Ei Ei Phyu MBF
Ei Ei Phyu MBF
Ei Ei Phyu MBF
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE
MASTER OF BANKING AND FINANCE PROGRAMME
EI EI PHYU
(MBF- 4th BATCH)
DECEMBER, 2018
“Attitude Towards the Use of Mobile Wallet and Mobile
Payment Services in Myanmar”
Supervised by Submitted by
DECEMBER, 2018
ABSTRACT
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would first like to thank Rector Dr Tin Win , programmme director Professor
Daw Soe Thu and advisor Associate Professor Daw Khin New Ohn , whose office
door was always open whenever I ran into a trouble spot or had a question about my
research or writing. She consistently allowed this paper to be my own work, but
steered me in the right the direction whenever she thought I needed it.
Roll No -63
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ABSTRACT i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ii
TABLE OF CONTANT iii
LAST OF TABLE v
LIST OF FIGURES vi
CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION
1.1 Rationale of the Study 1
1.2 Object of Study 2
1.3 Scope and Method of study 2
1.4 Organization of the study 3
iii
CHAPTER IV PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF FIRST
PRIVATE BANK
4.1 Research Design 22
4.2 Analysis of Quality of Management and Operations by 23
CAMEL
4.3 Composite Rating or FIRST PRIVATE BANK’s Score 28
Sheet
CHAPTER V CONCLUSION
5.1 Findings 29
5.2 Other Recommendation 30
REFERENCES
APPENDIX (1)
APPENDIX (2)
iv
LIST OF TABLES
v
LIST OF FIGURES
vi
ABSTRACT
This study intends to identify the mobile wallet services provided by selected
mobile financial services (MFS) License Company in Myanmar and to explore the
attitude on using mobile wallet and mobile payment services. This study focus on the
active customers of the selected sample sized organizations which are OK$ and Wave
Money. In order to fulfill the research objects, both primary and secondary data are used
in this study. For this study, the primary has got from the survey, questionnaires and
interviews from the targeted respondents by using the quota sampling method from the
selected organizations. For the secondary part, the study is focused on the changing from
the traditional banking sector to cashless payment system from the related public sources.
In the finding section, the study is mainly based on the objectives and the data about the
attitude of customers on using mobile wallet services. Because of the ease of use and
convenient, the attitudes of the users are changed and they started feel that the services
are intention to use.
i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First and foremost, I would like to express special thanks to express special thank
and gratitude to the Rector, Prof. Dr. U Tin Win, Yangon University of Economics for
giving me the chance to do this thesis as requirement of master degree.
Secondly, I also wish to express my respectful and thankful to Prof. Dr. Soe Thu,
Head of Department of Commerce and Master of Banking and Finance Programme,
Yangon University of Economics for her valuable guidance and comment to accomplish
this thesis. I also deeply blessing to all my respected professors, lecturers and a cheerful
group of fellow students from student affair who gave valuable lecturers, share
knowledge, kind encouragement and valuable comments and helpful advices, great
supervision and interest from the beginning to the end of my thesis paper.
Finally, my warmest and sincerest to my parents, family and colleagues who are
always supporting me and encouraging me all my studies and contribute towards the
completion of my thesis paper.
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ABSTRACT i
ACKNOWLEDEMENTS ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS iii
LIST OF TABLES v
LIST OF FIGURES vi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS vii
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Rationale of the Study 2
1.2 Objectives of the Study 3
1.3 Scope and Methods of the Study 3
1.4 Organization of the Study 3
iii
4.3 Analysis of Mobile Wallet Service Usage 29
4.4 Analysis of Influencing factor on Mobile Wallet 33
CHAPTER 5 CONCLUSION
5.1 Finding 37
5.2 Suggestion 38
5.3 Limitation and Need for Future Research 39
REFERENCES
iv
LIST OF TABLES
v
LIST OF FIGURES
2.1 Types of mobile payments made using from mobile wallet in 2017 9
vi
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
vii
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Mobile Payment is about the combination of financial services and information
technology. Banks and other financial institutions can be delivered customer services and
other core services such as remittances and funds transferring through the internet rather
than by physically investing the bank premises (Cheung & Lee, 2006). Increasing
knowledge of internet technology has been compelling consumers to use fast and efficient
ways of banking rather than traditional fixed services. (Chang & Hamid, 2010) defined
mobile wallet as the process that customers can complete banking transaction without
going to the banks physically.
Smart phones are started as the important one in the daily lifestyle because of their
developing technology and advance. Originally, mobile phones were intended only to
make voice calls and send text message. Today, mobile phones have many functions so
far that they can provide a wide range of services such as email, social media interface.
Moreover,mobile users can make payment for goods and services by using a personal
mobile device as the transaction terminal and it can manage their financial from mobile
wallet.
Recently, different models of mobile wallet have emerged all around the world
and increased of mobile payments. Currently, they try to take advantage of the repaid
development of mobile phones functionalities, of the large diffusion of this kind of
terminals in all countries and generations of consumers, and of their easy use- at every
hour of the day – inside and outside the areas of Internet access. Two contrasting uses of
mobile payments command attention: cashless payments and mobile transfer payments.
For the cashless payments, the mobile phone is far more efficient that electronic purse: it
saves transaction costs for users and investment costs in specific terminals for
shopkeepers. For mobile transfer payments, mobile wallet offers services without any
need of ATM, banking branch.
1
Viettel of Vietnam and Myanmar firms, was licensed in January 2017. The Central Bank
of Myanmar gave permission to apply technology in mobile financial services not only
the banking sector but also the other sectors like telecommunications and organizations
related with financial services.
In March 2016, the Central Bank of Myanmar issued Mobile Financial Service
License (MFS) to non-bank entities. Now, mobile payment providers can digitally
connect the un-banked in Myanmar and the CBM boosts the financial culture of
Myanmar by changing shift from cash-based to digital economies in the country.
In this thesis, the business network theory applied to study how interaction takes place
within the current development of Mobile Wallets, which are becoming the base of the
mobile payments industry.
Myanmar financial sectors is normally influenced by the cash economy and most
of the traditional bank services users face several issues like long queue and huge crowd
in the banking hall for cash withdraw and deposit. Myanmar’s financial service sector is
the last developed in Southeast Asia and apart from 20 percent of the population,
Myanmar is more preferably on using cash based economy (Frontier, 2016).
The residents have the fear to change from cash based economy to online based
financial services so the licensed organizations introduce easy features in the application
they operated.Main aim of using mobile wallet system for the users to perform financial
activities at home via internet individually.
Mobile financial services license organization that got licenses from Central Bank
of Myanmar are also trying to upgrade and fulfill customers’ requirements to solve daily
financial management via mobiles. Such activities include the Utility bill payment, phone
bill top-up, P2P paymentsand Agent banking, etc. Mobile wallet is the solution for
creating convenience financial services directly to customer. The aims of the thesis are to
2
provide knowledge about mobile financial services for both urban and rural, to manage
both transfers and payments not only in nations but also in internationals and the last is to
reduce inflation by using mobile wallets.
1. To identify the users’ changes in using mobile wallet and services by applying
modernized tools
2. To study the functions and procedures of mobile wallet and mobile payment
services
To identify and analyze the attitude changes in Myanmar, this study is focusing on
the customers’ changes of using from traditional ways to using online based wallet
services. Scope of the study is collected from the 120 customers who are now the active
customers of the selected Mobile Financial Services license organizations which are OK$
and Wave Money in Myanmar. Descriptive method used in this research. Quantitative
and Qualitative analysis applied in this research.
The study employs primary data as well as secondary data. Secondary data was
collected from different published sources; reports, research papers, articles and news
from Internet, Information from Central Bank of Myanmar and Mobile Financial Services
license organization. Primary data was collected by structured survey. The survey was
created and sent to the respondents who are users of OK$ and Wave Money using quota
sampling. The respondents, who were approached email and by hand, were 120.
The research is compromised with the five chapters. Chapter 1 introduced the
research background and the rationale for research. The objectives and aim are also being
included in the Chapter1 by providing an overview of the academic and managerial
contributions of the study. Chapter 2 provides review the literature relevant to Mobile
Wallet and customers’ perception. Chapter 3 identifies the services of mobile banking
3
provided by selected licensed organizations. Chapter 4 describes the analysis of
perception of mobile banking based on the results of the questionnaire. Chapter 5 is the
concluding chapter in which summary of finding are first presented and then conclusion
drawn, relevant suggestions and need for further research are finally made.
4
CHAPTER 2
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
In this chapter, the study is described in the following about the role of mobile
wallet, its history and mobile payment services provided for user behavior intention to
use, trust and security of mobile payment serviceand customer adoption process of
theoretical background.These things are influencing factors on using mobile wallet.
Mobile wallet is developed from a concept called “Digital Wallet”. It dated back
in 1996 when the founder of Digital Wallet, Sam Pitroda, who filed the patent in the
United Sates (Sam Pitroda Patents). He “professed that digital wallet would consist of a
liquid crystal display no much bigger than a regular plastic card, which preferably a
touch-sensitive screen and simple user interface that lets the user flip through the digital
wallet in the same manner he/she flips through a leather wallet’. (Pitroda S., Desai
M.,2010). So far, there has not been yet a proper definition for the world “Mobile Wallet”
written by specific scholars. The mobile wallet was defined as “a software application on
a mobile handset that function as a digital container for payment cards, tickets, loyalty
cards, receipts, vouchers and other items that might be found in a conventional wallet
(GSMA,2012). The mobile wallet enables the user to manage a broad portfolio of mobile
NFC [Near Field Communication] services from many different companies” (GSMA,
2012). In other words, mobile wallet is “formed when your smartphone functions as a
leather wallet; it can have digital coupons, digital money (transaction), digital cards, and
digital receipts, etc. all in your smartphone.
Mobile wallet is a virtual wallet that store payment card information on a mobile
device. Mobile wallets are a convenient way for a user to make in-store payments and can
be used at merchants listed with the mobile wallet service provider. The business-
consumer relationship is swiftly becoming digital. Mobile wallet services changed from
e-commerce, businesses are transforming the way they operate to meet the ever-changing
needs of their clients and increasing use of mobile phones and devices. Companies in the
financial sector are emerging that offer digital platforms and solutions and recognized as
members of the Fintech sector. These emerging companies create disruptive tools and
services that are easily accessible at a low cost. One area of the financial industry that is
5
rife with innovations is the payments sector. Using mobile technology such as
smartphones, tablets, companies and users are adapting to online and offline transactions
using devices such as mobile wallet.
Mobile payment adoption has been varied across markets owing to the differences
in their economies, regulations and banking infrastructure. Geographically, Asia Pacific
(APAC) was the first one to adopt mobile payment, due to the existence of a large,
unbanked, economy, followed by Europe and North America. Though the early mobile
transactions are recorded in the late 1990, the first patent that defined “mobile payment
system” was filed in 2000. In 1997, Coca Cola introduce a few vending machines in
Helsinki that allowed customer to buy their drink through text message. Although small,
this innovative use case is still regarded as the first example of mobile wallet and
introduced the idea of using mobile devices for transactions. In 1999, PayPal was
launched as a money transfer service and it followed by the emergence of mobile wallet
that were used to buy movie tickets, arrange travel, pizza, etc (Prime Index,).
The major player in mobile wallets is Google and Apple. Google launched the
mobile wallet in 2011 and it is the first major company to provide a mobile wallet to
market. In 2012, Apple introduce the Apple’s Passbook, an application that targeted
boarding passes, tickets and coupons instead of actual mobile payments. After launched
Apple’s Passbook, Apple announced their new product namely Apple Pay in 2014
(Angela, Nov.2016). It was soon followed by a flood of such mobile wallet performs
6
andthe prominent ones among those were Microsoft Wallet, Android Pay and Samsung
Pay as well as payment services like PayPal and Venmo.
According to the Statista report (2018) that about of mobile payments usersin
region wide, Asia/Pacific has the largest number of mobile payment users, followed by
Africa and North America. In 2016, Asia/Pacific had 163.6 million users, while there
were 101.3 million users in Africa and 90.7 million in North America. North America
registered the largest growth during 2009-2016 (CAGR of 62.13%), followed by Europe
(35.90%) and Africa (25.37%). (Statista.com,2018)
Mobile wallet service is newly thing for everyone and it is the very first
experience for the residents who are very used to with traditional banking sector. Mobile
wallet service launched in Myanmar in 2016 and most of the user are trying to use like a
physical wallet. Most of the mobile financial service license companies are Bank
Organizations, Mobile Network Organizations in Myanmar. These organizations help the
customers to use the money in anywhere and anytime by providing the wallet application
in the mobile phones. Like buying things from websites and social media platform,
transferring payments, booking tickets, reservation hotels and others are also done with
the wallet from mobile payment. So, mobile payment is the interaction between
customers and business. In Future, mobile wallet is empowered the commerce field an
advantage of mobile payment is that customer won’t pay via cash in Myanmar.
7
2.3 Services of Mobile Wallet
Mobile wallet is a digital form of debit card, credit card, or prepaid card
information on mobile devices used for sending or receiving payment and to do online
money transaction. Mobile wallet can provide an alternative method for physical plastic
card to make quick purchase through mobile apps. They are extremely convenient for
regular payments such as utility bill payments, groceries etc., and has gained wide
popularity in various sectors such as retail, utilities, telecom, and transportation, among
others. Many customers and expect believe that mobile wallet is secure, time saving and
convenience for user.
Mobile wallet is very similar to bank accounts wherein customers can hold the
money in any currency, that can be used later various purpose, such as payments, local or
oversea money transfers, paying utility bills, prepaid cards and so on. Customer can easily
convert the money from one currency in any currency to their intended beneficiaries, both
locally and world-wide mobile wallet services for user are check cash balance and
transaction history, deposit and withdrawal cash, payments for Utility bill, refill phone
bill, online payments for goods and services, Taxi fares payments, Other services
(transportation, loans, charity etc.).
8
Figure 2.1 Types of mobile payments made using from mobile wallet in 2017
Mobile payments use varies by type of activity and with age. In the United State,
64% of the adult person are made the mobile payment transactions, 49% paid a bill and
44% purchase in application or online. A few persons made received loyalty points, P2P
transfer (sent/ received money), paid in-store, paid for parking, taxi and transit, withdraw
money from ATM, paid by text message and transfer money globally. Most of the mobile
wallet user believe that mobile payment to be secure, forgery or loss of data doesn’t occur
from keeping information during electronic payment and can possible to track
information of transaction list.
Mobile wallet is enabling Myanmar people that helps to carry out transaction at
any times and anywhere. Transactions through mobile wallet are compromised with the
account balances and lists of latest transactions, bill payment and fund transfer between
customer’s or another’s accounts. Due to the above facts and bored to use the cash-based
system, the customers would like to use mobile payments so merchants are trying to
adopt in the mobile wallet market. In terms of security, the data of the customers from
mobile device to store at Myanmar financial service security because customers’ trust is
an important issue in the mobile service system. So, MFS license companies are used
biometric mechanism for minimizing the risk.
9
2.4 Mobile Wallet Technology
Mobile wallets are composed of both mobile device and mobile wallet systems.
There is dedicated mobile wallet device which is called the biometric wallet. (David,
2013). All the major mobile platform developer, such as Apple, Google, Microsoft, and
BlackBerry have supported Bluetooth for the last several (Andrew, 2016). Presently there
have further explorations for smartphones with NFC digital wallet capabilities, such as
Samsung series and Google Nexus smart phone utilizing Google’s Android operating
system and Apple’s device utilizing Apple Pay.
Nowadays, the technologies of Mobile Wallets are used One Time Ticket (OTT),
Quick Response Code (QRC), Near Field Communication (NFC) and Secure Element
(SE). One Time Ticket is an open one-time code sent to the receiver, where only the
client or receiver is required to authenticate a transaction (Accumulate AB, 2004). Quick
Response Code (QRC)- A two-dimensional bar code that downloads a web page to into
the consumer’s smartphone when photographed with a mobile tagging app in the phone
(Swedbank AB, 2012). Near Field Communication (NFC) controller and antenna – it is a
wireless technology that enables mobile devices to securely send the consumer’s account
information at the POS terminal at the merchant. The tags associated with consumer
products which are kept at the billing counter are read through contactless technology
(First Data, 2012). Secure elements (SE)- A secure smart card chip which stores and
enable account information handling and it is completely different with the phone
memory card. The information present in the secure element is protected by layers of
security (First Data, 2012). Mobile application provides the users interface for the
consumer to manage accounts and initiate payments from the wallet app in the mobile
device (First Data, 2012).
Apple Pay, Android Pay, Samsung Pay and Capital One Financial institution
wallet are used Near Field Communication (NFC). WeChat Wallet, Starbucks mobile
payment, Chase Pay and Walmart Pay are used Quick Response Code (QRC). Alipay,
Paytm, PayPal, Pay with Amazon and ICIC Pockets are used Digital only and these
online payments are drawn payments from the wallets at merchants. M-Pesa, MTN
Mobile Money, Tigo, Orange Money are used Text based. SMS based payment platform
with mobile phone function both as sending device and POS terminal.
10
In Myanmar emerging market, mobile money products (typically SMS-based) and
QRC based mobile wallets have demonstrated the greatest traction. For consumer
payments at the point of sale (POS), QRC are one of the quickest and most cost-effective
ways for merchants to accept electronic payments. Merchants only need to print the code
on a piece of paper. But as the merchant’s business grows, he or she may consider adding
more functionality—perhaps an POS dongle that attaches to his or her phone or,
eventually, a standalone terminal. By enabling QRC mobile payment acceptance,
payments companies can create opportunities to bring merchants into the card system.
Mobile wallet service is the most suitable one for the mobile lifestyle, offers a
convenient payment transaction method to human’s life. The ability to allow customer to
have more control over the financial situation is one attraction of mobile financial
services (Laukkanen&Lauronen, 2005), as the consumer prefers to act for himself/herself
when dealing with his/her own monetary transactions through the mobile device.
Luakkanen (2005) found that the flexibility of being able to use the service wherever and
whenever the users want enables immediate completion of banking tasks (transferring
money or paying a bill). This would save time and be perceived as convenient and
efficient. Therefore, the characteristics of the service as perceived by the user and
provided by the bank institution and service provider are important factors influencing the
usage of mobile wallet.
11
amongindividuals (Davis, 1989). The model provides the provision to add
externalvariables as the determinants of perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use.
TAM is tailored and designed to explain how external variables likely to influence
an individual’s decision to use the new technology. The aim of this study is to
accessfactors influencing mobile financialservices in mobile wallet users. Mobile wallet
is the new technology especially in thiscontext of developing countries,TAM is
illustrating about the users developed perception of the usefulness and easy to use of
various technologies which lead to the actual usage of the technology. Hence, themodel is
useful in giving the insight on adoption of new technology.
12
For this research, Technology Acceptance Model by David1989 is directly apply
for the analysis. The literature findings have demonstrated that influencing factor on
mobile wallet and focus on the issue of perceived Usefulness, perceived ease of use and
attitude towards use.
Extensive research over the past decade provides confirmation of the significant
effect that ease of use has on perceived usefulness (Agarwal & Prasad, 1999; Davis et al.,
1989; Hu, Chau, Sheng & Tam, 1999; Venkatesh, 1999,2000; Venkatesh& Davis, 1996,
2000; Venkatesh& Morris, 2000). Mobile banking systems must be both easy to learn and
easy to use in order to prevent the using of mobile wallet system. In this study, it is
argued that the mobile wallet ease of use is one of the motivating factors of perceived
usefulness of mobile wallet.
Perceived Usefulness
13
Attitude towardsthe use of Mobile Wallet
14
CHAPTER 3
In this chapter, the study is described about the mobile financial services provided
by MFS licensed-organizations. Before presenting about the nature of MFSlicensed-
organizations, this study focusesmobile financial services and the organization structure
of OK$ Co., Ltd as well as Wave Money Co.,Ltd which is the licensed-organization from
CBM for doing financial services.
In January 2017, the Central Bank of Myanmar cancelled all restrictions on doing
financial services and then the CBM is welcoming all international payment companies in
the market for restraining from controlling the market by local firms. With the aim of
dramatically changing from cash-based to digital economies within the country, CBM
gave the opportunities for all international payment providers can connect the un-banked
in Myanmar.
Mobile Financial Service License companies are needed to follow the CBM rules
and regulation, especially transaction limits and Know Your Customer and Customer Due
15
Diligence (KYC/CDD). For the purpose of AML/CFT requirements, MFS accounts are
categorized into three levels- Level 1 and Level 2 for individuals and Level 3 for
registration. KYC/CDD requirements are required and proper record keeping is necessary
for all account opening. The cumulative transaction limits and maximum balance limits
can vary from time to time by the Central Bank.
Maximum
KYC(Require One Day One Month
Rank Balance
Document) Transaction Transaction
Limit
Sim Card
Registration (or)
Level -2 NRC (first Priority)
500,000 1,250,000 1,000,000
For Personal or Driving license
(Second Priority) or
Passport
Business
Level -3 Registration No.,
1,000,000 25,000,000 10,000,000
For Personal Account No., Other
Documents
Source: CBM Instruction for Mobile Wallet dated on 30th November 2017
16
3.2 Development of Myanmar Mobile Financial Services
The key players of mobile financial services are Banks, MNOs, Regulators,
Payment Service Providers and Agents/Retail Networks. Banks offer banking services
and hold float or account in customers’ names.Banks provide the services such as full
banking relationships and promote the usage of new banking channels with new clients.
(SME, corporate clients). MNOs provide infrastructure and communications services and
acquire clients, super agents. Agents provide cash-in, cash-out and account opening
functions and support customer services, sales and marketing. Payment service provider
(PSPs) provide payment infrastructure and IT platforms. Regulators provide enabling
environment and protect stability of financial system. Regulators are encouraged and
protect behavior change.
Mobile Wallets allow the customer to perform the Utility bill payment, Wages
disbursement, B2B supply chain payments, Mobile commerce, Retailer and Agent
banking. Mobile Wallet can conduct banking transaction from the home 24 hours
comfortably. Because of this factor, mobile wallets’ customers can better manage their
financing and Corporate (or) SME customer enable specific growth opportunities with
corporate and SME clients, generating with banks to get involved and boosting overall
penetration and volume.Customer can register easily for Mobile Wallet from mobile with
NRC, License or Passport.
This section provides the profile information of OK$ Internet Wallet Myanmar
and Wave Money that are now operating and they got trust from customers.
17
(1) Profile of OK$ Internet Wallet Myanmar Company
OK$Internet Wallet Myanmar Limited was founded in January 2017 which was
developed by OK$ Mobile Payment, on the other hands, Mobile Wallet to Myanmar
People as a Service.(Opencorporates, 2017). OK$ Internet Wallet Myanmar Limited is
one of the Group of companies of Consumers Good Myanmar Limited which inaugurated
in Myanmar as a company with multi-subsidiaries that manufacture and sell through our
own distribution centers to all over Myanmar reaching mass consumers base. They have
various kinds of Consumer Products such Coffee Mix, Rice, Sugar etc.Internet Wallet
Myanmar Limited has distribution branch offices in all 14 States and Regions of the
Republic of Union Of Myanmar to serve OK$ to Myanmar people as best service.(CGM,
2017)
In 2018, OK$ has around 1,000,000 mobile wallet users including 200,000
merchant users and 6,000 agent users in all over the Myanmar within 3 years. OK$ wallet
user can make cash in and cash out transaction from their CGM Office (Main Office),
One Stop Mart, OK$ agent shops, Post offices and some banks.
During this year, OK$ Internet Wallet Myanmar create OK TAXI service and Go
Auto ticket mobile applications. OK TAXI services provide transportations for people
18
and Go Auto ticket service provide the bus ticket, train ticket and movie ticket, etc. OK
TAXI and GO Auto ticket wallet user can pay the charges from OK$ wallet.
OK$ mobile wallet services aim to unique convenience when customer use. And
the main function of OK$ is secure and convenient money transaction, payment gateway
(direct pay) and other additional services like phone top up, billing, Bus Ticket, Air
Ticket and Digital Gift Card, movie tickets, share bill with friend, buy commodities, shop
online and do much more.
OK$ offers the customers with lower service price and provide value added
services. In the first year of using their app to do financial services, OK$ won’t be
charged the fees of transferring. After one year of using, they charge about 50% like other
mobile banking charges based on the customers’ using services from the OK$ mobile
app. And then, OK$ create agent network in the most populated cities and states in the
whole Myanmar. OK$ always seek to give the best offers to the customers and to meet
the customers’ satisfactions.
OK$ arranges to include multi functions in their mobile wallet and prepare to use
more conveniently for the customers. However, most of the users prefer to use mobile
top-up and meter bill because OK$ always give discount for mobile top-up and free of
Charge for meter bill payment. They maintain and attract their consumers by promoting
discount program and promotion program to pursue for using mobile wallet with the aim
of growing financial knowledge in Myanmar.
The following features are general internet banking services provided by OK$ wallet.
1. Account Register
2. Cashless Payment
3. Balance Inquiry
4. Bus Ticket Fees Payment
5. Cash In/ Cash Out from Bank Account
6. Gift Card
7. Cash In/ Cash Our at Agent
8. Bill Payment
9. Merchant Payment
19
10. Phone bill top-up
11. Request Money
12. Promotion
13. Agent Location
Wave Money was the first company in Myanmar to receive MFS license from the
Central Bank and has been in operation since 2016. Wave Money is a joint venture
between Telenor and Yoma Bank to provide accessible, safe and convenient mobile
financial services via a nationwide agent network or via a wave account on phone.
Telenor Group is one of the world’s major mobile operators with 192 million mobile
20
subscriptions across 13 countries. Yoma Bank is an innovative and leading private bank,
operating since 1993, with more than 3,000 employees and 63 branches across Myanmar.
Wave Money has Vision that empower Myanmar people with the freedom
to manage their money the way they most prefer. Wave Money has Mission that provide
reliable, simple, affordable, and trustworthy financial services which can be conveniently
accessed via mobile phones and our extensive agent network. Wave Money promises to
customers that Wave Money allows customer to transfer money quickly, safely and
conveniently throughout Myanmar, freeing you from the hassles and worries of
traditional methods.
In 2018, Wave Money has around 1,300,000 mobile wallet users and operate with
over 24,000 wave shops cross in all over the Myanmar. Wave Money provides easy, fast
and reliable mobile financial services through a nationwide agent network. Wave Money
introduce a unique way of transferring money, brining millions of people in Myanmar
access to formal financial services. Thousands of people can transfer money via Wave
Money mobile wallet and the agents anywhere at any times. The Wave Money arranges
the 24/7 call center which the customers can call and can complain the errors all day long.
(wave Money, 2018).
Wave Money wallet is an innovative way to transfer money. Wave Money wallet
user can transfer money anywhere anytime. Wave Money wallet user can transfer money
safely through their mobile phone or from one neighborhood Wave Shop agents. Wave
Money offers customer instant, safe and convenient way of sending and receiving money,
bringing financial inclusion to all.
The following features are general internet banking services provided by Wave Money.
1. Account Registration
2. Pay
3. History
4. Cash In
5. Wave Account Balance
6. Mobile Top-up
7. Bill
8. Donation
21
9. Bus Ticket Payment
Everyone can available registration by themselves via online. There are no fees
for account registration. Pay function allows customer to send money from Wave
Account to Wave account and non-account holder (NRC, phone number) using phone
anywhere, anytime. All transactions are secured by secret pin number. History feature
allows to customer check their account balance. Wave wallet user can visit any of the
thousands of Wave Money shops to Cash-in into Wave Account with Wave account
number or receiver’s mobile phone number. Confirmation message sent one transaction is
completed. And then, cash in feature allows customer to transfer money from some
mobile wallet by banks (Yoma, CB, KBZ). Mobile top-up function allows to customer
top-up their phone easily. Donation feature allows to customer make donate some charity
firm on mobile wallet. Bus ticket payment feature allow to customer pay for bus ticket
that no need to go bus station.
22
expand user network in Myanmar. Wave Money generate revenue through small fees for
taking cash out of the network, as well as by reselling phone top-up for Telenor. Wave
Money wants to become a broader financial services company (DIGFIN, 2017)
OK$ and Wave Money are the pioneers for money transfer in Myanmar and is
now settled as a top-of-mind brand in the country. They create their mobile wallet is easy
to use and stylish. The verification process via SMS goes on automatically and you can
quickly navigate through the app. They help to people change from cash base to card and
banking base to mobile payment system base that is secure, safe a convincing payment.
23
CHAPTER 4
ANALYSIS OF ADOPTION ON MOBILE WALLET AND MOBILE
PAYMENT SERVICES IN MYANMAR
This Chapter analyses the attitude changes of customers in using Mobile Wallet
and Mobile Payment services provided by selected Mobile Financial Services licensed
organization based on their response to questionnaires which designed to explore their
adoption. The study is chosen 120 respondents who are users of selected local mobile
financial services organization (OK$ and Wave Money) are interviewed by using the
structured questionnaires attached in Appendix.
This study analyzed the customer adoption on mobile wallet and mobile payment
services and identifies the factor affecting the usage of mobile wallet services in
Myanmar. Moreover, the study is also focusing on the changes of customer attitudes in
using mobile wallet services despite of the traditional ways. To know the detail reasons
and procedures, the study is collected information by using quota sampling method.
To support this study, the required information was collected via survey. As a
survey instrument, a structured questionnaire was used. The questionnaires instrument
includes three sections. First section is compromised with the respondents’ demographic
characteristics such as gender, age, marital status, occupation, income and education level
and average monthly income. The second section included the customer thoughts and
using attitudes about mobile wallet. In the last section is concerned with the main
effective factors of mobile wallets such as perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness and
attitude to use of mobile wallets.
As a sampling method, the quota sampling was employed in this study which used
in this research paper to approach the respondents and collect the data on time and also to
avoid low response rate. In the process of sampling, the 120 questionnaires are distributed
by hand and email to customer and enough time given to respondents to fill the
questionnaire to reduce the error.
After receiving the raw data from 120 respondents, the study evaluated the
investigated information based on the data got from respondents. Statistical Package for
24
Social Science (SPSS) version 22 is used to analyze the data through statistical instrument
for this research particularly, descriptive analysis. Finally, these analyses are discussed in
term of customer attitude towards the use of mobile wallet in Myanmar.
The respondents are not only males, but also females. Table (4.1)show the gender
of respondents.
Male 58 48.3
Female 62 51.7
25
between 18 and 25 years, between 26 to 35 years, between 36 to 50 years and above 50
years. Table (4.2)respectively show the frequency distribution of age in year.
18-25 12 10.0
26-35 83 69.2
36-50 23 19.2
Above 50 2 1.7
Total 120 100.0
Source: Survey Data, 2018
According to the observation, 83 respondents fall in the age group between 26 and
35 years, followed by 23 respondents fall between 36 and 50 years, 12 respondents fall
between 18 and 25 years, 2 respondents fall 50 years and above, respectively. In terms of
percentage share the age group between 26 and 33 years has highest percentage share
with 69.2% and the age group 50 years and above has lowest percentage share with 1.7%.
Most of the respondents for the question is between 26-35 years old so it means that most
employee have more interest in using in mobile wallets than other ages. Therefore, about
69% respondent prefer to use mobile wallet service that is the highest percentage who has
age limit between 26 and 35 years are more aware to use mobile wallet.
The study compromised with three main sections for this questionnaire.There are
three categories for educational status in questionnaire: Undergraduate, Graduate,
Master/PhD. These are expressed in Table (4.3).
Undergraduate 3 2.5
Graduate 76 63.3
Master/PhD 41 34.2
Basically, the occupational statuses are classified by four types which are student,
government staff, company staff and self-employed person. In this study, the occupational
statuses of sample customers are found in Table (4.4).
Student 6 5.0
Government Staff 17 14.2
Company Staff 81 67.5
Self employed 16 13.3
Total 120 100.0
Source: Survey Data, 2018
From Table (4.4), 67.5 percent of the sampled customers are company staffs who
prefer to use mobile wallet service that is the highest percentage of using mobile wallet
and follow 14 percent are government staff, 13.3 percent are self-employed and
remaining 5 percent are student. The majority of customer is company staffs.
Income is one of the important and sensitive demographic variables. This group is
classified by five categories, according to survey on the basic Income level and found the
most of mobile wallet’s customer are having income amount between MMK 300,001-
500,000 and MMK 500,001- 1000,000 per month and which is contributed to about 32%
of the total. In other words, if can also that most of customers are between MMK
300,001- 500,000 and MMK 500,001- 1000,000 income status.
27
Table 4.5 Number of Respondent by Income Level
There are three types of bank account of respondents mostly used banking
services in Myanmar. The mobile wallet customers are used Saving account, Current
account and Card account. Table (4.6) show the respondent most commonly use bank
account on the survey result.
28
(g ) Number of Respondent by Banking Services Channel Usage
There are four channels of respondents mostly used banking services in Myanmar.
They are branch, ATM/POS, mobile Banking/internet banking, E-commerce. Table (4.7)
show the respondent mostly use banking channel based on survey results.
Branch 47 39.2
ATM/POS 27 22.5
E-commerce 3 2.5
According to Table (4.7), the 47 customers out of sample 120 use the branch
banking channel with 39.2% of the total sample. The 43 customers out of sample 120 use
the mobile banking channel with 35.8%, 27 customers out of sample 120 use the
ATM/POS channel with 22.5% and 3 customers out of sample 120 use the e-commerce
channel with 2.5%. Therefore, it can be seen that 47 respondents mostly use the branch
banking.
In this section, the study is investigated mobile wallet users’ thoughts and habits
using mobile wallet service. This section presents the most commonly use of mobile
wallet between OK$ and Wave Money, the most commonly used mobile wallet
services,duration of usage of mobile wallet, frequency of the usage of mobile wallet,
reasons using to mobile wallet in OK$ and Wave Money.
When asked to respondents about the mobile wallet service they are processing at
agent shop. Respondents could choose only one mobile wallet which they really used
29
most of the mobile wallet services for this question. The two mobile wallets namely OK$
and Wave Money are selected in this study. Results are shown in the following Table
(4.8).
OK$ 58 48.3
There are many services of mobile wallet. In this study, according to respondents
answer, these services are divided by six categories. There are shown in the following
Table (4.9).
M-Commerce 4 3.3
30
Table (4.9) show that the most frequently used transactions at the mobile wallet by
the customers. As a result, 44 respondents out of 120 sample size preferred the internet
banking in order to transfer money from one person to another person. And then, 41
respondents are using mobile wallet for phone bill top-up. The lowest amount of choosing
M-commerce (online shopping via wallet) was only 4 respondents out of 120 sample size.
Based on the figure, the study is assumed that most the respondents are more prefer of
using two main functions: transferring money from account to account and phone bill top-
up.
The duration of the usage the mobile wallet is divided by three categories in the
questionnaire: less than 1 year, between 1 to 3 years and 3 years above. The respondent’s
duration of the usage the mobile wallet is shown in the following Table (4.10).
31
Table 4.11 Frequency of the Usage of Mobile Wallet
Table (4.12) are show that 120 respondents are using the mobile wallet and they
answered reason to use. Respondents were allowed to choose only one option for this
question.
According to the results, their reasons for using the mobile wallet services
respectively; 37% time saving, 32% ease of use, 29% make transaction 24hrs availability
and 2% be security. The main reason to use the mobile wallet services are firstly time
saving and secondly 24hrs services and ease of use.
32
4.4 Analysis of attitude towards the use of mobile wallet and mobile payment
services in Myanmar
The respondents were asked to express their degree of agreement against each
question. This question is separated three parts, which is including for Perceived Ease of
Use, Perceived Usefulness and Attitude. The results are shown in following Table (4.13).
Standard
No. Statement Mean
Deviation
33
mean and standard deviation is within 1.114 to 1.145 so the users are prefer to use and
can accept these are modernized, ease and reduced time consuming.
Standard
No. Statement Mean
Deviation
34
deviation is under 1.137 so the little amount of the users agreed about the improvement of
financial knowledge, safer than other channels of banking. Therefore, it can consider that
all variables in Usefulness are as agree level.
Standard
No. Statement Mean
Deviation
35
1.151 to 1.053 so the users’ attitudes on the mobile wallets are interested, feels it is easy
to understand and the functions are clear. The lowest mean of the sentence: Learning to
use Mobile Wallet won’t be difficult for me has about 3.37 and the standard deviation is
1.214 so that most of the users tried to absorb quickly about the procedures of mobile
wallets and they took time about learning how to use mobile wallets. Therefore, it can
consider that all variables in Attitude to use mobile wallet are as agree level.
36
CHAPTER5
CONCLUSION
In this chapter of research, the study compromised with three main sections:
findings, suggestions and need for further research. In the first part, this study finds and
make the research from other papers, analysis and then, customers’ opinions on the
internet banking. In the second part, it includes the recommendations that are from the
results of the research findings. In the last part, the studysummarizes about the facts from
the last two part and further research.
The research is mainly focusing on the customers’ attitude on the using of mobile
wallets by local unbanked organizations in Myanmar. Firstly, the study analyzed about
the processes and procedures of mobile wallet services and the study is analyzed which
things areuseful in changing process from traditional financial services to digital financial
system as the second one.
To reach the main objectives of the research and to avoid bias of analyzing, the
study is made the required data through sample survey by collecting. The total of 120
respondents who are already being customers of OK$ and Wave Money were surveyed to
represent the customers ‘perception. Age level, gender level, education level, types of
company, income level are assumed as the demographic factors.
The mobile wallet which is the integrated and updated one and it can manage the
human beings’ daily financial management in their everyday life. First of all, the research
is mainly focused on the changing the culture and influencing factor which are so used to
in Myanmar’s people. As the study previously described, the traditional way of managing
financial services via banks are time consuming and waiting of long queue makes the
higher dissatisfaction of the customers. According to the analysis, Myanmar people is
now more prefer to use the cashless payment system than the traditional way of using
cash payment.
By reviewing on survey data regards with the customers’ attitude, the customers’
attitude level is above score 3 because of their ease of using and the mobile wallets are
more useful for everybody who is started to use or interest to use. The customers can use
mobile wallets not only for the banking functions but also for the managing daily personal
37
operations. Based on the analysis, middle age and young people are interested in using
mobile wallets and they think that the functions inside the wallet are attracted and easy to
use. Last 2 year ago, the customers are started interesting in using mobile wallet because
their features are like banks including account to account transfer, phone bill, buying
tickets online and etc. in Myanmar. Mobile wallet users are mostly interesting to use
money transfer and mobile top-up function.
5.2 Suggestions
The critical point of using mobile wallet service is that how to attract the
customers by offering attractive promotions for the users. It is the most important part of
improving mobile wallet service in Myanmar. People in the country is needed to try
familiar with the cashless payment system which can be used in buying things, meter
bills, transferring money and etc. Mobile wallets have better features than the banking
sectors so the study is wanted to suggest that people who can use the modernized mobile
phones should try to use the mobile wallets in their daily life style.
Due to findings, the following suggestions has been proposed to the mobile
financial sector for improving the mobile wallet services in alignment with the attitudes
of respondents: the mobile wallet developers need to arrange the knowledge sharing
section of using mobile wallets, the features including in an application is also easy to
use, the advantages of using mobile wallets and etc. It is better when the study searches
more information from other people’ literature reviews and researchers. In the surveying
process, there should be prepared more comprehensive surveying questions with more
participants and more wide area focus not only the Yangon but also including other cities
which the users are staying. The research is aimed to improve the respondents’ attitudes
on using mobile wallets and to grow up the platform of improving the mobile wallets
which is the one of cashless payment systems in Myanmar than previous.
38
5.3 Limitation and Need for Further Research
The current research is only focusing on the two of the mobile wallets which are
developed in Myanmar and this study could not make analysis and surveys in depth
because of short time frame. The research is only selected 120 respondents from OK$ and
Wave Money which are the active users located in Myanmar. If this study is getting
enough time framework, the study can make more analysis like the condition of using
traditional banking sector, current condition of Myanmar financial services and using
mobile wallets.
Therefore, the research was analyzed and only focused on the attitude towards the
use of mobile wallets and also the survey is based on the attitude factors. So, the next
paper should be more focus on the life cycle of changing traditional methods of using
cash to cashless payment system in the further research.
39
Survey on Mobile Wallet Services
Personal Information
1.Gender
o Male
o Female
2.Age
o 18-25
o 26-35
o 36-50
o Above 50
3.Education Status
o Undergraduate
o Graduate
o Master/ PhD
4.Profession
o Student
o Government Staff
o Company Staff
o Self employed
5.Monthly Income
o Below MMK 100,000
o MMK 100,000 – 300,0000
o MMK 300,001 – 500,000
o MMK 500,001 – 1,000,000
o Above MMK -1,000,000
10.How many years have you been using for the Mobile Wallet?
11.On average, how frequently have you used Mobile Wallet over the past 6
months?
12.Which one in the following is encouraged you to use the Mobile Wallet service?
o Ease of use
o Time Saving
o 24hrs availability
o Security
Part C
The following set of statements indicate the Mobile Wallet Payment in terms of
usefulness, ease of use, and attitude. Please indicate your agreement or disagreement with
the statements reflecting your own perceptions about the payments through mobile wallet
on the following scale (1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 = Disagree, 3 = Neutral,
13. The usefulness of Mobile Wallet can be improved the financial knowledge of
human beings.
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
15. The convenience of using Mobile Wallet service is clearer and more
understandable.
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
18. Mobile Wallet can manage the financial functions more smoothly.
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
21. Mobile Wallet service is the modernized one which can handle the payments
easier.
5 4 3 2 1
22. Using Mobile Wallets can save the transaction handling fees in performing
banking transaction. (Bank, ATM).
5 4 3 2 1
5 4 3 2 1
24. Using mobile wallet can reduce the time consuming to go banks.
5 4 3 2 1
25. Some users aren’t afraid of making mistake in the Mobile Wallet services.
5 4 3 2 1
26. The functions in the Mobile Wallet are easy to learn and understand for users.
5 4 3 2 1
27. Less cost and saving time of Mobile Wallet is more comfortable for users.
5 4 3 2 1
28. It can support the Financial industrial growth and efficiency of cash
management.
5 4 3 2 1
29. As a user, Mobile Wallet is aimed to use also in the future because of their easy
and comfortable functions.
5 4 3 2 1