IPR chapter 1
IPR chapter 1
IPR chapter 1
(Mgu exam Janu 2022 - 5 marks, mgu exam Janu 2022- 15 marks,mgu exam 2021- 2 marks,)
Intellectual property rights are the rights given to persons over the
creations of their minds. They usually give the creator an exclusive right over the use of his/her
creation for a certain period of time.
IPR covers the following under the guidance of World Intellectual Property Organization
(WIPO):
• Industrial design
• Scientific discoveries/inventions
• Protection against unfair competition
• Literary, artistic and scientific works, inventions in all fields of human endeavor,
trademarks, commercial names and designation.
• All other rights resulting from intellectual activities in the individual scientific literacy
or artistic field.
Types of IPR
• Copy Rights
• Patent Rights
• Trade Marks
• Trade secrets
ADVANTAGES OF IPR
Meaning : A patent is an exclusive right granted for an invention. In other words, a patent is an
exclusive right to a product or a process that generally provides a new way of doing something,
or offers a new technical solution to a problem.
Patents are the most generalized way for protecting the rights of inventors. A patent is
an exclusive right granted by the state for the protection of an invention. The patent grants to
its holder the exclusive right to use or exploit the invention and prevent third parties from using
it without consent.
PATENTEE
A patentee is a person who is entered in the register of patents as the grantee or
proprietor of a patent for the time being. The person to whom the patent has been granted is
known as Patentee. The Patentee is entitled to use the property or invention in the same manner
as the owner of any movable property.
RIGHTS OF PATENTEE
The patent holder is granted with the rights of assigning or granting licenses for manufacture
and distribution of the patented products to others. In case there are co-owners of the patented
product, the permission to grant license to the other person shall be sought from the co-owners.
The license would be considered to be granted when the request has been duly authorised by
the controller.
The owner of the patent has the right to surrender his patent after seeking permission from the
controller. The controller then advertises about this surrender as per the procedure laid down
in the Indian Patents Act. The parties interested in getting the ownership of the patent can then
approach the controller. The controller examines the party’s claims and.surrenders the
ownership respectively.
Right before sealing
Section 24 of the Indian Patents Act implies that a patent is sealed from the date of notification
for acceptance to the date of acceptance of the notification. The right of the patentee begins
after the notification for acceptance has been presented.
This provision is provided in Section 54 to 56 of the Indian Patents Act. This provision provides
for the modifications in the existing invention. In such a case, the patent holder is granted the
right to the modified invention after the notification of the acceptance comes out. Once the
notification is presented, the owner is provided with the same rights as provided to the previous
patent.
When any of the rights of the patent holder is violated, then it is termed as patent infringement.
This is to mean that if the patented invention is used, manufactured or sold for commercial
purposes by any person, then it will be accused of patent infringement. In case of violation of
patentee’s rights, the patentee can approach either the district court or a high court. If the person
is proven guilty of infringement, the courts will either grant permanent injunction or damages
or both.
REGISTRATION OF PATENT.
The Registrar himself shall either handle the cases which are pending with the
officers or transfer them to another officers. Such transfer must be made by an order in writing
with reason for transfer.
Steps of Registration
(a) Write down the invention in details including the following.
o Area of invention
o Description of the invention
o How does it work?
o Advantage of the invention
(b) Supporting documents
Include drawing, diagrams or sketches explaining of inventions. It should be designed so as to
explain the working of the invention in a better way.
(c) Evaluation whether the invention is patentable
All inventions are not patentable so check the invention is patentable or not as per the Act.
(d) Patentability search
Check whether the invention meets all patentability criteria as per Indian patent Act. i.e. About
• Novelty
• Non obviousness
• . Industrial application
• Enabling
(e) Draft application
In case application is at an early stage of research, then you can go for provisional application
so that it gives the following benefits:-
▪ . secures filing date 12 months of time to file complete specification
▪ Low cost
(f) Publication of application
Upon filling complete specification along with application of patent, the application is
published after 18 months of first filing. An early publication request can be made along with
prescribed fee if you do not want to wait till the expiry of 18 months from date of filing for
publishing your patent application.
(g) Request for examination
The application is examined only after request for examination. Upon receiving this request
the controller gives patent application to patent examiner who examines the patent application
with different patentability criteria like patentable subject matter
▪ Novelty
▪ Non obviousness
▪ Inventive step
▪ Industrial application
▪ Enabling
The examiner creates first examination report of the application thereon the review has been
done. Everything happening to patent application before grant of patent is generally called as
patent prosecution.
The first examination report submitted to controller by examiner generally contains prior arts
which are similar to the claimed invention and same is reported to patent applicant.
(h) Respond to objections
Majority of applicants will receive same type of objection based on examinations report. This
is the chance for inventor to communicate his novelty over prior arts(existing details) found in
the examination report.
(i) Clearing all objections
The communication between controller and patent applicant is to ensure that all objections
raised in the patent application are resolved and the inventor has his fair chance to prove his
point to establish novelty. Based on the finding that the patent application is in order, eligible
in all respects and found to be meeting all the patentability requirement, request shall be
accepted.
(J)Grant of patent
The grant of patent is notified in the patent journal which is published time to time.
✓ the method by which it is to be performed i.e the best method of performing the
intentioned has to be disclosed.
5. Register of patent
A register of patent has to be maintained at the patent office, containing the following:-
• Names and addresses of patentees
• Notification of assignment and transmission of patent or license under patents and
amendment, extension, and revocation.
• Particulars of such other matters affecting the validity or proprietorship of patents as may be
prescribed.
The register is to be kept under the control and management of Controller but it
remains under the supervision and direction of Central Government. It is lawful to keep the
register of patents or its part thereof in computer floppies, diskettes, etc. subject to such
safeguards as may be prescribed.
INFRINGEMENT OF PATENTS (Mgu Exam, Oct 2019 -2 Marks, Mgu Exam Oct2019-
5 Marks, Mgu Exam Feb 2021-5 Marks, Mgu Exam Feb 2021-15 Marks, Mgu Exam Janu –
2022, 2 Marks)
Introduction
Patent infringement means the violation of the exclusive rights of the patent holder. As
discussed earlier, patent rights are the exclusive rights granted by the Government to an
inventor over his invention for a limited period of time. In other words, if any person exercises
the exclusive rights of the patent holder without the patent owner's authorization then that
person is liable for patent infringement. Sections 104-114 of the Patents Act, 1970 provide
guidelines relating to patent infringement.
Unlike the Design law, the Patents law does not specify as to what would constitute
infringement of a patented product or process. However, the following acts when committed
without the consent of the patentee shall amount to infringement:
(i) making, using, offering for sale, selling, importing the patented product;
(ii) using the patented process, or using, offering for sale, selling or importing the product
directly obtained by that process
Types of Infringement
There are two kinds of infringement :
Direct Infringement
Direct patent infringement is the most obvious and the most common form of patent
infringement. Basically, direct patent infringement occurs when a product that is substantially
close to a patented product or inventions marketed, sold, or used commercially without
permission from the owner of the patented product or invention.
Indirect Infringement
Indirect patent infringement suggests that there was some amount of deceit or accidental patent
infringement in the incident. For instance, A holds a patent for a device and B manufactures a
device which issue substantially similar to the A’s device. B is supplied with a product from
another person C to facilitate manufacturing of the B’s device. If the device so manufactured
by B infringes upon A’s patent, then the person C indirectly infringes A’s patent. Further, if
such a product is knowingly sold or supplied, it may lead to “contributory infringement”. In
the above example, if the person C knowingly supplies the product to B then the infringement
is construed as contributory infringement.
Types of Trademark
Trademark is logo or combination of characters and numerals used by a company
to claim its ownership on a term or design to represent its products and services. There are
various of types of trademarks which can be registered like product mark, service mark,
collective mark, certification mark, shape mark, sound mark and pattern mark.
Product Mark
Product mark is a mark that is used on a good or on a product rather than on a service. This this
type of trademark is used to recognize the origin of the product and helps in maintaining the
reputation of a business. Trademark applications filed under trademark class 1-34 could be
termed as a product mark, as they represent goods.
Service Mark
Service mark is similar to the product mark but a service mark is used to represent a service
rather than a product. The main purpose of the service mark is that it distinguishes its
proprietors from the owners of other services. Trademark applications filed under trademark
class 35-45 could be termed as a service mark, as they represent services.
Collective Mark
Collective mark is used to inform the public about certain distinguished features of a product
or service used to represent a collective. A group of individuals can use this mark so that they
are collectively protecting a goods or service. The mark holder can be an association or can be
a public institution or can also be a Section 8 Company.
In a collective mark, normally the standards of the products are fixed by the regulator owing
the mark. Others associated with the collective are held responsible to adhere to certain
standards while using the mark
Certification Mark (mgu exam oct 2019 2 marks)
Certification mark is a sign that denotes a products origin, material, quality or other specific
details which are issued by the proprietor. The main purpose of certification mark is to bring
out the standard of the product and guarantee the product to the customers. A certification
mark can also be used to uplift the product’s standard amongst the customers by showing that
the product had undergone standard tests to ensure quality. Certification marks are usually seen
on packed foods, toys and electronics.
Register of Trade Marks (Sec 6) (mgu exam oct 2019 – 15 marks,)
A register on trademarks shall be maintained in the office of trade Mark Registry. All the
registered trade mark shall be entered into this register with name, address and description of
the proprietors, notification and transmission and assignments. The register shows the
names,address and description of registered users, conditions, limitations andother relevant
matters as per rule.
In addition to the conventional form of records the registrar willalso keep soft copies
of trademarks and other information subject tosuch safeguards as may be prescribed in the Act.
A copy of register shall be kept at each branch office of the Trade Mark Registry.
o Vienna codification
It is an international classification or codification of figurative elements of
marks. Once the trade marks application for registration is filed, the registrar will apply the
Vienna classification to the trade mark based on the figurative elements of marks. The status
of registration while in this process will reflect as Sent for Vienna codification.
o Trademark examination
Once the codification is completed the trade mark registration application will be allotted to a
trademark officer in the Trademark Registrar office. He then reviews the application for
correctness and issue a trademark examination report. The trademark officer has the right to
accept or reject the application. In the case of acceptance, he may allow the trademarks for
publication in journal. If it is objected, the applicant has the right to appear before Trademark
officer and address the objections. If he satisfied with the justifications of the applicant, the
trademarks would be allowed for trademark journal publication.
Collective Marks
A collective trade mark is defined in section 2 (g) says that a trade mark distinguishing the
goods or services of the members of group or an Association of Person(AOP) which is the
proprietor of the mark from those of others. The AOP for this purpose is not to include a
partnership under the partnership Act 1932.
✓ The manner in which the collective trademarks is used by proprietor or authorized user
has caused to mislead the public
✓ The proprietor failed to comply with the regulations governing
to use of the mark.
The trade marks have to be got registered in respect of those goods or services as per rule in
the name as proprietor of the certification trade mark
A mark not to be registered in the name of a person who is carrying on a trade in goods and
services of the kind certified.
• Whether the applicant is competent to certify the goods in respect of which the marks
is to be registered,
• Whether the draft of the regulation is satisfactory
• Whether in all the circumstances, the registration applied for would be to the public
advantage.
Well known trade mark is defined as a trade mark known by large portion of the public and
that can be immediately recognized as relating to the product and services for which it is used.
Subsequent to implementation of globalization policies, India has opened its doors for foreign
investors. The investors are even permitted the use of their foreign brand names in India.
Resultantly a number of globally well established brands already started with investment
optionsin India.
To address different infringement issues in the market, they relied on the common law or
passing off, as there was no specific provision in the old trade mark for the protection of well
known marks. A new law to handle well known marks and related issues was enacted in 1999
following the requirement protected in GATT. The new act included with the provision that
any trade mark which is well known in any part of the globe can be registered even though the
product is not in Indian market.
The law will undoubtedly increase the interest of the foreign investors to protect their well
known marks in India. A reputed mark can be protected comprehensively in India by our laws.
The big brands can enjoy the freedom of using their well known trademarks without
any anxiety of infringement. There are high chances of elimination of duplicate similar
products from the market and market will expectedly comprised of original products.
The term well known trademarks has been defined in the TM Act 1999 and refers to a mark
which has become so to the substantialsegment for public which uses such goods or service
that the use of such mark in relation to other goods or services would be likely to be taken as
indicating a connection in the course of trade between those goods in services and a person
using the mark in relation to the first mentioned goods and services.
In the Trade Marks Act, the definition of well known trade mark has been provided, But
whether a mark is well known or not, is to be considered on the basis of following criteria:-