Yoga Psychotherapy
Yoga Psychotherapy
Yoga Psychotherapy
ABSTRACT: This article offers a comprehensive perspective on how Western psychological theory
and practice, specifically developments in somatic psychology, can be integrated with the scientific
insights of Yoga in order to produce a more thorough model that seeks to reduce the symptoms of
psychological trauma and promote overall well-being. Toward this goal, the article offers a literature
review that includes trauma studies, neuroscience, mindfulness, and yoga. By integrating these
disciplines, we discover new possibilities for healing psychological trauma in the body through yogic
techniques, including physical postures, meditation, and breathing exercises. The article also introduces
an overview of the Yoga & Psyche Method, a process that allows practitioners to easily experience and
teach this integration to clients and offers five key insights and possibilities that result from this
integration. This synthesis of Eastern philosophy and modern scientific research offers a possibility for
further developments in psychological theory, research, and effective therapeutic treatments.
KEYWORDS: somatic psychology, trauma, yoga, neuroscience, mindfulness.
This article offers an insight into what the integration of Western psychology
and ancient yogic wisdom might look like. We begin by describing important
findings and developments in somatic psychology, yoga research, breathing
techniques, and mindfulness. The literature review then summarizes current
trauma research in order to illustrate the importance of incorporating the body
and yoga in the treatment of trauma. To conclude, we offer five key insights
and implications of this integration, and consider the important questions and
research directions for further developments in this emergent interdisciplinary
Email: mariana@realspirituality.com
Delving into the vast field of Yoga, one discovers that the physical exercises we
commonly understand as Yoga are but one aspect of a highly refined
philosophy that offers a psychological view of the human being. When we
consider Yoga from this wider perspective, we discover many of the goals of
modern psychology to be complementary with those of Yoga.
The precise origins of Yoga are not known, and even great Yoga scholars differ
vastly on the dates they cite in Yoga’s history. Eliade (1975) suggests that the
first systematized form of Yoga could have been written by Patañjali in his
Yoga Sūtras. There seems to be no consensus of when Patañjali lived and wrote
this classical text, but it is thought to be somewhere between 300 BCE to 500
CE. Feuerstein (1998) dates the writing of the Yoga Sūtras back to the Classical
Age (100 BCE to 500 CE) and suggests that less structured yogic ideas and
practices can be found dating back to the time of the Rig-Veda, which is
thought to be composed before 1900 BCE. Additionally, Bryant (2009) in his
book The Yoga Sūtras of Patañjali talks about images of figures in yogic
postures, dating to pre-vedic times (3000 - 1900 BCE) adding that, ‘‘This
evidence suggests that, irrespective of its literary origins, Yoga has been
practiced on the Indian subcontinent for well over four thousand years’’ (p. xx).
Further building blocks that positively impact our capacity to integrate these
theories and practices are the emerging fields of neuroscience and trauma
research. Both are beginning to reveal a substantial body of research-based
evidence about how trauma resides in the body, brain, and nervous system.
Many of the most effective methods for working with post-traumatic stress
disorder and complex trauma involve body-centered treatments (Emerson &
Hopper, 2011; Lopez, 2011; Ogden, Minton & Paine, 2006; Ogden, Pain, &
Fisher, 2006; Rothschild, 2000; van der Kolk, 1994; van der Kolk, 2006).
Although somatic psychology has only picked up momentum within the past
decade, its roots date back to the early originators of modern psychology,
including Freud, Ferenczi, Adler, Groddeck, Reich, and Jung (McNeely,
1987). It took the outside view of scholars, some fifty years later, to name this
phenomenon as the single field of somatic education. Summarizing the history
of somatic practices, Eddy (2009) wrote:
Within this discipline of somatic psychology, the mind and body are viewed as
an interactive whole where mental and physical symptoms are connected and
are representative of an individual’s whole being. In this way somatic
psychology links psychotherapy with the soma, which allows one to consider
the psychological meaning of symptoms that manifest in the body (Hartley,
2004). The change from doing psychotherapy strictly in the mind to moving it
into the body is a radical shift. Somatic approaches work directly with present
tense phenomena in the body and ‘‘unwind’’ psychological material via the
means of direct experience. Berg et al. (2010) state that becoming more aware
of the connection between bodily symptoms and emotions allows clients to
increase their feeling of control. This approach empowers individuals as
physical symptoms morph into information about their body that they can
then learn to understand and integrate.
YOGA RESEARCH
In the West, the intricacies and depth of Yoga are not widely practiced to its
fullest extent (see endnote1). The Yoga research and literature reviewed here
includes studies of physical yoga, as well as breathwork and meditation; the
latter is often investigated under the term ‘‘mindfulness.’’ The authors do
recognize that due to all the different types of meditation and breathwork
approaches, it is difficult to compare the results and psychological effects of the
various methods (Sedlmeier et al., 2012).
Numerous studies have been conducted that demonstrate that the physical
practice of Yoga āsana decreases stress, promoting increased relaxation and
regulation at a psychological and neuromuscular level. In the Harvard Mental
Health Letter (Harvard Health Publications, 2009), an article entitled, ‘‘Yoga
for Anxiety and Depression’’ spoke to the significance of yoga on stress
management:
Some researchers have conducted similar studies using short term yoga
interventions and have found a relationship between Yoga and decreased stress
across many different populations such as young adults (Gard, Brach, Hölzel,
Noggle, Conboy, & Lazar, 2012), older adults, (Bonura & Pargman, 2009),
businessmen and women (Wolever, Bobinet, McCabe, Mackenzie, Fekete,
Kusnick, & Baime, 2012), and patients suffering from chronic illness (Pritchard,
Elison-Bowers, & Birdsall, 2010; Salmon, Santorelli, & Kabat-Zinn, 1998). Yoga
helps to train the body to relax on a muscular level, allowing the stress response
to be more easily managed (Serber, 2000). Brisbon and Lowery (2011) found that
compared to beginners, advanced practitioners of Hatha Yoga displayed lower
levels of stress and increased awareness of being present in the moment.
Yoga also gives individuals a framework for regulating emotions and a space
to practice self-soothing techniques (Harper, 2010). Gootjes, Franken, and Van
Strein (2011) conducted a study that confirmed that yogic meditative practices
help with successful emotion regulation. There is also evidence to suggest that
yoga aids in the development of the self-soothing capacity of traumatized
youth (Spinazzola et al., 2011). Overall, yoga practice has been shown to
support stress management at a level comparable to cognitive behavioral
interventions, helping to increase relaxation and improve emotion regulation
(Granath, 2006). Breathwork has also been found to increase one’s ability to
regulate emotions, in addition to improving heart rate variability by balancing
the interaction between the sympathetic and parasympathetic systems (Brown
& Gerbarg, 2009; Holzel, Lazar, Gard, Schuman-Oliver, Vago & Ott, 2011).
Numerous studies have revealed that Yoga benefits various clinical diagnoses,
as articulated by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th
ed.; DSM-5; American Psychological Association, 2013). An example of this is
children with a diagnosis of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)
for whom a yoga practice has been shown to stabilize emotions, reduce
hyperactivity and impulsivity, increase attention span, feelings of calmness and
confidence, and improve social skills. It also has shown to improve the quality
of the parent-child relationship, sleep patterns, and positively change the
child’s approach to school (Abadi, Madgaonkar, & Venkatesan, 2008;
Harrison, Manocha, & Rubia, 2004; Jensen & Kenny, 2004).
When applied to those with eating disorders, such as anorexia nervosa, bulimia
nervosa, and eating disorders not otherwise specified, yoga has shown to
improve mood, increase physical and emotional awareness, and decrease eating
disorder symptoms. A study conducted by Dale, Mattison, Greening, Galen,
Neace, & Matacin (2009) reported that ‘‘Women’s intense fear of gaining
weight, preoccupation with weight, body dissatisfaction, extreme desire to be
Yoga has also been shown to benefit those with schizophrenia by reducing
psychopathology when paired with standard psychiatric treatment. Studies
have found reduced psychotic symptoms and depression, improved cognition,
enhanced social and occupational functioning, and an increased quality of life
(Bangalore & Varambally, 2012; Duraiswamy, Thirthalli, Nagendra, &
Gangadhar, 2007; Visceglia & Lewis, 2011).
Studies have shown that the practice of following the breath is a valuable aid in
the treatment of depression and anxiety. Miller (1994) found that yogic,
diaphragmatic breathing increases ego strength, emotional stability, confi-
dence, alertness, and perceived control over one’s environment, as well as
reducing anxiety, depression, phobic behavior, and psychosomatic problems.
Lalande, Bambling, King, and Lowe (2012) studied how the suppression of
inner experiences, possibly triggered by traumatic events, may be linked to
inhibited breathing which in turn may be furthering states of depression and
anxiety. Additionally, a meta-analysis conducted by Baer (2003) suggests that
mindfulness-based interventions may be helpful in the treatment of several
issues including chronic pain, anxiety, depression, eating disorders, patients
with cancer, fibromyalgia or psoriasis all with positive results.
Amy Weintraub (2004) describes in detail various yoga practices that can be used to
treat depression. Her work is grounded in research and based as well on the
experience of healing and managing her own depression through Yoga. In a more
recent effort (Weintraub, 2012) she also illuminates how therapists can learn and
teach a variety of yogic processes—including breath, sound, mudras (hand positions),
imagery, and self-inquiry — to increase the effectiveness of psychotherapy.
Yoga also improves the mood of individuals who do not suffer from a
diagnosable disorder and overall offers a practice that promotes general well-
The ability to be present increases with the practice of yoga, which has a positive
effect on overall well-being. Studies on mindfulness have found how it helps
people increase attention and focus (Lazar, Bush, Gollub, Fricchione, Khalsa, &
Benson 2000). Shelov, Suchday, & Friedberg (2009) found that just eight weeks
of yoga practice significantly increased mindfulness, insightful understanding,
and an open attitude. Meditation can also be useful with deeper issues around
personality and maturity of relatively healthy individuals (Epstein, 1986).
Findings such as these are important in thinking about preventative mental
health, protecting against disorders such as anxiety and depression, and
strengthening the already existing resources that every individual possesses.
Yoga has been shown to relieve suffering during periods of grief and
bereavement. Philbin (2009) wrote, ‘‘The therapeutic process creates a safe and
sacred space for processing sensations, thoughts, and emotions… Grieving
adults who participated in the yoga therapy intervention showed significant
improvements in vitality and positive states and a trend toward improved
satisfaction with life’’ (p. 129). Yoga can also provide a space for connection
and relationship building. Partner yoga can foster deep emotional connection,
healthy boundaries, trust, and a strong sense of self while simultaneously being
in relationship (Swart, 2011).
TRAUMA RESEARCH
A significant amount of attention has been paid to the study and treatment
of trauma in the last few decades. The most effective treatments for trauma
often include body-centered methods as these have a direct effect on the
Traumatic symptoms are not caused by the ‘‘triggering’’ event itself. They
stem from the frozen residue of energy that has not been resolved and
discharged; this residue remains trapped in the nervous system where it
can wreak havoc on our bodies and spirits. (p. 19)
Trauma symptoms arise when the arousal cycle cannot be completed, keeping
the individual locked in an aroused state of fear. This traps the traumatized
person in a cycle of fear that affects the entire body, including the mind, the
emotional system, and the neurological system that regulates the body (Levine,
1997). Stephen Porges (Porges, 2001; Prengel, 2011), a professor in the
Department of Psychiatry at the University of Illinois at Chicago, proposed,
through his polyvagal theory, that in addition to the fight or flight defenses of
the sympathetic nervous system, there is a vagal defense system that causes
immobilization and a newer mammalian development, the myelinated vagus,
which plays a role in self soothing (Prengel, 2011). When treating trauma these
systems are important to note as they are physiological components that can
keep the trauma victim locked in a frozen state and unable to self soothe.
Experiencing trauma puts the individual under great physical and emotional
distress, and the biological changes that happen in the body result in various
forms of symptoms that can show up months or years following the event. It is
the biological alterations that lead to the psychological effects of trauma, which
are often not within control of the individual. A comprehensive literature
review on complex trauma observed in childhood trauma revealed seven areas
of impairment: attachment, biology, affect regulation, dissociation, behavioral
regulation, cognition, and self-concept (Cook et al., 2005). Leading trauma
researcher Bessel A. van der Kolk (2002) wrote:
The limbic system, an area of the brain that is associated with emotions and
survival behaviors, is also affected by trauma. The result of this is that the
individual may feel the emotions as if they were a reenactment of the traumatic
event, leading him/her to act irrationally to events that may be irrelevant in the
moment but important during the traumatic event (van der Kolk, 2006).
Emotions can be uncontrollable and overwhelming, becoming the enemy,
turning the individual against his or her self, therefore learning to self-soothe is
essential in healing from trauma (Gallop, 2002). The goal of treating PTSD is
to help the client live safely in the present without being pulled back into the
trauma.
While talk-based and cognitive therapies can be of great benefit, there are
situations in which mind-body approaches, such as yoga, qigong, tai chi,
breathing practices, and meditation can be extremely beneficial and sometimes
necessary for full recovery… Learning how to use the body to speak to the
mind circumvents the prohibition against talking and can be more effective
than relying solely on verbal, cognitive, or intellectual approaches. (p. 199)
One week of yoga has proven to reduce fear, anxiety, sadness, and interrupted
sleep in individuals who survived natural disasters, suggesting that yoga may
be useful in managing the negative emotional and somatic-based effects of
these disasters. (Telles, 2007; Telles, Singh, Joshi, & Balkrishna, 2010).
Additionally, yogic breathing can help relieve psychological distress in
individuals that have undergone trauma from such events (Descilo et al., 2010).
CONCLUSION
Through our review of the major studies exploring yoga (including āsana,
breath control, and meditation), somatic psychology, and trauma, we have
found yoga and psychology to be complementary to each other and that the
integration supports the process of recovering from psychological trauma. In
closing, we propose the following five insights and possibilities for this
integration:
This method can be taught in a workshop setting where the facilitator teaches,
demonstrates, and guides participants through the steps listed below, followed
by an opportunity to share in dyads, bring questions to the facilitator in a group
setting, and then continue to practice and refine the skills. The steps can also be
applied in the psychotherapy room, with the therapist directly guiding the client
through the process over several weeks or months. The process deepens and
becomes more effective the longer it is practiced. It can be integrated with most
other therapeutic modalities, complementing their efficacy.
The following steps are an outline of the process, which can be adapted and changed
according to the skills of the therapist and needs of the clients or practitioners:
1. Educate the client or group about a) the field of somatic psychology, b) how
Yoga and psychology complement each other, c) trauma and its treatment,
and d) an overview of how the exercise will be experienced in their bodies.
2. Teach client(s) to move awareness from their minds into their bodies by
teaching exercises that create psychological safety and bring in
visualization, yogic breathing, and mindfulness.
3. Once clients have a sense of how to experience their emotional states as
bodily sensations, a process called pendulation or titration (Levine, 1997)
is introduced through which clients learn to move their awareness
between creating a sense of safety in their bodies to briefly (30–60 seconds)
experiencing the sensations associated with traumatic experience and then
moving back to that place of safety in their bodies. This process of pendulation
(Levine, 1997) can be repeated several times for a gradual deepening, and
clients discover they can learn to move back into a sense of safety.
Once the therapist or facilitator is comfortable with these steps, these practices
can range in length from a short, 5–10 minute individual or group process, to a
45 minute – 1 hour session, including the time for integration and discussion.
This practice is safe as long as the therapist or facilitator keeps the interaction
between the client and their traumatic material in gentle 30–60 section
intervals, instead of longer periods of time, which tend to facilitate catharsis
rather than gradual integration.
It is the hope of the authors that many new methods and practices will continue
to emerge alongside the continued developments in neuroscience, trauma
research, somatic psychology, and Yoga research.
NOTES
1
Although outside the scope of the present article, some researchers—especially Sovatsky– are of the position
that modern psychology is incomplete and operates from a scientia sexualis (science of sexuality) perspective,
thus missing further maturational states that a system operating from ars eroticas (erotic art), such as Kundalini
Yoga, embraces and embodies. This position suggests that modern psychology does not fully comprehend the
depth of yogic phenomena. Furthermore, it is said that asanas exported to US are disconnected from their tantric
traditions and shaped by European practices, such as ballet and gymnastics (Sovatsky, 1998). Norman Sjoman
(1999) stated that modern yoga ‘‘appears to be distinct from the philosophical or textual tradition, and does not
appear to have any basis as a tradition as there is no textual support for the asanas taught and no lineage of
teachers’’ (p. 35). For those who may wish to further explore this matter, please see Singleton, M. (2010), Sjoman,
N.E. (1999), and particularly Sovatsky, S. (1998).
REFERENCES
The Authors
Mariana Caplan, Ph.D., MFT, is a psychotherapist and the author of six books
in the fields of psychology and spirituality, including Eyes Wide Open:
Cultivating Discernment on the Spiritual Path (Sounds True, 2010), Halfway Up
the Mountain: the Error of Premature Claims to Enlightenment (Hohm Press,
1999), and The Guru Question: The Perils and Rewards of Choosing a Spiritual
Teacher (Sounds True, 2011). As a psychotherapist, she specializes in using
somatic approaches to therapy to support spiritual practitioners and teachers
of all traditions and religions to heal trauma and thrive, as well as working with
complex spiritual traumas within spiritual communities. She has been an
adjunct professor at The California Institute of Integral Studies in San
Francisco since 2001, as well as teaching extensively at Naropa University,
Sophia University and John F. Kennedy University.
Adriana Portillo, M.A., is an avid meditator with over 15 years of practice and
has a background in management. She earned her degree in Integral
Counseling Psychology from the California Institute of Integral Studies and
currently combines her work as a psychotherapist both with children, through
a school based program and with adults through private practice in Berkeley,
California. She is interested in finding creative ways to address trauma at all
levels of existence.