Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                

Anti Piracy Manual Shipmaster 2023 en

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 72

Anti-Piracy Manual

Shipmaster
Peter van der Kruit, LLM

The Netherlands Shipmasters’ Association


(January 2023)
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Anti-Piracy Manual for the Shipmaster of


a ship flying the flag of the Netherlands

A practical, legal reference work for the Shipmas-


ter to help protect his ship and those on board
against pirates in the Gulf of Aden and along a sec-
tion of the coast of East Africa, in the official High-
Risk Area (HRA)
This Manual is an initiative and publication of the Netherlands Shipmasters’ Association (Ne-
derlandse Vereniging van Kapiteins ter Koopvaardij, NVKK) and has been produced in cooper-
ation with the Ministry of Justice and Security, the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Man-
agement, and the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate.

1
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster


by

P(Peter) J.J. van der Kruit


(PhD, LLM, MPA)

For a more detailed discussion about maritime legal subjects see the ‘Legal
Handbook Shipmaster’, also published by the NVKK

Author P.J.J. van der Kruit, LLM, in collaboration with Alex van Binsber-
gen and Henri A. L’Honoré Naber of the Anti-Piracy Committee
of the NVKK
Cover Henri A. L’Honoré Naber
© 2023 NVKK
The Hague (NL) 1 January 2023

This Manual and the Legal Handbook Shipmaster are available free of charge on the NVKK
website: www.nvkk.nl

Disclaimers
1. Where applicable, words used in this Manual in the masculine gender shall include all people.
2. This Manual may be downloaded free of charge and stored in an automated database or be made public, in any form or by any
means, whether electronically, mechanically, by means of photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission
from the publisher. This Manual may be used for personal use or for educational purposes, but not for purely commercial purposes,
such as selling or lending against payment. The content of this document may not be edited, supplemented or changed. The copy-
right owners have tried to trace any possible copyright claims. If any individuals believe they have such claims, they may contact us.
3. This Manual does not establish any relationship between client and legal adviser. This Manual has been produced with the greatest
possible care; the copyright owners do not accept any liability for any information included which is nevertheless incomplete or in-
correct. Although this Manual has been produced with the greatest possible care, no rights may be derived from it. Under no circum-
stances will the information in this Manual replace the information as it has been laid down in legislation or otherwise.
4. The copyright owners reserve the right to make changes and corrections to this Manual - without prior notification - at any time.
They are not responsible or liable for any inaccuracies or omissions. Neither are they responsible or liable for any direct, exceptional,
indirect, additional or consequential damage or any damage - of whatever nature and due to whatever cause - as a result of the use
of information obtained - directly or indirectly - via the NVKK website or this Manual.

2
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Foreword
Shipmaster and crew can be exposed to serious danger while
sailing in an area with a high risk of piracy.
The safety of ship, crew and cargo is always the main focus.

Since 1 February 2022, is possible for ships sailing under the


Dutch flag to get protection from private security personnel if a
VPD of the Royal Netherlands Navy is unable to board the ship.

When private security personnel are on board, it is very im-


portant for the shipmaster to be well prepared.

This practical Manual, with a large number of uniquely numbered checklists, is intended for
masters of ships sailing under the Dutch flag, who may encounter piracy during their voyage.
From the preparation of the voyage to the final mandatory travel reports, the shipmaster are
guided in their task.

The core of this Manual is formed by a number of uniquely numbered checklists to make sure
the shipmaster does not forget anything.
Furthermore, a number of important subjects are discussed, such as the use of force, notifi-
cations and reports, fines, etc.

This manual is primarily for the shipmaster, but it is also recommended to all other seafarers
and interested parties, such as ship managers, trade unions, educational institutions and the
government.

This Manual only applies to the Gulf of Aden and along a section of the coast of East Africa.

This new digital publication will be updated frequently and can be downloaded free of charge
from the website https://www.nvkk.nl/

NVKK trusts that this publication too will meet the existing need.

Leen van den Ende


President of the NVKK
The Hague, 1 October 2022

3
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Contents
Foreword .................................................................................................................................... 3

1. Outline................................................................................................................................ 8

1.1. Introduction................................................................................................................. 8

1.2. Process ........................................................................................................................ 9

1.3. Shipmaster................................................................................................................. 11

1.4. Structure.................................................................................................................... 13

2. Legislation and definitions ............................................................................................... 14

2.1. Introduction............................................................................................................... 14

2.2. Legislation.................................................................................................................. 14

2.3. Definitions and terminology...................................................................................... 15

3. Important rules for the shipmaster ................................................................................. 19

3.1. Introduction............................................................................................................... 19

Article 6 Merchant Shipping Protection Act ....................................................................... 21

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 21

3.2 Protective measures.................................................................................................. 23

Article 2.4.1 Decree (Information obligation in terms of protective measures) ................. 23

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 23

Article 3 Regulations (Protective measures) ....................................................................... 23

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 24

3.3 Duty to verify information from the ship manager .................................................. 25

Article 2.4 Decree (Information obligation; shipmaster's responsibility) ........................... 26

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 26

3.4 Additional responsibilities of the shipmaster ........................................................... 28

Article 3.3 Decree (Responsibility of the master) ................................................................ 28

4
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 28

Article 5.9.1.b Decree (Requirements for the security team) ............................................. 29

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 29

Section 8 Merchant Shipping Protection Act ........................................................................... 29

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 29

Article 3.2 Decree (Weapons or ammunition safe) ............................................................. 29

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 30

Article 3.3 Decree (Responsibility of the shipmaster) ......................................................... 30

Article 4 Regulations (Weapons safe and transport cases with weapons) ......................... 30

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 31

Section 9.7 Merchant Shipping Protection Act ........................................................................ 31

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 32

Article 3.4.5. Decree (Further instructions for the use of force) ......................................... 32

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 32

Article 17 Regulations (Team leader) .................................................................................. 33

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 33

Section 10.3 Merchant Shipping Protection Act...................................................................... 34

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 34

Section 11.4 Merchant Shipping Protection Act...................................................................... 34

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 34

Article 23 Regulations (Retention period) ........................................................................... 34

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 35

Section 12 Merchant Shipping Protection Act ......................................................................... 35

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 36

5
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Article 6 Regulations (Embarkation form, report forms and notification about the use of
force) .................................................................................................................................... 37

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 37

Section 17 Merchant Shipping Protection Act ......................................................................... 38

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 38

Article 20 Regulations (Administrative fine imposed on the shipmaster) .......................... 39

Explanation ...................................................................................................................... 39

4. Checklists ......................................................................................................................... 41

4.1. Introduction............................................................................................................... 41

A. Checklist: Preparing the voyage................................................................................... 44

B. Checklist: Outside the high-risk area (HRA) ................................................................. 46

C. Checklist: Inside the high-risk area (HRA) .................................................................... 48

D. Checklist: Consultation between shipmaster/teamleader about use of force ........... 50

E. Checklist: Notification about the use of force ............................................................. 52

F. Checklist: Reporting after the voyage.......................................................................... 57

5. Explanatory notes ............................................................................................................ 60

5.1. Introduction............................................................................................................... 60

5.2. Gathering information .............................................................................................. 60

5.3. Use of force ............................................................................................................... 61

5.4. Notifications and reports .......................................................................................... 62

Nationally ......................................................................................................................... 62

Internationally.................................................................................................................. 65

5.5. Overview of fines imposed on the shipmaster ......................................................... 66

Protective measures ........................................................................................................ 67

No permission for private security personnel ................................................................. 67

6
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

End-of-voyage report ....................................................................................................... 68

Notification about the use of force ................................................................................. 68

Schedule of fines .............................................................................................................. 68

Annex 1 Recommended literature and websites ................................................................ 69

This Manual only applies to the Gulf of Aden and along a section of
the coast of East Africa, in the official High-Risk Area (HRA)

7
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

1. Outline
1.1. Introduction
The purpose of this Manual is to provide more insight and information to the shipmaster
when armed private maritime security personnel come on board; this is due to new legisla-
tion in this area.

As the new legislation only concerns piracy in the Gulf of Aden and
East Africa, this Manual applies only to this official High-Risk Area
(HRA) and not to other areas with a high piracy risk, such as the Gulf
of Guinea.

Figure 1. Official High-Risk Area (HRA).

8
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

In short, only in the above High-Risk Area may ships sailing under the Dutch flag make use of
armed private security personnel.
Under this legislation the shipmaster gets new responsibilities and obligations, which can
also be enforced and, where necessary, penalised with sanctions or measures.

The shipmaster can navigate this Manual via the Contents page or a search function. NVKK’s
Legal Handbook Shipmaster may be useful for the explanation of certain legal issues. Both
the Handbook and this Manual can be downloaded free of charge from the NVKK website
(www.nvkk.nl).

The new legislation on armed private security personnel has entered into force. If the cor-
rect permissions and permits have been granted, a shipmaster may sail in the Gulf of Aden
and along a section of East Africa with armed private security personnel.
See Figure 1 for the High-Risk Area where armed private security personnel are permitted.

The application process will be explained in detail below to provide the shipmaster with a
better understanding.

The diagrams (Figures 2 and 3) are intended for the shipmaster. It shows the shipmaster his
own tasks and responsibilities, placed within a broader context.
The shipmaster is and remains the pivot on board the ship.

1.2. Process
1. The ship manager may submit a request for protection to the Coastguard.
2. The Coastguard will decide whether a VPD team should be used or if private security is
an option. The principle is: “VPD, unless...”.
3. If official permission is granted for private security, the ship manager will engage a mari-
time security company with an official Dutch licence to perform maritime security activi-
ties.

9
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

4. The agreement (contract) between the ship manager and this maritime security com-
pany (licence holder) sets out details such as numbers, embarkation point, time, rates,
duration, etc.
5. Protective measures such as those specified by law, BMP, etc. remain in force, even if
armed private security personnel are on board.
6. The ship manager passes on all the mandatory details and data, such as documents,
names and weapon numbers to the shipmaster.
7. On the basis of this information, the shipmaster will check the maritime security person-
nel and their firearms when they board the ship.
8. The shipmaster and the team leader of private security personnel will ensure that they
have the same information about names, arms, the rules about the use of force, etc.
9. The shipmaster also needs to check the documents/licences of the coastal state where
the ship is moored.
10. If there is something wrong with the papers, the security personnel or the firearms, the
shipmaster must refuse the security personnel or firearms permission to come on board.
11. The shipmaster must then postpone departure until everything is in order.
12. When the security personnel and their firearms are on board, the shipmaster is the per-
son responsible.
13. The shipmaster stores and guards the firearms and ammunition and has the key to the
arms and ammunition safes.
14. No more than two hours before arrival in the HRA, the team leader gets the key to the
arms and ammunition safes.
15. The security personnel may only use force against pirates after the shipmaster and the
team leader have had a consultation about this unless there is no time or opportunity to
do so.
16. The team leader - not the shipmaster - has the leadership and responsibilities of the use
of force.
17. The shipmaster still has the leadership of and authority over the ship, including changes
in course and speed or evading manoeuvres as well as protective measures, etc.
18. The team leader keeps the shipmaster informed about the use of force against pirates.

10
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

19. Immediately after the use of force, this is reported by the shipmaster to the Netherlands
Public Prosecution Service.
20. After the voyage, the shipmaster and the team leader separately report to the Human
Environment and Transport Inspectorate about the whole voyage, the so-called end-of-
voyage report.

Shipmanager Master Master Teamleader Master

• Makes voyage
• Permission for private preperations • Consulting
armed guards • Checks security teamleader
• BMP, SSP etc. • Controls use of
• Contract with the personnel and their arms • Evasive
• Course & speed force
maritime security at embarkation. manoeuvres
• Evasive maneuvers • Rules of
company: llicense • Consults with • Crew concern
• Reporting authorities Engagement
holder. teamleader about • Reporting to the
• Responsible
• Informs the Master information Prosecuter
about all details • Controls all weapons

Figure 2. Overview of the private security personnel process

1.3. Shipmaster
• The shipmaster gets all the information required by law from the ship manager.
• The shipmaster also has an active request obligation.
• The shipmaster prepares the voyage properly, including all protective measures rea-
sonably required.
• The shipmaster checks the team leader, security personnel and firearms against the
data provided by the ship manager before embarkation.
• The shipmaster consults with the team leader before the start of the voyage. All in-
formation is compared.

11
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• The shipmaster must postpone departure until everything is in order.


• The shipmaster is in control of the firearms and ammunition on board.
• No more than two hours before entering the HRA, the shipmaster gives the keys to
the arms and ammunition safes to the team leader.
• The shipmaster reports the ship’s movements in the HRA to the appropriate authori-
ties (see also page 65 of this Manual).
• The shipmaster consults with the team leader before the use of force.
• Immediately after the use of force, the shipmaster sends a notification to the Neth-
erlands Public Prosecution Service, including video and sound recordings.
• On leaving the HRA, the shipmaster is in control of the firearms in the ammunition
safes again.
• On debarkation, all private security personnel disembark with their firearms.
• On debarkation, the shipmaster is responsible for the correct, local documentation
for the firearms, as the shipmaster may be importing firearms.
• The shipmaster sends a general report on the whole voyage to the Human Environ-
ment and Transport Inspectorate.

Maritime Security
Shipmanager Agreement
Company

End-of-
voyage
HE&
TI Prosecuter
report

Master Consultation Team Leader Reporting


use of force

Figure 3. Overview of the Merchant Navy (Protection) Act

12
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

1.4. Structure
Chapter 1 is the introduction to this Manual.
Chapter 2 gives all the definitions and terminology.
Chapter 3 focuses on the statutory provisions important for the shipmaster. They are in-
cluded verbatim, followed by a brief explanation. The term ‘master’ is in bold in these statu-
tory provisions.
Chapter 4 is the key chapter of this Manual. It includes several uniquely numbered checklists
which can be downloaded or printed individually, which makes it easy to use them on
board. These checklists can also be used as an annex to the mandatory reports.
Chapter 5 gives a brief explanation of a few complicated subjects.

13
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

2. Legislation and definitions


2.1. Introduction
This section briefly introduces the legislative system of the new piracy legislation. It informs
the shipmaster of the difference between the Act, the Decree and the Regulations. This is
followed by a description of the definitions and terminology used in this legislation.
Legislation may change, so make sure you always have the most recent version. You can find
this on the website: wetten.overheid.nl.

This new legislation only applies to ships sailing under the Dutch flag
in the Gulf of Aden and along a section of the coast of East Africa.
See Figure 1.

2.2. Legislation
As the legislation consists of several provisions, obligations and rules which together form a
hierarchical structure, this chapter starts with a brief explanation of the Act, the Decree and
the Regulations.
Merchant Shipping Protection Act (Wet ter Bescherming Koopvaardij, WtBK):
• Contains general mandatory provisions that apply to everyone.
• Describes the rules that apply to this subject in general terms.
• Has been adopted by the Senate and the House of Representatives after receiv-
ing advice from the Council of State.
• Changing the law takes years.
Merchant Shipping Protection Decree (Besluit bescherming koopvaardij, Bbk):
• This is also called an Order in Council (Algemene Maatregel van Bestuur, AMvB)
or a Royal Decree (Koninklijk Besluit, KB).
• Gives a detailed elaboration of the Act.
• Has been adopted by the Government after receiving advice from the Council of
State.
Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations (Regeling bescherming koopvaardij,
Rbk):
• Has been derived from the Act and the Decree.
• Is the detailed, concrete interpretation of the Act and the Decree.
• Contains specific rules and details about specific subjects.
• Has been adopted by the Minister of Justice and Security.

14
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Merchant Shipping Protection Act

Merchant Shipping Protection Decree

Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations

Figure 4. Hierarchy of the Act, Decree and Regulations

2.3. Definitions and terminology


Below are some of the terms and definitions from the Act, the Decree and the Regulations.
The Act has its own terms and definitions. The Decree and the Regulations use the defini-
tions from this Act and add a few more. Several terms have also been added.

In some definitions, the legal jargon has been converted into more understandable lan-
guage.

Term Definition
Use of force The use of force and the threat of force, including the drawing of a fire-
arm.
Protective Planning and operational measures to be taken by the ship manager
measures and shipmaster for protection against piracy.
Security team The private maritime security personnel, including the team leader, de-
ployed or to be deployed on board a ship.
Boarding Pirates on board, the shipmaster still has control of the ship.

15
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Medical certifi- Medical certificate of fitness to perform maritime security activities.


cate
Force Anymore-than-minor compulsive force exercised on persons or prop-
erty.
Rules for the Rules for the Use of Force (RUF) are rules for private maritime security
use of force personnel in which the use of force is defined, including:
• To which extent;
• Under which conditions;
• Who gives authority;
• Under which circumstances;
• In which manner;
• When applicable.
Weapons The equipment and weapons designated under the Act for the use of
force on board.
Hostage-taking Pirates have control of the ship and restrain persons on board.
Maritime secu- An enterprise that, during the exercise of its profession or business, of-
rity company fers and performs security activities on board a ship and mainly uses
the services of persons for this purpose.
Maritime secu- Monitoring of the safety of persons and goods on board a ship by pri-
rity activities vate maritime security personnel.
Notification Mandatory notification by the shipmaster to the Public Prosecution Ser-
about the use vice that force has been used during an incident with pirates. The ship-
of force master can demonstrate in this notification that they have done every-
thing possible to prevent the use of force and that the use of force was
within the terms of the legislation.
Excessive force Exceeding of the criteria and conditions of legitimate self-defence as a
in legitimate consequence of vehement emotions such as fear, anger or panic.
self-defence

16
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Storage place Place ashore or on a ship used by the licence holder for the storage of
firearms and ammunition. This is not the weapons safe on board.
Private mari- Staff employed by a maritime security company or staff made available
time security to the maritime security company based on a temporary employment
personnel agency contract.
Private security The private maritime security personnel, including the team leader, de-
team ployed or to be deployed on board a ship.
Private mari- Member of the security team who will be or has been deployed by the
time security licence holder on board a ship.
staff member
Piracy Any illegal act of violence or detention or depredation committed for
private ends by the crew, or the passengers of a private ship directed
against another ship outside the territorial sea of a state, or an attempt
thereto (Article 101 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea)
Attempt Approach of the ship by a vessel with pirates.
Report A report by the shipmaster after the voyage with private maritime secu-
rity personnel (end-of-voyage report).
High Risk Area The official maritime area where pirates can be expected. The exact co-
ordinates are given in the Decree. See also Figure 1 of this Manual.
Ship manager The ship manager as defined in Section 1 (1) (1) of the Seafarers Act
(shipowner).
Team leader The private maritime security officer who is designated by the maritime
security company as supervisor for the other private maritime security
personnel and who is operationally in charge of the private maritime
security personnel during the transport.
Permission Permission to hire private security personnel.
Supervisory of- Officials of the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate, who
ficials are responsible for supervising compliance with the provisions from the
Act, the Decree and the Regulations.
Transport Movement of a ship between two or more seaports.

17
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Licence holder Maritime security company that is the holder of a licence as provided
for in the law.
Licence Legal permission to engage private security personnel to provide ser-
vices.
Transport case Storage place for the permitted weapons (firearms), to be sealed with a
lock.
Weapons safe Storage place on board, to be sealed with a lock, to be used for the
transport cases with weapons (firearms).
Seafarer A natural person working on board a ship in any capacity.
Self-defence / Legitimate self-defence is a legal concept. Self-defence as such is a
legitimate self- more general term. Self-defence is defending yourself, other persons
defence on board and the ship against pirates or the threat of pirates. Criteria
and conditions for self-defence are:
• The use of force must be proportionate, so do not use more force
than is necessary to fend off the attack.
• Immediate threat of danger, such as an aggressive approach by a
vessel with visible pointed arms and a ladder.
• The ship has not been put at risk due to your own fault, which
means preventative measures, as specified in the most recent ver-
sion of the BMP, are also included.

18
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

3. Important rules for the shipmaster


3.1. Introduction
Legislation is the combination of the law and the corresponding decree and regulations.

Below the most important provisions for the shipmaster are quoted verbatim (in italics) and
explained briefly point by point. The most important provisions from the Act are given first,
followed by the corresponding provisions from the Decree and the Regulations. A decree is
ranked lower than the law, while regulations are ranked lower than a decree.

The most important subjects from this legislation are described from the point of view of
the shipmaster of a ship sailing under the Dutch flag and for the area with a high-risk (HRA)
in the Gulf of Aden and along a section of the coast of East Africa. See also Figure 1 of this
Manual.

All statutory provisions in which the shipmaster is mentioned will be described.


The term ‘master’ is shown in bold in the legislation quoted verbatim.

The legislation uses the term ‘master’, while the Manual uses the
term ‘shipmaster’. Both mean the same person, also known as the
captain of the vessel.
This manual uses the terms ‘section’ and ‘article’ of the legislation
interchangeably.

Only that part of the article in which the ‘master’ is mentioned will be quoted. The article is
therefore not always quoted in full. This does not mean that the other provisions are not im-
portant for the shipmaster.

For reasons of clarity, only the most important articles and provisions are discussed in this
Manual. For the full text, please refer to the current legislation. If you are interested, you
can find the explanation (Explanatory Memorandum) of the subjects on the internet, usually
on: overheid.nl.

19
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Each article of the Act that is explained starts on a new page, followed by the details from
the articles of the Decree and the Regulations. The articles are in the same order as in the
Act. See the order by subject in the table below.

Subject Act Decree Regula-


tions
Duty to verify, permission for private security Section 6.2 Art. 2.4 Art. 6.2
personnel Section 6.3
End-of-voyage report Section Art. 5.13 Art. 6.3
12.1
Section
12.2
Fines Section Art. 20
17.2.a
Section
17.2.b
Section
17.2.d
Section
17.2.e
Handing over pirates Section
10.3
Management of firearms Section 8 Art. 3.2 Art. 4
Art. 3.3
Notification about the use of force Section Art. 6.4
12.3
Protective measures Section 6.1 Art. Art. 3
Section 6.2 2.4.1.a
Responsibilities of the shipmaster Section 6.4 Art. 2.4
Art. 3.3

20
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Art.
5.9.1.b
Shipowner’s information obligation towards Section 6.3 Art. 2.4 Art. 6
the shipmaster
Use of force Section 9.7 Art. 3.4.5 Art. 17
Video/sound recordings, privacy Section Art. 23
11.4
Table 1. List of sections and articles from the legislation on piracy

This table only mentions those articles that refer to the shipmaster. The other articles pro-
vide more context and are obviously also important for the shipmaster.

Article 6 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


1. The master and the ship manager shall apply all the reasonably possible protective measures, designated
by ministerial regulation (the Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations), prior to and during a transport on
which private maritime security personnel are deployed.
2. Prior to the deployment of private maritime security personnel, the master and the team leader must ensure
that the permission referred to in Section 3 (2) has been granted and that the rules laid down by or pursuant
to this Act relating to the protective measures, the identity and nationality of the private maritime security
personnel, the weapons, cameras and microphones have been complied with.
3. The ship manager and the licence holder shall provide the master or the team leader with correct and com-
plete information in accordance with their duty to verify. Rules shall be laid down by or pursuant to an order
in council regarding the information and the provision of the information.
4. Rules shall be laid down by or pursuant to an order in council (the Merchant Shipping Protection Decree)
regarding the master's responsibility for the safety of the ship and the persons on board in connection with
the maritime security activities and compliance with the rules referred to in subsection 2.

Explanation
• Section 6 (1) states that the shipmaster must take all reasonably possible protective
measures on board. This is at the discretion of the shipmaster, who is the person re-
sponsible for these measures.
• If the ship manager submits the application for private security personnel to the Coast-
guard, the ship manager will also state all reasonably possible protective measures. The
shipmaster can get this checked.

21
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• The ship manager must ensure that everything is on board for this purpose. The ship-
master can always ask the ship manager for more or specific protective measures if the
shipmaster thinks this is necessary.
• Section 6 (2) states that the shipmaster must ensure that permission has been granted
by the Minister to take armed private security personnel on board. The ship manager
must provide this information to the shipmaster. If this has not been done, the shipmas-
ter must request this information from the ship manager.
• The shipmaster must also comply with all the rules about protective measures, data on
private security personnel, cameras, microphones, firearms, etc. Otherwise, the ship-
master may be given a fine.
• Section 6 (3) states that the ship manager must provide the correct and complete infor-
mation to the shipmaster, which the shipmaster needs to have in order to check private
security personnel and their firearms when boarding the ship.
• This concerns, for example, the names of the security staff members and the numbers of
the firearms, including the relevant documents. See below under Article 2.4 Decree.
• The team leader will get this information from their own company.

The shipmaster and the team leader must compare the information
they have with each other and check it (verify it). If this information
is incorrect, this must be resolved before the ship sails out to sea.

• The shipmaster must check all the data before the security personnel board the ship
with their firearms. The shipmaster can take photos of the firearms, their numbers or
other external characteristics as evidence for this.

The shipmaster can refuse the security personnel and their weapons
permission to board if the data is incorrect. As soon as the security
personnel are on board, the shipmaster is responsible for these peo-
ple and their firearms.

• Section 6 (4) states that the Decree gives the shipmaster even more responsibilities. See
hereafter under Article 2.4 Decree and Article 3 Regulations.
• It is of crucial importance that the shipmaster inspects the data, including any local doc-
uments if the security personnel embark in a foreign port.

22
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Inadequate inspection can result in the shipmaster receiving a high


fine.

3.2 Protective measures


Hereafter the subject Protective Measures will be explained in full, using the relevant provi-
sions of the Decree and Regulations.

Article 2.4.1 Decree (Information obligation in terms of protective measures)


Prior to the embarkation of the security team, the master and team leader shall receive the correct and complete
information from the ship manager or the licence holder regarding the protective measures;

Explanation
• In the application for private security, the ship manager must demonstrate that all rea-
sonably possible measures will be taken. This means that not all measures are always
compulsory. It depends on the type of ship, the number of crew, etc. See also the most
recent BMP and other guidelines.
• The ship manager must inform the shipmaster about the protective measures to be
taken. These are also included in the official “permission” to sail with private security
personnel on board. The shipmaster therefore must have that permission on board and
check it.

Article 3 Regulations (Protective measures)


1. The ship manager guarantees in any case the availability of the following protective measures, provided for
in Section 6 (1) of the Act:
a. binoculars for the team on the bridge;
b. floodlights;
c. concertina razor wire;
d. materials that can be used to bolt doors and hatches that provide access to the bridge, the quarters
of crew and passengers and the engine room, and
e. materials that can be used to reinforce windows and portholes.
2. Prior to the passage through the High-Risk Area, the master will in any case take the following protective
measures, provided for in Section 6 (1) of the Act:
a. the designation of a safe muster point or safe room for the seafarers and passengers on board the
ship;

23
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

b. fitting the concertina razor wire in places designated for that purpose;
c. fitting water or foam jets at possible access points on board;
d. preparing the crew by means of drills focusing on protection against piracy;
e. bolting doors and hatches that provide access to the bridge, the quarters of seafarers and passen-
gers as well as the engine room;
f. the reinforcement of large windows and portholes that need such reinforcement, and
g. the protection of equipment and devices of the ship against use by third parties.
3. During the passage through the High-Risk Area, the master will in any case take the following protective
measures, provided for in Section 6 (1) of the Act:
a. the use of one or more lookout posts with trained crew;
b. the use of binoculars by the team on the bridge, and
c. having floodlights available for immediate use.
4. If, due to special circumstances, it is not possible to take one or more of the measures specified in paragraphs
1 to 3, the ship manager must report this, explaining the reasons, on the form specified in Article 2, stating
any alternative measures that are being taken where possible.

Explanation
• This article from the Regulations gives very detailed provisions about protective
measures. The shipmaster must comply with them on board the ship whenever such is
reasonably possible.
• Article 3 (1) Regulations addresses the ship manager regarding specific protective
measures, but the shipmaster must ensure they are in place on board before departure
to an area with a high piracy risk.
• The ship manager can state and justify in the permission application why certain protec-
tive measures cannot be taken. The shipmaster must be able to check this, as it is the
shipmaster who is responsible.
• Article 3 (2) Regulations directly addresses the shipmaster. The shipmaster must take all
the measures mentioned before entering the HRA. The Ship Security Plan (SSP) could
also play a part in this.
• Article 3 (3) Regulations is also directly aimed at the shipmaster and concerns the pas-
sage through the HRA. The shipmaster must take specific measures at that point. Flood-
lights and deck lights may be used, but they can also attract pirates in the dark. It is up
to the shipmaster, in consultation with the team leader, to decide this.

24
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• Many of these measures must be organised together with the ship manager as part of
the preparations for the voyage. However, the shipmaster is the person responsible on
board the ship.

The ship manager provides all that is required for the protective
measures, while the shipmaster applies them and is responsible for
them on board.

• Article 3 (4) states that the ship manager must also specify any protective measures that
cannot be taken, for example due to the type of ship, when submitting the application
for private protection. The shipmaster must ensure, however, that this has all been
properly arranged. The ship manager must inform the shipmaster about this. The ship-
master is responsible for all protective measures on board.

If some protective measures cannot be taken on board, the ship


manager must be able to give a proper justification for this in the ap-
plication for sailing with private security personnel. But it is the ship-
master who is responsible on board.

3.3 Duty to verify information from the ship manager


Hereafter the subject verification of information by the shipmaster will be explained in full,
using the relevant provisions of the Decree and Regulations.

Sections 6.2 and 6.3 of the Act are about the shipmaster’s “duty to verify” and state that the
ship manager must provide the shipmaster with correct and complete information about
private security personnel and their weapons.
The shipmaster uses this information to check private security personnel and the weapons
that come on board the ship.
The shipmaster also discusses with the team leader whether both have the same appropri-
ate and correct information (they verify each other).

25
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Article 2.4 Decree (Information obligation; shipmaster's responsibility)


1. Prior to the embarkation of the security team, the master and team leader shall receive the correct and
complete information from the ship manager or the licence holder regarding:
a. the protective measures;
b. the size of the security team, the identification data and the nationality of the private maritime
security staff members;
c. the number of firearms and brand, type and registration number of each weapon and the quantity
of associated ammunition;
d. the weapons safe or safes,
e. the number of sets of handcuffs and the number of cameras and microphones.
2. Furthermore, they shall receive:
a. a copy of the mandatory national and local documents from the relevant coastal states allowing
the firearms concerned to be taken on board in a legal manner;
b. a copy of the end user's certificates evidencing the legal ownership of the relevant firearms;
c. a copy of the permission, the licence and the ISO certificates referred to in Article 5.1, and
d. a copy of the agreement between the ship manager and the licence holder concerning the perfor-
mance of maritime security activities.
3. If the information and documents referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 are incomplete and incorrect, the master
shall refuse to take the security personnel, firearms and ammunition on board.
4. The master shall postpone the departure of the ship or entry into the High Risk Area if the rules laid down
by or pursuant to the Act have not been complied with.
5. Further rules may be laid down by ministerial regulation regarding the information and documents referred
to in paragraphs 1 and 2, and the time at which these must be provided at the latest, as well as the recording
thereof by the master and the team leader within the period specified.

Explanation
• Section 6 of the Act states that the Decree includes rules about providing the correct
and complete information by the ship manager to the shipmaster. They have been laid
down in the above article.
• The shipmaster must have this information at the time when the security personnel go
on board at the latest. The Regulations state that this is four hours prior to departure.
See below.
• However, information about the protective measures should, of course, be on board
sooner, as the shipmaster will otherwise not have time to build this up.

26
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• The shipmaster will check private security personnel and their firearms when they board
the ship.
• The information the shipmaster must get from the ship manager includes:
o All protective measures;
o Size of the security team;
o Identity and nationality of the private maritime security staff members;
o Number of firearms and brand, type and registration number of each weapon;
o Quantity of associated ammunition;
o Weapons safe or safes;
o Number of sets of handcuffs;
o Number of cameras and microphones;
o Copy of the mandatory national and local documents from the relevant coastal
states allowing the firearms concerned to be taken on board in a legal manner;
o Copy of the end user's certificates evidencing the legal ownership of the relevant
firearms;
o Copy of the permission, the licence and the ISO certificates referred to in Article
5.1;
o Copy of the agreement between the ship manager and the licence holder about
the performance of maritime security activities.
• The maritime security company provides this information to the team leader of the
security personnel.
• The shipmaster and the team leader must compare this information before, during
or after embarkation. Any discrepancies or doubts about the data on the security
personnel or their weapons must be resolved. If necessary, this is done with the help
of the shipowner and the maritime security company.
• If specific data on security staff members or firearms is incorrect, the shipmaster
must refuse to allow these people or weapons on board.
• If the above information and documents are incomplete or incorrect, the shipmaster
must postpone the ship’s departure; in any case, the shipmaster may not enter the
HRA.

27
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

3.4 Additional responsibilities of the shipmaster


Hereafter the subject additional responsibility of the shipmaster will be explained in full, us-
ing the relevant provisions of the Decree and Regulations.

Section 6.4 of the Act states that the Decree gives the shipmaster additional responsibilities.
This has already been partly described above and will be discussed in more detail below.

Article 3.3 Decree (Responsibility of the master)


1. The master is responsible for the management and the safe storage of the firearms and the associated am-
munition on board the ship and is in possession of the keys to the weapons safe or weapons safes.
2. Two hours prior to sailing into the HRA at the latest, the management of the firearms and the associated
ammunition shall be transferred to the team leader, including the keys to the weapons safe or weapons
safes.
3. For safety reasons, firing exercises by private maritime security personnel may take place on board and
around the ship only after the team leader has received consent from the master.

Explanation
• The Decree contains additional responsibilities of the shipmaster for the security of the
ship and the persons on board in connection with the maritime security activities, such
as managing and guarding the firearms and ammunition on board.
• The security personnel bring their firearms on board in locked transport cases.
• These are stored in locked weapons or ammunition safes or in cabinets, storage places
or cabins.
• Firearms and ammunition are stored in separate ammunition safes.
• The shipmaster keeps the keys to the weapons and ammunition safes and gives them to
the team leader two hours before sailing into the HRA, enabling the team leader to get
everything ready before the HRA is entered.
• The shipmaster must record in the ship’s log that they have handed over these keys to
the team leader.
• The shipmaster must give permission for firing exercises by private security personnel.
Shipping movements around the ship and safety on board in particular are important in
this respect. This is recorded in the ship’s log.

28
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Article 5.9.1.b Decree (Requirements for the security team)


1. The maritime security company shall ensure that each member of the maritime security team:
a. …..
b. Participates in safety drills on board the ship, after receiving instructions from the shipmaster to do
so;
c. ……

Explanation
• Article 5.9 (1) (b) Decree states that private security personnel must take part in the se-
curity drills required by law. These may include a lifeboat drill, fire drills as well as anti-
piracy drills. This is to be decided by the shipmaster.

Section 8 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


Private maritime security personnel shall not use any weapons other than those designated by the Minister by
an order in council (the Merchant Shipping Protection Decree) for performing maritime security activities. Rules
(the Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations) shall also be laid down by or pursuant to an order in council (the
Merchant Shipping Protection Decree) regarding the method of storage of the designated weapons on board the
ship.

Explanation
• This section from the Act concerns the use of specific weapons and how they are stored
(firearms and ammunition). The section states that the details of this are set out in the
Decree and the Regulations.
• The shipmaster must ensure that only approved weapons and ammunition come on
board. The shipmaster will get the details from the ship manager for that purpose in ad-
vance. If this is not the case, the shipmaster will actively request them.
• As firearms and ammunition are mainly the shipmaster's responsibility, the Decree and
the Regulations are described in detail below.

Article 3.2 Decree (Weapons or ammunition safe)


1. The firearms and the associated ammunition shall be safely stored on the ship during a transport in a sepa-
rate, properly locked weapons or ammunition safe.

29
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

2. By regulation of the Minister (the Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations), further rules shall be laid down
regarding the weapons or ammunition safe.

Explanation
• The Decree states that the firearms and ammunition must be securely stored in locked
weapons and ammunition safes. The ship manager must provide these safes, while the
shipmaster is responsible for them on board.
• Weapons/ ammunition safe: storage place on board to be sealed with a lock, in which
the transport cases with firearms and ammunition are stored separately.
• Transport case: storage space for firearms or ammunition, to be sealed with a lock.
• Firearms must always be stored separately from the ammunition, i.e. in different safes.
• The Regulations give more details about management and storage. See below.

Article 3.3 Decree (Responsibility of the shipmaster)


See page Article 3.3 Decree 28.

Article 4 Regulations (Weapons safe and transport cases with weapons)


1. The weapons safe may only be accessed by the master or, with express permission from the master, by the
team leader or another official designated by the master.
2. The master keeps a record of persons who have access to the weapons safe.
3. Opening a transport case and distributing weapons require express permission from the shipmaster.
4. On board the ship, a transport case will be opened only by the team leader or their replacement.
5. Firearms stored in a transport case are not loaded with ammunition. The ammunition is stored separately in
a transport case.
6. The team leader daily registers the brand, type, serial number and quantity of weapons present in each
transport case. The master ensures that the registration takes place and signs the registration for that pur-
pose, together with the team leader.
7. Two hours prior to reaching the HRA, the team leader, in consultation with the master, will take the transport
cases to the bridge.
8. The weapons that are not used during the passage through the HRA are stored in a transport case on the
bridge. The transport cases are not locked during this passage and are supervised by the armed member of
the security team on duty on the bridge.
9. No later than two hours after leaving the HRA, the team leader puts the transport cases with weapons back
into the weapons safe.

30
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

10. The team leader ensures that the firearms are regularly maintained and work adequately, in accordance
with the instructions of the licence holder.

Explanation
• Weapons or ammunition safe: storage place on board to be sealed with a lock, in which
the transport cases with firearms and ammunition are stored separately from each
other.
• Transport case: storage space for weapons, to be sealed with a lock;
• Weapons and ammunition arrive on board with the transport cases. They are then
stored separately in the weapons safe and the ammunition safe respectively.
• The shipmaster manages the weapons and ammunition safes and has the key.
• Management also includes registering the persons who have access to the safes.
• The transport cases may only be opened by the team leader with permission from the
shipmaster.
• The team leader records all details daily, while the manager checks and verifies whether
the team leader is doing so.
• The keys of the weapons and ammunition safe are handed by the shipmaster to the
team leader of private security personnel two hours before entering the HRA.
• The team leader prepares everything, including the weapons, for any confrontation with
pirates. These are guarded by a security guard at all times.
• Two hours after leaving the HRA, the weapons and ammunition are put back into
transport cases and respective safes. From then on, they are the shipmaster’s responsi-
bility again.

Section 9.7 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


The team leader shall not issue an order for the use of force until after they have determined, in consultation
with the master, that the protective measures referred to in Section 6 (1) have not resulted in averting the risk
of piracy, unless this consultation or the result thereof cannot reasonably be expected.

31
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Explanation
• This section is about the deployment of private maritime security personnel and the use
of force, including the rules for the use of force. These are described in the Decree. See
below.
• Section 9 is very important for the shipmaster, as it determines that the team leader of
private security personnel - and therefore not the shipmaster - is responsible for the use
of force. This differs from the national legislation of many foreign flag states.
• The shipmaster and the team leader must consult with each other about the possible
use of force against pirates in advance unless such consultation is not possible.
• It must be established in this consultation that the protective measures have failed and
that the pirates intend to attack the ship. The decision to use force must then be taken.
See page 52 of this Manual for the checklist for this consultation between the shipmas-
ter and the team leader.
• The team leader will give the order to use force. Private security personnel will not use
force if they have not been ordered to do so by the team leader, unless there is no time
to wait for that order because danger posed by the pirates has increased unexpectedly
and suddenly.
• Of course, the shipmaster does retain the command and authority of the ship, such as
course and speed settings or avoidance manoeuvres and sailing away, but the shipmas-
ter also remains in charge of preventative protective measures, the use of the safe
room, watchkeeping, etc.
• Section 9 (8) of the Act states that the Merchant Shipping Protection Decree sets out the
instructions for the use of force for private security personnel.
• These instructions for the use of force can be found in Article 3.4 Decree.

Article 3.4.5. Decree (Further instructions for the use of force)


The team leader shall continuously keep the master informed of their orders to the team members and the course
of events relating to the use of force unless this is not reasonably possible.

Explanation
• This article contains the rules for the use of force on board when the pirates attack.

32
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• This means Dutch law gives permission to use force on board under specific circum-
stances.
• There is a clear structure in the use of force: from warning shots to shooting non-vital
body parts of the pirates.
• The team leader keeps the shipmaster informed about the incident’s developments, un-
less this is not possible.

Article 17 Regulations (Team leader)


1. Without prejudice to what has been determined by or pursuant to Sections 6, 9, 11 and 12 of the Act, the
team leader has the following tasks:
a. acting as an intermediary between the security team and the master;
b. acting as an intermediary between the licence holder and the master;
c. giving advice to the master about security measures to be taken on board the ship which do
not involve the use of weapons;
d. leading the joint drills of the security team and the crew in the maritime security activities
aimed at protecting against piracy if the master orders to do so.
2. The team leader takes at least the following actions before embarkation:
a. informing the other members of the security team about the procedure manual and the rules
governing the use of force;
b. getting the other members of the security team to sign a declaration stating that they are fa-
miliar with the content of the procedure manual and the rules governing the use of force;
c. inspecting the weapons and equipment of the members of the security team;
d. carrying out a drill with the security team in the use of weapons in particular, and
e. appointing a member of the security team as team medic.

The shipmaster must check whether the team leader has carried out
the above.

Explanation
• This article once again establishes that the team leader of private security personnel -
and therefore not the shipmaster - is responsible for the operational management of
any use of force against the pirates.
• The team leader is in charge of private security personnel, but as persons on board the
ship they are ultimately the shipmaster’s responsibility.

33
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• The shipmaster is in charge of private security personnel where the safety and public or-
der of the ship are concerned.
• The shipmaster must also check whether the team leader has performed all the pre-
scribed actions, in particular those mentioned in Article 17 (2).

Section 10.3 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


The arrested persons shall be immediately handed over to the shipmaster by the private maritime security per-
sonnel. The provisions of Title VIB of Book 4 of the Dutch Code of Criminal Procedure shall apply mutatis mutandis.

Explanation
• Article 10 (3) of the Act determines that any captured pirates must be handed over to
the shipmaster.
• The shipmaster is also responsible for the captured persons.
• The shipmaster will discuss this with the Public Prosecutor in the Netherlands.
• This is described in detail in the “Legal Handbook Shipmaster”, also published by NVKK.
• See also the provisions in the Code of Criminal Procedure.
• The Decree and the Regulations do not have any provisions about this.

Section 11.4 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


The team leader shall provide the master with the files containing the video or audio recordings to facilitate the
master’s reporting or notification obligation, as referred to in Section 12.

Explanation
• Private security personnel wear cameras and microphones during a piracy incident.
• The video and sound recordings are saved.
• The team leader gives these recordings to the shipmaster, who adds them to the notifi-
cations and reports. See also under Section 12 of the Act below.

Article 23 Regulations (Retention period)


1. The ship manager, the maritime security company, the master and the team leader are entitled to view the
video recordings and listen to the audio recordings.

34
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

2. The files with video and audio recordings will be deleted by the ship manager, the master and the private
maritime security personnel from their systems once they have been sent, together with the reports referred
to in Section 12 (2) and (3) of the Act, to the Minister or the Public Prosecution Service respectively, but no
later than within 28 days of leaving the HRA.
3. In derogation from paragraph 2, the files with video and audio recordings may be stored for a longer period
by the ship manager, the master and the private maritime security personnel where such is necessary for
the establishment, exercise or defence of a legal claim.

Explanation
• The Act states that the shipmaster may view and listen to all recordings, in-
cluding those of private security personnel.
• The shipmaster can do so via the team leader.
• As soon as the files have been sent to the Public Prosecution Service or the
Ministry in the Netherlands, they must be deleted from the systems on board.
• Otherwise, all files must be deleted 28 days after leaving the HRA.
• All files may, however, be stored on board if this is necessary for possible evi-
dence in a lawsuit.
• All this is to be decided by the shipmaster.

Section 12 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


1. For each transport on which private maritime security personnel are deployed, a report shall be drawn up,
in accordance with rules (the Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations) to be issued by the Minister, in the
Dutch or English language, separately by the master and the team leader of the private maritime security
personnel.
2. These reports shall in all cases state whether and how the powers referred to in Sections 9 and 10 have been
exercised. If these powers have been exercised, the files with video or audio recordings as referred to in
Section 11 (2) or (5) shall be attached to the reports. The reports shall be sent to the Minister.
3. Any use of force and any use of handcuffs by private maritime security personnel shall be reported in a
notification immediately by the master to the Public Prosecution Service once the risk of piracy has ended in
accordance with the rules to be issued by the Minister. The files with video or audio recordings, as referred
to in Section 11 (2) or (5), shall be attached to this notification.

35
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• Send the end-of-voyage report to the Human Environment and


Transport Inspectorate.
• Send notification about the use of force to the Public Prosecution
Office in the Netherlands.

Explanation
• Section 12 of the Act is important to the shipmaster as it deals with the notification
about the use of force and the end-of-voyage report. See also pages 31 and 35 of this
Manual.
• Sections 12 (1) and (2) state that after each transport (i.e., voyage) where armed private
security personnel were on board, a report must be prepared for the Human Environ-
ment and Transport Inspectorate. See the website for the correct address.
• Both the shipmaster and the team leader prepare an end-of-voyage report, so two dif-
ferent reports are prepared.
• This general end-of-voyage report also confirms whether force has been used and
whether handcuffs have been used.
• The video and sound recordings of the private security personnel are added to this end-
of-voyage report. See Article 11 of the Act for more details.
• For the content of this end-of-voyage report, see page 57 of this Manual. The checklists
of this Manual can be used as an annex to the official report forms. This simplifies the
shipmaster’s task.
• Section 12 (3) states that the shipmaster must issue a notification about the use of force
during a piracy incident separately. The video and sound recordings are also added to
this.
• This notification about the use of force is sent to the Public Prosecution Service in the
Netherlands immediately after the use of force.
• For the content of this notification about the use of force, see also page 52 of this Man-
ual. This checklist may be used for the notification about the use of force, as an annex to
the official form. That makes it easier for the shipmaster.

36
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

NB: even just picking up a firearm constitutes the use of force and
requires sending a notification to the Public Prosecution Service. See
also the definitions relevant to this legislation on page 15 of this
Manual

Article 6 Regulations (Embarkation form, report forms and notification about


the use of force)
1. The ship manager provides the master with the information specified in Article 2.4 (1) and (2) of the Decree
at least four hours before the embarkation of the security team, the weapons and the equipment.
2. In order to comply with the duty to verify, provided for in Section 6 (2) of the Act and Article 2.4 (1) and (2)
of the Decree, the master and the team leader will use the standard forms included in Annex 2 and Annex 3
respectively. The master will send the forms completed by the master and the team leader to the Coastguard
and the Inspectorate to inform them immediately upon embarkation.
3. For the reports, specified in Section 12 (1) of the Act, the master and the team leader of the private maritime
security personnel will use the standard form, included in Annex 4 and Annex 5 respectively. The forms, spec-
ified in paragraph 1, form part of these reports. The master and the team leader send the reports, specified
in Section 12 (1) of the Act, to the Inspectorate within 48 hours of the debarkation of the security team.
4. For the notification to be sent to the Public Prosecution Service, as provided for in Section 12 (3) of the Act,
the master will use the report forms included in Annex 6.

Explanation
• This article specifies what the shipmaster must report and when. The annexes referred
to concern the Regulations.
• This has been further elaborated in Chapter 5 of this Manual and the checklists.
• Article 6 (1) determines that the shipmaster must receive all the information from the
ship manager at least four hours before the embarkation of the security team with fire-
arms.
• Article 6 (2) determines that the shipmaster and the team leader must verify whether
they have the same information. This is done on the basis of the form from Annexes 2
and 3 of the Regulations.
• In practice, a copy of the crew list, with the required information about the members of
the security team, can also be added. This means that the shipmaster does not always
need to complete the whole form but can also add existing information to the official

37
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

form. An example is the completed checklist from this Manual. This can help the ship-
master save time.
• Article 6 (3) determines that the shipmaster must produce an end-of-voyage report, on
the basis of the official forms from Annex 4 of the Regulations. Again, the shipmaster
can use the completed checklists from the Manual. They can be added as an annex to
the official form. This means the shipmaster does not need to complete all kinds of
forms unnecessarily.
• Article 6 (4) states that the shipmaster must use the official form, Annex 6 to the Regula-
tions, for a notification about the use of force. Again, the shipmaster can use the check-
list from this Manual as an annex, which saves a lot of work.

Section 17 Merchant Shipping Protection Act


1. The Minister may impose an administrative fine on the licence holder for an amount to be determined by
ministerial regulation in respect of violation of the rules laid down by or pursuant to this Act and the condi-
tions attached to the licence.
2. The Minister may:
a. impose an administrative fine on the ship manager and the shipmaster for an amount to be
determined by ministerial regulation in respect of violation of the rules laid down by or pursu-
ant to Section 6 (1);
b. impose an administrative fine on the team leader and the master for an amount to be deter-
mined by ministerial regulation in respect of violation of Section 6 (2);
c. impose an administrative fine on the ship manager for an amount to be determined by minis-
terial regulation in respect of violation of the rules laid down by or pursuant to Section 6 (3);
d. impose an administrative fine on the master for an amount to be determined by ministerial
regulation in respect of violation of the rules laid down by or pursuant to Section 6 (4);
e. impose an administrative fine on the team leader and the master for an amount to be deter-
mined by ministerial regulation in respect of violation of the rules laid down by or pursuant to
Sections 12 (1) and (2).
3. The administrative fine to be determined based on subsections 1 or 2 shall be, at most, the amount deter-
mined for the fourth category referred to in Section 23 (4) of the Dutch Criminal Code.

Explanation
• This section is about the administrative fines that may be imposed on the shipmaster if
the shipmaster breaches Article 6 of the Act (see above);

38
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

• An administrative fine may be imposed on the shipmaster if one of the following occurs:
o A breach of the rules on protective equipment;
o The permission to use private security personnel has not been properly checked
(verified);
o Failure to check private security personnel properly on embarkation, including all
data on the security personnel, firearms, ammunition, cameras, etc. In short,
check (verify) with the team leader whether you both have all the correct data;
o Noncompliance with the rules about the shipmaster’s responsibility for the
safety of the ship and those on board in connection with the maritime security
activities;
o Failure to send a notification about the use of force or the end-of-voyage report.
• The administrative fine for the above breaches is € 4,500 maximum.
• The amounts of the other fines are set in the Regulations. (See below.)

Article 20 Regulations (Administrative fine imposed on the shipmaster)


The highest administrative fine that may be imposed on the master for a violation of Section 6 (1) and (4) and
Section 12 (1) and (2) of the Act and Article 6 (2) in conjunction with Article 2.4 of the Decree is the same as the
second category fine provided for in Section 23 (4) of the Criminal Code.

Explanation

An administrative fine may be imposed on the shipmaster for


breaching Section 17 of the Act (see above), but also for breaching
several other sections of the Act (see below).

The shipmaster may be fined when one of the following sections are breached:
• Merchant Shipping Protection Act
o Section 6 (1): Failure to apply sufficient protective measures;
o Section 6 (2) / Article 2.4 Decree: Sailing into the area with a high piracy risk
(HRA) without sufficient protection;
o Section 6 (4): Failure to take the additional responsibilities, such as checking the
permission for the use of private security personnel and of all the data on secu-
rity personnel, firearms, ammunition, cameras, microphones, etc.;

39
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

o Section 12 (1): failure to submit an end-of-voyage report to the Human Environ-


ment and Transport Inspectorate;
o Section 12 (2): failure to submit a notification about the use of force to the Public
Prosecution Service.
• These fines are imposed by the supervisory officials of the Human Environment and
Transport Inspectorate.
• The maximum amount of this fine is € 4,500.
• The Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate applies a schedule of fines with the
exact amount of the administrative fines for each violation.
• The shipmaster must ensure there are reasonably adequate protective measures in
place before and during the voyage. The shipmaster can check the official permission for
that purpose, which must be sent to them by the ship manager.
• The shipmaster may be fined if they depart to an HRA and not all the rules have been
met. In that case, the shipmaster must postpone departure. The same applies to enter-
ing an HRA without sufficient protective measures.
• Some rules, such as those about the unlawful use of force, can also be enforced under
criminal law in the Netherlands, i.e. via the police and the Public Prosecution Service.
• In short, if the shipmaster breaches any rules from the Merchant Shipping Protection
Act, the Merchant Shipping Protection Decree or the Merchant Shipping Protection Reg-
ulations, the shipmaster may incur an administrative fine or be brought to trial under
criminal law.

40
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

4. Checklists
4.1. Introduction
The core of this Manual consists of a number of checklists that can help ensure that the
shipmaster does not forget anything when a voyage involves passing through an area with a
high piracy risk.

The checklists make sure that the inspection of the tasks carried out on board is complete,
comprehensive and systematic.
The purpose of a checklist or inspection list is to tick off a list of items that must be checked,
so that nothing is forgotten. The checklists can be completed with yes/no answers or a brief
comment.

The checklist also serves to give the shipmaster of a ship sailing under the Dutch flag a clear
structure before, during and after any possible violent incident with pirates, while there are
armed private security personnel on board.

There are several checklists, from voyage preparation to the final report to the Minister in
the Netherlands.

All checklists start on a new page, so that each checklist can be downloaded and printed in-
dividually on board. That means everyone in any place can use the same checklist. Because
of the unique numbering system, a checklist can easily be completed by more than one per-
son.

Of course, the checklists are not always complete for each ship in each situation, but they
can serve as an aid for the shipmaster. The shipmaster can always add items to the check-
lists, reflecting the specific situation.

More general and detailed checklists can be found on the internet. See also Annex 1 of this
Manual for references. Those checklists and books are not specifically intended for Dutch

41
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

ships and Dutch legislation, but they do provide the shipmaster with useful background in-
formation.

The Merchant Shipping Protection Act states that several reports and notifications must be
issued by the shipmaster. The corresponding Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations
state which reports, and notifications must be issued, including the corresponding standard
forms.
These standard forms sometimes ask for information that is already kept up to date on
board, such as crew lists and journals.

Existing data and completed checklists from this Manual may be sent
as annexes with the standard forms prescribed by law. In other
words, they do not need to be completed again. This can potentially
save the shipmaster a lot of time.

If the supervisory body requires more details, it may ask the shipmaster to provide them.

The checklists in English can also be used for sending notifications to the Maritime Security
Centre - Horn of Africa (MSCHOA), United Kingdom Marine Trade Operations (UKMTO),
Netherlands Coastguard and the ship manager.

You will find the following checklists in this Manual:


A. Checklist: Preparing the voyage
B. Checklist: Outside the area with a high piracy risk (HRA)
C. Checklist: Inside the area with a high piracy risk (HRA)
D. Checklist: Consultation between shipmaster and team leader about the use of force
E. Checklist: Notification about the use of force
F. Checklist: Reporting after the voyage

42
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Checklist A Checklist B Checklist C


Preparing Outside HRA Inside HRA
the voyage

Checklist F
End-of voyage- Checklist D
report Consultation
Shipmaster/teamleader

Checklist E
Notification use of force

Figure 5. Overview of checklists

43
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

A. Checklist: Preparing the voyage

This checklist concerns all the preparations before the voyage, from the moment it is known
that the ship will sail through an area with a high piracy risk until armed private security per-
sonnel embark the ship. Certain protective measures obviously have to be taken at an early
stage, in which the ship manager plays an important role.
This checklist can be used in respect of the shipmaster’s duty to verify and consult with the
team leader. (Section 6 of the Act, Article 2.4 Decree and Article 6 Regulations).
See also the forms of Annexes 2 and 3 to the Regulations. Checklist A can be added to these
legal forms as an annex, which will save the shipmaster time when filling in the official
forms.

A Checklist:
Preparing the voyage
A.1. Date/place of embarkation and debarkation of security personnel and
firearms.
Embarkation:
Debarkation:
A.2. Has the shipmaster thoroughly checked the security personnel and their YES/NO
firearms on embarkation?
A.3. Are the number of security personnel and their names and nationality YES/NO
in accordance with the ship manager’s information / the official permis-
sion?
A.4. Is the number, brand, type and registration number of the firearms in YES/NO
accordance with the ship manager’s information / the official permis-
sion?
A.5. Is the number and calibre of the ammunition in accordance with the YES/NO
ship manager’s information / the official permission?

44
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

A.6. Are the corresponding official documents of security personnel, fire- YES/NO
arms and ammunition, including those of the coastal state, in accord-
ance with ship manager’s information / the official permission?
A.7. Are the weapons safes on board in accordance with the rules? YES/NO
A.8. Number of sets of handcuffs known and on board? YES/NO
A.9. Number of cameras and microphones known and on board? YES/NO
A.10. Copy of end user’s certificates for the legal ownership of firearms on YES/NO
board?
A.11. Copy of ship manager’s permission and contract between ship manager YES/NO
and maritime security company (licence holder) on board?
A.12. Copy of licence and all ISO certificates, such as 9001:2015, 2800:2007 YES/NO
and 28007:2015 on board?
A.13. Was the departure postponed because not all conditions and rules were YES/NO
complied with?
A.14. Are the weapons and ammunition stored in accordance with the rules? YES/NO
A.15. Has the knowledge among the private security personnel of Dutch legis- YES/NO
lation on piracy, such as the rules for the use of force, been checked?
A.16. Has there been adequate consultation (verification) between the ship- YES/NO
master and the team leader, including the exchange of information as
prescribed in the legislation?
A.17 Have all important phone numbers on board been checked and distrib- YES/NO
uted?
A.18 Is there a policy about having AIS on/off in the HRA? YES/NO
A.19 Have all reasonably possible protective measures been taken in accord- YES/NO
ance with the official permission, BMP and SSP?
A.20. Anything to add or any comments?

45
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

B. Checklist: Outside the high-risk area (HRA)

This checklist is used from the time when the security team embarks the ship until the area
with a high piracy risk is reached.

B Checklist:
Outside the high-risk area (HRA)
B.1. Have any drills with crew and private security personnel taken place, YES/NO
e.g., about the rules for the use of force?
B.2. Do those on board - in particular private security personnel - have YES/NO
knowledge about and comply with the rules for the use of force?
B.3. Are the shipmaster’s express wish and order to prevent the use of force YES/NO
and only use this out of legitimate self-defence, in accordance with the
legal standards, known to all persons on board?
B.4. Do those on board have knowledge about and comply with all the in- YES/NO
structions of the Public Prosecution in the Netherlands and also, where
relevant, of the coastal state?
B.5. Does the shipmaster keep the key of the weapons safes, as prescribed YES/NO
in the legislation?
B.6. Have the private security personnel been integrated into the safety YES/NO
protocols on board, such as opportunities for drills and protection, but
also lifeboat drills and fire drills?
B.7. Have the shift rosters and working and resting hours of the private se- YES/NO
curity personnel been checked by the shipmaster?
B.8. Are weapons and ammunition stored separately, as prescribed by law? YES/NO
B.9. Has the ammunition been checked in accordance with the rules, e.g. YES/NO
temperature and storage life?

46
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

B.10. Have all the protective measures been taken as prescribed in the legis- YES/NO
lation and BMP?
B.11. Has the shipmaster given permission for firing exercises? YES/NO
B.12. Have the weapons been used by certified persons only? YES/NO
B.13. Have the keys to the arms safes been transferred to the team leader YES/NO
two hours before entering the HRA?
B.14. Will an opportunity to sail in convoy in the HRA be used? YES/NO
B.15. Are any opportunities for extra protection, e.g. by royal navy ships, be- YES/NO
ing used?
B.16. Have the time and location of entering the HRA been established? YES/NO
B.17. Have the entry into the HRA and the ship’s movements been reported YES/NO
to the locally coordinating authorities, such as MSCHOA and UKMTO?
B.18. Are all points of access to accommodation and control rooms blocked YES/NO
from access from outside?
B.19. Have all openings that could give pirates access to accommodation YES/NO
(portholes, doors, etc.) been locked?
B.20. Have the most likely scenarios been checked? YES/NO
B.21. Have the persons on board been informed about a safe position, such YES/NO
as the citadel?
B.22. Additional information and comments

47
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

C. Checklist: Inside the high-risk area (HRA)

The checklist below will help the shipmaster when sailing in an area with a high piracy risk
(HRA) and in the event of a possible confrontation with pirates. All protective measures
must be taken before the HRA is entered.

C Checklist:
Inside the high-risk area (HRA)
C.1. Have all protective measures been taken? YES/NO
C.2. Have the lookouts been briefed and put into strategic places? YES/NO
C.3. Are dummies being used? YES/NO
C.4. Are warnings on banners being used? YES/NO
C.5. Is the policy for navigation lights and deck lights known and being imple- YES/NO
mented?
C.6. Have tools, gas cylinders, etc. been locked away? YES/NO
C.7. Has the bridge been set up as the control centre? YES/NO
C.8. Are the radar and other relevant instruments under constant surveillance? YES/NO
C.9. Are there specific brief shifts for guards on deck and on the bridge? YES/NO
C.10. Are there any ships that are trying to get closer? YES/NO
C.11. Has any manoeuvring taken place to keep a distance from possible danger? YES/NO
C.12. Have any avoidance manoeuvres been carried out? YES/NO
C.13. Have the swell, waves, wind, etc. been used to prevent the approach and YES/NO
boarding by pirates?
C.14. Are the daily positions, incidents, SITReps, etc. passed on to the authori- YES/NO
ties?
C.15. Are shift rosters and work lists kept for private maritime security person- YES/NO
nel?

48
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

C.16. Does the team leader take responsibility for the storage, management and YES/NO
use of all weapons and ammunition after receiving the key?
C.17. Have the Ship Security Plan (SSP), the Ship Security Alert System (SSAS) and YES/NO
the Automatic Identification System (AIS) been activated?
C.18. Have the Best Management Practices (BMP) been implemented and main- YES/NO
tained?
C.19. Have the time and location of incidents been recorded? YES/NO
C.20. Is the emergency communication plan ready for immediate start? YES/NO
C.21. Are all statutory rules complied with? YES/NO
C.22. Additional information and comments.

49
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

D. Checklist: Consultation between shipmaster/teamleader about use of


force
• The Act states that the shipmaster and the team leader must consult with each other
about the result of all protective measures first before the team leader may give an or-
der to use force.
• This consultation takes place as soon as the ship is threatened by pirates, but it must al-
low the team leader sufficient time to secure the ship and the persons on board.
• If there is no time within reason to wait for this consultation, the team leader may use
force against the pirates.
• The advice is to record the date/time of this consultation in the ship’s log.
• From that moment, the team leader is responsible for the use of force against the pi-
rates.
• The checklist below can be used for this consultation between shipmaster and team
leader. If all the boxes have been ticked, this is a strong indication that the team leader
may give an order to use force and will be responsible for this. From that moment, the
shipmaster is not responsible for the use of force.
• The shipmaster will always remain responsible for all other shipping matters, such as
navigation, deciding on the course and speed, manoeuvres to avoid the pirates’ ships
and regular ship management.

D Checklist:
Consultation between shipmaster and teamleader about the
use of force
D.1. The ship is in the HRA? YES/NO
D.2. All relevant protective measures have been taken (SSP and BMP)? YES/NO
D.3. Requested help from the locally coordinating authorities (MSCHOA, YES/NO
UKMTO, etc.)?
D.4. The preventative protective measures have not averted the threat? YES/NO
D.5. Do the pirates have weapons, a ladder or other climbing equipment? YES/NO

50
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

D.6. Have the pirates shown any weapons? YES/NO


D.7. Have the pirates used any weapons? YES/NO
D.8. Is there any immediate threat? YES/NO
D.9. Is the safety of the ship, persons on board and cargo at risk? YES/NO
D.10. Have all the options to prevent the use of force been applied in vain? YES/NO
D.11. Is there any assistance in the proximity? YES/NO
D.12. Is everyone familiar with the rules for the use of force? YES/NO
D.13. Is the use of force recorded wherever possible? YES/NO
D.14. Have the team leader and the shipmaster concluded that all possible YES/NO
preventative measures have failed and that only the use of force can de-
fend the ship and the persons on board against assaulting pirates?
D.15. Is the use of force the last resort to protect the ship, the persons on YES/NO
board and the cargo?
D.16. Additional information and comments?

51
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

E. Checklist: Notification about the use of force

• The shipmaster must issue many notifications and reports. Some notifications and re-
ports are required by law, while others are strongly recommended. See page 60.
• All notifications and reports can also be sent to the ship manager, if the ship manager
has not prescribed their own reporting system.
• Throughout the voyage through the area with a high piracy risk, the shipmaster must re-
port to locally coordinating authorities such as MSCHOA and UKMTO.
• A notification about the use of force and the end-of-voyage report must be sent to the
Dutch authorities.
• Below you will find the checklist for the notification about the use of force sent to the
Public Prosecution Service in the Netherlands, which is required by law.
• This notification is drawn up by the shipmaster immediately after the use of force. The
team leader does not report on the use of force.
• The notification about the use of force consists of different parts: before, during and af-
ter the use of force. These notifications can be added to the general end-of-voyage re-
port sent to the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate.
• The notification about the use of force is not the same as end-of-voyage report on the
whole voyage. That is a separate report and is directed to the Human Environment and
Transport Inspectorate. See page 64.

This Checklist E can be used as an annex to the official report form


on the use of force in accordance with Annex 6 to the Regulations.

E Checklist:
Notification about the use of force
Basic data
E.1. Ship’s name:

52
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

E.2. Call sign:


E.3. IMO number:
E.4. Name and contact details of the shipmaster:

E.5. Name and contact details of the ship manager/DPA:

E.6. Details of permission for sailing with private security personnel:

E.7. Name and contact details of the security company:

E.8. Name and contact details of the team leader:

E.9. Details of the security company’s licence:

E.10. Details of the contract between ship manager and security company:

Incident including the use of force


E.11. Date and time (GMT) of start and end of the incident:
E.12. Ship’s position:

E.13. Your ship’s freeboard during the attack:


E.14. Light or dark?
E.15. Your ship’s course and speed:
E.16. Avoidance manoeuvres carried out? YES/NO
E.17. Weather conditions and conditions of the sea:

E.18. Pirates’ mother ship present? YES/NO


E.19. Type and number of pirates’ assault boats:

53
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

E.20. Number of pirates:


E.21. Type and number of pirates’ weapons and ammunition:

E.22. Weapons shown by pirates? YES/NO


E.23. Do the pirates have any ladders or other climbing equipment? YES/NO
E.24. Immediate threat posed by pirates? YES/NO
E.25. Safety of your own ship, cargo and those on board at risk? YES/NO
E.26. Possibility of external assistance? YES/NO
E.27. Citadel / safe room in use? YES/NO
E.28. Alarm raised? YES/NO
E.29. Have any requests for assistance been issued by the shipmaster? YES/NO
E.30. Measures/actions taken by the shipmaster:

E.31. Measures/actions taken by the team leader:

E.32. Measures/actions taken by those on board, e.g., use of safe room:

E.33. Are the protective measures no longer sufficient? YES/NO


E.34. Has any consultation taken place between shipmaster and team leader YES/NO
about the use of force?
E.35. Distance between pirate vessel and your own ship while using force:

E.36. Use of force by pirates? YES/NO


E.37. Shots in the air or targeted shots by pirates? YES/NO
E.38. Attempt, boarding or kidnapping by the pirates? YES/NO
E.39. Time of transfer of responsibility for use of force to team leader:

54
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

E.40. Use of force ordered by team leader? YES/NO


E.41. Weapons taken up and shown by private security personnel? YES/NO
E.42. Use of force only according to rules for the use of force, out of legitimate YES/NO
self-defence?
E.43. Use of force within the legislation and instructions? YES/NO
E.44. Compliance with the rules for the use of force? YES/NO
E.45. What kind of force has been used by the security personnel and for what purpose?

E.46. Use of force against pirates in their boat at sea? YES/NO


E.47. Use of force against pirates on board, including putting on handcuffs? YES/NO
E.48. Structure of use of force followed? YES/NO
E.49. Warning shots by security personnel? YES/NO
E.50. Shots targeting pirate vessel or persons? YES/NO
E.51. Casualties? YES/NO
E.52. Injury of and assistance to casualties? YES/NO
E.53. Use of force by others, e.g. a naval vessel to provide assistance? YES/NO
E.54. Pirates flee with own vessels? YES/NO
E.55. Pirates captured at sea by, for example, naval vessels? YES/NO
E.56. Pirates apprehended on board and handed over to the shipmaster? YES/NO
E.57. Recorded in ship’s log, etc.? YES/NO
E.58. Add video and sound such as film, video and photos as an annex. YES/NO
E.59. Witness statements present? YES/NO
E.60. Status of casualties known? YES/NO
E.61. Treatment of apprehended pirates? YES/NO
E.62. Incident assessment by the team leader of the private security person- YES/NO
nel?
E.63. Incident assessment by the shipmaster, in which the shipmaster argues YES/NO
convincingly that they have done all they could to prevent the use of

55
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

force and that all rules were observed by the shipmaster and those on
board during the use of force?
E.64. Reported to the Dutch Coastguard and the locally coordinating authori- YES/NO
ties?
E.65. Time when the ship resumes its voyage?

E.66. Damage assessment? YES/NO


E.67. Comments and additional information

E.68. Signed by the shipmaster

56
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

F. Checklist: Reporting after the voyage


Below you will find the checklist for the general end-of-voyage report to be sent to the Hu-
man Environment and Transport Inspectorate. This mandatory report is written by the ship-
master after the voyage. The team leader also reports to the Inspectorate after the voyage,
independently and separately. So, both reports go to the Inspectorate. The email addresses
can be found on the Inspectorate’s website.

NB: The notification about the use of force is a separate notification and is sent to the Public
Prosecution Service in the Netherlands. See Checklist E.

Any notifications about the use of force must be added to this general end-of-voyage report
to the Inspectorate. See also page 57 of this Manual.

• Checklist F is the end-of-voyage report for the shipmaster, or it can be


used for this purpose.
• The shipmaster can use all the completed checklists to compile the
end-of-voyage report, i.e., Checklist F, for example by adding all the
completed checklists as an annex to the legal form (Annex 4 to the
Regulations) of the official end-of-voyage report; the video and audio
recordings can also be added.

F End-of-voyage report
F.01. Ship’s name:
F.02. Call sign:
F.03. IMO number:
F.04. Name and contact details of the shipmaster:

F.05. Name and contact details of the ship manager/DPA:

57
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

F.06. Details of permission for sailing with private security personnel:

F.07. Name and contact details of the security company:

F.08. Name and contact details of the team leader:

F.09. Details of the security company’s licence:

F.10. Details of the contract between ship manager and security company:

F.11. Add completed Checklist A YES/NO


F.12. Add completed Checklist B YES/NO
F.13. Add completed Checklist C YES/NO
F.14. Add completed Checklist D YES/NO
F.15. Add completed Checklist E YES/NO
F.16. Add video and audio recordings YES/NO
F.17. Shipmaster’s signature
F.18. Additional information and comments.

58
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

End-of-
Shipping
voyage Prosecuter
report Inspection

Ship manager
Share all
information
Notification
use-of-force

Teamleader
Private guards Use-of-force
Firearms
• Make sure/verify
• Check at
embarkation

Foreign/local authorities

Reporting in/out
HRA etc.

Figure 6. Overview of shipmaster’s network for combating piracy

59
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

5. Explanatory notes
5.1. Introduction
These explanatory notes will briefly deal with the following:
• Gathering information;
• Use of force;
• Mandatory notifications and reports;
• Fines imposed on the shipmaster.

The explanation is given from the shipmaster’s point of view and as a clarification for the
shipmaster. The shipmaster is and remains the key player when there is an incident with pi-
rates. The shipmaster is responsible for ship, crew and cargo.

5.2. Gathering information


The shipmaster can use different sources to gather information.
Several international and national organisations are often active in areas with a high piracy
risk around the Horn of Africa.

These organisations try to work together, but they do not always succeed in this. This is due
to the presence of foreign naval vessels, which usually only assist the ships sailing under the
flag of their own country and in some cases other merchant ships. They do not participate in
the international coalition.

The shipmaster must actively gather all information needed to guide


the ship through the area with a high piracy risk as safely as possible.
This applies from preparing the voyage to leaving the dangerous
area.

For up-to-date information, the websites of these organisations should be consulted.


The NATO Shipping Centre and Netherlands Coastguard can also play an important role in
this, including the references to other ministries. Other interesting sources of information
include IMO/Maritime Security and Piracy, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC)

60
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

and its department Commercial Crime Services, as well as the International Maritime Bu-
reau (IMB) and its Piracy Reporting Centre.
All these organisations provide information on their websites.
They also often have specific information for the shipmaster. See also Annex 1 of this Man-
ual.

5.3. Use of force


Force is any more-than-minor compulsive force exercised on persons or property, using a
weapon.

Weapons are the equipment and weapons designated under the Act for the use of force.
Even just holding and displaying a firearm constitutes the use of force.

The use of force is prohibited and punishable, and this also applies on board. An exception is
an instance where force is used based on the Dutch Merchant Shipping Protection Act or as
legitimate self-defence.
The use of force on board is regulated in the Netherlands in the approved Rules for the Use
of Force (RUF). These are generally not national laws or rules originating from the govern-
ment, but regulations applied within a profession.

RUF applied on board must have been approved by the Dutch gov-
ernment and must be known to the shipmaster, crew and private se-
curity personnel. It is up to the shipmaster to check whether the lat-
ter is the case. The shipmaster will do so in consultation with the
team leader. This can also be recorded, e.g., in the ship’s log.

Normally, the use of force against pirates takes place outside the territorial sea of a coastal
state, i.e., in international waters. If the use of force took place in the territorial waters of a
coastal state, there is a chance that this coastal state also requires a notification or report.
This may be the case because the legislation of that coastal state also applies in its territorial
waters. The best thing you can do is to send the notification/report to the coastal state as
well, in consultation and in cooperation with the ship manager.

61
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

5.4. Notifications and reports

Required
Notifications & Reports

Nationally Internationally

Notification End-of-
about the use voyage
MSCHOA UKMTO
of force to report to
PPO Inspectorate
Figure 7. Overview of notifications and reports issued by the shipmaster

Nationally
For the shipmaster, there are two forms of reporting that are nationally required by law:
1. Notification about the use of force to the Public Prosecution Office in the Netherlands;
2. Report to the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate at the end of the voyage
with private security personnel.

Notification about the use of force


After using force against pirates, the shipmaster must send a notification about this to the
Public Prosecution Service in the Netherlands immediately. See Checklist E of this Manual.
Even just picking up a firearm and threatening to use it or the use of handcuffs constitutes
the use of force. This notification is prepared by the shipmaster and should be brief, factual,
clear and concise, with the checklist as guideline. See page 42 of this Manual.

This is a notification, not a report.

62
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

The checklist does not aim to be complete. Subjects can and may be added to it at any time,
especially if those subjects are relevant to demonstrating that the shipmaster has done eve-
rything possible to act within the applicable legislation.

The shipmaster must send all the relevant video and sound recordings with the notification
about the use of force. The team leader must make these recordings available to the ship-
master for that purpose.

Following the notification about the use of force, the Public Prosecution Service may ask for
a more detailed report. The same checklist can then be used again, adding a more detailed
description and answers to specific questions from the Public Prosecution Service.

Procedure for notification after use of force on board


1. The shipmaster sends a notification about the use of force to the Public Prosecution Ser-
vice, possibly via the ship manager.
2. The ship manager may add their own views to this notification.
3. In principle, the team leader - not the shipmaster - is responsible for the use of force on
board.
4. The Public Prosecution Service may ask the shipmaster for a further, more detailed re-
port.
5. The Public Prosecution Service will decide whether the use of force was lawful or unlaw-
ful.
6. If the use of force was lawful, the Public Prosecution Service will report this to the team
leader, the maritime security company and the shipmaster, possibly via the ship man-
ager.
7. If the use of force was unlawful or if there is any doubt, the Dutch police will start an in-
vestigation on the instructions of the Public Prosecution Service.
8. On the basis of this police investigation, the Public Prosecution Service will decide
whether to bring charges against the team leader or private security guard.
9. The shipmaster can be heard as a witness.

63
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

10. If this leads to criminal proceedings, the court will ultimately decide about the lawful-
ness of the use of force.
11. Following this, an appeal to a higher court or the Supreme Court is possible, if the team
leader / security guard disagrees with the court decision about the use of force against
the pirates.

End-of-voyage report
After the end of each voyage with private maritime security personnel, shipmaster and
team leader must report to the Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate separately.
See also Checklist F from this Manual.

The end-of-voyage report can be compiled from all completed check-


lists from this Manual.

The end-of-voyage report of the shipmaster also states whether any weapons were raised
and used. If so, it states how this was done, if an order was given to do so and if the rules for
the use of force were observed. But it also mentions whether any persons were appre-
hended, whether they tried to escape and whether they were handed over to the shipmas-
ter.
Previous notifications about the use of force sent to the Public Prosecution Service in the
Netherlands can also be used for this end-of-voyage report, for example as an annex to the
report.

The end-of-voyage report is written by the shipmaster and the team leader separately.
The shipmaster can outsource this to one of the persons on board, such as the Ship Security
Officer (SSO), but the shipmaster signs the report as the person responsible.

This report is a brief chronological outline of the facts and circumstances and contains the
parts mentioned in the previously completed checklists. This report is accompanied by all
the video and sound recordings made. The team leader will make them available to the
shipmaster.

64
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Internationally

A ship entering the HRA must report to several civil or military organ-
isations.

This is provided for in the Merchant Shipping Protection Regulations and comes under the
protective measures the shipmaster must take.
The shipmaster can also call or email these organisations to request assistance in the event
of any incident involving pirates.

Keeping the communication with these organisations open, e.g., by reporting on the ship’s
movements through the HRA and requesting assistance when there is a risk of an attack, is
therefore a protective measure. These organisations have different communication chan-
nels, such as email, logging in on their websites, telephone, the on board communication
system and also Twitter.

The two most important international organisations for the HRA in the Gulf of Aden and
along part of the coast of East Africa are discussed in brief below.

MSCHOA
The Maritime Security Centre - Horn of Africa (MSCHOA) is part of the EU: it belongs to EU
NAVFOR as the maritime pillar of the EU counter-piracy mission Atalanta. This therefore
only applies to East Africa.
MSCHOA monitors maritime merchant shipping movements around the Horn of Africa and
forms the link between the military operation Atalanta and merchant shipping.
A ship manager or shipmaster can register with this organisation voluntarily. This is referred
to as the EU NAVFOR Voluntary Registration Scheme, VRS.

The shipmaster notifies the organisation of the anticipated course and speed. This is done
via the Vessel Movement Form, which is also sent to the Dutch Coastguard.

65
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

MSCHOA also has an interactive website, enabling the shipmaster to see on board where
any incidents are taking place or what the latest protective measures are.
MSCHOA also shows maps of the HRA on its website with the recommended routes, the so-
called Maritime Security Transit Corridors or the Internationally Recommended Transit Cor-
ridors (IRTS). The shipmaster must report when the ship enters or leaves the corridor.

Always visit this organisation’s website for the latest information: www.mschoa.org

UKMTO
United Kingdom Marine Trade Operations (UKMTO) forms part of the British Royal Navy. It
also keeps track of all the data on shipping in the HRA.

UKMTO’s role is to gather and distribute information and also to coordinate military assis-
tance in the event of a pirate attack. It gets a lot of information from local governments and
organisations. As the UK is no longer part of the EU, this may lead to a degree of confusion.

UKMTO would also like to be informed when a ship passes through the HRA, uses corridors
and leaves the HRA. But it would also like to hear about any suspicious activity or actual pi-
rate attack.

Always visit this organisation’s website for the latest information: www.ukmto.org

5.5. Overview of fines imposed on the shipmaster


The Act, the Decree and the Regulations are enforced by officials of the Human Environment
and Transport Inspectorate of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management. Any
fines imposed are administrative fines.

This legislation provides for administrative fines for different people or companies, such as
the licence holder, the ship manager, the team leader and the shipmaster. An administrative
fine is a sanction under administrative law that can be imposed by the Human Environment

66
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

and Transport Inspectorate without intervention of the police, the Public Prosecution Ser-
vice or a court.
An objection or an appeal can be lodged against an administrative fine. For more infor-
mation, see Legal Handbook Shipmaster.

However, the Public Prosecutor can also enforce legislation when criminal law is concerned.
This may be the case, for example, when innocent fishermen rather than pirates are shot at.
In such case the court will pass its judgement, which can be appealed against at the Court of
Appeal or even at the Supreme Court: See the Criminal Code and the Code of Criminal Pro-
cedure. These laws are also explained in Legal Handbook Shipmaster.

Protective measures
The ship manager must provide the shipmaster with sufficient and adequate protective
measures. On board the ship, the shipmaster is responsible for them. Exceptions to the rea-
sonably possible protective measures on board are in the official permission provided by the
ship manager to the shipmaster.
If the shipmaster takes insufficient protective measures, this may incur a fine of € 4,500
maximum.

No permission for private security personnel


If there is no official permission for armed private security personnel but the shipmaster
nevertheless takes them on board, the shipmaster can be given a considerable fine.
The ship manager will ask the Minister for permission to sail with armed protection. If that
permission for armed private security has been granted, the ship manager must notify the
shipmaster and present a copy of the document granting permission.

Before the armed security personnel board the ship, the shipmaster must check whether
the ship manager has been officially granted permission for armed private security person-
nel by the Minister. If this permission is not in order, the shipmaster may receive a fine of €
4,500 maximum.

67
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

End-of-voyage report
If the shipmaster fails to submit an end-of-voyage report to the Human Environment and
Transport Inspectorate, the shipmaster may be given a fine of € 4,500 maximum.

Notification about the use of force


If the shipmaster fails to submit a notification about the use of force to the Public Prosecu-
tion Service in the Netherlands, the shipmaster may be given a fine of € 4,500 maximum.

Schedule of fines
The maximum fines imposed on the shipmaster are often € 4,500.
The total sum of the fines imposed on the shipmaster may amount to thousands of euros.
The Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate has compiled a schedule of fines, stat-
ing the concrete amounts of the fines for each infringement. These fines are called adminis-
trative fines.

68
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

Annex 1 Recommended literature and websites

The documents and websites mentioned below contain a lot of detailed information about
piracy. These are general documents that do not focus on the shipmaster.
But reading these documents will give the shipmaster a good overview of the general inter-
national context of piracy.

This Manual only applies to the Gulf of Aden and along a section of
the coast of East Africa, in the High-Risk Area.

1. Legal Handbook Shipmaster, available free of charge on the NVKK website:


https://www.nvkk.nl/files/1116/1996/2043/JHK_2021digitaal_.pdf
2. BMP5, Best Management Practices to Deter Piracy and Enhance Maritime Security in the
Red Sea, Gulf of Aden, Indian Ocean and Arabian Sea (2018):
(http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Security/PiracyArmedRobbery/Docu-
ments/BMP%20West%20Africa.pdf).
3. IMO documents about piracy:
(http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Security/PiracyArmedRobbery/Pages/Default.aspx).
4. IMO-Piracy and armed robbery against ships:
https://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Security/Pages/PiracyArmedRobberydefault.aspx
5. IMO-Global Counter Piracy Guidance for Companies, Masters and Seafarers (2018):
(http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Security/PiracyArmedRobbery/Documents/global-
counter-piracy-guidance-bmp_low_17-07-18.pdf).
6. UN & Piracy under International Law:
https://www.un.org/Depts/los/piracy/piracy.htm
7. NATO Shipping Centre:
• https://shipping.nato.int/nsc
• https://shipping.nato.int/nsc/operations/global-maritime-risk
8. Counter-piracy under International Law:
https://www.geneva-academy.ch/joomlatools-files/docman-files/Publications/Acad-
emy%20Briefings/Counterpiracy%20Briefing%201.pdf

69
Anti-Piracy Manual Shipmaster (1/1/2023)

9. Maritime Security Centre - Horn of Africa (MSCHOA):


https://on-shore.mschoa.org/home/
10. Netherlands Coastguard:
www.kustwacht.nl
11. International Chamber of Shipping (ICS):
https://www.ics-shipping.org/free-resources/maritime-security
12. IMB Piracy Reporting Centre:
https://www.icc-ccs.org/index.php/piracy-reporting-centre
13. ICC Commercial Crime Services:
https://www.icc-ccs.org/
14. UKMTO, United Kingdom Marine Trade Operations:
• https://www.ukmto.org/indian-ocean/recent-incidents
• Contacts: https://www.ukmto.org/indian-ocean/contacts
• Reporting Formats: https://www.ukmto.org/indian-ocean/reporting-formats

70

You might also like