Appropriate Use of Polymerase Chain Reac
Appropriate Use of Polymerase Chain Reac
Appropriate Use of Polymerase Chain Reac
www.elsevier.com/locate/diagmicrobio
Abstract
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests that detect herpes simplex virus (HSV) DNA in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) are increasingly used to
diagnose central nervous system (CNS) infections caused by HSV. To determine proper utilization of this test at an inner-city hospital, we
performed a case-control study of adult patients, with HSV detected in CSF by PCR. Retrospective review of characteristics of adult patients
hospitalized between 1997 and 2000 with CSF positive for HSV was done and compared to control patients with suspected CNS infection
and negative CSF PCR. CSF from 1174 patients was tested; 20 (1.7%) had HSV DNA detected, 19/20 were HSV-2 and 1 was HSV-1. The
HSV-2 cases were females (74%), with a median age of 41 years, of African-American ethnicity (100%). Of the cases, 90% had acute aseptic
meningitis versus 13% controls ( P b .001). Recurrent meningitis occurred in 42% cases and 3% controls ( P b .001). CSF parameters
significantly associated with HSV-2 positivity was lymphocytic pleocytosis (median leukocyte, 475 cell/mm3, 90% lymphocytes) ( P b .001).
In conclusion, HSV-1 was rarely detected in CSF of patients with suspected CNS infection. HSV-2 is more frequent, predominantly in young
African-American women with lymphocytic aseptic meningitis, and is often recurrent. PCR testing for HSV-2 in CSF at inner-city hospitals
can be greatly reduced by the application of these parameters.
D 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction suggests that these sensitive but expensive PCR tests are
increasingly overutilized (Mitchell et al., 1997). Over a
Herpes simplex virus (HSV) infections of the central 2 1/2-year period, test requests increased from an average of
nervous system (CNS) in adults typically present as 23 to 140 per month without a corresponding increase in the
2 distinct syndromes—viral meningitis caused by herpes rate of detection of HSV-DNA in the CSF (Mitchell et al.,
simplex virus 2 (HSV-2) and encephalitis due to herpes 1997). We wished to assess the use and to provide guidance
simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) (Corey, 2005). for the proper utilization of the PCR test in adult patients
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) detection of HSV admitted to an inner-city university medical center with
DNA in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is a sensitive and suspected CNS infection. A case-control study was there-
rapid test that has facilitated the diagnosis of HSV ence- fore performed of all patients who had a CSF specimen
phalitis, thus sparing brain biopsies, and has helped identify positive by PCR for HSV-1 or HSV-2 DNA at the Detroit
HSV as a potential cause of aseptic meningitis (Tang et al., Medical Center in downtown Detroit, MI.
1999a, 1999b). However, a report from a referral laboratory
2. Methods
The study was presented in part at the 40th Annual Meeting of the
IDSA, October 24–27, 2002, Chicago (abstract no. 760).
All CSF samples submitted for PCR testing for HSV
4 Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-313-745-7105; fax: +1-313-993-0302. DNA, from adult patients hospitalized between January 1997
E-mail address: galangaden@med.wayne.edu (G. Alangaden). and December 2000 at 3 inner-city urban hospitals within the
0732-8893/$ – see front matter D 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.diagmicrobio.2006.09.002
310 N. Afonso et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 57 (2007) 309 – 313
Detroit Medical Center in Detroit, MI, were analyzed. PCR 7.0 (1995; SPSS, Chicago, IL). The 2 groups were
testing was performed at a single core laboratory. The CSF compared using the Student t test and v 2 test for continuous
samples were stored at 4 8C and testing was performed twice and dichotomous variables, respectively. Results are pre-
weekly. Briefly, CSF was extracted and the DNA concen- sented as mean F SD or number and percentage. Statistical
trated using the QIAmp DNA Mini Kit PCR (Qiagen, significance for all tests was established at a nominal P level
Valencia, CA). PCR was performed using oligonucleotide of b.05.
primers specific for a 476-bp DNA signature sequence
present in HSV-1 and HSV-2 DNA polymerase gene. Primer
sequences utilized were (P1) 5V CAG TAC GGC CCC GAC
TTC GTG A 3V and (P2) 5V GTA GAT GGT GCG GGT GAT 3. Results
GTT 3V (Rogers et al 1991). Viral DNA was amplified up to During the 4 years of the study, 1174 CSF samples from
1012-fold by PCR using a 9600 Thermocycler (Applied patients with suspected CNS infections were submitted to
Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA), and the product was the laboratory with a request for PCR testing for HSV. Of
detected using a colorimetric microtiter-based system with a these, HSV DNA was detected in 20 (1.7%) of the
RNA probe specific for the HSV target (Sharp Signalk specimens; HSV-2 was detected in 19 patients and HSV-1
System, Digene Diagnostics, Gaithersburg, MD, USA) in a single patient. The single patient with HSV-1 DNA in
(Rogers et al., 1991). Amplification was done according to the CSF was an 87-year-old female hospitalized with fever,
the protocol outlined (Roger, 1991) with the following mental status changes, seizures, and was diagnosed as
exceptions: PCR reaction volumes were 50 AL, 10% glycerol having HSV encephalitis.
was added to each reaction, and the PCR was run for 60 Characteristics of the 19 patients with HSV-2 DNA and
cycles (Podzorski et al 2000). Specimens positive for HSV
controls are summarized in Table 1. There were no
by PCR were typed by restriction fragment analysis
significant differences in the demographic characteristics
(Podzorski et al., 2000). Briefly, restriction endonuclease
between cases and controls, the majority being African-
reactions were performed with DrdI or AvaII and were set up
American women, with a median age of about 40 years
according to product inserts (DrdI, New England Biolabs,
(Table 1). Recurrent aseptic meningitis (RAS) was identified
Beverly, MA; AvaII, Roche Diagnostics Corporation, Indian-
in 8 cases (42%) as compared to a single control patient.
apolis, IN) using 25 AL of PCR product directly from the
Five of these patients had a prior history of RAS at the time
amplification reaction and 5 U of each restriction enzyme.
of initial PCR detection of HSV DNA; the other 3 patients
The reactions were incubated overnight. After restriction,
25 AL from each reaction was run on a 3% agarose gel, had a subsequent hospitalization for aseptic meningitis,
stained with ethidium bromide, and visualized using UV which was detected during the follow-up review done at the
illumination (Podzorski et al 2000). No viral cultures were end of 2004. Of these patients, 1 had 5 episodes, 2 each had
performed on the CSF specimens. 4 and 3 episodes, and 3 each had 2 episodes of RAS,
We used the laboratory database to identify adult patients respectively. The single control patient with RAS was a
with a CSF sample positive by PCR for either HSV-1 or 22-year-old woman with 2 hospitalizations for symptoms
HSV-2 DNA. Case records of every patient whose CSF was and CSF findings suggestive of aseptic meningitis; on both
positive for HSV DNA in the CSF were compared to occasions, PCR of the CSF was negative for HSV. No
2 hospitalized control patients. A control was defined as a definite etiology was established. Fever was present in the
patient with suspected CNS infection who had a negative majority of cases and controls (Table 1). However, features
HSV PCR assay of the CSF. Age and gender were selected of meningitis, that is, photophobia, neck pain/rigidity,
for matching controls because most of our HSV-positive headache, and nausea/vomiting, were significantly more
cases had HSV-2 meningitis, which tends to occur common in the HSV-2–positive cases as compared to
predominantly in young women (Read and Kurtz 1999; controls. In contrast, alteration in mental status was
Peter et al., 2001; O’Sullivan et al., 2003). A follow-up significantly more common in controls. Of 19 HSV-
review of the medical records of all patients and controls 2–positive cases, 6 (32%) exhibited all 4 symptoms of
was repeated at the end of December 2004 to determine if meningitis and 9 of the 19 patients (47%) had at least 3 of
any subsequent hospitalizations occurred for CNS infec- the above symptoms. Overall, 17 of the 19 (90%) HSV-
tions, or if any subsequent PCR testing of the CSF was 2–positive cases had clinical features compatible with
performed. The analysis included patient demographics, aseptic meningitis. The 2 patients without symptoms of
clinical presentation, initial and final diagnoses, CSF aseptic meningitis, 1 with colon cancer, and the other with
parameters, radiologic tests, treatment, and outcome. The systemic lupus had symptoms of transverse myelitis. Both
study was conducted in accordance with the policies of the presented with numbness of the trunk and lower extremities.
local human investigation committee. The patient with lupus also had weakness of the left lower
extremity and a vesicular rash consistent with herpes zoster
2.1. Statistical analysis
along the left T9 dermatome. Both patients had evidence of
The data obtained were coded, entered into a data file, transverse myelitis on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
and analyzed using SPSS for Windows software, Release scans. No varicella zoster viral DNA was detected by PCR
N. Afonso et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 57 (2007) 309 – 313 311
2003). Most of HSV-2–positive tests occurred in young The high frequency of CT/MRI brain scans performed in
women as was noted in our study (Read and Kurtz 1999; cases and controls is of interest. Most of our HSV-2 cases
Peter and Sevall, 2001; Studahl et al., 2000; Simko et al., had features of aseptic meningitis without focal neurologic
2002; O’Sullivan et al., 2003). Seroprevalance of HSV-2 has signs. Criteria for appropriate use of CNS imaging in cases
steadily increased with the greatest lifetime cumulative of meningitis include focal neurologic abnormality, abnor-
incidence of 80% in African-American women (Corey, mal mentation, seizure, age N 60 years, immunocompromis-
2005), the group most affected in our study. Therefore, it is ing condition, or a prior CNS disease (Hasbun et al., 2001).
likely that PCR testing will be positive for HSV-2 rather Specific antiviral therapy was administered in only 42%
than HSV-1 if utilized within an inner-city hospital setting. of HSV-2–positive cases. The majority of patients had
This is the first case-control comparison of the clinical spontaneous resolution of symptoms and were discharged
and CSF characteristics of hospitalized patients with HSV-2 before receipt of the PCR results. Both treated and untreated
DNA in the CSF. RAS was significantly associated with cases had subsequent episodes of RAS. This suggests that
HSV-2 positivity. Since the PCR detection of HSV-2 in the despite detection of HSV-2 DNA in the CSF in patients with
CSF of patients with RAS by Tedder et al. (1994), there aseptic meningitis the benefit of specific antiviral therapy
have been additional reports of the association between remains uncertain. Recommendations for antiviral therapy
RAS and HSV-2 (Picard et al., 1993; Jensenius et al., 1998; for RAS are based upon expert opinion and suggest
Kupila et al., 2004). In adult patients with aseptic meningitis treatment should be individualized based upon the number
and HSV-2 DNA in CSF, prior meningitis occurred in 27% and severity of recurrences (Tyler 2004). A randomized
to 67% (Read and Kurtz 1999; Studahl et al., 2000; Simko multicenter evaluation of suppressive therapy with valacy-
et al., 2002; O’Sullivan et al., 2003), similar to the 42% of clovir is ongoing in Sweden (Tyler, 2004).
our cases with RAS. Thus, patients with RAS should be Although our study is retrospective, the findings will
considered for HSV-2 PCR. help identify appropriate patients for CSF testing for HSV-2
The clinical features indicative of HSV-2 positivity were DNA, thereby reducing overutilization of expensive PCR
acute-onset aseptic meningitis (89%) presenting with testing. The cost of a PCR test at our center is $160 with an
photophobia, neck pain/rigidity, headache, or nausea/vomit- estimated cost of approximately $188,000 for the study
ing. HSV-2 infection of the CNS in adults typically presents period. Because only 1.7% of 1174 patients tested had a
as acute aseptic meningitis, generally during primary genital positive CSF HSV PCR, considerable cost saving might
infection (Corey, 2005). Altered mental status was associ- have been realized if the test was applied to selected
ated with a negative predictivity for HSV-2. It is likely that patients. Once the diagnosis of encephalitis versus menin-
PCR testing in many of the controls was requested due to gitis is made, newer real-time PCR assays that specifically
clinical suspicion of encephalitis indicated by fever and identify either HSV-1 or HSV-2 DNA can be utilized (Corey
altered mental status. However, only 1 of the controls had et al., 2005).
encephalitis recorded as the admission diagnosis, and only 3 Thus, CSF specimens from patients with suspected CNS
received empiric acyclovir that was discontinued in 2 after a infections should be stored and PCR testing for HSV-2 be
negative PCR result. performed only in patients especially young women with a)
None of our cases had HSV skin or mucosal lesions. symptoms of RAS or b) patients with acute aseptic
Although skin lesions were noted in 7–18% of patients with meningitis and CSF demonstrating lymphocytic pleocytosis.
CSF positive for HSV-2 (Read and Kurtz, 1999; Simko Application of these parameters would reduce the number of
et al., 2002), a recent study of patients with aseptic PCR tests performed without a proportional decrease in the
meningitis and positive HSV-2 PCR reported no skin positive results for HSV-2 DNA. This would result in cost
lesions at presentation (O’Sullivan et al., 2003). savings without significant impact on clinical outcomes.
Laboratory parameters significantly associated with HSV-2
positivity in our study were elevations in CSF leukocyte
count and lymphocyte predominance. In patients with Acknowledgments
suspected CNS infections, a CSF WBC count of z 5/mm3
We thank Anil Aranha for statistical evaluation of
together with fever, a virus-specific rash, or headaches were
the manuscript.
reported as independent predictors of a positive PCR result
for HSV DNA (Jeffery et al., 1997; Minjolle et al., 2002;
Simko et al., 2002), whereas CSF with normal protein and
cell counts had a negative predictive value (Tang et al., References
1999a, 1999b). Two reports comparing patients with HSV-1 Cimolai N, Thomas EE, Tan R, Hill A (2001) Utilization of herpes simplex
encephalitis and HSV-2 meningitis reported median WBC PCR assays for cerebrospinal fluid in a pediatric health care setting.
Can J Microbiol 47:392 – 396.
count of 238 and 484/ mm3 (96% and 87% lymphocytes) and
Corey L (2005) Herpes simplex virus. In Mandell, Douglas and Bennett’s
median protein levels of 55 and 129 mg/dL, respectively Principles and Practice of Infectious Diseases. Eds, GL Mandell, JE
(Simko et al., 2002; O’Sullivan et al., 2003), which was Bennet and R Dolin. (6th ed.). New York, NY7 Churchill Livingstone,
similar to the findings noted in our study. pp 1762 – 1780.
N. Afonso et al. / Diagnostic Microbiology and Infectious Disease 57 (2007) 309 – 313 313
Corey L, Huang ML, Selke S, Wald A (2005) Differentiation of herpes Picard FJ, Dekaban GA, Silva J, Rice GP (1993) Mollaret’s meningitis
simplex virus types 1 and 2 in clinical samples by a real-time Taqman associated with herpes simplex type 2 infection. Neurology 43:1722 – 1727.
PCR assay. J Med Virol 76:350 – 355. Podzorski RP, Baker J, Merline JR, Qureshi R, Holsinger JE (2000) Utility
Hasbun R, Abrahams J, Jekel J, Quagliarello VJ (2001) Computed of restriction fragment analysis for typing herpes simplex virus
tomography of the head before lumbar puncture in adults with amplicons following PCR of targets in the DNA polymerase gene.
suspected meningitis. N Engl J Med 345:1727 – 1733. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis 37:289 – 291.
Jeffery KJ, Read SJ, Peto TE, Mayon-White RT, Bangham CR (1997) Read SJ, Kurtz JB (1999) Laboratory diagnosis of common viral infections
Diagnosis of viral infections of the central nervous system: clinical of the central nervous system by using a single multiplex PCR
interpretation of PCR results. Lancet 349:313 – 317. screening assay. J Clin Microbiol 37:1352 – 1355.
Jensenius M, Myrvang B, Storvold G, Bucher A, Hellum KB, Bruu AL Rogers BB, Josephson SL, Mak SK (1991) Detection of herpes simplex
(1998) Herpes simplex virus type 2 DNA detected in cerebrospinal virus using the polymerase chain reaction followed by endonuclease
fluid of 9 patients with Mollaret’s meningitis. Acta Neurol Scand cleavage. Am J Pathol 139:1 – 6.
98:209 – 212. Sauerbrei A, Wutzler P (2002) Laboratory diagnosis of central nervous
Kupila L, Vainionpaa R, Vuorinen T, Marttila RJ, Kotilainen P (2004) system infections caused by herpesviruses. J Clin Virol 25(Suppl. 1):
Recurrent lymphocytic meningitis: the role of herpesviruses. Arch S45 – S51.
Neurol 61:1553 – 1557. Simko JP, Caliendo AM, Hogle K, Versalovic J (2002) Differences in
Minjolle S, Arvieux C, Gautier AL, Jusselin I, Thomas R, Michelet C, et al laboratory findings for cerebrospinal fluid specimens obtained from pa-
(2002) Detection of herpesvirus genomes by polymerase chain reaction tients with meningitis or encephalitis due to herpes simplex virus (HSV)
in cerebrospinal fluid and clinical findings. J Clin Virol 25(Suppl. 1): documented by detection of HSV DNA. Clin Infect Dis 35:414 – 419.
S59 – S70. Studahl M, Hagberg L, Rekabdar E, Bergstrom T (2000) Herpesvirus DNA
Mitchell PS, Espy MJ, Smith TF, Toal DR, Rys PN, Berbari EF, et al (1997) detection in cerebral spinal fluid: differences in clinical presentation
Laboratory diagnosis of central nervous system infections with herpes between alpha-, beta-, and gamma-herpesviruses. Scand J Infect Dis
simplex virus by PCR performed with cerebrospinal fluid specimens. 32:237 – 248.
J Clin Microbiol 35:2873 – 2877. Tang YW, Mitchell PS, Espy MJ, Smith TF, Persing DH (1999a) Molecular
Najioullah F, Bosshard S, Thouvenot D, Boibieux A, Menager B, diagnosis of herpes simplex virus infections in the central nervous
Biron F, et al (2000) Diagnosis and surveillance of herpes sim- system. J Clin Microbiol 37:2127 – 2136.
plex virus infection of the central nervous system. J Med Virol Tang YW, Hibbs JR, Tau KR, Qian Q, Skarhus HA, Smith TF, et al (1999b)
61:468 – 473. Effective use of polymerase chain reaction for diagnosis of central
O’Sullivan CE, Aksamit AJ, Harrington JR, Harmsen WS, Mitchell PS, nervous system infections. Clin Infect Dis 29:803 – 806.
Patel R (2003) Clinical spectrum and laboratory characteristics Tedder DG, Ashley R, Tyler KL, Levin MJ (1994) Herpes simplex virus
associated with detection of herpes simplex virus DNA in cerebrospinal infection as a cause of benign recurrent lymphocytic meningitis. Ann
fluid. Mayo Clin Proc 78:1347 – 1352. Intern Med 121:334 – 338.
Peter JB, Sevall JS (2001) Review of 3200 serially received CSF samples Tyler KL (2004) Herpes simplex virus infections of the central nervous
submitted for type-specific HSV detection by PCR in the reference system: encephalitis and meningitis, including Mollaret’s. Herpes
laboratory setting. Mol Cell Probes 15:177 – 182. 11(Suppl 2):57A – 64A.