Bacteriological Examination of Some Public Swimming Pools
Bacteriological Examination of Some Public Swimming Pools
Bacteriological Examination of Some Public Swimming Pools
ISSN 1990-9233
© IDOSI Publications, 2019
DOI: 10.5829/idosi.mejsr.2019.364.370
Department of Applied Microbiology, Ebonyi State University, P.M.B. 053, Abakaliki, Nigeria
Abstract: The bacteriological analysis of some public swimming pools were carried out in Abakaliki, Ebonyi
State. A total of eight public swimming pools were randomly selected for the analysis. Isolation of the bacterial
species was carried out using the pour plate method while bacterial identification was carried out using
morphological, physiological and biochemical tests. Results of the bacterial load of the samples showed that
bacterial contamination of the swimming pools ranged from 1.3 ×101 cfu/ml to 4.1 ×10 1 cfu/ml. The following
bacteria species were isolated from the samples; Staphylococcus species, Streptococccus species,
Listeria species, Enterococcus species, Pseudomonas species, E. coli, Proteus species and Bacillus species.
Result of the percentage distribution of the bacterial species showed that Staphylococcus species occurred
most frequently at 13(21%) while Bacillus species had the least occurrence of 5 (8%). The presence of some
bacteria species like E. coli and other enteric bacteria species isolated from this study suggest the likelihood
of faecal contamination of the swimming pools and its unsatisfactory sanitary condition. It is therefore
recommended that public swimming pools in Abakaliki and beyond be regularly disinfected /chlorinated.
Those who normally take care of these swimming calculated by multiplying the number of colonies on each
pools have little knowledge about the importance of plate by the reciprocal of the dilution factor of sample
maintaining the pools to meet both the microbiological dilution plated and multiplied by ten, which was reported
and physiochemical standards. Some tend to economize as colony forming units per ml.
chemicals use for sanitizing the pools due to their scarcity
or over chlorinate the pools due to little knowledge of the Number of colonies X Dilution factor
Number of organisms =
recommended quantities to apply and hence compromise 0.1 1
the quality of the swimming pools [10]. The standard Coliform Count: The conventional multiple-tube
guidelines of swimming pools, particularly in developing fermentation (MTF) technique was used to determine the
countries, are not adhered to because little is known most probable number (MPN) of coliform bacteria present
about the contaminants in the pools and the possible in 100 ml of pool water. This technique normally involves
health risks involved [11]. Hence, more studies are needed three steps: Presumptive, confirmed and completed test.
to generate additional information necessary for the
development of swimming pool water quality standards. Presumptive Test: Differential medium for the isolation
This study was designed to assess the bacteriological of coliforms was MacConkey broth. Three broth tube
examination of some public swimming pools within series – the first series containing 3 double strength broth
Abakaliki, Ebonyi state, Nigeria. tubes and the remaining two series comprising 6 single
strength broth tubes – were inoculated with 10ml, 1ml and
MATERIALS AND METHODS 0.1ml of water (ratio 3:3:3) respectively. Tubes were
incubated at 37°C and observed at 24 and 48 hours.
This research was carried out within Abakaliki Presumptive test is positive for coliforms if acid and gas
Metropolis. The population of people in the city has are produced in Durham tubes.
increased as well as the social life of the residents.
Building of hotels with recreational centres such as Confirmed Test: To eliminate false-positives from
swimming pools had been on increase. non-coliform organisms, eosin methylene blue (EMB) agar
plates were inoculated with a loopful from each positive
Sample Collection and Transportation: A total of 16 water presumptive broth tube by streaking across the agar
samples were collected two times from eight different surface. Plates were incubated for 24 h at 37°C.
hotels within Abakaliki metropolis. The sampling periods
were morning before bath and evening after bath. For Completed Test: Finally, nutrient agar slants and
anonymity the selected swimming pools were coded SS, MacConkey broth tubes were inoculated with distinct
SD, AS, CS, SL, OL1, OL2 and VH. Each water sample was colonies picked from cultured isolates on EMB agar
collected with a sterile 250 ml wide mouth plastic container plates. After incubation for 24 hours at 37°C, broth
at depth of about 30 cm from each swimming pool and cultures were observed for acid and gas production and
transported to the laboratory of Applied Microbiology, cultured isolates on agar slants were Gram stain using
Ebonyi State University in a flask containing ice cubes for technique described by Ekopai et al. [12].
analysis within 15 minutes.
Identification of Isolated Bacteria: Growth representative
Bacteriological Examination of Samples of colonies were sub-cultured on nutrient agar medium
Total Aerobic Plate Count: The water samples were and incubated for 24 hours at 37°C. The colonial
10-fold serially diluted in 9 ml of sterilized peptone water characteristics on agar plates were taken into
contained in each of the tubes by transferring 1ml of water consideration. The characterization and identification of
in the first test tube and mixed; then 1 ml of the first isolated bacteria were carried out using the procedures of
dilution was drawn out into the second tube. This was Francois and Schrenzel [13]. The chemical and
continued until the 4th tube. Then 100 ??l of two sample biochemical tests employed were, Gram’s staining
dilutions of 10 2 and 10 4 including the neat (undiluted reaction, motility, catalase, coagulase, methyl red, oxidase
sample) was plated onto the plate count agar by surface reaction, indole, Voges proskauer, urease, motility, citrate
spread using a sterilized glass spreader for uniform utilization and sugar fermentation.
inoculation. The plates were incubated at 37°C for
48 hours. Following appropriate length of incubation, Statistical Analysis: The frequency of occurrence of the
all visible colonies were counted and the results were bacteria isolated were calculated using.
365
Middle-East J. Sci. Res., 27 (5): 364-370, 2019
366
Middle-East J. Sci. Res., 27 (5): 364-370, 2019
The confirmatory test of coliforms from the selected Most of these bacterial isolates are known enterotoxin
swimming pools shows that the water from swimming producers when ingested into the body, therefore the
pools designated SD, OL1 and OL2 showed positive with presence of these bacteria in pools is a threat to public
Eosin methylene blue agar as shown in Table 5. health [20]. The presence of pathogens in water for
drinking and swimming purposes is of public health
DISCUSSION concern [21]. Swimmers can accidentally swallow
contaminated pool water during swimming which can
The bacterial load of six swimming pools (SS, SD, CS, result in outbreaks of diseases like cholera, shigellosis,
SL, OL1 and OL2) water analyzed was relatively high as typhoid fever, gastroenteritis and diarrhea [22, 23].
shown in Table 1. This high bacterial load might be due to Staphylococcus species is known to produce
the low residual chlorine level or because the bacteria enterotoxin. Proteus species belongs to the intestinal flora
have become resistant to the calcium hypochlorite that is but is also widely distributed in soil and water Reali et al.
used in treating those swimming pools, similar reports [24]. Enterobacter aerogenes isolated from the water
were also made by Francois and Schrenzel [13], Itah and samples are examples of non faecal coliform and can be
Ekpombok [14], Klapes and Vesley [15] , Lumb et al. [16]. found in vegetation and soil which serves as sources
The results obtained in this work with bacterial count that by which the pathogens enters the water Saba and
ranged from 1.3×101 Cfu/ml to 4.1×101 Cfu/ml showed that Tekpor [25]. Schlegel[26] suggested that pool operators
the swimming pools did not meet the WHO standard that should drain the water from the pools and do disinfection
has been accepted by Nigeria. Also, samples in AS and after use. In line with the report of this study, Shittu,
VH were acceptable according to WHO standard for Olaitan and Amusa [27] in Accra, Ghana isolated E. coli,
aerobic plate count as a result of no growth in them Enterobacter faecalis, Klebsiella pneumonae,
(WHO, 2004). Staphylococcus aereus and Staphylococcus epidermides
The following bacteria species were isolated from the from swimming pools. Also, in a related study on
samples; Staphylococcus species, Streptococccus swimming pools in Ilorin, Nigeria, Micrococcus,
species, Listeria species, Enterococcus species, Aeromonas, Pseudomonas, Klebsiella, Lactobacillus,
Pseudomonas species, E. coli, Proteus species and Bacillus, Citrobacter, Corynobacterium, E. coli and
Bacillus species (Table 2). The isolation of different Staphylococcus aureus were equally isolated [28].
species of bacteria which are known human pathogens Another similar study which was investigated on
from these pools might be due to feacal contamination swimming pools in Lagos, the bacteria isolated were
from both humans and animals [17, 18]. Pseudomonas Enterococcus faecalis, Clostridium perfringes, Bacillus
species are associated with surface run-off water, while cereus, E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Proteus
E. coli, S. epidermidis and S. aureus are usually vulgaris, Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus
contributed by bathers in the swimming pools [19]. epidermidis [29]. Staphylococcus aureus and Bacillus
367
Middle-East J. Sci. Res., 27 (5): 364-370, 2019
cereus could be associated with gastroenteritis when to swimmers will increase because the concentration of
ingested with swimming pool water and both organisms chlorine is not enough to eliminate the microorganisms in
are enterotoxin producers [30]. The presence of the pool. Anyim et al. [7] stated that a swimming pool may
Pseudomonas species found in this study is likely to be be infected with pathogenic microorganisms such as
attributed to the growth of Pseudomonas species being coliforms entering the pool either directly or indirectly
supported by the warm, moist environment on decks and through contaminated human or animal excrement such as
floors as previously reported by the Saskatchewan feces and urine from the swimmers. Tate, Mawer and
Ministry of Health (2010). The E. coli isolates obtained in Newton [28] stated that the treatment of water for drinking
this study is most probably derived from swimmers, and swimming purposes should focus on the elimination
human origin is presumed. of coliform bacteria so as to prevent an epidemic of water
Staphylococcus species had the highest occurrence related diseases.
with the percentage occurrence of 21.0 %, followed by
Streptococcus species (16.0 %), Enterococcus species CONCLUSION
(13.0 %), while E. coli and Pseudomonas species had the
least occurrence of 10.0 % (Table 3). The findings that the The study indicated that most swimming pools within
species of Staphylococcus species isolated from the the Abakaliki metropolis were contaminated. The isolation
swimming pools were more than other bacterial isolates of pathogenic enteric bacteria and Staphylococcus aureus
was not surprising because this organism exist in large from this study is an indication of poor bather hygiene
number on the human skin, in other words, they are and poor compliance of the standards. Thus, there is a
normal flora of the skin. Similarly, Yang et al. [31] also need to increase monitoring of the recreational facilities,
reported that the major contaminating bacteria of increased bather hygiene education, as well as pool staff
swimming pools have been Staphylococci species. education and improved pool circulation. Furthermore,
Yoder et al. [32] reported that the major contaminants of studies should be carried out on other microbial
swimming pools and other recreational waters with high contaminants apart from bacteria that contaminate
bather density are Staphylococcus epidermidis and swimming pool water and also on pool architecture and
Staphylococcus aureus. The result of this study is also bather population that contribute to poor compliance of
similar to that of Alcock [3] who reported Staphylococcus the standards.
aureus as the highest bacterial isolated obtained from
swimming pools in Accra, Ghana. REFERENCES
Three swimming pools (SD, OL1 and OL2) out of the
eight sampled for presumptive test were coliforms positive 1. Abd El-Salam, M.M., 2012. Assessment of water
on lactose broth shown in Table 4. This three swimming quality of some swimming pools: A case study in
pool designated SD, OL1 and OL2 were also positive for Alexandria, Egypt. Environmental Monitory
coliforms with Eosin methylene blue agar as the Assessment., 184: 7395-7406.
confirmatory test (Table 5). The presence of coliforms in 2. Abdou, M.H., M.A. Akel, W.I. El-Shal and
swimming pools is as a result of low free chlorine A.S. El-Naggar, 2005. Study of the environmental
concentrations which are usually below the minimum health aspects of swimming pools in Alexandria
permissible limit set by the National Swimming Pool city. Journal of Egyptian Public Health Association.,
Foundation [30]. Microbes can quickly multiply in water 80: 263-296.
because of lack cleansing ability due to the lower 3. Alcock, S.R., 1979. Acute otitis externa in divers
concentrations of chlorine [24]. It has been previously working in the North sea: A microbiological
reported that there is a significant association between survey of seven saturation divers. Journal of
pool contamination and free residual chlorine Hygiene, 18: 359-409.
concentration [5]. However, even though the chlorine 4. Amala, S.E. and C.P. Aleru, 2016. Bacteriological
levels were not measured in this study, all results for the Quality of Swimming Pools Water in Port Harcourt
total coliform, E. coli and other bacteria load can be Metropolis. Natural Science, 8: 79-84.
attributed to the level of free residual chlorine 5. American Public Health Association, APHA, 1998.
concentrations in the swimming pools water. [31], Microbiological examination. In standard methods for
reported that when the concentration of free chlorine is the examination of water and Wastewater.
too low, the risk for bacterial growth and infection disease Washington, DC, USA, 12: 308-309.
368
Middle-East J. Sci. Res., 27 (5): 364-370, 2019
6. Aneja, K.R., 2003. Experiments in microbiology, plant 17. Maida, C.M., M.A. Di Benedetto, A. Firenze,
pathology and biotechnology. New Age G. Calamusa, F. Di Pazza and M.E. Milici, 2008.
International, New Delhi, India, pp: 100-256. Surveillance of the sanitary conditions of a public
7. Anyim, C., A.C. Nwuzo, O. Nworie, M.O. Oko and swimming pools in the city of Palermo (Italy). Sanita
M.V. Agah, 2012. Evaluation of water quality used for Publication, 649(5): 281-293.
drinking and swimming purposes in Ishiagu 18. Nemery, B., P.M. Hoet and D. Nowak, 2002.
community, Ebonyi State. Journal of Chemical, Indoor swimming pools, water chlorination and
Biological and Physical Sciences, 3(1): 581-587. respiratory health. European Respiratory Journal,
8. Ayandele, A.A., E.A. Adebayo and E.K. Oladipo, 19: 790-793.
2015. Assessment of microbiological quality of 19. Osei-Adjei, G., S.K. Sarpong, E. Laryea and
outdoor swimming pools in Ilorin, Kwara state. IOSR E. Tagoe, 2014. Bacteriological Quality
Journal of Environmental Science, Toxicology and Assessment of swimming pools in the Osu-Labadi
Food Technology, 9(8): 25-30. Area, Accra. Journal of Natural Sciences Research,
9. Barna, Z. and M. Kadar, 2012. The risk of contracting 4(19): 126-129.
infectious diseases in public swimming pools: A 20. Pesewu, G.A., N.A. Boakye, V. Norshie, D.N. Adjei,
review. Annali Dell'Istituto Superiore Di Sanita., M.A. Olu-Taiwo, F.C. Mills-Robertson, S. Osei-
48: 374-386. Djarbeng, R.H. Asmah and P.F. Ayeh-Kumi, 2015.
10. Bello, O.O., O.O. Mabekoje, H.O. Egberongbe and Bacteriological assessment of water quality of public
T.K. Bello, 2012. Microbial qualities of Swimming swimming pools in the Accra Metropolis, Ghana.
Pools in Lagos, Nigeria. International Journal of Current Research Journal of Biological Science,
Applied Science and Technology, 2(8): 89-96. 7(2): 31-36.
11. Cairns, J.J. and K.L. Dickson, 2003. Biological 21. Prescott, L.M., J.P. Harleyand D.A. Klein, 2002.
methods for the assessment of water quality. Microbiology, 5th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Book:
American Water Works Association Bulletin, 1026.
pp: 13-5. 22. Public and Environmental Health Act of Government
12. Ekopai, J.M., N.L. Musisi, H. Onyuth, B.G. Namara of Australia, PEHAGA, 1998. Standard for the
and C. Sente, 2016. Determination of bacterial quality Operation of Swimming Pools and Spa Pools in South
of water in randomly selected swimming pools in Australia. PEHAGA Report., pp: 42.
Kampala city, Uganda. Natural Science, 8: 79-84. 23. Rasti, S.K., M.A. Assadi, L. Iranshahi, M. Salfari,
13. Francois, P. and J. Schrenzel, 2008. Rapid diagnosis H.R. Gilasi and M. Pourbabee, 2012. Assessment of
and typing of Staphylococcus aureus. WEINERs: Microbial Contamination and Physicochemical
Molecular Genetics. Caister Academic Press, USA., Conditions of Public Pools In Kashan, Iran.
pp: 978. Jundishapur Journal of Microbiology, 5(3): 450-455.
14. Itah, A.Y. and M.V.N. Ekpombok, 2004. Pollution 24. Reali, D., M.G. Deriu, P. Baldi, A. Baggiani and
status of swimming pools in south-south zone of B. Pinto, 2004. Mycobacteria in swimming pool water
south-eastern nigeria using microbiological and and the meaning of microbiological conventional
physicochemical indices. South East Asian Journal of indicators. Annali D’Igiene, 16(1-2): 247-253.
Tropical Medicine and Public Health, 35(2): 488-493. 25. Saba, C.K.S. and S.K. Tekpor, 2015. Water quality
15. Klapes, N.A. and D. Vesley, 1986. Rapid assay for assessment of swimming pools and risk of spreading
in situ identification of coagulase-positive infections in Ghana. Research Journal of
staphylococci recovered by membrane filtration from Microbiology, 10(1): 14-23.
swimming pool water. Applied and Environmental 26. Schlegel, H.G., 2002. General microbiology. 7th edition.
Microbiology, 52: 589-590. Cambridge University Press, United Kingdom,
16. Lumb, R., R. Stapledon, A. Scroop, P. Bond, pp: 480.
D. Cunliffe, A. Goodwin, R. Doyle and I. Bastian, 27. Shittu, O.B., J.O. Olaitan and T.S. Amusa, 2008.
2004. Investigation of spa pools associated with Physico-chemical and bacteriological analysis of
lung disorders caused by Mycobacterium avium water used for drinking and swimming purposes in
complex in immunocompetent adults. Applied and Abeokuta, Nigeria. African Journal of Biomedical
Environmental Microbiology, 70: 4906-4910. Research, 11(3): 285-290.
369
Middle-East J. Sci. Res., 27 (5): 364-370, 2019
28. Tate, D., S. Mawer and A. Newton, 2003. Outbreak 31. Yang, L., C. Schmalz, J. Zhou, C. Zwiener,
of Pseudomonas aeruginosa folliculitis associated V.W.C. Chang, L. Ge and M.P. Wan, 2016. An insight
with a swimming pool inflatable. Epidemiology and of disinfection by-product (DBP) formation by
Infection, 130: 187-192. alternative disinfectants for swimming pool
29. Van Heerden, J., M.M. Ehlers and W.O.K. Grabow, disinfection under tropical conditions. Water
2005. Detection and risk assessment of adenoviruses Research, 101: 535-546.
in swimming pool water. Journal of Applied 32. Yoder, J.S., B.G. Black, G.F. Craun, D.A. Lery,
Microbiology, 99: 1256-1264. N. Chen, S.H. Lee, R.L. Caldeon and M.J. Beach, 2004.
30. World Health Organization, WHO, 2006. Surveillance of water borne disease outbreaks
Guidelines for safe recreational water environments: associated with recreational water. United States,
Swimming pools and similar environments. WHO, 2001-2002. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report
USA, 2: 118. Surveillance Summaries, 53: 1-22.
370