Transcript Digital Grid Unleashed A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript Digital Grid Unleashed A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
Slide 2: Welcome
For best viewing results, we recommend that you maximize your browser window now. The screen controls
allow you to navigate through the eLearning experience. Using your browser controls may disrupt the
normal play of the course. Click the Notes tab to read a transcript of the narration.
Slide 3: Objectives
At the completion of this course you will be able to
Discuss the challenges that the energy market faces as it steps away from a centrally managed, fossil-fuel-
dominated approach to distribution
Describe the benefits of distributed energy resources (DERs)
Identify different types of microgrids and the benefits of each
This course will seek to address the delicate balancing act that must occur to aid in energy sustainability. To
understand where we are headed, we need to look at where we have been. We’ll begin with a review of the
traditional electric utility.
As we can see here, large centralized power plants on the left hand side, are connected to a transmission
grid backbone, shown by the towers. Power plants connected to the transmission backbone primarily run on
fossil fuels (coal, gas, oil), as well as with nuclear and hydro power. They can adjust their production
according to demand variations. Hence, they are called dispatchable units.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
long distance, interconnection requirements, and sub-sea transmission systems. Large electro-intensive
industries such as oil and gas refineries, cement plants or infrastructures like railways are connected directly
to the transmission system.
On the right hand side is the distribution utility perimeter, delivering electricity from the substation to the
customer meters over MV (Medium Voltage) and LV (Low Voltage) circuits for the last mile, in a one-way
power flow as shown by the arrows. Distribution circuits may be either underground cables or overhead
lines.
This is the way the utility industry was working until the late 20th century, when things starting to change.
Once constructed, wind turbines and solar panels are “free” to fuel from an energy generation perspective
(i.e., no coal needs to be procured and burned to drive the turbines), which is likely the most significant
productivity improvement of this century. In the meantime, however, this advance could raise havoc with
traditional wholesale power market structures.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
Aging infrastructure will drive grid modernization needs which includes an evolution to a hybrid environment
that includes both centralized and de-centralized power structures. Utilities are recognizing that a migration
to smarter grids is not a start-from-scratch process. It requires a reconfiguration — a reimagining — of
existing networks, which, in many cases, works reliably and in which capital investment has not been fully
depreciated.
Since electricity cannot be stored, the transmission system operator has to constantly maintain the almost
perfect balance between generation and loads at all times to maintain system frequency (50 Hz or 60 Hz
depending on regions) as represented by the oscillating scale we see here. Any severe imbalance can
result in frequency collapse, and subsequently, a major blackout.
The legacy grid has been governed by mature rules of physics using the generators as the main resource
for grid stability: To put it in a simplistic way: Generation (left tray of the scale) follows load (right tray of the
scale »)
Those rules have to adapt to the future mix of resources connected to the grid:
Planned retirement of large conventional power plants
More inverter-based generators (wind & solar)
New loads connected through inverters (like EV)
This shift drives profound rethinking in the grid management: a shift towards more « load follows
generation »
New « rules of the game » for all stakeholders, called grid codes (or network codes in Europe)
New grid operation practices, leveraging capabilities of the new resources
Flexibility is the buzzword here
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
Energy is in the midst of significant transition as a result of what are known as the 3 Ds + E: decarbonization,
digitization, decentralization, and electrification. First D stands for Decarbonization which is about meeting
COP21 Paris agreement CO2 emission reduction targets. One of the solution is the massive integration of
renewable energy including solar. Second D stands for Digitization which brings a large variety of
technology enablers. Third D is Decentralization, which bears may facets, both technical and managerial.
Finally the “more Electric” part aligns with the predicted electricity consumption growth. World-wide
consumption grew by a record 3.1% in 2017. Emerging economies like India and China grew sharply, while
OECD/mature economies had limited if no growth.
The demand for decentralized and decentralized electricity is only expected to increase as world resource
markets undergo seismic shifts — such as the arrival of autonomous electric vehicles, rapid advances in
clean technologies like battery storage, and the need to contend with the risks posed by climate change,
including business continuity disruption and natural resource depletion.
The 3 Ds + E have been driven by breakthroughs in technology and automation. The falling price of
technology is behind the penetration of renewable energy on the grid. The ability to improve energy
efficiency through technology is driving decarbonization. And connected devices, digitization, and IoT is at
the heart of it all.
1. The traditional vertically integrated model of “all under one roof” still persists in places, like U.S./South
East, Hong Kong, remote islands and territories. The percentage of electricity delivered by this model,
world-wide is 10%.
2. The single buyer model reflects the introduction of private companies (IPP: Independent Power Producer
or “merchant” generators in U.S.) in the power generation space (either traditional or renewable). This is still
the dominant model in the world in places like China, Egypt, and Thailand. The percentage of electricity
delivered by this model, world-wide is 40%.
3. Wholesale competition goes one step further, putting all generators at level playing field with the
introduction of a power exchange market place where power can be traded at different time horizons. This
market provides system-level savings by allowing participation of the least-cost generation resource at any
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
given time. This happens in places like Brazil, U.S./California, Ontario/Canada. The percentage of
electricity delivered by this model, world-wide is 30%.
4. Retail competition allows customers to choose their electricity retailer from a variety of competing energy
providers. The retail market may be partially opened to competition or fully opened. Three of the countries
this happens in are Europe (EU-28+3), U.S./Texas, and Singapore. The percentage of electricity delivered
by this model, world-wide is 20%.
5. The nascent next-generation model called “Distribution platform model“ is in line with the emergence of a
very strong penetration of decentralized resources, enabling local transactions and local system operation.
It’s a seismic change in the way the grid is orchestrated, adding another significant layer of complexity. This
is why it is still at investigation stage to make sure that the new rules will preserve grid security and ensure
healthy business models for all stakeholders. This model can currently be found in places like Australia,
California, and New York.
In summary, we are still very far for total market deregulation, but changes are happening as a
consequence of the decentralization process. These so called “market reforms” do have major
consequences for all stakeholders
US survey source:
https://www.power-eng.com/2020/06/25/survey-finds-74-of-consumers-want-to-select-their-energy-
supplier/#gref
Distributed Energy Resources (DERs) are energy resources, can provide similar services provided by
central generation, are expected to grow, and need to be properly managed. DERs are smaller-scale
sources of electricity generation. Unlike bulk-energy baseload and peaking power plants, which ship the
electricity they produce to local distribution systems over high-voltage transmission lines, DERS are
installed locally, within those distribution networks. Managing high penetration of DERs requires a business
transformation involving changes to utility policies, organization, business processes, and technology.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
A platform is needed to manage a coordinated system with such diverse assets as solar, wind, energy
storage, combined heat and power, and conventional generators. Enter the distributed energy resource
management system (DERMS). With it, a utility can ensure power reliability with high amounts of DER,
lower costs, and create new value streams for other local utilities, their customers, service providers,
developers and site owners.
Currently, the market research firm IDC sees customer satisfaction as a challenge for many distribution
utilities, predicting that, by 2018 only one in five utilities will be capable of raising customer satisfaction
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
scores by 10%. To better serve customers, many utilities are starting to invest in technology that delivers a
consistent experience across multiple platforms, from laptops to smartphones to call centers.
Microgrids can be classified by their connection mode to the main grid and their type of ownership. In
general, they fall into one of the four major categories. Let’s explore each one now!
Connected to the main grid, these microgrids are created for improved reliability in places where main grid
reliability is not adequate, or when the utility is providing attractive price incentives for load shedding.
Some examples are high-availability, single commercial buildings, corporate research or business
campuses, hospitals and data centers.
Benefits of these installations include lower energy bills, an ability to integrate more renewable sources, and
improved resiliency.
The energy policy decision maker for grid-connected facilities is usually the site’s energy manager.
Supported by analysis tools, this individual typically makes choices that optimize the site’s energy usage for
improved:
The energy manager aims to optimize microgrid assets with assistance from the microgrid provider and a
commercial aggregator to:
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
Utilize all practical and cost-effective means of local production (DERs) and optimize self-consumption.
Improve energy flexibility of the facility using a battery energy storage system.
Monetize energy flexibility through a commercial aggregator.
Benefit from advanced microgrid control that manages DER flexibility and reduces energy bills through tariff
management optimization.
The energy manager prioritizes investments and optimizes energy efficiency (minimizing kWh consumed)
and the kWh price. The site reaches new levels of optimization by self-consuming low-carbon, low-cost
energy when it’s available.
The LearningGrid project at Institut des Métiers et des Techniques (IMT), aims to create a local microgrid
across campus buildings to optimize energy performance, reduce consumption, train energy specialists and
empower apprentices to understand energy issues as part of their professional training. IMT serves more
than 2,400 students and the campus consists of 6 buildings, some of which date back to the 1960s, and
others built as recently as 2015. It's like a little city combining all typical businesses: a hotel, garage, bakery,
hair salon, restaurant, etc. IMT currently has an overall picture of its energy consumption, but it now wants
to control costs and measure when, where and how it consumes energy, in order to reduce its total costs by
30%, relying on 15% renewable sources and 30% from local production.
Schneider Electric is implementing the microgrid. A pooled management system of solar and cogeneration
production, storage and the buildings’ loads will interconnect the electricity grid and the district heating
network. At its heart will be a newly constructed 400 m² building - an "energy cockpit" to centralize all local
facilities.
These microgrids serve multiple consumers and producers, are connected to the main grid, or managed as
dispatchable units – or, with optimized power exchanges, with the utility’s main grid. They serve districts that
range in size from business campuses in cities to green villages to eco-districts or even small municipalities.
They offer multiple benefits, including the ability to optimize the cost of energy, ensure resiliency, and
integrate more renewable sources.
To run grid-connected communities, a new position is necessary: the district administrator aims to maximize
self-consumption with locally produced energy, while purchasing energy from the grid, if necessary.
Alternatively, when surplus energy is available, the district administrator can sell, store, or distribute it to the
sites. The district administrator also typically determines energy flexibility for the district, and selects
participation in attractive curtailment events through a commercial aggregator. This economic optimization
at the district level benefits all the district’s sites, the community, and the campus owners.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
For off-grid microgrids, more public utilities and private entities call for tenders from private independent
power producers (IPPs). The IPP is an entity that is not a public utility, but which owns facilities to generate
electric power for sale to utilities and end users. These agreements typically include:
Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC), which includes all the activities required to bring
systems online, from design, procurement, construction, to commissioning.
Solution connections, including the microgrid system, decentralized energy resources, energy management
system, and electrical distribution.
Business model/funding, which could take the form of direct ownership as a capital expenditure, microgrid
as a service model, which would mean an operational expenditure, pay-as-you-go arrangement for small,
remote systems, community ownership through municipal bonds, or spark spread, which compensates
customers based on the difference between the cost of fuel and generation vs. the cost to buy electricity.
These are the most common type of microgrids today globally, and they are typically found in remote areas
not reached by the traditional grid. Examples include remote military bases, remote mines or industrial sites,
and isolated buildings such as resorts. The main benefits of these microgrids include high-reliability energy,
so customers avoid downtime, and integration of low carbon renewable energy to optimize both cost and
environment.
The main benefits of these microgrids include a high percentage of renewable generation such as biomass,
solar PV, and wind power to minimize fuel dependency with the added benefits of minimizing pollution and
energy cost. Once they approach a certain size, off-grid, community-led microgrids experience constraints
that can be alleviated by microgrid optimization and management technologies.
Microgrids are forcing utilities to consider moving beyond their existing responsibilities in order to become
operators or owners of generation, storage, and load controls on the demand side of the meter.
Today’s active consumers seek to be citizens of this new electric world as well. Whether it’s through tracking
the output of their rooftop solar panels or following repair progress after an outage event, they are
demanding clear, real-time communications through multiple social and digital commerce platforms to
support new customer engagement initiatives to effectively cross-sell new products.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
IDC suggests that the most effective utility responses to such customer demands will be based on the
“three-I” approach, which includes:
Individualized – Meaningful, relevant communication to the customer that addresses each as an individual.
Instant – Power made available when it matters.
Interconnected – Power that is delivered through the most convenient channel for the customer in a
seamless manner.
All of these elements will profoundly impact the value chain by shifting where both consumers, producers
and prosumers will concentrate their resources in their attempts to maximize efficiency, reliability, and
resiliency, and reduce costs.
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
make sense of the growing volume of data and additional layers of information about customer
demographics and individual/household behavior.
In addition, energy suppliers are not alone in this race and consumers are not waiting for them. Competition
is intensifying from all sides. Internet/telecommunications companies and security firms are offering home
energy monitoring and home automation solutions. Start-ups are exploring the market with home energy
management services and consumers are becoming market players, either individually (as prosumers) or
collectively (via community schemes).
Suppliers will have to proactively find their place in this new ecosystem. They will need to improve
operational coordination of activities, invest in data analytics and new IT platforms, recruit data experts and
develop partnerships with service provider companies.
In the next course in our Digital Grid series, we will further identify utility stressors and explore their solutions.
New technologies, the rising influence of regulatory agencies, and favorable economics are all pushing the
accelerated development of clean, low carbon renewable power sources
Meeting the challenge of a more distributed future will require distribution utilities to rethink technology
investment strategies and engage with their customers as partners
Smarter electricity grids will be vital to success, because they support tomorrow’s electricity-dependent
world
Microgrids can be classified by their connection mode to the main grid and their type of ownership
Grid-connected facility microgrids
Grid-connected community microgrids
Off-grid, facility microgrids
Off-grid, community microgrids
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.
Digital Grid Unleashed - A Value Chain Facing Disruption
Transcript
© 2020 Schneider Electric. All rights reserved. All trademarks provided are the property of their respective owners.