVM), lin-
ear regression, and multilayer perceptron.
In the classification of diabetes proteins, machine learning has already been
used as an instance in biological sector [31,32], and in the prediction of diabetes
and heart disease [33]. The ANN, fuzzy logic, K-mean, SVM are some of the best
classifiers used in this reaction [34]. The fuzzy logic classifier approach is an
alternate form of CI methodology that scholars have used to categorize COVID-
19 situations [35]. In [35], the authors propose a classification model for calculating
and projecting the occurrences of COVID-19 outbreak for a period of 10 days
based on previously documented cases in China. The suggested framework is an
enriched adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) with flower pollination
algorithm using the Salp swarm algorithm model. The rate of misclassified
instances with contradiction was used to measure the accuracy of their studies, and
38 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Big data has impacted all areas of people’s lives in the twenty-first century, parti-
cularly the healthcare industries, which include genetics and medicine [19,55]. The
use of electronic health records (EHR) that replace the paper health reports has
resulted in data growth [56]. To take evidence-based actions, big data provides
incentive and insight for specialist, epidemiologists, and physicians, which resulted
in patient safety [57]. In the present era, numerous technologies such as IoT devices
and sensors contribute significantly to the tremendous expansion of big data.
Current developments in computation, storage, and connection of various devices
have resulted in massive datasets. This extracted useful information from the big
data generated from the connected devices are used for the benefits of government,
industry, science, and society.
The adoption of various IoT-based devices and sensors has increased the
number of data collected and yields a huge amount of healthcare [58]. These sen-
sors and devices will be used to generate over 847 zettabytes (ZB) of data by 2021
based on Cisco recent report [59,60]. Conventional methods cannot process, col-
lect, or regulate this kind of data. Hence, the analysis of such data requires BDAs
for huge datasets with various kinds of data [61]. In order to identify hidden pat-
terns, latent relationships, market dynamics, consumer demands, and other critical
business information BDA are very necessary [62]. The ability to scrutinize this
data can assist a company in dealing with significant information that could have a
negative influence on the organization [63].
Hence, BDA’s main purpose is to help industrial organizations improve their
data interpretation and, as a result, make better and more informed judgments.
BDA enables research and specialists to examine such data that is normally not
possible to analyze using traditional approaches [62]. BDA is a technique that
transforms structure and unstructured data into a more intelligible one for investi-
gative purposes. These computational approaches’ algorithms must recognize
shapes, patterns, and relationships in data across several time horizons [64]. The
results of the findings from BDA are presented using tables, three-dimensional
maps, and charts to aid decision-making.
The process of big data implementation becomes difficult in some application
due to the problem of scalability in the operation of some of these systems, and the
Application of big data and computational intelligence 41
data is sophisticated in core operations of these systems [65]. The critical issues in
big data analysis are to obtain meaningful information from huge data that will
necessitate flexible investigative procedures and methods to report timely results.
Since the conventional techniques are not suitable for big data processes compared
with BDA in gain, an insight into the big data is predicted for meaningful results
[66]. As a result, to accommodate parallel data processing, all-encompassing net-
works and modern technologies are required. Furthermore, complex data streams
from various data sources have several arrangements required analytics models to
get better and understandable results from such data [67]. As a result, the existing
processing models are not efficient based on the problem of inefficiency arise
during computing processes [68]. Figure 2.1 depicts the framework for big data–
enabled CI for COVID-19 outbreak.
Although only a few programs can manage big data volumes in a short pro-
cessing period, customers receive input and advice from BDA systems in a long
time [69]. The best of the best systems, on the other hand, cope with huge amounts
of data and data complexity using a complicated trial-and-error process [70]. One
of the big data graphic analytics is the investigative data examination used to
process large datasets collected from an earth structural model [71]. Because the
volume of big data is so large, traditional database management applications cannot
be used to collect and analyze it. Modern warehouse databases, like as Apache
Hadoop, provide the resolution by allowing for the analysis of distributed data.
Image- Digital
based data data
Input Output
OMICS- Wearable
based data sensors
Computational intelligence: information
Sources of COVID-19 related data
and data mining for emergency response
In the fight against COVID-19 outbreak, big data has played significant roles
and shown to be a powerful tool in this direction [72,73]. Big data in combination
with BDA have shown to be very useful and creating an intriguing possibilities for
fighting this outbreak. The use of these concepts can aid monitoring the spread of
this pandemic and is useful in the areas of treatment, vaccine development, mon-
itoring on infected patient, among others [74]. For example, combining coronavirus
data streams with AI-based models can be used to create simulation models for
epidemic estimation. This will allow health officials to follow the coronavirus’s
progress and better plan for preventive measures [75]. Big data models, with its
ability to aggregate data and use enormous volumes of data for early detection,
further boost the potential COVID-19 disease prediction. Large-scale COVID-
19 studies can also be used with BDA using data from real-world sources like
infected patients to build high-reliability, robust treatment strategies [76,77]. The
healthcare providers will have a better understanding of the virus’ progression
using the BDA for the huge data processing and allow them to respond more
effectively to various diagnoses and therapies.
In the control and monitoring of COVID-19 outbreak, big data plays a critical
role because of its ability to provide a huge amount of data for predicting outbreaks.
Like the case in [78] study, using the big data records from the outbreak in Italy
used to assess the likelihood for outbreaks is critical for the formulation of efficient
disease management efforts. Rather than utilizing a basic and deterministic human-
transmission-based model, the scientists built more sophisticated models that may
appropriately define pandemic dynamics utilizing data provided by the civil
defense database from Italy. The publicly available dataset can serve as another
data source for epidemic prediction to map localities with similar COVID-19 out-
break [79]. The first experiment is a Wuhan inquiry targeted at tracking individual
movement from and to Wuhan, in order for health officials to quarantine the
COVID-19-infected population.
Big data also helps in the prediction of outbreaks on a worldwide scale.
From the perspective of statistical analysis, the outbreak is forecast using
available datasets that, due to a lack of detailed investigations, put the precision
of the fit for accurate prediction under question. Accuracy may be affected by a
variety of factors, including illness cases, population, living situations, and
ecosystems. Inspired by this, researchers in [80] used a large dataset from many
locations and nations to estimate the pandemic like in China and Korea using
logistic model to assess the forecasts’ credibility. Another study [81] used data
generated from South Korea, China, Italy, and Iran by employed Google Trends
to acquire coronavirus-related data. Five environmental regions are used as the
data textual: (1) globally, to ascertain the global interest of the outbreak; (2)
China the sources of the outbreak; (3) South Korea; (4) Italy; and (5) Iran. This
aggregation of data sources will help visualize the pattern of the outbreak and
predict the future outbreak. The outbreak reports from these countries are also
gathered and evaluated using a data optimization model targeted at accurately
predicting everyday cases of coronavirus infection as well as potentially long-
term epidemic forecasts [82].
Application of big data and computational intelligence 43
In [83], datasets collected from confirmed, death, and recovered cases of all
countries from the John Hopkins University repository were used for prediction
model using ML algorithm. The research was for short-term intervals of 2 weeks in
India. The proposed data analytic can be extended to create larger model for long-
term prediction to estimate the outbreak theoretically. Meanwhile, the American
large-scale datasets were used for the purpose of prediction in the United States
using data analytical approach for a proper investigation of the outbreak [84]. The
main aim of the analysis is to improve the accuracy of the future estimation for any
likely pandemic-like coronaviruses, and fitting the prediction errors in order to
refine the model.
Big data has been used in the monitoring of COVID-19 spread in order to help
the healthcare sectors and government to successfully manage the spread of the
pandemic [75,85]. This has also been used to facilitate the tracking of the COVID-
19 distribution with a variety of newly emerging solutions. For example, the study
in [86] proposed the use of BDA model to track the pandemic spread from the huge
generated data from the outbreak. The China National Health Commission pro-
vided a large dataset of 854,424 flight travelers that flew from Wuhan Airport with
55 airlines to various parts of the 49 cities in China between December 2019 and
January 2020. Using predicted factors such as the local inhabitants and air travelers
to measure the variance of recorded cases in China cities, a multiple linear model is
constructed. More precisely, the authors used a Spearman correlation analysis with
the number of 49 reported cases from Wuhan using travelers’ traffic for a period of
time. The results of the finding have shown a high correlation between the popu-
lation and the infection cases within the cities in China. In [87], the Geographic
Information Systems (GIS) was used with big data for spatial analysis to promote
heterogeneous data integration from healthcare data tools like the data from the
patients, patients, clinical laboratories, and the public.
Jin et al. [88] provided a detailed guide with valuable methods for the treatment
and diagnosis of COVID-19. The techniques of the guiding principle, biological
aspects, disease prevention, diagnosis, and COVID-19 disease care are all included in
this document. From the 11,500 people tested by Zhongnan Hospital of Wuhan
University as a pilot trial, 276 were discovered as potentially infected casualties, with
170 being diagnosed. A huge set of dataset has been investigated using clinical tests,
including CT/X-ray imaging, CT/X-ray imaging in response to pathogen detection in
the respiratory tract, and manifestations to hematological analysis.
The development of vaccine is very paramount in the prevention of individuals
from the burden of infectious diseases and pandemic. In the identification of better
vaccine for the treatment of COVID-19 outbreak, big data plays prominent roles.
The use of this huge data within this short time has really helped in the production
of suitable vaccine for COVID-19 outbreak globally. The use of GISAID database
in the work of [89] has aided in the removing residues amino acids. The goal of
research is to find effective opportunities for the growth of vaccines and medica-
tions to combat the COVID-19 pandemic. Another vaccine research initiative by
[90] compares the spike proteins in SARS-CoV, MERS-CoV, and SARS-CoV-2
with other coronavirus strains in four humans previously isolated. This research
44 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
will aid in the essential screening of the SARS-CoV-2 spike sequence and structure,
which could aid in the development of an effective vaccine.
In the production of drugs manufacturing models to battle COVID-19 pan-
demic, big data has played prominent roles. For instance, [91] proposed a mole-
cular docking-based solution for drug research in fighting COVID-19 outbreak.
The first screening involved more than 2,500 small molecules and was validated
through the use of Glide molecular docking software in the FDA-approved drug
database. In the experiment, 15 of the 25 verified medicines exhibited considerable
inhibitory properties. The drug formulation toward COVID-19 is triggered by the
inhibitory incremental change and chronic inflammation. In addition, the authors in
[92] used big data to develop a drug repositioning strategy to combat the COVID-
19 epidemic. For the development of COVID-19 vaccines, the authors use ML to
incorporate both the information graph and the literature.
In addition, reverse vaccinology and immunological computer science can be
employed to produce vaccines for the global COVID-19 outbreak [93]. The
National Center for Biotechnology Information’s online database selected SARS-
CoV-2 strain to analyze various entries while Immune Epitope Database online
epitope was utilized for B-cell and T-cell prediction. To classify the possible vac-
cine constructions from the produced dataset, a number of procedures may be
required, including immunogenicity, genotoxicity, and biophysical features of
products. The National Center for Biotechnology Knowledge for Promoting the
Manufacture of Vaccines [94] has also acquired a large dataset. Different peptides
have been suggested for the two-step production of a new COVID-19 vaccine. To
begin, the entire genome of COVID-19 was examined using a comparative geno-
mic method to identify the most likely antigenic target.
tracking techniques must be kept in place in order to prepare for another pandemic
outbreak, or second wave of COVID-19-related diseases, as we have seen in India and
other Asian nations. An instance of another outbreak of Ebola in the central region of
Africa requires the emerging of using modern tracking mechanisms to be put in place
for any emergency. CI-based radiological innovation has been considerably adopted
by several Chinese clinics, and the promise of CI-based models’ complete adoption
magically reappears. Radiologists have highlighted concerns about a dearth of data for
training CI-based models, and the bulk of the outbreak samples accessible from
country medical institutes does not include sample preference. The use of CT scans
and X-rays has the tendency to escalate infection and contaminate the instruments.
The use of crowded social platforms, big data hubris, and outlier data are still
not reliable and valid due to a lack of evidence, and technological challenges in
COVID-19 outbreak forecasting [98]. CI techniques are not used in the bulk of
monitoring and forecasting frameworks currently in use. Rather, most analysts
consider SIR models, which are epidemiologically validated models. The use of
immunological SIR model for instance has been adopted by Robert Koch Institute
in Berlin that includes government controls like curfews, sterilization, and social
disassociating advice. This approach was created in China to demonstrate that
isolation might lower the rate of incidence below the catastrophic value [99].
Table 2.1 summarizes the CI issues in the COVID-19 epidemic.
The present pandemic has brought serious challenges because it can spread
quickly with human interaction and among people traveling internationally; thus
there is total ban on inter-traveling among several nations [100,101]. Due to these,
foreign visitors are forced to supply their full details like personal information,
travel history, reason for their visiting, and place of residence, and most impor-
tantly there is imposed quarantine restriction globally [102]. The Chinese media
secretly published visitors secret information is an example of such cases; this
explains that the importance of visitor information can cause dispute-of-law in any
nation. (1) The important and distinct definitions of right to personal data have been
clearly defined by the EU, United States, and China; (2) the growth to centralized
approach to relevant laws by these three nations points to the fact that healthcare
privacy law is to be a contractual law; and (3) the de-Americanization is aggres-
sively advocated for and has important data privacy laws. This added to how
international information regulation is being applied or the patterns and methods of
administration of the privacy data laws [1,70].
In the making of CI-based model and BDA, the lack of standard datasets poses
a significant challenge for their use in combating the COVID-19 pandemic.
Various CI models using huge datasets have been discussed in this literature, but
none have been assessed using the same dataset. Thus, to draw conclusion becomes
difficult due to the use of two datasets with different quantities of samples for
COVID-19 outbreak prediction and detection. In comparison, the majority of
datasets in the literature were created as a result of individual efforts, such as when
writers acquire information on the Internet then combine them to form their own
dataset and test the methods they suggest. Healthcare organization like WHO and
CDC plays important roles in resolving this issue as well as the governments, and
large since they have accessed to high-quality and massive datasets. Medical data
like X-ray and CT scans can be obtained from hospitals, reports from self-diagnosis
applications, satellite data, and personal information.
The CORD-19 dataset is being managed by various collaborators with the original
owner Georgetown Security Center like Microsoft Research, Chan Zuckerberg
Initiative, Allen Institute for AI, and National Institutes of Health [103]. Also, in China,
Alibaba DAMO Academy has partnered with various hospitals to create AI-based
models for COVID-19 case prediction and identification, and more than 5,000 instan-
ces of COVID-19 have been reported, and hospitals are responsible for delivering CT
scans. As recorded in [104] thanks to its remarkable performance, this device has been
used by more than 20 hospitals in China: 96% accuracy in just 20 s. Data scientists
encounter numerous challenges when working with big data. One challenge is com-
piling, integrating, and storing big data derived from various sources [64,65]. Another
vital problem is the administration and application of this generated data in healthcare
systems. To maximize the effectiveness of big data in utilization in medical case
required the use of a reliable BDA like CI model to facilitate the perception of a
dependable data. BDA is built on the foundation of good data management.
The utilization of huge data generated from the use of various techniques like
sensors, devices, and patients’ symptoms using healthcare internal infrastructure is
another difficulty in generating a reliable result from huge data [16]. The majority
Application of big data and computational intelligence 47
These technologies will remain dislocated and unworkable unless the aforemen-
tioned issues are rectified. It appears that all three problems may be aided by directing
the majority of funds and knowledge to the communities most vulnerable to epi-
demics. Methodologically, effective modeling solutions that incorporate diverse pre-
dictions to reduce uncertainty are being created. Using modern big data technologies,
nimble, distributed groups of people will be required to cover the systematic and
functional components of the epidemic response. To complement and explain the
restricted availability of socio-geographical data needed to track the progress of sig-
nificant forecasts. The methods can be used to forecast the current pandemic so that
the policy-makers can plan ahead of another similar outbreak or epidemic of this kind.
The combination of both BDA and CI models can be troublesome if the available data
for modeling is very small since CI model depends meanly on a huge amount of data
to be able to diagnosed, predicted, and classifier efficiently and properly.
The fulfillment of these methods in healthcare systems significantly depends
on serious investment on training, development of relevant models that can be used
to tackle any infectious diseases. Furthermore, there should constant release of fund
to fill the critical gap in analytics process, especially in the developing nation. The
social media sites, X-ray images, scanning images, phones recordings among others
can be a source of generating big data in medical systems with public available data
[111], and their text or video can be used in a variety of ways. In the context of
COVID-19 outbreak, big data can inform of generated information about the epi-
demic locations, medical records, infected case history, scanned and X-ray images
among others. Big data and analytics have been proving useful in fighting against
COVID-19 pandemic [73].
75:25
CXR images HOG PCA train test Extra trees
or COVID-19, split model
normal
and PTB
Confusion matrix
120
COVID19 129 4 1
100
80
True label
Normal 23 65 14
60
40
PTB 22 5 69 20
result was based on the split set, which represents 25% of the entire dataset because
the dataset was split. This experiment was done out on a Windows computer
operating systems running on an Intel Core i3-4200 CPU at 2.50–2.70 GHz and 4
GB RAM, with R-programming language for executing the programming code.
The Extra Trees algorithm yielded a result of 79.22% accuracy, 81.00% precision,
79.00% recall, and 79.02% F1-score. The best features from the generated HOG
features were chosen using the PCA technique, resulting in a better outcome.
lungs, and 69 (72%) of 96 cases were incorrectly classified as NORMAL lungs but
were accurately diagnosed as PTB.
0.8
True positive rate
0.6
0.4
ROC curve of class COVID-19 (area = 0.97)
ROC curve of class NORMAL (area = 0.99)
0.2 ROC curve of class PULMONARY (area = 0.98)
Micro-average ROC curve (area = 0.98)
Micro-average ROC curve (area = 0.98)
0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
False positive rate
Precision-recall curve
1.0
0.8
Precision
0.6
0.4
Precision-recall curve of class COVID-19 (area = 0.936)
0.2 Precision-recall curve of class NORMAL (area = 0.846)
Precision-recall curve of class PTB (area = 0.787)
Micro-average precision-recall curve (area=0.846)
0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Recall
recall, or vice versa. A good data categorization model should be able to keep both
precision and recall high [113]. Class has a COVID-19 PRC value of 0.936,
NORMAL of 0.846, and PTB of 0.787.
2.6 Conclusion
COVID-19 is a one-of-a-kind coronavirus from the pneumonia family. It is vital to
have a reliable method for detecting COVID-19 in infected patients, and CI has
proven to be effective. This chapter looked at various recent COVID-19 control
strategies that used CI. The majority of the studies we looked at focused on
COVID-19 pandemic diagnosis, prediction, and monitoring, as well as image
classification with CXR images and CTs for COVID-19 outbreak. While the bulk
of the recent studies employed either machine learning/deep learning to extract and
choose features, a handful of them combined the two approaches by using ML to
extract and select features and DL for classification and prediction. There has been
effort to improve the accuracy of CI algorithms, there are still CI-based diagnostic
methods that yield positive results, but still there is no readymade answer in this
direction. The system developed using CI models has been proved useful in mon-
itoring, diagnosis, and prediction of COVID-19 outbreak in developed nations. The
model works on the provided data that is related to COVID-19 signs and symptoms.
The models that this has improved have seriously helped physicians in dealing with
infected patients and the control of the spread of COVID-19 pandemic globally.
This helps in early diagnosis of COVID-19 patients, vaccine development, and the
monitoring of isolated patients. Therefore, the use of BDA and CI algorithms has
really help in the diagnosis, prediction, classification, and treatment during this
outbreak. Though the use of BDA and CI models has not be fully integrated to
really combat infectious diseases, its use can never be overemphasized and played
substantial role in the development of vaccines for the treatment of any infectious
disease. The findings of this chapter show that BDA and CI algorithms place pro-
minent roles in fighting COVID-19 pandemic globally, and their direct application
can reduce the spread of this pandemic within nations.
References
[1] Lukman, A. F., Benedicta, A., Awotunde, J. B., et al. (2022). Robust
statistical modeling of COVID-19 prevalence in African epicentres.
Studies in Systems, Decision and Control, 366, 315–358.
[2] Dunford, D., Dale, B., Stylianou, N. L., Ahmed, M. and Arenas, IdlT,
(2020). Coronavirus: the world in lockdown in maps and charts. BBC News
(available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-52103747).
[3] Awotunde, J. B., Jimoh, R. G., AbdulRaheem, M., Oladipo, I. D., Folorunso,
S. O. and Ajamu, G. J. (2022). IoT-based wearable body sensor network for
COVID-19 pandemic. In Advances in Data Science and Intelligent Data
Communication Technologies for COVID-19 (pp. 253–275). Cham: Springer.
52 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[4] Guan, W. J., Ni, Z. Y., Hu, Y., et al. (2020). Clinical characteristics of
coronavirus disease in 2019 in China. New England Journal of Medicine,
382(18), 1708–1720.
[5] Roy, S. and Chakraborty, C. (2021). Panic buying situation during COVID-
19 global pandemic. Journal of Information Technology Management, 13(2),
231–244.
[6] Garg, L., Chakraborty, C., Mahmoudi, S. and Sohmen, V. S. (2021).
Healthcare informatics for fighting COVID-19 and future pandemics. In
EAI/Springer Innovations in Communication and Computing. Springer
Nature. ISBN: 978-3-030-72751-2.
[7] Shelke, Y. and Chakraborty, C. (2020). Augmented reality and virtual reality
transforming spinal imaging landscape: a feasibility study. IEEE Computer
Graphics and Applications, 41(3), 124–138.
[8] Jang, S., Lee, S., Choi, S. M., Seo, J., Choi, H. and Yoon, T. (2016).
Comparison between SARS CoV and MERS CoV using apriori algorithm,
decision tree, SVM. In MATEC Web of Conferences (Vol. 49, p. 08001).
EDP Sciences.
[9] Awotunde, J. B., Folorunso, S. O., Bhoi, A. K., Adebayo, P. O. and Ijaz, M. F.
(2021). Disease diagnosis system for IoT-Based wearable body sensors with
machine learning algorithm. In Hybrid Artificial Intelligence and IoT in
Healthcare (pp. 201–222). Singapore: Springer.
[10] Brown, D. E., Abbasi, A. and Lau, R. Y. (2015). Predictive analytics:
predictive modeling at the micro level. IEEE Intelligent Systems, 30(3),
6–8.
[11] Chakraborty, C. and Abougreen, A. N. (2021). Intelligent internet of things
and advanced machine learning techniques for COVID-19. EAI Endorsed
Transactions on Pervasive Health and Technology, 7(26), e1.
[12] Ahmed, M. B., Boudhir, A. A., Santos, D., El Aroussi, M. and Karas, İ. R.
(Eds.). (2020). Innovations in smart cities application. In The Proceedings of
the 4th International Conference on Smart City Applications (3rd ed.).
Springer Nature.
[13] Rodgers, W. (2020). Artificial Intelligence in a Throughput Model: Some
Major Algorithms. CRC Press.
[14] Priyanka, K. and Kulennavar, N. (2014). A survey on big data analytics in
health care. International Journal of Computer Science and Information
Technologies, 5(4), 5865–5868.
[15] Kruse, C. S., Goswamy, R., Raval, Y. J. and Marawi, S. (2016). Challenges
and opportunities of big data in health care: a systematic review. JMIR
Medical Informatics, 4(4), e38.
[16] Oussous, A., Benjelloun, F. Z., Lahcen, A. A. and Belfkih, S. (2018). Big
data technologies: a survey. Journal of King Saud University-Computer and
Information Sciences, 30(4), 431–448.
[17] Olaronke, I. and Oluwaseun, O. (2016, December). Big data in healthcare:
prospects, challenges and resolutions. In 2016 Future Technologies
Conference (FTC) (pp. 1152–1157). IEEE.
Application of big data and computational intelligence 53
[18] Dai, H. N., Wang, H., Xu, G., Wan, J. and Imran, M. (2020). Big data ana-
lytics for manufacturing Internet of Things: opportunities, challenges and
enabling technologies. Enterprise Information Systems, 14(9–10), 1279–1303.
[19] Hulsen, T., Jamuar, S. S., Moody, A., et al. (2019). From big data to preci-
sion medicine. Frontiers in Medicine, 6, 34.
[20] Austin, C. and Kusumoto, F. (2016). The application of Big Data in medi-
cine: current implications and future directions. Journal of Interventional
Cardiac Electrophysiology, 47(1), 51–59.
[21] Galetsi, P., Katsaliaki, K. and Kumar, S. (2019). Values, challenges and
future directions of big data analytics in healthcare: a systematic review.
Social Science & Medicine, 241, 112533.
[22] Lacroix, P. (2019). Big data privacy and ethical challenges. In Big Data, Big
Challenges: A Healthcare Perspective (pp. 101–111). Springer, Cham.
[23] Hu, Z., Ge, Q., Jin, L. and Xiong, M. (2020). Artificial intelligence fore-
casting of COVID-19 in China. arXiv preprint arXiv:2002.07112.
[24] Bai, H. X., Hsieh, B., Xiong, Z., et al. (2020). Performance of radiologists in
differentiating COVID-19 from viral pneumonia on chest CT. Radiology.
[25] Zurada, J. M., Marks, R. J. and Robinson, C. J. (1994). Computational
Intelligence Imitating Life (No. CONF-940699). Institute of Electrical and
Electronics Engineers, Inc., New York, NY.
[26] Siddique, N. and Adeli, H. (2013). Computational Intelligence: Synergies of
Fuzzy Logic, Neural Networks and Evolutionary Computing. John Wiley &
Sons.
[27] Awotunde, J. B., Matiluko, O. E. and Fatai, O. W. (2014). Medical diag-
nosis system using fuzzy logic. African Journal of Computing & ICT, 7(2),
99–106.
[28] Ayo, F. E., Folorunso, S. O., Abayomi-Alli, A. A., Adekunle, A. O. and
Awotunde, J. B. (2020). Network intrusion detection based on deep learning
model optimized with rule-based hybrid feature selection. Information
Security Journal, 29(6), 267–283.
[29] Ayo, F. E., Ogundokun, R. O., Awotunde, J. B., Adebiyi, M. O. and Adeniyi,
A. E. (2020). Severe acne skin disease: a fuzzy-based method for diagnosis.
In Lecture Notes in Computer Science (including subseries Lecture Notes in
Artificial Intelligence and Lecture Notes in Bioinformatics) (Vol. 12254
LNCS, pp. 320–334). Cham: Springer.
[30] Oladele, T. O., Ogundokun, R. O., Awotunde, J. B., Adebiyi, M. O. and
Adeniyi, J. K. (2020). Severe acne skin disease: a fuzzy-based method for
diagnosis. In Lecture Notes in Computer Science (including subseries
Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence and Lecture Notes in Bioinformatics)
(Vol. 12254 LNCS, pp. 428–441). Cham: Springer.
[31] Kurd, Z., Kelly, T. and Austin, J. (2007). Developing artificial neural net-
works for safety-critical systems. Neural Computing and Applications, 16(1),
11–19.
[32] Berglund, E. and Sitte, J. (2006). The parameterless self-organizing map
algorithm. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, 17(2), 305–316.
54 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[47] Muhammad, L. J., Algehyne, E. A., Usman, S. S., Ahmad, A., Chakraborty,
C. and Mohammed, I. A. (2021). Supervised machine learning models for
prediction of COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset. SN Computer
Science, 2(1), 1–13.
[48] Haleem, A., Vaishya, R., Javaid, M. and Khan, I. H. (2020). Artificial
intelligence (AI) applications in orthopaedics: an innovative technology to
embrace. Journal of Clinical Orthopaedics & Trauma, 11, S80–S81.
[49] Bobdey, S. and Ray, S. (2020). Going viral – Covid-19 impact assessment: a
perspective beyond clinical practice. Journal of Marine Medical Society,
22(1), 9.
[50] Gozes, O., Frid-Adar, M., Greenspan, H., et al. (2020). Rapid AI develop-
ment cycle for the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic: initial results for
automated detection & patient monitoring using deep learning CT image
analysis. arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.05037.
[51] Pirouz, B., Shaffiee Haghshenas, S., Shaffiee Haghshenas, S. and Piro, P.
(2020). Investigating a serious challenge in the sustainable development
process: analysis of confirmed cases of COVID-19 (new type of cor-
onavirus) through a binary classification using artificial intelligence and
regression analysis. Sustainability, 12(6), 2427.
[52] Smeulders, A. W. and Van Ginneken, A. M. (1989). An analysis of pathol-
ogy knowledge and decision making for the development of artificial
intelligence-based consulting systems. Analytical and Quantitative Cytology
and Histology, 11(3), 154–165.
[53] Hussain, A. and do Vale Moreira, N. C. (2020). Clinical considerations for
patients with diabetes in times of COVID-19 pandemic. Diabetes &
Metabolic Syndrome, 14(4), 451.
[54] Gupta, R., Ghosh, A., Singh, A. K. and Misra, A. (2020). Clinical con-
siderations for patients with diabetes in times of COVID-19 epidemic.
Diabetes & Metabolic Syndrome, 14(3), 211.
[55] Riba, M., Sala, C., Toniolo, D. and Tonon, G. (2019). Big data in medicine,
the present and hopefully the future. Frontiers in Medicine, 6, 263.
[56] Dinh-Le, C., Chuang, R., Chokshi, S. and Mann, D. (2019). Wearable health
technology and electronic health record integration: scoping review and
future directions. JMIR mHealth and uHealth, 7(9), e12861.
[57] McCue, M. E. and McCoy, A. M. (2017). The scope of big data in one
medicine: unprecedented opportunities and challenges. Frontiers in
Veterinary Science, 4, 194.
[58] Tariq, N., Asim, M., Al-Obeidat, F., et al. (2019). The security of big data in fog-
enabled IoT applications including blockchain: a survey. Sensors, 19(8), 1788.
[59] Adeniyi, E. A., Ogundokun, R. O. and Awotunde, J. B. (2021). IoMT-based
wearable body sensors network healthcare monitoring system. In IoT in
Healthcare and Ambient Assisted Living (pp. 103–121). Springer, Singapore.
[60] Hofdijk, J., Séroussi, B., Lovis, C., Sieverink, F., Ehrler, F. and Ugon, A.
(2016). Transforming healthcare with the Internet of Things. In Proceedings
of the EFMI Special Topic Conference.
56 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[61] Mital, R., Coughlin, J. and Canaday, M. (2015). Using big data technologies
and analytics to predict sensor anomalies. In AMOS (p. 84).
[62] Berman, E., Felter, J. H. and Shapiro, J. N. (2020). Small Wars, Big Data:
The Information Revolution in Modern Conflict. Princeton University Press.
[63] Raghupathi, W. and Raghupathi, V. (2014). Big data analytics in healthcare:
promise and potential. Health Information Science and Systems, 2(1), 3.
[64] Teijeiro, D., Pardo, X. C., González, P., Banga, J. R. and Doallo, R. (2018).
Towards cloud-based parallel metaheuristics: a case study in computational
biology with differential evolution and spark. The International Journal of
High Performance Computing Applications, 32(5), 693–705.
[65] Candela, L., Castelli, D. and Pagano, P. (2012). Managing big data through
hybrid data infrastructures. ERCIM News, 89, 37–38.
[66] Marjani, M., Nasaruddin, F., Gani, A., et al. (2017). Big IoT data analytics:
architecture, opportunities, and open research challenges. IEEE Access, 5,
5247–5261.
[67] Assuncao, M. D., Calheiros, R. N., Bianchi, S., Netto, M. A. and Buyya, R.
(2013). Big data computing and clouds: challenges, solutions, and future
directions. arXiv preprint arXiv:1312.4722, 10.
[68] Hashem, I. A. T., Yaqoob, I., Anuar, N. B., Mokhtar, S., Gani, A. and Khan,
S. U. (2015). The rise of “big data” on cloud computing: review and open
research issues. Information Systems, 47, 98–115.
[69] Singh, D. and Reddy, C. K. (2015). A survey on platforms for big data
analytics. Journal of Big Data, 2(1), 8.
[70] Awotunde, J. B., Folorunso, S. O., Jimoh, R. G., Adeniyi, E. A., Abiodun, K.
M. and Ajamu, G. J. (2021). Application of artificial intelligence for
COVID-19 epidemic: an exploratory study, opportunities, challenges, and
future prospects. In Artificial Intelligence for COVID-19 (pp. 47–61).
Springer, Cham.
[71] Steed, C. A., Ricciuto, D. M., Shipman, G., et al. (2013). Big data visual
analytics for exploratory earth system simulation analysis. Computers &
Geosciences, 61, 71–82.
[72] Chae, S., Kwon, S. and Lee, D. (2018). Predicting infectious disease using
deep learning and big data. International Journal of Environmental Research
and Public Health, 15(8), 1596.
[73] Bansal, S., Chowell, G., Simonsen, L., Vespignani, A. and Viboud, C.
(2016). Big data for infectious disease surveillance and modeling. The
Journal of Infectious Diseases, 214(Suppl. 4), S375–S379.
[74] Eisenstein, M. (2018). Infection forecasts powered by big data. Nature,
555(7695).
[75] Buckee, C. (2020). Improving epidemic surveillance and response: big data
is dead, long live big data. The Lancet Digital Health, 2(5), e218–e220.
[76] Awotunde, J. B., Jimoh, R. G., Oladipo, I. D., Abdulraheem, M., Jimoh, T.
B. and Ajamu, G. J. (2021). Big data and data analytics for an enhanced
COVID-19 epidemic management. In Artificial Intelligence for COVID-19
(pp. 11–29). Springer, Cham.
Application of big data and computational intelligence 57
[77] Kent, J. (2020). Understanding the COVID-19 pandemic as a big data ana-
lytics issue. Erişim Tarihi, 11, 2020.
[78] Giordano, G., Blanchini, F., Bruno, R., et al. (2020). A SIDARTHE model of
COVID-19 epidemic in Italy. arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.09861.
[79] Chen, B., Shi, M., Ni, X., et al. (2020). Visual data analysis and simulation
prediction for COVID-19. arXiv preprint arXiv:2002.07096.
[80] Tátrai, D. and Várallyay, Z. (2020). COVID-19 epidemic outcome predic-
tions based on logistic fitting and estimation of its reliability. arXiv preprint
arXiv:2003.14160.
[81] Strzelecki, A. (2020). The second worldwide wave of interest in coronavirus
since the COVID-19 outbreaks in South Korea, Italy and Iran: a Google
Trends study. arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.10998.
[82] Long, Y. S., Zhai, Z. M., Han, L. L., et al. (2020). Quantitative assessment of
the role of undocumented infection in the 2019 novel coronavirus (COVID-
19) pandemic. arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.12028.
[83] Mahajan, A., Sivadas, N. A. and Solanki, R. (2020). An epidemic model
SIPHERD and its application for prediction of the spread of COVID-
19 infection in India. Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 140, 110156.
[84] Heroy, S. (2020). Metropolitan-scale COVID-19 outbreaks: how similar are
they? arXiv preprint arXiv:2004.01248.
[85] Awotunde, J. B., Ogundokun, R. O., Adeniyi, A. E., Abiodun, K. M., and
Ajamu, G. J. (2022). Application of mathematical modelling approach in
COVID-19 transmission and interventions strategies. Studies in Systems,
Decision and Control, 366, 283–314.
[86] Zhao, X., Liu, X. and Li, X. (2020). Tracking the spread of novel cor-
onavirus (2019-nCoV) based on big data. medRxiv.
[87] Zhou, C., Su, F., Pei, T., et al. (2020). COVID-19: challenges to GIS with
big data. Geography and Sustainability, 1, 77–87.
[88] Jin, Y. H., Cai, L., Cheng, Z. S., et al. (2020). A rapid advice guideline for
the diagnosis and treatment of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) infected
pneumonia (standard version). Military Medical Research, 7(1), 4.
[89] Ahmed, S. F., Quadeer, A. A. and McKay, M. R. (2020). Preliminary iden-
tification of potential vaccine targets for the COVID-19 coronavirus (SARS-
CoV-2) based on SARS-CoV immunological studies. Viruses, 12(3), 254.
[90] Banerjee, A., Santra, D. and Maiti, S. (2020). Energetics based epitope
screening in SARS CoV-2 (COVID 19) spike glycoprotein by immuno-
informatic analysis aiming to a suitable vaccine development. bioRxiv.
[91] Ganasegeran, K. and Abdulrahman, S. A. (2020). Artificial intelligence
applications in tracking health behaviors during disease epidemics. In
Human Behaviour Analysis Using Intelligent Systems (pp. 141–155).
Springer, Cham.
[92] Ge, Y., Tian, T., Huang, S., et al. (2020). A data-driven drug repositioning fra-
mework discovered a potential therapeutic agent targeting COVID-19. bioRxiv.
[93] Enayatkhani, M., Hasaniazad, M., Faezi, S., et al. (2020). Reverse vacci-
nology approach to design a novel multi-epitope vaccine candidate against
58 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[111] Cottle, M., Hoover, W., Kanwal, S., Kohn, M., Strome, T. and Treister, N.
(2013). Transforming Health Care Through Big Data Strategies for
Leveraging Big Data in the Health Care Industry. Institute for Health
Technology Transformation, http://ihealthtran. com/big-data-in-healthcare.
[112] Hotelling, H. (1933). Analysis of a complex of statistical variables into
principal components. Journal of Educational Psychology, 24(6), 417.
[113] Folorunso, S. O., Awotunde, J. B., Adeboye, N. O. and Matiluko, O. E.
(2022). Data classification model for COVID-19 pandemic. In Advances in
Data Science and Intelligent Data Communication Technologies for
COVID-19 (pp. 93–118). Cham: Springer.
[114] Dalal, N. and Triggs, B. (2005, June). Histograms of oriented gradients for
human detection. In 2005 IEEE Computer Society Conference on Computer
Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR’05) (Vol. 1, pp. 886–893). IEEE.
[115] Cohen, J. P., Morrison, P., Dao, L., Roth, K., Duong, T. Q. and Ghassemi,
M. (2020). Covid-19 image data collection: prospective predictions are the
future. arXiv preprint arXiv:2006.11988.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Cloud-based IoMT for early COVID-19
diagnosis and monitoring
G. Boopathi Raja1, T. Sathya1, V. Gowrishankar1 and
M. Parimala Devi1
Abstract
COVID-19 has been posing a threat to survival from the second half of 2019. Each
country in the world must fight against the COVID-19 pandemic with caution. Many
researchers around the world have developed many vaccines, but some of them are
found to be effective. This chapter introduces an effective scheme for the diagnosis
and tracking of patients with COVID-19 based on symptoms. The concept behind the
proposed approach is to use an Internet of Things (IoT)-based system to handle the
real-time symptom data from patients in order to diagnose coronavirus cases early.
Additionally, the framework has the ability to track the medical records of those who
have healed from the COVID-19 disease. The proposed framework must learn
automatically about the origin of the virus by monitoring and analyzing necessary
data. Because of the significant and rapid rise in the number of patients after the
COVID-19 pandemic, it is crucial to focus an eye on patients’ health before any new
disease or infection occurs. IoT security has recently become a serious concern and a
hard problem. For researchers, transferring the large amount of collected healthcare
information data of patients who do not want their personal healthcare details shared
has remained a difficult task. The health status of patients is determined in this model
by predicting critical situations and examining physiological data received from
smart medical IoT devices, ensuring that patients’ personal information is kept pri-
vate. Based on current advancements, the suggested model is thought to be
suitable for delivering an appropriate remote patient monitoring model with accurate
data in cloud-based IoT systems.
1
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Velalar College of Engineering and
Technology, Erode, India
62 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
3.1 Introduction
As of May 27, 2021, more than 168 million COVID-19 confirmed cases had been
recorded worldwide since its detection in late December 2019, with a daily rise of
about 5%. More than 95,000 people have died as a result of these incidents,
representing a 4.2% mortality rate. The World Health Organisation classified this
unique coronavirus as a pandemic on March 11, 2020. Unfortunately, there is no
effective therapy or vaccination available at this time. The production of an
effective vaccine was done, and it had taken over a year, especially because the
identification of the existence of the virus is a challenging task. However, the
production of the number of vaccines to the entire population worldwide is not
sufficient due to a lack of resources [1].
Coronaviruses are a broad category of viruses with a wide range of char-
acteristics. Some of these make sick people with colds. Others infect animals such
as cattle, camels, and bats. The first human coronavirus was found in the year
1965. It was the cause of a common cold. During the decade, researchers
uncovered a set of identical human and animal viruses with crown-like appear-
ances [2].
Seven coronaviruses are capable of infecting humans. In 2002, the deadly
SARS virus was identified in southern China and rapidly spread to 28 other
countries. More than 8,000 persons had been affected by July 2003, with 774 of
them dying. Only four additional cases were reported in a minor epidemic in 2004.
Fever, headaches, and respiratory problems such as coughing and breathing pro-
blem are all symptoms of the coronavirus [3].
In 2012, MERS was discovered for the first time in Saudi Arabia. Nearly 2,500
cases are found among the people who stay in or visited the Middle East recently.
The coronavirus, though less contagious than SARS, is more deadly, having killed
858 people. It involves respiratory problems similar to a regular cold, but it can also
lead to renal failure.
Currently, the only method in the world for dealing with this coronavirus is to
use social isolation, hand washing, and face masks to limit its spread. By allowing
for early identification and tracking of new outbreaks, technology, on the other
hand, could be able to help limit the disease’s spread. These approaches require
cloud, big data, and fog capabilities, as well as the handling of information col-
lected via remote monitoring to track the real-time health status of the patients
located at long distances, teleHealth, m-Health [4]. This research presents an
effective approach for the diagnosis and tracking of COVID-19 patients that uses
wearable sensor technology to capture real-time symptom data.
The summary of this chapter is discussed as follows. Section 3.2 elaborates the
symptoms of COVID-19, possible diagnostic methodologies, therapeutic techniques,
suitable vaccination along the important happenings worldwide as a COVID-19
timeline. The existing works along with the requirements are described under
Section 3.3. Section 3.4 introduces the methodology and architecture of the proposed
framework along with a flow diagram. Section 3.5 describes the implementation of
the proposed framework cloud-based IoMT system for early COVID-19 diagnosis
Cloud-based IoMT for early COVID-19 diagnosis and monitoring 63
and monitoring. Section 3.6 demonstrates the results and discussion with
suitable illustrations.
3.2.1 Symptoms
COVID-19 has a wide range of impacts on different people. The majority of sick
people will have minor to severe symptoms and will heal without needing to go to
the hospital. Patients having COVID-19 have a different range of problems ranging
from mild to moderate pain and sometimes up to life-threatening sickness. COVID-
19 has a wide range of impacts on different people. The majority of sick people will
have minor to severe symptoms and will survive without requiring even going to
the hospital. Symptoms include nausea or vomiting, severe diarrhea, and a new lack
of taste or odor [5].
Fever, dry cough, and fatigue are the most common symptoms in COVID
patients. Any of the less common symptoms are aches and pains, indigestion, fever,
loss of color in fingers, lack of taste or odor, a rash on the scalp, conjunctivitis, and
sore throat. COVID-19 symptoms include tiredness, difficulties in movement, and
shortness of breath or difficulty in breathing, chest pain, and loss of speech.
Patients who are experiencing severe symptoms require prompt medical
intervention. Mild symptoms should be managed at home by otherwise healthy
people. When a patient is infected with the virus, signs usually start after 5–6 days,
although it can take up to 14 days.
COVID-19 illness is more likely to have major symptoms in the elderly and
those with severe chronic medical problems such as heart disease or diabetes.
Patients experiencing problems in breathing, persistent discomfort or pain in
the chest, gray, pale or blue-colored skin, lips, or nail beds, depending on skin tone,
and an inability to wake or stay awake should seek immediate medical assistance.
For the time being, the most widely used procedures for diagnosing COVID-19
are RT-PCR and immunological testing. These procedures, however, necessitate
the use of qualified staff. Furthermore, the findings of PCR might take up to a few
days to get. Antibodies and recombinant proteins are required for immunological
tests. As a result, there is a tendency toward developing new SARS-CoV-2 diag-
nostic procedures that are quicker, less expensive, and more reliable.
The findings of RT-PCR can be received in a few hours and have good sen-
sitivity and specificity. In addition to lung samples, saliva, blood, urine, and stools,
it may identify viral DNA. However, there are significant disadvantages to RT-
PCR, including the requirement for a costly thermocycler and experienced
employees to execute the experiment and interpret the data. Furthermore, bench-
mark validation is critical for the validity of the data, as false-negative findings
might occur as a result of sample deterioration, sample collection quality and time,
and inefficiency of some test kits. The sensitivity and specificity of LAMP tech-
niques are equivalent to those of RT-PCR. Some kits, on the other hand, have
reduced sensitivity. It can be done for about half an hour with a crude sample,
allowing them to be used in POC testing. SARS CoV-2 detection has also been
created using the CRISPR approach, which has great sensitivity and specificity. It
takes 1 h to complete and can be used with the lateral flow assay [7]. For LAMP
and CRISPR, a costly thermocycler is not required. A lateral flow assay is a simple
approach that may be used by nonprofessionals to produce findings in 15 min in
blood or serum samples. Storage, shipping, and sample collection do not affect
antibodies. Its disadvantage is that it takes a long time to manufacture antibodies.
Although ELISA is simple to use, it cannot be utilized for early detection like the
lateral flow test. It can, however, be used to test the immunity of healthcare workers
and to investigate herd immunity.
Live-attenuated vaccine
A virus that seems to be alive and has been diluted, or one that is highly close, is
used in a live-attenuated vaccine. Rubella, mumps, and measles vaccinations, as
well as chickenpox and shingles vaccinations, fall under this category. This process
is equivalent to the production of neutralizing antibodies and may be done in huge
quantities. People with weakened immune systems, on the other hand, may not be
able to benefit from such vaccinations.
December 31, 2019 The Wuhan Municipal Health Commission has confirmed a cluster of
pneumonia cases in Hubei Province, China. A new coronavirus was
later discovered
January 4, 2020 A group of pneumonia cases was reported by the WHO on social
networking sites in Wuhan, Hubei province, although no deaths
were reported
January 12, 2020 COVID-19’s genetic sequence was published by China
January 13, 2020 The first occurrence of COVID-19 outside of China was confirmed in
Thailand
January 20 and 21, A short field visit to Wuhan was performed by WHO specialists from
2020 the China and Western Pacific regional offices
February 3, 2020 The International Community’s Strategic Preparedness and Response
Plan, published by the WHO, would help in the security of countries
with poor health systems
February 11 and 12, Over 400 experts and key contributors from across the world attended
2020 a COVID-19 Research and Innovation Forum, which featured
lectures by experts from CDC
March 19, 2020 ● All incoming international flights banned in India
Indian government
March 20, 2020 ● WHO delivered 1.5 Million Lab test kits to many countries
April 2, 2020 Global corona virus cases recorded the one million; mortality exceeds
50,000
April 8, 2020 Global corona virus cases surpass 1.5 million
April 22, 2020 First trials for a corona virus vaccine are approved by Germany
May 3, 2020 The total number of fatalities in the United States was 65,464 people
May 7, 2020 The UN reports that the corona virus has affected 14 million people.
The mortality rate in the United States has reached 1 lakh
May 28, 2020 Latin America accounted for about 40% of COVID-19 mortality
worldwide
June 11, 2020 In July, the Biotech company Moderna began the last phase of a
testing for a corona virus vaccine on 30,000 people
June 23, 2020 The region’s first vaccination trial has begun in South Africa. At the
same time, the number of people who have died as a result of the
corona virus in Latin America has reached 1 lakh
June 24, 2020 India reports over 15,000 and it was the highest single-day rise new
corona virus infections
July 2, 2020 In spite of corona virus cases surpass 600,000 and 17,834 deaths, India
announces reopening measures
July 16, 2020 India records 1 million corona virus cases. The corona virus outbreak
rises in rural areas of the country
(Continues)
68 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
August 1, 2020 More than 57,000 new victims were reported in India
August 13, 2020 COVID-19 cases have increased by over 67,000 in India. It appears
that this is the largest daily rise since the epidemic began
August 15, 2020 Russia starts production of vaccine: Sputnik V COVID-19
September 4, 2020 India has reached 83,000 new positive victims
September 5, 2020 India currently has 90,000 daily cases, overtaking Brazil as the country
with the second-highest number of cases
October 12, 2020 After a volunteer experience an unexpected illness, Johnson &
Johnson suspends its COVID-19 vaccination trials
October 29, 2020 COVID-19 cases have reached 8 million in India
November 20, 2020 ● The world passes 50 million corona virus cases
● Preliminary data suggest that Pfizer and BioNTech’s vaccine is
March 12, 2021 The vaccine developed by Johnson & Johnson has been approved by
the WHO for emergency use
April 20, 2021 According to the WHO, worldwide COVID-19 cases have risen for the
seventh week in a row. The number of people who have died as a
result of the coronavirus has exceeded 3 million worldwide
May 1, 2021 In a single day, India becomes the first country to report over 4 lakh
cases
May 28, 2021 ● Globally, the total confirmed cases of COVID-19 have reached over
169,021,000, with more than 3,511,000 deaths and over
118,593,000 recoveries
● The total number of COVID-19 cases has crossed 30 million in
South Asia
● India is the most heavily affected country in Asia, but neighboring
countries such as Nepal, Bangladesh, and Pakistan are also suffering
from the disease
5. Detecting HD in the event of an HTN diagnostic test and predicting HTN risk
and severities.
6. Providing the medical teams with the disease prediction process’s analytical
results.
Cloud-based IoMT for early COVID-19 diagnosis and monitoring 69
continually recorded without being contacted. This system has a minimum of four
primary sensors to update patient’s data regularly. This information is updated on
mobile phones for monitoring purposes.
Monitor respiration rate, temperature, and pulse of a patient are a major con-
cern and hence the data acquired by the signal conditioning unit could be connected
to mobile phones of the patients. The system monitors COVID-19 patients in real
time rapidly. The efficiency of the monitoring system has improved by the data
collected from the sensors, which are saved in the cloud also in a regular period.
This system not only helps the suspected COVID-19 patients but also helps
healthcare providers to monitor many patients in remote places.
come into contact with a potentially confirmed person. The second characteristic
(live) indicates whether the person resided, traveled to, or passed through a con-
taminated location. As a result, a 14,767-data-record preprocessed dataset was
produced. There were 854 COVID-19 cases whose records had been confirmed and
622 COVID-19 cases whose records had not been confirmed.
values. The label of that test case is determined by the largest value among these
probabilities.
K-Nearest neighbors (K-NN). It belongs to supervised learning. The process
of learning moves at a slow pace. There is no model creation.
K-NN calculates the similarities among a given test instance along with all the
training instances for a specific set of labeled training examples (each case corre-
sponds to either the positive or negative class). The test instance’s class label is
then assigned (or predicted) using these distances. The class names of the K
training samples closest to the test sample are combined to achieve this.
Decision table. Another example of a supervised learning approach is the
decision table. In this technique, it generates a decision table from a set of labeled
training cases to calculate a classifier (each case corresponds to either the positive
or negative class). The table is made up of a series of criteria and actions. It is said
to be complete when it assesses all combination cases for the criteria and provides
appropriate steps with each of them.
Decision stump. This technique belongs to supervised learning. In this tech-
nique, it creates a decision tree for only one input feature to find a model from a
group of labeled training instances. Alternatively, it makes a forecast for each test
instance based just on one sample attribute. Each component is selected by calcu-
lating the entropy of all features across all training samples and choosing the one
with the highest accuracy.
Zero rule (ZeroR). These types of algorithms fall under the category of
supervised learning. Based on the group of labeled training cases, this algorithm
defines a classifier using just the target feature (i.e. class) and neglecting most of
the other features. It belongs to the basic classification approach. The majority class
is assigned to any new test instance. It is usually utilized as a starting point for
determining baseline performance.
One rule (OneR). Another technique that falls under supervised learning is
OneR. This technique generates one rule for every feature in the dataset from a set
of labeled training instances (each case corresponds to either the positive or
negative class). After that, the one with the smallest overall error is selected.
and from any location. Because of the significant and rapid rise in the number of
patients after the COVID-19 pandemic, it is crucial to focus on patients’ health
before any serious symptoms occur.
Cloud
Physiological Uploading
parameters patients data
e
antin
Quar
Centre
for quarantine and isolation
Collecting Centre
and uploading of symptom data for quarantine and isolation
Fever, cough, fatigue, sore throat and
shortness of breath are examples of Maintaining digital records of those who
relevant symptoms that may be collected have been placed in quarantine or
using wearable devices. In addition to isolation, including confirmed and
user data such as travel and contact suspected cases
information.
Health experts
Suspected cases should be monitored and Contact suspected cases and medical
reviewed facilities.
The scenario of the framework (or process) is depicted in Figure 3.2, which
may be summarized as follows.
The system uses smart biowearable sensors to collect noninvasive real-time
user symptom data. Cough, sore throat, fatigue, fever, and shortness of breath are
the symptoms again. Furthermore, the user enters information regarding living in
(or traveling to) contaminated locations, as well as probable interaction with
COVID-19-affected people, using a mobile application. Regularly, the quarantine/
isolation center delivers statistics on isolated and confined patients who are held
there. That information is analogous to the real-time information obtained from
patients.
Using Google assistant, the collected symptom data is sent to the cloud data
analysis center. Regularly, the smart biowearable sensor sends data to the health-
care center for data analysis. The data analysis center is home to AI algorithms that
update their models daily using data from the research center. Based on each user’s
real-time symptom data, the AI classifiers are then used to identify possible
76 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
instances. The data center’s data is evaluated in real time, and the results are dis-
played on a dashboard. The dashboard may be used by doctors to understand more
about the virus’s characteristics.
If a possible case is detected, the relevant physician will be alerted and the
patient will be immediately followed. After that, the patient will be called and
invited to come in for clinical testing, such as a PCR test to detect positive
instances. If the infection is confirmed, the victim will be quarantined and sepa-
rated from his or her contacts.
The use of the identical mobile app to communicate with consumers, deliver-
ing critical information about how to avoid illness and then being treated with
antibiotics, is an additional and critical component of this strategy.
Data preprocessing
Normal Abnormal
condition condition
Yes No
End of treatment procedure Is the patient
critical?
Emergency Non-emergency
case case
Forwarding the diagnostic Forwarding the
results to the patients, family diagnostic results to
members and informing to the patients
emergency service providers
Provide immediate
Allow them to home
hospitalization to the patient
for continuous monitoring and quarantine
treatment
patients with normal symptoms (moderate), and patients with light symptoms or
no symptoms. Based on suggestions provided by experts, the keywords asso-
ciated with each symptom are grouped in each category.
Based on the command provided by the patient through the Google
Assistant, this setup automatically maps that patient to the corresponding
patient group. Through this, doctors can be able to give treatment on a
priority basis.
78 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Cloud storage/
Connectivity via analytics
Patient with high fever IFTTT
Patient 1
Connectivity via
IFTTT
Google assistant
Connectivity via
Patient having mild
IFTTT
symptoms
Patient having no
Patient 2
symptoms Data analytics center
and hospital
Patient 3
Google assistant
Google assistant
Status of each patient can be tracked
continuously from cloud using
adafruit application
COVID-19 has a wide range of impacts on different people. The majority of sick
people will have minor to severe symptoms and will survive without requiring even
Cloud-based IoMT for early COVID-19 diagnosis and monitoring 79
going to the hospital. Symptoms include nausea or vomiting, severe diarrhea, and a
new lack of taste, tiredness, difficulties in movement, and shortness of breath or
difficulty in breathing, chest pain, and loss of speech.
Figure 3.6 shows Google Assistant response for a person having cough
symptoms. Based on symptoms (cough) provided, the immediate response will be
provided to the patient. Figure 3.7 shows a Google Assistant response for a person
having no symptoms.
Patients who are experiencing severe symptoms require prompt medical
intervention. Mild symptoms should be managed at home by otherwise healthy
people. When a patient is infected with the virus, signs usually start after 5–6 days,
although it can take up to 14 days. COVID-19 illness is more likely to have major
symptoms in the elderly and those with severe chronic medical problems such as
heart disease or diabetes.
Figure 3.8 shows Google Assistant response for a person having fever and
Figure 3.9 shows Google Assistant response for a person having severe fever.
Based on the status provided, immediate actions will be taken.
Figure 3.6 Google Assistant response for person having cough symptoms
Figure 3.7 Google Assistant response for person having no symptoms
Figure 3.9 Google Assistant response for patient having high fever symptoms
Figure 3.10 illustrates that the cumulative reports of all the patients under
treatment are listed along with time. This report is continuously tracked and ana-
lyzed by health experts for further decisions.
Due to the increasing elderly population and persons suffering from life-threatening
chronic conditions, as well as the high expenses of care for all of these patients, the
rising demand for the health-monitoring framework required for the patients at
remote places has become a prime requirement in the present scenario in terms of
the coronavirus (novel COVID-19) pandemic. Real-time monitoring and analysis
of a patient’s health status can show crucial and abnormal circumstances, which
can aid in the early detection of any potentially fatal ailment. Advanced technol-
ogies along with cloud resources and medical IoT devices are critical in the
development of digital remote health-monitoring systems.
82 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Figure 3.10 Cumulative reports of all the patients through Adafruit API
References
[1] Parimaladevi M., Sathya T., Gowrishankar V., Boopathi Raja G. and Nithya
S. An Efficient Control Strategy for Prevention and Identification of
COVID-19 Pandemic Disease. In: Tripathi S. L., Dhir K., Ghai D., Patil S.
(eds) Health Informatics and Technological Solutions for Coronavirus
(COVID-19). (CRC Press, 2021). https://doi.org/10.1201/9781003161066.
[2] Coronavirus History: https://www.webmd.com/lung/coronavirus-history.
[3] COVID-19: A History of Coronavirus: https://www.labmanager.com/lab-
health-and-safety/covid-19-a-history-of-coronavirus-22021.
[4] Kamta N. M. and Chinmay C. A Novel Approach Toward Enhancing the
Quality of Life in Smart Cities using Clouds and IoT-Based Technologies.
In: Digital Twin Technologies and Smart Cities, Internet of Things
(Technology, Communications and Computing), pp. 19–35. (Springer,
2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-18732-3_2.
[5] Symptoms of COVID-19. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/
symptoms-testing/symptoms.html.
Cloud-based IoMT for early COVID-19 diagnosis and monitoring 83
[6] Sheikhzadeh E., Eissa S., Ismail A. and Zourob M. Diagnostic Techniques
for COVID-19 and New Developments. Talanta, 220, 121392, 2020. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.talanta.2020.121392.
[7] Alpdagtas S., Ilhan E., Uysal E., Sengor M., Ustundag C. B. and Gunduz O.
Evaluation of Current Diagnostic Methods for COVID-19, APL
Bioengineering, 4, 041506, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0021554.
[8] Information for Clinicians on Investigational Therapeutics for Patients with
COVID-19. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/therapeutic-
options.html.
[9] Lalit G., Emeka C., Nasser N., Chinmay C. and Garg G. Anonymity
Preserving IoT-based COVID-19 and Other Infectious Disease Contact
Tracing Model, IEEE Access, 8, 159402–159414, 2020. 10.1109/
ACCESS.2020.3020513, ISSN: 2169-3536.
[10] Archived: WHO Timeline – COVID-19. https://www.who.int/news/item/27-
04-2020-who-timeline—covid-19.
[11] Timeline of the Corona virus: https://www.thinkglobalhealth.org/article/
updated-timeline-coronavirus.
[12] Akhbarifar S., Javadi H. H. S., Rahmani A. M. et al. A Secure Remote
Health Monitoring Model for Early Disease Diagnosis in Cloud-Based IoT
Environment, Personal and Ubiquitous Computing, 2020. https://doi.org/10.
1007/s00779-020-01475-3.
[13] Cinay D., Brian L. D and Chinmay C. Generative Design Methodology for
Internet of Medical Things (IoMT)-based Wearable Biomedical Devices,
International Congress on Human-Computer Interaction, Optimization and
Robotic Applications (HORA’21), 1–4, 2021, 10.1109/HORA52670.
2021.9461370.
[14] Amit K., Chinmay C. and Wilson J. Intelligent Healthcare Data Segregation
using Fog Computing with Internet of Things and Machine Learning,
International Journal of Engineering Systems Modelling and Simulation, 12
(2/3), 2021, 10.1504/IJESMS.2021.10036745.
[15] Amit K., Chinmay C., Wilson J., Kishor A., Chakraborty C. and Jeberson W.
A Novel Fog Computing Approach for Minimization of Latency in
Healthcare Using Machine Learning, International Journal of Interactive
Multimedia and Artificial Intelligence, 1–11, 2020. http://dx.doi.org/10.
9781/ijimai.2020.12.004.
[16] Parimala Devi M., Raja G. B., Gowrishankar V. and Sathya T. IoMT-Based
Smart Diagnostic/Therapeutic Kit for Pandemic Patients. In: Chakraborty C.,
Banerjee A., Garg L., Rodrigues J. J. P. C. (eds) Internet of Medical Things
for Smart Healthcare. Studies in Big Data, vol 80. (Springer, Singapore,
2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-8097-0_6.
[17] Boopathi Raja G., Sathya T., Ragavi P. and Parimaladevi M. Remote Based
Wireless Framework for Diagnosing Covid-19 using Internet of Things,
International Journal of Advanced Research in Computer and
Communication Engineering, 10(5), 80–83, 2021. https://doi.org/10.17148/
IJARCCE.2021.10514.
84 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[18] Otoom M., Otoum N., Alzubaidi M. A., Etoom Y. and Banihani R. An IoT-
based Framework for Early Identification and Monitoring of COVID-19
Cases, Biomedical Signal Processing and Control, 62, 102149, 2020. https://
doi.org/10.1016/j.bspc.2020.102149.
[19] Chinmay C. and Arij N. A. Intelligent Internet of Things and Advanced
Machine Learning Techniques for COVID-19, EAI Endorsed Transactions
on Pervasive Health and Technology, 1–14, 2021. http://dx.doi.org/10.4108/
eai.28-1-2021.168505.
[20] Muhammad L. J., Ebrahem A. A., Sani S. U., Abdulkadir A., Chinmay C.
and Mohammed I. A. Supervised Machine Learning Models for Prediction
of COVID-19 Infection using Epidemiology Dataset, SN Computer Science,
2(11), 1–13, 2021. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42979-020-00394-7.
[21] Sukanya R. and Chinmay C. Panic Buying Situation During COVID-19
Global Pandemic, Journal of Information Technology Management, 13(2),
231–44, 2021, DOI:10.22059/jitm.2021.80625.
[22] Adafruit IO website: https://io.adafruit.com.
[23] If This Then That (IFTTT) website: https://ifttt.com/.
Chapter 4
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global
economics and trades
Hemanta Kumar Bhuyan1 and Chinmay Chakraborty2
Abstract
The worldwide epidemic known as COVID-19 is being labeled a worldwide pan-
demic on the earlier of 2020, the globe has still not recovered. Cases rapidly spread
from China; leading world governments to take extensive infection control mea-
sures to several cases and restrict the virus’s global transmission rate. However,
these controls have undermined the contemporary world economy’s main sup-
porting pillars of global commerce and collaboration. In light of the epidemic’s
context, this chapter critically evaluates the inventory of the pandemic’s bad and
positive influences in different sections. This advocates for a complete overhaul of
the global economic development paradigm based on a linear economy system that
leverages profiteering and energy-guzzling industrial processes.
Due to the worldwide breakout of the pandemic COVID-19, the world’s
political, social, economic, religious, and financial systems have all been thrown
into total disarray. As of April 2020, an estimated 4.7 million individuals have been
tested, and the illness has resulted in a confirmed infection count of around
2.7 million individuals, with 182,740 deaths attributed to the virus. More than 80
nations have forced companies to shut, locked borders to nations in transition,
quarantined their people, and shuttered schools for around 1.5 billion school-age
children. A total global economic collapse is inevitable because of the world’s
largest economies of different countries. The global financial markets have been
battered, and tax income sources have crashed into a bottomless pit even more
worrisome. Infection is substantially affecting global economic growth. It is
anticipated that if the present growth rate continues, the virus might outpace world
economic growth by almost 2.0% per month. If the global economic slump is deep
and extensive, global commerce might decline from 13% to 32%. It will be years
before the full impact of the outbreak is revealed. It looks into the correlation
between COVID-19 and the development of the national economy and the stock
1
Department of Information Technology, Vignan’s Foundation for Science, Technology, & Research,
Guntur, India
2
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, BIT Mesra, Ranchi, India
86 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
market in order to prove how well the COVID-19 economic growth prediction is
linked with the gross domestic product. The utilization of publicly accessible data,
as found on Yahoo Finance, the International Monetary Fund, John Hopkins
COVID-19 map, and regression models was used to carry out the goal of this study.
COVID-19 is used to measure the economic effect, and the stock market serves as a
proxy for economic variability to test whether or not the forecast is reliable. In the
aim that the model can make predictions about two quarters out, it is supposed to
provide explanations for changes in the quarter ahead. This study will aid those
with government-level decision-making, business-stage strategic thinking, and
capital-market investment to better comprehend the current state of affairs and use
the model for forecasting.
4.1 Introduction
The World Health Organization (WHO) proclaimed the new coronavirus (COVID-
19) a pandemic, the world came to attention to a severe issue [1,2]. The virus
quickly spread worldwide, first to Japan, South Korea, Europe, and the United
States. In preparation for the official pandemic proclamation, early this year, sub-
stantial economic signs showed that the globe was leaning in the direction of an
unparalleled watershed in human history if not of our time [3]. Many specialists
within the professional cadres of various industries have made warnings of a global
financial disaster. Expert commentary had predicted an escalating disease crisis
but, by all accounts, the growing chaos brought by the pandemic was more than
what was expected. Based on the number of deceased individuals, the virus has
spread over 800,000 [4]. As a result, livelihoods have been interrupted for millions
of people. At the time of writing, a global recession is looming [5]. Countries
worldwide undertook strict steps to combat the epidemic while also trying to
minimize the number of cases. These included obligatory national lockdowns and
border closures.
The pillars on which these tactics have destroyed contemporary economies
rest. The financial consequences of this epidemic are still being calculated as of
now. Data is in constant motion, government policies often shift, and the virus that
kills its victims spreads from country to country, interrupting manufacturing,
introducing supply networks to dysfunction, and destabilizing financial markets
[6]. Overall, the increasing data indicates that we are at a time when the earth’s
sustainability has to be reconsidered. At the same time, though, inevitable acci-
dental environmental and ecological consequences have resulted from govern-
mental policies. Going ahead, it is now possible to imagine a significant shift to
human biological and physical activity on Earth [7]. But according to [5], noted by
these authors, our investment in global integration and economic growth is no
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global economics and trades 87
longer feasible for stable development. A possible answer to the quest for
numerous economic, environmental, and financial goals is implementing the
financial system.
On the one hand, these packages concentrate on accelerating the existing eco-
nomic status quo. On the other hand, they are dedicated to building a more sustain-
able low-carbon economy. This chapter urges for the recalibration and rethink of the
current global economic growth model, which is predicated on a linear economy
system and uses industrial methods that need excessive use of natural resources and
the pursuit of profit before the environment. Both future resilience and competi-
tiveness are made possible by this plan and the belief that future unintentional that
emerged during the corona virus calamity may be effectively utilized or frozen to
supply openings for both long-term strength and the future.
4.2 Backgrounds
Gray literature
CE strategy recommendation
after COVID-19
10 20 40
Global market share
Figure 4.2 Global product export from China to other countries as [43]
Table 4.1 Different global products shared in a different country as Figure 4.2
Table 4.2 Month-wise new COVID-19 cases in 10 most affected countries (as
k ¼ 1,000 values)
Feb 2020 Mar 2020 Apr 2020 May 2020 Jun 2020 Jul 2020 Aug 2020
India 0 0.1 1 2 6 23 70
USA 0 0.1 30 31 20 60 70
Brazil 0 0.1 1 5 20 40 50
Mexico 0 0.1 1 5 8 5 4
Colombia 0 0.1 1 2 2 3 6
Argentina 0 0.1 1 2 2 3 3
Peru 0 0.1 1 2 4 3 3
South 0 0.1 1 2 2 3 10
Africa
Iran 0 0.1 1 2 2 3 4
Russia 0 0.1 1 2 2 3 4
Table 4.3 Comparison finance effects between COVID-19 lockdown 2020 and
global financial crisis 2009
The collective GDP loss due to COVID-19 might be over $9 trillion over the
following year.
The current rise in worldwide poverty might be the first since 1998. Up to
49 million people might be forced into severe poverty because of the effect
94 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
110
100
90
Index on crisis months
80
70
60
50
For SARS (2003) NAAR
40 Square for avian flu (2005) SA
For SARS (2003) AP
30
× For SARS (2003) CDM
20 + For avian flu (2013) APAR
Dimond for MERS flu (2015) SK
10
–4 –2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Crisis on before and after months
corresponding loss in revenue of $198–$273 billion. They stated that the pro-
jected outcomes are dependent on the length and magnitude of the pandemic and
on the number of funds put toward managing the crisis, the degree of consumer
trust for air travel, the state of the global economy, and the speed of the country’s
economic recovery [44].
When losses occur in the aviation sector, it is essential to contextualize the
situation, and various other comparisons have also been made about the airline
business. Foreign passengers are expected to decrease from 44% to 80% between
2019 and 2020. Airports Council International predicted that air passenger traffic
would decline by two-fifths and cost $76 billion in 2020 if airport revenues
remain constant. IATA anticipated $113 billion in mislaid income and a 48%
decrease in domestic and international flights. Predicting an epidemic scenario is
mentioned in Figure 4.3. The history of prior illness outbreaks reveals the degree
of their influence on aviation. The 8% drop in RPKs and $6 billion in incomes for
Asia/Pacific airlines have all been down to COVID-19’s influence. While the 6-
month recovery road for SARS seems long, it offers an understanding of global
markets.
However, the aviation industry also has an obligation for several economic
aspects, such as fuel economy and waste utilization, and not just focus on income
loss due to COVID-19. This is rather unfortunate news, as per economical air
travel, since it will likely result in significant job losses. However, in the eyes of
environmentalists, these projections are hopeful, and they should motivate the
airline sector to examine greener, more sustainable methods.
96 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
World Europe Asia and the Pacific Americas Africa Middle East
January 2 6 2 0 4 6
February 9 6 37 3 4 5
March 57 60 64 46 44 41
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global economics and trades 97
30%
Spanish flu World war II Global
Great First financial
depression oil shock crisis
20%
Second
oil shock
10%
0%
–10%
–20%
1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020
Figure 4.4 Yearly rate of change with effecting energy demand highlighted
previously, average, moderate, and inactive exercisers have seen that their exer-
cise program frequencies go up by 88%, 38%, and 156%, correspondingly
improved beach cleanliness. Beaches defend the land from maritime storms and
cyclones and are essential for coastal natural capital assets. They contribute to the
sustainability of coastal communities by providing (such as tourism and leisure as
Table 4.5) valuable services. They are precious since overexploitation must be
controlled. Changes have been noticed because of the COVID-19-induced
measures.
35
30
25
20
Growth
15
10
0
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 2020
Global energy-related emissions
resources. Let us take the manufacturing industry example; around 90% of raw
materials are considered trash before leaving the production facility, yet in manu-
facturing, 80% of things made have been disposed of during the first 6 months of
their existence. Similarly, Hoornweg and Bhada-Tata [46] have found that an
annual quantity of 1.3 billion tonnes of solid waste with a total price tag of $205.4
billion. They estimate that the total quantity of this waste could grow to 2.2 billion
tonnes by 2025, which would increase the total price tag to $375.5 billion. Thus,
worldwide demand for resources is expected to increase by 2-fold by the year 2050.
Under these circumstances, it maximizes the ability to decouple financial devel-
opment from raw materials and reduce waste and building capital has intensified.
These three ideas are key in developing a comprehensive environmental sys-
tem design: create goods and materials out of waste, utilize goods and materials,
and regenerate natural systems. CE is focused on (i) I helping companies maximize
the ecological benefits of their manufacturing and product recovery activities; (ii)
bringing about a harmonious ecological partnership between corporations, con-
sumers, and governments; and (iii) moving to a manufactured goods worth that
takes into consideration the environmental impact from inception to end-of-life.
Now is the perfect opportunity to study how the CE principles may be used in
the actual world when the global economy rebounds. The pandemic has made it
abundantly clear financial system, which is falling short on solving environmental
and social problems. Humans have only intensified their interconnections and
interdependencies in the current global pandemic, with their natural environment,
economy, and social systems. This chapter will briefly explore the several possible
uses of CE as a tool in terms of mitigating climate change, helping construct well
financial system, and fostering socially equitable and inclusive societies.
used in food delivery and grocery shopping. We have hardly given attention to the
disposal of these nonbiodegradable plastics, yet most of these items are created
from them. Reaction in the environmental community has arisen due to the treat-
ment of these types of waste, resulting in reasonable apprehension in several sec-
tors. Even frustratingly, there are not many things that can be done in the present.
All that can be done is to devise appropriate waste management policies for these
potentially dangerous materials. When confronted with the complexities of typical
HCI waste management procedures, the effort is overwhelming. Another critical
step in implementing waste reduction and recycling strategies is reducing the
physicochemical complexity of HCI waste. These goals correlate with the CE
mission, which stresses waste reduction above all else.
In a study conducted by Wong et al. [52], the researchers discovered that
different materials were found in hospital wastes. Medical device manufacturers
may take steps to address the COVID-19 threat by increasing the amount of bio-
products. In fact, even with use of bioplastics and recyclable materials, there will be
medical devices and supplies that cannot be made from them. On the other hand,
there is also a lot of resistance to CE in the healthcare business (HCI). However,
environmental gains may be outweighed by health and safety risks and rules that
need for strict compliance. On the other hand, though, CE is beginning to gain
traction in HCI, helping hospital supply chains run more efficiently while reducing
operational costs while at the same time doing good with good life.
For the most part, the use of finance system is related to the movement of
materials and waste evaluation. Classifying 80% of hospital garbage as general
garbage, along with the remaining 20% as infectious trash, has shown that in recent
years, hospitals have almost doubled their general garbage generation since the
1990s. There are two kinds of HCI waste: incineration is a popular way to deal with
both of them. Large quantities are not problematic for incineration since it creates
such toxic products. Thus, lowering the amount of nonhazardous waste by using
green buying practices or lowering waste input in the manufacturing and supply
chain is molded by adopting such activities. While this might be of use in the short
term, we must take a long-term approach in tackling this problem, adopting CE.
This will enable an eventual shift to environment-friendly HCI, beginning with the
life cycle evaluation of medical products and working our way up to the concept of
reusable medical equipment. Voudrias [53] provides several CE solutions for
hospital waste management, as outlined by Kane et al. [54]. The proportion of
infectious trash increases because hospitals are doing everything they can to keep
the epidemic under control. However, it is still possible to realize the potential of
recycling large amounts of general trash using thermal, microwave, or biochemical
sterilizing methods. It should go into all aspects of building and the built environ-
ment to embrace resource efficiency.
Based on the financial section, COVID-19 has called attention to the failings of
present practices in ecology, especially regarding affordable housing and inflexible
building stocks. In some instances, people who lived in inadequate housing and tiny
dwellings with inefficient energy consumption become infected with the virus. The
situation is most apparent in impoverished nations where people cannot access
106 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
proper sanitary facilities, hindering them from adhering to safe practices that are
essential to fighting the spread of disease. Despite these concerns, a rising worry
over the industry’s resource-wasting character, coupled with the increasingly pre-
valent belief that something must be done, make a compelling argument for
reconsidering it. As a result, the CE will be positioned to propose viable solutions
to these issues.
Occupancy requirements may provide behavioral issues, and CE may assist to
balance them. Research has shown that humans spend around 90% of their time
inside. It is also probable that office and commercial space renovations need
adapting them to varying demands, such as change in occupant density, social
distance, ventilation, and the like. When there is not enough air, healthcare staff
and patients at temporary hospitals might get infected. The measure’s influence on
energy consumption must be assessed because of social distancing strategies, which
might need lower population density but higher ventilation rates. Therefore, despite
improved energy recovery being very relevant for the built environment, reducing
mechanical ventilation needs for a lesser number of people places extra require-
ments on building energy consumption. Some academics have advocated that
buildings should utilize 100% fresh outside air instead of recirculation (important
for energy savings). It helps to circulate resources and better utilize resources,
helping to reduce CO2 emissions and provide employment opportunities. In the
case of a warehouse, an ARUP study calculated that planning for steel reuse may
lead to a 6%–27% and 9%–43% savings, resulting in material cost reductions of up
to 25%. Policies that the EU is advocating would make recycled materials (a con-
cept known as material looping) a mandatory component in certain building goods
once safety and functionality have been checked. To help designers and researchers
to make their objects suited for circulation, projects of this kind should encourage
them to use material looping in their entire design approach, beginning at the
product design stage and on through the whole value chain. It has been shown that
by using this material winding process, costs for disposal are reduced and sec-
ondary materials may provide new sources of revenue. Reducing building waste
will assist to cut solid waste by a third in India.
4.7 Conclusions
The wastefulness of paradigm has been shown in COVID-19. While short-term
plans for coping with the rapid spread of the pandemic are unlikely to be long-term
solutions, the approach might work for a while until something better comes along.
Their findings underscore crucial concerns, such as the vital relationship between
pollution in the environment and the pollution generated by cars and industry.
Unrestricted air travel is clearly implicated in the spread of many viral epidemics,
with industries like tourism and aviation being seriously impacted owing to
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global economics and trades 109
References
[1] Sohrabi, C., Alsafi, Z., O’Neill, N., et al., World Health Organization
declares global emergency: a review of the 2019 novel coronavirus
(COVID-19). Int. J. Surg. 2020, 76: 71–76.
[2] WHO, Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Pandemic. World Health
Organization, 2020. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-cor-
onavirus-2019.
[3] Gopinath, G., Limiting the Economic Fallout of the Coronavirus With Large
Targeted Policies. IMF. March 10, 2020.
[4] JHU, MAPS & TRENDS: New Cases of COVID-19 In World Countries.
Coronavirus Resource Center, Johns Hopkins University (JHU) 2020.
https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html.
[5] Naidoo, R. and Fisher, B., Reset sustainable development goals for a pan-
demic world. Nature 2020, 583(7815): 198–201.
[6] Sarkis, J., Cohen, M.J., Dewick, P. and Schröder, P., A brave new world:
lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic for transitioning to sustainable supply
and production. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2020, 159: 104894.
[7] Anderson, R.M., Heesterbeek, H., Klinkenberg, D. and Hollingsworth, T.D.,
How will country-based mitigation measures influence the course of the
COVID-19 epidemic?. Lancet 2020, 395: 931–934.
[8] Piguillem, F. and Shi, L., The optimal COVID-19 quarantine and testing
policies. EIEF Working Papers Series 2004, Einaudi Institute for Economics
and Finance (EIEF), 2020.
[9] Ibn-Mohammed, T., Application of mixed-mode research paradigms to the
building sector: a review and case study towards decarbonising the built and
natural environment. Sustain. Cities Soc. 2017, 35: 692–714.
[10] Snyder, H., Literature review as a research methodology: an overview and
guidelines. J. Bus. Res. 2019, 104: 333–339.
[11] Grant, M.J. and Booth, A., A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14
review types and associated methodologies. Health Inf. Libr. J. 2009, 26:
91–108.
[12] Bloom, D.E. and Cadarette, D., Infectious disease threats in the 21st century:
strengthening the global response. Front. Immunol. 2019, 10: 549.
[13] Bloom, D.E. and Canning, D., Epidemics and economics. In Interactions
between Global Change and Human Health, 2004, Scripta Varia 106.
pp. 304–331. Vatican City: The Pontical Academy of Sciences.
[14] Hotez, P.J., Alvarado, M., Basáñez, M.-G., et al., The global burden of
disease study 2010: interpretation and implications for the neglected tropical
diseases. PLoS Negl. Trop. Dis. 2014, 8: e2865.
[15] Saunders-Hastings, P.R. and Krewski, D., Reviewing the history of pan-
demic influenza: understanding patterns of emergence and transmission.
Pathogens 2016, 5(4): 66.
[16] Horrox, R., The Black Death. Manchester University Press, 2013, pp. 1–364.
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global economics and trades 111
[17] Wagner, D.M., Klunk, J., Harbeck, M., et al., Yersinia pestis and the Plague
of Justinian 541–543 AD: a genomic analysis. Lancet Infect. Dis. 2014, 14:
319–326.
[18] Gibbs, M.J., Armstrong, J.S. and Gibbs, A.J., Recombination in the
hemagglutinin gene of the 1918 “Spanish flu”. Science 2001, 293: 1842–
1845.
[19] De Cock, K.M., Jaffe, H.W. and Curran, J.W., The evolving epidemiology of
HIV/AIDS. AIDS 2012, 26: 1205–1213.
[20] Lee, J.-W. and McKibbin, W.J., Estimating the global economic costs of
SARS. Learning from SARS: Preparing for the Next Disease Outbreak:
Workshop Summary. National Academies Press, Washington, DC, 2004,
pp. 92.
[21] Baseler, L., Chertow, D.S., Johnson, K.M., Feldmann, H. and Morens, D.M.,
The pathogenesis of Ebola virus disease. Annu. Rev. Pathol. 2017, 12: 387–418.
[22] Murray, N.E.A., Quam, M.B. and Wilder-Smith, A., Epidemiology of den-
gue: past, present and future prospects. Clin. Epidemiol. 2013, 5: 299–309.
[23] Fernandes, N., Economic effects of coronavirus outbreak (COVID-19) on
the world economy. 2020. Available at SSRN 3557504.
[24] McKee, M. and Stuckler, D., If the world fails to protect the economy,
COVID-19 will damage health not just now but also in the future. Nat. Med.
2020, 26: 640–642.
[25] McKenzie, B., Beyond COVID-19: supply chain resilience holds key to
recovery. Oxford Econ. 2020, 24: 20.
[26] Muhammad, L.J., Ebrahem, A.A., Sani, S.U., Abdulkadir, A., Chinmay, C.
and Mohammed, I.A., Supervised machine learning models for prediction of
COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset. SN Comput. Sci. 2021,
2(11): 1–13. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42979-020-00394-7.
[27] Gupta, A.K, Chinmay, C. and Gupta, B, Monitoring of epileptical patients
using cloud-enabled health-IoT system. Trait. Signal, IIETA 2019, 36(5):
425–31. https://doi.org/10.18280/ts.360507.
[28] Sukanya, R. and Chinmay, C., Panic buying situation during COVID-
19 global pandemic. J. Inf. Technol. Manage. 2021, 13(2): 231–44.
DOI:10.22059/jitm.2021.80625.
[29] Chinmay, C. and Abougreen, A.N., Intelligent Internet of Things and
advanced machine learning techniques for COVID-19. EAI Endorsed Trans.
Pervasive Health Technol. 2021, 7: 1–14. http://dx.doi.org/10.4108/eai.28-1-
2021.168505.
[30] Bhuyan, H.K., Kamila, N.K. and Jena, L.D., Pareto-based multi-objective
optimization for classification in data mining. Cluster Comput. 2016, 19(4):
1723–1745.
[31] Bhuyan, H.K., Kamila, N.K. and Pani, S.K., Individual privacy in data
mining using fuzzy optimization. Engineering Optimization, Taylor &
Francis, May 2021. pp. 1–19.
[32] Baldwin, R. and Evenett, S., Covid-19 and Trade Policy: Why Turning
Inward Won’t Work. CEPR Press, London, 2020.
112 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[33] Ranney, M.L., Griffeth, V. and Jha, A.K., Critical supply shortages—the
need for ventilators and personal protective equipment during the Covid-19
pandemic. N. Engl. J. Med. 2020, 382(18): e41.
[34] Bhuyan, H.K. and Kamila, N.K., Privacy preserving sub-feature selection in
distributed data mining. Appl. Soft Compu. Elsevier, November 2015,
volume 36. pp. 552–569,
[35] Bhuyan, H.K. and Kamila, N.K., Privacy preserving Sub-feature Selection
based on fuzzy probabilities. Cluster Comput. 2014, 17(4): 1383–1399.
[36] Bhuyan, H.K., Chakraborty, C., Pani, S.K. and Ravi, V.K., Feature and sub-
feature selection for classification using correlation coefficient and fuzzy
model. IEEE Trans. Eng. Manage. 2021. 10.1109/TEM.2021.3065699.
[37] Iyengar, K., Bahl, S., Vaishya, R. and Vaish, A., Challenges and solutions in
meeting up the urgent requirement of ventilators for COVID-19 patients.
Diabetes Metab. Syndr. 2020, 14(4): 499–501.
[38] Solomon, M.Z., Wynia, M. and Gostin, L.O., Scarcity in the Covid-19
pandemic. Hastings Cent. Rep. 2020, 50: 3.
[39] Bown, C.P., COVID-19: demand spikes, export restrictions, and quality
concerns imperil poor country access to medical supplies. In Trade
Protection in the Age of COVID-19. CEPR Press VoxEU.org eBook, 2020,
volume 31, pp. 1–179.
[40] Browne, M., Sweet, M., Woodburn, A. and Allen, J., Urban freight con-
solidation centres final report 10 Transport Studies Group, University of
Westminster, 2005.
[41] Livingston, E., Desai, A. and Berkwits, M., Sourcing personal protective
equipment during the COVID-19 pandemic. JAMA 2020, 323(19): 1912–1914.
[42] WHO, Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): situation Report – 107, 2020, pp. 1–17.
[43] Javorcik, B., Global supply chains will not be the same in the post-COVID-
19 world. COVID-19 and Trade Policy: Why Turning Inward Won’t Work
111, 2020.
[44] Wang, P., Chen, K., Zhu, S., Wang, P. and Zhang, H., Severe air pollution
events not avoided by reduced anthropogenic activities during COVID-19
outbreak. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2020, 158: 104814.
[45] IEA, Global Energy Review, The impacts of the COVID-19 crisis on global
energy demand and CO2 emissions. International Energy Agency. IEA
Publications, 2020, pp. 1–56.
[46] Hoornweg, D. and Bhada-Tata, P., What a waste: a global review of solid
waste management, 2012.
[47] Gates, B., COVID-19 is awful. Climate change could be worse. Climate and
the Coronavirus, GatesNotes, 2020. https://www.gatesnotes.com/Energy/
Climate-and-COVID-19.
[48] Korhonen, J., Honkasalo, A. and Seppälä, J., Circular economy: the concept
and its limitations. Ecol. Econ. 2018, 143: 37–46.
[49] Bhuyan, H.K., Chakraborty, C., Shelke, Y and Pani, S.K., COVID-19 diag-
nosis system by deep learning approaches. Expert Syst. 2021: e12776.
https://doi.org/10.1111/exsy.12776.
Assessment analysis of COVID-19 on the global economics and trades 113
[50] Bhuyan, H.K. and Ravi, V., Analysis of sub-feature for classification in data
mining. IEEE Trans. Eng. Manage. 2021: 1–15 (Early Published).
[51] Bhuyan, H.K., Dash, S.K., Roy, S. and Swain, D.K., Privacy preservation
with penalty in decentralized network using multiparty computation. Int. J.
Adv. Comput. Technol. 2012, 4(1): 297–303.
[52] Wong, K.-F.V., Narasimhan, R., Kashyap, R. and Fu, J., Medical waste
characterization. J. Environ. Health 1994: 19–25.
[53] Voudrias, E.A., Healthcare waste management from the point of view of
circular economy. Waste Manage. 2018, 75: 1–2.
[54] Kane, G.M., Bakker, C.A. and Balkenende, A.R., Towards design strategies
for circular medical products. Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 2018, 135: 38–47.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 5
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using
cloud-based IoMT for COVID-19
Madhura S. Mulimani1, Shridhar Allagi1,2 and
Rashmi R. Rachh1
Abstract
The entire globe has been battling with deadly coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-
19) pandemic from the time December 2019. Around 190 million people have been
affected by the virus, and 4 million have lost their lives to it. It has adversely
influenced the socio-economical lives of people in almost all countries across the
world. Hence, it is essential to detect the disease at an early stage and ensure that
the transmission of the virus is curbed, in turn, saving the lives of many other
people. With the advancements and developments in the information technology
field, it is possible to diagnose infectious diseases like the current COVID-19
pandemic at an early stage and give proper treatment to the infected. In addition to
analyzing the disease early, many other approaches are employed to deal with this
deadly disease. In this chapter, various Internets of Things that are being used to
track the patients’ health and provide them the necessary care and treatment even in
remote locations have been discussed. Also, machine learning and deep learning for
early diagnosis and remote monitoring have been discussed. An experimental case
study using COVIDX dataset has been discussed along with the results.
Comprehensive experiments have been carried out with varying computed tomo-
graphy (CT) sizes of CT images and an average accuracy of above 80% has been
achieved. In all, how the use of technology in the medical field proves beneficial
and how it can be leveraged even further to control the spread of the diseases has
been elucidated in this chapter.
1
Department of Computer Science, Visvesvaraya Technological University, Belagavi, India
2
Department of Computer Science, KLE Institute of Technology, Hubballi, India
116 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
5.1 Introduction
An unusual coronavirus called the very severe acute respiratory syndrome
coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2), initially discovered in China’s Hubei province,
Wuhan, at the end of December 2019, has caused a calamitous event and impacted
entire world economy to collapse adversely, further engendering the societal and
political disruptions. As of July 16, 2021, more than 190 million people worldwide
have been infected with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), and around four
million have succumbed to it, as per the John Hopkins University and Medicine,
Coronavirus Resource Center, United States [1,2].
Once an individual is exposed to the virus, it may usually take about 5–6 days
to show signs. Individuals with slight symptoms may recoup independently, but
others may suffer from severe symptoms, especially if they already suffer from
other health ailments such as diabetes or heart problems. Animals, too, can get
affected by this virus and can transmit the infection [3].
The pandemic has been rising mainly due to global travels and exploitation of
the environment. Hence, it is crucial to recognize any emergent epidemics and
formulate policies to restrain and thwart the spread of COVID-19 contamination
and save the lives of individuals worldwide, which can be done by detecting the
disease early and ensuring proper treatment for the patients diagnosed with
COVID-19 as well as for the safety of public health [4].
Since there was no vaccine for COVID until recently, the only way to cure or
prevent it was through its early diagnosis. This helps to avoid its further spread
wherein the patients are advised to quarantine or isolate themselves. Most of the
patients with COVID-19 stay asymptomatic. Others demonstrate mild-to-moderate
symptoms with high fever, shortness in breathing, mild cough, and signs alike oxygen
capacity dipping or sometime lung auscultation. These all signs and indications play a
decisive role in ascertaining any infection and execution of further diagnostic tests [5].
Several preventive tools and measures that are being used to prevent the
infection from spreading use personal protective equipment, properly used face-
masks, face-shields, use of gloves, and ventilators [4], washing hands repeatedly
with soap for 25–30 s, continuing social distance, masking mouth and nose with a
disposable tissue paper while sneezing and so on [6]. In addition to all this, to curb
the spread of the disease, there is a need for expeditious and precise testing of
COVID-19 in people, considering the furious spread of the disease.
This major contribution of the chapter includes a comprehensive coverage of
various Internet of Medical Things (IoMT) devices that are being used in the
medical field for diagnosing and remote monitoring of patients with different dis-
eases, procedures carried out during early diagnosis of COVID-19 and remote
monitoring of home isolated or quarantined patients, an experimental case study
that uses machine learning (ML) with deep learning (DL) techniques to distinguish
between the computed tomography (CT) images of normal and COVID-19-infected
patients mainly to identify and diagnose if the patient has been infected with
COVID-19, and various measures that different countries are adopting to thwart the
spread of the virus from affecting more people.
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 117
People who are infected by the virus and exhibit symptoms such as fever, cough,
body aches, running nose, headache, and sore throat undergo specific tests. The
following two categories of tests are used for COVID-19 detection:
The purposes of the two classes of tests overlap in the supervision of the
COVID-19 pandemic. The first class of testing recognizes persons infected with
SARS-CoV-2 during the critical phase of contamination. In contrast, the second
class of testing recognizes individuals within whom antibodies to the virus have
118 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
increase of infected patients has made it more difficult for domain experts to
complete the diagnosis on time. Hence, some computer-aided diagnostic systems
that generally use CT scans are needed to manipulate better and understand the
CCT images. ML approaches have been successfully applied to diagnose lung
diseases. They have also been used to analyze COVID-19 using CCT images with
unpredictable sources and amounts of data [5].
The sensitivity of CT scan images in diagnosing and detecting COVID-19
cases is higher. However, their low-specificity represents that CT scan is extra
precise in COVID-19 cases but less in nonviral pneumonia instances [2]. CCT
scans have been used to detect COVID-19-related lung damage effectively.
However, this diagnostic has some limits.
The CT findings are conventional in a few patients at the beginning of the
infection. Hence, using the CT alone causes it to have a negative prognostic value.
Since the CT scans have a high false-positive rate, it could lead to difficulties in
detecting non-COVID-19 cases. Moreover, if it necessitates for patients to have
manifold CT scans in the course of the disease, the CT scanner rays can harm them
and cause complications.
Hence, the American College of Radiology advises against CT scans as the
first line of diagnosis. Since a CT scan is expensive and there is disease transmis-
sion risk while using the CT scan device, it leads to serious complexities for the
patient and the healthcare systems. Hence, it is advisable to replace a CT scan with
CXR radiography if medical imaging is needed.
Compared to CT scans, X-ray imaging is inexpensive and has widespread
usage. Since the digital image need not be transferred from the contact point to the
examination point, the diagnostic process is accomplished much more swiftly.
Chest radiography is beneficial and quick for the medical triaging of patients. X-ray
imaging expects less occasional and less affluent equipment [2].
healthcare and medical care applications and are based on communication between
machines through wireless connectivity to transfer data. IoMT finds usage potenti-
ality in various applications such as health monitoring, home medication, fitness
projects, chronic ailments, elderly care, and compliance with treatment. Hence, smart
devices include multiple sensors and medical devices, imaging devices, and diag-
nostics, and they form a primary part of the IoMT, the major benefits of which
include an increase in the standard of living, reduced cost, and increased user’s
knowledge in healthcare systems [8]. Hence, an IoMT platform can be defined as an
intelligent system comprising various elements such as sensors and electronic cir-
cuits, a processing unit, a network device, a storage component, and a visualization
platform. Sensors and the electronic circuits procure biomedical indicators from a
patient that are operated on by the processing unit. A network unit transmits the
biomedical information over a network and stores it in a storage unit that may either
be temporary or permanent. A visualization framework with artificial intelligence
(AI) schemes decides as per the convenience of the physician. The IoMT architecture
is presented in Figure 5.1.
IoMT systems are used in varied areas and are very ubiquitous. They play a
crucial role in the healthcare sector and provide real-time surveillance using
wireless body area networks, AI and the cloud-based remote health testing, remote-
healthcare-monitoring (RHM), and wearable health-monitoring devices. They also
Data is forwarded to
Public internet network layer
network
provide real-time, continuous, and remote monitoring of patients. They can make
healthcare more convenient and efficient, especially regarding accuracy, visibility,
accessibility, reliability, continuity, and real-time tracking. For example, hospita-
lized patients suffer massive money on the patients, healthcare centers, and insur-
ance companies. In addition, it is extremely difficult for all those patients who live
in remote locations and cannot easily access either the hospitals or caregiver cen-
ters. In such cases, they may need to travel lengthy distances to pursue healthcare.
However, with the advancement in IoT, they are being used for RHM due to their
characteristic features such as interoperability, communication, and information
exchange. This, in turn, has enabled RHM to provide an enhanced and continuous
monitoring for chronic diseases. Hence, they qualify to be excellent candidates that
can predict, prevent, and monitor any emerging transmissible diseases such as
COVID-19. In the IoMT system, end-user devices such as health monitors, tags, or
cell phones use wearable sensors/devices to gather the remote data for patients.
They then store the collected data in the cloud databases and send the data to the
cloud platform for real-time analysis and application, i.e., for caregivers’ decision-
making and analytics. Hence, the IoMT devices can be leveraged as an early
indication system to control infectious diseases [10].
thus, enable more viral spread. Nevertheless, to detect COVID-19 early on in real-
time, there is a contingency for accessible and inexpensive methods [11].
5.4.1 Wearables
The fight against the COVID-19 pandemic may be easier when apposite wearable
devices are used. The usage of wearable devices has proved to be an efficient and
effective way to diagnose the disease early during the pandemic as they can detect the
COVID-19 symptoms of the patients. For instance, a wearable IoT device can be used
to determine whether the respiratory symptoms of a patient are normal or not, which, in
turn, can help the patient to witness changes, if any, in their health state and accordingly
choose to have a medical appointment prior to the appearance of any other symptoms.
These technologies are defined as a blend of electronics and anything that can be
worn. They may be described as app-enabled computing technologies that use built-in
Bluetooth wireless technology to receive and process input when worn on the body or
stuck. These intelligent wearables include bands, glasses, and watches and are
designed for various purposes to be used in diverse domains like healthcare, fitness,
and lifestyle. IoT-wearable devices include smart wearable tools such as smart helmet,
smart thermometers, IoT-Q-band, smart glasses, proximity trace, and EasyBand [12].
Helmet with
optical and
thermal camera
Alarm Processing
cameras, and the built-in face detection technology makes it easy to monitor
crowds, and the tracking procedure once suspicious cases are detected. Moreover,
since Google Location History can capture the places visited by the suspicious
subject, it can effectively empower further actions with more excellent reliability.
An example of such a smart glass is the Rokid that uses infrared sensors and
monitors up to 200 people. Once these devices detect people with elevated tem-
peratures, they make the recorded information available to medical centers or
authorities.
5.4.1.4 Robots
A robot is often “a machine bearing resemblance to a living being in its capability
to move independently.” The evolution in the robotic field has led to the devel-
opment of networked robots within the cloud, and such robots are called the
Internet of Robot Things. These robots can perform various repetitive tasks, make
life easy and simple. Considering the current COVID-19 pandemic situation, dif-
ferent robots such as telerobots, autonomous robots, social robots, and collaborative
robots are being used.
IoT-linked robots can be used in the initial diagnosis of the infection. These
robots remarkably process a patient’s treatments and lower work stress levels for
the healthcare workers. These autonomous robots can help in combating all phases
of COVID-19. For example, autonomous swab test robot can collect throat swabs
samples from patients and help in the process of diagnosis, and as a result, it can
prevent the medical team from getting infected. Vayyar Imaging and Meditemi are
the two companies that have jointly developed a robot to carry out this process,
called the Intelligent Care Robot. It uses a quick scanning of a person within a span
of 1-m without touching any control or interface and captures the breathing signs
and thermal reading to detect the COVID-19 symptoms in just 10 s. Xenex disin-
fection robot is used to sterilize virus and bacteria-contaminated areas like hospitals
and helps in reducing the possibility of infection for the healthcare staff.
124 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
5.4.1.5 Drones
A drone is simply an aircraft that is flown with little or no human operation with the
help of a remote monitor. It is an aerial vehicle with no crew onboard and is called
the unmanned or uncrewed aerial vehicle (UAV) and functions using GPS, sensors,
and transmission services. Drones with IoT implementation within them are called
the Internet of Drone Things, and such drones perform varied tasks such as mon-
itoring, searching with delivering. The smart drones are usually operated using a
smartphone and a controller unit and require a least amount of time and energy.
Hence, they can be resourcefully used in various fields such as defense, agribusi-
ness, and medicare. IoT-based drones include a range of drones such as disinfectant
drones, medical drones, thermal imaging drones, multipurpose drones, surveillance
drones, announcement drones. Multipurpose drones that are usually used in the
healthcare domain are now primarily being used to combat the COVID-19
pandemic.
In the initial diagnosis phase of COVID-19, it is imperative to find the infected
people in the crowd. To hasten the process of finding the infected people and areas,
the most common way is to use the UAV, and more specifically, the IoT-based
drones during the pandemic. Since drone technology reduces human communications
and reaches difficult-to-access locations, it is much more useful, especially during the
COVID-19. Combining such drones with virtual reality (VR) as a vesture gadget can
help detect individuals with elevated thermal readings. A Canadian company has
developed the Pandemic Drone application that remotely monitors and detects any
cases of infection. It captures the biological parameters such as temperature, any
sneezing or coughing, and respiratory signs such as heart rate [12].
collects the metrics such as resting heart rate (RHR), respiratory rate, and heart rate
variability (HRV) and transfers data via wireless communication to the mobile devi-
ces on which the connected WHOOP app runs. From that point onward, data is
conveyed to a WHOOP system that consists of protected cloud-based data storage and
processing server. The system provides physiological data as follows:
● Respiratory rate: The average number of respirations per minute represents the
respiratory rate. The photoplethysmogram present in the strap uses photo-
plethysmography to derive this value every single night for the key sleep
period duration.
● Resting heart rate (RHR): It represents the average values of beats per minute
(bpm) inspected in the previous 5-min duration of the past occurrence of slow-
wave sleep each night.
● Heart rate variability (HRV): It uses the root mean square of successive RR
interval difference method to investigate the slow wave sleep sample during
the last 5–10 min of the previous incident each night. It is expressed in units of
milliseconds.
WHOOP system is usually used to track physiological data automatically.
With additional functionality, it has been able to track COVID-19 symptoms as
well as test outcomes during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic. Since the primary
stages of the infection may have measurable signs, recognizing SARS-CoV-2
condition before and during the first days of symptoms could help recognize all
those entities who need to self-isolate or quarantine and seek testing [14].
Clinical testing and image testing, which do not have many transformations, differ
mainly in their procedures. In clinical testing forms, filing procedures take a long
time and are annoying, especially in urgent situations. In contrast to this, image
testing does not have long processes to be followed. In clinical testing, doctors
themselves analyze the reports. This testing is slightly more accurate than image
128 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
testing. One needs to rely on the computer, which will intelligently perform tasks
until precise instructions are given. These two types of tests differ mainly in terms
of cost. Image testing is more economical than clinical testing. CT scans can also
be evaluated for other viruses to distinguish them from the coronavirus using dif-
ferent DL-based techniques [3].
ML and DL approaches have established themselves as valuable approaches
that can assess gigantic high-dimensional features of medical images. CT or X-ray
discoveries of COVID-19 sufferers and that of other uncommon diseases like
pneumonia are quite alike. ML and DL approaches can be used to discern between
COVID-19 and other pneumonia conditions robotically. COVID-19 can also be
discerned from other diseases using drug-induced viruses or immune-pneumonitis.
Various DL approaches such as VGG-16, Ensemble, InceptionNetV3, MobileNet
v2, ResNet, Xception, CNN, KNN, and Truncated Inception Net have been used to
evaluate chest images of COVID-19 patients, and their solicitation has produced
hopeful results. This is significant as X-rays are easily acquirable and cost little.
The significant advantage of these methods are that in addition to diagnosing
COVID-19 patients, they can even forecast the austerity of COVID-19 pneumonia
and the threat of fleeting mortality. The number of studies conducted to measure
each of the X-ray and CT images is almost the same, even though the X-rays are
less expensive when compared to the CT images. Some other research studies have
applied procedures on both kinds of images. Several independent studies have
shown that convolution neural networks (CNN)-based methods have classified
COVID-19 patients from further causes of pneumonia or even related ailments with
an accuracy of 99.99%. This means that these approaches can be used as screening
procedures for the primary assessment of COVID-19 cases.
Though both ML and DL approaches can be used for the stated objective, they
vary in some regards. For example, ML can use a minor amount of data from the
users, while DL requires a massive volume of labeled training data for a succinct
denouement. ML methods require the users to accurately define the features.
However, DL methods require high-performance hardware. DL generates features
on its own and, hence, consumes more time to train when compared to ML. ML
divides the tasks into smaller ones and later combines the obtained results into one
conclusion. On the contrary, DL uses end-to-end principles to resolve the problems.
DL is a rapid and efficient method used for the identification and forecast of
various ailments mainly due to its good accuracy rate. Hence, it can be used in
medical science as the most efficient technique. Models are explicitly trained to
categorize the inputs into various classes as per the programmers’ preference. Such
models are used in the medical field for multiple tasks such as detecting heart
problems, diagnosing cancer and tumors using image analysis, and several addi-
tional applications. They are also exploited to discriminate between CT scan ima-
ges of the patients diseased with COVID-19 as positive or negative. In the medical
field, DL method such as CNN efficiently processes CT scan images to the parti-
cular model. Since a CT scan image gives a detailed image of a specific area, it
helps to detect internal defects, tumors, measurements of the parts, injuries, etc.,
and thus, a CT scan proves to be more reliable than RT-PCR method in the case of
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 129
COVID-19 and efficiently classifies the images of COVID-19 patients with great
accuracy at a faster rate.
Additionally, during the COVID-19 pandemic, they were able to detect the reti-
cular pattern, ground-glass-opacities, alliance, and crazy tiling pattern, which are the
hallmarks of COVID-19 infection. However, CT scans have side effects, such as
patient exposure to radiation when numerous CT scans are conducted. Diagnosing the
disease early largely increases the chances of treating the disease or the virus in a
better way. Sometimes a few minor symptoms can steer in diagnosing a major illness
like cancer or a minor disease like a simple viral, which can be wrongly predicted [3].
5.8.2 Methodology
In this segment, we discuss the proposed model for screening patients’ CT scan
images using DL models such as CNN. The model is iteratively trained with nor-
mal and COVID-infected CT images. The images in the dataset are preprocessed to
fit in the considered model. The proposed model consists of the following stages:
(1) Preprocessing and (2) EfficientNet-B0 architecture.
The flow diagram for the proposed model is given in Figure 5.4.
1. Preprocessing:
The image dataset has been captured in real time. The intensity of pixels across
an image varies. For any CNN, it is essential to normalize the pixels across the
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 131
31,020
21,400
18,000
5,000
4,500
3,580
Normal Pneumonia COVID
(a)
Training Testing
44,520
21,400
18,000
8,500
4,500
3,580
Figure 5.3 (a) Data distribution of variant A and (b) data distribution of variant B
image. For this purpose, we have used pixel intensity normalization of all
pixels in the range [0, 1]. This process also helps in the training stage of model
convergence.
For any of the CNNs, images are to be reduced to standard size. Once the
images are reduced, there is a scope of loss of data. Since the cost involved in
EfficientNet is low in terms of memory and latency, we do not have to reduce
the size of the image. Thus, the information in image can be retained.
Figure 5.5(a) and (b) shows the sample images of COVID CT scan and Normal
CT scan, respectively.
132 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
COVIDX-dataset
Variant A Variant B
Classification
Preprocessing
Model
Size reduction
convergence Evaluation metrics
Model training
Image augmentation
EfficientNet-B0 architecture
2. EfficientNet-B0 architecture:
The EfficientNet-B0 baseline architecture belongs to the family of multi-
objective neural networks. It is further developed for B1–B7 to achieve a
higher accuracy rate. Table 5.2 describes the architecture.
The three parameters, width, depth, and resolution are scaled using compound
coefficient parameters ∅ for the proposed model. The alpha, beta, and gamma scaling
multipliers are used as per (5.1)–(5.3) to compute the depth, width, and resolution.
Depth D ¼ a∅ (5.1)
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 133
(a) (b)
Width W ¼ b∅ (5.2)
Resolution R ¼ g∅ (5.3)
w:r:t:a b g 2; a 1; b 1 and g 1
2 2
The proposed model uses various residual blocks with different configurations
with swish activation functions and inverted residual blocks. Using swish activation
is to minimize the error and increase the accuracy as ReLu produces unexpected
changes. The Swish activation function can be represented as (5.4). Here, it does
not nullify the negative values as ReLu:
Sx ¼ X Sigmod ðX Þ (5.4)
5.8.3 Training
In DL models, large datasets need to be used in the training model because of the
complexity in computations involved. But, in real time, availability of a large
dataset is challenging, and hence, to address this issue, we employ the technique of
data augmentation. We increased the sample size by transformation operations over
134 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Data
augmentation
augmentor
images such as rotation, scaling, and flip. Figure 5.6 gives the sample instance of
data augmentation operation.
The image augmentations are performed using the python augmenter package.
The transformation parameter applied for rotation is 0–20 anticlockwise. For
scaling, it is up to 30% zoom. The operations are involved in different probability
orders on samples. Figure 5.7 shows an augmented image in the dataset.
GHz, Titan X Pascal with 12 GB, 64 GB Ram, and the TensorFlow with Keras
framework for Python. The training model initiates with a limit learning rate of
0.001 with the Adam-Optimizer for 15 epochs using categorical cross-entropy loss.
The experiment for the proposed model is carried out with varying input image
sizes, and various performance metrics are computed and shown in Table 5.3.
Figure 5.8 gives the ROC curve for the proposed approach.
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 135
ROC curve
1.0
0.8
True positive rate
0.6
0.4
0.2
interactions. Thus, the information obtained from the approach can be used to
notify the healthcare workers and people of their risk of infection [4].
2. COVID-19 monitoring using smartphones: Around the world, several
smartphone applications have been developed and deployed. Official gov-
ernments in China, India, and Singapore support some of them. Different
countries have used different approaches to monitor the spread of COVID-
19. Some countries have made it mandatory for citizens to enter their data.
Other countries are automatically tracking the movement of citizens with the
help of authorities who monitor law enforcement. These tracing applications
locate phones using Bluetooth in the vicinity that uses the identical appli-
cation. The Bluetooth signals contain data such as how often individuals
were close to each other, the distance between the individuals. The result of
a person testing positive is uploaded to the app, and depending on how close
other people were to the person, a notification is sent to them who may have
been exposed to the virus.
3. COVID-19 tracking with search queries and news coverage: Any keywords in
Google search queries or any daily news coverage related to COVID-19 are
analyzed using ML to track COVID-19 [12]. Cloud services may either be paid
or free and use different transmission models like Zigbee, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, for
short-distance transmissions and LTE, Sigfox, etc., for long-distance trans-
missions, which are especially used to transmit data to the cloud and are
included on the IoT. IoT defines the connection between humans and devices
that allow all or a subset of the devices to connect to execute the intended job
exclusive of human interaction [24].
One method that can limit the spread of the disease is to use a surveillance system
that can track the infected and exposed individuals and the clinical outcomes.
However, since these surveillance systems have limitations regarding factors such
as spatial resolution, timeliness, and scalability, reporting in these systems has the
tendency to be specific to a nation or a region. They may not have adequate
evidence about maladies at the community or city level. This affects the social
distancing and quarantine measures, and as a result, the disease cannot be con-
tained [16].
IoT and innovative medical devices can monitor and screen patients’ health
conditions anywhere, anytime. As a result, the healthcare systems have improved
tremendously and can provide timely services in various locations. However, due to
the novel COVID-19 pandemic, there has been an unexpected and massive increase
in patients. Hence, it is imperative to constantly monitor the patient’s health con-
ditions to avoid any serious disorder or infection. The IoT and smart medical
devices produce gigantic volumes of sensitive information about patients.
However, the patients do not want their personal and sensitive information to be
disclosed. This raises serious security concerns concerning IoT data [25].
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 137
References
[1] Seshadri DR, Davies EV, Harlow ER, et al., Wearable Sensors for COVID-
19: A Call to Action to Harness Our Digital Infrastructure for Remote
Patient Monitoring and Virtual Assessments. Frontiers in Digital Health.
2020; 2: 8.
[2] Ghaderzadeh M and Asadi F, Deep Learning in the Detection and Diagnosis
of COVID-19 Using Radiology Modalities: A Systematic Review. Journal
of Healthcare Engineering. 2021: 1–10.
[3] Shah V, Keniya R, Shridharani A, Punjabi M, Shah J and Mehendale N,
Diagnosis of COVID-19 Using CT Scan Images and Deep Learning
Techniques. Emergency Radiology. 2021; 28: 497–505.
[4] Allam M, Cai S, Ganesh S, et al., COVID-19 Diagnostics, Tools, and
Prevention. Diagnostics. 2020; 10(409): 1–33.
[5] Abbasi WA, Abbas SA, Andleeb S, et al., COVID: An Expert System to
Diagnose COVID-19 and Predict Its Severity Using Chest CT Scans:
Application in Radiology. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked [Internet]. 2021;
23(100540):1–8. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.imu.2021.100540.
[6] Khanday AMUD, Rabani ST, Khan QR, Rouf N and Mohi Ud Din M,
Machine Learning based Approaches for Detecting COVID-19 Using
Clinical Text Data. International Journal of Information Technology
(Singapore). 2020; 12: 731–9.
138 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[7] Carter LJ, Garner LV, Smoot JW, et al., Assay Techniques and Test
Development for COVID-19 Diagnosis. ACS Central Science IN FOCUS
[Internet]. 2020; 6: 591–605. Available from: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.
1021/acscentsci.0c00501.
[8] Bharati S, Podder P, Mondal MRH and Paul PK, Applications and
Challenges of Cloud Integrated IoMT. In: Studies in Systems, Decision and
Control [Internet]. Springer International Publishing; 2021. p. 67–85.
Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-55833-8_4.
[9] Vishnu S, Jino Ramson SR and Jegan R, Internet of Medical Things (IoMT)
– An Overview. In: ICDCS 2020–2020 5th International Conference on
Devices, Circuits and Systems. 2020. p. 101–4.
[10] Aman AHM, Hassan WH, Sameen SAL, Attarbashi ZS and Alizadeh M, IoMT
amid COVID-19 Pandemic: Application, Architecture, Technology, and
Security. Journal of Network and Computer Applications. 2021; 174: 1–20.
[11] Mishra T, Wang M, Metwally AA, et al., Pre-Symptomatic Detection of
COVID-19 from Smartwatch Data. Nature Biomedical Engineering
[Internet]. 2020; 4: 1208–20. Available from: https://www.nature.com/arti-
cles/s41551-020-00640-6.
[12] Nasajpour M, Pouriyeh S, Parizi RM, Dorodchi M, Valero M and Arabnia HR,
Internet of Things for Current COVID-19 and Future Pandemics: an
Exploratory Study. Journal of Healthcare Informatics Research. 2020; 4(4):
325–64.
[13] Chai PR, Zhang H, Jambaulikar GD, et al., An Internet of Things Buttons to
Measure and Respond to Restroom Cleanliness in a Hospital Setting:
Descriptive Study. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2019; 21(6): 1–10.
[14] Miller DJ, Capodilupo JV, Lastella M, et al., Analyzing Changes in
Respiratory Rate to Predict the Risk of COVID-19 Infection. PLoS One
[Internet]. 2020; 15(12): 1–10. Available from: http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/
journal.pone.0243693.
[15] Otoom M, Otoum N, Alzubaidi MA and Etoom Y, An IoT-based Framework
for Early Identification and Monitoring of COVID-19 Cases. Biomedical
Signal Processing and Control. 2020; 62(102149): 1–16.
[16] Gong M, Liu L, Sun X, Yang Y, Wang S and Zhu H, Cloud-based System
for Effective Surveillance and Control of COVID-19: Useful Experiences
from Hubei, China. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2020; 22(4):
1–9.
[17] Ates HC, Yetisen AK, Güder F and Dincer C, Wearable Devices for the
Detection of COVID-19. Nature Electronics. 2021; 4(1): 13–4.
[18] Muhammad LJ, Algehyne EA, Usman SS, Ahmad A, Chakraborty C and
Mohammed IA, Supervised Machine Learning Models for Prediction of
COVID-19 Infection using Epidemiology Dataset. SN Computer Science
[Internet]. 2021; 2(1): 11. Available from: http://link.springer.com/10.1007/
s42979-020-00394-7.
[19] Dash S, Chakraborty C, Giri SK, Pani SK and Frnda J, BIFM: Big-Data
Driven Intelligent Forecasting Model for COVID-19. IEEE Access
Early diagnosis and remote monitoring using cloud-based IoMT 139
Abstract
In recent times, COVID-19 pandemic data collected via the Internet of Medical
Things–enabled channels can be transmitted seamlessly and processed remotely by
medical practitioners globally. However, the confidentiality and integrity of these
channels pose serious security concerns. The transmission of medical information,
which comprises highly sensitive personal data, must meet stringent security
requirements. In order to achieve this, blockchain has been deployed to enhance the
security, confidentially, trust, and integrity of sensitive data being transmitted over
insecure channels as a result of its cryptographic characteristics. Blockchain is
regarded as a protected and distributed structure of data, which enhances security,
simplifies the tracking, and analyses the stored medical information independently.
Additionally, blockchain allows the transmission and exchange of messages
between two parties in a network configuration, independent of sole trusted
authority. Blockchain technology is verifiably safe against an attacker who mis-
manages the scheme and compromises the central controller. Furthermore, block-
chain technology has been deployed to handle distributed medical data in standard
medical laboratories. The decentralized and immutability features of blockchain
have facilitated the rapid development of the beyond 5G wireless services for
health-related data sharing and processing. However, the adoption of blockchain
technology in medical data handling is still in its infancy, and the need for a
1
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Lagos,
Lagos, Nigeria
2
Department of Electrical Engineering and Information Technology, Institute of Digital Communication,
Ruhr University Bochum, Bochum, Germany
3
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Tandon School of Engineering, New York
University, New York, USA
4
Discipline of Electrical, Electronic & Computer Engineering, School of Engineering, Howard College
Campus, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa
5
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Birla Institute of Technology, Mesra,
Ranchi, India
142 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
rigorous study in this domain cannot be overemphasized. Toward this end, this
chapter first highlights how blockchain technology has developed in recent times
and how it is applied in the medical data-handling space. Further to this, the chapter
examines the potential benefits, key challenges, and prospects in blockchain tech-
nology. Additionally, the chapter highlights research efforts in blockchain in
healthcare, especially as it relates to the dreaded COVID-19 pandemic. The chapter
also discusses the application of blockchain technology in healthcare data-handling
practices that can build trust with automated tracking of integrity and responsible
credential verification. Finally, practical COVID-19 pandemic data were analyzed
and presented to motivate the chapter further.
6.1 Introduction
The present inconsistencies of channels through which COVID-19 pandemic data are
transmitted and collected have given rise to the increasing need for better secured, yet
more reliable, data accessible to health professionals and policy makers [1]. Globally,
these data help manage the spread of COVID-19. Through the Internet of Medical
Things (IoMT), they can be received and processed for health and environmental
benefits. The sensitivity of these data demands the highest level of channel con-
fidentiality and integrity, which are currently inadequate. In addition, the health data
transmission and processing systems designed to improve treatment outcomes may
suffer centralization and licensure that invariably leads to failure at one or more
points in the transmission or collection process [2]. In response, blockchain tech-
nology addresses this by improving the reliability of health logistics, supporting early
detection of an outbreak, and protecting users’ privacy during the pandemic [3].
Blockchain is a system of distributed databases that work using stable decen-
tralized servers and a computer network [4]. Blockchain technology manages a
record of chronological data transactions that are distributed among available nodes
in a verifiable, node-synchronized, decentralized, cost-effective, and timely manner
[5–7]. As the pandemic prevails even with control measures being developed, the
global healthcare system is consistently strained, and characteristic data have
become a precious resource to curb the spread of the virus. We also live in a
technology-driven world that is transforming rapidly. It is valuable to collect and
record digital activities like sensitive data through smart devices and digital mon-
itoring tools. Individuals give these devices access to manage their personal and
business data directly or indirectly, and even though the devices appear reliable,
data may not be handled appropriately. This gives rise to the misuse of sensitive
data that other digital or examining systems collect the data of users and their
network. In most cases, they use these data dishonorably [8]. Although this may be
a common occurrence within social Internet channels, several sensitive data have
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 143
Diagnosis time
Effectiveness
Workforce limitations
Increased
throughput
Convenience
xBlockchain helps experts to conveniently monitor and manage the care of patient
Revenue
After Bitcoin and Ethereum, the applications developed as the third blockchain
technology have been instrumental to healthcare, supply chain, and Internet of
Things (IoT) [8]. In Section 6.6, an explanation will be provided on how blockchain
can be used to handle healthcare data across the network to build trust. For many
years, the IoT has been revolutionizing the healthcare industry to improve medical
information records, collect data for prescribed drugs, and provide insurance
information [12,13]. For handling COVID-19 data, the IoMT collects important
data of patients, provides disease symptoms and trends, automates process logistics,
facilitates remote caring, and gives patients access to control their healthcare [14–
16]. Hence with one or more of these devices, it is possible to monitor patients in
real time, enable treatments, conduct check-ups, and even follow up on the progress
of improvement. In turn, this helps to deliver faster healthcare while reducing
hospital costs. With sensors in medical devices, data can be collected and securely
sent over a wireless network to a health specialist who would then analyze the data
for possible anomalies. Essentially, this has a higher potential to manage the
COVID-19 pandemic and reduce the spread of the virus more securely and reliably
than conventional strategies employed to address the widespread epidemic
experienced in the past. This is evident in the operation that expands technology
capabilities while minimizing the risk of exposing patients, medical practitioners,
and health specialists to COVID-19 since contact is only established on a critical
need basis. Patients can also improve their self-care and easily access support using
digital and communication tools developed using blockchain technology [17]. An
illustration of the operation of blockchain technology in the management of
healthcare and sensitive data using through the IoMT is shown in Figure 6.2.
In content and focus, this chapter explores how blockchain technology can
transmit medical information that comprises sensitive data associated with the
COVID-19 pandemic more securely and efficiently. This would highlight the
essential features of blockchain technology, potential challenges, and emerging
opportunities related to healthcare data of the prevailing COVID-19 pandemic.
Accordingly, the key contributions include recent developments of blockchain
technology in relation to its application to handling medical data, potential benefits,
key current and impending challenges, prospects of blockchain technology,
research efforts on blockchain technology in healthcare, blockchain technology
application to handling healthcare data, and real-time COVID-19 pandemic data
analysis. The conclusion of this chapter reiterates key findings, future research
directions, and further reading.
Patient medical
Treatment
history
checklist
Blockchain
Distributed
Cloud
ledger
storage
Lab
results
Distributed ledger
Blockchain
User 3
Distributed ledger
Blockchain
Distributed ledger
Blockchain User 5
User 4
2,000
Value (million USD)
1,500
1,000
500
0
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Year
estimated 1 000% increase in the size of blockchain technology from the year 2016
to the year 2021 worldwide [20], as shown in Figure 6.4.
The application of blockchain technology in the handling of medical data is
constantly transforming healthcare. As new measures are developed to manage the
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 147
spread of COVID-19, this has been an invaluable tool to medical experts, health-
care specialists, policy makers, and patients. In these times, digital transformation
is more than just a choice for any business. It has become essential for survival in a
rapidly changing environment with limited resources, as the COVID-19 pandemic
increasingly puts a strain on everyday companies. In healthcare, blockchain tech-
nology is making remarkable changes in managing health issues and the provision
of care. In effect, the sector is looking to become more digital with blockchain help
in data exchange, supply-chain management, and contracts [21].
The autoregression integrated moving average (ARIMA) model with machine
learning is another recent development that can be integrated into blockchain
technology. Using the available sensitive data, this model contributes to COVID-19
data handling by forecasting its outbreak or predicting the reported cases of
COVID-19 in a certain region [22]. It does this through phases of transformation,
model identification, estimation of the best suited ARIMA, and diagnostics.
Health entity
(internal system)
Database
server
External authorized
users
Application
server
Blockchain
Health entity
Web server (internal system)
Database
server
Synchronization
Internal work
stations
Application
server
database servers connected to the blockchain to store and process this medical
information. Through another application server within, authorized clinical per-
sonnel can communicate with the data system. At the same time, the medical
information from the databases of medical devices in their institutions is combined
with that of the blockchain, using a synchronizing component. This setup guaran-
tees a high level of security and data integrity in the event of breakage or con-
nectivity loss in the chain [27].
Systems for ensuring that previous analyses are not used for new diagnostic
processes have also been developed to support data handling. While these systems
have been developed over the last decade, it has also been accompanied by chal-
lenges such as incapacity for early detection of disease, poor data quality, high cost,
patient privacy, lack of interoperability, and inefficient patient data management
[28,29]. The blockchain-developed eHealth system of today improves the system’s
intervention by supporting electronic medical information solutions that overcome
the limitations of power while synchronizing clinical research and information
technology. In effect, more privacy, better scalability of data, and less fragmenta-
tion are experienced. Blockchain technology maintains integrity by securely storing
data that otherwise may be inappropriately accessed due to the instability of com-
munication networks or intermittent connection failures [27]. Other healthcare data
systems developed using blockchain technology are being applied to medical
records of several individuals at the risk of exposure to COVID-19 for swift
intervention and addressing connectivity and data transmission issues.
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 149
only intensified with the COVID-19 pandemic. Following the required procedure
and consent, several representatives work to enforce the standardization of sensi-
tive data transactions, which, for the most part, requires access to complex data
through a high level of transparency, confidentiality, and integrity. Intelligent
Healthcare Networks are being developed to track data gathered, transmitted,
received, revenue, and permission status using blockchain technology. As expec-
ted, this comes with an improved scalability and speed of health administrative
process that can also be employed in a larger situation like the fight against the
spread of COVID-19.
6.2.4 Pharmaceuticals
Pharmaceuticals and drug production play a significant role in managing the
COVID-19 pandemic, and the industry is fast moving toward blockchain technol-
ogy. Given that large data are a big part of pharmaceuticals, the management of
data is essential. Aspects of the industry that may generate a large amount of data
include pharmaceutical research for the production of vaccines and suppressants;
clinical testing; development of applications for healthcare like the IoT; and the
expansion of new regulations for drugs and supply chain. As large as these data
may be in many cases, it must also be maintained and organized. Blockchain
technology is currently improving this and providing smart security of data and
transparency in data handling and logistic activities [36]. In effect, safer drugs
production can now be enforced with minimum errors that can be detected and
traced, if any. This is important to deliver quality healthcare and minimize unsafe
drugs, especially in curbing the spread of COVID-19. Accordingly, several initiates
are currently being developed to support this. Some of these projects track and
verify pharmaceutical returns using blockchain technology that detects when a drug
is touched and the person who did. This is expanding to other applications as in the
year 2020, blockchain technology helped to combat the production of counterfeit
COVID-19 drugs, while sophisticated tools like machine learning are employed to
optimize this function in this present time [37,38]. This would require training deep
learning models using the interpreted COVID-19 dataset within the network for
data-transfer learning and data augmentation [39].
With the increase in the number of individuals vaccinated against COVID-19,
blockchain technology is implemented to accurately manage medical information
on the storage and transportation of several batches of vaccines. This is done using
the IoT through sensors affixed to the storage containers and transport vessels of
the vaccines. While helpful data are collected, transmitted, and stored on the
blockchain, healthcare institutions, regulators, and distributors can instantly view
this information to affirm the safety and effectiveness of how the vaccines were
stored and transported. This has dramatically minimized the spread of COVID-19
and maximized clinical research and trials. These require the careful handling of a
large amount of sensitive data from various sources. Blockchain functions to con-
nect these disparate data from different clinical research facilities and then create a
traceable record with an in-built safety mechanism and an audit framework
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 151
accessible to regulatory bodies and healthcare services. The basic structure of how
blockchain technology securely handles data through a supply-chain system is
shown in Figure 6.6.
In order to carry out this function for data security, blockchain technology is
developed to instantly alert authorized individuals when any attempt to alter data at
any point of the chain is detected. In compliance with regulatory requirements, this
has improved the authenticity, confidentiality, and trust in the data from healthcare
systems currently managing the COVID-19 pandemic.
Electronic
Implants medical
Ambulatory
Health records
medical
solution Smart health
devices
devices
Activity
monitoring
Connected
Peripherals equipment Lab on a chip
Home medical
devices
healthcare provision like finance, logistics, health workers, back-end data input, and
management for decision-making [43]. Generally, this improves data integrity,
reduces medical costs, and decentralizes operations. Blockchain also can deliver
precision that is essential to improve the care of patients and management of critical
health situations. At the same time, records of medical information are connected
across networks. Using the IoMT to track the different data nodes and update patient
data, these benefits consolidate real-time monitoring of health and the measures
adopted to inhibit the pandemic. Globally, blockchain technology adds benefits of
high data accuracy and reliable data security when health systems are developed
based on seamless data sharing [44,45]. Hence, blockchain technology can be used in
any data-driven areas of healthcare, including health claims, supply chain, healthcare
records, and supply chain. Top-rated potential benefits of blockchain technology in
securely handling COVID-19 data may be seen in the following.
maintain and expand their capacity to provide adequate care for patients and con-
trol a critical situation like the COVID-19 pandemic. Blockchain technology has
the potential to enable the secure transfer of valuable records of research outcomes
and clinical trials, which minimizes the possibility of errors or interference in
healthcare data records. This is possible because of the encryption associated with
blockchain. In effect, previous clinical trial logs can be tracked by blockchain while
avoiding redundant clinical trial outcomes or data that have been altered [31].
Given that this area of healthcare management is guided by manufacturing, dis-
tribution, and administration regulations, the government may provide the needed
assistance for health facilities to meet the challenges of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The fight against COVID-19 has led to several clinical trials to develop a
partial remedy for the virus. This is known to yield so much data that those may be
challenging to track. These data may also be hidden, corrupted, forged, or erased by
external influences and some researchers. In the consideration of this in handling
COVID-19 pandemic data, blockchain technology has the potential to confirm any
document transmitted through the network authentically. Blockchain may first
maintain an inalterable record of data that can all be verified for approval [47]. In
turn, the transparency and accuracy of these data build confidence in researchers,
policy makers, and medical supply firms.
6.4.1 Security
While blockchain technology provides data encryption, there are possibilities of
revealing the identity of individuals or other sensitive data, mainly when separate
medical information of an individual is linked within a network, and a public
blockchain is adopted for healthcare data [52]. Some health facilities have also
experienced attacks on their healthcare blockchain from fraudulent organizations,
and this breaches the security of sensitive data leading to a compromise of privacy.
This may also be due to a compromised data decryption and encryption function in
the blockchain, which these organizations leverage by gaining unauthorized access
to sensitive healthcare data stored. In most cases, this may not be detected early on
if the blockchain is not maintained for optimized functions. This is a significant
challenge as several reports of cyberattacks on blockchain networks control the
data functions of cryptocurrencies [53].
6.4.2 Speed
In many cases, the performance of the blockchain technology system is compromised
with a low processing speed. Although the blockchain may have great potential
benefits for combating COVID-19, inadequate data-processing speed is considered a
major challenge [54]. For health cases like the COVID-19 pandemic, more data
should be processed at high streaming speeds in data collection and transmission to
the appropriate destinations. This is because processing in blockchain technology may
introduce some latency, particularly in cases where all network nodes participate in a
data validation process during and after blockchain setup [53]. In addition to the data
load, this results in a significant processing delay. The tradeoff in improving the speed
may consider a few nodes in the data validation or consensus processes, which may
not be sufficient to deliver an optimized data function of the size of data generated
from the COVID-19 pandemic. While the public blockchain may require any node to
participate in these data processes, the security and content of data transmitted may be
inadequate to meet the need of managing the pandemic.
6.4.3 Interoperability
In order to manage the COVID-19 pandemic, it can be challenging to implement
blockchain technology where there is no existing standard for developing secure
handling of data. This makes interoperability a major challenge for developed appli-
cations that securely handle a large amount of data. There is a lack of interoperability
between two blockchain systems, so the exchange of relevant data becomes difficult
[54]. In most cases, it is impossible for one platform to synchronize with another. This
results in loss of data, inaccurate data, or delay in obtaining data. In turn, this gen-
erates an inconsistent provision of healthcare and control of the pandemic, which is
both critical end-products of handling the pandemic data securely.
leaves data unaltered once it has been saved. As a result, implementing blockchain
technology to handle data securely can be challenging given the sensitivity of the
COVID-19 data pandemic. Although, in some cases, this regulation may not be
considered when other people have to make data privacy decisions for patients who
are unable to do so, historic data for medical record purposes may be altered when
data protection regulations are effected. Nevertheless, this would be counter-
productive when erasing a medical history is desired by patients or their repre-
sentatives. In turn, it would be difficult to control the spread of COVID-19 and
develop future preventive measures with accurate data.
6.4.5 Scalability
This is another major challenge when implementing blockchain technology in
secure data handling. The scalability of blockchain technology data systems is the
capacity to handle the changing demands of handling data resources. While scal-
ability requires specialized techniques to deliver as it should, it is a significant
challenge in healthcare solutions because of the high volume of data handled in the
COVID-19 pandemic. Generally, the blockchain was built with the capacity to
store a too high volume of medical data than it can take, leading to severe perfor-
mance degradation [6]. Given the conditions of the COVID-19 pandemic, the
traffic on the blockchain would become bulky with an increasing number of
transactions daily. As each node stores all validated data transactions, a restriction
would be experienced on the size of the block and the time taken to create a block
[54]. In turn, there would be a delay in validation and data processing since the
management of the pandemic is accompanied by a high data load [55]. Hence, the
challenge of scalability also affects the speed of transactions on the network.
6.4.6 Privacy
As key data balances and details are validated by authorized network users,
blockchain technology may have privacy leakages. Although blockchain technol-
ogy has the potentials to offer patients and clinical specialists better control over
the healthcare data of individuals, which translates to better management of the
COVID-19 pandemic, it is not originally designed for this function, so at an initial
stage, sensitive data can be stored on a distributed log that is accessible to any user
on the network. This limits the privacy function of blockchain technology, espe-
cially with a weak network. Hence, the privacy function of blockchain technology
can be supported when the blockchain network is developed to have nodes that
process data without revealing any of it. This may be a good measure to handle this
challenge, but more resources would be demanded optimum function.
Nevertheless, systems that provide this optimization service to blockchain tech-
nology have been developed with newer systems underway. However, they offer no
guarantee of perfection with the optimized networks.
While implementing blockchain technology in healthcare applications persist,
some solutions have been developed to manage them. In order to prevent fraud or
unauthorized access to data in the blockchain, a mixing solution system is
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 157
blockchain is used to access and transfer data stored and processed by blockchain
elements in a typical healthcare scenario is shown in Figure 6.8.
Doctor Pharmacist
Patient Blockchain
Data analyst
Healthcare X-ray
policy maker specialist
also evaluated in relation to disease data storage, processing, and sharing. Also
addressed were optimization models on the blockchain application, like the design
of machine learning models that preserve data privacy better, which can also sup-
port collaborative learning. Overall, a disease data-handling system that integrates
machine learning models on blockchain was recommended [4].
Other studies identified new characteristics of blockchain that are of great
benefit to healthcare systems, including healthcare industry collaboration, health
business models, optimized auditability, disintermediation, and continuity [18].
Results from statistical models identify blockchain technology as a platform also
created to provide reliable recording, where initially fragmented medical informa-
tion records would be combined to easily track the health records of an individual
[69,70]. The difficulty of building a tracking capable foundation of high integrity
has led to an inconsistency in accessing healthcare records. Further to this, history-
based diagnoses are costly because of the complexity of medical information
records, privacy issues of the network, and fragmentation. Blockchain technology
offers a system to address all these through the continuous track of services, which
it provides [18]. The combination of blockchain and artificial intelligence can also
offer a solution for these healthcare data problems while also supporting the
seamless access and storage of data on the blockage. However, these ideas can be
implemented when regulatory barriers from data privacy policies are addressed or
revised to deliver healthcare or mitigate COVID-19 spread.
While many more research outputs have been presented, it is worthy of con-
sidering collaboration in healthcare to drive the development of brilliant ideas and
effect the needed change. In managing the COVID-19 pandemic by exploring
secure data handling, this is highly critical considering that a large amount of
medical data are shared among healthcare facilities and clinical experts expedi-
tiously across several miles globally.
infected, and the recovered (or deceased) [72]. Several research outputs have been
generated by modeling the outbreak using the basic susceptible recovery infectious
(SIR) model. Examples include the estimation and simulations of all the sympto-
matic cases of the COVID-19 virus in Wuhan [73]; the identification of contagion,
death rates, and recovery of COVID-19-infected individuals in Italy [74]; the
combination of a basic SIR model with probabilistic methods for the estimation of
the number of infected people in France [75]; and the use of the SIR model with a
parameter to maintain social distancing measures, in order to forecast the outbreak
stages of COVID-19 in Brazil [76]. The SIR model is more appropriate for a
localized epidemic outbreak because mostly it only examines temporal dynamics.
Hence, it can be most effective for analysis at a country, city, or state level.
Noteworthy is that the SIR model simplifies COVID-19 data analysis.
Inferentially, the model also assumes that recovered individuals who were infected
can be immune to COVID-19. While unconfirmed reports support this, the model
can capture relevant data that can be viewed to make healthcare decisions in the
control of the COVID-19 pandemic.
the COVID-19 healthcare for a patient, the techniques can incorporate data to
estimate time ratios, infection rates, and hazard ratios [78].
The models discussed earlier have been used to analyze several COVID-19
data for targeted interventions to mitigate the spread globally. Recent real-time
COVID-19 data from a few European countries are presented and analyzed as a
sample to make health-related and COVID-19 safety decisions.
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
Belgium
Croatia
Cuba
Cyprus
Estonia
Europe
European union
France
Germany
Greece
Hungary
Italy
Lithuania
Monaco
Norway
Romania
Russia
Spain
Sweden
Turkey
Ukraine
United Kingdom
Finland
Iceland
Ireland
Poland
Denmark
Table 6.2 Data on COVID-19 cases in European countries from March 2020 to
July 2021
Country March 2020 July 2021 Absolute change Relative change (%)
Belgium 0.01 127.64 127.63 1 063 558
Croatia 0.24 37.65 37.41 15 331
Cuba 0.06 688.72 688.66 10 931 105
Cyprus 4.18 983.42 979.24 23 410
Denmark 0.15 126.62 126.48 85 456
Estonia 0.21 81.2 80.98 37 667
Europe 0.39 172.46 172.07 44 120
European Union 0.62 156.32 155.7 25 195
Finland 0.13 76.36 79.23 61 420
France 0.25 288.81 288.56 115 887
Germany 0.19 19.87 19.68 10 144
Greece 0.1 225.92 255.82 266 479
Hungary 0.13 5.9 5.77 4 336
Iceland 10.88 249.5 238.62 2 192
Ireland 0.17 251.56 251.38 144 474
Italy 3.64 75.52 71.89 1 977
Lithuania 0.05 71.89 71.84 138 156
Monaco 3.64 353.1 349.46 9 601
Norway 0.66 41.9 41.24 6 258
Poland 0.06 2.77 2.71 4 512
Romania 0.02 5.78 5.75 26 159
Russia 0 159.03 159.03 –
Spain 0.25 547.89 547.64 218 185
Sweden 0.18 40.67 40.48 22 002
Turkey 0.03 155.85 1 555.82 519 413
Ukraine <0.01 25.78 25.77 859 100
United Kingdom 0.04 482.1 481.96 346 737
New confirmed cases in Europe (for every 1 million people).
Source: CCSE COVID data, John Hopkins University.
Figures 6.10 and 6.11 represent the results of the analysis of COVID-19 data
recorded in Table 6.3. This accumulated data from 2020 to 2021 was drawn from
the central, eastern, northern, northwestern, and southwestern regions of Virginia,
United States and covers the information of the number of individuals who have
been and not been vaccinated along with the outcomes of their experiences with the
COVID-19 pandemic. Accordingly, these data must contain the personal informa-
tion of individuals in Virginia and should be securely and effectively handled
across the network. These data are valuable to pharmaceuticals and useful in the
several clinical trials involved in developing vaccines that are in global circulation
to fight against the COVID-19 pandemic. Although when infected, living with the
COVID-19 virus and experiencing its symptoms is unavoidable since there is no
proven cure [79], the measure of vaccine effectiveness is evident in the reduced
number of COVID-19 cases, hospitalization, and death rates altogether. Hence, the
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 167
70,000
60,000
50,000
40,000
30,000
20,000
10,000
0
COVID-19 cases Total hospitalized Total deaths
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
COVID-19 cases Total hospitalized Total deaths
data in Table 6.3 can be analyzed using the time-to-event analysis, which captures
the effects of the virus experienced by individuals while using estimation techni-
ques to incorporate data time ratio, spread rates, and hazard ratios [78]. With this
model, clinicians and healthcare researchers can interpret outcomes appropriately
to influence the management of the pandemic.
168 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Table 6.3 Data on COVID-19 cases and vaccination status by VDH (August
2021)
Region Not fully vaccinated COVID-19 cases Total hospitalized Total deaths
Central – 44 306 1 250 622
Eastern – 57 982 2 468 776
Northern – 52 749 1 280 335
Northwest – 37 341 1 088 371
Southwest – 36 047 1 865 643
ALL – 228 425 7 951 2 747
Fully vaccinated (Virginia)
Region Fully vaccinated COVID-19 cases Total hospitalized Total deaths
Central 697 833 713 37 12
Eastern 805 413 699 45 13
Northern 1 427 757 747 28 7
Northwest 632 690 571 33 4
Southwest 543 183 629 75 14
ALL 4 642 482 3 359 218 50
Updated data on COVID-19 cases in Virginia, the United States, from December 2020 to August 2021.
Source: Virginia Department of Health—COVID-19 in Virginia.
Results from Figures 6.10 and 6.11 show some positive evidence in the
effectiveness of the vaccines, as the COVID-19 cases of those that have been fully
vaccinated are more than six times less than reported cases of those who have not
been fully vaccinated all through Virginia. Consequently, hospitalization and the
amount of recorded deaths are lower in those who have been vaccinated. While this
may be enough information to influence clinical trials, other sensitive data such as
the history of an individual’s health conditions and their personal data would be
needed for other control modalities.
Figure 6.12 reflects the updated records of total COVID-19 tests and cases in
selected African countries. This gives an idea about how the pandemic has been
managed across Africa. From Figure 6.12, it is evident that many COVID-19 tests
have been conducted across Africa, and while the cases that emerged are a lot less,
the test numbers are a good move toward the management of COVID-19.
Figure 6.13 also reflects data of the number of individuals who have recovered and
died of the disease. Results generated from Table 6.4 show that the critical cases
from COVID-19 complication may lead to death. While extensive research on the
different variants of COVID-19 is ongoing [80], these data may help clinical
experts consider preventive measures or adopt interventions to manage the disease
better for the purpose of reducing the number of reported COVID-19 cases. Hence,
risk factors and underlying health conditions that increase the susceptibility of an
individual getting infected are important medical information. To analyze these
Blockchain technology for secure COVID-19 pandemic data handling 169
Ethiopia
Libya
Kenya
Algeria
Nigeria
Mozambique
Botswana
Namibia
Zimbabwe
Ghana
Uganda
Cameroon
Rwanda
Senegal
Malawi
DRC
Angola
Madagascar
Sudan
Mauritania
Egypt
Ivory coast
Total tests Total cases
Figure 6.12 COVID-19 data of African countries showing total tests and cases
Ethiopia
Kenya
Algeria
Nigeria
Mozambique
Botswana
Namibia
Zimbabwe
Ghana
Uganda
Cameroon
Rwanda
Senegal
Malawi
DRC
Angola
Sudan
Mauritania
Egypt
Ivory coast
Madagascar
Figure 6.13 COVID-19 cases and effects in African countries showing the total
cases vs. death and recovery records (August 2021)
data from Table 6.4, the standard logistic regression model is most suitable, given
that predictive analysis for possible future outcomes is often implemented on these
data. Given that this medical information is shared among health experts managing
a COVID-19 patient, it should be handled securely. Blockchain technology pro-
vides a distributed data handling that addresses this. For a robust blockchain
170 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Table 6.4 Data on COVID-19 cases, death, and recoveries in African countries
analysis of COVID-19 data illustrated in the previous section and the limitations of
blockchain technology to be addressed.
First, blockchain technology protects the privacy of patients and authorized
users while preserving data consent and automated provenance in areas such as
healthcare, wherewith strong security, medical information can be shared between
doctors and health facilities; IoMT, where privacy is maintained for the preference
of any IoMT device; and data storage, where there are data protection and data
access control across the network. In-line with this, more blockchain technology
application systems should be built and optimized for better healthcare support that
reduces COVID-19 cases to the lowest minimum and improves other sectors. It has
been established that the potential benefits of blockchain transcend the healthcare
sector to practically all sectors that operate with data and things across a network.
Therefore beyond the COVID-19 pandemic, blockchain technology should be
adopted for better cyber security, data privacy, and communication.
However, limitations such as data policy and regulations, interoperability,
scalability, and response time are acknowledged as the major challenges to be
addressed. For stringent data policies and regulations, extensive research and
healthcare influence may introduce operational standards of blockchain technology
for handling sensitive data like that of the COVID-19 pandemic. Perhaps, only
permissioned blockchain should be adopted for the handling of COVID-19 pan-
demic data to avoid cyberattacks and unauthorized data sharing. Alternatively, the
medical information of patients can be protected by blockchain encryption that
should be updated or maintained regularly. The interoperability still experienced in
some blockchain systems prevents optimal operational communication between
two frameworks, while the synchronization of blockchain with healthcare facilities
persists, particularly in developing countries. This can be addressed with the
introduction of a few subchains that would reduce the pressure on the blockchain
network and allows smaller and quicker transactions on the blockchain. The pro-
cessing speed and efficiency of the system can also be improved with interoper-
ability when fewer nodes are involved in the validation process. However, other
optimization tools should be in place to control the tradeoff.
Scalability also limits the operation of blockchain on the network as it affects
the processing speed and the validation of transactions. It has been established that
larger networks are more costly to run nodes and take more response time. To
address this, using smaller blocks can help to provide a better scale without com-
promising the response time or increasing the processing cost. Smaller blocks are
also compatible with cloud solutions, thereby also providing better interoperability.
Future research direction may be in the design of blocks that provide optimal scale
and interaction within the network.
Existing healthcare applications also experience some security concerns
following the detection of several data leaks and attacks on blockchain applica-
tions across networks. This is critical because valuable data runs blockchain
technology systems. So compromised data defeat one of the main purposes of
adopting blockchain technology to handle data as sensitive as that of the COVID-
19 pandemic. The integration of machine learning and other system security
172 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
optimization programs in the blocks are likely to better secure data on the
network.
Given that blockchain technology systems can solve most real-world problems,
future research areas may focus on optimization strategies in areas of privacy,
security, data access, and block size. Furthermore, extensive research on blockchain
technology implementation to improve data handling may be considered since there
are currently only a few ongoing developments of working prototypes that go
through a series of clinical trials and system testing to manage blockchain limitations.
The integration of blockchain technology in big data–processing functions is also yet
to be explored. Therefore, working models for the best data management imple-
mentation practices are needed. This can play a vital role in future healthcare,
communication, IoMT, and identity management systems. However, the acceptance
of these new models would need new data regulations that support blockchain
technologies operations. Nevertheless, blockchain technology systems must comply
with the GDPR in their existing and impending solutions.
miscommunication, delayed response time, and failure at single points. This study
has also shown that blockchain can be used for other healthcare functions like
pharmaceutical supply-chain management, counterfeit drug detection, remote
health monitoring, and biomedical research. Therefore, it is important to regularly
update or maintain these systems for optimal functions in controlling the COVID-
19 and tracking other infectious diseases. As evidence, key elements of the
blockchain, like already existing smart contracts, may be expanded to enable easy
interaction between users and the blockchain, while blockchain applications may
be extended to accommodate a larger amount of data.
Acknowledgments
References
[1] A. Azim, M. N. Islam, and P. E. Spranger, “Blockchain and novel cor-
onavirus: Towards preventing COVID-19 and future pandemics,” Iberoam.
J. Med., vol. 03, pp. 215–218, 2020, [Online]. Available: http://creative-
commons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
[2] N. T. Lee, J. Karsten, and J. Roberts, “Removing regulatory barriers to tel-
ehealth before and after COVID-19,” Brookings Inst., pp. 1–24, 2020,
[Online]. Available: https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/
05/Removing-barriers-to-telehealth-before-and-after-COVID-19_PDF.pdf.
[3] D. C. Nguyen, M. Ding, P. N. Pathirana, and A. Seneviratne, “Blockchain
and AI-based solutions to combat Coronavirus (COVID-19)-like epidemics:
A survey,” IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 95730–95753, 2021.
[4] M. Hiwale, S. Phanasalkar, and K. Kotecha, “Using blockchain and dis-
tributed machine learning to manage decentralized but trustworthy disease
data,” Sci. Technol. Libr., vol. 40, no. 2, pp. 190–213, 2021, doi: 10.1080/
0194262X.2020.1859046.
[5] A. Hasselgren, K. Kralevska, D. Gligoroski, S. A. Pedersen, and A. Faxvaag,
“Blockchain in healthcare and health sciences—A scoping review,” Int. J.
Med. Inform., vol. 134, p. 104040, 2020, doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2019.104040.
[6] C. Agbo, Q. Mahmoud, and J. Eklund, “Blockchain technology in health-
care: A systematic review,” Healthcare, vol. 7, no. 2, p. 56, 2019, doi:
10.3390/healthcare7020056.
[7] A. F. da Conceição, F. S. C. da Silva, V. Rocha, A. Locoro, and J. M.
Barguil, “Electronic health records using blockchain technology,” 2018,
[Online]. Available: http://arxiv.org/abs/1804.10078.
174 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
errors and how to avoid them,” Clin. Epidemiol., vol. 12, pp. 925–928, 2020,
doi: 10.2147/CLEP.S256735.
[72] J. Chu, “A statistical analysis of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) in Italy
and Spain,” PLoS One, vol. 16, no. 3, p. e0249037, 2021.
[73] J. T. Wu, K. Leung, M. Bushman, et al., “Estimating clinical severity of
COVID-19 from the transmission dynamics in Wuhan, China,” Nat. Med.,
vol. 26, no. 4, pp. 506–510, 2020, doi: 10.1038/s41591-020-0822-7.
[74] G. C. Calafiore, C. Novara, and C. Possieri, “A Modified SIR Model for the
COVID-19 Contagion in Italy,” Proc. IEEE Conf. Decis. Control, vol. 2020-
Decem, pp. 3889–3894, 2020, doi: 10.1109/CDC42340.2020.9304142.
[75] L. Roques, E. K. Klein, J. Papaı̈x, A. Sar, and S. Soubeyrand, “Using early
data to estimate the actual infection fatality ratio from covid-19 in France,”
Biology (Basel), vol. 9, no. 5, pp. 1–11, 2020, doi: 10.3390/biology9050097.
[76] S. B. Bastos and D. O. Cajueiro, “Modeling and forecasting the early evo-
lution of the Covid-19 pandemic in Brazil,” Sci. Rep., vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 1–
15, 2020, doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-76257-1.
[77] M. E. Shipe, S. A. Deppen, F. Farjah, and E. L. Grogan, “Developing pre-
diction models for clinical use using logistic regression: An overview,” J.
Thorac. Dis., vol. 11, no. Suppl. 4, pp. S574–S584, 2019, doi: 10.21037/
jtd.2019.01.25.
[78] J. Le-Rademacher and X. Wang, “A Time-to-event data: An overview and
analysis considerations,” J. Thorac. Oncol., vol. 16, no. 7, pp. 1067–1074,
2021. doi: 10.1016/j.jtho.2021.04.004.
[79] L. J. Muhammad, E. A. Algehyne, S. S. Usman, A. Ahmad, C. Chakraborty,
and I. A. Mohammed, “Supervised machine learning models for prediction
of COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset,” SN Comput. Sci.,
vol. 2, no. 1, 2021, doi: 10.1007/s42979-020-00394-7.
[80] A. S. Lauring and E. B. Hodcroft, “Genetic variants of SARS-CoV-2 – What
do they mean?,” JAMA – J. Am. Med. Assoc., vol. 325, no. 6, pp. 529–531,
2021, doi: 10.1001/jama.2020.27124.
[81] A. Rahman, C. Chakraborty, A. Anwar, et al., “SDN–IoT empowered intel-
ligent framework for industry 4.0 applications during COVID-19 pandemic,”
Cluster Comput., pp. 1–18, 2021, doi: 10.1007/s10586-021-03367-4.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 7
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19
Aumnat Tongkaw1
Abstract
Because of the COVID-19 scenario, the viral infection rate in Thailand has sky-
rocketed as people commute to work and go about their everyday lives. Social
divides have a role in illness prevention. As a result, Thailand is focusing on
adopting different technologies to assist us in managing the gap and support
everyone’s ability to work. Adopting this technology has resulted in it being the
New Normal in use as a substitute for older systems. It also plays a role in instilling
everyone a sense of social responsibility and caution to avoid near individuals from
becoming infected; it has become an accepted part of daily life. This chapter offers
a template analysis of stakeholder interviews conducted with the aid of technology
to accomplish social distancing, which is divided into three categories: educational,
public health, and social distancing, as well as manufacturing employees. A soft-
ware usage pattern has been developed due to data analysis utilizing the content
analysis to help create social distancing for job planning and everyday use. It can
also be used to plan future smart cities.
7.1 Introduction
Since the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, the government in several nations has
adopted the phrase “social distancing.” Social distancing is a physical distancing
technique that involves establishing a distance between two individuals or among
people to limit their interaction with one another. This scenario has a considerable
influence on how the population work and interact with one another. The accept-
ability of the distance is no more than 6 ft apart. In public health, social distancing
is frequently referred to as physical distancing. In a collection of non-
pharmaceutical measures aimed at preventing the transmission of a contagious
illness by keeping a physical barrier between individuals, minimizing the number
1
Faculty of Science and Technology, Songkhla Rajabhat University, Songkhla, Thailand
182 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
of times people came into contact with one another, and limiting huge crowd
gatherings. Scientists and engineers are using all available technologies to combat
the virus’s spread; ICT can provide valuable tools for ensuring social distancing. To
be a generation in which technology has improved hardware and software,
including mobile applications and many Internet of Things (IoT) sensor actuators in
devices. Artificial intelligence (AI) techniques such as machine learning, data
mining, deep learning, and other AI approaches are also included in some tech-
nologies. For 2019-nCoV pandemic patients, these options would make diagnosis
and prognosis easier. In one study, for example, supervised machine learning
models for COVID-19 infection were developed [1]. People are using social media
more than ever before during COVID-19. Technological developments and social
media platforms give opportunities to keep people safe, informed, and connected.
Working from home has become possible because to access to social media during
COVID-19. Furthermore, technology enables people to interact online or work
from home in order to preserve social distance. Every firm in Thailand, both gov-
ernment and commercial, has embraced social media and technology to improve
work efficiency even further.
7.2 Methodology
The content of this chapter came from the 30 participants in three sectors: education,
industry, and healthcare. The literature draws the theme of interview questions and
analysis by using template analysis that is a part of thematic analysis [2,3]. Template
emphasizes hierarchical coding while balancing a high level of organization in the
process of analyzing textual data with the flexibility to adjust it to the needs of a
specific study [3]. Researchers questioned 30 persons involved in utilizing technology
to assist in times of need social distance, interpreting the details from the interview,
recording it, and documenting it. Subsequently, preliminary coding was performed for
important information the interviewees had discussed the same issue or are essential
or a focus, which may lead to the main point of using those technologies. The
researchers recorded the respondents’ remarks regarding problems of interest and
impediments to leadership. Following that, the researcher gathered several issues—
both primary and sub-issues—which were discussed, and the intricacies of each issue
were discovered in depth. The researchers then published this article based on the
resultant template to demonstrate to readers the uniformity of technology imple-
mentations utilized in three areas: education, public health, and manufacturing.
study attempts to characterize the various models and platforms utilized in online
learning for future instructors during the social distance phase [4]. Many online
teaching and learning tools are proliferating. Some university courses that need
practice laboratories must consider how to isolate classes of students and how to
alert when students are close to one other in the lab. As a result of the COVID-19
epidemic, many nations have had to adjust to new conditions in various fields,
including education. The Indonesian government has decided to shift education
away from face-to-face meetings and video conferencing using various learning
management systems (LMSs) such as Moodle and Google Classroom.
Su
students, and make a schedule for collecting assignments and others. Being a
relatively new platform for learning, the need for Google Classroom in online
Indonesian learning is worth investigating from various perspectives, both from the
side of students, teachers, and supporting facilities. For example, from the student
aspect, active student involvement, accuracy in doing assignments, student enthu-
siasm, and student learning outcomes. From the teacher’s perspective, for example,
the teacher’s mastery of information technology, the teacher’s skills in preparing
lesson plans, implementing learning, and providing evaluations. Meanwhile, in
terms of infrastructure, the examples are the availability of a strong network,
Internet connection, and the financial readiness of parents and perhaps teachers to
purchase data packages. This Best Practice will not reveal all aspects related to the
implementation of online learning using Google Classroom during the COVID-19
pandemic but is only limited to increasing student activity and learning outcomes
through online learning using Google Classroom [10]. Google Classroom is a free
application that allows teachers to create courses, give and mark homework, and
offer feedback to students. Instructors may set permissions for students, parents,
and co-teachers, share their display, connect a student’s screen and lockdown for a
pop quiz. Teachers can also employ digital learning to augment classroom educa-
tion. Figure 7.2 shows many classes in a Google Classroom in a university of
Thailand.
7.3.1.3 Moodle
Moodle is a program that manages the LMS, or for short, the LMS. That is the LMS
Martin Dougiamas created for use in online teaching and learning. The system
management structure is a Web-Based Instruction that has a vital component in the
writing language, which includes PHP and MySQL database, which provides
186 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
online using various technologies. According to the interview data, the most
commonly utilized system is a social media platform that parents or kids use on a
daily basis to contact friends or teachers at school, such as LINE or Facebook.
Students utilize social media to connect with one another and form groups for
teaching and learning. Students also utilize conference software for communicating
and teaching, such as Google Meet, Zoom, Webex, Team, or LINE Group call.
higher quality based metadata for patient monitoring. Future patient monitoring and
health information delivery systems will be dramatically impacted by advances in
communications combined with IoT and embedded system technologies [15]. This
can provide services through a smartphone theory of growth for chronic wound
image processing at the patient’s side, as well as providing better integration
between doctor and patient remotely, end-to-end daily schedule-based diagnostic,
and sustaining patient history [16].
and wait at the hospital for an extended period of time and may conduct errands
elsewhere first As a result, this method provides social distance control to minimize
the transmission of COVID-19. Figure 7.4 shows the slip queue that notified the
patient when the patient queue was nearly called.
Camera
Monitor
EDC
Barcode reader
Slip printer
Patients will be assigned a number once they have made a payment in the
financial system. The LINE notification system will remind the patient within a few
minutes to pick up the medication. See Figure 7.6. Moreover, the patient can also
use delivery to deliver medicines at home.
includes a QR code scanner for checking in and out of places such as shopping
centers or supermarkets, which would update the user’s timeline. If there were an
infected individual in the area, the application would send the information to the
Ministry of Public Health Database and notify the citizens of the immediate area
to evacuate the area. The update notification relies on mobile functions such as
GPS and Bluetooth to relay updates to users quickly. The infectious rate of the
virus decreased significantly with the use of the ThaiChana application. In the
future, this application may monitor the COVID-19 vaccine and others at risk of
becoming infected. Those who contact the disease avoid crowded locations,
where patients would be restricted to a particular area of mobility such as the
hospital or at home. The New Normal has proved to be a time of new technolo-
gical advancement with the advent of COVID-19, making technology a part of
everyday life. Not only can the latest mobile apps make life easy, but they also
aim to keep people safe and healthy. This issue government introduces an
application worth downloading and installing to help people deal efficiently with
present and potential developments.
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19 193
telephone network, it can help reduce the cost of calling, whether it is an interna-
tional or domestic call. IP network communication requires the employment of a
router (Router) with a specific purpose to ensure the quality of the IP channel in
order for the information to be sent or returned correctly. Furthermore, there may
be privileges before other IP packets (quality of service: QoS) to provide high-
quality services, which will be seen in the development of current network equip-
ment switches, which have included Port QoS. Employees at businesses utilized
VoIP phones; when working from home, they may continue to use the phone as if
they were at work. A program named SIP Client must be installed on the mobile
system. To communicate with the device, the user may also utilize the SIP Client
program if they wish to use it from their computer.
7.6.2.2 E-Documents
During the COVID-19 epidemic, medium-sized and big companies prioritized IT
systems, working on papers online. Electronic Document Management System
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19 199
summary of data gathered from all corporate databases. The objective of the report
is to provide executives with an evaluation of current developments, an overview of
the company, and drive management and audit operations. On the other hand, the
report’s breadth is defined by the nature of the data and its intended purpose.
Reports may be issued on a regular basis (e.g., an income statement or a balance
sheet), on-demand, or in response to specific situations or occurrences. An MIS can
be designed to allow the user to access anywhere by accessing through a web
browser and the MIS client system installed on the computer. To safeguard access
to information, the user may need to utilize a VPN. MIS is a technology that allows
people in many departments to work from home as if they were in an office.
7.6.3.1 LINE
Thailand already had a high number of LINE users prior to the COVID-19.
However, it is not yet obvious for academic purposes. After the lockdown, LINE
has played a larger part in education, and teachers must develop ways to commu-
nicate with pupils about homework and assignments. All the school directors,
instructors, and educational staff interviewed stated that by using the group LINE
to establish a group with students, LINE returned to play a role in teaching and
learning. A new LINE feature is the ability to use group calls that appear like
teleconferencing. LINE groups make it easy to arrange online courses. Online
tutoring through LINE’s group sessions, on the other hand, is exclusively offered to
primary school pupils. Teachers will seldom utilize LINE with kindergarten chil-
dren. Teachers may only meet with pupils for 10–20 min so that kids may go to
activities or worksheets, and parents can send worksheets to the teachers via LINE.
In addition, LINE also plays a role in many other meetings because it can be used
for unlimited meetings. Furthermore, a small group can meet together without
many of the advanced features, allowing for communication individually. Parents
could conveniently send files and images for meetings. Both large and small
entrepreneurs use LINE as their main communication service since the lockdown.
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19 201
7.6.3.2 Zoom
In Thailand, many universities consider using Zoom applications. The user who has
created the room is considered an administrator or host of the room. When a person
enters a Zoom conference room, they are considered an attendance hosted by another
user. The meeting organizer or substitute host (if the original host is unable to attend)
will have host controls, such as the capability to silence audio, utilize video, share
your screen, and more. The attendance microphone can be muted and unmuted by the
host. The host can also control the room’s sound by clicking on the arrow next to the
mute button, and the host will get further audio settings options. The host, for
example, can change the attendance microphone, switch off the computer’s audio, or
access the audio settings. Attendees can switch on or off the camera by pressing the
Start/Stop Video button. By pressing the arrow adjacent to the start/stop video button,
attendees can swap showing cameras, adjust Zoom video options, or change a virtual
background. The attendance can see who is presently in the meeting by clicking on
participants and raising their hand or changing the name on the participant’s list.
Moreover, the attendance can share their screen in the meeting if the host allows it.
The attendance screen share will be able to be stopped by the host. Other features of
Zoom include a breakout room assignment. Zoom allows the host to assign partici-
pants into groups which encourages a smaller and active learning environment. The
host or the instructor could quickly assess each student of their understanding, which
is proven to be a convenient online alternative learning experience for college taught
subjects that require active participation and higher level understanding, such as
medicinal chemistry [24].
7.6.3.3 Google Meet
During the COVID-19 epidemic, the Google Meet application provides secure
video conferencing for teams and companies while remaining simple for students to
utilize. Organizations may use enterprise-grade video conferencing based on
Google’s secure global infrastructure to keep employees securely connected and on
the go. It is backed up with safe design architecture.
Many Thai institutions have Google Education licenses, which are part of the
Google Meet platform. Google Meet uses self-security and a well-known world-
wide network to secure data and privacy to the greatest extent feasible. During
transmission, Google Meet uses an encrypted video session, and various anti-abuse
measures are activated by default. Google Meet is offered at no cost to educational
institutions. However, in order to host a virtual meeting for up to 250 participants,
the institution must register as an enterprise. Google Enterprise also includes fea-
tures such as internal live broadcasting and the ability to save call recordings to
Google Drive and the ability for room creators to invite up to 100 people to each
Google Meet session without requiring them to install the Google Meet app on
individual devices. Users can join the conference using only a web browser;
moreover, room creators in Google Meet Enterprise can add group members for up
to 24 h of video chatting. Meeting room organizers may now view all of the day’s
scheduled meetings in one place and join with a single tap from the dedicated
Gmail mobile app or Meet app. Google Workspace also assigns a phone number to
202 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
each meeting, ensuring that all attendees have a positive experience. Meetings may
be joined immediately via calendar events, email invitations, or Gmail, which is
also linked to Google’s infrastructure. Those in attendance can join the meeting
from any computer, phone, or conference room. All event details will be consistent.
With live captioning, low-light mode, and noise suppression are employed, meet-
ings become more productive.
7.6.3.4 Webex
Customers may need to hold an online conference when they begin to work from
home. The school should invest more in online instruction and has begun to employ
video conferencing software for distant sessions. During this time, one of the most
popular programs is “Webex,” which can hold continuous meetings for 50 min and
handle 100 devices. Webex may be accessible via a variety of channels, including
installing an app on a Tablet or Smartphone for both iOS and Android or using a
web browser on a PC, Windows, or MAC OS, and there is software available to
download into the device for convenience.
critical for the major aspects of the application, which allow users to encounter
minimal issues in order to receive correct and timely information. Furthermore, the
adoption of this technology across the country causes frequent network failures and
the delivery of erroneous SMS messages, resulting in the message not being ver-
ified. There was an issue with data handling, and the service had to be terminated.
These applications rely on Google Maps for network services in order to use the
maps. Furthermore, alerts from LINE apps and Facebook improve efficiency.
classrooms and auditoriums, but it also presents alternate solutions for those who
seek further knowledge and fill educational gaps. LMSs are used widely by edu-
cational institutions to ease the access of course materials and to provide a simple
tool for instructors to use; examples mentioned include Google Classroom and
Moodle. MOOC is another alternative to regular classroom settings, allowing stu-
dents to be able to access university-level course content online for free, which
promotes self-learning during the closure of schools and university campuses due
to COVID-19. Along with the education sector, healthcare is in need of technolo-
gical solutions to manage social-distancing guidelines in facilities and the man-
agement of patients. Wearable technology becomes a commodity for both patients
and healthcare workers, which allows the administration to track movements and
location and notify if a health policy has been a breach or if there is a potential
health risk. In large healthcare facilities, a system is put in place to guide patients
through the medical process easily. This includes a screening system to scan
patients upon arriving at the facility, a queue system to manage the order of patients
receiving medical care, and a payment system to ensure a safe and efficient
checkout. However, protecting the public interest in health and safety from
COVID-19 extends beyond the hospital walls. Some applications manage the
general population’s well-being by notifying them of potential health risks and
organizing other health services in one system, such as vaccination registration.
Another sector that employs the use of technology is manufacturing. Some tech-
nological solutions include using big data and AI such as video analytic and Wi-Fi
monitoring to mitigate infection rates within manufacturing facilities. Some man-
ufacturing firms also require employees to have a wearable device to monitor their
conditions and their location for the best of the employee’s interest and safety in the
workspace. While health safety is important for the human workforce, intelligence
systems are being used in all systems where human labor is redundant. These
systems not only reduce the risk of mass infection within factories but also save
cost and time. Nevertheless, many firms allow employees to work from home,
which will help reduce employee interaction. To ensure protection from a data
breach or other technological threats while working from home, VPN access and
entitlements are given to each employee. Access to sensitive information is very
limited. Different applications that would support remote work are also mentioned.
These include VoIP, e-documents apps, cloud service, MIS, and conferencing apps,
such as Zoom, Google Meet, and Webex. VoIP is very beneficial for call center
applications, where existing Internet service and all voice calls are processed
through the same channel. E-documents applications enable online collaborative
documents to work to be done remotely, which could be a part of cloud services
where file-sharing is made easier through the cloud. Meetings and conferences
could also be held online due to in-person limitations by apps such as Webex,
Zoom, and Google Meet. Achieving a fully hi-tech “New Normal” society requires
a smart city framework. Agencies on many levels tend to lean in on AI and big data
solutions. Still, intelligence systems tend to have limitations, and understanding the
usage would be key to solve necessary tasks. The understanding of technology
should also be given to the general public if technology is being implemented for
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19 205
their purpose. Other factors that should be considered are the privacy and security
of the users, which are required by laws and policies.
References
[1] Muhammad L., Algehyne E.A., Usman S.S., et al. Supervised Machine
Learning Models for Prediction of COVID-19 Infection Using Epidemiology
Dataset. SN Computer Science. 2021; 2(1): 1–13.
[2] King N. Template Analysis. Sage Publications Ltd; 1998.
[3] Brooks J., McCluskey S., Turley E., et al. The Utility of Template Analysis
in Qualitative Psychology Research. Qualitative Research in Psychology.
2015; 12(2): 202–222.
[4] Gunawan G., Suranti N.M.Y. and Fathoroni F. Variations of Models and
Learning Platforms for Prospective Teachers During the COVID-19
Pandemic Period. Indonesian Journal of Teacher Education. 2020; 1(2):
61–70. Available from: https://journal.publication-center.com/index.php/
ijte/article/view/95.
[5] Raza S.A., Qazi W., Khan K.A., et al. Social Isolation and Acceptance of the
Learning Management System (LMS) in the Time of COVID-19 Pandemic:
An Expansion of the UTAUT Model. Journal of Educational Computing
Research. 2020; 59(2): 183–208. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1177/
0735633120960421.
[6] Octaberlina L.R. and Muslimin A.I. EFL Students Perspective towards
Online Learning Barriers and Alternatives Using Moodle/Google Classroom
during COVID-19 Pandemic. International Journal of Higher Education.
2020; 9(6): 1–9. Available from: http://www.sciedu.ca/journal/index.php/
ijhe/article/view/18485.
[7] Hermanto F. and Putri N.A. Learning Ability and Supporting Capacity of
Online Learning In Students during Covid-19 Pandemic. 3rd International
Conference on Environmental Geography and Geography Education IOP
Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science. 2021; 747(1): 012080.
Available from: https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/747/1/012080.
[8] John C., Staubitz T. and Meinel C. Took a MOOC. Got a Certificate. What
Now?. In: 2019 IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference (FIE); 2019. p. 1–
9. ISSN: 2377-634X.
[9] Razai M.S., Kankam H.K.N., Hourston G.J.M., et al. Lessons Learned From
Producing Guidance Articles and Rapid Massive Open Online Courses
During the Covid-19 Pandemic in Primary Care. Journal of Primary Care &
Community Health. 2020; 11: 2150132720963624. Available from: https://
doi.org/10.1177/2150132720963624.
[10] Sutrisno S. Increased Learning Activities and Outcomes Through Online
Learning with Google Classroom in The Covid-19 Pandemic Period. Ideguru:
Jurnal Karya Ilmiah Guru. 2020; 5(1): 95–106. Available from: https://jurnal-
dikpora.jogjaprov.go.id/index.php/jurnalideguru/article/view/151.
206 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[11] Filippidi A., Tselios N. and Komis V. Impact of Moodle Usage Practices on
Students’ Performance in the Context of a Blended Learning Environment.
Proceedings of Social Applications for Life Long Learning; p. 2–7.
[12] Chakraborty C. and Abougreen A.N. Intelligent Internet of Things and
Advanced Machine Learning Techniques for COVID-19. EAI Endorsed
Transactions on Pervasive Health and Technology. 2021; 7(26).
[13] Islam M.M., Rahaman A. and Islam M.R. Development of Smart Healthcare
Monitoring System in IoT Environment. SN Computer Science. 2020; 1(3):
185. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42979-020-00195-y.
[14] Alarifi A. and Alwadain A. Killer Heuristic Optimized Convolution Neural
Network-Based Fall Detection with Wearable IoT Sensor Devices.
Measurement. 2021; 167: 108258.
[15] Chakraborty C., Gupta B. and Ghosh S.K. A Review on Telemedicine-Based
WBAN Framework for Patient Monitoring. Telemedicine and e-Health.
2013; 19(8): 619–626. PMID: 23841489. Available from: https://doi.org/10.
1089/tmj.2012.0215.
[16] Chakraborty C., Gupta B. and Ghosh S.K. Mobile Metadata Assisted
Community Database of Chronic Wound Images. Wound Medicine. 2014; 6:
34–42. Available from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S2213909514000445.
[17] Khandelwal P., Khandelwal A., Agarwal S., et al. Using Computer Vision to
enhance Safety of Workforce in Manufacturing in a Post COVID World;
arXiv:2005.05287. https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.05287.
[18] Seshadri D.R., Davies E.V., Harlow E.R., et al. Wearable Sensors for
COVID-19: A Call to Action to Harness Our Digital Infrastructure for
Remote Patient Monitoring and Virtual Assessments. Front Digit Health.
2020; 2: 8.
[19] Nguyen C.T., Saputra Y.M., Van Huynh N., et al. Enabling and Emerging
Technologies for Social Distancing: A Comprehensive Survey and Open
Problems. IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 153479–153507. Comment: 43 pages, 21
figures, journal.
[20] Venkatnarayan R.H. and Shahzad M. Demo: Measuring Distance Traveled
by an Object Using WiFi-CSI and IMU Fusion. In: 2019 IEEE 27th
International Conference on Network Protocols (ICNP); 2019. p. 1–2.
[21] Punn N.S., Sonbhadra S.K., Agarwal S., et al. Monitoring COVID-19 Social
Distancing with Person Detection and Tracking via Fine-Tuned YOLO v3
and Deepsort Techniques. arXiv:200501385 [cs]. 2021.
[22] Zuo F., Gao J., Kurkcu A., et al. Reference-Free Video-to-Real Distance
Approximation-Based Urban Social Distancing Analytics amid COVID-19
Pandemic. Journal of Transport & Health. 2021; 21: 101032. Available from:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214140521000268.
[23] Coombs C. Will COVID-19 Be the Tipping Point for the Intelligent
Automation of Work? A Review of the Debate and Implications for
Research. International Journal of Information Management. 2020; 55:
102182.
Social distancing technologies for COVID-19 207
Abstract
COVID-19 pandemic has caused huge economic losses in almost all industries.
Thus, the economic crisis caused by this pandemic has modeled huge challenges
for leisure industry. Travel bans, closed borders, mandatory quarantine after border
crossing, reduced contacts are just some of the problems that citizens around the
world have encountered. Observed from the point of view of tourism, a special
problem was curfew and quarantine closure of cities and areas. All these sig-
nificantly disrupted global tourism, which have been in full upswing in the years
before pandemic. The research described in this chapter aims to give a description
of the proposed software solution intended for better control and records of infected
persons. The straightforward use of the proposed software solution aims to reduce
the potential for the virus to spread among tourists. In order to reduce the potential
for the spread of the virus, the proposed software solution needs to enable a better
control of the movement of infected persons. Proper control of the movement of
infected persons reduces the pressure on the tourism sector and opens the possibi-
lity of reoperation of tourist facilities for persons who are not infected. The pro-
posed system is based on mutual cooperation of several actors. Thus, at the local
and state level, the healthcare system can be singled out. Actors acting only at the
local level are tourism organizations and local governments, while the actor acting
only at the state level is border control. When it comes to the process of collecting
personal data of patients, the bearer of this task within the system is the local health
organization, which is certainly the first in contact with infected patients. In this
way, the role of the healthcare organization is the proper registration of infected
patients, and their entry into the proposed system. This part of the system also
provides data on vaccinated and revaccinated patients. In order not to further bur-
den the healthcare system, proposed software solution will use existing data and
1
Faculty of Tourism and Hospitality Management, Singidunum University, Belgrade, Serbia
2
Department of Computer Science and Informatics, Faculty of Electronic Engineering Niš, University of
Niš, Niš, Serbia
3
Department of Computer Science and Informatics, Faculty of Technical Sciences, University of
Pristina, Kosovska Mitrovica, Serbia
210 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
will not require additional tests. Based on provided data from all actors, the inte-
grated management system will create a database with vaccinated or tested positive
persons. This database will be obtained by merging several databases into one so-
called centralized register. However, each of the actors in the system has the right
to use only that part of the data that is essential for their work. In this way, the
system is able to protect personal patient data from unauthorized access. The sys-
tem will allow one to check vaccination or home isolation status of an individual
and, based on the results, approve or deny reservations. The edge/cloud architecture
at the same time will provide data availability, and data access control.
8.1 Introduction
When this software solution is proposed (May 2021), 168 million people were
infected by COVID-19 virus. In the same time this virus caused the deaths of
around 3 million people worldwide. From the start of the 2020 year, more precisely
after the onset of the COVID-19 virus, a mass pandemic people’s daily activities
were disordered with different constrains and rules. People’s daily activities like
interacting with each other, traveling, having fun have taken on a whole new form
or have been banned. COVID-19 also affects different fields of world economy.
From the aspect of human health, the COVID-19 virus has endangered both the
physical and mental health of the world’s population. In addition to physical and
mental health, the fight against the pandemic also affected personal data privacy.
Personal data were found in one chain cycle, where on the one hand it is necessary
to preserve those, while, on the other hand, it is necessary to enable their processing
in order to reduce pandemic [1].
One of the ways to fight the pandemic proposed by the World Health
Organization is to close the borders of many countries around the world. Their
borders remained closed for a long period of time for both visitors and tourists. This
move has caused great economic losses, especially for those countries that base
most of their budgets on tourism. Furthermore, the pandemic affected the tourism
sections of these countries significantly, making it harder for economy. For the first
time ever all global tourist destinations have introduced some form of restriction
[2]. Restrictions in terms of movement, gatherings, travel did not bypass domestic
tourism either. Revenues from domestic tourism have decreased significantly. The
easing of measures enabled the reopening of tourist destinations. Of course, the
emphasis on reopening was placed on respecting the prescribed measures and
respecting the imposed restrictions. The overall situation with the pandemic has led
to the fact that there are a large number of individuals who, despite the easing of
measures and the opening of borders, do not dare to go on international trips. There
is also a group of people who cannot afford international travel given that they have
lost their jobs or their incomes have been significantly reduced. Prior to the
Social health protection in touristic destinations during COVID-19 211
pandemic, tourism was considered the sector with the highest economic growth. In
support of this are the data that in 2018 alone, 1,407 million international depar-
tures were made. For the sake of comparison, some of the most popular countries in
terms of the number of tourists such as France, China, Spain, during 2020 faced a
large number of infected patients and the closure of borders, which led to a huge
drop in visits compared to 2019. The extent to which the pandemic caused eco-
nomic losses to the tourism sector is also shown by the fact that a loss of $297
billion was recorded in the United States alone, as a result of the suspension of
tourism in the first quarter of the year [3]. Furthermore, for a very large number of
countries, tourism represents the main income for their citizens, and in the same
time basic government revenue, based on the fact that tourism is one of the
industries that employ a significant number of workers. Without such a key type of
earnings, many countries experienced significant losses in gross domestic product.*
One of the partial solutions for economic and psychological crisis is to gather
necessary information about tourists and use them to allow or deny different
activities. By providing a solution for simplification and organization of patient
data, categorization of individuals tested positive or negative, without compro-
mising privacy rights. All these will be achieved within the proposed software
solution by introducing different privacy policies. This will provide greater travel
opportunities for individuals tested negative for COVID-19 or vaccinated ones.
Viewed from the point of view of patients whose results have shown to be positive
for the virus, the proposed software solution enables a better control of the move-
ment of such patients, as well as a better control of compliance with measures to
prevent the spread of the virus.
The proposed software solution described in this chapter is based on the use of
data obtained from different sources. The data obtained from the health system
database represent the backbone of the entire system. In practice, these data are
crucial in separating people positive and negative for the COVID-19 virus. The
data obtained from the health system within the proposed software solution are
combined with the points obtained by the local administration, tourist organiza-
tions, as well as border control. In this way, the possibility of monitoring the
movements of infected persons is realized. The contribution of the proposed system
is primarily reflected in providing better data protection for persons registered as
COVID-19 positive. In addition to data protection, the proposed software solution
should reduce the spread of the virus by ensuring a better monitoring of infected
persons and preventing their reckless behavior. Finally, for all those who are not
infected, as well as for tourism in general, the contribution of the software solution
is to ensure the reopening of tourist destinations and the free movement of all
persons who are negative for the COVID-19 virus or vaccinated against it.
The chapter is organized as follows: the second section of the chapter provides
an overview of the literature as well as relevant papers related to the research
presented in this chapter. The third section describes the architecture of the pro-
posed software solution intended for use in order to reduce the spread of viruses
*
OECD Better Policies for Better Lives, Retrieved 15.10.2020, from http://www.oecd.org/.
212 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
and increase opportunities for tourism recovery. An overview of legal norms, laws,
and bylaws related to the protection of personal data during the pandemic of the
COVID-19 virus is given in the fourth section. The fifth section of the chapter
summarizes key benefits of proposed system, key conclusions, and plans for future
research.
The traditional approach to monitoring the health status of patients, as well as their
treatment, has changed a lot during the last 2 years. A large number of medical
institutions have switched from the traditional to the remote approach to treating
patients, in all those cases where this was possible. A significant number of studies
conducted on this topic have contributed to this treatment system. One of the
researches on this topic described in [4] presents system for home healthcare.
Practically, this is a system with remote access whose task is to provide assistance
in the healthcare home. Within this chapter, the authors proposed a software system
whose task from the patient’s point of view is to obtain a prescription for medi-
cations without going to the doctor. System enables monitoring of the patient’s
health status in order to determine the right therapy. The software solution is based
on the Android mobile application. This application connects to a web-based
application. In this way, mutual communication between the doctor and the patient
is possible. The collection of data relevant to the determination of therapy is done
automatically using sensors. These sensors record the psychophysical parameters of
the patient. In order to provide accurately read data of psychophysical parameters,
the authors performed the installation of a HAC monitoring framework. With the
implementation of this framework, the performance of the system itself has been
improved. The proposed software solution aims to monitor patients remotely,
without any contact with them. The proposed mobile platform enables the sending
of daily values of parameters, as well as communication between the doctor and the
patient, during the period of time that the patient spends in isolation.
The use of telemedicine to improve health services in rural and highly occu-
pied areas of India was one of the topics of research presented in [5]. Within this
chapter, the authors emphasized the possibilities of using new technological solu-
tions in order to improve the healthcare system of India. The authors also empha-
sized that the use of technological solutions is especially visible during epidemics
and pandemics. Epidemics and pandemics pose a kind of challenge for both the
healthcare system and healthcare workers. The conclusion of the author is that the
need for new information and communication solutions leads to quality changes in
the management of the healthcare system. The research highlighted potential
challenges, as well as the opportunities offered by the use of telemedicine in order
to improve the healthcare system during a pandemic.
In the study conducted by the group of authors, a system aimed to detect
COVID-19 virus based on thermal image processing is shown. Reduction of
interference among people is provided by the use of a smart helmet [6]. The
Social health protection in touristic destinations during COVID-19 213
on the cloud platform in order to obtain more accurate results in real time. This
approach to data storage and processing is beneficial to both government and
citizens. Cloud computing within this model offers access capabilities regardless of
user location.
The research presented in [15] was conducted in two major directions. The first
direction was the challenges that the hospitality and tourism industry have due to
the new situation with the COVID-19 virus pandemic. The second line of research
concerned the vital industry. The research was based on interviews in which 15
participants participated. Participants were people in senior positions in hospitality
and tourism. By analyzing the results obtained after all the interviews, 27 subtopics
were created, which were later grouped into four larger groups. Out of the total
number of 27 subtopics, some dominant subtopics singled it out. The main goal of
the research was to determine the basic topics for combating a further decline in the
tourism and hospitality rate caused by the COVID-19 virus pandemic.
Author in [16] presents latency minimization in e-healthcare through fog
computing. More precisely, the authors presented a new scheme that uses machine
learning, more precisely the k-fold random forest algorithm, to segregate multi-
media data. The authors also presented models for calculating the total latency. By
the simulation procedure, they repented that it is possible to create a model that will
have a classification accuracy of 92%. The model also created showed a reduction
in latency of approximately 95% compared to previously existing models. In this
way, the quality of services belonging to e-health has been increased.
Authors in research presented in [17] show their model that should allow for
anonymity. This model is based on the use of IoT technologies. The authors pre-
sented the RFID concept by which it is possible to track nonhuman virus carriers.
Practically in this way, it will be possible to follow both animals and objects that
move like cars. By applying the model, animals and moving objects will be able to
send or receive notifications if they approach the marked area. The simulation
results showed very high efficiency.
Panic shopping at the beginning of each of the pandemics can cause great
logistics and supply to stores. The authors in one of the researches dealt with the
analysis of panic purchases during the corona virus pandemic [18].
The contribution of machine learning applied to data obtained during a pan-
demic can facilitate decisions about its further course. The aim of one of the papers
was to review the contribution of machine learning and IoT in the fight against the
COVID-19 epidemic [19].
by the pandemic, it can be said that it has suffered the greatest losses compared to
other industries. The collapse of the economy coming from tourism has directly
affected a large number of families [20]. As the economies of almost all counties
worldwide rely directly on the revenues that are generated from the tourism sector,
it is necessary to find the best possible solution to relax the measures introduced in
response to the corona virus pandemic. Given the seriousness of this pandemic, the
opening of tourist destinations for tourists as well as the relaxation of the intro-
duced measures must be carried out in a way that will not endanger the health of
both natives and tourists.
Observed from the stakeholders’ point of view and principally having in mind
the current knowledge about the way the coronavirus spreads, as well as the ways to
fight against it, some of the key factors can be singled out. In the first place, special
attention should certainly be paid to tourists as potential carriers of the corona
virus. Viewed from the point of view of tourists as carriers, tourists can bring the
virus with them to the tourist destination where they are staying. Also, if, during
their stay at a specific tourist destination, they come into contact with the virus and
become infected, they can bring it home when they return and thus continue to
spread it. In this regard, a very important aspect in the protection of the health of
the population is certainly the precise testing and records of health institutions in
terms of tested and positive people for COVID-19.
Immunization of the population as one of the key measures in the fight against
the coronavirus opens up opportunities for easing measures, and restarting tourism,
as well as for facilitated travel and movement of tourists. This practically means
that it is necessary to establish a system that will provide facilities both in terms of
performing daily activities and in terms of enabling travel to the immunized part of
the population. Based on the regulations in force at the time of writing, persons who
have a certificate are not COVID-19 positive, as well as persons who have been
vaccinated, do not need to be in self-isolation. Each of the actors in the system has a
clearly defined role. Also, each of the actors in the proposed software system has a
predefined set of data with which it operates and for which it is responsible. The
system itself is organized as a series of services, grouped by levels. Mutual inter-
connection of all actors could be seen from Figure 8.1.
Application
level
Analysis
level
Analysis modules
Supporting
level
Logs Reports
Core level
facility for data readings and also implements different protocols for data pro-
tections. If the data need to be preprocessed for clarification, or if there are
invalid instances that must be processed, this is where such a service will be
logically located. Command represents a service family that facilitates and con-
trols action requests from one side of the system to another. It should expose the
commands in a common, normalized way to simplify communications between
the actors. Metadata represent a repository and associated management service of
metadata about the actors that are connected to platform. Metadata provide the
possibility to create new sources, and store and manage information about the
services that serve as platform interfaces to the actual actors. Database services
are other services that communicate directly with the actors and normalize
information and communications.
The service layer provides support for the operation of software applications
such as logging, data cleaning, data scheduling. In our cases, supporting service
cannot be considered optional, as it is necessary to provide legal traces for data
sharing. These services can be fundamental because they could provide valuable
evidences in case of data leak or breach. Furthermore, this type of application
features can be very important for maintenance, bug tracing and further develop-
ment of the system. Service architecture can allow each of the actors to have their
own settings for logging and log file storage.
Social health protection in touristic destinations during COVID-19 217
Since we created a system that has access to global data, it will be useful to
perform different analytics tasks on the collected and shared data. In this way, we
can get useful insights from the data that are relevant not only to public health, but
also for the entire human existence and well-being. Services in this level can use
data for which they have access permissions, making this entire system more
resilient for data breaches. Although this level is rather optional, we expect it to
become main focus of development in the future. With the increased data, the
demand for analysis will be brought to the fronts, because the knowledge extracted
from confirmed accurate data can be valuable for the entire population.
The role of application level is to extract, process/transform and send data from
platform to an actor. Services on the application level should be adjusted to meet
different requirements from different users. Furthermore, special attention must be
given to data privacy and data access control services. Each actor of the system will
be represented as a service on this level. This is the most efficient way to control
shared data and data access among the participants. Furthermore, services on this
level can use results and models created in analysis level to create different actions
or to generate comprehensive reports that can provide useful knowledge.
This way of organizing the management system was chosen to support
expansions while taking data privacy in mind. Each of the individual actors of the
system is enabled to operate on data on different devices. More about the individual
functionalities of each part of the system from the point of view of individual actors
will be given in the following sections. Each component on the application level
will be explained. Components on the other levels in this system are very general
and not specific to this particular implementation and usage and thus are not
explained in detail in this chapter.
emissions and storage of all measured values on the cloud via a central software
platform. In this way, after they recover and return home, the local health institu-
tion has data on the patient’s condition and all the treatments he has undergone.
Data of this type can be entered within the system either by healthcare profes-
sionals, if their additional processing is required before the entry or automatically
using a data logger after each reading from the installed sensors. The role of the
data adapter as well as the filters shown in Figure 8.1, which belong to the
healthcare system, is reflected in the processing of data about each patient. In this
way, the recorded data on each individual patient required for the treatment of the
patient are processed so that only those data that are relevant will be forwarded to
the central system. The use of the mentioned adapter and filter prevents the
exchange of irrelevant data on patients of a specific healthcare institution. For
example, data on patients not recorded as COVID-19 positive would be considered
irrelevant data. Also if a person is recorded as COVID-19 positive, data on his or
her previous medical history will not be relevant within the proposed system and
should therefore certainly not be taken from the system of the healthcare institution.
Operating exclusively on approved data, as well as their targeted use by specific
system actors, reduces the possibility of their misuse.
Regarding the processing of data on the immunized part of the population,
depending on the immunization policy and recognition of vaccines of individual
manufacturers, each of the holdings within the system will define the rules
according to which other system actors will be guided when checking a particular
tourist. The task of the healthcare system within the immunization process is to
accurately record data on each person who received both the first and second doses
of the vaccine. Observed from the angle of the proposed software system, the
healthcare institution records data on each individual patient after vaccination.
After receiving the second dose, the healthcare institution should, in accordance
with the regulations issued by the state authorities of the country to which it
belongs, issue a certificate of vaccination to the patient. It should also add the
electronic data from the certificate to the central software platform of the proposed
software system. Electronic data on each vaccinated citizen in this way would
become available to all other actors in the system, which would enable easier
control of potential tourists, as well as tourists whose period of stay has
already begun.
positive or if he has been in contact with positive people, the reservation will not be
approved. Exceptions are cases when a COVID-19 positive person creates a
reservation for the period of stay that will be realized after the anticipated period of
isolation. Potential tourists who submit a negative PCR test or vaccination certifi-
cate are checked within the proposed system. Practically in this way, the authen-
ticity of the attached document is checked. If a person is indeed negative for
COVID-19 or has been immunized with one of the vaccines, it must be added to the
system by a healthcare institution that has performed either testing or immuniza-
tion. The employee within the travel agency forwards the data for verification
within the proposed system and receives a confirmation of the authenticity of the
documents. Vaccinated tourists must submit the green certificate or QR code in
order to prove that they received both doses of the vaccine. The speed of checking
the data of each of the tourists largely depends on the uniformity of the document
on the performed vaccination, which is issued by the authorized health institution.
This is especially reflected in cases when it comes to checking data for tourists who
are residents of another country or have not been vaccinated in their own country.
The application of such a system reduces the pressure on hoteliers, tourist
organizations as well as staff employed within tourist destinations. If each indivi-
dual tourist who paid for the stay through the agency has previously checked the
task of local tourist organizations, the hotel staff is reflected only in checking
tourists who have organized specific activities within the tourist destination
(accommodation, tourist tours, transportation, etc.) using various applications or in
person at the tourist place.
institutions of local self-government are informed if the check shows that the
vaccination certificate has been falsified. Such an organized check once again
shows that uniformity is needed when it comes to documents confirming the per-
formed vaccination or negative results of the PCR test.
be used. On the other hand, it is necessary to clearly emphasize what are the per-
sonal data that, regardless of the situation, no one would have the right to use
without the prior consent of the person to whom they relate [22]. From the point of
view of the healthcare system, it can be said that in the event of a pandemic, the
health system is the one that has the most sensitive data of people infected with the
virus. A number of studies have shown that data on infected people are crucial in
order to create opportunities for their publication to process them and draw con-
clusions that can reduce the pandemic and thus reduce the number of infected
people. Also, monitoring the condition of patients using digital devices that log
each read parameter is of undoubted importance to the scientific community in the
process of creating predictive models that would much more accurately predict the
future condition of patients. Observed from the point of view of patients, and based
on published experiences, it is concluded that in the case of the COVID-19 virus
pandemic, the publication of data on infected people led to alienation and distance
between people, which greatly affected the psyche of patients and their
environment.
This way of collecting and processing data obtained in digital form by the
health system can lead to the fact that a large amount of both personal and non-
personal data from the group of sensitive data can be found in the data. If such data
are not used exclusively for the purpose of suppressing the spread of the pandemic,
but are misused, then such a processing procedure can lead to a serious violation of
human rights.
A potential problem that may arise in the process of collecting, publishing and
processing personal data of patients as well as data on their health status is the use of
these data even after the end of the epidemic. More precisely, the problem that may
arise is the public availability of data, which can enable individuals or organizations
to use them even after the approval issued during the epidemic, has formally ceased
to be valid. Precisely for these reasons, it is necessary to unequivocally adopt laws
and bylaws that would regulate this area, as well as that would regulate cases in
which it is possible to make exceptions. It is of utmost importance to control the
access to these data, if possible only to machines, which will generate summarized
and anonymized results when possible. Regarding the healthcare system, it is advi-
sable to apply the principle of patient data confidentiality.
In response to the problems of digital personal data protection during the
COVID-19 pandemic, a European Union directive on the privacy of electronic
communications was adopted. Within the framework of this directive, it is expli-
citly defined that data obtained from any source for processing for the purpose of
combating the COVID-19 pandemic may be used only if they are anonymous.
More precisely, if any information that may indicate which person is in question
has been removed from the data itself. If it is not possible to make the data anon-
ymous by removing information about the person in question, each of the member
states should prescribe special regulations that will regulate how to act in such
situations. Transferred to medical data, by removing the personal data of the patient
or his ID, it is possible to use all other information related to the example for
diagnosis, measured values of various parameters and so on.
222 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
After the adoption of the directive, many countries of the European Union and
beyond began to apply it, especially in the field of collecting the location of people of
interest. For example, in Italy, mobile operators have made data on the locations of
their users available to government services. This was of particular importance to the
Ministry of Health as it made it possible to point out citizens who had disobeyed a
restraining order or home isolation. Similar to the Italian model, the Polish authorities
created a software solution that used mobile operators to wash citizens who should be
in quarantine. The application is created so that from time to time, without the exact
time interval, it requires citizens to take selfies with geolocation to determine whe-
ther the quarantine measure is adhered to or not. The authorities in China have gone
even further, so that every citizen, when returning from abroad, receives an electronic
bracelet that sends geolocation, as well as a warning to the authorities if there is a
violation of the self-isolation measure. Singapore, on the other hand, has made all
data on patients and citizens tested positive. This procedure is designed so that all
citizens who are in the database can be followed and in order to discover which part
of the country can be a potential hotbed.
Articles 6 and 9 of the GDPR define legal norms related to employers and
healthcare organizations, which regulate the handling of personal data in the epi-
demic. However, the exchange of information in such cases must be proportional to
the risk and the actual need for exchange, meaning that organizations must check
regularly and carefully if the data access is absolutely necessary. It is up to employers
to adopt the measurements that must be taken to protect their employees [23].
The protection of personal data was certainly one of the aspects when devel-
oping the proposed software solution. The use of data obtained from the healthcare
system within the proposed system is done with special attention aimed at their
protection [24].
References
[3] Farzanegan M. R., Gholipour H. F., Feizi M., Nunko R. and Andargoli A. E.
‘International tourism and outbreak of coronavirus (Covid-19): a cross-
country analysis’. Journal of Travel Research. 2021; 60. https://doi.org/10.
1177/0047287520931593.
[4] Olutosin T. and Absalom E. E. ‘Smart healthcare support for remote patient
monitoring during covid-19 quarantine’. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked.
2020; 20, pp. 1–11.
[5] Geetanjali S., Munish S. and Ajita K. ‘Evolution of smart healthcare: tele-
medicine during COVID-19 pandemic’. Journal of the Institution of
Engineers (India): Series B. 2021, pp. 1–6.
[6] Mohammed N. A., Halimatuz Z., Sairah A. K., Rusyaizila R. and Eddy Y.
‘Novel covid-19 detection and diagnosis system using IoT based smart hel-
met’. International Journal of Psychosocial Rehabilitation. 2020; 24(7),
pp. 2296–2303.
[7] Naveen N. R. G., Ajay S., Shiv L. S. and Puri G. D. ‘Real-time smart patient
monitoring and assessment amid COVID-19 pandemic – an alternative
approach to remote monitoring’. Journal of Medical Systems. 2020; 44(131),
pp. 130–131.
[8] Singh A., Naik B. N., Soni S. L. and Puri G. D. ‘Real-time remote surveil-
lance of doffing during COVID-19 pandemic: enhancing safety of health
care workers’. Anesthesia & Analgesia. 2020; 131, pp. e112–e113.
[9] Zhang Y., Liu H., Su X., Jiang P. and Wei D. ‘Remote mobile health mon-
itoring system based on smart phone and browser/server structure’. Journal
of Healthcare Engineering. 2015; 6(4), pp. 717–737.
[10] Rahman A., Chakraborty C., Anwar A., et al. ‘SDN-IoT empowered intel-
ligent framework for Industry 4.0 applications during COVID-19 pandemic’.
Cluster Computing. 2021, pp. 1–18. 10.1007/s10586-021-03367-4.
[11] Dash S., Chakraborty C., Giri S. K., Pani S. K. and Frnda J. ‘BIFM: big-data
driven intelligent forecasting model for COVID-19’. IEEE Access. 2021; 9,
pp. 97505–97517. 10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3094658.
[12] Aslam B., Javed A. R., Chakraborty C., Nebhen J., Raqib S. and Rizwan M.
‘Blockchain and ANFIS empowered IoMT application for privacy preserved
contact tracing in COVID-19 pandemic’. Personal and Ubiquitous
Computing. 2021, pp. 1–17. 10.1007/s00779-021-01596-3.
[13] Islam Md. M., Rahaman A. and Islam Md. R. ‘Development of smart
healthcare monitoring system in IoT environment’. SN Computer Science.
2020; 1(185).
[14] Tuli S., Tuli S., Tuli R. and Gill S. S. ‘Predicting the growth and trend of
COVID-19 pandemic using machine learning and cloud computing’.
Internet of Things. 2020; 11.
[15] Kaushal V. and Srivastava S. ‘Hospitality and tourism industry amid
COVID-19 pandemic: perspectives on challenges and learnings from India’.
International Journal of Hospitality Management. 2021; 92, pp. 1–19.
[16] Kishor A., Chakraborty C. and Jeberson W. ‘A novel fog computing
approach for minimization of latency in healthcare using machine learning’.
Social health protection in touristic destinations during COVID-19 225
Abstract
Biomedical data analysis is an exceedingly broad field. It includes array data ana-
lysis, biomedical image analysis, integrated or hybrid data analysis, and patient
data analysis using machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI). Array
data analysis can be further classified into RNA-sequence, single-cell RNA-
sequence, microarray, and ChiP-seq data analysis. Biomedical imaging encom-
passes different parameters like gathering of biomedical signal, formation of an
image, processing of an image, display of image, and the medical diagnosis that are
built on the features obtained from various images. AI was mainly used to break
down healthcare data and used to track and screen patients while Internet of Things
was used mainly for monitoring a patient remotely. There are different radiological
imaging processes that include the radiography, ultrasound, thermography, mag-
netic resonance imaging, nuclear medicine and computed tomography. We, in this
book chapter, provide a comprehensive survey (road map) on various array-based
sequence data analyses and biomedical imaging along with their integrated studies
for different tissue-specific dreadful diseases (such as cancer). We included the
integrated studies of biomedical imaging and array-based data analysis for the same
set of patients (samples) that covered the problem of combinatorial gene signature
detection as well as disease subtype image classifications while specific multi-
modal data from well-known data repository (e.g., TCGA, ICGC) had been
1
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, University of Calcutta, Kolkata, India
2
Center for Precision Health, School of Biomedical Informatics, University of Texas Health Science
Center at Houston, Houston, USA
3
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Bankura Unnayani Institute of Engineering,
Bankura, India
4
Siemens Healthineers Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore, India
5
Pamela Sklar Division of Psychiatric Genomics, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York,
USA
6
Institute for Integrated Circuits, Johannes Kepler University Linz, Linz, Austria
228 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
provided. Finally, our book chapter covers the maximum area of biomedical ima-
ging as well as array-based sequence data analysis along with the contribution of AI
and ML in order to build a smart healthcare system, and provide a new dimension
to the interested biomedical researchers.
9.1 Introduction
Biomedical
data analysis
Single-cell
Biomedical RNA Chip
RNA Microarray
image -sequence -sequence
-sequence data analysis
analysis data analysis Data analysis
Data analysis
included the integrated study of biomedical imaging [15,16] and array-based data
analysis for the same set of patients (samples) that covered the problem of com-
binatorial gene signature detection as well as disease subtype image classifications
while specific multimodal data from well-known data repository (e.g., TCGA,
ICGC) had been provided. Finally, our book chapter covers the maximum area of
biomedical imaging as well as array-based sequence data analysis along with the
contribution of AI and ML in order to build a smart healthcare system and provide a
new dimension [17] to the interested biomedical researchers. The chapter aims to
provide researchers a review on various topics of biomedical data and the
advancement of new technologies that can be used to assist in battling COVID-19
disease.
The major contributions of the book chapter include the following: the first
section demonstrates the definition of various biomedical data and a comparative
study on different computational algorithms (AI- and IoT-based techniques)
applied to the biomedical data, while the second section of this book chapter covers
the advent of smart technologies during COVID-19 [18,19]. The last chapter
describes the conclusion regarding the empowerment of the new researchers to
further work on evolving additional solutions to combat COVID-19 and its future
applications in other biomedical applications (Figure 9.1).
positions, while each spot consisting of a defined DNA sequence (gene). The
microarrays are easier to use and cost-effective. They do not require huge scale of
DNA sequencing.
RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) is a process that is used to study the magnitude
and structures of RNA in a sample employing the next generation sequencing
technique. We can get RNA-seq data from various sources like ICGC, TCGA,
NCBI Gene Omnibus as stated by Geng et al. [2]. scRNA-seq is a demanding topic
used since the last decade. The scRNA-seq data are a prevalent and robust tech-
nology that permits researchers to describe the entire transcriptome of a huge
quantity of specific cells. scRNA-seq data are a popular dataset nowadays, but
analyzing scRNA-seq data is difficult due to technical variability, high noise levels,
and its massive sample sizes. scRNA-seq data have more dropouts and most often
generate sparse matrix that makes it a challenging process to identify original zeros
and dropouts.
There are three kinds of data analysis available, viz., (i) algorithms for biomedical
imaging data analysis, (ii) algorithms for array-based data analysis, and (iii) algo-
rithms for hybrid data analysis containing same set of patients.
efficacy of the technique meant for a couple of individual use cases, every single
comprising a couple of available set of data. For point-wise discussion on scRNA-
seq data, see Table 9.1.
9.4.2 Breast
The usual type of cancer in the females across the globe is the deadly breast cancer.
But the early discovery and identification of the breast cancer can minimize the
mortality rate significantly. The various categories of imaging modalities that have
been employed in order to detect and accumulate samples are mammography, US,
CT, MRI, and many others. The CADx generally facilitates the doctors and
pathologists in the detection of breast cancer. Kaushal et al. [3] report various
methodologies for diagnosing breast cancer using various histopathological images.
The important steps included in CAD analysis are preprocessing, segmentation,
feature extraction, and classification. The digital image preprocessing is performed
soon after the image is acquired. This plays the most essential part in detecting the
organic tissues depicted in the image by enhancing its quality without obliterating
the vital aspects. The second most essential stage is to detect the cells and the nuclei
of various histopathological images that form the basis for the classification are
called the segmentation stage. The third step, i.e., feature extraction phase, gen-
erally indicates the idea of getting prominent features that are immutable to the
inappropriate changes of the input. Following the image segmentation stage, mostly
the mining of features is done at the tissue level or could as well be done at the
cellular level in order to quantify the changes. Finally, classification is used to
classify which new instance belongs to which set of categories based on the
existing dataset. For detecting abnormality in the images, different classifiers are
used to classify tissues in various groups on the basis of the various kinds or grades
of the breast malignancy.
9.4.3 Kidney
Another most common form of cancer is renal cancer as reported by the National
Cancer Registry Program and Surveillance Epidemiology, and this renal cancer
Analysis of Artificial Intelligence and Internet of Things 237
accounts for almost 3–4 percent of the entire fresh cancer incidents in Indian sub-
continent and in the Western part of the world. We know that CADx systems can
help enhance the abilities of physicians and also reduce the total span needed to
conduct the exact analysis. Only way to survive for patients suffering from kidney
cancer is premature discovery and therapy employing various imaging modalities
that are noninvasive. Currently, renal cancer tomography mainly depends on CT. It
basically is believed as the benchmark for identifying and categorization of kidney
nodules. Kaur et al. [11] throw light on the massive role played by CADx for
kidney nodules. It starts with an acquisition of image, preprocessing, segmentation,
extraction of feature, selection, and categorization. Chaudhuri et al. [12] suggested
another deep learning model known as U-Net for semantic segmentation of kidney.
The main reason for selecting U-Net is that it is suitable for a smaller set of data,
and it was initially devised for the process of biomedical image segmentation.
9.4.4 Ovary
Ovarian cancer is another most suffered disease. It can sneak up on us like a beast
at night veiled as ordinary problems such prolonged bloating, then fatigue and the
constant need to pee. The extremely common form of ovarian cancer initiates in
aphelion cells, a particular type of cell that basically creates the tissue covering up
the ovarian surface. To treat the ovarian cancers in the best possible way, doctors
first confirm the identification and then discover the stage or the extent of the
cancer that requires a technique called the surgical staging during which the doctor
investigates the pelvic and the abdominal areas. The stage of the ovarian cancer is
determined by the position of the cancer cells prevalent in our body. In the first
stage, it is generally found on the upper surface of one or both ovaries or in the
fallopian tube or in the abdominal fluid. In the second stage, the cancer gets pro-
pagated from the initial site to other nearby areas such as the ovaries, the fallopian
tube, or even the uterus. In the third stage, cancer gets spread outside the pelvis like
the lymph nodes or also on the surface of liver or spleen as stated by Togashi [17].
All modalities like CT, US, and MR imaging have almost equal precision rate when
it comes to identifying stage of ovarian cancer.
Table 9.6 Algorithms for hybrid biomedical data having biomedical data and
array data together
System, software based on deep learning, to inevitably obtain and evaluate areas
believed to be affected with the virus. Then Silva et al. [45] came up with a voting-
based approach and a cross-dataset analysis called as Efficient-CovidNet. Here the
images from a given patient are categorized as a group in a voting system. The
method is examined in the two biggest datasets of COVID-19 CT analysis with a
patient-based split. To the best of our knowledge the two datasets are SARS-CoV-2
CT scan dataset and COVID-19 CT dataset. A cross-dataset analysis is also intro-
duced to evaluate the strength of the models in a more accurate scenario in which
data come from various divisions. Elaborate discussion on COVID-19 detection
patterns using CT images is given in Table 9.7.
healthcare service. While the IoT was used mainly used for monitoring a patient
remotely, AI, on the other hand, was mainly used to break down healthcare data
and used to track and screen patients.
patient instead can use this to diagnose the disease and carry on the prognosis based
on the data accumulated remotely. Hence with this, patients can continue to be at
their home and get consulted by doctors by sharing their day-to-day health
symptoms.
The authors in [49] proposed a technique to track patients and staff and thereby
lessen the waiting period. With the usage of smart devices like blood gas analyzers,
thermometer, smart bed, glucometer, US, and X-rays, there is a drastic improve-
ment in inpatient care. It builds an integrated information system in a hospital
where all events are stowed digitally, and other data analytics are utilized toward
problem-solving throughout COVID-19 pandemic. By means of constant examin-
ing the health status, it notifies almost every forthcoming ailment and offers a
solution for its inhibition. It is beneficial in the exposure of an asthma attack and
also as a reminder of on-time medication.
9.8 Conclusion
Hence, in our book chapter, we have provided a comprehensive detailed survey
(road map) on various biomedical imaging and array-based sequence data analyses
along with their integrated study for different tissue-specific dreadful diseases
(such as cancer). We also include a brief review of ML and IoT that helped in
paradigm shift in leveraging medical facilities and incorporating smartness of
healthcare for COVID-19 treatment.
In this regard, initially, we provided different algorithms on biomedical ima-
ging stated by Bej et al. [8] that included multilevel thresholding [9,10], MRF
model [11], and clustering algorithms [12]. The advantages, shortcomings, and
usages of different algorithms of biomedical imaging are demonstrated here.
Second, we yielded different array-based sequence data analysis algorithm that is
very much useful for biomedical research. These array-based data might be divided
into different categories, viz., single-cell sequencing data, RNA-seq as stated by
Shen and Thompson [6] data, microarray data, etc. Various algorithms applied to
each category of the sequence data have been notified here. This includes various
computational problems such as gene signature discovering, biomarker discovery,
disease classification or disease subtype classification, differential expression or
differential methylation analysis, prognosis study, gene module detection [13,14],
multimodal data integration, etc. For each problem, specific algorithms (or, tools)
have been mentioned here for the benevolent of the new researchers in this domain.
The advantages, limitations, and overall usages of each category of the algorithms
along with the corresponding comparative study of the different categories of
algorithms are also described here. As a future work, we will develop a new
algorithm using ML and deep learning applied to integrated data consisting of
array- and image-based profile together. Moreover, we will also perform some
computational work on de novo mutation.
Hence, various algorithms from different backgrounds can be utilized together
to solve computational problem in big biological data. Moreover, IoT and ML
Analysis of Artificial Intelligence and Internet of Things 255
approaches are used for single RNA-seq data for COVID-19. As a future scope, we
will try to comprehensively illustrate the transcriptional changes in peripheral
blood mononuclear cells and also the risks of COVID-19 virus on different
respiratory system conditions during the recovery stage of COVID-19 by scRNA-
seq technique and scRNA data analysis.
References
[1] Jiang S., Zhou D., Wang Y., et al. ‘Identification of de novo mutations in
prenatal neurodevelopment-associated genes in schizophrenia in two Han
Chinese patient-sibling family-based cohorts’. Translational Psychiatry. 2020.
[2] Geng C., Ning B. and Shi T. ‘Single-cell RNA-seq technologies and related
computational data analysis’. Frontiers in Genetics. 2019.
[3] Kaushal C., Bhat S., Singla A., et al. ‘Recent trends in computer assisted
diagnosis (CAD) system for breast cancer diagnosis using histopathological
images’. IRBM. 2019; 40: 211–227.
[4] Mann R., Cho N. and Moy L. ‘Breast MRI: State of the art’. RSNA
Radiology. 2019.
[5] Chandrashekar V., Sureshkumar V., Kumar T. S. and Shanmugapriya S.
‘Disease prediction based on micro array classification using deep learning
techniques’. Microprocessors and Microsystems. 2020; 77.
[6] Shen L. and Thompson P. ‘Brain imaging genomics: Integrated analysis and
machine learning’. Proceedings of IEEE. 2019; 108: 125–162.
[7] Sayed E., Dahshan A., Mohsen H., et al. ‘Computer-aided diagnosis of
human brain tumor through MRI: A survey and a new algorithm’. Expert
Systems with Applications. 2014; 41: 5526–5545.
[8] Bej S., Galow A., David R., et al. ‘Automated annotation of rare-cell types
from single-cell RNA-sequencing data through synthetic oversampling’
BMC Bioinformatics. 2021; 22: 557.
[9] Bandyopadhyay S. and Mallik S. ‘Integrating multiple data sources for
combinatorial marker discovery: A study in tumorigenesis’. IEEE/ACM
Transactions on Computational Biology and Bioinformatics. 2018; 15:
673–687.
[10] Hirotaka M., Kiryu H., Furusawa C., et al. ‘SCODE: An efficient regulatory
network inference algorithm from single-cell RNA-seq during differentia-
tion’. Bioinformatics. 2017; 33: 2314–2321.
[11] Kaur R., Juneja M. and Mandal A. ‘Computer-aided diagnosis of renal
lesions in CT images: A comprehensive survey and future prospects’.
Computers & Electrical Engineering. 2019; 77: 423–434.
[12] Chaudhuri K., Sharma R. and Halarnker P. ‘Kidney and tumor segmentation
using U-Net deep learning model’. 5th International Conference on Next
Generation Computing Technologies (NGCT-2019). SSRN. 2020.
[13] Colaprico A., Olsen C., Matthew H., et al. ‘Interpreting pathways to discover
cancer driver genes with Moonlight’. Nature Communications. 2020; 11.
256 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[44] Gullo R., Daimiel I., Morris E. and Pinker K. ‘Combining molecular and
imaging metrics in cancer: Radiogenomics’. Insights into Imaging. 2020; 11: 1.
[45] Silva P., Luz E. and Getal S. ‘COVID-19 detection in CT images with deep
learning: A voting-based scheme and cross-datasets analysis’. Informatics in
Medicine Unlocked. 2020; 20.
[46] Sandhu R., Sood S. K. and Kaur G. ‘An intelligent system for predicting and
preventing MERS-CoV infection outbreak’. The Journal of Supercomputing.
2016; 72: 3033–3056.
[47] Debnath S., Barnaby D. P., Coppa K., et al. ‘Machine learning to assist
clinical decision-making during the COVID-19 pandemic’. Bioelectronic
Medicine. 2020; 6: 1–8.
[48] Ozkaya U., Ozturk S. and Barstugan M. ‘Coronavirus (COVID-19) classi-
fication using deep features fusion and ranking technique’. In: Hassanien
AE., Dey N. and Elghamrawy S. (eds.), Big Data Analytics and Artificial
Intelligence Against COVID-19: Innovation Vision and Approach. Studies in
Big Data, vol. 78. Springer, Cham; 2020.
[49] Javaid M. and Khan I. ‘Internet of Things (IoT) enabled healthcare helps to
take the challenges of COVID-19 Pandemic’ Journal of Oral Biology and
Craniofacial Research. 2021; 11(2): 209–214.
[50] Gurcan M., Boucheron L., Can A., et al. ‘Histopathological image analysis:
A review’. IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering. 2009; 2: 147–171.
[51] Mallik S. and Zhao Z. ‘Identification of gene signatures from RNA-seq data using
Pareto-optimal cluster algorithm’. BMC Systems Biology. 2018; 12(8): 126.
[52] Mallik S., Qin G., Jia P. and Zhao Z. ‘Molecular signatures identified by
integrating gene expression and methylation in non-seminoma and semi-
noma of testicular germ cell tumors’. Epigenetics. 2020; 16(2): 1–15.
[53] Akbari Y., Hassen H., Al-Maadeed S. and Zughaier S. M. ‘Covid-19 lesion
segmentation using lung CT scan images: Comparative study based on
active contour models’. Applied Sciences. 2021; 11: 8039.
[54] Garg L., Chukwu E., Nasser N., Chakraborty C. and Garg G. ‘Anonymity
preserving IoT-based COVID-19 and other infectious disease contact tracing
model’. IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 159402–159414.
[55] Roy S. and Chakraborty C. ‘Panic buying situation during COVID-19 global
pandemic’. Journal of Information Technology Management. 2021; 13(2),
231–244.
[56] Chakraborty C. and Abougreen A. N. ‘Intelligent Internet of Things and
advanced machine learning techniques for COVID-19’. EAI Endorsed
Transactions on Pervasive Health and Technology. 2021: 1–14.
[57] Gupta A, Chakraborty C. and Gupta B., ‘Secure transmission of EEG data
using watermarking algorithm for the detection of epileptical seizures’.
Traitement du Signal. 2021; 38(2): 473–479. https://doi.org/10.18280/ts.
380227.
[58] Shahid O., Nasajpour M., Pouriyeh S., et al. ‘Machine learning research
towards combating COVID-19: Virus detection, spread prevention, and
medical assistance’. Journal of Biomedical Informatics. 2021; 117.
Analysis of Artificial Intelligence and Internet of Things 259
[59] Choi S., Lee J., Kang M. G., Min H., Chang Y. S. and Yoon S. ‘Large-scale
Machine Learning of media outlets for understanding public reactions to
nation-wide viral infection outbreaks’. Methods. 2017; 129: 50–59.
[60] Taiwo O. and Ezugwu A. E. ‘Smart healthcare support for remote patient
monitoring during COVID-19 quarantine’. Informatics in Medicine
Unlocked. 2020; 20.
[61] Zhang Y., Ma Y., Huang Y., et al. ‘Benchmarking algorithms for pathway
activity transformation of single-cell RNA-seq data’. Computational and
Structural Biotechnology Journal. 2020; 18: 2953–2961.
[62] Dash S., Chakraborty C., Giri S. K., Pani S. K. and Frnda J. ‘BIFM: Big-data
driven intelligent forecasting model for COVID-19’. IEEE Access. 2021; 9:
97505–97517. 10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3094658.
[63] Baran Y., Bercovich A., Sebe-Pedros A., et al. ‘MetaCell: analysis of single-
cell RNA-seq data using K-nn graph partitions’. Genome Biology. 2019; 20:
206.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 10
Review of medical imaging with machine
learning and deep learning-based approaches for
COVID-19
Swapnil Singh1, Vidhi Vazirani1 and Deepa Krishnan1
Abstract
1
Computer Engineering Department, Mukesh Patel School of Technology, Management, and
Engineering, NMIMS University, Mumbai, India
262 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
and deep learning algorithms and presented a critical review of the major short-
comings in existing mechanism that could open further research in this area.
10.1 Introduction
Coronavirus affects distinct species causing varied symptoms and diseases. The
latest mutant of the coronavirus family is the novel COVID-19 virus. This mutant
has affected millions of people all over the globe. The initial cases of this virus
were observed in Wuhan, China in early December 2019. After declaring the virus
that had already affected thousands a ‘Public Health Emergency Outbreak’ on 30
January 2020, the World Health Organization declared the severe acute respiratory
syndrome coronavirus 2 a pandemic on 11 March 2020.
With the increase in spread from one country to another, COVID-19 virus has
started to show mutations that are more dangerous and hence a cause of concern.
These mutations have started to show symptoms which are not displayed by the
traditional virus. These symptoms are low-grade fever, dry mouth, non-salivation,
gastrointestinal symptoms, and headaches [1]. It is important to detect the virus as it
can be easily transmitted from one person to another. Scientists anticipate that the
virus can be transmitted via droplets or aerosols released by an infected person. The
spread is typically within a 1-m radius [2]. However, some studies suggest that
COVID-19 is airborne and can spread to greater distances. This is a cause of great
concern. Greenhalgh et al. [3] presented 10-fold reasons to support the transmission
of COVID-19 being airborne. A reason stated to prove this was the transmission of
the virus between people in different rooms. Considering the high transmission rate
of the virus, governments all over the world have applied social-distancing restric-
tions to stop the spread of the virus. But treating a person is difficult considering the
social distancing norms. So Rahman et al. [4] developed the EdgeSDN-I4COVID,
this is a human-less IoT-enabled environment working without interruption. This
architecture assures efficient and intelligent management of COVID-19.
Considering the high growth rate of COVID-19, governments were not able to
prepare for the pandemic. Dash et al. [5] used the Facebook Prophet model to
predict the value of cases for the next 90 days, including the peak. They used data
from the USA, Brazil, India, France, Russia, and the United Kingdom shows that
these are the six most worst hit countries. The model was also able to identify five
significant change points and gave a goodness-of-fit as 85% mean absolute per-
centage error (MAPE).
COVID-19 is curable if it is detected at an early stage and the appropriate
medication is given to the patient. Several ways to detect COVID-19 are reverse
transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), rapid antibody testing (RAT),
and imaging techniques like computerized tomography (CT) scan, ultrasound, and
Review of medical imaging 263
chest X-ray (CXR). RAT is the fastest way of detecting COVID-19, and its kits
provide results in a few minutes, but it has a lower efficiency than RT-PCR. RAT
tests are done by pricking one’s finger and putting the blood in the test kit.
However, the problem with RAT is that since it tests antibodies and thus gives
negative results when the patient is recently infected, indicating a false negative.
Another problem is that in case the person has recovered, the person can still have
antibodies present in his/her blood, which would give a positive result, indicating a
false positive. Scohy et al. [6] got an efficiency of 30.2% for RAT tests. Thus, they
concluded that even though RAT tests give fast results, they are not reliable.
RT-PCR tests are more accurate than RAT tests, as proved by authors of [6],
but they are costly and take a lot of time. Considering a highly populated country
like India, RT-PCR test results take days to reach the patient; this creates life-
threatening concerns for the patients and people around them. Another concern
with RT-PCR test is that it is not able to detect the new mutants of COVID-19.
Thus, there is a need to explore other options which are reliable and more efficient.
This is where radiology comes into the picture. Pneumonia being the most common
symptom of COVID-19 can be detected with the help of CT scans and CXRs.
Chendrasekhar et al. [7] performed a comparative study on the efficiency of chest
CT scans and RT-PCR test. They performed their study on 1,400 individuals out of
which 41.6% were males and the average age was 46.282.7 years. They repre-
sented the results in an odds ratio (OR) with the confidence interval being 95%.
They proved that chest CT scan is superior to RT-PCR (OR 3.86, 95% CI), and it is
a rapid and more efficient alternative to RT-PCR tests.
Another radiological way of detecting COVID-19 is with the aid of a CXR.
CXRs are commonly used to detect pneumonia. CXRs can be obtained easily, as
they are cheap, readily available, and give results fast. Yasin and Gouda [8] per-
formed a study on 350 patients who were COVID-19 positive already. Out of these
350 patients, 220 showed baseline abnormalities in the CXRs. Out of the remaining
130 patients, 48 patients showed abnormalities in a follow-up. They concluded that
their findings were good for accessing COVID-19.
COVID-19 is spreading and mutating at high pace. Many counties have faced
second and third waves of COVID-19. In a country like India which has seen more
than 4 lakh positive cases per day, there is a need for an efficient, fast, and cheap
way of detecting COVID-19 so that the infected people can be treated on time. RT-
PCR tests take a lot of time for giving results and require a lot of workforce and
logistics, so it is not an optimal choice, whereas in the case of RAT tests, they have
a low efficiency rate. There comes in the field of radiography. As seen earlier, CT
scans and CXRs have established their efficiency for detecting COVID-19. CT
scans and CXRs provide a fast and efficient way of detecting COVID-19.
Machine learning and deep learning provide us with an opportunity to reduce
the burden of doctors and medical professionals. These models when trained
properly can give us accurate and efficient detection mechanisms that can help us
in an early detection of COVID-19. Training algorithms with the help of CT scans,
CXRs, and ultrasound can help us in automating the scanning process for detecting
COVID-19. Deep learning algorithms can be used to extract the important features
264 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
from these radiography images and then be used to train machine learning models.
Other feature extraction algorithms can be used to extract features, and then these
features can be used to train machine learning models. Image-processing techni-
ques can be used to enhance the radiography images before passing them through
the model for training them. These techniques can also be used to localize and
pinpoint the infected regions in CT scans, CXRs, and ultrasound images. These
applications would not only help in better diagnosis but also in reducing the burden
of medical staff, when there is a surge in the number of positive cases.
The major contributions of this survey include the following:
1. Reviewing the machine learning and deep learning architectures that are used
by researchers for the detection of COVID-19 giving emphasis to datasets used
and contributions by authors.
2. Presented a comparative analysis of the research works reviewed with impor-
tance to the challenges addressed by researchers in each work.
3. Identified the research gaps and provided future directions for the same.
This chapter is structured as follows: Section 10.1 consists of the introduction.
Section 10.2 talks about the reviewed work. The preliminary discussion gives a
brief idea about the various models and techniques discussed in the reviewed work.
Further in Section 10.3, a comparative study is done on the work as reviewed in the
previous section. Section 10.4 describes the most common research gaps;
Section 10.5 as “Conclusion” states the future scope of expanding this study.
14
14
12
11
10 9
8
Count
7 7 7
6
5
4
4
3 3 3
2
2
1 1 1 1
0
Custom CNN
VGG
Xception
ACGAN
GRNN
PNN
StackNet
GoogLeNet
ResNet
DenseNet
SqueezeNet
AlexNet
InceptionV3
InceptionResNetv2
NasNet
ML algorithms
MobileNetV2
Algorithms
related works the authors’ research works have attained better score in accuracy,
precision, recall, F1 score, sensitivity, and specificity. However, the model per-
formed poorly in low-quality X-ray images.
Another research work [10] in the same line is by authors Hernandez et al.
where they have used CNN with non-COVID-19 pulmonary X-rays and tuning
the final layers with COVID-19 X-ray images. The authors have accounted for the
data scarcity problem for COVID-19 images through augmentation techniques
available in OpenCV. The first approach used by the authors was to train CNN
model using pulmonary X-rays from CheXpert. Later final layers were added and
trained using CNN with COVID-19 X-ray images. However, the accuracy, pre-
cision, recall, and F1 score are found to be 0.68, 0.67, 0.63, and 0.65, respec-
tively. The second approach used by authors is with transfer learning using
ResNet50, VGG16, and DenseNet121. ResNet50 architecture is found to have
better accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score of around 90%. The authors have
also extended the work as a multi-classification task with three classes of normal,
COVID-19, and pneumonia. The testing accuracy for VGG16 is found to be
266 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
above 0.91 for the three-class classification scenarios and is less prone to over-
fitting than the other models. They also extended the work with DenseNet121 and
are found to have more false predictions.
In [11] also, a custom CNN and transfer learning using ImageNet models are
trained on publicly available datasets. In customized CNN approach, the authors have
reduced the model parameters using the separable convolutions. They have also used
the Talos optimization package to optimize the parameters and hyper parameters.
The iterative model pruning technique is used to find the optimal number of neurons
in the convolutional layers. The custom model gave an accuracy of 0.9467 and an
AUC score of 0.9842. It is found that VGG16 and VGG19 based models are found to
have the highest accuracy and AUC score. When the transfer models are applied on
binary classification task of detection between normal and COVID-19, it gave very
high-performance measures. In the three-class classification task for normal, bac-
terial pneumonia or COVID-19 pneumonia InceptionV3 gave an accuracy of 0.9742
and an AUC score of 0.9969. One of the significant contributions made in this pro-
posed work is iterative pruning of the specific models which helps in reducing the
number of trainable parameters. They have also improved the performance by using
ensemble of models. The performance of the model is further validated by using
visualization techniques that verify the localization of the ROI of the input dataset.
GoogLeNet
GoogLeNet is a state of art algorithm developed by Team GoogLeNet. Mayya et al.
[13] explained an application of GoogLeNet along with RF to detect COVID-19.
Their work consisted of a fusion of image and text classification. For selecting the
best combination of features, they used RF and trees on the two cases, first case
with two classes which were COVID-19 and non-COVID-19, and the second case
with four classes which were COVID-19, H1N1, pneumonia, and normal. Along
with RF, they also used RUSboost Trees, Boosted Trees, Medium Trees, Bagged
Trees, Coarse Trees, and Fine Trees. The text dataset had 32 attributes, when all of
them were taken into consideration, and the accuracy for four-class classification
was 77.5% and for two-class classification was 85.8%. Next, they reduced to 28
attributes and achieved an accuracy of 84.2% for four-class classification and
90.8% for two-class classification; finally, they reduced the attribute count to 22
attributes, hence, achieved an accuracy of 83.3% for four-class classification and
two-class classification. For the image dataset, it was preprocessed by using a
median filter that was used to smooth the intensity of the images, and they used
Otsu automatic thresholding to get the target regions and clear borders and hole
filling. For image classification, they replaced the fully connected layers for two-
and four-class classifications. For the image classification model, the four-class
classification gave an accuracy of 95.5% for COVID-19 and 72.43% for other
classes, whereas in the case of two-class classification, the COVID-19 accuracy
was 80.3% and 75% for non-COVID-19 class. Similarly, for the fusion model, the
accuracy of four-class classification is 91.3%, and 91.67% for two-class classifi-
cation. Since the model is trained on both textual and image data, missing values in
the textual data should not affect the performance of the model.
VGG
VGG networks are prominent neural networks that are used in transfer learning.
One such work was presented by Panwar et al. [14], where they used
VGG16 model to produce a new model, named nCoVNet. The images in the
dataset were first resized to 224 224 3. These images were then augmented by
rotating the images in the rage of 20 degrees, flipping images horizontally and
vertically. The model consisted of an input layer, followed by 18 combinations of
convolutional layers with ReLU as activation function and MaxPooling. These
layers were part of the VGG16 model. These layers were followed by a flatten
layer, an AveragePooling2D layer, a fully connected layer with 64 neurons and
ReLU as activation function, a dropout layer with the threshold of 0.5, and then we
have an output layer with two neurons. The model was compiled using the Adam
optimizer for 80 epochs and 0.0001 as learning rate. After training they got true
positives as 41, false negatives as 1, false positives as 9, and true negatives as 33.
The training accuracy was in the range of 93%–97% and with the training loss of
0.2%. They tried to solve the problem of data leakage by splitting the dataset using
a logical method instead of the traditional train_test_split.
Another such work was presented in [15], they compared VGG16, VGG19,
ResNet50V2, InceptionV3, Xception, InceptionResNetV2, NasNetLarge, and
268 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
DenseNet121; after comparing these CNN models, the best results were found in the
case of VGG19. The fine-tuned VGG19 model was trained and tested using X-ray
images, CT-scans, and ultrasounds. Since the dataset was small, data augmentation
was performed by flipping images horizontally and vertically. To reduce the effect of
sampling bias authors decided to apply N-CLAHE, this method not only normalizes
the images but also enhances the minute details in the images. After studying the
trends in tuned hyperparameters, five experiments were conducted, each having a
separate set of hyperparameters and dataset. The output classes for each of the five
experiments were different as well. The highest accuracy observed, using the
Ultrasound dataset, was 100%. The parameters were as follows: learning rate was
105, dropout rate kept at 0.2, batch size was 2, hidden layer states were set to 64 and
100 epochs. The best accuracy is for the X-ray dataset was 86% and was achieved by
tuning the learning rate to 103 dropout rate at 0.2, batch size and hidden layer state
to 8 and 100 epochs. For CT scans, however, the epochs had been set at 70 to avoid
overfitting and batch size was reduced to 4 while hidden states were increased to 64.
After tuning the learning rate at 103 and dropout rate at 0.2, an accuracy of 84% was
achieved.
Vaid et al. [16] presented the work on VGG19 with the main aim being to
reduce the false-negative cases as they are a major cause of concern. The model
proposed in the study was a modified version of VGG19. A trainable multi-layer
perceptron (MLP) was added to the traditional model to increase accuracy. This
MLP, consisted of four fully connected layers consisting of 512, 512, 64, and 2
neurons, respectively, the output layer used SoftMax as the activation function.
After the architecture was finalized, the hyperparameters were tuned: learning rate
was set to 0.001, epochs were 100, and batch size was made 15. Dimensions of the
input image was 512 512 and the output was binary classification (COVID-19 vs
no COVID-19). The modified VGG19 model gave superior results with an accu-
racy of 96.3% and 0.151 binary cross entropy loss. The testing data gave 74 true
positives, 32 true negatives, 3 false negative, and 1 false positive. However, the
study did have some limitations. The number of samples in the dataset was small
due to the non-availability of appropriate data. Another limitation stated was that
the results were purely based on the X-ray images and did not consider the various
external factors that may influence the result.
Brunese et al. [17] presented the use of VGG16 with two models to classify the
CXRs into healthy and disease classes and other disease classes and COVID-19.
Authors proposed a three-step method: first detecting pneumonia from the dataset,
second segregating COVID-19 from pneumonia, and third localizing the area
where the infection was present in COVID-19 CXRs. They used VGG16 for
detecting pneumonia from the dataset and then detecting COVID-19 from the
pneumonia samples. They replaced the fully connected layers of VGG16 with
average pooling layer, flatten layer, a fully connected layer with 512 neurons, a
dropout layer with threshold as 0.5, another fully connected layer with 64 neurons,
and finally an output layer with 2 neurons and activation function as SoftMax.
After classification, they used Grad-CAM, where a heat map is generated using the
gradient information in the last convolutional layer, and then a heat map is created.
Review of medical imaging 269
This heat map when added with the CXR gives the infected regions. The accuracy
for classifying healthy and disease classes was 96% and the time taken by the
model was 2.569 s, whereas the model gave an accuracy of 98% for the classifi-
cation of COVID-19 and other forms of pneumonia and the time taken by the
model was 2.498 s. For the future work, the authors aim to use this model over a
wider range of pulmonary diseases and find ways to verify the accuracy of the
model. A limitation of this chapter was that the dataset was highly biased and not
equally distributed; also the authors only restricted their work to VGG16 network
and did not explore other transfer learning models.
ResNet
ResNet CNN architectures are based on residual networks. ResNet18, ResNet34,
ResNet50, and ResNet101 are popular ResNet architectures. Minaee et al. [18]
compared ResNet18, ResNet50, SqueezNet, and DenseNet-121. For this purpose,
the authors built a custom dataset, COVID-CXR dataset, with CXR of COVID-19
and normal patients. The training set initially had just 84 COVID-19 X-rays and
had to be extended to around 420 images using data augmentation. The testing set
had 100 COVID-19 and 3,000 normal images. Even after data augmentation, the
number of training samples is limited and thus the authors only fine-tune the last
layer of each model after performing transfer learning. Each model runs for 100
epochs, has a learning rate of 0.0001, batch size is 20 and uses Adam Optimizer and
Cross-Entropy as its loss function. The loss function is minimized using stochastic
gradient descent. After training was completed, the models were tested and eval-
uated using performance metrics like sensitivity and specificity, precision–recall
curve, and confusion matrix. The best models were ResNet18 and SqueezeNet.
While all models had a sensitivity of approximately 98%, ResNet18 had a speci-
ficity of 90.7% while SqueezeNet had a specificity of 92.9%. Both ResNet18 and
SqueezeNet had only 2 false negatives, but 321 and 237 false positives, respec-
tively. The authors suggest that the model needs to be trained on larger COVID-19
datasets in order to achieve the desired performance.
More CNN models were compared by Nayak et al. [19] who concluded that
ResNet50 worked best when performing a binary classification on COVID-19
images. The authors started their study by collecting the right dataset. Images were
normalized by dividing the pixels with 255. Data augmentation was performed to
increase the number of images. Images were rotated by an angle of 5 degrees
(clockwise), horizontally flipped, scaled by 15%, and Gaussian noise (mean ¼ 0
and variance ¼ 0.25) was added to the images. The eight models compared by the
study were InceptionV3, MobileNet, AlexNet, GoogLeNet, VGG16, SqueezNet,
ResNet34, and ResNet50. Images were resized to 224 224 for all models expect
for InceptionV3 which has an input size of 299 299. Apart from different models,
different hyperparameters (optimizer, learning rate, epochs, and batch size) were
tested on each model to understand what worked best. For optimizers, Adam,
RMSProp, AdaDelta, and SGD were tested. Adam worked best for most models. A
batch size of 32 gave the best results for all models expect VGG16 and MobileNet
and thus was selected for the study. After comparing all the models using different
270 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
performance metrics, it was found that ResNet models gave 100% sensitivity.
However, ResNet34 outperformed ResNet50 due to its higher accuracy. While
ResNet34 gave an accuracy of 98.33%, ResNet50 stood at 97.50%.
Authors of [20] presented a combination of ResNet50 and U-Net for detecting
COVID-19 from CT scans, naming the network CoVNet. The ResNet50 model was
modified and after all the convolution layers, the final feature maps were fed to a
fully connected layer, giving probability for each class. The dataset contained only
those CT scan slices of thickness less than 3 mm. From the CT scan images, with
the help of U-Net, the lung area, which was the region of interest, was extracted and
used for training the model. For COVID-19 class, the sensitivity, specificity, and
AUC score were 90%, 96%, and 0.96, respectively, whereas the pneumonia class
gave a sensitivity of 87%, specificity of 92%, and the AUC score was 0.95.
Similarly, the AUC score for normal class was 0.98, specificity was 96%, and
sensitivity was found to be 94%. For better interpretation, the authors used Grad-
CAM for highlighting the infected regions in the CT scans. Some limitations stated
by the authors about their studies are as follows: (i) since COVID-19 shows
symptoms similar to that of pneumonia; (ii) the lugs could be affected by multiple
infections at the same time, so it is not possible to differentiate these images just
based on the visual appearance; (iii) a large dataset can be used for the study, for
creating a better and generalized model; (iv) deep learning models are not
interpretable and not transparent.
Ismael et al. [21] compared three ways to detect COVID-19 cases using CXRs:
deep feature extraction followed by SVM classification, fine-tuning pre-trained CNN
models, and building a custom end-to-end trained CNN model. In the first method,
the various kernels used in combination with SVM were linear (epsilon ¼ 0.04),
quadratic (epsilon ¼ 0.02), cubic (epsilon ¼ 0.01), and Gaussian (epsilon ¼ 0.01).
VGG16, VGG19, ResNet18, and ResNet101 were also used for feature extraction;
however, the results were not satisfactory enough. ResNet50 gave an average accu-
racy of 92.6% (all kernels combined). The ResNet50, combined with the linear
kernel SVM, gave an accuracy of 94.7%. In the case of fine-tuning, the same CNN
models were tuned and tested. Again, ResNet50 gave the highest accuracy of
94.63%, two false negatives, and five false positives. The custom CNN gave an
accuracy of 91.83% which was not as good as the previous models. Thus, the best
results were obtained using ResNet50 in combination with linear kernel function
of SVM.
In a study proposed by Zhong et al. [22], ResNet50 was used as base model for
feature extraction from CXR images. The authors began by collecting data from
three sources: COVIDx, five hospitals from Partners HealthCare system in the
United States, and four hospitals in South Korea. There were three classes in this
study: COVID-19, non-COVID-19 pneumonia, and control (normal images). After
performing essential preprocessing steps, segmentation was performed using an
ensemble of five deep neural networks based on the EfficientNet architecture.
ResNet50 is used as the backbone of the main model. Features are extracted in two
parts of the model. The first part, F1 consists of the first 22 layers of the ResNet50
architecture whereas the second part, F2 contains the next 18 layers. Between the
Review of medical imaging 271
two parts, there is a special attention module placed that generates a 16 16 mask
applied on the output of the ResNet50 model. After the two parts and attention
model, the features are mapped and passed through the remainder layers of the
ResNet50 architecture. To train this model, the Adam optimizer was used along
with a learning rate of 3e5, batch size of 48, 5 epochs, and 2,000 iterations. The
aim of the entire model is to learn function f that embeds given image into a
d-dimensional space. The next step is to classify the images using the features. To
do so, KNN algorithm is used with k ¼ 10. The KNN is found using the cosine-
similarity measure:
Si;j ¼ h f ðxi Þ; f xj i=kf ðxi Þk2 kf xj k2 (10.1)
However, to normalize the embedding, the denominator is set to 1. To calcu-
late the loss in the final paired metric learning stage, the multi-similarity loss
function in the following equation is used:
" #
1X m
1 X
aðSi;j lÞ
L ¼ log 1 þ e
m i¼1 a
" j2Pi
# (10.2)
1 X
bðSi;j lÞ
þ log 1 þ e
b j2Ni
where xi is the anchor image, Pi is the images with same label, Ni is the images with
different label, m is the batch size, a, b, l are the hyperparameters.
To better understand the effectiveness of the proposed architecture, the results
were compared with the baseline ResNet50 model. While the proposed model had
an accuracy of 83.9%, ResNet50 showed an accuracy of 81.5% on the same data.
The proposed model was also more sensitive towards the COVID-19 inputs.
DenseNet
DenseNet or Dense Convolutional Network connects one layer to all the layers in
the sequence ahead. Authors of [23] proposed a comparative study wherein CNN
models were used for extracting features followed by classification done by
machine learning techniques. For the study, the authors custom-made two datasets
– Dataset A and Dataset B. The only difference between the two datasets was that
they had normal X-ray images from different sources. To increase the size of
training samples, data augmentation using the affine transformations was per-
formed. A total of 144 experiments were conducted under this study. Each had a
different pair of CNN model and classifier. Since both datasets had different
samples, different models worked best for them. For Dataset A, DenseNet121 with
MLP worked best. But for Dataset B, DenseNet201 along with MLP worked.
Accuracy scores for the two datasets were 98.974% (approx.) and 95.641%
(approx.), respectively. However, when data was not augmented, Dataset A gave
best results with MobileNet and SVM (linear) and gave the highest accuracy. They
took into consideration many performance metrics like confusion matrix, F1 score,
false-positive rate, and time taken by network for training.
272 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
SqueezeNet
SqueezeNet provides similar efficiency as AlexNet. Chowdhury et al. [26] presented
the comparison between SqueezeNet, AlexNet, DenseNet201, and ResNet18 for the
detection of COVID-19 with the help of CXRs. These X-rays were collected from
various sources and then resized to 224 224 for DenseNet201 and ResNet18 and
227 227 for AlexNet and SqueezeNet. Since the number of images in the dataset
was low, the images were augmented and the normalized. Mini batch gradient decent
was chosen as the optimizer, the learning rate was set to 0.0003, momentum as 0.9,
and 16 mini-batches. For two-class classification, ResNet18 gave the testing accu-
racy of 96.7%, AlexNet gave the testing accuracy of 97.5%, whereas the testing
Review of medical imaging 273
accuracy of DenseNet201 was 98%, and the highest testing accuracy was 98.3%.
SqueezeNet gave the AUC as 0.998 and F1 score as 0.983. For three-class classifi-
cation, the testing accuracy for ResNet18 was 95%, testing accuracy of AlexNet was
95.4%, whereas DenseNet201 gave the testing accuracy as 96.7%, and again the
highest testing accuracy was given by SqueezeNet as 98.3%. The AUC score was
0.99 and F1 score was 0.983 for SqueezeNet. The performance of this chapter could
be improved by using more images in the dataset, which would help to generalize the
models.
Xception
Xception architecture is based on the Inception CNN architecture and is short for
‘Extreme Inception’. Khan et al. [27] presented the use of Xception architecture to
build a model – CoroNet – to detect COVID-19 using CXR images. In addition to
the traditional Xception architecture, CoroNet has a dropout layer and two fully
connected layers at the end of the model. After finalizing the architecture, three
models were prepared. The first and most elaborate set was a four-class classifi-
cation (COVID-19, Viral Pneumonia, Bacterial Pneumonia, and Normal). The
accuracy of this classification was 89.6%, F-measure was 89.8%, precision of 90%,
recall 89.92%, and specificity 96.4%. The other two models were based on this
main multi-class classification model. They were used to perform three-class
(COVID-19, normal, pneumonia) and two-class binary (COVID-19, normal) clas-
sifications. While the accuracy of the three-class model was 95%, the model made
for binary classification gave an accuracy of 99%. Although CoroNet provides a
way to detect the deadly virus in a less expensive manner and gives good accuracy
especially with binary classification, it needs to be trained and tested using bigger
datasets before it can be used practically.
Jain et al. [28] after comparing InceptionV3, ResNeXt, and Xception found
that the best results were obtained using the Xception model. The dataset used in
the comparison was gathered from Kaggle. The model proposed was for a three-
class classification (COVID-19, Normal, and Pneumonia). Preprocessing was done
using the Keras Data generator. The data was then used to train the model. The
CNN models used LeakyReLU for the activation function and SoftMax for the final
classification. While the Xception model gave an accuracy of 100% for the training
data, the testing data had an accuracy of 97%. The other two models, Inception and
ResNet, had a testing accuracy of 96% and 93%, respectively. The biggest limita-
tion of this study, however, was that the dataset was highly imbalanced.
In a more elaborate study as proposed by El Gannour et al. [29], six dif-
ferent CNN models were compared – VGG16, VGG19, InceptionV3, Xception,
ResNet50V2, and MobileNetV2. The ‘COVID-19 Radiography’ dataset used for
this study was curated by University of Doha and is publicly available on
Kaggle. Transfer learning was used to train the model on the COVID-19 dataset.
After preprocessing, the images were fed to these models for training.
Hyperparameter tuning was performed: learning rate ¼ 0.0001, batch size ¼ 15,
and epochs ¼ 50. While most models gave an accuracy of 97%, InceptionV3,
and Xception gave an accuracy of 98%. However, Xception proved to be the
274 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
better model as it had 100% COVID-19 sensitivity compared to the 95% sen-
sitivity displayed by the inception architecture.
MobileNetV2
MobileNetV2 is an improved version of MobileNetV1 and works on the concept of
ResNet. Apostolopoulos et al. [30] presented the use of MobileNetV2 and other
transfer learning algorithms to compare their efficiency in detecting COVID-19
from CXRs. For this purpose, they used two datasets, containing three classes
which were normal, pneumonia, and COVID-19. For their study, they used
VGG19, MobileNetV2, Inception, Xception, and InceptionResNetV2, and they
compared the performance of these models by using ReLU activation function for
all layers, a dropout layer between two fully connected layers, Adam optimizer to
compile the model, and trained the model for 10 epochs with the batch size 64.
VGG19 gave an accuracy of 93.80% on the first dataset whereas the accuracy for
MobileNetV2 was 92.85% on the same dataset. Similarly, on the same dataset,
Inception, Xception, and InceptionResNetV2 gave an accuracy of 92.85%. The two
best performing algorithms, VGG19 and MobileNetV2, were applied on the second
dataset. Here MobileNetV2 outperformed VGG19 and gave an accuracy of
94.72%, sensitivity of 98.66%, and specificity of 96.46%. MobileNetV2 is better
than VGG19 because it gives a better specificity, thus proving to better for the
classification task on a particular dataset. A limitation to the study was that all five
algorithms were trained for only 10 epochs, training the models further could
increase the efficiency.
An excellent example of MobileNetV2 being deployed in a mobile application
was demonstrated by Li et al. [31]. Authors used deep learning to build an applica-
tion that would detect COVID-19 from CXRs. They use a two-stage detection
mechanism where DenseNet121 is used as a pretrained attending physician and
resident doctor and MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet are used as medical students. The
goal of DenseNet121 is to classify the input X-ray image into normal, pneumonia,
and COVID-19. The DenseNet121 acting as the attending physician extracts features
from the CXRs, and then this is used to fine-tune the DenseNet121 acting as the
Resident Doctors. The tuned DenseNet121 is used to train MobileNetV2 and
SqueezeNet using knowledge distillation. MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet extract
features and predict whether the condition of the patient has improved, is stable, or
has deteriorated. Authors use probabilistic compact loss for training the
MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet, and the following equation displays the same:
1X K X X K
Lpc ðqÞ ¼ max 0; fj ðxik Þ þ x fk ðxik Þ (10.3)
N k¼1 i 2S j¼1;j6¼k
k k
where x is the tuning parameter for the network, larger the value, more would be
the interclass compactness. MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet were tested for their
resource consumption on six mobile phones. Overall, MobileNetV2 was better than
SqueezeNet for high performance phones, whereas SqueezeNet is more suitable for
low performance phones.
Review of medical imaging 275
AlexNet
AlexNet model won ILSVRC10 and had a top-5 error of 17.0%. Maghdid et al. [32]
presented a comparison between modified AlexNet and a custom CNN by training
the model over CT scan and X-ray images. The custom model consists of an input
layer, and this was followed by a convolutional layer with 16 filters of size 5 5 and
ReLU activation function, following this was batch normalization, two fully con-
nected layers, and finally the output layer with two neurons and SoftMax as activa-
tion function. The weights were initialized using Glorot and cross-entropy as loss
function. The modified AlexNet network had the input size of 127 127 3, the
batch size was set to 10, trained for 20 epochs, the learning rate was initialized to
0.0003. The accuracy for X-ray was 94% and for CT scan was 94.1% on the custom
CNN, whereas an accuracy of CT scan was 82%, and X-ray was 98% for modified
AlexNet. A limitation to the work is that the proposed models were only trained for
20 epochs, and further increase in accuracy could be observed.
10.2.1.3 Ensemble
As we have seen, transfer learning models have performed individually well,
researchers have tried to combine these models together for even better results. One
such work was presented in [33], the authors’ ensemble MobileNetV2 and
SqueezeNet for feature extraction from the CXR images, and then classified into
normal, pneumonia, and COVID-19 using SVM classifier. They preprocessed the
image with the help of fuzzy colour technique. Next, these images were given as
input to MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet and features are extracted keeping momen-
tum as 0.9, decay as 0.000001, batch size as 64, using stochastic gradient decent
activation function, and learning rate as 0.00001 for both the models. These features
were then clubbed using social mimic optimization and given as input to SVM for
classification. When MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet were used individually using the
same method, the overall accuracies were 98.54% and 97.81%, respectively, whereas
the ensemble model gave an overall accuracy of 99.27% which is clearly better than
the individual models. The future work of this model, as stated by the authors, is to
use deep learning to find the impact of COVID-19 on other organs to.
Another work was presented in [34] by using DenseNet121 and VGG19 for
feature extraction from CXR images and then using SVM for classifying the fea-
tures into normal, COVID-19, and pneumonia and named this model as CoVNet-
19. In the DenseNet121 model the last fully connected layer was removed, the
model now gave an output of 32 features in the shape of 32 1, like DenseNet121,
VGG19 was also gave an output of 32 features in the shape of 32 1 after the
removal of the last fully connected layer. These features were then concatenated to
the shape 64 1 and used to train SVM. Before giving input to the model, the
images in the COVID-19 class are augmented. For VGG19 and DenseNet121, the
Adam optimizer was used to train the model with the learning rate of 0.001 and
decay rate of 10 after each epoch, and batch size of 32. Individually the training and
testing accuracy for three-class classification of VGG19 and DenseNet121 was
96.17% and 96.08%; and 97.79% and 96.30%, respectively, whereas the CoVNet-
19 gave testing and training accuracy as 98.28% and 99.02%. For two-class
276 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
classification, the training and testing accuracy of VGG19 and DenseNet121 was
98.47% and 99.61%; and 99.87% and 99.60%, respectively, whereas the CoVNet-
19 gave testing and training accuracy as 100% and 99.71%. Future work as stated
by the authors is to eliminate the limitations to their proposed model, creating a
lighter version of the model so that it can be deployed on mobile phones.
feed-forward neural network used for classification and is a variant of the Bayesian
Network. Ardhya et al. [37] proposed a model that combines the two approaches
using the AND operator. The proposed model works as a multi-class classifier. It
classifies CXR images into four classes – normal, pneumonia viral, pneumonia
bacterial, COVID-19. Three sets of experiments are covered in this study – binary
classification (COVID-19 vs normal), three-class classification (COVID-19 vs
normal vs pneumonia bacterial), and four-class classification (COVID-19 vs nor-
mal vs pneumonia bacterial vs pneumonia viral). The dataset used in this study is
created by Joseph Cohen. Since the dataset is very small, one-shot learning tech-
nique was used. To ensure maximum accuracy, the model is trained using all
images, one at a time. However, an optimum number of training iterations is fixed
empirically. It derives raw features from the image which are then fed to the GRNN
and PNN models. However, it is important to choose the best samples and form a
cluster using the enhanced features. Thus, there is a need to combine the results
obtained by these models using the ensemble AND operation. Once the clusters are
ready, the model can be tested using the testing samples. Raw features are extracted
from the testing sample and fed to the ensemble model which classifies it. For
experiment 1 (binary classification), 100% accuracy was achieved. In experiment 2
(three-class classification), the highest accuracy of 85.23% was achieved when
13 samples were taken into consideration. Finally, for the last experiment (four-
class classification), an accuracy of 74.05% was achieved when a number of
samples were 29. Although the model considerably fails for four-class classifica-
tion, it ensures a 100% accuracy in its binary classification.
10.2.1.6 YOLO
Bhuyan et al. [35] used segmentation techniques followed by applying deep
learning to detect COVID-19 in CXRs and CT scans. YOLO with full-resolution
CNN was used to segment the infected areas in the images. The authors used a
dataset consisting of 2,794 images for training and 1,061 images for testing. After
segmentation, a CNN is used to classify if it is COVID-19. Classification was
performed over 4-fold cross-validation of test dataset. In the fourth cross-fold
validation with mass segmentation, the sensitivity was 96.66%, specificity was
99.41%, accuracy was 99%, MCC was 96.07%, and F1 score of 96.66%.
10-fold cross-validation, they extract the top 16 features. Using these features the
previously stated group of classifiers were trained. In the DT group, tree fine gave an
average accuracy of 83.57% and tree medium gave an average accuracy of 83.56%.
Linear discriminant gave an average accuracy of 79.11%, and in the ensemble
family, bagged tree gave an accuracy of 90.92%, subspace discriminant gave an
average accuracy of 89.87%, and subspace KNN gave an average accuracy of
95.58%. For SVM they used different kernels; for cubic kernel, the average accuracy
was 96.23%; for quadratic kernel, the average accuracy was 95.84%; for Gaussian
kernel, the average accuracy was 95.37%; and the average accuracy for linear kernel
was 94.75%. Similarly, different kernels were used for KNN also; for fine kernel, the
average accuracy was 95.19%; for medium kernel, the average accuracy was
92.25%; for coarse kernel, the average accuracy was 85.84%; for cosine kernel, the
average accuracy was 91.70%; for cubic kernel, the average accuracy was 91.79%;
and the average accuracy for weighted kernel was 94.78%. As seen from the results,
SVM with cubic kernel gave maximum average accuracy which was 96.23%. The
limitation to this study is the small size of the dataset. Since they have not used many
images, so their model would not be generalized.
Another study was performed in [39] to use local binary patterns and machine
learning algorithms to detect COVID-19. Local binary pattern is a method of tex-
ture feature extraction of images. The pixel values are compared with that of its
neighbours and a binary string is generated using the difference. This binary string
is converted to decimal, and this becomes the value of that pixel. The hyperpara-
meter for this is the radius (R) and the number of neighbours (P). They then applied
the extracted features to train naı̈ve GNB, KNN, SVM, random tree, and RF; they
also used ensemble of RF-RT-SVM, RF-RT-KNN, and RF-SVM-KNN. They
applied different combinations of R and P on the model are (1,8), (2,16), (3,24),
(4,32), (5,40), (6,48), (7,56), (8,64), (9,72), and (10,80); the average accuracies for
the models on these combinations are 84.467%, 83.525%, 84.344%, 83.525%,
83.361%, 83.852%, 83.648%, 81.926%, 80.328%, and 80.328%, respectively. It is
evidently visible that R1 (1,8) gave the best average accuracy, and overall, the
ensemble of RT-RF-KNN for (6,48) and (7,56) gave the best accuracy as 89.180%.
The limitation of this study is the small sample size used for the study.
Thepade et al. [40] proposed a way of detecting COVID-19 with the help of
global texture feature extraction using colour space. The images are converted from
RGB (red green blue) to YCrCB, Kekre-LUV, and CIE-LUV colour spaces, a feature
vector is generated considering different combinations of colour space. The first
feature vector is the concatenation of CIE-LUV and YCrCb, the second vector is the
concatenation of CIE-L, Y, and Kekre-LUV, and the third vector is the concatenation
of Kekre-LUV and YCrCb. These feature vectors are given as input to machine
learning model for classification; the models used were RF, ET, GNB, and ensemble
of ETþRFþSimpleLogistic (SL), ETþRFþGNB, and ETþRFþRT. These models
were trained using 10-fold cross-validation. For the first feature vector (YþCIE-
LþKekre-LUV), GNB gave an accuracy of 65%, ET gave an accuracy of 71.67%,
RF gave an accuracy of 82.92%, whereas the ensemble models ETþRFþRT,
ETþRFþNB, and ETþRFþSL gave accuracies of 80.83%, 80.83%, and 84.167%,
Review of medical imaging 279
respectively. Clearly, the ensemble of ETþRFþSL performed best for this feature.
When the second feature vector (YCrCbþKekre-LUV) was used, GNB gave an
accuracy of 66.67%, ET gave an accuracy of 78.33%, RF gave an accuracy of
82.917%, whereas the accuracies of the ensemble models ETþRFþRT,
ETþRFþGNB, and ETþRFþSL were 80.83%, 85.83%, and 87.083%. Again, the
ensemble of ETþRFþSL gave the best accuracy for the second feature vector too.
For the third feature vector (YCrCbþCIE-LUV), the accuracy for GNB, ET, and RF
were 67.5%, 80.83%, and 84.583%, respectively, whereas for the ensemble models
of ETþRFþRT, ETþRFþGNB, and ETþRFþSL the accuracies were 83.33%,
85%, and 84.167%, respectively. For the third feature the ensemble of ETþRFþNB
gave the best results. Overall, the combination of the feature vector YCrCbþKekre-
LUV and ETþRFþSL gave the best results of 87.083% accuracy, 87% precision,
87.1% recall, 86.9% F1 score, and 79.5% Matthews correlation coefficient. Though
the proposed model has low computational power, but the data used to train the
model is less, due to which the results are not up to the mark.
SqueezeNet(24
60 Xception(25)
MobileNetV2(28)
AlexNet(30)
40 MobileNetV2 and SqueezeNet(31)
DenseNet and VGG(32)
Generative Networks(33)
GRNN and PNN(34)
20 SVM(35)
KNN(36)
LR(37)
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0
Two class Three class Four class
Models (research work)
Research Feature ex- Dataset Sample size and classes Data augmenta- Class imbal- Major contri- Limitations
work traction tion ance butions
[12] Yes, using COVID-19 chest COVID-19: 634; pneu- Yes, Synthetic Yes, solved Proposed
VGG16 X-ray dataset monia: 4,474; normal: minority using aug- CovStacknet
(GitHub), 1,583; 2 combination of oversampling mentation
COVID-19 chest classes technique
X-ray (Kaggle), Normal and pneumo-
and labelled OCT nia; COVID-19 and
and chest X-ray non-COVID-19
images for clas-
sification (Kag-
gle)
[36] No IEEE COVID- COVID-19: 403; normal: Yes, using Yes Proposed a state GAN architecture
19 chest X-ray 721 ACGAN of art Covid- can be improved
dataset, COVID- GAN further; small da-
19 radiography taset
database,
COVID-19 chest
X-ray dataset
initiative
[37] Yes, using one Joseph Cohen 306 (69 COVID-19, 79 in No No 100% accuracy Accuracy of four-
shot learn- (COVID-19 chest normal, pneumonia in binary class classifica-
ing X-ray dataset) viral, pneumonia classification, tion is very low
bacterial); 3 combina- one-shot
tion of classes COVID- learning
19 and normal; normal, approach on
bacterial pneumonia, COVID-19
and COVID-19; dataset
normal, bacterial pneu-
monia, viral pneumo-
nia, and COVID-19
[9] No COVID-R 2,843 COVID-19 images, No Yes Proposed a cus- Model performed
3,108 normal images tom made 22- poorly in low
and 1,439 pneumonia layer CNN quality X-ray
images: a total of 7,390; images
COVID-19 and normal;
normal, bacterial pneu-
monia, and COVID-19;
normal, bacterial pneu-
monia, viral pneumo-
nia, and COVID-19
[27] No SIRM, Stanford 288 samples; normal and Yes, Python No Proposed a cus- Too many false
CheXpert COVID-19; normal, OpenCV tom CNN predictions
COVID-19, and pneu- model
monia
[11] No Paediatric CXR da- Normal: 7,595; unknown No Yes 22 High class imbal-
taset, RSNA pneumonia: 6,012; bac- ance
CXR dataset, terial pneumonia:
twitter COVID- 2,780; COVID-19: 313;
19 CXR dataset, normal and COVID-19;
Montreal normal, bacterial pneu-
COVID-19 CXR monia, and COVID-19
dataset
[13] No Italian society of 240 images out of which No Yes Proposed a fu- There are 120
medical and in- 120 were for COVID- sion model of images for
ternational radi- 19; COVID-19 and GoogLeNet COVID-19 due
ology and other non-COVID-19; and random to which it leads
medical re- COVID-19, normal, forest for im- to a bias dataset
sources pneumonia, and H1N1 age and text
classification
(Continues)
Table 10.1 (Continued)
Research Feature ex- Dataset Sample size and classes Data augmenta- Class imbal- Major contri- Limitations
work traction tion ance butions
[14] No COVID-19 image 142 PA images from 192 Yes, rotate No Proposed a deep The dataset is very
data collection images COVID-19 and images, hori- learning based small in size
and Kaggle’s 142 from the normal zontal and ver- neural net-
chest X-ray class of the Kaggle’s tical flip work called
images (pneumo- chest X-ray images da- nCoVNet
nia) taset; 2 classes COVID-
19 and non-COVID-19
[15] No CT-scan: COVID- X-ray: 729; CT: 746; ul- Yes No Made a compar- –
19-CT-dataset; trasound: 911; X-ray ison between
ultrasound: PO- classes-normal, all popular
COVID-Net: COVID-19, and pneu- imaging tech-
(POCUS); X- monia; CT classes- niques as well
rays: COVID-19 normal and COVID-19; as popular
image data col- ultrasound classes- CNN models
lection: prospec- normal, COVID-19,
tive predictions and pneumonia
are the future
[16] No COVID images: 181 COVID-19, 364 nor- No Yes High accuracy Research based on
publicly avail- mal with just 1 literature review
able papers/arti- false negative that may not be
cle, normal: NIH peer-reviewed
clinical centre
[17] No Dataset collected 6,523 images out of which Yes (rotation by Yes Highlighting the The dataset is
from various 250 were for COVID- 15 degrees) areas of in- highly imbal-
medical facilities 19 and 3,520 were nor- fection in the anced, study was
mal chest X-rays restricted to only
one model
[18] No COVID chest X-ray 406 images (203 in Rotated by an an- No Compared most Models are not
dataset for COV- COVID-19 and normal gle of 5 degrees popular mod- tested for multi-
ID images, classes each) (clockwise), els with var- class classifica-
GitHub repo horizontally ious tuneable tion
chest X-ray 8 da- flipped, scaled hyperparame-
taset for normal by 15% and ters
Gaussian noise
(mean ¼ 0 and
variance¼0.25)
[19] No Dataset collected COVID-19: 1,296; pneu- No No Highlighting the The dataset is small,
from 6 medical monia: 1,735; normal: infected area the model was
facilities 1,325 using grad- not analysed over
cam accuracy, preci-
sion, and
F1 score
[20] Yes, Re- COVID-19 X-ray 180 COVID-19, 200 nor- randomly rotat- No Proposed and –
sNet18, Re- chest and CT – mal ing, shifting, compared
sNet50, Re- Kaggle; and flipping the three different
sNet101, X-ray chest – training images ways of de-
VGG16, normal images tecting
and VGG19 COVID-19
[21] Yes, Re- COVIDx, 5 hospi- 4,119 COVID-19, 8,173 No Yes Used a combi- Achieved accuracy
sNet50 tals from partners control, 5,763 non- nation of deep not satisfactory
healthcare system COVID-19 pneumonia learning and for medical based
in the United machine research
States and 4 hos- learning
pitals in South
Korea
(Continues)
Table 10.1 (Continued)
Research Feature ex- Dataset Sample size and classes Data augmenta- Class imbal- Major contri- Limitations
work traction tion ance butions
[22] No Custom dataset, 5,184 (5,000 normal, 184 Yes; Flipping, Yes Achieved sensi- Data was imbal-
COVID-19-X- COVID-19) small rotation, tivity of ap- anced even after
ray-5k, using adding small prox. 98% for augmentation
COVID-19 chest amount of dis- all models
X-ray dataset and tortions
CheXpert
[23] Yes, using 12 COVID-19 images Both datasets: 388 images Yes; Affine trans- No Performed a to- Limited dataset for
CNN mod- – JP Cohen, (194 in COVID-19 and formations tal of 144 ex- training DL
els COVID-19-X- non-COVID-19 classes periments models
rays (Kaggle) each) using different
Normal (Dataset combinations
A) – chestX-ray of CNN mod-
images (pneumo- els and classi-
nia)Normal (Da- fiers
taset B) – NIH
chest X-rays
[24] Yes; Dense- COVID-19-CT- 746 images (397 non- Yes; reflection No Used extreme Data augmentation
Net201 ar- dataset COVID-19, 349 COV- (relative to the learning ma- was overused
chitecture ID-19) x and y axes) chine (EML) (dataset increased
rotation (angle from 746 to
values of 90 3,730)
and 270 de-
grees)
[25] Yes; Re- Dataset 1: chest X- Dataset 1: 5,856 (bacteria, Yes; Affine trans- Yes Model devel- Difference in image
sNet50, Ray images virus, normal) formation, his- oped gives sizes led to addi-
Dense- (pneumonia) Dataset 2: 441 (COV- togram en- higher accu- tional steps
Net169 Dataset 2: COV- ID-19, other viruses) hancement racy as com-
ID-19 chest X- Dataset 3: 2,000 (1,000 pared to base
ray dataset images, 1,000 masks) models
(GitHub)
Dataset 3: U-Net
[26] No Italian society of COVID-19: 190; normal: Yes, rotation, Yes, solved Proposed the ef- Lower number of
medical and in- 1,341; viral pneumonia: scaling, image by image ficiency of images in the da-
terventional radi- 1,345 translation augmenta- SqueezeNet taset
ology COVID-19 tion over Dense-
database, novel Net201, Re-
corona virus sNet18, and
2019 dataset, AlexNet
COVID-19 posi-
tive chest X-ray
images from dif-
ferent articles,
chest X-ray
images
[27] Na COVID-19 images 1,300 (290 COVID-19, No No Proposed model Proposed model
– GitHub repo by 310 normal, 330 bac- is computa- needs further
Joseph; normal, terial pneumonia, 327 tionally less clinical testing
pneumonia bac- viral pneumonia) expensive and
terial, pneumonia gives 99% ac-
viral – Kaggle’s curacy for
chest X-ray two-class
images (pneumo- classification
nia)
[28] No Chest X-ray (COV- Total ¼ 6,432; Yes, random rota- Yes Xception gave More models could
ID-19 and pneu- train ¼ 5,467 (COVID- tion 100% training have been com-
monia) 19 ¼ 490; (range ¼ 10 accuracy and pared
normal ¼ 1,345; degrees), 97% testing
pneumonia ¼ 3,632) flipped hori- accuracy
zontally,
zoomed in or
out
(range ¼ 0.4)
(Continues)
Table 10.1 (Continued)
Research Feature ex- Dataset Sample size and classes Data augmenta- Class imbal- Major contri- Limitations
work traction tion ance butions
[29] No COVID-19 radio- 2,905 images (219 No Yes 100% sensitivity More popular CNN
graphy COVID-19, 1,341 nor- for COVID- models could
mal, 1,345 pneumonia) 19 class using have been com-
Xception pared
[30] No (1) GitHub repo by 1,428 (224 COVID-19, No Yes Comparative Study does not
Cohen; (2) Kag- 700 pneumonia, 504 study of all consider other si-
gle – RSNA, normal) recent and milar virus that
radiopaedia, trending mod- may result in si-
SIRM; (3) (Ker- els – best per- milar X-rays
many et al.) formance by
MobileNetV2
[31] No RSNA pneumonia DS1: 179 images for nor- No No Develop a mo- Authors do not
detection chal- mal, pneumonia, and bile app consider the tra-
lenge (DS1) and COVID-19 classes COVID- ditional perfor-
COVID-19 im- each; DS2: 76 worse, MobileXpert mance evaluators
age data collec- 38 stable, and 45 im- like accuracy and
tion (DS2) proves loss
[32] No Chest X-ray images X-ray: COVID-19: 85 and No Yes Comparison of The dataset size is
(pneumonia) normal: 85; CT scan: transfer learn- small, authors
(Kaggle), radio COVID-19: 203 and ing and cus- have not ex-
helia, COVID- normal: 153 tom CNN plored other
19 chest X-ray CNNs
dataset (GitHub),
BSTI
[33] Yes, Mobile- Joseph Paul Cohen 458 (295 COVID-19, 65 No Yes Proposed an en- –
NetV2 and dataset, Qatar normal X-rays, 98 semble of
SqueezeNet University (Kag- pneumonia) MobileNetV2
gle – X-ray) and Squeeze-
Net for fea-
ture extraction
[34] Yes, VGG19 COVID-19 radio- COVID-19: 798; normal: Yes, width shift, Yes, tried to Proposed a state The dataset still re-
and Dense- graphy database 2,341; pneumonia: height shift, solve it of art model mains imbal-
Net201 (Kaggle), chest 2,345 zooming, using aug- called anced after
X-ray images shearing, and mentation CoVNet-19 augmentation.
(pneumonia) rotation by a Authors should
(Kaggle), COV- small angle have taken the
ID-19 chest X- same number of
ray dataset neutral and
(GitHub), COV- pneumonia
ID-19 chest X- images and then
ray dataset initia- applied augmen-
tive (GitHub), tation to the en-
and COVID-19 tire dataset
X-ray dataset
(Kaggle)
[38] Yes, using GitHub, Kaggle COVID-19: 135; pneu- No No Proposed the de- The dataset used is
multi- monia: 150; normal: tection of merely 435
kernel local 150 COVID-19 images, this is
binary pat- using machine very less to cre-
tern learning and ate a generalised
F-transform model for practi-
cal use
[39] Local binary COVID-19 image 305 (68 COVID-19, 79 No No Complete ma- Overall accuracy is
patterns data collection normal, 158 pneumo- chine learning higher for DL
(LBP) nia) based model models
(Continues)
Table 10.1 (Continued)
Research Feature ex- Dataset Sample size and classes Data augmenta- Class imbal- Major contri- Limitations
work traction tion ance butions
[40] Yes, YCbCr, COVID-19 image 60-COVID-19; 60-nor- No No Use of lumi- Small dataset; max-
Kekre- data collection mal; 60-viral pneumo- nance Chroma imum accuracy
LUV, and nia; 60-bacterial features for produced is of
CIE-LUV pneumonia COVID- 84.583% which
19 classifica- is low for medi-
tion cal applications,
hence model
cannot be de-
ployed in real
time
[41] Yes, non- – COVID-19: 291; influen- No No Random forest Small dataset, ac-
subsampled za A/B: 160; other dis- based model curacy is not
dual-tree eases: 119 for detection good for medical
complex COVID-19 application
contour let from other
transform pneumonia
and grey images
level co-
occurrence
Review of medical imaging 289
sources. We have tried to address these limitations in the next section and provided
a way for working ahead on these challenges.
10.5 Conclusion
With COVID-19 spreading all over the world, it has become vital that we try to
detect the virus at the earliest so that the infected person can be isolated and treated.
However, the most popular approach to detect the virus is the RT-PCR test that
takes hours to give results. The next best shot at detecting the virus is using
radiography techniques like CXRs, CT-scans, and ultrasounds. Although the ima-
ging is done within a few minutes, it requires experts and professionals to analyse
the obtained images and to detect the virus. Possibility of human errors increases
the misinterpretation rates. Thus, it is vital to develop a system that not only makes
such predictions in seconds but also yields satisfactory results. In this chapter, we
have summarized various research studies based on machine learning and deep
learning models. Majority of the models are trained using real-time data and yield
good results. Though training these models may be time-consuming, once trained,
they take a few milliseconds to test each sample. However, as discussed in many
papers, the biggest disadvantage to any COVID-19 related study is that there is very
limited amount of reliable data which is not sufficient to train deep learning mod-
els. Although the chapter features some papers that give high accuracies, the idea of
the model being biased due to imbalanced datasets cannot be completely elimi-
nated. Thus, future research should be done on datasets that have a sufficient
number of samples in each class. The best way to tackle the current problem is to
merge different models for detecting COVID-19. Merging the X-ray or CT scan
method with supervised machine learning models that detect COVID-19 using
various parameters like age, sex, diabetic, pneumonia, as discussed in [42], can
result in error-free and more accurate results. Apart from clinical methods to limit
the spread of the virus, various non-pharmaceutical techniques can be used as well.
One such technique as mentioned in [43] is to track the people who were in contact
with a positive patient. Thus, the most efficient way to fight the disease is to make a
Review of medical imaging 291
hybrid system that combines various models to detect COVID-19 using radio
imaging techniques.
References
[1] Apollo Pulmonologist. New COVID-19 symptoms to look out for [Internet].
Ask Apollo; 2021. [cited 2021 May 5]. Available from: https://healthlibrary.
askapollo.com/new-covid-19-symptoms-to-look-out-for/.
[2] World Health Organization. Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): How is it
transmitted? [Internet]. World Health Organization. 2020 [cited2021 May 6].
Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/coronavirus-dis-
ease-covid-19-how-is-it-transmitted.
[3] Greenhalgh T, Jimenez JL, Prather KA, Tufekci Z, Fisman D and Schooley
R. Ten scientific reasons in support of airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-
2. Lancet. 2021; 397(10285): 1603–5.
[4] Rahman A, Chakraborty C, Anwar A, et al. SDN–IoT empowered intelligent
framework for industry 4.0 applications during COVID-19 pandemic.
Cluster Comput. 2021; 4. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10586-
021-03367-4.
[5] Dash S, Chakraborty C, Giri SK and Pani SK. Intelligent computing on time-
series data analysis and prediction of COVID-19 pandemics. Pattern
Recognit Lett [Internet]. 2021; 151: 69–75. Available from: https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.patrec.2021.07.027.
[6] Scohy A, Anantharajah A, Bodéus M, Kabamba-Mukadi B, Verroken A and
Rodriguez-Villalobos H. Low performance of rapid antigen detection test as
frontline testing for COVID-19 diagnosis. J Clin Virol. 2020; 129.
[7] Chendrasekhar A. Chest CT versus RT-PCR for diagnostic accuracy of
COVID-19 detection: a meta-analysis. J Vasc Med Surg. 2020; 8(4): 1–4.
[8] Yasin R and Gouda W. Chest X-ray findings monitoring COVID-19 disease
course and severity. Egypt J Radiol Nucl Med. 2020; 51(1).
[9] Hussain E, Hasan M, Rahman MA, Lee I, Tamanna T and Parvez MZ.
CoroDet: A deep learning based classification for COVID-19 detection
using chest X-ray images. Chaos, Solitons Fractals [Internet]. 2021; 142:
110495. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2020.110495.
[10] Hernandez D, Pereira R and Georgevia P. COVID-19 detection through X-
ray chest images. 2020 Int Conf Autom Informatics, ICAI 2020 – Proc. 2020.
[11] Rajaraman S, Siegelman J, Alderson PO, Folio LS, Folio LR and Antani SK.
Iteratively pruned deep learning ensembles for COVID-19 detection in chest
X-rays. IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 115041–50.
[12] Rabbah J, Ridouani M and Hassouni L. A new classification model based on
StackNet and deep learning for fast detection of COVID 19 through X rays
images. 4th Int Conf Intell Comput Data Sci ICDS 2020. 2020.
[13] Mayya A and Khozama S. A novel medical support deep learning fusion
model for the diagnosis of COVID-19. Proc IEEE Int Conf Advent Trends
Multidiscip Res Innov ICATMRI 2020. 2020; 2–7.
292 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Chroma features of chest x-ray images. 2020 IEEE Bombay Sect Signat Conf
IBSSC 2020. 2020; 36–41.
[41] Wu Z, Li L, Jin R, et al. Texture feature-based machine learning classifier
could assist in the diagnosis of COVID-19. Eur J Radiol. 2021; 137.
[42] Muhammad LJ, Algehyne EA, Usman SS, Ahmad A, Chakraborty C and
Mohammed IA. Supervised machine learning models for prediction of
COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset. SN Comput Sci [Internet].
2021; 2(1): 1–13. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/s42979-020-
00394-7.
[43] Garg L, Chukwu E, Nasser N, Chakraborty C and Garg G. Anonymity pre-
serving IoT-based COVID-19 and other infectious disease contact tracing
model. IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 159402–14.
Chapter 11
Machine-based drug design to inhibit
SARS-CoV-2 virus
T. Lurthu Pushparaj1, E. Francy Irudaya Rani2,
E. Fantin Irudaya Raj3 and M. Appadurai4
Abstract
Researchers worldwide are striving hard to design the best anti-coronavirus drug to
overcome the current pandemic situation. Due to the lack of animal and human
trials data, the process is still complicating and causing more death worldwide.
Since biological testing costs more money and time-consuming, the combination of
computerized programs-based evaluation like molecular docking, virtual screening
(AutoDock, HEX, Schrodinger, Gaussian, and Glide), and molecular dynamics
study serves as a hopeful way in drug developing and studying their effect over
severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS)-coronavirus-causing components like
spike (S) protein present around the SARS-coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2), main
protease (M-pro), and ribonucleic acid cooperate. The keen analysis of the amino
acid sequences in the coronavirus-19 infection-causing proteins will give very
important information about the virus transformation and replication cycle. The
amino acid sequences and their active sites provided in the 3D crystalline structure
of M-pro (PDB ID; 6LU7) afford valuable data to the researchers about the type of
inhibitors that corresponds to the SARS-CoV-2 inhibition. Compared to all other
deadly viruses like flu, human immunodeficiency virus, and SARS, novel cor-
onavirus SARS-CoV-2 shows superior binding affinity over a human transmem-
brane protein christened angiotensin-converting enzyme 2, found in human lungs.
Since the target is very clear, every scientist aims to design a new drug or check the
available prodrug activity through a computer program to defeat the COVID-19
disease. Nowadays, many synthetic and natural drugs have been tested for their
suitability against M-pro. Since the coronavirus-19 infection spreads more
1
PG Chemistry & MRI Research Lab, TDMNS College, Affiliated to MS University, Tirunelveli, India
2
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Francis Xavier Engineering College,
Tirunelveli, Affiliated to Anna University, India
3
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Dr. Sivanthi Aditanar College of Engineering,
Tiruchendur, Affiliated to Anna University, India
4
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Dr. Sivanthi Aditanar College of Engineering, Tiruchendur,
Affiliated to Anna University, India
296 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
vigorously, the traditional real-time PCR test will need more time for infection
confirmation, so machine-based imaging studies like MRI, computerized tomo-
graphy (CT), and X-ray are needed. The MRI and CT need contrast agents (CAs) to
give more precise images. The development of image contrast-enhancing agents
will give more appropriate outcome image in detecting COVID-19 infection in the
early stages. The designing of perfect multimodal CAs is the current research
among MRI researchers. It will behave as both targeting and coronavirus-19 killing
drug for the current pandemic situation. All the above-said applications can be
accomplished only by designing the drug and then studying their binding studies
through a computer application.
11.1 Introduction
In the fast genetic research world, silicon chip-engineered devices have become a
right hand for researchers. Since the application of this is unlimited, a good science
researcher can develop a new genetically modified microbe, vaccine, or drug for
the deadliest disease. This becomes true on seeing the current pandemic situation
rooted by the deadliest beta microbes called severe acute respiratory syndrome
coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2), a perfectly laboratory-made virus-containing BAT
and PIG genes [1]. Typically, viruses that reason illnesses in people are known to
program at least one protease that assumes significant parts in the viral life cycle.
Reacting rapidly to obscure microbes is essential to stop the uncontrolled spread of
sicknesses that lead to an outbreak, for example, the novel coronavirus. In the past
two decades, six coronaviruses, like SARS-coronavirus (fatality rates of 9.6%),
MERS-coronavirus (fatality 34%), HCoronavirus-HKU1, HCoronavirus-OC43,
HCoronavirus-NL63, and HCoronavirus-229E, have infected the human population
in the years 2002 and 2012.
Currently, the new SARS-CoV-2 and a genetically modified SARS-CoV-2
with a high fatality rate >83% identified during December 2019 have killed about
4.8 crore people worldwide. It is hard time for every science researcher to develop a
smart vaccine without side effects or a molecular efficient drug in a short time to
avoid the current uncontrollable infection. The standard protocols in medicinal
research involve defining the exact problem developing or creating a site and
design a lead drug or vaccine for genome infections. This methodology will require
long periods of innovative work, which requests colossal theory, which cannot
execute for the permanent virulent disease. Maybe we need a quick and worthwhile
come-up to hinder the viral disease. In silico strategies are a preexamination loom
before wet research facility studies, which enjoys the benefit of having the option to
make a quick and cost-productive investigation. Also, by selecting suitable algo-
rithms, we can exactly predict the reactive site on the virus from this; we can
Machine-based drug design to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 virus 297
elucidate the molecular structure of the vaccine candidate and a growth inhibition
drug for infected proteins. By choosing the target site, we can synthesize a lead
drug for the deadliest virus, which causes coronavirus-19 infection.
The scientists report speculation that inborn traces of coronavirus can incor-
porate into our cell chromosomes and stick there for a long time even after the
disease is cured. They tracked down those undeniable degrees of regular ribonu-
cleic acid (RNA) have created in light of the mix of infection with cell DNA that
peruses its grouping and makes a greater amount of it for duplication. It is
recommended that in uncommon discovering, individuals can recuperate from
coronavirus yet then test positive for coronavirus again months after the fact. The
scientists underlined that viral combination did not mean individuals who recup-
erated from coronavirus-19 stay irresistible. Since the COVID-19 antibodies
dependent on messenger RNA (mRNA) may be one way or another change human
DNA. The protein, switch transcriptase, is encoded by LINE-1 components,
groupings that litter 17% of the human set of chromosomes and address antiques of
earlier contaminations by retroviruses.
A genetic laboratory analysis reports that when human cells spike with addi-
tional LINE-1 components of coronavirus, DNA adaptation of SARS-CoV-2’s
groupings settle into the cell chromosomes. The experimental evidence from
“National Cancer Institute” supports the original hypothesis that the integrated viral
sequences will remain on human cells even after cured of coronavirus. The
advanced program that can be incorporated into in silico methods can assist
researchers in developing a drug that can target two or more diseases at one time
(combination therapy) [2]. In any case, the improvement of the best combos is the
most part difficult to make in a brief period span in a prudent and harmless to the
ecosystem. To smooth out combos dosing regimens, the improvement of particles
with double hindrances abilities against at least two unique classes of the objective
would be ideal [3]. It turns out to be more important, if clinically demonstrated
FDA-supported antivirus, virus tracking MRI contrast agents (CAs), monoclonal
antibody (mAb) drugs are considered for the studies. To develop smart multi-target
molecules for the current situation, the researcher needs to pick an appropriate
antiviral drug from the drug data bank that is already in use for other viral infec-
tions. After that, the researcher can study their limiting linkage with lung
TMPRSS2, angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), and RdRc (viral) proteins on
SARS-CoV-2.
This chapter will discuss in detail the computer-based designing program used
for the designing and pre-synthesis of an antiviral drug for COVID-19 infection.
The readers will gain extra knowledge about the process happening in COVID-19
virus replication and the in silico procedure adopted to identify the key amino acid,
which is the root cause for the viral replication and structural transmission. The
chapter will give in-depth knowledge about the status of antiviral drugs that are
under reinvestigation for their ability against COVID-19 infection. In addition, the
chapter throws limelight on the importance and application of MRI, dual imaging
MRI, and computerized tomography (CT) imaging modalities that are the best
among the best than PCR analysis.
298 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
The sequence of this chapter is in the following order. First, we have given a
detailed introduction based on a literature survey about the in silico methods used
in drug designing against COVID-19. Second, we discussed the types of COVID-
19 virus and their replication and stereochemical transforming mechanism, fol-
lowed by the role of antibody and vaccine available against COVID-19. Third, we
described the test available for COVID-19 infection. Fourth, we discussed the top-
notch in silico methods used in anti-COVID-19 drug research and their working
procedure. Fifth, we have given a summary of the previous four portions and the
future scope. Finally, we finished the chapter with conclusions followed by
references.
SARS-CoV-2 quite fit with Coronaviridae, a family with huge enveloped RNA.
The RNA set of the chromosome of Coronaviridae extends up to 27–32 kb with full
of interlinked structural and nonstructural proteins.
The name SARS-CoV-2 is derived from the fact that approximately 82% of the
RNA set of the chromosome is identical to the SARS-coronavirus [4], 50% iden-
tical with MERS [5], and 79% resemblance with SARS. The X-ray diffracted 3D
crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2 has about 88% identical employing a set of cor-
onavirus identified in bats (bat-SLCoronavirus-ZC45 and bat-SLCoronavirus-
ZXC21). Coronaviruses are an infectious disease with thousands of thornlike active
proteins arranged in a throne pattern mostly on the boundary that could infect pigs,
bats, cows, birds, and other mammals. Furthermore, it mutates quickly to one
another and humans, causing diseases in the respiratory tract, lung, gastro-intestinal
(GI) tract, liver, kidney, and central nervous systems (Figure 11.1).
These infections are competent to be grouped into four typical varieties called
alpha COVID, beta COVID, MERS COVID, and SARS-COVID-2 [6]. In the set of
COVID-19 chromosomes, the 50 -replicase generates a polyprotein. A frameshift
occurs between ORF-1b and ORF-1a, resulting in the formation of two polypep-
tides: pp1ab and pp1a, which are subdivided into 16 non-underlying proteins (nsp-1
to nsp-10 and nsp-12 to nsp-16) whose mutual mutation is interceded by the main
protease (M-pro) (nsp-5, 3CL-pro (3CL protease)/M-pro) and nsp-3, PL-protease
SARS-CoV-2 (3D-Str)
(S1 and S2 spike proteins)
SARS-CoV-2
(PL-pro). The 30 -end modulates multiple core protein molecules that have epithelial
layer (M), spike (S) proteins, nucleocapsid (N), envelope (E), hemagglutinin-
esterase (HE), as well as eight movable proteins (p6, 3a, 3b, 7a, 7b, 8b, 9b, and
orf14). Approximately 29 highly active proteins are involved in SARS-CoV-2
transmission and replication in congregation cells [7]. Every structural protein
received the translational pathology from the viral subgenomic messenger called
vsgRNAs, which has the RNA cooperate. The crystal structure of RdRc on SARS-
CoV-2 revealed that one nsp-12 subunit (cooperate responsive catalytic subunit)
contains a nidovirus RdRc-associated nucleotidyltransferase (NiRAN) realm in the
nitrogen atom functioned array and anchoring part to connect the C-terminal RdRc
with NiRAN domain [8]. The catalytic site has ASP 760, ASP 761 (SDD), and SER
759 residues that lie in the pattern “C” used for the primer binding of RdRc with the
congregation. However, the M-pro looks like a calm enzyme but contributes
equally to RdRc in the regeneration of SARS-CoV-2. This enzyme consists of
about 305 asymmetric amino acid sequences through His41 and Cys145 catalytic
divectors and the substrate-binding mark positioned between the sandwiched
domains I and II. Tai et al. [9] put forward the truth that the amino acid present
between 331 and 524 residues of spike protein produces receptor-binding domain
(RBD) fragment that helps the SARS-CoV-2 to bind strongly with bat ACE2
(bACE2) and human ACE2 (hACE2) as receptors. Thus, this pointed protein sec-
tion is accountable for a mutual admission of SARS-CoV-2 and SARS-coronavirus
in human lung ACE2-state cells.
Every structural protein received the translational pathology from the viral
subgenomic messenger called vsgRNAs, which has the RNA cooperate (RdRc and
nsp-12) and the 30 -50 exo-RNA. The crystal structure of RdRc revealed that one nsp-
12 subunit contains a nidovirus RdRc-associated nucleotidyltransferase (NiRAN)
realm in the nitrogen atom functioned array and anchoring part to connect the C-
terminal RdRc with NiRAN domain [8]. The catalytic site has ASP 760, ASP 761
(SDD), and SER 759 residues that lie in the pattern “C” used for the primer binding
of RdRc with the congregation. However, the M-pro looks like a calm enzyme but
contributes equally to RdRc in the regeneration of SARS-CoV-2. This enzyme
consists of about 305 asymmetric amino acid sequences through His41 and Cys145
catalytic divectors and the substrate-binding mark positioned between the sand-
wiched domains I and II. Tai et al. [9] put forward the truth that the amino acid
present between 331 and 524 residues of spike protein produces RBD fragment that
helps the SARS-CoV-2 to bind strongly with bACE2 and hACE2 as receptors.
Thus, this pointed protein section is accountable for a mutual admission of SARS-
CoV-2 and SARS-coronavirus in human lung ACE2-state cells.
bind over the protease domain congregation cell and undergo replication in
humans. Every human has transmembrane proteins, ACE2, in the lungs, GI track,
kidney, and brain. Initially, spike proteins attack the ACE2 enzyme through RBD
and undergo conformational changes by the fusion of viral molecular RNA with the
human congregation cell layer. After the dispersion interaction, the viral ribosome
goes into the congregation cell and creates more infections by replicating its
arrangement of chromosomes and causes viral contamination. Once tainted, the
viral subgenomic messenger, which has nsps, gets collected into multiethnic
cooperate composites, to establish a reaction appropriate for recording and repli-
cations of the viral arrangement of a chromosome. The viral chromosome sequence
on the site will develop virions with primary proteins [10].
During the replication cycle inside the congregation, the RNA-subordinate RNA
cooperate (RdRc), nitrogen-functioned protein, long-chain ribosome, and modified
active ribosomal frameshifting locale of the infection are profoundly associated with
connection with RNA of the congregation cell. There are four primary useful desti-
nations installed in the entire ribosome: (a) the mRNA-restricting site; (b) the tRNA-
restricting locales that contain the aminoacyl spot, neutral peptide spot, and cleaving
function; (c) the peptidyl relocate center (PTP); (d) anchoring center for replication
[11]. It demonstrates that ACE2 is set to be a more essential enzyme to recombine
SARS-CoV-2 over RdRc. In the spreading stage, the high polar region combined
through RdRc, this repeated procedure supports the nonstop Virna RN acid replica-
tion. From molecular screening contemplates, it accounted for that the coarticulation
of angiotensin-converting and TMPRSS2 enzymes in the lung and stomach-related
tracks is a key for SARS-CoV-2 to enter the human tissue anatomy [12]. The report
additionally affirmed that amino acid groups like Hi-296, Ar-345, and Se-441 were
the reaction performing groups of TMPRSS2, which also contains the highly viral
replication supportive amino acids like Ar-435, Se-436, and Gly-464. To help the
assertion, the Ar-710 at ACE2 element from 697 to 716 assists the arrangement of the
ACE2–TMPRSS2 complex [13]. This connection supports the enzymatic change in
ACE2 receptors to make connections with the TMPRSS2 enzyme and Ar-652. This
site can be anchored by tracking the presence of the TMPRSS2 enzyme.
From the docking outcome (Figure 11.2), it is affirmed that the Arg652 is
situated at the suitable pose toward the protease catalectic group of three amino
acids. Also, Arg716 is available at the connection spot of ACE2, and Arg710 offers
more in making H-bonds to do appropriate protease-receptor cooperation [14]. The
M-pro protein comprises three spaces. A notable b-barrel is mostly taken after
chymotrypsin is found in spaces I (deposits 8–101) and II (buildups 102–184). Yet,
space III has remnants from 201 to 306 that contain a-helices. The missed remnant
from 185 to 200 is utilized to associate spaces II and III individually. It calls
attention to space III of M-pro. It is more fundamental for keeping up the proteo-
lytic modification, which occurs by holding the space II and the long circle remnant
Machine-based drug design to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 virus 301
ASP 713B
GLU 638B
TYR 414C ARG 413C
ARG 710B
ARG 417C
ARG 652B
SER 436C
A5P345C
HIS 296G
SER441C
Figure 11.2 The boundary of ACE2 enzyme in lung and TMPRSS2 proteins
MHC II
Cytotoxic TLR2/TLR2
T cell TLR4/MD2
mbrane
TH2 Plasma me
TH1 cytokine
cytokine
Epitope binding
causes cytotoxic Mal Tram MyD88 Mal
MHC I
ol TRIF
Epitopic T cells to divide Antigen Cytos MyD88
sequences and attack presenting cells IRAK4
recognized infected cells B cells are IRF 3
Helper T
by the MHC activated by
cell
cytokines IRAK1 IRAK2
Activated
plasma cell NF-NB
Few T cells Activated
Antigen converts into cytotoxic T Memory B cell
cell Nucleus
presenting cells memory cells
Infected cell
Deactivated Purified
virus RNA
Fluorescence
E N
RT-qPCR~2 h per primer set
Purified RNA is reverse transcribed to cDNA
PCR amplification
Retrotranscription Threshold
Negative
involves the current gold standard intended for nucleic acid recognition, novel
approaches such as pulse-controlled multiplication are being investigated. Pulse-
controlled multiplication requires no RNA excavation and can be completed in 10 min
using a tiny device. In the years ahead, S- and N-based antigen detection systems will
be used in conjunction with nucleic acid amplification tests to improve COVID-19
diagnostic accuracy at a low cost. Upcoming years, efforts to build new therapeutic
platforms could pay off if the analyses are exact, original, and uncomplicated to
execute, deliver results promptly, and are inexpensive to produce in mass [26].
Table 11.1 List of approved natural and synthetic drugs that are in trials against
COVID-19 outbreak
N-oxide (QO) and Quinoline (Q) nitro compounds were analytically explored
(Figure 11.5).
The medication candidates are associated well with the M-pro active site, with
binding energies ranging from 4.31 to 5.04 kcal/mol. In addition, some of the
nitro-QO compound inhibitors, such as N9-QO, N8-QO, and N4-QO, showed
slightly higher stabilizing binding energy values than their nitro-quinoline coun-
terparts. Docking tests were done with the commercialized medications CQ and
HCQ, which are presently used to treat SARS-CoV-2 contamination, to test the
possibility of such discoveries, in addition to their binding, energy conditions were
determined to be 2.33 and 2.80 kcal/mol, correspondingly (Table 11.2).
The hydrogen-bonded relation of the N4-Q molecule with Cys44 at 2.78 Å and
hydrophobic interactions with other amino acid sequences like Cys145, Gln189,
Glu166, Gly143, His41, His163, His164, Met49, Met165, Ser46, Ser144, Thr45,
and Val42, respectively, are given in Figure 11.6 (MD-1). These linkages are
310 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
C145
H41
H41 C145
E166
E166
HOH
HOH H41
HOH
E166
H164
C145
C145
H41 HOH
HOH H41
E166
HOH
Figure 11.5 Binding structure of (D-1) N4-Q, (D-2) N4-QO, (D-3) CQ, (D-4)
CQO, (D-5) HCQ, and (D-6) HCQO in the M-pro active site
Table 11.2 Binding sites and their affinity energy for the antiviral drugs
chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine
CH3 BS-3
BS-2 CH3 CH3 OH
H N CH3 H N CH3
N N
BS-3 BS-2
Cl N Cl N
BS-1 BS-1
MET
THR MD-1 MD-2 A:165 PRO
A:45 A:39
GLN HIS
CYS A:189 A:164
A:44
GLU
HIS
A:166
A:41
SER GLY SER
A:46 A:143 A:46
MET
A:49 GLN SER
HIS
A:189 A:144
A:163
CYS
MET A:145
HIS A:49 SER
A:41 VAL CYS
MET GLU HIS A:147
A:42 A:145 GLY
A:165 A:166 A:163 A:146
LEU
A:27
HIS GLY SER
A:164 A:143 A:144
Figure 11.6 Image of molecular dynamics analysis done for N4-Q and N4-QO
with M-pro
necessary for decreasing M-pro’s enzyme reactions, and they are consistent with
the findings of earlier docking studies [37]. The N4-QO molecule, on the other
hand, binds to the M-pro was stabilized by four H-bonds such as Ser144 (3.04 Å),
Gly143 (3.01 Å), His41 (2.93 Å), and His163 (2.72 Å), and hydrophobic affinity
with Cys145, Glu166, Gly146, Gln189, His164, Met49, Met165, Leu27, Pro39,
Ser46, and Ser147, respectively, Figure 11.6 (MD-2). Interestingly, the binding
affinity of HCQO gets raised to 1 kcal/mol, which confirms their stability than any
other derivatives of CQ. Possible variations of HCQO and CQO compounds could
be used for evaluating the weight of the N-oxide group at different sites. Every
medication nominee’s molecular modeling position suggested that they can anchor
precisely within the membrane chamber. According to molecular docking and
binding energy calculations, viral proteases that are responsible for hewing the viral
polypeptides and maintaining the viral regeneration process could be ideal ther-
apeutic targets for viral illnesses. In cases where the virus generated confrontation
by transmutation, protease inhibitors have been employed in combination medi-
cation therapy. Since the M-pro enzyme contains two polyproteins, pp1a and pp1ab
act as the most important foundation for virus duplication. HTVS, SP, and XP-
based gliding scores are used to create hit molecules using a docking-based mole-
cular modeling approach, while ADMET can then be used to depict the pharma-
cologic and physicochemical properties of the suggested lead compounds.
To investigate the affinities of the lead compounds, molecular concept mod-
eling might be used. When comparing the binding affinity of the molecule ABBV-
744 to M-pro (G-bind 45.43 kcal/mol), it is discovered that the combination is more
stable than other protein–ligand complexes. It is a hypothesis that remdesivir
attaches to targets, RdRc and 3CLpro on SARS-CoV-2 with high interaction score.
According to the results of a molecular docking study, remdesivir and its enzyme
(GS-441524) have excellent binding scores of 6.4 and 7.0 kcal/mol, respec-
tively, and stability that with M-pro (Figure 11.7), indicating supplemental
312 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
–5
Affinity (kcal/mol)
–6
–7
te ine
F he e
Di avip xine
yc b le
M oro xol
GS nas st
Ka -441 rin
4
En ina l
d n
in
N3
ox Am amo r
Um tec vir
Qu nov r
Re erc ir
Cu fina ir
rc vir
K
p o
id vi
ife avi
om uin
em 52
m eti
l v
Ci luka
O6
Lo pfer
um
on qu
e
yr ira
Ne esi
hl ro
Br roq
lo
Ch
p
dr
Hy
GI tract rupture, which causes diarrhea. Curcumin stabilizes the interaction with
SARS-CoV-2 major protease, according to molecular modeling experiments, with
better interaction energy of 7.1 kcal/mol. When it creates stable compounds
with the M-pro, the other antimicrobial drugs quercetin and kaempferol, which
seem to be abundant in fruits and vegetables, have greater docking studies values
of 6.45 and 6.62 kcal/mol, correspondingly (Figure 11.7).
Nelfinavir is used to treat HIV, and a molecular modeling investigation of such
an antiviral drug revealed a kind of approaches, a score of 7.01 kcal/mol with the
SARS-CoV-2, major proteases. The higher bonding strength indicates their ther-
apeutic implications for inhibiting M-pro in COVID-19 illness. It is currently being
tested in clinical trials as an antiretroviral to prevent SARS-CoV-2 replication.
Umifenovir is an antimicrobial agent available in Russia and China that has been
experimentally used in China to manage COVID-19. In vitro, umifenovir reduces
SARS-CoV-2 with an IC50 of 30 M [39]. It has also demonstrated significant
benefits as COVID-19 distributed postexposure prophylaxis. According to a
molecular modeling study, the M-pro site of SARS-CoV-2 can engage with the
major enzyme and limit replicating with an interactive score of 6.51 kcal/mol. An
asthma inhibitor molecular drug, montelukast, shows excellent suppression of M-
pro, as evidenced by the interaction affinity 6.2 kcal/mol acquired via docking
studies. Montelukast has also been shown to be effective as an anti-inflammatory
agent in the SARS-CoV-2. Another medication drug dipyridamole has a wide range
of antiviral properties and has been clinically demonstrated to be an excellent anti-
COVID-19 drug [40]. Dipyridamole’s antiviral mechanism includes the inhibition
of the M-pro, as demonstrated by an in vitro surface plasmon resonance experi-
ment. The binding energy score is 5.8 kcal/mol.
The docked complex with low RMSD score (Table 11.3) implies a high-
quality model. HADDOCK grouped 120 structures into 12 MHC class I clusters,
accounting for 60.0% of the water-sophisticated HADDOCK mock-up. The low
HADDOCK score of 214.74.1 shows that the antibody and MHC class I
receptor has significant affinities, and the reduced RMSD indicates that the
docked complex is stable. HADDOCK groups 64 structures into nine MHC class
II clusters, accounting for 32% of the water-refined HADDOCK stimulate
models. The stable and strong molecular interaction between the virus active
spot and vaccine is proved by the low HADDOCK score. The human MHC class
I cell surface receptor HLA-A*0201 is one of the most common ones. HLA-
A*0201 has a three-dimensional shape found in the RCSB protein database
under the PDB ID 1I4F (Figure 11.8). Chain-A with 275 amino acids and the
beta-2 microglobulin chain, which has 100 amino acids, make up HLA-A*0201
[42].
Table 11.3 HADDOCK binding values for TLR-2, TLR-4, MHC-I, and MHC-II
with M-protease
180
~b
b
135 b ~b
~I
90
I
45
a
0
~a
–45
–90
ASP 29 (A)
–135 b ~p
p
b
~b
Figure 11.9 The image showing the Phi (degree) vs Psi (degree) for HLA-A*0201
(Ramachandran plot)
T:U10
P:U20
Ground-glass
opacification
Normal SARS-CoV-2
infection
Tissue
damage
Normal SARS-CoV-2
infection
1,500
0
T2 (ms)
50
25
0
Pre-contrast 10 min 20 min (Gd) (mM)
0.15
0.075
0
(Dy) (mM)
0.7
0.35
Figure 11.13 Dual contrast agent [Gd(III) and Dy(III)] administered tumor
image from fluorescence MRI analysis
10
9 7
6 8
H N 10
N
2 8 7 7
4 5
1
Cl N
3
Hyperpolarization
12 34 5 6 7 8 9 10
9.5 9.0 8.5 8.0 7.5 7.0 6.5 6.0 5.5 5.0 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0
1H NMR (ppm)
10 8 11
6 9 7
H N
N OH
2 9 8 8
4 5
1
Cl N Hyperpolarization
3
1 2 3 4 5 67 8 9 10, 11
10.0 9.5 9.0 8.5 8.0 7.5 7.0 6.5 6.0 5.5 5.0 4.5 4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5
1H NMR (ppm)
11.9 Summary
Scientists, who won Nobel Prize for genetics, virology, drug designing, many other
live researchers, and doctors have confessed that the SARS-CoV-2 is a man-made
genetically modified virus. Scientists create numerous vaccines and antiviral drugs to
prevent the progression of the whole virus, but still it cannot be stopped. It is due to
the critical mechanism used in the construction of a viral molecule. The geneticists
who designed COVID-19 used three types of RNA, the majority of which came from
bats and pigs. Since RNA is important for constructing DNA in living things,
aggressive treatment on the virus-affected patient will lead to death. Therefore, the
only procedure we can do is to hide the RNA from coronavirus infection. Several
vaccines have been reported in the literature, but these are all accepted for medical
practices under pandemic situations without doing human trials. Therefore, the future
ill effect or the side effect of the currently available vaccine is unknown. Vaccines
will activate the human immune system against COVID-19 disease. However,
according to the WHO analysis and another medical report, there is widespread
concern that patients are dying as a result of SARS-CoV-2 virus infection even after
Machine-based drug design to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 virus 323
vaccination. On the other hand, it is recognized that the changeover in the protein
sequences from normal to high critical version on the coronavirus happens only
because of the vaccinated patient who got a COVID-19 infection.
Based on the discussion, it is concluded that each version of COVID-19
requires ACE2 enzyme for multiplication in the respiratory system, GI, kidney, and
brain, making it an important enzyme to recombine SARS-CoV-2 over RdRc. In
the spreading stage, the high polar region on the virus combined through RdRc, this
repeated procedure supports the nonstop viral RN acid replication. Furthermore, the
coarticulation of angiotensin-converting and TMPRSS2 proteins within the
respiratory system and stomach-related pathways have just been attributed as a key
for SARS-CoV-2 to enter the human tissue anatomy. The virus cannot generate
energy for its replication like cancer microbes. COVID-19 requires a huge amount
of sugars for their survival. This thirst for energy is satisfied by the presence of key
amino acids like Hi-296, Ar-345, Se-441, Ar-435, Se-436, Gly-464, and Ar-710 at
ACE2, and virus spike proteins. Therefore, if we need to stop the replication, we
need a target specific or amino acid-binding or anchoring antiviral drug. These
drugs can be newly designed or an already existing one. The requirement is the
high water solubility, long stay on the target, less steric strain, and zero side effects.
Currently, no antiviral drug has the abovesaid criteria. It is hoped that using in
silico methods, we will be able to design a new drug. Researchers can use in silico
methods to help them design new efficient drugs, find the anchoring spot over
coronaviruses, and test their antimicrobial properties. Researchers can use com-
puter programs such as Biorod, ChemSketch, and ACD labs to design drugs.
For evaluation, the molecular docking and molecular dynamics procedures are
addressed to be more user-friendly than the other algorithms. This computerized
algorithm will provide detailed amino acid sequences in viruses, enzymes, and any
complicated proteins, as well as additional information about the drug’s binding
efficiency and binding site on the coronavirus and other enzymes and proteins
involved in virus replication. For virtual screening, the AutoDock Vina and struc-
tural mechanics are found to be more reliable. The catalytic breaking interaction of
3CL-pro at distinct subsists of the polyproteins releases different polypeptides. As
discussed earlier, nearly 29 highly active proteins are involved in SARS-CoV-2
transmission and replication in the human lungs cell. 3CL-pro has been identified
as a potential-targeted therapy for COVID-19 diagnosis due to its vital role in
disease progression and indeed the lack of a near-human counterpart. According to
this molecular analysis of the M-pro, the Arg652 moiety is in the proper position to
form a link with Arg716 and Arg710, which are present over the ACE2 enzyme in
the human lung, brain, kidney, and GI tract. Any drug molecule that can disrupt the
linkage of these three amino acids will be the most effective anti-COVID drug. In
addition, it has been established that the M-pro protein is responsible for viral
replication as well as gene conversion or transmission. As a result, any drug
molecule that ideally ties the M-pro pocket may inhibit SARS-CoV-2 replication.
It is claimed that designing and developing a new chemical molecule with
these binding properties takes more time. Furthermore, their medicinal trial studies
on living organisms will take longer time. As a result, reanalyzing, reusing, or
324 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
and time required. The ever-green PCR test itself makes the wrong decision on
COVID infection analysis. The PCR tool can be upgraded with a live gene repli-
cating algorithm to detect coronavirus infections and their structurally changed
virus molecule. Once the infection is confirmed, the next step is to locate the virus.
This information is critical for patients who have other chronic diseases as well as a
coronavirus infection. CT and MRI are the most promising treatments. The
advancement in the design of image-enhancing CAs with dual color-producing
properties will identify the locations where the virus spreads and the concentration
of the virus in the location. From this, the physician can understand the severity of
the organ, which got an infection. The biomolecular elemental analysis will give
information about the amino acid sequences, enzyme present, and tissue pH. Basic
information about the molecular sequence on the ROI is available in the Protein
Data bank. Next, it is in the researcher’s hand to analyze the chemical bonding
sequence through molecular imaging (AutoDock Vina-4.2) and analyzing program
(Gaussian algorithm integrated python module). For instance, the researcher can
select antiviral drugs like chloroquine, remdesivir, leucovorin, nelfinavir, and cur-
cumin from viral data bank and perform the docking and molecular dynamics study
to find the antiviral efficiency against SARS-CoV-2. Other synthetic scientists can
do their research in designing and evaluating drug molecules by using the pre-
viously discussed in silico procedures. Once the design is finished through this
algorithm, the binding energy and the viral inhibition efficiency can be calculated.
This will reduce the laboratory time and the cost of invention. The in vivo study can
be performed on animals and human samples using advanced MRI instruments.
The live monitoring of the drug action using CT scans and dual-color-based mul-
timodal MRI scanning agents will be the future scope of this study.
References
[1] Rome B. N. and Avorn J. ‘Drug evaluation during the Covid-19 pandemic’.
New English Journal of Medicine. 2020; 382(24): 2282–2284.
[2] Bang S., Son S., Kim S. et al. ‘Disease pathway cut for multi-target drugs’.
BMC Bioinformatics. 2019; 20(74): 1–12.
[3] Zhou J., Jiang X., He S., et al. ‘Rational design of multitarget-directed
ligands: Strategies and emerging paradigms’. Journal of Medicinal
Chemistry. 2019; 62(20): 8881–8914.
[4] Zhang L., Lin D., Sun X., et al. ‘Crystal structure of SARS-CoV-2 main
protease provides a basis for design of improved a-ketoamide inhibitors’.
Science. 2020; 368(6489): 409–412.
[5] Park M., Thwaites R. S., and Openshaw P. J. M. ‘COVID-19: Lessons from
SARS and MERS’. European Journal of Immunology. 2020; 50(3): 308–311.
[6] Rabaan A. A., Al-Ahmed S. H., Haque S., et al. ‘SARS-CoV-2, SARS-CoV,
and MERS-COV: A comparative overview’. Le Infezioni in Medicina. 2020;
28(2): 174–184.
[7] Shanmugaraj B., Siriwattananon K., Wangkanont K., and Phoolcharoen W.
‘Perspectives on monoclonal antibody therapy as potential therapeutic
326 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[21] Zhu X., Wang X., Han L., et al. ‘Multiplex reverse transcription loop-
mediated isothermal amplification combined with nanoparticle-based lateral
flow biosensor for the diagnosis of COVID-19’. Biosensors and
Bioelectronics. 2020; 166: 112437.
[22] Corman V. M., Landt O., Kaiser M., et al. ‘Detection of 2019 novel cor-
onavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR’. Eurosurveillance. 2020; 25
(3): p2000045.
[23] Shen Z., Xiao Y., Kang L., et al. ‘Genomic diversity of severe acute
respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 in patients with coronavirus disease’.
Clinical Infectious Diseases. 2020; 71(15): 713–720.
[24] Smyrlaki I., Ekman M., Lentini A., et al. ‘Massive and rapid COVID-19 testing
is feasible by extraction-free SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR’. Nature Communications.
2020; 11: 4812.
[25] Abduljalil J. M. ‘Laboratory diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2: Available approa-
ches and limitations’. New Microbes and New Infections. 2020; 36: 100713.
[26] Kevadiya B. D., Machhi J., Herskovitz J., et al. ‘Diagnostics for SARS-CoV-
2 infections’. Nature Materials. 2021; 20: 593–605.
[27] Trott O. and Olson A. J. ‘AutoDock Vina: Improving the speed and accuracy
of docking with a new scoring function, efficient optimization and multi-
threading’. Journal of Computational Chemistry. 2010; 31(2): 455–461.
[28] Tien H., Haoran W., and Binquan L. ‘In silico exploration of the molecular
mechanism of clinically oriented drugs for possibly inhibiting SARS-CoV-
2’s main protease’. The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters. 2020; 11(11):
4413–4420.
[29] Guedes I. A., Costa L. S. C., dos Santos K. B., et al. ‘Drug design and
repurposing with DockThor-VS web server focusing on SARS-CoV-2 ther-
apeutic targets and their non-synonym variants’. Scientific Reports. 2021; 11
(1): 5543.
[30] Keretsu S., Bhujbal S. P., and Cho S. J. ‘Molecular modeling studies of
pyrrolo [2, 3-d] pyrimidin-4-amine derivatives as JAK1 inhibitors based on
3D-QSAR, molecular docking, molecular dynamics (MD) and MM-PBSA
calculations’. Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics. 2021; 39(3):
753–765.
[31] Pushpakom S., Iorio F., Eyers P. A., et al. ‘Drug repurposing: Progress,
challenges and recommendations’. Nature Reviews Drug Discovery. 2019;
18(1): 41–58.
[32] Chen Y. W., Yiu C. P. B., and Wong K. Y. ‘Prediction of the SARS-CoV-2
(2019-nCoV) 3C-like protease (3CL pro) structure: Virtual screening reveals
velpatasvir, ledipasvir, and other drug repurposing candidates’.
F1000Research. 2020; 9: 129.
[33] Muralidharan N., Sakthivel R., Velmurugan D., and Gromiha M. M.
‘Computational studies of drug repurposing and synergism of lopinavir,
oseltamivir and ritonavir binding with SARS-CoV-2 protease against
COVID-19’. Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics. 2021; 39(7):
2673–2678.
328 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[34] Muhammad L. J., Algehyne E. A., Usman S. S., Ahmad A., Chakraborty C.,
and Mohammed I. A. ‘Supervised machine learning models for prediction of
COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset’. SN Computer Science.
2021; 2(11): 1–13.
[35] Elfiky A. A. ‘Ribavirin remdesivir, sofosbuvir, galidesivir, and tenofovir
against SARS-CoV-2 RNA dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp): A mole-
cular docking study’. Life Sciences. 2020; 253: 117592.
[36] Wu C., Liu Y., Yang Y., et al. ‘Analysis of therapeutic targets for SARS-
CoV-2 and discovery of potential drugs by computational methods’. Acta
Pharmaceutica Sinica B. 2020; 10(5): 766–788.
[37] Assis L. C., de Castro A. A., de Jesus J. P. A., et al. ‘Computational evidence
for nitro derivatives of quinoline and quinoline N-oxide as low-cost alternative
for the treatment of SARS-CoV-2 infection’. Scientific Reports. 2021; 11: 6397.
[38] Murugan N. A., Kumar S., Jeyakanthan J., and Srivastava V. ‘Searching for
target-specific and multi-targeting organics for Covid-19 in the Drug bank
database with a double scoring approach’. Scientific Reports. 2020; 10: 19125.
[39] Lu H. ‘Drug treatment options for the 2019-new coronavirus (2019-nCoV)’.
BioScience Trends. 2020; 14(1): 69–71.
[40] Liu X., Li Z., Liu S., et al. ‘Therapeutic effects of dipyridamole on COVID-
19 patients with coagulation dysfunction’. Acta Pharmaceutica Sinica B.
2020; 10(7): 1205–1215.
[41] Van Zundert G. C. P., Rodrigues J. P. G. L. M., Trellet M., et al. ‘The
HADDOCK 2.2 webserver: User-friendly integrative modeling of biomole-
cular complexes’. Journal of Molecular Biology. 2016; 428(4): 720–725.
[42] Kumar N. ‘Cytotoxic T-lymphocyte elicited vaccine against SARS-CoV-2
employing immunoinformatics framework’. Scientific Reports. 2021; 11: 7653.
[43] Elmezayen A. D., Al-Obaidi A., Şahin A. T., and Yelekçi K. ‘Drug repur-
posing for coronavirus (COVID-19): In silico screening of known drugs
against coronavirus 3CL hydrolase and protease enzymes’. Journal of
Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics. 2020: 1–13.
[44] Garg L., Chukwu E., Nasser N., Chakraborty C., and Garg G. ‘Anonymity
preserving IoT-based COVID-19 and other infectious disease contact tracing
model’. IEEE Access. 2020; 8: 159402–159414.
[45] Chakraborty C., and Abougreen A. N. ‘Intelligent Internet of Things and
advanced machine learning techniques for COVID-19’. EAI Endorsed
Transactions on Pervasive Health and Technology. 2021: 1–14.
[46] Taka E., Yilmaz S. Z., Golcuk M., et al. ‘Critical interactions between the
SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein and the human ACE2 receptor’. The
Journal of Physical Chemistry B. 2021; 125(21): 5537–5548.
[47] Choy K. T., Wong A. Y., Kaewpreedee P., et al. ‘Remdesivir, lopinavir,
emetine, and homoharringtonine inhibit SARS-CoV-2 replication in vitro’.
Antiviral Research. 2020; 178: 104786.
[48] Bullen C. K., Hogberg H. T., Bahadirli-Talbott A., et al. ‘Infectability of
human BrainSphere neurons suggests neurotropism of SARS-CoV-2’. Altex.
2020; 37(4): 665–671.
Machine-based drug design to inhibit SARS-CoV-2 virus 329
[49] Bernheim A., Mei X., Huang M., et al. ‘Chest CT findings in coronavirus
disease-19 (COVID-19): Relationship to duration of infection’. Radiology.
2020; 295(3): 200463.
[50] Zhou Z., Guo D., Li C., et al. ‘Coronavirus disease 2019: Initial chest CT
findings’. European Radiology. 2020; 30(8): 4398–4406.
[51] Pushparaj L. T. and Alexander V. ‘Trinuclear Gd(III) metal complex with
amide core display remarkable enhancement in relaxivity’. Applied
Magnetic Resonance. 2017; 48(8): 813–825.
[52] Salarian M., Turaga R. C., Xue S., et al. ‘Early detection and staging of
chronic liver diseases with a protein MRI contrast agent’. Nature
Communications. 2019; 10: 4777.
[53] Pushparaj L. T., Francy I. R. E., and Uma D. M. ‘HSA and CA-125 binding
study of [Pr-(DO3-Ch-Ph-Am-Gd(III))2Pt(IV)] complex as M-MRI contrast
agent for ovarian cancer treatment’. Journal for Innovative Development in
Pharmaceutical and Technical Science. 2021; 4: 1–8.
[54] Anderson C. E., Donnola S. B., Jiang Y., et al. ‘Dual contrast – Magnetic
resonance fingerprinting (DC-MRF): A platform for simultaneous quantifi-
cation of multiple MRI contrast agents’. Scientific Reports. 2017; 7: 8431.
[55] Lindeman L. R., Jones K. M., High R. A., et al. ‘Differentiating lung cancer
and infection based on measurements of extracellular pH with acidoCEST
MRI’. Scientific Reports. 2019; 9: 13002.
[56] Abbasi A., Javed A. R., Chakraborty C., Nebhen J., Zehra W., and Jalil Z.
‘ElStream: An ensemble learning approach for concept drift detection in
dynamic social big data stream learning’. IEEE Access. 2021: 1–12.
[57] Kevadiya D., Machhi J., Herskovitz J., et al. ‘Diagnostics for SARS-CoV-
2 infections Bhavesh’. Nature Materials. 2021; 20:593–605.
[58] Anderson C. E., Johansen M., Erokwu B. O., et al. ‘Dynamic, simultaneous
concentration mapping of multiple MRI contrast agents with dual contrast –
Magnetic resonance fingerprinting’. Scientific Reports. 2019; 9(1): 19888.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 12
Stress detection for cognitive rehabilitation in
COVID-19 scenario
Ahona Ghosh1, Sima Das1 and Sriparna Saha1
Abstract
Due to the current demand for emerging technologies like the Internet of Things
integrated with machine learning in industry and academics, brain–computer
interface tools like electroencephalogram in healthcare have drawn worldwide
attention. As has been noticed that during recent times, mobile phone exposure to
people increased in at least 2-fold way, so games have been used as stimuli for
detecting how our brain becomes overburdened with increased exposure. After the
data acquisition from 14 channels of an electroencephalogram, the activated
regions were identified. Features were extracted from the most activated ten elec-
trode channels using discrete wavelet transform. To reduce the dimensions of the
feature space for enhancing the performance, principal component analysis was
used. The mental state classification was performed using a support vector machine
based on the detected stress. The proposed system has outperformed the existing
ones for its effectiveness and efficiency in a broad application area of cognitive
rehabilitation. Classification accuracy was obtained as 92.79% and different other
metrics proved that the combination of channel selection, feature extraction, and
classification methods in our proposed approach has outperformed the others.
Privacy is maintained, and it is flexible to the user as per his/her convenient time.
12.1 Introduction
In this era, stress is a common event that happens to everyone. Machine learning
(ML) is set as a benchmark in emerging technology, and EEG is connected with the
1
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Maulana Abul Kalam Azad University of
Technology, West Bengal, India
332 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
area for further exploration. The motivations behind taking up this research chal-
lenge include the following:
1. to study the presence of stress in players based on android games;
2. to overcome the shortcoming present in state-of-the-art literature and to gra-
dually improve the performance of stress detection;
3. to detect the three factors of game-based regulating mental state, i.e., related-
ness (the capability of gamers to other people in society), the competence of
completing necessary game levels, and autonomy.
The contributions of our proposed framework for the detection of stress levels
in ordinary people during the pandemic era can be briefed as per the following:
1. It has been able to detect whether the subject is stressed or not stressed.
2. Haar as the wavelet basis function in the DWT used as the feature extractor in
our proposed approach has outperformed the other wavelet basis functions
used in the state-of-the-art literature.
3. The training set size is larger than the existing benchmarks in the related area
as per our knowledge. So, the classification accuracy of the SVM model has
been achieved as 92.79%, which outperforms the state-of-the-art literature in
its concerned domain. Also, hyperparameter tuning has been carried out to
choose the best parameters for achieving the highest accuracy.
The remaining of the chapter is as follows: in Section 12.2, we have discussed
related works of stress level detection and cognitive load; in Section 12.3, we have
proposed our system and algorithm of the system also be discussed; experimental
outcomes are discussed in Section 12.4; last but not the least, concluding statements
regarding the proposed approach are given in Section 12.5.
of both got considered to classify healthy and depressed subjects using quadratic
and linear discriminant analysis, multilayer perceptron, and radial basis function
(RBF) network in [21]. The alpha band as the linear feature and both of the non-
linear features achieved the highest accuracy with a multilayer perceptron, RBF,
and linear discriminant analysis, respectively. The combined linear and nonlinear
feature set performed best with the RBF in terms of specificity, sensitivity, and
accuracy. However, a more generalized outcome can be achieved by testing the
framework with a greater number of patients in the future. Among the five layers of
CNN, the first four max-pooling layers were used in feature selection and the last
one, i.e., fully connected layer was applied in a classification where batch nor-
malization and dropout also took place to reduce the chance of overfitting in [22].
Here EEG data obtained from only two electrodes achieved satisfactory accuracy
since the training sample size of the PhysioNet database was also effective for such
a motor imagery task and CNN alone has extracted and selected features; thus, the
complexity of employing other artificial methods to preprocess, and feature
extraction was avoided also.
Artificial intelligence has been widely applied in different COVID-19-based
research works [23]. The existing literature on COVID-19 somewhere has
attempted to model the lockdown decision-making [24] and somewhere has
attempted to detect respiratory distress due to virus attack [25]. Additionally, the
convolutional network has verified its efficiency in various fields, including sen-
timent analysis [26], gesture recognition [27], sign language detection [28].
Table 12.1 presents a comparative study among state-of-the-art works from where
it is clear that existing literature lacks suitable infrastructure for stress detection and
recovery systems and as per our understanding, the proposed framework has
addressed the gaps found in those. The impact of playing different games and
beating the other player’s scores on human emotion has been analyzed in [29] using
EEG. A deep learning-based type 2 fuzzy set has been applied to classify the
emotion changes during game playing. Facial expression as well as brain signals
were monitored parallelly, and the games for which the negative emotions domi-
nated the positive ones can be avoided for a better quality of life in the future [30].
A bidirectional long short-term memory (LSTM) has been used based on the
player’s attention while engaged in game playing, and the dimensionality-based
scarcity has been handled using feature augmentation technique before feeding it in
the LSTM for emotion classification in [31]. The system was validated with some
combined five-by-two paired t-test and Friedman test. Based on the rating of
adversarial effects, the spreading of damaging computer and android games may be
controlled by the parents.
Ref. de- Motivation EEG device Subject Preprocessing Feature extrac- Classification/ Contribution Shortcoming
tail tion Clustering found (if any)
Asif Stress level Four-channel A total of Notch band stop Absolute power, Sequential mini- The highest accu- The training sam-
et al. detection in MUSE 13 fe- filter rejectingrelative mal optimiza- racy (98.76% ple can be in-
[32] response to head-band males frequency be- power, coher- tion, stochastic for two-level creased in the
the music and tween 45 and ence, phase gradient des- and 95.06% for number of sub-
track 14 males 64 Hz lag, and am- cent, logistic three-level) jects and fea-
plitude asym- regression, was obtained tures in the
metry multilayer per- from logistic future to get
ceptron regression higher accuracy
using deep
learning
Saeed Long-term EMOTIV Xa- A total of DC offset re- Power spectral Support vector Involvement of The training sam-
et al. stress re- vier test- 13 fe- moval using density of five machine, naı̈ve psychology ex- ple can be in-
[33] cognition in bench ver- males fast Fourier channels, al- Bayes, k near- perts to label creased in
resting-state sion and transform and pha and beta est neighbor, the stress in- several subjects
by PSS-10 3.1.21 head- 20 males minimal eye- asymmetry, multilayer per- tensity and and features in
question- set blink in closed and feature ceptron, logis- highest accu- the future to get
naire eye state selection tic regression racy achieved higher accuracy
using t-test by SVM and using deep
LR having al- learning mod-
pha symmetry els
feature
Ahn Stress assess- Two-channel 14 male EOG signal re- Right and left Analysis of var- The combination The convenience
et al. ment using EEG and subjects moval using normalized al- iance to con- of EEG and to put on such a
[34] mental ar- one channel only fast Fourier pha and beta firm the heart rate device can be
ithmetic, ECG transform band power, statistical sig- variability im- increased by
Stroop col- and each nificance and proved the replacing the
or–word band’s power support vector stress assessing wet electrode
test asymmetry machine to classifier per- with dry ones
classify stress formance and the training
situations sample size can
be increased for
better accuracy
Kalas Stress level RMS MAXI- Ten sub- Noise reduction Features from Calculation of Helpful in stress Sensitivity analy-
and estimation MUS jects only using discrete two stages, stress indices management sis and inter-
Mo- and reduc- 24 channel wavelet trans- i.e., baseline and grouping and takes less vention can be
min tion EEG form and task-load into high stress time and hu- considered a
[35] got extracted and low stress man resource future exten-
based on a sion to check
threshold using stress reduction
K means clus-
tering
Priya Stress detec- EEG having a A total of Artifact-free EEG A total of 64 SVM and k-near- Gaussian SVM More evaluation
et al. tion during 10–20 elec- 36 sub- signal was power ratio est neighbor as having KS>2.5 on higher order
[36] serial sub- trode loca- jects considered feature extrac- a classifier and performed bet- polynomial
traction tion system containing 182 tion by power k-fold cross- ter. kNN with SVM can be
task s of relaxed spectral den- validation to one neighbor done in the fu-
state and 62 s sity using fast check the gen- performed well ture as it could
of a stressed Fourier trans- eralized and in that work achieve good
state form unbiased per- performance
formance but takes more
time
Liao Stress predic- NeuroSky Seven sub- Not mentioned EEG frequency Binary classifica- The highest vali- Click button ad-
et al. tion by lis- Mind-wave jects only using Fast tion into two dation accuracy dition can be
[37] tening to Mobile Fourier Trans- classes, i.e., is 80.13%. done in the fu-
music and form meditation and High precision ture to control
calm the attention using for meditation the action
mind down deep learning class, better where higher
model with F1-score, and attention means
ReLU activa- high recall for higher button
tion function attention class. click accuracy
(Continues)
Table 12.1 (Continued)
Ref. de- Motivation EEG device Subject Preprocessing Feature extrac- Classification/ Contribution Shortcoming
tail tion Clustering found (if any)
and fully con- Small MSE
nected layers loss of 0.0882
Sharma Stress identi- Not men- Not men- Fifth-order But- EEG signal de- Support vector The highest accu- The training sam-
and fication tioned tioned terworth filter composition machine used racy in the al- ple size is not
Cho- during the has outper- into intrinsic in the proposed pha frequency mentioned and
pra aptitude test formed the mode function model has out- band is 94% integration of
[38] combined 45- and frequency performed k and the average deep learning
Hz finite im- feature extrac- nearest neigh- is 90%. The method can be
pulseResponse tion using bor, quadratic accuracy of incorporated in
(FIR) filter and Hilbert– discriminant SVM is the the future for
0.75 Hz high Huang trans- analysis, and highest greater perfor-
pass filter form linear discrimi- mance
nant analysis
Peng Chronic stress EEG of a 11 Artifact removal A total of 20 Statistical analy- Features had a The number of
et al. detection 10–20 elec- using low pass features sis using Ana- significant dif- control and ex-
[39] and moni- trode loca- filter of 40 Hz namely max lysis of ference for the perimental
toring tion system cut off fre- power, abso- variance in control and group is not the
quency and lute power, SPSS 17.0 and stressed groups same, thus,
EOG removal relative paired sample in nonlinear more samples
using wavelet power, center t-test to analyze EEG analysis. should be
method frequency, en- and differenti- The only rela- added. Sensi-
tropy, correla- ate between left tive power of tivity and spe-
tion dimen- and right hemi- alpha-band was cificity should
sion, alpha sphere activ- significantly be used to
asymmetry ities of the different for evaluate the
brain control and performance
stressed in
linear EEG
analysis
Virmani Stress recog- 10–20 elec- 23 Not mentioned Two emotional Russell’s circum- The overall accu- Accuracy is not
et al. nition using trode place- features, plex model- racy of k near- up to the mark
[40] ECG and ment sys- namely arou- based k nearest est neighbor— which can be
EEG for tem EEG sal and va- neighbor and 68% and deci- increased by
audio and lence using decision tree to sion tree—75% having more
visual sti- power spectral classify be- training sample
muli density tween stressed size and other
and non- models can be
stressed sub- tested for better
jects performance
Al- Stress quanti- BrainMaster A total of Third-order But- Wavelet trans- Two-sample t-test Accuracy of SVM The right prefron-
Shar- fication 24E system 12 sub- terworth filter form for five having mean p- decreased with tal cortex has
gie during three jects only in passband decomposition values as 0.03, increasing level been identified
et al. levels of frequency levels and one 0.042, and 0.05 of the given ar- as the responsi-
[41] arithmetic 0.5–30 Hz and approximation for level one, ithmetic task ble brain region
task artifact re- level ranging two, and three, for stress; how-
moval using between 0 and respectively ever, the result
independent 30 Hz can be im-
component proved further
analysis by considering
a larger training
size
340 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
classification using SVM’s workflow has been presented. The functionality of our
entire system has been pictorially presented in Figure 12.1.
Feeling
Stressed Not stressed
Cognitive
rehabilitation
Thoughts Behavior
AF3 AF4
F7 F8
F3 F4
FC5 FC6
T7 T8
P7 P8
O1 O2
Figure 12.2 EEG electrodes used to acquire data in the proposed approach
Stress detection for cognitive rehabilitation 341
and location are represented by a and b, respectively. The CWT of signal s(t) can be
defined by
ð þ1
Tc ðm; nÞ ¼ sðtÞgðm;nÞ ðtÞdt (12.1)
1
1 X 1 X 1 X
Td ðtÞ ¼ pffiffiffiffi Wx ðp0 ; qÞxp0 ;q ðtÞ þ pffiffiffiffi Wy ðp; qÞyp;q ðtÞ (12.3)
m k m p¼p0 k
1 X m1
Wx ðp0 ; qÞ ¼ pffiffiffiffi Td ðtÞ~x p0 ;q ðtÞ: (12.4)
m t¼0
1 X m1
Wy ðp; qÞ ¼ pffiffiffiffi Td ðtÞ~y p;q ðtÞ (12.5)
m t¼0
and p0 is the arbitrary initial scale. Figure 12.3 has shown the mechanism of
wavelet decomposition of a signal s(t) by considering three layers of decomposition
for an instance [46] where x and y have been used for the approximate and detail
coefficient, respectively.
342 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
s(t)
x(t) y(t)
2 2
2 2 2 2
x1
PC1
PC2 PC2
(Second maximum variance)
0 x2
Optimal hyperplane
Support Maximized
vectors margin
(a)
Y
3D representation of
Y nonlinear data
X
Z
(b) X Best hyperplane
the classes as shown in the blue line. Hence SVM aims to create a decision
boundary, and the best decision boundary among several possible boundaries gets
called a hyperplane. The distances between the hyperplane and the support vectors
are called margins, and the hyperplane having maximum margin between support
vectors is called the optimal hyperplane. For nonlinear data, one more dimension z
has to be added since no single straight line can act as the boundary between the
classes and it can be calculated by
z ¼ x2 þ y2 : (12.6)
In three-dimensional space, the hyperplane looks like a parallel to the x-axis
whereas in two-dimensional space, considering z¼1, the circumference can be
obtained with radius as 1 unit.
played by 28 different subjects with a total duration of 20 min (each game for 5
min). The games are of horror, fun, cool, and boring genre, respectively. Fourteen
electrode channels were considered to collect the data, namely AF3, AF4, T8, T7,
P8, P7, O2, O1, FC6, F8, F7, F4, F3, and FC5.
L A R L S R A S P
Figure 12.6 sLORETA-based brain activation for the class: not stressed
346 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
L A R L S R A S P
based EEG data for four wavelet functions, namely Haar, db1, sym5, and db5, have
been shown in Figure 12.8. From the results, it can be said that the Haar wavelet
function is the best choice for the proposed work.
Level 1
Level 1
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 2
Level 2
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 3
Level 3
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 4
Level 4
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 5
Level 5
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
(a) (b)
Approximation coefficients Detail coefficients Approximation coefficients Detail coefficients
Level 1
Level 1
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 2
Level 2
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 3
Level 3
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 4
Level 4
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
Level 5
Level 5
0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300 0 100 200 300
(c) (d)
Figure 12.8 Approximation and detailed coefficients (for five levels) applied on
GAMEEMO dataset [69]: (a) Haar function, (b) sym5 function, (c)
db5 function, and (d) db1 function
2 component PCA
Stressed
12.5 Not stressed
10.0
Principal component 2
7.5
5.0
2.5
0.0
–2.5
–5.0
–2.5 0.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0
Principal component 1
employed as a feature vector. The game genres described in [69] have influenced us
to classify the data points into two labels: stressed and not stressed. The players
playing the cool and funny games are labeled as not stressed, and the players
playing the horror and boring game have been labeled as stressed during the
training process.
80
Accuracy in percentage
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
kNN DT RF NB SVM
Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve
1.0 ROC 1.0 ROC
0.8 0.8
True positive rate
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
(a) (b) False positive rate
False positive rate
Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve
1.0 ROC 1.0 ROC
0.8 0.8
True positive rate
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
False positive rate False positive rate
(c) (d)
Figure 12.11 Receiver-operating characteristic curve for the four kernels of SVM:
(a) for linear, (b) for sigmoid, (c) for RBF, and (d) for polynomial
350 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
RBF kernel-based SVM having a gamma value of 0.01 (marked as bold) is the best
choice for the current research work [72].
The comparison of our SVM classification result has been carried out by
considering accuracy as the metric with the existing related works [29,31,32] in
Figure 12.12. From the evaluation of effectiveness and applicability [73] of the
proposed approach, it is seen that the proposed framework works better than the
related ones.
100
92.79 90.71
90 87.58
80
74.02
70
Accuracy in percentage
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5
SVM (29) (31) (32)
have been presented also using the paired t-test. The statistical significance level of the
difference of the means of the best two algorithms have been presented in Table 12.4’s
last column, where “þ” represents the t-value of 49 degrees of freedom that is statis-
tically significant at a 0.05 level of significance by two-tailed test. The sample size for
all of the t-tests is set as 25. The best ones have been marked with bold.
Mental state detection using EEG and ML techniques is a rapidly emerging field in
this era. Stress affects the mental and physical health of people, and in the modern
era, it is a common problem for people belonging to different age groups. To get
valid results in detecting human mental pressure during the pandemic era, we need
reliable identification of human stress. To identify stress levels, channel selection is
also important. The proposed methods are as follows, collection of human brain
signals using EEG, feature extraction by DWT, dimensionality reduction by PCA,
and the classification by SVM. The current work has classified the mental state of the
gamer as not stressed and stressed with an accuracy of 92.79%. Brain maps have also
been generated to detect stress levels in the brain’s active regions.
The work can be further extended by considering different stimuli apart from
the game, like movie watching, music listening, social media posts for detecting
stress, and possible rehabilitative measure during the pandemic.
Acknowledgment
The first author (i.e., Ahona Ghosh) is grateful to the university for providing the
AICTE Doctoral Fellowship, with appointment letter Ref. No.2.2.1/Regis./Appt.
(AG)/Ph.D(ADF)/2021 dated 01.02.2021. The third author (i.e., Sriparna Saha) is
grateful to the university for providing research seed money, File No. 9.6/Regis./
352 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
SD/Mn.(SS)/2019 dated 19.06.2019 and UGC Start-up Grant under the scheme of
Basic Scientific Research, File No. F.30-449/2018(BSR) dated 21.11.2019.
References
[1] Javed B., Sarwer A., Soto E.B. and Mashwani Z.U.R. ‘The coronavirus
(COVID-19) pandemic’s impact on mental health’. The International
Journal of Health Planning and Management. 2020; 35(5): 993–996.
[2] Xiong J., Lipsitz O., Nasri F., et al. ‘Impact of COVID-19 pandemic on
mental health in the general population: A systematic review’. Journal of
Affective Disorders. 2020; 277: 55–64.
[3] Willman M., Kobasa D. and Kindrachuk J. ‘A comparative analysis of fac-
tors influencing two outbreaks of Middle Eastern respiratory syndrome
(MERS) in Saudi Arabia and South Korea’. Viruses. 2019; 11(12): 1119.
[4] Hasöksüz M., Kiliç S. and Saraç F. ‘Coronaviruses and SARS-CoV-2’.
Turkish Journal of Medical Sciences. 2020; 50(SI-1): 549–556.
[5] Baize S., Pannetier D., Oestereich L., et al. ‘Emergence of Zaire Ebolavirus dis-
ease in Guinea’. New England Journal of Medicine. 2014; 371(15): 1418–1425.
[6] Buheji M., Jahrami H. and Dhahi A. ‘Minimising stress exposure during
pandemics similar to COVID-19’. International Journal of Psychology and
Behavioral Sciences. 2020; 10(1): 9–16.
[7] Elbay R.Y., Kurtulmuş A., Arpacıoğlu S. and Karadere E. ‘Depression,
anxiety, stress levels of physicians and associated factors in Covid-19 pan-
demics’. Psychiatry Research. 2020; 290: 113–130.
[8] Schoenfeld J. ‘The Invisible Risk: Pandemics and the Financial Markets.’ In
Tuck School of Business Working Paper No. 3567249; 2020.
[9] Dash S., Chakraborty C., Giri S.K., Pani S.K. and Frnda J. ‘BIFM: Big-data
driven intelligent forecasting model for COVID-19’. IEEE Access. 2021; 9:
97505–97517.
[10] Aslam B., Javed A.R., Chakraborty C., Nebhen J., Raqib S. and Rizwan M.
‘Blockchain and ANFIS empowered IoMT application for privacy preserved
contact tracing in COVID-19 pandemic’. Personal and Ubiquitous
Computing. 2021: 1–17.
[11] Ravi V., Narasimhan H., Chakraborty C. and Pham T.D. ‘Deep learning
based meta-classifier approach for COVID-19 classification using CT scan
and chest X-ray images’. Multimedia Systems. 2021: 1–15.
[12] Chakraborty C., Banerjee A., Garg L. and Coelho Rodrigues J.J.P. Internet
of Medical Things for Smart Healthcare – COVID-19 Pandemic, Big data
series. Singapore: Springer Nature; 2020.
[13] Garg L., Chakraborty C., Mahmoudi S. and Sohmen V.S. Healthcare
Informatics for Fighting COVID-19 and Future Epidemics. EAI/Springer
Innovations in Communication and Computing. Cham: Springer Nature; 2021.
[14] Wada K., Shibata T., Musha T. and Kimura S. ‘Effects of robot therapy for
demented patients evaluated by EEG.’ In IEEE/RSJ International
Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems. IEEE; 2005. pp. 1552–1557.
Stress detection for cognitive rehabilitation 353
[15] Ali M., Mosa A.H., Al Machot F. and Kyamakya K. ‘EEG-based emotion
recognition approach for e-healthcare applications.’ In 2016 Eighth
International Conference on Ubiquitous and Future Networks (ICUFN);
2016. pp. 946–950.
[16] Mahato S. and Paul S. ‘Electroencephalogram (EEG) Signal Analysis for
Diagnosis of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD): A Review.’ In Nath V. and
Mandal J. (eds.) Nanoelectronics, Circuits and Communication Systems,
Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering. Springer, Singapore, vol. 511;
2019. pp. 323–336.
[17] Mohammadi M., Al-Azab F., Raahemi B., et al. ‘Data mining EEG signals
in depression for their diagnostic value’. BMC Medical Informatics and
Decision Making. 2015; 15(1): 1–14.
[18] Liao S.C., Wu C.T., Huang H.C., Cheng W.T. and Liu Y.H. ‘Major
depression detection from EEG signals using kernel Eigen-filter Bank
common spatial patterns’. Sensors. 2017; 17(6): 1385.
[19] Niemiec A.J. and Lithgow B.J. ‘Alpha-band characteristics in EEG spectrum
indicate reliability of frontal brain asymmetry measures in diagnosis of
depression.’ In IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology 27th Annual
Conference, Shanghai, China, 2005. IEEE; 2005. pp. 7517–7520.
[20] Cai H., Sha X., Han X., Wei S. and Hu S. ‘A pervasive approach to EEG-
based depression detection’. Complexity. 2018; 2018: 1–13.
[21] Mahato S. and Paul S. ‘Detection of major depressive disorder using linear
and non-linear features from EEG signals’. Microsystem Technologies.
2019; 25(3): 1065–1076.
[22] Lun X., Yu Z., Chen T., Wang F. and Hou Y. ‘A simplified CNN classifi-
cation method for MI-EEG via the electrode pairs signals’. Frontiers in
Human Neuroscience. 2020; 14.
[23] Fong S.J., Dey N. and Chaki J. Artificial Intelligence for Coronavirus
Outbreak. 1st edn. Springer, Singapore, vol. 74; 2020. p. XI.
[24] Ghosh A., Roy S., Mondal H., Biswas S. and Bose R. ‘Mathematical mod-
elling for decision making of lockdown during COVID-19’. Applied
Intelligence. 2021: 1–17.
[25] Dutta P.K., Ghosh A., De P. and Soltani M. ‘A proposed model of a semi-
automated sensor actuator resposcopy analyzer for ’covid-19’ patients for
respiratory distress detection.’ In 11th International Conference on Cloud
Computing, Data Science & Engineering (Confluence), India, 2021. IEEE;
2021. pp. 618–623.
[26] Adhikary S., Ghosh A., Das P., Roy S. and Bose R. ‘Scope of sentiment
analysis on news articles regarding stock market and GDP in struggling
economic condition’. International Journal of Emerging Trends in
Engineering Research. 2020; 8(7).
[27] Sagayam K.M., Andrushia A.D., Ghosh A., Deperlioglu O. and Elngar
A.A. ‘Recognition of hand gesture image using deep convolutional
neural network’. International Journal of Image and Graphics. 2021:
2140008.
354 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[28] Datta P.K., Biswas A., Ghosh A. and Chaudhury N. ‘Creation of image
segmentation classifiers for sign language processing for deaf and dumb.’ In
2020 8th International Conference on Reliability, Infocom Technologies and
Optimization (Trends and Future Directions) (ICRITO). IEEE; 2020.
pp. 772–775.
[29] Ghosh L., Saha S. and Konar A. ‘Decoding emotional changes of android-
gamers using a fused Type-2 fuzzy deep neural network’. Computers in
Human Behavior. 2021; 116: 106640.
[30] Hajian-Tilaki K. ‘Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis for
medical diagnostic test evaluation’. Caspian Journal of Internal Medicine.
2013; 4(2): 627.
[31] Ghosh L., Saha S. and Konar A. ‘Bi-directional long short-term memory
model to analyze psychological effects on gamers’. Applied Soft Computing.
2020; 95: 106573.
[32] Asif A., Majid M. and Anwar S.M. ‘Human stress classification using EEG
signals in response to music tracks’. Computers in Biology and Medicine.
2019; 107: 182–196.
[33] Saeed S.M.U., Anwar S.M., Khalid H., Majid M. and Bagci U. ‘EEG based
classification of long-term stress using psychological labeling’. Sensors.
2020; 20(7): 1886.
[34] Ahn J.W., Ku Y. and Kim H.C. ‘A novel wearable EEG and ECG recording
system for stress assessment’. Sensors. 2019; 19(9): 1991.
[35] Kalas M.S. and Momin B.F. ‘Stress detection and reduction using EEG
signals.’ In 2016 International Conference on Electrical, Electronics, and
Optimization Techniques (ICEEOT). IEEE; 2016. pp. 471–475.
[36] Priya T.H., Mahalakshmi P., Naidu V.P.S. and Srinivas M. ‘Stress detection
from EEG using power ratio.’ In 2020 International Conference on
Emerging Trends in Information Technology and Engineering (IC-ETITE).
IEEE; 2020. pp. 1–6.
[37] Liao C.Y., Chen R.C. and Tai S.K. ‘Emotion stress detection using EEG
signal and deep learning technologies.’ In 2018 IEEE International
Conference on Applied System Invention (ICASI). IEEE; 2018. pp. 90–93.
[38] Sharma R. and Chopra K. ‘EEG signal analysis and detection of stress using
classification techniques’. Journal of Information and Optimization
Sciences. 2020; 41(1): 229–238.
[39] Peng H., Hu B., Zheng F., et al. ‘A method of identifying chronic stress by
EEG’. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing. 2013; 17(7): 1341–1347.
[40] Virmani D., Minocha A., Goyal L., Malhotra M. and Gupta M. ‘Se. Re. Ne.:
Stress detection using EEG and ECG.’ In Proceedings of 3rd International
Conference on Computing Informatics and Networks: ICCIN 2020. Springer
Singapore; 2021. pp. 189–198.
[41] Al-Shargie F.M., Tang T.B., Badruddin N. and Kiguchi M. ‘Mental stress
quantification using EEG signals.’ In International Conference for
Innovation in Biomedical Engineering and Life Sciences. Springer,
Singapore; 2015. pp. 15–19.
Stress detection for cognitive rehabilitation 355
[42] Al-Fahoum A.S. and Al-Fraihat A.A. ‘Methods of EEG signal features
extraction using linear analysis in frequency and time-frequency domains’.
International Scholarly Research Notices, 2014.
[43] Evans J.R. and Abarbanel A. (eds.). Introduction to Quantitative EEG and
Neurofeedback. London: Elsevier; 1999. p. XVIII.
[44] Teplan M. ‘Fundamentals of EEG measurement’. Measurement Science
Review. 2002; 2(2): 1–11.
[45] Al-Haj A. ‘Combined DWT-DCT digital image watermarking’. Journal of
Computer Science. 2007; 3(9): 740–746.
[46] Wu Y.L., Agrawal D. and El Abbadi A. ‘A comparison of DFT and DWT
based similarity search in time-series databases.’ In Proceedings of the Ninth
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management;
2000. pp. 488–495.
[47] Turnip A. and Siahaan M. ‘Adaptive principal component analysis based
recursive least squares for artifact removal of EEG signals’. Advanced
Science Letters. 2014; 20(10–11): 2034–2037.
[48] Yang N., Yuan J., Zhou Y., et al. ‘Enhanced multiclass SVM with thresh-
olding fusion for speech-based emotion classification’. International Journal
of Speech Technology. 2017; 20: 27–41.
[49] Nguyen T., Bass I., Li M. and Sethi I.K. ‘Investigation of combining SVM
and decision tree for emotion classification.’ In Seventh IEEE International
Symposium on Multimedia (ISM’05), Irvine, CA, USA; 2005. p. 5.
[50] Mehmood R.M. and Lee H.J. ‘Emotion classification of EEG brain signal
using SVM and KNN.’ In 2015 IEEE International Conference on
Multimedia & Expo Workshops (ICMEW); 2015. pp. 1–5.
[51] Guo K., Candra H., Yu H., Li H., Nguyen H.T. and Su S.W. ‘EEG-based
emotion classification using innovative features and combined SVM and
HMM classifier.’ In 2017 39th Annual International Conference of the IEEE
Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC); 2017. pp. 489–492.
[52] Datta S., Sen D. and Balasubramanian R. ‘Integrating geometric and textural
features for facial emotion classification using SVM frameworks.’ In Raman
B., Kumar S., Roy P., Sen D. (eds.) Proceedings of International Conference
on Computer Vision and Image Processing. Advances in Intelligent Systems
and Computing, Springer, Singapore; 2017. vol. 459, pp. 619–628.
[53] Han B.J., Rho S., Jun S., et al. ‘Music emotion classification and context-
based music recommendation’. Multimedia Tools and Applications. 2010;
47: 433–460.
[54] Yi-Lin L. and Gang W. ‘Speech emotion recognition based on HMM and
SVM.’ In International Conference on Machine Learning and Cybernetics;
2005. vol. 8, pp. 4898–4901.
[55] Vaidya J., Yu H. and Jiang X. ‘Privacy-preserving SVM classification’.
Knowledge Information Systems. 2008; 14: 161–178.
[56] Yu H., Vaidya J. and Jiang X. ‘Privacy-Preserving SVM Classification on
Vertically Partitioned Data.’ In Ng W.K., Kitsuregawa M., Li J. and Chang
K. (eds.) Advances in Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. PAKDD
356 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Abstract
The proposed work elaborates the necessity of sterilisation especially during
COVID-19 period. In this chapter, we will discuss about the development and
construction of an ‘Arduino-based robot for the purification of COVID-19 using far
UVC light’. Throughout history, the outgrowing technology has solved major
problems. Technology has made everything possible, from making knowledge
more available to more people and bringing group of people associated, to making
our planet cleaner and even saving lives. But the current circumstance of COVID-
19 is threat to human lives as there are high chances of getting sick in no time, so in
order to fight with this novel virus. There is necessity to keep our surroundings
clean and tidy. Cleanliness is the most important factor to keep ourselves away
from diseases. The objective of the current work is to discuss various inventions
made during the pandemic scenario and to contribute to the battle against COVID-
19 propagation, a novel human corona virus in hospitals, public transports, airlines,
and any enclosed areas with an approach, which is a basically a bot named
‘Arduino-based robot’ which uses ultraviolet (UV) sterilisation method to kill and
eliminate all the germs and viruses present in the surroundings and sanitises the
entire surroundings by cleaning and disinfecting the environment. Far-UVC
(ultraviolet C) radiation has a wavelength range of 207–222 nm. The decontami-
nating efficiency of far UVC light was previously tested by exposing bacteria that
were irradiated on a surface or in suspension. We have developed a UV-based
sterilisation method that uses single-wavelength far-UVC light produced by filtered
exclaims to selectively inactivate microorganisms while causing no biological
damage to exposed cells and tissues. The method is based on biophysical princi-
ples, as far-UVC light can penetrate and thus inactivate bacteria and viruses with
dimensions in micrometre or smaller, while far-UVC light cannot penetrate even
the outer dead-cell layers of human skin, nor the outer tear layer of an eye, due to
its high absorbance in biological materials. The far-UVC lamp plays a major role in
1
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Sreenidhi Institute of Science and
Technology, Hyderabad, India
360 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
a disinfection robot. This bot will disinfect the virus and clean the areas; it will
travel autonomously and sterilise the areas without the need for human interven-
tion. In the discussion section, a demonstration of the bot’s implementation and
presentation was shown. This robot can also be used as a vacuum cleaner, elim-
inating the need for and expense of cleaning by humans.
13.1 Introduction
This chapter gives information about an Arduino-based far UVC (ultraviolet C)
sterilisation disinfection robot. It is a robot made by using ultrasonic sensor, far-
UVC lamp, accelerometer sensor, Arduino Uno. Arduino IDE (integrated devel-
opment environment) is the software used in building this robot for writing the code
that is been dumped in the Arduino Uno. The main purpose of this robot is to
sanitise surroundings and to make them free from harmful germs by using UV
(ultraviolet) rays. UV sterilisation is the method used to kill the microorganisms
using UV lamps [1]. In present days, UV, UVC, and far-UVC lamp are being used
for sterilisation process. The UV rays and UVC lamp may affect the tissues in
human body, so it cannot be used for sterilisation of surroundings in public places
and households. Under extreme conditions, they can be used in public places only
in the absence of all living organisms. The better way to solve the previous issue is
using a far-UVC lamp. Far-UVC lamps will not affect human tissues and give more
powerful and effective results when compared to the other lamps. Far-UVC lamps
make use of tiny wavelength far-UV light to eradicate or inactivate microorganisms
such as germs, bacteria, and viruses by exterminating their nucleic acids and dis-
rupting their DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid), preventing them from multiplying in
large numbers and rendering them incapable of performing essential cellular
functions. Our robot makes use of the far-UV excimer lamps [2]. This method is
based on the principle that very little penetration from the far UV lamp can cover
and kills the germs and viruses, and most importantly the far-UV light can neither
penetrate through the outer dead cell layers of human skin nor the outer surface of
the human eye. So, the far-UV light does not cause any harm to humans [3]. We
can also use few robotic vacuum cleaner components to make its function as a
robotic vacuum cleaner. With single robot, we can perform both cleaning and
sterilisation of surroundings.
13.1.1 Arduino
Arduino is an open-source platform which enables the users to use in software and
hardware projects easily. Arduino project began at Interaction Design Institute
Ivrea, Ivrea, Italy in the year 2005. The major goal of Arduino was to give a low-
cost and simple solution for students from all disciplines to create projects using
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 361
numerous sensors and actuators. The Arduino was named after the bar ‘Arduino of
Ivrea’, the place where the founders of the Arduino usually encountered.
Creative Commons attribution share-Alike 2.5 is responsible for hardware
designs and distribution of Arduino. Although the Arduino hardware and software
designs are accessible for free under copyleft licences, the developer has requested
that the name not be changed. ATmega8 AVR (Alf-Egil Bogen, Vegard Wollan,
RISC) microcontroller [4] is widely used in Arduino boards with various ranges of
flash memory, pins, and features. In 2012, 32-bit Arduino Due with Atmel
SAM3X8E was introduced. Single or double row pins or female headers are used to
make connections for programming the circuit as well as for incorporating into
other circuits. Arduino offers the capacity to link with ‘shields’, which are add-on
modules. For power supply, Arduino board manufactures mostly 5-V linear reg-
ulators and 16-MHz crystal oscillators, or ceramic resonators to generate clock
pulses. For the simplification of uploading programmes to on-chip flash memory,
Arduino microcontrollers are pre-programmed with a boot loader. Programmes are
loaded onto board via serial connections to another computer. But currently USBs
(universal serial buses) are being used to upload the programmes onto the board for
this purpose. USB-to-serial adapter chip-like FTDI (Future Technology Devices
International Limited) FT232 is being used. AVR chip with USB-to-serial firmware
is used in Arduino Uno model boards. It can re-programme itself by using its own
ICSP (in-circuit serial programming) header. Other boards, such as the Arduino
mini, rely on a separate USB-to-serial adaptor or Bluetooth.
Arduino board microcontroller has several I/O pins which help in connecting
various other circuits. The number of pins will differ from one version to another.
Arduino Uno board has 13 digital I/O pins and six analogue pins to provide ana-
logue output in the range of 0–1,023. It has ATMEGA328P had microcontroller in
Arduino [5]. Along with these pins, there are several other pins as follows: Tx pin,
used for transmission of data; Rx pin, used to receive data; Vin pin, helps in pro-
viding input voltage; and 5 and 3.3-V pins are used to supply voltage to external
devices.
Analogue pins act as an interface in order to convert analogue data into digital
format. With the help of these pins the code written in human understandable
language (English language) is converted into a hex file using compiler and stored
in memory of microcontroller.
There are several versions of Arduino boards. Some of them are as follows:
● Arduino Mega
● Arduino Nano (DIO-30 footprint)
● Arduino LilyPad 00 (rev 2007) – no USB
● Arduino robot
● Arduino Esplora
● Arduino Ethernet (AVRþW5100)
● Arduino Yun (AVRþAR9331)
● Arduino Due (ARM (advanced RISC machines/Acron RISC machine) Cortex-
M3 core)
For the functioning of Arduino hardware, one has to dump the code in Arduino
board. The code for Arduino board can be written in any of other programming
languages like Java, C, Cþþ with their suitable compilers. The Arduino-integrated
development environment (IDE) is a Java-based cross-platform development
environment that runs on Windows, Linux, and macOS. This software is licensed
under the GNU Lesser General Public License (LGPL) or the GNU General Public
License (GPL). This software is initiated from IDE for handling and writing of
languages. Many code editing features like text copying, cutting and pasting,
searching and replacing, highlighting syntax, automatic indenting, and brace
matching are included in this software. This software is easy to use because the user
can compile and upload programmes using one-click mechanisms. With special
rules of code structuring, Arduino IDE supports C and Cþþ. It has software library
which contains many commonly used inputs and functions. The application
AVRdude is used to convert executable code into a hexadecimal-encoded text file.
Arduino Pro IDE (alpha version) was released on 18 October 2019. Although
this version still uses command line interface (CLI), there are improvements like
autocompletion support, git integration, and more professional development
environment. Eclipse Theia Open Source IDE is a base for front-end of this
application. Some main features of alpha release are fully modernised and featured
environment. Three modes are classic (similar to classic Arduino IDE), dual, and
pro (file system view).
● New board manager
● New library manager
● Board list
● Basic auto completion (Arm targets only)
● Integration with Git
● Serial monitor
● Dark mode
Though many microcontrollers and microcontroller platforms like Parallax
BASIC stamp, MIT’s (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) Handy Board,
Phidgets, Netmedia’s BX-24 are available for physical computing, but most of us
prefer Arduino for its easy to use nature.
Code is written as a block of statements in Arduino IDE software dump it in
Arduino board with USB portal. Later the power supply is given to the board
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 363
through power sources like power bank, power jack, or supply voltage to vin pin.
The code writer can check the functioning of code using serial monitor. The fol-
lowing are the steps involved in writing code in Arduino IDE and dumping:
95% in 11 min, 99% in 16 min, and 99.9% inactivation in 25 min. They concluded
that virus is high sensitivity to a far-UVC light. It can also eliminate the SARS-
CoV-2 (severe acute respiratory syndrome-coronavirus-2) virus as it is similar to
HCoV-OC43 and HCoV-229E [7]. The other study was done by Hiroshima
University and included SARS-CoV-2 containing solutions. They placed 100-mL
solution containing the virus spread onto a 9-cm sterile polystyrene plate [8]. They
placed far-UVC lamp near to that plate. After 30 s of exposure to far-UVC radia-
tion, 99.7% of the SARS-CoV-2 was eliminated in this experiment.
Mainly, we use a 222-nm excimer lamp with a 120-V power supply and
operate at 150 W as shown in Figure 13.1. This device is priced at $1,000. It is
high-efficiency germicidal lamp and has strength to prevent regrowth of bacteria
[9]. Design of a robot and installation of it in-house determines to observe the
working performance.
The main intention of our work is to eradicate germs, bacteria, and viruses
from the surroundings by designing a robot and placing it in the house/hall for the
following purposes:
● To keep the surroundings and objects clean and tidy by sanitising them timely.
● To reduce human efforts and to make life easier.
● To protect humans from becoming victims of dreadful viruses and diseases.
The remaining part of this chapter is organised as follows. In Section 13.2, we
present a review of previous efforts relevant to the proposed work followed by a
description of an Arduino-based robot. Section 13.3 gives the working and imple-
mentation of a proposed robot. Section 13.4 elaborates the performance of the
designed robot and provides discussion on its usages. Section 13.5 provides the
conclusion of this chapter with future enhancements.
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 365
COVID. This made humans to think about cleanliness and they started to buy
masks, sanitisers, toilet papers, etc. These items have become their first choice to
buy as they are willing to keep their surroundings clean. These items caused a huge
business for many people and the cost of these items was increased 10 times the
original cost and failed to meet the required demand. People are panic about the
situation and urge to keep clean and sanitised surroundings.
Onur Dogan, Sanju Tiwari, M. A. Jabbar, and Shankru Guggari have done a
research work on AI/ML (machine learning) techniques used in outbreak of
COVID-19. They discussed about those techniques in brief and explained how they
were used in detection and extracted the data. Mainly CNN (convolutional neural
network), RF (random forest), ResNet (residual network), and SVM (super vector
machine) approaches are the most used AI/ML techniques against COVID-19. The
main objective of AI/ML techniques in COVID-19 are collection, prediction, and
diagnosis [20]. ‘A review on telemedicine-based WBAN (wireless body area net-
work) framework for patient monitoring’ is the paper written by Chinmay
Chakraborty, Bharat Gupta, and Soumya K. Ghosh. This paper is about the research
towards issues and challenges that were faced during the development of patient
monitoring in telemedicine. Because of the emerging developments in the inte-
gration of communications and microelectronics and embedded system technolo-
gies, there was a structural change in patient monitoring and health information
delivery systems. They used wireless body area network (WBAN) infrastructure to
be mounted on the people in hospitals. Various sensors are used to generate ECG
(electrocardiography), EMG (electromyography), EEG (electroencephalogram),
temperature, and many more. In this paper, they covered the key components of
WBAN in terms of information collection, data processing, data storage, and
patient monitoring in this post. It also discusses WBAN’s scalable architecture for
providing real-time patient health data. The QoS (quality of service) requirements
for integrating internal and exterior sensors into an autonomous system are defined
by this architecture [21].
The paper written by Muhammad et al. explained about ‘Supervised machine
learning model for prediction of COVID-19 infection using epidemiology data
test’. This paper discusses about building an ML model by using supervised
learning technique to detect the COVID-19 infection using an epidemiology
labelled data set. It also includes algorithms like decision tree logistic regression
and nail by us support with commission and artificial neural network (ANN). This
model takes chest X-rays images as a data set and pre-trained models’ inspectionV3
ResNet50 and inspection ResNetV2, an auto waitress net pre-trained model, give
the highest accuracy that is 98%. The ResNet pre-trained can be used for frontline
workers as it can detect the disease at early stage [22]. Whereas in [23] authors
have developed a robot for sterilisation process, they used UVC lamp and ozone
light to have double disinfection. They carried out by using MATLAB (Matrix
Laboratory), Arduino IDE, and ANNs. They tested the ANN in MATLAB and they
tested the behaviour of a robot in Proteus 8 software. They used three micro-
controllers, i.e., Arduino. First, Arduino with ANN will decide the location that to
be carried out for disinfection process; second, Arduino for displacement; third,
368 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Start
Yes
Finger No SPO2<
present? threshold?
No
Yes
Arduino is for obstacle detection. In this way the disinfection process is carried out
in their model [23]. Megantoro et al. designed a model for disinfection process, it is
user controller robot. The disinfection process will be done by using sprayer. It has
key components like LoRa (long range) sender/receiver, Arduino Mega 2560, GPS
(global positioning system), camera unit, non-contact temperature, accelerometer,
and humidity temperatures. They have created one UI integration, where user can
see the video streaming, sensors value, etc.; through this, a user controls the robot.
The sprayer will spray the disinfection liquid to objects and places and thus dis-
infection process is done in this model [24].
From the paper of Metcalfe, Benjamin there is ‘A cost-effective pulse oximeter
designed in response to the COVID-19 pandemic’ which works with the help of
optical sensors. They designed it by using Arduino Nano microprocessor,
MAX3010x pulse oximeter breakout board, and an SSD1306-based display. It is a
low-cost optical pulse oximeter that comes with a finger clip. They made a finger
clip by using the 3D printing process. This oximeter is convenient for many hours
of use as it works on a 9-V battery. Figure 13.2 shows the working of pulse oxi-
meter in the form of block diagram [25].
Social distancing is a must and should be a habit that has to be followed during
this pandemic, but there will be times where people forget about it or accidentally
violate it. Basil Reji’s paper says about the ‘smart cap’, the device which helps in
maintaining the proper social distance. They designed a cap with a PIR sensor
which detects the presence of human beings within a radius of 1 m and alerts the
person by buzzer sound and also with a message. They used an SIM (subscriber
identification module) 808 (GPS–GSM module) module was used to track the
location of the person and to send the message when the temperature exceeds the
normal range. A face shield was also for additional protection in cases of mis-
placement of mask. When the person using this cap is tested COVID positive, it is
easy to locate the primary contacts because of the SIM 808 (GPS–GSM module).
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 369
They used the Arduino Uno as a microcontroller to control the sensors. The entire
system works on a 9-V battery with a switch [26]. ‘Flexible (portable) COVID-19
detecting device using Arduino and Sensors’ was discussed in the paper written by
Katha Roy. This a portable device which can be fixed on the mask or wrist. They
designed the device based on the principle that the air human exhale is moist,
humid in vapour form, and warmer than the surroundings. When person violates the
social distance and enters the zone of exhaled gas, this device alerts the person with
a buzzer sound. This device will be a great help during this pandemic as the disease
is airborne. It is also light in weight unlike the smart cap [27].
Sashmita Raghav’s paper discusses about the device ‘Suraksha’ which helps in
maintaining social distance. They made a headgear using a PIR sensor to detect the
human. They preferred using of this sensor because of their 120-degree view
instead of ultrasonic sensors with a 30-degree view. So, to cover entire 360 degrees,
they used three PIR sensors. NodeMCU (node micro controller unit) ESP32, 32-bit
microprocessor with on-board Wi-Fi and Bluetooth was used to act as an interface
between the buzzer, sensors and to establish connection with a mobile phone to
exchange data instead of MQTT and SIM 808 which were used in IoT-based indoor
safety and smart cap, respectively. In the case of violating social-distance
NodeMCU ESP32 sends the information about duration and closeness of contact
and also gives the buzzer sound to alert the user. Figure 13.3 describes about steps
involved in working of a Suraksha device [28].
Dr R. Dhaya’s paper ‘Deep Net Model for Detection of Covid-19 using
Radiographs based on ROC (Receiver Operating Characteristics) Analysis’ dis-
cusses about the CNN models that are developed to find the infected persons using
chest X-rays. Their study helps to overcome shortage of test kits due to which
spreading of infection is rapid. There are three CNN models ResNet50, ResNetV2,
and InceptionV3 out of which ResNet50 is the fastest [29]. The paper of Singh,
Sundaram, and Aditya Garg discusses about ‘Automatic Door Handle or Knob
Sanitiser’. This contraption is powered by an Arduino Nano, an infrared sensor, and
a servo motor. It automatically sanitises the door knob that is used in public places.
Whenever the IR senses the hand at the door knob, the servo motor pulls the handle
of sanitiser bottle to release the liquid to clean the surface of knob and hand [30].
The paper on ‘A Review On Smart Health System To Monitor People In
Covid-19 Quarantine’ of Mr Sushilkumar Thakare and Mahadeo Kokate discusses
Positive
Negative
about quarantine system. This system is an integration of pulse sensor and breathe
sensor. This system is designed by using Arduino Pro mini, the smallest of Arduino
series and HC-06 Bluetooth module to establish connection to doctors and family.
It helps in monitoring the blood pressure, blood pH (potential of hydrogen), heart
rate, body temperature, respiratory rate of the patient who is in home quarantine. If
any of the important parameters of the patient falls below the limit, it alerts the
family members and doctors through email and twitter messages with the help of
Bluetooth module [31]. Bhagwant, Gavade Poonam, and V. V. Purohit discussed
about the device used to check the safety regulations at entrance by using IR sen-
sors, temperature sensors. They made a device using three IR sensors, temperature
sensor, pulse oximeter interfaced with Arduino Uno microcontroller. Two IR sen-
sors will be placed outside the gate and one sensor inside the gate. When person
approaches the gate, temperature was measured by using contactless IR thermo-
meter and the person is asked to place the finger on the pulse oximeter. If the
person has normal temperature and blood oxygen levels greater than 90%, then the
person is allowed into the hall. Unlike ‘IoT-based solution for indoor safety’ device
which measures the social distance inside the hall, this device allows person to
enter the mall only if the sufficient place to maintain is available inside the hall. So,
when the person enters the hall, the IR sensor placed inside the gate automatically
increases the count [32].
The article in ‘The Print’ discusses about ‘Bag valve masks’ that was a low-
cost ventilator invented by students of IIT – Hyderabad. These ventilators are made
within the cost of Rs. 5,000 which is 100 times less than the conventional machine.
These are at present at 3D powered range. At present these are hand powered and
can be further developed to be operated with a simple power source like car bat-
teries. They are of a great help in this pandemic period where there is a large
requirement of ventilators [33]. The paper ‘Far-UVC applications in healthcare’
has written by Parker Esswein gives idea about various healthcare devices using
far-UVC. This paper tells us about the importance of a far-UV lamp in disinfection
and various applications using far-UV in health centres. A far-UVC box sanitiser
helps in sanitising objects and far-UVC disinfection wand can be used to sanitise
small objects like mobile phones. In these two systems, human support is required
and it is limited to few objects. This project is similar to our object but with no
human assistance [34]. The paper ‘Far UV-C lights and fibre optics-induced
selective far-UVC treatment against COVID-19 for fatality-survival trade-off’ by
Imran Haider, Asad Ali, Tooba Arifeen, and Abdus Sami Hassan gives information
about the effectiveness of far-UVC lights in eradicating corona virus. This paper
gives an idea about the usage of far-UV light in public places and for the treatment
of humans. A far-UVC light with the help of optical fibre can treat a person without
damaging the skin [35].
Simply using a sanitiser and mask would be a great help in protecting us from
the viruses, but to sanitise our surroundings, there is no such product available. This
bot is a product which helps us sanitise our surroundings without any harmful
effects. UV is the electromagnetic radiation in the range of 100–400 nm [36] as
shown in Figure 13.4. We have three lamps: UV (254 nm), which is harmful to
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 371
Light
Wavelength(nm)
100 280 315 400 700
Ultraviolet Visible Infrared
(a) (b)
human skin, UVC lamp which is also dangerous to the human skin and the radiation
received from that emitter in surfaces depends on the location where it is present
[37]. Far-UVC (222 nm) is the third lamp which is not harmful to human skin and
does not contain the traces of mercury [38]. Therefore, it is safe to use in this
project, and hence it can be used for sterilisation process.
Existing solutions are displayed in Figure 13.5. Figure 13.5(a) shows a picture
of a corona cleaner which uses UVC light to inactivate the RNA (ribonucleic acid)
of the viruses thereby not allowing the transfer of viruses and bacteria. This device
sanitises all the portable electronic gadgets through UVC lamps. It is portable and
easy to use [39]. Figure 13.5(b) shows the picture of the ‘the UV blaster’, which
again uses UVC light to sanitise virus-prone areas. It is used in hotels, restaurants,
airports, shopping malls, metros, and factories. This can be operated with a remote
using a mobile or laptop using a Wi-Fi link. It includes six UVC lamps, each with a
UVC power of 43 W and wavelengths of 254 nm for 360-degree lighting [40].
‘The disinfection period for a space of around 1212-ft2 size is around 10
min’, says the concern, adding that a 400-ft2 area can be sanitised in 30 min if the
device is placed in various locations throughout the room.
372 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Motor driver
Motor drivers form an interface between the motors and control circuits. It has
a voltage regulator, a power led, a 5-V jumper ENA, and ENB pins. IN1, IN2,
IN3, and IN4 are direction control pins at the edges of motor driver as shown in
Figure 13.8. They require a large amount of current whereas low current sig-
nals are worked on by the controller. So, the job of a motor driver is to trans-
form a low-current signal into a high-current signal that may be used to drive
a motor.
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 375
12-V battery
Lead–acid batteries are used in marine industries. In general, it has two 6-V bat-
teries in series, or a single 12-V battery. Batteries are arranged with several single
cells in series manner, where each cell produces approximately 2.1 V. In a 12-V
battery, six single cells are arranged in series producing an output voltage of 12.6
V. A battery is a mostly used component in projects. In the place of a battery, we
can use voltage regulators based on requirement of applications.
Ultrasonic sensor
Arduino
Uno
Gear
Motor driver
motors
(a)
Start
Motor driver
Ultrasonic sensor
detects the obstacle
(b) Locomotion
Figure 13.10 (a) Block diagram of the bot and (b) flow chart describing the
design flow
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 377
(a) (b)
Figure 13.11 (a) Front and (b) side view of the project
evident that the Arduino Uno is a key component of the proposed work. This is the
brain of the proposed work as it controls and sends the information; here the
ultrasonic sensor detects the objects and sends the information to Arduino and it
decides what operation has to be done. Based on ultrasonic observations, Arduino
Uno commands the motor driver to regulate the gear motors.
There are components like ultrasonic sensors which help the bot to detect
obstacles in their paths and move forward. This entire set-up can be employed in
houses, offices, malls, theatres, and hospitals. This set-up would sanitise the entire
place in about 15 min. It would cause no harm to humans and would prove to be a
boon to many as it is automatic and needs no human efforts to operate it and also
helps us keep our surroundings and objects clean, thereby protecting us from dan-
gerous diseases or viruses and keeping us clean, hygienic, and healthy. CAD
(computer-sided design) models of the proposed idea are shown in Figure 13.11.
Figure 13.11(a) and (b) shows the view of a CAD model of our project. The
two parts show the box in which ultrasonic sensors, Arduino Uno, and other elec-
trical components are placed internally. On the top of the surface, pole-shaped far-
UVC lamps are placed as shown in Figure 13.11 for sanitising the surroundings and
at the bottom surface, four LED shaped far-UVC lamps are placed for sanitising the
ground.
the cleaning process and decreases the risk. It is very significant in the hospitality
industry. It can be used by all households, industries, offices, hospitals, and other
places to maintain the cleanliness.
Interfacing of the Arduino with a motor driver and gear motors is shown in
Figure 13.13. Whenever the ultrasonic sensor detects the object, the information is
sent to the Arduino. Now Arduino determines and sends the instruction to motor
driver regarding the direction of movement. The motor driver regulates the power
to move gear motors.
The robot model was successfully created in AutoCAD, and the prototype was
completed as shown in Figure 13.14. The ultrasonic sensor is connected to Arduino
of 2, 3, 4, 5 pins, and other ultrasonic sensors were connected in the same way. The
transmitter pin will send the wave and when it identifies the object, it sends the
echo wave to receiver pin of ultrasonic sensor that goes to Arduino; now Arduino
decides and sends commands to a motor driver, then the motor driver controls the
gear motors. In this way, the robot locomotion works. The far-UVC lamp will be
ON while the robot is moving. The lamp will sanitise the room while it was moving
and at the same time it will clean the floor.
After implementing this robot steriliser using Arduino and ultrasonic sensors,
it has been observed that some difficulty aroused from ultrasonic sensor, like get-
ting trouble while it was moving in corner areas of rooms or halls. To overcome
such problems, LIDARs (light detection and ranging) can be used in the place of
ultrasonic sensors along with an accelerometer sensor in the future enhancement of
the proposed work. LIDAR and accelerometer sensors make the robot into a
complete autonomous. A typical remote-sensing method for estimating the exact
distance of an object on the earth’s surface is LIDAR. It benefits us by sending out
pulsed light waves into the environment. These pulses re-enter the sensor after
380 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
bouncing off nearby objects. The sensor calculates the distance travelled by using
the time it took for each pulse to return to the sensor. So that it can recognise
corners and walls in less time, allowing us to do the sanitisation in less time. In
addition to that, we can develop an app for the proposed work so that it would be
more helpful for the people in controlling the robot remotely. This bot will be a
great help in sanitising the surroundings and making them clean and tidy, by era-
dicating germs and preventing from being infected from dangerous virus. This bot
can be used in public places like malls, theatres, parks, and schools to reduce the
chance of persons being affected.
We can add a feature to this model like making the robot climbing up the walls
and cleaning the walls too. In order to achieve this, we need to change the shape of
the model such that it can climb the walls. Then the robot will be capable of
cleaning walls and floors. It would be great advantage for the people. The mobile
application can also be developed so that we can control it and if needed we can
change the option either it is being used for sanitising the floor or walls. In a
hospital the patient/staff can also use it if they needed for cleaning. The same robot
can be used for monitoring the patient condition in the hospital room using AI/ML
techniques. The robot will supply food to patients, it checks the temperature and
oxygen level of patients and sends data to store using blockchain technology, and
this feature reduces the work of staff and provides comfort for patient too.
Arduino-based robot for purification of COVID-19 381
References
[1] Armani AM, Hurt DE, Hwang D, McCarthy MC, and Scholtz A. ‘Low-tech
solutions for the COVID-19 supply chain crisis’. Nature Reviews Materials.
2020;5(6):403–6.
[2] Welch D, Buonanno M, Grilj V et al. ‘Far-UVC light: A new tool to control
the spread of airborne-mediated microbial diseases’. Scientific Reports.
2018;8(1):01–07.
[3] Olcay A, Albayrak SB, Akturk IF et al. ‘A new Far-UVC based method for
germ free hospitals and travel: Initus-V’. medRxiv. 2021.
[4] Louis L. ‘Working principle of Arduino and using it as a tool for study and
research’. International Journal of Control, Automation, Communication,
and Systems. 2016;1(2):21–9.
[5] Badamasi YA. ‘The working principle of an Arduino’. 11th International
Conference on Electronics, Computer, and Computation (ICECCO), IEEE.
29 September 2018. pp. 1–4.
382 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[20] Dogan O, Tiwari S, Jabbar MA, and Guggari S. ‘A systematic review on AI/
ML approaches against COVID-19 outbreak’. Complex and Intelligent
Systems. 2021:1–24.
[21] Chakraborty C, Gupta B, and Ghosh SK. ‘A review on telemedicine-based
WBAN framework for patient monitoring’. Telemedicine and e-Health.
2013;19(8):619–26.
[22] Muhammad LJ, Algehyne EA, Usman SS, Ahmad A, Chakraborty C, and
Mohammed IA. ‘Supervised machine learning models for prediction of
COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset’. SN Computer Science.
2021;2(1):1–3.
[23] Ocaña J, Flores E, Naquin E, Pacheco A, and Felix E. ‘Smart system model
to disinfect SARS-CoV-2 in physical environments’. Journal of
Contemporary Issues in Business and Government. 2021;27(2).
[24] Megantoro P, Setiadi H, and Aji Pramudita B. ‘All-terrain mobile robot
disinfectant sprayer to decrease the spread of covid-19 in open area’.
International Journal of Electrical and Computer Engineering (IJECE).
2021;11(3):2090–100.
[25] Metcalfe B, Iravani P, Graham-Harper-Cater J, Bowman R, Stirling J, and
Wilson P. ‘A cost-effective pulse oximeter designed in response to the
COVID-19 pandemic’. Journal of Open Hardware. 2021;5(1).
[26] Reji B, Rathesh A, Suresh S, Jose N, and Benny J. ‘Smart Cap for Prevention
of Contagious Diseases and Social Distancing Using Arduino’. Bangalore
Humanitarian Technology Conference (B-HTC), IEEE. 8 October 2020.
pp. 1–5.
[27] Roy K. ‘Flexible (Portable) COVID 19 detecting device using Arduino and
sensors’. International Journal of Engineering Research in Computer
Science and Engineering. 2021;8(3):32–3.
[28] Raghav S, Vijay G, Harika PS et al. ‘Suraksha: Low Cost Device to
Maintain Social Distancing during CoVID-19’. 4th International Conference
on Electronics, Communication and Aerospace Technology (ICECA), IEEE.
5 November 2020. pp. 1476–80.
[29] Dhaya R. ‘Deep net model for detection of covid-19 using radiographs based
on roc analysis’. Journal of Innovative Image Processing (JIIP). 2020;
2(03):135–40.
[30] Singh S and Garg A. ‘Automatic door handle or knob sanitizer’. Journal on
Today’s Ideas-Tomorrow’s Technologies. 2020;8(1):35–40.
[31] Thakare MS and Kokate M. ‘A review on smart health system to monitor
people in Covid-19 quarantine’. International Journal of Advance Scientific
Research and Technology. 2020;5:28–33.
[32] Bhagawan GP and Purohit VV. ‘Safety regulations checks at entrance for
COVID safety’. International Journal of Research Publication and Reviews.
2021;2(3):383–6.
[33] Sharma K. ‘The ideas and innovations IITs have come up with to help India
fight coronavirus’. The print. 1 April 2020.
384 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Abstract
Late within the year of 2019, the entire world roused by a reality of an epidemic of
coronavirus disease (COVID-19). It has become very vital and important to take all
possible precaution till the world finds a definite treatment against this disease as
there is least information about its behavior and origin. World Health Organization
(WHO) informed that proper guidelines need to be followed for COVID-19 waste
management as it is extremely infectious and contaminated. Personal protective
equipment has become a very vital element to guard from exposure of any infec-
tious materials. It is usually used in healthcare or hospital settings during any
outbreak. These enormous challenges are with all stakeholders for avoiding spread
through waste. Additionally, to WHO, each country was adopted different safety
measures and developed guidelines to control the contamination and manage the
waste. The previously mentioned guidelines are very useful for managing the
infectious waste and providing protection and security of waste handlers. Not only
the spread of COVID-19 is reduced by practicing appropriate technologies to
handle wastes, but it generates worth through increasing the recyclability chance of
waste. Due to COVID-19, there were lots of social and economic changes hap-
pened in the world, which leads to reduction in manufacturing units and various
business processes. All these have significantly affected waste management that is
a very vivacious step for the health outcomes of the patients as well as caregivers,
especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Among all the issues created by
COVID-19, the problem that will create major mess is, not handling biomedical
waste properly. If the spreading needs to be controlled, it requires a strict mon-
itoring of the complete cycle starting from the point of generation. However, due to
the invaluable service of waste management sector only, it is possible to avoid
spread of the COVID-19 and ensure that the weird tons of waste will not be gath-
ered that increases health risks and the spread of disease.
1
Department of Hospital Administration, All India Institute of Medical Sciences Bhubaneswar,
Bhubaneswar, India
2
Department of ECE, BIT Mesra, Ranchi, India
386 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
14.1 Introduction
needs policy consequences [11]. This rising plastic use leads to a channel for
contamination and increases the chance of spread. To control the pandemic a pro-
hibition of movements was implemented, which affects the countries that depend
on external technologies for waste reprocessing and management. As a result, the
waste generated in that said period is disposed of rather than recycled. COVID-19
pandemic like emergencies made the sustainable management of BMW proble-
matic and amplified. The hefty waste either needs to be collected for disposing or
recycled. Both the processes are compromised because of the shortage of man-
power and hard work to implement infection control measures [12,13]. These dis-
rupted services lead to mishandling of waste and it increased up to 300% at few
rural communities of the United Kingdom (UK) [14]. Due to this pandemic the UK
Environment Agency allowed a temporary storage of waste and incineration ash at
sites that further threatens the environment [15]. The waste management system as
a whole needs to be considered, from waste generation, to treatment, including
resource use, and disposal of extra waste to reduce the socioeconomic and envir-
onmental impacts of waste as well as shielding of waste management chains will
help to achieve sustainable cities and communities [16]. In the last two decades,
COVID-19 pandemic is the third major zoonotic disease episode. First, it was the
SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) in 2002–03 and the second was MERS
(Middle East respiratory syndrome) in 2012. The disease was first reported to
WHO by the Chinese Health Officials on December 31, 2019 as atypical pneu-
monia of unknown reason [17]. According to Van Doremalen et al., the survival
period varies from hours to days depending on the materials and environment.
Survival phases on copper and cardboard vary from 3 to 4 h, while on plastic,
stainless steel varies from 1 to 3 days and some time as high as up to 9 days, even in
tap or waste water at 20 C for 2 days [18,19]. This longer survival period can lead
to a high danger of communal spread by inappropriate. In this chapter, first various
impacts like socioeconomic, environmental and also impacts on waste generation
and waste management are discussed. Different subsequent challenges faced due to
these impacts on waste management are enumerated. Lastly, it described the new
models or rethinking in the processes of waste management during pandemic.
markets detected the major decline after 2008 economic disaster. The market slide
continues as global markets also fell down quite a lot. However, later slowly it
gained up after October/November 2020.
As a global pandemic, COVID-19 contributed a lot of environmental issues,
especially in BMW management. Wuhan city generates 200 t of BMW, four times
greater than the capacity of its waste treatment capabilities [24]. Ocean Asia, a
leading NGO, mentioned that BMW generated in Hong Kong spoiled the seaside
atmosphere [25]. Due to COVID-19, countries must announce lockdown measures
to safeguard their citizens and limit the exposure from COVID-19 [26]. Several air
changes were found around the world like air pollutants that came down in New
York by 50%, 25% reduction of emission in China due to 40% decrease of coal use
and a significant reduction of air pollution during pandemic [27]. Nevertheless,
financial influences of COVID-19 were very vital, but they highly contributed
toward an ecofriendly decarbonized environment, and air quality improved sig-
nificantly as reported in the various literature [28,29]. Satellite pictures of NASA in
order to analyses air quality show 20%–38% reduced pollutants in Korea, Spain,
Germany, and the USA [30].
With the increasing number of patients, BMW generated from the COVID-19
patient wards are also increasing and becoming a bigger concern for hospital. Thus,
we have to ensure that this contaminated trash from hospitals should not cause any
harm to the public before they are safely disposed. Changes in BMW character-
istics are as follows: BMW includes the waste generated from hospitals, medical
institutions, medical laboratories, etc. where there are many patients who are
managed [31]. Generally, 75%–90% waste generated from hospital is general,
nonhazardous waste and does not require any special management, and only 10%–
25% are BMW and require special treatment for disposal. But, in a pandemic
situation, all the wastes generated within a facility would be measured as BMW and
managed with full precautions. To manage these unusual amount of BMW, the
existing waste treatment facilities need to be modified based on the real informa-
tion of the amount produced and availability of the treatment facilities [32]. A
report from UNEP says that hospitals generating waste 0.5 kg/bed/day before
pandemic increased the same during pandemic by 3.4 kg/bed/day. In India, waste
generation increased from 0.5 to 2.5–4 kg/bed/day as reported by Ramteke and
Sahu [33]. Also, in a study at a Chinese hospital by Peng et al. [10], it is reported
that the average waste generation rate is more than 6 kg/bed/day during pandemic.
Asymptomatic infections are caused by the COVID-19 virus [34,35], so that there
are obstacles in determining the level of COVID-19 transmission in communities
and between countries. A method that is quite effective in detecting and analyzing
the spread of virus is COVID-19 surveillance in wastewater as it provides unbiased
results and it can be used as an early warning system. Wastewater monitoring is a
virus identification system that has contaminated the environment and society;
Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on waste management system 389
PPE was used chiefly by healthcare experts only, but as pandemic continues, PPE
has been used by general population very widely, which leads to increase the
demand of PPE during the pandemic. Almost every country has instructed man-
datory facemask use for its citizens. The mask uses of some countries are shown in
Table 14.2. A mask or PPE is largely composed of plastic (>80%) [43]. The
increase in demand and the mandatory masks use transformed the plastic waste
generation dynamics and enhanced intricacies of management of plastic and hin-
dered the hard work to decrease plastic trash [44].
Plastic waste: with the change in lifestyle, the use of plastics also increases for
convenience and reassurance. But at the same time concern about the reduction of
plastic waste was prevalent among everybody based on the world pollution due to
plastic. During this pandemic, there is a shift from concern about environmental
pollution of plastic to preferring plastic packaging [46]. Demand has risen abruptly
for packaging and transportation during this pandemic [47]. In most countries, to
control the spread quarantine caused an increase demand for online shop services
[44]. Overall, when compared to pre-pandemic, the online trading has increased in
pandemic and post pandemic era (16.6%) [48].
Food waste: COVID-19 has made changes in the life style and in the con-
sumption habits, which stimulate food loss and waste (FLW). In April 2020, a
survey of US households found, during pandemic, cooking at home increased by
54% (n ¼ 1,005) [49], which implies more food waste, whereas 57% conveyed less
waste, which means net effect with no change. Individuals waste more food, with
an anticipation of shortage of food during crisis, which results in excess food sto-
rage [50]. In Spain, consumption data shows increase in food purchases (29.8% and
10.9%) in first and second weeks and then decreased by 20.3% in the third week of
lockdown, which indicates that pandemic had very less effect on the FLW by 12%
hike that might be due to the socioeconomic crisis [51].
As per the CDC, hazards of transmission of COVID-19 are high in persons who are
in close contact with an already diseased person or by touching a surface or object,
which is a less known mode of virus spreads. However, OSHA states that
Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on waste management system 391
acquaintance chance will be increased for the workers who deal with waste and
wastewater management. A WHO report showed that in 2000, 21 million people
were infected with hepatitis B, 2 million with hepatitis C, and 260,000 with HIV
because of polluted needle [52]. However, the waste thrown by isolated families
could lead the waste handler workers as well as cloth pickers to risk. It is further-
more crucial to ensure that waste should not be mixed at regular dumping grounds.
A good waste management stratagem denotes the program of a facility for mana-
ging produced waste for treatment and disposal. In response to the pandemic, every
country has implemented the best suitable management strategies based on their
resources [42,53]. There should be appropriate facilities to keep waste in temporary
storage in sealed container and in very secure areas, in the case of problem in
treatment and disposal methods. Disinfectant must use to avoid probable virus
transmission. Mobile incineration and autoclaves can be used to dispose the extra
BMW generated in pandemic. Designated vehicles should be used for transferring
waste with proper record [41] and special permit to collect healthcare waste for
smooth handling. The authorities should strictly oversee the process that regula-
tions are followed properly based on national and local guidelines. Any good
management system requires an assessment available options, plans, and clearly
defined roles and responsibilities of personnel. There should be a waste manage-
ment committee that will implement the plan. Strategies should be periodically
reviewed, and all staff involved in waste management processes should be updated
with the periodic changes [54]. Overall, the optimized use of resources and proper
waste segregation minimize the waste significantly [45]. As waste generation
cannot be predicted with increasing infections, temporary waste treatment tech-
nologies like autoclaves burn incinerators, it is difficult to manage waste effectively
[55]. Suitable waste management always helps in raising the quantity of recyclable
waste by the use of these alternative technologies during the pandemic [42].
Considering all these options, healthcare waste can be utilized to augment value to
the country’s economy during the pandemic [11,56].
Various international organizations published many policies or guidelines
related to waste management from time to time. Some countries have laws related
to BMW and some instantly issued new strategies and plans to overcome the
pandemic. Unexpected rise in BMW is a huge challenge for all. India also released
policies in time to time on BMW management [44]. In Iran, pandemic causes the
clearance of infectious waste to entirely stop for a certain period [45]. The National
Institute of Public Health, Romania, includes quarantine home generated waste as
infectious waste and implements firm waste management actions [57]. Diverse
decontamination and discarding methods and technologies are used based on fac-
tors like, quantity, type, and costs, some of them are given in Table 14.3 [29,56]. In
all-purpose, an amalgamation of chemical disinfection and incineration, the most
widely accepted, safe, simple and effective technology would be adopted [29]. In
the case of overloaded BMW treatment facilities, industrial furnaces or cement
kilns may be used safely [41]. On-site and mobile treatments are preferred due to
their flexibility in retorting to fluctuating demands. Fixed, mobile, coprocessing
facilities, and nonlocal disposal methods were all successively used in China,
392 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Table 14.3 Disinfection and disposal techniques for biomedical waste (BMW)
although all these are supplementary methods of techniques used in waste man-
agement [58].
emptied in another bag. Strict hand hygiene should be maintained after handling
waste bag.
Worldwide, the spread of COVID-19 has amplified the use of PPE manifold, and
all these littered PPE waste from healthcare and home might be a vector for COVID
virus, due to the potential ability of survival of the virus even up to 7 days on
masks, gloves, and fomite. Additionally, a polymer plastic, polypropylene, takes
long time to degrade and likely culminate in further plastic pollution as reported by
WHO [52]. A COVID-19 patient can generate 3.4-kg waste per day that shows the
gradual increasing trend in waste quantity in pandemic [41]. The BMW from the
healthcare institution and hospital in India is generating 517 t/day. Out of 517 t/day,
only 501 t/day waste could be treated in Common Biomedical Management Waste
Treatment Facility over 28 states of India. The rest 16 t/day wastes are accumulated
untreated daily. Some states like Goa, Andaman Nicobar, Mizoram, Nagaland, and
Sikkim are not having CBWTFs at all [44]. Many other countries are also facing
alike challenges to manage the vast quantity of waste [41]. Healthcare solid waste
in France increased from 40% to 50% and in the Netherlands, it increased to 50%
from 40% similar to India and Iran as reported by Zand and Heir [42] and Prata
et al. [44]. European administrations are facing challenges in retaining waste
management staff, providing them a good atmosphere and space for extra waste
generated in pandemic. In many of the developing countries, there are no effective
BMW management policies and resources. South Asia is a thickly populated sec-
tion of the world with 24.89% of the global population. Safe and accurate BMW
management is a legitimate necessity for such areas to avoid a further health crisis.
Also, the urban–rural inequality in waste management is a great challenge. The
394 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
INCLEN Program Evaluation Network Study Group reported that a big section of
healthcare system (82% of primary, 60% of secondary, and 54% of tertiary care) is
lacking in proper waste-handling system [4]. In rural areas, informal practitioners
with no or very little practical knowledge handle BMW, and awareness of BMW
segregation and management is more different among staff in urban than in rural
areas. Lots of studies recommended that these previously mentioned countries need
to formulate comprehensive guidelines to seal knowledge gaps in the BMW
handling. Developing countries have neglected BMW management in obedience
with rules for a long time. The discussed issue of indiscriminate dumping of waste
will pose a severe environmental impact and occupational health risks. Besides,
ignorant public conduct will put waste handlers at risk as the quarantined domestic
litters are disposed with the regular household MSW. During these pandemics, like
India, many countries have come up with some thought-provoking problems that
include the following:
● The significantly increasing quantity of hazardous elements led to tricky issues
of separate waste collection.
● During pandemic, no formal training was given to sanitary workers on how to
handle the waste. Arranging regular training to the operators is also a
challenging issue.
● Irregularity in supply of PPEs and disinfectants increase the probabilities of
collection staff who are prone to get infected.
● Inappropriate donning and doffing of the PPEs among waste worker may
increase spread between them.
● Not keeping the social-distancing measures at collection centers and
treatment areas.
● Wastewater of healthcare facilities may contain virus, staff who are handling
wastewater treatment plants may at a high risk of infection.
● No door-to-door collecting staff are there from residential areas, and the one-
point collection is predominant for increasing the infection risk.
● Use of separate vehicles for infected and noninfected waste transport and lack
of disinfectant to clean the vehicles increase the chance of spreading the virus.
● Lack of proper monitoring review and verification systems in towns and villages.
● Challenges in implementing strategies and advisory at the ground level people
who handling waste.
● Difficulty to make general public aware within short span of importance and
rules of segregating the waste.
● At few places, manual loading or unloading of the waste is required, which
raises the probabilities of contaminations.
were accustomed with or restructured their strategies of waste management for the
COVID-19 outbreak. In this connection, China can offer valued inputs considering
their experiences of building an all-inclusive disposal system through a mixture of
central disposal as well as on-site emergency disposal of waste (like mobile treat-
ment and industrial kilns). The pandemic not only reformed people’s lifestyle but
stirred extra contemplation on the human and nature relationship. In addition, there
are few critical issues about whether the existing systems of BMW management
can quickly restore the waste processing, and ability of general population to focus
on waste reduction. These issues need to be discussed and studied for betterment in
the future. There is not a solitary resolution available for different countries, which
varies in terms of infested cases, health resources; therefore diverse resolutions
should be implemented. There are lots of issues in dealing with appropriate and
actual waste management as it involves many departments and many individuals,
requiring interdepartmental collaboration. For a country to determine whether it
can manage a substantial rise in BMW production, it should analyze its existing
strategies, rules, structures, and also the present operation status of waste man-
agement. The main issue is not how to frame the strategies and policies, rather how
successfully can they be implemented. To creating a sustainable waste management
system throughout and subsequently the pandemic at national or local levels, both
strategy makers and experts need to consider at least seven thematic significance
areas as mentioned by UNICEF [4].
References
[1] Bashir MF, Ma B, and Shahzad L. A brief review of socio-economic and
environmental impact of Covid-19. Air Quality, Atmosphere & Health 2020;
13:1403–1409. doi:10.1007/s11869-020-00894-8. Epub ahead of print.
PMID: 32837620; PMCID: PMC7395801.
[2] Bashir MF, Ma B, Bilal, et al. Correlation between climate indicators and
COVID-19 pandemic in New York, USA. Science of the Total Environment
2020; 728:138835. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.138835.
[3] Chakraborty I and Maity P. COVID-19 outbreak: migration, effects on
society, global environment and prevention. Science of the Total
Environment 2020; 728:138882. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.
138882.
Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on waste management system 399
[4] WHO and UNICEF. Water, sanitation, hygiene and waste management for
the COVID-19 Virus. Interim Guidance, WHO/2019-nCoV/IPC_WASH/
2020.2. [Online] April 23, 2020; 1–6. [Cited: April 15, 2021] https://apps.
who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/331846/WHO2019-nCoV-IPC_WASH-
2020.3-eng.pdf.
[5] Calma J. The COVID-19 pandemic is generating tons of medical waste.
[Online] Mar 26, 2020. [Cited: April 15, 2021] https://www.theverge.com/
2020/3/26/21194647/the-covid-19-pandemic-is-generating-tons-of-medical-
waste.
[6] Lal P, Kumar A, Kumar S, et al. The dark cloud with a silver lining:
Assessing the impact of the SARS COVID-19 pandemic on the global
environment. Science of the Total Environment 2020; 732:139297.
[7] Espejo W, Celis JE, Chiang G, and Bahamonde P. Environment and
COVID-19: Pollutants, impacts, dissemination, management and recom-
mendations for facing future epidemic threats. Science of the Total
Environment 2020; 747:141314. doi:10.1016/j.scitotenv.
[8] Somani M, Srivastava AN, Gummadivalli SK, and Sharma A. Indirect
implications of COVID-19 towards sustainable environment: An investiga-
tion in Indian context. Bioresource Technology Reports 2020; 11:100491.
[9] Ragazzi M, Rada EC, and Schiavon M. Municipal solid waste management
during the SARS-COV-2 outbreak and lockdown ease: Lessons from Italy.
Science of the Total Environment 2020; 745:141159.
[10] Peng J, Wu X, Wang R, Li C, Zhang Q, and Wei D. Medical waste man-
agement practice during the 2019–2020 novel coronavirus pandemic:
Experience in a general hospital. American Journal of Infection Control
2020; 48(8):918–921.
[11] Klemeš JJ, Fan YV, Tan RR, and Jiang P. Minimising the present and future
plastic waste, energy and environmental footprints related to COVID-19.
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2020; 127:109883. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.rser.202.
[12] European Commission. Waste Management in the Context of the
Coronavirus Crisis. Brussels: European Commission, 2020.
[13] Association of Cities and Regions for Sustainable Resource Management.
Municipal waste management and COVID-19. Municipal waste manage-
ment and COVID-19. Association of Cities and Regions for Sustainable
Resource Management, 2020.
[14] Roberts K, Stringfellow AM, and Williams ID. Rubbish is piling up and
recycling has stalled – waste systems must adapt. The Conversation, 2020.
Available from: https://theconversation.com/rubbish-is-piling-up-and-recy-
cling-has-stalled-waste-systems-must-adapt-137100.
[15] UK Environment Agency. COVID-19 and storing waste at unpermitted sites
due to exceeding your storage limits: RPS C17. UK Environment Agency,
2020.
[16] United Nations. Sustainable development goal 11: Make cities and human
settlements inclusive, safe, resilient, and sustainable. United Nations, 2020.
400 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[17] Poon LLM and Peiris M. Emergence of a novel human coronavirus threa-
tening human health. Nature Medicine 2020; 26(3):317–319.
[18] van Doremalen N, Bushmaker T, Morris DH, et al. Aerosol and surface
stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1. The New England
Journal of Medicine 2020; 382(16):1564–1567.
[19] Wang D, Hu B, Hu C, et al. Clinical characteristics of 138 hospitalized
patients with 2019 novel coronavirus–infected pneumonia in Wuhan, China.
JAMA 2020; 323(11):1061–1069. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.
[20] Collivignarelli MC, Abbà A, Bertanza G, Pedrazzani R, Ricciardi P, and
Miino MC. Lockdown for CoViD-2019 in Milan: what are the effects on air
quality? Science of the Total Environment 2020; 732:139280. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.139280.
[21] Messner W. The institutional and cultural context of cross-national variation
in COVID-19 outbreaks. medRxiv 2020. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.30.
20047589.
[22] Goodell JW and Huynh TLD. Did congress trade ahead? Considering the
reaction of U.S. industries to COVID-19. Finance Research Letters 2020;
36:101578. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2020.101578.
[23] Bogoch II, Watts A, Thomas-Bachli A, Huber C, Kraemer MU, and Khan K.
Pneumonia of unknown etiology in Wuhan, China: Potential for interna-
tional spread via commercial air travel. Journal of Travel Medicine 2020; 27.
https://doi.org/10.1093/jtm/taaa008.
[24] Luan PT and Ching CTS. A reusable mask for coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19). Archives of Medical Research 2020; 51:455–457. https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.arcmed.2020.04.001.
[25] Hellewell J, Abbott S, Gimma A, et al. Feasibility of controlling COVID-19
outbreaks by isolation of cases and contacts. The Lancet Global Health
2020; 8:e488–e496. https://doi.org/10.1016/S221.
[26] Zambrano-Monserrate MA and Ruano MA. Has air quality improved in
Ecuador during the COVID-19 pandemic? A parametric analysis. Air
Quality, Atmosphere & Health 2020; 13:929–938. https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11869-020-00866-y.
[27] Gautam S. COVID-19: air pollution remains low as people stay at home. Air
Quality, Atmosphere & Health 2020; 13:853–857.https://doi.org/10.1007/
s11869-020-00842-6.
[28] Conticini E, Frediani B, and Caro D. Can atmospheric pollution be con-
sidered a co-factor in extremely high level of SARS-CoV-2 lethality in
northern Italy? Environmental Pollution 2020; 261:114465. https://doi.org/
10.1016/j.envpol.2020.114465.
[29] Sharif A, Aloui C, and Yarovaya L. COVID-19 pandemic, oil prices, stock
market, geopolitical risk and policy uncertainty nexus in the U.S. economy:
Fresh evidence from the wavelet-based approach. The International Review of
Financial Analysis 2020; 70:101496. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.irfa.2020.101496.
[30] Knowland EK, Keller C, Ott L, et al. Local to global air quality simulations
using the NASA GEOS composition forecast model: GEOS-CF, 2020.
Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on waste management system 401
[31] Rupani PF, Nilashi M, Abumalloh RA, Asadi S, Samad S, and Wang S.
Coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19) and its natural environmental impacts.
International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology 2020;
17:4655–466.
[32] Sarkodie SA and Owusu PA. Global assessment of environment, health and
economic impact of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19). Environment,
Development and Sustainability 2020: 1–11.
[33] Ramteke S and Sahu BL. Novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)
pandemic: Considerations for the biomedical waste sector in India. Case
Studies in Chemical and Environmental Engineering 2020; 2:100029. doi.
org/10.1016/j.cscee.2020.100029.
[34] Nishiura H, Kobayashi T, Suzuki A, et al. Estimation of the asymptomatic
ratio of novel coronavirus infections (Covid-19). International Journal of
Infectious Diseases 2020; 94:154–155. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijid.20.
[35] Mizumoto K, Kagaya K, Zarebski A, and Chowell G. Estimating the
asymptomatic proportion of coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid19) cases on
board the diamond princess cruise ship. Eurosurveillance 2020; 25(10):1–5.
https://doi.org/10.2807/15607917.es.2020.25.10.20.
[36] O’Bannon D., Xagoraraki I, and O’Brien E. Wastewater-based
Epidemiology for Early Detection of Viral Outbreaks. Women in Water
Quality. Springer Nature Switzerland, 2020; 75–79. https://doi.org/10.1007/
978-3-030-17819-2.
[37] Nemudryi A, Nemudraia A, Surya K, et al. Temporal detection and phylo-
genetic assessment of SARS-CoV-2 in municipal wastewater. Cell Reports
Medicine 2020; 1(6):10098. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xcrm.2020.100098.
[38] ADEPT. COVID 19 – Waste survey results, week commencing 18th May.
[Online] ADEPT, 2020. www.adeptnet.org.uk/documents/covid-19-waste-
survey-results-wc-18th-may.
[39] Naughton C. Will the COVID-19 pandemic change waste generation and
composition? The need for more real-time waste management data and systems
thinking. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 2020; 162:105050.
[40] Rahman MM, Bodrud-Doza M, Griffiths MD, and Mamun MA. Biomedical
waste amid Covid19: Perspectives from Bangladesh. The Lancet Global
Health 2020; 8(10):e1262. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/arti-
cle/PIIS2214-109X(20)30349-1/abstract.
[41] Asian Development Bank (ADB). Managing infectious medical waste dur-
ing the COVID-19 pandemic. [Online] Asian Development Bank (ADB),
2020. www.adb.org/publications/managing-medical-wastecovid1.
[42] Zand AD and Heir AV. Emerging challenges in urban waste management in
Tehran, Iran during the COVID-19 pandemic. Resources, Conservation and
Recycling 2020; 162:105051.
[43] Prata JC, Silva ALP, Walker TR, Duarte AC, and Rocha-Santos T. COVID-
19 pandemic repercussions on the use and management of plastics.
Environmental Science & Technology 2020; 54(13):7760–7765.
402 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[44] Vanapalli KR, Sharma HB, Ranjan VP, et al. Challenges and strategies for
effective plastic waste management during and post COVID-19 pandemic.
Science of the Total Environment 2021; 750:141514.
[45] Rodrı́guez-Pardo J, Fuentes B, Alonso de Leciñana M, et al. Acute stroke
care during the COVID-19 pandemic. Ictus Madrid Program recommenda-
tions. Neurologia 2020; 35:258–263.
[46] Grodzińska-Jurczak M, Krawczyk A, Jurczak A, Strzelecka M, Rechciński
M, and Boćkowski M. Environmental choices vs. Covid-19 pandemic fear –
Plastic governance re-assessment. Socialist Register 2020; 4(2):49–66.
[47] Feber D, Lingqvist O, and Nordigården D. How the packaging industry can
navigate the coronavirus pandemic. mckinsey.com. [Online] 2020. www.
mckinsey.com/industries/paper-forest-productsand-packaging/our-insights/
how-the-packaging-industry-can-n.
[48] Clement J. Coronavirus global online traffic impact as of September 2020.
[Online] September 2020. www.statista.com/statistics/1105495/coronavirus-
traffic-impact.
[49] Hunter. Food Study Special Report. [Online] slideshare.net, 2020. www.
slideshare.net/HUNTERNY/hunter-food-study-special-report-america-gets-
cooking-231713331.
[50] Brizi A and Biraglia A. “Do I have enough food?” How need for cognitive
closure and gender impact stockpiling and food waste during the COVID-19
pandemic: A cross-national study in India and the United States of America.
Personality and Individual Differences 2021; 168:110396.
[51] Jribi S, Ben Ismail H, Doggui D, and Debbabi H. COVID-19 virus outbreak
lockdown: What impacts on household food wastage?. Environment,
Development and Sustainability 2020; 22(5):3939–3955.
[52] World Health Organization. Safe Healthcare Waste Management. Policy
Paper. Department of Protection of the Human Environment Water,
Sanitation and Health. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2016.
[53] Singh N, Tang Y, Zhang Z, and Zheng C. Covid19 waste management:
Effective and successful measures in Wuhan, China. Resources,
Conservation & Recycling 2020; 163(105071):1–3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
resconrec.2020.105071.
[54] Thakur V. Framework for PESTEL dimensions of sustainable healthcare
waste management: Learnings from COVID-19 outbreak. Journal of
Cleaner Production 2021; 287:125562.
[55] Yu H, Sun X, Solvang WD, and Zhao X. Reverse logistics network design
for effective management of medical waste in epidemic outbreaks: insights
from the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in Wuhan (China).
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020;
17:1770.
[56] Ilyas S, Srivastava RR, and Kim H. Disinfection technology and strategies
for COVID-19 hospital and bio-medical waste management. Science of the
Total Environment 2020; 749:141652.
Effect of COVID-19 pandemic on waste management system 403
[57] Mihai FC. Assessment of COVID-19 waste flows during the emergency state
in Romania and related public health and environmental concerns.
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020;
17(15):5439.
[58] Yang L, Yu X, Wu X, et al. Emergency response to the explosive growth of
health care wastes during COVID-19 pandemic in Wuhan, China.
Resources, Conservation and Recycling 2021; 164:105074.
[59] Bhuyan HK, Chakraborty C, Shelke Y, and Pani SK. COVID-19 diagnosis
system by deep learning approaches. Expert Systems 2021:e12776. https://
doi.org/10.1111/exsy.12776.
[60] Dash S, Chakraborty C, Giri SK, Pani SK and Frnda J. BIFM: big-data
driven intelligent forecasting model for COVID-19. IEEE Access 2021: 1–
13. 10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3094658.
[61] Aslam B, Javed AR, Chakraborty C, Nebhen J, Raqib S, and Rizwan M.
Blockchain and ANFIS empowered IoMT application for privacy preserved
contact tracing in COVID-19 pandemic. Personal and Ubiquitous
Computing 2021; 1–17. 10.1007/s00779-021-01596-3.
[62] Ikiz E, Maclaren VW, Alfred E, and Sivanesan S. Impact of COVID-19 on
household waste flows, diversion and reuse: The case of multi-residential
buildings in Toronto, Canada. Resources, Conservation and Recycling 2021;
164:105111.
[63] Patrı́cio Silva AL, Prata JC, Walker TR, et al. Increased plastic pollution due
to COVID-19 pandemic: Challenges and recommendations. Chemical
Engineering Journal 2021; 405:126683.
[64] Mondal R and Satyanarayana P. Bio-Medical Waste Segregation Monitoring
in Healthcare Establishment – An Indian Scenario. LAP LAMBERT
Academic Publishing, 2018. ISBN-10: 6139941172; EAN:9786139941179.
[65] Mondal R and Satyanarayana P. A study on bio-medical waste segregation
monitoring in a tertiary care hospital at Andhra Pradesh. Asian Journal of
Management 2017; 8(1):73–77. doi:10.5958/2321-5763.2017.000117.
[66] Roy S and Chakraborty C. Panic buying situation during COVID-19 global
pandemic. Journal of Information Technology Management 2021; 13
(2):231–244. doi:10.22059/jitm.2021.80625.
[67] Chakraborty C, Roy S, Sharma S, and Tran TA. Environmental
Sustainability for Green Societies: The Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic.
Springer Nature, 2020. ISBN: 978-3-030-66489-3.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 15
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than
COVID-19 antiviral therapies
Betul Ozdemir1 and Zeliha Selamoglu2
Abstract
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic is the largest health problem
worldwide. Unfortunately, the lack of an effective and clear treatment causes it to
be a major health problem. There are currently no effective antiviral drugs or
vaccines. The symptoms and course of the disease differ individually. Symptoms
vary from asymptomatic to intensive care, even death. The individual variation of
this symptom pattern is related to viral load, individual’s current comorbid condi-
tions, age, gender, and most importantly, immune status. Considering the course
differences of the disease in all these individual, familial, and demographic dis-
tributions, it suggests that genetic and environmental factors play an important role.
There is a systemic inflammatory response in COVID-19. High levels of chemo-
kine and proinflammatory cytokines are detected in patients. Nutrition is one of the
most important factors for health. With the support of the immune system, people
can be protected from COVID-19 and make the process easy when suffering from
disease. Apart from the current treatments, some herbal and natural products are
used as adjunctive therapy. Key dietary components such as vitamins C, D, E, zinc,
selenium, nonflavonoids, flavonoids, polyphenols, and curcumin have been shown
to have immunomodulatory properties, which can help with infectious illnesses.
Most of these nutrients also have been demonstrated to be useful in the treatment of
COVID-19. The importance of such dietary elements in immunity and their parti-
cular consequences in COVID-19 patients are discussed in this review.
1
Department of Cardiology, Faculty of Medicine, Niğde Ömer Halisdemir University, Niğde, Turkey
2
Department of Medical Biology, Faculty of Medicine, Niğde Ömer Halisdemir University, Niğde,
Turkey
406 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
15.1 Introduction
The 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) or it is now referred to as the severe
acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) that origins in Wuhan
City of Hubei Province of China then is rapidly spreading the rest of the world and
causes the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) [1]. In this pandemic period,
which affects many individuals, some of the burdens on the health system should be
relieved with easy methods [2,3]. Many people with similar symptoms of fever,
cough, and shortness of breath applied to health institutions in Wuhan around
December 12, 2019 [4]. On March 11, 2020, it was announced to the whole world
that COVID-19 was a pandemic. In order to take precautions in pandemics, it is
necessary to know the origin of the pathogen, its hosts and evolution. The exact
origin of SARS-CoV-2 is still unclear. It has been determined that the genetic
structure of SARS-CoV-2 and the genetic structure of the bat SARS-like corona
virus are 96% similar. However, new coronavirus genomes have been shown in
pangolins showing 85.5%–92.4% similarity to SARS-CoV-2. In the animal king-
dom, only bats and pangolins have been found to be infected with SARS-CoV-2-
associated coronaviruses [5]. Coronaviruses have a structurally enveloped genetic
stalk containing a positive single-stranded RNA [6]. Coronaviruses are divided into
four subfamilies: alpha-, beta-, gamma-, and delta-coronaviruses. SARS-CoV-2 is a
member of the beta-coronavirus family. Its anatomy has been recognized as spike
(S) protein, membranes (M) protein, and envelope (E) protein. The S protein atta-
ches to the cell and allows the parasite to infiltrate the host. The N protein, which is
a member of the helix nucleocapsid holding genomic RNA, is just another element
of beta-coronavirus [7]. SARS-CoV-2 transmission is known to occur through
respiratory droplets and contact pathways. Transmission occurs through droplets
from all mucous membranes such as the mouth, nose, and eyes. Contact with sur-
faces around an infected person causes indirect transmission. Transmission may
also occur during the presymptomatic incubation period [8]. Follow-up of contacts
is as important for infection control as the diagnosis of infection [9]. After an
incubation period of approximately 5.2 days appear the symptoms of COVID-
19 infection. The period from the beginning with an average of 14 days is expected
for COVID-19 symptoms, and also the patient’s immune system response and
average of the age of the patient effect on that period are observed. It causes
contamination in asymptomatic patients [10]. It has been shown that symptoms
generally emerge on the 4th and 5th days after contact [11]. The most common
symptoms are fever, cough, fatigue, and shortness of breath. The diagnostic
approaches for corona virus diagnosis are basic molecular experiments on respira-
tory samples (esophagus swab/nasopharyngeal swab/saliva/bronchoalveolar lavage
and endotracheal extracts). SARS-CoV-2 RNA, determined by reverse transcription
polymerase chain reaction, is collected from the nasopharyngeal swab widely.
Apart from the nasopharyngeal swab, virus particles are also detected in the stool
and blood. Other laboratory examinations are not specific to the virus and indicate
infection. In the measurements made, the white-cell count is normal or low. The
platelet count in the whole blood test is usually normal. C-reactive protein (CRP) is
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than COVID-19 407
elevated due to inflammation. Procalcitonin levels are normal and elevated, which
should suggest a bacterial coinfection. Elevated prothrombin time, creatinine, and
D-dimer levels indicate the severity of the disease. Chest CT scan presented as an
indicator for pneumonia is important clinical assay. SARS-CoV-19 virus pre-
dominantly affects the pulmonary system. First, cells in the respiratory system are
infected by SARS-CoV-19 and cause inflammation and are observed with some
clinical symptom. In pulmonary involvement, a diffuse ground glass appearance
is seen on chest tomography. However, the mechanism of the infection pathway is
not clear. Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) receptor for entry into the
cells that are abundant in the lower respiratory tract. Importantly, in the brain,
heart, intestinal epithelium, vascular endothelium, and the kidneys is expressed
ACE2 that makes potential targets capacity for all these organs. In addition, other
organ involvement, septic shock, and metabolic acidosis may occur [12].
According to the pathological findings of autopsies and biopsies restriction, in
addition to the lung SARS-CoV-19 can inter numerous tissues and organs, as the
liver, spleen, heart, brain and kidney [13].
COVID-19 [19]. COVID-19 tries to destroy the respiratory tract and begins to
grow quickly in the early stages of infection, though many patients remain
asymptomatic [20–22]. Monocytes and macrophages show the first response. Viral
replication continues. Vasodilation, endothelial permeability, and leukocyte
aggregation are all caused by tissue injury and chronic inflammation. The chronic
inflammation in some individuals continues to escalate, leading in systemic
inflammation. Several distal organs can be harmed by systemic problems. COVID-
19 infection causes cytokine storm and multiple organ damage. The occurrence of
cytokine storm is associated with age and gender. In the cytokine storm, proin-
flammatory cytokines are released uncontrollably and their amounts increase.
Excessive cytokine release that occurs causes acute respiratory distress syndrome
(ARDS) development in the lungs [23]. When the virus enters macrophages and
dendritic cells, it leads to the activation of immunity [24]. It causes cytokine release
after CD4þ T cells. Uncontrolled release of cytokines and mediators causes cyto-
kine storm syndrome. The exact mechanism of this syndrome against viral infec-
tions is still unknown [25]. Acute lung injury is the result of cytokine storm
syndrome. This is seen in patients with SARS-CoV-2 infection, lung disease that
can lead to widespread lung damage, inflammation, and ultimately death. High
amounts of proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines have been found in the
plasma of patients infected with SARS-CoV-2. It has been found that patients with
critical illness have higher cytokine concentrations in their plasma [12]. Interleukin
6 (IL-6) plays an important role in cytokine storm syndrome. It has both anti-
inflammatory and proinflammatory effects. IL-6 levels have been shown to be
associated with the severity of the disease [26]. Whether SARS-CoV-2 releases
immunity, and if so, which antibody titers are protective is still a matter of debate. It
has been observed that infected patients develop antibody titers 10–15 days after
symptom onset. More research is needed to see if antibody titers can predict whe-
ther or not a person will recover first from condition.
present in plants show that extensive research is required for drug production.
Naturally, occurring antiviral compounds with least toxicity have been found to be
the best choice against coronaviruses. Many bioactive compounds are produced as
secondary metabolites in plants. The most useful classification of phenolics in two
major companies, flavonoids and non-flavonoid polyphenols, is shown in
Table 15.1. There are over 6,000 different flavonoids that have been identified, and
this number continues to increase. Flavonoids, a large group of phenolic com-
pounds, are found in many fruits and vegetables, giving color and flavor to the
foods they are found in. The antioxidant effects of flavonoids are for having three
properties. Metal chelating capability, which is significantly influenced by the
configuration of hydroxyl and carbonyl groups surrounding the molecule, the
availability of hydrogen that is capable of reducing free radicals, and the flavo-
noid’s capacity to delocalize the unpaired electron precursors are all important
factors. Flavonoids show their antioxidant effects by chain-breaking reactions. Due
to the synergistic effects with other products in plants, instead of taking phenolic
compounds as supplements, taking them naturally into foods makes their anti-
oxidant effects stronger. Recently, antioxidants have gained importance due to their
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than COVID-19 411
role in free radical scavenging to stop the process of oxidation. Nowadays, natural
antioxidants importance in human health and nutrition is increased by researching
of antioxidants. The Mother Nature’s defender can boost up the immune system,
lower cholesterol and blood pressure level, many benefits from a compound that
comes from many fruits and vegetables. Polyphenolic compounds such as flavo-
noids have been used since ancient times for their positive effects on health, even
before modern medicine was developed. The phenolics are fascinating biologically
active compounds that have exhibited great promise in both the inhibition and
treatment of many human ailments. Plants create these chemicals in responses to
damage or infection by microbial or fungal pathogens. It has antioxidant, anti-
inflammatory, antitumor, antimicrobial effects. Biologically, active compounds act
by targeting specific sites in cells. It has direct effects on proteins, receptors, and
enzymes. They affect the inhibition or activation of enzymes. They provide a
modification of proteins. Phenolic compounds are attached to peptides and proteins
by hydrogen bonding. As a group effect, it is valuable for human health due to their
antioxidation, anti-inflammation, modulation of signal transduction, anti-microbial
activity, and anti-proliferation activities. Use of phytochemicals as antiviral agents
provides a hope against proliferation of SARS-CoV-2.
15.4.1.1 Resveratrol
Polyphenols, nonflavonoids, and flavonoids are abundant in red wine, grapes,
berries, and nuts. These compounds have been shown to have antioxidant,
antitumor, and antiviral effects in the organism [29]. Resveratrol (RESV) is a
nonflavonoid compound and has anti-inflammatory properties [30]. Besides its
anti-inflammatory effect, RESV contributes to antiviral and cellular survival.
RESV has been shown to disrupt the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein and to inhibit
ACE2 receptor binding [31]. Despite these effects, many studies are needed for
effective dosage and safe use.
15.4.1.2 Celastrol
Celastrol has been shown to have anti-inflammatory effects in lung diseases by
suppressing NF-kB signaling [32]. It has also been shown to have curative effects
in lung diseases by increasing antioxidant defenses by decreasing levels of IL-8,
TNFa, and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 [33]. It has been shown to control
ARDS by reducing proinflammatory cytokines and NF-kB activation [34].
Celastrol has been shown to decrease S protein proliferation and cell viral entry
[35].
15.4.1.3 Curcumin
Curcumin is a phenolic acid that is found in turmeric. Curcumin possesses anti-
inflammatory and immunomodulatory properties, analogous to many other plant
phenolic acids [36]. Curcumin protects the cell entrance by binding to the SARS-
CoV-2 virus’s S protein and the ACE2 receptors protein’s viral binding ability [37].
It is known that curcumin’s antithrombotic, anti-cytokine, and antifibrotic proper-
ties can be used in COVID-19 patients [38]. Despite the known effects of curcumin,
412 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
more studies are needed because the safety dose in COVID-19 patients is
not known.
15.4.1.4 Quercetin
Quercetin may be found in abundance in fruits like apples and citrus, as well as
vegetables like onion, broccoli, and tomato. Quercetin functions as an antioxidant
that protects bodily tissues from oxidative stress and boosts cell survival rates [39].
Quercetin has high anti-inflammatory activity. It does this by inhibiting the
cyclooxygenase enzyme and by inhibiting prostaglandin synthesis [40]. Quercetin
decreases viral replication, resulting in decreased viral load.
15.4.2 Melatonin
Melatonin, a pineal gland hormone, has anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory
effects. Melatonin modulates cytokine release by affecting T and B cells with mel-
atonin receptors [53]. One reason for the severe course of COVID-19 in the elderly
population may be associated with low melatonin levels [54]. An amount of 2 mg of
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than COVID-19 413
15.4.3 Zinc
The trace mineral zinc plays an important role in the inflammatory process.
Proinflammatory cytokines increase in zinc deficiency. In zinc deficiency, proin-
flammatory cytokines sensitivity increases in lung epithelial tissues; in addition,
cell-barrier functions are impaired. This is why zinc is an essential element in
COVID-19 infection [55]. Zinc increases the amount of IL-2, an anti-inflammatory
cytokine. In addition, it inhibits the proliferation of coronavirus [56].
15.4.5 Vitamin D
Vitamin D is a steroid hormone precursor that is fat-soluble. Vitamin D deficiency
is a common health problem, and there are many factors that cause it. In the
COVID-19 pandemic, vitamin D deficiency was frequently observed in severely ill
patients, suggesting the importance of vitamin D supplementation [10]. Vitamin D
enhances cellular immunity by increasing the expression of antimicrobial peptides.
Vitamin D is known to increase intercellular connections, thereby reducing pul-
monary edema caused by viruses [62]. Vitamin D regulates the immune response
by modulating the release of proinflammatory cytokines while increasing the
release of anti-inflammatory cytokines [63]. Although this has been claimed that
vitamin D insufficiency enhances the incidence and severity of COVID-19 infes-
tation, there has been no definitive research to support this theory. Vitamin D intake
is indicated to increase immunity versus COVID-19 and prevent human fatalities,
according to the theory. Vitamin D deficiency is considered to help defend the
414 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
15.4.6 Vitamin E
Vitamin E is the main component of antioxidant defense. Vitamin E aids immune
regulation by regulating immune cells and increasing IL-2 cytokine secretion
through its antioxidant effect [68]. In the studies, the protective effect of vitamin E
from respiratory tract infections was mentioned. Both immunomodulator and
antioxidant effects are important for COVID-19 so vitamin E is one of the essential
vitamins for adjunctive therapies.
15.4.7 Selenium
Selenium (Se) is a vital micronutrient for public health. Se deficiency is a common
health condition worldwide. Se viral infections are known to be the determinant of
the response. Although Se levels are high in seafood, for most foods, the Se content
depends on the Se level in the soil. The trace element selenium is the main com-
ponents of the antioxidant defense. Studies have shown that the immune response
changes in Se deficiency. A study conducted in China found that the change in Se
levels changed the rate of recovery from COVID-19 [69]. It is important to prevent
cytokine storm, which is one of the most important causes of mortality in COVID-
19 patients; therefore elements with high antioxidant and immunomodulatory
effects such as Se are important [70].
References
[1] Wang D., Hu B., Hu C., et al. ‘Clinical characteristics of 138 hospitalized
patients with 2019 novel coronavirus-infected pneumonia in Wuhan, China’.
JAMA. 2020;323(11):1061–9.
[2] Muhammad L.J., Algehyne E.A., Usman S.S., Ahmad A., Chakraborty C.
and Mohammed I.A. ‘Supervised machine learning models for prediction of
COVID-19 infection using epidemiology dataset’. SN Computer Science.
2021;2(11):1–13, 2.
[3] Chakraborty C., Gupta B. and Ghosh S.K. ‘Mobile metadata assisted com-
munity database of chronic wound images’. Wound Medicine. 2014;6:34–42.
416 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[4] Zhu N., Zhang D., Wang W., et al. China Novel Coronavirus Investigating
and Research Team. ‘A novel coronavirus from patients with pneumonia in
China, 2019’. New England Journal of Medicine. 2020;382(8):727–33.
[5] Zheng J. ‘SARS-CoV-2: An emerging coronavirus that causes a global
threat’. International Journal of Biological Sciences. 2020;16(10):1678–85.
[6] Velavan T.P. and Meyer C.G. ‘The COVID-19 epidemic’. Tropical
Medicine & International Health. 2020;25(3):278–80.
[7] Masters P.S. ‘The molecular biology of coronaviruses’. Advances in Virus
Research. 2006;66:193–292.
[8] Arons M.M., Hatfield K.M., Reddy S.C., et al.; Public Health–Seattle and
King County and CDC COVID-19 Investigation Team. ‘Presymptomatic
SARS-CoV-2 infections and transmission in a skilled nursing facility’. The
New England Journal of Medicine. 2020;382(22):2081–90.
[9] Garg L., Chukwu E., Nasser N., Chakraborty C. and Garg G. ‘Anonymity
preserving IoT-based COVID-19 and other infectious disease contact tracing
model’. IEEE Access. 2020;8:159402–14.
[10] Pan X., Chen D., Xia Y., et al. ‘Asymptomatic cases in a family cluster with
SARS-CoV-2 infection’. The Lancet. Infectious Diseases. 2020;20(4):410–1.
[11] Guan W.J., Ni Z.Y., Hu Y., et al.; China Medical Treatment Expert Group
for Covid-19. ‘Clinical characteristics of coronavirus disease 2019 in China’.
The New England Journal of Medicine. 2020;382(18):1708–20.
[12] Huang C., Wang Y., Li X., et al. ‘Clinical features of patients infected with
2019 novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China’. The Lancet. 2020;395
(10223):497–506.
[13] Xu Z., Shi L., Wang Y., et al. ‘Pathological findings of COVID-19 asso-
ciated with acute respiratory distress syndrome’. The Lancet. Respiratory
Medicine. 2020;8(4):420–2.
[14] Zhou P., Yang X.L., Wang X.G., et al. ‘A pneumonia outbreak associated
with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin’. Nature. 2020;579
(7798):270–3.
[15] Hamming I., Timens W., Bulthuis M.L., Lely A.T., Navis G. and van Goor
H. ‘Tissue distribution of ACE2 protein, the functional receptor for SARS
coronavirus. A first step in understanding SARS pathogenesis’. The Journal
of Pathology. 2004;203(2):631–7.
[16] Shereen M.A., Khan S., Kazmi A., Bashir N. and Siddique R. ‘COVID-
19 infection: Origin, transmission, and characteristics of human cor-
onaviruses’. Journal of Advanced Research. 2020;24:91–8.
[17] Li X., Geng M., Peng Y., Meng L. and Lu S. ‘Molecular immune patho-
genesis and diagnosis of COVID-19’. Journal of Pharmaceutical Analysis.
2020;10(2):102–8.
[18] Imai Y., Kuba K., Rao S., et al. ‘Angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 protects
from severe acute lung failure’. Nature. 2005;436(7047):112–6.
[19] Wang M., Hao H., Leeper N.J. and Zhu L.; Early Career Committee.
‘Thrombotic regulation from the endothelial cell perspectives’. Arteriosclerosis,
Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology. 2018;38(6):e90–5.
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than COVID-19 417
[20] Bhuyan H.K., Chakraborty C., Shelke Y. and Pani S.K. ‘COVID-19 diag-
nosis system by deep learning approaches’. Expert Systems. 2021: e12776.
https://doi.org/10.1111/exsy.12776.
[21] Dash S., Chakraborty C., Giri S.K., Pani S.K. and Frnda J. ‘BIFM: Big-data
driven intelligent forecasting model for COVID-19’. IEEE Access. 2021:1–
13. 10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3094658.
[22] Aslam B., Javed A.R., Chakraborty C., Nebhen J., Raqib S. and Rizwan M.
‘Blockchain and ANFIS empowered IoMT application for privacy preserved
contact tracing in COVID-19 pandemic’. Personal and Ubiquitous
Computing. 2021:1–17. 10.1007/s00779-021-01596-3.
[23] Coperchini F., Chiovato L., Croce L., Magri F. and Rotondi M. ‘The cyto-
kine storm in COVID-19: An overview of the involvement of the chemo-
kine/chemokine-receptor system’. Cytokine & Growth Factor Reviews.
2020;53:25–32.
[24] Li G., Fan Y., Lai Y., et al. ‘Coronavirus infections and immune responses’.
Journal of Medical Virology. 2020;92(4):424–32.
[25] Tisoncik J.R., Korth M.J., Simmons C.P., Farrar J., Martin T.R. and Katze
M.G. ‘Into the eye of the cytokine storm’. Microbiology and Molecular
Biology Reviews. 2012;76(1):16–32.
[26] Coomes E.A. and Haghbayan H. ‘Interleukin-6 in Covid-19: A systematic
review and meta-analysis’. Reviews in Medical Virology. 2020;30(6):1–9.
[27] Ragab D., Salah Eldin H., Taeimah M., Khattab R. and Salem R. ‘The
COVID-19 cytokine storm; what we know so far’. Frontiers in Immunology.
2020;11:1446.
[28] Chakraborty C. and Abougreen A.N. ‘Intelligent Internet of Things and
advanced machine learning techniques for COVID-19’. EAI Endorsed
Transactions on Pervasive Health and Technology. 2021:1–14.
[29] Bravo L. ‘Polyphenols: Chemistry, dietary sources, metabolism, and nutri-
tional significance’. Nutrition Reviews. 1998;56(11):317–33.
[30] Gao Y., Fu R., Wang J., Yang X., Wen L. and Feng J. ‘Resveratrol mitigates
the oxidative stress mediated by hypoxic-ischemic brain injury in neonatal
rats via Nrf2/HO-1 pathway’. Pharmaceutical Biology. 2018;56(1):440–9.
[31] Wahedi H.M., Ahmad S. and Abbasi S.W. ‘Stilbene-based natural com-
pounds as promising drug candidates against COVID-19’. Journal of
Biomolecular Structure & Dynamics. 2021;39(9):3225–34.
[32] Habtemariam S., Nabavi S.F., Berindan-Neagoe I., et al. ‘Should we try the
antiinflammatory natural product, celastrol, for COVID-19?’. Phytotherapy
Research. 2020;34(6):1189–90.
[33] Shi K., Chen X., Xie B., et al. ‘Celastrol alleviates chronic obstructive pul-
monary disease by inhibiting cellular inflammation induced by cigarette
smoke via the Ednrb/Kng1 signaling pathway’. Frontiers in Pharmacology.
2018;9:1276.
[34] Wei Y. and Wang Y. ‘Celastrol attenuates impairments associated with
lipopolysaccharide-induced acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) in
rats’. Journal of Immunotoxicology. 2017;14(1):228–34.
418 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
[35] Iwata-Yoshikawa N., Okamura T., Shimizu Y., Hasegawa H., Takeda M.
and Nagata N. ‘TMPRSS2 contributes to virus spread and immunopathology
in the airways of murine models after coronavirus infection’. Journal of
Virology. 2019;93(6):e01815–8.
[36] Aggarwal B.B., Gupta S.C. and Sung B. ‘Curcumin: An orally bioavailable
blocker of TNF and other pro-inflammatory biomarkers’. British Journal of
Pharmacology. 2013;169(8):1672–92.
[37] Das S., Sarmah S., Lyndem S. and Singha Roy A. ‘An investigation into the
identification of potential inhibitors of SARS-CoV-2 main protease using
molecular docking study’. Journal of Biomolecular Structure & Dynamics.
2021;39(9):3347–57.
[38] Lelli D., Sahebkar A., Johnston T.P. and Pedone C. ‘Curcumin use in pul-
monary diseases: State of the art and future perspectives’. Pharmacological
Research. 2017;115:133–48.
[39] Xu D., Hu M.J., Wang Y.Q. and Cui Y.L. ‘Antioxidant activities of quercetin
and its complexes for medicinal application’. Molecules. 2019;24(6):1123.
[40] Jan A.T., Kamli M.R., Murtaza I., Singh J.B., Ali A. and Haq Q.M.R.
‘Dietary flavonoid quercetin and associated health benefits – An overview’.
Food Reviews International. 2010;26(3):302–17.
[41] Pasupuleti V.R., Sammugam L., Ramesh N. and Gan S.H. ‘Honey, propolis,
and royal jelly: A comprehensive review of their biological actions and
health benefits’. Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity. 2017;2017:
1259510.
[42] Banskota A.H., Tezuka Y. and Kadota S. ‘Recent progress in pharmacolo-
gical research of propolis’. Phytotherapy Research. 2001;15(7):561–71.
[43] Burdock G.A. ‘Review of the biological properties and toxicity of bee pro-
polis (propolis)’. Food and Chemical Toxicology. 1998;36(4):347–63.
[44] Sforcin J.M. ‘Biological properties and therapeutic applications of propolis’.
Phytotherapy Research. 2016;30(6):894–905.
[45] Mărghitas L.A., Stanciu O.G., Dezmirean D.S., et al. ‘In vitro antioxidant
capacity of honeybee-collected pollen of selected floral origin harvested
from Romania’. Food Chemistry. 2009;115(3):878–83.
[46] Talas Z.S., Ozdemir I., Ciftci O., Cakir O., Gulhan M.F. and Pasaoglu O.M.
‘Role of propolis on biochemical parameters in kidney and heart tissues
against L-NAME induced oxidative injury in rats’. Clinical and
Experimental Hypertension. 2014;36(7):492–6.
[47] Selamoglu Z.S., Ozdemir I., Ciftci O., Gulhan M.F. and Savci A.
‘Antioxidant effect of ethanolic extract of propolis in liver of L-NAME
treated rats’. Advances in Clinical and Experimental Medicine. 2015;24
(2):227–32.
[48] Babu P.V. and Liu D. ‘Green tea catechins and cardiovascular health: An
update’. Current Medicinal Chemistry. 2008;15(18):1840–50.
[49] Eckerson H.W., Wyte C.M., and La Du B.N. ‘The human serum para-
oxonase/arylesterase polymorphism’. American Journal of Human Genetics.
1983;35(6):1126–38.
Natural adjunctive therapies options other than COVID-19 419
[50] Zheng J.P., Zhang Y., Edvinsson L., Hjalt T. and Xu C.B. ‘NF-kappaB
signaling mediates vascular smooth muscle endothelin type B receptor
expression in resistance arteries’. European Journal of Pharmacology.
2010;637(1–3):148–54.
[51] Simão S., Gomes P., Pinto V., et al. ‘Age-related changes in renal expression
of oxidant and antioxidant enzymes and oxidative stress markers in male
SHR and WKY rats’. Experimental Gerontology. 2011;46(6):468–74.
[52] Xu J., Fan G., Chen S., Wu Y., Xu X.M. and Hsu C.Y.
‘Methylprednisolone inhibition of TNF-alpha expression and NF-kB acti-
vation after spinal cord injury in rats’. Brain Research. Molecular Brain
Research. 1998;59(2):135–42.
[53] Srinivasan V., Maestroni G.J., Cardinali D.P., Esquifino A.I., Perumal S.R.
and Miller S.C. ‘Melatonin, immune function and aging’. Immunity &
Ageing. 2005;2:17.
[54] Gunn P.J., Middleton B., Davies S.K., Revell V.L. and Skene D.J. ‘Sex
differences in the circadian profiles of melatonin and cortisol in plasma and
urine matrices under constant routine conditions’. Chronobiology
International. 2016;33(1):39–50.
[55] Skalny A.V., Rink L., Ajsuvakova O.P., et al. ‘Zinc and respiratory tract
infections: Perspectives for COVID-19 (Review)’. International Journal of
Molecular Medicine. 2020;46(1):17–26.
[56] te Velthuis A.J., van den Worm S.H., Sims A.C., et al. ‘Zn(2þ) inhibits
coronavirus and arterivirus RNA polymerase activity in vitro and zinc
ionophores block the replication of these viruses in cell culture’. PLoS
Pathogens. 2010;6(11):e1001176.
[57] Johnston C.S., Barkyoumb G.M. and Schumacher S.S. ‘Vitamin C supple-
mentation slightly improves physical activity levels and reduces cold inci-
dence in men with marginal vitamin C status: A randomized controlled trial’.
Nutrients. 2014;6(7):2572–83.
[58] Jafarnejad S., Boccardi V., Hosseini B., Taghizadeh M. and Hamedifard Z.
‘A meta-analysis of randomized control trials: The impact of vitamin C
supplementation on serum CRP and serum hs-CRP concentrations’. Current
Pharmaceutical Design. 2018;24(30):3520–8.
[59] Hiedra R., Lo K.B., Elbashabsheh M., et al. ‘The use of IV vitamin C for
patients with COVID-19: A case series’. Expert Review of Anti-Infective
Therapy. 2020;18(12):1259–61.
[60] Zhou L. and Xu H. ‘A Clinical Study for the Efficacy and Safety of
Adalimumab Injection in the Treatment of Patients With Severe Novel
Coronavirus Pneumonia (COVID-19)’. 2020. http://www.chictr.org.cn/
showprojen.aspx?proj¼49889.
[61] Hoang B.X., Shaw G., Fang W. and Han B. ‘Possible application of high-
dose vitamin C in the prevention and therapy of coronavirus infection’.
Journal of Global Antimicrobial Resistance. 2020;23:256–62.
[62] Gorman S., Buckley A.G., Ling K.M., et al. ‘Vitamin D supplementation of
initially vitamin D-deficient mice diminishes lung inflammation with limited
420 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Abstract
COVID-19 has brought tremendous changes in everyone’s lifestyle. It also brought
awareness among us on how analysis and prediction of situations play a crucial
role. These kinds of situations and risk assessments are considered critical factors in
reducing the seriousness of the situations. Due to a lack of risk assessment, proper
preventive measures cannot be taken. Generally, if an epidemic occurs throughout
the world and shows its impact on more people, it is declared a pandemic. In a
pandemic situation, the greatest weapon one can use to fight against it is risk
assessment and taking measures. The word risk assessment refers to the procedure
of identifying, evaluating the factors that cause harm to the environment, and living
beings. It also involves making decisions on how to put an end to it. For example, if
we consider COVID-19 pandemic, to manage the risk of spreading, analysis was
done on understanding the situations that increase the risk of transmission of the
virus, identifying the majorly affected people in that situation, coming up with
some solution to stop this from happening or to control the situation. In COVID-19,
the government provided many practical measures such as wearing masks, sani-
tizing our surroundings repeatedly, and maintaining a physical distance. This book
chapter will have clear discussions on the steps taken to assess the risk and stop the
spread of pandemics like COVID-19. We believe that prevention is always better
than cure. The chapter presents an analysis of prevention using prediction techni-
ques. Using sentiment analysis in machine learning, weighted density ensembles,
forecasting models, and risk assessment can be done. Further, a bot named
SAUCHA is proposed for automatic sanitization.
1
Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering, Sreenidhi Institute of Science and
Technology, Hyderabad, India
2
School of Computer Science and Engineering (SCOPE), VIT, Vellore, India
3
Department of Mechanical Engineering, CVR College of Engineering, Hyderabad, India
422 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
16.1 Introduction
The novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak rapidly spread world-
wide, causing a public health crisis globally [1]. Risk assessment consists of two
words: risk and assessment. Risk can be defined as a situation in which the chance
of people being harmed due to any hazard is high. Assessment refers to the analysis
of factors that can cause harm. The magnitude of the increase in confirmed cases in
an influenza pandemic is a proxy for epidemic size and disease transmissibility [2].
This complete process will help us to identify the problem, understand, and analyze
the reasons and the risks associated with it. Risk analysis includes two major steps.
They are risk evaluation and risk control. Whenever there is an occurrence of any
situation that has a negative impact on the health of the people this risk assessment
is used. This book chapter will discuss the steps taken to assess the risk of COVID-
19 and its spread [3].
Coronavirus belongs to the family of viruses that is capable of causing common
cold to severe health issues. The first case of coronavirus was found in the month of
December. In the month of February, many countries were affected by this making it
an issue of international concern. The name COVID-19 was issued to the coronavirus
disease on the February 11, 2020 by the World Health Organization. It is declared as
a pandemic in the month of March. The word pandemic in medical terminology can
be defined as the condition in which there is a rapid spread of a disease throughout
the world, affecting millions of people. This data shows us how rapid the spread of
the virus was.
Assessing the risk associated with COVID-19 WHO issued few guidelines to
all the countries like maintaining 1-m distance from each other, wearing masks, and
sanitizing regularly. Countries also issued guidelines for lockdown to stop the
transmission and to break the chain of virus. COVID-19, in our opinion, has
become a pandemic, with small chains of transmission in many countries and large
chains resulting in widespread infection in a few countries such as Italy, Iran, South
Korea, and Japan [3]. The findings revealed that controlling infectious disease
transmission is the primary concern in pandemic disease [4]. This chapter gives
information about various methods used for risk assessment and different strategies
for the management of epidemics.
the requirement for the early disclosure of new EVD cases and immediate treatment,
colleagues passed information to empower a smooth and fast information stream [7].
A successful regulation of external ventricular drain (EVD) depends on a metho-
dology that includes different intercessions: case the board, observation and contact
following, correspondence, and social assembly. In addition, the utilization of active
surveillance, comprising close management and collection of vital signs and critical
clinical indications, is essential to the strong restraint of EVD.
Gene Xpert was initially designed to detect tuberculosis cases but has since
been modified to allow rapid testing of various pathogens, including HIV, malaria,
STIs, and Ebola. It is one of the technologies used to detect Ebola in the DRC. For
example, technicians at the INRB laboratory in Kinshasa can use Gene Xpert to test
for the Zaire strain of Ebola in just 1 h, with the help of USAID, WHO, Canada, the
Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network, and the Emerging and Dangerous
Pathogens Laboratory Network. If a sample is found to be negative, it is tested
again to see if it contains any other Ebola strains, other viral hemorrhagic fevers, or
other diseases [8].
OraQuick is a quick diagnostic test developed in collaboration with the US
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and GOARN. In less than
30 min, OraQuick will test blood or saliva samples for Ebola [9]. Users can enter
the latest data or change the data saved on their phones using the ODK Collect
Application. When the data is finalized, it is submitted. During submission, the
location is automatically integrated with the data. The form hub technology created
forms using the same paper forms that were used to collect data [10]. Whenever
new cases are discovered, the contact tracer enters the information into a new case
on the phone then sends it directly to the form center server. If for any reason, the
phone does not have an Internet connection, the collected data is stored temporarily
on the phones. At the end of the day, when they are returned to the control center,
the phones are connected to the Internet, and stored data is affixed to the server.
The Dashboard technology mainly focuses on providing information based on
proofs to assist the management to make timely decisions. A TV is used to show the
live updates of daily contacts, the interviewers. It can also show symptomatic
contacts as well as maps displaying the location of contacts that have been traced
up in the last 2 days. One of the dashboard segments also shows lab results for
speculated and confirmed cases. The detected contacts and cases within the cities
were plotted with the help of coordinates that were recorded on the ODK forms and
then combined using ArcGIS Mapping software to display the contacts and cases in
the cities. These informed areas concentrated on social mobilization, sensitization,
and awareness generated by social mobilization teams.
COVID-19 is a global pandemic on par with World War II and the
1918 Spanish Flu. For suppressing the COVID-19 pandemic, physical distancing
and self-quarantine are required. To maintain this mandate while preserving the
current state of things, various human behaviors, such as entertainment, education,
meeting, and working, have transitioned from online to offline. This resulted in the
emergence of a variety of digital technologies. There are extensive digital tech-
nologies being used in the COVID-19 epidemic. Based on the different types of
424 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
Employers and teachers are examples of providers, whereas employees and stu-
dents are receivers in the education and work sectors. Even though they utilize
diverse types of technology in their daily lives, they all employ the same kind.
16.2.1 Healthcare
During the pandemic, medical professionals and patients with various chronic diseases
are the most frequent consumers of digital technology. On the front lines, radiologists,
surgeons, and nurses are diagnosing and treating patients. The radiologists play a critical
role in diagnosing computerized CT scan for a patient either positive or negative for
COVID-19 disease and describing primary CT characteristics and lesion distribution. In
addition, patients with various chronic conditions, particularly those who have already
been infected with the coronavirus, get services and treatment from healthcare experts
via technology during the same time. Patients with many immune suppressed or chronic
diseases, for example, will have to choose between risking iatrogenic COVID-19
exposure at the time of a doctor visit and delaying required treatments. In addition,
patients must deal with the unavoidable utilization of technology, for example, the
computerized tomography equipment, video communication platforms to acquire
advice and directions from a healthcare expert, whether they choose a direct appoint-
ment, postpone a visit, or use virtual healthcare [18]. As a result, the main groups of
technology users at COVID-19 are healthcare professionals and their patients.
16.2.2 Education
Because of COVID-19, a considerable portion of the population was forced to
study from home to comply with the quarantine obligation. The teachers quickly
adapted to online teaching and put significant effort into preparing for online
classes and engaging the students. The majority of the education sector uses video-
based communication devices and platforms. During this epidemic, students and
teachers have surpassed the general public as the second most frequent consumers
of digital technology [19].
16.2.3 Work
Work professionals have emerged as a significant segment of technology users
during the pandemic. During COVID-19, researchers, scientists, and employees
continue to work remotely using digital technologies. From the work standpoint,
regardless of the technology employed, most work professionals serve as con-
tributors and receivers. An employee, for instance, receives guidance from their
boss while also having to report their work via Zoom.
16.2.4 Others
Apart from the two primary users listed before, health authorities, government
officials, and the public all use technology. To deal with this global spread, indi-
viduals worldwide are becoming more familiar with the technology they use daily.
Public health experts and government officials, for example, employ mobile-based
monitoring technologies to follow the spread of an epidemic or big data
426 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
technologies to assess outbreaks and devise policies. At the same time, the general
population receives information via digital devices from all over the world.
3. Assessment of risks
4. Preparing report
5. Reviewing and implementing the measures
While working on risk assessment, we consider the following factors. Risks
generally include health, environment, finance, technology, safety. In general
assessment, we also use 10Ps principle. Risk assessment can be performed in two
ways: individual and group. Individual risk assessment is carried out by considering
each and every individual. This helps us to understand the risk at the root level.
This assessment majorly focuses on the psychological and ideological factors of
individuals. Most of the individuals feel there is no risk for them and their situation
is in control. This type of analysis is considered essential during pandemics. Group
risk assessment is generally performed in a group or large scale where individual’s
conditions are not given much priority. For example, risk assessment during a
cyclone comes under this category. We also name this as system risk assessment.
As we are aware, a system can be linear or nonlinear. When a system is linear,
assessment is easier. In the case of nonlinear as data changes frequently, prob-
abilistic analysis can only be possible.
In organizations, a concept called risk register is used to access the risks. This
register will store all the information related to the risks, which helps that organi-
zation monitor, analyze, and manage the risks. The fisheries science and manage-
ment practitioners at a recent time have begun to carry out formal risk management
processes for fishing activities [23]. A personal perspective and lessons learnt
through risk assessments applied to the management of numerous significant spe-
cies and ecosystems are presented. The significance of engaging and empowering
stakeholders through more intuitive risk assessment methodologies so that they can
actively comprehend and participate in the risk assessment process is one of the key
lessons gained [24]. The development of the “Risk Society,” in which governments,
communities, organizations, and individuals spend much of their day-to-day efforts
managing risk and, where possible, transferring risk to others, has been linked to
the modernization of many nations over the last century, according to prominent
sociologist Ulrich Beck [25].
The health sector’s policies and regulations are becoming increasingly risk-
based. As a result, indicators that focus on the risk to life expectancy, or the average
number of years foregone or added as a result of a proposed policy instrument, are
increasingly routinely used to evaluate health policy [26].
To understand risk assessment in detail, let us discuss the following methods:
1. What-if analysis
2. Fault-tree analysis (FTA)
undesirable event that may cause health hazards, one must be aware of its origin,
causes, and consequences and should have complete information about that aspect.
In this analysis technique, people with expertise in that particular topic will sit
together. They start with identifying the problematic situation, its effects, and
methods that can be used to tackle them. They discuss existing solutions, their
disadvantages, and the improvements that are needed. Through this thorough dis-
cussion, they discover opportunities for new methods to be successfully imple-
mented [27]. The steps that are followed by them are as follows:
1. Presenting detailed diagrams and guidelines
2. Prepare questions
3. Analysis and assessment of risk
4. Discussion
5. Summary of the major points
6. Preparation of plan of action
Limitations of this method:
1. Majorly depends on the questions that are framed.
2. Active participation of members is essential.
3. This method is considered introspective.
4. Reviewer plays a major role.
Advantages of this method:
1. Simple and easy
2. No requirement of specialized tools
errors occurring. One such analysis is the FTA [30]. FTA is an analysis tool that
helps identify faulty events and would result in damages and disasters if not cor-
rected on time [31]. It can be said that FTA is a hierarchical model defining the
topmost columns—the ones that are the most important operations, which include
various fields of production, distribution, maintenance based on the implementation
area [32]. Thus, making the FTA defined events as a set of true or false assertions,
cutting down all the undesirable conditions using the logic gates [33].
It would be a good practice to implement FTA before initiating any projects or
activities to overcome hurdles later on and can avoid great tragedies. Some of the
applications of FTA are reliable power systems [34]. Gas leaks from the industrial sites
can be halted [35]. Usage of hazardous methods in the production can be seized in its
initial stage [36]. Implementations of both Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and
FTA together bring awareness in the public about the environment and help in detecting
the areas of errors and prevent it from happening, ensuring a secure environment [8].
To represent these logics in FTA symbols like basic event, external event,
undeveloped event, conditioning event, intermediate event, let us have a brief
discussion on the steps included in FTA:
1. Identification of undesired event
2. Understanding the working of system
3. Designing the fault tree
4. Analyzing the fault tree
5. Assessing the risks
Advantages of FTA:
1. It is suitable for computer programs.
2. Capable of finding faults in different paths.
3. Effective in analyzing the reasons for faults.
Let us also discuss the guidelines that are issued by the World Health
Organization to control this situation.
analysis, management becomes very easy as we can understand and analyze the
situation very easily. Management completely concentrates on stopping the spread of
virus and reducing the number of people affected by it. Epidemic preparedness is very
crucial in this regard. Another crucial factor to be considered is the management of
epidemics that comprises combination of various sectors like public and health. Active
involvement and response from all the sectors are also important. Coordination and
cooperation between various sectors is crucial in effective management.
The causes of epidemics may be different but most of the effects are almost
similar. Even during this COVID-19, one of the countries was able to effectively
manage the situation. As a result, the rate of transmission and number of corona
deaths were very low when compared to all other countries. The reason behind this
is that particular already faced this kind of situation which helped them in pre-
dicting and taking measures as per the requirement.
Various strategies are employed for the effective management of epidemics.
Let us explore them.
This method will help us in fighting effectively with the coronavirus. Using this
analysis, public statement can be analyzed and we can take measures according
to that to strengthen them. In this analysis process, first social media platforms
are tracked. Then data is collected through them. Once the collection of data is
processed, data analysis is performed to analyze the sentiments behind the
statements.
The epidemics have different kinds of impacts on various fields. In the case of
COVID-19 pandemic, it affected the lives of teachers, students, migration workers
and laborers. It has a negative impact on each and every field. It has affected the
economy very badly. Apart from these things, people’s mental health is also getting
disturbed as they are restricted to their houses. In terms of economy every family is
facing problems as they are unable to get their salaries on time, prices of essential
commodities and vegetables increased suddenly. Most of the people are suffering
from food scarcity.
The impacts of COVID-19 are much more when compared to the two world
wars. In the two world wars only few countries participated but almost all the
countries were affected due to this COVID-19. In Italy and the United States, the
numbers of deaths due to coronavirus were very high. Let us discuss the impacts on
each field in a detailed manner.
The major problem to everyone after the COVID-19 is fear of bacteria, germs, and
viruses. The extreme places for germs, bacteria, and virus are through the floor.
Even though in the major places like hospitals and malls they clean regularly, there
will be germs and bacteria on the floor itself as there will be many different people
visiting there. Some of them become airborne and spread. So, when they touch our
feet or shoes and when we kick up that can spread to the air we breathe and can
cause illness to us.
be germs and bacteria on the floor itself as there will be many different people
visiting there.
UVC radiation is a known disinfectant for air, water, and nonporous surfaces.
This radiation has effectively been used for decades to reduce the spread of bac-
teria, such as tuberculosis. For this reason, UVC lamps are often called “germici-
dal” lamps. This UVC LED plays a vital role in killing the germs and bacteria on
the surfaces. Nowadays, people show a great interest toward technology and every
human-made things can be achieved through technology. So a robot controlled
through Bluetooth will have a great impact on attracting the people as well as its
very convenient to the user.
As we know that even after COVID-19 sanitization plays a vital role, most of
the people think about it, so this UVC sanitization had an effective sanitization and
helps in killing germs and bacteria, and an autonomous hand sanitizer is also very
important to avoid common contact, which helps in preventing the spread of
the virus.
15. L-clamps
16. Jumper wires
These components are connected together for the implementation of SAUCHA
as shown in Figure 16.2.
To verify the simulation results in the bot, the interfacing of the components in
Proteus software is connected as shown in Figure 16.4.
The bot LCD is connected to Arduino. LCD is used for displaying the
instructions and information. An ultrasonic sensor is used to measure the distance
between the person and the bot. UV-LED is used to disinfect the person. A motor
driver is used to control the motors and the wheels are used for the movement of the
bot. The servomotor is used for flipping UVC LEDs, and a servomotor is also used
in a sanitizer dispenser. An IR sensor is used for obstacle detection during the
movement of our bot. Relay is used for controlling the circuit. Arduino IDE is used
for writing and uploading the code in to the board. Proteus is the software used for
the simulation of our circuit. When a person is detected, the ultrasonic sensor
detects and drives the motor to rotate the sanitizer dispenser that will open and it
will sanitize the person. Bluetooth module that is connected to Arduino can be used
to transfer data which can be an add-on feature for future scope to access the data
from bot.
References
[1] Wu Z and McGoogan JM. Characteristics of and important lessons from the
corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) outbreak in China: Summary of a
report of 72314 cases from the Chinese center for disease control and pre-
vention. JAMA. 2020; 323: 1239–42 10.1001/jama.2020.2648.
[2] Chong KC, Zee BCY and Wang MH. Approximate Bayesian algorithm to
estimate the basic reproduction number in an influenza pandemic using
arrival times of imported cases. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease.
2018; 23: 80–6.
440 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
LSTM: see long short-term memory MLP: see multi-layer perceptron (MLP)
(LSTM) MobileNetV2 274
lycorine 317 motor driver 374
MQTT: see message queuing telemetry
machine-assisted designing and transport (MQTT)
evaluation of COVID-19 drug MRF model: see Markov random field
high ambiguity–driven protein– (MRF) model
protein DOCKing 313–16 mRNA: see messenger RNA (mRNA)
molecular docking program MSW: see municipal solid waste
curcumin 313 (MSW)
favipiravir 312 multi-layer perceptron (MLP) 268
montelukast 313 municipal solid waste (MSW) 386
M-pro enzyme 312
N4-QO molecule 310 Naı̈ve Bayes 71–2
natural and synthetic drugs 309 nidovirus RdRc-associated
nelfinavir 313 nucleotidyltransferase
remdesivir 312 (NiRAN) 299
molecular dynamics 316–18 NiRAN: see nidovirus RdRc-
machine learning (ML) 37, 116, 182, associated
263–4, 277–9, 331 nucleotidyltransferase
COVID-19 diagnosis 127–9 (NiRAN)
IoT-based framework 70–2 NodeMCU: see node micro controller
sentimental analysis using 433–4 unit (NodeMCU)
state-of-the-art deep learning and, node micro controller unit
comparison of 279–89 (NodeMCU) 369
management information system
(MIS) 199–200 omega-3 fatty acids 414
Markov random field (MRF) model 229 OneR: see One rule (OneR)
mathematical model 427 One rule (OneR) 72
MDH: see medical diagnosis humanoid
(MDH) PCA: see principal component analysis
medical diagnosis humanoid (MDH) 365 (PCA)
melatonin 412–13 PCR: see polymerase chain reaction
mental stress 332 (PCR)
MERS: see Middle East respiratory personal protective equipment (PPE) 386
syndrome (MERS) PNN: see probabilistic neural network
message queuing telemetry transport (PNN)
(MQTT) 365 polymerase chain reaction (PCR) 63
messenger RNA (mRNA) 297 PPE: see personal protective
microarray data analysis 233, 244–6 equipment (PPE)
Middle East respiratory syndrome principal component analysis (PCA)
(MERS) 387 39, 334, 342, 346–7
MIS: see management information probabilistic neural network (PNN)
system (MIS) 276–7
ML: see machine learning (ML) propolis 412
452 Smart health technologies for the COVID-19 pandemic
QoS: see quality of service (QoS) SARS: see severe acute respiratory
QTs: see quantitative traits (QTs) syndrome (SARS)
quality of service (QoS) 367 SARS-CoV-2: see severe acute
quantitative traits (QTs) 235 respiratory syndrome
quercetin 412 coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2)
scRNA-seq data analysis 234–5,
radial basis function (RBF) 335 239–40
radio frequency identification (RFID) SDGs: see Sustainable Development
366 Goals (SDGs)
rapid antibody testing (RAT) 262 SDN: see software development
RAT: see rapid antibody testing (RAT) network (SDN)
RBD: see receptor-binding domain selenium 414
(RBD) severe acute respiratory syndrome
RBF: see radial basis function (RBF) coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2)
real-time quantitative PCR 116, 324–5, 406
(RT-qPCR) 305 ACE2 enzyme 301
receptor-binding domain (RBD) 299 amino acids 323
recursion-based prediction COVID-19 chromosomes 298
model 427 genetic laboratory analysis reports
rehabilitation 333 297
remote-healthcare-monitoring (RHM) in human 300
120 machine-integrated advanced
ResNet 269–71 techniques
respiratory rate 125 computerized tomography 318–19
resting heart rate (RHR) 125 COVID-19 treatment, MRI for
RESV: see resveratrol (RESV) 320–2
resveratrol (RESV) 411 microscopic and 3D molecular
reverse transcription polymerase chain image of 298
reaction (RT-PCR) 262 NiRAN 299–300
RFID: see radio frequency physiopathogenesis of 407
identification (RFID) pp1ab and pp1a 299
RHM: see remote-healthcare- real-time COVID-19 identification
monitoring (RHM) test (RT-PCR)
RHR: see resting heart rate (RHR) isothermal enhancement 304
ribonucleic acid (RNA) 297 limitations of 304–5
RNA: see ribonucleic acid (RNA) nuclear chain antiques 304
RNA-seq: see RNA sequencing protein-based findings 304
(RNA-seq) ribosome 300
RNA-seq data analysis 233–4, 241–3 silico crystallographic results 301
RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) 231 silico methods
RT-PCR: see reverse transcription assisted anchoring site analysis
polymerase chain reaction 305–7
(RT-PCR) machine-assisted designing and
RT-qPCR: see real-time quantitative evaluation of COVID-19 drug
PCR (RT-qPCR) 308–18
Index 453