Global Marketing Assignment (Saphie Alim)
Global Marketing Assignment (Saphie Alim)
Global Marketing Assignment (Saphie Alim)
11
[Texte]
Page 0
Executive summary ................................................................................................................................. 3 Introduction............................................................................................................................................. 4 1 Marketing research overview.......................................................................................................... 5 1.1 1.2 1.3 SABMiller Overview ................................................................................................................. 5 Theoretical background........................................................................................................... 6 SABMiller Research Brief ......................................................................................................... 6 Information requirement and research objectives ......................................................... 6 Approach and methodology ............................................................................................ 7 Assessment of the research value ................................................................................. 10 Data analysis .................................................................................................................. 10 Interpretation and Presentation ................................................................................... 10
Marketing audit ............................................................................................................................. 10 2.1 External audit ........................................................................................................................ 10 Macroenvironment ....................................................................................................... 10 Porters five forces ........................................................................................................ 15 BCG Matrix..................................................................................................................... 16 Interest and power matrix............................................................................................. 16 Ansoff matrix ................................................................................................................. 17
2.2.1 2.3
2.3.1 2.3.2 3
Marketing strategy recommendations.......................................................................................... 24 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 Local issues ............................................................................................................................ 25 The four Ps: Product, placement, pricing and promotion ..................................................... 26 Unique Selling Proposition and Branding .............................................................................. 31 SCP (Segmentation, Targeting, Positioning) .......................................................................... 31 Strategic choices .................................................................................................................... 33 Page 1
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 2
Executive summary
SABMiller is a global brewing company from South African that is to expand into India. The assignment is about this company which is one of the largest brewers, with more than 200 beers. SABMiller operates over 75 countries with 70,000 employees worldwide being one of the worlds largest bottlers of coca-cola products. In todays fast-paced and challenging market place, the world is going through drastic changes due to the effects of globalisation. As globalisation is reaching into increasing unfamiliar territories, expansions of companies are becoming more of a necessity than a choice. Small companies are getting weighed down by larger companies, which benefit from economies of scale on their factors of production. The main purpose of this academic report is to recommend marketing strategies that will help SABMiller penetrate the Indian Market successfully considering the fierce competition as well as the macroenvironment. This report thus highlights the current strategic situation of SABMiller identifying its strategic position in terms of its business macroenvironment, its core competencies and capabilities as well as stakeholders expectations. The paper then critically discusses the issues they involve investigating their implications of these issues for SABMiller in the future. The rationale behind this is to demonstrate how SABMillers capabilities could help them enter India facing these challenges. A rigorous market research will be conducted coupled with an exhaustive market audit which will enable us to make key decisions regarding the strategic priorities that should be considered to face SABMillers new challenges. The first part of this report helps us understand the market and consumers need. The second part of this paper evaluates the market through analytical tools which are critically discussed. Key strenghs include a wide geographical presence, talented and motivated workforce as well as sustainable development (strong corporate social responsibility). Weaknesses comprises declining market share in sector, limited liquidity position and management capability impairment. At the same time, three opportunities are addressed: the brewing industry consolidation, strategic acquisitions and agreements, the growing concern for HIV/AIDS as well as growing interest worldwide for emerging markets like India. On the other hand, intense competition, rise in input costs, change in consumer preferences, raw material volatility as well as regulatory change in the alcohol industry are genuine threats for the profitability of SABMiller. Last but not least, this report points out marketing strategies recommendations discussing three options (namely product development, market development and joint-venture) that may help SABMiller successfully enter the Indian Market as a reputable and premium brand to develop its business.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 3
Introduction
SABMiller is evolving from an operating company, concentrating essentially on brewing, to a brandled company. SABMiller has a predominant presence and position in South Africa in terms of profit and cash. In addition to its aggressive strategy to drive volume and productivity in major markets like the USA and Europe, the companys incremental focus is also on emerging global market (economy) where it could value its core competencies for sustainable growth mainly through acquisition. SABMiller aims to create a balanced spread of businesses on a global scale, develop valuable brand portfolios through strong corporate awareness constantly improvising its local business. This sets SABMiller apart from their competitors supporting their vision to become the most successful and well-known company in the global brewery industry. However, given the increasing competition and market changes, SABMiller can no longer rely solely on optimising and expanding established positions in developing market. Owing to the changing market coupled with the growing competition, SABMiller needs to seek value-adding opportunities to enhance their position as a global brewer. Thus, our marketing objective will concentrate on entering India, a potential and attractive market in todays business world. The main purpose of the assignment is to advice the SABMiller Company having its origin in South Africa about the research and marketing strategies in order to enter the Indian market successfully. At the same time, how to conduct the research in effective manner so as to gain the insight knowledge about the drinking behavior of Indians and also find out the cultural and the social attitudes towards alcohol to advice the company about the market strategies they can implement. Further in addition suggestions to promote their product through various promotional tools. The paper is divided into three parts: the marketing research overview that includes the company overview, the theoretical background as well as research and methodology; the market audit that involves the internal and external analysis of SABMiller through various tools such as PESTLE, SWOT, BCG matrix and Ansoff model. Last but not least, the report suggests key marketing recommendations to allow SABMiller to perform as effectively as possible in India.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 4
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 5
1.3.1
An opportunity for SABMiller has been identified in Indian market. According to all India Brewers Association the Indian beer industry has been witnessing steady growth of 7-9% per year over the last ten years. A decision whether Indian market is profitable enough for SABMiller to enter has to be made. In case of a positive answer decisions about the appropriate marketing mix have also to be reached. Therefore, marketing research to be conducted covers the areas and has the objectives as described in the table provided below.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 6
To explore Indian market potential such as peoples attitude towards alcohol in general and beer in particular - To identify the average level of consumption of beer and on which occasions and where it is usually drunk - To discover preferred flavours of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beer The variations on the data should be looked at and categorized based on demographic factors such as gender, age, rural or urban area of living, level of income and education, profession and position held Competitor - To identify the main competitors currently operating in Indian market information - To establish their resources and capabilities - To analyse their current corporate, business and functional strategies Porters five forces as well as some secondary sources of information will be used to acquire this knowledge. Special attention has to be paid to the current marketing strategy of the direct competitors, what messages are conveyed, what promotion tools and distribution channels are used Foreign - To determine the level of attractiveness of country currency exchange - To obtain the information on the interests rates - To acquire analytical information about the future of the Indian market - To find out if the recession benefited domestic lager over imported lager Secondary sources of information will be used to evaluate favourability of Indian economic conditions for SABMiller operations Prescriptive - To get profound knowledge in Indian laws and regulations concerning alcohol information consumption, age and time restrictions, advertising limitations, beer import and taxation on the product As India is a big country and is a federal republic variations in laws are expected Resource - To establish whether India has appropriate human (number of educated information people, level of unemployment) and physical (suitable places to build plants if needed) resources for conducting the business General - To make an overall review of sociocultural, political, and technological conditions environments A mix of secondary and primary data will be mined for this purpose. Local agencies are to be used to overcome subjective opinions and biased results of SABMillers researchers as well as to get a better understanding of the above mentioned factors. 1.3.2 Approach and methodology
Any marketing research should begin with investigation of the available secondary data. Secondary data is the information that has previously been gathered for some purpose other than the current research project (Alan Wilson, 2006). There are several reasons why obtaining and analysing secondary data at the very beginning of our marketing research is essential. First of all, it may cover some issues relevant to the current project, for example, most of India PESTEL factors can successfully be analysed using secondary data. More depth is required though in social issues investigation and other research methods will be recommended below for that purpose. Moreover, secondary information is comparatively cheap.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 7
First of all information directories can be used. For example, Euromonitor offers a report about beer market in India available for purchase for 600 and includes analysis of key supply-side and demand trends, detailed segmentation of international and local products, company and brand market volume shares, five year forecasts of market trends and market growth, production and imports by origin. This source of information is based on robust and transparent market research methodology, conducted in-country and it would potentially answer most of the question areas specified above. Another valuable source to consider is MarketResearch.com, the worlds largest and continuously updated collection of market research. More than 300,000 market research reports are available there from over 700 leading global publishers. Canadeans 2010 India Beer Market Insights report which has been found there is highly recommended as it provides the most comprehensive analysis of the market including legislation and taxation information, a detailed overview of current and emerging trends, exhaustive market segmentation data by price, alcoholic strength and beer type, a thorough analysis of distribution channels and packaging trends. Moreover, Indian government statistics and census records can be used to obtain information on Indian population characteristics. The Indian Census for example (www.censusindia.gov.in) is the most credible source of information on demography, economic activity, literacy and education, housing & household amenities, urbanisation, fertility and mortality, scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, language, religion, migration, disability and many other socio-cultural and demographic data. Furthermore, annual reports of direct competitors can be obtained online to help SABMiller management understand their competitive advantages/disadvantages relative their rivals, provide an informed basis to develop competitive strategies and forecast the returns of the possible future investments in the market. Finally, additional information can be gained through online search engines, social networking sites, newsgroups, blogs, and discussion forums. It should be pointed out that marketers have to make sure that all the used sources of information are reliable, valid, up-to-date and comparable over time. In some cases the information found in the reports may not be related to the research question and the temptation may be to force the data to
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 8
After collecting and analysing all the secondary data initial findings are analysed and the decision is taken whether the company needs to use some primary sources for further investigation of the market. According to Keegan and Green (2011) direct sensory perception provides a vital background for the information that comes from human and documentary sources. Therefore, the so-called informal market research is highly recommended in SABMiller case to get some primary information about Indian culture and life. There are two types of primary data - quantitative primary data, which is undertaken using a structured research approach to produce quantifiable insights into the consumers behaviour, and qualitative primary data, which is obtained using loosely structured research approach and tells about peoples opinions, motivations and attitudes. Overall advantages of primary sources of information over secondary ones would include the companys ability to have greater control over the research and address specific issues which are relevant to the project. Moreover, only the company that has carried out primary research can have benefits from its results as it doesnt share this information with anybody. According to John Pawle (1999) for consumer products, qualitative research is especially well suited to accomplish essential tasks. In SABMiller case qualitative research will provide better consumer understanding through gaining a comprehensive insight into the social and cultural context, including cultural, religious, and political factors that impact purchasing decisions. Qualitative research will help SABMiller to identify its core brand equity and to determine what people really feel about it. Qualitative research in SABMiller case can be conducted through ethnographic observation, which involves total immersion in the life of the subject. Researchers will spend a considerable amount of time living in Indian society and getting acquainted with its attitudes to alcohol and drinking habits. This method will be the most accurate one since the potential for bias is reduced as the researcher will witness natural behaviour, though the drawback may be a big amount of time required to complete the research and analyse its findings. Focus groups when a number of respondents are gathered together to generate ideas through the discussion of, and reaction to, specific stimuli (Market Research Society, 2008) are another effective means of getting reliable data during marketing research. The recruitment of respondents is advised to be carried out by the local professional recruitment services identified on the MRS website (www.mrs.org.uk). For SABMiller research 8-10 focus groups will be required to cover northern and southern parts of India as well as explore representatives of different social classes (scheduled castes and scheduled tribes) and age groups. Two focus groups per segment of interest will be analysed. Segments of interest will be discovered as a result of secondary data research. The main advantages of this method over ethnographic observation are that its more efficient in terms of time, is excellent for uncovering hidden motivations and it can be recorded for later analysis.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 9
1.3.3
All the research techniques should be developed in line with the budget a company has set for the purpose. Research requires an investment of both money and managerial time, and it is necessary to perform a cost-benefit analysis before proceeding further. (Keegan, W.J. and Green, M.C., 2011)
1.3.4
Data analysis
After all the data is collected it should be analysed in order to be useful to decision-makers. Several techniques are available for researcher to do this, for example, hypothesis testing, correlation analysis, regression analysis and factor analysis. There exist many software packages that can make it easy, such as Excel and SPSS. The important thing here is to understand what exactly these packages do to the valuable data and to produce efficient analysis which allows a focus on a research problem.
1.3.5
Once data has been analysed it will be presented in a written form, orally, or electronically via video. Results will be clearly stated and provide a basis for managerial action.
2 Marketing audit
2.1 External audit
2.1.1 Macroenvironment
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 10
Brief overview: PESTLE analysis allows a business environmental scan of a company that helps identify the external macroenvironment in which the business (may) operate(s) (Chernev and Kotler, 2008). PESTLE consists of six different factors. It is hence important for SABMiller to be aware of these factors while expanding into India which is an emerging and complex market given its specific government and culture.
Political
India political scenario is specific unlike other countries worldwide as not only does the Indian government type consist of a federal republic, but it also includes separate personal law codes to Muslims, Christians and Hindus. This explains its complexity as compared to other countries. Accordingly, it is vital for every organisation entering the Indian market to scan the political environment. In addition to being the biggest democracy in the world, Indian federal republic is based on judicial review of legislative acts and requires compulsory ICJ (International Commission of Jurists) with reservation. India currently has a coalition led government and both major political parties the UPA (United Progressive Alliance) and BJP (Bharatiya Janata Party) are powerful ensuring the stability in the country. Therefore, a great political sensitivity is needed par SABMiller when dealing with the Indian government. Nonetheless, the political situation in the country remains unstable, sometimes more or less stable. State politics have been dominated by different national parties such as the BJP or CPI (Communist Party of India). As Kurian (2010) argued, this has led to the implementation of different regulations and rules for liquor (beer) in the brewing industry as a whole. For instance, certain states namely Gujrat are dry areas where the sales of liquor are entirely banned. Aside from that, some states have time limits: after 9: pm the sales of beer are prohibited as liquor board stores have to close before that time. Furthermore, the age limit for drinking in India is still a controversial debate. It is currently 25. It therefore becomes hard for SABMiller to produce and distribute beer in large quantities to reach economy of scale. This may hinder its productivity. Thus, SABMiller must be very specific and accurate when targeting its consumers. As alcohol advertising is prohibited causing huge discussion, SABMiller should use other marketing tools to promote its products. To overcome this issue, it may actually cash its international reputation to stimulate its sales and increase brand awareness in the domestic market targeting the public houses and discotheques for its promotion.
Economic
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 11
Social
India is widely known as a multicultural land; it is subsequently hard to categorise the country under one segment. For instance, the northern part is entirely different from the southern part and as per capita income is continuously rising, so does the gap between the rich and the most impoverished people. To support this point, Stanley (2010) also asserted that unequal distribution of wealth is widening in India. SABMiller should consider this especially for entering this changing market even if these disparities are expected to change. Thus, the company can target the new Indians who are open to change. SABMiller consequently needs to adapt (adaptation) to Indians drinking habits and mentalities to achieve a successful implementation especially if the brewing company is willing to position itself as a premium brand. In addition, with a rise in the buying power in India, the Indians who used to prefer local hard liquor which is the cheapest are now able to taste the relatively expensive beer market. This may be beneficial for SABMiller as this has led to lifestyles changing and thereby a substantial increase in the availability of disposable income and the consumption of beer in India. From 2005 to 2010, there has been an increase of 94% in the beer consumption rate. This increase is by far higher than the increase in the BRIC nations of Brazil (20%), Russia (50%) and China (58%) (King, 2010). This shows a clear positive trend towards beer industries booming in India. However, new trends like wines and spirits may have adverse effects on SABMiller activity. The company thus has to anticipate these issues.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 12
Technological
Importing beer in India involves heavy taxes from the government resulting in higher prices. Therefore, to enter the Indian market, it is advisable for SABMiller to set up plant in this country. For instance, it may set up several breweries in Himachal Pradesh, Maharashtra and Rajasthan where beer consumption is continuously increasing so as to lower costs. Additionally, the Indian brewing industry is rapidly growing with many foreign players penetrating the Indian market. The technological knowhow and expertise is also booming in India leading to fast-paced competition. A prime example of this is the big corporation Ziemann Group, a beer brewing technology which entered the Indian market setting up manufacturing plant in the country and thereby founding SABMiller India. This will help enhance technological knowhow and develop the production of beer. SABMiller may place an order for the design and construction of two turnkeys plants in India to Ziemann (Cook, 2011). The new plants may be planned for Sonipat in Haryana and for another location near Bangalore where beer consumption is widespread. Both breweries can be expected to have an annual capacity of 1 million hectoliters each to start and might be extended over the five coming years. Thus, with booming technologies entering the Indian beer market, production may increase and lowering cost of production could play a key role in the Indian beer market. SABMiller can take advantage of this extension of new technologies to ensure that the beer that it markets is of better quality and great taste. If it is successful, this will enable the company ensure consistent quality (standardization) to its products and thereby appeal to consumers increasing its sales as well as its brand awareness.
Environmental
Environmental factors involve the weather and climate change. As the climate in India is generally warm, SABMiller can increase the promotions during the summer season. As the company will be new in the country, SABMiller will yet have to observe its first effects on environment. Weather conditions can adversely affect SABMiller profitability in Indian markets that is why environmental factors should be accorded greater interest.
Legal
SABMiller must be very careful about the Indian political environment which could dramatically affect the companys profitability. As the laws vary from one country to another (e.g: workforce laws), it will be advisable for SABMiller to make asocial networking website so that its purpose of marketing is solved and complies with the Indian law as well. The OLI Model
Ownership
The Indian Market offers good ownership opportunities for SABMiller in India. The government policies are relaxing and large corporations like InBey (one of the biggest competitors of SABMiller)
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 13
Location
There are many advantages for SABMiller in India. According to Hurian (2010), the Indian beer industry is expected to grow given the exponential growth of the Indian markets compound annual growth rate (CAGR) that increased by 9.2% from 2006 to 2010 (Stanley, 2010). The beer market volume is also expected to increase to 1655 million liters by 2013 with a rise of 42.1% from 2006. North India is increasingly consuming beer and during the first quarter of 2010, roughly 7 million cases of beer were sold in Punjab and Haryana as against 600,000 cases in 2005 (Kurian, 2010). This is due to the fact that the government has revised its policies and regulations are thus more relaxed. Distribution channels are now more developed in these areas. By 2020, India is set to become the second largest beer market in Asia behind China. Given the positive impact of these factors on SABMiller expansion into India coupled with India having neighboring countries such as Sri Lanka and Nepa where beer could be exported through the country (India), it can be agreed that the Indian market is a good opportunity and location advantage for SABMiller. However, the attractiveness of this market intensifies the competition. Therefore, SABMiller needs to develop a differentiated strategy that will set it apart from its competitors.
Internalisation
Internalisation is in line with SABMillers vision which wants to become the largest and most successful brewing corporation in the world. India is the second most populous nation in the world. Expanding into emerging markets like India will help SABMiller stay ahead of the competition. In fact, there is a growing attention on India as it is part of the BRIC nations; it is thus considered as a huge potential market. As other companies would come in and develop their business (distribution channel and infrastructures) according to recent studies, cost of productivity may be lower. Last but not least, contractual problems while exporting make India a better place to import rather than to export.
Limitations of OLI and PESTLE: They are very difficult to plan as the modern world is constantly evolving. Therefore, it becomes difficult to accurately forecast future trends and thereby strategic options.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 14
Brief overview: Porters five forces help us identify the intensity of competition within an industry. In analysing each market force, the question is whether it is sufficiently effective to lower industry profits (Collis and Montgomery, 2005).
Limitations of this framework: This model was designed for analysing individual business strategies and does not therefore address synergies and interdependencies with the portfolio of large global organisations like SABMiller. Furthermore, this framework assumes relatively static market structure; in addition it does not consider new business models and the newfound dynamism of the industries. These are the reasons why care should be taken while applying this model.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 15
2.1.3
BCG Matrix
Brief Overview: Based on the product life cycle theory, BCG Matrix is useful to enhance portfolio management. It helps allocate resources among different business units at a glance (Scholes and Johnson, 2010).
Stars
Latin American Market Eastern Europe Market Asian Market excluding Vietnam Top quality premium brands (Miller Genuine Draft, Pilsner Urquel and Peroni Nastro)
Cash cows
South African Market USA Market
Dogs
Western European Market
Question mark
Indian Market African Market except South Africa Vietnam Market
Limitations: The problem with this framework is that high market share is considered as the major business factor. In addition, dogs may earn more cash than cash cows; this may distort the analysis.
2.1.4
Brief overview: This tool helps identify key stakeholders and their level of influence on the strategic position of the organisation (Jobber, 2001). It may also enable SABMiller to build its strategic priorities by taking into account stakeholders influence and expectations.
Key players
Indian government Top executives (directors) of SABMiller Group
Minimal effort
Large public
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 16
Keep satisfied
Media Customers Employees
Keep informed
Consumers Employees Shareholders Suppliers Retailers and distributors
Limitations of this tool: There is a high risk of misinterpreteting a stakeholders influence that may potentially distort the strategic planning.
2.1.5
Ansoff matrix
Brief overview : Ansoff matrix helps companies make decisions about their strategy of market growth considering challenges they (might) face and opportunities they have.
1) Product development
Premium beer segment is booming as a fast rate increasing the chance of success of SABMiller including product development opportunity Indian brewing industry is a booming market which attracts most of global businesses. This is an opportunity for SABMiller to stay ahead of the competition. SABMiller already has a potfolio of hotels, gambling centers and match factory To introduce SABMiller as a premium brand in India
Limitations: The model is only related to the marketing strategy and the product of the company. Therefore, using solely this matrix is failing to investigate the market and to identify to key trends. That is why whatever the case, Ansoff matrix should be combined with PESTLE and SWOT analysis to provide an exhaustive analysis of the marketplace which will be helpful for the choice of the strategic priorities.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 17
From 2008 to 2010, SABMillers revenue has slightly decreased by 16% from 21,410 to 18,020 while its net income has remained constant.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 18
Brief overview: The main purpose of SWOT analysis is to identify the key strengths and weaknesses within SABMiller, and help the company deal with the challenge of facing opportunities and threats in the marketplace. Wood (2010) also highlights the value of using SWOT analysis when he asserts that it enables to balance strengths and weaknesses. In addition, Wood (2010) argues that it anticipates threats and uses strengths to compensate weaknesses and threats.
Internal analysis
Strenghts
Sustainable development into business strategy Wide geographical presence Delivering transformation Talented and motivated workforce
Weaknesses
Declining market share in sector Limited liquidity position Management capability impairment
Strengths
Sustainable development into business strategy
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 19
Delivering transformation
SABMiller has begun executing a major business capability programme that improves processes making them much easier and thereby accessible to everyone (SABMiller plc annual report, 2010). It also helps the company lower costs allowing local management teams to enhance focus on their targeted markets. This may have a positive impact on SABMiller expansion in India. The risk here may be failure to execute and derive benefits from the ongoing projects. This may lead to a rise in project costs and business disruption hindering competitive edge in the medium term. To face these challenges, SABMiller may globally leverage its skills while raising the profitability of its local businesses on a continuous basis. Senior leadership may be involved in monitoring progress and making important decisions. Effective programme management and governance with adequate resources may also be implemented.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 20
Weaknesses
Declining market share
Over the past 5 years, SABMillers market share has been decreasing. This can negatively affect its global expansion.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 21
Opportunities
Strategic acquisitions and agreements Global expansion into three high growth and booming market Asian, Indian and African markets and BRIC countries. Industry consolidation HIV/AIDS
Threats
Intense competition Rise in input costs
Change in consumer preferences Regulatory changes in the alcohol industry Raw material volatility
Opportunities
Strategic acquisitions and agreements
Mergers, acquisitions, alliances and agreements are widely known as beneficial for companies. As a result, most companies increasingly find a way to collaborate with other firms so that they can gain an edge over competitors. In fact, acquiring another firm may help a company to stay ahead of the competition, to more effectively challenge biggest rivals, to obtain high speed access to resources and to avoid barriers to entry in foreign developing and booming markets. Accordingly, acquisitions and agreements may allow SABMiller to more easily enter India. The beer company may acquire more revenue which may involve greater profits and innovation including advancements in technology and research. However, acquisitions as well as agreements involve some drawbacks. After an acquisition, the buyer usually fires excess employees if too many workers are performing similar tasks. Because of this eventual redundancy, many employees start looking for other vacancies in other firms or quit after the organisation inform them about its acquisition plan. Employees retention may thus be a major issue. In addition, organisational culture may become a serious issue as the two joined companies may not have the same culture. For instance, a company that has an authoritarian style of leadership may acquire a company which is much more democratic and flexible allowing workers more autonomy. Thus, SABMiller needs to consider both side of acquisition and agreement before planning to undertake them.
Industry consolidation
Despite attaining the maturity, the global brewing industry is expected to consolidate on a continuous basis. This may be an opportunity for SABMiller to not only leverage its global scale but to also enter growth markets and thereby gain synergy benefits. However the risk here may be high if SABMiller fails to participate in value-adding transactions and also to implement integration plans effectively after transactions are achieved. This may lower growth rate affecting dramatically both profitability and financial returns. To overcome this, SABMiller can continue to develop a balanced and and attractive global spread of businesses that will undoubtedly raise its profitability.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 22
HIV/AIDS
In spite of being a serious issue worldwide and in South Africa especially, HIV/AIDS can be an opportunity for SABMiller which can develop its cause related marketing to attract the large public that is sensitive about this growing issue.
Threats
Intense competition
There is a growing competition in the brewing industry which has been rapidly consolidating these last decades. SABMillers two largest competitors are currently InBey and Anheuser-Bush which are respectively the first and third biggest brewing organisations in the world. The most profitable and successful of the three is Anheuser-Busch. Aside from that, barriers to entry in booming countries are moderate. This increases the threat of new entrants in emerging markets.
Page 23
Limitations of SWOT: Using this tool is likely to lead companies to list pros and cons rather than thinking critically about what needs to be emphasised to meet goals. In addition, there is a risk that the resulting list will be use ineffectively as it is difficult to prioritise the key issues and to cope with that correctly. A prime example of this is that weak opportunities may seem to balance strong threats.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 24
12C
Caveats
Source: Doole,I., Lowe, R., 2004, International marketing strategy, Analysis, development and implementation. 4th edition. London: Thomson Learning, p. 87.
After analysing our target market using the 12C framework, we discovered the following about the most relevant factors for our case:
1. Culture/Consumer Behaviour
We conducted the research with help of a local partner in the urban areas of India namely New Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, and Madras and found out that the SABMiller brand has limited recognition as of now but after educating about the history and success of the brand, majority of the respondents agreed that they would consume the product. In past, foreign
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 25
2. Channel:
The raw material for production of alcohol will be mostly sourced from local producers of barley and grapes in or around manufacturing facilities. Importing raw materials would be a tricky affair since the product will be sold in high volume and considering heavy excise duty on import in India, this would not be feasible for the company. Furthermore, distribution partners in India hold a lot of power in determining which brand gets more easily available to consumers. Hence, it would be advisable to form partnerships with them individually rather than going through the union.
3. Contract:
Our decision to go into strategic alliance will have a positive effect because we will be tapping into the tacit knowledge from our local partners. However we need to keep into account the contractual obligations to our local partners and take care of their needs. Indian legal processes are known to be prolonged and plagued by bureaucracy. Hence, a team of highly qualified lawyers will be allotted to make sure a viable contract should be formed which covers for collateral damage. Generally in India, liquor contracts are signed with a profit sharing arrangement. However a more informed decision will be taken upon conducting a legal due-diligence.
4. Concentration:
As we are targeting urban, open-minded, young population, we should focus our consumer research, strategies, policies and alliances to most populated cities in India. According to our market research the four most important markets are metro cities such as Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, and Madras.
Product
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 26
Firstly, SABMiller products are to be positioned as high-quality, prestigious, eco-friendly. Secondly, product extension will be valued. Communication Adaptation will be used as a primary strategy. The product will remain unchanged, while the marketing communications program will be adapted. Direct advertising of alcoholic products is banned in India, so other ways to promote the brand should be developed, such as surrogate advertising. New flavours are advised to be introduced later on though according to the local tastes. This will enable SABMiller to compete on the national level since it will show that the company is willing to respond and contribute to the culture and local traditions.
Most products go through similar life cycle as is depicted above. In the home market of South Africa and Europe, the product is in the saturation phase as alcohol consumption is really popular and there are a lot of competitors fighting in a limited market. The market share for SAB Miller is eroding in
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 27
PACKAGING
The packaging will remain the same with a high usage of recyclable and reusable materials. Labelling is to be changed according to the local regulations on mandatory label content. All the ingredient and use and care instructions should be properly translated into Hindi. Health warnings are advised to be included as part of the companys CSR programme.
Placement
It is advised to set up SABMiller own manufacturing plants on the territory of India to avoid heavy taxation on its products. In addition, vertical forward integration via acquisitions and strategic alliances with reputable intermediaries is recommended to gain control over the distribution channel. Last but not least, selective distribution is recommended to support differentiation. Places for products distribution may include department stores, supermarkets, high-class pubs and restaurants. In fact, SABMiller product distribution can be made through restaurants, pubs and supermarkets where our target segment usually goes in public. In India, there is a concentration of this segment in the metropolitan cities. Accordingly, we have decided to initially start product distribution in four metropolitan cities, which are the biggest cities of India in terms of population, alcohol consumption, economy, and social life. A particular focus will be in placing our products in pubs and bars in partnership with their proprietors. Furthermore, agreements with Alcohol shops and supermarkets will be done to place the product on eye-level on counters, thereby increasing visibility for SABMiller products. Furthermore, the manufacturing plants for these products will ideally be located close to these metropolitan cities to reduce transport cost and to reduce any distribution problems. An important point to keep in mind would be India complex and sometimes flawed Logistics systems. There is a heavy reliance on intermediaries like Wholesalers, distributors, Agents, Retailers, etc. In order to avoid blockage in distribution multiple indirect channels should be used in order to make the product available to consumer smoothly. An innovative way to provide an alternative channel could be internet sales through e-marketing. With growing computer literacy in urban areas, this unique channel could be made a competitive advantage if executed properly.
Price
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 28
PRICING STRATEGIES MATRIX Source: Hollensen, S., 2001, Global Marketing, A market-responsive approach. 2nd edition. London: Prentice Hall, pp. 56-489.
Promotion
DRIP model (differentiate, reinforce, inform, persuade) will be applied so as to consolidate our brand awareness and thereby our reputation (Doole and Lowe, 2004). Being aware of the fact that SABMiller beer will be in an introductory phase of its lifecycle in India, we recognise that the main purpose of the companys promotion campaigns will be to inform the potential customer about the
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 29
SABMiller is recommended to use the companys logo (standardisation) or distinctive brand colors while sponsoring community events or issuing public service announcements, so that people are exposed to the companys branding without seeing an explicit ad for the companys product. This will strengthen SABMillers consistency. At the same time SABMiller positions itself as a social responsible company. An illustration of this can be responsible drinking campaigns, dont drink and drive campaigns, HIV/AIDS combat campaigns, etc. Sales promotions: As beer is not a new product in India, SABMiller should take sales promotion into consideration to generate interest and encourage initial trial. Bearing in mind that most of the Indian population still live on a low income, SABMiller should use free sampling and demonstrations for that purpose. All sales promotion campaigns should take place in urban areas. To ensure trial point-of-use sampling should be used, for example at festivals and pubs. Coupons and sweepstakes should also be looked at as good incentives for potential customers in the new market. Caution is required though to prevent damage to the brand image with frequent promotional campaigns.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 30
BRAND NAME:
SABMiller brand as a complex of images and experiences in the customers mind (Keegan and Green, 2011) plays an important role in the companys promotion strategy since as soon as its equity becomes strong in the potential market, it will ensure greater loyalty, less vulnerability to the rivals marketing actions, result in larger margins and increase marketing communication effectiveness (Keller, K.L., 1998). Therefore, substantial investment is needed for its promotion in India. After due research and analysis in the local market, we have decided to enter the market with the strong global brand names such as Peroni Nastro Azzurro and Fosters. The first reason for this decision is that SABMiller is an established brand name in Europe, it will thus add to the feeling of tradition associated with the product. The second argument is that SABMiller will give an international feel to the product and the customer perceives it to be of a higher quality. Moreover, no negative cultural interpretations of the name were identified. Further, the name is easy to pronounce in the local Indian languages. Nevertheless, it should be pointed out that there is a strong local heritage in the brewing industry and people identify with their local brewery (Willman, J., 1999). Therefore, the future development of the national brands is highly recommended to establish national portfolio needed for long-term success in India.
Page 31
High Price
TARGET SEGMENT:
Based on the segmentation done previously and the understanding of customers requirements and companys capabilities, we believe an ideal candidate for the product must have most (preferably all) of the characteristics stated below: Cosmopolitan Young (23-35) Open to Western Products
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 32
MARKET ENTRY:
ANSOFF Model
Source: Doole,I., Lowe, R., 2004, International marketing strategy, Analysis, development and implementation. 4th edition. London: Thomson Learning, p. 87.
But in this report, we will be focusing on market development, product development and jointventure. Firstly referring to Ansoffs model (1998), we would be launching an established brand and product in a new market i.e. Product Development Strategy.
Product development strategy Most Relevant parameters in method and direction of Market Entry
Our strategy will be to source raw materials from local producers, established processes and specific expertise from SABMiller. We also plan to form exclusive strategic alliances with local manufacturers
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 33
As we will be having a shared risk, shared profit agreement with our local partners, the risk involved is significantly lowered. Also, as stated earlier, we are doing market development in the Indian market, so the risk of the manufacturing processes going wrong is lower.
UNARTICULATED DEMAND:
Unarticulated demand is the demand that customers dont explicitly know that they require. It is upto the organizations to improve their products due to this unarticulated demand. Following steps will be taken to identify and fulfill of unarticulated demand. Firstly, we will rely on the tacit knowledge of the local partners. Interacting with the local people is
important to share and understand their daily routine. We will thus have people staying
with families in their homes to identify their behaviour and needs. Aside from that, R&D centres will be located in the local market with help of local partners to identify unarticulated demand and come up with innovative solutions.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 34
Therefore, product development might be an excellent opportunity for SABMiller. However, the Indian brewing industry future growth is very much in the balance and might not be guaranteed as Indian drinkers are likely to be strongly loyal to their (local) existing brands being reluctant to taste new products from foreign countries. The global brewing company Carlsberg has an important presence in India and may thus be a fierce competitor for SABMiller and thereby a potential barrier.
Page 35
Joint-venture
A joint-venture with a major brewing corporation like Carlsberg which is well-known in India and worldwide may be mutually beneficial. Despite having significant expertise in the market developing world, a major western brewer can bring to the table what SABMiller lacks enhancing its entry points into a highly emerging market like India. It can be highlighted that SABMiller already used this strategy when it acquired Miller but it did not gain enough ground in the US to justify that point. It can also be argued that this business may involve high risk considering the increasing competition in emerging markets like India. This growing interest for developing countries is likely to lead to market saturation in the next coming years. These are the reasons why care should be taken when implementing this strategy.
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 36
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 37
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 38
Magazine William, J., 1999, Time for Another Rund, Financial Times, June 21, p. 15. Websites Cook, S., 2010, The 14th best beers in India. [online] (28th September 2010) Available at : http://www.gqindia.com/content/14-best-beers-india [Accessed 28th november 2011]. Cummings, R., 2011, SABMiller success story. [online] (26th May 2011) Available at: http://www.opentext.com/2/global/successstories?sys_action=show&id=816 [Accessed 28th november 2011]. Kurian, B., 2010, SABMiller India Operations to see change of guard. [online] (29th july 2010) Available at : http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2009-06 29/news/27665545_1_sabmiller-beer-consumption-beer-volume [Accessed 28th november 2011]. SABMiller Group, 2010, SABMiller plc annual report 2010. [online] Available at : http://www.sabmiller.com/files/reports/ar2010/2010_annual_report.pdf [Accessed 28th november 2011]. SABMiller Group, 2010, SABMiller market positions. [online] Available at : http://www.sabmiller.com/index.asp?pageid=2100 [Accessed 4th december 2011].
Vikas, V., 2010, How to Conduct Market Research, Bright Hub. [online] (10th april 2011) Available at: http://www.brighthub.com/office/entrepreneurs/articles/95823.aspx [Accessed 28th december 2011]. Stanley, C., 2011, India economy in 2010. [online] (28 november 2010) Available at: http://www.economywatch.com/indianeconomy/indian-economy-overview/ [Accessed 28th november 2011].
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 39
Like Castle Lager, Miller Genuine draft, Perroni Nastro Azzurro,Pilsner Urequell. Being the second largest producer of brewery the company has manage to establish the consolidated position among the value, premium and ultra-premium brands with the privilege of vending different brands in single market. In addition to this they are the major bottlers of Coco Cola, Minute Made, Sprite and Crystal.
Business and Financial Metrics: Fiscal Results 2010 During fiscal year 2010 showed greater amount of volume than the previous year. The group revenue raising up to 4% and EBITA to that of 6% as compared to that in Asia which was relatively low. Europe showed the enhanced EBITA of whereas Latin America the strong appraisal of 17% due to cost capabilities. SABMiller improved functional enactment promoted due to low tax rates enhances the EPS to 17%
Trends and Forces: 1. Economic growth in Latin AmericaThe economic condition of Latin America is stabilizing with the gradual passage of time therefore resulting in increase of per capita beer intake. On an average a person consumes 20-40 litres of beer in a year in LA as compared to USA where it is 80-90 litres a year. This consumption can increase provided there is a promising GDP growth in Latin America. SABMiller is planning to invest 1.8 billion USD in 2012 to increase the production and increasing the infrastructure thereby causing a net growth of the company assets by 8%. 2. Economic growth in ChinaIt is worlds fastest growing economies. China stands at 105th position in terms of per capita GDP of $2,034. However this rate of GDP is escalating tremendously. This has resulted in overall reduction in
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 40
Substitutes: The 3 types of alcohols namely wine; beer and spirits act as substitutes to each other like if demand for beer is more than demand for wine and spirits automatically decreases. Intake of wine has increased manifolds to 180% in UK in last 20 years whereas consumption of hard liquors has been steady so far. Intake of beer in UK has been reduced remarkably owing to the increasing trends in consumption of Wine. On the contrary, the beer intake has touched sky-high limits in the last 5 years with an estimate of whooping 62% increase annually amongst the liquor consuming population. Surprisingly, the drinking of wine and other hard liquors have remained constant, thus following the natural trend of substitution. The scenario in USA is exactly opposite where the wine intake has seen a substantial rise in the last few years whereas the consumption of beer has been constant. Hard liquor on the other hand in US follows the same principle of a steady intake owing to the substitution. These demographic transitions between different countries can have a huge impact on SABMillers performance in different economies. Competition: During early 90s, the worlds five largest brewing giants were accountable for only 17% of the market share as compared to magnificent 45% share as of now. The topmost contenders for SABMillers are InBav and Inheuser-Busch which are the first and third largest brewing companies in terms of volume production respectively. Out of these 3 giants, InheuserBusch controls the 76% of the US brewing market and hence the topmost contender for the first slot. It has spread its roots into China and Latin America by undertaking and acquiring local breweries. Similarly InBav has diversified its geographical operations with 38% market control in Latin America.
Market Share Region United States Worldwide SABMiller Anheuser-Busch InBev NV Molson Coors 23% 11% 48.4% 3% 11.5% 1.1% 19% 14% 11% 21.1% 3.8%
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 41
Anand BAKSHI A4023517 Fariha MAHBUB A4035835 Iryna SHASHKO A4039218 Saphie ALIM A4032674 Shilpa JAIN A4034354
Page 42