Eng Ets 617
Eng Ets 617
Eng Ets 617
ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 1 of 21 Rev. F
Name Title
Authoriser Russell Sparks Mechanical & Reliability Manager
Technical Approver Dave Waugh Mechanical Refinery Engineer
Custodian Dave Waugh Mechanical Refinery Engineer
Controller Alan Sweenie Quality Management Focal Point
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 2 of 21 Rev. F
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 3 of 21 Rev. F
This page must be completed to obtain approval and entered onto SharePoint
Comments
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 4 of 21 Rev. F
CONTENTS
1.0 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................... 5
2.0 SCOPE ................................................................................................................................. 5
3.0 COMPETENCE ...................................................................................................................... 5
4.0 BOLT TIGHTENING ............................................................................................................... 5
4.1 Flange Assembly ...................................................................................................................... 5
4.2 Tightening Patterns.................................................................................................................. 8
4.2.1 Tightening Pattern for Circular Flanges .................................................................................... 8
4.2.2 Torqueing Method for Rectangular Flanges ............................................................................. 9
4.3 Quality Assurance (QA) of Bolted Joints .................................................................................... 9
4.3.1 Turnarounds.............................................................................................................................. 9
4.3.2 Maintenance ............................................................................................................................. 9
5.0 APPENDIX .......................................................................................................................... 10
Appendix A : Selection of Most Appropriate Bolt Tightening Method ............................................. 10
Appendix B : Values of Bolt Stress and Torque to be Applied .......................................................... 11
B1. Standard Flanges.....................................................................................................................11
Table 1 : Imperial Torque Values using Belzona 8211 Anti-Seize.....................................................12
Table 2 : Metric Torque Values using Belzona 8211 Anti-Seize .......................................................13
B2. Non Standard Flanges .............................................................................................................14
B3. Cast Iron Flanges .....................................................................................................................14
Appendix C : Flange Bolting Diagram ............................................................................................. 16
Appendix D : Nickeleez Torques Values.......................................................................................... 17
Table 3 : Imperial Torque Values for Nickeleez ................................................................................17
Table 4 : Metric Torque Values for Nickeleez ..................................................................................18
Appendix E: Joint Assembly Record QA Sheet ................................................................................ 19
Appendix F: Additional Requirements............................................................................................ 20
Appendix G : Gr660 Stamping ........................................................................................................ 21
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 5 of 21 Rev. F
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this Engineering Technical Specification is to define the procedure which
shall be followed when tightening flange bolting during maintenance activities on Essar Oil
(UK) Ltd owned assets on Stanlow and Tranmere sites. The specification will detail the
method of flange tightening and the engineering requirements to be followed while
assembling the joint.
The requirements of this document have been compiled after review of industry guidance,
best practise and company learnings from incidents; the aim is to ensure efficient assembly
of lasting leak-free joints.
2.0 SCOPE
This ETS is for the application of bolt tightening methods on flanged connections.
It gives specific instructions on how to bolt tighten on piping flanges conforming to Stanlow
Piping Classes that include all metallic and semi-metallic gaskets, (including Spiral Wound
(SPW), Tanged Graphite (PSM), Maxiprofile™/Kammprofile™), Flexicarb, PTFE reinforced
gaskets, and klingersil™ C4430
This ETS also applies to all non-standard flanges, equipment flanges and standard flanges.
Appendix F lists specific assets where the standard requirements in this document must be
supplemented as detailed in the table provided.
3.0 COMPETENCE
Persons assembling flange joints must be competent to do so. ENG-ETS-620 defines the
competency requirements of personnel making a joint on Essar Oil (UK) Ltd owned assets
on Stanlow and Tranmere sites. ENG-ETS-700 defines the trade standards for personnel
making a joint.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 6 of 21 Rev. F
flange is re-jointed. The flange shall then be inspected for damage or corrosion. The
condition of the HF acid detection paint on the flange must be examined and if
damaged or unpainted, it must be repainted.
Gaskets : Reconditioning of MRG Type 108 gaskets is permitted when ENG-MNT-016 is
followed; otherwise, gaskets must be new.
Bolt and Nut quality : New bolts and nut should be used according to the piping class
or JIS. They should be examined for any visual damage or imperfection. If necessary,
nut and bolt condition can be tested; they should be able to turn freely by hand past
where they will come to rest after tightening. If bolts are to be re-used, a concession
should be raised by the mechanical engineer and the nuts and bolts shall be
thoroughly cleaned (wire bushed) before doing so.
The back of the flange at the nut seating area should be smooth finished.
When a new Gr 660 bolt is fitted & bolt tensioned for the first time both ends shall be
die stamped with the month of initial tensioning, e.g. 7th April 94 would be 4/94. At
each subsequent tensioning of the Gr660 bolt, the month of the tensioning shall also
be stamped on each end of the bolt. The remaining bolt life shall be calculated as
shown in the full procedure, detailed in Appendix G and if the remaining bolt life does
not meet the next planned maintenance on that joint.
Bolt Lubrication : The standard approved lubricant for use at Stanlow Manufacturing
Complex is Belzona 8211 High Temperature Anti-Seize Grease. Other lubricants may
be used with approval from the PU Assurance Engineer. On Site there is experience of
using SwanTek Nickeleez (μ= 0.12). For nickel based products such as Nickeleez™, the
correct precautions defined in MSDS for handling nickel should be adopted. The
approved lubricant should then be liberally applied to the following :
i) The bolt threads
ii) The spot face and threads of the nut to be tightened.
iii) The spot face of the flange where the nut to be tightened will sit.
If washers are fitted, only lubricate the nut bearing surface of the washer. DO NOT
LUBRICATE THE UNDERSIDE OF THE WASHER OR THE FLANGE.
Bolt / Nut engagement : Bolt thread protrusion shall be a minimum of 1 complete
thread at each nut. Where over length studs are present it is acceptable to have the
excess thread protruding on the side of the joint that will allow stud removal. The
other side shall remain a minimum of 1 thread and a maximum of 2, (flush or recessed
studs are not permitted on Stanlow Site, see Appendix C).
HFA : Pass the bolt through the flange holes BEFORE applying the lubricant. Ensure the
lubricant is applied onto the flange spot face, the threads of the nut and the part of the
bolt thread which will mate with the nut.
Selecting the Correct Bolt Tightening Method : See Appendix A for representation of
the tightening method selection process.
Bolting up sequence : Bolts shall be tightened in four stages, the first to 30% of
load/torque following the diametrical ‘star’ sequence, the second to 60% in the
diametrical ’star’ sequence, the third to 100% in the diametrical ’star’ sequence and
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 7 of 21 Rev. F
the fourth in a circular pattern around the whole flange and to continue until no
further nut rotation occurs. This sequence method is further outlined in Section 5.4
Flange Alignment : The flange should sit naturally in position so that it does not cause
any undue stresses to the seal assembly. If the load to align the joint is greater than
20% of the total target assembly bolt load, consult an engineer.
Note : More stringent alignment tolerances are normally required for connections to
machinery, if specific guidance has not been provided then consult to the PU
Assurance Engineer who will refer to API Recommended practise 686.
Note : For normally hot lines that require a cold pull, or any pipe-work that is in
tension, bolt Torquing and tension values are invalid, as the bolt stresses will be
subject to the load induced by the opposing forces of the pipe-work, reducing
the compressive load on the gasket.
Bolt Load : Subject to exceptions in Appendix F or exceptions listed on the JIS: when
using Belzona 8211 lubricant, Appendix B should be used to establish the target bolt
load. Appendix D should be used to establish the target bolt load when using
Nickeleez™ lubricant.
Hot Bolting : Flanges which require hot bolting shall be listed in Appendix F and the
requirement shall be shown on the JIS. Hot bolting is performed when the
temperature of the flange of bolts is between 150 and 230⁰C or within 24 hours if the
joint temperature remains below 150⁰C. Start-up re-torque should be performed in a
circular pattern and continued until the nuts no longer turn at the applicable torque
value.
Cast Iron Flanges : (see Section B3).
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 8 of 21 Rev. F
4 bolt flange 1, 3, 2, 4
8 bolt flange 1, 5, 3, 7, 2, 6, 4, 8
12 bolt flange 1, 7, 4, 10, 2, 8, 5, 11, 3, 9, 6, 12
16 bolt flange 1, 9, 5, 13, 3, 11, 7, 15, 2, 10, 6, 14, 4, 12, 8, 16
20 bolt flange 1, 11, 6, 16, 3, 13, 8, 18, 5, 15, 10, 20, 2, 12, 7, 17, 4, 14, 9, 19
24 bolt flange 1, 13, 7, 19, 4, 16, 10, 22, 2, 14, 8, 20, 5, 17, 11, 23, 6, 18, 12,
24, 3, 15, 9, 21
28 bolt flange 1, 15, 8, 22, 4, 18, 11, 25, 6, 20, 13, 27, 2, 16, 9, 23, 5, 19, 12,
26, 3, 17, 10, 24, 7, 21, 14, 14, 28
32 bolt flange 1, 17, 9, 25, 5, 21, 13, 29, 3, 19, 11, 27, 7, 23, 15, 31, 2, 18, 10,
26, 6, 22, 14, 30, 8, 24, 16, 32, 4, 20, 12, 28
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 9 of 21 Rev. F
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 10 of 21 Rev. F
5.0 APPENDIX
Appendix A : Selection of Most Appropriate Bolt Tightening Method
Bolt Size ½ 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2
5/ 1/ ¼ 3/ ½ 5/ 7/ 2 ½
8 8 8 8 8
↔ “ “ ¾“ 7/ “ 1” “ “ “ “ “ “ ” ¼“ “ +
8
Manual
Improved Accuracy
Torque
Wrench
During TA’s
The hierarchy per bolt size is: BLUE (if Applicable) then RED
Note 1 : For a given bolt size, alternative tightening methods can be used, subject to
approval by a maintenance concession.
Note 2 : Appendix F lists those applications that have been deemed necessary to use a
more accurate tightening technique than the default tool. See section 5 for more
details.
Note 3 : Flogging spanners shall only be used when other means of tightening have been
deemed impractical, and their use is strictly controlled see ENG-ETS 700.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 11 of 21 Rev. F
BOLTING MATERIALS
Ferritic Steels : ASTM A193 B7, B16, B7M
ASTM A320 L7, L7M, L43
Austenitic Steels: ASTM A193 B8 cl 2
ASTM A453 660A, 660B and 660C (see OMC/WI/CCU5)
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 12 of 21 Rev. F
TORQUE VALUES
Table 1 : Imperial Torque Values using Belzona 8211 Anti-Seize
(coefficient of friction = 0.09)
Table 1 figures derived from the following data source and calculation :
“Tips on Torque” by F.J. Allen Jr in 1972. – using bolt data from the machinery
handbook.
“An introduction to the design and behaviour of bolted joints” by John. H. Bickford
this references the same long equation. Endorsed by N. Motosh 1976.
ASME PCC-1 Guidelines for pressure boundary bolted flange joint assembly
All data has been modified in response to Stanlow experimental data used to determine
the effectiveness of the calculated torque values to achieve the designated residual bolt
stress.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 13 of 21 Rev. F
Table 2 figures derived from the following data source and calculation :
“Tips on Torque” by F.J. Allen Jr in 1972. – using bolt data from the machinery
handbook.
“An introduction to the design and behaviour of bolted joints” by John. H. Bickford
this references the same long equation. Endorsed by N. Motosh 1976.
ASME PCC-1 Guidelines for pressure boundary bolted flange joint assembly
All data has been modified in response to Stanlow experimental data (see document
00846694S000P00000) used to determine the effectiveness of the calculated torque values
to achieve the designated residual bolt stress.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 14 of 21 Rev. F
Alignment :
Alignment of flange faces is essential, along with control of assembly bolt
torque, so as not to overstress the cast iron flanges.
Care must also be exercised to ensure that piping loads transmitted to cast
iron flanges are controlled, taking into account its lack of ductility.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 15 of 21 Rev. F
Flange face separation shall be within the gasket spacing ±1.5 mm (1/16 in.).
Only one gasket per flanged connection shall be used.
Connecting to any cast iron flange. The flange face alignment check shall be
performed with bolting (inserted easily by hand) loose, the acceptance
criteria shall be as given below.
Gaskets
Gaskets for FF flanges (ASME B16.5)
For all Class 125 and 250 FF flanged connections, soft cut gaskets must be used
these include Gortex GR™, rubber, Klinger grades PSM and C4430.
IBC (Inside Bolt Circle) gaskets must not be used.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 16 of 21 Rev. F
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 17 of 21 Rev. F
Table 3 figures have been derived from the following data source and calculation :
“Tips on Torque” by F.J. Allen Jr in 1972. – using bolt data from the machinery
handbook.
“An Introduction to the Design and Behaviour of Bolted Joints” by John. H.
Bickford this references the same long equation. Endorsed by N. Motosh 1976.
ASME PCC-1 Guidelines for pressure boundary bolted flange joint assembly
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 18 of 21 Rev. F
Table 4 figures have been derived from the following data source and calculation :
“Tips on Torque” by F.J. Allen Jr in 1972. – using bolt data from the machinery
handbook.
“An introduction to the design and behaviour of bolted joints” by John. H.
Bickford this references the same long equation. Endorsed by N. Motosh 1976.
ASME PCC-1 Guidelines for pressure boundary bolted flange joint assembly.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 19 of 21 Rev. F
The following table shows who completes each field in the document and at what stage the
information is populated:
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 20 of 21 Rev. F
Appendix F
For ODP equipment see the embedded spreadsheet (above).
For other units see ENG-Mech-050
Note : other Units are in the process of being added to the Appendix F spreadsheet and so
the two documents will be combined in due course.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.
Stanlow Engineering Procedures Document No. ENG-ETS-617
Title :
Bolt Tightening & Joint Making Page 21 of 21 Rev. F
Definition
Gr 660 ASTM A453 Gr 660 material.
References
SJM/Gr 660 Technical report on allowable bolt life of Gr 660 bolting at elevated temperature.
Procedure
1. When a new Gr 660 bolt is fitted & bolt tensioned for the first time both ends shall be die
stamped with the month of initial tensioning, e.g. 7th April 94 would be 4/94.
2. At each subsequent tensioning of the bolt the month of the tensioning shall be stamped on
each end of the bolt.
3. Prior to each planned shutdown a survey shall be made of each joint where grade 660
bolting is used and an assessment shall be made of which bolts will need to be replaced.
4. A bolt shall be replaced at a shutdown if the remaining bolt life after tightening is
insufficient to last until the next planned maintenance on that joint.
5. Remaining bolt life in years, Tb, as derived in technical report SJM/Gr 660, is given by :
Tb = 18.25 - 2.57N - Te.
Where N = number of times tensioned excluding initial commissioning tightening.
Te = time elapsed in years since first tensioned, excluding unit shutdown time.
Example
If a bolt is stamped 4/88, 7/89, 3/91 and 3/94 and next planned shutdown is 9/97 at the
end of September 1994 :
N= 3
Te = 5.75 years (assumes 8 months of shutdown duration)
Tb = 18.25 - (2.57*3) - 5.75
= 4.8 years
Thus the bolt will have sufficient remaining life to remain in service until July 1999 based
on continuous running. It will, however, require to be replaced at the next major
shutdown.
DISTRIBUTION: Held as an electronic document as part of the Engineering Quality System and is uncontrolled once printed,
please check the database for latest revision before use.