ANALYSIS OF BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA AS A METHOD IN THE

INVESTIGATION OF NON-NEGLIGENT MANSLAUGHTER

By

Sherise Nundhkumar
STUDENT NUMBER: 62761552

Submitted in Partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Research Report in
Forensic Science and Technology (HRFOR81)

In The Bachelor of Arts Honours in Forensic Science and Technology

School of Criminal Justice UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA

SUPERVISOR: Dr Lesiba Motsepe

ASSIGNMENT: 03

Year: 2023
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Table of Contents
1. Introduction 2

2. Research Statement 3

3. Research Aim 7

4. Research Question 8

5. Key Concepts 8

5.1 Blunt force trauma 8

5.2 Evidence 9

5.3 Non-negligent manslaughter 9

5.4 Criminal Investigation 9

5.5 Forensic Analysis 9

6. Research Approach and Design 10

7. Ethical considerations 14

8. Research Discussion (Literature Review) 15

8.1 Introduction 15

8.2 Understanding Blunt Force Trauma 16

8.3 Categories of blunt force trauma 17

8.3.1 Abrasion 17
8.3.2 Contusion 17
8.3.3 Fracture 18
8.3.4 Laceration 18

8.4 Organ Vulnerability in Blunt Force Trauma 18

8.4.1 Identifying the Most Prone Organ 18
8.4.1.1 The brain 18
8.4.1.2 The liver 19
8.4.2 Effects of blunt force trauma on the body 19
8.4.2.2 Nerve damage 20
8.4.2.3 Organ injury 20
8.4.2.4 Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) 21

8.5 Ensuring Accuracy and Reliability: Measures for Blunt Force Trauma Evidence in Non-negligent Manslaughter Investigations 21
8.5.1 Methods used in forensic analysis of blunt force trauma in criminal investigations 21
8.5.2 Tools and techniques used in forensic analysis of blunt force trauma in criminal investigations 23

8.6 Limitations and challenges in using blunt force trauma analysis in determining non-negligent manslaughter 25
8.6.1 Ambiguity in injury causation 25
8.6.2 Variable force dynamics 26
8.6.3 Hidden traumas 26

9. Findings and Recommendations 27

9.1 Section A: Findings 27

9.2 Section B: Recommendations 28

10. Conclusion 29

11. List of References 30

12. Annexure 1: Marked Assignment 1 35

13. Annexure 2: Marked Assignment 2 42

14. Declaration of Authority 78

1
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

ANALYSIS OF BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA AS A METHOD IN THE

INVESTIGATION OF NON-NEGLIGENT MANSLAUGHTER

1. Introduction

The introduction to the research technique has significant importance within a study, as it
serves to establish the background and outline the topic at hand (Mbanaso, 2023, pp.59-
80). The introductory section of a research paper is to familiarize the reader with the topic,
provide contextual information, and create a foundation for the development of research
inquiries or hypotheses. The aforementioned statement serves as a guiding principle for
following actions, guaranteeing that the reader possesses a well-informed viewpoint.

Blunt force trauma, an often-seen factor leading to fatalities in cases of intentional killing,
encompasses a field of study that intricately combines forensic pathology, criminal
investigation, and medical research (Ely, 2023, pp. 239-277). The aforementioned text
discusses the range of injuries caused by the strong collision of blunt instruments, including
bats, mallets, and even natural components like stones.

The intricacies inherent in the examination of blunt force trauma are of utmost importance.
The severity of the injuries sustained serves as evidence of both the magnitude of the force
applied and the specific anatomical area that was impacted. Within the domain of homicide
investigation, the evaluation of blunt force trauma encompasses more than just establishing
the cause of death. It delves into a comprehensive analysis that can unveil the selection of the
weapon used and perhaps provide insights into the underlying reasons behind the criminal act
(Ely, 2023, p. 239-277). The precise and thorough examination conducted by forensic
specialists in analysing the site and severity of wounds provides significant knowledge
regarding the interactions between the victim and the perpetrator, potentially reconstructing
the precise sequence of events that preceded the lethal occurrence.

However, the investigation of blunt force injuries requires a thorough and all-encompassing
methodology. Forensic pathologists use the crime scene and the deceased individual’s corpse
as a medium through which they construct their story (Thakral, 2023, p. 102577). The precise
collection of blood, tissue, and DNA samples serves as the fundamental basis for perpetrator
identification. DNA, in particular, plays a pivotal role in forensic science, providing a wealth
of information about individuals involved in a case (Alketbi Salem, 2023). Simultaneously,
comprehensive examinations may be carried out to determine the magnitude and speed of the
colliding entity, while prospective armaments found at the location are meticulously
analysed.

In the course of this research undertaking, it is imperative to acknowledge the many origins
of blunt force trauma. The range of situations covered by this phenomenon includes instances
of individuals experiencing falls and motor vehicle accidents, as well as instances of
individuals enduring traumatic assaults and occurrences connected to sports activities
(Quintana, 2023, pp. 1563-1568). The field of epidemiology provides additional insight into

2
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

complex patterns that are influenced by several factors, including age, gender, and
geographic location. Certain populations, such as athletes and those in the military, may have
an increased susceptibility, along with certain demographic groups such as young people and
men.

Embedded within the complex fabric of blunt force trauma resides a diverse array of injuries
(Morillas, 2022, pp. 310-326). Fractures, which occur when bones break due to the
application of significant force, provide a clear demonstration of the intensity experienced.
Contusions, often known as bruises, are visible evidence of the burst of tiny blood vessels
under the surface of the skin, which occurs as a result of trauma. Lacerations, which are
complex fissures occurring in the dermis and underlying subcutaneous tissues, vividly
illustrate the extent of the imparted force or violence. Within the confines of the human body,
the potential for internal organ damage is a significant concern since it can lead to substantial
changes in both structure and function resulting from the persistent application of force.

This literature review aims to explore the intricate terrain of blunt force trauma in the context
of homicide investigations, with the objective of synthesising the existing body of
information on the subject. This study aims to increase the effectiveness of forensic analyses
in critical investigations by exploring the complex relationship between several aspects, such
as impact dynamics and the diverse range of injuries. Through a comprehensive examination,
this research endeavours to contribute to a more profound knowledge of these phenomena.

2. Research Statement

A research problem is an issue, problem, or disagreement in a certain field of study that

needs more research and analysis (Islam, 2022, pp. 1-11). Researchers analyse gaps in
their knowledge or evidence. This inspires a thorough literature analysis plus observation
of a real-world situation that needs further study typically provide a good research subject.
It should be brief, targeted, and relevant.

Blunt force trauma has the potential to result in many injuries, hence posing challenges in
determining the specific cause of death (Wedel, 2013). Blunt force trauma is a leading cause
of mortality in several scenarios, including accidents, falls, and instances of violence
(Morrison, 2013, pp. 263-268). The phenomenon of blunt force trauma is characterised by its
intricate nature, diverse aetiology, and the challenges it poses in ascertaining the precise
cause of death, mostly owing to limitations imposed by medical and forensic factors
(Sulaiman, 2014, p.33).

The researcher has chosen to explore this issue for a variety of reasons. Specifically:

- The inquiry into the cause of death in instances involving blunt force trauma has the
potential to generate curiosity among individuals, leading to an increased interest in
the domains of forensic science, criminal investigations, and associated disciplines.

3
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

- The subject of education can help people who know more about how things like
injury location, severity, underlying medical conditions, and time can affect the
investigation of cases involving blunt force trauma to the ribs understand them better.
- The precise identification of fatalities resulting from blunt force trauma holds
significant implications for criminal investigations, legal proceedings, and insurance
claims. The examination of these investigations may emphasise the necessity for
precise and dependable forensic evidence.
- Gaining insight into the difficulties encountered by forensic investigators in instances
of blunt force trauma can contribute to the public's comprehension of forensic science
and the need for conducting thorough and precise investigations.

Blunt-force trauma is a term used to describe injuries resulting from the application of blunt
force. Fractures, contusions, and internal haemorrhaging have the potential to cause harm to
several anatomical regions, including the cranium, thorax, abdomen, pelvis, extremities, and
internal organs (Arroyo, 2013, pp. 1745-1749). The degree and spatial distribution of an
injury are contingent upon several factors, including the magnitude and vector of the applied
force, the angle and direction of impact, the proximity between the source of force and the
victim, the pre-existing condition of the victim, and the individual's age.

The identification of fatalities resulting from blunt-force trauma has historically posed
challenges for forensic pathologists (Marinho, 2016). Blunt force trauma, resulting from the
impact of a bat, hammer, or fist, does not typically result in the penetration of bodily tissues.
The aetiology of injuries may be ambiguous. During the nineteenth century, forensic
pathology emerged as an early endeavour aimed at addressing this particular challenge.
Forensic pathologists conduct thorough examination and analysis of physical evidence, with
a particular focus on injuries resulting from blunt-force trauma, in order to ascertain the cause
and manner of death. The use of X-rays and CT scans has significantly enhanced the
diagnostic capabilities in this particular field of study.

Notwithstanding these advancements, the identification of mortality resulting from blunt-

force trauma poses challenges. In some circumstances, the determination of the cause of
death becomes challenging due to the presence of severe injuries. Occasionally, injuries may
be of a minor nature but nevertheless have the potential to result in fatality, hence posing
challenges in accurately determining the cause of death. The cause of death resulting from
blunt-force trauma has been a persistent challenge for forensic pathologists and other medical
professionals.

Immediate fatalities can occur as a result of severe harm caused by blunt-force trauma (Kahl,
2013, pp. 195-201). The potential outcome for the sufferer includes survival or the absence of
visible injury. Therefore, the diagnosis of blunt-force trauma fatalities poses significant
challenges.

The determination of the temporal boundaries for blunt force trauma death investigations is
challenging due to the presence of several complicating circumstances. Nevertheless, various

4
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

factors, such as the extent and site of the trauma, the coexistence of additional injuries or
medical ailments, the accessibility and reliability of medical records and evidence, and the
proficiency and background of the medical examiner or forensic pathologist involved in the
inquiry, can collectively influence the complexity associated with ascertaining the underlying
cause of death.

In cases where the body sustains serious damage and there are no other variables that worsen
the condition, the cause of death may be readily apparent. Nevertheless, in cases where the
trauma is less severe or occurs in a concealed or protected area of the body and there are
accompanying injuries or medical conditions that might have influenced or obscured the
trauma, establishing the exact cause of death becomes more challenging.

The quality and accessibility of the evidence, which may include witness testimony, medical
records, and forensic evidence, as well as the skill and experience of the medical examiner or
forensic pathologist, may all complicate the investigation into the cause of death. The
investigation of blunt force trauma deaths necessitates a comprehensive examination,
encompassing a thorough view of the corpse, analysis of medical records, and consultation
with experts

Identifying the cause of death might pose challenges in cases involving non-lethal or
extensively prevalent injuries. The type and potency of the objects employed can influence
the appearance and gravity of the wounds, introducing complexities to the investigative
process. This can aid in ascertaining the nature of the death, whether it was accidental,
suicide, or purposeful.

In order to identify injuries and ascertain mortality, it may be necessary to employ CT scans
or conduct an autopsy. The investigative process may encompass several activities, such as
conducting a thorough examination of the crime scene, interviewing witnesses to elicit
pertinent information, and procuring evidence, including the weapon, for further analysis.
The determination of fatalities resulting from blunt-force injuries poses challenges in the field
(Marinho, 2016, pp. 1416-1430).

The presence of blunt force trauma makes the estimation of mortality difficult. Blunt-force
trauma has the potential to induce many injuries, encompassing both fatal and non-fatal
conditions that may progressively evolve into life-threatening illnesses (Mathews et al.,
2009). The presence of blunt-force trauma injuries can often be inconspicuous, posing
challenges in ascertaining the underlying cause of death. Internal injuries may not be
observable without a comprehensive evaluation of the entire body. This phenomenon
presents challenges in determining the underlying factors contributing to mortality and severe
bodily harm. Blunt force trauma is a leading cause of mortality in several scenarios, including
accidents, falls, and instances of violence (Morrison, 2013, pp. 263-268). The phenomenon of
blunt force trauma is characterised by its intricate nature, diverse aetiology, and the
challenges it poses in ascertaining the precise cause of death, mostly owing to limitations
imposed by medical and forensic factors (Sulaiman, 2014, p.33).

5
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

The determination of the cause of death is often complicated by the presence of blunt-force
injuries. The injuries sustained during falls or vehicular accidents might differ from injuries
caused by blunt object attacks. The type of force or object utilised can have an impact on the
characteristics and severity of injuries, hence influencing the process of identifying fatalities.
Blunt-force trauma fatalities may be complicated by factors such as the age, health, and pre-
existing medical conditions of the sufferer. These aforementioned elements may potentially
introduce complexities to the study of injuries, necessitating more investigation in order to
ascertain the underlying cause.

The duration of the issue is continuous. The issue of blunt force trauma as a cause of
mortality is a significant problem that extends beyond certain time periods. The question of
occurrence in accidents, falls, and violent occurrences across diverse groups and
environments remains pertinent in numerous contexts. The correct identification of fatalities
resulting from blunt force trauma continues to provide a persistent issue in the fields of
forensic pathology and criminal investigations. Hence, the duration of this issue is of an
endless nature, thereby requiring continuous endeavours to enhance techniques and practises
within this field.

The potential impact of blunt force trauma analysis on the criminal justice system and the
determination of the cause of death can be facilitated by the examination of blunt force
trauma, particularly in instances where the victim's demise can be attributed to injuries
inflicted by blunt force trauma.

1. The utilisation of blunt force trauma analysis can also serve as a means to exonerate
those who have been unfairly charged and are shown to be innocent. A
comprehensive examination of blunt force trauma can contribute to the identification
of an individual who is not involved in a criminal act by presenting substantiating
data on the specific weapon employed, the trajectory and force of the impact, as well
as the precise anatomical site of the inflicted damage.
2. The identification of perpetrators can be facilitated by the analysis of blunt force
trauma, as it can yield valuable data pertaining to the weapon employed, the trajectory
and force of the impact, as well as the specific site of the inflicted damage. The
aforementioned process has significant importance in the identification and
subsequent legal action against individuals involved in illegal activities.
3. The enhancement of criminal investigations may be achieved by the examination of
blunt force trauma, as it offers investigators significant insights into the characteristics
of the offence and the injuries sustained by the victim. This can facilitate the process
of conducting the investigation and discerning potential individuals who may be
involved.
4. An Examination of Arguments in Favour The use of blunt force trauma analysis has
the potential to bolster the prosecution's case in criminal proceedings through the
provision of evidentiary support pertaining to the specific weapon employed, the
trajectory and power of the impact, as well as the precise anatomical site of the

6
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

inflicted damage. This can potentially bolster the prosecution's argument and enhance
the probability of securing a conviction.

There are several reasons why it is essential to accurately determine the cause of death.
Forensic pathologists employ the determination of causes of death to advance medical
procedures, therapies, and pharmaceuticals. This measure has the potential to prevent such
tragedies. Furthermore, determining the underlying reason for death might perhaps offer a
sense of closure to the bereaved family and friends. The utilisation of this approach may be
advantageous in the context of insurance claims and inheritance disputes. In conclusion, the
surveillance and comprehension of the primary factors contributing to death can provide
valuable insights for public health interventions, therefore mitigating the occurrence or
severity of specific diseases or conditions.

In situations involving blunt-force trauma, the determination of the cause of death has
significant importance due to several factors, hence necessitating the conduct of research in
this area. In order to ascertain the commission of a crime, it is imperative to establish the
underlying cause of death, which may include various forms of violence such as assault,
murder, or domestic abuse resulting in blunt-force trauma.

1. The determination of the cause of death allows investigators to establish the

occurrence of a crime and identify the individual(s) accountable for it.
2. The identification of causes of death can provide insights into potential environmental
safety hazards. In the event of a fatality caused by a descending object, investigators
have the potential to discover hazards in close proximity, thereby mitigating the
occurrence of subsequent catastrophes.
3. Determining the cause of death might offer a sense of closure to the family and close
acquaintances. Understanding the cause of death can play a crucial role in facilitating
the bereavement process by providing closure and addressing inquiries surrounding
the deceased individual's demise.
4. The identification of the aetiology of death in cases involving external force trauma
can serve several purposes, including the establishment of criminal liability, the
identification of safety concerns, and the provision of emotional resolution for the
bereaved family.

3. Research Aim

The significance of research methodological objectives cannot be overstated due to several

factors. Firstly, it directs the investigation and establishes parameters. This facilitates the
alignment of research subjects and hypotheses with the objectives of the study (Denny,
2022, p. 1166). The purpose of the investigation is further reinforced by highlighting its
significance and addressing any existing gaps in information. Additionally, it offers a
quantifiable outcome for assessing the advancement of the research. Having a clearly
defined objective enables researchers to make informed decisions and prevent any potential

7
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

deviation or uncertainty. The objective functions as a navigational tool to ensure that each
research step is intentional and contributes to the overarching objective of the study.

The aim of this research is to analyse the use of forensic blunt force trauma as a method in
determining the causes of death during an active investigation of non-negligent manslaughter.

4. Research Question

The formulation of a methodological research question holds significant importance for a

multitude of reasons (Davis, 2021, pp. 131-140). Firstly, the study is endowed with a clear
emphasis and objective, so maintaining its concentration and specificity. This matter
pertains to the identification of the necessary data required to address the research
problem and the selection of appropriate analytical methodologies. The selection of a well-
chosen research topic contributes to the significance and worth of the study, hence
enhancing its relevance within the academic discipline. The assessment aids in
determining the feasibility and manageability of the study in light of the resources already
available. A research subject that is unambiguous, aligns with the objectives of the study,
and has the potential to create hypotheses that can be tested is considered to be clear. The
formulation of a research question serves the purpose of providing lucidity and directing
the exploration of novel facts within the chosen subject matter.

To what extent can forensic analysis of blunt force trauma provide valuable evidence in the
determination of non-negligent manslaughter in criminal investigations?

5. Key Concepts

The establishment of clear definitions and the understanding of key concepts in research
methodology are of paramount importance. Initially, the clarification of terminology serves
to mitigate any potential misconceptions and enhance the effectiveness of communication
between researchers and stakeholders (Sevara, 2022, pp.21-26). The research is situated
within the existing body of knowledge, demonstrating its pertinence and its potential to
advance the field. Clearly defined concepts also provide limits and restrictions,
guaranteeing the logical consistency and pertinence of study. The aforementioned process
is crucial in the operationalization of variables in quantitative studies and the
establishment of a framework for data collection and analysis. Precise delineations
facilitate the formulation and examination of hypotheses, the juxtaposition of research
outcomes, and the verification of empirical evidence. In addition, they ensure the
verification of legal and ethical conformity within the realm of regulatory research. The
aforementioned technique plays a crucial role in the progression of knowledge, ensuring
coherence, and facilitating the accumulation of insights within a particular discipline.

5.1 Blunt force trauma

Blunt force trauma is an injury induced by a blunt object or force, as opposed to one that is
pointed. Accidents, assaults, sports injuries, and automobile crashes may cause this injury.
Blunt force trauma may cause fractures, bruises, internal bleeding, and concussions, among

8
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

other problems. Falling on a hard surface might break limb bones, while a blow or kick can
cause discoloration and internal bleeding. Concussions and fractures may arise from car
accidents (Champine, 2022, pp. 1-14).

5.2 Evidence
Any information or material that supports or proves a fact or argument is referred to as
evidence. There are various types of evidence, such as witness testimony, physical objects,
documents, photographs, and recordings. Evidence is crucial in numerous disciplines,
including law, medicine, science, and history. Evidence supports or refutes a claim in court.
A witness may testify about what they saw or heard, and DNA or security video may be used
to support an argument. Science proves or disproves hypotheses using evidence. To support
their arguments, researchers may conduct experiments, observations, or surveys. Evidence is
needed for educated judgments, correct conclusions and truth-finding (Shelmerdine, 2023,
p.20211078).

5.3 Non-negligent manslaughter

Non-negligent manslaughter, also known as voluntary manslaughter, is a crime in which a
person intentionally causes another person's death without premeditation. In contrast to
murder, which requires the intent to kill, non-negligent manslaughter does not involve
premeditation or planning. For example, when a spouse finds their partner in adultery, a
person may kill them in a rage. The killer didn't want to kill, but their emotions drove them to
act without thinking, killing the victim. Manslaughter without fault is a severe crime. The
laws and punishments for this infraction differ by jurisdiction and instance (Huber et al.,
2022).

5.4 Criminal Investigation

Criminal investigation is the process of collecting and analysing evidence to identify
criminals and solve offenses. It entails a methodical and exhaustive approach to obtaining
information via techniques such as interviews, forensic analysis, surveillance, and others. The
objective is to unearth the truth about the offense and bring the perpetrator to justice
(Stainton, 2022).

Examples of criminal investigations:

i. Cybercrime investigations.
ii. Drug trafficking investigations.
iii. Financial crime investigations.
iv. Homicide investigations.
v. Organized crime investigations.

5.5 Forensic Analysis

Examining and analysing evidence to ascertain the cause and manner of a particular event or
offense is the process of forensic analysis. Legal investigations use this form of analysis, but
finance, computer science, and engineering may also use it (Morillas, 2022, pp. 310-326).

9
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

6. Research Approach and Design

The research approach and design serve as the foundational framework for every research
technique, delineating the entirety of the research process. The research design
encompasses the objectives, scope, and methodologies for data collection, analysis, and
interpretation. This study encompasses pivotal determinations pertaining to research
subjects, data acquisition, sample selection, and data analysis. On the contrary, the
research strategy refers to the researcher's conceptual framework, including knowledge,
reality, and technique. This methodology may use a quantitative approach, which
prioritises the use of numerical data and statistical analysis; a qualitative approach, which
focuses on capturing participants' perspectives; or a hybrid approach, which combines
both methods to provide a comprehensive understanding. Both the research design and
methodology ensure that the study is conducted with rigour, achieves its objectives, and
generates data that is valid and reliable. Creswell's work on qualitative inquiry and
research design provides valuable insights into choosing among these various approaches
(2013). This seminal work offers a comprehensive guide for researchers navigating the
complexities of research methodology and design.

The selected methodology for this study entails the use of a mixed-methods approach that
integrates both quantitative and qualitative methodologies. This methodology is especially
suitable for examining the complex characteristics of blunt force injuries in situations of non-
negligent manslaughter. The inclusion of a quantitative element in the study would facilitate
the methodical gathering and examination of numerical data pertaining to the scope, nature,
and trends of injuries resulting from blunt force trauma. This will provide measurable
insights into the frequency and attributes of such instances (Kumar, 2014). Additionally, a
qualitative approach will be used to get a fuller picture of the circumstances surrounding each
event, such as the specifics of the situation, the reasons behind it, and any possible solutions
that could make the problem better (Lichtman, 2014). The utilization of qualitative data will
contribute to a nuanced viewpoint, hence facilitating a thorough understanding of the intricate
nature inherent in these studies (Liamputtong, 2013).

The utilization of a mixed-methods approach has demonstrated efficacy in prior research

endeavours focused on the analysis of violent crime investigations (Punch, 2014). This study
is in accordance with the established research tradition on the subject since it employs the
aforementioned technique (Ritchie, 2014). Nevertheless, it is crucial to recognize possible
obstacles. One significant obstacle is the amalgamation of quantitative and qualitative data,
given the intricate nature of reconciling diverse data types (Silverman, 2013). Furthermore,
the inclusion of a qualitative component in the study may include the subjective interpretation
of data, thus leading to the introduction of researcher bias (Silverman, 2013).

Although there are some problems, the mixed-methods approach is thought to be the best for
this study because it can give a full picture of blunt force trauma in cases of non-negligent
manslaughter. The utilization of triangulation enables the integration of data obtained from
several sources, hence augmenting the strength and credibility of the research outcomes
(Ritchie, 2014). Furthermore, it allows a detailed examination of both the quantitative

10
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

patterns and the qualitative subtleties, guaranteeing a meticulous inquiry into this crucial
forensic domain (Mills, 2014).

The term "research approach" refers to the broader philosophical or theoretical perspective
that researchers use to guide their study (Wagner, 2012). It provides a framework for
comprehending the nature of knowledge and the methods of acquiring it. The research
approach influences the research design, data collection, and analysis techniques.

According to Creswell (2014), there are three primary categories of research methodologies:

1. Quantitative approach emphasizes the accumulation and analysis of numerical data

in order to establish patterns, relationships, and statistical significance (Salkind,
2012). It makes use of deductive reasoning to generalize findings to a larger
population.
2. Qualitative approach emphasizes gaining a comprehension of social phenomena
from the perspective of the participants (Leedy, 2013). It entails gathering descriptive
data using techniques such as interviews, observations, and textual analysis. It is
based on inductive reasoning and seeks to generate profound insights.
3. Mixed Methods approach incorporates quantitative and qualitative research methods
(Silverman, 2014). It entails gathering and analysing both numerical and textual data
to obtain a complete understanding of the research problem. The mixed-methods
strategy permits triangulation and can yield a more robust and nuanced analysis.

Quantitative data obtained from the literature review can be analysed using descriptive
statistics and meta-analysis to identify patterns, trends, and prevalence rates of various
categories of blunt force trauma (Silverman, 2014). The qualitative data from interviews can
be transcribed, coded, and thematically analysed to find key themes about the methods of
forensic analysis, the instruments used, their limitations, and the problems that come up when
trying to figure out if someone killed someone else without being negligent (Liamputtong,
2013).

To make sense of the collected data, one can apply a process of data reduction and
interpretation. Statistical analyses can help identify significant findings and establish
relationships between variables, casting light on the prevalence and characteristics of blunt
force trauma when applied to quantitative data (Salkind, 2012). The qualitative data can be
subjected to thematic analysis to find recurring themes. For example, the themes could be
about how reliable certain forensic analysis methods are, how useful certain tools are, or how
hard it is to accurately determine non-negligent manslaughter (Silverman, 2014).

One of the challenges in the field of data analysis is the availability and quality of data. The
acquisition of complete and trustworthy evidence pertaining to instances of blunt force
trauma, particularly within the framework of non-negligent manslaughter, may provide a
formidable obstacle (Salkind, 2012). The implementation of a mitigation strategy is crucial to
addressing and minimizing the potential negative impacts of a certain event or situation

11
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

(Leedy, 2013). By conducting a comprehensive examination of the current body of literature

and engaging in collaborative efforts with pertinent organizations or authorities, we can
effectively tackle this difficulty.

For the research topic "An analysis of blunt force trauma as a method in the investigation of
non-negligent manslaughter," a mixed-methods approach with a sequential explanatory
design would be best. The need to gain a thorough understanding of blunt force trauma, its
forensic analysis methodologies, and its application in determining non-negligent
manslaughter justifies this choice (Gray, 2014).

An initial quantitative phase would focus on an overview of blunt force trauma, including
types and categories, causes, organs most susceptible to injury, and effects on the body. This
phase can be accomplished by conducting a comprehensive literature review and analysis of
existing data sources (Kumar, 2014), which will provide a solid foundation for the study.

After the quantitative phase, the qualitative phase would look into how blunt force trauma is
analysed in criminal investigations and what problems it can cause when trying to figure out
non-negligent manslaughter (Wagner, 2012). This phase may include interviews with
forensic experts, medical professionals, and law enforcement officials in order to gain an in-
depth understanding of the methodologies, tools, and techniques used to analyse blunt force
trauma, as well as the obstacles encountered.

Obtaining cooperation from forensic specialists, medical professionals, and law enforcement
authorities for interviews poses a time-consuming and arduous challenge (Mills, 2014). The
implementation of a mitigation strategy is crucial to addressing and reducing the negative
impacts of a particular issue or problem. In order to tackle this difficulty, it is imperative to
establish effective communication channels, underscore the value of the study, and prioritize
confidentiality and ethical treatment of participants (Ritchie, 2014).

Ethical considerations are a crucial aspect to be taken into account in any academic study or
research endeavour (Wagner, 2012). The task at hand involves the exploration of the ethical
implications associated with conducting interviews in sensitive domains, specifically
focusing on the principles of informed consent and confidentiality (Silverman, 2014). The
implementation of a mitigation strategy is crucial in addressing and minimizing the potential
risks and negative impacts associated with a certain situation or event (Salkind, 2012).
Adherence to rigorous ethical principles, the acquisition of informed consent, and the
preservation of participant confidentiality throughout the course of the research are essential
procedures (Liamputtong, 2013).

Bias and subjectivity are significant challenges in academic writing (Punch, 2014). In the
context of qualitative research, it is important to acknowledge the possibility of researcher
bias that may arise throughout the process of data collection and subsequent interpretation
(Silverman, 2013). To reduce potential biases, it is essential to adopt rigorous research

12
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

methodologies (Leedy, 2013), uphold reflexivity (Mills, 2014), and utilize triangulation
approaches (Ritchie, 2014).

The scope and depth of the analysis are significant challenges (Wagner, 2012). Achieving a
harmonious equilibrium between the levels of analysis in both quantitative and qualitative
stages might present a formidable challenge (Silverman, 2014). The implementation of a
mitigation strategy is crucial to addressing and reducing the negative impacts of a particular
issue or problem. By employing a systematic It is vital to establish precise research
objectives, construct a well-organized research process, and uphold a concentrated strategy
(Creswell, 2014).

The limitations imposed by available resources Challenge: Conducting the research may
require a substantial allocation of time, financial resources, and the availability of specialist
materials and facilities. The implementation of a mitigation strategy is crucial to addressing
and reducing the negative impacts of a particular issue or problem. By developing and
executing Implementing prudent financial planning, actively pursuing grants or financing
prospects, and fostering partnerships with pertinent organizations can effectively mitigate
limitations in resources (Punch, 2014).

The challenge is effectively integrating quantitative and qualitative data into research. The
process of integrating quantitative data with qualitative insights might have inherent
complexities. The implementation of systematic data integration techniques, such as theme
analysis or mixed-methods matrixing, would play a pivotal role in the mitigation strategy
(Silverman, 2013).

The generalization of findings refers to the process of extending the results of a study to a
broader population or context. It involves drawing conclusions that may be applied beyond
the specific One potential challenge in research is the restricted ability to generalize findings,
especially when working with qualitative data. One potential approach to addressing this
difficulty is to implement a mitigation strategy that involves effectively communicating the
limits of the study and placing the findings within the appropriate context of the research
(Wagner, 2012).

The challenge is ensuring the quality and dependability of both forms of data. The
implementation of a mitigation strategy may be achieved through the utilization of
established research procedures, the execution of pilot studies, and the incorporation of
member-checking in qualitative research. These measures serve to augment the credibility
and dependability of the research findings (Liamputtong, 2013).

One of the challenges individuals often face is effectively managing their time. Effective time
management is crucial in the sequential explanatory design to guarantee that the qualitative
phase adequately complements and expands upon the quantitative findings (Gray, 2014). The
implementation of a mitigation strategy is crucial to addressing and reducing the negative
impacts of a particular issue or problem. Developing a comprehensive study timetable,

13
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

establishing significant milestones, and consistently reviewing progress will be crucial for
efficient time management (Creswell, 2014). The obstacles and constraints encountered
during the study process will be duly acknowledged and taken into account, with suitable
solutions being developed to effectively mitigate them as they manifest. Implementing this
proactive strategy will enhance the strength and reliability of the study (Gray, 2014).

When you combine quantitative and qualitative results, you can get a full picture of blunt
force trauma as a way to investigate non-negligent manslaughter. Triangulation of the data
can help validate the results, improve the study's credibility, and provide a deeper
understanding of the subject (Ritchie, 2014). The sequential explanatory design makes sure
that the qualitative phase builds on the quantitative findings. This makes the analysis richer
and lets the research findings be interpreted in more depth (Leedy, 2013).

7. Ethical considerations

The ethical considerations in research pertain to the observance of rules and norms that
safeguard the rights, dignity, and welfare of all those who are either directly participating
in or impacted by the study. This involves a variety of factors, including the acquisition of
informed permission from participants, safeguarding their anonymity, mitigating any
damage, and ensuring that the study is done in an equitable and ethical manner. Ethical
research encompasses the principles of transparency and honesty in the dissemination of
findings and the conscientious utilization of resources. Additionally, it is important to
demonstrate a dedication to resolving any potential conflicts of interest or prejudices that
may emerge along the course of the research endeavour. In general, adherence to ethical
research procedures is crucial to maintaining the integrity of a study and exhibiting regard
for the autonomy and well-being of the individuals participating in it (Fusar-Poli et al.,
2022).

In the course of this study on "An examination of blunt force trauma as a method for
investigating non-negligent manslaughter," significant emphasis was placed on ethical
considerations to ensure adherence to the principles of civil conduct and to protect the rights
and welfare of all individuals involved.

Before initiating the research, it was necessary to seek ethical permission from the
appropriate institutional review board. This measure guaranteed that the study design,
technique, and data collection processes adhered to the ethical norms established by the
academic and scientific community.

Stringent methods were adopted to ensure participant engagement and secure informed
consent. All interview participants, including forensic specialists, medical professionals, and
law enforcement authorities, were given comprehensive and explicit information on the
study's objectives and scope. The participants were provided with explicit assurance that their
involvement in the study was completely voluntary, and they retained the freedom to resign
from the study at any given time without incurring any adverse repercussions. Furthermore, a

14
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

high level of secrecy was upheld, with personal information being anonymized and data
being securely kept to mitigate the risk of unwanted access.

Furthermore, proactive measures were implemented to minimize any potential adverse effects
or emotional discomfort experienced by the individuals. The study team received sensitivity
training in order to promote empathetic and respectful discussions pertaining to blunt force
injuries and non-negligent manslaughter. The participants were provided with a chance to
engage in discussions about their experiences in a controlled and nurturing setting.
Additionally, they were offered access to counselling services and other forms of support,
should they require further assistance.

Transparency and honesty were maintained throughout all stages of the study process,
including interactions, discussions, and reporting of findings. All potential conflicts of
interest were transparently acknowledged, and the study team maintained objectivity and
impartiality throughout the process of data collection and analysis.

In brief, this study was undertaken with utmost attention to ethical issues. The study
demonstrated adherence to ethical principles by getting informed consent, safeguarding
confidentiality, limiting potential damage, and preserving transparency. These actions were in
accordance with the civil code of conduct, therefore upholding the integrity and credibility of
the research within the wider research community.

8. Research Discussion (Literature Review)

8.1 Introduction

The examination of blunt force trauma within the framework of non-negligent manslaughter
inquiries encompasses a convergence of several fields, ranging from forensic pathology to
criminal law. This study explores the complexities of injuries resulting from the forceful
impact of blunt tools, providing insights on their categorizations, susceptibility of organs, and
subsequent impacts on the human body. The present paper provides a complete examination
of several categories of blunt force trauma, including a wide range of injuries such as
abrasions, contusions, fractures, and lacerations. Each of these categories exhibits specific
features that are crucial for forensic investigation. Additionally, this study looks into the
significant effects of blunt force trauma on a number of organs and makes important
discoveries about the pathophysiological process these kinds of injuries trigger. As the field
of study progresses, it undergoes a shift towards the crucial realm of guaranteeing the
precision and dependability of forensic evidence obtained from the investigation of blunt
force trauma. This necessitates a comprehensive examination of the methodologies,
instruments, and strategies used in the forensic evaluation of these injuries, highlighting the
need for rigorous investigative procedures. Nevertheless, this domain presents a multitude of
obstacles and constraints that need cautious examination. Dempsey (2020, p. 110140)
emphasizes the importance of critically evaluating the evidentiary value of skeletal trauma
analysis in forensic research, drawing attention to the need for meticulous scrutiny of
methodologies and practices. Ruchonnet (2019, pp.350-357) conduct an experimental study

15
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

utilizing polyurethane bone spheres to investigate cranial blunt force trauma in relation to the
victim’s position, contributing valuable insights into the biomechanics of such injuries. This
paper provides a critical evaluation of the limitations associated with the use of blunt force
trauma analysis in the determination of non-negligent manslaughter. It aims to provide a
comprehensive grasp of the many factors involved in this crucial forensic undertaking. The
following sections will explore each aspect of this analysis, shedding light on the significant
discoveries and suggestions that arise from this extensive investigation.

8.2 Understanding Blunt Force Trauma

In the realm of investigations pertaining to non-negligent manslaughter, it is essential to

possess a thorough comprehension of blunt force trauma. Blunt force trauma pertains to the
infliction of injuries resulting from the impact of a blunt object with the human body. This
includes physical impacts administered by punches, kicks, or strong contact with objects such
as bats or stones. The assessment of the severity and geographical distribution of these
injuries might provide crucial information regarding the nature of the assault and the probable
use of certain weapons. For instance, in the case of abrasions resulting from blunt force
trauma, envision a scenario where an individual is assaulted with a knuckle-duster, a weapon
with a rough and abrasive surface. The resulting injuries, characterized by the removal of the
outer layers of skin, align with the definition and characteristics of abrasions as discussed.
Additionally, previous research by Imaizumi (2015, pp. 67-74) emphasizes the forensic
investigation of burnt human remains, underscoring the importance of comprehensive
examinations in forensic cases involving trauma.

Blunt-force trauma has the capacity to induce a variety of injuries, including abrasions,
contusions, fractures, and lacerations. Abrasions, which include the partial or complete loss
of the epidermis and perhaps the dermis, often occur as a consequence of direct contact with
rough or irregular surfaces. Contusions, sometimes referred to as bruises, arise as a result of
the disruption of small blood vessels located under the skin, primarily induced by a hard
impact. Fractures are characterized by the breakdown of bone integrity, which may occur as a
result of the application of significant external stress to a specific area. Lacerations are
distinguished by the substantial destruction of both the outermost layer of skin (epidermis)
and the underlying tissues, leading to more severe injuries. Likewise, consider a situation
where an assailant strikes a victim with a blunt object like a baseball bat. The impact causes
disruption to the small blood vessels beneath the skin, resulting in contusions or bruises. Each
kind of damage provides distinct viewpoints on the qualities and extent of the blunt force
used, aiding forensic investigators in reconstructing the chronological progression of events
leading to the fatal incident. Furthermore, the study by Ruchonnet, Diehl, Tang, and Kranioti
(2019, pp. 832-838) utilizing polyurethane bone spheres offers valuable experimental insights
into cranial blunt force trauma in relation to the victim’s position, contributing to the
biomechanical understanding of such injuries.

In addition, the comprehensive analysis of blunt force trauma in forensic investigations

requires a meticulous assessment of the characteristics, configuration, and dispersion of the

16
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

inflicted wounds. This investigation has the capacity to determine the characteristics of the
item or surface involved, the force exerted, and the probable processes of damage.
Furthermore, in the case of fractures, envision an unfortunate incident where a person falls
from a height. The impact on the bones can lead to fractures, exemplifying the connection
between external force application and specific types of injuries. Suryadi's (2021, pp.9-12)
case report regarding an alleged murder due to blunt head injury provides a practical example
of the application of forensic investigation techniques in real-world scenarios.

To understand blunt force trauma, you need to think about how it happens by looking at the
forces that are transmitted when something hits something, how these forces can be either
compression or shearing, and how different factors can cause different types and levels of
injury severity. For example, imagine a car accident where the victim's body experiences
both compression from the seatbelt and shearing forces due to the movement within the
vehicle. The acquisition of these data is of utmost importance in order to effectively evaluate
and interpret the impact of blunt force trauma in the context of forensic inquiries, medical
assessments, and legal actions. The mentioned studies and cases highlight the critical role of
forensic examination in understanding and interpreting blunt force trauma in various
contexts, underscoring the necessity for rigorous investigative procedures and
multidisciplinary approaches.

8.3 Categories of blunt force trauma

Blunt-force Trauma, often arising from a non-penetrating force or impact applied to the body,
may lead to various ailments such as tissue damage, fractures, and other physical harm. The
following are four kinds that have been mentioned:
8.3.1 Abrasion
Abrasion refers to the removal of the outermost layer of the skin as a result of blunt-force
trauma, leading to scraping or scratching. This phenomenon may occur when the skin comes
into direct contact with a rough surface, such as pavement or gravel. As an example, in the
event that an individual has a fall from a bicycle while traversing a gravel road, it is plausible
that they may get abrasions or lacerations on their palms and lower extremities. Dempsey's
(2020, p. 110140) review, which emphasizes the significance of incorporating post-mortem
CT scans in forensic death investigations and highlights the value of thorough examinations,
supports this.
8.3.2 Contusion
A contusion, also known as a bruise, is a manifestation of blunt-force trauma that impacts the
integumentary system and underlying tissues without causing any disruption to the skin's
integrity. Frequently, these symptoms manifest as pain, swelling, and discoloration.
Additionally, they have the ability to induce internal haemorrhaging or inflict harm on bodily
organs. Consider a hypothetical scenario in which an individual falls down a set of stairs,
resulting in an impact on their leg against the edge of a step. This potential consequence may
lead to the formation of a contusion on the individual's lower extremity. This aligns with
Kranioti et al. (2023, pp. 832-838) research on post-mortem CT in the investigation of
homicides, emphasizing the role of advanced imaging techniques in understanding trauma-
related injuries.

17
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

8.3.3 Fracture

A fracture is the result of a bone breaking as a consequence of blunt-force trauma. This

particular kind of damage may occur as a result of either accidental falls or direct impacts.
Fractures exhibit a spectrum of severity, ranging from moderate to severe, sometimes
necessitating surgical intervention. For example, in the event of an individual experiencing a
fall from an elevated position and subsequently impacting their arm, there is a potential for
the occurrence of a fracture in the bone of the arm. This might potentially require
immobilization and, in certain cases, surgical intervention to facilitate an appropriate
recovery. The study by Thomsen (2022, pp.2343-2350) on blunt force homicides in
Denmark, which offers crucial insights into the epidemiology of such cases, further supports
this.

8.3.4 Laceration

Lacerations are a consequence of blunt-force trauma, which induces a detachment between

the skin and the underlying tissues. This phenomenon may manifest in situations involving
pointed implements such as fragmented glass. Lacerations include a spectrum of injuries
ranging from simple cuts to severe wounds necessitating the application of sutures or surgical
intervention. For instance, an individual may inadvertently get a laceration from a fragment
of broken glass during the process of dishwashing. This has the potential to result in a manual
injury requiring the application of sutures. Peterson's (2023) comparative investigation of
equine-related and bovine-related human fatalities in Oklahoma, which highlights the variety
of blunt force trauma scenarios, further supports this finding.

The aforementioned practical examples effectively demonstrate various forms of blunt-force

trauma. However, it is crucial to acknowledge that real-life situations sometimes include
more complexity. Several factors, including the magnitude of impact, the angle and surface
area of contact, and the individual's health condition, may all have an effect on the severity
and presentation of these injuries. Moreover, the coexistence of concurrent injuries or
comorbid medical disorders might potentially introduce complexities into the process of
diagnosing and treating the patient.

8.4 Organ Vulnerability in Blunt Force Trauma

8.4.1 Identifying the Most Prone Organ
The vulnerability of bodily organs to blunt-force trauma is a fundamental aspect of forensic
investigations, requiring a deep understanding of the organs most susceptible to harm and the
potential consequences of such trauma. The real-world implications of this understanding are
profound and can be exemplified through practical examples and critical analysis, bolstered
by contemporary research findings.
8.4.1.1 The brain

Let's begin with the brain, a vital organ encased within the cranium. Blunt-force trauma to the
head can lead to a spectrum of outcomes, from concussions characterized by symptoms such

18
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

as headaches and disorientation to more severe traumatic brain injuries that may result in
memory loss and impairment of motor function. For instance, recent research by Bird (2022,
p. 14604086221076650) sheds light on the management and outcomes of renal injuries in
paediatric trauma patients. This contemporary study underlines the evolving understanding of
organ vulnerability in trauma cases.

8.4.1.2 The liver

Moving to the liver, situated in the upper right abdomen, it is responsible for filtering blood
and producing bile for digestion. When subjected to blunt-force trauma, untreated liver
injuries can lead to life-threatening haemorrhages. In some scenarios, surgical intervention
becomes necessary in order to effectively manage haemorrhaging or eliminate compromised
tissue (DeCou, 2022, pp. 169-184). This demonstrates how the location and intensity of the
hit directly affect the magnitude of organ damage.

8.4.1.3 The spleen

The spleen, positioned in the upper left quadrant of the abdomen, plays a crucial role in
immune response and blood filtration. Blunt force trauma to the spleen can lead to internal
bleeding and may ultimately require a splenectomy. This medical intervention, while life-
saving, introduces new considerations for long-term health (Barsky, 2022, p. 17132). This
example highlights the intricate equilibrium between the preservation of organ function and
the prevention of life-threatening circumstances.

8.4.1.4 The kidneys

The kidneys, which play a critical role in blood filtration and urine production, are also
vulnerable to blunt-force trauma. Renal injuries, if not promptly managed, can lead to renal
failure. In severe cases, surgery may be required to correct the damage (Khatti, 2022, pp.
895-896). This exemplifies the crucial need for prompt medical attention in instances of
blunt-force injuries.

8.4.2 Effects of blunt force trauma on the body

Depending on the severity and location of the injury, blunt-force trauma can have a number
of effects on the body. Below are four other examples of severe force trauma effects:

8.4.2.1 Internal haemorrhage

Internal haemorrhage, a condition that may result from blunt-force trauma, has the potential
to be fatal if not properly treated. The consideration of this issue is of utmost importance
since the presence of internal haemorrhage may not be readily apparent, rendering it a covert
but possibly lethal outcome of trauma. In a study by Hughes, (2022, p.167), comprehensive
insights into abdominal trauma were provided, emphasizing the critical nature of prompt

19
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

medical attention to address potentially life-threatening conditions such as internal

haemorrhage.

The occurrence of internal haemorrhage serves as a prime illustration of the concealed

dangers associated with blunt force trauma. In the context of a motor vehicle accident, it is
possible for an individual to encounter an abrupt deceleration force. The collision between
internal organs and skeletal structures may result in the occurrence of internal bleeding,
which may have the potential to cause significant severity. In the absence of prompt medical
action, this condition might lead to deadly consequences. This is aligned with the study by
Choi (2022), which delves into the trauma mechanisms and injury sites in patients with blunt
abdominal trauma, underscoring the critical need for early intervention.

8.4.2.2 Nerve damage

Blunt-force trauma can cause nerve injury, which can have a variety of negative effects,
including pain, sensory impairment, and even paralysis. This particular component
emphasizes the complex network of nerves present in the human body and their vulnerability
to injury. Tsai (2022, p.12416) conducted a clinical assessment of functional recovery
following nerve transfer for traumatic brachial plexus injuries, shedding light on the intricate
process of nerve recovery after traumatic incidents. Consider a case where an individual is
involved in a sports-related injury resulting in nerve damage. This practical example
underscores the enduring nature of some blunt force trauma effects and the challenges of
managing long-term complications.

The manifestation of a nerve injury highlights the intricate nature of the nervous system's
reaction to blunt trauma. For example, let us suppose a scenario involving a descent from an
elevated position. The potential consequence is the compression of the spinal cord, leading to
varying degrees of nerve impairment. The potential consequences of this condition include a
range of outcomes, ranging from transient sensory impairment to enduring paralysis,
contingent upon the specific site and gravity of the trauma.

8.4.2.3 Organ injury

Organ Injury: The application of blunt force trauma has the potential to result in internal
harm to organs, hence impacting critical anatomical components such as the liver, pancreas,
and kidneys. The aforementioned scenario presents intricate challenges due to the potential
occurrence of lesions to these vital organs, which may lead to internal bleeding and a variety
of related consequences. Pothiawala (2022, p. 492) highlighted the diagnostic challenges
associated with traumatic abdominal wall hernia, underscoring the importance of a
comprehensive evaluation in cases of blunt trauma.

The occurrence of organ damage serves to underscore the intricate equilibrium inherent in the
internal structure of the human body. In instances of physical attack characterized by
repetitive strikes to the abdominal region, there is a considerable likelihood of sustaining

20
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

harm to internal organs. The occurrence of a forceful impact on the abdominal region has the
potential to result in lacerations of the liver or contusions of the pancreas, which may
ultimately give rise to problems that pose a significant risk to an individual's life.

8.4.2.4 Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is not limited to the physical repercussions of blunt
force trauma; it may also have significant psychological implications. Flashbacks, anxiety,
and several other trauma-related symptoms are characteristics of post-traumatic stress
disorder (PTSD), which may have a significant impact on a person's psychological health and
general quality of life. Sherin (2022) delved into the neurobiological impact of psychological
trauma, shedding light on the intricate relationship between trauma and its psychological
consequences. Imagine a situation where an individual is a victim of a physical assault. The
critical analysis here highlights the significance of addressing not just the physical injuries
but also the psychological aftermath of such trauma.

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) underscores the extensive ramifications of blunt-force

trauma. Consider a hypothetical scenario in which a person falls victim to a severe act of
physical aggression. Despite the resolution of physical injuries, the enduring presence of
psychological scars remains a significant concern. The aforementioned element highlights the
need for comprehensive treatment for those who have experienced trauma, including the
management of both their physical and mental health.

To summarize, the ramifications of blunt force trauma on the human body are diverse,
including both immediate and potentially life-threatening outcomes such as internal bleeding
as well as enduring psychological consequences like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Forensic investigations need a thorough approach to each element, taking into account not
just the visible injuries but also the possible concealed hazards. The present study
underscores the imperative need for multidisciplinary cooperation among forensic specialists,
medical practitioners, and mental health professionals in order to guarantee precise
assessment and analysis of instances involving blunt force trauma.

8.5 Ensuring Accuracy and Reliability: Measures for Blunt Force Trauma Evidence in Non-
negligent Manslaughter Investigations
8.5.1 Methods used in forensic analysis of blunt force trauma in criminal
investigations

The examination of blunt force trauma via forensic analysis is of significant importance in
the field of criminal investigations, as it offers essential perspectives on acts of violence. The
aforementioned investigation has significant importance in the process of reconstructing
events, establishing culpability, and upholding principles of justice. The present study
investigates several methodologies used by forensic specialists in the analysis and
interpretation of data related to blunt-force trauma. These methodologies include
conventional autopsy, sophisticated imaging modalities, and biomechanical simulations.

21
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Analysts endeavour to provide a complete and dependable narrative for legal procedures by
using a multidisciplinary strategy.

The following are examples of forensic analysis techniques for blunt force trauma:

8.5.1.1 Autopsy

The use of autopsies serves as an essential component in the realm of forensic investigations,
as it allows a thorough analysis of the deceased individual's body, thereby enabling the
determination of the cause of death and the identification of any associated injuries. In
instances where there is suspicion of a murder, an autopsy may serve the purpose of not only
determining the cause of death but also offering valuable insights about the characteristics
and extent of the blunt force injuries inflicted. For example, Collini (2023, pp. 59-65)
conducted a retrospective study of autopsy cases, correlating soft tissue and skeletal injuries
in violent deaths. This approach provided invaluable insights into the correlation between
external and internal injuries.

8.5.1.2 CT scans

Computed tomography (CT) scans provide a comprehensive visualization of interior

anatomical structures, facilitating the identification of small lesions that could go unnoticed
during a conventional exterior examination. A computed tomography (CT) scan has the
capability to detect concealed injuries such as brain haemorrhages or internal organ damage
in the context of a vehicle collision, hence facilitating the establishment of a more precise
comprehension of the magnitude of the trauma. Kranioti et al. (2023, pp. 832-838)
demonstrated the utility of post-mortem CT scans in investigating homicides, showcasing its
ability to provide precise details about internal injuries.

8.5.1.3 External examination

The first stage of evaluating blunt force trauma involves doing an external examination,
which mostly focuses on observable indicators such as changes in skin colouring, surface
injuries, cuts, and bruises. In instances where a fall is implicated, a comprehensive external
examination has the potential to uncover distinct damage patterns. For example, Shinkawa
(2022, p.102452.) presented an autopsy case report highlighting the importance of examining
tramline bruises with various shapes, offering histological and mechanistic considerations.

8.5.1.4 Forensic evidence collection

The acquisition of trace evidence, such as blood spatter, hair, and fibres, plays a key role in
establishing a definitive connection between a crime scene and a particular instance of blunt
force trauma. The presence of a weapon at a crime scene allows for the potential collection of
trace evidence, which may be used to establish a connection between the weapon and either
the victim or the offender. This linkage of evidence plays a crucial role in furnishing vital
information for the ongoing investigation. The role of the medical examiner in crime scene

22
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

investigations, as outlined by Al-Saif et al. (2022, pp. 49-63), emphasizes the importance of
trace evidence in building a compelling case.

8.5.1.5 X-rays

X-ray imaging is a crucial method for evaluating skeletal injuries, facilitating the detection
and characterization of fractures, dislocations, and other forms of bone-related damage. X-ray
imaging has the potential to detect fractures at different phases of the healing process, hence
providing evidence of recurring abuse in instances of physical assault. Rowbotham (2023, pp.
195-213) developed reference measurements for the human neurocranium, aiding in the
interpretation of blunt force trauma cases through precise analysis of cranial bones.

These strategies are mutually reinforcing. For example, whereas an autopsy gives a
comprehensive examination, CT scans provide a more intricate inside analysis. The use of a
multi-faceted strategy enhances the probability of obtaining precise and reliable results. In
some scenarios, it is possible for numerous procedures to provide comparable information,
thereby possibly resulting in duplication. Nevertheless, this repetition may function as a kind
of verification, bolstering the precision of the results. The use of all these strategies might
impose a significant demand on resources. The selection of appropriate methodologies by
forensic investigators is contingent upon the unique characteristics and circumstances of each
case. Technological progress, namely in the fields of imaging and trace analysis, persists in
enhancing the efficacy of these methodologies. It is essential for forensic professionals to
have up-to-date knowledge of the newest technologies and procedures.

A multidimensional approach is crucial in the field of forensic investigation pertaining to

blunt force trauma. The comprehensive toolset includes autopsies, CT scans, external exams,
evidence collection, and X-rays. Each methodology offers a distinct viewpoint, and their
collective implementation guarantees a comprehensive and precise evaluation of traumatic
occurrences. The use of an integrated method enhances the likelihood of discovering essential
information that may have a substantial influence on legal inquiries.

8.5.2 Tools and techniques used in forensic analysis of blunt force trauma in criminal
investigations

Among the several procedures used in the forensic study of blunt force trauma,
biomechanical analysis emerges as a particularly important method.

8.5.2.1 Biomechanical Analysis: Precision in understanding Trauma

According to Tierney's research in 2022, studying biomechanics in the area of concussion

biomechanics is a structured way to understand the mechanical aspects of cranial trauma. The
aforementioned framework offers a scientific basis for understanding the necessary force and
trajectory to cause a particular injury, which aligns with the objective of Tierney's literature
analysis in establishing criteria for brain injuries. According to research by Rowbotham
(2023, pp. 195-213), the meticulous accuracy of this approach is extremely valuable in

23
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

situations where the angle and size of the collision are crucial. The study conducted by the
researchers focuses on determining the mean thickness of the bones of the human
neurocranium. This examination underscores the need for accurate measurements when
interpreting instances of blunt-force trauma. Biomechanical analysis serves to provide a
foundation of quantitative data for the research.

By using biomechanical analysis and Tierney's perspectives, it is possible to determine the

necessary force to cause the recorded injuries in a hypothetical situation involving a potential
fall. The ability to differentiate between accidental falls and probable foul play is of utmost
importance. Rowbotham and colleagues' study lends more evidence to the need for precise
measurements in these evaluations.

8.5.2.2 Biomechanical Analysis: Reconstruction of Traumatic Incidents

According to research by Veenstra (2022, pp.359-367) on gunshot damage to human subjects'

long bones, the field of biomechanical analysis has proven to be very effective in the
reconstruction of events that result in blunt force injuries. Through the use of engineering
concepts, it is possible to replicate the very circumstances in which the trauma happened.
This replication process offers valuable diagnostic assistance to forensic anthropologists,
enabling them to gain practical insights. Forensic investigators are able to acquire a
comprehensive comprehension of the chronological progression of incidents, including the
victim's location and the magnitude of force used. The use of this tool seems to be very
effective in providing a comprehensive understanding of the intricacies involved in a
traumatic incident, which is in line with the comparative biomechanical study conducted by
Szkoda-Poliszuk and Załuski (2022) on thoracolumbar compression fractures. The study
conducted by the authors highlights the significance of biomechanical evaluations in
comprehending distinct forms of trauma.

Let us examine a scenario where a pedestrian has been involved in a collision with a motor
vehicle. The biomechanical analysis, as described by Veenstra (2022, pp.359-367), is capable
of replicating the impact by considering many characteristics such as velocity, angle, and
location of contact. The process of reconstruction assists in ascertaining the driver's liability
and comprehending the magnitude of the trauma.

8.5.2.3 Biomechanical Analysis: Augmenting Investigative Accuracy

Researchers are getting better at studying blunt force trauma by using biomechanical
analysis. This is in line with the goals set out in Tierney's study of concussion biomechanics
and Szkoda-Poliszuk and Załuski's work on pedicle-screw-based fixation for thoracolumbar
compression fractures. This method offers measurable data pertaining to the amount of force
required to induce a certain damage, hence providing a degree of objectivity that supports
other approaches such as visual inspection. The need for objectivity is especially significant
in situations where the establishment of causation and purpose is of utmost importance.

24
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

According to the study by Szkoda-Poliszuk and Zauski, using biomechanical analysis can
help determine whether an individual's injuries are consistent with the alleged assault. For
instance, it could determine whether the force required to cause a specific fracture is
consistent with eyewitness accounts.

In summary, the incorporation of biomechanical analysis into these study results represents a
substantial advancement in the accuracy, impartiality, and thoroughness of studies pertaining
to blunt force trauma. The use of a multidimensional approach in forensic analysis
contributes to the enhancement of the dependability of forensic results, hence enabling the
administration of justice with a heightened degree of precision.

8.6 Limitations and challenges in using blunt force trauma analysis in determining non-
negligent manslaughter
8.6.1 Ambiguity in injury causation

Although the tools and approaches mentioned provide useful insights, it is crucial to
recognize their inherent limits. In instances of non-negligent manslaughter, the establishment
of intent plays a crucial role. Nevertheless, relying only on blunt force trauma research may
encounter difficulties in conclusively differentiating between deliberate damage and
unintentional injuries.

Within a densely populated establishment, a contentious dispute intensifies. A forceful strike

is executed, resulting in the recipient's descent and subsequent acquisition of a cranial
trauma. The examination of blunt force trauma has the potential to uncover evidence of a
fracture in the skull. However, the task of distinguishing between the intention to inflict
significant injury and the intention to protect oneself becomes complex.

The differentiation between purposeful damage and unintentional injuries based only on the
examination of blunt force trauma might present challenges due to inherent ambiguity. This
assertion has particular validity in situations when the observed injuries exhibit
characteristics that are indicative of both an intentional act of striking and an accidental
occurrence of falling.

In their study, Li et al. (2023) performed a thorough examination of the processes and
research methodologies pertaining to blunt ballistic head damage. Their investigation
provided valuable insights into the intricate nature of brain injuries resulting from blunt-force
trauma. The systematic review conducted by Dever (2022, p. 1480) places significant
emphasis on the complexities associated with comprehending and evaluating gait disability in
individuals who have had traumatic brain injury. Bullock (2023, pp. 297-304) conducted
research that brought attention to the lack of clarity in scientific models and methodologies
pertaining to the evaluation of shoulder range of motion and its association with elbow
injuries in baseball. This study underscores the difficulties in effectively assessing these
problems. The research by Hebali (2022, pp. 177-191) looks at what happens to FG plates
when the visco-Pasternak foundations are changed. They look at how the plates bend and

25
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

move. This research highlights the intricate nature of structural behaviour analysis, which
may be likened to the complexity involved in trauma analysis.

8.6.2 Variable force dynamics

The examination of blunt force trauma, while essential, often fails to include environmental
elements. The magnitude of force necessary to induce a certain injury may exhibit substantial
variation contingent upon variables such as the age and physical state of the victim, as well as
the nature of the impact surface. The presence of variability in the data might inject a certain
degree of uncertainty into the study.

A geriatric person has a loss of footing and subsequently sustains a significant cranial trauma
upon encountering a slick surface. Although the magnitude of the force applied may be
relatively small, the resulting injuries are disproportionately severe as a consequence of the
individual's susceptibility to fractures in their frail bones.

The dynamics of variable force in relation to causing certain injuries may exhibit
considerable variation depending on parameters such as the age and physical condition of the
victim, as well as the nature of the impact surface. The inclusion of this factor throws a
certain degree of ambiguity into the study.

The mini-review conducted by Jang (2022, p. 931) sheds light on the intricate nature of
traumatic axonal damage, drawing attention to the intricate aspects of cerebral concussion
and underscoring the need for developing a comprehensive comprehension of head trauma.
The average bone thickness in the human neurocranium is the subject of a study by
Rowbotham and colleagues (2023, pp. 195-213). This research highlights the complexities
involved in the interpretation of skeletal trauma, hence emphasizing the difficulties
encountered in trauma analysis.

8.6.3 Hidden traumas

The examination of blunt-force trauma generally centers on observable damage.

Nevertheless, it is possible that it may fail to detect latent injuries that are not immediately
evident. This constraint may be especially relevant in situations where there is a temporal gap
between the occurrence of the traumatic incident and the subsequent death of the individual
affected.

Following a small vehicular collision, an individual who has suffered damage may exhibit no
immediate visible signs of injury. Nevertheless, it is important to note that internal injuries
may not exhibit apparent symptoms. Over an extended period of time, spanning many days or
weeks, these injuries may give rise to significant sequelae, hence presenting difficulties in
ascribing the eventual cause of death exclusively to the original blunt force trauma.

The investigation of blunt force trauma typically focuses on observable injuries, neglecting
the potential presence of hidden traumas. Nevertheless, it is possible that it may fail to detect

26
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

latent injuries that are not immediately evident. This constraint may be especially relevant in
situations where there is a temporal gap between the occurrence of the traumatic incident and
the subsequent death of the individual affected.

The research conducted by Biss et al. (2022) examines the haematological assessment of
bruising and bleeding in children, highlighting the intricate nature of assessing instances of
physical mistreatment. This complexity is comparable to the difficulties encountered in
detecting concealed wounds resulting from blunt-force injuries.

9. Findings and Recommendations

The study of blunt force trauma as a method in the investigation of non-negligent

manslaughter has shown a complex interplay between forensic issues, medical evaluation,
and legal consequences. The extensive investigation conducted has resulted in valuable
findings regarding the characteristics of blunt force injuries, their impact on the human
anatomy, and the forensic techniques applied for their analysis. Based on the aforementioned
discoveries, a set of suggestions has been developed to improve the precision, morality, and
effectiveness of inquiries pertaining to blunt force injuries. The recommendations put forth in
this proposal involve adopting a multidisciplinary approach, leveraging technological
advancements, and implementing specialized training programs. The primary objective of
these measures is to enhance the quality of forensic practice and, in turn, bolster the criminal
justice system's ability to accurately determine the circumstances surrounding cases of non-
negligent manslaughter. This section outlines the key findings in understanding blunt force
trauma and its forensic implications, followed by a set of strategic recommendations poised
to catalyse advancements in this critical domain.

9.1 Section A: Findings

1. The issue of ambiguity in injury causation arises when analysing blunt force trauma,
since this method, while very beneficial, encounters constraints in accurately
distinguishing between purposeful damage and unintentional injuries. The presence of
ambiguity is particularly notable in situations where the determination of purpose is
crucial, hence posing difficulties in attributing responsibility.
2. The magnitude of force necessary to induce certain injuries exhibits significant
variation contingent upon characteristics such as age, physical fitness, and the nature
of the impact surface. The presence of variability in this context puts a certain degree
of uncertainty into the analysis, hence emphasizing the intricate nature of evaluating
force dynamics.
3. The examination of blunt force trauma largely focuses on observable injuries, which
may result in the inadvertent neglect of non-evident traumas. This constraint is
especially relevant in situations where there is a time interval between the occurrence
of the traumatic incident and the eventual mortality of the victim, since internal
injuries may not manifest immediately.

27
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

4. The precision of blunt force trauma analysis is heavily reliant on the level of skill
possessed by the forensic examiner. The presence of many experts with divergent
interpretations of identical data might result in disparate findings, bringing a
subjective component into the investigation process.
5. The study of head injuries caused by blunt force trauma involves sophisticated
systems that require specialist comprehension and research methodologies. The
investigation is further complicated by factors such as the influence of ballistic forces
and the impairment of gait seen in cases of traumatic brain injury.
6. The assessment of shoulder range of motion and baseball elbow injuries is
characterized by considerable uncertainty in scientific models and methodologies.
The presence of ambiguity presents difficulties when it comes to precisely assessing
and diagnosing these illnesses.
7. Analysis of Structural Behaviour: Looking into how different visco-Pasternak
foundations affect the bending and moving features of functionally graded (FG) plates
shows how complicated it is to analyse structural behaviour. The intricacy seen in this
phenomenon bears a resemblance to the difficulties encountered in the investigation
of blunt force trauma.
8. The phenomena of cerebral concussion and traumatic axonal damage bring to light
concealed realities that underscore the need for a sophisticated understanding of
cranial trauma. The presence of these injuries may not be readily apparent and
requires specific expertise for a precise diagnosis.

9.2 Section B: Recommendations

1. Facilitate the establishment of collaborative networks among professionals in the

fields of forensics, biomechanics, and medicine, with the aim of harnessing a wide
array of specialized knowledge in the investigation of blunt force trauma. This
approach has the potential to alleviate the difficulties associated with variations in
interpretation and the concealment of traumatic experiences.
2. Establish dedicated training and certification initiatives tailored to forensic examiners
and investigators specializing in the examination of blunt force injuries. The use of
this approach will lead to an improvement in the reliability and precision of
interpretations, thereby mitigating the influence of subjective factors in the process.
3. The integration of sophisticated technologies, such as 3D printing, CT scans, and
biomechanical modelling, may be used to enhance the study of blunt force trauma.
These methods have the potential to provide extensive insights and enhance the
precision of injury causation evaluations.
4. This paper advocates for the use of a longitudinal strategy for medical assessment
when dealing with instances of blunt force trauma. This includes further evaluations
aimed at identifying latent traumas that may not be readily apparent.
5. The objective of this study is to establish uniform protocols for the systematic
evaluation of injuries caused by blunt force trauma, with due consideration given to
factors such as age, physical fitness, and the nature of the impact surface. This

28
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

approach may assist in alleviating the difficulties linked to fluctuating force

dynamics.
6. Facilitate the continuous pursuit of research in the domain of blunt force trauma
analysis and ensure that forensic practitioners remain abreast of the most recent
breakthroughs and approaches.
7. Highlight the significance of comprehensive documentation and superior photographs
in situations involving blunt force trauma. This will facilitate the detection of both
apparent and possibly concealed injuries, hence improving the precision of studies.
8. Promote the practice of collaborative case reviews, when numerous specialists get
together to collaboratively assess complex situations. This approach may aid in
reducing the potential for variation in interpretation and promoting a more thorough
assessment of the available data.
9.

10. Conclusion
In conclusion, the analysis of blunt-force trauma can provide useful evidence for determining
non-negligent manslaughter in criminal investigations. A forensic analysis of blunt force
trauma can aid in determining the cause, nature, and extent of the victim's injuries. The
forensic analysis of blunt force trauma can be aided by the use of X-rays, CT scans, and
histological analysis. However, the investigation and prosecution of non-negligent
manslaughter are difficult and complex due to the necessity of establishing intent and the
absence of negligence. The legal framework for non-negligent manslaughter varies by
jurisdiction, as do the crime's elements and definitions. To improve their ability to analyse
blunt force trauma in criminal investigations, law enforcement agencies and forensic experts
should receive training and acquire new technologies and techniques. To develop new
instruments and techniques for the forensic analysis of blunt force trauma and to investigate
their potential applications in criminal investigations, additional research is required. Future
research should also examine the impact of blunt force trauma analysis on the criminal justice
system, as well as the equity and precision of the investigative and judicial processes.

29
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

11. List of References

Al-Saif, D. 2022. The Role of the Medical Examiner in the Crime Scene Investigation.
Manual of Crime Scene Investigation: 49-63.

Alketbi Salem, K., 2023. The role of DNA in forensic science. A comprehensive review.

Arroyo, W. 2013. ‘Pelvic trauma’: What are the predictors of mortality and cardiac, venous
thromboembolic and infectious complications following injury? Injury, 44(12): 1745-1749.

Barsky, D. 2022. A feasibility study using sodium alginate injection for penetrating
abdominal trauma in a swine model. Scientific Reports, 12(1): p.17132.

Bird, R. 2022. The characteristics, management and outcomes of high-and low-grade renal
injuries in paediatric trauma patients at a major trauma centre. Trauma:
p.14604086221076650.

Bullock, G.S. 2023. ‘Shoulder range of motion measurements and baseball elbow injuries’:
Ambiguity in scientific models, approach, and execution is hurting overhead athlete health.
Arthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation, 5(1): 297-304.

Champine, R.B. 2022. ‘What does it mean to be trauma-informed?’: A mixed-methods study

of a trauma-informed community initiative. Journal of Child and Family Studies: 1-14.

Choi, Y. 2022. A study on trauma mechanisms and injury sites in patients with blunt
abdominal trauma. Emergency medicine international.

Collini, F. 2023. ‘Correlation of soft tissue and skeletal injuries in cases of violent death’: A
retrospective study of autopsy cases for forensic anthropology. Journal of forensic sciences,
68(1): 59-65.

Creswell, J.W. 2013. Qualitative inquiry and research design. Choosing among
five approaches. London: Sage.

Creswell, J.W. 2014. Research design. Qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods
approaches. London: Sage.

Davis, M. 2021. What is a researchable question in design? In The Routledge Companion to

Design Research: 131-140.

DeCou, J. 2022. ‘Abdominal Trauma’: In Pediatric Surgery. Diagnosis and Treatment: 169-
184.

30
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Dempsey, N. 2020. ‘Evaluating the evidentiary value of the analysis of skeletal trauma in
forensic research’: A review of research and practice. Forensic science international, 307:
p.110140.

Denny, E. 2022. ‘How to do qualitative research?’: Qualitative research

methods. Bjog, 129(7): p.1166.

Dever, A.2022. ‘Gait impairment in traumatic brain injury’: A systematic review. Sensors,
22(4): p.1480.

Ely, S.F. 2023. Approach to blunt, sharp, and transportation deaths. In Principles of Forensic
Pathology: 239-277.

Ely, S.F. 2023. The pathophysiology of death and death certification. In Principles of
Forensic Pathology: 31-64.

Gray, D.E. 2014. Doing research in the real world. London: Sage.

Hebali, H. 2022. Effect of the variable visco-Pasternak foundations on the bending and
dynamic behaviors of FG plates using integral HSDT model. Arch, 83(2): 177-191.

Hughes, T. 2022. ‘Abdominal trauma’: ABC of Major Trauma. Rescue, Resuscitation with
Imaging, and Rehabilitation: 167.

Imaizumi, K. 2015. Forensic investigation of burnt human remains. Research and Reports in
Forensic Medical Science: 67-74.

Islam, M.A. 2022. Justification for adopting qualitative research method, research
approaches, sampling strategy, sample size, interview method, saturation, and data analysis.
Journal of International Business and Management, 5(1): 1-11.

Jang, S.H. 2022. ‘Hidden Truth in Cerebral Concussion Traumatic Axonal Injury’: A
Narrative Mini-Review. In Healthcare 10(5): 931.

Kahl, J.E. 2013. The changing nature of death on the trauma service. Journal of Trauma and
Acute Care Surgery, 75(2): 195-201.

Khatti, S.N. 2022. ‘Current Practice for the Management of Blunt Abdominal Trauma in a
Tertiary Care Hospital’: A Prospective Study. Pakistan Journal of Medical & Health
Sciences, 16(06): 895-895.

Kranioti, E.F. 2023. Post-mortem CT in the investigation of homicides. Clinical radiology,

78(11): 832-838.

31
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Kumar, R. 2014. Research methodology. A step-by-step guide for beginners. (4th edition).
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Leedy, P.D. 2013. Practical research, Planning and Design. Boston, MA: Pearson.

Liamputtong, P. 2013. Qualitative research methods. (3rd edition). New York: Oxford
University Press.

Lichtman, M. 2014. Qualitative research. London: Sage.

Marinho, L. 2016. Comparing known and reconstructed circumstances of death involving a

blunt force trauma mechanism through a retrospective analysis of 21 skeletonized
individuals. Journal of forensic sciences, 61(6): 1416-1430.

Mbanaso, U.M. 2023. Foundational Research Writing, Background Discussion and Literature
Review for CS, IS and CY. Research Techniques for Computer Science, Information Systems
and Cybersecurity: 59-80.

Mills, J. 2014. Qualitative methodology. London: Sage.

Morillas, A.V. 2022. ‘Unlocking the potential of forensic traces’: Analytical approaches to
generate investigative leads. Science & Justice, 62(3): 310-326.

Morrison, J.J. 2013. Injury pattern and mortality of noncompressible torso hemorrhage in UK
combat casualties. Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, 75(2): 263-268.

Peterson, K.S. 2023. A Comparative Investigation of Equine-Related and Bovine-Related

Human Fatalities in Oklahoma. Doctoral dissertation, University of Central Oklahoma.

Pothiawala, S. 2022. ‘Traumatic abdominal wall hernia’: a rare and often missed diagnosis in
blunt trauma. World Journal of Emergency Medicine, 13(6): 492.

Punch, K.F. 2014. Introduction to social research Quantitative and qualitative approaches.
London: Sage.

Quintana, M. 2023. ‘A multicenter citywide report on recurrent violent injury’: Injury, 54(6):
1563-1568.

Ritchie, J. 2014. Qualitative research practice. A guide for social science students and
researchers. London: Sage.

Rowbotham, S.K. 2023. ‘Average thickness of the bones of the human neurocranium’:
Development of reference measurements to assist with blunt force trauma interpretations.
International Journal of Legal Medicine, 137(1): 195-213.

32
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Ruchonnet, A. 2019. ‘Cranial blunt force trauma in relation to the victim’s position’: An
experimental study using polyurethane bone spheres. Forensic science international, 301:
350-357.

Salkind, N.J. 2012. Exploring research. Boston, MA: Pearson.

Sevara, A. 2022. Basic theoretical concepts and notions in Chomsky Hale phonology.
Multidisciplinary International Journal of Research Lines and Projects, 13: 21-26.

Shelmerdine, S.C. 2023. ‘Post-mortem perinatal imaging’: What is the evidence? The British
Journal of Radiology, 96(1147): p.20211078.

Sherin, J.E. 2022. ‘Post-traumatic stress disorder’: The neurobiological impact of

psychological trauma. Dialogues in clinical neuroscience.

Shinkawa, N. 2022. An autopsy case report of tramline bruises with various shapes
histological and mechanistic considerations. Journal of forensic and legal medicine, 92:
p.102452.

Silverman, D. 2013. Doing qualitative research. (4th edition). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Silverman, D. 2014. Interpreting qualitative data. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Stainton, I. 2022. Criminal investigation. Critical Publishing.

Sulaiman, N.A. 2014. Blunt force trauma to skull with various instruments. The Malaysian
journal of pathology, 36(1): 33.

Suryadi, T. 2021. ‘An alleged murder due to blunt head injury from a viewpoint of forensic
investigation’: A case report. Journal of International Surgery and Clinical Medicine, 1(1):
9-12.

Szkoda Poliszuk, K. 2022. A comparative biomechanical analysis of the impact of different

configurations of pedicle-screw-based fixation in thoracolumbar compression fracture.
Applied Bionics and Biomechanics.

Thakral, S. 2023. ‘Therapeutic artifact’: Case series. Journal of Forensic and Legal
Medicine, 98: p.102577.

Thomsen, A.H. 2022. Blunt force homicides in Denmark 1992–2016. Journal of forensic
sciences, 67(6): 2343-2350.

Tierney, G. 2022. Concussion biomechanics, head acceleration exposure and brain injury
criteria in sport: A review. Sports biomechanics: 1-29.

33
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

Tsai, Y.J. 2022. Clinical Assessment of Functional Recovery Following Nerve Transfer for
Traumatic Brachial Plexus Injuries. International journal of environmental research and
public health, 19(19): 12416.

Veenstra, A. 2022. ‘Gunshot trauma in human long bones’: Towards practical diagnostic
guidance for forensic anthropologists. Forensic Science, Medicine and Pathology, 18(3):
359-367.

Wagner, C. 2012. Doing social research. London: McGraw-Hill.

Wedel, V.L. 2013. Broken bones: Anthropological analysis of blunt force trauma. Charles C
Thomas Publisher.

34
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

12. Annexure 1: Marked Assignment 1

An analysis of blunt force trauma as a method in the

investigation of non-negligent manslaughter

By

Sherise Nundhkumar
STUDENT NUMBER: 62761552

Submitted in Partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of HRFOR81

In The

School of Criminal Justice UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AFRICA

SUPERVISOR: Dr Lesiba Motsepe

ASSIGNMENT: 01

35
HRFOR81 | 62761552

36
HRFOR81 | 62761552

37
HRFOR81 | 62761552

38
HRFOR81 | 62761552

39
HRFOR81 | 62761552

40
HRFOR81 | 62761552

41
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

13. Annexure 2: Marked Assignment 2

42
HRFOR81 | 62761552

43
HRFOR81 | 62761552

44
HRFOR81 | 62761552

45
HRFOR81 | 62761552

46
HRFOR81 | 62761552

47
HRFOR81 | 62761552

48
HRFOR81 | 62761552

49
HRFOR81 | 62761552

50
HRFOR81 | 62761552

51
HRFOR81 | 62761552

52
HRFOR81 | 62761552

53
HRFOR81 | 62761552

54
HRFOR81 | 62761552

55
HRFOR81 | 62761552

56
HRFOR81 | 62761552

57
HRFOR81 | 62761552

58
HRFOR81 | 62761552

59
HRFOR81 | 62761552

60
HRFOR81 | 62761552

61
HRFOR81 | 62761552

62
HRFOR81 | 62761552

63
HRFOR81 | 62761552

64
HRFOR81 | 62761552

65
HRFOR81 | 62761552

66
HRFOR81 | 62761552

67
HRFOR81 | 62761552

68
HRFOR81 | 62761552

69
HRFOR81 | 62761552

70
HRFOR81 | 62761552

71
HRFOR81 | 62761552

72
HRFOR81 | 62761552

73
HRFOR81 | 62761552

74
HRFOR81 | 62761552

75
HRFOR81 | 62761552

76
HRFOR81 | 62761552

77
 HRFOR81 | 62761552

14. Declaration of Authority

I, Sherise Nundhkumar declares that this portfolio of evidence/assignment is my own original

work and I did not copy any person’s work. I also understand Unisa Plagiarism policy, which
prohibit the submission of plagiarized work as one’ own work. Where I have used
information from other sources, a list of reference and in- text reference was provided in
order to acknowledge the original authors of the information.

Signature:

Date: 24 October 2023

Place: Residence

78