Litfiles Midterm
Litfiles Midterm
Litfiles Midterm
LESSON 1
OVERVIEW ON THE NATURE OF LITERATURE AND ITS GENRES
BACHELOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION MAJOR IN ENGLISH
TOPICS COVERED
Literature as Significant Human Experience
Purposes of Literature
Prose vs. Poetry vs. Drama
Fiction vs. Non-Fiction
Filipino Authors
International Well-Known Authors
Literature Competencies in English K to 12 Curriculum
Prepared by
We can enumerate many reasons for studying literature. Here are but few:
o We study literature so that we can better appreciate our literary heritage. We cannot appreciate
something that we do not understand. Through a study of our literature, we can trace the rich heritage
of ideas handed down to us from our forefathers. Then we can understand ourselves better and take
pride in being a Filipino.
o Like other races of the world, we need to understand that we have a great and noble tradition which
can serve as the means to assimilate other cultures.
o Through such a study, we will realize our literary limitations conditioned by certain historical factors and
we can take steps to overcome them.
o Above all, as Filipinos, who truly love and take pride in our own culture, we have to manifest our deep
concern for our own literature and this we can do by studying the literature of our country.
In literature, we do not study things; rather, we feel them. Therefore, authors cannot teach us the
knowledge of things; rather, their writings evoke feelings of beauty and pleasure in our minds. Literature aims
to fulfill our emotions. Our mind follows three main cognitive principles: knowledge, will, and emotion.
Knowledge enables us to find truth while the will encourages us to seek virtue and righteousness. Then where
do emotions lead us? To put it simply, they lead us to discover beauty, which gives us pleasure. Virtue and
truthfulness are necessary to fulfill our desire to live spiritually, but beauty is just as essential. If one is
spiritually fulfilled, then, we can say that one possesses those three qualities in balance. Our desire to know
makes us love knowledge. And if one behaves badly by ignoring virtue, one will undoubtedly be criticized by
society. By the same token, we can say that one’s mind is deformed if one has love for knowledge and will,
but no desire to seek beauty. Of course, there are people whose primary interest lies in science. A passion
for virtue would lead others to become devoted to religion and ethics. And those who seek beauty may
become writers and artists. Such people are specialists. However, it is necessary for average people to
embrace all three elements in a balanced way to discover how to perfect and refine their character.
Certainly, literature serves purposes apart from the cultivation of personal character. By portraying
life, it enables us to understand the subtleties of human affairs. It helps a lowly man understand the thoughts
and emotions of a noble man; it helps a rich person understand the living conditions of the poor; it helps
people in the cities understand the lives of farmers, and an evil person see the thoughts and emotions of a
righteous man. This communicability of literature helps us understand foreigners and ancient people as well.
Similarly, we gain knowledge by reading literature, which is necessary for education and helps us adapt to
society. Furthermore, the supreme virtue of literature is that it helps us examine the lives and interactions of
people from all kinds of backgrounds. The sympathy it induces becomes a driving force behind virtuous acts.
Thus, the rich will sympathize with the poor, the noble with the lowly, and the good with the bad. Third, by
portraying how men commit sin, literature helps us uphold virtue. By delineating the ups and downs of a
person’s psychology, it teaches us all how to make progress in our own lives. Fourth, we discover pure
pleasure from literature in this world of suffering, which frees our minds from injustice. Thus, in literature we
can wander imaginatively through an ideal world, experiencing the lives and thoughts of others. If a person
has a deep affection for literature, we can say that he or she possesses the spiritual assets of mankind that
have been accumulated over time. Fifth, the reason people have developed harmful addictions to sex and
alcohol is that they lack a refined taste. If a person develops her or his interest in literature, she or he will be
able to overcome such addictions. Sixth, although a good literary work does not necessarily aim to teach us
to act morally, it still provides certain important lessons. Literature unknowingly shapes our character and
develops our intellectual abilities
Prose
For long time, the study of prose has been overlooked and even the definition of it lacks the precision
and to some degree is very vague. For the convenience, it is required that a clear understanding of what is
prose is necessary. Originally, the word prose originated from the Latin one "prosa" meaning straightforward
discourse. In the new oxford American dictionary it is defined as "written or spoken language in its ordinary
form, without metrical structure." This indicates that any writing not in verse form can be thought of prose. It
can also be termed in two senses: the broad one and the narrow one as well as the one which is in between.
In a broad sense, it refers to a literary medium distinguished from poetry especially by its irregularity and
variety of rhythm and its close correspondence to the patterns. According to this definition, fiction and drama
fall within the scope of prose. In a narrow sense, however, it refers to a type of literary genres opposed to
poetry, fiction and drama. And there are some features which make it possible to distinguish it from poetry,
drama and fiction.
There are different categorizations of prose varying with different people. Generally speaking the
influential and widely accepted ones are the categorization of prose into three types and that into four types.
The representative of the former is Alexander (1963) who categorized prose into three types: narrative,
description and argument. The first type refers to writing which describes an action or a series of actions to
tell a story; the second refers to writing which describes scenes, object, people, or even a person's feeling in
such a way that we can imagine them vividly. For the last type he remarks that it differs from the previous
two in "idea, not about action or object: a problem is presented, an argument is built logically round it and
often, but not always, the author draws conclusions from his argument, giving his view of the question that
he is discussing" (Alexander, 1963:68). Besides Alexander, another one who holds such kind of
categorization of prose is Sheridan (1981).
According to him, "in essence, description is spatial, and narration is temporal" (1981: 165) which
well illustrates the difference between description and narration. He also makes it clear that sometimes in a
piece of writing description and narration blend so effectively so that it is almost indistinguishable. Tao is one
who holds such view in China and further explicates there are different forms of prose, such as letters, diary,
reminiscent, traveling account (2002: 1). Those who are the proponents of categorization or prose into four
types regard that prose can be categorized into: narrative, argument, object, lyric (Fang, 2004:35). Their
definitions of descriptive, narrative and argument are almost like that by Alexander. In this categorization,
lyric is defined as the writing of feeling expression. Though such a categorization is apparently much finer
and more delicate than the previous one, still some problems are involved in it. Firstly it excludes some prose
writings concerned with scenes and objects hence breaches the "principle of inclusiveness"-one of the
principles of categorization proposed by Ye (Fang, 2004:31). Secondly there is no consistent standard with
respect to categorization for the standard of narrative and argumentative is based on the mode of expression,
while object and lyric are on the subject matter dealt with in the prose writing.
Poetry
Poetry is mostly characterized by its meter and stanza which can strike reader immediately. And
meter and stanza are the two obvious ways to differ a piece of poetry from prose. Sometimes poetry can be
called verse, and this depends greatly on the natural rhythms and sounds of language for its special effects
(Burton, 1973:1). Most often, the first word of every line begins with a capital letter, even in the middle of a
sentence. While meters in prose are hardly unperceivable to reader and stanza does not exist which makes
a prose passage seems to be shapeless.
Poetry is any kind of verbal or written language that is structured rhythmically and is meant to tell a
story, or express any kind of emotion, idea, or state of being. Poetry is used to achieve this artistic expression
in several ways. There are certain forms and patterns that poets follow in the composition process of their
work. These different forms were birthed out of separate artistic and cultural movements. Most of these forms
coincide with the previously mentioned definition of poetry; and, the most popular of these forms are elegy,
narrative, ode, ballad, sonnet, villanelle, sestina, free verse, and epic.
Frost believes that poetry in ones self derives from a passion of something. Something you feel so
strongly about that the words become free flowing. A wrongdoing, homesickness and lovesickness were all
appropriate examples of that. He describes the thought process as the poem beginning in the throat, as
nothing more than a lump, and as it travels, the thought and the poem find each other and come together to
form something beautifully scripted. Frost also said, "Poetry is about the grief." The poetry is a result of dying
emotions of the poet’s rather hot or creative imaginations. Poetry turns all things to loveliness. It makes the
beautiful more beautiful thus all familiar things are shown with a touch of better beauty than they actually hold
the most important tool used in the composition of poetry is language. Language is a weapon, it is a shield.
What you choose to use it as is the choice of the poet. Language as a weaponry allows the author to attack
its reader with a barrage of words that exaggerate the theme and plot to a necessary level. Using it as a
shield is a defense mechanism for poets. They open themselves just enough to construct prose, but the
language used guards them from any criticism or feedback on a sensitive issue they may or may not be
consciously ready to accept from an outsider. It gives them their outlet, but still shelters themselves from the
reader.
Drama
Drama is literature designed to be performed by actions. Like fictions it may focus on a single
character or a small number of characters and it enacts functional elements as if they were happening in the
present, to be witnessed by an audience. Although most modern plays use prose dialogue, in the belief that
dramatic speech should be as lifelike as possible, many play from the past like those of ancient Greece and
renaissance England are in poetic form. It is mainly composed of the character's conversation or monologue,
which is sometimes called line.
Drama as a literary genre is realized in performance, which is why Robert Di Yanni (quoted in Dukore)
describes it as “staged art” (867). As a literary form, it is designed for the theatre because characters are
assigned roles and they act out their roles as the action is enacted on stage. These characters can be human
beings, dead or spiritual beings, animals, or abstract qualities. Drama is an adaptation, recreation and
reflection of reality on stage. Generally, the word, dramatist is used for any artist who is involved in any
dramatic composition either in writing or in performance.
Drama is different from other genres of literature. It has unique characteristics that have come about
in response to its peculiar nature. Really, it is difficult to separate drama from performance because during
the stage performance of a play, drama brings life experiences realistically to the audience. It is the most
concrete of all genres of literature. When you are reading a novel, you read a story as told by the novelist.
The poem’s message in most cases is not direct because it is presented in a compact form or in a condensed
language. The playwright does not tell the story instead you get the story as the characters interact and live
out their experiences on stage. In drama, the characters/actors talk to themselves and react to issues
according to the impulse of the moment. Drama is therefore presented in dialogue.
You can see that as a genre of literature, drama occupies a unique position. It is also the most active
of other genres of literature because of the immediate impact it has on the audience. It is used to inform, to
educate to entertain and in some cases to mobilize the audience. Most people associate funny action or other
forms of entertainment as drama. An action could be dramatic yet it will not be classified as drama. The
dramatic is used for any situation or action which creates a sense of an abnormality or the unexpected.
Sometimes we use it to describe an action that is demonstrated or exaggerated. For instance, if you are at a
bus stop, a well-dressed young girl passes and cat-walks across the road, her high-healed shoes breaks and
she slips, the immediate reaction will be laughter from almost everybody there. For some people, this is
drama. Although she was walking in an abnormal way and unexpectedly her shoe breaks, her action could
be called dramatic but it is not dramatic action. Again, the action of a teacher who demonstrates, by injecting
life into his teaching as he acts out certain situations, is dramatic but it is not drama.
What then is drama? Drama is an imitation of life. Drama is different from other forms of literature
because of its unique characteristics. It is read, but basically, it is composed to be performed, so the ultimate
aim of dramatic composition is for it to be presented on stage before an audience. This implies that it a
medium of communication. It has a message to communicate to the audience. It uses actors to convey this
message. This brings us to the issue of mimesis or imitation. We say that drama is mimetic which means that
it imitates life. You may have heard people say that drama mirrors life. Yes, it is the only branch of literature
which tries to imitate life and presents it realistically to the people. It is this mimetic impulse of drama that
makes it appeal to people. Drama thrives on action.
I. PROSE
There are many types of prose. These include the following:
a. Novels. A long narrative divided into chapters and events are taken from true-to-life stories.
Example: WITHOUT SEEING THE DAWN by Stevan Javellana
b. Short story. This is a narrative involving one or more characters, one plot and one single
impression. Example: THE LAUGHTER OF MY FATHER by Carlos Bulosan
c. Plays. This is presented on a stage, is divided into acts and each act has many scenes. Example:
THIRTEEN PLAYS by Wilfredo M. Guerrero
d. Legends. These are fictitious narratives, usually about origins. Example: THE BIKOL LEGEND
by Pio Duran
e. Fables. These are also fictitious and they deal with animals and inanimate things who speak and
act like people and their purpose is to enlighten the minds of children to events that can mold their
ways and attitudes. Example: THE MONKEY AND THE TURTLE
f. Anecdotes. These are merely products of the writer’s imagination and the main aim is to bring out
lessons to the reader. Example:THE MOTH AND THE LAMP
g. Essay. This expresses the viewpoint or opinion of the writer about a particular problem or event.
The best example of this is the Editorial page of a newspaper.
h. Biography. This deals with the life of a person which may be about himself, his autobiography or
that of others. Example: CAYETANO ARELLANO by Socorro O. Albert
i. News. This is a report of everyday events in society, government, science and industry, and
accidents, happening nationally or not.
j. Oration. This is a formal treatment of a subject and is intended to be spoken in public. It appeals
to the intellect, to the will or to the emotions of the audience.
II. POETRY
There are three types of poetry and these are the following:
A. Narrative Poetry. This form describes important events in life either real or imaginary.
The different varieties are:
1. Epic. This is an extended narrative about heroic exploits often under supernatural control.
Example:THE HARVEST SONG OF ALIGUYON translated in English by Amador T. Daguio
2. Metrical Tale. This is a narrative which is written in verse and can be classified either as a ballad or
a metrical romance. Examples: BAYANI NG BUKID by Al Perez HERO OF THE FIELDS by Al Perez
3. Ballads. Of the narrative poems, this is considered the shortest and simplest. It has a simple structure
and tells of a single incident. There are also variations of these: love ballads, war ballads, and sea
ballads, humorous, moral, and historical or mythical ballads. In the early time, this referred to a song
accompanying a dance.
B. Lyric Poetry. Originally, this refers to that kind of poetry meant to be sung to the accompaniment
of a lyre, but now, this applies to any type of poetry that expresses emotions and feelings of the poet.
They are usually short, simple and easy to understand.
1. Folksongs (Awiting Bayan). These are short poems intended to be sung. The common theme is love,
despair, grief, doubt, joy, hope and sorrow. Example: CHIT-CHIRIT-CHIT
2. Sonnets. This is a lyric poem of 14 lines dealing with an emotion, a feeling, or an idea. These are
two types: the Italian and the Shakespearean. Example: SANTANG BUDS by Alfonso P. Santos.
3. Elegy. This is a lyric poem which expresses feelings of grief and melancholy, and whose theme is
death. Example: THE LOVER’S DEATH by Ricaredo Demetillo
4. Ode. This is a poem of a noble feeling, expressed with dignity, with no definite number of syllables
or definite number of lines in a stanza.
5. Psalms (Dalit). This is a song praising God or the Virgin Mary and containing a philosophy of life.
6. Awit (Song). These have measures of twelve syllables (dodecasyllabic) and slowly sung to the
accompaniment of a guitar or banduria. Example: FLORANTE AT LAURA by Franciso Balagtas
7. Corridos (Kuridos). These have measures of eight syllables (octosyllabic) and recited to a martial
beat. Example: IBO NG ADARNA
C. Dramatic Poetry
1. Comedy. The word comedy comes from the Greek term “komos” meaning festivity or revelry. This
form usually is light and written with the purpose of amusing, and usually has a happy ending.
2. Melodrama. This is usually used in musical plays with the opera. Today, this is related to tragedy just
as the farce is to comedy. It arouses immediate and intense emotion and is usually sad but there is
a happy ending for the principal character.
3. Tragedy. This involves the hero struggling mightily against dynamic forces; he meets death or ruin
without success and satisfaction obtained by the protagonist in a comedy.
4. Farce. This is an exaggerated comedy. It seeks to arouse mirth by laughable lines; situations are too
ridiculous to be true; the characters seem to be caricatures and the motives undignified and absurd.
5. Social Poems. This form is either purely comic or tragic and it pictures the life of today. It may aim to
bring about changes in the social conditions.
Types of Drama
Let us consider a few popular types of drama:
Comedy – Comedies are lighter in tone than ordinary works, and provide a happy conclusion. The
intention of dramatists in comedies is to make their audience laugh. Hence, they use quaint
circumstances, unusual characters, and witty remarks.
Tragedy – Tragic dramas use darker themes, such as disaster, pain, and death. Protagonists often
have a tragic flaw — a characteristic that leads them to their downfall.
Farce – Generally, a farce is a nonsensical genre of drama, which often overacts or engages
slapstick humor.
Melodrama – Melodrama is an exaggerated drama, which is sensational and appeals directly to the
senses of the audience. Just like the farce, the characters are of a single dimension and simple, or
may be stereotyped.
Musical Drama – In musical dramas, dramatists not only tell their stories through acting and
dialogue, but through dance as well as music. Often the story may be comedic, though it may also
involve serious subjects.
Examples of Drama in Literature
Example #1: Much Ado About Nothing (By William Shakespeare)
Much Ado About Nothing is the most frequently performed Shakespearian comedy in modern times. The
play is romantically funny, in that love between Hero and Claudio is laughable, as they never even get a
single chance to communicate on-stage until they get married.
Their relationship lacks development and depth. They end up merely as caricatures, exemplifying what
people face in life when their relationships are internally weak. Love between Benedick and Beatrice is
amusing, as initially their communications are very sparky, and they hate each other. However, they all of
sudden make up, and start loving each other.
Function of Drama
Drama is one of the best literary forms through which dramatists can directly speak to their readers, or
the audience, and they can receive instant feedback of audiences. A few dramatists use their characters
as a vehicle to convey their thoughts and values, such as poets do with personas, and novelists do with
narrators. Since drama uses spoken words and dialogues, thus language of characters plays a vital role, as
it may give clues to their feelings, personalities, backgrounds, and change in feelings. In dramas the
characters live out a story without any comments of the author, providing the audience a direct presentation
of characters’ life experiences.
Reading requires concentration and patience, attributes that students find increasingly difficult in
modern times. Boredom can emerge very quickly, and students are no longer accustomed to working on one
activity for a long period of time, which reading entails. This reality is a beneficial for language educators and
acquirers, as working with texts of personal interests can be highly motivational (McCormick, 2007).
Language teachers can draw from any conceivable topic or genre that is of interest to acquirers.
Fiction
Fiction is a written work which made by someone based on imagination. Fiction is a part of literature
involves feeling and human sense. People read fiction for pleasure. The elements of fiction bring the reader
to an imaginative worlds, enlarge our understanding of ourselves, and deepen our appreciation of life. A work
of fiction implies the inventive construction of an imaginary world and, most commonly, its fictionality is
publicly acknowledged, so its audience typically expects it to deviate in some ways from the real world rather
than presenting only characters who are actual people or portrayals that are factually true. Fiction is generally
understood as not fully adhering to the real world, which consequently leaves its themes and its context, such
as if and how it relates to the real world or real issues, open to various interpretations. Characters and events
within some fictional works may even exist in their own context entirely separate from the known physical
universe: an independent fictional universe.
Traditionally, fiction includes novels, short stories, fables, legends, myths, fairy tales, epic and
narrative poetry, plays (including operas, musicals, dramas, puppet plays, and various kinds of theatrical
dances). However, fiction may also encompass comic books, and many animated cartoons, stop motions,
anime, manga, films, video games, radio programs, television programs (comedies and dramas), etc.
The Internet has had a major impact on the creation and distribution of fiction, calling into question
the feasibility of copyright as a means to ensure royalties are paid to copyright holders. Also, digital libraries
such as Project Gutenberg make public domain texts more readily available. The combination of inexpensive
home computers, the Internet, and the creativity of its users has also led to new forms of fiction, such as
interactive computer games or computer-generated comics. Countless forums for fan fiction can be found
online, where loyal followers of specific fictional realms create and distribute derivative stories. The Internet
is also used for the development of blog fiction, where a story is delivered through a blog either as flash fiction
or serial blog, and collaborative fiction, where a story is written sequentially by different authors, or the entire
text can be revised by anyone using a wiki.
Types of literary fiction in prose are distinguished by relative length and include:
Short story: the boundary between a long short story and a novella is vague,[13] though a short story
is commonly fewer than 7,500 words
Novella: 17,500 to 40,000 words long is typical; examples include Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange
Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde (1886) or Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness (1899)[14]
Novel: 40,000 words or more in length
Fiction is commonly broken down into a variety of genres: subsets of fiction, each differentiated by a
particular unifying tone or style; set of narrative techniques, archetypes, or other tropes; media content; or
other popularly defined criterion. Science fiction, for example, predicts or supposes technologies that are not
realities at the time of the work's creation: Jules Verne's novel From the Earth to the Moon was published in
1865 while in 1969 astronauts Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first persons to land on the Moon.
Historical fiction places imaginary characters into real historical events. In the 1814 historical novel
Waverley, Sir Walter Scott's fictional character Edward Waverley meets a figure from history, Bonnie Prince
Charlie, and takes part in the Battle of Prestonpans. Some works of fiction are slightly or greatly re-imagined
based on some originally true story, or a reconstructed biography.[15] Often, even when the fictional story is
based on fact, there may be additions and subtractions from the true story to make it more interesting. An
example is Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried, a 1990 series of short stories about the Vietnam War.
Fictional works that explicitly involve supernatural, magical, or scientifically impossible elements are
often classified under the genre of fantasy, including Lewis Carroll's 1865 novel Alice's Adventures in
Wonderland, J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter series, and J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. Creators of
fantasy sometimes introduce imaginary creatures and beings such as dragons and fairies
Historical fiction places imaginary characters into real historical events. In the 1814 historical novel
Waverley, Sir Walter Scott's fictional character Edward Waverley meets a figure from history, Bonnie Prince
Charlie, and takes part in the Battle of Prestonpans. Some works of fiction are slightly or greatly re-imagined
based on some originally true story, or a reconstructed biography.[15] Often, even when the fictional story is
based on fact, there may be additions and subtractions from the true story to make it more interesting. An
example is Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried, a 1990 series of short stories about the Vietnam War.
Fictional works that explicitly involve supernatural, magical, or scientifically impossible elements are
often classified under the genre of fantasy, including Lewis Carroll's 1865 novel Alice's Adventures in
Wonderland, J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter series, and J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. Creators of
fantasy sometimes introduce imaginary creatures and beings such as dragons and fairies. In contrast to
fiction is its traditional opposite: non-fiction, in which the creator assumes responsibility for presenting only
the historical and factual truth. Despite the usual distinction between fiction and non-fiction, some modern
works blur the boundary, particularly ones that fall under certain experimental storytelling genres—including
some postmodern fiction, autofiction,[8] or creative nonfiction like non-fiction novels and docudramas—as
well as deliberate literary frauds, which are falsely marketed as nonfiction
Fiction generally is a narrative form, in any medium, consisting of people, events, or places that are
imaginary—in other words, not based strictly on history or fact. In its most narrow usage, fiction refers to
written narratives in prose and often specifically novels, though also novellas and short stories. More broadly,
fiction has come to encompass imaginary narratives expressed in any form, including not just writings but
also live theatrical performances, films, television programs, radio dramas, comics, role-playing games, and
video games.
By reading fiction, the students are confronted with the culture, customs and lifestyles of the countries
where the language is spoken, and can learn many interesting facts to enrich their studies and knowledge. It
is true that the world‘ of a novel, play or short story is a created one, yet it offers a full and vivid context in
which characters from many social backgrounds can be depicted. A reader can discover their thoughts,
feelings, customs, and possessions: what they buy, believe in, fear, enjoy; how they speak and behave
behind closed doors. (Collie and Slater in Thomas, H. 2000).
Non-Fiction
Non-fiction is a written work that actually happened. Nonfiction presents interesting details and
information about something and have many purposes— for example, to inform people some facts or to
explain how something occurred. All written works other than imaginative prose (fiction) are considered
nonfiction. Nonfiction (also spelled non-fiction) is any document or media content that intends, in good faith,
to present only truth and accuracy regarding information, events, or people. Nonfictional content may be
presented either objectively or subjectively. Sometimes taking the form of a story, nonfiction is one of the
fundamental divisions of narrative writing (specifically, prose)— in contrast to fiction, which offers information,
events, or characters expected to be partly or largely imaginary, or else leaves open if and how the work
refers to reality.
The numerous literary and creative devices used within fiction are generally thought inappropriate
for use in nonfiction. They are still present particularly in older works but they are often muted so as not to
overshadow the information within the work. Simplicity, clarity and directness are some of the most important
considerations when producing nonfiction. Audience is important in any artistic or descriptive endeavor, but
it is perhaps most important in nonfiction. In fiction, the writer believes that readers will make an effort to
follow and interpret an indirectly or abstractly presented progression of theme, whereas the production of
nonfiction has more to do with the direct provision of information. Understanding of the potential readers' use
for the work and their existing knowledge of a subject are both fundamental for effective nonfiction. Despite
the claim to truth of nonfiction, it is often necessary to persuade the reader to agree with the ideas and so a
balanced, coherent and informed argument is vital. However, the boundaries between fiction and nonfiction
are continually blurred and argued upon, especially in the field of biography; as Virginia Woolf said: "if we
think of truth as something of granite-like solidity and of personality as something of rainbow-like intangibility
and reflect that the aim of biography is to weld these two into one seamless whole, we shall admit that the
problem is a stiff one and that we need not wonder if biographers, for the most part failed to solve it."
Semi-fiction is fiction implementing a great deal of nonfiction, e.g. a fictional description based on a
true story. Common literary examples of nonfiction include expository, argumentative, functional, and opinion
pieces; essays on art or literature; biographies; memoirs; journalism; and historical, scientific, technical, or
economic writings (including electronic ones). Journals, photographs, textbooks, travel books, blueprints, and
diagrams are also often considered nonfictional.[citation needed] Including information that the author knows
to be untrue within any of these works is usually regarded as dishonest. Other works can legitimately be
either fiction or nonfiction, such as journals of self-expression, letters, magazine articles, and other
expressions of imagination. Though such works are mostly either or the other, a blend of both is also possible.
Some fiction may include nonfictional elements. Some nonfiction may include elements of unverified
supposition, deduction, or imagination for the purpose of smoothing out a narrative, but the inclusion of open
falsehoods would discredit it as a work of nonfiction. The publishing and bookselling business sometimes
uses the phrase "literary nonfiction" to distinguish works with a more literary or intellectual bent, as opposed
to the greater collection of nonfiction subjects.
Nonfiction's specific factual assertions and descriptions may or may not be accurate, and can give
either a true or a false account of the subject in question. However, authors of such accounts genuinely
believe or claim them to be truthful at the time of their composition or, at least, pose them to a convinced
audience as historically or empirically factual. Reporting the beliefs of others in a nonfiction format is not
necessarily an endorsement of the veracity of those beliefs, but rather an exercise in representing the topic.
Works of nonfiction need not necessarily be written text, since statements expressed by pictures or film can
also purport to present a factual account of a subject.
Students rarely select nonfiction materials such as newspapers, magazines, or informational
literature. The ability to read and extract information from nonfiction becomes increasingly important to a
student‘s academic success as the student progresses through school. Non-fiction is simply said all texts
that are not considered fiction. Fiction is an expression of creativity that is essentially imagined, whereas non-
fiction refers to reality, and the transfer of information of that reality. While it is true nonfiction is about finding
facts, deep understanding of expository material lies in seeing the big picture, identifying relationships, and
evaluating information (Benson, 2003). Moss (2003) in her book under the title Exploring the Literature of
Fact, suggested that the items needed to be successful in reading nonfiction include accessing quality
literature, learning reading strategies, understanding the use of text structure, and
responding to the literature. Nearly 80-90% of classroom reading before fourth
grade is fictional after which most classroom reading becomes nonfiction (Benson,
2003).
Maxim (1998 as cited in Harvey 2002) stated that the students should be
engaged in nonfiction by asking student to read fiction aloud, explore nonfiction to
satisfy curiosity, use nonfiction for instruction, read nonfiction to find out information, read nonfiction to do
research, skim nonfiction to answer questions, show particular features of nonfiction—the titles, headings,
bold print, graphs, charts—and point out the purpose of these text elements, and read nonfiction to write it
well.
FILIPINO AUTHORS
Top 10
Name: Carlo J. Caparas
Age: 57
Born on: December 15, 1958
Magno “Carlo” Jose Caparas, widely known as Carlo J. Caparas, is a Filipino comic strip creator/writer-
turned director and producer, who is best known for creating such Filipino superheroes and comic
book characters as Panday, Bakekang, Totoy Bato, Joaquin Bordado, Kamagong, Kamandag, Elias
Paniki, Tasya Fantasya, Gagambino, Pieta and Ang Babaeng Hinugot Sa Aking Tadyang, among others. He
is also known as a director of numerous massacre movies such as Kuratong Baleleng and The Cory
Quirino Kidnap: NBI Files. Caparas was awarded the 2008 Sagisag Balagtas Award.
His contribution to Philippine History and Entertainment Industry are beyond compare. He has contributed
numerous literary works that bought smiles and brough about lessons that we can use and apply in real-life
situations. He took a large step in moulding Philippine History that will ever remain in every Filipino’s Heart.
A few examples of his works that mainly contributed to Entertainment Industry;
Panday
Kamandag
Bakekang, and such
Top 9
Name: Mars Ravelo
Age: 71
Born on: October 9, 1916-September 12, 1988
Mars Ravelo was a Filipino graphic novelist who created the characters Darna, Dyesebel, Captain Barbell,
Lastikman, Bondying, Varga, Wanted: Perfect Mother, Hiwaga, Maruja, Mariposa, Roberta, Rita, Buhay
Pilipino, Jack and Jill, Flash Bomba, Tiny Tony, and Dragonna among others.
Mars Ravelo had greatly contributed countless literary pieces mainly in entertainment industry. He helped
mold our imagination and even told the Filipino youth,
“Be what you want to be. Make your imagination as the source of your success.”
Most Remarkable Pieces:
Darna
Dyesebel
Lastikman
Top 8
Name: Louie Mar Cangcuangco
Age: 29
Born on: March 26, 1987
Dr. Louie Mar Gangcuangco is an HIV researcher, best-selling novelist, and one of the youngest licensed
physicians from the Philippines. He is the author of the multi-awarded Filipino novel Orosa-Nakpil,
Malate and is currently working as a clinical research associate for the Hawaii Center for AIDS. He made a
novel mainly about erotica, but gave lessons and reflected on what’s happening in our generation.
Most Remarkable Piece:
Orosa-Nakpil, Malate
Top 7
Name: Gilda Olvidado
Age: 59
Born on: August 9, 1957
Gilda Olvidado, from Cebu City, Cebu, is a Filipino movie and television writer, and melodrama novelist. Her
novels have been turned into live-action movies by VIVA Films, and also been remade for television
through Sine Novela.
Olvidado had contributed greatly in Entertainment Industry through her novel-turned movies. She had kept
us well-entertained by making absolute pieces.
Most Remarkable Piece:
Huwag Mo Kaming Isumpa (1981, novel)
Sinasamba Kita (1982, novel)
Kung Mahawi Man Ang Ulap (1984, novel)
Top 6
Name: Nick Joaquin
Age: 87
Born on: May 4, 1917-April 29, 2004
Nicomedes Márquez Joaquín was a Filipino writer, historian and journalist, best known for
his short stories and novels in the English language. He also wrote using the pen
name Quijano de Manila. Joaquín was conferred the rank and title of National Artist of
the Philippines for Literature. He is considered one of the most important Filipino writers
in English, and the third most important overall, after José Rizal and Claro M. Recto.
Most Remarkable Pieces:
May Day Eve (1947)
Prose and Poems (1952)
The Woman Who had Two Navels (1961)
La Naval de Manila and Other Essays (1964)
A Portrait of the Artist as Filipino (1966)
Top 5
Name: Lualhati Bautista
Age: 71
Born on: December 2, 1945
Bautista was born in Tondo, Manila, Philippines on December 2, 1945 to Esteban Bautista and Gloria Torres.
She graduated from Emilio Jacinto Elementary School in 1958, and from Torres High
School in 1962 being a lowest in her class. She was a journalism student at the Lyceum
of the Philippines, but dropped out for the reason of failed grades. She started her
writing career in the Liwayway magazine. Despite a lack of formal training, Bautista as
the writer became known for her honest realism, courageous exploration of Philippine
women’s issues, and her compelling female protagonists, who confront difficult
situations at home and in the workplace with uncommon grit and strength.
Most Remarkable Piece/s:
Bulaklak sa City Jail
Dekada ’70
Bata, Bata… Pa’no Ka Ginawa?
‘GAPÔ
Sixty in the City
In Sisterhood
Top 4
Name: F. Sionil Jose
Age: 92
Born on: December 3, 1924
José attended the University of Santo Tomas after World War II, but dropped out and plunged into writing
and journalism in Manila. In subsequent years, he edited various literary and journalistic publications, started
a publishing house, and founded the Philippine branch of PEN, an international organization for writers. José
received numerous awards for his work. The Pretenders is his most popular novel, which is the story of one
man’s alienation from his poor background and the decadence of his wife’s wealthy family.[3][4] José Rizal‘s
life and writings profoundly influenced José’s work. The five volume Rosales Saga, in particular, employs
and interrogates themes and characters from Rizal’s work. Throughout his career, José’s writings espouse
social justice and change to better the lives of average Filipino families. He is one of the most critically
acclaimed Filipino authors internationally, although much underrated in his own country because of his
authentic Filipino English and his anti-elite views.
Most Remarkable Piece/s:
Po-on (Source) (1984) ISBN 971-8845-10-0
The Pretenders (1962) ISBN 971-8845-00-3
My Brother, My Executioner (1973) ISBN 971-8845-16-X
Mass (December 31, 1974) ISBN 0-86861-572-2
Tree (1978) ISBN 971-8845-14-3
Top 3
Name: Fransisco Balagtas
Age: 73
Born on: April 2, 1788-February 20, 1862
Balagtas learned to write poetry from José de la Cruz (Huseng Sisiw), one of the most famous poets
of Tondo, in return of chicks. It was De la Cruz himself who personally challenged Balagtas to improve his
writing. Balagtas swore he would overcome Huseng Sisiw as he would not ask anything in
return as a poet.
Upon his deathbed, he asked a favor that none of his children become poets like him, who
had suffered under his gift as well as under others. He even went as far as to tell them it
would be better to cut their hands off than let them be writers.
Most Remarkable Piece:
Florante at Laura
(Click for source)
Top 2
Name: Bob Ong
Age: Unknown
Born on: Unknown
Bob Ong, is the pseudonym of an anonymous Filipino contemporary author
known for using conversational Filipino to create humorous and reflective
depictions of life as a Filipino.
A Filipino Literary critic once commented:” Filipinos really patronize Bob Ong’s
works because, while most of his books may have an element of comedy in
them, this is presented in a manner that replicates Filipino culture and
traditions. This is likely the reason why his first book – and those that followed
it, can be considered true Pinoy classics.” The six books he has published thus far have surpassed a
quarter of a million copies. His words of wisdom were applied by some of the Filipinos to their daily lives.
Most Remarkable Piece:
Ang Paboritong Libro ni Hudas
Alamat ng Gubat
Top 1
Name: José Protasio Rizal Mercado y Alonso Realonda
Age: 35
Born on: June 19, 1861
From an early age, José showed a precocious intellect. He learned the alphabet
from his mother at 3, and could read and write at age 5. Upon enrolling at the Ateneo Municipal de Manila,
he dropped the last three names that made up his full name, on the advice of his brother, Pacianoand the
Mercado family, thus rendering his name as “José Protasio Rizal”. Of this, he later wrote: “My family never
paid much attention [to our second surname Rizal], but now I had to use it, thus giving me the appearance
of an illegitimate child!” This was to enable him to travel freely and disassociate him from his brother, who
had gained notoriety with his earlier links to Filipino priests Mariano Gomez, Jose Burgos and Jacinto
Zamora (popularly known as Gomburza) who had been accused and executed for treason.
Most Remarkable Pieces of Rizal:
El Filibusterismo
Noli Me Tangere
INTERNATIONAL WELL-KNOWN AUTHORS
Famous Authors
Authors throughout history have helped capture something about their lives, their era, and the society
around them. From Homer in the 8th century BC all the way until now, there is something in the works of
these authors that can capture our imagination and help us expand our knowledge. Here are some of the
greatest authors in history and a little something about the works that they created.
Homer (8th Century BC) Sun Tzu (544-496 BC) Virgil (70 BC-19 BC)
Nationality: Greek Nationality: Chinese Nationality: Roman
Known for: Iliad, Odyssey Known for: The Art of War Known for: Eclogues, Georgics,
Homer is considered to be the Sun Tzu was a military strategist in Aeneid
greatest of the ancient Greek poets ancient China. His book – The Art of Widely known as one of Rome’s
as he wrote two epic poems that still War – was written as a strategy for the greatest poets, Virgil had a major
live on today – the Iliad and Chinese military. It is still widely read influence on Western literature.
the Odyssey. These stories were today by leaders of armed forces. In The Aeneid is modeled after
epic poems that detailed Greek fact, it is on the list of recommended Homer’s works and it tells the
culture, including the geography, reading for the US Marine Corps and story of a Trojan, named Aeneas,
history, and ideals. It also set a other divisions of the military. who was adopted by the Romans.
precedence because other empires His work had such an impact that
wanted similar epic poems written Dante used him in his Divine
about their cultures. Comedy to guide him through
hell.
Alexandre Dumas (1802-1870) Edgar Allan Poe (1809-1849) Charles Dickens (1812-1870)
Nationality: French Nationality: American Nationality: English
Known for: The Count of Monte Known for: The Raven, The Pit and Known for: Oliver Twist, A Tale of
Cristo, The Three Musketeers the Pendulum, The Tell-Tale Heart Two Cities, A Christmas Carol
Dumas is one of the most prominent Poe was one of the premier writers Often referred to as the greatest
French writers with his historical during the Romantic Movement. novelist of Victorian times, Dickens
novels that tell of adventurous tales. His works are known for their had several works that were praised
Since the early 20th century, his mystery and grim themes, many of by critics and peers. His first
works have been made into about which include the death of one of recognized work was in 1836
200 movies. His complete works the characters. He is credited with with The Pickwick Papers. He helped
total 100,000 pages and due to the being the father of detective fiction popularize serial publications, which
level of success of his early works, as well as one of the early science meant pieces of his work were
he was able to be a full-time writer fiction writers. published in magazines in
and dedicate himself solely to installments.
writing.
References
Ahmed, A. (2017). Literature and It’s Influence on Human Life. Retrieved from:
http://data.conferenceworld.in/NCCW/P129-134.pdf
Chen, G. (2019). A Literature Review on Prose Study. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338246507_A_Literature_Review_on_Prose_Study
Haruna, A. (2019). The Use Of Fiction And Nonfiction Text In Reading Comprehension (A Comparative Study
At The Second Year Students Of Sman 8 Gowa).
Olila, B & Jantas J. (2006). Definition of Petry. Retrieved from:
https://joejantas.files.wordpress.com/2011/04/the-definition-of-poetry1.pdf
TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF
LITERATURE STUDIES (ELT 228)
LESSON 2
TEACHING LITERATURE – AN OVERVIEW
BACHELOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION MAJOR IN ENGLISH
TOPICS COVERED
Value of Literature
Factors Affecting Interests in Literature
Choosing Books and Reading Materials
Models of Teaching Literature
Language Model
Cultural Model
Personal Growth Model
Approaches to Teaching Literature
Language-Based Approach
Paraphrastic Approach
Moral-Philosophical Approach
Stylistics Approach
Levels of Comprehension Questions
Assessment Strategies in Teaching Literature
Prepared by
“Issues of value and evaluation tend to recur whenever literature, art, and other forms of cultural
activity become a focus of discussion, whether in informal or institutional context”, Barbara Herrnstein
Smith (1995: 177) observes at the beginning of her fine essay on the intricate and thorny topic of
“Value/Evaluation”. Debates about value(s) and evaluation, and the ethical dimension of literature have
indeed been perennial issues in literary criticism and literary theory, even “central to Western critical
theory for at least the past two hundred years” (ibid.). The last two decades, however, have witnessed a
renewed interest in the relationship between literature and values and the ethical dimension of literature,
culminating in what has been dubbed ‘the ethical turn’ and the re-emergence of ethical criticism. While
the developments and new perspectives subsumed under such umbrellas as ‘the ethical turn’, ‘ethical
criticism’ or ‘the ethics of criticism in the age after value’ have been mapped by a number of informative
surveys (cf. e.g. Antor 1996; Eaglestone 1997, 2003; Davis/Womack 2001), the complex and reciprocal
relationship between literature and value have not received as much attention as it arguably deserves:
“The importance of literature and other media for the dissemination of ethical values within a culture has
not yet been duly acknowledged and submitted to scrutiny” (Grabes 2008: 3-4).
The present volume seeks to redress the balance, not by providing yet another mapping of the
ethical turn or a meta-summary of the new perspectives and transformations that the renewed interest in
ethical criticism has brought about, but by looking more closely at the relationship between literature and
values and by exploring the characteristics, functions and roles of literary texts that make literature so
fascinating and valuable (cf. Erll/Grabes/Nünning 2008). The main goals of this introduction are to gauge
the relationship between literature and values, and to provide a provisional overview of some of the most
important functions of literature, while also giving a brief survey of the wide range of topics and
perspectives that the contributions that follow deal with and explore.
It is a truth universally acknowledged, of course, that the relationship between literature and
value, and the views that have been put forward about this topic, have themselves been subject to
historical change. While many authors, critics and theorists have maintained that the value of literature is
inseparable from the ways in which norms and values are represented, others have equally forcefully
asserted that the realms of art and moral values, or of aesthetics and ethics, are oceans apart and should
never be confused. In the ‘Preface’ to his equally famous and infamous novel The Picture of Dorian Gray,
Oscar Wilde, for example, bluntly proclaimed: “There is no such thing as a moral or an immoral book.
Books are well written or badly written. That is all.” Two more quotations from the Preface may serve to
show just how important it was for Wilde to dissociate literature as well as the other arts from morality
and ethical values:
The moral life of man forms part of the subject matter of the artist, but the morality of art consists
in the perfect use of an imperfect medium.
No artist has ethical sympathies. An ethical sympathy in an artist is an unpardonable mannerism
of style.
Whether or not Oscar Wilde and his works lived up to his own sayings, or to his immoral
reputation, may be open to debate (cf. V. Nünning 2002), but the majority of his contemporaries certainly
did not seem to share this avant-garde view of the aestheticists, who wanted to divorce literature and art
from morality once and for all. On the contrary, Wilde’s views were generally regarded as a challenge to
ingrained Victorian assumptions about the central function, and value, of literature. As is well known,
Wilde himself was severely taken to task later on in his life for having published what was regarded as
demoralising literature, and the alleged immorality of his novel was even publicly debated in court in order
to ‘prove’ that The Picture of Dorian Gray was an immoral book, which in turn served to demonstrate that
its author Oscar Wilde held immoral views himself. In doing so, the attorney and judge as well as a host
of commentators in the newspapers merely did what Victorians critics, publishers and readers had been
doing for decades, namely exploring in how far a given literary work served to disseminate Christian and
ethical values and to promote moral behaviour. Peter Keating (1989: 252) aptly described this “unwritten
code”: “They acquiesced in what amounted to a gigantic moral conspiracy with publishers, libraries,
reviewers, editors, and easily-shocked readers.” Though the case of Oscar Wilde is, of course, much
more complex than these brief observations may imply, they may suffice to illustrate that in the Victorian
fin-de-siècle, there was no longer an implicit general agreement on what the role of literature vis-à-vis
moral values was taken to be.
Several decades later, in the heyday of poststructuralism and postmodernism, widespread
agreement prevailed again, but amidst an era of poststructuralist relativism, readers and writers,
publishers and critics now seemed to agree that the realms of literature and morality were indeed two
entirely separate spheres. For a while it really seemed that we were living in an ‘Age after Value’ and that
the question of whether literature had anything to do with values seemed irrelevant at best, meaningless
at worst. Influential postmodern writers like John Barth, Donald Barthelme, Richard Brautigan, Robert
Coover or Thomas Pynchon foregrounded in their works the “Contingencies of Value” (1988) Barbara
Herrnstein Smith and many other critics presented as the most advanced view. Yet – as E. Ann Kaplan
pointed out in her otherwise friendly review of the book – “the preoccupation with context, with multiple
variables, with instability, and with historical accounting cannot, in themselves, explain gender and power
differentials” (Kaplan 1990: 53). How else to explain the radically different opinion held by many of her
American colleagues living under quite similar circumstances – as it became all too evident when
Herrnstein Smith raised a scandal when first presenting her view at an MLA convention and as it was
forcefully presented a few years later by Richard A. Etlin in his In Defense of Humanism: Value in the
Arts and Letters (1996).
The more poststructuralist and constructivist epistemology has made clear that our common
‘truths’ are to a previously unrealized extent culturally constructed, the more the necessity of values that
provide individual and communal orientation has become felt. At the same time, the weight of traditional
values has become more contested and the readiness of people to be directly preached to has diminished
considerably.
What therefore has become more important is the indirect promotion of values by supplying moral
models and presenting practical examples of human behaviour. This is a field in which literature and the
media seem to be particularly efficient because of their wide range of aesthetic possibilities and because
readers, listeners or viewers are less involved and more open to exterior influences than agents in the
life-world whose practical interest is at stake. When Richard Rorty sought to demonstrate that what we
need on account of our physical and psychic vulnerability to cope with contingency is solidarity (Rorty
1989), he reverted to literary examples instead of relying solely on his power of argumentation. As Wayne
C. Booth observed, “stories are our major moral teachers” (Booth 2001: 20). It is through narratives
and fictional worlds that we are sensitised to ethical questions and moral inquiries insofar as they open
up possible ways of life, which we can either subscribe to or reject. Literature and the media thus provide
the incentives for engaging in ethical discourse by confronting us with both admirable and corrupted
characters, triggering our moral reasoning in every character and each event they depict.
In order to be able to gauge the manifold and subtle ways in which literary texts can indirectly
disseminate values, the critic and cultural historian needs equally subtle theoretical and methodological
tools. Though the productiveness of the theory industry has been second to none, there are not very
many approaches that would aptly serve the critic interested in discerning values. One of them is the
ethical and rhetorical approach to narrative fiction pioneered by Wayne C. Booth and further developed
by James Phelan and Peter Rabinowitz. It is based on the hypothesis that narrative technique can have
profound ethical and moral implications and that writers use narrative and rhetorical strategies in order
to disseminate their world-view and hierarchy of values. As Wolfgang G. Müller (2008) has convincingly
demonstrated, narrative technique and point of view can have profound ethical implications.
Strategies of mediating moral values and alerting readers to moral issues and problems will be related to
basic modes of narration such as (1) authorial narration with an omniscient narrator, which provides a
moral orientation for the reader through comment and reflection; (2) point of view narration, which makes
it the reader’s task to decode the moral qualities of life, norms and values (manifested e.g. in social
interaction, texts in the literary tradition, and media of other symbolic systems). Secondly, literary texts
can represent valid, alternative or different norms and values by textual means and literary
techniques (configuration): Literary works sometimes disseminate, generate or project socially
sanctioned or desired, yet more often unsanctioned, excluded and repressed forms of life as well as their
underpinning values and norms. Therefore, they can be viewed as “experiments in life” (George Eliot;
cf. Nünning 2008), i.e. as models and test cases that generate possible worlds as well as idealized or
alternative hierarchies of values through a series of specifically aesthetic procedures or literary forms. In
turn, such literary productions of norms and values are, thirdly, able to have an effect on extra-
literary reality (refiguration): Literature, to no insignificant degree, has contributed (and still does so) to
the forming as well as the stabilization of norms and values, and social conceptions of a good life.
The essays in this volume focus both on the representation of cultural norms and values in
literature and on the construction-aspect of literature as an active medium in the generation or production
of norms and values. In doing so, they emphasize that the stages between prefiguration and configuration
on the one hand, and between configuration and refiguration on the other, are always inextricably
intertwined. Just as literature heavily draws on existent norms and values, which are translated into the
fictional sphere to be further investigated, expanded, or altered to probe their boundaries, society does
not only rely on literature for the dissemination of its values but also uses it for the affirmation of
its moral concepts and social norms. Literature, society and the media, therefore, engage in a dynamic
negotiation and exchange of norms and values, which are constructed, maintained, and revived in a
constant dialogue between them.
The first question to be addressed is of how, and with what literary methods or techniques,
cultural notions of norms and values are represented in a given text. From this perspective, literature
comes into view as a medium of the representation of extraliterary norms and values and as a
medium that is capable of constructing or generating new or alternative hierarchies of norms and
values. Secondly, literature has always served as a medium for the dissemination of norms and
values, be it those generally accepted by society or alternative values. Thirdly, therefore, literature
appears as a medium for the construction of norms and values. Another question to be addressed
concerns the connections between configuration and refiguration: What functions can literature fulfil for
the development, modelling, alteration, critique, and even destruction of norms and values (cf. Zapf 2001,
2002)?
Two dimensions of the relations of literary works to extra-literary norms and values – and thus
also two fundamental directions for the special potential of literature in culture – should therefore come
into focus: The first dimension concerns the specific potential of the medium of literature, through its
aesthetic forms, to thematise, represent, and disseminate norms and values in their cultural contexts.
Secondly, and deriving from the aesthetic form, the potential of the medium of literature as well as of
other media to actively construct and generate norms and values, as well as to question and critique,
prevailing value-hierarchies and collective views of what constitutes a ‘good life’ is also of interest. In
short, the focus of this volume is on exploring the role of literature as a medium of the representation and
reflection, the dissemination and problematising, and the modelling and construction of norms and values.
In order to avoid possible misunderstandings we should like to emphasize that the concept of
‘mimesis,’ however, does not refer to a naïve concept of mere reflection, but rather to theoretical concepts
emphasizing the active creation of realities or worldmodels (‘poiesis’), or of norms and values, through
literary texts and other media. Though literary texts are simultaneously characterized by a reference to
extra-literary reality, as emphasized unanimously, albeit with a basis in different concepts, by Paul
Ricœur, Wolfgang Iser and Jürgen Link and others, they never merely reflect cultural models or norms
and values (cf. Kövecses 1999, 2006). Ricœur (1984 [1983]) makes clear that the creation of world-
models or versions of reality through literary works rests on dynamic transformation processes – on an
interaction among the “prefiguration” of the text, that is, its reference to the pre-existent extra-textual
world (mimesis); the textual “configuration” that creates a fictional object (mimesis II); and the
“refiguration” by the reader (mimesis III). The literary process thus appears as an active constructive
process, in which cultural systems of meaning, literary processes of formal configuration and
practices of reception are equally involved and in which reality is not merely reflected, but instead
first poetically created (cf. ibid.: 107) and then “iconically enriched” (cf. 127).
To sum up: The symbolic order of the extra-literary reality, e.g. of norms and values that
actually exist in the real world, and the literary or possible worlds created within the medium of
literature enter into a relationship of mutual influence and change. Ricœur’s “circle of mimesis” can
thus contribute to a differentiation among different levels of the relationship between literature and values:
First, literary works are related to extra-literary norms and values (prefiguration); second, they
represent norms and values, their content and functioning, in the medium of fiction
(configuration); and third, they can help form new norms and values (refiguration). What
perspectives are opened up through such an examination for the analysis and interpretation of novels,
plays and poetry as well as of other media from the point of view of a literary studies focussing on the
value(s) and functions of literature?
Conclusion
Values are established in a dynamic dialogue between reader and text, which involves
empathy and the ability to reflect on one’s emotional response. Intuitive and sensual reactions
therefore have to be taken into account when assessing the ethical dimension of literature. Pure
reasoning, however, would be insufficient as literature, unlike science, often does not follow the rules of
pure logic. Nor does its specific effect derive from explicit ethical values but its ‘value’, as well as the
value of all art, lies in what Ronald Shusterman refers to as a “metaethical dimension”, which involves
the evaluation, interpretation, and judgement by the reader. It is a characteristic of making errors: The
interpretation of another person and another life embraces the potentiality of misinterpretation and it is
this experience of ‘strangeness’ and alterity which characterises the ethical dimension of complex
literature. Misreadings seem to be precluded, however, whenever we are confronted with literary
characters that are pushed to their existential limits in torture or in humiliation. These situations seem to
evoke a return to and reflection of intrinsic (in the Kantian sense) values, which can be regarded as
transcendental or as parts of a shared value system which regulates our being-in-the-world, and whose
applicability is reflected in numerous modern narratives and becomes seminal in de Kretser’s and
Coetzee’s novels (Philipp Wolf). The neglect of these intrinsic values in times of war, in violent oppression
and torture causes traumatic experiences which have become a key theme in contemporary fiction
(Susana Onega). The Holocaust, the Vietnam War as well as the two World Wars have become
frequent topics of twentieth-century novels, a fact which underlines the ethical dimension of
literature and furthermore shifts the focus to the function of memory in the discourse on norms
and values.
Considering that a certain spatial and temporal distance is indispensable for adequately
evaluating the actions and lives of others, the literary memoir seems a particularly apt genre for
investigating the intersection of the aesthetic and ethical dimension of literary texts while, at the same
time, foregrounding the responsibility of the author in the process of life-writing and literary worldmaking
(Katarzyna Kuczma). The author’s task thereby is less to explicitly state ethical issues or weave
allegorical plots but – as Roger D. Sell argues referring to the poetry of William Wordsworth – the
dissemination of values rests on the art of ‘genuine communication’, a communication which is uncoercive
and timeless insofar as it is not only addressed to readers of a specific era but embraces qualities of a
universal language which continues to attract people of different eras and cultures. Poetry appears as a
popular and effective medium not only for the communication but also for the construction of imperial,
religious and political values. Thus, as Birgit Neumann’s article shows, in eighteenth-century Britain, for
instance, a whole net of imperial poetry can be identified which was highly charged with political and
moral values and served to promote and consolidate the greatness of the empireProviding new
perspectives on the relationship between literature and value(s), the articles in this volume not only
explore historical changes and developments in the assessment of the value of literature. They also attest
and contribute to the ongoing dialogue between, and interdependence of, the extra-literary world and the
possible worlds of literature in prefiguring, manifesting, and disseminating norms and values. Besides
offering new insights into the relationship between values and literature, this volume aims to promote new
approaches to an interdisciplinary field of research, which is still one of the most controversial and, at the
same time, most fruitful and fascinating areas in literary and cultural studies
Literature, however, is but one effective vehicle for the formation and dissemination of
values: In the global and multimedia village, digital media play a seminal role in our daily lives, providing
alternative worlds and experiments that illustrate how to do things with norms and values. As Kirsten Pohl
argues, computer games use very specific narrative strategies to promote and simulate behavioural rules,
actions and ethical judgements, some of which raise the question of the moral boundaries of computer
simulation. The breaking of certain ethical norms in the digital or in the real world does not, however,
necessarily undermine society’s value system: It may as well necessitate a re-negotiation of existent
values which ultimately serves their stabilisation. Sonja Altnöder and Martin Zierold present an argument
for the usefulness of media scandals and social mechanisms which arise from a blatant violation of
prevailing values and for that very reason are likely to provoke a discussion and re-evaluation of social
norms and even a reconciliation of conflicting sets of values in society.
Providing new perspectives on the relationship between literature and value(s), the articles in
this volume not only explore historical changes and developments in the assessment of the value of
literature. They also attest and contribute to the ongoing dialogue between, and interdependence of, the
extra-literary world and the possible worlds of literature in prefiguring, manifesting, and disseminating
norms and values. Besides offering new insights into the relationship between values and literature, this
volume aims to promote new approaches to an interdisciplinary field of research, which is still one of the
most controversial and, at the same time, most fruitful and fascinating areas in literary and cultural
studies.
3. Students' Needs
There has been a great deal of agreement among researcher about the importance of
considering students' needs in the material selection process for the ESL-EFL reading class. Gebhard
states that the teachers should always discover the students' needs before making any decisions about
the course content. Similarly, Gray says that the teacher should be aware of the students' needs to be
able to help them fulfill these needs by providing appropriate materials. According to Grellet, there are
certain needs that all the students have in addition to their individual needs. For instance, all students
need to be able to read fast, to time themselves, to know basic reading techniques, and others. Educators
must then take into account common needs as well as the individual needs in the process of material
selection. The mismatch between students' expectations in regards to their needs and interests can result
in students' frustration, which might imply failure on a reading course.
1. Relevance
Choosing reading materials wisely also implies considering the text itself. The topic, the type of
text and the information it sustains make the text relevant. Students must find that the reading material
used in the course is relevant for their professional lives. Richards mentions that the readings should be
related to real world reading purposes. For this reason, it is necessary to involve the learners to contribute
to the reading selection process. Permitting the students to contributing will certainly benefit the educator
as well. Gebhard asserts that “understanding the needs of students in specific fields can provide the
means through which materials can be selected and created.” The teachers can determine how
appropriate the reading materials are by considering whether they are relevant to the leamer or not
(Lotherington). If the instructor carefully selects pertinent reading material for the EFL class, the students
are more likely to be interested in the class and will probably be anxious to use diverse strategies to
comprehend the material.
2. Content
Fox and others agree that the most important criterion for selecting reading material for the ESL
class is content. They affirm that if the selected content is interesting for the students, they will be
successful in the reading process no matter how difficult the text might be. When the students are required
to read a complex text that is at the same time interesting for them or that refers to knowledge required
in other classes, they will probably make more effort to comprehend it, and they will probably use a variety
of strategies to digest it.
In order to select reading material with appropriate contents, it is necessary to take the students'
interests and needs into account. This can be done by asking the students to make a list of topics that
they will study in their specific fields or that they would like to read for fun. A good selection of readings
can result from asking the students to bring their own material to the class. Students could then devote
some class time to studying this material. Teachers might want to get copies of the readings and classify
them according to field of study for future reference.
3. Authenticity
Some researchers regard authenticity as another important criterion for the selection of readings
for the ESL/EFL class. However, whether the material used for ESL/EFL classes should be authentic or
not has been widely questioned by those who advocate the use of teacher-made materials. Among those
who advocate the use of authentic material, Melvin & Stout state that teachers should take full advantage
of the potential benefits of authentic materials. In a like manner, Gebhard points out that authenticity
should be part of the criteria taken into account when selecting appropriate reading material for ESL
classes.
The rationale for selecting authentic material may include the following:
Students need to be able to comprehend real-life language.
Teachers can take advantage of the grammatical aspects found in the texts.
Students will be prepared to read any type of text.
The fact that language is simplified does not ensure comprehension.
We can provide the students with different strategies to ensure a better comprehension.
It is better to simplify the reading process, rather than the text.
On the other hand, there are researchers and practitioners who consider that teachers should
create their own reading materials or adapt existing ones. Researchers such as Lotherington-Woloszcyn
and Cray justify the adaptation of reading materials in order to satisfy students' needs.
The reasons that they have provided for the use of simplified texts are as follows:
Adapting materials can make them accessible, interesting and informative.
Arranging materials around one theme allows the learner to build up background knowledge of
the content.
Attention should be given to what the learners find easy and interesting.
If the text is poorly presented, it can always be improved.
Teacher-created materials are based on authentic texts.
They allow teachers to evaluate their students.
Teachers must be open minded and carefully analyze the
advantages and disadvantages of using both commercial and teacher made materials; in this
way they can make informed decisions with
Conclusion
The purpose of selecting reading materials wisely for the ESL/EFL class implies the teacher
awareness as well as student's involvement in the material selection process. ESL/EFL teachers are
expected to provide students with appropriate reading materials. For this reason, the reading selection
process should be a thoughtful process of carefully consideration to those factors involved in this process.
In this important process of selecting the material for a reading class, the teacher cannot neglect the
students' level, interests, needs and background knowledge in order to consider text difficulty, content
and authenticity.
This text selection process requires some effort on the instructor. Some form of assessment is
crucial in order to compile an appropriate set of reading materials for the class: a survey, an informal
discussion, individual interviews, or any other form of inquiry can give the instructors some insight of what
type of materials to select for each particular class. Selecting appropriate reading materials for the
ESL/EFL class is certainly time consuming, but it is really beneficial for the students as well as the
teacher. Smith points out that "for beginners and experienced readers alike, there is always the possibility
of fluent reading and the possibility of difficult reading.” Consequently, the teacher can enhance the
reading process by providing the students
with appropriate texts.
MODELS OF TEACHING LITERATURE
What is literature in language teaching, and why should teachers use it?
There are a good many reasons for teachers to use literature in the language classroom. For a
range of readings see Brumfit and Carter (1986) for an introduction, Sage (1975) for a how-to guide that
manages to be both well-researched and directly practical, and Hall (2005) for an overview of research
trends. The likely benefits can be usefully considered in relation to Carter and Long’s (1991) three models
of why teachers use literature: the cultural model, the language model, and the personal growth model.
From the above discussion, it can be said that these three models of teaching literature differ in
terms of their focus on texts. In the language model, texts are used as a focus for grammatical and
structural analysis; in the cultural model, texts are used as cultural artifacts, and in the personal growth
model, texts are considered a stimulus for personal growth activities. Each approach has different
strengths and weaknesses. For example, Savvidou (2004) comments that the cultural model tends to be
teacher-centered, and there is little opportunity for extended language work. Therefore, what is needed
is an integrated approach model comprising key elements of all three models so that literature becomes
accessible to EFL students and most beneficial for their development.
APPROACHES TO TEACHING LITERATURE
Language-Based Approach
This approach is closely related to the Language Model presented by Carter and Long (1991)
where literary texts are seen as means to helping students’ improve language proficiency. This is done
by providing them exposure to the target language and connecting them to specific vocabulary and other
aspects of the language. A. Maley and Duff (1990) insist that the primary aim of this approach is “quite
simply to use literary texts as a resource for stimulating language activities”. With the use of language-
based approaches, the focus shifted to the learner, the reading process and creating language
awareness in the learners (Too Wei Keong 2007). In line with this approach, a language-based framework
for reading literary texts is proposed by McRae (1991) and McRae and Vethamani (1999) which moves
from lexis (vocabulary), syntax (sentences) to coherence (discourse). It also focuses on phonology
(sounds), graphology (visual effect of the text), semantics (meaning), dialect (variations of standard
English), register (tone), period (archaisms) and function (message in the text).
The following can help teachers employ this approach:
Guide students to express their opinions towards a text
Set language activities in literature lesson
Encourage students to actively participate in the process of understanding the meaning of text
Students work with their classmates in the process of understanding the text
Generate language practice using the text
Activities that can be employed by teachers:
Group work
Language activities (cloze, jigsaw puzzle, prediction exercises)
Debate
Performance activities (drama, role play, poetry recital)
Paraphrastic Approach
This approach deals with the surface meaning of the text (Diana Hwang & Amin Embi 2007).
Rosli (1995) asserts that it allows teachers to use simpler words and sentence structures compared to
the more complicated ones in the texts and sometimes the teacher can translate it into other languages.
He argued further that this approach is suitable for beginners of the target language as it acts as a
stepping stone in formulating original assumptions of the author’s work.
The following can help teachers employ this approach:
Re-tell the text to students to help them understand
Use simple terms to explain what the story is about to students
Discuss what the author says in the text
Get students to tell the storyline of the text
Activities that can be employed by teachers:
Translation of text using L1
Re-tell story to students
Students read paraphrased notes in the workbook/handouts
Students re-tell story to the class
Moral-Philosophical Approach
This is an approach which incorporates moral values across curriculum. The focus of this
approach is to discover moral values while reading a particular literary text (Diana Hwang & Amin Embi
2007). It seeks to find the worthiness of moral and philosophical considerations behind one’s reading
(Rosli 1995). Ministry of Education has outlined moral values to be inculcated among secondary school
students such as being independent, being honest, being grateful, and respecting others.
The following can help teachers employ this approach:
Incorporate moral values in lessons
Ask students the values they learn from the text
Get students to search moral values from a text
Raise students' awareness of values derived from the text
Activities that can be employed by teachers:
Reflective sessions
Discussions on moral dilemmas
Tell moral values to students
Conduct self-evaluation activities
Stylistic Approach
Stylistics is a distinctive term that may be used to determine the connections between the form
and the effects within a particular variety of language. Therefore, stylistics looks at what is ‘going on’
within the language, what the linguistic associations are that style of language reveals. It plays a vital role
in teaching of literature. Really, the purpose of stylistics is to develop readers’ interpretative procedures
rather than make them dependent on the told meanings.
As Widdoson has stated, “stylistics provides a basis of aesthetic appreciation by bringing it to the
level of conscious awareness, features of the text otherwise will be assessable only to trained individuals”.
Thus, the aim of stylistics is to characterize text as a piece of communication. There are two reasons for
the concern that stylistics shows towards a literary text. They are : (i)methodological, which relates to the
nature of literature , and (ii) pedagogical, which relates to the values that stylistic analysis has for teaching
purposes. This fact brings us to consider how far stylistics is helpful in the investigation of language items
used in the text and how it develops interpretative procedures in readers’ minds.
The following can help teachers employ this approach:
Guide students to interpret a text by looking at the language used by the author
Get students to mark any linguistic features from the text that are significant to their reading
My literature lesson looks at the language of the text, thus, encourages language awareness
Encourage students to discuss beyond the surface meaning of the text
Activities that can be employed by teachers
Identify linguistics features (eg. vocabulary, tenses) in a text
Discuss different meanings of a text
Extract examples from a text that describe a setting
Identify adjectives that describe a character
LEVELS OF COMPREHENSION QUESTIONS
Types of Comprehension
The six types of comprehension proposed and discussed by Day & Park (2005) this taxonomy
has been influenced in particular by the work of Pearson and Johnson (1972) and Nuttall (1996).
1. Literal comprehension
Literal comprehension refers to an understanding of the straightforward meaning of the text, such
as facts, vocabulary, dates, times, and locations. Questions of literal comprehension can be answered
directly and explicitly from the text. In our experiences working with teachers, we have found that they
often check on literal comprehension first to make sure that their students have understood the basic
or surface meaning of the text.
An example of a literal comprehension question about this article is: How many types of
comprehension do the authors discuss?
2. Reorganization
The next type of comprehension is reorganization. Reorganization is based on a literal
understanding of the text; students must use information from various parts of the text and combine
them for additional understanding. For example, we might read at the beginning of a text that a woman
named Maria Kim was born in 1945 and then later at the end of the text that she died in 1990. In order
to answer this question, How old was Maria Kim when she died?, the student has to put together two
pieces of information that are from different parts of the text.
Questions that address this type of comprehension are important because they teach students
to examine the text in its entirety, helping them move from a sentence-by-sentence consideration of
the text to a more global view. In our experience, students generally find reorganization questions
somewhat more difficult than straightforward literal comprehension questions.
3. Inference
Making inferences involves more than a literal understanding. Students may initially have a
difficult time answering inference questions because the answers are based on material that is in the
text but not explicitly stated. An inference involves students combining their literal understanding of the
text with their own knowledge and intuitions.
An example of a question that requires the reader to make an inference is: Are the authors of
this article experienced language teachers? The answer is not in the text but there is information in the
third paragraph, page 2 of this article that allows the reader to make a good inference: "These types of
comprehension and forms of questions are a result of our work in teaching foreign language reading
and in developing materials for teaching foreign language reading." Readers are required to use their
knowledge of the field, teaching foreign language reading, with what they have gained from reading
the article, in particular that sentence, to construct an appropriate answer. That is, readers might
understand that newcomers to the profession generally do not develop materials or write articles, so
the authors are probably experienced language teachers.
4. Prediction
The fourth comprehension type, prediction, involves students using both their understanding of
the passage and their own knowledge of the topic and related matters in a systematic fashion to
determine what might happen next or after a story ends. We use two varieties of prediction, while-
reading and post- (after) reading. While-reading prediction questions differ from post-reading prediction
questions in that students can immediately learn the accuracy of their predictions by continuing to read
the passage.
For example, students could read the first two paragraphs of a passage and then be asked a
question about what might happen next. They can determine the answer by reading the reminder of
the text. In contrast, post-reading prediction questions generally have no right answers in that students
cannot continue to read to confirm their predictions. However, predictions must be supported by
information from the text. Generally, scholarly articles, such as this one, do not allow for postreading
prediction questions. Other types of writing, such as fiction, are fertile ground for such questions. To
illustrate, consider a romance in which the woman and man are married as the novel comes to a close.
A post-reading prediction question might be: Do you think they will stay married? Why or why not?
Depending on a variety of factors including evidence in the text and personal experiences of the reader,
either a yes or a no answer could be justified.
Having students make predictions before they read the text is a pre-reading activity. We do not
see this type of prediction as a type of comprehension. Rather, it is an activity that allows students to
realize how much they know about the topic of the text.
5. Evaluation
The fifth type of comprehension, evaluation, requires the learner to give a global or
comprehensive judgment about some aspect of the text. For example, a comprehension question that
requires the reader to give an evaluation of this article is: How will the information in this article be
useful to you?
In order to answer this type of question, students must use both a literal understanding of the
text and their knowledge of the text's topic and related issues. Some students, because of cultural
factors, may be reluctant to be critical or to disagree with the printed word. In such circumstances, the
teacher might want to model possible answers to evaluation questions, making sure to include both
positive and negative aspects.
6. Personal response
The sixth type of comprehension, personal response, requires readers to respond with their
feelings for the text and the subject. The answers are not found in the text; they come strictly from the
readers. While no personal responses are incorrect, they cannot be unfounded; they must relate to the
content of the text and reflect a literal understanding of the material.
An example of a comprehension question that requires a personal response is: What do you like
or dislike about this article? Like an evaluation question, students have to use both their literal
understanding and their own knowledge to respond. Also, like evaluation questions, cultural factors
may make some students hesitate to be critical or to disagree with the printed word. Teacher modeling
of various responses is helpful in these situations.
Forms of questions
We present and discuss five forms that comprehension questions may take to stimulate students'
understanding of texts. This is not a discussion of all possible ways of questioning students. For example,
we do not discuss fill-in-the-blank activities or cloze, as such activities or tasks may be more appropriate
for assessing, and not comprehending, the types of comprehension presented and discussed in the
previous section.
Yes/no questions
Yes/no questions are simply questions that can be answered with either yes or no. For example,
Is this article about testing reading comprehension? This is a common form of comprehension question,
but it has the drawback of allowing the student a 50% chance of guessing the correct answer. So when
using yes/no questions, we recommend following up with other forms of questions to ensure that the
student has understood the text. Yes/no questions can be used to prompt all six types of comprehension.
When yes/no questions are used with personal response or evaluation, other forms of questions seem
to follow readily.
For example, Did you like this article? Why? The follow-up questions may be more useful in
helping students than the initial yes/no questions.
Alternative questions
Alternative questions are two or more yes/no questions connected with or: for example, Does
this article focus on the use of questions to teach reading comprehension or to test reading
comprehension? Similar to yes/no questions, alternative questions are subject to guessing, so the
teacher may want to follow up with other forms discussed in this section. Alternative questions have
worked best for us with literal, reorganization, inference, and prediction types of comprehension. We have
found that they do not lend themselves as well to evaluation and personal response.
True or false
Questions may also take the form of true or false. While true or false questions are found
frequently in commercially available materials, there is a potential danger in relying exclusively on them.
As with yes/no questions, students have a 50% chance of guessing the correct answer. Teachers might
simply accept a right answer, failing to ask why the answer is correct or the distracters (the wrong choices)
are not correct.
An example of a true or false question focusing on literal comprehension is: Is this statement true
or false?: The authors believe that the use of well-designed comprehension questions will help students
become better readers.
True or false questions are difficult to prepare. The false answers must be carefully designed so
as to exploit potential misunderstandings of the text. False answers that are obviously incorrect do not
help teach comprehension because students do not have to understand the text to recognize them as
incorrect. True or false questions may also be hard to write because sometimes, as written, both answers
are plausible, regardless of the degree of comprehension of the text. Like yes/no questions, true or false
questions can be used to prompt all six types of comprehension. When used with personal response or
evaluation, follow-up tasks are sometimes necessary. To illustrate, a personal response question about
this article might be: Is this statement true or false? I like this article. Explain your choice.
Wh- questions
Questions beginning with where, what, when, who, how, and why are commonly called
whquestions. In our experience, we have found that they are excellent in helping students with a literal
understanding of the text, with reorganizing information in the text, and making evaluations, personal
responses and predictions. They are also used as follow-ups to other questions forms, such as yes/no
and alternative.
In particular, wh- questions with how/why are often used to help students to go beyond a literal
understanding of the text. As beginning and intermediate readers are often reluctant to do this, using
how/why questions can be very helpful in aiding students to become interactive readers.
Multiple-choice
Multiple-choice questions are based on other forms of questions. They can be, for example, a
wh-question with a choice: When was Maria Kim born?
a. 1940
b. 1945
c. 1954
d. 1990
Generally, but not always, this form of question has only one correct answer when dealing with
literal comprehension.
The multiple-choice format may make wh-questions easier to answer than no-choice wh-
questions because they give the students some possible answers. Students might be able to check the
text to see if any of the choices are specifically discussed, and then make a choice.
Multiple-choice questions may be used most effectively, in our experience, with literal
comprehension. They can also be used with prediction and evaluation. However, when used for these
types of comprehension, we suggest using follow-up activities that allow students to explain their choices.
As with true or false questions, developing good multiple-choice questions requires careful
thought. They found that developing a question with four choices works best for students with low
proficiency in the target language. One of the four, obviously, is the desired answer; the others should be
seemingly plausible responses.
An important consideration
Regardless of the level of comprehension or the form of the question, teachers and materials
developers need to make sure that the questions are used to help students interact with the text. This
can be done by making sure that students keep the text in front of them while answering questions on
the text. They should always be able to refer to the reading passage, for we are interested in teaching
reading comprehension, not memory skills. Another element in ensuring that the questions actually teach
is avoiding what we call tricky questions. If the goal is helping students to improve their reading
comprehension abilities, teachers must resist the temptation to trick them with cleverly worded questions
(e.g., a complex sentence in which one clause is true and the other is false). Negative wording in a
question can also make it tricky. Such unclear or misleading questions tend to discourage students. It is
better to ask about important aspects of the text in a straightforward, unambiguous fashion.
Conclusion
In our experience, the use of well-designed comprehension questions can be used to promote
an understanding of a text. However, comprehension questions are only a means to an end. The use of
questions by themselves does not necessarily result in readers who interact with a text utilizing the six
types of comprehension discussed in this article. The teacher, through a combination of teacher-fronted
and group activities, must promote a discussion of the answers, both the right and wrong ones, so that
students are actively involved in creating meaning. We would like to end on a note of caution. Beware of
the death by comprehension questions syndrome. The use of comprehension questions in teaching
reading can be overdone. Even the most highly motivated student can become bored having to answer
20 questions on a three paragraph text. As with most things in life, moderation is the best course of
action.
ASSESSMENT STRATEGIES IN TEACHING LITERATURE
Evaluation is the process of making judgments about the assessment information (Airasian,
2005). These judgments may be about individual students (e.g. should Jacob’s course grade take into
account his significant improvement over the grading period?), the assessment method used (e.g. is
the multiple choice test a useful way to obtain information about problem solving), or one’s own
teaching (e.g. most of the students this year did much better on the essay assignment than last year so
my new teaching methods seem effective).
Assessment Strategies
There are many assessment strategies, each offering its own strengths and weaknesses, that
educators can use to assess their student.
Some of the most familiar assessment strategies are quizzes, tests, state-administered
standardized tests, and essays. While each of these relatively traditional forms of assessment has its
place in a curriculum, many teachers are finding that they are limiting in other, important ways.
Authentic assessment strategies, such as portfolios, performances, and exhibitions, allow
students to showcase their talents and what they have learned in a course in creative manner.
Many teachers are now also experimenting with self-evaluation and peer-evaluation. Some
educational theorists believe that students are more invested in their performance in the course when
they know that they (and their peers) are actively involved in the overall assessment.
No matter the type of assessment, instructors must create unambiguous expectations and be
open to employing a range of assessment strategies assessment: An appraisal or evaluation. self-
evaluation: allowing students to evaluate their own performance on assignments peer-evaluation:
allowing students to evaluate the performance of their peers on assignments.
There are many different types of assessments that teachers can use to analyze what their
students have learned. Some of the most familiar are quizzes, tests, state-administered standardized
tests, and essays. And while each of these relatively traditional forms of assessment has its place in a
curriculum, many teachers are finding that they are limiting in other, important ways. This has prompted
many teachers to design alternative assessments that they feel better match and evaluate the content of
the instruction.
For example, fine arts courses may not be particularly well-suited to any of the traditional forms
of assessment listed above. By contrast, asking a student to put on a performance, to create a portfolio,
or to curate an exhibition might well help gauge just how well students have understood the central
concerns of the course. Such forms of assessments are referred to as “authentic assessment” or, more
neutrally, as “alternative assessment.” Authentic assessment strategies can be used in almost any types
of courses, even those that more often use traditional forms of assessment.
Many teachers are now also experimenting with self-evaluation and peer-evaluation. Some
educational theorists believe that students are more invested in their performance in the course when
they know that they (and their peers) are actively involved in the overall assessment.
No matter the type of assessment, the following two best practices should guide all instructors’
assessment strategies. First, instructors must create unambiguous expectations. Students cannot
perform well on any assessment if, in the time leading up to the assessment, there is uncertainty
surrounding just what is to be known or done. Second, instructors should be open to employing a wide
range of assessment strategies. Instructors obviously reserve the right to utilize the assessment strategy
of their choice. But they should recognize that different students succeed in different assessment venues,
and, thereby, to try to incorporate a few different types of assessments over the course of a unit. By
utilizing different assessment strategies, teachers can help students experience more success by tapping
into their various learning preferences.
22 Simple Assessment Strategies & Tips You Can Use Every Day
3. Use quizzes
Give a short quiz at the end of class to check for comprehension.
5. Hand signals
Hand signals can be used to rate or indicate students’ understanding of content. Students can
show anywhere from five fingers to signal maximum understanding to one finger to signal minimal
understanding. This strategy requires engagement by all students and allows the teacher to check for
understanding within a large group.
6. Response cards
Index cards, signs, whiteboards, magnetic boards, or other items are simultaneously held up by
all students in class to indicate their response to a question or problem presented by the teacher. Using
response devices, the teacher can easily note the responses of individual students while teaching the
whole group.
7. Four corners
A quick and easy snapshot of student understanding, Four Corners provides an opportunity for
student movement while permitting the teacher to monitor and assess understanding.
The teacher poses a question or makes a statement. Students then move to the appropriate
corner of the classroom to indicate their response to the prompt. For example, the corner choices might
include “I strongly agree,” “I strongly disagree,” “I agree somewhat,” and “I’m not sure.”
8. Think-pair-share
Students take a few minutes to think about the question or prompt. Next, they pair with a
designated partner to compare thoughts before sharing with the whole class.
9. Choral reading
Students mark text to identify a particular concept and chime in, reading the marked text aloud
in unison with the teacher. This strategy helps students develop fluency; differentiate between the reading
of statements and questions; and practice phrasing, pacing, and reading dialogue.
12. 3-2-1
Students consider what they have learned by responding to the following prompt at the end of
the lesson: 3) things they learned from your lesson; 2) things they want to know more about; and 1)
questions they have. The prompt stimulates student reflection on the lesson and helps to process the
learning.
Electronic References
Arias, I. (2007). Selecting Readi ng Materials Wisely. Retrieved from:
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/descarga/articulo/5476220.pdf
Bisesi, T. et al. (1998). Assessment in Liter Assessment in Literature-Based Reading Pr e-Based Reading Programs: Ha
ams: Have We Kept Our Promises. University of Nebraska – Lincoln. Retrieved from:
http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1036&context=teachlearnfacpub
Bibby , S. & McIlroy, T. (2013). Literature in language teaching: What, why, and how. Retrieved from: https://jalt-
publications.org/sites/default/files/pdf-article/37.5tlt_art06.pdf
Baumbach, S., Grabes, H., & Nünning, A. (2009) Literature and Values. WVT Wissenschaftlicher Verlag Trier. ISBN 978-3-
86821-143-6. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/283548187_Values_in_Literature_and_the_Value_of_Literature_Literatu
re_as_a_Medium_for_Representing_Disseminating_and_Constructing_Norms_and_Values
Mustakim, S., Mustapha, R. & Lebar, O. (2014). Teacher’s Approaches in Teaching Literature: Observations of ESL
Classroom. Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1086201.pdf
Rashid, R. (2010). Approaches Employed by Teachers in Teaching Literature to Less Proficient Students in Form 1 and
Form 2. Vol. 3, No. 4. Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1081986.pdf
Surtantini, R. (2019). Reading Comprehension Question Levels in Grade X English Students’ Book in Light of the Issues of
Curriculum Policy in Indonesia. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334463947_Reading_Comprehension_Question_Levels_in_Grade_X_E
nglish_Students'_Book_in_Light_of_the_Issues_of_Curriculum_Policy_in_Indonesia
Tung, N. & Ly, L. (2020). Factors affecting literature learning behavior of secondary high school students: Evidence in
Vietnam. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342161027_Factors_affecting_literature_learning_behavior_of_secondar
y_high_school_students_Evidence_in_Vietnam
Verma, M. (2015). A Stylistic Approach to Teaching Literature at the College Level. ISSN 1930-2940 Vol. 15:8. Retrieved
from: http://www.languageinindia.com/aug2015/meenakshistylisticapproach1.pdf
Yimwilai, S. (2015). An Integrated Approach to Teaching Literature in an EFL Classroom. Vol. 8, No. 2; ISSN 1916-4742.
Retrieved from: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1075195.pdf