1 PB

European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.
org
ISSN 2222-1905 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2839 (Online)
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
A Comparative Study of Interest Free Banking Practices in

Ethiopia Private Commercial Banks Between Oromia
International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank in Dire Dawa
Districts
Biniyam Kebede Desta (MBA)
M & N Research & Business Consultant Plc. (G. Manager) in Dire Dawa, Ethiopia
Kokobe Meliese Bekele (MBA)

Graduated Rift Valley University Dire Dawa Campus, in Dire Dawa, Ethiopia
Abstract
The purpose of the study was to assess interest free banking practices in Ethiopia private commercial banks
Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank in Dire Dawa. The researcher was used descriptive
survey research design and multistage sampling techniques (both probability and non-probability techniques) to
reach at the specific respondents. In this study was employed a descriptive and also inferential statistics such as
such as independent-samples t-test and ordinal logistic (O logit) regression to see the effects of independent
variables on dependent variable by using Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26 software.
More specifically five interest free banking practices factors identified in the study; which are Awareness,
Compatibility, Complexity, Perceived trust and Relative advantage with implementation of interest free banking
(IFB) practices in private commercial banks. The Nagelkereke R2 indicates the model can for 63.3% of the
variance in the implementation of interest free banking practices. The survey findings also revealed that interest
free banking service it shows that “Complexity” have statistically insignificant and negative relationship with the
implementation of interest free banking service. Thus, banks need to take these factors into account when
developing their interest free banking services to ensure the success of their Islamic banking products and
services. Banks need to enhance accessibility, profitability and service quality factors.
Keywords: Awareness, Compatibility, Perceived trust, Complexity, Relative Advantage, Implementation of IFB
DOI: 10.7176/EJBM/13-19-05
Publication date:October 31st 2021
1.1. Background of the Study

Interest free banking is a banking system that compliance with Islamic Law “Shariah”. The rules and practices
under interest free banking are in accordance with the primary sources of Shariah Law. The growth of Interest
free Banking partly reflects demand from Muslim population and non-Muslim clients for Interest free deposit
facilities and fund management services which involve Shariah compliance (Wondwosen, 2018).
According to Franzoni and Allali (2018), quite apart from the conventional finance, Islamic finance is built
upon five pillars which are the indispensable measurements of religious validity (Sharia Compliance) of any
financial activity performed under the umbrella of Islamic finance. These fundamental pillars are prohibition of
Riba (interest), ban on speculative elements in financial contracts (Gharar), Prohibition of gambling (mayser),
ban on the use of trade and investment involving any element of prohibited asset or activity (Haram), profit and
loss sharing principle and the imperative to have real assets underlying any given financial transaction.
Among these financial instruments accepting deposit, money transfer, bankers called sarrafeen or sayarifah,
promissory notes (reqaah al-sayarifah), bills of exchange (suftaja), cheque (sakk) and treasury (Baytal-Mal) were
common (Mohamad, et al., 2013; Alharbi, 2015). Suadiq and Ibrahim (2020) on the subject of adapting
conventional financial system Muslim scholars’ opinion fall into three groups. Scholars in the first group opined
accessing conventional financial services is halal (permitted). Contrary to this, the second group of scholars
argued accessing conventional finance is Haram (prohibited) but, it is also important. The third group argued that
accessing conventional finance is necessary though riba (interest) is undoubtedly prohibited (haram).
The Ethiopian banking sector has expanded in the few past decades and benefit only some part of the
community so that introducing interest-free banks which is the way to improve the poor and the
disadvantaged segments of the society is a logical next step. As far as potential for interest free banking
(Islamic bank) is concerned, the government facilitated the necessary legal framework about 8 years ago. The
potential benefits of allowing Islamic banking include; decreased economic disparity between the rich and
poor, better integration, and consequently accelerated economic growth (Mohamed Muhumed, 2012).
Government of Ethiopia can leap a step closer towards the fulfillment of the much appreciated dream of
“Middle Income Country” by reforming its banking sector and allowing the establishment of Islamic Banks.
36
European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.org
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
Even if the developments of Islamic finance in the Ethiopia have taken place since the first individual and group
initiatives surfaced in early 2008 years it is at developing stage. The past legal framework in Ethiopia does not
permit full-fledged Islamic Banking which offers the owners of capital to share the profits made by the
entrepreneur who comes up with investment projects, rather the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) issued a
directive to banks allowing them to provide interest-free banking (Islamic banking) service using a separate
window along with their other banking services to suit society's diverse financial needs.
The National Bank of Ethiopia’s directive came into force in October 2011 about first Islamic Financial
Institution in Ethiopia, However, the implementation of this banking system was started only in 2013 by few
commercial banks like Oromia international bank S.C, Commercial Bank of Ethiopia and united bank S.C.
Customers who are interested in the interest free banking are assured that they will obtain all those services that
they would get from a fully-fledged interest free banking. However, the implementation part is not as speedy as
the business persons would prefer, who would like to move immediately and get financing for their projects as
quickly as possible because the newly established interest free banking must first collect enough deposits, since
the principle does not allow them to finance Murabaha projects from the bank’s conventional deposits. So,
currently at Oromia international bank S.C out of above birr 5 billion deposit mobilized during the financial year
2013/2014 under review, 3% or Birr 175 million(Ethiopian money) from total accounts of 8,819 maintained in
76 branches was mobilized through newly introduced bank product, Interest Free Bank Service.
The Interest Free Bank Window was commenced operation in mid of December 2013 which has
contributed and promised a potential of differently mobilizing resources ahead of the Bank’s time, the service
being commenced on a limited number of branches only (Oromia international bank S.C Annual report 2013/14).
In addition the commercial bank of Ethiopia starting launching interest free banking services at the end of
October, 2013 and has attained 6,000 customers for its interest free banking service, with 100 million Birr
(Ethiopian money) in savings from 23 interest free banking clients by the first week of May. Currently as the
Commercial Bank of Ethiopia interest free banking performance document indicated at October 29, 2014 the
total deposit of 364 million from each Wadiya Amanah, Qard, Mudaraba saving accounts are 282 million, 46
million and 36 million Birr respectively from the 145 bank branches and 23,686 customers. It also indicated as
92 million Birr approved for finance granted by the bank (Fortune report, May 18, 2014).
Starting from 2011 there is an improvement and development in IFB system in Ethiopia. Currently above
nine banks have the license from National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) and start promoting Interest Free Banking
(IFB) service and accepting noninterest deposits but five of the conventional banks are involved in financing.
The finance given by those banks are, Profit and loss sharing (murabah), a profit sharing joint venture
(musharaka), a profit sharing agreement (mudaraba), supplying industrial products to clients order (istisna), a
globally recognized mode of leasing (ijara) and other services (Wondwosen, 2018).
As per the Directives of National Bank of Ethiopia SBB/51/2011, all commercial banks that are licensed to
engage in the Conventional Banking Business are privileged to engage in Interest Free Banking (IFB)
business through the existing branch offices only after securing independent license for running the business,
which is subject to fulfillment of some 10 to 11 terms and conditions set out thereof, among others, the
directive also orders banks not to go past the maximum share of interest-free banking business in their
consolidated balance sheet without prior approval from the National Bank. A violation of this could lead to
the closure of an interest-free banking window. Preparation of separate financial reports, keeping all data and
ensuring the segregation of activities from conventional banking are also some of the requirements set by the
directive.
Subsequent to the issuance of the working directive, the NBE has granted the IFB service license to Oromia
International Bank S.C on September 16, 2013. Same license is granted to the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia on
September 17, 2013. Accordingly CBE using its 23 pilot branches and OIB using its 24 branch offices launched
IFB operation on October 24, 2013 and December 16, 2013 respectively. On May 1, 2014, United Bank S.C.
began providing IFB service and recently, Cooperative Bank of Oromia, Nib International Bank, Abay Bank and
Wegagen Bank have joined the IFB business by giving depository products for the time being. However,
Initially, Zemzem, a prospective new bank, requested to join the banking industry as a full-fledged interest-free
bank, was unable to start operations as the directive requires that interest-free banking be given alongside
conventional banking services (Tsion, 2017).
The main motivation of this study is therefore, to assess Interest Free Banking practices between private
commercial banks in Dire Dawa Districts Ethiopia by using the case of two private commercial banks such as
(Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank) operating in Dire Dawa.
1.2. Statement of the Problem

The empirical evidence shows that interest free banking have rapidly spreading and developing across the world.
Studies in Ethiopia on IFB have been very few due to the infancy of the industry. For instance, Akmel (2015)
studied about challenges and prospects of Islamic banking for resource mobilization in Ethiopian commercial
37
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
banks. The study focuses on challenges and opportunities of IFB only on resource mobilization other challenges
and opportunities are not well addressed.
On the other hand Yewubedar (2018) also conducted research on challenges and opportunities of interest
free banking in case of commercial bank of Ethiopia northern district. The research concludes that lack of
sheriah advisors boards, lack of awareness of customers regarding interest free banking, lack of confidence by
customers, unavailability of the service in all branches are challenges of interest free banking operation.
A study conducted by Tsion (2017) the result of this study stated that lack of awareness by customers and
difficulty to segregate fund for effective implementation of IFB service. The researcher concludes that the
opportunities of interest free banking are more significant than the challenges. Numerous researches on the
prospects, challenges, operational and risk aspects of Interest free banking studies Mohammed in (2012) in his
work discuss the potential challenges as: lack of awareness, regulatory, supervisory and institutional challenges,
lack of support, gap in research and development in Islamic studies, lack of qualified human resource as well as
wrongful association with specific religion.
Most of the studies were conducted on challenges and opportunities of interest free banking services in
Ethiopia. Researchers were identified and investigated several factors considered as relevant in influencing
customers as well as attracting them towards the adoption of the Interest Free Banking Window Service (IFBW).
This, study, therefore, attempts to fill this research gap by investigating the major factors faced by service
providers and users of IFB service provided by Ethiopian Private Commercial Banks through Interest Free
Banking Window Service (IFBW). Thus, the researcher was to assess variables of the interest free banking
practices there are some determinant factors such as Awareness, Compatibility, Complexity, Perceived trust,
Relative advantage and Demographic factors (sex, age, educational status, religion and monthly income) in
Ethiopian Private Commercial Banks. It is important to ascertain a comparative study of interest free banking
practices by considering the case of two private commercial banks operating in Dire Dawa. Therefore, in this
study the intention is not only to know to what extent customers are aware of IFB products and services but also
to predict whether customers’ awareness on IFB attributes affects the adoption of Interest Free Banking Window
Service (IFBW).
1.3. Research Questions

1. What are the key factors (Awareness, Compatibility, Complexity, Perceived trust and Relative
advantage) affecting the implementation of Interest Free Banking practices in Private Commercial
Banks in Dire Dawa?
2. Do demographic factors (sex, age, educational status, occupation, religion and monthly income)
affecting the implementation of Interest Free Banking practices in Private Commercial Banks in Dire
Dawa?
1.4. Objectives of the Study

1.4.1. General Objective
The general objective of this research is to assess interest free banking practices between Private Commercial
Banks in Dire Dawa Districts.
1.4.2. Specific Objectives
1. To examine the relationship of the key factors (Awareness, Compatibility, Complexity, Perceived trust
and Relative advantage) with Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices in Private Commercial
Banks in Dire Dawa.
2. To find out how demographic factors (sex, age, educational status, occupation, religion and monthly
income) affect the Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices in Private Commercial Banks in
Dire Dawa.
1.5. Hypotheses of the study

1. Awareness has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
2. Compatibility has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
3. Complexity has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
4. Perceived trust has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
5. Relative advantage has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
6. A demographic factor (sex, age, educational status, occupation, religion and monthly income) has a
38
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private commercial banks.
1.6. Significance of the Study

The significance of the study is a comparative study of interest free banking practices between Private
Commercial Banks in Dire Dawa Districts. The findings of the study will have theoretical and practical
contributions. On the practical side, this study will help to acquire knowledge and practical experience to the
bank policy and decision makers, bank managers, to identify how key factors (Awareness, Compatibility,
Complexity, Perceived trust Relative and Advantage) affects the implementation of interest free banking
practices in private commercial banks so as to make a decision. Theoretically, the findings of this study will fill
an important gap and serve as a reference material and initiate other interested researchers as a starting point to
carry out more extensive studies in the area.
1.7. Limitations of the Study

There has not been much literature developed in the Ethiopian context which again limits researcher’s endeavor
to frame the study in the theoretical and conceptual framework. The study will apply a quantitative research
method and also the sampling was applied by using only non- probability sampling technique. When compared
to the largeness of the target population, the researcher resorts to a smaller sample size. Even if broader research
that encompasses all privet banks will give a more holistic view on the study; however, due to time and financial
constraint the study is delimited geographically, conceptually and methodologically. The study was also limited
only to the pieces of information that the respondents were unwilling due to Covid-19 pandemic disease. It is
limit to the respondents’ capability to answer such questions. This study was conducted in Oromia International
Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank in Dire Dawa and may not be generalizing to other Private Commercial
Banks and Public owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia in Dire Dawa.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Factors of Interest Free Banking Practices
2.1.1. Customers Awareness
A new idea does not go beyond the knowledge function, if sufficient knowledge is not obtained to become
adequately informed so that, persuasion can take place (Kotler & Amstrong, 2001; Rogers, 2003). On the other
hand, in an age of information and “innovation overload” (Herbig & Kramer, 2004) in which bank new products
are continuously being introduced, many new products providers are extremely conscious of the need to provide
consumers with as much information as possible about their product to make customers aware because new
products require effective communication. Customers awareness have been tested as one of the key variable and
positively influence customers attitude in numerous studies specifically in the area of on-line banking, internet-
banking and self- services technology adoption (Gerad et al., 2003; Gholami et al., 2010; Daud et al., 2011;
Hanafizadeh & Khedmatgozar, 2012; Agarwal et al., 2009). However, limited studies have investigated on
customers’ awareness in the area of Islamic banking adoption. Most of these studies, include Metawa &
Almossawi (1998); Okumus (2005); Bley & Kuehn (2004); Hamid & Nordin (2001); Naser, et al., (1999); Haron,
et al., (1994); Khattak & Rehman (2010); Saini et al., (2011); Ahmad & Haron (2002) indicates that consumers
are aware of existence of Islamic banks.
However, they are unaware regarding the use of specific Islamic method of finance or low usage rate and
could not differentiate between Islamic and conventional banks‟ financial products and services because of
Islamic banks have not done enough in educating their customers and promoting products and services
appropriately. Adoption is the acceptance and continued use of a product, service or idea.
2.1.2. Perceived Complexity
The degree to which a product, idea or innovation seems to be difficult to understand as well as use is main
concept of complexity (Rogers, 2003). Actually, complexity explains required level of physical or mental efforts
which is needed by individuals for adopting and continues usage of a particular innovation (Nor et al., 2010). An
innovation with substantial complexity requires more technical skills and needs greater implementation and
operational efforts to increase its chances of adoption (Wang et al., 2007). In addition, it has been hypothesized
and proved as complexities have a negative connection with rate of adoption (Rogers, 1995; Ndubisi and Sinti
(2006); Lee et al., 2011; Corrigan, 2012) due to the fact that complexity of an innovation, idea or product can act
as an inhibitor for its implementation in successful way (Wang et al., 2010). In contrast, a study by Tan and Teo
(2000) in Singapore confirmed that complexity as one of perceived attributes of innovation characteristics does
not have any noteworthy impact on adoption of internet banking. In this study perceived complexity of Interest
free financial products and services is observed from whether it requires mental efforts which is needed by
individuals for understanding and adopting it and whether the terms and concepts the bank used is difficult for
adopting.
39
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
2.1.3. Perceived Compatibility

Compatibility refers to the degree to which an innovation, idea or product is known to be consistent with past
related experience, current values (religious and ethical values basis) and different needs of potential adopters
(Rogers, 2003). An innovation is more likely to be adopted when it is compatible with social system norms as
well as values (Tornatzky & Klein, 1982; Anuar et al., 2012b). Furthermore, previous studies widely have
indicated that compatibility positively influencing adoption and as one of perceived attributes of innovation
characteristics in concept of beliefs and past experiences as well as values affect innovation adoption in multiple
different context (Tung et al., 2008; Norazah, 2006; Beiglo and Zare, 2011; Wu et al., 2007; Hernandez and
Mazzon, 2007; Arts et al., 2011; Giovanis et al., 2012; Papies and Clement 2008; Elahi and Hassanzadeh, 2009).
As such, in regards to banking experiences and practices, the Ethiopian banking consumers have already possess
banking habits from the long operating conventional banks and Interest free banking functions and operations are
new to them. Therefore, this study seeks to examine compatibility concerning IFB in the context of consumers‟
felt need for banking based on their religious and ethical values.
2.1.4. Perceived Trust
Trust has been described as interest of people to be vulnerable linked to other people or part actions (Mayer et al.,
1995). Actually, trust is identified as extensively accepted predictor of adoption in different studies and scholars
constantly have indicated that trust positively influence adoption of different type of innovation, products and
services therefore, it should be taken into consideration by the Service providers; if consumers do not feel secure
they will be reluctant to use the services (Gefen, 2000, Gholami et al., 2010; Sohail and Shanmugham, 2003;
Suh and Han, 2003; George, 2002; Liu and Wu, 2007; Kim et al., 2009). As Cerf (2010) asserted, trust is
essential to most human transactions so banking should show trustworthiness by keeping their promise to
determine how well-intentioned and truthful banking is. Farah and Higby (2001); Sipior et al., (2004) also
indicated as the success of Innovative products and services adoption is highly related to consumer’s trust; Nitin
Nayak et al., (2014) specified as Trust between the customers and the service provider is very Important to deal
with in better way. This paper also intend to investigate the role of trust in context of Interest free financial
products and services from customers’ point of view relating to whether performance of the bank is properly
Shariah based service.
2.1.5. Relative Advantage of Interest Free Banking
Relative advantage has been designed to reflect perceptions of customers which all or certain qualities of the
proposed innovation can offer incremental value to its potential adopter comparing with present available
options (Rogers, 2003; Flight et al., 2011). Rogers (1995, 2003) have indicated that relative advantage can be
explained as economic profitability, discomfort decreasing, saving in time and effort, low initial cost, social
prestige, and/or other potential benefits that possible user would receive by applying the current innovation.
Potential adopters want to know, if the new idea is better than an existing one. Besides, several scholars have
found relative advantage to be one of the best predictors of an innovation’s rate of adoption (Brown et al., 2003;
Tan and Teo, 2000; Hsu et al., 2007; Tung & Rieck, 2005; Thambiah et al., 2011b; Gerrard and Cunningham,
2003).
2.3. Empirical Literature Review

Interest free banking is an infant stage in Ethiopia banking industry is not a well-studied area, through; few
studies were conducted on the attributes of IFB. Mohammed (2012) has studied the “Prospects, Opportunities
and Challenges of Islamic Banking in Ethiopia” and his work has identified the potential challenges as: lack of
awareness, regulatory and supervisory challenges, institutional challenges, lack of support and link institutions,
gap in research and development in Islamic studies, lack of qualified human resource as well as wrongful
association with specific religion and the global terrorism. On the other hand Teferi’s (2015) study about the
“Contribution of IFB to economic development and its prospect in Ethiopia”. He assessed the contribution of the
inclusion of the Muslim population in the banking (financial system) to the economic development and GDP
growth.
Another study by Debebe (2015) has conducted a study on “Factors Affecting Customers to Use Interest
Free Banking in Ethiopia”. The study is centered on “customer” intention and willingness to use interest free
banking‟. The result showed that perceived relative advantage, perceived compatibility, customers‟ level of
awareness and subjective norm have a significant positive effect on the attitude towards interest free banking in
commercial bank of Ethiopia. This study is about effect assessment on the attitude towards IFB usage which
does not address the factors determine on implementation of Interest free Banking products and service in
Ethiopian. Akmel (2015) the study focused on assessing challenges and prospects of Islamic banking service in
resource mobilization efforts in three commercial banks in Ethiopia. This study is more concentrated on the
challenges in the banks’ operational activity of resource mobilization. The research made by Kerima (2016)
finds out the following challenges: lack of capacity to deliver IFB product at full rage, lack of awareness of
customer about IFB products, lack of trust and confidence of customers, inadequate marketing and promotion,
40
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
double taxation, nature of IFB products, unavailability of IFB products in all of its branches and the IFB being
delivered in a Window model. Accordingly, the following recommendations were forwarded by her aggressive
promotion and marketing campaign about IFB products, provide sustainable and continuous training to build the
capacity of the manpower, the bank shall increase accessibility of its products with the expected services
attached to the products, the bank has to have Sharia’h Advisor, give the required attention and focus for the
business and the bank has to be transparent in its IFB business undertaking, in addition to these NBE directives,
tax and ECX law shall include exceptions for IFB business.
The recent study by Abraham (2017) on determinate of customers’ intention to use interest free banking
products and factors affecting employees’ product knowledge in the context of commercial bank of Ethiopia and
the result show that except knowledge, all the other variables: attitude, social influence, perceived financial cost
and religious belief have significant effect on IFB use intention. Furthermore, chi-square test was used to analyze
the association between selected demographic factors and IFB usage intention. The findings of this study have
shown that, except for educational level, all other demographic factors found to have an insignificant on IFB
adoption intention.
The reviewed literature was on different aspect of Interest free banking mainly about concept and practice
of interest free banking. It was highlighted that the Ethiopian population is one of the fastest growing
populations in the world and the Muslim community was a great proportion of that growing population. Though
the introduction of interest free banking in the county was found to be a very great achievement for the
development of the country’s economy however, few researches had given attention to understanding this
concept in the Ethiopian context. It was found out that the few researches dealt with factors affecting consumers
to use IFB, this study provides information relevant to the understanding of the customers’ side.
There is, no study so far has tested by employing ordinal logistic (O logit) regression modeling to see the
effects of independent variables on dependent variable. This study therefore intends to investigate the factors
affecting the implementation of Interest free banking practices between Private Commercial Banks in Dire Dawa
Districts. Hence the present study is expected to fill that gap by giving first-hand information on such as an
important topic.
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1. Research Design
The researcher was used descriptive survey research design, which is a fact finding enquiry that explains
phenomena as they exist at that moment in time. Survey involves asking structured questions to a representative
cross section of the population at a single point in time.
3.2. Target Population

The study target populations were account holders of IFB from two private commercial banks such as (Oromia
Cooperative Bank and Oromia International Bank) operating in Dire Dawa. This sample was used to select from
Oromia Cooperative Bank selected branch such as Connele branch Afetisa branch and Sabiyan branch (7,085,
14,950 and 13,700 respectively) and from Oromia International Bank selected branch such as Connele branch
Afetisa branch and Sabiyan branch (3,270, 5,476 and 3,000 respectively) customers (account holders) of IFB
data published annually (2020).
3.3. Sample Size and Sampling Technique

In this study was employed sample size, the researcher based on the document found a list of the population
from selected Oromia Cooperative Bank and Oromia International Bank annually report data (2020). The sample
size selection was considered as representative of some selected 4,497 customers from two private banks in
DDA. Population is large enough to allow for precision, confidence and general liability of the research findings.
To ensure the representativeness of the sample, for large population size Cochran (1963) used the following
formula: Where: n= Sample size 397; N= population size 47,483; Z= Z statistical for a level of confidence (95%)
Confidence interval equal to 1.96; P= expected population (in proportion of one) (0.5); d= precision (in
population of one) (5%). The study was involve a sample size total of 397 populations were account holders of
IFB from two private commercial banks such as (Oromia Cooperative Bank and Oromia International Bank) to
gather information from the respondents.
This study used multistage sampling techniques (both probability and non-probability techniques) to reach
at the specific respondents. The same technique was employed by previous researches (Debebe, 2015; Kerima,
2016; Abraham, 2017, cited in Nobele 2019). Therefore, the researcher was used Stratified Random Sampling
Technique to draw the sample elements.
3.5. Methods of Data Analysis

In this study, both descriptive statistics and inferential statistical analysis models were applied in order to analyze
41
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
and understand the effect of interest free banking practices between Private Commercial Banks in Dire Dawa
Districts. Data was analyzed with the help of Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) Software version
26.0. Program to help generate statistical analysis and present the data through the statistical techniques was
presented in tables.
3.6. Model Specification Ordinal Logistic Regression (O logit)

In this study was used Ordinal Logistic Regression (O logit) model. Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression
analysis is a technique used to analyze the association between a single DV and several IVs (Gujarati & Porter,
2010). Ordinal logistic regression is a generalized linear modeling technique that may be used to model a single
response variable which has been recorded on at least an interval (ordinal) scale. Independent Variables such as
Awareness, Compatibility, Perceived trust, Complexity, and Demographic factors (sex, age, educational status,
marital status, religion and monthly income) and Dependent Variable were Implementation of Interest Free
Banking Practices (IIFBP) in Oromia Cooperative Bank and Oromia International Bank. According to Gujarati
(2004) the model is represented as the following function. Generally, we can express the ordinal logistic model
for k predictors with P-1 levels response variable as:
Log [p(y≤j/x)] α+β1x1 + β2x2 + β3x3 +β4x4 + …………..ε

Log (IIFBP*i) = αj+ β1 Awareness* i +β2 Compatibility*i + β3Perceived trust * i + β4 Complexity *i + β5
Relative Advantage *i+ β6Demography*i + ε*i
Where: IIFBP*i = is the Customer of IFB respondent i (i=1, 2, 3…..),
αj = represents Constant term
i= represent each respondent whose response will be used for analysis
βj= (j = 1, 2, 3,…11) are logistic regression coefficients to be estimated and,
εi = random errors which are assumed to be independent.
3.7. Reliability of the Research Instrument

Reliability test is used to obtain stability and consistency of measurement where replication obtains same results
over different circumstances if same method is used. Cronbach’s alpha Awareness 0.734, Compatibility 0.755,
Complexity 0.739, Perceived trust 0.756 and Relative advantage 0.776. Reliability test was conducted by use of
Cronbach’s alpha. Alpha values ranged from 0.734 to 0.875, thus indicating an acceptable level of reliability.
This implies that the instrument was reliable for use in data collection.
4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

4.1. Response rate
Response rate out of the 397 questionnaires administered, 285 were returned fully completed, giving a response
rate of 72%. Out of this sample, 112 questionnaires were not returned which will make the non-response rate of
28%. Therefor the response rate is enough to carry out the analysis and which was considered appropriate for the
study. According to Zikmund et.al., (2010) note that a response rate of over fifty percent (50%) is adequate for
analysis, sixty percent (60%) good while seventy percent (70%) and over to be very good enough. High response
rate enhances validity and importance of the findings. Hence, since the overall response rate in this study was
eighty percent (72%), it was regarded good and adequate for further analysis.
4.2. Descriptive Statistics of Overall Implementation of Interest free banking

Descriptive statistics involved computing the mean of the statements that reflect on the research questions. For
easier interpretation of the results of the study, researcher refers to the interpretation of scores 1.00 - 1.80 = worst,
1.81 - 2.60 = low, 2.61 -3.40 = enough/moderate, 3.41 - 4.20 = high and 4.21 - 5.00 = very high (Bahri et al.,
2012; Munizu, 2013; Sugiyono, 2008). Respondents opinion Overall Implementation of Interest free banking
was discussed with respondents and their reaction analyzed and presented in Table 1 illustrates the distribution
of descriptive statistics the employees’ views in the form of frequency, percentage, mean and Std. Deviation.
42
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
Table 1: Descriptive Statistics of Overall Implementation of IFB

Level of agreement Frequency Percent
Very low 15 5.3
Low 55 19.3
Moderate 62 21.8
High 70 24.6
Very High 83 29.1
Total 285 100.0
Mean 3.53
Std. Deviation 1.240
The findings in table 1 above, the respondents were asked that to what extent do you agree that the
provision of interest free banking service the survey results reveal that the majority of respondents 83 (29.1 %)
were very high and who high 70 (24.6 %), while 62 (21.8 %) moderate, 55 (19.3 %) low and 15 (5.3 %) very low.
This was collaborated with a high mean (3.53) and slightly low standard deviation at (1.14) indicating that the
variation between the respondents is high.
4.3. Inferential Statistical Analysis

The aim of inferential statistics is to approximate and make inferences about statistical characteristics of
populations. Inferential statistics are techniques that allow the use of samples to generalize the populations from
which the samples were drawn (Firtle, 2013). The methods of inferential statistics are majorly the estimation of
the parameter(s) and the testing of statistical hypotheses. It describes the data with making inference or
conclusion and summarizing sources of numerical data in to meaningful form. In this study were employed
independent-samples t-test, and ordinal logistic (O logit) regression to see the effects of independent variables on
dependent variable by using Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26 software.
4.3.1. Independent Sample T-Test result
An independent-samples t-test is used to compare the mean score for two different groups (Oromia International
Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank) to investigate if there is a significance difference between the mean scores
of interest free banking practices in two groups. The study was to assess Awareness, Compatibility, Perceived
trust, Complexity and Relative Advantage with implementation of interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
Table 2: Group Statistics between Private Commercial Banks
Variables Banks N Mean Std. Std. Error
Deviation Mean
Gender Oromia International Bank 57 .39 .491 .065
Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 .65 .477 .032
Age Oromia International Bank 57 2.05 .854 .113
Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 2.08 .872 .058
Education Oromia International Bank 57 3.19 1.187 .157
Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 2.64 1.200 .079
Occupation Oromia International Bank 57 1.00 .000 .000
Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 2.90 1.028 .068
Monthly Gross Oromia International Bank 57 5.00 .000 .000
Income Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 3.90 .975 .065
Religion Oromia International Bank 57 1.00 .000a .000
Oromia Cooperative Bank 228 1.00 .000a .000
Awareness Oromia International Bank 57 3.55 .566 .037
Compatibility Oromia International Bank 57 3.90 .939 .062
Complexity Oromia International Bank 57 3.53 .811 .054
Perceived Trust Oromia International Bank 57 3.49 .824 .055
Relative Advantage Oromia International Bank 57 3.60 .899 .060
IFB services Oromia International Bank 57 3.63 .724 .048
43
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
In Table 3 below this section presents the results of selected continuous variables of the two essential
normal distribution functions: Leven’s test for equality of variance and the independent sample t-test for equality
of means. The interpretation and analysis of the result has gone through two steps. Leven’s test for equality of
variance (F-test) has been first examined for each variable to check whether homogeneity of variance can be
assumed followed by selection of correct t-test value.
Table 3: Independent Samples Test between Private Commercial Banks
Variables Levene's Test for T-test for Equality of Means
Equality of Variances
F Sig. t df Sig. Mean Std. Error 95% Confidence
(2- Difference Difference Interval of the
tailed) Difference
Lower Upper
Gender Equal 1.034 .310 -3.766 283 .000 -.268 .071 -.407 -.128
variances
assumed
Equal -3.700 84.354 .000 -.268 .072 -.411 -.124
variances not
assumed
Age Equal 172 .679 -.205 283 .838 -.026 .129 -.279 .227
variances
assumed
Equal -.207 87.525 .836 -.026 .127 -.279 .226
variances not
assumed
Education Equal .103 .748 3.142 283 .002 .557 .177 .208 .906
variances
assumed
Equal 3.162 86.874 .002 .557 .176 .207 .907
variances not
assumed
Occupation Equal 95.370 .000 - 283 .000 -1.904 .136 -2.172 -1.635
variances 13.962
assumed
Equal - 227.000 .000 -1.904 .068 -2.038 -1.769
variances not 27.960
assumed
Monthl Income Equal 90.742 .000 8.478 283 .000 1.096 .129 .842 1.351
variances
assumed
Equal 16.978 227.000 .000 1.096 .065 .969 1.224
variances not
assumed
Awareness Equal 17.188 .000 3.021 283 .003 .238 .079 .083 .393
variances
assumed
Equal 3.896 132.068 .000 .238 .061 .117 .359
variances not
assumed
Compatibility Equal 15.446 .000 1.845 283 .066 .239 .130 -.016 .494
variances
assumed
Equal 2.514 150.346 .013 .239 .095 .051 .427
variances not
assumed
Complexity Equal 12.600 .000 2.212 283 .028 .253 .114 .028 .479
variances
assumed
Equal 2.648 113.409 .009 .253 .096 .064 .443
variances not
assumed
Perceived Equal 5.048 .025 3.657 283 .000 .424 .116 .196 .653
Trust variances
assumed
Equal 4.457 117.387 .000 .424 .095 .236 .613
variances not
assumed
Relative Equal .153 .696 2.192 283 .029 .293 .134 .030 .556
Advantage variances
assumed
Equal 2.166 84.959 .033 .293 .135 .024 .561
variances not
assumed
IFB services Equal 22.757 .000 3.047 283 .003 .302 .099 .107 .498
variances
assumed
Equal 4.342 168.53 .000 .302 .070 .165 .440
variances not
assumed
4.3.1.1. Awareness Factors
The results shown in above Table 4 regarding the category of Awareness Factors, the t-test for independent
44
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
samples had a p-value of 0.000, and that is less than the established significance level of 0.05. Resultantly, the
null hypothesis is rejected and research hypothesis is supported and it can therefore be concluded that there is a
significant difference of Interest Free Banking Practices between Oromia International Bank and Oromia
Cooperative Bank, t (17.188) = 3.021, P = 0.000 with respect to Awareness Factors. The mean score of
Awareness Factors for Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=3.79 SD=0.364) is
statistically higher than that of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.55; SD=0.566).
In other words Awareness Factors Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant
more Awareness Factors Interest Free Banking Practices by the Awareness Factors as compared Oromia
International Bank.
4.3.1.2. Compatibility Factors
The category of Compatibility Factors, the t-test for independent samples had a p-value of 0.000, and that is less
than the established significance level of 0.05. Resultantly, the null hypothesis is rejected and research
hypothesis is supported and it can therefore be concluded that there is a significant difference Interest Free
Banking Practices between Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank, t (15.446) = 1.845, P =
0.000 with respect to Compatibility Factors. The mean score of Compatibility Factors for Interest Free Banking
Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=4.14 SD=0.543) is statistically higher than that of Compatibility Factors
of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.55; SD=0.566). In other words Interest Free
Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant more Interest Free Banking Practices by the
Compatibility Factors as compared Oromia International Bank.
4.3.1.3. Complexity Factors
The results shown in above Table 4 regarding the category of Complexity Factors, the t-test for independent
significant difference Interest Free Banking Practices between Oromia International Bank and Oromia
Cooperative Bank, t (12.600) = 2.212, P = 0.000 with respect to Complexity Factors. The mean score of
Complexity Factors for Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=3.78, SD=0.598) is
statistically higher than that of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.53; SD=0.811).
In other words Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant more Interest Free
Banking Practices by the Complexity Factors as compared Oromia International Bank.
4.3.1.4. Perceived Trust Factors
Regarding the category of Perceived Trust Factors, the t-test for independent samples had a p-value of 0.025, and
that is less than the established significance level of 0.05. Resultantly, the null hypothesis is rejected and
research hypothesis is supported and it can therefore be concluded that there is a significant difference Interest
Free Banking Practices between Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank, t (5.048) = 3.657, P
= 0.000 with respect to Perceived Trust Factors. The mean score of Perceived Trust Factors for Interest Free
Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=3.92, SD=0.589) is statistically higher than that of Interest
Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.49; SD=0.824). In other words Interest Free Banking
Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant more Interest Free Banking Practices by the Perceived Trust
Factors as compared Oromia International Bank.
4.3.1.5. Relative Advantage Factors
The results shown Relative Advantage Factors, the t-test for independent samples had a p-value of 0.696, and
that is higher than the established significance level of 0.05. Resultantly, the null hypothesis is accepted and
research hypothesis is not supported and it can therefore be concluded that there is a no significant difference
Interest Free Banking Practices between Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank, t (0.153) =
2.192, P > 0.05 with respect to Relative Advantage Factors. The mean score of Relative Advantage Factors for
Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=3.89, SD=0.916) is statistically higher than that
of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.60; SD=0.899). In other words Interest Free
Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant more Interest Free Banking Practices by the
Relative Advantage Factors as compared Oromia International Bank.
4.3.1.6. Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices in Private Commercial Banks
The Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices in Private Commercial Banks, the t-test for independent
significant difference Overall Implementation of IFBP between Oromia International Bank and Oromia
Cooperative Bank, t (22.757) = 3.047, P = 0.000 with respect to Awareness Factors. The mean score of Overall
Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank (M=3.93 SD=0.381) is statistically
higher than that of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia International Bank (M=3.55; SD=0.566). In other
words Overall Implementation of Interest Free Banking Practices Oromia Cooperative Bank was significant
more Interest Free Banking Practices by the Overall Implementation of IFBP as compared Oromia International
45
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
Bank.
4.4. Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression model

Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression to see the effects of independent variables on dependent variable by using
Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26 software. Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression model
parameters using the maximum likelihood estimator, there is a need to assess the significance of the variables
with regards to predicting the response variable. There are a number of statistics that can be used to carry out the
assessment and these include deviance, likelihood ratio, Wald Test and Score Test (Harrell, 2001). These tests
are discussed in the sections below.
4.4.1. Model fitting information
The model fitting information shown in table 5 below had significant value of 0.000 which describe the model
was fit for logistic regression information. Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression is used in the analysis because it
was the predictor variables that are statistically significant in the model.
Table 5: Model fitting information
Model -2 Log Likelihood Chi-Square df Sig.
Intercept Only 859.789
Final 788.298 71.491 10 .000
Link function: Logit
According to Prempeh, (2009) the likelihood-ratio test is chi-square distributed and if test is significant then
the dropped variable was a significant predictor in the equation whilst on the other hand if the test is not
significant then the variable is considered to be unimportant and thus is excluded from the model.
4.4.2. Goodness-of-Fit
The observed values of the dependent variable must be compared with the estimated values obtained from
models with and without the variable in question. This comparison is based on the log-likelihood function
according to Hosmer and Lemeshow (2000), the statistic D, is called the deviance, and it plays an essential role
in the assessment of goodness of fit of the model. The deviance plays the same role in logistic regression as the
residual sum of squares plays in linear regression. A p-value greater than 0.05 (the significance level) is an
indication that at least one coefficient is non-zero (Abdelrahman, 2010). The goodness of fit of fit table contains
the Pearson and Deviance chi-square tests, which are useful for determining whether a model exhibits good fit to
the data. Non-significant tests results are indicators that the model fits the data well (Field & Miles, 2010). In
this analysis, both the Pearson chi-square test [x2 (1126) = 1197.938, P= 0.067] and the deviance test [x2 (1126)
= 788.298, P=1.000] were non-significant these results suggest good model fit.
Table 6: Goodness-of-Fit
Chi-Square df Sig.
Pearson 1197.938 1126 .067
Deviance 788.298 1126 1.000
Link function: Logit.
4.4.3. Pseudo R-Square
The fourth test of fitness was Pseudo R-Squire which showed how the model explained by the Explanatory
variable using those three variables describes the model ability of determination in contrary to the common use
of R2. These indicators that substitute the classical coefficient of determination of R2 is called pseudo-
coefficients of determination and are for ordinal regression the statistics of Cox and Snell (Cox and Snell, 1989),
of Negelkerke (Nagelkerke,1991) and of McFadden,(McFadden, 1974) the Result of this pseudo-coefficients are
also presented at table 7.
The value of Cox and Snell’s (0.622) and Negelkerke’s (0.633) statistics indicate an obvious good fitting
ability for the model .the corresponding value of McFadden (0.083) can be considered acceptable. As a result,
almost 63.3% (Negelkerke’s = 0.633) of interest free banking practices between Private Commercial Banks in
Dire Dawa Districts by those statistically significant antecedents in this study. The Nagelkereke R2 indicates the
model can for 63.3% of the variance in the implementation of interest free banking practices.
Table 7: Pseudo R-Square
Cox and Snell .622
Negelkerke .633
McFadden .083
4.4.4. Test of Parallel Lines
The last procedure for the evaluation of the model is the parallel line tests (see table 8) this test of the model,
because it helps to assess, whether the assumption that the parameters are the same for all categories is
46
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
reasonable. Substantially parallel lines test suggest a hypothesis testing the null hypothesis was acceptable
(Norusis, 2004) when P value presents higher score than 0.05 or 0.1(McCullagh & Nelder, 1980). In the case of
ordinal model the null hypothesis was not accepted since the statistical significance was P value less than 0.05.
Table 8: Test of Parallel Lines
Model -2 Log Likelihood Chi-Square df Sig.
Null Hypothesis 788.298
General 653.445b 134.853c 30 .000
This is the log likelihood of the fitted model. It is used in the Likelihood Ratio Chi-Square test of whether
all predictors' regression coefficients in the model are simultaneously zero.
4.4.5. Logistic Regression Parameter Estimates
Regressions of the data was computed using order logit link and predict the factors of interest free banking
practices with implementation of interest free banking in private commercial banks antecedents and the
following regression output of the model were summarized in table 9.
Table 9: Logistic Regression Parameter Estimates
95% CI
Variables Estimate Std. Wald df Sig. Lower Upper
Error Bound Bound
Threshold [IFB = 1] 3.531 1.536 5.285 1 .022 .520 6.542
[IFB = 2] 5.446 1.539 12.514 1 .000 2.428 8.463
[IFB = 3] 6.633 1.556 18.168 1 .000 3.583 9.683
[IFB = 4] 7.908 1.575 25.211 1 .000 4.821 10.995
Location Sex -.600 .228 6.905 1 .000 -1.047 -.152
Age .085 .133 .411 1 .521 -.176 .347
Education .017 .097 .030 1 .864 -.174 .207
Occupation .215 .208 1.067 1 .302 -.193 .622
Awareness 3.876 .701 30.533 1 .000 2.501 5.251
Compatibility -.942 .234 16.193 1 .000 -1.400 -.483
Complexity -.452 .240 3.528 1 .060 -.923 .020
Perceived Trust -.550 .228 5.837 1 .016 -.996 -.104
Relative Advantage 7.908 1.575 25.211 1 .000 4.821 10.995
Income 5.446 1.539 12.514 1 .000 2.428 8.463
[Religion=1] 0a . . 0 . . .
a. This parameter is set to zero because it is redundant.
4.5. Result and Discussion

The regression results are shown in Table 9 above the ordered logit regression model was also fitted to estimate
the effects of a unit change in the individual hypothesized explanatory variable of interest free banking practices
towards implementation of interest free banking service in private commercial banks.
4.5.1. Awareness Factors
From the coefficient for “Awareness” is 3.876, has positive and significant influence [beta (β) = 3.876; Wald
Statistics= 30.533; P=0.000] on implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial
banks. For one-unit increase in “Awareness”, there will be 3.876 (the odds ratio= eestimates=e3.876) increase 48.2
times significantly implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial banks
increases in the probability of log-odds of being higher level of IFB practices (service); in other words ceteris
paribus (other predictors remains constant), will lead to the private commercial banks to be increases by 48.2
times likely to implement of interest free banking. Thus, a high value of “Awareness” is associated with an
increase in implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial banks.
Hypothesis 1: Awareness has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
Hence, hypothesis 1 is supported. The results showed that awareness of Islamic banking services has
significance effect on the implementation of interest free banking service in private commercial banks. Thus
from this finding is in accordance with the findings of the studies by (Rammal and Zurbrugg, 2007; Thambiah et
al., 2011a; Echchabi and Aziz, 2012b) which indicated customer’s awareness have a significant relation with the
implementation of Islamic Banking.
4.5.2. Compatibility Factors
From table 9, the coefficient for “Compatibility” is -0.942, has negative and significant influence [beta (β) = -
0.942; Wald Statistics= 16.193; P=0.000] on implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in
47
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
private commercial banks. For one-unit increase in “Compatibility” there will be -0.942 (the odds ratio=
eestimates=e-0.942) increase or decreases 0.389 times significantly implementation of interest free banking practices
(service) in private commercial banks increases or decreases in the probability of log-odds of being lower level
of IFB practices (service); in other words ceteris paribus (other predictors remains constant), will lead to the
private commercial banks to be increase or decreases by 0.389 more times likely to implementation of interest
free banking. Thus, a low value of “Compatibility” is associated with an increase or decreases in implementation
of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial banks.
Hypothesis 2: Compatibility has a significant and negative influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
Hence, Hypothesis 2 is supported. This is in line with the findings of (Echchabi and Aziz, 2012a; Tan and Teo,
2000; Nor, 2005 and Thambiah et al., 2011a). Another study by Raman (2010) indicates that construct
compatibility appear to be insignificant in influencing the decision to adopt or not the Islamic banking products.
Compatibility turns out to be the most important factor in the Islamic banking adoption products and services
observe Islamic banking as well suited to their existing habits, needs and style.
4.5.3. Complexity Factors
From the coefficient for “Complexity” is -0.452, has negative and insignificant influence [beta (β) = -0.542;
Wald Statistics= 3.528; P=0.06] on implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private
commercial banks. For one-unit increase in “Complexity”, there will be -0.255 (the odds ratio= eestimates=e-0.452)
decrease 0.636 times significantly implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private
commercial banks decreases in the probability of log-odds of being higher level of IFB practices (service); in
other words ceteris paribus (other predictors remains constant), will lead to the private commercial banks to be
decreases by 0.636 times likely to implementation of interest free banking. Thus, a low value of “Complexity” is
associated with a decrease in implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial
banks.
Hypothesis 3: Complexity has negative and insignificant influence on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks.
Hence, Hypothesis 3 is not supported. Although perceived complexity negatively affects the attitude of
customers towards implementation of Interest free banking, it is statistically insignificant p value 0.60 % of
greater than (0.05) at significance level as shown in the above table that support the null hypothesis which says,
there is a negative relationship between complexity and implementation of Interest free banking window services.
Complexity has negative and insignificant not influence the attitude of customers towards interest frees banking.
This is similar to the findings of the study with, Shih and Fang, (2004), as well as Taylor and Todd, (1995).
Therefore, even though Islamic banking services can be considered as a new concept, it is still a form of
continuous financial innovation, which suggests that customers are not required to create many changes in their
usage pattern of banking services. The findings of this study reveal that ‘Complexity’ is negatively associated
with the Islamic banking adoption. This illustrates that individuals are not likely to adopt Islamic banking if they
discover that such products and services are complicated and difficult to understand.
4.5.4. Perceived trust Factors
The coefficient for “Perceived trust” is -0.550, has negative and significant influence [beta (β) = -0.550; Wald
Statistics= 5.837; P=0.01] on implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private commercial
banks. For one-unit increase in “Perceived trust”, there will be -0.255 (the odds ratio= eestimates=e-0.550) increase or
decreases 0.576 times significantly implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private
commercial banks increases or decreases in the probability of log-odds of being lower level of IFB practices
(service); in other words ceteris paribus (other predictors remains constant), will lead to the private commercial
banks to be increase or decreases by 0.576 more times likely to implementation of interest free banking. Thus, a
low value of “Perceived trust” is associated with an increase or decreases in implementation of interest free
banking practices (service) in private commercial banks.
Hypothesis 4: Perceived trust has a significant and negative influence on interest free banking practices in
private commercial banks.
Perceived trust has negative and significant influence the attitude of customers towards interest frees banking. As
a result, the alternate hypothesis (H4) is accepted, while the respective null hypothesis rejected. This finding
supports (Doraisamy, Shanmugam and Raman, 2011; Ostlund, 1974; Zhao et al., 2010). Thus, much emphasis
on the marketing and management strategies should be on the shariah complaint, religious value, and the specific
financial needs and secured investment in line with the philosophy of doing banking businesses. It is worth
mentioning that the main dimensions measuring ‘Perceived Trust’ in this study is the perception of customers on
the security and trustworthiness of Islamic institutions, how the banks deal with clients and compliance with the
Shariah principles.
4.5.5. Relative Advantage Factors
From table 9, the coefficient for “Relative Advantage”, is 7.908, has positive and significant influence [beta (β)
48
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
= 7.908; Wald Statistics= 25.211; P=0.000] on implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in
private commercial banks. For one-unit increase in “Relative Advantage”, there will be 7.908 (the odds ratio=
eestimates=e7.908) increases 2.718 times significantly implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in
private commercial banks increase in the probability of log-odds of being lower level of IFB practices (service);
in other words ceteris paribus (other predictors remains constant), will lead to increase the private commercial
banks by 2.718 more times likely to implementation of interest free banking. Thus, a low value of “Relative
Advantage” is associated with increase in implementation of interest free banking practices (service) in private
commercial banks.
Hypothesis 5: Relative advantage has a significant and positive influence on interest free banking practices in
private commercial banks. Thus alternative hypothesis (H5) is accepted whereas the respective null hypothesis is
rejected. This finding supports Nain Tara (2014) and Echchabi et al., (2014) the perceived relative advantage
emerged as the best predictor of customers’ acceptance of Islamic banking services. They indicated that relative
advantage have a significant effect on the customers’ intention to adopt Islamic Banking service.
4.5.6. Demographic factor
Hypothesis 6: Demographic factor such as (sex and monthly income) has a significant and positive influence on
interest free banking practices in private commercial banks. Sex and monthly income with a p value of less than
0.05. Thus, the alternate hypotheses for these constructs are accepted and null hypotheses rejected. The
coefficient for Demographic factors such as Age, educational status and occupation has negative and
insignificant influence on interest free banking practices in private commercial banks with a p value of greater
than 0.05. Thus, the null hypotheses for these constructs are accepted and alternate hypotheses rejected. The
present findings clearly imply that religious beliefs reasons are still instrumental in influencing the
implementation of IFB products and services to certain extend. Therefore, religious beliefs reason could be the
contributing factor for the interest free banking customers in particular to perceive IFB products and services as
fair and economically advantages, a banking system instilled with religious principles. This result is consistent
with the findings of (Thambiah et al., 2013; and Abdul Ghafoor Awan & Maliha, 2014).
5. Conclusion and Recommendations

On the basis of the findings the following conclusions and recommendations are forwarded in order to improve
the interest free banking practices in private commercial banks of Oromia International Bank and Oromia
Cooperative Bank in Dire Dawa.
The number of customers and deposits also increased when banks start to provide Interest free banking
products. The survey also revealed that interest free banking service benefits banks to improve
competitiveness and enhance bank’s brand image by serving as an alternative banking system. Interest
free banking services have been benefiting, not only in terms of increasing customers and mobilizing
deposits, but also some banks enjoy greater profitability generation. This indicates private commercial
banks currently having Interest free banking window have been benefited from the operation of Interest
free banking services.
The basic awareness of the customers and their essential knowledge about Interest free banking and
Shariah based products and services in the market have positively influenced their perception and usage
towards the Interest free banking. However, majority of the account holders did not well understand the
basic principle used in interest free banking. Furthermore, it is unlikely to aware every type of interest
free banking products and services, but the majority of account holders little aware or unaware for most
of interest free products.
Awareness and Relative advantage the significant factor on interest free banking practices in private
commercial banks Islamic banking products and services. These two factors explain the degree to which
the benefits of using Islamic banking products and services can be observed and communicated with the
other members in the social system. The benefits here can be described in the dimensions of economic
profitability, social prestige, low initial cost, the immediacy of the reward, a decline in discomfort, and
a saving in effort and time which have been depicted as sub-divisions of relative advantage.
In terms of public awareness of IFB products, we recommend the first step would be to inform the
client base which has opted out of receiving interest on the conventional products, their new accounts
terms and conditions. A clear explanation that their monies will now be used to finance projects which
are in compliance with Islamic financial principles should be provided to these customers.
Obtaining feedback from existing and prospective IFB customers could be used as a base for
developing an adequate marketing strategy for IFB products. Further marketing and communications
strategies can be developed as regulations and products are put in place.
The survey also revealed that interest free banking service it shows that “Complexity” have statistically
insignificant and negative relationship with the implementation of interest free banking service. Thus,
banks need to take these factors into account when developing their Shariah compliant products and
49
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
services to ensure the success of their Islamic banking products and services. Banks need to enhance
accessibility, profitability and service quality factors.
The Bank need to consider on the intense regular training programs, Seminars, workshops on Islamic
finance, and standards and procedures of Interest free banking must be organized for the officials and
employees on the interest free counters of the by private commercial banks as a result they can aware
customers through their daily activities on issues raised from the customer regarding the
implementation of interest free banking service.
Suggestions for Further Research

The main objective of this study was to assess interest free banking practices in Ethiopia private commercial
banks in Dire Dawa. This study was conducted in Oromia International Bank and Oromia Cooperative Bank in
Dire Dawa and may not be generalizing to other Private Commercial Banks and Public owned Commercial Bank
of Ethiopia in Dire Dawa. The study was to emphasize Awareness, Compatibility, Complexity, Perceived trust;
Relative Advantage and Demographic factors (sex, age, educational status, and occupation, religion and monthly
income) with implementation of interest free banking practices in private commercial banks are not the only
factors that contribute to interest free banking practices. Further studies shall also be carried out to investigate
other factors that might be affecting interest free banking system in public and commercial banks and in the
future studies may replicate this study to other Private Commercial Banks or Public Commercial Banks.
REFERENCES
Abdelrahman A.I., (2010) Applying Logistic Regression Model to the Second Primary Cancer Data. Ain Shams
University Egypt.
Abdul Ghafoor , Awan & Maliha Azhar. (2014) Consumer behavior towards Islamic banking in Pakistan,
European Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Finance Research
Abraham .R. (2017) Determinants of Customers’ Intention to Use Interest Free Banking Products and Factors
Affecting Employees’ Product Knowledge: The case of Commercial Bank of Ethiopia. Master Thesis
(MBA), Addis Ababa University.
Agarwal, R., and Prasad, J. (2009) A conceptual and operational definition of personal innovativeness in the
domain of information technology Information systems research, 9(2), 204-215
Ahmad, N. and Haron S. (2002) Perceptions of Malaysian corporate customers towards Islamic banking products
and services International Journal of Islamic Financial Services, Vol. 3 No. 4, pp. 13-29
Akmel, H. (2015) Challenges and Prospects of Islamic Banking for Resource Mobilization in Ethiopian
Commercial Banks an unpublished MBA thesis St. Mary’s University, Department Of Accounting And
Finance
Alharbi, A. (2015). Development of the Islamic Banking System Journal of Islamic Banking and Finance, 3(1),
12-25.
Anuar, M. M., Adam, F. and Mohamad, Z. (2012b) Muslim Consumers‟ Perception on Internet Banking
Services International Journal of Business and Social Science, 3, 63-71
Arts, J. W. C., Frambach, R. T., & Bijmolt, T. H. A. (2011) Generalizations on consumer innovation adoption: A
meta-analysis on drivers of intention and behavior. International Journal of Research in Marketing, 28(2),
134-144
Bahri S, Hamzah D, Yus RM. (2012) Implementation of Total Quality Management and Its Effect on
Organizational Performance of Manufacturing Industries through Organizational Culture in South
Sulawesi, Indonesia. IOSR Journal of Business and Management; 5(1):10-24.
Beiglo, S. H. B. and Zare, R. (2011) A Survey on Factors Effecting Continuity the Use of Government‟ E-
Services. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 5, 209-220.
Bley, J. and Kuehn, K. (2004), “Conventional versus Islamic finance: student knowledge and perception in the
United Arab Emirates”, International Journal of Islamic Financial Services, Vol. 5 No. 4, pp. 17-30.
Brown, I., Cajee, Z., Davies, D. & Stroebel, S. (2003) Cell phone banking: predictors of adoption in South
Africa an exploratory study. International Journal of Information Management, 23, 381-394
Cerf V.G (2010), Trust and the Internet, IEEE Internet Computing, Backspace, pp 95-96
Cochran, W.G. (1963) Sampling Techniques, Wiley, New York
Corrigan, J. A. (2012). The implementation of e-tutoring in secondary schools: A diffusion study. Computers &
Education
Cox, D. R., and E. J. Snell (1989) The Analysis of Binary Data, 2nd ed. London: Chapman and Hall
Daud, M., Yussof, I. M. and Abideen, A. (2011), the establishment and operation of Islamic Banks in Nigeria:
Perception study on the role of the Central Bank of Nigeria. Australian Journal of Business and
Management Research Vol, 1
Debebe Alemu (2015). Factors Affecting Customers’ to Use Interest Free Banking in Ethiopia unpublished
50
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
project paper Addis Ababa University Ethiopia

Directives of National Bank of Ethiopia SBB/51/2011
Doraisamy, B., Shanmugam, A. and Raman, R. (2011) A study on consumers’ preferences of Islamic banking
products and services in Sungai Petain Academic Research International, 1(3): 201-210.
Echchabi, A., & Aziz, H. A. (2012a), The relationship between religiosity and customers' adoption of Islamic
banking services in Morocco. International Journal of Contemporary Business Studies, 3(5), 25-31
Echchabi, A., & Aziz, H.A. (2012b). The relationship between religiosity and customers’ adoption of Islamic
banking services in Morocco. Arabian Journal of Business and Management review (OMAN Chapter),
1(10), 89-94.
Elahi, S., & Hassanzadeh, A. (2009) A framework for evaluating electronic commerce adoption in Iranian
companies International Journal of Information Management, 29(1), 27-36.
Firtle, G.N. (2013) Marketing Research: An Applied Orientation, 4th ed Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle
River, N.J.
Flight, R. L., D'Souza, G., & Allaway, A. W. (2011) Characteristics-based innovation adoption: scale and model
validation. Journal of Product & Brand Management, 20(5), 343-355.
Franzoni, S., & Ait Allali, A. (2018) Principles of Islamic Finance and Principles of Corporate Social
Responsibility What Convergence Sustainability, 10(3), 637
Gefen, D. 2000. E-commerce: the role of familiarity and trust. Omega, 28, 725-737
George, J. F. (2002) Influences on the intent to make Internet purchases Internet Research, 12, 165-180.
Gerrard, P. and Cunningham, J.B. (2003b),“The diffusion of internet banking among Singapore consumers”,
International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 21 No. 1, pp. 16-28.
Gholami, R., Ogun, A., Koh, E. and Lim, J. (2010) Factors affecting e-payment adoption in Nigeria. Journal of
Electronic Commerce in Organizations (JECO), 8, 51-67.
Giovanis, A. N., Binioris, S., & Polychronopoulos, G. (2012), An extension of TAM model with IDT and
security/privacy risk in the adoption of internet banking services in Greece. Euro Med Journal of
Business, 7(1), 24-53.
Gujarati, D.N., (2004) Basic econometric, 4th International ed. McGraw Hill New York, USA
Hamid, A and Nordin N (2001) A study on Islamic banking education and strategy for the new millennium
Malaysian experience International Journal of Islamic Financial Services 2(4)
Haron, S., Ahmad, N., and Planisek, S. L. (1994) Bank patronage factors of Muslim and non-Muslim customers
International Journal of Bank Marketing, 12(1), 32-40
Harrell F. E, Jr., (2001) Regression Modeling Strategies: With Applications to Linear Models, Logistic
Regression, and Survival Analysis. Springer
Hernandez, J. M. C., & Mazzon, J. A. (2007) Adoption of internet banking: proposition and implementation of
an integrated methodology approach. International Journal of Bank Marketing, 25(2), 72-88.
Hosmer D. W., and Lemeshow S., (2000) Applied Logistic Regression, Second Edition. John Wiley & Sons
Hsu, C. L., Lu, H. P. and Hsu, H. H. (2007) Adoption of the mobile Internet: An empirical study of multimedia
message service (MMS). Omega, 35, 715-726.
Kerima, A. (2016), Challenges on Interest Free Banking Services: The Case of Commercial Bank of Ethiopia,
An EMBA Thesis submitted to Addis Ababa University, Department of management
Khattak, N.A. and Rahman, K. U. R. (2010), “Customer satisfaction and awareness of Islamic banking system in
Pakistan”, African Journal of Business Management, Vol. 4 No. 5, pp. 662-671
Kim, H., Kim, T. T. and Shin, S. W. (2009) Modeling roles of subjective norms and e Trust in customers'
acceptance of airline B2C e Commerce websites. Tourism Management, 30, 266-277.
Lee, Y. H., Hsieh, Y. C. and Hsu, C. N. (2011) Adding Innovation Diffusion Theory to the Technology
Acceptance Model: Supporting Employees‟ Intentions to use E-Learning Systems. Educational
Technology & Society, 14,124-137
Liu, T. C. and Wu, L. W. (2007) Customer retention and cross-buying in the banking industry: an integration of
service attributes satisfaction and trust. Journal of Financial Services Marketing, 12, 132-145.
Mayer, R. C., Davis, J. H. and Schoorman, F. D. (1995) An integrative model of organizational trust. Academy of
management review, 709-734
McFadden, D. Conditional logit analysis of qualitative choice behavior (1974) In: Frontiers in Economics, P.
Zarembka, eds New York: Academic Press
Metawa, S.and M. Almossawi, (1998) Banking behavior of Islamic bank’s customers: Perspectives and
Implications. International journal of bank marketing, 16(7): 299-315
Mohammad T., Mohd Y., Mohd A and Ummu Z (2013), the historical development of modern Islamic banking:
A study in South-east Asia countries. African journal of business management
Mohammed, M. (2012) Islamic banking: Prospects, opportunities and challenges in Ethiopia, An MBA Thesis
submitted to Addis Ababa University, Department of Accounting and Finance
51
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
Munizu M. (2013) The Impact of Total Quality Management Practices towards Competitive Advantage and
Organizational Performance: Case of Fishery Industry in South Sulawesi Province of Indonesia Pakistan
Journal of Commerce and Social Sciences. Vol. 7(1), 184-197
Nagelkerke, N. J. D. (1991) A note on the general definition of the coefficient of determination. Biometrika, vol.
78, pp. 691-692.
Naser, K., Jamal, A. and Al-Khatib, K. (1999), “Islamic banking: a study of customer satisfaction and
preferences in Jordan”, The Internal Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 17 No. 3, pp. 135-51.
Ndubisi, N. O. and Sinti, Q. (2006) Consumer attitudes, system's characteristics and internet banking adoption in
Malaysia Management Research News, 29, 16-27.
Nobel Demissie (2019) “Factors Affecting Implementation of Interest Free Banking Services in Ethiopia: The
Mediation Role of Customer Involvement” unpublished thesis Masters of Business Administration Addis
Ababa University
Nor, K., Pearson, J. M. & Ahmad, A. (2010) Adoption of internet banking: Theory of the diffusion of innovation
International Journal of Management Studies, 17, 69-85
Okumus, S.H., (2005) Interest free banking in Turkey: a study of customer satisfaction and bank selection
criteria. Journal of Economic Cooperation, 26(4): 51-86.
Oromia International Bank (2018) Interest Free Banking. https://www.orointbank.com/node/88
Ostlund, Lyman E. (1974), Perceived Innovation Attributes as Predictors of Innovativeness. Journal of
Consumer Research, 1, 23-29.
Papies, D., & Clement, M. (2008) Adoption of new movie distribution services on the Internet. Journal of Media
Economics, 21(3), 131-157.
Prempeh E. A., (2009. Comparative Study of the Logistic Regression Analysis and the Discriminant Analysis
University of Cape Coast
Rammal H.G. & Zurbruegg R. (2007) Awareness of Islamic Banking Products among Muslims: The Case of
Australia. Journal of Financial Services Marketing, 12(1), 65-74.
Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5thedition) The Free Press: New York
Rogers, E., (1983) Diffusion of Innovations. The Free Press, New York.
Rogers, E.M. (1995) Diffusion of innovations Fourth edition New York Free Press
Saini, Y., Bick, G., and Abdulla, L. (2011) Consumer awareness and usage of Islamic banking products in South
Africa South African Journal of Economic and Management Sciences, 14(3), 298-313
Shih, Y. and Fang, K. (2004) The use of decomposed theory of planned behavior to study Internet banking in
Taiwan, Internet Research, 14(3), 213-223
Sipior, J.C., Bard, B.T. & Rongione, N.M. (2004) Ethics of collecting and using consumer internet data.
Information System Management, 21, 1, 58–66.
Sohail, S. and Shanmugham, B. (2003) E-banking and customer preferences in Malaysia: An empirical
investigation Information Sciences, 150, 207-217
Suadiq Mehammed Hailu and Ibrahim Bushera (2020) Interest Free Banking in Ethiopia: Prospects and
Challenges International Journal of Islamic Economics and Finance Studies, 2020/2: 119-137 DOI:
10.25272/ijisef.678972
Sugiyono J. (2008) Statistics for Research Bandung, Indonesia Alfabeta Press
Suh, B., & Han, I. (2003) Effect of trust on customer acceptance of Internet banking. Electronic Commerce
Research and Applications, 1(3-4), 247-263
Tan, M., & Teo, T. (2000) Factors influencing the adoption of Internet banking. Journal of the Association for
Information Sciences, 1, 1-42.
Taylor, S. and Todd, P. A. (1995) Understanding information technology usage: A test of competing models
Information systems research, 6(2):144–176.
Teferi, M (2015). Contribution of IFB to economic development and its prospect in Ethiopia, An EMBA Thesis
submitted to Addis Ababa University, Department of Management.
Thambiah, S., Eze, U. C., Santhapparaj, A. J., & Arumugam, K. (2011a) Customers' Perception on Islamic Retail
Banking: A Comparative Analysis between the Urban and Rural Regions of Malaysia International
Journal of Business & Management, 6(1)
Thambiah, S., Ismail, H., Ahmed, E. M., & Khim, A. A. (2013) Islamic Retail Banking Adoption in
Malaysia:The Moderating of Religion and Region International Journal of Applied Economics &
Finance, 7(1).
Thambiah, S., Ramanathan, S. & Mazumder, M.N.H. (2012) The determinants of Islamic retail banking adoption
in Malaysia, International Business & Economics Research Journal (IBER),11(4), 437-442.
Thambiah, S.; Eze, U. C.; Santhapparaj, A. J. & Arumugam, K. (2011b) Customers‟ Perception on Islamic
Retail Banking: A Comparative Analysis between the Urban and Rural Regions of Malaysia.
International Journal of Business and Management, 6 (1), 187- 198
52
Vol.13, No.19, 2021
Tornatzky, L. G., & Klein, K. J. (1982) Innovation characteristics and innovation adoption-implementation: A
meta-analysis of findings. IEEE Transactions on engineering management, 29(1), 28-45.
Tsion sisay (2017), Challenges and opportunities of interest free banking in Ethiopia .A Thesis submitted to the
Department of Accounting and Finance for the fulfillment of the requirements of the Degree of Master of
Science in Accounting and Finance
Tung, F. C., Chang, S. C. and Chou, C. M. (2008), An extension of trust and TAM model with IDT in the
adoption of the electronic logistics information system in HIS in the medical industry. International
journal of medical informatics, 77, 324
Wang, M. S., Chen, C. C., Chang, S. C., and Yang, Y. H. (2007) The selection of banks and banking services
among corporate customers in South Africa, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 7 No. 5, pp.
36-43.
Wang, M. S., Chen, C. C., Chang, S. C., and Yang, Y. H. (2010) Effect of Online Shopping Attitudes, Subjective
Norms and Control Beliefs on Online Shopping Intentions: A Test of the Theory of Planned Behavior.
International Journal of Management, 24(2), 296-302.
Wondwosen Teshome (2018) operational challenges and opportunities of interest free banking in Ethiopia
unpublished thesis submitted to Addis Ababa University College of business and economics department
Addis Ababa Ethiopia
Wu, J. H., Wang, S. C., & Lin, L. M. (2007) Mobile computing acceptance factors in the healthcare industry: A
structural equation model International journal of medical informatics, 76(1), 66-77.
Yewubedar Getachew (2018), Assessment of prospects and challenges of interest free banking in Ethiopia in the
case of commercial bank of Ethiopia, north Addis district
Zhao, A., Koenig-Lewis, N., Hanmer-Lloyd, S. & Ward, P., (2010) Adoption of internet banking services in
China: is it all about trust? International Journal of Bank Marketing, 28(1), 7-26
Zikmund, W. G., Babin, B. J., Carr, J. C. & Griffin, M. (2010) Business Research Methods (8thed) New Delhi:
McMillan Publishers
53

1 PB

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1 PB

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

1 PB

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

European Journal of Business and Management www.iiste.

A Comparative Study of Interest Free Banking Practices in

Kokobe Meliese Bekele (MBA)

1.1. Background of the Study

1.2. Statement of the Problem

1.3. Research Questions

1.4. Objectives of the Study

1.5. Hypotheses of the study

1.6. Significance of the Study

1.7. Limitations of the Study

2.1.3. Perceived Compatibility

2.3. Empirical Literature Review

3.2. Target Population

3.3. Sample Size and Sampling Technique

3.5. Methods of Data Analysis

3.6. Model Specification Ordinal Logistic Regression (O logit)

Log [p(y≤j/x)] α+β1x1 + β2x2 + β3x3 +β4x4 + …………..ε

3.7. Reliability of the Research Instrument

4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

4.2. Descriptive Statistics of Overall Implementation of Interest free banking

Table 1: Descriptive Statistics of Overall Implementation of IFB

4.3. Inferential Statistical Analysis

4.4. Ordinal logistic (O logit) regression model

4.5. Result and Discussion

5. Conclusion and Recommendations

Suggestions for Further Research

project paper Addis Ababa University Ethiopia

You might also like