Vgo Hdt Feed
Vgo Hdt Feed
Vgo Hdt Feed
(HRRL)
DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL
1 NO COMMENTS
V VOID
REVIEW CATEGORY
1 REVIEW
2 RECORD
NO OF REVIEW
DRAWING/DOCUMENT NO REV DESCRIPTION
SHEETS CATEGORY
PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 A/B (41 DIA X 20 H)
MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001 01 11 TANKS
RECORD
.
NO OF
SL NO DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION FROM TO
PAGES
1 COVER SHEET 1 2 2
2 PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 AB (41 DIA X 20 H) TANKS 8 3 10
MSK GR SS 01 04-10-2023
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
1 of 37
Page 1 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
DOC.NO : MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
2 of 37
Page 2 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
INDEX
S. NO DESCRIPTION PAGE NO
1 COVER PAGE 1
2 INDEX 2
5 METEOROLOGICAL DATA 8
6 CHANGE LIST 9
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
3 of 37
Page 3 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
4 of 37
Page 4 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
HOLDS:
1 DELETED 01
2 DELETED 01
3 DELETED 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
5 of 37
Page 5 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
M3-4
PVRV NS
LT2
LT3 EV 01
LT1 G TE
N
01
FN
MX
SI 1-4
M1-2
F
COD C0 1-4
1:100
D1/2/3
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
6 of 37
Page 6 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
1 Tank Diameter D m 41
2 Tank Height H m 20
Tank Datasheet
3 Tank Inlet Flowrate Q1 m³/hr 522
4 Tank Outlet Flowrate Q2 m³/hr 330
B Response time :
Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level (
5 T1 min 30
LLL )
High Liquid Level ( HLL ) to High High Liquid Level
6 T2 min 15
(HHLL)
High High Liquid Level ( HHLL ) to Safe Fill Liquid
7 T3 min 15
Level (HHHLL)
C Low Level Calculations :
13 Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) D4 mm 1320 D3 + D3 '' (or ) as per Mixer vendor recommendation 01
Distance [Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level
14 D5 mm 125 (Q2/60)x 4 x T1 / (π x D² ) x 1000
( LLL ) ]
28 Pumpable Capacity V5 m3 22286 (π/4 x D² x (D8 - D4))/ 1000 Between HHHLL and LLLL 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
7 of 37
Page 7 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
M
T3
T2 20
HEIGHT
DIAMETER 41 M
T1
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
8 of 37
Page 8 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
9 of 37
Page 9 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
Liquid Stored capacity Updated based on the Mixer vendor requirement/ minimum
1 3
revised liquid levels as per the mixer vendor pumpable Volumne (Note -1)
requirement.
Mixer vendor requirement and change liquid
2 4 Pumpbale volume is updated based
levels
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
10 of 37
Page 10 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
As per Clause no. 2.1, EPC Contractor to note that submission of all revisions Noted
of documents (including the first submission of documents included in Bid
Package) must be accompanied by a change list listing the changes made to
the document and the specific reasons for the same. If the document revision
is in response to comments made, comment resolution sheet for the same
2
must also be submitted. Documents submitted without complying to the
above requirements will be returned without review and the EPC Contractor
will be required to resubmit the documents after complying to the above
requirements.
EPCC to note that the approval of the process documents is limited only for Noted and All changes are with blue color (instead of
the revisions duly clouded and change list provided. The changes other than providing cloud) and revision mark is added at right side of the
3 the above done by EPCC due to any reason, if made, EPCC shall be sheet.
responsible and liable to correct at any stage without any cost/time
implication.
EPCC to update the Revision Number to Rev 0 in place of Rev A in all Noted and updated rev A to Rev 00 and provided in next
4 sheets of the PDS in line with the first sheet. This comment is valid for all revision as Rev 01
EPCC dcouments.
In Page 1 of 10, EPCC to update the Package name as Package 6A in Project Noted and updated
5 heading; EPCC to correct the Rev No and update the description at Bottom
as ISSUED FOR REVIEW. This comment is valid for all EPCC dcouments.
6 In Page 2 of 10, EPCC to correct the name as DESCRIPTION. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, With Doc No at TOP, EPCC also to mention the EIL PDS Noted and updated
7
number.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Coil area as 70 m2 in line with EIL Noted and updated required heating coil area is 50m², as per
PDS else provide the reason. heating coil calculations - MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-VGO-
8 CRT-MEC-CAL-004. However Updated with 70 m² inline
with EIL PDS. And provided area in the design calcualtions
shall be updated.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Piping spec for nozzles as B9A in line Noted and updated. Also provided Rating for each nozzle in
9 with EIL PDS. the sheet as per comments in other data sheets.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to has considered Foam nozzle which is not as per As per EIL Scope of work && Supply Doc.no: B224-323-81-
EIL PDS, EPCC to provide the reason. 45-SOW-6006 REV.A PAGE 5/10 : Semi Fixed Foam System
10 required for this tank. Hence we have provided the foam
nozzle
In Page 3 of 10, PVRV nozzle size shall be confirmed and hold shall be Noted and updated
11
removed.
12 In Page 3 of 10, Foam nozzle number and size shall be confirmed. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, Mixer nozzle number, size and elevation shall be confirmed Noted and updated
13
and hold shall be removed.
14 EPCC to remove all holds in next revision. Noted and updated
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to As per the area required for heating coil, there is sufficient
centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the steam coil has been accounted for in the space to provided the required length. Minimu clearance
15 calculation. (distance from inlet/out) shall be provided at the mixer in all
directions.
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to Low-Low liquid levels are evaluated based on the maximum
16 centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the mixer has been accounted for in the requirement on the inlet/outlet nozzle c/l elevations and mixer
calculation. vendor recommendations.
In Annexure-1, Low Liquid level (LAL) shall be confirmed as per Mixer Noted and Revised Levels as per Mixer Vendor confirmation.
17 vendor inputs for minimum operating level and PDS shall be submitted for
review.
Insulation thickness in Tender PDS was 25 mm for this whole Tank. Noted & Provided for the roof also.
18 However, EPCC has provided insulation for shell only. Please clarify why
insulation is not considered for Roof.
EPCC to note that our Code-2 approval is subjected to the compliance and Noted
19
satisfactory closure of above comments.
INSTRUMENTATION COMMENTS
Please refer attach file for Instrument comments No attachement for Instrument comments along with
20
comments.
SME COMMENTS
21 Please refer attach file for SMED comments No attachement for SMED comments along with comments
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
11 of 37
Page 11 of 37
Please find attached EIL Comments.
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
12 of 37
Page 12 of 37
EIL Comments on PDS of VGO HDT Feed Storage Tanks (323-T-1016 A/B) of Package-6A_Rev 1
Date: 03.05.2023
Client: HPCL RAJASTHAN REFINERY LIMITED Department: Process-2
Project: RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT EIL Job No: B224
Plant: OFFSITES (Unit-323) Vendor Doc No: & MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001 Rev 0, Rev 1
Rev No:
Vendor: MAHATHI INFRA SERVICES PVT. LTD.
PDS of VGO HDT Feed Storage Tanks (323-T-1016 A/B)
Item No:
Sr No. EIL Process Comment Vendor Reply EIL Reply on Rev 1 dated 09.11.2023
It is Contractors's responsibility for ensuring correctness, completeness and consistency of the
1 document to meet the overall functional and operational requirements as per Tender/ Technical Noted
Amendments scope and corresponding Contractor documents.
As per Clause no. 2.1, EPC Contractor to note that submission of all revisions of documents (including
the first submission of documents included in Bid Package) must be accompanied by a change list listing
the changes made to the document and the specific reasons for the same. If the document revision is in
2 response to comments made, comment resolution sheet for the same must also be submitted. Noted
Documents submitted without complying to the above requirements will be returned without review
and the EPC Contractor will be required to resubmit the documents after complying to the above
requirements.
EPCC to note that the approval of the process documents is limited only for the revisions duly clouded
and change list provided. The changes other than the above done by EPCC due to any reason, if made, Noted and All changes are with blue color
3 EPCC shall be responsible and liable to correct at any stage without any cost/time implication. (instead of providing cloud) and revision
mark is added at right side of the sheet.
EPCC to update the Revision Number to Rev 0 in place of Rev A in all sheets of the PDS in line with the Noted and updated rev A to Rev 00 and
4 first sheet. This comment is valid for all EPCC dcouments. provided in next revision as Rev 01
In Page 1 of 10, EPCC to update the Package name as Package 6A in Project heading
5 EPCC to correct the Rev No and update the description at Bottom as ISSUED FOR REVIEW. This comment Noted and updated
is valid for all EPCC dcouments.
6 In Page 2 of 10, EPCC to correct the name as DESCRIPTION. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, With Doc No at TOP, EPCC also to mention the EIL PDS number. In page 4,5,6,7,8 of 10, EPCC also to
7 Noted and updated
mention the EIL PDS number at top.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Coil area as 70 m2 in line with EIL PDS else provide the reason.
Noted and updated required heating coil
area is 50m², as per heating coil calculations
- MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-VGO-CRT-MEC-CAL-
8
004. However Updated with 70 m² inline
with EIL PDS. And provided area in the
design calcualtions shall be updated.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Piping spec for nozzles as B9A in line with EIL PDS.
Noted and updated. Also provided Rating for
9 each nozzle in the sheet as per comments in
other data sheets.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to has considered Foam nozzle which is not as per EIL PDS, EPCC to provide the
As per EIL Scope of work && Supply Doc.no:
reason.
B224-323-81-45-SOW-6006 REV.A PAGE
10 5/10 : Semi Fixed Foam System required for
this tank. Hence we have provided the foam
nozzle
11 In Page 3 of 10, PVRV nozzle size shall be confirmed and hold shall be removed. Noted and updated
12 In Page 3 of 10, Foam nozzle number and size shall be confirmed. Noted and updated
13 In Page 3 of 10, Mixer nozzle number, size and elevation shall be confirmed and hold shall be removed. Noted and updated
14 EPCC to remove all holds in next revision. Noted and updated
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10),
the steam coil has been accounted for in the calculation. As per the area required for heating coil,
there is sufficient space to provided the
15 required length. Minimum clearance
(distance from inlet/out) shall be provided
at the mixer in all directions.
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10),
Low-Low liquid levels are evaluated based
the mixer has been accounted for in the calculation.
on the maximum requirement on the
16
inlet/outlet nozzle c/l elevations and mixer
vendor recommendations.
In Annexure-1, Low Liquid level (LAL) shall be confirmed as per Mixer vendor inputs for minimum EPCC also to ensure low low liquid level
Noted and Revised Levels as per Mixer
17 operating level and PDS shall be submitted for review. (LLLL) based on steam coil vendor
Vendor confirmation.
recommendation.
Insulation thickness in Tender PDS was 25 mm for this whole Tank. However, EPCC has provided
18 Noted & Provided for the roof also.
insulation for shell only. Please clarify why insulation is not considered for Roof.
EPCC to note that our Code-2 approval is subjected to the compliance and satisfactory closure of above
19 Noted
comments.
Vendor to ensure correct nozzle number
and rating for roof manway, propeller
20
mixer, foam nozzle etc. as per design
requirement.
INSTRUMENTATION COMMENTS
Please refer attach file for Instrument comments No attachement for Instrument comments
21
along with comments
SME COMMENTS
No attachement for SMED comments along
23 Please refer attach file for SMED comments
with comments
Contractor to ensure that LALL or low low liquid level which is used to calculate pumpable capacity shall
23.1 not be changed at later stage. It is understood that this level (LALL) has been finalized based on mixer or
agitator supplier recommended low liquid level (If any), layout of Steam coil (If any).
Contractor to ensure that HHHLL or safe fill liquid height which is used to calculate pumpable capacity
and stored capacity shall not be changed at later stage. It is understood that this level (HHHLL) has been
23.2 finalized based on seismic free board and clearance of fouling of cone/dome roof structure (As
applicable) with floating roof accessories(As applicable). Also ensure that dome/cone roof structure is
not submerging in liquid at this level(HHHLL).
Contractor to ensure that stored capacity and pumpable capacity shall meet requirement of EIL PDS as a
23.3
minimum. Also, tank farm capacities shall meet requirement of OISD-118 also.
Change w.r.t. EIL PDS as highlighted in Blue color have been noted. Other details shall be as per EIL PDS.
23.4
Contractor's responsibility.
Gauge hatch as per EIL standard is for atmospheric tanks. For pressurized tanks, Contractor to provide
23.5
Doc. MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001 Rev. 01
slot dipping device also.
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
13 of 37
Page 13 of 37
Please refer attached file for Instrumentation comments:
1. LT2 shall be Radar Type as per P&IDs.
2. Level Instruments and Multi-point temperature element tags shall not
be equipped with still-well for VGO HDT Feed tanks T-1016A/B
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
14 of 37
Page 14 of 37
CLIENT HPCL RAJASTHAN REFINERY LTD. (HRRL)
DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL
1 NO COMMENTS
V VOID
REVIEW CATEGORY
1 REVIEW
2 RECORD
NO OF REVIEW
DRAWING/DOCUMENT NO REV DESCRIPTION
SHEETS CATEGORY
PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 A/B (41 DIA X 20 H)
MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001 01 11 TANKS
RECORD
.
NO OF
SL NO DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION FROM TO
PAGES
1 COVER SHEET 1 2 2
2 PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 AB (41 DIA X 20 H) TANKS 8 3 10
MSK GR SS 01 04-10-2023
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
15 of 37
Page 15 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
DOC.NO : MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
16 of 37
Page 16 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
INDEX
S. NO DESCRIPTION PAGE NO
1 COVER PAGE 1
2 INDEX 2
5 METEOROLOGICAL DATA 8
6 CHANGE LIST 9
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
17 of 37
Page 17 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
P&IDs
ROOF WHERE VAPOR CAN ACCUMULATE NO
INNER TANK NO
OUTER TANK NO
SUSPENDED DECK
ANY OTEHER
CATHODIC PROTECTION AT TANK BOTTOM NO
NOZZLES AND CONNECTIONS PIPING SPEC. FOR NOZZLES B9A 01
MARK Nos. SIZE(INCHES) Rating SERVICE MARK Nos. SIZE(INCHES) Rating SERVICE 01
F 1 18 300# TANK INLET/ OUTLET MX 1 32 150# PROPELLER MIXER 01
D1-D3 3 4 150# SIPHON DRAIN (SUMP) N 1 4 150# NITROGEN BLANKETING 01
LT1 1 24 300# LEVEL INSTR.(RADAR TYPE) NS 1 1.5 150# N2 PRESSURE SENSING LINE 01
LT2 1 24 300# LEVEL INSTR.(SERVO TYPE) PVRV 3 12 150# PR/VAC RELIEF VALVE 01
LT3 1 3 300# LEVEL INSTR.(VTF TYPE) M 1,2 2 24 As per SHELL MANHOLE 01
TE
Doc.
1
MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001
3
Rev. 01
300# MULTI-POINT TEMP. INSTR. M 3,4 2 30 Code ROOF MANWAY 01
As per CLEAN OUT DOOR SI1-4 4 2 150# LP STEAM INLET 01
COD 1 36 X 48
Code
G 1 8 (NOTE-8) 150# GAUGE / SAMPLE HATCH CO1-4 4 2 150# CONDENSATE OUTLET 01
EV 3 24" 150# EMERGENCY VENT FN 1-8 8 6 150# FOAM NOZZLE 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
18 of 37
Page 18 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
HOLDS:
1 DELETED Level Instruments and 01
2 DELETED Multi-point temperature 01
3 DELETED element tags shall not be 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
19 of 37
Page 19 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
M3-4
PVRV NS
LT2
LT3 EV 01
LT1 G TE
N
01
FN
MX
SI 1-4
M1-2
F
COD C0 1-4
1:100
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
20 of 37
Page 20 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
1 Tank Diameter D m 41
2 Tank Height H m 20
Tank Datasheet
3 Tank Inlet Flowrate Q1 m³/hr 522
4 Tank Outlet Flowrate Q2 m³/hr 330
B Response time :
Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level (
5 T1 min 30
LLL )
High Liquid Level ( HLL ) to High High Liquid Level
6 T2 min 15
(HHLL)
High High Liquid Level ( HHLL ) to Safe Fill Liquid
7 T3 min 15
Level (HHHLL)
C Low Level Calculations :
13 Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) D4 mm 1320 D3 + D3 '' (or ) as per Mixer vendor recommendation 01
Distance [Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level
14 D5 mm 125 (Q2/60)x 4 x T1 / (π x D² ) x 1000
( LLL ) ]
28 Pumpable Capacity V5 m3 22286 (π/4 x D² x (D8 - D4))/ 1000 Between HHHLL and LLLL 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
21 of 37
Page 21 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
M
T3
T2 20
HEIGHT
DIAMETER 41 M
T1
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
22 of 37
Page 22 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
23 of 37
Page 23 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
Liquid Stored capacity Updated based on the Mixer vendor requirement/ minimum
1 3
revised liquid levels as per the mixer vendor pumpable Volumne (Note -1)
requirement.
Mixer vendor requirement and change liquid
2 4 Pumpbale volume is updated based
levels
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
24 of 37
Page 24 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
As per Clause no. 2.1, EPC Contractor to note that submission of all revisions Noted
of documents (including the first submission of documents included in Bid
Package) must be accompanied by a change list listing the changes made to
the document and the specific reasons for the same. If the document revision
is in response to comments made, comment resolution sheet for the same
2
must also be submitted. Documents submitted without complying to the
above requirements will be returned without review and the EPC Contractor
will be required to resubmit the documents after complying to the above
requirements.
EPCC to note that the approval of the process documents is limited only for Noted and All changes are with blue color (instead of
the revisions duly clouded and change list provided. The changes other than providing cloud) and revision mark is added at right side of the
3 the above done by EPCC due to any reason, if made, EPCC shall be sheet.
responsible and liable to correct at any stage without any cost/time
implication.
EPCC to update the Revision Number to Rev 0 in place of Rev A in all Noted and updated rev A to Rev 00 and provided in next
4 sheets of the PDS in line with the first sheet. This comment is valid for all revision as Rev 01
EPCC dcouments.
In Page 1 of 10, EPCC to update the Package name as Package 6A in Project Noted and updated
5 heading; EPCC to correct the Rev No and update the description at Bottom
as ISSUED FOR REVIEW. This comment is valid for all EPCC dcouments.
6 In Page 2 of 10, EPCC to correct the name as DESCRIPTION. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, With Doc No at TOP, EPCC also to mention the EIL PDS Noted and updated
7
number.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Coil area as 70 m2 in line with EIL Noted and updated required heating coil area is 50m², as per
PDS else provide the reason. heating coil calculations - MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-VGO-
8 CRT-MEC-CAL-004. However Updated with 70 m² inline
with EIL PDS. And provided area in the design calcualtions
shall be updated.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Piping spec for nozzles as B9A in line Noted and updated. Also provided Rating for each nozzle in
9 with EIL PDS. the sheet as per comments in other data sheets.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to has considered Foam nozzle which is not as per As per EIL Scope of work && Supply Doc.no: B224-323-81-
EIL PDS, EPCC to provide the reason. 45-SOW-6006 REV.A PAGE 5/10 : Semi Fixed Foam System
10 required for this tank. Hence we have provided the foam
nozzle
In Page 3 of 10, PVRV nozzle size shall be confirmed and hold shall be Noted and updated
11
removed.
12 In Page 3 of 10, Foam nozzle number and size shall be confirmed. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, Mixer nozzle number, size and elevation shall be confirmed Noted and updated
13
and hold shall be removed.
14 EPCC to remove all holds in next revision. Noted and updated
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to As per the area required for heating coil, there is sufficient
centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the steam coil has been accounted for in the space to provided the required length. Minimu clearance
15 calculation. (distance from inlet/out) shall be provided at the mixer in all
directions.
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to Low-Low liquid levels are evaluated based on the maximum
16 centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the mixer has been accounted for in the requirement on the inlet/outlet nozzle c/l elevations and mixer
calculation. vendor recommendations.
In Annexure-1, Low Liquid level (LAL) shall be confirmed as per Mixer Noted and Revised Levels as per Mixer Vendor confirmation.
17 vendor inputs for minimum operating level and PDS shall be submitted for
review.
Insulation thickness in Tender PDS was 25 mm for this whole Tank. Noted & Provided for the roof also.
18 However, EPCC has provided insulation for shell only. Please clarify why
insulation is not considered for Roof.
EPCC to note that our Code-2 approval is subjected to the compliance and Noted
19
satisfactory closure of above comments.
INSTRUMENTATION COMMENTS
Please refer attach file for Instrument comments No attachement for Instrument comments along with
20
comments.
SME COMMENTS
21 Please refer attach file for SMED comments No attachement for SMED comments along with comments
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
25 of 37
Page 25 of 37
Please refer attached file
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
26 of 37
Page 26 of 37
CLIENT HPCL RAJASTHAN REFINERY LTD. (HRRL)
DOCUMENT TRANSMITTAL
1 NO COMMENTS
V VOID
REVIEW CATEGORY
1 REVIEW
2 RECORD
NO OF REVIEW
DRAWING/DOCUMENT NO REV DESCRIPTION
SHEETS CATEGORY
PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 A/B (41 DIA X 20 H)
MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001 01 11 TANKS
RECORD
.
NO OF
SL NO DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION FROM TO
PAGES
1 COVER SHEET 1 2 2
2 PROCESS DATA SHEET OF VGO HDT FEED 323-T-1016 AB (41 DIA X 20 H) TANKS 8 3 10
Only CRS points pertaining to SMED-1 (Static) department have been noted. Contractor
to ensure that all requirements of tender including amendments are complied with.
Document is retained for information.
In case, any discrepancy between PDS and GA drawing & other fabrication drawings of
respective equipment, Contractor to update GA drawing & other fabrication drawings
without time and cost implication.
General comments (regarding Rating of nozzles, Liquid levels, capacity, fouling etc.)
furnished on earlier revision(s) are applicable for this revision also.
MSK GR SS 01 04-10-2023
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
27 of 37
Page 27 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
DOC.NO : MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-PROC-DS-001
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
28 of 37
Page 28 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
INDEX
S. NO DESCRIPTION PAGE NO
1 COVER PAGE 1
2 INDEX 2
5 METEOROLOGICAL DATA 8
6 CHANGE LIST 9
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
29 of 37
Page 29 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
30 of 37
Page 30 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
HOLDS:
1 DELETED 01
2 DELETED 01
3 DELETED 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
31 of 37
Page 31 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
M3-4
PVRV NS
LT2
LT3 EV 01
LT1 G TE
N
01
FN
MX
SI 1-4
M1-2
F
COD C0 1-4
1:100
D1/2/3
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
32 of 37
Page 32 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
1 Tank Diameter D m 41
2 Tank Height H m 20
Tank Datasheet
3 Tank Inlet Flowrate Q1 m³/hr 522
4 Tank Outlet Flowrate Q2 m³/hr 330
B Response time :
Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level (
5 T1 min 30
LLL )
High Liquid Level ( HLL ) to High High Liquid Level
6 T2 min 15
(HHLL)
High High Liquid Level ( HHLL ) to Safe Fill Liquid
7 T3 min 15
Level (HHHLL)
C Low Level Calculations :
13 Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) D4 mm 1320 D3 + D3 '' (or ) as per Mixer vendor recommendation 01
Distance [Low Low Liquid Level ( LLLL ) to Low Liquid Level
14 D5 mm 125 (Q2/60)x 4 x T1 / (π x D² ) x 1000
( LLL ) ]
28 Pumpable Capacity V5 m3 22286 (π/4 x D² x (D8 - D4))/ 1000 Between HHHLL and LLLL 01
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
33 of 37
Page 33 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
18425 mm as per
agitator drawing.
Contractor to check
and revise. Revise
Free board 1800 MM 01
capacities accordingly.
M
T3
T2 20
HEIGHT
DIAMETER 41 M
T1
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
34 of 37
Page 34 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
35 of 37
Page 35 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
Liquid Stored capacity Updated based on the Mixer vendor requirement/ minimum
1 3
revised liquid levels as per the mixer vendor pumpable Volumne (Note -1)
requirement.
Mixer vendor requirement and change liquid
2 4 Pumpbale volume is updated based
levels
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
36 of 37
Page 36 of 37
RAJASTHAN REFINERY PROJECT
As per Clause no. 2.1, EPC Contractor to note that submission of all revisions Noted
of documents (including the first submission of documents included in Bid
Package) must be accompanied by a change list listing the changes made to
the document and the specific reasons for the same. If the document revision
is in response to comments made, comment resolution sheet for the same
2
must also be submitted. Documents submitted without complying to the
above requirements will be returned without review and the EPC Contractor
will be required to resubmit the documents after complying to the above
requirements.
EPCC to note that the approval of the process documents is limited only for Noted and All changes are with blue color (instead of
the revisions duly clouded and change list provided. The changes other than providing cloud) and revision mark is added at right side of the
3 the above done by EPCC due to any reason, if made, EPCC shall be sheet.
responsible and liable to correct at any stage without any cost/time
implication.
EPCC to update the Revision Number to Rev 0 in place of Rev A in all Noted and updated rev A to Rev 00 and provided in next
4 sheets of the PDS in line with the first sheet. This comment is valid for all revision as Rev 01
EPCC dcouments.
In Page 1 of 10, EPCC to update the Package name as Package 6A in Project Noted and updated
5 heading; EPCC to correct the Rev No and update the description at Bottom
as ISSUED FOR REVIEW. This comment is valid for all EPCC dcouments.
6 In Page 2 of 10, EPCC to correct the name as DESCRIPTION. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, With Doc No at TOP, EPCC also to mention the EIL PDS Noted and updated
7
number.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Coil area as 70 m2 in line with EIL Noted and updated required heating coil area is 50m², as per
PDS else provide the reason. heating coil calculations - MISPL-EIL-HRRL-B224-VGO-
8 CRT-MEC-CAL-004. However Updated with 70 m² inline
with EIL PDS. And provided area in the design calcualtions
shall be updated.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to correct the Piping spec for nozzles as B9A in line Noted and updated. Also provided Rating for each nozzle in
9 with EIL PDS. the sheet as per comments in other data sheets.
In Page 3 of 10, EPCC to has considered Foam nozzle which is not as per As per EIL Scope of work && Supply Doc.no: B224-323-81-
EIL PDS, EPCC to provide the reason. 45-SOW-6006 REV.A PAGE 5/10 : Semi Fixed Foam System
10 required for this tank. Hence we have provided the foam
nozzle
In Page 3 of 10, PVRV nozzle size shall be confirmed and hold shall be Noted and updated
11
removed.
12 In Page 3 of 10, Foam nozzle number and size shall be confirmed. Noted and updated
In Page 3 of 10, Mixer nozzle number, size and elevation shall be confirmed Noted and updated
13
and hold shall be removed.
14 EPCC to remove all holds in next revision. Noted and updated
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to As per the area required for heating coil, there is sufficient
centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the steam coil has been accounted for in the space to provided the required length. Minimu clearance
15 calculation. (distance from inlet/out) shall be provided at the mixer in all
directions.
In Annexure-1, EPCC to confirm that distance D2 from tank bottom to Low-Low liquid levels are evaluated based on the maximum
16 centreline of nozzle (Sr. No. 10), the mixer has been accounted for in the requirement on the inlet/outlet nozzle c/l elevations and mixer
calculation. vendor recommendations.
In Annexure-1, Low Liquid level (LAL) shall be confirmed as per Mixer Noted and Revised Levels as per Mixer Vendor confirmation.
17 vendor inputs for minimum operating level and PDS shall be submitted for
review.
Insulation thickness in Tender PDS was 25 mm for this whole Tank. Noted & Provided for the roof also.
18 However, EPCC has provided insulation for shell only. Please clarify why
insulation is not considered for Roof.
EPCC to note that our Code-2 approval is subjected to the compliance and Noted
19
satisfactory closure of above comments.
INSTRUMENTATION COMMENTS
Please refer attach file for Instrument comments No attachement for Instrument comments along with
20
comments.
SME COMMENTS
21 Please refer attach file for SMED comments No attachement for SMED comments along with comments
20-NOV-2023
GOLEY RAHUL[C756]
37 of 37
Page 37 of 37