2023 - Top 50 - Industry - Report
2023 - Top 50 - Industry - Report
2023 - Top 50 - Industry - Report
2023
SECURITY 50 INDUSTRY
REPORT:
AN INDUSTRY RESHUFFLING
IN THE CARDS?
Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1
Securing Asia in 2023: A deep dive into the region's security market
developments 14
China, meanwhile, registered a 2022 GDP growth of 5.1 percent, down from 9 percent for 2021, due to
challenges on several fronts. Domestically, China issued lockdowns in different cities throughout 2022,
in response to a rise in COVID cases. Then, there is China’s ongoing real estate crisis – the Chinese
government’s effort to regulate the debt limits of major Chinese developers, like the Evergrande Group,
had caused the country’s real estate market to tumble. External factors also played a role. Geopolitical
tensions between the U.S. and China had prompted the U.S. to place severe trade barriers and
restrictions against China.
Impact on security
So how did these factors play out in security last year? Upon first look, they brought little change to this
year’s Security 50. The top 10 global security manufacturers in access control and video surveillance in
our 2023 Security 50 ranking are Hikvision Digital Technology, Dahua Technology, ASSA ABLOY, Axis
Communications, Motorola Solutions, Allegion, Tiandy, Hanwha Vision (formerly Hanwha Techwin),
Uniview Technologies and Aiphone. Hikvision and Dahua remain the world’s largest security companies,
with 2022 security product/equipment sales reaching US$9.8 billion and $4.5 billion, respectively (based
on the IRS’s 2022 average currency exchange rates). There were several new entrants including China-
based smart home solutions provider MEARI and Korean biometric solution provider Union Community.
Yet a surprising part of this year’s Security 50 was the growth list. Of the 17 companies that registered
2022-2021 revenue declines, 12 were Chinese companies. While China companies’ revenue declines
were somewhat expected given the environment, the number of companies that inked sales declines,
and the magnitude of these declines (by as much as 40.2 percent), still caught us off guard.
Indeed, China’s internal and external challenges mentioned earlier – lockdowns, real estate crisis and
tensions with the U.S. – all played a part. “Chinese government spending was diverted away from other
areas, including spending on video surveillance, and towards battling COVID-19 and supporting its
economy during these lockdowns. Restrictions lasted much longer than many observers had anticipated,
with the Chinese government finally easing its ‘zero Covid’ policy in December 2022,” said Jon Cropley,
Principal Analyst, and Josh Woodhouse, Founder of Novaira Insights.
2
At the same time, U.S.-China tensions, which led to
legislation like the National Defense Authorization
Act (NDAA) that bans the US government from
purchasing video surveillance equipment by
Hikvision and Dahua, had caused Western and non-
China brands to register a proportional growth in
their 2022 revenue. These include VIVOTEK, with a
sales increase of 82.48 percent; Hanwha Vision,
47.52 percent; Axis, 36.01 percent; Milestone
Systems, 30.43 percent; and IDIS, 22.17 percent. It
should be noted that many of the U.S.’s Western
allies, for example U.K., have also enacted NDAA-
like legislation.
“The shift away from Chinese vendors continued at pace not just in the U.S., but across Northern Europe
and countries in Asia including Japan and South Korea. In part, many organizations and systems
integrators want to standardize on NDAA-compliant equipment to ensure existing and future business in
the U.S., while end users are expressing concerns around looming regulations in the EU and Asia,
cybersecurity weaknesses, and the potential for reputational damage connected to human rights abuses
committed by some of the banned Chinese manufacturers,” said Jamie Barnfield, Senior Sales Director
at IDIS Europe.
As for this year, Chinese companies are expected to fare better, even though they are not completely
out of the woods yet. “The Chinese market is forecast to recover slightly in 2023 but remain well below
its peak in 2021. Growth in demand will be much lower than in the years before the pandemic. At the
same time, a weakening exchange rate between the Chinese yuan and US dollar will also dampen growth
(when measured in US dollars),” Cropley and Woodhouse said.
3
Industry experts agree with that notion.
“We observed some economic growth and expansion in 2023, although it has been unevenly distributed
across different regions and sectors. This has had a mixed impact on the security industry,” said Choong
Hoon Ha, Chief Sales and Marketing Officer at Hanwha Vision. “Despite the mixed economic impact, the
security demands from society and individuals are still rising with the growing need for advanced
network-based systems, such as intelligent surveillance cameras. Businesses are willing to invest in
security solutions that protect their employees and assets, and even improve business efficiency and
productivity by providing business insight.”
“Long-term, sustainable growth is at the heart of our business planning. We plan for 15 percent growth
per year on average. And while the market itself is forecast to grow, Axis is again set to outpace it. We’ll
achieve this by continuing to broaden our portfolio into new areas, such as intercoms, access control,
audio solutions, and so on,” said Ray Mauritsson, CEO of Axis Communications.
“Artificial intelligence will continue to provide opportunities for innovation across the industry.
Application of AI to data streams from sensor fusion – combining and interpreting inputs from cameras
and other sensory devices – will shift security solutions towards proactive capabilities that drive new
value. AI’s influence is still in the transformational stage, for certain, but the applicability to the security
industry is strong and clear,” said Vince Wenos, Senior VP and CTO of Allegion.
“This year, we have witnessed a growing demand from customers to maximize the capabilities of their
cameras and sensors, with a strong emphasis on analytics. The industry continues to embrace the
dominant trend of edge analytics, with an increasing number of camera manufacturers expanding their
support for this technology,” said William Hinton, Product Line Manager for Video at Genetec.
According to Choong, customers are seeking technologies that can help them improve the accuracy of
detection, make their video surveillance systems more scalable and cost-effective, and take benefits
from video analysis.
“In other words, they’re looking for surveillance technology powered by AI and cloud,” Choong said.
“Many customers are still in the early stages of adopting AI and cloud-based video surveillance solutions.
However, the adoption of these technologies is expected to accelerate in the coming years, as
customers see the benefits that they can offer.”
Mobile credentials, meanwhile, have also emerged as a top trend in 2023. “Electronics continue to fuel
significant growth for the industry across both hardware and solutions providers. Increasing adoption of
mobile credentials and associated readers is providing healthy lift,” Wenos said. “Mobile credentials
continue to gain interest from customers, as they provide greater value to end users and system
operators.”
Digital wallets, an offshoot of mobile access, are also gaining traction. “We’re seeing a lot of interest in
digital wallets in large, tech-savvy office buildings. The first European rollout of employee badge in Apple
4
Wallet was at London’s 22 Bishopsgate, touted as the world’s smartest building. 14,000 mobile users at
22 Bishopsgate can now use just their iPhone or Apple Watch to access their offices, plus all the
building’s amenities,” said Prabhu Patel, Commercial Director for Physical Access Control Solutions,
ASEAN and India, at HID.
Cybersecurity continues to be a hot topic now that more and more devices are online. “For several years
we’ve witnessed a growing focus on the cybersecurity of solutions. Customers are aware the risks are
rising, demanding robust processes, vigilance and transparency. When vulnerabilities do occur, vendor
transparency is essential, allowing customers to respond as quickly as possible,” Mauritsson said.
Flexible payment
This year, we’re seeing at least two companies offering flexible payment options. These are i-PRO, who
announced their FlexPay Financing, and Eagle Eye Networks, who launched their Eagle Eye Camera
Direct Complete. The programs aim to help customers achieve more payment flexibility, reduce initial
investment and become more competitive in general.
“In some organizations an increasing amount of security ops fall under the IT department’s responsibility,
and they may have a preference for a greater amount of OPEX compared with the security industry’s
typical preference for capital expenditure purchases,” Cropley and Woodhouse said. “This type of
transition is indicative of a cloud business model transition. However, only the video surveillance vendors
themselves know whether the motive behind this is related specifically to products from specific
competitors.”
Yet according to Cropley and Woodhouse, there are advantages to scale of operation. “Each surveillance
scenario is unique. Variables include the size of installation, whether it is indoors or outdoors, and lighting
and weather conditions. At the same time, the channel varies considerably by geographic location with a
different set of distributors, systems integrators and installers serving its needs. Large vendors have a
range of solutions to meet all scenarios and have the resources to serve different channels in a wide
range of geographies,” they said.
5
Memoori report:
Prevailing physical security
trends in 2023
The physical security market is undergoing a significant
transformation, influenced by a host of factors from
technological advancements to geopolitical shifts. In this
article, drawn from Memoori's latest research into both
the Video Surveillance and Access control markets, we
will explore just a few of the key trends and challenges
our research indicates will be the most influential in
shaping the industry over the coming years.
The AI imperative
The integration of advanced Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning into video surveillance is
reaching unprecedented levels of maturity. Key drivers of this trend include:
Practical Implementations: Earlier discussions on AI in surveillance have moved from theoretical to
practical, with more real-world applications coming to the fore.
Sophisticated Analytics: The analytics capabilities have grown increasingly refined and reliable,
reducing false alarms and allowing for more nuanced and actionable insights.
Cost Decline: The falling costs of implementing AI and Machine Learning are making these
technologies accessible to a broader range of applications.
Availability of Edge-Based Analytics: There's a widespread rollout of edge-based analytics, based
on dedicated AI chip System on Chip architectures that offers the ability to process data closer to its
source, alleviating network bandwidth constraints and helping end-users to minimize the risk of
transferring or processing privacy related data.
We forecast that by 2028, the percentage of network security cameras with onboard AI capabilities is
projected to rise from today's 18% to over 50%. These advancements are fuelling new features like
6
object recognition, behavior analysis, and other forms of intelligent monitoring.
However, the growth in AI capabilities comes with its own set of challenges. Infrastructure issues such as
bandwidth limitations, latency, and cyber protections can impede the full utilization of AI-enhanced
cameras. Moreover, the lack of standardized data practices and testing methodology further
complicates the landscape. These challenges necessitate responsible and transparent implementation
of AI technologies.
As data volumes and the demand for analytics rise, we expect the market for Video Management
Software (VMS) & analytics to significantly outpace growth in the wider market, here, we are forecasting
growth at an 8.4% CAGR from 2022-2028. Here, the progressive transition to cloud-based analytics
driven by requirements to amplifying the power of video analytics by leveraging centralized computing
resources is set to continue.
Geopolitical tensions and shifting trade barriers have progressively transformed the global landscape of
video surveillance market over the past five years. While initial moves by the US government imposed
relatively minor tariffs and limited sales to particular US government agencies, more recently blanket
U.S. bans on the sale of equipment in the US by Chinese market giants Hikvision and Dahua enacted
under the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), have much more profound impact. These
progressively more stringent restrictions have significantly disrupted supply chains, forcing a
recalibration of power dynamics, and generated growth opportunities for Western, Korean and Japanese
manufacturers such as Axis, Hanwha Vision, IDIS, Secom. These players and others have developed new
strategies and supply chain relationships that seek to fill any voids left by the withdrawal of Hikvision &
Dahua from US markets.
7
For several of these companies, the is already having a major impact on their fortunes. For example
Hanwha Vision reporting 86% sales growth in the Americas from 2021 to 2022, capitalizing on its NDAA-
compliant status, while IDIS saw overseas revenue jump from $50m to over $80m after the NDAA ban.
US manufacturers are increasingly plugging their “Made in the USA” credentials, while Western
manufactures such as Axis Communications are leveraging their NDAA-compliant status to help boost
sales in North American markets. Several are also touting their stringent data security policies and
practices to further reinforce their market positioning for end users that are increasingly cognisant of
cybersecurity and ethics related issues.
Other notable Chinese surveillance companies including Tiandy Technologies, Infinova, TVT Digital
Technology, and Raysharp witnessed revenue declines between 3% and 40% in 2022 compared to 2021.
While much of this decline might be attributed to the adverse impact of COVID-induced lockdowns in
China, and overall slowdown in the Chinese economy over the period, the trade restrictions have also
undoubtedly been a contributing factor. While they’ve not been as directly impacted as Hikvision &
Dahua, these other Chinese manufactures will be nervously looking on from the sidelines, at the further
adverse impact that potential equivalent restrictions on their US operations could have, moves which are
being advocated for in some quarters.
The political impetus and related media exposure generated by the scale of US regulatory moves is also
having ripple effects beyond the US, for example influencing several major UK retailers to announce
plans to drop Hikvision and Dahua cameras due to ethical concerns, as well as ongoing legislative moves
to restrict usage of the companies’ devices in various public sector bodies in several territories across
Europe and beyond.
This evolving regulatory landscape will require firms to maintain agility, adapting their strategies to
navigate a shifting patchwork of trade barriers and regulations that are emerging in different regions.
Here, the underlying supply chain and security dynamics are similar, geopolitical uncertainties are having
a much more muted impact. Biometrics adoption has been somewhat stalled due to behavioral and
attitude changes resulting from COVID, but we see the primary driver for growth being the progressive
shift to mobile-based access control.
From a user standpoint, the allure of mobile access control lies in its convenience, enhanced security
features, and the flexibility it offers for system administration. Major manufacturers in the access control
space, including HID Global, Brivo, and WaveLynx, have been quick to recognize this shift, announcing
integrations with Apple Wallet and Google Wallet over the past year to capitalize on the momentum.
Customers, too, are taking note. According to a recent survey on access control trends, 42% of
respondents worldwide now have plans in place upgrade to mobile-ready systems. Our preliminary data
8
sentiment, projecting that by the end of 2023, mobile-based systems could constitute around 20% of all
newly issued access control credentials for non-residential buildings.
While the transition to mobile-based systems is underway, it isn't without its own challenges. Privacy and
cybersecurity remain as key concerns amongst many end users, particularly in cases where personal
devices are proposed as the primary means of access control. For this reasons, some organizations
remain reticent to back the shift, still preferring the use of physical cards to mitigate the risks associated
with personal data exposure on mobile devices.
Infrastructure is another consideration. The shift to mobile-based systems often necessitates upgrades
to existing hardware, such as the incorporation of Bluetooth or NFC readers, adding an extra layer of
complexity and cost to the transition.
Additionally, some vendors have expressed concerns over the complexity of Apple's process for wallet
integration, citing it as cumbersome and potentially slowing down the pace of adoption. It's also worth
noting that Apple Wallet incurs additional credential fees, which could be a factor for organizations
considering the switch.
Despite these challenges, the trend toward mobile-based access control is unmistakable and shows little
sign of abating. As manufacturers continue to innovate and as customers become increasingly aware of
the advantages, we can anticipate this segment to carve out a significant share of the access control
market in the coming years.
One of the key enablers in this transformation is improving standardisation of security data and its
metadata. Providing more contextually rich data is needed to inform more intelligent decision-making
across these previously siloed systems, and can be invaluable when integrated into a broader security or
building management system, enabling more nuanced and responsive actions like selective door locking
or lighting adjustments based on occupancy, or scheduling elevator movements to match patterns of
people movement within a building, saving energy and enhancing building user experiences.
While the promise of integration is compelling, successful delivery is not always straightforward.
Appropriately skilled systems integrators, endowed with the cross-domain knowledge across IT and OT
technologies, video systems access control and even building protocols like BACnet will be essential for
implementing complex unified security and BIoT solutions.
Legacy systems, proprietary protocols, and the absence of standardized data formats will also continue
9
to act as common roadblocks to integration until such systems are progressively phased out.
As the industry moves toward more standardized solutions, and cross functional expertise grows, we can
expect deeper, more seamless integrations to become the norm rather than the exception.
Looking forward
The physical security market clearly remains in a state of flux, influenced by technological
advancements, geopolitical shifts, and an increasing focus on integration and ethics. Companies that can
adapt to these changes, innovate, and offer intelligent, integrated solutions are likely to thrive. But this is
not a market for the complacent; staying ahead will require constant innovation, ethical considerations,
and perhaps most crucially, the ability to adapt to ever-changing conditions.
Other trends which merit consideration and are explored in our reporting include shifts towards multi-
sensor in both video surveillance and access control for multi-factor authentication, ongoing skills
shortages (especially those with expertise in cross-sectoral applications and artificial intelligence),
increased focus on environmental sustainability, and the ever-present influence of cybersecurity risk on
products, regulations, policies and end user priorities. These factors are not just affecting the cost
structures and policies but are being taken more seriously across the board, influencing both supply and
demand dynamics.
Ongoing market success will hinge on continual innovation, ethical vigilance, and a nimble approach to
the ever-changing landscape. Firms that keep their finger on the pulse of these multiple factors, and
remain open to new ideas and pragmatic investments, will be better positioned to dominate in this
evolving market.
10
2023 Tech Trends Maturity
and Suitability Index Survey
The “2023 Tech Trends Maturity and Suitability Index
Survey," sponsored by ZKTeco, garnered responses
from 633 channel players offering validated insights into
the technologies significantly impacting the video
surveillance and access control industry. This year's
survey includes a closer look at biometrics, with insights
on industry and emerging trends from key market
players and a comprehensive analysis of the survey
results. The full survey results and discussion can be
found here.
11
drones) and radar/LiDAR, the latter of which are companion detection technologies to video surveillance,
being able to detect objects in inclement conditions. LiFi or light fidelity is becoming mature yet is still
deemed unsuitable as a transmission solution.
Access control
Mature and suitable: Touchless biometrics (7) and
building/property management integration (8); Mature
but not as suitable: Unimodal biometrics (1), touch
biometrics (2), wireless locks (3), cloud access control
(4) and digital twins (5); Not as mature nor suitable:
Multimodal biometrics (6)
Access control
Mature and suitable: Mobile apps for video surveillance
(7), lowlight color cameras (6), 4K resolution (5), cloud
video surveillance (4) and bi-spectral camera (3); Not so
mature nor suitable: 8K resolution (1) and tri-spectral
camera (2)
12
Featured articles
2023 video surveillance tech trend survey: AI
dominance continues
In this year’s asmag.com video surveillance technology
survey, sponsored by ZKTeco, lowlight color cameras, 4K
and bi-spectral solutions all ranked high in both market
suitability and technical maturity, while AI continues to
gain traction as a solution that fulfills users’ security and
operational needs. This article takes a closer look at the
results.
To read the full article, click the link
below or scan the barcode:
https://www.asmag.com/showpost/33
827.aspx
13
Securing Asia in 2023:
A deep dive into the region's
security market developments
The Asian security market has witnessed significant
growth and transformation in the years 2022-23, driven
by technological advancements, government initiatives,
and evolving market demands. With the region's diverse
landscape, encompassing both developed and
developing economies, the security industry has had to
adapt and innovate to meet the unique needs of each
market.
From high-definition video surveillance systems to AI-powered analytics and facial recognition, the Asian
security market is now at the forefront of embracing cutting-edge technologies to ensure the safety and
security of its people, assets, and infrastructure.
This article delves into the current market conditions, key trends, and comments from some of the major
players shaping the Asian security market in 2022-23, providing a comprehensive overview of this
dynamic and rapidly evolving industry.
“We are experiencing double digit growth in physical security market, especially market acceptance of
new technologies i.e., biometric and AI-based face authentication and analytics is leading growth of the
market,” said Hanchul Kim, CEO of Suprema.
Vivianna Wang, GM of Marketing & Channel Development at Hikvision said that looking forward, in the
next five years, this landscape could be profoundly influenced by a few key trends.
“Digitization will spearhead this change, followed by the integration of innovative technologies like
artificial intelligence and IoT,” said Wang. “Additionally, we anticipate a more significant role for
sustainable and eco-friendly security solutions, adapting to global green and low-carbon initiatives.”
14
High-definition video surveillance
There is a growing demand for high-definition video surveillance systems, with a shift from 2MP to 5MP
resolution in IP cameras becoming the new norm. These systems provide clearer and more detailed
images, essential for effective monitoring and security.
“Currently, the market trend for IP cameras has shifted from 2MP to 5MP resolution, making it the
mainstream,” explained Alex Kuo, APAC regional business head at Vivotek. Hardware specifications
among various brands have also become quite similar. Therefore, product added value is crucial. This is
an important factor contributing to Vivotek's continuous growth in the Asia-Pacific region. For example,
through Vivotek's smart stream 3 feature, not only is image quality and resolution maintained at a high
level, but it also effectively conserves bandwidth. Additionally, the AI analysis and VCA capabilities allow
for quicker resolution of customer pain points, thereby enhancing operational efficiency.”
AI-powered functionality such as facial recognition and object detection has become increasingly
sophisticated and accurate with more companies able to justify adoption. AI technologies enable video
surveillance systems to not only capture and record footage but also analyze it in real-time, providing
operators with highly accurate alerts and enhancing the overall security capabilities. Metadata search
functions also speed up investigations from days to hours or even minutes, and Asian companies are
looking for the operational efficiencies AI can deliver.
“The same is true when it comes to business intelligence, particularly in retail where we’re seeing high-
demand for AI-powered and highly accurate people counting, heat maps, occupancy monitoring, and
queue management to boost profits with actionable insights,” Lee added. “There’s also a lot of demand
for high-definition and high-performance cameras supporting loss prevention strategies.”
15
“The physical security market is booming in Asia with many greenfield construction projects and
infrastructure investments happening, especially in the developing markets in Southeast Asia,” David
Thean, GM for Asia at Gallagher Security said. “As many of these developing economies in Asia expand,
demand for top tier security solutions is growing as well.”
Wang too pointed out that, considering the vast number of countries in Asia, there is some
differentiation.
“There’s a considerable surge in developing markets, like Southeast Asian region, showcasing great
potential and growth, while for some developed countries which are relatively saturated markets, gaining
modest growth,” Wang said.
“To date, IDIS India has upgraded close to 3,700 Railtel railway stations,” explained IDIS. “Hardware is
seamlessly monitored and managed by IDIS Solution Suite VMS with Railtel adopting service modules
including IDIS Critical Failover and IDIS Deep Learning Analytics as well as integration with third-party
facial recognition.”
Ahead of the Olympics in Tokyo, IDIS saw significant demand in Japan for surveillance upgrades
following a partnership agreement signed in 2019 with JVC to sell IDIS branded products across its
distribution network. It’s a winning strategy, particularly since Japan is known to prefer its own tech after
decades-long global prowess of its electronics brands.
“We’re more realistic in terms of the wider region and expecting a CAGR over the next five years of 10 to
15 percent,” IDIS said. “Yet Asia is dynamic with varying factors impacting the economic landscape in
each of our focus countries and core markets. Like many other parts of the world, we’re seeing sustained
demand for end-to-end solutions in the retail, banking, healthcare, hotels and hospitality, logistics, and
manufacturing sectors across the region.”
There are some common factors shaping each of these markets such as the rising need for enhanced
security and safety measures combined with a drive to increase operational efficiency. With increasing
incidents of crime, terrorism, and public safety concerns, governments and organizations are investing
heavily in high-definition video surveillance systems as well as analytics to monitor and protect their
facilities, people, and assets and address specific operational challenges. It’s a trend that is accelerating
as the demand for real-time monitoring and proactive security and safety measures grows.
“A significant trend is the need for high security to protect the growing infrastructures and modern
buildings in the region,” Thean added. “Cybersecurity requirements are also increasing for physical
16
security products, and smarter access controls – like facial recognition and iris scanners – and
contactless solutions such as mobile credentials are other trends in the region’s market. I’d also say
cloud solutions are gaining popularity.”
“Asia is dynamic with varying factors impacting the economic landscape in each of our focus countries
and core markets,” IDIS’ Lee said. “Like many other parts of the world, we’re seeing sustained demand for
end-to-end solutions in the retail, banking, healthcare, hotels and hospitality, logistics, and
manufacturing sectors across the region.”
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Asian security market has undergone significant transformation, adapting to the
evolving demands of a diverse landscape that encompasses both developed and developing economies.
The integration of cutting-edge technologies such as AI, edge computing, and high-definition video
surveillance has revolutionized the industry, providing more sophisticated and efficient security
solutions.
These advancements, coupled with government initiatives and investments in infrastructure, have
propelled the market to new heights. The increasing importance of cybersecurity in physical security
products, along with the adoption of contactless and biometric solutions, reflects the industry's
commitment to addressing the modern challenges of safety and security.
As the market continues to grow and evolve, we can expect to see further innovation and development
of comprehensive end-to-end solutions that cater to the specific needs of the Asian region, ultimately
leading to safer and more secure environments for all.
17
Featured articles
Security in North America 2023: Advanced tech
shaping the way forward
The 2023 North American physical security market is
dynamic and rapidly changing, reflecting the complex
and ever-changing threats organizations and individuals
face. Physical security, including surveillance cameras,
access control systems, security personnel, and barriers,
is more important than ever to protect assets, people,
and information. This article will examine the North
To read the full article, click the link
American physical security market in 2023, including its
below or scan the barcode:
https://www.asmag.com/showpost/33 key trends and future challenges and opportunities.
834.aspx
18