Twin Screw Melt Granulation
Twin Screw Melt Granulation
Twin Screw Melt Granulation
https://doi.org/10.1093/rpsppr/rqad039
Advance access publication 24 November 2023
Research Paper
Abstract
Objectives In this study twin-screw melt granulation (TSMG) was used to produce sustained release formulations and improve the poor com-
pressibility of paracetamol (PMOL).
Methods By using various amounts of polyethylene glycol (PEG), a low melting point binder and ethyl cellulose (EC) as insoluble carrier, the
formation of high content of PMOL granules occurred at low processing temperatures (55°C).
Key findings X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry analysis showed the presence of partially crystalline PMOL in the extruded
granules. Compressed caplet tablets comprising of TSMG granules presented sustained release profiles for 3-4 h depending on the EC concen-
tration. The tablets showed excellent tabletability and low compaction forces were applied.
Conclusions TSMG can be used for the processing of drugs with poor compressibility actives for the compression of high-dose tablets.
Keywords: twin screw; melt granulation; high dose; paracetamol; tableting
Introduction Vaingakar et al. exploited the use of TSMG for the opti-
Wet granulation is a method of increasing particle size based misation of high drug-loaded tablets with sustained release
on the development of bigger aggregates of tiny initial powder of metformin HCl.[13] The process was optimised by using a
particles and is considered one of the fundamental and largely range of polyethylene glycol (PEG) with different molecular
adopted processes in pharmaceutical manufacturing.[1] Some of weights and hydroxypropyl cellulose as the carrier where
the major advantages of granulation processing are improved metformin doses were fixed at 50% w/w. In other studies,
content uniformity, homogeneity between the drug substance PMOL and sodium diclofenac sustained-released tablets
and excipients in the formulation, controlling the particle size with loadings varying from 40% to 80% were developed
distribution to prevent segregation, enhancing tablet ability of using Compritol ATO888 to provide dissolution rates up to
powder formulations and regulating the drug dissolution rates. 12 h.[14–16] The dissolution rates were controlled by adjusting
Twin-screw melt granulation (TSMG) is a promising con- the processing temperatures while stability through the addi-
tinuous granulation technique for the manufacturing of tion of inorganic excipients. However, the use of lipids entails
various dosage forms with better process control, reducing some pitfalls when lipids undergo crystallinity transformation
waste, easy to scale up, and a green technology that does not over time. Hence there is a need to identify drug carriers that
require the use of solvents.[2–4] Besides that, TSMG features provide sustained dissolution rates and excellent stability.
advantages over high-shear batch granulation, including a In this study, PMOL was used as a model drug, and ethyl
shorter residence time (usually under a minute in comparison cellulose (EC) as a hydrophobic polymer for the development
to a few minutes in batch operations), flexibility in process de- of sustained dissolution rates by means of TSMG. The ex-
sign, effective material mixing and reduced energy consump- cellent feasibility of EC, a polymer with thermoplastic prop-
tion. Gamlen and Eardley (1986) introduced for the first time erties, offers a range of controlled release profiles for highly
wet TSMG to produce paracetamol (PMOL) granules[5] fol- water-soluble drugs and it has been used as a matrix former in
lowed by Lindberg (1987) and later Kleinebudde (1998).[6, 7] extrusion.[17, 18] It has been reported in several studies that hot
Since that time, several studies made it evident that TSMG is a melt extrusion can be used as an appropriate technology to
suitable technology for the manufacturing of a wide range of develop mini-matrices using EC to sustain the release of ibu-
granular forms with enhanced dissolution rates,[8] improved profen.[19–21] However, TSMG allows the formation of PMOL
flowability[9] and compressibility.[10] TSMG has been inves- granules at lower processing temperatures with increased
tigated for the development of high-dose dosage forms of throughput. By altering the PEG levels, extruded granules
poorly compressible drugs such as acetaminophen.[11, 12] were obtained and subsequently compressed into tablets.
Method time of 0.2 s per step;176 channels active on the PSD making
a total counting time of 35.2 s per step.
Materials
PMOL and EC were kindly donated from Mallinckrodt Particle size morphology and distribution
Chemical Ltd (Canada) and Colorcon (Dartford, UK), while SEM was used to examine the surface morphology of the
PEG (2000) was purchased from Sigma Aldrich (Gillingham, twin-screw extrudates. The samples were mounted on an alu-
UK), respectively. The solvent used in the HPLC analysis was minium stub using a double-sided adhesive carbon type and
HPLC grade and purchased from Fisher Chemicals (UK). All placed in a low-humidity chamber before analysis. Samples
the materials were used as received. were sputter coated with gold, and microscopy was performed
using a Cambridge Instruments Stereo-Scan S360 (UK), SEM
Twin-screw granulation
operating at an accelerating voltage of 20 kV.
Continuous twin-screw granulation experiments were car- The particle size distribution of the micronized extruded
ried out by using a Eurolab 16-mm twin-screw extruder granules of all formulations was measured by the Laser light
(ThermoFisher Scientific, Germany). The twin-screw extruder Scattering technique with a dry powder sample dispersion ac-
was equipped with a DD Flexwall®18 feeder (Brabender
Formulation Drug Drug (%, w/w) Polymer Polymer (%w/w) Binder Binder (%)
Feed rate (kg/h) Screw speed (rpm) T1 (°C) T2 (°C) T3 (°C) T4 (°C) T5 (°C) T6 (°C) T7 (°C) T8 (°C) T9 (°C)
0.25 50 30 30 60 160 60 60 60 30 30
Twin-screw melt granulation 3
predetermined time intervals, samples were withdrawn for narrow particle size distribution without fines suggesting that
HPLC assay. All dissolution studies were performed in dupli- no material remained ungranulated.
cate. The PMOL dissolution kinetics were determined using
the SigmaPlot 10.0 software (Systat Software Inc., Germany). Morphology
All formulations processed by TSMG were characterised by
HPLC analysis SEM to examine the surface morphology of the drug and
The release of PMOL was determined by using HPLC, Agilent extrudates. As shown in Figure 2, pure PMOL crystals exhib-
Technologies system 1200 series. A hychrome S50DS2-4889 ited mainly a rod-habit or prismatic microcrystal habit with
(5 μm × 150 mm × 4 mm) column was used for the HPLC anal- fine particulates on their surfaces. In other studies, it has been
ysis of PMOL. The wavelength was set at 276 nm. The mo- reported that PMOL crystals typically reveal an elongated
bile phase consisted of acetonitrile/water/phosphoric acid 1% habit.[22]
(50:50 v/v) and the flow rate was maintained at 1.5 mL/min
and the retention time was 4 min. A standard calibration X-ray powder diffraction
curve was prepared with concentrations varying from 10 to XRPD was used to investigate the crystalline state of PMOL.
Figure 1 Screw configuration with three kneading zones for high-shear granulation.
4 S.A. Ross et al.
167.31°C. It can be clearly seen a depression of the melting The same enthalpy depression could not be observed in the
enthalpy of bulk PMOL (626.97 mJ) due to the increase of thermograms of the physical mixtures. This is attributed to
the amorphous PMOL content in the granules. the high-shear mixing force during granulation which resulted in
Twin-screw melt granulation 5
Figure 4 DSC thermograms of pure paracetamol, physical and granulated PMOL/EC/PEG (5, 10%) formulations.
the breakage of the intermolecular bond. Lakshman et al. stated fuse on the surface of the API due to the high shear.[26] The DSC
that polymers behave differently during TSMG processing and result complies with the XRPD analysis which also showed re-
convert to a rubbery state at elevated temperatures and eventually duced PMLO crystallinity in the granulated formulations.
6 S.A. Ross et al.
Table 4 Dissolution rate constants and determination coefficients of paracetamol would become efficient in maintaining the ther-
PMOL/EC/PEG (60/35/10) compressed tablets apeutic plasma level of paracetamol for a longer period, and
therefore, it will improve patient compliance.[28] The release
Dissolution models A B rate of paracetamol in dissolution media is highly likely de-
Zero order k° (% h−1) 21.10. ± 1.49 21.89. ± 1.45
pendent on the EC and the compaction force applied to pre-
R2 0.9617 0.9632 pare the tablet.
First order k1 (h−1) 0.459 ± 4.8 × 10−2 0.455 ± 4.8
It has been stated that in Percolation theory when a compo-
R2 0.9965 × 10−2 nent of the system undergoes a geometrical phase transition it
0.9497 starts connecting the whole system. Therefore, when a matrix
Higuchi kH (% h−1/2) 42.42 ± 2.5 42.57 ± 2.5 is composed of a water-soluble drug and a water-insoluble
R2 0.9233 0.955 polymer, drug release occurs by the dissolution of the active
Hixson– Crowell kHC (% h−1/3) 0.1282 ± 8.2 × 10−3 0.1305 × 10−3 ingredient through capillaries composed of interconnecting
R2 0.9760 ± 7.8 × 10−3 drug particle clusters and the pore network.[29–33] EC, a hy-
0.9786 drophobic polymer with thermoplastic properties, has been
Peppas kP (h−n) 0.392 ± 0.033 6.689 ± 0.076 widely used in several sustained-release dosage forms in-
R2 0.9830 0.9897 cluding granulation processing. As drug release continues, the
n 0.755 ± 0.059 0.776 ± 0.037 interconnecting clusters increase the pore network through
Baker & Lonsdale k (h−1) 0.044 ± 0.010 0.053 ± 0.010 which interior drug clusters can diffuse. The total number of
R2 0.853 ± 14.39 0.833 ± 15.65 EC particles increases when their particle size is reduced. In
that sustained-release matrix, drug diffusion occurs predomi-
nantly as the drug is leached from the dosage form via the po-
rous network formed when drug crystals are dissolved from
In-vitro dissolution studies the inert matrix.[34] The resulting pore network becomes less
Like other analgesics, PMOL has a short elimination half- extensive and more tortuous resulting in slower drug release.
life of about 2–3 h. As a result, it requires frequent drug ad- To control the burst release of paracetamol, the extruded
ministration to maintain therapeutic plasma level, and hence, formulation was compressed into caplets using a Flexitab press
paracetamol sustain release formulation would be the great with 22-mm caplet punches. Various studies were carried out
course of action.[27] A reduced dosage of sustained-release for the co-processing of lipid–polymer with Windbergs et al.
Twin-screw melt granulation 7
using a quality-by-design approach. Drug Deliv Transl Res 2014; dose randomized two period crossover comparison in healthy In-
4: 377–87. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13346-014-0197-8 dian adult volunteers. Int J Curr Pharm Res 2010; 2: 28–31.
17. Follonier N, Doelker E, Cole ET. Evaluation of hot-melt extrusion 28. Tan C, Graudins A. Comparative pharmacokinetic of Panadol
as a new technique for the production of polymer-based pellets for Extend and immediate release paracetamol in a simulated over-
sustained release capsules containing high loadings of freely sol- dose model. Emerg Med Australas 2006; 18: 398–403. https://doi.
uble drugs. Drug Dev Ind Pharm 1994; 20: 1323–39. https://doi. org/10.1111/j.1742-6723.2006.00873.x
org/10.3109/03639049409038373 29. Caraballo I, Leuenberger H. 2004. Critical points in hydrophilic
18. Follonier N, Doelker E, Cole ET. Various ways of modulating the matrices. Abstracts of the European Congress on Drug Delivery
release of diltiazem hydrochloride from hot-melt extruded sustained and Pharmaceutical Technology, Seville, May 10–12, 2004, 145.
release pellets prepared using polymeric materials. J Control Release 30. Miranda A, Millán M, Caraballo I. Study of the critical points in
1995; 36: 243–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/0168-3659(95)00041-6 the release and hydration kinetics of swellable matrix type con-
19. De Brabander C, Vervaet C, Remon JP. Development and evalua- trolled delivery systems. Int J Pharm 2006; 311: 75–81. https://doi.
tion of sustained release mini-matrices prepared via hot melt extru- org/10.1016/j.ijpharm.2005.12.012
sion. J Control Release 2003; 89: 235–47. https://doi.org/10.1016/ 31. Miranda A, Millán M, Caraballo I. Study of the critical points
s0168-3659(03)00075-0 in lobenzarit disodium hydrophilic matrices for controlled drug
20. Van Den Abeele WM, De Brabander C, Vervaet C, et al. Bioavaila- delivery. Chem Pharm Bull 2006; 54: 598–602. https://doi.