2421-Article Text-4734-1-10-20201212
2421-Article Text-4734-1-10-20201212
Abstract:
Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) sector in India has a special significance for the
economy in terms of wealth creation and employment generation. This sector is expected to offer
more employment opportunities by 2020. It has become an important component of the Indian
Government’s flagship programs such as ‘Make in India’ and ‘Skill India’. The advent of Goods and
Service Tax (GST) posed a serious challenge to the consequent performance of MSMEs in particular
and the economy in general. The ambiguity over the GST is continuing even after two years of its
implementation. Many researchers are of the opinion that the introduction of GST brought about a
fresh wave of challenges particularly in the informal sector. Non-preparation for the perfect launch,
poor infrastructural facilities and delays in receiving Input Tax Credit directly affected the MSMEs
sector. Further, the advent of GST also affected logistic management to a great extent where small
traders acted as suppliers of raw material to big business houses. Some researchers have opined that
GST has left a positive impact on the performance of MSMEs in terms of ease of doing business, tax
reduction on new business, improvement of both logistic and transport services, and elimination of the
difference between goods and services. In this paper, an earnest attempt is made to analyze the impact
of the introduction of GST on the performance of MSMEs in the Indian Economy. The study is
divided into three sections. Introduction, review of literature, objectives, and research methodology
are discussed in the first section. The performance of the MSMEs during pre and post introduction of
GST is reported in the second chapter. The last chapter ends with the summary and the conclusion of
the study.
Introduction
Over the past five decades Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
(MSMEs) sector has become known to everybody as one of the dynamic and
vibrant sector of the economy (Alam, 2009; Chandra, & Pareek, 2014),. Its
4302
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
4303
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Review of Literature
There is ample of literature available on MSMEs. The authors have
tried to present the existing literature on the impact of GST on performance of
MSMEs after introduction of GST. As everybody knows review of literature
allows the researcher to identify the research gap so as to bridge it. The
following paragraphs present the existing literature in the field of study. Behera
and Wahi (2018) have assessed the recent credit dynamics and export
performance of MSMEs. They explained that GST implementation does not
seem to have had a significant impact on overall credit to MSMEs. Further,
they stated that the growth in credit to MSMEs had recovered from the lowest
registered during the late 2017 to reach the mid 2015 level. Furthermore, they
added that MSMEs exports got effected by GST in contrast to credit growth
during the same period. RBI (2019) in its report opined that at present MSMEs
must do multiple registrations with variety of entities such as GSTN, NSIC,
Udyog Aadhaar portal etc that leads to cumbersome registration with
duplication of work. Hence, the Committee has recommended that the
government should make PAN as Unique Enterprise Identifier (UEI) so as to
use it for different purposes like procurement, availing benefits from
government etc. Further, the Committee have had discussion upon the proposed
turnover based definition for MSMEs (Subrahmanya, 2019). The proposed
definition is considered as progressive and suitable in the light of introduction
of GST in which turnover details of enterprises are captured by GST Network
(GSTN) so that turnover declared by GST registered MSMEs units easily
verified through GSTN. Jayasree (2019) in her news paper article expressed
that the MSMEs are very much affected by GST as they had to adjust to a
variety of obligations under GST regime, require them to file numerous papers
for refund on input taxes. Further, she pointed that engaging professional
accountants is expensive as they are small in size and operations comparatively
large scale industries. Moreover, she made some suggestions to help out
MSMEs that the threshold for GST to be raised to Rs. 40 lakhs for MSMEs
sales threshold compulsory companies. She added that the earlier 20 lakh
threshold was instrumental to bring in a large number of MSMEs into GST
network. The tax exemption limit for central excise tax was Rs. 1 crore in 2017
and she recommended to raise it to Rs. 1.5 crore. Jayalakshmi and
Venkateswarlu (2018) opined that under GST any business enterprises whose
turnover is less than 10 lakhs need not register/collect GST. This allows many
small and medium scale enterprises not apply for GST returns. They added that
GST allows MSMEs to do their business at ease due to it less complexity, the
removal of difference between goods and services sector. They have shown
optimistic towards the better performance of MSMEs due to introduction of
GST and they expected that all the problems would go off in long run in turn
Indian MSMEs could compete with cheap cost centres like China, Philippines,
Bangladesh etc. Praveen Kutty (2019) expressed his views in his news paper
article that the replacement of near about 17 different taxes and numerous
cesses with GST made tax filling easy and systematic and streamlined process
(Mayank Aggarwal and Misra, 2018). The new tax has forced the business
houses to adopt digital technology so as to improve business efficiency, he
added. Mohan and Ali (2018) have assessed the implications of GST rollout on
Indian MSMEs and found that many enterprises find difficulty and costly to
adopt GST and it is resulted to slash their profit margins because of their
associated costs. There are several operational problems related GST filling
website, connectivity issues in rural areas and poor feedback mechanism. Their
findings also suggested that there is a positive relation between awareness of
GST structure and profitability of firms.
4304
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Methodology:
4305
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Discussion
turnover is less than 93 per cent occupied 93 per cent. It means most of the
MSMEs fall under this category. As it is noted in the introduction part, MSMEs
contribute a lion share to GDP of India. The reference period for the study is 1
July, 2017 which is the date of GST implementation date in India. Hence, it is
thought that the financial year 2016-2017 would be the reference year for the
study.
4306
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Table 3Credit Guarantee Extended and Total No of Claims Settled For MSMEs
from 2014-15 to 2019-2020
Total
Credit Number of
Guarantee Claims
Extended Settled
Amount Total Number Amount
Total Number of Claims (Rs. in
Year of Cases (Rs. in Crore) Settled Crore)
2014-15 403422 21275 25948 717.87
2015-16 513978 19949 34812 1002.29
2016-17 452127 19931 39069 1038.19
2017-18 263195 19066 33980 927.12
2018-19 435520 30167 36606 764.21
2019-20 394444 25711 29780 653.31
Source: Compiled by author
There is a sharp decline in the number of cases referred for settlement in the
succeeding year of implementation of GST whilst a slight decrease can be seen
in credit guarantee extended. The same trend can be observed in case of total
number of climes settled and the value of climes settled amount. It denotes the
impact of GST is almost insignificant in terms of credit guarantee given to
MSMEs and their settlement.
4307
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Khadi
No. of Khadi Sales
No. of Khadi No. of Artisans on Production (Rs.in
Financial Institutions Artisans Aadhaar (Rs.in Cr) Cr)
Year
2016-17 2375 455854 NA 1520.83 2146.60
2017-18 2518 465386 225667 1626.66 2510.21
2018-19 2632 495244 275428 1963.30 3215.13
Source: Compiled by author
There is an upward trend in all the variables of the study since the inception of
GST. It means there is a positive impact on Khadi institutions of MSMEs.
Table 5 explains the growth of exports coir and their products during the study
period. The exports of these products are amounted to Rs. 1630 crores during
2014-15 where as they reached to Rs. 2728 crores during 2018-19.
Achievement
Particulars 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19
Exports of Coir and
Coir Product (Rs. in
Crore) 1630 1901 2282 2532 2728
Source: Compiled by author
The data reveals that there is a constant growth throughout the study period
without any interruption. Hence, it may be said that there is no negative impact
of GST on exports of Coir and Coir Products. Deployment of credit is
oxygen for growth and progress of MSMEs in India. The gross bank credit
deployed by banking sector from September 2017 to September 2019 is given
in Table 6. The gross bank credit available for Micro and Small Scale
enterprises as on September 29, 2018 is Rs. 9,94,504 crore and it increased to
Rs. 10,56,600 crore as in September 2019. In terms of year to year percentage
change, there is a positive growth rate in between 2018 and 2019 with 6.24 per
cent. In case of manufacturing enterprises, a negative trend is traced. In terms
of percentage terms, it is -0.68 percent.
4308
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Percentage of
Sep.28, Sep.27, Change over
2018 2019 Sep.27, 2019 to
Sep.28, 2018
Reference period
Micro & Small Enterprise 9,94,504 10,56,600 6.24
Manufacturing 3,63,797 3,61,328 -0.68
Services 6,30,707 6,95,271 10.24
Medium 1,05,256 1,04,989 -0.25
MSME Sector 10,99,760 11,61,589 5.92
Source: Compiled by author
The services sector has exhibited magnificent growth rate with 10.24 per cent
in comparison to its previous year. In contrast to service sector medium sector
enterprise are registered a negative growth rate of -0.25 per cent in the
reference period. The overall MSME sector performed well with a year to year
growth rate of 5.92 per cent during the reference period. Hence, it may be
summed up that the GST implementation hampered credit availability for some
sectors of MSMEs though the overall performance is relatively good.
4309
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
Budget Utilized
Year Projects Approved Projects completed
(in Rs. Crore)
2016-17 9 10 121.68
2017-18 21 24 157.11
2018-19 36 28 172.73
Source: Compiled by author
References:
[1] Ainin, S., Parveen, F., Moghavvemi, S., Jaafar, N.I. and MohdShuib, N.L.
(2015), Factors influencing the use of social media by SMEs and its
4310
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
4311
PJAEE, 17(7) (2020)
[18] Walsh, M. F., & Lipinski, J. (2009). The role of the marketing function in small
and medium sized enterprises. Journal of Small Business and Enterprise
Development, 16(4), 569-585, Doi:10.1108/14626000911000929.
4312