The Electric Mine Report MM AMM
The Electric Mine Report MM AMM
The Electric Mine Report MM AMM
Electric Mine
In association with:
In partnership with
Mining
solutions
for a
sustainable
future WE1850-3 hybrid wheel loader
komatsu.com/en/our-commitment/
enhancing-quality-of-life/
Swift progress has been made on electrification, with mine operators already deploying or planning to deploy a
total of 352 trucks featuring battery or hybrid technologies. But as this report will show, challenges remain – and
these are being broken down by advancements in areas such as battery capacity and on-board charging systems
along with innovations involving older technologies, such as trolley-assist systems.
This report features expert discussion on the technologies that will enable miners to achieve full electrification. It
also includes profiles on three of the world’s leading OEMs and technology providers in the field of electrification:
ABB, Epiroc, and Liebherr.
Ready to start your battery-electric transition? Join our journey towards emission-free mining.
ROCKTECHNOLOGY.SANDVIK
2023 Whitepaper
Mining companies are rightly proud of the role that minerals such as copper, nickel, zinc, lithium and cobalt are
playing in the green energy transition. But at the same time, they are finding themselves having to reckon with
their status as major contributors to greenhouse gas emissions.
Direct emissions from the mining sector, excluding methane emissions from coal mining, currently account
for 1% of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to a recent McKinsey study. Diesel-powered mobile
equipment contributes 40-50% of these emissions, while non-renewable electricity sources such as coal and
natural gas contribute an additional 30-35%.
The October 2021 pledge by the 27 members of the International Council on Mining and Metals to achieve
net-zero Scope 1 and 2 emissions by 2050 or sooner marked the point of no return in the mining sector’s
commitment to reduce emissions. Although a handful of mine operators had previously set their own targets,
this was the first time a group of majors – in this case representing about 30 percent of global mine production
– had made a joint commitment on climate change.
To achieve net-zero, miners will need to focus their attention on two key areas: transition to low-carbon power
generation based on renewables or nuclear; and electrification of all mobile equipment.
Two main technological categories have emerged as the ideal solutions for heavy mobile equipment: battery-
electric vehicles (BEVs) and hydrogen-powered fuel-cell electric vehicles (FCEVs).
BEVs are the better option for lower-weight hauling, typically below 200 tonnes, due to the limitations of
lithium-ion energy density, as Richard Horton, partner, Partners in Performance, noted in the 2023 Mining
Magazine Intelligence Future Fleets Report.
FCEVs, on the other hand, have the energy density and flexibility necessary for hauling more than 200t, and
provide similar characteristics and refuelling times to diesel engines. However, hydrogen-powered vehicles
are currently limited by far higher capital costs and infrastructure requirements than their battery-powered
counterparts, as Horton explained.
Despite the challenges, the mining sector has made rapid progress on electrification of haulage solutions in
recent years. For decades, trolley systems provided the only feasible way of electrifying haul trucks.
The first feasibility study took place at Kennecott Copper Corporation’s Chino mine in New Mexico, in 1967,
which involved a truck carrying a payload of 123 tonnes up a 400m ramp at a 7% incline, but the trolley line
was not able to sustain a high-enough voltage to justify commercial implementation.
The big breakthrough came with the Kiruna Electric Truck system, which was developed by a joint venture of
LKAB, Kiruna Truck and ASEA (now ABB) in Sweden in the early 1980s for the purpose of developing an inclined
ore-haulage system for underground mining. The first model, the 50t K1050E, went into commercial operation
at Boliden’s Zinkgruvan underground mine in 1988. By 1995, when the joint venture introduced the 35t K635E,
16 trucks were in operation at four underground mines: Zinkgruvan, Canada’s Hope Brook and Kidd Creek, and
Australia’s Mount Isa Mines.
It was only in 2013* that Canada’s RDH Mining Equipment (later acquired by Scharf OEM) delivered the first
commercialised battery-powered truck and LHD – the 20-tonne Haulmaster 800-20EB truck and the 2m3
Muckmaster 300EB – to Kirkland Lake’s Macassa underground gold mine in Ontario Canada.
By 2017, a number of OEMs were offering battery-electric trucks and/or loaders, among them Epiroc, Liebherr,
Maclean Engineering, and Artisan Vehicles. However, fewer than 10 mines had begun trialling or deploying
these machines.
Electrification began to take off on its current trajectory around 2018, when Epiroc launched its second-
generation battery fleet following more than one million operational hours of its first generation of equipment.
The ascent since then has been rapid, with year-on-year increases in the delivery of electric fleets and the
deployment of mines on every continent.
By the end of 2022, mine operators had deployed or were planning to deploy a total of 352 trucks featuring
battery or hybrid technologies. Hydrogen technology, despite lagging far behind battery-electric technology,
was being trialled by Komatsu at Anglo American’s Mogalakwena platinum mine in South Africa and was
being considered by a handful of other big players, including Ivanhoe’s flagship Kamoa-Kakula project in the
Democratic Republic of the Congo.
However, the respondents could just as easily have been referring to the cost of capital, which can be 20-
25% higher for miners with the lowest ESG scores, according to the same McKinsey study we reference
earlier. In other words, although electrification requires large upfront capital costs, the cost of not embracing
electrification could end up being higher.
“Battery development has exceeded expectations. If you had asked us five to 10 years ago, we could not have
imagined where we would be today,” said Mehrzad Ashnagaran, global product line manager - electrification
and composite plant for ABB.
Continues
*
Data compiled from Mining Magazine Intelligence 2023 Future Fleets Report and data supplied to Mining Magazine by Jake Harris, on page 11
owner of UGMiningTech.com ▼
Sustainability has emerged as the number one That sense of being all-in is the driving force behind
goal for mining equipment manufacturer Epiroc the development of Epiroc’s Rocvolt unit which
in recent years, as it has for much of the sector as coordinates the wider company’s electrification efforts.
a whole. For both the company itself and the wide It is also why Epiroc is engaged in what Samuels
range of customers who use its products every day, described as a “two track” approach to electrifying its
that commitment to sustainability means, in large products.
part, a shift to electrification.
“Because of this [short time period] what we’ve done is
The Swedish founded business has set itself some develop new equipment Scooptram ST14, Minetruck
bold, ambitious targets to deliver a greener and MT42 and drilling equipment, but at the same time we
more sustainable future through electrification. It has are converting older equipment from diesel to battery,”
pledged to offer a complete range of underground he explained.
equipment in battery-electric form by 2025, while by
2030 it intends to provide a battery-electric version of So far, this process has seen Epiroc complete
every part of its vast portfolio of mining equipment. conversion of three models: its Scooptram ST14 and
Scooptram ST1030 loaders, and its Minetruck MT42
“Yes, it’s a big task and it’s a short time period,” admitted vehicle. It is currently working on conversions on the
Shawn Samuels, business line manager for Rocvolt, Scooptram ST7 loader and Minetruck MT436. The
an electrification accelerator unit within Epiroc that benefit of converting these models to battery power
focuses to drive electrification both internally and with is not only in reduced emissions. Epiroc has found
its mining customers who are increasingly embracing that they use 70% less energy, require 25-30% less
the concept of the electric mine. preventative maintenance spend, increase productivity
by 10% and account for less noise.
“I would say there’s customer interest, in every offering,
is to be electric and sustainable,” continued Samuels. The transformational nature of what Epiroc is doing
“We were a big driver ourselves to start with, when we in catering to a mining industry in the process of
saw it as the future, but over the last six or seven years electrifying operations on a vast scale is about more
I see everyone talking sustainability. The big mining than just the physical process of converting its
houses want to be sustainable and green, and we do longstanding diesel fleet to electric; it is also about
too. We are all in on this, and it’s full tilt.” skills and knowledge. The manufacturer has to replace
100 years’ worth of knowledge on diesel vehicles 2022 were Australian electrical infrastructure solutions
and plant into a similar level of expertise to cater for provider JTMEC and Remote Control Technologies
the electric future. In short, Epiroc needs to educate (RCT), another Australian firm that specialises in
an entire workforce to operate and service electric automation and remote control solutions for mining.
equipment, virtually from scratch.
In 2021, Epiroc partnered with Kempower, a Finnish
In part, the process of converting the existing fleet is tech start-up that designs and manufacturers direct
helping people in the business – and the company current fast charging solutions for electric vehicles
itself – to acquire this knowledge. The “two track” and machines. That year it also bought Canadian
approach is an important factor in this, as Samuels electrification infrastructure provider Meglab, to help
explained: “We’re making new equipment and new service north American mining customers.
designs and making battery equipment that way, but
Explaining the synergies these acquisitions bring for
we’re also taking the older models and converting
Epiroc and its clients, Samuels said: “These companies
them; so then we are using that knowledge we learned
knew infrastructure so now we can bring their
from the conversion process to provide new battery
knowledge to the table and we can talk substations,
equipment of the same models from our factory.”
we can talk power requirements, we can talk about
In addition, to help accelerate the process, Epiroc how much cable you need, the sizing, how much
is engaging with educational institutions as well as power you need to do these kind of things.”
developing its own training programmes to educate
and train its workforce.
United. Inspired.
On the charging side of the equation, the most-critical bottleneck is the connector and its ability to convey
more energy to a vehicle in less time, according to Ashnagaran.
In 2021, ABB launched eMine, a portfolio of advanced electrification, digital and autonomous solutions aimed
Continues
at helping operators integrate battery-electric vehicles into their operations while maximising energy efficiency on page 16
and performance. ▼
Innovation behind
Liebherr’s zero emission push
As one of the world’s leading suppliers and
manufacturers of heavy machinery, Liebherr was
always likely to be at the forefront of the mining
industry’s move towards electrification.
Liebherr’s application engineers use specialised “We have recognised that in the future electricity
simulation software to determine the optimal will continue to be the cheapest alternative to
combination of stationary charging and dynamic today’s diesel,” Ays explained. “For this reason, every
charging solutions for each customer. All elements – mine should try to use electricity whenever possible.
such as possible locations for trolley line hardware,
line length, ramp design and other key elements “Dynamic charging with trolley overhead lines
– are considered to optimise costs, maximise offers an optimal way to use electricity without
production, and minimise overall emissions. interrupting the mining process. Also, future
Liebherr trucks with zero emission drives will have
Trolley solutions this Trolley Assist option so that our customers can
keep their energy costs as low as possible.”
Liebherr has offered trolley solutions for its range
of mining trucks since 2016 through its Trolley The existing global fleet of Liebherr trucks with
Assist System. This system allows customers to the Trolley Assist System consists of 50 363t T284
power diesel-electric trucks by connecting them to trucks across two sites, and seven 100t T236 trucks
overhead electric powerlines. in Austria.
Mining
AD
Liebherr
Liebherr is a leader in proven low emission solutions, utilising grid
electrification. By 2030, fossil fuel free solutions will be established.
Liebherr strives for long-term sustainable solutions, providing different modular options centred on environmental
sustainability, safety, cost, flexibility, and maintainability including:
– 30 years experience in electric drive mining excavators with all machine models available ranging from
150 t to 800 t class
– Trolley Assist option available on all Liebherr mining trucks
– Liebherr combustion engine compliant with Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil (HVO) fuel
– Tier 4 Final certified engine available on trucks, excavators, and dozers
– Liebherr AC drive system on all truck models providing a modular platform for future powertrain technologies
–
Liebherr‘s roadmap includes batteries, combustion engines using green fuels, and hybrids.
Liebherr-Mining Equipment SAS • 49 rue Frédéric Hartmann • 68025 Colmar Cedex • France • Phone: +33 369 49 20 00
info.lec@liebherr.com • www.liebherr.com
2023 Profile: Liebherr
D98 engine
Liebherr’s D98 engine series is designed specifically
for mining applications. With its modular design,
this engine can be used in equipment produced by
Liebherr and by other OEMs.
Hydrogen and ammonia engines To engineer, manufacture and supply the new
trucks in accordance with Fortescue’s delivery
At the Bauma 2022 exhibition, Liebherr requirements, Liebherr will use its vast OEM
demonstrated its expertise in hydrogen engines by expertise in the design and manufacturing of
winning the Bauma Innovation Award in the climate machinery and machinery core technology such as
protection category for its first hydrogen-powered electric drive systems, hydraulics, and electronics.
excavator, powered by its H966 hydrogen engine.
Liebherr began developing hydrogen combustion Partnerships such as this are important in
engines in 2019 and now, following the H966 accelerating technical development, field testing,
engine’s success, is further exploring the capabilities and implementation of practical and relevant
of these engines to run with ammonia. Testing this solutions for clients. They support Liebherr’s
fuel source in an internal combustion engine is commitment to the zero emission agenda and to a
expected in early 2023. sustainable future for the mining industry.
▲ The electrification solution comprises charging systems and trolley lines. Whether operators choose one, the
Continued
from page 11 other, or both of these technologies requires mapping of the mine constraints, including:
The eMine portfolio includes a fast offboard charging system for smaller haul trucks used in almost-continuous
operations with limited idle time. These offboard systems are essentially charging stations installed at fixed
points throughout the mining area. Depending on battery size (which
typically ranges from 100-400 kWh for smaller haul trucks), it takes 6-24
Trolley-assist systems, minutes to get from a 30% charge to 90% and 10-40 minutes to get from
0% to 100%.
whose commercial Trolley-assist systems, whose commercial implementation predated that
implementation of battery-electric trucks by a quarter-century, are making a comeback as
an intermediate solution for mine operators looking to reduce emissions
predated that of associated with existing diesel fleets. A trolley system takes a hybrid diesel-
electric truck (a truck with an electrical motor and diesel generator) and
battery-electric feeds power into the truck, eliminating the need for diesel along the entire
trucks by a quarter- length of the trolley line. Each vehicle is equipped with a pantograph,
which collects power through contact with the overhead lines, much
century, are making a like an electric train, tram, or electric bus. Other essential infrastructure
includes poles, an overhead line system, substation, and rectifier station
comeback that converts normal AC power to DC power at about 1,500 to 3,000 volts.
ABB has successfully implemented this system at Boliden’s Aitik open-pit copper mine in Sweden, where
four large diesel-haul trucks connect to a 700m trolley line, and at Copper Mountain’s flagship mine in British
Columbia, Canada, where seven diesel-electric haul
trucks connect to a 1km-long trolley line. In both cases,
the system has helped to substantially reduce diesel
usage, saving the operators money and minimising
The challenges associated
greenhouse gas emissions. with mine electrification have
In a unique approach to the problem of charging larger
haul trucks, ABB is also developing a combined solution
led the sector to embrace
that uses trolley-assist to provide in-motion charging collaboration, as seen in the
along fixed-distance routes.
creation of a Global Mining
With this system, “the battery is charged while the truck
is connected to the trolley system,” Ashnagaran said. Guidelines Group
“It’s too early to say, but we see this is as (potentially)
being the better solution for larger trucks, while the smaller-sized trucks can operate as full battery-equipped
vehicles with the offboard charging system.”
In July 2022, the GMG published a 121-page “Recommended practices for battery-electric vehicles in
underground mining.” This guideline comprises sections on mine design and operations, battery-electric
vehicle design, energy storage systems, charging
systems and methods, charging and connection
interfaces, and performance standards.
—
ABB Ability™ eMine.
For your world, and mine.
Did you know that every electrified mining truck eliminates enough CO2 emissions
per year to save 3,000 square meters of arctic ice? Imagine the impact of
electrifying the entire mine. ABB Ability™ eMine makes that possible. Building on
decades of experience and expertise, we fully integrate electrification and digital
systems from the mine to the port, reducing your environmental impact, lowering
your costs and raising your productivity. Refreshing, isn’t it?
▲ In this case, Epiroc and the other equipment manufacturers will supply CCS-Type 1 charging systems, one of
Continued
from page 17 the two widely-used charging systems recommended in the GMG guidelines.
Rocvolt takes Epiroc beyond its traditional role as an OEM, offering a suite of solutions to support customers
in their electrification journey. These include batteries, chargers, substation and power components, and
digital solutions. But at the same time, it remains mindful of its customers’ need to be able to pick and choose
solutions from different providers.
“Mine operations are moving more towards control towers, like the production and plant areas did a long time
ago. These control towers use digitalisation, telemetry and all this other software to monitor, track and put out
tasks to equipment to the machines and personnel in the mine area. They (the mine operators) don’t want to
have one form of communications to look at one piece of equipment and another form of communications to
look at another,” Samuels said.
“Mine operations are moving more As a result, “these digital solutions can’t be
an Epiroc solution or a MacLean solution,
towards control towers, which use they need to be agnostic. That’s really
important for the mine operators.”
digitalisation and telemetry to ABB has been a vocal proponent of
monitor, track and put out tasks to collaboration between OEMs and
technology, arguing that combined
equipment to the machines and solutions are critical to meeting the
with two major OEMs, Hitachi Construction Machinery and Liebherr Mining Equipment, to work together on
electrification, as well as an informal collaboration with Komatsu.
In the case of the Hitachi MoU, the partners will explore possibilities to apply ABB’s electrification, automation
and digital solutions to mining trucks and excavators provided by Hitachi as part of wider efforts with mine
operators to electrify all processes from pit to port.
These partnerships include a focus on integrating OEM equipment with ABB’s trolley support. But they also go
beyond that, reaching into the spheres of automation and digitalisation.
“Integration of electrification with automation and digital systems is crucial,” Ashnagaran said.
“We are set up to plan, monitor and optimise the operation and energy usage from grid to wheel. And we nee
to effectively manage the process and power control simultaneously. That is why we have to deliver a highly
standardised, configurable, automation solution for
continuous production, which is connected to the
power control and to advanced integration, and which
also considers interoperability (between machines from
different OEMs),” he explained.
Conclusion
Electrification won’t happen overnight, but miners will get there
If the current trend is any indication, then it’s easy to imagine fully electric mines becoming commonplace in
the near future.
With that said, electrification is not a one-size-fits-all-solution. While it could make sense for a large greenfield
project or brownfield expansion with a long mine life to implement full electrification, existing operations may
only consider converting some of the fleet to electric if at all.
Brownfield operations should weigh up whether electrification will deliver sufficient reductions in carbon
emissions and operational costs to justify the capex, according to Ashnagaran. Greenfield operations “make our
job easier,” he said, as electrification can be integrated into mine planning and designing.
But, ultimately, ABB recommends a phased integration of battery-electric equipment into a mine operation
rather than transitioning from diesel to electric in one fell swoop.
“An electric mine looks different from a traditional mine. We are working with miners to break down this long-
term roadmap into short-term actionable projects, piece by piece, to gradually transform their operations,”
Ashnagaran said.
“A phased approach enables mines to immediately lower carbon footprints with a limited up-front capital
investment, while simultaneously advancing progressively as technology becomes more mature, scalable and
cost effective.”
Editorial
Managing editor Chris Cann
E-mail: chris.cann@mining-journal.com
Editor, ContentWorks Nadav Shemer Shlezinger
E-mail: nadav.shlezinger@aspermont.com
Author Nadav Shemer
Advertising
Group chief commercial officer Matthew Smith
Tel: +44 (0) 7500 958452 E-mail: matt.smith@aspermont.com
Subscriptions
Sales director Roger Cooke
Tel: +44 (0)20 7216 6064 E-mail: roger.cooke@aspermontmedia.com
Subscription Enquiries (Asia Pacific Region)
Tel: +61 8 6263 9100 E-mail: subscriptions@aspermont.com
Subscription Enquiries (Asia Pacific Region)
Tel: +44 (0) 208 187 2299 E-mail: subscriptions@aspermontmedia.com
www.aspermont.com
In partnership with