Gender Differences in English Language Learning
Gender Differences in English Language Learning
Gender Differences in English Language Learning
Differences,
Male and
GENDER DIFFERENCES
Female
IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LEARNING
Students,
English
Language
Tarina Dashela; Yeni Mustika Learning
Bina Sarana Informatika University
tarina.tdl@bsi.ac.id; yeni.yem@bsi.ac.id
092
Abstract- This article focused on the gender differences in English Language Learning.
It discovers students’ learning styles as affected by the notions about men’s and
women’s differences in communication. The data were randomly collected from ten
male and ten female students of the English department of Tanjungpura University
Pontianak. The population was the third-semester students of English department
students. They were given an online questionnaire through Google Form. It is to find
out their attitudes towards speaking to a different gender, strategy to express an
opinion, group work preferences, and activeness/passiveness in the class. The findings
showed some factors affect the different styles of female and male students in learning
English. The result of the data indicated that more females felt reluctant to speak
English to a different gender. Besides, it can also affect the successful strategies of
English students in learning English. The great potency of female students to be
ashamed, nervous, and women’s language can affect their achievement in English.
Meanwhile, male students as influenced by their need to challenge and maintain
strength as men and can use speaking English ability as a way to show their status as
men.
INTRODUCTION
females. Men and women interact in daily life as social beings. Thus, creating
differences in the interaction activity (Irawan & Triandjojo, 2017, p.34)
Gender
Differences,
Male and As socially and culturally constructed, gender differences are one of the
Female
interesting phenomena in contemporary society related to the characteristic, the style of
Students,
English using language and communication. Men and women are different in their ways of
Language communication, and therefore they should be treated differently. Irawan & Triandjojo
Learning
(2017, p.35) study that men and women are different in their politeness and their choice
of words. The women use standard and polite words while the men use harsh and
impolite words to communicate. Besides, Wahyuningsih (2018, P.89) finds out that men
093
and women have differences in forms, contents, and uses in communication. The study
shows that men are more directive and use plain words while women are more
expressive and polite in using language. In short, gender has its characteristics in using
language and style of communication.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
This discourse had been seriously and creatively debated since Lakoff (1976)
and Tannen (1990), in their study on English-speaking countries, illuminated the
concept of women’s language which highlights the existence of men’s and women’s
differences in communication. One characteristic of women’s language as stated by
Lakoff (1976) is the great tendency of women in using lexical hedges or fillers (e.g. you
know, sort of, well, you see), tag questions (she’s very nice, isn’t she?), rising intonation
declarative (it’s really good), empty adjectives (divine, charming, cute), precise color
terms (magenta, aquamarine), intensifiers (just, so), hypercorrect grammar (consistent
use of standard verb forms), super polite forms (indirect requests, euphemisms),
avoidance of strong swear words (fudge, my goodness), and emphatic stress.
Gender differences mean men and women that are specific to a particular culture
and influenced by its attitudes and practices. Another difference is that women are more
passive than men. If they are talking, they tend to show that they are not sure about what
they are saying. The passiveness and tentativeness of women in communication are
affirmed by Rahmi (2015). Conversely, men are represented as leaders and
breadwinners. Furthermore, in some cultures women take the name of their husbands
after getting married, sons have more freedom to play outside the house, and daughters
must stay at home and take care of younger ones.
Gender
Differences,
Male and
Women are different from men not only in verbal communication but also in Female
nonverbal communication. One study by Sud et al (2019) looked at women to be better Students,
leaders. At this stage of the evolution of human society, women seem to have some English
Language
advantage in the power dynamics caused by nonverbal communication. It explores
Learning
various nonverbal behaviors like appearance, gestures, facial and eye expressions,
silence, proxemics, kinesics, haptics, paralinguistics, chronemics, oculesics, vocalic, and
others. 094
Tymson (1998, p.8) classifies differences between men and women in
communication as seen in Table 1:
Data Collection
This article was based on data collected from English Department students at
Tanjungpura University Pontianak. The population of the paper was the third-semester
students of the English Education study program. For the sampling, the researcher just
took 20 students from class A: 10 male students and 10 female students.
The respondents were given an open-ended questionnaire, such as online
questionnaires through Google forms to reveal their perceptions regarding their
strategies in learning English as affected by gender differences. The questionnaires were
directed to find out whether or not the students feel reluctant to speak English with
different gender, what ways they prefer to express their opinions either indirect
(writing) or direct way (speaking), and what kinds of groups they prefer to work with
either single-gender group or mixed-gender group, whether the students prefer to be
active or not (silent), and how the students’ perception on the strategies to improve
English skills dealing with gender difference. The questions were addressed to the
respondents individually through Google Form.
Gender
Differences,
The questionnaires are as follows. Male and
1. Do you sometimes feel reluctant to speak English with another gender? Explain! Female
Students,
2. In an English class, what way do you prefer to express your opinions, written or
English
oral form? Explain! Language
3. In a group discussion, which one do you prefer, working with the same gender Learning
or different gender? Explain!
4. In an English class, do you sometimes choose to keep silent or active? Why?
5. Do you think working with the same gender or different gender can make your 098
English better?
Data Analysis
The data were analyzed by using qualitative analysis. The researchers used
Google form as the tool for collecting the data. The researcher generated the questions
mainly about their preferences in gender to communicate in English, reluctance in
speaking with different gender, preferences in expressing opinions, and preferences of
being active. The results were explained descriptively about gender differences.
Based on Table 3 and Table 4, the researcher concluded that female students
chose to speak English to convey their opinions by using their gestures, body language,
and facial expressions. It is one of the simplest ways for them to voice their ideas. Then,
more male students preferred to write English to communicate their assumptions.
Gender
Differences,
Students’ Preference in Working with Groups Male and
Female
In working with a group, female and male students also had different
Students,
preferences, either single or mixed-gender groups when it came to group projects. The English
single group refers to individuals of the same gender, such as females. Whereas, the Language
Learning
mix-gender group works with people of different genders, such as males and females. In
this research, males (50%) chose to work with mixed-group, while others chose to work
with mixed-group. Besides, the female students preferred working with single-group
100
(60%) whereas there were only 40% of female students preferred workings with mixed-
group. Female students chose to work with a single-gender group that an ed-gender
group. Then, male students preferred working with the mixed-gen groups.
There are some reasons for male students working with a single-gender group,
such as similar thoughts to express something, being more cooperative, and the easiest
way to build good teamwork. On the other hand, different gender had a different
thoughts. It got every perspective when discussing things. Female students preferred
working with a single-gender group, they built a cooperative team and got a similar way
of thinking. Besides, they chose to work with different gender because they could see a
different point of view and had better insights.
CONCLUSION
In this paper, the writer has discussed the possible impact of gender differences
in language and communication on the ways female and male students learn English. It
is revealed that differences in the ways men and women communicate. The great
potency of female students to be ashamed, nervous, and not certain, as characterized as
women’s language, can affect their achievement in English. For example, because they
are ashamed, they cannot express their ideas in English although they are able to. This
can be seen in the majority of the female students choosing writing as the way to
express their ideas in order to get rid of those problems. Conversely, male students as
influenced by their need to challenge and maintain strength as men can use speaking
English ability as a way to show their status as men.
The study only focused on gender differences in language learning. Therefore, it
is suggested to get a more intensive observation of their learning in English by
recording their conversations, to find out whether there are different patterns in their
English expressions as well as their English achievement. For future teachers, the
gender differences may know more about the characteristics of female and male
students in learning English. More intensive observation is necessarily required in the
future to find out other contributing factors influencing these differences of gender in
language learning.
Gender
REFERENCES Differences,
Male and
Azhar, K.A.& Iqbal, N. (2018). Turn-taking and gender differences in language
Female
classroom. Journal of Nelta, 23(1-2): 54 -67. DOI: 10.3126/nelta.v23i1-2.23349.
retrieved in: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331547269 Students,
Bose, A. (2019). Gender differences and Power in Non-Verbal Communication. Empire English
State College, State University of New York. A Thesis. Language
Cahyaningsih, R.A. (2017). Teacher’s Perception on Folklores in English. Jurnal Kredo Learning
Vol. 1 No. 1.
Erdiana, N., Bahri, S., & Akhmal, C. N. (2019). ‘Male vs. Female EFL Students: Who
Is Better in Speaking Skill?’, Studies in English Language and Education, 6.1,
131–40 104
Faizah, Izah & Kurniawan, E. (2016). A study of interruption and overlap in male-
female conversation in the talk show Mata Najwa. Journal of Barista, 3(1):25-36
Gustafsson S., M., Bäck, E. A., & Lindqvist, A. (2015). Introducing a Gender-neutral
Pronoun in a Natural Gender Language: The Influence of Time on Attitudes and
Behavior. Frontiers in Psychology, 6 (July), 1–12. Retrieved from
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00893
Holmes, J. (2013) An Introduction to Sociolinguistics. Longman.
Irawan, J. & Triandjojo, I. (2017). Gender Differences in Daily Conversation in ‘It’s A
Boy Girl Thing’ Movie Script. Jurnal Culture Vol.4 No.1
Kim H, Sefcik JS, Bradway C. (2017). Characteristics of qualitative descriptive studies:
A systematic review. Research in Nursing & Health 40: 23–42.
Lakoff, R. T. (1976). Language and Woman's Place. New York: Octagon Books.
Lestari, et al. (2018). Politeness Strategy Preference of Male and Female Teachers in
Classroom Interaction during English Classes. Bali: Pendidikan Ganesha
University.
Manzoor, S., Sarwar, S., & Asim, M. (2020). M-Learning in Higher Education:
Exploring the Gender-Based Faculty Performance of Business Schools in
Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Gender Studies, 20(1), 195–210.
https://doi.org/10.46568/pjgs.v20i1.428
Muin, F. (2019). Sociolinguistics A Language Study in Sociocultural
Perspectives. Jurusan Pendidikan Bahasa dan Seni, Fakultas Keguruan dan
Ilmu Pendidikan, Universitas Lambung Mangkurat. ISBN 978-602-53643-1-0
Nurjanah, O.W, et al. (2017). Male and Female Linguistic Politeness in Speaking
Classroom. International Journal of Pedagogy and Teacher Education (IJPTE),
1(2). Surakarta: Sebelas Maret University.
Rahayu, S. (2016). The Comparison between Male and Female Students’ Speaking
Ability. ELTIN Journal, 4(2). Bandung: STKIP Siliwangi.
Rahmi. (2015). Gender and Language Use. Jurnal Interlektualita, 3(1).
Severiens, S & Dam, G. (2005). ‘Speer, S.A. 2002. Sexist Talk: gender Categories,
Participant Orientations, and Irony. Journal of Sociolinguistics, 6(3): 347-377.
Sirbu, A. (2015). The Significance of Language as A Tool of Communication. Mircea
Cel Batran Naval Academy Scientific Bulletin, Volume Xviii. Issue 2.
Sugihartono et al. (2007). Psikologi Pendidikan. Yogyakarta : UNY Press
Sukarno. (2015). Sociolinguistics in Language Teaching Perspectives. Yogyakarta:
Deepublish Publisher.
Gender
Differences,
Male and
Tannen, D. (1990). You Just Don't Understand: Women and Men in Conversation. New
Female
York: Morrow.
Students, Tymson, C. (1998). Gender Games: Doing Business with the Opposite Sex. Australia:
English Tymson Communication.
Language Wahyuningsih, S. (2018). Men and Women Differences in Using Language: A Case
Learning Study of Students at Stain Kudus. Edulite Journal Volume 3 No.1
105