Strategy Management 1-5
Strategy Management 1-5
Strategy Management 1-5
© Sunil Mehrotra
Strategic Management Process
• Envisioning Strategy
– Definition
– Framework
– Visual Models
• External Analysis
– PEST
– PEST Impact Analysis
• Industry Analysis
– Industry Structure
– Evolution of Industries
– Industry Supply Chain
– Potential Industry Earnings
– Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis
– Competitive Intensity
– Strategies for minimizing competitive forces
– Perceptual Map
– Barriers to Entry/Incumbency advantages
– DSIR effect
• Company Internal Analysis
– Value Creating Processes
– Core Competencies
– Growth Strategies
– SWOT Analysis
– Mckinsey 7-S Framework
– Change Management
– Risk Assessment
– Balanced Scorecard
– GE Mckinsey Matrix
Envisioning Strategy: Visual Models
3
2
1
5
4
1. Visualize
2. Think Clearly
3. Communicate Effectively
4. Understand Deeply
5. Share the Vision
6. Act Coherently
www.idiagram.com
Visual Model
A Business Ecosystem
The
The environment
environment
Governments
Governments
Standards
Standards bodies
bodies
New
New entrants
entrants
Competitors
Competitors
Supplier’
Supplier’s suppliers
Supplier’s suppliers Suppliers
Suppliers Organisation
Organisation Customers
Customers Customer’
Customer’s customers
Customer’s customers
Substitutes
Substitutes
Stakeholders
Stakeholders
International
International law
law
New Paradigm Consulting
Visual Model
Comprehensive View
Strategic Management
• Is the process by which an organization
– Establishes its goals and objectives both short
and long-term
– Formulates plans and charts a course of
action for meeting these goals and objectives
in the desired time-frame.
– Implements the actions
– And analyzes progress and results
Strategic Management
• Deals with
– How to grow the business
– How to satisfy customers
– How to compete with rivals
– How to respond to changing environment
– How to manage each functional piece of the business
– How to build organizational capabilities and align
organization to achieve desired goals
– How to achieve strategic and financial objectives
Mission, Vision and Values
Analyzing
Analyzing the firm’s
Analyzing Analyzing Analyzing the firm’s Architecture,
the the the Strengths & Routines &
Environment Industry Competition Weaknesses Culture
Shareholder
Returns
Strategic Planning Framework
External Factors Internal Factors
•Profit
•Sales Shareholder
•Market Share Returns
•ROI
•Market Value
Strategic Analysis Framework
External Factors Internal Factors
•Week 3 •Week 8
•Week 11
•Week 1 •Week 4 • Week 6 •Week 9
•Week 12
•Week 2 •Week 5 • Week 7 •Week 10
Analyzing
Analyzing the firm’s
Analyzing Analyzing Analyzing the firm’s Architecture,
the the the Strengths & Routines &
Environment Industry Competition Weaknesses Culture
•Profit
•Sales Shareholder
•Market Share Returns
•ROI
•Market Value
Three Tests of Best Strategy
• A good strategy has to be well matched
to Industry and competitive conditions,
market opportunities and threats, and
other aspects of a firm’s external
The Goodness of environment
Future: To here • At the same time, it has to be tailored to
Fit Test
the company’s resource and strengths
and competitive capabilities
www.studymarketing.org
16
DEFINITION
2
17
PURPOSE OF STRATEGY
• Focus execution efforts
• Always requires good execution
• Make choices
• Investments
• Acquisitions
• People
• Create value
WHAT ARE THE COMPONENTS 18
OF A STRATEGY?
• Mission
• Goals
• Where to compete/grow
– Customers/geographies
• What to offer
– Products/services
STRATEGY?
• Clear and compelling
• Grounded in facts
AGENDA
• What is strategy?
By 2011:
over $2B valuation
• Goals: + Gross margin 50%+
#1 in our business
© Sunil Mehrotra
Strategic Management Process
• Envisioning Strategy
– Definition
– Framework
– Visual Models
• External Analysis
– PEST
– PEST Impact Analysis
• Industry Analysis
– Industry Structure
– Evolution of Industries
– Industry Supply Chain
– Potential Industry Earnings
– Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis
– Competitive Intensity
– Strategies for minimizing competitive forces
– Perceptual Map
– Barriers to Entry/Incumbency advantages
– DSIR effect
• Company Internal Analysis
– Value Creating Processes
– Core Competencies
– Growth Strategies
– SWOT Analysis
– Mckinsey 7-S Framework
– Change Management
– Risk Assessment
– Balanced Scorecard
– GE Mckinsey Matrix
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Analysis
GDP
Fiscal Policy GDP growth
Monetary Policy Exchange rate
Tax laws Unemployment rate
Intellectual Property protection Skilled labor
ic Education levels
Copyright laws m
Securities Laws Poli
tica ono ge Trade unions
Ec han
Infrastructure
Business climate l Cha Healthcare costs
ng e C Raw materials
Opportunities
Opportunities
Threats
Threats
New technologies i cal
log e So Demographics
Materials technologies
o c
Process technologies
chn ang Ch ial Income Distribution
Information technologies Te ang Social stability
Communication technologies
Ch e Ethnic patterns
Consumerism
Government incentives
Discretionary income
Energy costs
Fashions/fads
Broadband penetration Consumer trends
Technology incubation
© Sunil Mehrotra
It is crucial to describe the subject
for the PEST analysis clearly so
that people, contributing to the
analysis, and those interpreting the
results from PEST analysis, could
PEST Impact Matrix
understand the purpose of the
PEST assessment and its
implications
Political Change
Economic
Change
Social
Change
Technological
Change
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Impact example:
Political Change
Economic
Change
Social
Change
Technological
Change
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Analysis Example:
ic
m
Poli ono ge
tica Ec han
Emerging
Infrastructure
l Ch Markets
ang Technologies C
e
Digital
Connections
Originations
Opportunities
Opportunities
Environmental Demographics
Solutions
i cal So
l og c
o Ch ial
chn ange ang
Te Ch e
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Impact example:
Political Change
Economic
Change
Social
Change
Technological
Change
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Impact example:
Demographics
© Sunil Mehrotra
PEST Impact example:
© Sunil Mehrotra
Scenario Planning
http://strategicframing.com/strategic-planning-workshop/
Contemplating the Future
Student Examples: Pest Analysis
Breanne Hayes
April 2008 MBA
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
Elizabeth Passeretti
April 2008 MBA Candidate
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
PEST Analysis
Impact on J&J
Political Change
Shorten
More
Political Change FDA Longer time Product
approval process conservative to market Development
Cycle
© Sunil Mehrotra
Political Change
inelastic.
However, third-party payers certainly feel the pain of an economic
downturn and may impose cost cutting measures which reduce
Medium
patient reimbursement and put more of an economic burden on
patients. And Biotech firms often depend on single-source
suppliers for raw materials and are therefore sensitive to
increasing costs.
Elizabeth Passeretti April 2008 MBA Candidate
Graziadio School of Business and Management,Pepperdine University
Impact
Change
Operational
Democratic party More
Political Change in power government
Pressure on Efficiency to
prices reduce costs
control
© Sunil Mehrotra
Envisioning Strategy
© Sunil Mehrotra
Strategic Management Process
• Envisioning Strategy
– Definition
– Framework
– Visual Models
• External Analysis
– PEST
– PEST Impact Analysis
• Industry Analysis
– Industry Structure
– Evolution of Industries
– Industry Supply Chain
– Potential Industry Earnings
– Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis
– Competitive Intensity
– Strategies for minimizing competitive forces
– Perceptual Map
– Barriers to Entry/Incumbency advantages
– DSIR effect
• Company Internal Analysis
– Value Creating Processes
– Core Competencies
– Growth Strategies
– SWOT Analysis
– Mckinsey 7-S Framework
– Change Management
– Risk Assessment
– Balanced Scorecard
– GE Mckinsey Matrix
© Sunil Mehrotra
Industry Analysis
Understand Deeply
Suppliers
Competitors
Industry Analysis
•Porter’s 5 Forces Analysis
•Competitive Intensity
•Strategies for minimizing
competitive forces
Customers •Incumbency advantages
•Value Chain
•Potential Industry Earnings
•Evolution of Industries
•DSIR effects
© Sunil Mehrotra
Low
Spectrum of Competition High
Competitive Intensity
Perfect Competition
•Many firms
Niche Market •No product differentiation
•Product Differentiation •Price based competition
Oligopoly •Localized competition
•Few Firms Commodities
Clothing Stores
•Strategic Interdependence Gas Stations
•Profitability determined by behavior
Dominant Firm
•Few large firms Automobiles
•More small firms Commercial Aircrafts
•Pricing leadership
Monopoly •Protected Niches
Single Firm
Computer OS
Utilities
Industry Profitability
Adapted from: Saloner, Shepard, & Podolny: Strategic Management, Wiley and Sons, 2001 © Sunil Mehrotra
Industry Evolution: Traditional View
Introduction Growth Maturity Decline
Revenue
Operating
Income
1 Mature/Vertically
Integrated
Three major phases of industry
evolution
Cycle-driving discontinuities
include deregulation, technology,
shifts in consumer preferences,
globalization of markets, etc.
3 2
Recombinant Focused
Market New Entrants
Leaders http://www.manyworlds.com/
The New View:
The Cycle of Industry Creative Destruction
Operating
System
Windows Apple Linux
Computer
IBM HP Apple Dell
Chips
INTEL AMD
Adapted from: Saloner, Shepard, & Podolny: Strategic Management, Wiley and Sons, 2001
Industry Supply/Value Chain
Suppliers
Manufacturers
Distributors
Retailers
Consumers
© Sunil Mehrotra
Student Examples: Supply Chain
Breanne Hayes
April 2008 MBA
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
Elizabeth Passeretti
April 2008 MBA
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
Overview of Industry Value Chain:
Consumer Health Products
Cotton, Plastics, Chemicals, etc.
Retailers:
Pharmacies, Drug Stores, Supermarkets
Consumers
Breanne Hayes, April 2008 MBA,
Graziadio School of Business and Management Pepperdine University
Industry Analysis Legend
Value = Product
Value = Knowledge
Regulators/Gatekeepers
Industry Supply Chain
Raw materials, Lab equipment,
Chemicals
Profit Value
Added
Value
PRICE
Added
Value
Added
Material
cosls
Manufacturers
Consumers
Distributors
Suppliers
Retailers
© Sunil Mehrotra
Value Added Template
Manufacturers
Consumers
Distributors
Suppliers
Retailers
Value Added
Profitability
Asset
Intensity
ROI
Opportunity Cost of
Resources
Adapted from: Saloner, Shepard, & Podolny: Strategic Management, Wiley and Sons, 2001
PIE Analysis
J&J is in a position to capture
Price more potential industry earnings
as a result of increased consumer
demand
Cost to J&J
Quantity
Adapted from: Saloner, Shepard, & Podolny: Strategic Management, Wiley and Sons, 2001
Porter’s 5 Forces Framework
Concentration of buyers
Economies of scale
Incumbents are fragmented
Product is undifferentiated High initial investments and fixed costs
Switching to another supplier is simple Learning economies
Product is not strategic to the customer Depreciated assets
Customers can produce the product Brand loyalty
themselves
Protected intellectual property
Customer knows the production costs
Customers can integrate back-words Scarcity of qualified resources
Access to raw material controlled by existing players
Distribution channels controlled by existing players
Existing players have close customer relations
Better prices
Better performance
Similar functionality
www.themanager.org
© Sunil Mehrotra
Impact on Profitability
Threat/Power
Industry Industry
A B
High Moderate Low
Competitive
Intensity
Bargaining power
of Suppliers
Bargaining power of
Customers
Nicholas Merriam
April 2008 MBA
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
• Coffee Growers
• Pastry makers Consumers
• Coffee machine
makers
• Teas
• Juices
• Regular coffee Nicholas Merriam, April 2008 MBA,
Graziadio School of Business and Management Pepperdine University
Porter’s 5 Forces:
Barriers to entry: Small
firms generally specialize in
R&D and cannot realize
Similarity of manufacturing efficiencies
products enables that large incumbents benefit
easy switching from
MODERATE WEAK
MODERATE
INTENSE
INTENSE
Breanne Hayes, April 2008 MBA,
Graziadio School of Business and Management Pepperdine University
Porter’s 5 Forces: Thomas Weisel Partners
Customer’s
Customer’s Power
Power Threat
Threat of
of New
New Entry
Entry
Companies
Companies are are able
able to
to Bulge
Bulge Bracket
Bracket Banks
Banks
choose
choose whowho theythey partner
partner encroaching
encroaching into
into Middle
Middle
with,
with, but
but are
are limited
limited by
by Market
Market
their
their ability
ability to
to run
run aa
MODERATE
business
business and
to
to investors.
and shop
investors.
shop aa deal
deal
High
MODERATE
WEAK
Supplier’s
Supplier’s Power
Power
Investors
Investors have
have power
power toto
choose
choose where they place
where they place
there
there money,
money, but
but don’t
don’t have
have
ability
ability to organize or
to organize or know
know of
of
new
new opportunities.
opportunities.
INTENSE
Competitive
Competitive Intensity
Intensity
Industry
Industry isis highly
highly
competitive
competitive Mathew Kemp, April 2008 MBA,
Graziadio School of Business and Management Pepperdine University
Impact on Profitability
Threat/Power
Competitive
Intensity
Bargaining power
of Suppliers
Bargaining power of
Customers
Competitive
Intensity
Bargaining power
of Suppliers
Bargaining power of
Customers
Bargaining power Better insulated Better able to pass on Better able to pass on
of Suppliers supplier price increases supplier price increases
from suppliers
to customers to customers
Examples:
www.studymarketing.org
Product Differentiation minimizes
competitive intensity
Perceptual Map of Automobile Brands
On a
• Women
Old
Budget Milwaukee Light Light Light Less Filling
Adapted from: Prof. Ganesh Iyer, UC Berkeley
Perceptual Map of 2000 Presidential Candidates
Leader
Colin Powell
John McCain
George W. Bush
Religious
Traditional
Bill Bradley Conservative
Liberal
Alan Keyes
Elizabeth Dole
Steve Forbes
Al Gore
Pat Buchanan
Donald Trump
Jesse Jackson
Republican
Opportunistic
Democrat
Source: 12Americans.com, 2000
www.populus.com
Independent
Student Examples:
Perceptual Mapping
Nina Tooley
April 2008 MBA
Graziadio School of Business and
Management
Pepperdine University
Perceptual Map Example:
Contemporary
Zara
Discount Expensive
Classic
Zara
Young Mature
Classic
Nina Tooley, April 2008 MBA,
Graziadio School of Business and Management Pepperdine University
Barriers to Entry/
Incumbency Advantage
• Economies of Scale
• Cumulative Investments
• Learning economies
• Innovation advantage
• Promotional advantage
• Customer loyalty
advantage
• Switching costs advantage
• Demand Side increasing
returns advantage
© Sunil Mehrotra
Adapted from: Saloner, Shepard, & Podolny: Strategic Management, Wiley and Sons, 2001
Economies of scale occur when increased output leads to lower unit costs (lower average costs)
Wal-Mart can sell products more cheaply because its huge buying power gives it economies of scale.