Pat - I
Pat - I
Pat - I
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
PATROLOGY -I.
PART ONE
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
2. The spiritual system, which the East adopts: The Eastern churches
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
PATROLOGY
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
In Patrology the term “Fathers” was not confined to bishops, priests and
deacons, but included all those who supported us with orthodox Christian
literature. This designated the apologists who defended the Christian faith
in the early church even though they were not clergymen. It also
designated the leaders of the monastic life who escaped from priesthood
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
NECESSARY QUALIFICATIONS
Certain qualifications are necessary and only some of the ecclesiastical
writers are called Church Fathers . These qualifications are:
a. The “Father” according to Patrology, is the one who participates in
the Christian Literature, such as discourses, dialogues, letters,
sermons, advises and (or) commentaries on some books of the
Scripture.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
d. Antiquity: Some scholars see that the Patristic epoch starts by the
Apostolic Fathers down to the sixth century. Others take it further to
the eighth century while others see that there is no specific era for
the Fathers. They believe that it extends throughout all ages, forthe
Spirit of God is working in the Church of Christ, as in every age there
are saintly teachers and “Fathers.”
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
the wisdom of the holy Fathers. Again in his writings against Nestorius, he
declared that the Holy Spirit spoke in the holy Fathers.
The Lutheran theologian, John Gerhard, from the seventeenth century, was
the first scholar who used the word “Patrologia” as a title of his work, which
he published in 1653. But the idea of publishing the sayings of the fathers
dates back to the early centuries of Christianity.
We may divide the History of Patrology into four epochs, which may be
introduced in succession:
The beginning of the spread of Christianity.
The church historians epoch.
The setting of “De viris Illustribus.”
A new scientific epoch.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
He actually presented a list of all the writers and their works. He also
recorded part of the quotations to most of them. His book is the most
important reference in Patrology, though some of the works from which he
quoted had been lost. In spite of its numerous errors it is still the only
reference to some of the early Christian writers.
This book motivated many of the writers in the East and the West to
complete it. They are called “The Church Historians,” such as Socrates,
Sozomen and Theodoret. Their works are similar, but they mostly ignore
the western church. In the west Rufinus translated Eusebius’ work into
Latin, and added to it some events until the age of Theodosius the Great
(392 A.D). These additions have little value.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
In his work, St. Jerome, imitated Suetonius, who published his book: “The
Illustrious Fathers” in c. 100 A.D. He dealt in brief with the renowned Latin
writers.
REMARKS ON “ DE VIRIS ILLUSTRIBUS- St. Jerome depended on Eusebius
in the first 78 chapters, though he stated that he did not depend on
previous writings. Yet he repeated Eusebius’ same errors. He was
considered the only source for some early writers, i.e. Marcius Felix,
Novetian, Tertullian etc.
In the introduction he mentioned that his work was bound by those who
wrote concerning the holy Scripture, but in fact it included those who wrote
on theological issues.
As he published it, St. Augustine criticized it6, saying that Jerome did not
separate the Orthodox writers from the heretics. It included some heretics,
i.e. Tatian, Priscillian, Basdesanes and Eunomius; and pagan philosophers,
such as Seneca. It also included some Jewish writers, such as Philo of
Alexandria and Josephius.
E. C. Richardson stated that Jerome did not compose it for scientific
purposes but for practical reasons. He wrote very briefly about well-known
writers, such as. SS. Athanasius, Basil the Great, Cyprian, Gregory of Nyssa,
Epiphanius and Ambrose.
St. Jerome ignored the writings of St. Augustine which were published at
that time, perhaps because of the contention which existed between them.
This work has its precious value in the West. Although it is more than a
thousand years old, it is regarded as a basis of all their studies in this
branch. Attempts are still being made to complete it.
This work was well -connected with the work of Gennadius, a priest in
Marseilles (died at 496 A.D).
REMARKS ON GENNADIUS’ WORK
Richardson states that this work has little value, and is out of sequence
when compared with that of St. Jerome. However, we cannot ignore the
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
3. SCIENTIFIC EPOCH.
A new epoch started in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, by
publishing the first series of the ancient church writings in an exquisite style.
In the nineteenth century many patristic texts were discovered and there
were serious desires to study these texts scientifically. Many academic
institutions and universities established special branches for this subject.
The twentieth century has been predominantly concerned with the history
of ideas, concepts, and terms in Christian literature, and the doctrine of the
various ecclesiastical authors.
OUR CONCERN
When the western scholars are involved in Patrology, they look to the
Church of Alexandria as a living fountain that spreads on the Christendom a
great deal of the Patristic literature texts and spirit.
At the end of the middle age and the beginning of the modern age
treasures of our libraries had been brought to the western museums and
universities, which form a great part of the material of Patrology. J.
Quasten says, “Moreover, the newly discovered papyri of Egypt enabled
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
IMPORTANCE OF PATROLOGY
Patrology is not just a branch of Christian Theology, it is an essential source
of all branches of theology, because the lives and writings of the Fathers
are an open and practical gospel that testifies to the whole aspect of
Christian life and doctrines.
Patrick J. Hamell says, “Theological training is incomplete without the
elements of the history of Dogma and Positive Theology. All the great
theologians studied the Fathers carefully, and reveal that in their works by
extensive quotations.”
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
2. LANGUAGES
√ The Greek (Eastern) Fathers: the majority of the eastern Fa-thers
wrote in Greek beside their national languages, such as the Coptic,
Syriac and Armenian.
√ The Latin (Western) Fathers.
3. PLACE
√ The Egyptian Fathers, especially those of the School of Alex-
andria, and the Desert Fathers.
√ The Antiochenes.
√ The Capadocian Fathers.
√ The Latin Fathers.
4. THE MATERIAL
● Apologetic writings.
● Biblico-exegetical writings.
● Homilies and sermons.
● Letters.
● Liturgical works.
● Christian poetry and songs.
● Dialogues.
● Ascetic writings.
● Church canons.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
● Church history.
Many scholars had set a classification which is a mixture of some of the
above-mentioned ones.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
from our own body, and that He appeared as if He was a man, but He never
suffered nor was crucified. Therefore the primitive formula was not
sufficient. There was a need of em-phasizing the reality of incarnation,
suffering, crucifixion, resurrection and ascension of our Incarnate God.
When heresies, concerning the Trinitarian faith spread, reciting a creed with
emphasis on church faith became necessary, not only for baptism, but in
every worship, private or communal. “Say the creed daily,” St. Augustine
advised his flock, “when you compose yourself to sleep, repeat your creed,
render it to the Lord, be not irked to say it over.”
PRIMITIVE CREEDS
Patrology presents many creed formulas mentioned in the writings of the
Eastern and Western Fathers. Schaff presents a com-parative table of the
Ante- Nicene Rules of Faith, as related to the Apostles’ Creed and Nicene
Creed:
The Apostles’ Creed (Rome), about 340 A.D.
Irenaeus of Lyon, 180 A.D.
Tertullian of Carthage, 200 A.D.
Cyprian of Carthage, 250 A.D.
Novatian of Rome’ 250 A.D.
Origen, Alexandria, 250 A.D.
Gregory of Neo-Caesarea, 270 A.D.
Lucian of Antioch, 300 A.D.
Eusebius of Caesarea, 325 A.D.
Marcellus of Ancyra, 340 A.D.
Cyril of Jerusalem, 350 A.D.
Epiphanius of Salamis, 374 A.D.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
ITS CONTENTS
A study of the earliest history of the Creed reveals two distinct forms: the
christological and the Trinitarian formulas.
K. S. Latourette states that this creed was used by the candi-dates of
baptism, declaring that they deny the beliefs of Marcion.
[The opening affirmation “I believe in God the Father Al-mighty” (in original
Greek the word translated “almighty” means “all governing” or “all
controlling,” as one who governs all the universe), quite obviously this rules
out Marcion’s contention that the world is the creation of the Demiurge and
not of the loving Father. The phrases which, “and in Jesus Christ His Son,
who was born of Mary the Virgin, was crucified under Pontius Pilate, on the
third day rose from the dead, ascended into Heaven, sitteth on the right
hand of the Father, from which he cometh to judge the living and the dead,”
clearly do not permit the Marcionite teaching that Christ was a phantom,
but asserts positively that He was the Son, not of the previously unknown
God, but of God who is also the Creator, who was born of a woman, and so
from his conception shared man’s flesh that as sharing as an individual
human being He had a specific place in history, having been crucified and
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
buried under a Roman official whose name is known. This, of course, does
not deny that He is also the Son of God and so divine, but, as against
Marcion, it asserts the fact that Jesus Christ was also fully human. The
symbol likewise declares that the risen Christ is seated by the right hand of
the Father, the God who is the Creator and ruler of the universe, so
stressing the conviction that there is only one God, not two gods. By
emphasizing the belief that Christ, the Son of the Father, is to be the Judge,
the creed is repudiating, either deliberately or without that view explicitly in
mind, the Marcionite contention that it is Demiurge, not the Father of The
Son, who is the Judge. Of the concluding phrases {I believe} “In the Holy
Spirit, and the resurrection of the flesh,” the first was not in controversy and
so was not amplified, but the second an addition to the primitive formula,
seems to have been intended as a protest against the view which counted
flesh as evil9.]
THE TEXT
I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth;
And in Jesus Christ, His Only Son, our Lord:
Who was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary; 4. suffered
under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried;
He descended into Hades, the third day He rose from the dead; 6. He
ascended into heaven, and sits on the right hand of God the Father
Almighty;
from thence He shall come to judge the living and the dead.
And I believe in the Holy Spirit;
the holy Catholic Church; the communion of saints;
the forgiveness of sins;
the resurrection of the body;
and the life everlasting.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
the way from A.D 70 to A.D 180. J. P. Audet, who published a very thorough
study of the title work in 1958, has argued that the first half (thorough 11:2)
comes from about A.D 70, while the rest was added not long afterwards.
Perhaps as a whole book it should be dated about the last third of the first
century, possibly around A.D 906.
Its writing dated back to the second half of the first century and not to the
Apostolic era for the following reasons:
1. The details contained in it refer to the stability of the Church
situation. This had been realized at the end of the Apostolic time.
2. Most of the quotations are derived from the Gospel according to St.
Matthew, which means that it was not collated before 90 A.D.
3. It does not deal with the attitude of Judaism, which was the first and
the essential problem the Church faced at the Apostolic age.
Nevertheless, the work had an inner witness that it was collated at a time
very close to the Apostolic era, for the following reasons:
1. Mentioning the running water in baptism, and the absence of
any text of the creed.
2. Its language was very simple, which fitted the period of the
change, from the writing of the New Testament to the writings of
the church.
PLACE
Some scholars state that the method of the Two Ways used here indicates
its place of origin as the East, perhaps Syria or Alexandria.
Some scholars state that Alexandria is the place of its origin for the
following reasons:
1. Alexandria used the method of the Two Ways, such as in the
Apostolic Church order (The Egyptian Church Order).
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
This section gives directions affecting church rites and orders. It treats
Baptism and Eucharist with the agape. The oldest Eucharistic prayers have
come to light in the Didache.
It refers to some traditional practices at that time, such as;
● .Baptism was practised by immersion in a running water, i.e. in the
rivers. [7:1 -3]. This custom was known in the Apostolic era and in the
proceeding years.
● Baptism by pouring water from a vessel or from the hand of the
minister of baptism was allowed in cases of scarcity of water. After-
wards this mode was applied only to sick persons who could not
leave their bed; hence called clinical baptism [the word κλινικοι from
the word κλινη (bed). Clinicus designated one who was baptized on
the sick bed.]
● Fasting is necessary for candidates, the minister of Baptism, and
others, for one or two days before Baptism. [7:4] In the Coptic Church
this custom is still practised on the same day until Baptism takes
place.
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
In the last days of the world false prophets and deceivers will abound,
sheep will be perverted and turn into wolves, and love will change to hate,
for with the growth of lawlessness men will begin to hate their fellows and
persecute them and betray them.
Then the Deceiver of the World will show himself, pretending to be a Son of
God and doing signs and wonders, and the earth will be delivered into his
hands, and he will work such wickedness as there has never been since
the beginning.
After that, all humankind will come up for their fiery trial; mul-titudes of
them will stumble and perish, but such as remain steadfast in the faith will
be saved by the Curse.
And then the signs of the truth will appear: first the sign of the opening
heavens, next the sign of the trumpet’s voice,and thirdly the rising of the
dead - not of the dead - not of all the dead, but, as it says, the Lord will
come, and with him all his holy ones.
And then the whole world will see the Lord as He comes riding on the
clouds of heaven...’’
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
END. !!!
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page
HOLY TRINITY UNIVERSITY
FACULTY OF PRACTICAL THEOLOGY
Dept., of pastoral Theology
29 | Page