Bashige Et Al 2022 - Antityphoidal Plants in Lubumbashi
Bashige Et Al 2022 - Antityphoidal Plants in Lubumbashi
Bashige Et Al 2022 - Antityphoidal Plants in Lubumbashi
Publication history: Received on 14 September 2022; revised on 21 October 2022; accepted on 24 October 2022
Abstract
No documented study reports the ethnobotanical knowledge of the medicinal plants involved in the management of
typhoid fever in Lubumbashi. This study aims to identify plants and recipes used by traditional medicine practitioners
(TMPs) in Lubumbashi to manage typhoid fever. The cross-sectional descriptive survey was carried out on TMPs
through a direct interview, making it possible to collect ethnobotanical data. Fifty TMPs consulted (sex ratio M / F = 2.5,
age = 45 ± 11 years, experience: 20 ± 13 years) made it possible to list 57 plants. These taxa are mostly shrubs (52%),
Microphanerophytes (52%), endemic to tropical Africa (32%), belonging to 28 botanical families dominated by
Fabaceae and indicated in 47 other causes of consultation for which diarrhea comes first position. From these 57 plants
derived, 67 anti-typhoid recipes were administered orally. The stem bark was the most used part (33%), and the
decoction (72%) was the most common preparation method. This study reports for the first time the ethnobotanical
anti-typhoidal use of 25 species, among which Ficus sur Forssk. (0.22), and Monotes katangensis DeWild (0.18) has the
highest consensus indexes (CI) and Diplorhynchus condylocarpon (Müll.Arg.) Pichona (UVp = 0.19) followed by Albizia
antunesiana Harmsa (0.17), the highest usual values (UVp). TMPs use several plants in Lubumbashi to treat typhoid
fever. Some are specific to the ecological environment, and others are used in other regions of the continent.
Pharmacological studies are underway to assess the therapeutic efficacy of lesser-known plants among those listed.
Keywords: Typhoid fever; Medicinal plants; Traditional Medicine; Lubumbashi; Traditional medicine practitioners
(TMPs).
1. Introduction
Typhoid fever is a severe food poisoning caused by a gram-negative bacterium, Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica
serovar Typhi, present in water and food contaminated with faeces [1, 2]. The acute form of the pathology is
characterized by prolonged fever, headaches, fatigue, and digestive disorders, including nausea, constipation, or
diarrhea. Severe complications of typhoid fever occur in 10-15% of hospitalized patients, usually after 2-3 weeks of
illness, and can include life-threatening gastrointestinal bleeding, intestinal perforation, and encephalopathy [3, 4]. This
infectious pathology mainly occurs in developing countries where hygiene conditions are precarious [5, 6].
Every year, typhoid fever affects between 11 and 20.6 million people worldwide and causes more than 223, 000 deaths
[7]. In sub-Saharan Africa, typhoid fever is more than 100 per 100, 000 people per year, and the number of annual
deaths due to the disease is estimated at 33, 490 [6, 7]. Data on the prevalence of the disease at the national level are
not accessible. However, 40 to 60% of prevalences are reported in certain regions of the country, particularly in Kikwit
[5, 8] and Goma [9]. In Lubumbashi, indirect studies have reported prevalence estimated at 38.4%, n= 203 [10] and 62
%, n=510 [11].
In the past, chloramphenicol was used as the treatment of choice for typhoid fever. Still, as soon as multi-drug strains
resistant to chloramphenicol, ampicillin and co-trimoxazole appeared, fluoroquinolones (ciprofloxacin and ofloxacin)
became a more serious alternative. Although fluoroquinolones are superior to cephalosporins, the diffusion of strains
less sensitive to ciprofloxacin has limited their effectiveness, especially in Asia. Thus, extended-spectrum
cephalosporins (ceftriaxone and cefixime) and azithromycin remained suitable alternatives for S. Typhi less susceptible
to fluoroquinolones. Increasingly combinations of cephalosporin and azithromycin are used frequently to treat patients
who have not responded quickly [12]. Although there are models of anti-typhoid vaccines, which can strengthen the
axis of prevention, their effectiveness-accessibility-risk ratio significantly reduces their performance in the fight against
typhoid fever [13]. Despite all these alternatives for managing typhoid fever, the fact remains that cases of resistance in
the most affected countries are increasingly alarming, and the number of new cases is increasing.
In the absence of accessibility to the drug, as mentioned earlier, associated with low efficiency and socio-cultural habits,
80% of the population, which does not have access to primary health care or drinking water, is exposed to infectious
pathologies, especially typhoid fever, and resorts to traditional medicine. Some plants like Annona senegalensis Pers
(Annonaceae), Euphorbia hirta L. (Euphorbiaceae) or Piliostigma thonningii (Schumach.) Milne-Redh. (Fabaceae) are
claimed in traditional African medicine both in Nigeria [14] and Cameroon [15] in the treatment of typhoid fever and
have also shown efficacy against S. Typhi in vitro [16–18]. In DR Congo, some plants are reported to be used in traditional
medicine in some cities against typhoid fever. This is particularly the case of Cymbopogon citratus (DC.) Stapf (Poaceae)
in Lubero [19], Crassocephalum monthuosum (S. Moore) Milme-Redh (Asteraceae) in Butembo [20], Dialium angolense
Welw. Ex Oliv (Fabaceae) in Bukavu [21], Morinda morindoides (Baker) Milne-Redh. (Rubiaceae) in Kinshasa [22] and,
Cymbopogon densiflorus (Steud.) Stapf (Poaceae) in Lubumbashi [23]; However, no study has been devoted to collecting
plants against typhoid fever in Lubumbashi, despite the danger presented by the disease and the effective use of
medicinal plants observed within the target population.
This study aims to list the plants and recipes used in Lubumbashi by traditional medicine practitioners (PMTs) to
manage typhoid fever to draw up an ethnomedicinal profile.
The city of Lubumbashi is located between 11°26'- 11°55′ south latitude and 27°15′ – 27°40′ east longitude at an
altitude of 1230 meters. The climate is tropical, with an average annual temperature of 22.4°C and an average yearly
precipitation of 512.7 mm3. The rainy season (from November to April) is shorter in two seasons. The characteristic
vegetation is dominated by the Miyombo forest [24].
266
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
The geographic types were determined based on data from the database « African Plant Database ». The botanical names
of the species have been formatted based on the information contained in the databases, African Plant Database
(https://africanplantdatabase.ch/), Plants of the World Online (https://powo.science.kew.org/), or World Flora Online
(http://www.worldfloraonline.org/).
In this study, UV: makes it possible to assess the medicinal importance of a plant in the study environment, IC: makes it
possible to identify the level of consensus of a species as to its anti-typhoidal use; IF: makes it possible to establish an
agreement of informants around an anti-typhoidal recipe.
3. Results
267
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
268
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
49 Senna spectabilis (DC.) H.S. Irwin & Fabaceae Kifunfub RAS [57] KIP523712350
Barneby
50 Solanum aethiopicum L. Solanaceae Mutete g RAS [58] KIP452120032
56 Vachellia hockii (De Wild.) Seigler & Fabaceae Lungoleb RAS RAS KIP203066812
Ebinger
269
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
a: Bemba name, b: Luba name, c: Rund name, d: Hemba name, e: Lamba name, f: Shi name, g: Swahili name, h: Tabwa name, i: Lingala name, j: Mbala
name, k: Nande name, l: Sanga name, m: Tetela name, Uo: ethnobotanical use in DR Congo, Up: ethnobotanical use outside the country, RAS: Nothing
to report.
270
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
The plant species inventoried during this study present 3 morphological types, where the shrub represents the most
dominant morphology (60%). It is followed by grass with Fi = 30%. These taxa also present 3 biological types, where
the McPh type (60%) comes first, followed by the MePh type (30%). Three sites, Kamalubwe, Kashamata, and Mimbulu,
served as collection locations, and 50% of the taxa were collected from Kamalubwe. These species have 11 geographical
types with a 75% predominance of 2 types: the tropical type: TA (Fi= 32%), and the Australo-tropical type: SA-TA, Fi=
23% (Figure 4).
According to data from the available literature, the plants inventoried (Table 1) can be grouped into 4 classes where
most of the plants (43.9%) are unknown both from the point of view of anti-typhoidal activity and from the point of
view of for use in the management of typhoid fever. However, among the 57 plants, those reported and proven as active
plants on S. Typhi represent 31.6% (Figure 4).
Ethnobotanical use anti-typhoidal (-) anti-typhoidal activity (-) previous: Class α, Ethnobotanical use anti-typhoidal (+) anti-typhoidal activity (-)
previous: Class β, Ethnobotanical use anti-typhoidal (+) activity anti -typhoidal anterior (+): Class γ, Ethnobotanical use anti-typhoidal (-) anti-
typhoidal activity anterior (+): Class δ. (-): absent, (+): present. MePh: Mesophanerophytes, McPh: Microphanerophytes, NPh: Nanophanerophytes,
Th: Therophytes, TA: tropical Africa, SA: southern Africa, MA: Madagascar, NA: North Africa.
3.2. Ethnomedicinal profile of the plants collected from the PMTs consulted
From 57 listed plants, derive 65 anti-typhoidal recipes, which all use a single plant and for which only Strychnos spinosa
has 3 anti-typhoidal recipes (R56-58). It is followed by 6 other species, Albizia antunesianaα, Antidesma venosumγ,
Asparagus bequaertiiα, Piliostigma thonningii.δ, Senna sopheraα, and Vitex madiensisα which each have 2 anti-typhoid
recipes. The balance is made up of one-recipe plants (Table 2).
271
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Acalypha villicaulis R1: Decoction for 15 0.04 1 R Diarrhea and 0.06 0.06
Hochst. ex A. Rich.α minutes of a handful of Typhoid Fever.
root bark in 2 liters of
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Albizia antunesiana R2: Decoction for 15 0.06 0.6 ER Tonsillitis, 0.17 0.13
Harms α minutes of a handful of Diabetes,
root bark in 2 liters of Typhoid fever,
water. Drink 200 mL Gonorrhoea,
twice a day for 5 days. Peptic ulcer
disease,
Tuberculosis.
R3: Decoction for 15 0.04 0.4 Fr Diabetes, 0.06
minutes 5 handfuls of Typhoid Fever
fruit in 2 liters of water. & STI.
Drink 200 mL twice a day
for 5 days.
Albizia versicolor R4: Decoction for 15 0.02 1 ER Intestinal 0.06 0.06
Welw. ex Olivα minutes of a handful of worms, Fever,
root bark in 2 liters of typhoid,
water. Drink 200 mL Gastrointestinal
twice a day for 5 days. disorders.
Aloe vera (L.) Burm.f.γ R5: Decoction for 45 0.02 1 F Acnes, 0.06 0.06
minutes of a handful of Diarrhoea,
fresh leaves in 1 L of Typhoid fever.
water. Drink 150 Ml twice
a day for 5 days.
Ananas comosus (L.) R6: Decoction for 15 0.04 1 Fr Constipation, 0.10 0.10
Merr.β minutes of the whole fruit Gastrointestinal
in 1 litter of water. Drink disorders,
100ml twice a day for 5 Typhoid fever,
days. Malaria,
Intestinal
worms.
Annona senegalensis R7: Decoction for 30 0.02 1 F Intestinal pain, 0.10 0.06
Pers.γ minutes of a handful of typhoid fever,
fresh leaves in 1L of HIV.
water. Drink 100 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Antidesma venosum E. R8: Decoction for 30 0.1 0.5 ER Anemia, 0.15 0.08
Mey. ex Tul.γ minutes of a handful of Diarrhoea,
root bark in 1.5 liters of Typhoid fever,
water. Drink 100 mL Gastrointestinal
twice a day for 7 days. disorders.
R9: Decoction for 30 0.1 0.5 ET Urogenital Tract 0.08
minutes of a handful of Infections,
stem bark decoction in Gastrointestinal
1.5 liters of water. Drink Disorders,
272
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
273
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Cajanus cajan (L.) R18: Decoction for 30 0.04 1 F Elephantiasis, 0.10 0.10
Huthγ minutes of a handful of Influenza,
fresh leaves in 1L of Typhoid fever,
water. Drink 100 mL Gingivitis,
twice a day for 5 days. Hepatitis.
Carica papaya Lγ R19: Decoction for 30 0.1 1 F Asthma, 0.08 0.08
minutes of a handful of Beriberi,
leaves in 1L of water. Typhoid fever,
Drink 100 mL twice a day wounds.
for 5 days.
Cassia abbreviata Oliv.γ R20: Maceration for 72 0.06 1 ER Diarrhoea, 0.08 0.08
hours of 5 handfuls of Typhoid fever,
root bark in 1 litter of Malaria, Peptic
water. Drink 100 mL ulcer disease.
three times a day for 3
days.
Celosia trigyna L.δ R21: Infusion for 30 0.06 1 F Gastrointestinal 0.06 0.06
minutes of a handful of disorders,
leaves in 2 liters of water. Typhoid fever,
Drink 200 mL twice a day Intestinal
for 5 days. worms.
Citrus × limon (L.) R22: Decoction for 30 0.1 1 F Angina, typhoid 0.04 0.04
Osbeckγ minutes of two handfuls fever.
of fresh leaves in 1L of
water. Drink 100 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Combretum R23: Decoction for 15 0.02 1 ER Conjunctivitis, 0.06 0.06
celastroides Welw. ex minutes of a handful of Joint pain,
M. A. Lawson α root bark in 2 liters of Typhoid fever.
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Crossandra leucodonta R24: Decoction for 15 0.02 1 ER Amoebas & 0.04 0.04
Vollesen α minutes of a handful of Typhoid Fever.
root bark in 2 liters of
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Cryptolepis R25: Decoction for 15 0.02 1 ER Diarrhoea, 0.08 0.08
oblongifolia (Meisn.) minutes of a handful of Typhoid fever,
Schltrα root bark in 2 liters of Gastro-
water. Drink 200 mL duodenal ulcer,
twice a day for 5 days. Cough.
Cymbopogon citratus R26: Infusion for 30 0.02 1 ET Bronchitis, 0.10 0.10
(DC.) Stapfγ minutes of a handful of wounds,
stem bark in 2 liters of rheumatism,
water. Drink 200 mL typhoid fever,
twice a day for 5 days. tuberculosis.
Cymbopogon R27: Infusion for 15 0.04 1 R Asthma, 0.08 0.08
densiflorus (Steud.) minutes of a handful of Epilepsy,
Stapfδ roots in 1 litter of water. Typhoid fever,
Drink 150 mL once a day Colds.
for 5 days.
274
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
275
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Lannea acida A. Richγ R36: Maceration for 72 0.04 1 ET Diarrhoea, 0.06 0.06
hours of 5 handfuls of Dysentery &
stem bark in 1 liter of Typhoid Fever.
water. Drink 100 mL
three times a day for 3
days.
Lantana camara Lγ R37: Infusion for 45 0.04 1 F Typhoid fever, 0.08 0.08
minutes of a handful of Rheumatism,
leaves in 1 L of water. Peptic ulcer
Drink 150 mL twice a day disease, Cough.
for 5 days.
Monotes katangensis R38: Maceration for 72 0.18 1 ET Cough, 0.06 0.06
De Wild α hours of 5 handfuls of Diarrhoea &
stem bark in 1 litter of Typhoid Fever.
water. Drink 100 mL
three times a day for 3
days.
Moringa oleifera Lamc R39: Decoction for 30 0.02 1 ET Typhoid fever, 0.06 0.06
minutes of a handful of Malaria,
stem bark in 1.5 liters of Gastrointestinal
water. Drink 150 mL disorders.
twice a day for 5 days.
Ochna afzelii R.Br. ex R40: Decoction for 15 0.06 1 ER Peptic ulcer & 0.04 0.04
Oliv.β minutes of a handful of Typhoid fever.
root bark in 2 liters of
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Ocimum americanum L R41: Decoction for 30 0.02 1 R Diabetes, 0.06 0.06
α minutes of a handful of Gingivitis &
the roots in 3 liters of Typhoid Fever.
water. Drink 150 mL
twice a day for 7 days.
Parinari alvimii Prance R42: Decoction for 15 0.06 1 ER Typhoid fever. 0.02 0.02
α minutes of a handful of
root bark in 2 liters of
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Pericopsis angolensis R43: Infusion for 45 0.1 1 F Convulsions, 0.06 0.06
(Baker) Meeuwenβ minutes of a handful of Typhoid Fever
leaves in 1 L of water. & Malaria
Drink 150 mL twice a day
for 5 days.
Phragmanthera R44: Maceration for 72 0.04 1 ET Acne, Diarrhoea, 0.06 0.06
capitata (Spreng.) c hours of 5 handfuls of Typhoid fever.
stem bark in 1 liter of
water. Drink 100 mL
three times a day for 3
days.
Phragmanthera R45: Infusion for 45 0.04 1 F Typhoid fever. 0.02 0.02
leonensis (Sprague) minutes of a handful of
Balleα leaves in 1 L of water.
276
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
277
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Senna spectabilis (DC.) R54: Decoction for 15 0.06 1 ER STI, Typhoid 0.02 0.06
H.S. Irwin & Barneby δ minutes of a handful of fever,
root bark in 2 liters of Tuberculosis.
water. Drink 200 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
Solanum aethiopicum R55: Decoction for 30 0.02 F Typhoid fever 0.04 0.04
L.δ minutes of a handful of and high blood
fresh leaves in 1L of pressure.
water. Drink 100ml twice
a day for 5 days.
Strychnos spinosa R56: Decoction for 30 0.04 0.7 F Diarrhoea, 0.25 0.17
Lam.δ minutes of a handful of Typhoid fever,
leaves in 1L of water. Miscarriage,
Drink 100ml twice a day Gastritis,
for 5 days. Haemorrhoids,
Urogenital tract
infections,
Toothache,
Tuberculosis.
R57: Decoction for 15 0.02 0.3 ET Diarrhoea, 0.06
minutes of a handful of Typhoid fever,
stem bark in 1.5 liters of Intestinal
water. Drink 100 mL worms.
twice a day for 5 days.
R58: Decoction for 15 0.02 0.3 ER STIs, typhoid 0.10
minutes of a handful of fever,
root bark in 2 liters of gastrointestinal
water. Drink 200 mL disorders,
twice a day for 5 days. ringworms,
intestinal
worms.
Terminalia mollis M.A. R59: Decoction for 15 0.02 1 ER Diabetes, 0.08 0.08
Lawsonγ minutes of a handful of Diarrhoea,
root bark in 2 liters of Gastrointestinal
water. Drink 200 mL disorders,
twice a day for 5 days. Typhoid fever.
Tetradenia riparia R60: Decoction for 15 0.1 0.5 ET Angina, sores, 0.17 0.08
(Hochst.) Coddδ minutes of a handful of typhoid fever,
leaves in 1.5 liters of gastrointestinal
water. Drink 100 mL disorders.
twice a day for 5 days.
Tithonia diversifolia R61: Decoction for 30 0.04 0.7 F Diabetes, 0.10
(Hemsl.) A. Gray c minutes 3 handfuls of Amoeba,
leaves in 1L of water. Cancer, Typhoid
Drink 100ml twice a day Fever &
for 5 days. Intestinal
Worms.
Turraea floribunda R62: Decoction for 15 0.02 0.3 ET Typhoid fever. 0.02 0.02
Hochstα minutes 2 handfuls of
stem bark in 1.5 liters of
278
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Vachellia hockii (De R63: Decoction for 30 0.02 1 R Epilepsy, 0.06 0.06
Wild.) Seigler & minutes of a handful of Typhoid fever,
Ebingerα the roots in 3 liters of Gastrointestinal
water. Drink 150 mL disorders.
twice a day for 7 days.
Vitex madiensis Oliv α R64: Decoction for 15 0.04 0.7 ET Malaria, 0.08 0.04
minutes 2 handfuls of Typhoid fever
stem bark in 1.5 litters of
water. Drink 100 mL
twice a day for 5 days.
R65: Decoction for 15 0.02 0.3 ER Diabetes, 0.06
minutes 2 handfuls of Typhoid Fever &
root bark in 2 liters of Gastrointestinal
water. Drink 200 mL Disorders
twice a day for 5 days.
IC= Consensus index (IC=n /N), IF: fidelity index (nr/Np: the number of people who cited the recipe out of the number of people who cited the
plant); UV: usual value (UV=∑Ui /U the set of uses of an organ (Uo), of a plant (Up) out of all the uses identified in the study). F: Leaves, ET: Stem
bark; ER: root bark, R: roots; Fr: Fruit.
A third of anti-typhoidal recipes (33%) are made from stem bark, but the use of leaves and root bark occurs with the
same frequency (Fi= 27%), occupying the second position. Although rarely used, fruits are only used at 3% (Figure 5).
The consensus indices of different species vary between 0.02 and 0.22, and those of fidelity range from 0.3 to 1. The
recipes R33, R28 (CI= 0.12) and R38 present respectively the highest consensus indexes (CI = 0.22, CI= 0.12 and CI=
0.18) and reliability If (IF = 1). These 3 recipes are respectively those based on taxa, Ficus sur Forsskα, Dalbergia boehmiα
and Monotes katangensisα However, it is the taxa Strychnos spinosa δ (UVp =0.25), Diplorhynchus condylocarpon α (UVp
= 0.19) and Albizia antunesianaα have the 3 highest usual values, which vary between 0.02 and 0.22 (Table 2).
Apart from typhoid fever, these 57 plants are implicated in 47 other causes of consultation, where diarrhea (34%),
gastrointestinal disorders (29.8%), diabetes (27.7%), and gastroduodenal ulcers (25, 5%) constitute the first 3
indications (Figure 6).
279
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
280
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
4. Discussion
This study has just identified for the first time 57 plant species used by the PMTs of Lubumbashi in the management of
typhoid fever. Most of these taxa belong to the Fabaceae family 28.1% (Figure 3). The preponderance of Fabaceae
reflects the importance of this family in traditional medicine for the management of several pathologies, as reported in
various ethnobotanical studies carried out in the Lubumbashi region. This is particularly the case of the survey carried
out on the plants used in the management of sexual dysfunction [21], or that carried out on plants known to be
antimalarial [23] or diabetes [25], or against tooth decay [26], against schistosomiasis [27] or for diarrhea [28]. The
preponderance of Fabaceae during this study can be linked to the fact that it constitutes the most prominent family of
trees in the tropical and dry forests of Africa [29], mainly from Lubumbashi [30].
This study reports for the first time, 25 species as usual plants against typhoid fever in Lubumbashi (Figure 4). These
taxa have never been the subject of a previous biological study on S. typhi. Those are: Acalypha villicaulis, Albizia
antunesiana, Albizia versicolor, Asparagus bequaertii, Brachystegia allenii, Brachystegia taxifolia, Bulbostylis scabricaulis,
Combretum celastroides, Crossandra leucodonta, Cryptolepis oblongifolia, Dalbergia boehmi, Diplorhynchus
condylocarpon, Dysphania ambrosioides, Euphorbia ingens, Ficus sur, Julbernardia paniculata, Monotes katangensis,
Ocimum americanum , Parinari alvimii, Phragmanthera leonensis, Phyllanthus muellerianus, Senna sophera, Turraea
floribunda, Vachellia hockii, and Vitex madiensis. Among these 25 species, no accessible ethnopharmacological
information are reported on nine taxa: Albizia versicolor, Asparagus bequaertii, Brachystegia allenii, Brachystegia
taxifolia, Bulbostylis scabricaulis, Crossandra leucodonta, Ficus sur, Monotes katangensis, Phragmanthera leonensis. This
study therefore reports for the first time the ethnopharmacological knowledge of these 9 plant species. Subsequent
investigations must be carried out as a priority on these 9 plants to confirm their uses against typhoid fever, especially
since they emerge as rare and endemic to the region. The order of importance in studying these plants can be based on
their ethnobotanical indexes. In this case, concerning the consensus index, Ficus sur (Ic = 0.22) and Monotes katangensis
(Ic = 0.18) may take precedence; however, if we refer to their usual value, Monotes katangensis (UVp = 0.15) and
Brachystegia allenii (UVp = 0.8) occupy the first two places. If we consider the two indices concomitantly (IC and UVp),
Monotes katangensis takes precedence, followed by these 3 other species mentioned above.
This study also shows that the plants listed are primarily named in Bemba: 40% (Figure 2) but that most of the PMTs
consulted are from the Luba ethnic group of Katanga (38%) (Table 3). This disparity can be justified by the fact that the
PMTs are not necessarily the harvesters, so they know the plants that is not of their ethnicity. Another variable that
could explain this disparity would be the fact of a cultural mix which means that the knowledge of the PMT of
281
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Lubumbashi exceeds that acquired from its ancestors; However, it should be noted that the various ethnobotanical
studies carried out in the region [23, 25, 27, 31] show that the practice of traditional medicine is dominated by the
Bemba and the Luba. They would probably constitute the majority ethnic groups of the region.
Furthermore, the fact that 38.6% of plant species under examination have been previously reported as anti-typhoids
and that among them 31.6% have already been studied on S. typhi (Figure 5) suggests some credibility to be accorded
to the information resulting from the investigations. Thus it is probable to find among the plants not studied but
informed during the present study those active on S. Typhi.
This study lists from 57 plants, 65 anti-typhoidal recipes for which the stem bark constitutes the most used part (Fi=
33%) and the decoction (Fi=72%) the mode of preparation of the recipes, the most used (Figure 5). Although these
results are similar to those encountered in the various ethnobotanical surveys carried out in the region about decoction
[23, 25–27, 31, 32], there is a disparity regarding the most used part. The leaf is more used in some studies of the region
[23, 26, 32], while in others [25, 27, 31], it is the root that is the most used part. In the present study, the stem bark is
the most used. In certain ethnobotanical studies targeted towards anti-typhoidal use, in particular, those carried out in
Benin [4], Nigeria [33], and Cameroon [15], the decoction (50 -100%) and the leaf (34.2 - 68%) constitute the method
of preparation and the most used organ. It is, therefore, possible to identify a trend of consensus on decoction as the
preferred mode of use of plants for anti-typhoidal use, unlike the organ. However, this hypothesis is considered very
modestly given the few studies mentioned.
Nevertheless, it would be interesting to review the literature on the plants used in the management of typhoid fever at
the national and continental levels to have a clear-cut point of view. The use of leaves offers lower stability of constancy
in the activity than stem bark. Indeed, the leaf being generally the organ of synthesis, depending on whether the leaf is
harvested young or at maturity, its composition can easily change, unlike the harvesting of stem bark which constitutes
the storage places where the design should be slightly affected by the synthesis of metabolites.
In previous ethnobotanical studies carried out in Lubumbashi on medicinal plants [23, 25–27, 31], as in the present
study (Table 3), men over the age of 40 old were the most encountered during the survey, unlike women, and their level
of education was deficient. On the other hand, in particular, in works carried out in North Africa [34–36], women
predominate in traditional medicine. One of the reasons that could justify this situation would be that in Lushoise
society, the woman is mainly occupied with housework, leaving the man to look for food for the household. However,
suppose the traditional medicine practice is regarded as a profession in the region; in that case, the probability of
meeting men in its practice seems higher than that of meeting women.
5. Conclusion
This study reports 57 plants used in 65 anti-typhoid recipes by TMPs in Lubumbashi. Pharmacological investigations of
eighteen 57 plants, including Annona senegalensis, have already been registered from different parts of Africa as
potential medicinal herbs to manage typhoid fever. Their studies on S. typhi have shown them to be active. Twenty-five
other species, such as Monotes katangensis or Ficus sur are reported for the first time and have a high medicinal use
value in Lubumbashi. In addition to treating typhoid fever, these plants also treat several other pathologies, such as
diabetes. These results suggest that further work is needed to establish the scientific basis for the anti-typhoidal use of
these plants in traditional medicine and possibly identify the compounds likely to justify this activity.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank Nkulu, Makwasa, and the Kipopo herbarium, respectively, for preparing the herbariums
during the harvest and for the botanical identification of the taxa.
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that might appear
to influence the work reported in this article.
282
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
Author contributions
Data collection: Kasongo Ilunga Pierre; Project design, formal analysis, statistical data processing, and writing of the
draft article: Bashige Chiribagula Valentin; Supervision - revision and editing of the project: Mboni Manya Henri, Félicien
Mushagalusa Kasali, Okusa Ndjolo Philippe, Lumbu Simbi Jean-Baptiste.
References
[1] Wibisono FM, Wibisono FJ, Effendi MH, Plumeriastuti H, Rafi A. A Review of Salmonellosis on Poultry Farms :
Public Health Importance. Syst Rev Pharm 2020;11(9):481–486.
[2] Kim CL, Maria L, Espinoza C, Vannice KS, Tadesse BT, Owusu-dabo E, et al. The Burden of Typhoid Fever in Sub-
Saharan Africa : A Perspective. Res Rep Trop Med 2022;13(1):1–9.
[3] Cruz Espinoza LM, McCreedy E, Holm M, Im J, Mogeni OD, Parajulee P, et al. Occurrence of Typhoid Fever
Complications and Their Relation to Duration of Illness Preceding Hospitalization: A Systematic Literature
Review and Meta-analysis. Clin Infect Dis 2019;69(Suppl 6): S435–S448.
[4] Kakpo AB, Ladekan EY, Gbaguidi F, Kpoviessi S, Gbenou JD. Ethnopharmacological investigation of medicinal
plants used to treat typhoid fever in Benin. J Pharmacogn Phytochem 2019;8(6):225–232.
[5] Brainard J, D'hondt R, Ali E, Van den Bergh R, De Weggheleire A, Baudot Y, et al. Typhoid fever outbreak in the
Democratic Republic of Congo: Case control and ecological study. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2018;12(10):1–17.
[6] Muresu N, Sotgiu G, Are BM, Cossu A, Cocuzza C, Martinelli M, et al. Travel-related typhoid fever: Narrative review
of the scientific literature. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2020;17(2):1–12.
[7] Mutai WC, Muigai AWT, Waiyaki P, Kariuki S. Multi-drug resistant Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi isolates with
reduced susceptibility to ciprofloxacin in Kenya. BMC Microbiol 2018;18(1):4–8.
[8] Ali E, Van Den Bergh R, D'hondt R, Kuma-Kuma D, De Weggheleire A, Baudot Y, et al. Localised transmission
hotspots of a typhoid fever outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Pan Afr Med J 2017;28:1–9.
[9] Kamwira IS, Tshikongo AK. Profile of the prevalence of typhoid fever at the Beni Reference General Hospital in
the city of Beni in the Democratic Republic of Congo. J Med Res 2017;3(5):239–242.
[10] Marie-France BK, Patricia ML, Theophile RM, Serges KT, Pascal KM, Charles MM, et al. Clinical and
Epidemiological Aspects of Certain Diseases with Weekly Notification in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC):
Case of Three Hospitals in Lubumbashi. OALib 2021;08(01):1–13.
[11] Bashige CV, Manya MH, Bakari AS, Sangwa KG, Kahumba BJ, Pierre D, et al. Prévalence et caractéristiques de
l’automédication chez les étudiants de 18 à 35 ans résidant au campus de la Kasapa de l’Université de
Lubumbashi. Pan Afr Med J 2015;21:77.
[12] Veeraraghavan B, Pragasam AK, Bakthavatchalam YD, Ralph R. Typhoid fever: Issues in laboratory detection,
treatment options & concerns in management in developing countries. Futur Sci OA 2018;4(6):1–12.
[13] Mukhopadhyay B, Sur D, Gupta S Sen, Ganguly NK. Typhoid fever: Control & challenges in India. Indian J Med Res
2019;150(1):437–447.
[14] Igberaese PO, Ogbole OO. Ethnobotanical Survey of Plants used in the Treatment of Typhoid and its
Complication(s) in Esan North East Local Government Area, Uromi, Edo State. J Pharm Res 2018;14(2):175–188.
[15] Fodouop Chegaing SP, Yemele Mefokou D, Talom Tangue B, Sokoudjou JB, Telemgone Menoudji S, Tchuente
Kamsu G, et al. Contribution to the ethnobotanical inventory of medicinal plants used for the treatment of typhoid
fever in Adamaoua region, Cameroon. Int J Biol Chem Sci 2021;14(9):3078–3096.
[16] Uddin S, Billah M, Nuri ZN. Pharmacological actions of Euphorbia hirta: A review. Int J Hortic Food Sci
2019;1(1):84–89.
[17] Yandev D, Ngbede J, Ogbonna I, Orhii C. In-vitro antibacterial activity of Annona senegalensis root and stem
extracts against Salmonella typhimurium, Shigella flexneri and Escherichia coli. Int J Multidiscip Res Growth Eval
2022;3(3):394–399.
[18] Abdulsalami H, Daudu YOA, Adabara NU, Hamzah RU. Antisalmonellal Activity and GC-MS Analysis of Piliostigma
thonningii leaf extract. AROC Nat Prod Res 2022;02(02):01–09.
283
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
[19] Kasika EL, Vasombolwa VK, Lejoly J. Popular medicinal plants used by the Bantu people and Pygmies living in the
administrative territories of Beni and Lubero ( DRC ). J Med Plants Res 2016;10(30):479–494.
[20] Kasali F, Mahano A, Kadima N, Mpiana P, Ngbolua K, Tshibangu T. Ethnopharmacological Survey of Medicinal
Plants Used against Malaria in Butembo City (D. R. Congo). J Adv Bot Zool 2014;1(1):1–11.
[21] Bashige C V, Bakari AS, Ndjolo PO, Kahumba BJ, Duez P, Lumbu SJ. Ethnobotanical study of plants used as
antimalarial in traditional medicine in Bagira in Eastern RD Congo. J Pharmacogn Phytochem 2020;9(4):1–14.
[22] Ngbolua K, Mihigo SO, Liyongo CI, Masengo C. Ethno-botanical survey of plant species used in traditional
medicine in Ethno-botanical survey of plant species used in traditional medicine in Kinshasa city ( Democratic
Republic of the Congo ). Trop Plant Res 2016;3(2):413–427.
[23] Mbuyi KS, Kalunga MR, Kalonda M, Cimanga CC, Numbi WI, Kahumba BJ, et al. Aperçu ethnobotanique de plantes
réputées antipaludéennes utilisées dans la ville de Lubumbashi et ses environs , dans le Haut-Katanga en RD
Congo. Ethnopharmacologia 2019;61:75–83.
[24] Sikuzani YU, Boisson S, Kaleba SC, Halleux J, Bogaert J. Dynamique de l ’ occupation du sol autour des sites miniers
le long du gradient urbain-rural de la ville de Lubumbashi , RD Congo. Biotechnol Agron Soc Environ
2020;24(1):1–14.
[25] Amuri B, Maseho M, Lumbu S, Pierre D, Byanga K. Ethnobotanical survey of herbs used in the management of
diabetes mellitus in Southern Katanga Area/DR Congo. Pan African Med Journal 2018;30(2018).
doi:10.11604/pamj.2018.30.218.11718.
[26] Bashige C V., Manya-Mboni H, Ntabaza-Ndage V, Numbi Ilunga E, Bakari-Amuri S, Kalonda Mutombo E, et al. Étude
ethnobotanique, biologique et chimique de plantes réputées anticariogènes à Lubumbashi – RD Congo.
Phytotherapie 2017;15(1):2–9.
[27] Muya K, Tshoto K, Cioci CC, Aseho MM, Kalonji M, Byanga K, et al. Survol ethnobotanique de quelques plantes
utilisées contre la schistosomiase urogénitale à Lubumbashi et environs. Phyothérapie 2014.
doi:10.1007/s10298-014-0877-z.
[28] Lumbu S, Kahumba B, Kahambwe T, Mbayo K, Kalonda M, Mwamba M, et al. Contribution à l’étude de quelques
plantes médicinales antidiarrhéiques en usage dans la ville de Lubumbashi et ses environs. Ann.de Pharm
2005;3(1):75–86.
[29] Ahmad F, Anwar F, Hira S. Review on medicinal importance of fabaceae family. PhOL 2016;3(152):151–156.
[30] Useni Y, Malaisse F, Cabala S, Kalumba A, Mwana A, Nkuku C, et al. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening Tree
diversity and structure on green space of urban and peri-urban zones : The case of Lubumbashi City in the
Democratic Republic of Congo. Urban For Urban Green 2019;41(March):67–74.
[31] Bashige CV, Alombong AG, Kamwimba MA, Bakari AS, Okusa NP. Ethnobotanical study of medicinal plants used
in the treatment of sexual dysfunctions in traditional medicine in Kampemba-Lubumbashi, DR Congo. World J
Adv Res Rev 2020;7(3):016–032.
[32] Okombe V, Simbi JL, Stévigny C, Vandenput S, Pongombo C, Duez P. Traditional plant-based remedies to control
gastrointestinal disorders in livestock in the regions of Kamina and Kaniama ( Katanga province , Democratic
Republic of Congo ). J Ethnopharmacol 2014;153(3):686–693.
[33] Abdulrahman MD, Hamad SW, Usman M, Tahir SM, Sunusi N, Yunusa A. Therapeutic plants used for Typhoid
Fever treatment in Kaduna State Nigeria. Al-Qadisiyah J Pure Sci 2021;26(3):9–21.
[34] Meddour R, Sahar O, Ouyessad M. Enquête ethnobotanique des plantes médicinales dans le Parc national du
Djurdjura et sa zone d ’ influence , Algérie - Ethnobotanical survey on medicinal plants in the Djurdjura National
Park and its influence area , . Ethnobot Res Appl 2020;20(46):1–25.
[35] Karous O, Jilani IBH, Ghrabi-Gammar Z. Ethnobotanical Study on Plant Used by Semi-Nomad Descendants'
Community in Ouled Dabbeb—Southern Tunisia. Plants 2021;10(642):1–33.
[36] Ilyass AM, Loubna K, Mostafa E. Ethnobotanical profile of medicinal plants used by people of North-eastern
Morocco : Cross-cultural and Historical approach ( Part I ). Ethnobot Res Appl 2021;21(34):1–45.
[37] Gorsi FI, Kausar T, Murtaza MA. Evaluation of antibacterial and antioxidant activity of Aloe vera ( Aloe
barbadensis Miller ) gel powder using different solvents. Pure Appl Biol 2019;8(2):1265–1270.
284
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
[38] Egharevba HO, Dalhatu NA, Ibrahim JA. Chemical composition of the leaf essential oil of Antidesma venosum E .
Mey . ex . Tul . and comparative phytochemical and pharmacognostic analysis of its leaf , stem bark and root. Int
J Bioassays 2015;4(12):4625–4628.
[39] Joseph N, Edith TF, Tala S, Raissa V, Matchawe C, Jonas K. Chemical screening and identification of secondary
metabolites by HPLC-MS-UV and antimicrobial activity of Bidens pilosa ( Asteraceae ) extracts. J Pharmacogn
Phytochem 2019;8(4):1001–1006.
[40] Chingwaru C, Bagar T, Chingwaru W. Aqueous extracts of Flacourtia indica , Swartzia madagascariensis and
Ximenia caffra are strong antibacterial agents against Shigella spp . , Salmonella typhi and Escherichia coli O157.
South African J Bot 2020;128(2020):119–127.
[41] Waris A, Anugerah M, Temarwut FF, Kurnia A. Aktivitas Antibakteri Ekstrak Daun Cajanus cajan ( L .) Millsp .
terhadap Salmonella typhi dan Staphylococcus aureus. J Pharm Sci 2021;12(2):109–114.
[42] Efunwole OO, Adetuberu IA, Oladipupo OA, Abejoye OA. Antibacterial effect of Carica papaya against Salmonella
typhi , causative agent of Typhoid fever . J Environ Sci Toxicol Food Technol 2014;8(1):92–95.
[43] Godfrey E, Chauka LJ, Chacha M. Antimicrobial and cytotoxicity activity of selected Pare folk medicinal plants Bazı
Pale yöresi şifalı bitkilerinin antimikrobiyal ve sitotoksik aktivitesi. Spat DD 2015;5(4):207–214.
[44] Gosa BB, Wana TW. Evaluation of the Phytochemical and Antibacterial Activity of Four Selected Plant Extracts
against Some Pathogenic Bacteria. Int J Environ Agric Biotechnol 2022;7(4):265–276.
[45] Nsangou MF, Happi EN, Simone V, Atangana AF, Franc A, Wansi JD, et al. Chemical Composition and Synergistic
Antimicrobial E ff ects of a Vegetatively Propagated Cameroonian Lemon , Citrus x limon ( L .) Osbeck. ACS Food
Sci Technol 2021;1(1):354−361.
[46] Olukunle OF, Adenola OJ. Comparative Antimicrobial Activity of Lemon Grass (Cymbopogon citratus) and Garlic
(Allium sativum) Extracts on Salmonella typhi. J Adv Med Pharm Sci 2019;20(2):1–9.
[47] Takaisi-kikuni N, Tshilanda D, Babady B. Antibacterial activity of the essential oil of Cymbopogon densiflorus.
Fitoterapia 2000;71(2000):69–71.
[48] Isah M, Manga SS, Muhammad A, Tondi ZY, Sa M. The In vitro Antibacterial Effects of Ficus sycomorus Stem Bark
Extracts on Salmonella typhi and Escherichia coli. Equity J Sci Technol 2020;7(1):108–113.
[49] Ouattara L, Koudou J, Zongo C, Barro N, Savadogo A, Bassole I, et al. Antioxidant and Antibacterial Activities of
Three Species of Lannea from Burkina Faso. J Appl Sci 2011;11(1):157–162.
[50] Ezebo RO, Okonkwo CC, Ozoh CN, Nwankwo CA, Nwafor EC. Phytochemical Screening and Antimicrobial Activity
of Ethanol and Methanol Extracts of Lantana camara Leaf. World News Nat Sci 2021;37(2021):151–163.
[51] Raubilu I, Isah U, Ahmad M. Antimicrobial Activity of Moringa Oleifera : A Short Review. Bayero J Pure Appl Sci
2019;12(1):128–132.
[52] Ohikhena FU, Wintola OA, Afolayan AJ. Evaluation of the Antibacterial and Antifungal Properties of
Phragmanthera capitata (Sprengel) Balle (Loranthaceae), a Mistletoe Growing on Rubber Tree, Using the Dilution
Techniques. Sci World J 2017;2017(1):1–8.
[53] Oluwafemi F, Debiri F. Antimicrobial Effect of Phyllanthus amarus and Parquetina nigrescens on Salmonella typhi.
African J Biomed Res 2008;11(May):215–219.
[54] Nyam MA, Abdullahi UI, Atsen E, Itelima JU. Studies on the antibacterial effect of the ethanolic extracts of
Cnidoscolus aconitifolius ( Miller ) ( Hospital Too Far ), Piliostigma thonningii ( Schum ) ( Camels Foot ) And
Lantana camara ( Linn ) ( Lantana ). J Med Biomed Appl Sci 2020;8(2):343–351.
[55] Abdallah MS, Mustafa M, Choi S, Paik J, Rusea G. Determination of phenolics and flavonoids of some useful
medicinal plants and Bioassay-Guided fractionation substances of Sclerocarya birrea (A . Rich) Hochst Stem
(Bark) extract and their efficacy against Salmonella Typhi. Front Chem 2021;9(1):1–13.
[56] Bagega AI, Usman AA, Dankaka SM, Amina M, Mani AU. Antibacterial Activity and Phytochemical Analysis of
Cassia occidentalis Leaf Extract on Salmonella Typhimurium. Bioremediation Sci Technol 2018;6(2):5–8.
[57] Mongkol R, Chavasiri W. Antimicrobial and weed inhibitory activities of Senna spectabilis extracts against plant
pathogens. Int J Agric Technol 2018;14(7):1445–1454.
[58] Oluremi BB, Oloche JJ, Adeniji AJ. Anticancer and Antibacterial Activities of Solanum aethiopicum L., Solanum
macrocarpon L. and Garcinia kola Heckel. J Nat Prod Res 2021;5(5):938–942.
285
GSC Biological and Pharmaceutical Sciences, 2022, 21(01), 265–286
[59] Uttu AJ, Sallau MS, Risikat O, Iyun A. Recent Advances in Isolation and antimicrobial efficacy of selected Strychnos
Species : A Mini Review. J Chem Rev 2022;4(1):15–24.
[60] Maregesi SM, Vlietinck A, Mgole S, Pieters L, David O, Apers S. Screening of some Tanzanian medicinal plants from
Bunda district for antibacterial, antifungal and antiviral activities. J Ethnopharmacol 2008;119(2008):58–66.
[61] Fernandez ACAM, Rosa MF, Fernandez CMM, Bortolucci WC, Melo UZ, Siqueira VLD, et al. Antimicrobial and
Antioxidant Activities of the Extract and Fractions of Tetradenia riparia ( Hochst .) Codd ( Lamiaceae ) Leaves
from Brazil. Curr Microbiol 2017;74(1):1453–1460.
[62] Sefunmi A, Kayode OA. Anti-bacterial Activity of Tithonia diversifolia , Secamore afzelli and Jaundea pinnata
Against Plasmid-bearing Multiple Antibiotics Resistant Bacteria from Different Water Sources in Akure , Nigeria.
Adv Biosci Bioeng 2019;7(2):22–26.
286