Cornette 2011
Cornette 2011
Cornette 2011
24
The Emotional Impact of Obesity on Children
Robert E. Cornette
Department of Nursing, Berea College, Berea, Kentucky
Global Perspectives on Childhood Obesity 257 Copyright Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
258 24. THE EMOTIONAL IMPACT OF OBESITY ON CHILDREN
mechanism in response to internal or external stressors prized as a symbol of status and prosperity. But as early
should be recognized. Although not the result of phys- as 400 BC, Hippocrates, the father of medicine, wrote of
ical influences, overeating as a coping mechanism to the association between obesity, disease, and early death
stressors could be considered as a manifestation of [9]. Early Egyptians were concerned with diet as a means
a psychological dysfunction and, in fact, treatment of maintaining health [8] but utilized extreme measures
approaches that have focused on dialectical behavioral to limit the quantity of food they digested such as
therapy rather than nutritional management have been purging, vomiting, and fasting [10].
promising [6]. Early writings regarding the stigmatization associ-
Clearly, there are some psychological disorders that ated with being obese occurred in medieval Japan.
manifest with compulsive eating (e.g., pica, anorexia Scrolls from the 12th century depict a wealthy woman
nervosa, and bulimia), but one study found that whereas who became obese. It explains that the woman could
binge-eating disorders only affect 2% to 3% of the no longer walk easily, needed assistance with her activ-
general population, they are reported in 25% or more ities of daily living, perspired profusely, and gasped for
of obese people [7]. Nevertheless, obesity remains breath [11]. The culture in Japan at the time saw this
a physical or medical condition that results from nonho- woman’s obesity as a result of her greed and selfishness
meostatic eating. Although the excessive caloric intake [12]. In Europe, even during the culture of voluptuous
may result from metabolic conditions such as Prader- women depicted in the paintings of Rubens and Renoir
Willi syndrome, a genetic disorder characterized by [13], society was being influenced by the Christian ideol-
uncontrolled, compulsive eating, more often it is the ogy that obesity was a characteristic of gluttony, which
result of the individual eating more calories than he or would eventually be categorized in the 5th century as
she expends. Possibly because obesity has been consid- one of the Seven Deadly Sins [14]. Obesity was not
ered a medical rather than a psychological condition, only seen as a moral failure but now it was a transgres-
little attention has been focused on the psychological sion against God [13].
ramifications of living as an obese individual. Often,
healthcare professionals counsel obese patients on
methods to lose weight and educate on the physical THE METAPHYSICAL CONSEQUENCES
consequences of failing to do so. Rarely, this counseling FOR OBESE CHILDREN
includes surveillance of the patient’s emotional state or
assumes that any emotional trauma from being obese For the first time in recent history, children today may
will be alleviated with weight loss. be facing a shorter life span than their parents due, in
large part, to the alarming rise in obesity [15]. Thirty
states have rates of childhood overweight (body mass
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL HISTORY index [BMI] of or greater than 85th percentile for age
OF OBESITY and gender) and obesity (BMI of or greater than 95th
percentile for age and gender) for children age 10 to 17
For most people, the issue of the rapidly rising above 30%, with one state, Mississippi, obtaining
number of overweight and obese children, adolescents, a rate of 44% [16]. Overall, one in three children (10 to
and adults is one that has just recently come into the 17 years old) is overweight or obese [17]. A national
public’s consciousness. Although the current number survey found that obese adolescents had the following
of overweight and obese people is the highest our planet risks:
has seen, it is fair to say that overweight people have
• A 60% higher risk of being diagnosed with anxiety or
existed throughout history. And though the perception
depression
of these overweight individuals may have varied
• A 40% greater risk of having feelings of worthlessness
according to the predominate culture, these views may
• A 40% greater risk of parental concerns about their
shed some insight into the origins of the development
child’s self-esteem
of current labels, stereotypes, or biases regarding the
• A 70% greater risk of being told by a healthcare
overweight and obese.
provider that they have behavioral problems
It may be impossible to determine when the first
• A 30% greater risk of being withdrawn
obese person existed in history, if he or she were a child,
• A 40% greater risk of bullying others [18]
or what emotional consequences that individual experi-
enced as a result. We do know that figurines, called the Given the increase in the rate of obesity in children, it
Venus of Willendorf, date back 30,000 years and depict could be assumed that there would be a reduction in the
an obese woman. It is uncertain if the figurines were stigmatization of obese children; yet negative views of
fertility symbols or erotic tokens [8]. Obesity in early obese children are higher now than that of four decades
history most likely rarely occurred and may have been ago [19]. Nonobese children have stated that they would
to assist them in buffering the negative effects of weight 8. Haslam D. Obesity: A medical history. Obesity Reviews 2007;8(1):
bias, increasing supportive peer and family relation- 31e6.
9. Hippocrates (400 BC). De Priscina Medicina.
ships, and providing obese children with supportive 10. Siculus (20 BC). “Bibliotheca historica.”
opportunities to participate in social and recreational 11. Komatsu S. “Gaki-zoshi Jigoku-zoshi Yamai-zoshi Kusoshi-emaki,”
activities [25, 58]. Finally, interventions should be Vol. 7 Nihon no emaki. Tokyo: Chuo koronsha; 1990.
framed in a manner that emphasizes positive behavioral pp. 102e47.
changes such as monitoring television viewing time, 12. Lafleur W. “The Karma of words: Buddhism and the Literary Arts of
Medieval Japan”. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1983.
sensible fast-food and sweets consumption, and phys- pp. 35e7.
ical activity, rather than motivating change through 13. Stunkard A, LaFleur W, Wadden T. Stigmatization of obesity in
body-image modification [80]. medieval times: Asia and Europe. International Journal of Obesity
1998;22:1141e4.
14. Schwartz H. “Never Satisfied: A cultural history of diets, fantasies and
fat”. New York: Anchor Books; 1990.
CONCLUSION 15. Olshansky S, Passaro D, Hershow R. A potential decline in Life
Expectancy in the Unites States in the 21st century. The New
Throughout the history of the human race people England Journal of Medicine 2005;352:1138e45.
have been victimized for their beliefs, their practices, 16. Trust for America’s Health, (2009). F as in fat: How obesity policies
or their appearance. Children today are faced with are failing in America. Washington, DC: Robert Wood Johnson
Foundation.
a culture that deeply values physical appearance and 17. National Survey of Children’s Health. Portland: Oregon Health
views obesity as a symptom of laziness, weakness, and & Science University. (2007).
selfishness. Thus, it is easy to fathom the emotional 18. Belue R, Francis L, Colaco B. Mental health problems and
sequela experienced by overweight and obese children overweight in a nationally representative sample of adoles-
and adolescents. While obesity is not classified as cents: Effects of race and ethnicity. Pediatrics 2009;123(2):
697e702.
a psychiatric disorder it can manifest several psycholog- 19. Latner J, Stunkard A. Getting worse: The stigmatization of obese
ical symptoms such as: anxiety; feelings of worthless- children. Obesity Research 2003;11:452e6.
ness; low self esteem; aggression; social withdrawal; 20. Staffieri J. A study of stereotype of body image in children.
depression; and even suicidal behavior. With the rapid Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1967;7:101e4.
increase in the number of obese children, it stands to 21. Goodman N, Dornbusch S, Richardson S, Hastorf A. Variant
reactions to physical disabilities. American Sociology Review
reason that we will see an increase in the number of chil- 1963;28:429e35.
dren suffering from mental health disorders. Interven- 22. Maddox G, Back K, Liederman V. Overweight as a social devi-
tions should be directed towards the psychological as ance and disability. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 1968;9:
well as the nutritional health of the child. Additionally, 287e98.
interventions should be crafted that: reduce social biases 23. Richardson S, Goodman N, Hastorf A, Dornbusch S. Cultural
uniformity in reaction to physical disabilities. American Sociolog-
towards the obese; help develop effective coping mech- ical Reviews 1961;26:241e7.
anisms for obese children; increase supportive relation- 24. Warschburger P. Unhappy obese child. International Journal of
ships; and emphasize positive lifestyle changes rather Obesity 2005;29:S127e9.
than modifying body image. 25. Neumark-Sztainer D, Falkner N, Story M, Perry C, Hannah P,
Mulert S. Weight teasing among adolescents: Correlations with
weight status and disordered eating behavior. International Jour-
References nal of Obesity 2002;26:123e31.
26. Rothblum E, Brand P, Miller C, Oetjen H. Results of the NAAFA
1. National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). survey on employment discrimination: Part II. NAAFA Newsletter
(2006). Atlanta: Center for Disease Control and Prevention. 1989;17:4e6.
2. Devlin M. Is there a place for obesity in the DSM V? International 27. Neumark-Sztainer D, Story M, Harris T. Beliefs and attitudes
Journal of Eating Disorders 2007;40:S83e8. about obesity among teachers and school health care providers
3. Saper C, Chou T, Elmquist J. The need to feed: Homeostatic and working with adolescents. Journal of Nutritional Education 1999;31:
hedonic control of eating. Neuron 2002;36:199e211. 3e9.
4. Colantuoni C, Rada P, McCarthy J, Patten C, Avena N, 28. Kimm S, Sweeney C, Janosky J, MacMillian J. Self-concept
Chadeayne A, Hoebal B. Evidence that intermittent, excessive measure and childhood obesity: A descriptive analysis. Journal of
sugar intake causes endogenous opioid dependence. Obesity Developmental Behavioral Pediatrics 1991;12:19e24.
Research 2002;10:478e88. 29. Manus H, Killeen M. Maintenance of self-esteem by obese chil-
5. Avena N, Hoebel B. A diet promoting sugar dependency causes dren. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing 1995;8:
behavioral cross sensitivity to a low dose of amphetamine. 17e24.
Neuroscience 2003;122:17e20. 30. Loeber R. Developmental and risk factors of juvenile antisocial
6. Telch C, Agras W, Linehan M. Dialectical behavioral therapy for behavior and delinquency. Clinical Psychology Reviews 1990;10:
binge eating disorder. Journal of Consulting Clinical Psychology 1e41.
2001;69:1061e5. 31. Crick N. Engagement in gender normative versus non-normative
7. Pull C. Binge Eating Disorder. Current Opinion in Psychiatry forms of aggression: Links to social psychological adjustment.
2004;17(1):43e8. Developmental Psychology 1997;33:610e17.
75. Adams GR, Hicken M, Salehi M. Socialization of the physical 78. Bell S, Morgan S. Children’s attitudes and behavioral interven-
attractiveness stereotype: Parent expectations and verbal behav- tions towards a peer presented as obese: Does a medical expla-
iors. International Journal of Psychology 1988;23:137e49. nation for the obesity make a difference? Journal of Pediatric
76. Hayden-Wade H, Stein R, Ghaderi A, Saelens B, Zabinski M, Psychology 2000;25:137e45.
Wilfrey D. Prevalence, characteristics and correlations of teasing 79. Gray W, Kahnan N, Janicke D. Peer victimization and pediatric
experiences among obese vs. non-obese peers. Obesity Research obesity: A review of literature. Psychology in the Schools 2009;46
2005;13:1381e92. (8):720e7.
77. Weiner B, Graham S. An attributional approach to emotional 80. Dolan M, Faith M. Prevention of overweight with young children
development. In: Izard CE, Kagan J, Zojonc RB, editors. and families. In: Latner J, Wilson G, editors. “Self-help approach for
“Emotions, cognitions, and behavior”. Cambridge: Cambridge obesity and eating disorders: Research and practice”. New York:
University Press; 1984. pp. 167e91. Guilford Press; 2007. pp. 265e88.