1670 4275 1 PB
1670 4275 1 PB
1670 4275 1 PB
net/publication/316700169
CITATIONS READS
13 18,368
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Md. Shahidul Islam on 06 May 2017.
Abstract: This paper briefly discusses the growth, types and activities and both positive and negative impacts of NGOs
in Bangladesh. The result showed the NGOs have started their work in Bangladesh as a relief and rehabilitation
activities but they are now becoming a large partner of the government for socio-economic development. After that, this
paper also showed the implementer, catalyst, and partner role of the NGOs in Bangladesh. Although NGOs have the
largely positive impact in our socioeconomic development especially in the grassroots level, they have also negative
impact in our society. Some NGOs in Bangladesh is working like as a quasi commercial activities and corporate bodies
where their main intention is to making profit. Some microcredit provider in Bangladesh working like as the traditional
banking system and they make the trap for the poor where they have to repay the loan with high interest rate. Finally,
this paper makes a clear view that NGOs’ activity in Bangladesh is positive and good.
5. The Emergence and Expansion of NGOs The historical background of NGOs in post-liberation
in Bangladesh: period can be categorized in the following discussion-
5.5.1First generation (1971-1972):After 1971
Many researchers consider the development of NGO was liberation war, the government of Bangladesh, faced
initiated with the starting of British rule in this difficulties to resettle at least ten million people with
subcontinent. But the NGOs have been developed poor resources, neither had sufficient capacity nor had
significantly since Pakistan period. The development of enough finance to deal with this war affected people in
NGOs can be divided into some periods: single handed (Ahsan, 2005). Besides that, the Pakistani
Advances in Asian Social Science (AASS) 1185
Vol. 7, No. 2, 2016, Pages: 1182-1188, ISSN: 2167-6429
Copyright © World Science Publisher, United States
www.worldsciencepublisher.org
army destroyed physical infrastructures such as bridges, society played a major role to the end of Ershad regime
roads, highways, and rail tracks. The whole country was too. Through the anti-autocracy movement in 1990, the
distorted into various parts and it was very difficult to civil society was developed and extended their works in
reach government support to the remote places. Bangladesh. At that time, many organization like the
At this time, NGOs in Bangladesh emerged to rights of women in society committee, help to law-
undertake relief and rehabilitation activities to reduce abiding committee, emancipation of woman society,
the suffering of the war victim’s people and to develop crime reporters associations, democracy watch was
the physical infrastructure of this country. In that time, growth.
their prior operation was to distribute food, medicine,
blankets, cloths, etc. Among the war affected people. 5.6 Second phase (1990-to date):
Some NGO origin from outside of the Bangladesh, for
example, Terred des Honmmes supported the unwanted After 1990, NGO sectors were rapidly increased
children of the war. At this time, some indigenous NGOs because foreign assistance is available at that time.
such as BRAC, Proshika, Ganoshastho Kendro (GK), Similarly, some of the donors have established some the
Gono Shahajya Sangstha (GSS), Nijera Kori, and the specific fund for supporting specific NGOs only. In this
Association for Social Advancement (ASA) were time, NGOs have turned into enhance their activities to
established (Karim, 2001). For example, Gano Shastya maximize profit as fisheries projects, fertilizer supply,
was a well reputed a mobile medical unit, provided animal husbandry services, and handicrafts to more
medical support to the freedom fighters in 1971, RDRS recent initiatives like banking, garment manufacturing,
provided post- war rehabilitation services and supports retail outlets, telecommunications, and so forth (Devine,
and developed transpiration facility in the north-west 2006). In many political issues, civil society has broad
region and BRAC provided the necessary relief and participation. NGOs work to increase environmental
rehabilitation to the community of fishermen in the awareness, women empowerment, and preservation of
north-east (Zohir, 2004). biological diversity. By using and developing electronic
5.5.2 Second generation (1973-75): For the impact of media, civil society creates public opinion in particular
globalization and transfer of state power, the role of NGO issues. Civil society has the great enterprise in the
has been changed and emphasized on integrated formation of the Care Taker Government, changing
community development programs. By receiving foreign government in 1996 as well as 2001 and to mitigate
funds, NGO sectors emergent with the strongest role in extreme political crisis and conflict in 2006, those made
development self-reliant local development sectors. At the civil society was special identity in Bangladesh. After
this time, Swanirvar Bangladesh (SB) was established to 1990, Awami League and (Bangladesh Nationalist Party)
increase agricultural production and attain self- BNP supported civil society, two different and opposite
sufficiency to the deprive people and played an effective civil society has been observed. Researchers remarked
role in mobilizing youth in rural areas and small towns to that in the political issues, the civil society has great
reduce pilferage in the delivery of relief and development political division. Particularly, civil society has played an
services through government channels(Zohir, 2004).But important role to change the political scenario in the
disfavoring the relief activities, NGOs have transformed context of 1/11 in Bangladesh.
themselves to create an effective organizational
mechanism for performing work at the grass-roots level 6. Positive aspect of NGOs
especially for the poor because they realized that merely NGOs are now considered as the third sectors that
relief efforts do not solve the problem of the poor come forward to provide social services to people of this
(Haider, 2011). For that reason, their activities expanded country. NGOs have achieved greater success in case of
to rehabilitation program such as agriculture, fisheries, developing the socioeconomic condition in the remote
livestock, cooperatives, health and family planning, adult rural area whether the government failed to reach this
education, vocational training, etc)(Haider, 2011). area. The main aim of NGOs are to develop the socio-
5.5.3 Third generation (1976-to date): First phase: economic condition, becoming very close to the
(1976-1990): Firstly, the civil society and NGOs played government, and working as services provider besides
the important role in establishing anti-political military the government. Sometimes, many government
rule ideology and democracy, human rights and the rule departments hire NGOs for delivering their services. For
of law. Secondly, many NGOs were developed to achieve example, NGOs are supporting the government policies
the financial capability of the marginal group of people and programs; mobilize resources in many development
and at the time of martial law under president Zia, civil agenda as like as health, education, poverty reduction, etc.
society could not play the very active role beyond some NGOs have undertaken many researches in our country
professional outburst of anger and protest against the new in various aspects to understand the present situation,
political order. But civil society was very active against find out the problems and opportunities. They share
Ershad’s regime. A large number of civil societies had result with the government and on the basis of this result,
emerged to lunch against Ershad’s doctrines such as labor they give suggestion to upgrade the government policy
and peasant associations, Bar Associations, Student (Ball & Dunn, 1995).
Organizations, The SKOP (Unity Council of Workers NGOs are becoming potential forces for social and
and Employees) and so on. The Hindu-Buddha-Christian economic development in Bangladesh. It has become the
Oikya Parishad, various cultural and professional groups, essential partners for national level development. They
etc were played a significant role against him. Civil are working to raise awareness, especially enable people
Advances in Asian Social Science (AASS) 1186
Vol. 7, No. 2, 2016, Pages: 1182-1188, ISSN: 2167-6429
Copyright © World Science Publisher, United States
www.worldsciencepublisher.org
to participate in recognizing their needs in national level the government simultaneously working in many fields
(Ball & Dunn, 1995). such as poverty alleviation, micro-credit provision,
Lewis identifies three major roles of NGOs which are health and family planning, education and training, rural
the implementer, catalyst, and partner. The implementer empowerment, disaster management, water supply and
role of NGOs deals with the mobilization of the resources sanitation etc (Haque, 2004). Moreover, NGOs are now
for providing goods and services to target people, become the partner in many simple assignments like as
especially to the disadvantaged and marginalized people. agriculture, irrigation, livestock, fisheries, forestry,
NGOs are giving services in many fields such as housing, population control, environment. For example,
healthcare, microfinance, agricultural extension, BRAC started partnership with government in the area of
emergency relief, and human rights. In the time of natural empowering women and income generation activities for
disaster or manmade emergency, the government and vulnerable women (Haque, 2004). Similarly, the
donors need the assistant of NGOs for providing government began to work in partnership with Proshika
necessary support to overcome such bad situation. After in agricultural cooperative system, especially in irrigation
the independence, there arose a general understanding program whether rural poor could hold irrigation
that infrastructure development programs were not equipment. The Nobel Prize winner Grameen bank has
appropriate for the rural poor, NGO sector in Bangladesh given loan without collateral for income generation
have shifted to services delivery programs from social activities to the poor and poverty reduction. Government
mobilization or community activism. Now, NGOs are has supported this microcredit program and formed
providing food aid, credit, health care, and education to collaboration with the Grameen Bank for the
the poor people. development of the microcredit scheme.
The catalyst role refers to the NGOs’ capacity to The Government and NGOs jointly have been worked to
motivate and contribute to social transformation. They improve classroom and teaching condition in both
are conducting many activities likely as grassroots government and of NGO schools under The Primary
organizing and group formation, gender and Education Development Program (1997–2002). NGOs
empowerment work, lobbying and advocacy work, and are still working to eradicate illiteracy, especially work
attempts to influence wider policy processes through for children’s education, particularly in girls’ education.
innovation, and policy entrepreneurship. They are BRAC has started with the collaboration with
operating many projects for the transformation toward government in the education sector, has started satellite
gender equality in Bangladesh. NGOs are now operating school system based on the informal education system.
intervention to train up the School Management BRAC has provided basic education to almost 10 million
Committee (SMC) members and primary school teachers Bangladeshi students
on gender issues (DeJaeghere & Wiger, 2013). NGOs' Bangladesh government is weak for giving support to
microcredit program enhances the women empowerment her large population in terms of health care facility,
in the rural area. In Bangladesh, women are considered as especially in the rural poor. The government and NGOs
subordinate to male and could not exercise the equal right are working together to provide health care services for
to participate in the economic, social, cultural, civil and the poor especially to disadvantaged rural poor (Ullah,
political position. Most of the women have the marginal 2006). The Government and NGO partnership is
position in the society; especially in rural areas they have successful in the health sector, especially in health,
few access to educational services, health care, economic nutrition, and family planning. For example, the
activities and so on. Women in Bangladesh they engaged Bangladesh Integrated Nutrition Project jointly is run by
in many activities like that supervision of crops, the government, the community, and NGOs (Haque,
livestock rearing , fisheries, foresty, energy and family 2004). Government and NGO partnership is effective in
(domestic chores as cleaning, cooking, childcare, the area of malnutrition and the underprivileged people
fetching water and so on) (Islam, Ahmed, & Alam, living in slums (Haque, 2004). The Bangladesh
2014). These types of activities cannot enhance the government and NGOs working together in family
women position or their contribution is unacknowledged. planning program that offers awareness including
Evidence supports that if women are engaged in maintaining small family size, direct education about the
economic activities; their social conditions also raise the sexual transmitted disease and distribution of
family and society. So, NGOs are giving loan without contraceptives from doors to doors visit and
any collateral to the women so that they can start income motivational activities as well as reproductive health care
generation activities. Group lending or microcredit and surgical services of rural women and urban slums in
programs provided by NGO not only increase economic Bangladesh.
condition of the rural women but also increases the social,
economic and political empowerment to the rural women. 7. Negative aspect of NGOs
Women who are participating in group savings and credit
programs can start small-scale income generation The working sectors of NGOs, especially in the rural
activities and this economic sustain leads to social and areas, are microcredit, health care, education and so on
economic empowerment. for a long time. So the existing rural people are
The partner role refers to cooperative activities NGOs depending on the NGOs services. Likewise, NGOs have
working with the government, donors and the private made a dependency network for economic and social
sectors, such as providing support in many program or services and tided the poor to maintain the network.
project, starting many socially business. Now, NGOs and “This relationship allows the NGO to inaugurate itself as
Advances in Asian Social Science (AASS) 1187
Vol. 7, No. 2, 2016, Pages: 1182-1188, ISSN: 2167-6429
Copyright © World Science Publisher, United States
www.worldsciencepublisher.org
the friend of the poor. Through rallies and other Finally, NGO operation in are complex, multi-
gatherings, the NGO speaks for the poor—but careful dimensional and changeable in Bangladesh. It is very
consideration will show that this voice is the voice of the difficult to generalize their activity and performances.
patron—in a patron-client relationship” (Karim, 2001). Despites many problems and difficulties of the NGOs,
Moreover, poor people have little capacity to bargain they have the notable success in rural development and
with NGO at the time of getting loan. NGOs have full poverty reduction (Khurshed, 2014). They have also
autonomy to choose selective poor in terms of providing another successful effort to give the credit to the rural
loan and services. They give the loan who are able to pay poor while the traditional banking system failed in 1970
the interest with installment. Even, they only give their to19 90 (McGregor, 1994).They have played a
services who are the receiver of the microcredit but they significant role in social development and make stable
give no consideration those are not receiver. That’s position as a stable player in this country. So, in
means that the NGOs are not accessible organization for conclusion, it is revealing that NGOs’ activity in
all the poor. Bangladesh is positive and good.(Khan, 2015)
So, sometimes some NGO‘s microcredit scheme have
no difference than formal banking system and emergence
as a parallel banking system. Some NGOs are giving loan References
with high interest which is losing their philanthropic
image. They give pressured to pay the weekly installment. Abed, H. (2000). Microfinance NGOs in Bangladesh:
The some NGOs For example, the Grameen bank Growth, impact and challenges. Dhaka: BRAC.
most leading microfinance institution in Bangladesh are Ahsan, A. H. M. K. (2005). Role of NGO`s Micro-credit
providing loan at 20 per cent interest charged. But the Programme in Poverty Reduction in Bangladesh:
bank receives foreign grants and taking loan in foreign A Study on Some Selected NGOs Pakistan
donors at two percent loan ( (Mallick, 2012). Despite this, Journal of Social Sciences (Vol. 3, pp. 1053-
Grameen banks 20 percent loans is higher (8-10 percent) 1059).
than the commercial bank. These types of activities Bagci, C. (2003). Historical evolution of NGOs: NGO
losing their philanthropic image and represent the proliferation in the post-Cold War era. Avrupa
commercial activities. Moreover some, Bangladeshi Gunlugu, 4, 299-326.
NGOs are bogus and are defrauding the people (Abed, Ball, C., & Dunn, L. L. (1995). Non-Governmental
2000). Organisations: Guidelines for good policy and
So, NGOs have huge manpower especially in the practice: Commonwealth Foundation.
remote area. They have the capacity to influences the Bureau, N. A. (2003). Retrieved from
local and national politics. For example,1996 the http://www.ngoab.gov.bd.
Association of Development Agencies in DeJaeghere, J., & Wiger, N. P. (2013). Gender discourses
Bangladesh(ADB), arranged a rally against the BNP in an NGO education project: Openings for
government where Over 100,000 people attend in this transformation toward gender equality in
rally, give pressure to the region the government and Bangladesh. International Journal of
established the Care Taker government for ensuring fair Educational Development, 33(6), 557-565.
election process (Devine, 2006). At this time, they have Devine, J. (2006). NGOs, Politics and Grassroots
been provided voter education services to more than 20 Mobilisation Evidence from Bangladesh.
million citizens and encouraging participating in the Journal of South Asian Development, 1(1), 77-
election process. At this time, some of NGOs actively 99.
campaigned on behalf of AL .In this time AL was wined Edwards, M. (2007). Some Practical Limits of the NGO
the election and increased their seats 88 to 145. Role: A Critical Perspective NGOs and the
On the other hand, ADAB campaigned against the Millennium Development Goals (pp. 49-52):
Jamaat-e-Islami, a leading Islamic party in Bangladesh, Springer.
given the level that they are fundamentalist and Fowler, P. (2010). The Drama of Bangladesh. Asian
discouraged to voter to give the vote to fundamentalist. Affairs, 41(2), 213-220.
As a result, Jamaat-e-Islami suffered very losses in the Haider, S. K. U. (2011). Genesis and growth of the
election, found only two seats where previously they NGOs: Issues in Bangladesh perspective.
have 18 seats. NGO may control the large voter bank in International NGO Journal, 6(11), 240-247.
rural area (Karim, 2001). Halim, M. A. (1993). Social welfare legislation in
International donors and agencies like as World Bank, Bangladesh: Oihik.
International Monetary Fund (IMF), International Haque, M. S. (2004). Governance based on partnership
Finance Corporation (IFC), Asian Development Bank with NGOs: implications for development and
(ADB), World Food Programme (WFP), and United empowerment in rural Bangladesh.
Nations Economic and Social Council (UNESCO) have International Review of Administrative Sciences,
pressured Bangladesh government to work with NGOs. 70(2), 271-290.
Even, they are pressured Bangladesh government to Islam, M. S., Ahmed, M. F., & Alam, M. S. (2014). The
reduce their control over NGOs. role of microcredit program on women
8. Conclusion empowerment: Empirical evidence from rural
Bangladesh. Developing Country Studies, 4(5),
90-97.
Advances in Asian Social Science (AASS) 1188
Vol. 7, No. 2, 2016, Pages: 1182-1188, ISSN: 2167-6429
Copyright © World Science Publisher, United States
www.worldsciencepublisher.org
Jamil, I. (1998). Transactional friction between NGOs Lewis, D., & Kanji, N. (2009). Non-governmental
and public agencies in Bangladesh: Culture or organizations and development: Routledge.
dependency? Contemporary South Asia, 7(1), Mallick, D. (2012). Microfinance and moneylender
43-69. interest rate: evidence from Bangladesh. World
Karim, L. (2001). Politics of the poor? NGOs and development, 40(6), 1181-1189.
grass‐roots political mobilization in McGregor, J. A. (1994). Government Failures and NGO
Bangladesh. PoLAR: Political and Legal Successes: Credit, Banking and the Poor in
Anthropology Review, 24(1), 92-107. Rural Bangladesh, 1970–90 Poverty, Inequality
Khan, N. A. (2015). THE DAILY STAR. and Rural Development (pp. 100-121): Springer.
Khurshed, A. (2014). Extending the Reach of Petras, J. (1999). NGOs: In the service of imperialism.
Microcredit: A New Model for Poverty Journal of Contemporary Asia, 29(4), 429-440.
Alleviation through Livelihood Mapping in Rahman, A. T. R. (1993). Volunteerism and nation-
Bangladesh. building for Bangladesh: Academic Publishers.
Kim, S. M. (2014). The impacts of gender differences in Weisbrod, B. A. (2000). To profit or not to profit: The
social capital on microenterprise business start- commercial transformation of the nonprofit
up. Affilia, 0886109913519789. sector: Cambridge University Press.
Lewis, D. (2010). Nongovernmental organizations, Zohir, S. (2004). NGO sector in Bangladesh: An
definition and history International overview. Economic and Political Weekly,
Encyclopedia of Civil Society (pp. 1056-1062): 4109-4113.
Springer.