The ROI of Data Loss Prevention: A Websense White Paper
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention: A Websense White Paper
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention: A Websense White Paper
Introduction
One data loss incident can result in continuous cost. After making affected customers whole, conducting
an internal investigation, repairing any damage to internal systems, and dealing with expected litigation,
you can count on external audits, increased regulatory oversight, and a damaged reputation to stay with
you for a while.
Organizations that rely on intellectual property (IP) for sale and use are subject to more long-
term and far-reaching costs when data is lost. IP is the heart of today’s technology, manufacturing,
pharmaceutical, and even financial firms, and their most coveted sustainable advantage. When lost, it
can have a direct and immediate impact on both the R&D costs, and the revenue estimates for the full
lifecycle of the asset.
Without question, a data leak is not a one-time cost. Even after your operations have recovered, effects
of the data loss could continue to impact your business for a decade or longer. One mistake can have
far-reaching consequences, and a serious leak may mean that your business never recovers—or at least
never returns to “normal.”
Fortunately, the threat of a leak is significantly mitigated through the use of technology—specifically, a
data loss prevention solution, which can provide a clear return on investment (ROI) and a manageable
total cost of ownership. Data loss prevention provides a sound cost-avoidance strategy and can
positively impact revenue—saving hundreds of millions of dollars with little upfront investment. The
risk of business as usual is clear, as is the reward for implementing diligent data control and data loss
prevention measures.
1
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
Table of Contents
The Challenge............................................................................................................................ 3
Conclusion................................................................................................................................... 14
Table of Figures.........................................................................................................................15.
2
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
The Challenge
A data loss incident can result in lost opportunity. The current business climate favors the informed,
making intellectual property (IP), customer records, and other sensitive information vital to your
competitive advantage. A single leak—be it proprietary data leaked to the public domain or customer
information to a competitor—can have catastrophic consequences, from the cost of near-term
remediation to the long-term damage to your credibility in the marketplace. A single leak can haunt your
company, eradicating, in moments, the goodwill you worked decades to create.
The cost to remediate data loss can be high and can grow with time. Measured against the total cost of
a leak, the total cost of ownership (TCO) of a data loss prevention (DLP) solution reflects a substantial
financial savings in the short-term and an evident competitive advantage throughout the life of your
company. Yet, the simple steps required to protect sensitive data are often overlooked.
A survey by the Ponemon Institute reveals that 85 percent of companies interviewed had experienced
some form of data loss in the previous 24 months (See Figure 1).1 The vast majority of these incidents
came from inside the organization. While only 6 percent resulted from criminal activity and 6 percent
from malicious employees, 42 percent of incidents were caused by the misplacement of devices (often
without knowing exactly what data was stored on them). Other causes were employee negligence and
third-party breaches, at 16 percent and 10 percent respectively. IT mishaps caused 7 percent of breaches,
and missing backup media accounted for 4 percent of breach events.
3
1
The Business Impact of Data Breach. Ponemon Institute LLC. May 15, 2007.
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
The direct costs resulting from a data loss incident of this kind typically consist of:
• The average cost per record associated with a leak to make affected parties whole
• Fees for legal representation
• Engaging a PR firm to minimize damage and restore reputation to the extent possible
• Consumer credit monitoring for all customers (not necessarily only those affected by the leak)
• Up to five years of system and process audits conducted by an independent third party
Intellectual property is a second, often overlooked category of data loss. Whether you are a computer
chip manufacturer creating the next great processor or a Wall Street investment firm creating the next
investment package of high-growth funds, intellectual property is the greatest competitive advantage a
company has toward sustainability and profitability. Most IP data losses go unreported for two reasons:
1) there are no public disclosure laws, to date, that apply to intellectual property, and 2) the impact on
valuation from a publicized loss would likely be tremendous.
• Fees for legal recourse to address who leaked the data and discover if it was being
used inappropriately
• Short-term impact to R&D cost recuperation
o Key variable(s): assets stage in its lifecycle
• Long-term impact to profitability/revenue projections
o Key variable(s): assets stage in its lifecycle, reproducibility, market demand
• System and process audits to identify and correct the source of the data loss
Direct Costs
The cost of data loss can vary, especially as the far-reaching effects can be difficult to gauge. Forrester
Research estimates that the average data leak results in $1.5 million in economic damage, while The
Ponemon Institute pegs the amount at $4.8 million.2 Ultimately, the cost of the data loss incident is
determined by the size and nature of the organization, the sensitivity of the data that was lost, and the
size of the incident itself.
4
2
Trends: Calculating the Cost of a Security Breach. Forrester Research, Inc. April 10, 2007.
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
Figure 2 outlines the major costs (according to Forrester Research) associated with data loss:
A simple data leak that results in the loss of 100,000 customer records can turn into a direct and
immediate cost of $21.8 million. To put this number in perspective, an employee who generates
$1,000 in revenue per hour would have to work for 21,800 hours—a total of 109 years—in order
to compensate for the loss.3
Indirect Costs
In the wake of data loss, an organization may face regulatory fines, additional security and audit
requirements, and other liabilities that are directly related to the loss (e.g., replacement cards in the
credit card business). In some states, compensating credit-bearing institutions for a loss that was the
result of another organization is or may soon be a legal requirement. Such additional, indirect costs
can exceed $10 million, resulting in an average cost of $2 million a year over an estimated five-year data
loss impact.
In addition, a cost often overlooked in analyses of data loss impact costs relates to professional services.
After a data loss event, organizations may face two costly professional service engagements: Periodic
audits and process redesign.
Periodic audits may be imposed by regulatory bodies (as the Federal Trade Commission did to DSW in
2005), making the cost unavoidable and requiring the services of an independent third party. In DSW’s
case, the FTC required bi-annual audits for 20 years, though some cases have only required annual
audits for five years. A third-party audit can cost a minimum of $500,000 (note: the firm conducting the
audit is not likely to have incentive to discount rates aggressively). If an annual audit is required for five
years, the total cost can exceed $2.5 million.
3. The author has only discussed direct costs of customer data to avoid confusion. It is difficult to calculate the impact of a loss of IP, simply because the loss is as unique as the asset, and any loss should be determined
by the affected organization by those who are privy to such data points as: time R&D, cost, asset life start data, asset projected end life date, new asset projected end life data, forecasted revenue associated with asset,
adjusted revenue associated with asset, expected profit margin, impact to operating margin, impact to profit margin, impact to sales (by region), impact to corollary IP/products, uniqueness of IP, reproducibility, market
demand (by region), existing
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
Process redesign is a cost that can catch an organization by surprise. A periodic audit only ensures that
its processes are effective in preventing future data loss, but the loss itself indicates that changes are
necessary. In order to redefine information technology operations, particularly in regard to information
security, an organization needs to engage a strategy and operations (S&O) consulting firm to develop
and implement a new operational model. Typically, the cost of this type of S&O engagement can exceed
$1.5 million and takes two years to implement.
Cost Summary
Thus, the direct cost of a 100,000-record leak could amount to a minimum of $35.8 million over
five years, averaging $7.2 million per year (See Figures 3 and 4). This amount does not include
future damage to your business such as:
$10,000,000
$8,000,000
$6,000,000
$4,000,000
$2,000,000
$-
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Year
Figure 4: Estimated Leak Remediation Costs Over 5 Years
6
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
The total economic impact could be a revenue decline of $120 million, or a 12 percent drop in revenue
the first year. Additionally, one must also consider that the costs to remedy the loss have led to
higher expenses, putting substantial pressure on margins, percent-operating margin, and
earnings per share (EPS). Before the leak, the company’s expenses were compared against total
revenues of $1 billion. Post-loss, the $1 billion is reduced by a hypothetical $120 million in lost
business and an estimated first year cost of $12.2 million for loss remediation. Assuming other
costs remain static, they have to be covered by $867.8 million ($1 billion less $120 million less
$12.2 million) instead of the full $1 billion.
Let us assume that this company has robust net margins of 20 percent, indicating a reasonable amount
of operational efficiency. This would allow $200 million to absorb the cost of the data loss. After
lost business opportunities, only $80 million in margin would be left to cover actual data loss costs.
With an estimated first-year data loss cost of $12.2 million, the net effect is a profit of only $67.8 million
when it otherwise would have been $200 million; the loss results in a 66 percent drop in profits the first
year. If the business can right itself in the wake of the loss incident, it can rely on revenue growth to
absorb the costs for years two through five. However, reputation damage, pressure from
watchdog groups, and negative media coverage are likely to constrain growth, ultimately making
it difficult to absorb the costs of the loss from one year to the next. See Figure 6 for a breakdown
of costs per year.
7
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
When you consider lost business opportunities and remediation costs within the context of revenue
growth and stable net margins (before data loss costs), the long-term effects of the loss can be
profound. As loss-related costs decline, the inability to attract new customers follows, resulting in
estimated lost margin of 62 percent in the fifth year following the leak.
$300,000,000
$250,000,000
$200,000,000
$150,000,000
$100,000,000
$50,000,000
$-
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
8
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
Net profits are increasing every year, even after the leak impact is considered, but profits still reflect a
net decline relative to what they would be if the loss had not occurred (See Figure 7). Implementing a
DLP solution can save hundreds of millions of dollars with little up-front investment. DLP clearly delivers
a cost-containment opportunity in a business environment characterized by both the unintentional
information management accidents and by the threat of externally initiated data theft.
• Software costs
• Installation and configuration costs
• Ongoing system administration and management
Direct Costs
Software costs consist of the fees necessary to acquire the software for use in the enterprise. Installation
and configuration addresses how that software is put to work. This may include professional services
support from the software vendor, as well as third-party consultants or additional software (such
as integration utilities) needed to ensure that the DLP software meets the company’s requirements.
Ongoing system administration and management involves the daily expense of using the DLP solution,
from power to system administrators to impact on business efficiency.
The cost of software varies based on the size and nature of the organization purchasing it, but
Websense® estimates that a 10,000-user organization may spend $17.50 per year, per employee
on a DLP solution. Therefore, if you have 10,000 employees, expect to pay approximately
$175,000 in software fees per year.
While DLP software does automate the identification and prevention of potential data leaks,
human involvement is necessary to:
Generally, an organization does not dedicate a single resource to DLP system administration;
instead, these responsibilities are distributed across a number of team members who share both
DLP administration roles and other information security roles in the Information Technology
department. Websense advises that one full-time employee (FTE) administrator should serve up to
50,000 employees. Thus, in an organization with more than 200,000 employees, four FTEs would be
appropriate. For extremely large organizations with straightforward data security policies, it may be
possible to leverage economies of scale and reduce the administrator footprint in the organization.
9
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
After the implementation of a DLP solution, the environment must be managed in order to yield
continuous results. Using a subscription model, the annual cost of the DLP solution is approximately
$175,000. For the first year, the total cost of DLP is $385,000 which includes a comprehensive view
of implementation. Ongoing management consists of the annual subscription fee for the DLP solution
($175,000) and the cost of headcount to manage the DLP environment. Given that the technology
involves a subscription model, the annual investment in DLP is typically an operational expenditure
rather than a capital expenditure, facilitating budgeting activity and accounting practices.
The cost of data protection and management can be reduced through the deployment of a network-
based solution rather than sole reliance on installing software at endpoints. Central management
facilitates the rigorous enforcement of policy and protection of data in a manner that delivers economies
of scale. Endpoint deployments require active management across the enterprise, which often leads to
higher costs, increased likelihood of error, and the assumption of greater risk.
Of course, effective DLP programs require a certain amount of administrator involvement, even if a
centralized model is used. However, the central implementation of a well-planned rules framework
can reduce that cost substantially. Websense estimates that the practitioner cost of ongoing DLP
system management is approximately $18,750 per year, based on an hour of direct time applied to DLP
management each week by an organization’s director of IT security (at $75 per hour) and six hours
of time by an IT security engineer each week (at a cost of $50 per hour). Thus, the total cost of DLP
management is a mere $375 per week. Compared to the cost of a single security breach, the advantages
of prevention are significant.
10
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
After the implementation year, the annual cost of DLP is approximately $200,000, which includes
technology and administration. The technology component is fixed, but administration is variable.
Some years see a higher investment as a result of improvement to business logic or other upgrades,
but these costs are offset by the operational advantages they yield. In general, the annual cost of data
management is linear after the year of implementation (See Figure 10).
$400,000
Cost to Manage
$350,000
$300,000
$250,000
$200,000
$150,000
$100,000
$50,000
$-
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
Software $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000
Administration $210,000 $18,750 $17,813 $16,922 $16,076
Total $385,000 $193,750 $192,813 $191,922 $191,076
This projection includes an annual decline of 5 percent in administration expenses after the first year to
account for the accumulation of institutional knowledge. Quite simply, as an organization gets better at
data loss protection, the process becomes less expensive.
DLP, as a percentage of the total data loss financial risk to which a company is exposed, is extremely
cost-effective. In fact, DLP becomes more cost effective every year. From one year to the next, company
growth increases the impact of a data leak, but also the operational efficiency of the DLP solution.
The case for prevention is evident. For less than a half a percent of the risk to which a company is
exposed, it can protect itself. Hundreds of thousands of dollars in expenses can lead to hundreds of
millions of dollars in savings, every year.
11
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
There are two primary benefits to maximizing affirmative business processes and remediating those that
are broken: 1) efficiency, and 2) effectiveness. By focusing on a core set of critical affirmative business
processes, you can audit and enforce your processes with a DLP solution, helping to ensure that the
organization is following the most efficient workflow possible and working toward maximum operational
efficiency and increased transactions/volume. In addition, DLP solutions give you situational awareness
to identify who is sending what data, where, and how, providing actionable intelligence to identify and
remediate broken business processes. A more efficient business is a more capable and competitive
enterprise. The second benefit, increased effectiveness, most closely translates to reduced operating
margin—net savings, increased profits, etc. By increasing the effectiveness of affirmative business
processes, you can decrease such variables as cost of sale, sales cycle, margin cost, cost per transaction,
and thus guarantee an increase in rate of return, return on investment, etc.
The above described direct revenue benefits are illustrated in the following example of a fictitious Wall
Street investment brokerage firm. The firm has a policy that encourages employees to use the Internet
to research and gather investment and market information. The Internet is a key tool for analysts to keep
track of investments, trends, and market-changing events. However, the policy has a specific parameter
that prohibits employees from visiting social networking Web sites (e.g., blogs, chat boards, etc.) during
work hours. The reason: the risk of employees posting confidential data on customers/investments is
too great for the firm to accept. As a result, its financial analysts are barred from a great source of real-
time investment/market information, and are either forced to uncover the information by other means
(inefficient) or go without it, at a disadvantage to other analysts (ineffective). However, with a DLP
solution that includes awareness and controls for users, data, and their destinations, the firm can set a
control for an affirmative business policy that says, “A financial analyst can visit any blog or chat board,
but cannot post confidential data to the site.” The policy can be applied to specific users, data types,
destinations, and even categorically (e.g., all financial analysts, all chat boards, all confidential data).
Thus, the affirmative business process is enabled, yet secured, making the employees both more efficient
and effective for their customers, and potentially having a marked influence on revenue.
Direct revenue benefits are based on the specific business processes and operational inefficiencies
addressed, and are unique to each specific organization. As such, no specific amounts will be
aggregated into the model in this paper. The reader should, however be sure to account for such direct
benefits when determining a ROI and should use the benefit to offset the cost of the solution.
12
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
The loss of data has the potential to alter a business completely, especially in a business climate
characterized by increasing competition and rapid product obsolescence. Most leaks are preventable,
through the implementation of DLP solutions and corresponding governance models, which can be used
as the backbone of improved operations that reduce risk while delivering a competitive advantage.
Websense is unique in its approach to DLP. Websense has long been a content security provider, as the
leader in Web filtering and Web security—protecting organizations from where their employees go on
the Web, downloading malicious code (whether knowingly or not), and improving overall productivity.
With Websense Data Security Suite, organizations get the market’s most advanced DLP solution to
discover data stored throughout the enterprise, monitor its use over a broad array of communication
channels, and protect it, with business-centric controls that map to real business processes. What
is unique to Websense DLP that no other vendor can deliver are three core components: detection
accuracy, policy framework, and solution coverage.
Detection Accuracy
Websense Data Security Suite accurately discovers network shares and the data stored on them
throughout the enterprise. The solution uses patented technology to analyze and report on the data,
looking deep into the file and using advanced, proprietary technology to accurately classify the data—
whether structured or unstructured. It includes patented fingerprinting technology that automatically
integrates with databases and file repositories to discover and classify data on a recurring basis, without
administrator intervention. A more accurate solution translates into fewer false positives and negatives,
lowering administrative costs, overall cost of ownership, and delivering a faster, higher rate of return on
your investment.
Solution Coverage
Websense Data Security Suite protects virtually all forms of data, including simple forms such as SSNs,
birth dates, and accounts numbers, as well as complex forms such as CAD drawings, business plans,
and other proprietary types. It also provides monitoring and protection for internal communications
because quite external leaks are often precipitated by internal leaks, where borders are less secure and
employees have greater access. The solution also provides coverage for over 250 built-in regulatory and
policy templates for worldwide coverage, enabling administrators to apply policies to new geographies,
regulations, and governance controls with the click of a button, as well as the ability to customize and/
or create new policies unique to your organization. Websense Data Security Suite delivers unparalleled
coverage for your business needs today and tomorrow, and helps ensure you continue to see a return on
your investment in the years to come.
Policy Framework
Websense Data Security Suite intelligently maps data policies to business processes. The solution can
discover broken business processes and provide a remedy. It includes intelligent, automated workflows
to secure data and educate employees, which reduces help desk calls and administrator intervention,
and solves what is fundamentally a business problem rather than an IT problem. Websense policy
framework is unique in its ability to manage who can send what data, where, and how. This framework
builds on over a dozen years of monitoring user activity on the Web, and integrates destination
awareness from Websense Web filtering and Web security solutions with Websense Data Security Suite.
Only Websense can enable policy controls with the click of a button to block sensitive data from going
13
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
to blogs, chat boards, phishing, gambling or other sites. Conversely, only Websense can authorize,
with the click of a button, the transmission of patient records to an authorized partner, but only over
encrypted email and automatically enforce the email’s encryption. This intelligent policy framework,
depicted in Figure 12, is not only unique to Websense, but is the cornerstone of an effective DLP
solution—real policy controls for real business processes.
Many of the cases covered in this document reflect possibility more than certainty. If data loss occurs,
the impact could exceed hundreds of millions of dollars. It might not happen to you. However, as
businesses become more complex, experience employee turnover, and have to face the cleverness of
hackers, the risk of a data loss increases. A relatively small price affords disproportionate protection.
Conclusion
Ultimately, every business seeks a competitive advantage. For the data-driven company, data protection
and DLP increase the protection of sensitive data and deliver a foundation for aggressive growth. The
cost reduction associated with data protection and process improvement frees operating capital for
investment in the company’s growth opportunities. Instead of reacting to data loss events, funds can
be redirected to initiatives that attract clients, increase sales, and otherwise advance the business. Data
that is not leaked retains its value longer. Once sensitive data leaves the company, its value can be
decimated—along with the competitive advantage it offered.
Websense focuses on the normal flow of business. Instead of locking down your data and preventing
employees from doing their jobs or allowing the free flow of data without any control, Websense is
able to deliver business-centric security. Protect the data in your enterprise, but do not disrupt the
business process.
14
The ROI of Data Loss Prevention
Evaluate solutions:
http://www.websense.com/global/en/Downloads/
Table of Figures
Figure 1: Causes of Security Breaches ................................................... 3 Figure 7: Estimated Impact to Profit Margin........................................ 8
Figure 2: Direct Cost per Record of a Leak.......................................... 5 Figure 8: DLP Estimated Cost Categories........................................... 10
Figure 3: Total Estimated Cost of Leak Summary.............................. 6 Figure 9: DLP EstimatedHeadcount Costs.......................................... 10
Figure 4: Estimated Leak Remediation Costs Over 5 Years........... 6 Figure 10: Declining Cost of DLP.............................................................. 11
Figure 5: Estimated Revenue Impact of a Leak.................................. 7 Figure 11: DLP as a Percent of Total Risk............................................... 11
Figure 6: Estimated Revenue Impact of a Leak Over 5 Years....... 8 Figure 12: Advanced Policy Framework................................................ 14
15
© 2008 Websense Inc. All rights reserved. Websense and Websense Enterprise are registered trademarks of Websense, Inc. in the United States and certain international markets.
Websense has numerous other unregistered trademarks in the United States and internationally. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. 10.20.08