Article
Article
Article
Section of Adult Medicine, Adult Medicine Research Unit, Department of Medicine, Philippine General Hospital, University of the Philippines Manila
1
2
College of Nursing, University of the Philippines Manila
3
Department of Clinical Epidemiology, College of Medicine, University of the Philippines Manila
4
School of Statistics, University of the Philippines Diliman, Quezon City
Table 1. Items in the UP-PGH PSNC Questionnaire per dimension Table 2. Characteristics of surveyed patients
a neutral person administering the instrument. This hiring sought jobs in higher paying countries and are replaced by
of a neutral person might not be feasible in this government neophytes. Nurses are required by the hospital to stay for at
institution at this time. The possibility of using ward staff, least two years, but not all nurses finish their contracts. This
on the other hand, is strongly discouraged, but there may be situation is not only present in UP-PGH but in other hospitals
advantages as well. The disadvantage is that patients may as well. Perhaps this can partly explain why more Filipino
feel pressured to answer positively and eventually might not patients were just satisfied and not highly satisfied with their
complete and forward the form to the ward staff. An advantage nurses in this area of care.
is that nurses will feel involved in the process and will always Several studies have shown the importance of providing
be aware that they need to perform their best. Whether it communication and adequate information to patients and
is more feasible to have non-nursing staff involved in the also citing the most common cause of dissatisfaction as the
nurses’ inability to provide sufficient information.15 In the
Table 3. Percent distribution of patient responses by dimension or development of the instrument, patients often verbalized
category their need to know hospital policies, vital signs, test results,
diet and discharge plans. Though they did not expect much
Dimension / 1 2 3 4 5
information from their nurses regarding their medical
Category Totally Disagree Uncertain Agree Totally
condition and even their management plan, they felt additional
disagree % % % % agree %
information from the nurse about these were still important
(95% CI) (95% CI) (95% CI) (95% CI) (95% CI)
and helpful. Obviously, nurses have failed in providing them
Dimension 1: 0% 3.0% 14.8% 47.9% 34.3%
with much needed information as only a few were highly
The nurse as a (0.8%, 5%) (10%, 19%) (41%, 54%) (28%, 40%)
satisfied. A third of the patients responded towards the
caring person
negative side of the scale. This is probably the most neglected
Dimension 2: 6.2% 30.8% 0% 45.8% 17.2%
duty of nurses in UP-PGH. It is not, however, an impossible
The nurse as (3%, 9%) (25%, 37%) (39%, 52%) (12%, 22%)
or time consuming task. Once a nurse has established rapport
an information
with the patient, the nurse can always bring a little piece of
provider
information at every bedside visit. Whether these bedside
Dimension 3: 0.8% 2.5% 15.8% 45.8% 35%
visits are frequent or few, depending on how sick or well a
The nurse as a (0.8%, 2.5%) (0.03%, 5%) (9%, 22%) (37%, 55%) (26%, 44%)
patient has become, imparting information may well improve
skilled & com-
a nurse-patient relationship.
petent health
Even though patient responses to their nursing experience
care provider
were more on the “agree” portion of the scale signifying average
Overall evalua- 0.4% 1.3% 5.1% 35.4% 57.8%
satisfaction levels, more than half of the patients responded as
tion of care (0.4%, 1.3%) (0.2%, 2.3%) (2.3%, 8%) (29%, 42%) (52%, 64%)
highly satisfied in terms of their overall evaluation of care.
Upon reviewing the items in this global evaluation, it was
distribution and collection of the questionnaires or whether noted that the focus shifted to more general questions like
there is a need for additional time and effort to accomplish willingness to come back to the hospital and recommending
this task, may be subject to several discussions on different the hospital to family and friends. Patients, when responding
levels of management that goes beyond just determining to these questions may have also considered other aspects of
patient satisfaction. hospital service, such as the doctors, the environment, and
other services including assistance from social workers. Cost
The sensitivity of the UP-PGH PSNC Questionnaire may have also played a part in the evaluation since it is still
The questionnaire was developed by gathering the cheaper to be hospitalized in UP-PGH than a service ward
perceptions, expectations and opinions of patients’ on their in a private hospital. Also, it seemed that the more broadly a
nursing care experience. It was hoped that the instrument question was phrased, the more likely a positive response was
being more attuned to Filipino patients’ views was able to given. In a way, the details of nursing care as reflected in the
truly capture how Filipino patients regard the nursing care rest of the items in the questionnaire provide a more explicit
they receive. Its uniqueness also lies in the fact that the tool review of the experience and thus patients can adequately
was developed with the involvement of the receivers of care judge each experience.
themselves–the patients. Looking at the results, one would immediately see that
A patient’s relationship with a nurse characterized by patients were generally happy with the nursing care they
understanding, respect, trust, honesty, cooperation personal received from UP-PGH nurses. Upon closer inspection of the
attention, patience and humor was most often related to a results of each dimension, however, more meaningful results
high level of satisfaction.16 This was also mentioned quite were seen, and this reflected well upon the usefulness and
often and emphasized by patients and their watchers in the sensitivity of the tool in discriminating between less satisfied
initial phase of this study. It would not be surprising therefore and more satisfied. Also, other factors need to be explored as
that the patients would rate their experience with nurses who well to explain the trends of the responses.
were less pleasant and did not provide much attention to them
as average. This result was actually reflected in the survey. The UP-PGH patients’ concept of satisfaction
Regarding competency and skill, a nurse that does work in Filipino patients who have health insurance or have a
a technically correct manner was an important factor to patient little saved up for medical emergencies will probably not
satisfaction16 with the absence of physical pain resulting in a seek help in a government hospital. The predicaments of
higher level of satisfaction.9 Patients expected nurses to be patients confined in the UP-PGH are obvious. One need only
able to assist doctors in procedures, give injections and prick walk by the medical wards to realize how dire circumstances
fingers without much pain. Of course these skills need to are among those confined. Filipino patients are known for
be mastered over time and with constant practice, but with their humor even in the face of adversity and thus may be
the high turnover rate of nurses in the wards, nurses keep pleased with just a little attention or an ounce of hope. It is not
changing regularly. Those who have mastered the skill have surprising that most patients would be most understanding
when it comes to their nurses by just observing the load their Acknowledgment
nurses are faced with everyday. The author would like to sincerely thank and acknowledge the valuable
Determining how satisfied patients are who are perhaps contribution and guidance of the following people in the completion of this
research work: Dr. Leonila Dans, Prof. Nina Castillo-Carandang, Prof. Araceli
already at a low point in their lives may be inappropriate Balabagno, and Prof. Lourdes Amarillo. The authors are also grateful to the
after all. Patients know that they are entering an institution Research Implementation and Development Office of the UP-College of
catering to hundreds of people a day, training hundreds of Medicine for providing grant support for this study, and the Adult Medicine
students, with just the basic equipment, with overflowing Research Unit for subsidizing the author’s education. Much appreciation is also
extended to Cila, Gem, Joan, Owen, Bambi, Nat, the author’s family and the
wards and with staffing problems. They probably consider patients of UP-PGH. Special thanks are also given to Dr. Dennis Sulit and Jyo
these things as they respond to questionnaires on patient Sulit.
satisfaction and would probably have pre-formed opinions in
light of the situation. Patients may have the tendency to adjust
References
their baseline scores accordingly. Their concept of satisfaction 1. Risser NL. Development of an instrument to measure satisfaction with
may indeed change by the mere fact that they are in UP-PGH. nurses and nursing care in primary care settings. Nurs Res. 1975;24(1):45-
Another matter that needs to be explored further, especially 52.
in the hospital setting, includes the primary caregiver or the 2. Davis J. Taking the measure of patient satisfaction. Nurs Times.
1999;95(24):52-53.
watcher. Their opinions may probably exert some influence 3. Chrystman J, Alexander M (CIHI Quadrant Coordinators), Murray MA
on the patient’s concept of satisfaction and their views and (University of Toronto Contributor). Patient Satisfaction in Hospital Report
opinions are also affected by their predicaments. 2002: Acute Care Technical Summary. Canada 2002.
The development of the tool based on the perceptions of 4. Irish Society for Quality & Safety in Healthcare, Health Services National
Partnership Forum, & The Health Boards Executive. Measurement of
patients facing similar predicaments helped identify what Patient Satisfaction Guidelines: Health Strategy Implementation Project
matters most to these patients and what adds to their quality 2003.
of life. These concerns need to be addressed by the healthcare 5. Urden LD. Patient satisfaction measurement: current issues and
community. This tool was developed specifically for patients implications. Outcomes Manag. 2002;6(3):125-131.
6. Mahon PY. An analysis of the concept of ‘patient satisfaction’ as it relates to
in the medical wards of UP-PGH and will need to be adapted if contemporary nursing care. J Adv Nurs. 1996;24:1241-1248.
administered elsewhere. Other hospitals will have a different 7. Bond S, Thomas LH. Issues in measuring outcomes of nursing. J Adv Nurs.
population base and their patient concerns may be different 1991;16:1492-1502.
altogether. This needs to be verified through another study. 8. Yellen E, Davis GC, Ricard R. The measurement of patient satisfaction. J
Nurs Care Qual. 2002;16(4):23-29.
However dire the situation is, healthcare has to be 9. Larrabee JH, Bolden LV. Defining patients perceived quality of nursing
provided in the best possible way even in the presence care. J Nurs Care Qual. 2001;16(1):34-60.
of limitations. Nursing care need not suffer considerably 10. Sitzia J, Wood N. Patient satisfaction: a review of issues and concepts. Soc
knowing that patients still appreciate the nurses’ fulfillment Sci Med. 1997;45(12):1829-1843.
11. Ventura MR, Fox RN, Corley MC, Mercurio SM. A patient satisfaction
of their simplest caring roles. Whatever helps in improving measure as a criterion to evaluate primary nursing. Nurs Res. 1982;31(4):226-
the service for this already disadvantaged group of people 230.
will matter. Therefore, it is extremely valuable to evaluate 12. Uzun O. Patient satisfaction with nursing care at a University Hospital in
quality of care and always offer some form of improvement Turkey. J Nurs Care Qual. 2001;16(1):24-33.
13. French K. Methodological considerations in hospital patient opinion
or even show attempts to improve service. surveys. Int J Nurs Stud. 1981;18:7-32.
The UP-PGH PSNC questionnaire is just one evaluation 14. Gorsuch RL. Factor Analysis. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1983.
method that might be useful in assessing basic nursing care 15. Johanesson P, Oleni M, Fridlund B. Patient satisfaction with nursing care in
services, but it must not be the only tool used for evaluation. the context of health care: a literature study. Scand J Caring Sci. 2002;16:337-
344.
Although it has shown that patients in the medical wards 16. Miller-Bader MM. Nursing care behaviors that predict patient satisfaction.
were generally satisfied with the nurses’ care and competency J Nurs Qual Assur. 1988;2:11-17.
or skill and that there may be a need to further improve the
nurses’ role as an information provider, a combination of
several assessment methods may be warranted to provide a
more accurate picture of the hospital’s nursing care service.