Wood & Wood-Based Materials As Sensors (Piezoelectricity Effect in Wood) - 31,01,2018
Wood & Wood-Based Materials As Sensors (Piezoelectricity Effect in Wood) - 31,01,2018
Wood & Wood-Based Materials As Sensors (Piezoelectricity Effect in Wood) - 31,01,2018
Department of
Agriculture
Wood and Wood-Based
Forest Service Materials as Sensors—
Forest
Products
Laboratory
A Review of the
General
Technical
Piezoelectric Effect
Report
FPL–GTR–212 in Wood
Robert J. Ross
Jiangming Kan
Xiping Wang
Julie Blankenburg
Janet I. Stockhausen
Roy F. Pellerin
Abstract Contents
A variety of techniques have been investigated for use in Introduction........................................................................... 1
assessing the physical and mechanical properties of wood Approach............................................................................... 1
products and structures. Ultrasound, transverse vibration,
and stress-wave based methods are all techniques that Technical Documents Reviewed in a Chronological
have shown promise for many nondestructive evaluation Order..................................................................................... 1
applications. These techniques and others rely on the use Patents Selected for Review.................................................. 2
of measurement systems to monitor the response of the Research Summary............................................................... 2
specimen under test. The primary sensing element in many
widely used measurement systems uses piezoelectric sen- Discussion............................................................................. 2
sors to monitor the response of the specimen under test to an Fundamental Concepts...................................................... 2
external force. Commonly used piezoelectric sensors rely on Baseline Studies................................................................ 4
a quartz crystal that converts mechanical energy into electri-
cal energy. The electrical signal obtained from such sensors Origin of the Piezoelectric Effect in Wood....................... 6
is then used in a variety of signal processing steps to arrive Piezoelectric Effect and the Properties of Wood
at basic properties of the material or structural system being and Wood Structural Members......................................... 7
tested. Summary............................................................................... 8
The objective of the research presented in this paper was to References............................................................................. 8
examine the worldwide literature on the piezoelectric effect
in wood. Results of a search of the worldwide literature,
including a patent search, are presented and discussed.
Keywords: Crystallinity, defects, piezoelectric effect,
piezoelectric modulus, wood
June 2012
Ross, Robert J.; Kan, Jiangming; Wang, Xiping; Blankenburg, Julie; Stock-
hausen, Janet I.; Pellerin, Roy F. 2012. Wood and wood-based materials as
sensors—a review of the piezoelectric effect in wood. General Technical
Report FPL-GTR-212. Madison, WI: U.S. Department of Agriculture,
Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory. 9 p.
A limited number of free copies of this publication are available to the
public from the Forest Products Laboratory, One Gifford Pinchot Drive,
Madison, WI 53726–2398. This publication is also available online at
www.fpl.fs.fed.us. Laboratory publications are sent to hundreds of libraries
in the United States and elsewhere.
The Forest Products Laboratory is maintained in cooperation with the
University of Wisconsin.
The use of trade or firm names in this publication is for reader information
and does not imply endorsement by the United States Department of
Agriculture (USDA) of any product or service.
The USDA prohibits discrimination in all its programs and activities on the
basis of race, color, national origin, age, disability, and where applicable,
sex, marital status, familial status, parental status, religion, sexual orienta-
tion, genetic information, political beliefs, reprisal, or because all or a part
of an individual’s income is derived from any public assistance program.
(Not all prohibited bases apply to all programs.) Persons with disabilities
who require alternative means for communication of program informa-
tion (Braille, large print, audiotape, etc.) should contact USDA’s TARGET
Center at (202) 720–2600 (voice and TDD). To file a complaint of discrimi-
nation, write to USDA, Director, Office of Civil Rights, 1400 Independence
Avenue, S.W., Washington, D.C. 20250–9410, or call (800) 795–3272
(voice) or (202) 720–6382 (TDD). USDA is an equal opportunity provider
and employer.
Wood and Wood-Based Materials
as Sensors—A Review of the
Piezoelectric Effect in Wood
Robert J. Ross, Supervisory Research General Engineer
Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, Wisconsin
Jiangming Kan, Associate Professor
Beijing Forestry University, School of Technology, Beijing, China
Xiping Wang, Research Forest Products Technologist
Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, Wisconsin
Julie Blankenburg, Supervisory Librarian
National Forest Service Library, Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, Wisconsin
Janet I. Stockhausen, Patent Advisor
Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, Wisconsin
Roy F. Pellerin, Professor Emeritus
Washington State University, Pullman, Washington
13. Hirai and others 1968b Table 1—Significant findings in a chronological order
14. Hirai and others 1970 Year Author Reported findings
15. Hirai and others 1972 1946 Shubnikov Discovery of piezo-effect in
16. Maeda and others 1977 wood
17. Hirai and Yamaguchi 1979 1950 Bazhenov and Konstantinova First reported experiments
18. Kellog 1981 on piezoelectricity in wood
19. Pizzi and Eaton 1984 1955 Fukada Inverse piezoelectric effect
20. Knuffel and Pizzi 1986 in wood
21. Fei and Zeng 1987 1963 Galligan and Bertholf Use of piezoelectric textures
22. Knuffel 1988 to observe stress wave behavior
23. Hirai and others 1992 in wood
24. Suzuki and others 1992 1970 Hirai and others Effects of tree growth, wood
25. Hirai and others 1993 quality, degree of crystallinity,
and micellar orientation
26. Nakai and Takemura 1993
1984 Pizzi and Eaton Correlation between molecular
27. Suzuki and Hirai 1995
forces in cellulose I crystal
28. Nakai and others 1998 and piezoelectric effect
29. Smittakorn and Heyliger 2001 1993 Nakai and Takemura Species, grain orientation
30. Suzuki and others 2003 effects
31. Nakai and others 2005 1998 Nakai and others Relationship to static
and vibration properties
Patents Selected for Review 2005 Nakai and others Relationship to crystal lattice
1. Best 1935 strain and tension stress
of individual wood fibers
2. Sanders 2001
3. Lammer 2006
4. Churchill and Arms 2010 example, lead zirconate titanate crystals will generate
measurable piezoelectricity when their static structure is
Research Summary deformed by about 0.1% of the original dimension. Con-
versely, those same crystals will change about 0.1% of their
Table 1 presents a summary of several of the significant
static dimension when an external electric field is applied to
findings in chronological order from the technical papers
the material.
we reviewed. Note that a piezoelectric effect in wood was
first hypothesized, and later discovered, by Russian scien- Piezoelectricity is found in useful applications such as the
tists in the 1940s–50s. Their work was initiated in an effort production and detection of sound, generation of high volt-
to find an appropriate trigger mechanism for military equip- ages, electronic frequency generation, microbalances, and
ment, specifically missiles. Since then, research has been ultrafine focusing of optical assemblies.
conducted to explore relationships between fundamental
The electrical character of a piezoelectric material must be
wood characteristics and the piezoelectric effect observed.
that of a dielectric wherein charge displacement far out-
Discussion weighs conduction. Thus, the material behaves according
to the relationship: C = Q/V, where C is the capacitance
Fundamental Concepts (farads); Q the charge (coulombs); and V, the potential dif-
ference (volts).
Piezoelectricity is the charge that accumulates in certain sol-
id materials (notably crystals, certain ceramics, and biologi- At the molecular level, a further requirement is placed on
cal matter such as bone and various proteins) in response to the piezoelectric material; there must be planes of molecular
applied mechanical stress. Piezoelectricity means electricity symmetry and within these planes the molecular constitu-
resulting from pressure and is the direct result of the piezo- ents must be oriented in such a manner that the electrical
electric effect. charge centers are not symmetrically located. Monocrystals
are representative of materials that meet these requirements.
The piezoelectric effect is understood as the linear electro-
mechanical interaction between mechanical and electrical When a piezoelectric crystal is strained, the charge centers
state in crystalline materials. Piezoelectric effect is a revers- are displaced relative to one another, causing a net charge
ible process in that materials exhibiting direct piezoelectric to occur on the crystal surface. The dielectric nature of the
effect (the internal generation of electrical charge resulting crystal, obeying the capacitance relationship, permits the
from an applied mechanical force) also exhibit the reverse charge to appear as a voltage. This voltage is the electrical
piezoelectric effect (internal generation of a mechanical evidence of the piezoelectric effect.
strain resulting from an applied electrical field). For
2
Wood and Wood-Based Materials as Sensors—A Review of the Piezoelectric Effect in Wood
3
General Technical Report FPL–GTR–212
z d'
Stress
δd
d"
Polarization
y
Figure 4—Vector representation of stress S
and polarization P (Fukada 1968). Graphic
used by permission of the Journal of Wood
Science and Technology.
x
4
Wood and Wood-Based Materials as Sensors—A Review of the Piezoelectric Effect in Wood
Table 2—A list of wood species investigated for piezoelectric effect in previous
studies
Reference Species
Fei and Zeng 1987 Magnolia grandiflora Linn
Tilia amurensis Rupr
Taxodium ascendens Brongn
Pinus massoniana Lamb
Cunninghamia lanceolata Hook
Fukada and others 1957 (10 old timbers from 8 years to 1,300 years)
Galligan and Courteau 1965 Douglas-fir
Hirai and others 1968 Tsuga (Tsuga sieboldii Carr.)
Shioji (Fraxinus mandshurica Rupr.)
Shirakaba (Betula platyphylla SUKATCHEV. var.; japonica HARA.)
Hônoki (Magnolia obovata THUNB)
Taiwanhinoki (Chamaecyparis taiwanensis MASAM. et SUZUKI)
Kiri (Paulownia tomentosa STEUD.)
Hinoki (Chamaecyparis obtuse ENDL.)
Sugi (Cryptomeria japonica D. DON)
Konara (Quercus serrata MURRAY.)
Akamatsu I (Pinus densiflora SIEB. et ZUCC.)
Akamatsu II
Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga taxifolia BRITT.)
Makanba
Hirai and others 1970 Sugi (summerwood and springwood)
Hirai and others 1972 Hinoki tree (Chamaecyparis obtuse SIEB. et ZUCC)
Hirai and Yamaguchi 1979 Hinoki
Knuffel and Pizzi 1986 Pinus patula
Knuffel 1988 Pinus patula
P. taeda
P. elliottii
Maeda and others 1977 Japanese cedar
Nakai and Takemura 1993 Beisugi (Thuja plicata Donn)
Hinoki (Chamaecyparis obtuse ((S. and Z.)) Endl.)
Beitsuga (Tsuga heterophylla ((Raf.)) Sarg.)
Beimatsu (Pseudotsuga menziesii ((Mirb.)) Franco)
Buna (Fagus crenata Bl.)
Nakai and others 1998 Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis Carr.)
Nakai and others 2005 Japanese cypress (Chamaecyparis obtuse Endl.)
Suzuki and others 1992 Hinoki (Chamaecyparis obtuse ((S. and Z.)) Endl.)
Beimatsu (Pseudotsuga menziesii ((Mirb.)) Franco)
Beihiba (Chamaecyparis nootkatensis ((D. Don)) Spach)
Agathis (Agathis sp.)
Igem (Podocarpus imbricatus Bl.)
Momi (Abies firm S. and Z.)
White fir (Abies alba Mill.)
Spruce (Picea pungens Engelm)
Shinanoki (Tilia japonica Simk)
Katsura (Cercidiphyllum japonicum S. and Z.)
Buna (Fagus crenata Bl.)
Lauan (Pentacme contorta Merr. and Rolfe)
Nato (Palaquium sp.)
Matoa (Pometia pinnata Forst.)
Sugar maple (Acer saccharum Marsh.)
Suzuki and Hirai 1995 Chamaecyparis botusa Endlicher
Larix leptolepis Gordon
Magnolia ovobata Thunberg
5
General Technical Report FPL–GTR–212
6
Wood and Wood-Based Materials as Sensors—A Review of the Piezoelectric Effect in Wood
Piezoelectric constant
kiln-dried Sitka spruce specimens and simultaneously re- O2 P2
2
corded scanning electron microscope images in real time I1
K2 L4
to observe the deformation process of wood. Results of
N2
their experiments showed that there were two types of mi-
R2 H5
croscopic destruction in the specimens. With the first type, 1
although a small uprush around the boundary of the annual
ring was observed, the specimens were broken only by
shearing fracture in the 45º direction. With the second type,
the specimens were finally broken by shearing fracture after
repeated buckling. They found that the piezoelectric voltage 0 5 10 15
increased almost linearly in the elastic region, preceded to Dynamic Young’s modulus (×1010 dyne/cm2)
the maximal point, and then decreased gradually, and a clear Figure 6—The relation between dynamic Young’s modulus
peak appeared in the bucking and shearing fracture. and the piezoelectric constants of old timbers (Fukada
and others 1957). Graphic used by permission of Oyo
Nakai and Takemura (1993) measured the piezoelectricity of Buturi.
air-dried specimens (from five species) under time-varying
load to investigate the possible relationship between piezo-
electricity and the fracture of wood. A time-varying load
Piezoelectric modulus, d×10–9 c.g.s.e.s.u
1
was applied at a constant rate, accompanying a preliminary
load and a sinusoidal load with a frequency of 20 Hz. They
found that the greatest voltage of the piezoelectric signals as 0.5
reported in a previous paper was in the case of a grain angle
of 45º, and the voltages of the piezoelectric signals depend-
ed on the magnitude of the load, species, and grain angle. Θ
0
The results of their experiments showed that the piezoelec- 0 45 90 135 180
tricity–time curves can be classified into three types (Type
A, B, and C). Each curve consists of an initial rising part, a
–0.5
gradually increasing part, a subsequent decreasing part, and
finally, a rapid rising and falling (Type A and B) or merely
falling part (Type C), where the second part of the Type B
–1
is much flatter compared with that of the Type A. They also
found that decreasing piezoelectricity against an increasing Θ: Angle between directions of tree and fiber axis
load was another characteristic behavior in the plastic region Figure 7—Anisotropy of piezoelectric modulus (Hirai and
before a sudden fracture of a specimen. others 1968). Graphic used by permission of Washington
State University, Pullman.
Fukada and others (1957) found that the relation between
the dynamic Young’s modulus and the piezoelectric con-
stant of the old timbers was linear (Fig. 6). Nakai and others piezoelectric signal usually began smaller, increased to max-
(1998) reported a similar linear relation in the kiln-dried Sit- imum after about five cycles, and then began to attenuate
ka spruce with the exact relationship between the dynamic to zero. Also, the piezoelectric response started to develop
Young’s modulus and the piezoelectric constant as almost simultaneously with the arrival of the stress wave
( )
and reached its first peak within 0.0001 s. They observed
Pp
Ec (×103 kgf/cm2) = 1.18 + 3.15 that the first peak of the piezoelectric signals might be either
ρ × Lp
positive or negative, which are uncontaminated by reso-
Hirai and others (1968a) found that the piezoelectric effect nance. They also found that the piezoelectric effect in the
varied with the angle between the direction of the stress wet boards was still found to be very strong. But because of
and the direction of the fiber axis and that maximum piezo- the conductive conditions, the electrical signal originating at
electric polarization was obtained when the direction of the the beginning of the board propagated faster than the stress
stresses were at angles of 45º and 135º with the direction of wave, and at 20% moisture content, the piezoelectric effect
the fiber axis (Fig. 7). began to coincide with the arrival of the stress wave.
Knuffel and Pizzi (1986) measured the piezoelectric effect Knuffel (1988) investigated the effect of the natural defects
in Pinus patula structural timber beams. They found that the on the piezoelectric effect in structural timber. There were
7
General Technical Report FPL–GTR–212
Figure 8—Piezoelectric response in structural timber (Knuffel 1988). Graphic used by permission of
Holzforschung.
three findings from their investigation. Firstly, the piezo- Fei, Y.Y.; Zeng, S.X. 1987. Piezoelectric effect in wood.
electric first wavepeak values showed a definite and very Journal of Nanjing Forestry University. 3: 100–104.
sensitive increase in amplitude in the vicinity of knots and
cross-grain (Fig. 8). Second, the piezoelectric response was Fukada, E. 1955. Piezoelectricity of wood. Journal of the
far more sensitive to the defects than to MOE. At last, the Physical Society of Japan. 10(2): 149–154.
piezoelectric effect was directly related to strain concentra- Fukada, E. 1965. Piezoelectric effect in wood and other
tions in the anatomical structure. crystalline polymers. In: Galligan, W.L., ed. Proceedings,
second symposium on nondestructive testing of wood. April,
Summary 1965. Spokane, WA: Washington State University. 143–170.
1. Research has been conducted on the piezoelectric ef- Fukada, E. 1968. Piezoelectricity as a fundamental property
fect in wood and wood materials, starting as early as the of wood. Wood Science and Technology. 2: 299–307.
1940s.
2. A number of wood species have been shown to exhibit a Fukada, E.; Yasuda, S.; Kohara, J.; Okamoto, H. 1957. The
piezoelectric effect. dynamic Young’s modulus and the piezoelectric constant of
3. The magnitude of the piezoelectric modulus of wood is old timbers. Oyo Butsuri [Journal of Applied Physics,
approximately 1/20 of that of a quartz crystal. Japan]. 26: 25–28.
4. Several studies have been conducted to identify the origin Galligan, W.L.; Bertholf, L.D. 1963. Piezoelectric effect in
of the piezoelectric effect in wood. wood. Forest Products Journal. 12(12): 517–524.
5. Studies have been conducted to explore its potential for
evaluating the structural properties of wood structural Galligan, W.L.; Courteau, R.W. 1965. Measurement of
members. elasticity of lumber with longitudinal stress waves and the
piezoelectric effect in wood. In: Galligan, W.L., ed. Pro-
References ceedings, second symposium on nondestructive testing of
wood. April, 1965. Spokane, WA: Washington State
Bazhenov, V.A. 1961. Piezoelectric properties of wood.
University. 223–224.
New York: Consultants Bureau. 176 p.
Hirai, N.; Asano, I. Sobue, N., Naito, H. 1970. Studies
Bazhenov, V.A.; Konstantinova, V.P. 1950. Piezoelectric
on piezoelectric effect of wood. III. Tree growth and varia-
properties of wood. Doklady Akod. Nauk SSSR 71(2).
tions of piezoelectric modulus. Mokuzai Gakkaishi.
Chemical Abstracts. 45, 2747.
16(7): 310–318.
Best, F.M., inventor. 1935 (August 13). Method of and ap-
Hirai, N.; Date, M.; Fukada, E. 1968a. Studies on piezoelec-
paratus for utilizing energy of a vibratory nature. U.S. Patent
tric effect in wood. I. Mokuzai Gakkaishi. 14(5): 247–251.
2,010,806.
Hirai, N.; Date, M.; Fukada, E. 1968b. Studies on piezo-
Churchill, D.L.; Arms, S.W., inventors. 2010 (April 6). Slot-
electric effect in wood. II. Modification of crystal structures.
ted beam piezoelectric composite. U.S. Patent 7,692,365 B2.
Mokuzai Gakkaishi. 14(5): 252–256.
8
Wood and Wood-Based Materials as Sensors—A Review of the Piezoelectric Effect in Wood
Hirai, N.; Hayamura, S.; Suzuki, Y.; Miyajima, K.; Mat- Pizzi, A.; Eaton, N. 1984. Correlation between molecular
suyama, S. 1992. Piezoelectric relaxation of wood in high forces in the cellulose I crystal and the piezoelectric effect in
temperature region. Mokuzai Gakkaishi—Journal of the wood. Holzforschung und Holzverwertung. 36(1): 12–14.
Japan Wood Research Society. 38(9): 820–824.
Sanders, J.F., inventor. 2001 (January 16). Composites
Hirai, N.; Morita, M.; Suzuki, Y. 1993. Electrical properties under self compression. U.S. Patent 6,174,595 B1.
of cyanoethylated wood meal and cyanoethylated cellulose.
Shubnikov, A.V. 1946. Piezoelectric textures. Moskova,
Mokuzai Gakkaishi. 35(5): 603–609.
Russia: Izvestiya Akademii Nauk, Seriya Biologicheskaya
Hirai, N.; Sobue, N.; Asano, I. 1972. Studies on piezoelec- [Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences, Biological Se-
tric effect of wood. IV. Effects of heat treatment on cellulose ries]. 84 pp. In Russian.
crystallites and piezoelectric effect of wood. Mokuzai
Smittakorn, W.; Heyliger, P.R. 2001. An adaptive wood
Gakkaishi. 18(11): 535–542.
composite: theory. Wood and Fiber Science. 33(4): 595–608.
Hirai, N.; Yamaguchi, A. 1979. Studies on piezoelectric ef-
Suzuki, Y.; Hirai, N. 1995. Piezoelectric relaxation of wood.
fect of wood. VI. Effect of moisture content on piezoelectric
II. Application of two-phase system model to piezoelectric
dispersion of wood. Mokuzai Gakkaishi. 25(1): 1–6.
relaxation in low temperature region. Mokuzai Gakkaishi.
Kellog, R.M. 1981. Physical properties of wood. In: Wan- 42(3): 271–280.
gaard, F.F., ed. Wood: its structure and properties. Clark C.
Suzuki, Y.; Hirai, N.; Ikeda, M. 1992. Piezoelectric relax-
Heritage Memorial Series on Wood. University Park, PA:
ation of wood. I. Effect of wood species and fine structure
The Pennsylvania State University. 195–223. Vol. 1.
on piezoelectric relaxation. Mokuzai Gakkaishi. 38(1):
Knuffel, W. 1988. The piezoelectric effect in structural lum- 20–28.
ber. Part II. The influence of natural defects. Holzforschung.
Suzuki, Y.; Kataoka, Y.; Matsui, H. 2003. Electrical proper-
42(4): 247–252.
ties of composite cyanoethylated pullulan film. Journal of
Knuffel, W.; Pizzi, A. 1986. The piezoelectric effect in Wood Science. 49(1): 100–103.
structural lumber. Holzforschung. 40(3): 157–162.
Kytmanov, A.V. 1967. Piezo-electric properties and shrink-
age of compressed Larch wood. Drevesina, -ee-za scita-i-
plastiki. 72-77. Moscow, USSR.
Lammer, H.J., inventor. 2006 (August 29). Flexible piezo-
electric films. U.S. Patent 7,098,578 B2.
Lin, R.T. 1967. Review of the electrical properties of wood
and cellulose. Forest Products Journal. 17(7): 54–66.
Maeda, H.; Tsuda, H.; Fukuda, E. 1977. Electrical and me-
chanical properties of bamboo and wood with various hy-
drations. Reports on Progress in Polymer Physics in Japan.
20: 739–742.
Nakai, T.; Igushi, N.; Ando, K. 1998. Piezoelectric behavior
of wood under combined compression and vibration stress
I: relation between piezoelectric voltage and microscopic
deformation of Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis Carr.). Journal
of Wood Science. 44: 28–34.
Nakai, T.; Takemura, T. 1993. Piezoelectric behaviors of
wood during compression tests. Mokuzai Gakkaishi.
39(3): 265–270.
Nakai, T.; Yamamoto, H.; Nakao, T.; Hamatake, M. 2005.
Mechanical behavior of the crystalline region of wood and
the piezoelectric response of wood in tension tests. Wood
Science and Technology. 39: 163–168.