How Curitiba's BRT stations sparked a

transport revolution – a history of cities in 50

Curitiba’s 357 tube-shaped stations serve the city’s bus rapid transit system. Photograph:
Rodolfo Buhrer/Fotoarena/Corbis
Cities is supported by

About this content






Shares

2,104

Comments

34

Drew Reed

Tuesday 26 May 2015 12.48 BST Last modified on Thursday 4 June 2015 10.01 BST

Rua Padre Anchieta, as one of the main thoroughfares in Curitiba, Brazil, is a logical focal point
for the city’s bus network. But whereas bus stops in many other cities consist of little more than
a sign and perhaps a bench, the ones on Rua Padre Anchieta are a bit different. In the middle of
the street sit two tube-shaped stations, raised from ground level and protected from the elements,
that open on to two-way express lanes. These lanes are reserved for long orange buses, which zip
past slower car traffic and quickly shuttle passengers on and off at the stations on outward-
folding ramps. Stations like this now exist throughout the city and metropolitan area.
Though difficult to imagine, these distinctive stations that are now the symbol of the city were
originally a cost-cutting measure. Implemented as a practical way for the city to create faster
mass transit without breaking the bank, they would go on to revolutionise transport, not just in
Curitiba but in cities around the world.

For much of its existence, Curitiba was a sleepy town eclipsed by São Paulo, its much larger
neighbour to the north-east. But by 1960, the city’s population was beginning to grow
significantly and within 20 years it had surged from 120,000 people to 361,000. Planners began
wondering how to cope with this growth, and initially, there were plans to make the city more
like Brasilia, the nation’s newly built capital. Avenues were to be widened and the city centre
was to be adapted so that cars could become the primary mode of transport.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest

However, these plans would be cut short when Curitiban architect Jaime Lerner, then in his early
thirties, took office as mayor in 1971. Under the dictatorship ruling Brazil in the late 1960s, the
local governor selected Lerner as mayor, confident that the young architect wouldn’t challenge
his political order.

Advertisement

Lerner immediately began to shake things up. His vision for Curitiba turned the conventional
urban planning at play in Brasilia on its head. Instead of widening avenues, he created a
pedestrian mall in the city centre. And rather than turning frequently flooding arroyos into
concrete drainage canals, he dammed the small streams to create parks, which would close
during floods. But his most memorable contribution came in his ideas for the city’s bus network.

Realising the importance of mass transit, planners called for the creation of subway lines, as well
as widened streets for cars – but construction would be costly and could take decades to
complete.

Instead, Lerner saw an opportunity in the one form of transport that many considered a lost
cause: the bus. His idea was to devise a system that gave buses as many of the functional
advantages of urban train systems as possible. He proposed to integrate dedicated bus lanes
along the city’s main arteries, with stations placed on medians along the routes. This would
allow buses to run at speeds comparable to light rail, while dramatically reducing the cost.

A savvy deal-maker, Lerner made a bargain with private bus operators to pay for the creation of
the new infrastructure, while they would provide the vehicles in exchange. With this trade-off in
place, the first rapid bus lanes of Curitiba ended up costing 50 times less than rail.
Facebook Twitter Pinterest
Curitiba’s population has now swelled to over 1.8 million people – more than four times what it
was when the BRT system first opened. Photograph: Getty Images/Flickr RF/EduardoPA

Though the system wasn’t an instant success after the opening of the first line in 1974, it
gradually worked its way into the livelihoods of residents. In 1979, Lerner created the Rede
Integrada de Transporte (Integrated Transport Network) to better manage the system and, as new
routes were added, it began to show its full potential. By 1993, it was carrying 1.5 million
passengers a day.

But high ridership created a problem. Buses in the system still used conventional boarding
systems, where passengers entered through the front of the bus and paid fares on board. Lerner,
who was back in office for his third term as mayor, came up with an elegant solution.

He called for a revamped station design that enabled faster boarding through multiple doors, and
fares would be exchanged before entering the station – similar to subway or light-rail systems.
Offboard payment would also allow for the creation of transfer stations, meaning one fare would
cover the entire system. To top it off, Lerner gave the stations a distinctive look by placing them
in futuristic glass tubes. These new “tube stations” debuted in October 1991 as part of the first
Ligeirinho express line. Today there are 357 tube stations throughout the city.

With this important addition, the city’s system became the world’s first bus rapid transit (BRT)
network. “Curitiba was the first to include the essential elements necessary for a BRT system to
function effectively,” says Andrés Fingeret, director of the Institute for Transportation and
Development Policy in Buenos Aires.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest

The success of Curitiba’s BRT, which had mostly gone unnoticed elsewhere, began to attract
attention from other cities in Latin America. BRT would be soon be given the chance to prove
itself on a much larger scale in Bogotá, Colombia, a city of 8 million people. There, mayor
Enrique Peñalosa seized on the concept as a way to solve the crippling traffic problems of his
city. After taking office in 1998 he borrowed and added to many of the system’s concepts to
build a viable BRT network, the Transmilenio. The stations, which feature many of the key
functional elements of Curitiba’s, contributed to its success.
From there, BRT’s success continued to grow, spreading as far as the United States, South Africa
and China. However, Latin America continues to have a special relationship with BRT, where
the systems carry more people than in any other region in the world. “Due to the similar
language and cultural context, it was easier for the success of BRT in Curitiba to be replicated
elsewhere in Latin America,” says Fingeret.

But as BRT took off internationally, it began to face problems back in Curitiba. Though ridership
remained among the highest in the world for BRT, a 2012 article in CityLab reported that it was
declining with respect to previous years, while car usage climbed. Curitiba newspaper Gazeta do
Povo has noted that the stations did a poor job protecting passengers from extreme temperatures,
and in some cases were inefficient at keeping out rainwater.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest

In addition, Curitiba’s population has now swelled to over 1.8 million people – more than four
times what it was when the BRT system first opened. Mobility remains an issue in the city and,
despite BRT’s success, the city has made initial plans for the creation of a subway system – a
form of transport Lerner called “a thing of the past” and did his best to avoid.

One other potential solution now being considered in Curitiba is the bicycle. Unlike other cities
known for sustainability, Curitiba is only recently beginning to take cycling seriously. After two
decades of hardly any new plans for cycling, a 2012 bicycle masterplan called for the creation of
400km of new lanes.

Fortunately, the bus system may be an asset toward these efforts. “The BRT system and cycling
can and should work together to provide better mobility options for the city,” says Alexandre
Costa Nascimento, editor of the Curitiba cycling blog Ir e Vir de Bike. Though critical of the
implementation of the city’s current bike masterplan, he notes: “Planners should consider
integration programmes such as bike racks, bike parking and fare incentives.”

Despite these lingering issues, BRT in Curitiba has become a cultural touchstone, the city’s
answer to the freewheeling carnival spirit of Rio and the fast-paced, business-dominated lifestyle
in São Paulo. The city’s ministry of culture has set up the Tuboteca, a book exchange
programme, in the city’s bus stations. And, as if to remove any doubt as to their status as this
city’s symbol, Curitiba’s airport gift shop is built in the shape of a life-size BRT station.