Chapter 1
Chapter 1
Chapter 1
1
Su,eeoSi;;1v 11,11/ 1;7 7~
former Is known as "donation mortis causa" subject to estate tax while th
latter is known as "donation Inter vlvos" subject to donor's ta e
Consequently, transfer taxes, which are typically assessed on the n:i
value of the taxable assets transferred, fall into two basic categorieS,
l ,
I namely; estate tax and donor's tax. ,·
I
r·f t ' J• .• I , • , ,
\)' I _i Succession is a mode of acquisition by virtue of whi?h, t~e ~roperty,
rights and Qbligatlons to the extent of the value of the inheritance, of a
persqn are !~~.!1smitted through his death 1
10 a_n~ther othe_rs either by his ?r
~iJl_or ~Y operation of law (Art.774 NCC). The inheritance includes all the
property, rights and obligations of a person which are not extinguished by
his death (Art. 776 NCC). The rights to the succession are transmitted
from . the ,:noment of death of the decedent (~rt. 777 NCC),
notwithstanding the postponement of the actual possession or enjoyment
of the estate by the beneficiary. The "heirs succeed immediately to all the
property of the deceased ancestor at the moment of death as completely
as if the ancestor had executed and delivered to them a deed for the
same before his death.
Property J-----~Gv
Rights } - - - - - ~ ~
Obligations ;----•~
2
The Law that Governs the Imposition of Estate Tax lr,' r J!· t• Jr
1
Juan is the only heir of the decedent. Pedro's remains were cremated on November 8,
2018. The executor of Pedro's estate filed the estate tax return and paid the
corresponding estate tax on October 31, 2019. The properties left by the decedent
were finally distributed to Juan on December 14, 2019. Answer the following:
Question 1: When will the transfer of ownership from the decedent to the heir take
effect?
· ❖ Answer: November 1, 20.18.
The rights to the succession are transmitted from the moment of death of the
decedent, notwithstanding the actual transfer dated December 14, 2019 (Art.
777 NCC).
Prior to TRAIN Law, the filing was within six months from death.
However, under RA10963 otherwise known as the TRAIN Law, the filing
period was extended to within one (1) year froi:n ~ate of death.
3
Question 3: Assume that Pedro's total outstanding liabilities as o • e time of
death amounted to P12,000,000. How much of the outstandi g fabiltties 0
decedent should be assumed by Juan?
❖ Answer: P10,000,000
Limited qnly to the extent of the val_ue of pro~rties and_righ~ inh~rited .__
I
,~1 ~ 2.
Legal or intestate succession. A type of succession which is effected
ii '\ 'b 1 1 k,\ by operations . of law (based on the provisions of the civil code
. ,,; , ,, ln ;egarding succession) since the decedent did not execute a will or if
"' 0 f r ' " •' the la t will and testament executed by him is void .
• <'.h , ~ tt .J •~ 1',,
-
STRATION 2:
following cases illustrate the different types of succession.
4
S=sW/f;dTr~ T~
- - --·- ---·--·· -·--- - ----- - ·-- . . -- -
Case .B: Intestate or Legal Succession
Assume the same data in illustration #1 except that Pedro did not execute a last will
and te~tament during his lifetime and Juan is the only legal heir qualified to inherit his
properties. In such a case, an intestate or legal succession exists. The estate of the
?ece?ent will be disposed of in accordance with the provisions of law on
tnhenta nee/succession.
ILLUSTRATION 3:
5
2 · When the i 1Wlli' 1 does not Institute ~n heir.
ILLUSTRATION 4:
A um ~h s~m dot In llhmtrntion #3-Case A, except that there was no heir
: id · ntlfl d 1n last will and tastt11110nt. Th devisee was simply described in the "will" as
Ifollows: :
"I m devising my parcel of land in Valle Verde Subdivision to my closest and favorite '
d ught r.'' As ume furthor that the testator has five (5) children.
• No heir was identified in the will. As a result, there is no valid "will" because
of the absence of an instituted heir.
Partial institution of heir means the entire estate was not disposed
of in the la~t will and testament. Therefore, a mixed succession
exists. Part of the estate will be disposed of or distributed to the heirs
based on the last will and testament. Nonetheless, since there are
properties in the estate that were not included in the will, such
properties shall be disposed of by operations of law (only as to the
undisposed portion or as to the portion of the estate not mentioned in
the will).
ILLUSTRATION 6:
Case A:
Assume Pedro named Juan in his will as his sole beneficiary, except that Juan died 1
ahead of Pedro. Accordingly, the last will and testament prepared by the testator shall 1
be considered void. ·
C11eB:
Assume Pedro named Juan in his will as his sole beneficiary. Nonetheless, the latter
is "mentally ill". The heir In this case is not capable of succeeding the testator.
Renee the last will and testament shall be declared void. ·
6
5. Other causes such as:
a. ~o~-fu_lflllment of the suspensive condition attached to the
mst1tut1on of heir. Suspensive condition is a condition
depending upon the happening of an uncertain event which
must be fulfilled before an obligation arises.
b. Preterition (omission in the testator's will of one, some or all of
the compulsory heirs in the direct line which has the effect of
ann~lling the institution of heir).
c. Fulfillment of "resolutory condition". A resolutory condition
refers to a condition whereby, upon fulfillment terminates an
already enforceable obligation.
d. Expiration of term or period of institution.
e. Non-compliance or impossibility of compliance with the will .
f. Repudiation of the instituted heir.
, r
r. I I. •IV • 1l O'( ' ff ~ l 'i ·. 1
~fements of Succession: " \'. . _1 • ': • • . , ,
1
. 1
. •
,1 I•
~ Successors i f ·J
Ari heir or successor is a person who is called to the succession
either the provision of a will or by operation of law (Art. 782 NCC).
Devisees and legatees are persons to whom gifts of real and personal
property are respectively given by virtue of a will. Successors or heirs
· are classified under the law as follows:
7
• I
8
;<- ,, ...., _.J
9
Collateral Relatives
ILLUSTRATION 7: Determinin
I
I /
\ Ct /
V I
I
H
M
tL ,+ ~ -H f I ·• ! (, i' (\ ' ,, N
,...____________:J:.=.:f~
l ~l~
i'r~,!..,~,~----~===-J
1., . .i
NOTE:
1. In the illustration, C and D are siblin s Th .
2• ~ :: :e daug;'er of c and E; J is th~ ~o~ :; ~0 : : ,0 ; parents are A and B.
3. e son o G and K;' N is the daughter of J and L.
10
,.........
Notes
½ divide by the number of LC , whether they survive alone or with
concurrin com u/so heir CH
1LC ½
ss ¼
2 or more LC ½
ss E ual to 1 LC
LC ½ All the concurring CH get from the half free portion, the share of the SS
ss ¼ having preference over that of the IC, whose share may suffer
IC ½ of 1 LC reduction ro-rata because there is no reference amon themselves
LPA ½ Whether the survive alone or with concurrin CH
LPA ½ IC succeed in the ¼ in equal shares
IC ¼
LPA ½
ss ¼
lPA ½
ss 1/8
IC 1/4
IC 1/2 Divide e uall amon the IC
ss 1/3
IC 1/3
ss 1/2 1/3 if marriage is in articulo mortis and deceased spouse dies within 3
months after the marria e
IP ½
·IP Excluded Children inherit in the amounts established in the foregoing rules
An child It de ends
IP ¼ Only the parents of IC are included. Grandparents and other
ss ¼ ascendants are excluded.
11
0
,
' .
. \111'1'<:1:1/1 1/ / t/1/1 t'/ l'///I,
' \ I'/ · r/ ~
r/ct'c'. 1•
I
Case A: Namaalam Nila died leaving an estate valued at P12,000,000. The surviving !
heirs were his spouse, 2 lagltirnate children and 1 illegitimate child.
Required: Distribute the estate by applying the rules on legitlmas. II
, Answer:
/ The distribution of his estate should be as follows (Based on Table 1-3):
I Legitimate Children (1/2):
• Legitimate child# 1
P6,000,000
P3, 000,000
1 • Legitimate child# 2 3,000,000
/ Illegitimate child (1/2 of 1 LC) 1,500,000
3,000,000
/ Surviving Spouse (1/4)
I Free Portion (remainder) _ !_200,00Q_
Total P12,000,000
NOTE: .. .
■ The legitime of the legitimate children as provided in the table of leg1time 1s ½ of the total
estate (regardless of the number of legitimate chil.~ren). .. .
• The legitime of an illegitimate child is ½ of the legItIme of 1 leg1t1rnate child .
• The legitime of the surviving spouse is ¼ as provided in the table of legitime
■ The remaining portion in this particular case is the free portion. It may be given by the
testator to anyone in accordance with his wishes. However, only those voluntary heirs
included in the provisions of the will should be recognized.
Case 8: Assume the amount of estate is P12,000,000 and the decedent is survived only
by his two (2) illegitimate children . The distribution of the estate under intestate
succession should be:
Illegitimate Child (1/2); (P3M per I.C .) P6,000,000
Free Portion (1/2) 6,000,000
Total P12,000,000
Case C: Assume the same data in Case 8 except that the testator provided P8,000,000
to Ana (his secretary) through his last will and testament. Obviously, the legitimes of the
two (2) illegitimate children were impaired. The amount of estate left after deducting the .
PB,000,000 will not be enough to satisfy the legitimes of the compulsory heirs amounting
to P6,000,000. Hence, the amount to be given to the secretary should be modified or 1
reduced to P6,000,000 to satisfy the legitimes. The distribution of the decedent's estate 1
should be as follows:
12
Wills
The law presumes that every person is of sound mind, in the absence
of proof to the contrary. The burden of proof that the ·testator was not of
sound mind at the time of making his dispositions is on the person who
opposes the probate of the will. If the testator, one month, or less, before
making his will was publicly known to be insane, the person who
maintains the validity of the will must prove that the testator made it during
a lucid interval. Supervening incapacity does not invalidate an effective
will, nor is the will of an incapable validated by the supervening of
capacity. A married woman may make a will without the consent of her
husband, and without the authority of the court. A married wo~an may
dispose by will of all her separate property as well as her share of the
conjugal partnership or absolute community property.
Kinds of Wills:
1. NOTARIAL OR ORDINARY OR ATTESTED WILL - is one which is
executed in accordance with the formalities prescribed by Art. 804 to
808 of the New Civil Code.
13
- , )/l[r'f '.;·1/t!lf, (//1/ 11~/Jf~ 'f,;f 't
The following are disqualified from being witn~ 0 · to a wlll (Ar . i~1,
NCC): . ..
• Any person not domiciled ,n the Ph1hpplnes.. . .
• Those who have been convicted of falsiflcat,on of a do urm-,nt, P':1u, 1
or false testimony.
14
► --
Foreign Wills
A will may be revoked by the testator at any time before his death
any waiver or restriction of this right is void (Art. 828). A revocation done
outside the Philippines, by a person who does not have his domicile in the
Philippines, is valid when it is done according to the law of the place
where the will was made, or according to the law of the place in which the
testator had his domicile at the time and if the revocation takes place the
Philippines when it is in accordance with the provisions of the new civil
code.
15
1JtYNj1.w nt w ll whJ(,,h do ru,t
Art, 837 NCC: r •v<JkP 1.h,1 prt:v1mh nt:t_, n ?Jn ,.xpn,:/,
''II' uftor 1n;1kino a will, tho m; nn ,r, annul or1ly u ·h dfr,p . JtJ, r rn h,!
(:1
t tator mako A oiJnd prior wllh ,Jn tJrf.! In<· m t ,t •nt vith bt
will oxpr 6 ly rovoklrt J ccntrary l<J thor, • U Jflfi;ln : 1 1n thl" I tt,:r
the fir I, lho rOVOCHllon will ·. A r ,vo "atlon ma Jc: in " ub'~~ u,.mt, v1ill
(i
of l:he ·oconcJ will do1c, •hall t k,J )ff t., t,v,m If h ) new ,111 '.,houltJ
not reviv th fir t will, b } 'Om • lnop •r tlW;! by rw oon of t ':
which c n be mvlvod Inc p lty of th~ h ir , d ·vlSf;:l• or lt;gl'it;~f;'>
only by anothor will or de. lgna d th ,min, or by h 1~ir rP~1unciatfr n.
codlcll''. A r •vo atlon of a wlll b •d on a fal~c ca119 !
or an lllcg I cau I null and void.
Disinheritance
16
5. Unconditional
6. Total (there is no partial disinheritance) ·
7. The heir disinherited must be designated in such a manner
that there can be no doubt as to his identity
The devises and legacies and .... ....... •,,:, •.~~ ~ ~ ~'. .~
....' ...... .. ...... ' ..... ... - ~~-~...
other testamentary dispositions shall be
;/ - ART.-856 -NCC - :.,
valid to such extent as will not impair ,
,: "A subsequent !
the legrtime. The children and ~
property which constitutes tlie legitime. .... ,...,. .. ~ • ,, • ,, . ..... . .. ,, ., .. •. .. •,. •••• •.,·~•• •.. •• •., •• •, •.. •. •.. •• •.. •.. ·~.4-•, •.. ·~•• •: - ..
1 When the heir has been found guilty of an attempt against th~ life of
· the testator, his/her descendants or ascendants, and spouse in case
of children and parents; . .
2 When the heir has accuseq the testator of a cn_me for which _the law
· prescribes imprisonment for 6 years or more, 1f the accusation has
been found groundless; · . fl
3 When the heir by fraud, violenc~, intimidation or undue in u_ence
· 5 the testator to make a will or to change one already m~~e, .
4. ~~~~=al without justifiable cause to support the testator who disinherits
such heir.
17'
Peculiar causes for Disinheritance
2. PARENTS/ASCENDANTS:
a. When the parents have abandoned their children or .induced their
daughters to live a corrupt or immoral life, or attempted against
b. their
Whenvirtue;
the parent or ascendant has been convicted of adultery or
concubinage with the spouse of the testator;
c. Loss of parental authority for causes specified in the Civil Code ;
and
d. Attempt by one of the parents against the life of the other, unless
there has been reconciliation between them.
3. SPOUSE:
a. When the spouse has given cause for legal separation-
b. When. the spouse has given grounds for loss of 'parental
authority.
Right of Representation
1. Death
2. Incapacity
3. Disinheritance
The representative( s) h
they represent would inherit, 1'fsheallwere i_nheritormore
not hving couldthan . at the person
. h wh
. in ent. (Art. 97 4).
18
►
The law further provkies that ~representation " is not available to:
2. As to voluntary heirs
19
TRUE OR FALSE .
. ·t Tru if tt e stat m nt is orr ct. 0th iwis , write Fa lse·
1. Estate ta ·is a t on th e right to transfer prope rty at de~tt, a nd on
rtain tr nsfers w hich r made by law the equivale nt of
t st mentary disp sition nd is measured by th e value of the property .
Estat ta is an e •cise ta .
T e ta pa er in estate ta ation is the e state of the decedent as a
juridi I person .
4 . Estate ta accrues as of the date of the actual possession or
enjo ment of the estate by the beneficiary.
5 . E ecutor is the person appointed by a court to carry out the directions
and request of a decedent in his will and to dispose of his property
according to his testamentary provisions after his death.
11 . The rights to the succession are transmitted from the moment the
heirs receive their share in inheritance.
12. The law presumes that every person is of sound mind -in the absence
of proof to the contrary .
13. Brothers and sisters (whether half or full blood) of the decedent are
not compulsory heirs .
14. Brothers and sisters (whether half or full blood) of the decedent can be
an intestate heir.
15. There cannot be a disinheritance for compulsory heirs.
16 . Relatives by affinity are strangers for estate tax purposes.
17. An heir who inherits a specific personal property by will is known as
devisee .
18. A codicil is a supplement or addition to a will, made after the execution
of a witl and anne,x ed to be taken as a part thereof, by which any
disposition made in the original will is explained , added to or altered.
20
S(LCCt._(j llflt t111/ ~/r,vuf- 7~
,..../
19. Under the law on legitime, if the only survivor is the widow or widower,
she or he shall be entitled to one half of the hereditary estate of the
deceased spouse, and the testator may freely dispose of the other
half.
20. Representation is a right created by fiction of law by virtue of which
the representative is raised to the place and degree of the person
represented and acquires the rights which the latter would have if he
were living or if he could have inherited.
21
...
.
C , '(', ill~//
,JI/'-'- ...
ti IIIi/ f
fl / 't i I/, 1• t'I ' fIr.(
'J ·' . , .
( 1(,\
Definition/Etements of Succession
8. It .s a mode of acquisition by virtue of which, the property, rights and
obffgabons, to the extent of the value of the tnheritance, of a person
a.-e transmitted through h.s death to another e.ther by his will or by
operation of law.
a. Succession C. Barter·
b . Purchase · d. Donation
J.O. Estate
_a. Is the s~m of aH the yro~~ of a ~ceased individual which
- are av~H~ble for d1spos1bon to hts heirs, successors or
beneftcianes, represented by an executor or administrator as
the case may be. ·
b. Is a person designated in the last wiff and testament to carry
out the provisions of the decedent's wUI.
c. Is a person who performs a fiduciary duty such as taking care
of the decedent's estate prior to final disposition to the heir(s).
d. Is a person appointed by the court and performs the same
duty, in lieu of an executor, if the latter refused to accept the
appointment, failed to quaHfy under the law or the last will and
testament did not appoint one.
22
S~.rUU d rz:u:f- ~~
~ 11. Statement 1: Inheritance refers to all the property, rights and
obl_igations of a person which are not extinguished by death and all
which have accrued thereto since the opening of succession .
Statement 2: Rights which are purely personal are not transmissible
for they are extinguished by death.
a. Statements 1· & 2 are false
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is false
c. Statement 1 is false but statement 2 is true
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
23
I
' I
Classification of Succession f .
18. Which of the following could legally effect transfer o properties
through succession?
a. BY virtue of a will
b. By -operations of law
9 By onerous transfer
d. By both "a" and "b"
.. . . ?
19. Which among the following are the kinds of succ_ess1on .
· I. Testamentary or testate succession
· II. Legal or intestate succession
Ill. Mixed succession
a. I only c. All of the above
b. I and II only d. None of the above
21. Which is true? Legal or intestate succession does not take place
a. If a person dies without a will, or with a void will, or one which
, has subsequently lost its-validity
b. When the heir instituted is capable of succeeding
.'e:.,· When the will does not d!spose of all the property belonging to
the testator
d. If the suspensive condition attached to the institution of heir
does not happen or is not fulfilled
24
J~m·c,;.>111/1 t1,u1[7;tVUf T4<1;e,s
.__,,
Relatives by Consanguinity
25
........._ '
{ ({(1(',1' '
Intestate Successors
27 . In a legal succession d isters may inherit.
a. Only full blood brothers an s sisters may inherit.
nd
b. Even half blood brothers ~ re not considered collateral
c. Half blood brothers an~ sisters a
relatives. · . d t ·nherit
d. Full blood brothers and sisters o no I •
30. In case where there are no relatives to receive the inheritance, who of
the following has the claim on the estate?
a. The nearest relative beyond fifth degree.
b. The closest associate or friend .
c. Any charitable institution located in the place where the bulk of
the estate is located.
d. The State.
Legitimes
. 32. Certain parts of the estate of a -~ec~ased Filipino citizen cannot be
freely disposed of because Ph1hppme law reserves them for the
"compulsory heirs". This portion of the decedent's estate is known as
26
►
a. Legitimes c. Legacy
b. Free Portion d. Bequest
34. If the surviving heirs in an intestate succession are the parents and a
legitimate child of the decedent, what is the share of the parents in the
legitimes?
a. 1/3 C. 1/4
b. 1/2 d. None
>3£'. Statement 1: Under the law on legitimes, if the only survivor is the
widow or widower, she or he shall be entitled to one half of the
hereditary es~ate of the deceased spouse, and the testator may freely
dispose of the other half
Statement 2: Legitimate and illegitimate child has equal share under
intestate distribution of estate.
a. Statements 1 & 2 are false
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is false
Statement 1 is false but statement 2 is true
Statements 1 and 2 are true
27
t statement 2 is false
b. Statement 1 ~s tfrulseebb~ut statement 2 is true
Statement 1 Is a
c. Stateme·nts 1 and 2 are true .
d. . does not disqualify parents to
The presence of ch1ldre 11
· 38. Statement 1:
inheritance. .. e substitute for testamentary
The rules on leg1tImes ar
Statement 2:
dispositions.
a. Statements 1 & 2 are falset nt 2 is false
Statement 1 is true but sta eme . t
~: Statement 1 is.false but statement 2 ,s rue
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
42. Probate of a will involves the following processes, which one is not?
-· a. Collecting the decedent's estate.
28
...---
• S1Lca-s.sltfl1, ,vufTr~ T~
b. Liquidating liabilities and paying necessary taxes.
c. Distributing property to the heirs
· d.' Collecting the heir's estate. ;
43. Mr. Mhalapit Nha executed a second will three months after he
executed the first one. The second will is silent as to the first will.
What effect does the second will produce? ·
a. The second will is void because he waived his right to revoke
the first will.
b. The first will is automatically revoked because of the existence
of a subsequent will.
c. The second will annul provisions of the first will that are
inconsistent with the second will.
d. The first will shall subsist over the second will because it is the
original will .
46. Statement 1: The making of a person's will may be left in part to the
discretion of a third person.
Statement 2: Persons of .either sex under ·eighteen years of age
cannot make a will. .
G, Statements 1 & 2 are false
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is false
c. Statement 1 is false but-statement 2 is true
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
-
.47. A testator may execute a holographic will instead of an ordinary will.
Which among the following statements pertaining to holographic will is
false?
29
a holographic will which must b
I. A person .may execdute d signed by. the hand of the testatoe
entirely written, date an r
himself. . . . t to no other form, and may be
11. A holog~a~hic will t15_dsu~:~he Philippines, and need not be
made within or ou s1 0
witnessed . . rt· cancellation erasure or alteration in a
111. In case ohf_any _1lnl stehe1~~~tator must ~uthenticate the same by
holograp 1c w1 ,
his full signa!ure. All f the above
a II only C. O
b: 111 0 ly,., d. None of the above
/ ' .
48. Ch06~;e the incorrect statement from the following: . ..
I. If a compulsory heir is given by will, less than his leg1t1me,_ !he
provisions of the last will and testament should not be mod1f1ed
in such a way that he will receive his legitime. ..
II. Compulsory heirs have rights to insists that the leg1t1me be
given in the form of a property.
Ill. The property left by the decedent without a will shall be
transferred in favor of the .government.
a. I only c. I and II only
b. II only ·. d. I, II and Ill
Disinheritance .
49. It deprives an heir to inherit properties by the decedent through the
issuance of a will.
a. Disinheritance c. Legitimate
b. Distributable share d. Disqualification
J,O. The following are causes of disinheriting a child. Which one is not?
.a. When a child has been found guilty of an attempt against the
life of the testator.
b. When a child has ~een convicted of adultery or concubinage
with the spouse of the testator.
e: When a child ' marries a person other than the testator's
choice.
d. When a child leads a dishonorable or disgraceful life.
51 . The allowing are causes for disinheriting a spouse, which orie is pot?
1a When the spouse justifiably refuses to support the children or
"...J the other spouse.
b. When the spouse has accused the testator of a crime for
which the law prescribes imprisonment for six years or more,
and the accusation has been found to be false.
30
...'
. .i> I
,,
,J
Representation
53. Statement 1: Representation is a right created by fiction of law by
virtue of which the representative is raised to the place and degree of
the person represented and acqutres the rights whk;h the latter would
have if he were living or if he could have inherited.
Statement 2: If a compulsory heir dies ahead of the testator, htS
legitime goes to the child by representation.
a. Statements 1 & 2 are faJse ·
b. Statement 1 is true but statement 2 is fatse
c. Statement 1 is false but statement 2 is true
d. Statements 1 and 2 are true
----
1
55.' Which is _.
not authorized to take charge of the estate during intestate
period?
a. Executor c. Administrator
b. Court ,d.1Heirs
. 31