Dr. Nancee
Dr. Nancee
Dr. Nancee
Nancee, Ph. D.
Assistant Professor, Department of Commerce, S.C.V.B Govt. College Palampur,
Himachal Pradesh, India, Email-id-nancychauhan001@gmail.com
Abstract
In order to fulfill human resource requirements, an enterprise will have to plan in advance its needs
and the sources. The terms human resource planning (also called employment or personnel planning)
and manpower planning are generally used interchangeably. Human resource planning is not a
substitute for manpower planning. Rather the latter is a part of the former i.e., manpower planning is
integrated with human resource planning. Human resource planning is a process that identifies
current and future human resources needs for an organization to achieve its goals. Human resource
is the most important asset of an organisation. Human resources planning are the important
managerial function. It ensures the right type of people, in the right number, at the right time and
place, who are trained and motivated to do the right kind of work, there is generally a shortage of
suitable persons. The enterprise will estimate its manpower requirements and then find out the
sources from which the needs will be met. If required manpower is not available then the work will
suffer. Presently developing countries are suffering from the shortage of trained managers. Job
opportunities are available in these countries but properly trained personnel are not available. These
countries try to import trained skill from other countries. Therefore, it can be said that Human
resource planning, or HRP, is the ongoing, continuous process of systematic planning to achieve
optimum use of an organization's most valuable asset its human resources.
INTRODUCTION
Human Resource Planning (HRP) is the process of forecasting the future human resource
requirements of the organization and determining as to how the existing human resource
capacity of the organization can be utilized to fulfill these requirements. It, thus, focuses on
the basic economic concept of demand and supply in context to the human resource capacity
of the organization. It is the HRP process which helps the management of the organization in
meeting the future demand of human resource in the organization with the supply of the
appropriate people in appropriate numbers at the appropriate time and place. Further, it is
only after proper analysis of the HR requirements can the process of recruitment and
selection be initiated by the management. Also, HRP is essential in successfully achieving the
strategies and objectives of organization. In fact, with the element of strategies and long-term
Copyright © 2017, Scholarly Research Journal for Interdisciplinary Studies
Dr. Nancee
(Pg. 8470-8485) 8471
objectives of the organization being widely associated with human resource planning these
days, HR Planning has now become Strategic HR Planning.
Human Resource Planning Process
Human resource planning is a process through which the company anticipates future business
and environmental forces. Human resources planning assesses the manpower requirement for
future period of time. It attempts to provide sufficient manpower required to perform
organizational activities. Fig 1.1 depicts the various steps involved in human resource
planning.
Fig 1.1
HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING PROCESS
gross sales, the department needs one employee. If sales are expected to rise by $30,000 in
the coming year, the department will need to hire two full-time employees.
Benchmarking/Thumb rule:
In business, benchmarking is a process in which a company compares its product and
methods with those of the most successful companies in its field, in order to try to improve its
own performance. In other words Benchmarking is a measurement of the quality of an
organisation’s policies, products, programs, strategies, etc., and their comparison with
standard measurements, or similar measurements of its peers. The objective of benchmarking
is
1. To determine what and where improvements are called for?
2. To analyse how other organizations achieve their high performance levels.
3. To use this information to improve performance.
Benchmarks or rule of thumb rise out of many years experience. Like general benchmarking,
Human Resource benchmarking is extremely important. When information on HR
performance has been gathered, it must be compared to a standard, which is a model or
measure against which something is compared to determine its performance level. For
example, the international benchmark for HR is 1:100 in an automated environment, which
indicates one HR employee can support and service 100 employees. Therefore if the
employee strength is 5,000, 50 HR employees will be needed. These benchmarks are useful
when forecasting has to be done in large volumes for a new business.
Scatter Plot:
Scatter plot is a graphical method used to help identify the relationship between two
variables- such as sales and a firm’s staffing levels. Scatter plots show how much one
variable is affected by another. By using scatter plot organization can forecast the needs of
human resource against the business activity (like sales). Thus, The Scatter Plot is a graphical
method used to identify the relationship between two variables. If these two variables - for
example, a measure of business activity and business staffing levels - are related, then if
company forecast the measure of business activity, company should be able to forecast their
HR requirements.
Fig 1.2
SCATTER PLOT
Fig 1.2 shows graphically how two different variables i.e., sales revenue and salesmen are
related. Scatter plot help determine if a factor as historically been related to staffing levels,
accordingly will determine what staffing levels should be change.
Trend Analysis
Trend analysis means studying historical organizational employment levels to predict future
employment levels. For example: If, on average, employment levels in the organization have
increase 5% per year, it might be logical to forecast a 5% increase for the next planning
period. A more accurate forecast using this method might be to evaluate trends in separate
departments or other organizational sub entities and then aggregate the increases (or,
potentially, decreases) at the organizational level. Doing so provides more specificity as to
not only the numbers of employees but also the types of employees needed. Hence, Trend
analysis assumes that history will repeat itself. In today’s more volatile times that might not
be the case. However, trend analysis provides some data on which a final forecast can be
made. The trend analysis provides both data describing how trends such as turnover will
affect the workforce and is a key element in the overall planning process.
Trend data is not limited to turnover data. It also may include the following:
Hiring and retirement patterns.
Years of service.
New-hire retention rate.
Transfers.
Promotions.
Trend information can help predict the supply of skills that may be available in the future and
project the future workforce supply needed. Careful planning and a thorough analysis of data
can help the workforce planner build a strategic plan for addressing the future needs of the
organization. For example- In a manufacturing plant in 2016-17 they were producing 10000
unit of product X with the help of 100 workers. Now they planned to expand the production
to 15000 unit of X product in 2017-18 year. We can calculate by trend that number of
workers required would be 150. So they need to hire 50 more workers.
Computerized Forecasts:
Computerized forecast means the determination of future staff needs by projecting a firm’s
sale, volume of production, and personnel required to maintain this required volume of
output, using computers and software packages. Employers also used computerized system to
personnel requirements. For example, the requirements for sales officers would depend on
the trend of sales in different markets, the number of product introduced, the difference in the
products (whether one salesman sell both products?) and customers for the product. The
computer program enables the manager to enter all these variables to generate the resource
requirement that is required to meet the business objectives. Hence, computerized forecasting
method can forecast in a complex environment better than other methods.
Work study Technique
This technique is also known as 'work-load analysis'. This technique is suitable where the
estimated work-load is easily measureable. Under this method, estimated total production and
activities for a specific future period are predicted. This information is translated into number
of man-hours required to produce per units taking into consideration the capability of the
workforce. Past-experience of the management can help in translating the work-loads into
number of man-hours required. Thus, demand of human resources is forecasted on the basis
of estimated total production and contribution of each employee in producing each unit items.
For example the estimated production of an organisation is 3,00,000 units. The standard
Copyright © 2017, Scholarly Research Journal for Interdisciplinary Studies
Dr. Nancee
(Pg. 8470-8485) 8476
man-hours required to produce each unit are 2 hours. The past experiences show that the
work ability of each employee in man-hours is 1500 hours per annum. The work-load and
demand of human resources can be calculated as under
Estimated total annual production = 300000 units
Standard man-hours needed to produce each unit = 2 hrs
Estimated man-hours needed to meet estimated annual production (i x ii) i.e.,
300000*2=600000 hrs
Work ability/contribution per employee in terms of man-hour = 1500 units
Estimated no. of workers needed (iii / iv) = 600000/1500 = 400 units
The above example clearly shows that 400 workers are needed for the year. Further,
absenteeism rate, rate of labour turnover, resignations, deaths, machine break-down,
strikes, power-failure etc. should also be taken into consideration while estimating
future demand of human resources/ manpower.
Qualitative/ Judgmental methods of demand forecasting
Qualitative forecasts use managerial judgment on a more individual basis, spotting needs
internally and then bidding for or training the requisite skills. Following are the main
qualitative techniques used in forecasting demand of human resource:
1. Managerial judgment
Bottom- up approach
Top-Down Approach
2. Delphi Technique
3. Zero based Forecasting
Managerial Judgment:
Managerial judgment is a type of brainstorming that involves a meeting of managers who
gather to diagnose and predict the future job market. These can generally be either top-down
or bottom-up, with either the executives forming their plans and trend analysis for discussion,
or the mid-level managers bringing their forecast to the meeting. The best types of
managerial judgment will combine forecasts from many sources, including HRM. Thus,
Managerial judgement technique is very common technique of demand forecasting. This
approach is applied by small as well as large scale organisations. This technique involves two
types of approaches i.e. 'bottom-up approach' and 'top-down approach'.
Bottom-up approach, under this approach line manger sends their departmental
requirement of human resources to top management. Each manager who is in charge will
create his own requirement. It starts from lowest level and moves to the middle level and then
to the senior. Thus, Top management ultimately forecasts the human resource requirement for
the overall organisation on the basis of proposals of departmental heads.
Top-down approach, under this approach there is minimum involvement of line managers in
the forecasting process. Most of the responsibility for forecasting is taken by the top
management who based on their experience, their view of future business and resource
constraints estimate human resource requirement for the future. This method is more time
efficient and business driven than the bottom approach.
However, a combination of both the approaches i.e. 'Participative Approach' should
be applied for demand forecasting. Under this approach, top management and departmental
heads meet and decide about the future human resource requirement. So, demand of human
resources can be forecasted with unanimity under this approach.
Delphi Technique
This Technique named after the ancient Greek Oracle at the city of Delphi. Delphi technique
is also very important technique used for estimating demand of human resources. This
technique takes into consideration human resources requirements given by a group of experts
i.e. mangers. The human resource experts collect the manpower needs, summarises the
various responses and prepare a report. This process is continued until all experts agree on
estimated human resources requirement. In a Delphi technique, the identity of the group
members is not revealed, and they are not even required to gather for a physical meeting.
Each member is free to give his opinion with respect to the problem, thereby avoiding the
influential effect that a powerful or authoritative member can have on the other group
members. This technique is quite advantageous as different opinions can be gathered from the
large pool of experts who might be geographically separated. Also, the quality of decision
gets improved as the expertise of each group member is capitalized to reach to a final
solution.
Zero based Forecasting
Under this technique, the organization's use current level of employment as the starting point
for determining future staffing needs. Managers need to build a budget for their manpower
requirement as if no baseline existed (i.e., previous records are not considered for forecasting
Copyright © 2017, Scholarly Research Journal for Interdisciplinary Studies
Dr. Nancee
(Pg. 8470-8485) 8478
future needs of manpower). Resources are not necessarily allocated in accordance with
previous patterns. The main emphasis is on the analysis of human resource needs. It produces
more and better management information in a readily accessible form. This improves the
quality of management decision, as there is participation of lower level management in the
budgetary process. Unexpected events that occur during the financial year can be more
readily adjusted for.
Supply forecasting
After demand forecasting, next step is to check availability of manpower inside the
organization too. So, Human Resource supply forecasting is the process of estimating
availability of human resource followed after demand for testing of human resource. For
forecasting supply of human resource organisation need to consider internal and external
supply. Internal supply of human resource available by way of transfers, promotions, retired
employees & recall of laid-off employees, etc. Source of external supply of human resource
is availability of labour force in the market and new recruitment external supply of human
resource depends on some factors mentioned below:
Supply and demand of jobs.
Literacy rate of nation.
Rate of population
Technological development.
Markov Analysis
Replacement charts
Staffing Tables
Wastage Analysis
Succession Planning
Markov analysis
Markov analysis is named for the Russian mathematician Andrei Andreevich Markov. In
hierarchical systems, routes for the employees, which is the promotion ladder, are well
defined. It means every employee elevates himself in the organisation through a well defined
career path. All employees start in an organisation at the bottom rung and climb up the ladder
one at a time. The basic assumption of this model is that an employee in a particular grade or
a status group has a fixed chance of promotion in a given year, independent of vacancy. At
the organizational level, Markov analysis may be applied to describe and forecast the process
of human resource flows or movements within, into, and out of the organization.
No workforce is stable or stationary. People are hired, they grow within system and
then some of them leave for a variety of reasons. The focus of Markov analysis is to attempt
to project into the future what the current workspace would like if the current mobility flow
continues with no changes. It is use to study the flow of people entering and existing the
system. For example Fig 1.3 shows hypothetical flow of people in a call center. In 2011 the
number of people in different jobs is given in the first column. There are 12 program
manager, 36 assistant manager, 96 supervisors, 288 team leaders and 1440 customer service
representative (CSRs). How these people make a transition in the next year is given in the
subsequent columns. The figures in percentage represent the transition i.e., the percentage of
people who will make a transition into that job in the coming year. For example, 74 per cent
of the total number of CSRs (1440) will stay in their current job, i.e., 1066 CSRs will
continue. About 6 per cent (of 1,440), i.e., 86 would get promoted to team leaders and 20 per
cent would exit the system, i.e., 288 will be separated. Thus, Markov analysis shows the
percentage of employees who remain in each job from one year to the next as well as the
numbers that get promoted, transferred or exit from the organization. It helps in tracking
patterns of employee movements through various jobs and aids in developing a transition
Fig. 1.3
MARKOV ANALYSIS
Replacement Charts:
Replacement charts are a forecasting technique used in succession planning to help
companies visualise key job roles, current employees and existing and future vacancies.
Positions are mapped alongside information such as potential replacements, gender and
promotion potential. Updates to replacement charts should be made regularly, at least
annually, and especially in response to fluctuations in economic conditions or business
activity.
Replacement charts classify employees into four groups
i) Employees ready for promotion
ii) Employees who would be ready for future promotions if given additional training.
iii) Employees performing satisfactorily but needs motivation and further improvements
iv) Employees who are not fit to be on employment and need to be replaced.
Fig 1.4
AN EXECUTIVE REPLACEMENT CHART
MANAGER KEY
Staffing Tables
It shows the number of employees in each job. It tries to classify employees on the basis of
age, gender, position, category, experience, qualifications, skills, etc. A study of the table
indicates whether current employees are properly utilised or not.
Staffing table is the graphical arrangement of the jobs in the organization along with the
number of employees currently working on this position as well as it shows the details of
future vacancy on each job. In human services, turnover, or employee withdrawal behavior,
has become a serious personnel problem.
Wastage Analysis:
Labour wastage should be taken into account while making future forecast and find out the
reasons of people leaving the organisation. Action can be taken to arrest the labour wastage
and replacement of uncontrollable losses. HR manager must know how to make wastage
analysis. For measuring permanent total loss due to labour the following labour turnover
formula is used.
Labour Turnover Rate = Number of Employees left specified period (Say one year)/ Average
Number of Employees during the same period x 100
HR Managers have to calculate the rate of labour turnover, conduct exit interviews etc. This
helps them forecast, the rate of potential loss, causes of loss etc. The steps can be taken to
reduce loss. HR Manager can calculate labour stability index by using the formula given
below.
Labour Stability Index = Number of Employees with one year’s service or more / Number of
Employees one year ago x 100
Thus, by knowing all these labour instability can be arrested and labour turnover can be
minimised.
Succession Planning
Another aspect of effective workforce planning is succession planning. Succession planning
is used by organizations to identify and prepare suitable employees to fill key positions when
current employees leave their jobs. An effective workforce planning process will include a
review of key leadership and business-critical roles and will identify key incumbents able to
progress into these roles. Having a succession plan in place generally ensures a smooth
continuation of business when key players leave due to retirement, resignations or transfers
within the company.
The types of positions included in a succession plan vary by organization. Traditionally, these
plans included only executive-level positions. In recent years, however, companies have been
selecting successors for positions throughout the organization. During times of economic
upheaval, when the economic security of organizations and their staffs may be uncertain, the
need for up-to-date succession plans increases. With a wavering economic outlook,
downsizing, mergers and acquisitions become more likely. With these events leading to
Copyright © 2017, Scholarly Research Journal for Interdisciplinary Studies
Dr. Nancee
(Pg. 8470-8485) 8483
5. Trainings Completed
6. Geographical Preferences
7. Career Aspirations and Objectives
8. Anticipated Retirement Dates.
Need for a skills inventory:
A skills inventory can be a useful tool in human resource development programs since it
brings into focus the present level of technical ability and the achievements of all employees
who might be considered for participation in education and training programs. It is a tool
through which the employees recognize the fact that they are working for an
organization which values their skills and competencies and where his contributions are
appreciated. Certain factors to which the design of skills inventories may be attributed to are:
1. Most organizations today lack complete, accurate and a comprehensive database
regarding the capabilities of the employees. There is always a need of a certain skill
level that the workforce possesses but lack of more precise information handicaps
ability to project potential and impending future requirements/shortages in certain
skill areas. This in turn undermines the ability to plan for necessary employee training
and education, as well as the ability to determine future directions for the recruiting,
selection of employees and if required purchasing contracted services from outside
the organization.
2. If certain individual position openings occurred within the organization that require a
unique combination of skills and experience it is difficult to readily identify the best
qualified individual. It happens that employees who are “most familiar” tended to
appear as potential candidates. This negatively affects management’s ability to move
employees periodically to different positions so as to capitalize on their varied talents,
as well as to afford employees opportunities for job variety and development of new
skills
REFERENCES:
Ahmad, S. (2019). Human Resource Planning: Effective Performance. Research Journal. of
Humanities and Social Sciences, 10(4), 1120-1124.
Akey, B. C. A., Dai, B., Torku, E., & Antwi, E. A. (2017). Human resource planning and the
development of employees in contemporary firms. European Journal of Contemporary
Research, 6(1), 299-305.