Dermatophytosis in Bhairahawa, Nepal: Prevalence and Resistance Pattern of Dermatophyte Species
Dermatophytosis in Bhairahawa, Nepal: Prevalence and Resistance Pattern of Dermatophyte Species
Dermatophytosis in Bhairahawa, Nepal: Prevalence and Resistance Pattern of Dermatophyte Species
DOI: 10.5455/umj.20201208055254
Introduction: Dermatophytosis is colonization by dermatophytic fungus of the keratinized tissues like hair, nails and
skin. They are considered important as a public health problem. The study was aimed to isolate, identify, and detect
the in-vitro antifungal sensitivity pattern of various dermatophytes isolates from clinically diagnosed cases of
dermatophytosis.
Materials and Methods: One hundred and sixty patients of all age group and both sexes and clinically diagnosed
with dermatophytosis were recruited in this study. The specimens included skin scales, hair pluckings and nail
clippings. Identification and isolation were done by microscopic examination, culture and biochemical analysis.
Results: Dermatophytosis was more common in males (60.62%) than females (39.37%). Tinea corporis (31.25%) was
the most common clinical presentation followed by Tinea faciei (25%). Trichophyton rubrum (36.19%) was the most
common isolate followed by Trichophyton mentagrophytes (15.23%). Out of four antifungal drugs used, fluconazole
was found most resistant while Itraconazole was most effective drug.
Conclusion: The epidemiology of dermatophyte infections may change with time. Antifungal susceptibility testing
will aid the clinician in initiating prompt and appropriate antifungal therapy and prevent emergence of resistance.
Keywords: Antifungal sensitivity, dermatophytosis, tinea infection, trichophyton
and Microsporum canis. T. rubrum is the most correlation between in vitro and in vivo action
frequently isolated agent in clinics (1). Nepal is of drugs (2, 14).
such a country where a wide variation in This study was planned to determine the
climate, socio - economic status, religion and prevalence of dermatophytes infection in
customs is quite prevalent in different parts Bhairahawa, Nepal as well as the resistance of
of the country. In developing countries, other the recovered dermatophyte species to
than hot and humid climatic conditions, low antifungal drugs. So far, skin fungal infection is
hygiene, poor access to water, overcrowding empirically treated and fungal culture and
contact also plays significant etiological role for sensitivity is not routine recommended in our
dermatophytosis (4-9). region; therefore, only handful of data is
Treatment options for dermatophytosis are available regarding incidence of skin infection
topical as well as systemic antifungal drugs. and drug resistance. Therefore, this study was
But during course of time dermatophytes have planned to find out the same.
also evolved drug resistance for single as Materials and Methods
well as multiple drug simultaneously. Studies A hospital-based prospective observational
conducted worldwide show that resistance study was conducted at Universal College of
among dermatophytes is not uncommon (10, Medical Sciences Teaching Hospital (UCMS-TH)
11). Due to high temperature and increased Bhairahawa from March 2019 to October 2019.
humidity, there are increased cases of dermato
phytosis and other fungal infections especially Ethical Statement
Ethical approval was taken from the institutional
in terrain and hilly region of Western Nepal.
review Committee (IRC) of UCMS-TH prior to
Since there was increased incidence of drug
the sample collection (I.R.C. Reg. No. UCMS/IRC
resistance observed over a period of time to
/036/019). A total of 160 patients of all age
the antimycotic drugs commonly used for
group and both sexes attending Dermatology
the treatment i.e., fluconazole, terbinafine
outpatient and clinically diagnosed with
and clotrimazole, the need for testing of
dermatophytosis were recruited in this study
antifungal susceptibilities of dermatophytes has
after informed consent. Patients with surface
become apparent. Recently CLSI (Clinical and
infections, accidental and surgical cases and
Laboratory Standards Institute) has approved a
also patients who were already on antifungal
micro broth dilution method for antifungal
treatment were excluded from the study. A
susceptibility testing of molds, but these tests
detailed history of selected cases was recorded
are cumbersome and difficult to be performed
that included name, age, sex, address, duration
in routine laboratory setup. The agar-based
of illness and other complaints. All the clinically
disc diffusion (ABDD) is an easy method
diagnosed 160 cases were subjected to
to determine the antifungal susceptibility of
mycological work. The specimens included skin
dermatophytes, but data regarding these
scales, hair and nails. The site of the lesions was
methods are scarce and not standardized (2, 12,
cleaned with 70% alcohol, samples were
13). The application of in vitro antifungal
collected in a sterile paper folds and labelled
susceptibility testing for guidance of antifungal
with details of patients. All the samples were
drug therapy has been limited due to uncertain
subjected to direct microscopy and culture. applied over MHA plates, after which the plates
One part of the specimen was directly observed were incubated at 280 C for 5-7 days.
under microscope by potassium hydroxide Trichophyton mentagrophytes ATCC 9533 and
(KOH) mount using 10% for skin and 40% Trichophyton rubrum ATCC 28188 strains
for hair and nail samples. Another part of the served as control. After the colonies grew, the
sample was inoculated on slants of Sabouraud’s zones of inhibition around the disc were
dextrose agar (SDA) with chloramphenicol measured in millimeters and recorded as
(0.05 mg/ml) and cycloheximide (0.5mg/ml). sensitive, intermediate or resistant (9, 12, 13).
Culture tubes were examined thrice weekly Control plates with fungus inoculum and
for appearance of growth, cultures were without antifungal disc were also tested.
incubated for 1 month before discarding All the data from cases was fed in MS Excel
them as negative. Cultures yielding growth (Microsoft office 2018) and then analyzed by
were evaluated to species level-based colony
Statistical Package for Social Service (SPSS) for
morphology, microscopic properties in Lacto window version; SPSS 22, Inc., Chicago, IL). All
phenol cotton blue (LPCB) mount and urease
data were expressed in terms of percentage.
test. The LPCB was obtained from Hi-Media
Laboratories Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai, India. The Results
isolates were subjected to the agar-based disc Out of 160 clinically diagnosed cases of
diffusion method to the study of sensitivity dermatophytosis, males (60.62%) were more
pattern of antifungals using antifungal drugs as affected than females (39.37%) with male:
described by Nweze et al, (12) and Prabhat female ratio 1.54:1. Most of the affected patients
Kiran Khatri et al.(15). All the dermatophytes belonged to the age group of 15-29 years
were sub cultured on potato dextrose agar (33.75%) followed by 30-44 years (26.87%)
and incubated at 280C to enhance sporulation which is shown in Table-1. Majority of
for 1 week. Following growth, conidia were the affected patients belonged to low socio
harvested in sterile saline and conidial economic status and were involved in active
suspension was adjusted to between 1.0×106 physical works like manual laborer, farmers,
and 5×106 spores/ml by microscopic carpenter, tailor, domestic help etc.
enumeration with cell counting hemocytometer Table 1. Distribution of patients according to age and sex
(Neubauer chamber) (16). Four antifungal drugs Age group Males Females Total
were tested against dermato phytes isolates. (in years)
The following commercially available antifungal 0-14 11 (6.87%) 7 (4.37%) 18 (11.25%)
drugs were obtained from HiMedia Laboratory 15-29 31 (19.37%) 23 (14.37%) 54 (33.75%)
Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai, India; fluconazole (25 µg), 30-44 24 (15%) 19 (11.87%) 43 (26.87%)
itraconazole (10 µg) and ketoconazole (10µg). 45-59 18 (11.25%) 9 (5.62%) 27 (16.87%)
Plates of non-supplemented Muller Hinton >60 13 (8.12%) 5 (3.12%) 18 (11.25%)
Agar (MHA) were streaked evenly in three N1 = 97 N2 = 63 N = 160
Total
directions with a sterile cotton swab dipped into (60.62%) (39.37%) (100%)
the standardized inoculums suspension. Plates Tinea corporis (31.25%) was the most common
were allowed to dry then antifungal disc were clinical presentation followed by Tinea faciei
(25%) and Tinea capitis (14.37%). There was most common isolate followed by Trichophyton
higher incidence of Tinea corporis and Tinea mentagrophytes(15.2%),Trichophyton tonsurans
faciei in males compared to females i.e. 27 (13.3%) and Trichophyton violaceum (12.4%).
(16.87%), 22(13.75%) respectively which is shown Trichophyton rubrum was the most common
in Table-2. dermatophyte isolated from 38 clinical
Table 2. Distribution of clinical types of dermatophytosis
types of dermatophytosis. All four isolated
Clinical Types Males Females Total
dermatophyte species were recovered from
Tinea corporis, the most common clinical
Tinea Corporis 27 (16.87%) 23 (14.37%) 50 (31.25%)
presentation which is shown in Table-4.
Tinea Faciei 22 (13.75%) 18 (11.25%) 40 (25%)
Antifungal susceptibility testing showed
Tinea Barbae 13 (8.15%) 0 13 (8.12%) itraconazole as the most sensitive antifungal
Tinea Capitis 12 (7.5%) 11 (6.87%) 23 (14.37%) agent, while ketoconazole was the least
sensitive. Among the dermatophyte isolates, M.
Tinea Pedis 10 (6.25%) 4 (2.5%) 14 (8.75%)
audouinii showed 100% sensitivity against
Tinea Unguium 7 (4.37%) 3 (1.87%) 10 (6.25%) Itraconazole followed by T. rubrum (84.21%)
Tinea Cruris 6 (3.75%) 4 (2.5%) 10 (6.25%) whereas the least sensitivity was shown by M.
canis (55.56%). T. mentagrophytes showed
Total 97 (60.62%) 63 (39.37%) 160 (100%)
68.75% sensitivity against fluconazole. Similarly,
Out of 160 samples processed, 130 (81.3%) T. violaceum showed highest sensitivity i.e.,
were positive for KOH mount while 105 (65.6%) 76.92 % against ketoconazole followed by T.
were culture positive. Out of 130 KOH positive tonsurans (71.43%) and T. mentagrophytes
samples, 102 (63.8%) were both KOH positive (62.5%) which is shown in Table-5.
and culture positive, rest were culture negative
which is elucidated in Table-3.
Table-3. Correlation between results obtained by direct
microscopy (KOH mount) and culture
KOH Number of cases
Culture Culture
Results Total
(+ve) (-ve)
KOH
102 (63.75%) 28 (17.5%) 130 (81.25%)
(+ve)
KOH
3 (1.88%) 27 (16.88%) 30 (18.75%)
(-ve)
Total 105 (65.62%) 55 (34.37%) 160 (100%)
Samples from patient with Tinea cruris resulted Figure 1. Clinical Pictures of Dermatophytosis Infection. A
100% KOH positivity followed by those from (Tinea faciei showing erythematous annular lesions with
cases of Tinea capitis which showed 78.26% central clearing), B (Annular erythematous scaly plaques
with advancing margin of tinea corporis), C (Tinea capitis
KOH positivity. Highest cultural positivity was showing patch of alopecia and ring formation at
observed in cases of Tinea corporis (74%) the periphery), D (Destruction of nail plates due to
Tinea unguium). E (Tinea barbae showing erythematous
followed by Tinea faciei (70%) and Tinea barbae annular lesions over bearded skin); F(Tinea cruris with
(61.5%). Trichophyton rubrum (36.2%) was the erythematous lesions at groin region).
while fluconazole (2.7%) was least sensitive). than culture. Majority of the cases were Tinea
Our findings about poor susceptibility of corporis followed by Tinea pedis and the Tinea
dermatophytes to fluconazole is compatible faciei and the commonest mycological isolate
with the studies by Hemendra Kumar Sharma with Trichophyton taking the lead, among them
et al (25), Basak P et al, (26) and EI Damaty the commonest species was Trichophyton
et al (33). The higher resistance to fluconazole rubrum. The fungal infections can be treated
may be due to its availability at pharmacies, by a proper dose of itraconazole than other
self-medication by patients due to its over the antifungal drug therapy. MIC values should be
counter (OTC) availability and rampant practice determined by broth microdilution test to
of irrational prescription by compounder. determine the proper dose.
In this study, out of 105 isolates, 80(76.19%) Recommendation
were sensitive to Itraconazole, while 20.83% Present study has highlighted the frequency
were resistant. Itraconazole is a much more of dermatophytosis in tertiary care hospital
affordable antifungal drug. Our study was in which also reflects the overall similar picture in
according to the Basak P et al, (31) and EI other part of our country. On the basis of the
Damaty et al, who also showed Itraconazole as study, it has made following recommendation:
the effective drug. It has effectiveness against Any clinical diagnosis needs to be supported
dermatophytes; hence, it must be a preferred by laboratory diagnosis. Since microscopy and
treatment option for better outcome in patients culture are easy to perform, cost effective and
suffering from dermatophytoses. In this study this should be done in all suspected cases of
out of 105 dermatophyte isolates, 54.28% dermatophytosis. As antifungal susceptibility
were sensitive to Ketoconazole while 45.71% testing facilities are now available for dermato
were resistant. We have observed average phytes, every isolate should be tested against
sensitivity to Ketoconazole which is in agree antifungal drugs so that increasing resistance
ment with study by Hemendra Kumar Sharma among dermatophytes can be reduced. This
et al,(25) which has suggested Ketoconazole as may help in surveillance and epidemiological
an average choice for the treatment of dermato study of resistant strains.
phytosis. Our work suggests that disk diffusion
Author Contribution
antifungal susceptibility testing is simple,
Subhash Lal Karn: Conceptualization, draft
inexpensive, and does not require high cost
editing, reviewing, writing, Ajay Gurung: draft
equipment. It allows for a comparison between
preparation, Writing, Amit Kumar Shrivastava:
different antifungal agents and may help
Preparation, reviewing, writing, original draft,
optimize the therapy for treating patients with
Sulochana Khatiwada Poudel: writing, Shristi
dermatophytosis.
Raut: Writing, Chandra Mohan Sah: Writing.
Conclusion
Conflict of Interest
This report documents the emergence and
The authors declared no conflict of Interest in
occurrence of dermatophytoses and its agent in
the present study.
Western part of Nepal. Males are more affected
than female with dermatophytoses infection. Acknowledgment
KOH examination is shown to be more sensitive None
Contact Details
Subhash Lal Karn
Department of Microbiology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: subas_karna@yahoo.com
ORCID: 0000-0002-5436-0330
Ajay Gurung
Department of Microbiology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: susilgrg007@gmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0002-4751-352X
Amit Kumar Shrivastava
Department of Pharmacology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: sr.akshri.ucms.np@gmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0002-8915-9186
Sulochana Khatiwada Poudel
Department of Microbiology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: sulokhatiwada@gmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0003-1555-0542
Shristi Raut Adhikari
Department of Microbiology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: rautshristi@gmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0002-5599-7763
Chandra Mohan Sah
Department of Dermatology, Universal College of
Medical Sciences, Bhairahawa, Nepal
E-mail: chandra01shah@hotmail.com
ORCID: 0000-0001-5173-5515