2015 ART Diseases
2015 ART Diseases
2015 ART Diseases
DOI: 10.1111/aogs.12799
10 ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15
A. Pinborg et al. Epigenetics and ART
ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15 11
Epigenetics and ART A. Pinborg et al.
Beckwith– Chromosome 11p15.5 1:15 000 Fetal macrosomia, macroglossia, renal anomalies, midline
Wiedemann abdominal wall defects, earlobe creases or ear pits, facial
• Paternal UPD (20–25%) nevus flammeus, neonatal hypoglycemia, and increased
• Methylation defects (50–60%) risk of childhood cancer
• Maternal mutations (5%)
• Translocation/inversion, duplication and
micro-deletions (each <1%)
• Unknown (10–20%)
Silver–Russell Genetically heterogeneous condition, 1: 392 000–1:3000 Intrauterine or postnatal growth retardation, learning
represents a phenotype rather than a disabilities, relative macrocephaly and small triangular
specific disorder face, limb length asymmetry and a variety of minor
Chromosome 7-related and 11p15.5 malformations
Angelman Chromosome 15q11-13 1: 20 000–1:12 000 Severe mental retardation, speech impairment, abnormal
EEG and seizures, often microcephaly, subtle dysmorphic
• Paternal UPD (2–7%) facial features, jerky movements and hand flapping and
• Maternal deletion (70–75%) happy disposition
• Methylation defect (2–5%)
• Point mutations (10%)
• Translocation, inversion (<1%)
• 10% unknown
Prader–Willi Chromosome 15q11-13 1:30 000–1:10 000 Neurodevelopmental disorder with cognitive disabilities,
characteristic facial appearance (narrow temples,
• Maternal UPD (25–35%) elongated face, thin upper lip, prominent nose), low
• Paternal de novo deletion (65–75%) muscle tone, short stature and hyperphagia
• Methylation defect (1–5%)
• Micro-deletions and translocations
(rare/unknown)
UPD, uniparental disomy (e.g. two copies of a chromosome, or of part of a chromosome, from one parent and no copy from the other parent).
12 ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15
A. Pinborg et al. Epigenetics and ART
hypermethylation of the RB1 gene promoter. Only 13% ART procedures per se from the effect of the reproductive
of cases of retinoblastomas are due to an epigenetic disease of the parents is a challenge.
change, hypermethylation of the RB1 gene promoter. As
none of the children conceived by ART expressed this
Fetal environmental conditions and epigenetics
hypermethylation in the retinoblastomas, it is not likely
that any of the tumors were associated with ART concep- While the research on epigenetic programming is mainly
tion (17). based on animal studies, data from the Dutch and Chi-
Studies have reported significant methylation alter- nese famines have shown that fetal environmental condi-
ations in sperm from men with different degrees of male tions can cause epigenetic changes in humans that persist
factor infertility and in oocytes from women undergoing throughout life (20). The epidemiological studies indi-
ovarian stimulation (18). In 2014, Whitelaw et al. (8) cated that children conceived during the Dutch Hunger
studied three imprinted genes/regions with known impli- Winter of 1944–45, experienced persistent detrimental
cations for reproduction. They explored aberrant imprint- health effects such as a higher rate of heart disease later
ing in the small nuclear ribonucleoprotein polypeptide N in life. Children exposed to the famine during the first
(SNRPN) region, which is known to be associated with 10 weeks in utero had lower mean birthweight and
Prader–Willi syndrome and Angelman syndrome. The hypomethylation of the imprinted insulin-like growth fac-
methylation level of SNRPN was associated with the dura- tor 2 (IGF2) gene compared with their unexposed same-
tion of infertility and was significantly higher in children sex siblings. By contrast, children exposed to the famine
conceived by ICSI than by standard IVF and spontaneous at the end of pregnancy showed no difference in methyla-
conception. However, the observed differences in methy- tion compared with their unexposed siblings. Similarly,
lation levels in children conceived by ART compared with studies on Chinese children born during the Great Chi-
spontaneously conceived children were relatively small. nese Famine of 1958–61 have linked prenatal exposure to
In a comprehensive review from 2013, it was estimated famine to an increased risk of diabetes, obesity and
that Beckwith–Wiedemann syndrome was significantly schizophrenia later in life (21). The findings from these
associated with ART with a pooled relative risk of 5.2 inter-generational studies highlight the fact that environ-
[95% confidence interval (CI) 1.6, 7.4]) (19). There were mental exposure during early fetal life may cause long-
too few data on Silver–Russell syndrome to draw a final term health effects even across generations.
conclusion, but the authors stated that a positive associa-
tion with ART was likely, whereas this was not the case
Epigenetic modification and ART
for Angelman syndrome, Prader–Willi syndrome and
retinoblastoma. However, the authors concluded that Animal studies have shown that gametogenesis, fertiliza-
Angelman syndrome and Prader–Willi syndrome may be tion and early embryo development are stages vulnerable
associated with couples having fertility problems (19). to epigenetic dysregulation (22,23). The epigenome is
The conflicting results are most likely due to the small known to be sensitive to environmental changes and to
populations in the reported studies. have the potential to sustainably alter gene expression,
A recent systematic review with a meta-analysis notably during embryonic development (24).
demonstrated an association between children conceived Several animal studies have confirmed that the type of
by ART and imprinting disorders when compared with conditions encountered by the embryo during the pre-
spontaneously conceived children (18). The combined implantation stage may affect the phenotype of the adult,
odds ratio of any imprinting disorder was 3.67 (95% CI and epigenetic modification has been suggested as the
1.39, 9.74), but weighted mean differences of selected possible mechanism (24). Grace and Sinclair showed that
imprinted genes showed no differences in methylation the various steps of the ART procedure in animal studies
levels between children conceived by ART and sponta- affected the epigenome, as superovulation and in vitro
neously conceived children (18). Lazaraviciute et al. con- culture of oocytes caused epigenetic changes in the
cluded that imprinting disorders are more common after embryos and offspring (6). Further in vitro embryo cul-
ART, but the amount of data is both heterogeneous and ture conditions have an established epigenetic effect on
limited, thus more controlled studies with adjustment for cultured embryos in animal models (25) and Horsthemke
the reproductive disease of the couples are needed. Most et al. (7) showed a difference in the methylation patterns
importantly, if such changes in the imprinting epigenetic of various genes associated with the ART process and/or
status in children conceived by ART hold true, the effect the etiology of infertility.
is small (18). Human studies have shown that different ART meth-
In summary, imprinting disorders have been associated ods such as ovarian stimulation and supraphysiological
with ART techniques, but disentangling the effect of the levels of sex steroid hormones, culture media and embryo
ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15 13
Epigenetics and ART A. Pinborg et al.
cryopreservation may be associated with intrauterine Recently, several new ART techniques have been intro-
growth resulting in altered birthweight profiles, which duced, such as prolonged culture time from 2 to 5 days
may be caused by epigenetic modification (4,26,27). (blastocyst culture) and ultra-rapid and effective freezing/
A recent study demonstrated altered gene expression pro- thawing methods (vitrification).
files associated with glucose intolerance in children con- To be able to study the long-term effects of the new
ceived by ART compared with spontaneously conceived techniques, all those working in the field of reproduction
children (28). should aim for national ART registers with high quality
Further, some reports indicate that children conceived registration with linkage between ART treatment and
by ART have an altered lipid profile, fasting glucose, and child outcome.
body fat distribution and cardiovascular function (29,30). The Committee of Nordic ART and Safety (CoNARTaS)
Hence, concern has been raised that children conceived has collected information on all Nordic children conceived
by ART may have a higher risk of developing cardiovas- by ART in one common database including more than
cular disease later in life, which may be related to epige- 90 000 children born from 1982 to 2007 (2). The aim of
netic changes (30). CoNARTaS is to conduct continuous surveillance of chil-
In contrast to singletons conceived after fresh embryo dren conceived by ART in all aspects related to morbidity
transfer, human singletons conceived after frozen embryo and development. This database is highly dependent on
transfer have a higher risk of being large-for-gestational- data from the Nordic national registers, emphasizing the
age or have a birthweight of more than 4500 g at term importance of including cycle-specific information and
(4,27). This phenomenon is also observed in sibling pairs new techniques, which possibly remain the best long-term
where the same mother has given birth to both a single- quality and safety controls of ART methods.
ton conceived after fresh embryo transfer and a singleton
conceived after frozen embryo transfer (4).
Funding
This indicates that embryo manipulations performed
during freezing and thawing may cause changes in the The Nordic Expert group research work was uncondition-
development of the feto-placental unit through epige- ally supported by MSD in Finland, Norway and
netic modification. Whether such early epigenetic alter- Denmark.
ations and changes in intrauterine growth can cause
long-term diseases, such as diabetes and cardiovascular References
diseases later in life, in children conceived by ART is
still unknown. 1. Kupka MS, Ferraretti AP, de Mouzon J, Erb K, D’Hooghe
Whether ART causes changes in the epigenetic pro- T, Castilla JA, et al.; European IVF-Monitoring
gramming can be detected by the measuring DNA methy- Consortium, for the European Society of Human
lation signatures on the whole genome, as presented by Reproduction and Embryology. Assisted reproductive
technology in Europe, 2010: results generated from
Tobi et al. (9). As is the case for (mal) nutrition, compre-
European registers by ESHRE. Hum Reprod.
hensive genome-scale studies of differential methylation
2014;29:2099–113.
following conception by ART are lacking in humans.
2. Henningsen AA, Gissler M, Skjaerven R, Bergh C,
Tiitinen A, Romundstad LB, et al. Trends in
Conclusions perinatal health after assisted reproduction – a Nordic
study from the CoNARTaS group. Hum Reprod.
The association between imprinting disorders and ART is 2015;30:710–6.
still debated; however, if such an association exists, it is 3. Pinborg A, Wennerholm UB, Romundstad LB, Loft A,
weak and at least partly related to the reproductive dis- Aittomaki K, S€ oderstr€om-Anttila V, et al. Why do
ease of the parents. Thus, future research should focus on singletons conceived after assisted reproduction
epigenetic modifications in children conceived by ART technology have adverse perinatal outcome? Systematic
and the long-term morbidity related to these epigenetic review and meta-analysis. Hum Reprod Update.
changes and should be able to adjust for the severity of 2013;19:87–104.
the reproductive disease of the parents. For the safety and 4. Pinborg A, Henningsen AA, Loft A, Malchau SS, Forman
quality surveillance of ART techniques, it is of utmost J, Andersen AN. Large baby syndrome in singletons born
importance that the Nordic ART registries include cycle- after frozen embryo transfer (FET): is it due to maternal
specific parameters, i.e. culture media, duration of cul- factors or the cryotechnique? Hum Reprod. 2014;29:618–
ture, freezing techniques, and additionally demographic 27.
data of the couples including cause and duration of 5. Young LE, Sinclair KD, Wilmut I. Large offspring
infertility. syndrome in cattle and sheep. Rev Reprod. 1998;3:155–63.
14 ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15
A. Pinborg et al. Epigenetics and ART
6. Grace KS, Sinclair KD. Assisted reproductive technology, intracytoplasmic sperm injection? Fertil Steril.
epigenetics, and long-term health: a developmental time 2013;99:642–51.
bomb still ticking. Semin Reprod Med. 2009;27:409–16. 20. Heijmans BT, Tobi EW, Stein AD, Putter H, Blauw GJ,
7. Horsthemke B, Ludwig M. Assisted reproduction: the Susser ES, et al. Persistent epigenetic differences associated
epigenetic perspective. Hum Reprod Update. 2005;11:473– with prenatal exposure to famine in humans. Proc Natl Sci
82. USA. 2008;105:17046–9.
8. Whitelaw N, Bhattacharya S, Hoad G, Horgan GW, 21. Lumey LH, Stein AD, Susser E. Prenatal famine and adult
Hamilton M, Haggarty P. Epigenetic status in the offspring health. Annu Rev Public Health. 2011;23:237–62.
of spontaneous and assisted conception. Hum Reprod. 22. Egger G, Liang G, Aparicio A, Jones PA. Epigenetics in
2014;29:1452–8. human disease and prospects for epigenetic therapy.
9. Tobi EW, Goeman JJ, Monajemi R, Gu H, Putter H, Nature. 2004;27:457–63.
Zhang Y, et al. DNA methylation signatures link prenatal 23. Miranda TB, Jones PA. DNA methylation: the nuts
famine exposure to growth and metabolism. Nat and bolts of repression. J Cell Physiol. 2007;213:
Commun. 2014;26:5592. 384–90.
10. Sasaki H, Matsui Y. Epigenetic events in mammalian 24. El Hajj N, Haaf T. Epigenetic disturbances in in vitro
germ-cell development: reprogramming and beyond. Nat cultured gametes and embryos: implications for
Rev Genet. 2008;9:129–40. human assisted reproduction. Fertil Steril. 2013;99:
11. Inbar-Freigenberg M, Choufani S, Butcher DT, Roifman 632–41.
M, Weksberg R. Basic concepts of epigenetics. Fertil Steril. 25. Market-Velker BA, Fernandes AD, Mann MR. Side-by-side
2013;99:607–15. comparison of five commercial media systems in a mouse
12. Hales BF, Grenier L, Lalancette C, Robaire B. Epigenetic model: suboptimal in vitro culture interferes with imprint
programming: from gametes to blastocyst. Birth Defects maintenance. Biol Reprod. 2010;83:938–50.
Res A Clin Mol Teratol. 2011;91:652–65. 26. Dumoulin JC, Land JA, Van Montfoort AP, Nelissen EC,
13. Hitchins MP, Ward RL. Constitutional (germline) MLH1 Coonen E, Derhaag JG, et al. Effect of in vitro culture of
epimutation as an aetiological mechanism for hereditary human embryos on birthweight of newborns. Hum
non-polyposis colorectal cancer. J Med Genet. Reprod. 2010;25:605–12.
2009;46:793–802. 27. Wennerholm U-B, Henningsen A-KA, Romundstad LB,
14. Available online at: http://www.imprinting-disorders.eu/. Bergh C, Pinborg A, Skjaerven R, et al. Perinatal outcomes
15. DeBaun MR, Niemitz EL, Feinberg AP. Association of of children born after frozen-thawed embryo transfer: a
in vitro fertilization with Beckwith-Wiedemann syndrome Nordic cohort study from the CoNARTaS group. Hum
and epigenetic alterations of LIT1 and H19. Am J Hum Reprod. 2013;28:2545–53.
Genet. 2003;72:156–60. 28. Sakka SD, Margeli A, Loutradis D, Chrousos GP,
16. Moll AC, Imhof SM, Cruysberg JR, Schouten-van Papassotiriou I, Kanaka-Gantenbein C. Gender dimorphic
Meeteren AY, Boers M, van Leeuwen FE. Incidence of increase in RBP-4 and NGAL in children born after IVF:
retinoblastoma in children born after in-vitro fertilisation. an epigenetic phenomenon? Eur J Clinic Invest.
Lancet. 2003;25:309–10. 2013;43:439–48.
17. Dommering CJ, van der Hout AH, Meijers-Heijboer H, 29. Ceelen M, van Weissenbruch MM, Prein J, Smit JJ,
Marees T, Moll AC. IVF and retinoblastoma revisited. Vermeiden JP, Spreeuwenberg M, et al. Growth
Fertil Steril. 2012;97:79–81. during infancy and early childhood in relation to
18. Lazaraviciute G, Krauser M, Bhattacharya S, Haggarty P, blood pressure and body fat measures at age 8–18 years
Bhattacharya S. A systematic review and metaanalysis of of IVF children and spontaneously conceived controls
DNA methylation levels and imprinting disorders in born to subfertile parents. Hum Reprod. 2009;24:
children conceived by IVF/ICSI compared with children 2788–95.
conceived spontaneously. Hum Reprod Update. 30. Scherrer U, Rimoldi SF, Rexhaj E, Stuber T, Duplain H,
2014;20:840–52. Garcin S, et al. Systemic and pulmonary vascular
19. Vermeiden JP, Bernardus RE. Are imprinting disorders dysfunction in children conceived by assisted reproductive
more prevalent after human in vitro fertilization or technologies. Circulation. 2012;125:1890–6.
ª 2015 Nordic Federation of Societies of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica 95 (2016) 10–15 15