Clinical Skills For Pharmacists-APatient-FocusedApproach3rdedition
Clinical Skills For Pharmacists-APatient-FocusedApproach3rdedition
Clinical Skills For Pharmacists-APatient-FocusedApproach3rdedition
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
• D efine pharmaceutical care and identify the four • S tate the eligibility requirements for pharmacist board
outcomes that improve a patient’s quality of life. certification and identify the areas for which board
• Define medication therapy management. certification is available.
• List the three goals and five core elements of • Define residency and fellowship and differentiate them
medication therapy management. with regard to length of training and mechanisms for
• List the knowledge and skills needed for patient- credentialing.
focused pharmacy practice. • Identify and differentiate among the various types of
• State the requirements for pharmacy state licensure health care settings and environments.
and relicensure. • Define health maintenance organization, point-of-
• Differentiate between pharmacist board certification, service plans, and preferred provider organizations.
pharmacist-specific disease-specific credentialing, • State the purpose of the medical team and identify the
multidisciplinary disease-specific credentialing, and roles and responsibilities of each team member.
pharmacy certificate programs in terms of eligibility and • Identify and describe unresolved health care system
requirements. issues.
1
2 Clinical Skills for Pharmacists: A Patient-Focused Approach
multidisciplinary certification programs (Table 1-2). program. Certificate programs are voluntary and do not
Requirements are different for each program. For exam- require any additional training or experience beyond
ple, the 2010 requirements for application for the Certi- that required for pharmacy licensure. ACPE certificate
fied Diabetic Educator (CDE) program include a minimum programs provide at least 15 hours of programming that
of 2 years of professional practice, completion of a mini- must include practice experiences to demonstrate the
mum of 1000 hours of diabetes self-management edu- given professional competency. Participants are evalu-
cation (DSME), completion of a minimum of 15 hours ated by a summative evaluation process. Completion of
of relevant continuing education activities within the 2 a certificate program provides evidence of achievement
years prior to application, and status as either a licensed of professional competencies beyond those required for
clinical psychologist, registered nurse, occupational ther- pharmacy licensure.
apist, optometrist, pharmacist, physical therapist, physi- Postlicensure residency and fellowship training pro-
cian (MD or DO), or podiatrist, or as a registered dietitian, grams. Pharmacy graduates obtain additional experi-
physician assistant, exercise physiologist, or other health ence, knowledge, and skills by completing a variety of
care professional with a minimum of a master’s degree.7 residency and fellowship postgraduate training certifi-
Certificate programs. In 2000, the ACPE assumed cate programs. Most residency and fellowship programs
responsibility for voluntary pharmacy certificate pro- require candidates to have either entry-level or postbac-
grams based on specific professional competencies (Phar- calaureate doctor of pharmacy degrees. The American
macy-Based Immunization Delivery, Pharmaceutical Society of Health-System Pharmacists (ASHP) publishes
Care for Patients with Diabetes, Pharmacy-Based Lipid a directory of ASHP-accredited residency programs. The
Management, OTC Advisor: Advancing Patient Self- American College of Clinical Pharmacy (ACCP) publishes
Care, and Delivering Medication Therapy Management a directory of residency and fellowship programs offered
Services in the Community). Pharmacists who success- by members of the ACCP. The APhA provides a searchable
fully complete a postgraduate certificate program receive on-line community pharmacy residency locator directory.
a certificate documenting successful completion of the A residency is defined as an “organized, directed, post-
graduate training program in a defined area of pharmacy
practice”8 (Table 1-3). Residencies provide pharmacists
Box 1-3 Portfolio Requirements for Added with 1 to 2 years of supervised experience in practice
Qualifications in Cardiology and management activities. Postgraduate year 1 (PGY-
1) residency programs train generalists; postgraduate
Letter requesting portfolio review
year 2 (PGY-2) residency programs train pharmacists in
Detailed summary of each of the following elements:
a specialty patient care area. Residents generally gain
Specific and current professional responsibilities
experience by providing a variety of inpatient and out-
Bibliography of professional publications
patient pharmacy services under the supervision of
Past (within last 7 years) and present research and other
one or more preceptors. Most residencies are based in
scholarly activities
hospitals; however, increased interest in community
Past (within last 7 years) and current activities in
pharmacy and ambulatory care residencies has resulted
didactic or clerkship, residency, or fellowship
in the creation of an increasing number of community
education of health care professionals in
pharmacy and ambulatory care residency programs. The
cardiovascular pharmacotherapy
ASHP accredits residency programs, but there are many
Current memberships in professional organization
nonaccredited residency programs.
related to cardiology
A fellowship is a highly individualized program
Special or unique training or professional development
designed to prepare the pharmacist to become an inde-
programs
pendent researcher.8 Fellows spend approximately 80%
Professional awards, honors, or special achievements
of their time in research-related activities. Currently no
related to cardiovascular pharmacotherapy
mechanism for accreditation of fellowship programs is
Current curriculum vitae
available. However, the ACCP Fellowship Review Com-
From Board of Pharmacy Specialties: Current Specialties. Available at: http:// mittee conducts a voluntary peer review of fellowship
www.bpsweb.org/specialties/specialties.cfm. Accessed October 12, 2009. programs. As of 2009, 17 fellowship programs were
ACCP, American College of Clinical Pharmacy; ACPE, American Council on Pharmaceutical Education; ASHP, American Society of Health-System Pharmacists.
*ASHP-accredited PGY-2 residency areas include ambulatory care, cardiology, critical care, drug information, emergency medicine, geriatrics, health systems
pharmacy administration, infectious diseases, human immunodeficiency virus, informatics, internal medicine, managed care pharmacy systems, medica-
tion use safety, nuclear pharmacy, nutrition support, oncology, pain and palliative care, pediatrics, pharmacotherapy, psychiatry, and solid organ transplant.
†ACCP-recognized fellowship programs include those with the following areas of emphasis: ambulatory care, cardiology, clinical pharmacology, critical care,
drug metabolism, infectious disease, oncology, pediatrics, pharmacodynamics, pharmacoeconomics, pharmacoepidemiology, and pharmacokinetics.
Defined by the Association of American Medical Colleges Box 1-5 Allied Health Care Professionals
as “a concept or model of care delivery that includes an
ongoing relationship between a provider and patient, Anesthesiologist assistant
around-the-clock access to medical consultation, respect Anesthesia technologist/technician
for a patient’s cultural and religious beliefs, and a com- Athletic trainer
prehensive approach to care and coordination of care Cardiovascular technologist
through providers and community services,”9 the medi- Electroneurodiagnostic technologist
cal home concept is of increasing interest to patients and Emergency medical technician/paramedic
health care professionals. Exercise scientist
Clinics, often affiliated with major medical centers Kinesiotherapist
and hospitals, are located in a variety of outpatient set- Medical assistant
tings, including community centers, medical offices, Medical illustrator
community pharmacies, and freestanding clinics. Clin- Occupational therapist
ics serve general unrestricted patient populations or Orthotist and prothetist
very specific patient groups (e.g., hypertension clinic, Perfusionist
diabetes clinic, anticoagulation clinic, medication refill Polysomnographic technologist
clinic). Several clinics may share the same physical Respiratory therapist
space; in this situation the schedule is set to allow each Surgical assistant
clinic to have a unique weekly or daily schedule (e.g., Surgical technologist
anticoagulation clinic on Tuesday afternoons, diabetes From Careers in Health Care. Available at: http://ama-assn.org/ama/pub/
clinic on Wednesday mornings, hypertension clinic on education-careers/careers-health-care/directory.shtml. Accessed October
Friday mornings). 21, 2009.
Hospitals are identified as public, private, or federal
hospitals, depending on the funding source. Public hospi-
tals are publicly funded and provide heath care services to Physicians are licensed by individual states and cre-
all patients, regardless of the patient’s type of insurance or dentialed by national examination. A physician must
ability to pay for the health care services. Some cities and graduate from an accredited medical school, receive pass-
states pay for public hospital services from tax revenues. ing grades on the medical licensure examination, and
Private hospitals are privately funded institutions whose complete 1 year of an accredited residency program to
services are generally not available, except for emergency become licensed to practice medicine. The United States
care, to patients who are not part of the private group. The Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) consists of four
federal government funds federal hospitals. The Veterans examinations taken sequentially starting during medi-
Administration hospital system is an extensive nation- cal school and finishing after completion of the medical
wide system of hospitals, clinics, and nursing homes degree (Table 1-5).11 Relicensure requires successful com-
funded by the federal government to provide health care pletion of the number of continuing medical education
services to American armed forces veterans. (CME) credits specified by the state in which the physi-
Hospitals, regardless of the funding source, may be cian practices. Most physicians complete 1 year or more
affiliated with medical schools. These hospitals, known of supervised experience in residency programs; some
as teaching hospitals, provide training sites for physicians complete additional training in highly specialized fel-
and other health care professionals. Community-based, lowship programs. The length of the residency program
nonteaching hospitals are sometimes called community depends on the specialty or subspecialty. Internal medi-
hospitals. Some hospitals, recognized for their highly spe- cine residencies are typically 3 years in duration; surgical
cialized services (e.g., pediatrics, oncology, cardiology) residencies may be 5 to 7 years.
and large referral patient populations, are known as ter- Board certification is a voluntary but increasingly
tiary hospitals. important credential for physicians. Many health care
plans require board certification for inclusion in member
HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS networks; many hospitals require board certification for
admitting privileges. Approximately 87% of physicians are
The American Medical Association recognizes more than board certified.12 There are 26 approved medical board spe-
80 health care–related careers, including physician, phar- cialties. The American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS),
macist, nurse, and allied health professional.10 Allied a group of 24 member boards, certifies more than 145 physi-
health care professionals, also known as paramedicals, cian specialties and subspecialties (Box 1-6).13 For example,
provide health care services and perform tasks under the there are 21 internal medicine subspecialties (Box 1-7).14
direction of physicians (Box 1-5). Board certification is a comprehensive process involving
peer evaluation, specific educational requirements, and
Physicians examination. Maintenance of certification (MOC; recerti-
Physicians, doctors who have medical or osteopathic fication) is required and occurs at 6- to 10-year intervals
degrees, are generally considered the health care team depending on the specific specialty. MOC requires an active
leaders. Allopathic physicians rely on standard treat- and unrestricted license in the state in which the physician
ment modalities; osteopathic physicians use the addi- practices, periodic self-evaluation of knowledge (continu-
tional technique of spine and joint manipulation to treat ing education), assessment of knowledge by examination,
disease. and assessment of practice performance.12
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Practice of Clinical Pharmacy 7
From United States Medical Licensing Examination. Available at: http://www.usmle.org. Accessed October 22, 2009.
Box 1-6 American Board of Medical Specialties Box 1-7 American Board of Internal Medicine
Member Boards Specialties
Allergy and Immunology Internal Medicine
Anesthesiology Adolescent Medicine
Colon and Rectal Surgery Advanced Heart Failure and Transplant Cardiology
Dermatology Allergy and Immunology
Emergency Medicine Cardiovascular Disease
Family Medicine Clinical Cardiac Electrophysiology
Internal Medicine Critical Care Medicine
Medical Genetics Endocrinology, Diabetes, and Metabolism
Neurological Surgery Gastroenterology
Nuclear Medicine Geriatric Medicine
Obstetrics and Gynecology Hematology
Ophthalmology Hospice and Palliative Medicine
Orthopaedic Surgery Infectious Disease
Otolaryngology Interventional Cardiology
Pathology Medical Oncology
Pediatrics Nephrology
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Pulmonary Disease
Plastic Surgery Rheumatology
Preventive Medicine Sleep Medicine
Psychiatry and Neurology Sports Medicine
Radiology Transplant Hepatology
Surgery
From Details about Each Exam by Specialty. Available at: http://www.abim.
Thoracic Surgery
org/exam/exams.aspx. Accessed October 22, 2009.
Urology
other health care professionals. NPs typically have unlim- pharmacy preceptor. Autonomy and the ability to pro-
ited prescriptive authority. spectively influence the health care team gradually
develop with experience. Although the types of experi-
Physician Assistants ences students have vary with the patient care environ-
The American Academy of Physician Assistants (AAPA) ment, the professional responsibilities remain the same.
defines physician assistants (PAs) as “health care profession-
als licensed, or in the case of those employed by the federal THE MEDICAL TEAM
government they are credentialed, to practice medicine
with physician supervision.”16 PAs perform many routine Teaching hospitals are the primary training sites for most
tasks (patient interviews, patient examinations), order and health care professionals. Health care services in teaching
interpret laboratory and diagnostic tests, treat minor ill- hospitals are structured around medical teaching teams
ness, counsel patients, and provide patient education. PAs composed of physicians, medical students, and, depend-
can prescribe medications in many states. PAs may have ing on the hospital, other health care professionals (Box
certificates, associate degrees, or master’s degrees. Most 1-8). Medical teams, organized to provide a structured
states require graduates of accredited programs to pass training environment, are responsible for the care of
certifying examinations. Those who pass the examination patients located in assigned areas of the hospital (e.g., the
may use the designation “Physician Assistant–Certified cardiology unit) or patients located throughout the hospi-
(PA-C).” Continuing licensure is contingent on comple- tal (e.g., patients with infectious disease or renal disease).
tion of continuing education requirements; recertification The team may provide consultative services in a medical
examinations must be passed periodically. subspecialty (e.g., dermatology) or be identified with a
specific physician group practice. The medical team func-
THE HEALTH CARE TEAM tions as a unit, with the division of labor and the responsi-
bility of each member determined according to the status
The health care team consists of all health care profes- of each individual. The team is structured so that each
sionals who have responsibility for patient care plus the team member receives guidance from a more experienced
patient (Figure 1-4). Although all members of the health health care professional. The team is the focus for group
care team interact directly with the patient, they rarely teaching and decision-making discussions. Most trainees
meet as a group; instead, information and recommen- spend about 4 weeks with a specific team. Physician team
dations are exchanged through written documentation. members include, in order of seniority, the attending
Verbal information exchange and recommendations physician, fellows, residents, and medical students.
occur on a less formal basis.
All members of the health care team contribute their Attending Physician
profession’s unique knowledge and skills. Pharmacists, The attending physician is the senior physician on the
the “drug experts” on the team, help teams develop, medical team. The attending physician assumes respon-
implement, and monitor the therapeutic regimen and sibility for all patients assigned to the team and provides
provide drug information and education services to the guidance and direction to team members. During team
patient and team. rounds, the attending physician leads the team through
Students have a unique role on the health care team. the decision-making process, helps the team make deci-
Students represent their profession and are expected to sions regarding patient care, and evaluates the perfor-
carry out their professional responsibilities under the mance of individual team members. Patient presentations
direct supervision of licensed professionals. For exam- may take place in a conference room, in the hallway out-
ple, pharmacy students are expected to provide patient- side of the patient’s room, or in the patient’s room. The
focused care under the direct supervision of a licensed
Box 1-8 Medical Team Composition in Teaching
Hospitals
Table 1-7 Public Health Policy Development Each team identifies a leader and a “latecomer.” Give
the “latecomer” a few pieces of the puzzle and have him
Date Issue or her go to another room or another area of the room
away from the team. Show each team leader the pic-
1930s-1940s Limited support for special patient
ture of the puzzle but do not give the leader the picture.
populations
Give the leader the rest of the puzzle pieces. Tell the
1940s-1950s Support for research, facilities, team leader that this is a competition between teams to
and training see which team can assemble its puzzle first. Give the
1960s Broadened health care coverage teams about 20 minutes to assemble the puzzles. Send
1970s Infrastructure support the “latecomers” back to their teams after 15 minutes.
1980s-1990s Cost, quality, and outcomes After the puzzles are assembled, discuss the following
2000s Health care reform
questions.
• Describe the team leader’s leadership style. Was the
Adapted from Kissick WL: The evolution of American health policy. Trans leadership style effective for this group and this
Stud Coll Phys Phila 11:187-200, 1989. task?
• How well did the team work together? Did everyone
the prevailing attitude of the time was that individuals, contribute? Would you change the group dynamics if
not society, should pay for health care. Health care pro- you had another task to accomplish?
fessionals and institutions were free to charge “custom- • How did the “latecomer” feel when he or she joined
ary, prevailing, and reasonable” fees for services; patients the team? Did the team welcome or ignore the
paid for private insurance or whatever they could afford “latecomer”?
to purchase if not covered by insurance. The health care • How did the team feel about being interrupted by the
system thus evolved to meet the needs of those who could “latecomer”?
afford to purchase expensive and inclusive services. Unfor-
tunately, this type of health care system excluded portions
of society. The federal government has had to gradually SELF-ASSESSMENT QUESTIONS
assume financial and regulatory control of larger portions
of the system.17 Public health policy evolved from a focus 1. Which one of the following is not an outcome
on limited support for special patient populations in the included in the definition of pharmaceutical
1930s and 1940s to interest in cost, quality, and outcomes care?
in the 1990s to health care reform in the 2000s (Table 1-7). a. Cure of disease
Many health care issues remain unresolved. The most b. Elimination or reduction of symptoms
pressing of these is how to decrease costs while maintain- c. Arrest or slowing of disease processes
ing high-quality health care. Inequities in the health care d. Prevention of disease or symptoms
system are significant; approximately 15.4% of the U.S. e. Reduction of health care costs
population did not have health insurance coverage in 2. Skills required for patient-centered pharmacy prac-
2008.18 People with preexisting medical conditions rou- tice include which of the following?
tinely are denied health insurance. The number of unoc- a. Therapeutic planning and monitoring skills
cupied hospital beds is large, which increases competition b. Physical assessment skills
in the provision of traditional and new hospital services. c. Communication skills
Regional oversupply and undersupply of physicians and d. All of the above
other health care professionals exists. The cost of medi- e. None of the above
cal malpractice to both the physician and the health 3. Which of the following is(are) core elements of MTM?
care system is high. Defensive medicine accounts for an I. Provide a comprehensive or targeted medication
estimated 15% of the total U.S. expenditures for physi- therapy review
cian services. The historic health care reform bill signed II. Complete and update the patient’s personal
into law by President Obama in March 2010 begins to medication record
address many of these issues, but until its provisions are III. Develop a medication-related patient-directed
fully implemented, the impact and cost of reform remain action plan
unknown. In addition, the roles of pharmacists, nurses, a. I only
and PAs are still evolving, and many questions regard- b. III only
ing authority and responsibility for patient care remain c. I and II only
unanswered. d. II and III only
e. I, II, and III
4. Which of the following is a voluntary certificate pro-
APPLICATION ACTIVITY gram just for pharmacists?
a. Pharmacy-Based Immunization Delivery
b. Certified Diabetic Educator
Activity 1-1 c. Certified Asthma Educator
The goal of this activity is to explore group dynamics as a d. Added Qualifications in Infectious Disease
team assembles a 100-piece jigsaw puzzle. This activity is Pharmacotherapy
best performed in small groups (five or six people). e. Clinical Lipid Specialist
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Practice of Clinical Pharmacy 13