Unit 2
Unit 2
Unit 2
Structure
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Objective
1.3 Model Prison Manual 1960
1.4 Draft Model Prison Manual 2003
1.5 Objectives of Draft Model Prison Manual 2003
1.6 The Substantive Provisions of the Draft Prison Manual 2003
1.7 Summary
1.8 Terminal Questions
1.9 References and Suggested Readings
1.1 INTRODUCTION
General apathy towards the prisons and the prisoners on the part of the
government is responsible for the various problems relating to prisoners
and prison administration. The majority of the prisons in India are
characterized by the overcrowding, sub-human conditions of living,
custodial death, inadequate medical facilities, corruption, etc.
Overcrowding affects overall quality life in prisons and makes the task to
maintain human dignity, safety and security of prisoners and prison staff
all the more difficult.
1.2 OBJECTIVES
Staff discipline
Staff welfare
Reception units
Quarantine
Study of prisoners
Classification of inmates:
Some basic features of the Model Prison Manual are discussed below.
The Model Prison Manual is consists of 6 parts and 54 chapters. Part one
deals with issues like: Headquarters organization and Prison
infrastructure. Accordingly, the Prison and Correctional services shall be
under the control of the Home Department. The organizational set-up of
the prison head-quarters shall be headed by a Inspector General (IG) and
the IG to be assisted by around twenty types of subordinate officers
including Deputy I.G., Prison Superintendent, Correctional Officers. The
power and function of the I.G., and other subordinate officers are
specifically recognized in the Model Prison Manual. The Model Prison
Manual recognized the importance of the reasonable diversification of
prison institution like, separate institution for delinquent children,
adolescent Offenders, habitual, professional and organized criminals,
women offenders, Leprosy unit, TB unit, under trial prisoners, Sub-jail
and open institutions. It has suggested the establishment of central
prison for inmates up to 750 specifically for the offenders sentenced for
terms of imprisonment exceeding two years. District prisons to be
established for offenders convicted under minor offences and the total
population inside the district prison shall not to be more than the
specified capacity. The Model Prison Manual enumerates number of
facilities for the Prisoners. These are like: education, work, technical and
vocational training, cultural activities, leave and emergency release,
sanitation and hygiene, diet, aftercare and rehabilitation. The Model
Prison Manual provides for physical, health, academic, social, vocational,
moral and cultural education of inmates and suggested a detail course
curriculum for the same. In the other hand, it has strongly recommended
that the prison work and training programme should be fundamentality
integrated with safe and national economic policies and suggested for
payment of appropriate wages to prison workers. The Manual has
highlighted that the cultural and recreational opportunities should be
extended to inmates in accordance with their institutional behavior and
response to institutional regimes. After care and rehabilitation under the
Model Prison Manual is aimed to help a released person to over come his
mental, social and economic difficulties. The Model Prison Manual
further classified the inmates on the basis of gender, age, punishment,
stage of criminal proceeding and nature of crime etc. It helps for a better
prison administration and management. An analysis of the basic
provisions of the Model Prison Manual shows that it not only enunciate
principles for an efficient management of prisons but also lay down
scientific guidelines for correctives treatment of various classes of
offenders.
The provisions of the Manual has also laid down about rights of the
prisoners it takes into account the basic need of the prisoners i.e.,
bedding, clothing, legal facilities, hygiene, sanitation, work wages,
medical facilities, diet, calories to be given to prisoners, the transfer of
prisoner another place on medical ground and facility to prisoner
desiring to file appear appeal in their cases. It favours the release of the
prisoner on remission, leave and also emergency release. A remission is a
concession which can be granted to prisoners by the State government/
inspector General of Prisons/ Superintendent of Police as the case may
be. Remission is not claimed as a matter of right. It is an incentive for
good behaviour and the work done. The very object of release of
prisoner’s on leave is to enable the inmate to maintain continuity with
his family members and relatives. The provisions for Review of Sentence
are also made it says that the cases of women offender, adolescent
prisoners and non-habitual women offender should be reviewed when the
undergone is three years or more. The cases of life convicts and habitual
offenders be reviewed after five years.
But, the fact remains the same that the Model Prison Manual of 1960 is
old and looking at the present scenario it lacks broad human right issues
and judicial guidelines recognizing the basic human rights. In order that
the Model Prison Manual has served as an effective guideline for the
development of state prison manual in different states and Union
Territories it need numerous changes. The Model Prison Manual of 1960
served as effective guidelines for the development of State Prison Manual.
Thereafter no efforts were made to formulate the Model Prison Manual on
the line of model penological thinking.
What are the main features of the Model Prison Manual 1960?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
.……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
Like many other revolutionary steps with respect to the prison and the
prisoners the judiciary also recognized the importance of Model Prison
Manual. The judiciary in the case of Ramamurthy vs. State of Karnataka
(1996) had emphasized the urgent need for bringing uniformity in laws
relating to prisons and directed the central and state governments to
formulate a new Model Prison Manual.
………………………………………………………………………………………………
.…………
The Model Prison Manual Committee has been observed that there exist
a wide gap with regards to the purpose and objectives (reformation and
rehabilitation of the prisoners) of the imprisonment. For developing
prison system in the country as an effective instrument for the
reformation and rehabilitation of offenders the draft Model Prison
Manual has been drawn with a view to:
Right to Communication
To respect the dignity and the right to live of every inmate, prison
staff and functionary;
To abstain from hurting religious feelings, beliefs and faiths of
other persons;
To help prison officials in the performance of their duties at all times and
maintain discipline and order;
Specify the rights of the prisoners provided under Model Prison Manual ?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
.……………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………
Visiting System
The draft manual recognize the importance of the visiting system and
specifies the role of Board of Visitors. It provides that the task of the
Board of Visitors shall include:
The draft Model Prison Manual provides that the State Government or
the Union Territory Administration will establish sufficient numbers of
prisons, as far as possible, and provide minimum needs essential to
maintain standards of living in consonance with human dignity. Prisons
will ensure that prisoners retain all their rights as human beings within
the limitations of imprisonment. The details have been given regarding
prison architect for constructing prison building, barracks, housing, cell,
latrine, kitchen, hospital bathing place.
The provisions of draft manual emphasis on the fact that the prisons will
have to ensure separation of the following categories of prisoners: a)
Women (b) Young offenders (c) Under-trials (d) Convicts (e) Civil prisoners
(f) Detenues (g) High security prisoners. The prisons' regime will prepare
prisoners to lead a law-abiding, self-supporting, reformed and socially
rehabilitated life. The draft manual talks about the establishment of
diversified institutions to be set up by each State/Union Territory
according to its requirements.
It also talks about the institutional personnel and lays down that it will
comprise of: Executive, Medical personnel, Welfare Units, Educational
Personnel, Technical Personnel and Agricultural personnel, guiding
personnel, medical personnel, educational personnel, technical personnel
The details regarding the duties of these personnel’s are also laid down.
Service conditions of prison personnel will be such as to secure and retain the best-suited
and qualified persons.
Efforts will be made to enlist community participation in effective
administration of prison programmes.
Medical Facilities
The draft manual talks about providing hospitals with in the prisons. The
prison hospitals as suggested by the draft manual may be of Types ‘A’
and 'B'. Big hospitals, with 50 beds and above shall be called 'A' type
hospitals. Other hospitals, with less than 50 beds, shall be called ‘B’ type
hospitals. The staff and equipment for the two types of hospital shall be
sufficiently provided. The general duties of the Chief Medical Officer/
Medical Officer (In Charge) shall cover every matter connected with the
health of the prisoners, their treatment when sick, and the sanitation
and hygiene of the prison. The daily visit by the medical officer to the
prison, special need of the aged person and treatment of drug addicts are
recommended. The duties of the assistant surgeon are well defined in the
draft, the provisions are also laid down for the hospital diet of the
prisoners, vaccination of the prisoner on admission.
Education
The education is required for the harmonious and all round development
of human faculties—mental as well as physical. Like any other individual
the education is necessary for the prisoners also. It is a tool by which the
knowledge, character and behaviour of the inmate can be moulded. The
emphasis is on the social, moral, cultural and spiritual education. It also
provides for that meditation therapy be used to erase the memory of past
bad experiences among prisoners. It helps a prisoner to adjust to the
social environment and his ultimate resettlement in society
Agriculture
Remission
Ordinary remission
Special remission
State government Remission
Leave And Special Leave
Premature Release
The draft manual talks about the After-care and the rehabilitation of the
prisoners and the work regarding the same should broadly be phased as
follows:
Women Prisoners
The draft manual separately dealt with the issue of women prisoners.
It has been provided that the women prisoners shall be classified and
kept separately as under:
(i) Under-trial prisoners shall be kept completely separated from
convicted offenders, even when their number is small.
(ii) Habitual prisoners shall be separated from casual offenders
(iii) Habitual offenders, prostitutes and brothel keepers must also be
confined separately.
(iv) In no circumstances should adolescent girls be confined with adult
women prisoners.
(v) Political and civil prisoners shall be kept separately from convicts
and undertrial prisoners.
It has been further provided that the a child up to six years of age of a
women prisoner shall be admitted to prison with his mother if no other
arrangements, for keeping him with relatives or otherwise, can be made.
Children born in prison may remain with their mothers up to six years of
age, if they cannot otherwise be suitably placed. The Medical Officer
shall determine the age of children not born in prison for the purpose of
this provision.
The provisions are made for the vocational training of women prisoner.
The sufficient work or vocational trades shall be provided to keep
prisoners actively employed for a normal working day. These may
include:
Tailoring; Embroidery; Needle-craft; Spinning; Handloom; Weaving; Soap;
making; Hosiery work; Cane and bamboo work; Candle making; Toy
making; Pottery; Stationery articles; Local handicrafts; Cottage industries
Gardening; Sewing machine repair; Typing; Computer training;
Beautician’s work; Telephone operation and secretarial practice;
Agricultural, horticultural, diary projects; Poultry; Sericulture; Fishery;
Mushroom cultivation; Fruit preservation and other local projects.
The welfare of the children of the Women Prisoners: The facilities for
crèches should also be made available for the children of women
peisoners. There shall be a creche and a nursery school attached to a
prison for women where the children of women prisoners shall be looked
after. Children below three years of age shall be allowed in the creche
and those between three and six years shall be looked after in the
nursery school.
1.7 Summary
1. What is the basis purpose behind the Model Prison Manual 2003?
Please define the salient features of this Manual?
2. Define the duties of the Board of Visitors as envisaged under the
Model Prison Manual 2003?
3. What are the duties of the prisoners as provided under the Model
Prison Manual 2003?
4. What are the terms of references for the Model Prison Manual
Committee?