2021 Article 1394
2021 Article 1394
2021 Article 1394
Midbrain dopamine neurons deteriorate in Parkinson’s disease (PD) that is a progressive neurodegenerative movement disorder.
No cure is available that would stop the dopaminergic decline or restore function of injured neurons in PD. Neurotrophic factors
(NTFs), e.g., glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) are small, secreted proteins that promote neuron survival during
mammalian development and regulate adult neuronal plasticity, and they are studied as potential therapeutic agents for the
treatment of neurodegenerative diseases. However, results from clinical trials of GDNF and related NTF neurturin (NRTN) in PD have
been modest so far. In this review, we focus on cerebral dopamine neurotrophic factor (CDNF), an unconventional neurotrophic
protein. CDNF delivered to the brain parenchyma protects and restores dopamine neurons in animal models of PD. In a recent
Phase I-II clinical trial CDNF was found safe and well tolerated. CDNF deletion in mice led to age-dependent functional changes in
the brain dopaminergic system and loss of enteric neurons resulting in slower gastrointestinal motility. These defects in Cdnf−/−
1234567890();,:
mice intriguingly resemble deficiencies observed in early stage PD. Different from classical NTFs, CDNF can function both as an
extracellular trophic factor and as an intracellular, endoplasmic reticulum (ER) luminal protein that protects neurons and other cell
types against ER stress. Similarly to the homologous mesencephalic astrocyte-derived neurotrophic factor (MANF), CDNF is able to
regulate ER stress-induced unfolded protein response (UPR) signaling and promote protein homeostasis in the ER. Since ER stress is
thought to be one of the pathophysiological mechanisms contributing to the dopaminergic degeneration in PD, CDNF, and its
small-molecule derivatives that are under development may provide useful tools for experimental medicine and future therapies
for the treatment of PD and other neurodegenerative protein-misfolding diseases.
INTRODUCTION [8, 9]. Lewy body pathology can be widespread in the central
Increased life expectancy and a growing aging population are nervous system (CNS) as well as in the peripheral nervous
leading to an increase in the incidence of age-related diseases, system (PNS) including the enteric nervous system (ENS) [10]. The
including Parkinson’s disease (PD) which affects 1% of population non-motor symptoms of PD can be related to the dysfunction
over 60 years of age [1], and with more than 6 million people of DA and other neurotransmitter systems, such as the
diagnosed with PD globally [2]. PD is a progressing neurodegen- noradrenergic and cholinergic systems [4]. However, the neuro-
erative movement disorder, in which midbrain dopamine (DA) pathological mechanisms behind the non-motor symptoms are
neurons in the substantia nigra (SN) degenerate and die. Major largely unknown.
motor symptoms of PD are slowness of movement, resting tremor, Treatments are available that can improve motor symptoms of
rigidity, and postural instability that appear when there is about PD in most patients, but no disease-modifying therapy exists.
30% loss of DA neurons in the SN and 50–60% reduction in striatal Future therapies should include interventions that slow down or
DA axon terminals [3]. Patients with PD also suffer from non-motor prevent the degeneration and death of DA neurons, regenerate
symptoms, including constipation, hyposmia, depression, lack of the remaining DA neurons and increase their functional activity.
motivation, sleep disorders, and cognitive decline that signifi- They should also alleviate non-motor symptoms of PD. Neuro-
cantly decrease quality of life [4, 5]. trophic factors (NTFs) hold great promise as drugs that could
Although a few toxins and genetic mutations are known to promote neuroprotection of DA neurons, and even have the
cause PD, the etiology is unknown in majority of cases. While capacity to regenerate them. NTFs are small, secreted proteins
precise mechanisms of DA neuron death are unclear, increasing that promote neuronal survival, regulate development, function
body of evidence suggests that protein aggregation, mitochon- and maintenance of neurons, and advance neuronal recovery
drial dysfunction, inflammation, and reduced growth factor levels from injury [5, 11, 12]. Glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor
are involved in the molecular pathogenesis of PD [6, 7]. (GDNF) family ligands (GFLs) GDNF (Figs. 1C, D and 3A) and NRTN
Aggregation of misfolded α-synuclein (αSyn), a major component have been shown to be efficient in protecting DA neurons in
of intraneuronal Lewy bodies, may possibly cause endoplasmic rodent and non-human primate (NHP) models of PD, but have
reticulum (ER) stress in DA neurons leading to neuronal death only shown modest effects in Phase II clinical trials in PD patients
Institute of Biotechnology, Helsinki Institute of Life Science, University of Helsinki, FI-00014 Helsinki, Finland. ✉email: mart.saarma@helsinki.fi
1
condition where protein-folding capacity of the ER is over- interaction with BiP was not required for its neuroprotective
whelmed resulting in accumulation of unfolded proteins in the activity [63]. Further studies demonstrated that MANF directly
lumen. It can be due to various physiological and pathological binds to the luminal domain of IRE1α [65]. MANF binding
conditions, including increased demand of protein secretion, decreased ER stress-induced oligomerization and phosphorylation
synthesis of mutant proteins, hypoxia, nutrient deprivation, or of IRE1α, leading to attenuation of UPR [65]. Under homeostatic
depletion of ER calcium. To overcome ER stress, an adaptive signal conditions, BiP binds to the luminal domain of IRE1α, PERK, and
transduction pathway termed the unfolded protein response ATF6 keeping them inactive, whereas in ER stress BiP is dissociated
(UPR) is activated to restore ER protein homeostasis by increasing triggering the activation of UPR sensors [41]. MANF was shown to
expression of chaperones to improve protein folding capacity, to compete with BiP for the interaction with IRE1α suggesting that
attenuate translation to reduce protein folding load, and to MANF is able to bind and regulate IRE1α activity only when BiP is
enhance ER-associated protein degradation (ERAD) to remove dissociated, as is the case in ER stress [65]. Thus, IRE1α could act as
misfolded proteins [41]. Three ER transmembrane proteins MANF receptor in the ER and MANF, by moderating IRE1α activity
inositol-requiring enzyme 1α (IRE1α; also known as ERN1), protein could promote cell survival during ER stress [65] (Fig. 2B). The
kinase R-like ER kinase (PERK; also known as EIF2AK3) and biological function of MANF in regulating ER protein homeostasis
activating transcription factor 6 (ATF6) function as sensors for was further supported by protein–protein interaction studies
disturbances in ER protein homeostasis in mammalian cells, and suggesting that MANF is a member of a large multiprotein
their activation induces UPR signaling [41–44] (Fig. 2A). If recovery complex of ER chaperones [63]. A recent report demonstrated that
of ER homeostasis fails, UPR can become chronic leading to MANF can function as a chaperone in the ER, although it does not
apoptosis [45]. UPR has been associated with pathophysiology of show structural or sequence homologies to known chaperone
several neurodegenerative protein-misfolding diseases, including families [66].
PD [46–48]. In ER stress-related disease models in vivo, expression of
Based on the structural homology between CDNF and MANF, endogenous CDNF was reported to increase after cerebral or
we can hypothesize that their molecular mechanism of cytopro- myocardial ischemia [67, 68]. In vitro, ER stress-inducing tunica-
tective action has some similar features. Both CDNF and MANF are mycin treatment increased CDNF expression in cardiomyocytes
widely expressed in mammalian tissues although with differential [69] but not in an osteosarcoma-derived cell line [58]. Thus,
levels [20, 49, 50] suggesting tissue-specific functions. The MANF responsiveness of CDNF to ER stress may depend on cell type.
promoter contains ER stress response elements recognized by However, intracellular CDNF was cytoprotective against ER stress
UPR-induced transcription factors [39, 51, 52] and its expression is and able to regulate UPR. Overexpression of CDNF alleviated ER
increased in ER stress-related conditions [39, 53–55]. Biological stress-induced astrocyte damage, and attenuated the expression
importance of endogenous MANF for the maintenance of ER of ER stress-induced apoptotic proteins in neurons [70, 71]. What is
protein homeostasis was demonstrated in conventional and more, CDNF overexpression may induce a mild adaptive
pancreas-specific MANF knockout mice, where chronic UPR conditioning UPR that prepares cells to encounter ER stress and
activation contributes to the loss of pancreatic insulin producing protects cells in this way [70]. Whether CDNF can regulate UPR via
beta cell mass and development of diabetes mellitus-like binding to UPR sensors, similarly to the interaction of MANF and
condition [56, 57]. In cultured cells, silencing of MANF led to IRE1α, is unknown (Fig. 2B).
activation of UPR and increased susceptibility to ER stress-induced Although CDNF and MANF are largely retained in cells, their
cell death [58]. UPR activation was also detected in Caenorhabditis secretion is increased in ER stress when ER calcium is depleted
elegans [59, 60] and Drosophila melanogaster [61] due to the loss [36, 62, 67]. Secreted CDNF and MANF may function as autocrine
of functional MANF. MANF interacts with an ER chaperone BiP or paracrine trophic factors, promoting cell survival. In accordance
[62, 63], and was shown to prolong BiP interaction with its clients with their potential trophic activities, endogenous CDNF and
thus promoting protein-folding homeostasis in the ER [64]. We MANF can be detected in human serum [72, 73]. Circulating
recently observed that intracellular MANF is able to promote the concentrations of CDNF were not altered in PD patients while
survival of cultured neurons by a mechanism relying on the MANF concentrations were significantly increased and positively
activity of either IRE1α or PERK pathways [63]. However, MANF correlated with the Beck Depression Inventory scoring, which is
used to measure the severity of depression. This suggests that seemingly different cytoprotective activities of CDNF and MANF
further studies would be useful to test whether blood MANF levels engage the same or different intracellular signaling pathways and
can be used as a clinical marker of PD [73]. It has been proposed molecular mechanisms is under investigation.
that serum MANF functions as a systemic regulator of inflamma- In contrast to classical NTFs, publications demonstrating
tion and metabolic homeostasis, thus protecting against age- survival-promoting effects of extracellular CDNF and MANF on
related deterioration [74]. naive neurons are limited. Exogenous CDNF was able to support
the development and survival of enteric DA neurons originating
Extracellular trophic activities and plasma membrane from enteric neural crest-derived cells in vitro [75], whereas it did
receptors not support the survival of cultured postnatal midbrain DA
Evidently CDNF and MANF can protect neurons as extracellular neurons [76]. CDNF promoted neither the survival of superior
trophic factors, as demonstrated for example in animal models of cervical ganglion (SCG) neurons, motoneurons, nor dorsal root
PD (as discussed later in detail), and as potential intracellular ganglion neurons in contrast to nerve growth factor (NGF) [20].
regulators of protein homeostasis in the ER. Whether these two MANF protein added to the cell culture was unable to promote
the survival of naive DA or SCG neurons, in contrast to GDNF and material. In hippocampal samples of PD patients, CDNF levels
NGF [29, 63]. Compared to naive neurons, the survival-promoting were increased while GDNF levels were decreased suggesting that
effects of CDNF and MANF have been more prominent on injured these factors could represent potential targets for modification to
or stressed neurons [20, 29, 63]. For example, exogenous CDNF help attenuate cognitive decline in PD [81].
protected DA neurons against toxicity of αSyn oligomers [30]. Biological functions of CDNF in the nervous system has been
CDNF also protected hippocampal cells against synaptotoxicity of studied using mouse and zebrafish knockout models [75, 82, 83].
amyloid-β peptide oligomers likely through regulation of ER stress These studies indicate that CDNF expression is important for the
[77]. In addition to neurons, MANF has various effects on non- development and maintenance of various neuronal types and
neuronal cells. Exogenous MANF stimulated the proliferation of circuits rather than specifically for DA neurons. Although CDNF
mouse and human pancreatic beta cells [56, 57, 78] that, protects midbrain DA neurons in rodent models of PD [20, 84–89],
compared many other cell types, have high physiological ER no gross anatomical changes were observed in the midbrain
stress due to synthesis and secretion of insulin [79]. MANF also DA system of conventional Cdnf−/− mice [83]. Numbers of DA
protected cultured embryonic DA neurons against ER stress and neurons in the SNpc, density of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)- or
decreased induction of UPR genes via a mechanism dependent on dopamine transporter (DAT)-positive fibers in the striatum, or
either IRE1 or PERK pathways [63] suggesting that exogenous striatal DA or DA metabolite levels did not differ between Cdnf−/−
MANF, similarly to intracellular MANF, can promote neuron and Cdnf+/+ mice [83]. However, Cdnf deletion did lead to
survival through regulating UPR. How could exogenous MANF changes of dopaminergic neurotransmission, as amphetamine
regulate UPR signaling in the ER? Bai and colleagues provided one administration induced an increased hyperlocomotor response,
possible answer to this by proposing that extracellular MANF possibly resulting from altered function of DAT in the dopami-
bound to sulfatide can be endocytosed to cells where it mediates nergic axon terminals in striatum of Cdnf−/− mice [83]. Expression
cytoprotection by promoting ER homeostasis [32] (Fig. 3B). The of UPR genes was not altered in the SN or striatum of Cdnf−/−
molecular mechanism of the potential endocytosis of MANF- mice, suggesting that CDNF expression is not essential for the
sulfatide and subsequent molecular events remain to be resolved. maintenance of ER protein homeostasis in the midbrain DA
Protein receptors proposed to interact with CDNF and MANF on system [83]. Further characterization of Cdnf−/− mice demon-
the PM are KDEL-R and neuroplastin (NPTN) [36, 67, 80] (Fig. 3B). strated the importance of Cdnf expression for the development
KDEL-R is mainly localized in the Golgi but it was also detected in and maintenance of neurons in the ENS. Cdnf−/− mice suffered
the PM where it could bind CDNF and MANF through C-terminal from an age-dependent loss of enteric neurons due to increased
KDEL-like sequences [36, 67] (Fig. 3B). Protective effects of neurodegeneration and autophagy observed selectively in the
exogenous CDNF against myocardial ischemia/reperfusion injury submucosal plexus of the intestinal wall, leading to slowed
was dependent on the presence of the C-terminal lysine- gastrointestinal motility [83]. Cdnf expression was found to be
threonine-glutamic acid-leucine (KTEL) sequence and PI3K-Akt necessary for the normal development and survival of enteric DA
signaling pathway [67]. However, the C-terminal arginine- neurons since Cdnf deletion resulted in loss of DA neuronal
threonine-aspartic acid-leucine (RTDL) sequence of MANF was markers in the submucosal plexus [75]. The observed ENS defect
dispensable for its neuroprotective activity in a model of cerebral in Cdnf−/− mice was not only for DA neurons as the numbers of
ischemia [33], suggesting alternative mechanisms for exogenous NOS-, GABA-, and CGRP-expressing neurons were also decreased
MANF activity. Recently, NPTN was identified as a novel PM [75]. The data suggest that the observed functional changes in
receptor for MANF [80] (Fig. 3B). Direct binding of MANF to NPTN the brain dopaminergic system and loss of ENS neurons in
decreased ER stress-mediated inflammation and cell death [80]. Cdnf−/− mice resemble deficiencies observed in early stage PD
However, it is unclear whether NTPN is the major PM receptor for [83]. In a human population study, mutations in CDNF gene were
MANF. Different from MANF, CDNF does not bind NPTN or not identified in patients with early-stage PD [90]. However, a
sulfatide [32, 80], suggesting that cell surface receptors for CDNF trend towards susceptibility to PD was observed in subjects
remain to be discovered. carrying an allele of an intronic CDNF single nucleotide
polymorphism (SNP) [90].
CDNF and MANF knockout neuronal phenotypes Zebrafish cdnf mutants generated using CRISPR/Cas9-genome
There are only few studies reporting endogenous levels of CDNF editing were viable, fertile, and had no gross morphologic
in patients with PD, obviously due to limited availability of tissue phenotype [82]. Importantly, loss of cdnf caused impairments
Fig. 3 Plasma membrane receptors of GFLs and MANF/CDNF. A GDNF Family Ligands (GFLs): GDNF; NRTN; artemin; and persephin, function
as homodimers to activate transmembrane receptor tyrosine kinase RET. Binding of GFLs to RET is mediated by GDNF family receptor-α
(GFRα1–4) co-receptors, which selectively interact with the GFLs. Ligand binding leads to homodimerization and autophosphorylation of RET,
resulting activation of multiple intracellular signaling cascades. GDNF binding to RET is mediated by GFRα1, and leads to activation of Akt,
MAPK and c-Src pathways, promoting neuronal survival and regeneration. B Neuroplastin (NPTN) is a novel receptor for MANF (1). Activation
of NPTN induces NF-κB transcription factor and expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines. MANF binding to NPTN decreases pro-
inflammatory response and protects cells against ER stress-induced inflammation and cell death [80]. MANF binds sulfatide (2). Sulfatide is
present in the plasma membrane (PM) of neurons and other cell types, suggesting that MANF can interact with sulfatide on the PM. MANF
bound to sulfatide can be endocytosed to promote ER homeostasis [32]. The molecular mechanism of the potential endocytosis of MANF-
sulfatide and subsequent molecular events are unclear. CDNF and MANF may bind to the KDEL-receptor (KDEL-R) on the PM via a C-terminal
KDEL-like sequence (3) [36, 67]. Exogenous CDNF promoted calcium homeostasis and mitochondrial maintenance in cardiomyocytes under ER
stress conditions by a mechanism dependent on its KDEL-like sequence suggesting that KDEL-R is binding CDNF [67]. The protective effect of
CDNF was mediated by PI3K/Akt signaling [67]. C MANF, CDNF, and KDEL-R are induced by ER stress. In unstressed cells, CDNF and MANF are
retained in the ER by KDEL-R, whereas in ER stress resulting from the depletion of ER calcium, they are released from cells. In ER stress, KDEL-R
possibly localizes to the PM where it may bind extracellular CDNF and MANF.
in dopaminergic, histaminergic, and GABAergic neurotransmitter expression of tyrosine hydroxylase 2 which functions in DA
systems in selective brain areas, indicating that CDNF is synthesis [82]. Alterations in the neurotransmitter networks were
important in shaping the structure of neurotransmitter circuits associated with abnormal behavior, including impaired social
in these fish CNS [82]. In the brain, cdnf deletion led to increased cohesion and anxiety-related risk taking in adult cdnf mutants
Fig. 4 CDNF promotes survival of dopamine neurons. A Midbrain dopamine (DA) neurons project from substantia nigra (SN) to the
putamen forming nigrostriatal pathway. B In Parkinson’s disease (PD), midbrain DA neurons degenerate leading to motor and non-motor
symptoms. Cell bodies of DA neurons are located in the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNpc). C CDNF prevents neurodegeneration and
induces functional recovery of injured DA neurons in animal models of PD. Therapeutic CDNF could reduce ER stress and
neuroinflammation that are thought to be involved in the neuropathogenesis of PD. Differently from GDNF, CDNF does not show
survival-promoting effects on naive DA neurons.
[82]. Mutant fish were also more susceptible to drug-induced number of dopaminergic fibers in the striatum, or the striatal
seizures. Interestingly, the observed behavioral phenotypes of concentrations of DA or its metabolites in adult mice [95].
cdnf mutant fish are reminiscent of human neuropsychiatric Although chronic activation of UPR was detected in the brain
conditions, such as schizophrenia [82], in accordance with the tissue of Manf−/− mice, it did not result in neurodegeneration [95].
suggested association between a CDNF SNP and schizophrenia In contrast to observations in Manf knockout mice, Drosophila
susceptibility in humans [91]. Manf, encoded by a single homolog of human MANF/CDNF,
Homozygous loss-of-function mutations of the human MANF appears to be essential for the maintenance of DA neurites and
gene were reported as a cause of childhood diabetes, and were DA levels in the fly [96]. In DmManf mutant larvae, the volume of
mechanistically connected to ER stress and impaired beta cell DA neurites was diminished whereas somas were maintained,
function [92]. A homozygous MANF mutation was also associated suggesting that DA neurites degenerate before cell bodies [96],
with mild intellectual disability, microcephaly, and deafness [93], thus resembling degeneration of DA neurons in PD. UPR-related
suggesting that MANF has a role in brain development and genes were upregulated in DmManf mutant embryos indicating
normal auditory function. In accordance, Manf inactivation in mice ongoing UPR [61]. Larval lethality of DmManf zygotic mutants was
resulted in a hearing loss [94]. However, characterization of rescued with ubiquitously expressed human MANF or CDNF,
conventional and CNS-specific Manf knockout mice indicated that indicating that DmManf and human MANF and CDNF are
endogenous MANF is not required for the maintenance of functionally conserved [97]. Also in zebrafish, studies of manf
midbrain DA neurons [95]. CNS-specific deletion of Manf in mice knockdown using antisense splice-blocking morpholino oligonu-
did not affect the number of TH-positive DA neurons in the SNpc, cleotides suggested that MANF is involved in the regulation of DA