Morisson
Morisson
Morisson
Abstract
Toni Morrison dealt pervasively and sequentially with the
traumatized experience of abused children in her fictional canon.
Morrison, an Afro-American writer opted for the adoption of
postmodern narrative techniques in order to overcome the quandary of
being a black writer whose primary narratee belongs to the mainstream
white American culture. This paper aims at investigating Morrison’s
schematic narrative technique in remembering, revealing and
eventually healing the traumatic history of abused African American
children in her last novel God Help the Child (2014). The paper
hypothesizes that Morrison adopts a postmodernist authorial stance in
the composition of God Help the Child depending mainly on the
dialogical polyphonic consonance of the heterodiegetic and
homodiegetic narrative voices of the main and minor characters in this
novel. Moreover, the hypothesis of the paper is based on the
presumption that Morrison’s narrative schema is traceable to the
psychoanalytic theory that the course of psychological recovery of the
traumatized victims of child abuse is preconditioned by rendering full
catharsis of trauma by means of narration.
Keywords: Child abuse, Trauma, Postmodern narrative,
polyphony, Judith Herman, Recovery, Magic Realism and
chronotope.
Associate Professor- Department of English Language and Literature -
Faculty of Arts- Damietta University.
It is worthy of note that the course of the events in God help the
Child: the remembering, the establishing of the trust in an
untrustworthy society and the victim’s cathartic revelation of the
traumatic past are concomitant with what Herman labels “The
fundamental stages of recovery,” which are basically the
“establishing [of] safety, reconstructing the trauma story, and
restoring the connection between survivors and their community”
(14).
“held a blanket over her face and pressed.” She even thought of
“giving her away to an orphanage.” As soon as she took her baby
home she stopped nursing her and started “bottle-feeding” (5).
The newborn child was also rejected by her father who
accused her mother of cheating on him. He never touched her and
treated her “like she was a stranger—more than that, an enemy”
(5). The father deserts them both forever when the mother tells
him that the child’s blackness “must be from his own family” (6).
Meanwhile, Sweetness had to look for a cheaper place and to take
some precautious measures against acknowledging her black-
skinned daughter publicly:
I know enough not to take her with me when I
applied to landlords so I left her with a teenager
cousin to babysit. I did the best I could and didn’t
take her outside much anyway because when I
pushed her in the baby carriage, friends or strangers
would lean down and peek to say something nice
and then give a start or jump back before frowning.
(6)
Sweetness’s shadism led her to project her racist fears against her
own daughter and to consequently maltreat her. She, for instance,
locked her daughter up because she didn’t want people to
recognize her as her daughter. Furthermore, Sweetness prohibited
Bride from call her “mother” or “Mama” in public. Thus, the
regretful tone in Sweetness’s personal voice confesses her
parental rejection and neglect of her daughter as she says, “I told
Booker, she doesn’t fully recover but later in the novel after a
journey of self-reconciliation and full confession of her life-long-
hidden secrets. The initiation of this journey ensues after Booker
decides to leave her when she tells him about her intention to visit
Sofia, the woman she accused of child abuse when she was eight
years old. Booker’s words “you not the woman I want,” (8)
express his deep disappointment in Bride for trying to make
amends with a child predator. The announcement of her intended
visit to that “raging alligator” (29) woman ripped the scab off his
unhealed wound of child abuse.
The oscillation between the narrative monologues of Bride
and Sweetness in the first part of the novel is intersected by the
narrative intervals of Brooklyn’s and Sofia Huxley’s monologues.
Both were victims of child abuse and molestation that affected
their psychological beings. We first meet Brooklyn in the first
part of the novel twice, then a third and fourth times in the second
and fourth parts consecutively. Brooklyn is Bride’s closest friend
and her assistant in Sylvia, Inc., where they both work. She is a
blond twenty-one young woman who has had her share of
childhood abuse, and same as Bride she had to run away from
home after her uncle “started thinking of putting his fingers
between [her] legs again” (139). She had to run away when she
was fourteen, but “invented” and “toughened [herself]” (140).
Brooklyn says she can “read [Bride’s] mind like a headline”
(139). However, Brooklyn knows how strong Bride is except for
idea of the lowest of the low” (66). Sofia was raised by austerely
religious parents, especially her mother who punished her
severely for some things she cannot even remember now, so she
“couldn’t wait to get out of Mommy’s house and marry the first
man who asked” (76). It is important to remark how Bride’s and
Sofia’s mothers abused their children by either rejecting or
maltreating them, and in both cases their children ran away as
soon as they could. Sofia recounts her vengeful attack on Bride
who was one of the students who “helped kill [her], take [her] life
away.” Still, Sofia is grateful for Bride for healing her
psychological pain as her narrative monologue achieves its
cathartic and/or healing effect:
For the first time after all those years, I cried. Cried
and cried and cried until I fell asleep….that black
girl did do me a favor. Not the foolish one she had
in mind, not the money she offered, but the gift that
neither of us planned: the release of tears unshed for
fifteen years. No more bottling up. No more filth.
Now I am clean and able. (70)
same as the rest of the characters who populate the social milieus
of the two main characters Bride and Booker. Rain had to run
away from her prostitute mother who forced her into child
prostitution. The mother kicked Rain out after she bit a regular
client on whom she was forced to perform oral coitus. The mother
apologized to the client, “gave back his twenty-dollar bill and
made [Rain] stand outside” (101). She never let her back in. Rain
had to learn “where sleep was safe” and “what kinds of people
would give you money and what for” (102-103). She was named
“Rain” for the rainy night Evelyn and Steve found her waiting
alone at the Salvation Army truck stop” (103).
The third part of the novel is written in the third-person
narrative voice same as the fourth part except for two
homodiegetic narrative intervals by Brooklyn and Sweetness,
whose final monologue signals off the novel as it began it.
Morrison chose to dedicate half of the narrative discourse in God
Help the Child to the omniscience of the heterodiegetic voice in
order to activate other narrative techniques such as magic realism
and chronotopic encounters. The application of these techniques
helps in accelerating the healing process of the main characters’
traumatic experiences through their final reconciliatory reunion
and full psychological catharsis to one another.
After her breakup with Booker and the deadly battering by
Sofia, Bride feels the unraveling of the strong independent
identity she has built up ever since running away from her
lid of Adam’s coffin as does the same color of the rose he tattooed
on his left shoulder” (120).
The images of the roses on Adam’s Coffin and Booker’s
shoulder have complex metaphorical connotations. Booker’s ideal
family life never returns to its normal course. So, after Adam’s
murder, there were no more family unions, communicative
discussions or trumpet playing by his father. Nonetheless, after
months of mourning the family decides to move on and this
shatters Booker’s psychological being. He became obsessed with
a “poisonous vein of disapproval” (125) of his family’s attitude.
In the course of time, Booker became increasingly incapable of
forgetting or forgiving, and he could not get over how his family
“pretend[ed] it was over? How could they forget and just go
on?”(117). Adam’s death meant the loss of Booker’s soul mate:
his murder left him alone. In fact, Adam’s death “became his
own life […] his only life” (147). Six years later, Mr. Humboldt,
Adam’s murderer, was caught and executed for the sexually
stimulated slaughter of six boys, whose names were tattooed
across his shoulders and their amputated small penises were found
in a decorated candy tin in his house. Booker’s vengefulness had
never been quenched because he thought that the execution of
child abusers such as Humboldt was “a too facile solution,” as
Ramirez writes in “Childhood Cuts Festered and Never Scabbed
Over”: Child Abuse in Toni Morrison’s God Help the Child.
Instead, Booker would rather have his murdered brother’s body
Booker from a police station after battering two drug addicts who
were “sucking on a crack pipe” while a two-year baby was left
“screaming and crying in the backseat of the crackheads’ Toyota”
(128). In spite of Felicity’s sarcastic remark about Booker being
“batman,” (129) it proves to be the right description of his self-
avowed mission to defend children against abusers. Having lost
his brother in such a horrendous crime, Booker constantly shows
aggressive and/or impulsive emotional reactions. However,
Booker’s impulsive aggression shows only as an enactment of his
will to defend helpless children against any possible predators.
This explains Morrison’s first introductory descriptive words of
Booker at the beginning of part four:
Blood stained his knuckles and his fingers began to
swell. The stranger he’d been beating wasn’t
moving anymore or groaning […]. He’d left the
beaten man’s jeans open and his penis exposed just
the way it was when he first saw him at the edge of
the campus playground. Only a few faculty children
were near the slide and one was on the swing. None
apparently had noticed the man licking his lips and
wavering his little white gristle towards them. (109)
had done that before. […] nobody put their own self in danger to
save me. Save my life. But that’s what my black lady did without
even thinking about it.” (105-106).
The final encounter between Bride and Booker takes place
after a transient sojourn with his aunt. Same as Sweetness,
Queen—Booker’s aunt—is a single mother who had been affected
by African patriarchy: both women had suffered the desertion of
their husbands and both are penalized for their neglect of their
children. Queen, however, proves to be a weaker mother than
Sweetness as she could not keep any of her children. She had
multiple husbands and had to abandon her children in order to
“marry other men. Lots of other men” (169). Queen had “no
opportunity to raise a single child beyond the age of twelve”
(159). Nevertheless, her main traumatic memory pertains her
failure to keep her daughter Hannah safe from sexual abuse by her
father. Queen refused to believe Hannah and ever since “the ice
between them never melted” (170). As a result, Queen had to
suffer the abandonment of her daughter who ran away same as
Bride, Rain, Brooklyn and Sofia did with their mothers.
At the final part of the novel—told in omniscient third-
person narrative voice—Bride and Booker give full catharsis of
their traumatic pain and achieve full recovery through narrating to
each other the atrocities of their traumatic past. Booker and Bride
reconcile after she admits giving a false testimony in Sofia’s trial
in order to please her psychopathic mother. This cathartic
Works Cited
Bakhtin, M. The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. University of
Texas Press, 1981.
-------------. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics, In C. Emerson (Ed.),
Minneapolis: University of Texas Press (1981).
Caruth, Cathy. Unclaimed Experience: Trauma, Narrative and
History. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996.
Online. Project MUSE, [doi:10.1353/book.20656.]
Edkins, Jenny. Trauma and the Memory of Politics. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2003.
Herman, Judith L. Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence-
from Domestic Abuse to Political Terror. London:
andora, 1992.
[http://issuu.com]
Hopper, E., Grossman, F., Spinazzola, J., & Zucker, M. “Treating Adult
Survivors of Childhood Emotional Abuse and Neglect: A
New Framework.” [https://www.traumacenter.org]
Lanser, Susan Sniader. “Unspeakable Voice: Toni Morrison’s Postmodern
authority.” Fictions of Authority: Women Writers and
Narrative Voice, Cornell University Press, 1992, pp. 120–
38. JSTOR, Accessed 25 Nov. 2022.
[http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7591/j.ctt207g6vm.10]
López Ramírez, Manuela. "“Childhood Cuts Festered and Never Scabbed
Over”: Child Abuse in Toni Morrison’s God Help the
Child." Alicante Journal of English Studies / Revista
Alicantina de Estudios Ingleses [Online], 0.29 (2016):
145-164.Web.24Nov.2022.
[https://doi.org/10.14198/raei.2016.29.08.]
Morrison, Toni. God Help the Child. New York: Vintage International,
2015.
-------------------. Unspeakable Things Unspoken: The Afro-American
Presence in American Literature. Mitchell, Angelyn,
editor. Within the Circle: An Anthology of African
American Literary Criticism from the Harlem Renaissance
to the Present. Duke University Press, 1994. JSTOR,
Accessed 25 Nov. 2022.
[https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1134fjj.]
Muyumba, Walton. “Lady Sings the Blues.” The Atlantic. Apr. 23, 2015.
[https://www.scribd.com/article/389342080/Lady-Sings-
The-Blues]
Paul, Meenakshi F. and Khem Raj Sharma “Childhood Matters: The
Palimpsest of Retellings in God Help the Child.”
Authorspress, 2015. 352-85.
[https://www.academia.edu/33828821/Childhood
Matters The Palimpsest of Retellings in God Help the
Child]
Ramirez, Manuela Lopez. “‘Childhood Cuts Festered and Never
Scabbed Over’: Child Abuse in Toni Morrison’s
God Help the Child.” vol.29, 2016,
pp.145-164,
[https://raei.ua.es]
الملخص
تناولت الكاتبة تونى موريسون بتوسع و على نحو مطرد فى نتاجها األدبى التجارب
آليات السرد ما بعد الحداثية لكي تتخطى معضلة كونها الكاتبة األفريقية التى ينتمى السواد
األعظم من قراءها إلى عموم الثقافة األمريكية البيضاء .و يهدف هذا البحث إلى دراسة خطة
آليات السرد التى اتبعتها موريسون فى تذكر صدمة االطفال األفارقة االمريكيون و افشاء
اسرارها و التعافى منها فى روايتها األخير "فليكن اهلل فى عون الطفل" ( .)4102و يقوم هذا
البحث على فرضية أن موريسون تتبنى منهجية سردية ما بعد حداثية فى تأليف روايتها
األخيرة معتمدة فيها بشكل أساسي على تعددية األصوات السردية بشكل حواري تتناغم فيه
أصوات السرد الذاتية داخل الشخصيات الرئيسة مع بعضها البعض فى مقابلة مع صوت
الراوى الذى يحكي قصصهم .كما تعتمد فرضية هذا البحث على فكرة ان خطة موريسون
السردية من الممكن تقفي أثرها فى نظرية علم النفس التى تفيد بأن طريق التعافى من صدمة
التعدي على األطفال مرهونة بشرط التخلص من ذكرى تلك الصدمة عن طريق السرد.
الكلمات الرئيسة :االعتداء على األطفال ،الصدمة ،السرد ما بعد الحداثي ،تعددية
األصوات ،جوديث هيرمان ،التعافى ،الواقعية السحرية ،الزماكانية