Narrative (83) Spacex To FCC
Narrative (83) Spacex To FCC
Narrative (83) Spacex To FCC
)
Application of )
)
SPACE EXPLORATION HOLDINGS, LLC ) Call Signs: S3069/S2992
)
For Modification of Authorization for the ) ICFS File No. SAT-MOD-_____________
SpaceX Gen2 NGSO Satellite System )
)
MODIFICATION OF AUTHORIZATION
FOR THE SPACEX GEN2 NGSO SATELLITE SYSTEM
Jameson Dempsey
Director, Satellite Policy
SPACE EXPLORATION
TECHNOLOGIES CORP.
1 Rocket Road
Hawthorne, CA 90250
310-682-9836 tel
In the nearly two years since SpaceX first launched satellites into its second-generation
(“Gen2”) satellite system, it has continually sought opportunities to provide ever-better service to
ever-more consumers while leading the way on responsible, sustainable operations in space. Building
upon its considerable on-orbit experience, this modification application seeks several small-but-
meaningful updates to the orbital configuration and operational parameters for its Gen2 space station
authorization to improve space sustainability, better respond to evolving demand, and more
efficiently share spectrum with other spectrum users. The application also seeks several conforming
changes to align the Gen2 authorization with the Commission’s flexible use policies, the Space
Innovation Agenda, and recent updates in Commission policy and international rules following the
(“WRC-23”).
In parallel to this application, SpaceX submits an amendment to the pending part of the Gen2
application requesting additional upgrades to its Gen2 system that the Commission has not yet
addressed, including SpaceX’s orbital shells below 400 km and frequencies beyond those requested
in the original application. Together, this modification and its companion amendment will enable the
Gen2 system to deliver gigabit-speed, truly low-latency broadband and ubiquitous mobile
connectivity to all Americans and the billions of people globally who still lack access to adequate
broadband. Because the modification and amendment will affect the overall Gen2 system, SpaceX
has prepared certain showings in its Technical Attachment to demonstrate that, taken as a whole,
SpaceX’s proposed Gen2 upgrade will benefit the public interest and will not cause significant
dynamically respond to evolving consumer demand. SpaceX first modifies the orbital parameters
i
of its current Gen2 authorization to improve the sustainability of its currently authorized Gen2 system
and keep pace with rapidly evolving consumer demand for high-quality broadband globally.
Specifically, SpaceX requests authority to lower the nominal altitudes of its shells at 525 km, 530
km, and 535 km to 480 km, 485 km, and 475 km altitude, respectively. For the lower-altitude shell
at 475 km, SpaceX requests authority to reduce the nominal inclination from 33 degrees to 32 degrees.
With the exception of its shell at 475 km altitude, SpaceX requests to modify its authorization to more
flexibly distribute satellites in up to 56 planes per shell and up to 120 satellites per plane. While this
reconfiguration will result in a higher potential maximum number of orbital planes and satellites per
plane for all but one shell at 475 km, the total number of satellites in the Gen2 system will not exceed
29,988 satellites, and the first tranche of satellites in the Gen2 system will remain 7,500 satellites
until such time that the Commission permits deployments beyond that first tranche.2 Finally, SpaceX
requests to align the altitude tolerance and inclination tolerance in its Gen2 authorization with the
tolerances that the ITU has established for NGSO operations—i.e., an altitude tolerance of +/- 100
1
SpaceX requests authority to operate satellites in its 475 km shell at 32 degrees inclination to accommodate
upcoming Starship launches of satellites for SpaceX’s Gen2 system from its Starbase launch facilities in Boca
Chica, TX. If the Federal Aviation Administration (“FAA”) does not allow for Starship launches at 32 degrees
from Starbase, TX, SpaceX requests for authority to launch into the 28-degree inclination at 475 km altitude.
2
SpaceX is also submitting, in parallel, an amendment to the deferred portion of its Gen2 application (collectively,
“Gen2 Upgrade Applications”) with a request for authority to deploy SpaceX’s full Gen2 system. For avoidance of
doubt, SpaceX seeks to operate both its authorized 7,500 first tranche of satellites and its pending request for the
remaining 22,488 satellites across all updated Gen2 orbital shells, including those proposed in this modification and
in SpaceX’s parallel amendment. Moreover, while neither the Commission’s rules nor the Gen2 Authorization
require SpaceX to file a modification or amendment to request Commission action on the deferred remainder of
SpaceX’s Gen2 Application, for completeness, SpaceX requests that as a part of any grant of the Gen2 Upgrade
Applications that it authorize SpaceX to deploy its entire requested Gen2 system, as modified and amended.
ii
This reconfiguration will enable SpaceX to deliver better broadband coverage and service
quality for American consumers in areas of high demand and respond to evolving consumer demand
by rapidly and flexibly deploying capacity across the United States and around the world where it is
needed most.
mobile and fixed services, and terrestrial and satellite networks, next-generation satellite operators
will require not just reliable access to spectrum resources, but also more flexible use of that spectrum.
To that end, SpaceX requests to modify its Gen2 authorization to use Ka-, V-, and E-band frequencies
for either mobile- or fixed-satellite use cases where the U.S. or International Table of Frequency
Allocations permits such dual use and where the antenna parameters would be indistinguishable.
SpaceX also seeks to modify its authorization to clarify the proposed uses of its stations with phased
array antennas and those with parabolic antennas. These small modifications, which align with
Commission precedent, do not involve any changes to the technical parameters of SpaceX’s
authorization, but would permit significant additional flexibility to meet the diverse connectivity and
higher quality service to consumers, SpaceX requests to modify its minimum elevation angle for
communications with earth stations for satellites operating in shells at nominal altitudes below 500
km. Specifically, SpaceX seeks to lower its minimum elevation angle from 25 degrees to 20 degrees
for satellites operating between 400 and 500 km altitude. Reducing the minimum elevation angle in
this way will enhance customer connectivity by allowing satellites to connect to more earth stations
directly and to maintain connections with earth stations for a longer period of time while flying
overhead.
***
iii
This Modification will vastly improve the coverage, quality, and reliability of the authorized
portion of SpaceX’s Gen2 system for American consumers and people around the world, and will do
so without causing significant interference problems for other licensed operators or increasing any
orbital debris mitigation risk. Accordingly, the Commission should find that grant of this
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................... i
CONCLUSION ........................................................................................................................... 16
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20554
)
Application of )
)
SPACE EXPLORATION HOLDINGS, LLC ) Call Signs: S3069/S2992
)
For Modification of Authorization for the ) ICFS File No. SAT-MOD-_____________
SpaceX Gen2 NGSO Satellite System )
)
Space Exploration Holdings, LLC (“SpaceX”) submits this application to modify its
system”) to further improve the sustainability of its Gen2 system and—together with its companion
to all Americans and the billions of people around the world who lack adequate broadband.3 This
modification application reflects SpaceX’s iterative approach to satellite innovation and the
significant on-orbit experience it has gained in the nearly two years since SpaceX first launched
satellites into its Gen2 satellite system. This experience has only further emphasized the
sustainability and consumer benefits of operating satellites at lower, self-cleaning altitudes. It also
reflects the need for operational flexibility to ensure that U.S.-licensed satellite operators not only
keep pace with growing and evolving consumer demand for high-speed, low-latency broadband
and ubiquitous mobile connectivity, but also remain globally competitive amidst the rise of state-
owned and state-backed satellite systems that have been deploying at a rapid clip.
3
See Application for Approval of Orbital Deployment and Operating Authority for the SpaceX Gen2 NGSO
Satellite System, ICFS File No. SAT-LOA-20200526-00055 (filed May 26, 2020); Amendment, ICFS File No.
SAT-AMD-20210818-00105 (filed Aug. 18, 2021) (collectively, “Original Application”).
6
A completed Form 312, accompanying Schedule S, Technical Attachment, and Waiver
Requests are associated with this application, consistent with the information required by the
I. DESCRIPTION OF MODIFICATION
The Commission has granted in part and deferred in part SpaceX’s application for its Gen2
satellite system, authorizing SpaceX to deploy and operate a first tranche of 7,500 satellites
operating using Ku-, Ka-, V-, and E-band spectrum in three orbital shells at nominal altitudes of
525, 530, and 535 km.4 Since then, SpaceX has made considerable progress deploying the system,
launching nearly 3,000 satellites that—together with SpaceX’s separate first-generation system—
now serve over four million people around the world. This modification seeks to further improve
the coverage, service quality, reliability, and sustainability of the Gen2 system by updating the
orbital parameters, satellite distribution, service allocations, and operational parameters of the
currently authorized part of the Gen2 system. These updates reflect both technological innovations
and regulatory developments in the Commission’s Space Innovation Agenda since SpaceX filed
its initial Gen2 application, and will allow SpaceX to keep pace with growing and evolving demand
from millions of Americans and people around the world for fiber-like, low-latency broadband
wherever they live or travel. As noted above, in parallel with this modification application, SpaceX
will submit an amendment to the part of the Gen2 application that remains pending.
Orbital reconfiguration of 500 km shells. SpaceX requests several changes to the orbital
parameters of its operations between altitudes of 525 km and 535 km. First, SpaceX requests
4
See Space Exploration Holdings, LLC, Order and Authorization, 37 FCC Rcd. 14882 (2022) (“Gen2 Order”);
Space Exploration Holdings, LLC, ; Request for Orbital Deployment and Operating Authority for the SpaceX
Gen2 NGSO Satellite System, DA 24-222, ICFS File Nos. SAT-LOA-20200526-00055 SAT-AMD-20210818-
00105 SAT-AMD-20221216-00175, Call Sign: S3069 (SB rel. Mar. 8, 2024) (granting authority for E-band
payloads); Stamp Grant, ICFS File No. SAT-MOD-20230322-00062 (SB reissued Nov. 9, 2023) (granting
authority for V-band payloads).
7
authority to lower the nominal altitudes of its shells at 525 km, 530 km, and 535 km to 480 km,
485 km, and 475 km altitude, respectively. For the lower-altitude shell at 475 km, SpaceX requests
authority to reduce the nominal inclination from 33 degrees to 28 or 32 degrees.5 Together, these
Lowering the nominal altitude of the authorized shells between 525 km and 535 km will promote
space sustainability by lowering the passive-decay collision probability and post-mission disposal
timeframe of Gen2 satellites. Lowering these nominal altitudes will also benefit consumers by
further reducing broadband latency for consumers. Reducing the nominal inclination of the 475
leverage launches of its Starship launch vehicle from Boca Chica, TX, which may initially require
Consistent with recent updates to the Radio Regulations following the 2023 World
Radiocommunication Conference, SpaceX requests to operate these Gen2 orbital shells within an
altitude tolerance of +/- 100 km and within an inclination tolerance of +/- 2 degrees.6 Beyond
aligning SpaceX’s operations with those of non-U.S. satellite competitors seeking to provide
similar services, updating the orbital and inclination tolerance of orbital shells within the Gen2
system would promote space sustainability as a greater number of NGSO satellite systems deploy
5
If the Federal Aviation Administration (“FAA”) does not allow for Starship launches at 32 degrees from Starbase,
TX, SpaceX requests for authority to launch into the 28-degree inclination at 475 km altitude.
6
See ITU Radio Regs., Resolution 8 (WRC-23).
8
in and around similar orbits.
To better adapt the system to evolving end-user demand, SpaceX also requests to distribute
satellites in its shells at 480 km and 485 km in up to 56 planes per shell with up to 120 satellites
per plane. While this reconfiguration will result in a higher maximum number of orbital planes
and satellites per plane, the complete Gen2 system will not exceed 29,988 satellites, and, as the
Technical Attachment shows, the reconfiguration will neither cause unacceptable interference to
GSO systems nor cause significant interference problems for NGSO systems.
Flexible use of authorized frequencies. The Commission has authorized SpaceX to use
Ku-, Ka-, V-, and E-band frequencies on its Gen2 satellites to deliver high-speed, low-latency
broadband service to consumers around the world. Consistent with the Commission’s long-
standing flexible-use policies and space station licensing precedent, this modification requests
authority to expand the range and quality of beneficial services that the Gen2 system can provide
to people on the ground and on the go. SpaceX updates its Schedule S and the Technical
SpaceX seeks authority to use its authorized frequency ranges in the Ku-, Ka-, V-, and E-
band for both Fixed-Satellite Service (“FSS”) and Mobile-Satellite Service (“MSS”) in frequency
ranges that share allocations for both FSS and MSS. Specifically, SpaceX requests that the
Commission permit satellites in its authorized Gen2 constellation to provide both FSS and MSS
operations in the (1) 14-14.5 GHz (uplink) band; (2) 19.7-20.2 GHz (downlink) and 29.5-30.0 GHz
(uplink) band; (3) 40-40.5 GHz (downlink) globally, 40.5-41 GHz (downlink) on a secondary basis
in Region 2; and (4) 71-74 GHz (downlink) and 81-84 GHz (uplink) bands.7 MSS operations in
7
SpaceX requests similar authority in certain additional frequencies in the accompanying amendment
request.
9
these bands will have the same characteristics—including highly directional beams—as SpaceX’s
FSS operations, and therefore would be indistinguishable from FSS operations in the bands.
In addition, SpaceX requests to modify its Gen2 authorization to permit use of all
authorized Gen2 frequencies in the Ku-, Ka-, V-, and E-bands—except for those frequencies
identified solely for TT&C—for either gateway earth stations or non-gateway earth stations (e.g.,
user links). Doing so will not involve changes to the operating parameters of SpaceX’s space
stations using these bands, but would better enable SpaceX to deploy equipment for consumer,
enterprise, and government use cases to meet individual capacity needs. In any event, authorized
earth station operations will comply with relevant technical limits and licensing requirements—
including individual or blanket licensing as applicable. For clarity, SpaceX refers herein to
different earth stations by their antenna type—parabolic or phased array—where earth stations
with phased array antennas will be used for communications in Ku- and Ka- band, while earth
stations with parabolic antennas will be used for communications in the Ka-, V-, and E-band.
Modern, efficient GSO-NGSO sharing. For spectrum bands governed by the overly
conservative equivalent power flux-density (“EPFD”) limits of the ITU, SpaceX requests to waive
the current EPFD limits for downlink operations within the United States, reflecting Commission
policy finding that those limits are outdated, overly restrictive, and harm consumers, competition,
and satellite innovation. SpaceX submits with this application a waiver request and technical
analysis demonstrating that its proposed Gen2 satellite system can continue to protect GSO FSS
Lower minimum elevation angle for earth stations. SpaceX requests to modify its Gen2
system to update the minimum elevation angle for communications with SpaceX’s parabolic and
10
phased array earth stations for satellites operating in shells at nominal altitudes below 500 km.
Specifically, SpaceX seeks to operate down to a minimum elevation angle of 20 degrees for
Granting this modification would promote the public interest by improving the coverage,
quality, reliability, and sustainability of SpaceX’s Gen2 system without causing significant
interference problems for other non-geostationary orbit systems or unacceptable interference for
geostationary orbit systems, or increasing orbital debris risk. Together with its companion Gen2
upgrade amendment, this modification will deliver fiber-like broadband and ubiquitous mobile
connectivity to help close the digital divide for billions of people around the world who still lack
The orbital reconfiguration of the 500 km shells will promote space sustainability and
enable more adaptive deployment to meet demand. SpaceX has continually sought opportunities
to lead the way in space sustainability, including by operating its satellites at lower altitudes even
when doing so comes at great cost to SpaceX. Permitting SpaceX to lower the nominal altitude of
its satellites in its 500 km shells to the 475 km to 485 km range will enhance space sustainability.
As the Commission recognized in the Gen2 Order, “lower altitudes present lower risk than at
higher altitudes, where remaining orbital lifetimes are longer.”9 Lowering satellites in the 500 km
shells downward will reduce the passive-decay collision probability of satellites in those shells as
well as the post-mission disposal timeframe. This adjusted nominal altitude also provides
additional flexibility for the Gen2 system to operate below emerging constellations with less
8
SpaceX will continue to operate down to five degrees minimum elevation angle at latitudes in polar regions, i.e.,
above 62 degrees.
9
Gen2 Order ¶ 85.
11
operational experience, including foreign systems that do not publish their ephemerides or
covariance data.
Shifting the nominal altitude of these shells downward will also help to anticipate
upcoming changes in the solar cycle. When SpaceX initially applied for its Gen2 system in 2020,
it did so in anticipation of upcoming solar maximum, where operating above nominal altitudes can
help to overcome increased solar activity and the resulting atmospheric drag on satellites. With
solar maximum now predicted to occur as early as this year, flexibility to operate above nominal
altitudes remains important. But after solar maximum, the calculation shifts as solar activity
decreases toward solar minimum. As it does, operating below nominal altitudes will ensure that
Revising SpaceX’s current Gen2 nominal altitudes downward will also help to compensate
for the current restriction that limits SpaceX’s Gen2 operations to below 580 km.10 The
Commission imposed that restriction at the request of Amazon, which claims, when convenient,
its future satellite system will be too fragile to share altitude ranges with other constellations. And
while Amazon now seems to claim that it is in fact capable of operating in orbits overlapping with
other systems, it has notably failed to request that the limitation it sought on SpaceX’s operations
be removed. So, while Amazon still has not deployed a single commercial satellite, the condition
has real-world impacts for SpaceX right now, providing tens of kilometers less room to maneuver
above its nominal orbital shell altitudes than it otherwise would be able to use. Revising the
nominal altitude for these 500 km shells would help to compensate for this restriction.
The updated orbital configuration for the 500 km shells will also enable SpaceX to more
responsively adapt its network deployment to efficiently respond to evolving consumer demand
10
Id. ¶ 135aa.
12
on a global scale. As next-generation satellite systems provide an increasing array of beneficial
services to people on the ground—from consumer broadband and cellular backhaul to Internet of
Things and supplemental coverage—network demand has rapidly grown and evolved. This
processing timeframes, creating significant risks of coverage and capacity constraints that could
otherwise be swiftly addressed through targeted deployments. Just as terrestrial operators are not
required to commit to specific base station locations at the time of licensing, SpaceX’s proposed
Gen2 orbital configuration would enable it to launch satellites and deploy capacity where it is
needed most in anticipation of, and in response to, evolving consumer demand. In so doing,
SpaceX can more efficiently deploy a global service free from capacity constraints and with a high
Finally, aligning SpaceX’s altitude and inclination tolerance with those that the ITU
adopted at WRC-23—namely an altitude tolerance of +/- 100 degrees and an inclination tolerance
of +/- 2 degrees—will ensure that SpaceX retains the same operational flexibility that its global
Permitting flexible use of the authorized Gen2 frequencies will enhance network
capacity and service quality for consumers and set the stage for 6G. The Commission has
repeatedly recognized how reliable access to Ku-, Ka-, and V-band frequencies enables next-
industrial, and government end users. As 6G interweaves mobile and fixed, as well as terrestrial
and satellite, networks, next-generation satellite operators will require not just reliable access to
these frequencies, but more flexible access too. Indeed, in the near future, an end user will be able
13
to seamlessly switch from a home fixed satellite broadband connection to a terrestrial cell tower
airplane or vessel over the course of a single day. The Commission has long supported flexible
terrestrial use of millimeter wave bands that share both fixed and mobile allocations, and expanded
this policy to NGSO FSS and MSS allocations when it authorized Amazon to use the 19.7-20.2
GHz and 29.5-30.0 GHz bands for both fixed and mobile use cases, noting the increasing
convergence of fixed and mobile satellite transmissions over the last 15 years.11 Permitting
SpaceX to use its authorized FSS frequencies for MSS operations in bands that share both FSS
and MSS allocations will further this fundamental Commission policy and accelerate realization
of 6G connectivity in the same way that the Commission’s flexible use policies for millimeter
In a similar way, permitting SpaceX to use its authorized Ku-, Ka-, V-, and E-band
frequencies for either gateway or non-gateway use cases will promote the public interest by
allowing SpaceX to flexibly tailor its offerings to individual capacity needs, particularly from
enterprise, industrial, and government customers that require dedicated capacity or operate in areas
Upgraded Gen2 hardware will improve spectrum efficiency and sharing. The upgraded
Gen2 system will feature enhanced hardware that can use higher gain and more advanced beam-
forming and digital processing technologies and provide more targeted and robust coverage for
American consumers. As a result, these upgraded satellites can maximize the use of the available
bandwidth, enabling more efficient allocation of resources and facilitating a broader range of
11
See Kuiper Systems, LLC; Application for Authority to Deploy and Operate a Ka-band Non-Geostationary
Satellite Orbit System, Order and Authorization, 35 FCC Rcd. 8324, ¶ 23 (2020).
14
services.
Lower minimum elevation angles will improve network performance. SpaceX’s request
to lower the minimum elevation angle of its earth station communications will improve end-user
service and latency by reducing or eliminating the need for communications to transit over
SpaceX’s laser mesh, reducing the end-to-end distance (and thus the potential round-trip latency)
of transmissions over the network. Lowering the minimum elevation angle will also increase
system reliability by allowing earth stations to maintain links with satellites for a longer period
of time as they cross the sky. In addition, lowering the minimum elevation angles for SpaceX’s
beams will promote more efficient spectrum sharing by increasing the portion of the sky that
interference problems for NGSOs. The Technical Attachment includes interference analyses
demonstrating that the modified Gen2 system—coupled with its companion Gen2 amendment—
can achieve all of the above-mentioned public interest benefits without causing unacceptable
interference to GSOs or “any significant interference problems”12 to NGSOs, and should therefore
be granted. These analyses include updated NGSO-NGSO interference analyses reflecting the
interference analyses to demonstrate that SpaceX’s proposed operations will protect GSO FSS and
12
Space Exploration Holdings, LLC; Request for Modification of the Authorization for the SpaceX NGSO Satellite
System, Order and Authorization and Order on Reconsideration, 36 FCC Rcd. 7995, ¶ 9 (2021) (quoting Teledesic
LLC, Order and Authorization,14 FCC Rcd. 2261, ¶ 5 (IB 1999)).
13
Revising spectrum Sharing Rules for Non-Geostationary Orbit, Fixed-Satellite Service Systems, 38 FCC Rcd.
3699 ¶¶ 38-42 (2023).
15
III. ITU COST RECOVERY
SpaceX is aware that, as a result of the actions taken at the 1998 Plenipotentiary
Conference, as modified by the ITU Council in 2005, the ITU now charges processing fees for
satellite network filings. As a consequence, Commission applicants are responsible for any and
all fees charged by the ITU. SpaceX confirms that it is aware of this requirement and accepts
responsibility to pay any ITU cost recovery fees associated with this application. Invoices for such
fees may be sent to the contact representative listed in the accompanying FCC Form 312.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, and for the reasons set forth in the accompanying materials,
SpaceX requests that the Commission find that authorizing SpaceX to upgrade its authorized Gen2
satellite system would serve the public interest, and issue such grant expeditiously.
Respectfully submitted,
SPACE EXPLORATION
TECHNOLOGIES CORP.
1 Rocket Road
Hawthorne, CA 90250
310-682-9836 tel
16