Dunn Emily Final
Dunn Emily Final
Dunn Emily Final
HONORS THESIS
by
by
Thesis Supervisor:
________________________________
Jon Lasser, Ph.D.
Department of Counseling, Leadership,
Adult Education, and School Psychology
Second Reader:
__________________________________
Ollie Seay, Ph.D.
Department of Psychology
Approved:
____________________________________
Heather C. Galloway, Ph.D.
Dean, Honors College
Acknowledgments
The very fact that I was able to acquire such thoughtful mentorship from the
Honors College faculty and students throughout my college career is nothing short of
inspiring. It has been a long journey from freshman to now an extended senior, and
throughout my time here I had slowly but significantly gathered inspiration for this thesis.
I would like to my thesis advisor, Dr. Jon Lasser. You had such enduring faith in my
ability to pursue this project; more than I could have hoped for. I would also like to thank
my second reader, Dr. Seay. I have been taking classes from you and including you in my
fledgling research attempts for quite a while now, and I cannot be more grateful for your
continued enthusiasm. Finally, thank you to my parents, friends and loved ones. If it were
not for all of you I would have no outlet other than my own scrutiny to evaluate my ideas.
3
ABSTRACT
There is a trend of romanticizing mental illness amongst the younger generation. I define
this age group as high school to college-age, around 13-22 years old. In this thesis I
clarify several reasons as to why this is happening, focusing on the influence of popular
culture. I assert that due to the well-meaning intention of destigmatizing mental illness in
society, there has been a movement in film and social media to humanize various mental
illnesses, which in twist of perception has caused it to be sensationalized. I will be using
the examples of depression, anxiety, personality disorder and schizophrenia. I use film as
the main medium of influence because historically, film has mirrored and magnified
social issues and changes of opinion as time progresses, a key example being both social
opinions towards women’s, and civil rights. The parallel is that the changing attitudes
towards mental health are now being shown through film as well. I add social media to
the mixture of influences because it is just as, if not more of an influence on attitudes as
film is, because social media is interactive. The consequence of admiration towards
mental illnesses are varied. On a lesser scale, it has shown in behaviors such as using
disorders such as depression or anxiety as accessories to make one’s personality more
interesting. On a more critical scale, it may lead to the tendency to not seek out help if
one is experiencing symptoms of poor mental health due to the weary opinions of the
older generation suspicious of fakery for attention. On the flip-side, over diagnosis can
also occur. There is nothing wrong with trying to humanize mental illness through
depictions in film and social media. However, it needs to be done so more objectively,
with realistic information, and with the “faded flower” aesthetic removed.
4
Historically, popular culture has romanticized and idolized illness. Most notable is
the infatuation with tuberculosis, or in lay terms, consumption, during the mid-1800s.
Medical doctors and common folk alike did not fully understand the nature of this
disease, and the consequences were devastating. Tuberculosis manifested in the forms of
great fatigue, coughing up blood, significant weight loss, and eventually death. As
horrific and bloody as this may sound, and for as many lives the illness claimed, there
was a strange, social phenomenon that occurred; the illness was addressed with an air of
tragic loveliness. Those suffering from it were seen with a new, macabre kind of beauty
(Mullin, 2016).
Tuberculosis was an equal opportunity disease, but was depicted in 19th century
popular literature as the illness of a beautiful young artist, who despite being wracked
with agony, continued to live and go on writing, painting, and engaging in other activities
associated with an intellectual mind. The aesthetic of the ‘faded-flower’ gained immense
popularity, so much so that young women soon began to do their best to appear thin, frail,
pale and flushed of the face despite being unafflicted (Mullin, 2016). This is not to say
that anyone went out of their way to convince a doctor that they were ill, but there was
Since the mystery was gone, the illness became less of an issue. Advancement of medical
knowledge reached not only doctors, but the layman as well. Better hygienic and
nutritional practices became more prevalent, and illness was approached more
methodically than superstitiously or with certain degrees of wonder. This explains why
the romanization of tuberculosis and other physical illness stopped. Without the air of
5
mystery surrounding an affliction, the charm is lost. However, there is a curious
phenomenon that has been rising over the past several decades that mirrors the Victorian
era. Now, instead of romanticizing certain types of physical illness, there has been a trend
of similar attitudes towards some mental illnesses. Despite advanced medical awareness
for the physical aspect of the human body, there is still a great deal hotly debated about
psychological illness, the research involved being just as controversial as it had been with
physical illness in the centuries before. Illnesses of the mind are more of a mystery than
tuberculosis had ever been, as often times the most extreme and detrimental symptoms of
This thesis asserts that there is a trend amongst the younger generation of
romanticizing mental illness, because of unrealistic portrayal in film and social media,
and general lack of understanding from producers of such films and social media
generation” as 13 to 22 years of age. While it is true that the older generation is also
capable of being influenced by popular culture, I am using the 13-22 age range because
those have been the prime populations of discussion in the literature review I have
conducted for this thesis. This is likely because this population is more concerned with
fitting in, and is still constructing their ideals of themselves and the world. Naturally, film
and social media will shape this process, as those are the main sources of information
acquisition and entertainment for the younger generation. This population is also of
special interest to me, as it is the age range I am in, where most of my relationships are,
and where I have the best observational ability due to my collegiate environment.
6
I am choosing film for the main culprit of influence for several reasons. On a
personal level, I have an extensive history with the world of cinema, as I grew up with
my parents owning the only video store in town for over 11 years. My father always
made a point to incorporate “film history education” into my childhood, so over time, I
have seen enough of it to find trends such as those I will be describing in this thesis. Film
has become a source of the misunderstanding of mental illness from the well-meant
attempt to show mental illness in a better and more informative light, in response to
decades of social stigma. I argue that Hollywood is a mirror that reflects societal stressors
and anxieties brought to attention by individual and organizational advocates for social
change.
With the rise of social media as another medium for popular culture, the same
trend can be identified, and I will be using it as a secondary source of influence in regard
to opinions on mental health. Social media are the primary source that most people,
especially the younger generation, use to keep up with world events, celebrity gossip, and
more importantly, societal shifts in opinion and popular trends. There has been a wave in
the past decade of Tumblr and Facebook groups that support depression and anxiety; the
disorders, not so much those that suffer from them. In the attempts of users on various
social media platforms to humanize mental illness, they glamorize it, show it as an
film comes from good intentions as it can be a difficult thing for those are mentally well
to wrap their head around. Those suffering from depression or anxiety will not (usually)
cough up blood, or develop a rash, as was the case with tuberculosis. But there are
7
behavioral manifestations such as withdrawal from the community, isolation from friends
and emotional outbursts. These symptoms can easily be misconstrued as someone simply
being “unagreeable.” Mental ailments are so often initially silent and manifest themselves
only after they have caused a drastic decline in one's quality of life. Many people do not
discuss having mental health issues because it has been considered taboo by Western
society, with more liberal perspectives only emerging in the mainstream since the early
1950s.
strides have been made to reduce the stigmatization of mental illness over the past several
decades. This has occurred due to a better understanding of the existence of it, as well as
causes and treatments. True reform of the way the mentally ill were treated occurred in a
rapid burst in the 1800s. Dorothea Dix is the most common house-hold name amongst
reformers. Dix was a Boston woman (alleged, but not proven to be mentally ill herself)
who spent years interviewing the patients of various mental institutions across New
England. Her results resonated the cruelty and inhumanity inflicted upon patients,
documenting instances such as the mentally ill being chained to their beds, lying in their
own filth, and physically abused (History of Mental Health Treatment, 2017). Her
Era was a writer named Nelly Bly. Bly agreed to go undercover as a mentally ill woman
for a local newspaper so that she may gain first hand experience of the way patients were
being treated. She wrote long accounts of how in closed and locked-in she was, to the
8
point of if there was ever a fire in the instruction, there would be absolutely no ability to
escape. “Treatments” administered to her were often harsh, and included solitary
confinement, hair pulling, and other forms of abuse (History of Mental Health Treatment,
2017). Bly outlined for the general public what living in such a facility was like, and
argued that it clearly was not helping anyone get better, and that public officials needed
isolation and physical abuse. The system now is not perfect though, not by a long shot.
Some states have laws that enforce the taking of psychotropic medication for certain
cases, even if it is against the patient's' will. The mentally ill and their advocates are
certainly still fighting for autonomy, but the situation is still much brighter than it was a
few mere decades ago (History of Mental Health Treatment, 2017). There is no way to
tell what the future of mental health treatment holds; however it is without a doubt that
the reforms beginning in the 1800s have created a healthier climate for mental health
issues. It only makes sense that once patients had ceased being locked up like animals
and made to live as such, that the layman stopped viewing them as people to be gawked
at and feared, and more as individuals that deserve compassion and legitimate medical
attention.
representation in film, but in an unfortunate twist, it is film that has been the main source
Hollywood has taken on the duty of mirroring various societal anxieties and pressures
9
through the decades. This is illustrated with the progression of films depicting hot topics
such as race relations and women’s rights. Before World War II, there was no cinema
that touched on the difficulties of being a woman in a man’s world. Before the 1960s, no
films really showed the tension between black and white Americans. However, these
things change. Around the middle to the end of the second world war, there were more
films showing strong female leads who had ample wit and ambition in the absence of
men. Likewise, around the 1960s, during the beginning of the Civil Rights Movement,
there were films coming out that not only had more African-American actors, but that
In the present century, social reform is centered around the shifting attitudes
regarding mental illness. It is easy to see the trend that film imitates life, as it had for
women’s issues and civil rights. It has even been directly commented on by the APA that
issues of gender equality and racial tension are not so different from mental illness
stigma. The APA vocalized this an article discussing the nation-wide need for
destigmatizing mental illness by stating that the negative feelings surrounding mental
illness are, “in the same category as sexism and racism” (APA, 2016, pg. 10).
Hollywood takes a keen look into such societal stressors. Issues of sexism and the
push for women’s rights have also had their time in the limelight for mainstream
entertainment. During the first world war, women had had to keep business running as
usual with the men all taken away to battle. Since that point, there was an insurgence of
films depicting stronger and more independent women. This theme of the self-sufficient
women arose in film as early 1941 in titles such as “The Little Foxes,” featuring a
southern bell, Regina Giddens, played by the very popular Bette Davis. The film focuses
10
on Regina striving to get a hefty portion of family inheritance whilst battling her brothers.
It was reviewed by The New York Times in a less than favorable light, describing Regina
as “callous,” and that there was “nothing pretty or inspiring” about her (Crowther, 1941,
p. 01). This is not a pleasant or kind review, but it was a product of its time. The idea of
critique of an independent female lead, which was a product of the attitude of the time,
Issues of racism got its time in the limelight a few decades after the rise of
“women’s films.” The 1967 film, “Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner” addressed the topic.
It may have been ahead of its time, but it illustrated the awkwardness, tension, and desire
for acceptance of an interracial couple. Acclaimed film critic of the time, Roger Ebert
noted, "I wonder if Krammer [director] isn’t sneaking up on one of the underlying causes
of racial prejudice when he implies that the fathers feel their masculinity is threatened”
(Ebert, 1968, p.02). It certainly could be argued that this film put a spotlight on some key
elements contributing to racial tension. Though produced in the middle of the 1960s, thus
admittedly a bit late to the Civil Rights party, it has been remembered for decades after
the fact as a quintessential film to represent the changing attitude of the time.
Issues of women’s rights and race relations still show themselves in modern films.
Some most recent examples include “Get Out,” a horror movie about an African-
American man visiting his Caucasian girlfriend’s family in the suburbs. The film took a
gruesome twist following the cult-genre of horror, but more importantly, it satirized the
awkward tension and still bumpy attempts to have smooth interracial relationships. In
11
regard to women's rights, what better way to highlight the strength of women than to
revamp the on-screen version of the Amazonian goddess herself, “Wonder Woman.” This
film was saturated in feminine strength, illustrations of leadership ability, and a general
message that stated, “we don’t need men to thrive, thank you very much.” With these
examples of such block-buster hits illuminating the tender parts of social conflict, we can
now take a step in a slightly different direction, and evaluate cinematic expression of
mental illness.
It was a rocky start, as to be expected, with initial films illustrating those with a
mental illness as either dangerous and psychotic, or child-like and foolish. One of the
more infamous films that uses mental illness as its main framework is Alfred Hitchcock’s
“Psycho” in 1960. This film forms a frightening horror flick, the center-source of the
horror stemming from Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) (sometimes called multiple
personality disorder) in Mr. Norman Bates. This is explained using the twisted
relationship he had with his mother. His mother in the film is deceased, but their warped
and unhealthy relationship had such an impact on him that he begins to take on her
identity, fluctuating from hers to his own in minutes. Psycho, while providing rich and
illness coupled with fear and uncertainty in the layman’s perspective, and crafted horror
from it. It portrayed DID as going hand in hand with psychotic and murderous behavior,
However, to the credit of Psycho, despite the use of DID to promote a horrific
film, it is not without its redeeming qualities, and stands out as being a film of surprising
psychological intelligence for its time. At the very end of the film the psychiatrist
12
character makes a compelling monologue explaining to the police officers and the sister
of the murdered woman the psychological nature of the crime. Though a bit
living with his mother after his father died, “as if they were the only two people in the
world” (Csmoke365, 2016). This fostered extreme jealousy when another man came into
the mother’s life. Bates could not bear it, so he killed the mother and the new man.
However, his attachment to his mother had become so fierce that he was obsessed with
forcing her to essentially live on, so her stole and preserved her body, and began to dress
as her, taking on her personality alongside his own. Sometimes he was Norman, other
times, he was “Mother.” This description of DID did in fact add a humanizing element to
the film. Norman was not just a psychotic killer, he was mentally ill.
entertaining, yet may cause some misinformation was 1991 psychological thriller
“Silence of the Lambs.” This more updated film that uses mental illness as a key focal
point in its storytelling introduces us to Dr. Hannibal Lecter, a famous psychiatrist turned
brutal cannibalistic serial killer. The premise of the film follows the events of fledgling
FBI agent Clarice, whom Lecter assists from behind his prison bars in conducting a
psychological profile on an active serial killer. Throughout the film, Lecter is presented
as charming and well-spoken with superior intelligence and a knack for entangling people
in his games of wit. The director of the prison that holds Lecter describes him in the
opening scene, as a psychopath. “Silence of the Lambs” was an immensely popular film,
and rather influential at the time. On top of carrying A-list names such as Anthony
13
Hopkins and Jodie Foster, it wove a story of intrigue around this psychopathic
personality.
prevalent in public thought. It was soon believed by a vast majority of people that
psychopathy and superior charm and intellect were a packaged deal. This widespread
misunderstanding has even been dubbed “The Lecter Myth” by some scholars (DeLisi,
Vaughn, Beaver & Wright, 2010). Though this is not necessarily an unfavorable way to
realistic. The implication that psychopathy is coupled with superior intelligence is not
only false, it is the exact inverse of what studies have shown. Though there are cases of
most common that individuals who show three or more psychopathic traits (narcissism,
lack of remorse, violence, etc) have lower than average verbal intelligence (DeLisi,
Vaughn, Beaver & Wright, 2010). The idea of a suave, charming serial killer is certainly
fun for the movies and an interesting idea to play with. However, Hollywood bears a
responsibility to accurately portray mental illness, given the significant influence that
films have on the public. We look to film for not only entertainment, but for
In the last two decades there has been a strong resurgence of film and media
exploring mental health in a more objective, sympathetic, and realistic light. Because
Hollywood mirrors prevalent concern and upset in modern society, as it did with race
relations and sexism, it is not surprising that there was a change in the mood of films
14
exploring mental health issues. Hollywood took on the task of exploring the changing
role of women, as shown in “The Little Foxes.” It had also made the effort represent the
education and advocacy for mental health, Hollywood takes on its next task of depicting
illnesses such as depression, anxiety, and even schizophrenia, with an informed sense of
respect and realism. How mental illness actually started being portrayed though, did not
It should be made clear that it is not society as a whole who is pushing for better
attitudes towards mental illness. For example, in a recent public opinion poll taken by the
American Psychiatric Association (APA) in April of this year, on the questions phrased
around whether not one would elect a public official who had been treated for a mental
illness. Results showed that 31 percent (out of a sample of 1,000 from the general
population) strongly agreed that they would not (APA, 2017) This figure certainly does
not indicate that everyone is comfortable with mental illness, however it is still a good
Despite a prevailing sense of unease regarding mental illness and those it affects,
some advocate for eliminating the stigma against mental illness. A foremost example is
the APA, and a powerful example they are. The APA produced an article in July 2016
discussing the need for a “national push” to end the stigma that those suffering from
mental illness face. The most important reason for this push to occur is that fear of
judgment keeps many from seeking treatment (Lu, 2016). This can cause a destructive
cycle, ending in extreme forms of mental illness that has gone untreated. These extreme
15
forms are what society fears; thus, the stigma is a self-fulfilling prophecy. Having disdain
Aside from the APA, another wide-scale organization that has been shouting out
against the stigma of mental illness is the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI).
Upon visiting the online site, the first thing that I saw was a bold headline asking, “Are
you stigma free?” NAMI offers everything from ways to donate to other smaller mental
health facilities, links to where to find support for a whole range of categories such as
LGBTQ, Veterans, Teens and Young Adults, and Family Caregivers. There is also a
whole page dedicated to how mental health is just as important amongst our law
family and loved ones in law enforcement who I have seen suffer, and even lose their
Organizations such as the APA and NAMI are without doubt two major
powerhouses behind the push to destigmatize mental illness in the United States, but
there are also individuals speaking out. Chirlane Mcray, the leader of mental health
advocacy group, Thrive NYC, discusses in her article “It’s Time to De-stigmatize Mental
Health. We Can Start by Talking About It,” discusses how by avoiding the subject of
In the New York Times, there was a frank and emotional article written
around Halloween of last year that discussed the implications of using psychiatric wards
Psychology and a psychiatric patient himself, disparaged Knotts Berry Farm in Buena
Park, CA for their virtual reality horror experience of a mental institution. The attraction
16
would strap its patrons into a wheelchair and put VR goggles on them. The scenes that
played out ranged from being escorted down terrifying halls with patients wandering
aimlessly, to more horrific scenes such as bloody bodies scattered across the floor (as if
they had been attacked by mental patients) (Solomon, 2016). Solomon, having gone
through crippling depression, suicidal thoughts, and multiple hospitalizations, found the
and other mental health advocates were informed of the situation, the issue was taken to
NAMI, who sprang into action and chastised Six Flags for having a similar attraction.
With such outrage underway towards Knott’s Berry Farm and Six Flags, both
respective entertainment industries caved. Knott’s Berry Farm shelved their psychiatric
horror idea, however Six Flags’ compromise may have been even more insulting. Instead
of having mental patients roam the haunted maze, they replaced them with zombies.
Solomon points out that the idea that those contrived as mentally ill can be replaced with
ghoulish creatures such as zombies, makes him feel like even more of an outsider.
It is quite evident that the respective voices of APA, NAMI and other individual
mental health advocates have been loud enough to stir up public concern for how mental
illness is being addressed and represented. Unfortunately, this has led to the issue being
sensationalized. This just goes to show that for social issues to be sensationalized, not
every single citizen needs to be on board with a movement. Powerful groups and
individuals can cause enough interest in reform. This was exactly the case with sexism
and civil rights. Big names and cases such as Susan B. Anthony, Griswold V.
Connecticut, Martin Luther King Jr, Malcolm X, Brown V. Board of education have all
17
been influential in stirring an interest in social reform. Hollywood in turn, has continued
So, with the transition of representation of mental health in popular culture from
silly and frightening to potent and sympathetic, where does this leave us? The optimal
outcome would be for mental health to be addressed with realistic sobriety and respect.
have inadvertently glamorized it, creating an idea that to have a mental illness suggests
This may seem like an initially ludicrous and potentially insensitive assumption;
regarding the tones taken towards mental illness over social media platforms and recent
TV programs. It must be kept in mind that each source I am about to describe has the
Hollywood in the last two decades has taken on the task of showing mental illness
as something not to be feared and run from (as so was clearly the vibe obtained from
Psycho), but to be understood and sympathized with, creating films such as “A Beautiful
Mind” and others that provide an alternative perspective. “A Beautiful Mind” follows the
life of a young mathematical genius who suffers from schizophrenia. This film does not
belittle or make fantastical this particular illness, as films have done in the past when
dealing with mental disorders. It instead provides a somber and realistic look into how
the illness affects normal living, and the toll it can have on personal relationships. It has
been hailed by film critics and news reporters alike of being one of the first films to really
18
hit the mark on depicting mental illness and associated struggles. However, despite
accolades for this film’s progressive take on mental illness, it also sets the stage for an
“genius” and throughout the film, his intellect is his saving grace. This has the potential
to couple mental illness with intelligence, just as “The Silence of the Lambs”
Sheldon Cooper from “The Big Bang Theory” is practically the poster-child for
the trope of the neurotic yet lovable weirdo. The sitcom aired in 2007, featuring four
awkwardness whilst grappling with superior intelligence over their peers. Sheldon’s
character is the quirkiest of them all, and though it is never out rightly stated what mental
schedule of certain meals each week, and having rigid “roommate rules.” He also has
hints of grandiosity, and potentially borderline personality disorder in his lack of ability
to empathize with others. The list could go on forever describing this character’s quirks,
but the moral of the story is that his character is also a “super genius” and the show has
received a huge fan following, with praise that it has humanized certain mental illnesses.
It cannot be denied that the attempts to humanize mental illness in the eyes
of the public have been tenacious and well-received. However, I would like to direct
attention to a different consequence of such efforts that have gone unnoticed. Very much
like the instance of romanticizing tuberculosis in the 1800s, mental illness has taken on
the air of something that makes those it affects as seemingly more unique and interesting
19
than those who have not had to deal with any sort of mental struggle. This is especially
problematic, as it has been frequently disproved that mental illnesses such as personality
intellect. Just recently at Texas State in fact, Dr. Abramovitch has dispelled a 115-year-
old theory (now myth) of Freud’s, that obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) is
colleagues from Israel and North Carolina, he concluded that most cases of OCD
2017).
Unlike modern romantic ideals of mental illness, the issue of romanization came
faster for the case of tuberculosis because it was not initially stigmatized. It was an
unfortunate medical illness that, in a morbid twist of perception, made those it affected,
beautiful martyrs. The fact that tuberculosis had not been initially stigmatized also meant
that research a to what it was and how to cure it also came much swifter, and in turn, the
There has been a trend in popular culture of portraying mental illness as a lovable
quirk rather than a serious personal struggle, and young individuals are beginning to
recognize and call out the effects. In 2014, Kayla Goldstein wrote an article to “Her
Campus,” a journal from Florida State, titled “Mental Illnesses are Not Accessories.”
(Goldstein, 2014). Kayla points out that it is predominately young girls who have fallen
victim to what Janet Street Porter from The Daily Mail has dubbed “The misery
movement” (Porter, 2010). The idea here is that mental illnesses such as depression and
anxiety have become “trendy,” and that they add some intrigue to an otherwise average
20
personality. Kayla attributes this phenomenon to the romanticization of mental illness as
a whole. She laments over hearing peers make such quips to each as “urgh I want a clean
room, I am so OCD!” and “my boyfriend broke up with me. I am depressed” (Goldstein,
2014, p.1). This kind of dialogue not only reveals romanization, but a similar trend of
self-diagnosis in humorous tones. This trend is not only harmful in that it creates the idea
that various mental illnesses are desirable, it is also incredibly insulting to those who
suffer legitimately from debilitating mental illness. It can be rightly assumed that those
who are truly suffering, do not wish to wear their illness as a badge of individuality.
It is not only in film and television that we see the glamorization of mental illness,
it is also pervasive in social media. With the advancement of the decades, we see an
has made a profound impact on people’s lives, about as much as film did when it first
became popularized. Social media is also arguably as, if not more than influential than
film, considering the fact that it is entirely interactive. It comes as no surprise considering
that Facebook and Twitter are a fast, easily accessible and digestible source of news,
popular culture and speaking platform for all opinions. According to Blue Corona, an
online marketing advice company, more than 56% of adults online use more than one
social media platform. On top of this large percentage, 81% of millennials check Twitter
at least once a day (McLeod, 2017). It is clear that social media has become an essential
On popular social media platforms such as Facebook and Tumblr, there are
support pages spreading awareness of depression and other mental illness. These pages
also act as hubs for people suffering to share their experiences, gain peer support and
21
even references to professional help sources. However, as Dawnie Cheng points out in
popular online journal, “Inkspire,” such social media platforms are taking a morbid twist
on reality. She comments that at 13-years-old, her first experience with the romanization
of mental illness was from the internet. “Suddenly it was ‘cool’ to have anxiety or
2017, p.1). Cheng then describes some disturbing aesthetic that comes into play. “Black-
and-white pictures of girls, accompanied with tragic monologues about low self-esteem,
were quite popular.” (Cheng, 2017, p.1). Cheng also points out that it was common to
read stories from the mass media of those who suffer from mental illnesses, and their
enduring romantic partners supporting them every step of the way. Cheng asserts that by
witnessing this kind of romantic situation, that we begin to “want their perfect
Moving from social media, and onto a more theatrical version of popular culture,
the 2017 Netflix series “13 Reasons Why” is another example of depression beautified
and used as the foundation for romantic interest. This series is based off a popular young-
adult novel that follows a high school girl who had gone through a good amount of
bullying and blows to her dignity and self-esteem. Tragically, she commits suicide (while
not graphic in the novel, extremely graphic in the TV series). This then sets up the story
for her former friend and would-be love interest to discover a series of 13 tapes that she
recorded, explaining each specific reason behind her suicide and who was responsible.
This series made headlines for shedding light on the topic of teen-suicide in a
matter of fact and thoughtful way. The is leading lady, Selena Gomez even going so far
as to call the series “beautifully tragic” (Jensen, 2017, p. 01). At this point, it is
22
appearing to be overtly evident that beautifying illness is not just reserved for Victorian
times. However, it is easy to see why this is problematic. This depiction of how a
beautiful girl went through depression and eventually suicide puts forth a powerful
message that in order to be noticed and cared about if one is having a hard time in life,
taking one’s own life is an excellent method. In a way, the suicide gave Hannah the last
word against her aggressors. This approach to dealing with conflict is not only unhealthy,
it is dangerous. Depression, anxiety, any mental health issue that leads to suicide is not
In many ways “13 Reasons Why” was well-meaning and is a far-cry more
sensitive and respectful on the topic of suicide than some of the earlier illustrations. Any
avid movie goer likely remembers cult classic film, “Heathers”, a film which represented
teen suicide as entirely vain, immature and laughable. The film was even turned into a
musical. What is worse about “Heathers” is that the characters who committed suicide
did not even undergo any harsh degree of bullying. The suicides were done on a whim for
attention. I will acknowledge though, that this may have been done on purpose to satirize
teen angst.
illness that I described above are on a spectrum. Social media platforms such as Tumblr
and series like “13 Reasons Why” are predominantly marketed to teens and young adults.
Every popular culture niche requires a demographic, but there are liabilities of marketing
younger generation could prove to be nothing more than an annoying trend. Maybe for
23
another decade we will need to endure sad—eyed models in black-and-white with
subtitles describing why they feel so lonely on Facebook. Perhaps the phrase “I am so
OCD!” will continue to be thrown around for attention until it dies out, as phases do. In
the high school and even college years, “fitting in” is an important goal for social
observing what is deemed “cool” or “popular” or even has a desired reaction of attention,
however it can lead to a spiral of negative consequences if gotten out of hand. A dilemma
that I already observe among my own personal peer relationships is that due to this trend
of romanization of mental illness, the professional community and older adults are
beginning to be suspicious of the younger generation. Those who verbalize or reach out
about legitimate mental health concerns to their parents, teachers or any older adult, are
not being taken seriously. This can lead to those younger individuals never feeling like
they can reach out for help. This consequence circles the whole situation back around to
the beginning of the issue around mental illness stigma in the first place.
On the other hand, maybe we should not be so quick to judge older adults
for not taking the younger pleas for help seriously. The trend of admiring mental illness
also leads to overdiagnosis. Cheung, in the same article relaying her experience of seeing
romantic images of mental illness in social media, cites a troubling statistic. From 2013,
according to Mirror Magazine, 34% of teens in the UK reported faking a mental illness
(Cheung, 2017). The fact that such a large percentage of young people feel the need to lie
24
about a mental illness indicates that there is certainly something wrong with the way it is
bad thing. In fact, it could do a great deal of good in the ongoing attempts to educate the
mass public in a way that everyone can understand. However, the continuation of making
those with mental illness seemingly more attractive, mysterious, intelligent or well-liked,
needs to end.
that my current work has provided an excellent platform to launch a replication of the
study, with the benefit of future resources that will come with more time and a graduate
program. In the replication I would like to gather quantitative regarding attitudes on the
general public towards mental illness before, and after the advent of film. I also find
value in conducting extended personal interviews with members of the 13-22 age
population, as well as mental health professionals. By the time this is feasible, it will be
nearly half a decade after the initial opinion-based information I drew from was
published. I predict that I will be able to unearth similar, and more detailed attitudes as
25
References
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11065-017-9358-0
https://www.psychiatry.org/newsroom/apa-public-opinion-poll-annual-meeting
2017
Cheung, Dawnie. (2017, June 26). When Did Having a Mental Illness Become Cool?
illness-become-cool/-KB0PgCBTrhCdmavWTLC
Retrieved from
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=abAsTTC9puk
Crowther, Bosley. (1941, August 22). Film Review: ‘The Little Foxes’, Full of Evil,
http://www.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=9E04EFD61F3BE233A25751C2AC
946093D6CF
26
DeLisi, M., Vaughn, M. G., Beaver, K. M., & Wright, J. P. (2010). The Hannibal Lecter
Ebert, Roger. ( 1968, January 25) Film Review: Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner.
Retrieved from
https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/guess-whos-coming-to-dinner-1968
Goldstein, Kayla (2014, April 9). Mental Illnesses are not Accessories. Her Campus.
Retrieved from
https://www.hercampus.com/school/fsu/mental-illnesses-are-not-accessories
http://www.dualdiagnosis.org/mental-health-and-addiction/history/
Jensen, Erin. (2017, April 28). Why Selena Gomez is ‘very proud’ of 13 Reasons Why.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/life/tv/2017/04/28/selena-gomez-very-proud-13-
reasons-why-wanted-kids-frightened/101019152/
27
Lu, S. (2016, July). Destigmatizing Mental Illness needs a National Push, Reports Say.
08/upfront-destigmatizing.aspx
McCray, Chirlane. (2016, May 16). It’s Time to Destigmatize Mental Illness. We can
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/may/16/mental-health-month-
stigma-talk-about-it#img-1
Mcleod, Betsy. (2017, April 25). 100+ Social Media Statistics You’ll Want To See
statistics-2017
Mullin, E. (2016, May 10). How Tuberculosis Shaped Victorian Fashion. Retrieved
nature/how-tuberculosis-shaped-victorian-fashion-180959029/
Porter, Janet. (2010, August 5). Depression? It’s Just the New Trendy Illness! Daily
1278510/Depression-Its-just-new-trendy-illness.html
28
Rose, Steve. (2017, January 12). From Split to Psych: why cinema fails dissociative
https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/jan/12/cinema-dissociative-personality-
disorder-split-james-mcavoy
29