ADA223092
ADA223092
ADA223092
NAVY~~~ IIGUI
EXEIETL A~A
GEORGE D. SULLIVAN
MAC 1990.
'ECTE
201990
DISTIMUTION STATE A
GEORGE D. SULLIVAN
MARCH 1990
tj. C. SCHWARTZ"
CAPT, MC, USN
Senior Medical Officer
c
<I>.
D.G. KIRBY
\ DTIC
LCDR, CF D 1"1
Fleet Projects Officer ft ELECTEf
K.A. HODINA
LT, USN
Acting Senior Projects Officer
6a. NAME OF PERFORMING ORGANIZ. 6b. OFFICE SYMBOL 7a. NAME OF MONITORING ORGANIZATION
(If applicable)
Navy Experimental Diving Unit
6c. ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code) 7b. ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code)
8a. NAME OF FUNDING/SPONSORING 6b. OFFICE SYMBOL 9. PROCUREMENT INSTRUMENT IDENTIFICATION NUMBER
ORGANIZATION (If applicable)
Naval Sea Systems Command OOC
8c. ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code) 10. SOURCE OF FUNDING NUMBERS
PROGRAM PROJECT TASK WORK UNIT
Washington, D.C. 20362-5101 ELEMENT NO. NO. NO. ACCESSION NO.
89-11
11. TITLE (Include Security Classification)
13a. TYPE OF REPORT 13b. TIME COVERED 14. DATE OF REPORT (YearMonthDay) 15. PAGE COUNT
17. COSATI CODES 18. SUBJECT TERMS (Continue on reverse if necessary and identify
FIELD GROUP SUB-GROUP by block number)
In response to reference (1) and as outlined in reference (2) the Navy Experimental Diving Unit
(NEDU) tested the MAKO 9700 electrical powered high pressure, breathing air compressor from 26 Dec 89
to 9 Jan, 90. The purpose of this test was to determine if the equipment was suitable for use
by the United States Navy (USN) diving community and for adding to the Approved for Navy Use
(ANU) Procurement List.
The MAKO 9700 met manufacturer's specifications for quantity of air produced with a quality which
met or exceeded purity standards in reference (3). The design and engineering were determined to be
adequate. With the inclusion of the recommendations in section V, the MAKO 9700 compressor is
considered suitable for USN requirements for compressors of this size and type. '
22a. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE INDIVIDUAL 172b. TELEPHONE (Includa Area Code)122c. OFFICE
DD FORM 1473, 84 MAR 83 APR edition may be used SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE
until exhausted.
All other editions are obsolete. UNCLASSIFIED
CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION ........................................................... I
E. MAINTENANCE......................................................... 6
V. RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................................7-8
Accession For
Dr~o NTIS GRA&I
COPY DTIC TAB 0
INWP CT Uninntunced [0
Just tfcatio
By
Distribution/
SAveil and/or
Dist Special
ii fv'I1 L
ILLUSTRATIONS
1 Compressor Description 3
2 Purification System 4
I. INTRODUCTION
Highly portable divers air compressors are designed to have high pressure with
relatively low volume outputs. Divers require low pressure with high volume.
The average divers high pressure air compressor is connected to large volume
high pressure air storage flasks to meet this need. In normal operation the
high pressure air is reduced to a lower pressure to act as a breathing media
for divers. As this is accomplished, the pressure gradually reduces in the
storage flasks. The compressors tend to run on a continuous basis as the
diving day continues because the demand is usually greater than the supply.
At the end of the diving day or when air requirements are reduced, the
compressors will exceed the demand and fill the air flasks.
There are various methods of testing compressor capacities. For the purposes
of this compressor test, NEDU chose compressor testing consisted of charging
from 0 to 2500 psig daily then opening the vent and maintaining 1500 psig for
continuous run. This method more closely simulated the use a compressor would
experience in the field. Additionally during the continuous run, random
charge rates were taken from 2000 to 2500 psig. The compressor was operated a
total of 50 test hours. The testing included subjective evaluation of the
system operation but did not include detailed mechanical review of the
individual components of the system.
The MAKO compressor block is common to the breathing air unit as well as
industrial high pressure compressor units. It is particularly suitable for
continuous operation because of its rugged design and the corrosion resistant
intermediate filter and cooler assemblies.
The prime mover is a Baldor 25 horsepower, three phase 460/220 volt, 3525
RPM electric motor. Rotational torque is transferred to the compressor by a
single bandel '--t.
Filtration system is a three chambered unit constructed of aluminum
alloy, designed for 5000 psi working pressure. The first chamber is a
mechanical separator to remove oil and water. Subsequent chambers utilize
replaceable cartridges to remove water vapor, hydrocarbons, noxious gases,
taste and odor. Carbon monoxide is also eliminated by catalytic oxidation.
The final chamber includes a visual moisture and carbon monoxide indicator.
All four stages of the compressor are protected by safety relief valves.
Figure 2 provides a diagram of the compressor purification system. For these
tests the MAKO 1803 and 1503 filters were used.
2
4r$4 STAGE AIR IN\TAKE
=APEJY VA.LVE
COOOLER
6ESEPARATOR
Figure 1
PURIFICATION SYSTEM
nn
IR 51
R -%WrrCu
fIt".-rGE
7 /?'-.
43- ;
1 M1303 90" Fitting (3/8 DIA. Line) 10 M1302 Fitting (For 3/8 DIA. Line)
1A M1303-1 90" Fitting (1/4 DIA. Line) IOA M1302-1 Fitting (For 1/4 DIA. Line)
2 I2708 Safety Valve (3600 PSI) 11 M1319 Bulkhead Fitting (For 3/8
2A M2708-1 Safety Valve (5250 PSI) DIA. Line)
2B M2708-2 Safety Valve (5450 PSI) 11IA M1372 Bulkhead Fitting (For 1/4
2C M2708-3 Safety Valve (4500 PSI) DIA. Line)
3 M1301 Adaptor Fitting 12 M1358 Plug
4 M1359 90° Pipe Fitting 13 M1315 Union Fitting
5 M4810 Check Valve 14 M2001 Fitting
6 M1355 Cross 15 M3 Back Pressure Valve (Pressurr
7 M1345 Fitting (1/4 to 1/8 Reduce) Maintaining Valve)
8 Bulkhead Fitting (1/4) 16 M9400 Drain Valve
9 M1320 Fitting 3/8 DIA. Line) 17 M1303-1 90" Fitting
9A M2001 Fitting (1/4 DIA. Line) 18 M7413 H2 0/CO Indicator (Filter -op
Type)
19 M1357 Fitting
20 M1330 Fitting
Figure 2
4
III. TEST PROCEDURE
The compressor and all ancillary equipment was received and set up in
accordance with the manufacturer's instructions. A Cole Palmer model 8502-14
temperature monitor and Yellow Springs Instruments 700 series thermistor
probes were attached to measure compressor discharge and ambient temperatures.
A safety line was installed on the charging whip. The unit was placed in an
exterior work area, open to ambient temperature but protected by an awning
from direct weather. APPENDIX A contains the complete test plan and the
pass/fail criteria used during the evaluation. APPENDIX B is the test log and
contains the recorded data.
A. ENDURANCE TEST
The compressor was operated daily to charge four 2250 cubic inch
(floodable volume) cylinders. The four cylinders were interconnected to
simulate one large 9000 cubic inch air flask. After a charge of 2500 psig on
the flasks the vent was opened and the compressor run at 1500 + psig. Since
the filter flasks hold 1500 psig the charge rate was verified by charging from
1500 to 2500 psig. A total of 50 hours of operation were logged on the
compressor. The following parameters were recorded
1. Date
2. Time
3. Total meter hours
4. Total test hours
5. Oil level
6. Oil pressure
7. All four stage pressures
8. Discharge air temperature
9. Ambient air temperature
10. Flask size
11. Flask pressure
5
B. CHARGE RATES
The volume of air delivered and the time to achieve that volume was
logged daily.
C. OIL CONSUMPTION
At the beginning of the test the oil sump level was measured as full (3/4
of sight glass). Oil level was monitored during operations and consumption
logged. An oil change was accomplished (as per manufacturer's
recommendations) at 25 hours of compressor operation. The oil used for the
change was MAKO regular compressor oil.
D. AIR SAMPLING
Air samples were taken from the compressor discharge at hours 1, 25 and
50 and sent to the NCSC Laboratory, Code 5130, for purity analysis.
E. MAINTENANCE
IV. RESULTS
A. ENDURANCE TEST
B. CHARGE RATES
NOTE: Differences in maximum and minimum charge rates were the result of
differences in the ambient temperature at the time the charge rates were taken
and not considered significant.
6
The majority of the temperature differentials between ambient and
compressor discharge temperatures were 5 to 8 degrees Fahrenheit. The maximum
recorded differential temperature was taken immediately after startup. It is
not considered to be a true reading because of the temperature drop of
compressed air dumping to empty flasks from the 1500 psig build up in the
filter system.
C. OIL CONSUMPTION
During the test the compressor consumed one quart of oil. Average
consumption was 0.04 pints per hour and is considered acceptable.
D. AIR SAMPLING
The results of the air samples are shown in APPENDIX D. All samples were
within limits established by reference (3).
E. MAINTENANCE
The MAKO 9700 compressor unit was easily maintained anid only minor
problems were encountered. The maintenance manual for the compressor is
considered adequate.
NOTE: During test hour 23 the oil pressure dropped below 1000 psi. As
suggested by the manual the pump was vented with no increase in oil pressure.
The oil pressure regulator set screw was used to adjust the pressure in
accordance with manufactures instruction manual and no further oil pressure
problems occurred.
V. RECOMMENDATIONS
The following are recommended considerations that the user should be aware of
when purchasing this compressor.
Depending on the specific use and environment it may be prudent to have the
manufacturer make the recommended changes prior to purchasing the compressor.
A good example of this would be if the compressor was going to be used inside
a protected area the recommendations would not apply as much if it was going
to be used out in the weather.
Justification
7
Justification
VI. CONCLUSIONS
8
VII. REFERENCES
9
DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY
NAVY EXPERIMENTAL DIVING UNIT
PANAMA CITY, FLORIDA 32407-5001 IN REPLY REFER TO:
NAVSEA Task 89-11
DECEMBER
1
1989
G.D. SULLIVAN S E.
E HALWACHS
Gs-g -1 cA USN AW
Test Director iyperbaric
Engineer Commanding Officer
H.L. PRUITT
LCDR, USN
Senior Projects Officer
ICDR, USN
-Executive Officer
A-1
RECORD OF CHANGES
Except as provided for herein, changes will be made only on the authority of
the Commanding Officer, NEDU. A dark vertical line in the left-hand margin
indicates the coverage of change.
A-2
TABLE OF CO-TFNTS
page
Record of Changes ............................................................ 2
Table of Contents ............................................................ 3
References .................................................................. 4
SECTION:
1. Introduction ..........................................................4
ANNEXES:
A-3
References:
(a) NAVSEA OOC MEMO Task 89-11 Evaluation of Commercially Available Divers Air
Compressors
(b) NAVAL EXPERIMENTAL DIVING UNIT TEST EVALUATION NUMBER 80-37
(c) NAVAL COASTAL SYSTEM CENTER Field test procedure SP80-13-OS6 for testing
Diving Air Compressors
(d) Mako Publication Number 54089 M 89 A, for Model 9700 Electric drive High
Pressure Air Compressor.
NAVSEA OOC Memo Task 89-11 directed NEDU to survey the commercial
domestic market to determine if currently available high and low pressure
compressors are applicable for fleet use. If applicable procure compressor
systems as required for evaluation. Make recommendations for inclusion on
Approved for Navy Use (ANU) listings.
(3). Safety devices are provided and audible and/or visual warning
functions as specified
A-4
(6). All drain, trap and safety valve discharge ports will
function without splashing, are conveniently located, and are away from
operating personnel.
e. Operate the compressor for one (1) hour under a no load condition
f. Take air samples following no-load test run, and have the analysis
conducted by NCSC Gas Analysis Laboratory.
3. Preliminary Arrangements
c. Prior to the actual test procedure the air compressor system shall be
operated then shut down when the system is at maximum pressure and the
following steps accomplished.
(1) Date
(2) Time
(14) Remarks
c. The compressed air system shall be set to run at 1500 psig adjusting
controls and bleed off rate.
10. Report Production. Test report and camera ready copy to be written and
prepared by the Test Director and submitted for approval to the Commanding
Officer via the Task Leader. Estimated publication date is six (6) weeks
following completion of testing. Test Directors will be the point of contact
for NEDU concerning this test and will be appointed by the Task Leader.
A-6
11. Comments and Additional Information. The NEDU Task'Leader and Test
Director are responsible for the following:
A-7
o E-4
to z 04
In E- rn
E-4
)E4 in a)
E-1E Z z w z z z rz z z
H w
H E44 pE- 4P P- P- P
0 w www
rU A 0 0 0 00 00000
n rU) U., 0 0 N ID c' 0 rl) -0 (1 0 0 0
w F (1
i-4 H qlr Hr
c-t Htn H H
LAD Ln H- LA LO U) to
HH H
En %0~r% %N0
ul H- - N in r- N 0 %1
S LA ~0 0 t0 0- (N (N %) 14: q LA U) Ho
0 E-4 U .D .! . * *o * **
U),
En q 0 (4 (nc 0 r mN H V) 0.
U) ) LO LA (n %D %0 %D %0 %0 IV LA L LA 10
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
rN H H 0 0 0 CID LA 0 (N U) LA LA N
o 1 --; w N
r- t-N - LA %0 cN %0 %0 %0 %0 %0
U)
E 0 0 0 0 LA0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
U)
En ce. A %0 w0 LO 0 %0 in %0 %0 *rJ 0 0 0 0
o 0 0 LA LA 0 LA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
(N f-H1 (~j
N H- N4 (N H (N (N (N (N N (N (9
> 0 (.4 elq C C '. e~lC~ N C~ N N (N e.J
o U U 0 0 0 U) 0 U) U) 0 H- 0 0 0 0
o LAm A L 0 0l 0 0 0l 0 0 0 0
4 0 (N C%3 (N4 (4 (N4 N (N4 N LA (N4 N C14 H-
HI a 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
004 H- H H H- H H H H H Hq H- H H H-
.> qc C4 (4 -; (N (4 -; r4 (N (N N (N (
H~wN Nq N' NNN N N
~ U) 0 0 0 0 000000
E- 0Y 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
E-.
U) 0 .. .. * *** *** *
0 w 0 H4 m~ LA N
r- o at0'
E-4E-~Z *D I *D 0 0 CDI
N
co i N I U) 0'. 0! H
0-w A L 0 0 0n 0 0D 0 0% 0 0
4 (N
OW L O~e' 0 c 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
9 E' 00 H Hf H H H H. 0 0 0 H- H
%0 %0 10 %0 k0 %D %D %0 %0 r- - r% N- N
o'.r (N (4
N N4 CV (N4 (N4 (3 (N4 (NI (N (4 03 03 (N
M'.4 (N (N C14 (N (i (N4 (N N4 (N (N e C* ( 4 ( 3 N
U) cn
04 04 0 04 0 4 at4 4 040N 04
0 0 0 za 000 0 0 0 0 0
IV H wz
E- E- E- 0 2Z -H P E4PH-
wz Nz 0 r
N w w
0 00) 0 0
nOu) '* 0 IV 0 In 0 9- CO (I T- 0 0 0
U') LO %D Ln H Ln C14 H- 0% Ot LA W) %D
H- H- H CH (14 C14 N( 4H H E- H- H qH
E2
r44 o ' , 0 0 zC
H H LO N' %.0 (I CD0 (nH > , %.0
P40 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 to 0 0 0 LA
0 C1 *4 N' (14 N* *4 N* N* N* (*4 0 (*4 (*4 N*
H )N N N LA
V (*44 (*4 (*4
U)00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
H 0 v IV p
E-
0 0 0 0LAL L 0 0 0 0 0
0 H H- H- H LA N4 N4 (4 C4 H- 0 H- H- 0
Ix: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N* 0 0 0
004 rj H H- H Hq-4 Hq H- H H- Hi H H- H
>z r4N N N N v N N1 N N N W N N4 N4
E- U) W 0 0 0 0n 0 01 0l 0n 0 0n 0 0
0 W0 0 H *,4 C*4 cn n
LA Hco M 0
E- E4 H H- H- H H4 H-
r4 H-
- H H- t-4 04
Co Co C, (*0
C', 0 (*)0'~
0~ a~
00 *N cl LA to o O * ()
C-) Hl H- H H H H- H- H 4 C1(4 (*4
FA1 Lo 0 0 000000H000
w 00 0 0 i 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
E-H H- r-4 4 N- o 0 ' 0 H C-4 H* 4 ?- H
~HHH H 00 0 H H H H
N, N N N Nco CD Co Co OD Co Co o co Co
(14' C1(4 N* (*4 (*4 N ( *4N (14 (*4 C14 (*4N (*4 (*4 C*4
B- 2
00
z zz ~ z
04 04 040404 00N 0 4 04 P4
0 0 0 0 00 0 0 a 0 0 wz
P E- P H
E4 E- E- Z H E-4
z z z z z z 2 rw 2 z 0
> > > > > > _ 4> > 0 > En
GU) 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 00 0 0
U)U i '0 ~1
~ n 00 cn C11 LO
2-
z co CID %D n in TH r- in iO in) in
T- wz H H- H- VH Hq CH H- VH rH T-
z4404 , 00 '
0---
H eq (N H- r- 0! 3'C0
H O N r, r, C (N
M n N 0
in %D0 in to in in v ~ in~
U)n inO .
0 000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
CO in in in) i)n in 0 (N4 in in in to
t- W v O 3'
ON 0% f to0 .% CID Nl W0 %D %0 %0
0 %.0
U4C) n ( . 0 ~ 0 0H 00 00 0O 0H 00 (n
* 0 0 0
w 0 0 in in 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
>( 0N 0 (N4 ( N N C (4 N (N (N4 0 (N (N (NA
E- in to
C/I (N% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0 C(N 0 0 0
-- 0 0
o o0 0 00 0 0
(V 0 (N1 (N (N (N (N in r4 (N4 0 (N N (Nj
HZ0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
004 H- 0 H- H- H- H- H- H H H- 0 H- H- H-
- N-( (N (N, (N (N (N .' C ( 4 (N (N
04 > (v Nq -q C1 C1 tv Nw tv ' 4 9 N4 N
s.. U 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
4 -w4 - 4 V l (N (N (N (N (N 0
E-4Un) -- ** * * ** 13~
0 W0 0 z H- Oa mi v in %0 N- z O 3
E-4 E- H C . 4 i
00 C O
n'0 % Nn CO %
0 ' H N (
0Hi 0 0 0 0
v e0 0 0- 00 0) 0 04
E-f H H- HA H- Hq H H 0 0 0 0 0 H- H
CO C O C :,C CO CO 3) ' 3' ', 3', 3' 3
0 wr 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
00 E-
ON~ H- H H- H H- H- H H- H- H- H- H- H- H
H~0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00
B- 3
Memorandum 27 December 1989
Oxygen 21.0 %
Nitrogen 78.1 %
Argon 0.9 %
Carbon Dioxide 12 PPM
Carbon Monoxide <0.5 PPM
Total Hydrocarbons* 3.4 PPM
Total Halogens** <0.5 PPM
Methane 3.4 PPM
Acetylene <0.1 PPM
Acetone <0.1 PPM
Freon 113 <0.1 PPM
Methyl Ethyl Ketone <0.1 PPM
Ethylene <0.1 PPM
Toluene <0.1 PPM
Benzene <0.1 PPM
Glen Deason
Chemist
C-I
Memorandum 3 January 1990
Oxygen 21.0 .
Nitrogen 78.1 %
Argon 0.9 %
Carbon Dic-ide 301 PPM
Carbon Mr oxide <0.5 PPM
Total Hyvrocarbons* 3.0 PPM
Total Halogens** <0.5 PPM
Methane 3.0 PPM
Acetylene <0.1 PPM
Acetone <0.1 PPM
Freon 113 <0.1 PPM
Methyl Ethyl Xetone <0.1 PPM
Ethylene <0.1 PPM
Toluene <0.1 PPM
Benzene <0.1 PPM
Glen Deason
Chemist
C-2
Memorandum 18 January 1990
Oxygen 21.0 %
Nitrogen 78.1 %
Argon 0.9 %
Carbon Dioxide 282 PPM
Carbon Monoxide <0.5 PPM
Total Hydrocarbons* 2.8 PPM
Total Halogens** <0.5 PPM
Methane 2.8 PPM
Acetylene <0.1 PPM
Acetone <0.1 PPM
Freon 113 <0.1 PPM
Methyl Ethyl Ketone (0.1 PPM
Ethylene <0.1 PPM
Toluene <0.1 PPM
Benzene <0.1 PPM
Glen Deason
Chemist
C-3
SPECIFICATIONS
UNIT DESIGNATION
TECHNICAL DATA
multi -ported
STAGE PRESSURES
5408 5409
Oi1 pressure ........ ... ...... 0...
...... psig 1000 1000
)-I
GENERAL 5408 5409
Volume free
air delivered ........... Q5000 PSI ft3/m 20.0 24.0
M3/hr 34.0 40.8
22100 PSI ft3/m 20.8 24.8
M3/hr 35.3 41.1
Front to rearside.................degrees 10 10
Left or right ...................... degrees 20 20
I)-2
Final delivery 5408 5409
O/D pipe connection ................ in 0.315 0.315
Mm 8 S
TEMPERATURES
Ambient and air
inlet temperature ............. min F 14 14
C -10 -10
D-3