Presentation Description: Financial Statement Fraud & Corporate Governancethe Satyam Case

Presentation Description
No description available.
Comments (0) Post a Comment Presentation Transcript

FINANCIAL STATEMENT FRAUD & CORPORATE GOVERNANCETHE SATYAM CASE :
FINANCIAL STATEMENT FRAUD & CORPORATE GOVERNANCETHE SATYAM CASE By A.K. Sharma
CHALLENGING TIMES :
CHALLENGING TIMES Number of financial statement frauds on increase Frauds against organizations are increasing Some recent frauds involve multiple individuals colluding to defraud Many investors have lost confidence More interest in fraud than ever before -now a course on many university campuses Forensic accounting and auditing/ IT Systems Audit Security/Controls/risks assessment
Satyam Case- Basic Facts :

Satyam Case- Basic Facts Fourth largest Indian IT Company listed in India & US Over US $ 2 billion annual revenue size Co Established in mid 1980s, grown to 53,000 employees; 600 plus customers including 185 fortune 500 Cos Operations in 66 countries across the globe Financial advisor: Merrill Lynch (now Bank of America) Auditors: Price Water House Coopers Bankers: Citi bank; BNP Paribas, HSBC & HDFC
Fraud is a Costly Proposition :

Fraud is a Costly Proposition Fraud Losses Reduce Net Income $ for $ If Profit Margin is 10%, Revenues Must Increase by 10 times Losses to Recover Effect on Net Income Losses. $1 Million Revenue.$1 Billion Fraud Robs Income Revenues $100 100% Expenses 90 90% Net Income $ 10 10% Fraud 1 Remaining $ 9 To restore income to $10, need $10 more dollars of revenue to generate $1 more dollar of income.
Impact of Fraud -Two Examples :

Impact of Fraud -Two Examples General Motors $436 Million Fraud Profit Margin = 10% $4.36 Billion in Revenues Needed At $20,000 per Car, 218,000 Cars Bank $100 Million Fraud Profit Margin = 10 % $1 Billion in Revenues Needed At $100 per year per Checking Account, 10 Million New Accounts
Fraud leads to Stock value crash :

Fraud leads to Stock value crash Financial statement fraud causes a decrease in market value of stock of approximately 300 to 1,000 times the amount of the fraud. $7 million fraud $2 billion drop in stock value
Types of Fraud :
Types of Fraud Fraudulent Financial Statements Employee Fraud Vendor Fraud Customer Fraud Investment Scams Bankruptcy Frauds Miscellaneous The common element is deceit or trickery!
Financial Statement Frauds :

Financial Statement Frauds Madoff Many others (Cendant, Lincoln Savings, ESM, Anicom, Waste Management, Sunbeam, etc.) Satyam First in India
Confession January 7th , 2009 :

Confession January 7th , 2009 I did it Indias Largest Corporate Fraud
Chairman Rajus Version :

Chairman Rajus Version Inflated billing to customers Non-existent cash & bank balances $ I bn Overstated Debtors $ 100 million Operating margin shown high at 24% in Q2 (Sept 2008) as against 3% real profit margin Such manipulation done in earlier years( 6 yrs-$ 1.2 Bn) Increased costs to justify higher level of operations Attempt to merge Sons Company Maytas with huge land Bank to bridge the gap failed
Why Confession ? :
Why Confession ? Recession drained the liquidity to run the show Out standings were piling up Since listed in US, SEC rigors would take over Unmanageable gap between actual and book
profit Every attempt made to eliminate the gap failed. As the promoters held a small percentage of equity, the concern was that poor performance would result in a take-over, thereby exposing the gap. It was like riding a tiger, not knowing how to get off without being eaten.
Consequences of confession :
Consequences of confession Investors- Panicked as Stock plummeted & Class action suits filed in US Employees- stranded in many ways- morally, financially, legally and socially Customersshocked and worried about the project continuity, confidentiality and cost over run Bankers concerned about recovery of financial and non-financial exposure and recalled facilities Government- worried about image of the Nation & IT Sector affecting faith to invest or to do business
Action after Confession :

Action after Confession Chairman, MD and CEO, CFO, Chief accountant and two of his associates arrested Two Partners of PW (Audit Firm) were also arrested Options before Government: i. Allow market forces to decide; ii. Announce bail out plan; iii. Think out of the box Government dissolved existing Board & nominated 6 of us Gave us complete freedom
Prioritized Plan of Action :

Prioritized Plan of Action Restore cash flow to secure Financial Stability Customer retention and infuse confidence to continue Employee motivation and Management restructure Legal advisorsIn India and USA appointed Internal audit entrusted to an external firm Management Consultants and Board Advisors appointed Forensic investigation to facilitate restatement of accounts initiated
Modus Operandi :
Modus Operandi Held weekly Board meetings-TN was stationed at Satyam round the clock Raised $135 million from 2 banks to supplement internal accruals Cleared all statutory dues; Paid global salary including insurance and taxes; Released payments to other dues Kept meeting, talking to and reaching out to employees and customers Video clippings; teleconference calls; personal meetings; E-News letter & Weekly Bulletin
Two critical options :

Two critical options Continue to run the Business, clean up and restate the accounts, re-audit, enable valuation, due-diligence and offer for take over; or Immediately identify a strategic investor who will infuse capital and take over control & management Chose the second option
after due deliberation Investment Bankers appointed, Bidding process set in motion with Former Chief Justice of India as Observer SEBI and CLB were moved for appropriate relaxations
Bidding Process :
Bidding Process Press release on 9th March inviting registration RFP was sent to 141 registeredonly 10 submitted EOI Out of 10, 7 met the criteria and were sent documents for execution 5 submitted documents but later 2 withdrew for want of internal approvals leaving 3 in race Thus, WL Ross; L&T and Tech Mahindra competed Information had to be given to Bidders to facilitate quoting price per share for preferential allotment
Strategic Investor Selection :

Strategic Investor Selection Virtual and Physical data room created & access provided Site inspection of 2 main campuses arranged Management presentation made for each bidder exclusively show casing the facts and potentials; Conference call slots were given to clarify on legal matters and again on financials separately One meeting between each of the bidders and the Government nominated board on 3rd April Technical and Financial bids received on 13th April and highest bidder Tech Mahindra selected
Prime Ministers Appreciation :

Prime Ministers Appreciation
Factors that contribute to Fraud :

Factors that contribute to Fraud Greed-Ethical values given a go by Executive incentives Stock market expectations Nature of accounting rules Audit failures- Internal & External Aggressiveness of investment banks, commercial banks, Rating agencies & investors Weak Independent directors and Audit committee Whistle blower policy not being effective
How did Satyam scam happen? :

How did Satyam scam happen? Ambitious growth drive Audit failure- example., External confirmations of Bank balances not properly done Deceptive reporting practiceslack of transparency ESOPs issued to those who prepared fake bills Excessive interest in maintaining stock prices High risk deals that went sour Above all, greed and lack of ethical values.
ROAD AHEAD :
ROAD AHEAD
Corporate Lessons to be learnt :

Corporate Lessons to be learnt Rotation of audit firm vs rotation of audit partner Strengthening of Quality review (Peer review) Joint Auditors to audit companies beyond a size Internal audit of Financials by an external firm with undiminished scope Composition of Board and quality & qualification of Independent Directors
Corporate Lessons to be :
Corporate Lessons to be Audit Committee meetings-adequacy of notice and adequacy of duration Criteria for remuneration to Key Personnel Effective whistle blower policy in place Focus on Intangibles & Tangibles follow Education on Ethical values
Moral Lessons for recapitulation :

Moral Lessons for recapitulation Humility helps while Ego hurts Think of a Rainy day, always Distinguish between opportunities and temptations Build quality teams and enable succession Adapt with technology/knowledge changes but stay static on fundamentals Listen to your head in complying with law and to your heart in dealing with people
Moral Lessons for :

Moral Lessons for Many good things done get washed away in one bad conduct To live beyond your age - Love people and use wealth Ability may take you to the top but it takes Character to stay there Nothing is impossible, if attempted with nobility
Slide 30:
Thank you

Presentation Description: Financial Statement Fraud & Corporate Governancethe Satyam Case

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Presentation Description: Financial Statement Fraud & Corporate Governancethe Satyam Case

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Presentation Description: Financial Statement Fraud & Corporate Governancethe Satyam Case

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Presentation Description

Comments (0) Post a Comment Presentation Transcript

Satyam Case- Basic Facts :

Fraud is a Costly Proposition :

Impact of Fraud -Two Examples :

Fraud leads to Stock value crash :

Financial Statement Frauds :

Confession January 7th , 2009 :

Chairman Rajus Version :

Action after Confession :

Prioritized Plan of Action :

Two critical options :

Strategic Investor Selection :

Prime Ministers Appreciation :

Factors that contribute to Fraud :

How did Satyam scam happen? :

Corporate Lessons to be learnt :

Moral Lessons for recapitulation :

Moral Lessons for :

You might also like